MAIL: worked examples, formative practice and mastery
Original practice for the supplied Media and Artificial Intelligence Literacy topics. Based on the preliminary January 2026 topic coverage; subject to framework revision.
Learning sequence in every activity
- Four concept lesson pages introduce the topic for approximately 10-year-old learners.
- Three worked question-and-answer examples show a source, a question, its answer and why the answer works.
- Five formative questions use four distinct objective formats and one short-answer or open-ended response. Each has a topic investigation, scoring and twelve feedback-language choices.
- Formative review shows the five item scores and a score out of 10. Learners can review or continue to mastery. An unavailable written AI score stays pending and can retry while they continue.
- Five mastery and critical-thinking pairs provide ten new questions and a separate score out of 20.
- Final summary shows formative /10, mastery /20, combined /30, and the current attempt’s saving and upload status. All fifteen responses are included in reporting.
| Mastery pair | Thinking focus | Maximum |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Applied Reasoning | 2 interactive + 2 written points |
| 2 | Justify Choice | 4 points |
| 3 | Transfer Application | 4 points |
| 4 | Error Analysis | 4 points |
| 5 | Design / Propose | 4 points |
These five thinking stages are the requested teaching sequence, not the OECD PISA proficiency scale. The questions and numerical classroom cases are original practice, not official released PISA items. Media and AI literacy concepts are checked against the primary sources listed below. Formative scores and mastery scores describe different stages of practice; the combined total is for complete module reporting.
Media and AI investigations
The activities reuse interaction patterns and administrative services from the supplied TEACHAID MATH119 Concept Mastery R9, TEACHAID 122 Concept First R12 and completed PISA collections. Twenty-six new MAIL workbench families let learners change feed rankings, compare recommendation rules, trace sharing paths, inspect prepared data and predictions, build prompts, compare source origins, crop context, inspect transcript clips, rehearse messages, assign tasks, revise drafts, preview privacy settings, examine permission terms and compare decisions.
Every topic uses at least three relevant interaction families in its formative section and three in its mastery section, including MAIL-specific tools. Suitable source-comparison, evidence, process, graph, data and sampling tools are also available. Students can adjust controls, compare saved views A and B, and write investigation notes. Assessment scores use the fixed stated facts that remain visible beside each workbench.
These are transparent, simplified classroom models with fictional cases and declared assumptions. The prepared continuation sampler is not a live language model; the tiny prediction model does not represent all AI systems; a transcript or crop explorer is not an authenticity detector. Source history and independent reports help an investigation but do not certify truth. Copyright cases state their permission conditions. Privacy and phishing examples use dummy records and non-clickable example addresses. Time planners show budgets rather than health scores; energy models state their limited operating-electricity assumptions.
Question-type selection is seeded and balanced during authoring. Each formative quiz has four different objective formats plus one written item. Each mastery section has five different objective formats paired with written reasoning. Together, both sections use all seven objective formats. Hotspots have labelled selectable answer areas or a suitable numerical diagram. Options vary in order when a new attempt begins. The five thinking levels stay in the requested sequence. Drag-and-drop items include click-and-place and dropdown alternatives; movable model handles also have ordinary controls.
The collection follows the supplied 109-topic list for Media and Artificial Intelligence Literacy. The OECD describes its first preliminary PISA 2029 MAIL framework as a January 2026 draft that may be revised. These original foundations are designed for approximately 10-year-old learners; they are not official released OECD/PISA items or a validated PISA proficiency scale. Official OECD PISA 2029 Media and Artificial Intelligence Literacy page.
Opening and completing a module
- Use Extract All on the ZIP. Open START_HERE.html or any individual activity HTML.
- Complete consent. Choose Region, Division and School, check the school code, and enter the learner initials, section and grade.
- Read the concepts and worked examples, then complete the formative quiz. The formative review leads to mastery.
- Use the question’s interactive workbench and investigation notebook. The stated question data remain fixed while the explorer changes. Drag-and-drop items also support selecting a token then its target.
- At the last question, open Results. Saving and uploading are automatic; no separate Submit button is required.
- Try Again reloads this standalone file and starts with fresh consent. Prior saved reports remain available to the reporting service.
Every activity is one complete HTML. It works without companion assets, a local web server, an installer or an executable. Use a current browser with JavaScript, IndexedDB and gzip DecompressionStream support. Lessons, sources and objective questions work offline. Live AI feedback, nonblank written scoring and uploads need internet access.
Scoring and multilingual feedback
Single-choice, true/false and hotspot items receive 2 for a correct answer and 0 otherwise. Matching, dropdown and drag-and-drop items receive 2 for all correct mappings, 1 for some correct mappings, and 0 for none. Multiple-answer items receive 2 for the exact correct set, 1 for a nonempty correct subset with no incorrect choice, and 0 if any incorrect option is selected.
Each written item has two explicit content requirements. A response meeting both receives an AI estimate of 2; one receives 1; neither, an irrelevant response, or a blank receives 0. The model is given the full source, question, reference answer, learner response and rubric. Equivalent reasoning and valid alternative proposals are accepted. Spelling and grammar are not scored unless meaning is unclear.
Blank written responses receive 0 locally. Nonblank responses use the existing AI scoring service. Missing, invalid or failed AI results stay pending; they are never converted into a zero or N/A. Final performance reports wait for all required estimates. Changing a written answer invalidates its previous AI score.
The feedback choices are English, Filipino, Ilocano, Pangasinan, Kapampangan, Bikol, Waray, Cebuano, Hiligaynon, Maranao, Maguindanaon and Tausug. Each selected-language request carries complete question context and the learner’s answer. The display rejects clearly English output for another selected language and some obvious mismatches; it does not certify fluency. Regional-language accuracy and AI grading quality depend on the deployed model and require teacher or proficient-speaker review. This update does not install or upgrade a server model.
Live feedback findings — 29 October 2026
All twelve requested languages returned HTTP 200 with nonempty responses from the existing gemma3:4b service in the live fictional-item check. Reliable output in all twelve languages was not demonstrated: several regional requests produced mixed-language or Filipino wording, and two sampled responses blurred the difference between an incorrect reminder and its correction. The existing client screen accepted these examples, so acceptance is not proof of language identity or factual accuracy. These are concrete feedback-output limitations, not a completed translation certification. Improve the server-side language generation and verification and repeat proficient-speaker and subject review before treating all twelve choices as reliable. Read LIVE_FEEDBACK_FINDINGS.txt; the complete fictional requests and responses are in live_feedback_smoke.json.
Saving, recovery and dashboard data
The established Science/Mathematics/Reading consent, school directory and reporting services are retained. One feedback instruction now asks for media and AI literacy reasoning, the supplied evidence and stated criteria. Draft responses and AI request evidence save before transmission. Completed results are frozen before their three report bodies are queued. Each activity and each attempt has its own identifier. MAIL uses new activity and content identifiers so records from other modules or editions cannot be mistaken for this attempt.
The staging endpoint remains https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/moodle-staging-upload.php. The supplied CSV schemas remain unchanged: 29 utilization/completion columns, 28 base and identity quiz-performance columns (29 when endpoint-request evidence is attached), and 73 item-response columns. The item-response report contains fifteen item rows. Each item’s response JSON identifies its formative or mastery phase and carries that phase’s score and maximum, with the full item context, response, rubric, simulation settings, snapshots and investigation notes and seven-page lesson progress. The performance report total is out of 30.
Live feedback uses https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/pisa-multilingual-feedback.php; written scoring uses https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/moodle-ai-feedback.php. The same existing server configuration is used. No production server changes are included in these files.
Final-summary saving and upload indicator
| Indicator | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Answers saved on this device | Responses are retained while AI scores or final report preparation are pending. |
| Saved on this device | The completed attempt and all three report bodies are saved locally. |
| Queued for upload · 0/3 confirmed | The saved reports are waiting for server receipts. Upload retries automatically. |
| Partly uploaded · 1/3 or 2/3 confirmed | The named reports have receipts. The remaining reports stay queued. |
| Upload confirmed by teachaid.ph · 3/3 | All three current-attempt receipts match the saved filenames and SHA-256 hashes. |
| Waiting for AI scores / Saving needs attention | The final reports are not yet ready. Keep the activity open for automatic retry. |
Completion, Performance and Item responses have separate status labels. Confirmation means the staging server received the reports; subsequent dashboard processing is a separate server step. Receipts from older attempts cannot mark this attempt as uploaded.
Allow browser storage and use the same browser profile when reopening pending work. Do not clear its activity data while reports or AI scores are pending. Copying an HTML file does not copy learner records. Retry runs while the activity is open and connected, or when it is reopened.
Access and presentation
The supplied Frontlearners logo, school directory, consent controls, watermark and supplied expiry remain embedded. The expiry remains 31 May 2027 at 23:59:59 device-local. The runtime is encoded to make casual inspection harder; this is not tamper-proof access control. Progress blocks track actual lessons, examples and questions within the same topic. All navigation stays in one tab.
Topic answer keys and written rubrics
Use these references to review student reasoning. Worked-example answers are teaching material; they are not scored. Quiz sources differ from the worked examples.
MAIL1.1 · How digital media are produced
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A quiet recording
Fictional worked example
A class podcast draft contains a long pause and the verified sentence “The reading room closes at four.” The editor removes only the pause.
Question: What did the edit improve?
Answer: It improved pacing while preserving the stated closing time.
Why: Removing a pause changes the listening experience without changing this factual message.
Example 2 · Picture or evidence?
Fictional worked example
A team draws an imaginary purple bus for a transport story and labels it “illustration”. It has no photograph of an actual purple bus.
Question: Can the drawing establish that the town owns a purple bus?
Answer: No. It illustrates the story; it is not a record of such a bus.
Why: The label tells the audience how the image was produced and limits what it can establish.
Example 3 · Two review jobs
| Check | Finding |
|---|---|
| Opening hours | Match the approved notice |
| Text visibility | Test readers cannot read it |
Fictional worked example
A fictional poster has correct opening hours but pale lettering that its test readers cannot read. The fact reviewer and design reviewer record different findings.
Question: Which issue remains before release?
Answer: Readability remains; the checked hours need not be changed.
Why: Content accuracy and communication design are separate checks.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · The garden-video team
Fixed fictional classroom case
For a fictional garden video, Ina checks plant labels, Bo records the approved explanation, and Cy arranges the clips. The team has not yet published.
F1 · Drag and drop
Place each person’s recorded job beside the role.
Complete or match: Checking information; Capturing the narration; Assembling the sequence
- a: Cy
- b: No named team member
- c: Ina
- d: Bo
The source assigns research to Ina, recording to Bo and editing to Cy.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Version history
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum caption was drafted by Lia on Monday. On Tuesday Rui changed “all jars” to “these two jars” after checking the display. On Wednesday Ana approved the corrected caption.
F2 · Matching
Match each recorded action to its maker.
Complete or match: Wrote the first wording; Narrowed the claim after checking; Approved the corrected version
- a: Ana
- b: An unnamed visitor
- c: Lia
- d: Rui
The history separates initial writing, evidence-based revision and approval.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · A missing condition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional script says, “Use the side gate only during the drill.” A proposed edit removes “only during the drill”, leaving “Use the side gate.”
F3 · True or false
True or false? The proposed deletion preserves when the gate instruction applies.
- true: True
- false: False
The deletion removes the drill-only limit and makes the instruction sound general.
Investigation: revision lab
F4 · Choose a usable format
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group needs a message that younger readers can use to find the three stations of a school trail. The supplied candidates are a labelled map, a song with no locations, an unlabelled photograph and a paragraph listing no places.
F4 · Hotspot
Which candidate directly meets the stated location-finding purpose?
- a: A song without any station locations
- b: A paragraph without any place names
- c: A map with the three station labels
- d: A wide photograph without labels
The labelled map connects the required station names with their locations.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A release request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional recycling poster has a checked collection date and an original drawing, but no text label explains the three bin colours. A younger test reader cannot tell which bin takes paper.
F5 · Short answer
Propose one revision and explain how you would check that it solves the reader’s problem.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add clear words beside the bins, including “Paper”. Ask a younger test reader to identify the paper bin using the revised poster.
- Proposes text labels or an equally clear non-colour-only way to identify the paper bin.
- Describes a reader check that tests whether the revised poster communicates the bin choice.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional full interview says, “Our club has ten members, but only six attended this week.” A clip keeps “Our club has ten members” and labels it “Attendance this week”.
1A · True or false
True or false? The clip’s attendance label is accurate because ten is spoken in the full interview.
- true: True
- false: False
Ten describes membership, while six describes attendance in the stated week.
1B · Short answer
Correct the attendance label and explain how the edit caused the error.
Example of a full-credit answer: The label should say six attended this week. The edit kept the membership number and removed the attendance condition, then used the wrong label.
- Identifies six as the stated weekly attendance.
- Explains the mismatch between the retained membership phrase and the attendance label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional safety-sign team must preserve the approved wording, provide readable labels and publish only after review. Plan A designs, checks wording/readability, then publishes. Plan B publishes before checking. Plan C replaces the approved wording with a joke.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the plan comparison.
Complete or match: Meets the stated sequence; Publishes before review; Replaces the approved message
- a: Plan B
- b: Plan C
- c: All three plans
- d: Plan A
Only A places the specified checks before publication and keeps the approved message.
2B · Open ended
Choose a plan and justify how it preserves the approved wording and places the required review before publication.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because it keeps the approved wording and checks readability and wording before publication.
- Selects A and connects it to preserving the approved message.
- Explains that checking occurs before publication, including the needed reader or wording check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team turns a video about a three-step handwashing demonstration into an infographic. The approved sequence is wet, wash, rinse. Candidate A labels all three in order; B shows rinse first; C omits wash; D replaces the steps with a smiling face.
3A · Hotspot
Which infographic preserves the stated demonstration sequence?
- a: A: wet, wash, rinse
- b: D: smiling face only
- c: C: wet, then rinse
- d: B: rinse, wet, wash
Changing medium does not justify changing or omitting the approved sequence.
3B · Open ended
Describe one feature the infographic should preserve and one feature it may change from the video.
Example of a full-credit answer: It should preserve the order wet, wash, rinse. It may replace moving clips with labelled drawings or still pictures.
- Preserves the complete approved sequence or explains why the order matters.
- Names a valid format change that keeps the meaning, such as labelled still drawings.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional animated notice looks professional but gives a trip time of 9:00. The approved schedule says 9:30. Its maker argues that animation proves the notice is accurate.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which two conclusions follow from the supplied records?
- a: A polished notice cannot contain errors.
- b: The displayed time needs correction.
- c: The schedule changed because of animation.
- d: Animation alone does not verify the time.
The checked schedule contradicts the time; appearance does not settle factual accuracy.
4B · Open ended
Identify the maker’s reasoning error and give a correction process for the notice.
Example of a full-credit answer: The maker confuses professional appearance with factual checking. Compare the time with the approved schedule, change it to 9:30 and review the corrected version.
- Explains that animation quality is not evidence of the trip time’s accuracy.
- Proposes correcting to 9:30 using the approved schedule and checking the revised version.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class has 30 minutes to make an original event card. Research takes 6 minutes, design takes 12, reader checking takes 5 and correction takes 4. The card must be checked before release. No borrowed artwork is needed.
5A · Multiple choice
Which statement correctly describes the proposed four-task plan?
- a: It uses 27 minutes and leaves 3.
- b: It uses 33 minutes and exceeds the limit.
- c: It uses 18 minutes and leaves 12.
- d: It uses 30 minutes and leaves 0.
6 + 12 + 5 + 4 = 27, within the 30-minute limit.
5B · Open ended
Propose an order for the four tasks and explain why a check must occur before release.
Example of a full-credit answer: Research, design, reader check, correction, then release uses 27 minutes. Checking before release lets the team find unclear or wrong details while there is time to fix them.
- Gives a workable order with research/design before checking and correction before release, within the stated budget.
- Explains how the pre-release reader check allows an identified problem to be corrected.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.2 · How digital content is distributed
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Two routes to one reader
Fictional worked example
A fictional notice goes from Kai to Lia and Mo. Both Lia and Mo send it to Neri. Include Kai when counting everyone who has the item.
Question: How many different people have it?
Answer: Four: Kai, Lia, Mo and Neri.
Why: Neri receives two deliveries but remains one distinct person.
Example 2 · A copy stays old
Fictional worked example
An approved club page changes its meeting room from Room 1 to Room 3. A learner’s earlier screenshot still shows Room 1.
Question: Which action resolves the version difference?
Answer: Check the current approved page and replace or clearly correct the old screenshot.
Why: A screenshot freezes what was shown at one time; it does not follow later page changes.
Example 3 · A smaller useful message
| What | When | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Notebook | Thursday | Room 2 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional recording is too large for the class’s transfer limit. Its essential message is “Bring your notebook on Thursday to Room 2.”
Question: What should a small text version retain?
Answer: The notebook, Thursday and Room 2.
Why: Reducing file size should not remove the details needed for the audience to act.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify the distribution method
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team puts an article on its class page, sends a link to families and gives an offline copy to the library. The offline copy was made before a later correction.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each description to the recorded method.
Complete or match: Makes the article available at its page; Points readers to that location; Can retain the earlier version
- a: Sending a link
- b: Publishing on a page
- c: Giving a saved copy
- d: Changing the author
The methods differ in whether they point to the current location or preserve a separate file.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · A three-step sharing route
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional route is Editor → Class leader → Group members. The editor supplies the original, the leader forwards it and group members receive it. No other route is shown.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the roles in this route.
Complete or match: Supplies the original; Forwards the item; Receives at the final shown stage
- a: Class leader
- b: Editor
- c: Group members
- d: Unknown public viewers
The arrow direction shows source, forwarder and final recipients in this limited map.
Investigation: reach lab
F3 · Preserve the useful content
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional event video cannot be transferred over the available connection. A text alternative must retain “Saturday, 10:00, library courtyard”. Other candidates omit the time, replace the place or keep only background music.
F3 · Hotspot
Which alternative preserves all three required event details?
- a: Saturday, 10:00, library courtyard
- b: Saturday, library courtyard, time missing
- c: Background music without event details
- d: Saturday, 10:00, different location
The first alternative retains the day, time and exact place.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · Two links are not two origins
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message appears on SchoolBoard and ClubBoard. Both explicitly credit the same one-page notice from the coordinator. Neither board made a separate check.
F4 · Multiple choice
How many independent starting notices are represented?
- a: No starting notice
- b: Three starting notices
- c: Two starting notices
- d: One starting notice
The boards are two copies of the coordinator’s single notice.
Investigation: origin lab
F5 · A correction after forwarding
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sports announcement says the match starts at 2:00. After it is forwarded to two class groups, the organiser corrects the approved page to 2:30. The forwarded pictures still show 2:00.
F5 · Open ended
Describe how to distribute the correction and explain why changing the page alone may be insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: Send a clear 2:30 correction and current link to both groups, asking forwarders to replace the earlier picture. Changing the page alone does not update the saved pictures.
- Proposes sending the corrected time/version through both affected group routes.
- Explains that existing pictures or saved copies do not automatically change with the page.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional map, A sends to B and C. B sends to D; C also sends to D. No one else receives the notice. Count A as well as the receivers.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements match the map?
- a: Five different people have the notice.
- b: D can receive it by two shown paths.
- c: Two paths prove the notice is accurate.
- d: Four different people have the notice.
Duplicate deliveries to D do not create a fifth person or verify the content.
1B · Short answer
Give the distinct-person count, then explain how counting the shown deliveries differs from counting people even if the totals happen to match.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are four people including A. There are also four shown deliveries, but those are different units: D receives twice, while A is the starting source rather than a recipient. The equal totals are coincidental.
- Gives four distinct people including the starting source A.
- Distinguishes receipt/delivery events from people using D’s duplicate receipt and/or A’s starting-source role, without claiming the two supplied totals must differ.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher approves a class-only page for a worksheet containing learner initials. Plan A shares its restricted class link; Plan B posts a public screenshot. The stated rule is to keep this version within the class.
2A · True or false
True or false? Plan A better fits the stated class-only distribution rule than Plan B.
- true: True
- false: False
The public screenshot would expose this restricted version outside the specified class audience.
2B · Open ended
Choose a route and justify it using the audience rule and the information in the worksheet.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose the restricted class link. The rule limits this version to class members, and the learner initials should not be exposed by a public screenshot.
- Selects the restricted class route and connects it to the explicit audience rule.
- Identifies the initials or restricted worksheet information as a reason to avoid public redistribution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional field-trip group cannot connect during the journey. The teacher provides a checked offline itinerary marked Version 3 and promises to announce changes in person. A public event feed is not the trip’s approved source.
3A · Matching
Match the trip information to its stated role.
Complete or match: Current checked travel reference; Approved change route during travel; Public listing that is not this trip’s approved source
- a: Offline Version 3
- b: Public event feed
- c: Unlabelled old copy
- d: Teacher’s in-person update
The plan provides a checked offline reference and a separate update route while disconnected.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the offline plan can work without a connection and name how the group should handle a later change.
Example of a full-credit answer: The checked Version 3 file is already saved for the journey. If a change occurs, use the teacher’s in-person update rather than assuming the saved file updates itself.
- Explains that a previously saved checked file remains accessible without connecting.
- Uses the stated in-person update route for later changes and recognises the copy is not self-updating.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional dashboard counts six views of a notice. Its log shows Ada opened it three times, Ben twice and Cara once. A learner claims six different people read it.
4A · Multiple choice
What is the supported distinct-reader count in this log?
- a: Six distinct readers
- b: Three distinct readers
- c: One distinct reader
- d: Two distinct readers
The log names three people, even though their views total six.
4B · Open ended
Identify the counting error and explain what extra evidence would be needed to claim that every invited learner read it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner counts repeat views as new people. The log names only three readers; compare a suitable receipt or confirmed-access record with the complete invited list to assess everyone.
- Distinguishes six views from the three named distinct readers.
- Names a suitable comparison with the full intended-audience list instead of assuming view count proves universal reading.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club must send a verified timetable to 20 families. Some can open only small text files. The club needs a route for corrections, and no learner names should appear in the public version.
5A · Hotspot
Which prepared package best meets the stated requirements?
- a: C: public timetable with learner names
- b: A: text, approved link, correction contact
- c: D: old screenshot without a date
- d: B: large video with no update route
A offers a small accessible version and an update route without requiring public learner names.
5B · Open ended
Propose a plan covering families with limited connections and explain how a correction would reach them.
Example of a full-credit answer: Send the same dated small text timetable to all families through the approved route, with a current link for those online. Send corrections through that route again, naming the changed detail and keeping learner names out.
- Provides a current small-file/text option that preserves essential timetable details and avoids public learner names.
- Specifies a practical correction route and identifies the changed detail or version.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.3 · How social-media platforms work
Three worked examples
Example 1 · One item and its display
Fictional worked example
A fictional service stores a class announcement and shows it among four items on a learner’s home screen.
Question: Which part is the feed?
Answer: The home-screen list of items.
Why: The announcement is one post inside that selected display.
Example 2 · A changed setting
Fictional worked example
A fictional poster is first set to “class” and then changed to “public”. Its wording stays the same.
Question: What changed?
Answer: The intended visibility changed, not the words.
Why: The audience setting affects who can access the item through the platform.
Example 3 · A request for review
| Stage | Status |
|---|---|
| Reports received | Yes |
| Evidence reviewed | Not yet |
| Decision issued | Not yet |
Fictional worked example
Two learners report a comment under a fictional service’s rule against personal insults. A moderator has not yet reviewed it.
Question: What can we conclude from the reports alone?
Answer: The comment has been flagged for review.
Why: A count of reports does not by itself establish the moderator’s finding.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Class view and public view
Fixed fictional classroom case
On a fictional platform, a study post is marked class-only. In the supplied test, class members see it and public visitors do not. No test of copying by members was made.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The test establishes that no class member could ever copy the post.
- true: True
- false: False
It tested visibility for two audiences, not whether an authorised receiver could copy content.
Investigation: privacy lab
F2 · Three platform tools
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional platform lets users publish a notice, reply below that notice and flag a problem for review. These actions are called Post, Comment and Report.
F2 · Matching
Match each purpose to the stated tool.
Complete or match: Publish an item; Reply beneath the item; Ask for a problem review
- a: Comment
- b: Post
- c: Report
- d: Offline drawing
The three labels describe different actions, not three ways to certify a claim.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · The chosen feed rule
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional feed is set to most-recent first. A is from today with 8 likes, B from yesterday with 70, and C from last week with 90. No paid placements are in this feed.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which post appears first under the stated rule?
- a: All three must share first place
- b: C, the item with 90 likes
- c: B, the item with 70 likes
- d: A, the item from today
The stated rule uses recency rather than likes.
Investigation: feed lab
F4 · A problem in a class comment
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class rule forbids sharing another learner’s private phone number. A comment includes such a number. The safe prepared actions are reporting it privately to the teacher, forwarding it widely, copying it into a public reply or asking strangers to call it.
F4 · Hotspot
Which action best follows the stated class rule?
- a: Ask strangers to call the number
- b: Forward the number to more groups
- c: Report privately to the teacher
- d: Copy the number into a public reply
A private report seeks help without increasing exposure of the private detail.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A like is a limited signal
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional lost-property post receives 40 likes. The item owner later checks its photograph and says the bag is not theirs. No ownership record accompanies the likes.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what the likes show and what additional check is needed before naming the bag’s owner.
Example of a full-credit answer: The likes show reactions to the post, not verified ownership. Ask the responsible teacher to compare a claimant’s identifying information with the bag safely before naming an owner.
- Distinguishes reaction count from evidence of ownership.
- Proposes a relevant safe ownership check rather than more likes or public private-data requests.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: verification lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class platform has a Share to public option. Mina uses it on a class event poster that contains no learner names and is explicitly approved for public sharing. The original remains on the class page.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from the stated action?
- a: The share proves every visitor agrees.
- b: The approved poster can reach public visitors.
- c: The share adds learner names automatically.
- d: The original class-page copy can remain.
Sharing affects distribution; it does not establish agreement or invent private fields.
1B · Short answer
Explain how the audience changes and name one conclusion the share does not establish.
Example of a full-credit answer: The poster becomes available through the public page as well as the class page. It does not show that every viewer agrees with it or has even read it.
- Explains the expansion from class-only availability to the stated approved public route.
- Identifies an unsupported conclusion such as universal reading, agreement or factual verification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional project thread asks for evidence about which reading corner gets more afternoon light. Reply A shares dated observations; B insults the questioner; C repeats an unrelated joke; D demands agreement without evidence.
2A · Multiple choice
Which reply best meets the thread’s stated purpose?
- a: D: demand agreement without evidence
- b: B: insult the person who asked
- c: A: share the dated observations
- d: C: repeat an unrelated joke
Dated observations can be checked and directly address the comparison.
2B · Open ended
Choose a reply and justify it by its relevance and its treatment of other participants.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because the dated observations address afternoon light and can be checked. It contributes evidence without insulting or pressuring the people discussing it.
- Selects A and connects its observations to the actual thread question.
- Explains its respectful, checkable contribution rather than popularity or pressure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learning board has three actions: Upload adds a class document, Suggest leaves a proposed edit, and Approve accepts a checked revision. The class rule requires the document owner to approve changes.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each action with its stated job.
Complete or match: Adds the starting document; Leaves an unaccepted proposed edit; Accepts a checked revision
- a: Approve
- b: Upload
- c: Delete the whole board
- d: Suggest
A proposed change and an accepted change are separate states.
3B · Open ended
Explain why a suggested correction is not yet an approved change and describe the required next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: Suggest records an idea for the owner to review. The owner must compare it with the evidence and use Approve if the correction is justified under the class rule.
- Distinguishes a proposed edit from an accepted document change.
- Describes evidence-based owner review followed by approval when justified.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional feed shows only posts from three followed clubs. The platform also holds six other clubs’ posts, which are available through its search tool. A learner says the missing clubs never posted.
4A · True or false
True or false? Absence from this followed-club feed proves that the other clubs made no posts.
- true: True
- false: False
The source states that their posts exist but are outside the feed selection.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s error and give a way to investigate the other clubs’ content.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats a selected feed as every post on the platform. Use the stated search tool or visit the other clubs’ approved pages to inspect their available posts.
- Explains that the feed is a limited selection rather than the complete platform collection.
- Names the stated search or approved-page route for checking the missing clubs.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class board needs a current homework notice, respectful questions and a private route for reporting personal-data mistakes. The teacher reviews corrections before replacing the notice.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the class-board routine.
Complete or match: Main post should contain; Comments should allow; Personal-data mistakes should use
- a: Respectful question thread
- b: Public list of private details
- c: Private report to the teacher
- d: Current homework notice
Each route has a different communication purpose.
5B · Open ended
Propose one posting-and-review routine and explain how it protects a learner whose private detail appears by mistake.
Example of a full-credit answer: An editor drafts the notice, the teacher checks updates and the class uses respectful questions. A learner reports an exposed private detail privately to the teacher so it can be corrected without repeating it publicly.
- Proposes a routine with a current notice and teacher review of corrections.
- Provides a private trusted-adult reporting step that avoids further public exposure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.4 · How content becomes popular
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Counts and rates differ
| Tutorial | Likes | Viewers |
|---|---|---|
| First | 12 | 30 |
| Second | 20 | 100 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional tutorial gets 12 likes from 30 recorded viewers. A second gets 20 likes from 100 viewers.
Question: Which has the higher like rate?
Answer: The first: 40%, compared with 20%.
Why: The second has more likes in total, but fewer likes per recorded viewer.
Example 2 · Repeated views
Fictional worked example
A learner opens a fictional rehearsal clip four times to practise. Two friends open it once each.
Question: Does six views mean six different people?
Answer: No. These views came from three people.
Why: The count measures openings, including repeat openings.
Example 3 · A tempting explanation
Fictional worked example
A fictional poster gets more shares on the day its title changes. A large class also forwards it that day.
Question: Can the title alone be identified as the cause?
Answer: Not from these records alone.
Why: Both the title and the additional exposure changed; their effects are not separated.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the measure
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional drawing post records 60 views, 15 likes and 4 shares during Tuesday. The log does not identify distinct viewers or why anyone shared it.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements are supported?
- a: Fifteen likes were recorded on Tuesday.
- b: Four shares were recorded on Tuesday.
- c: Sixty different people approved it.
- d: Every share expressed agreement.
The counts describe recorded actions, not unique people’s intentions.
Investigation: graph lab
F2 · Match the attention record
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional display, a view means opening an item, a like means pressing its reaction button and a share means sending it onward. The service records these separately.
F2 · Matching
Match each recorded action to its definition.
Complete or match: Opening an item; Pressing the reaction button; Sending the item onward
- a: View
- b: Independent fact-check
- c: Like
- d: Share
Opening, reacting and forwarding measure different behaviour.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · A visible position
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional feed uses likes to order posts. Oak has 18 likes, River has 32 and Hill has 9. The newest-first order is Oak, Hill, River.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place each post beside its position under the most-liked rule.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Hill
- b: No post can rank
- c: River
- d: Oak
32 is greater than 18, which is greater than 9.
Investigation: feed lab
F4 · Attention without verification
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional story is forwarded through five groups. Every copy repeats a single anonymous post and adds no evidence. Its claim has not been independently checked.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Five groups forwarding the story establishes that five independent checks confirmed it.
- true: True
- false: False
All shown copies depend on the same unchecked origin.
Investigation: origin lab
F5 · Compare a small and large audience
Fixed fictional classroom case
Two fictional class notices are measured for one hour. Notice P receives 8 replies among 20 viewers; Q receives 12 replies among 60 viewers. A learner calls Q more responsive because 12 exceeds 8.
F5 · Open ended
Calculate each reply rate and explain how the rates change the learner’s comparison.
Example of a full-credit answer: P has 8/20 = 40%; Q has 12/60 = 20%. Q has more replies, but P has the higher replies-per-viewer rate for this hour.
- Correctly identifies P as 40% and Q as 20%.
- Distinguishes the larger total reply count from the higher response rate.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poem starts with A. A shares to B and C; B shares to D and E; C also shares to E. All arrows occur once, and nobody else receives it.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from the map?
- a: Every receiver must think it is excellent.
- b: Six different people must have the poem.
- c: Five different people have the poem, including A.
- d: E receives the poem along two shown paths.
The duplicate path to E increases deliveries, not the number of distinct people.
1B · Short answer
Explain the distinct-person count and one limit on what the map tells us about popularity.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are five people including A; E is counted once despite two paths. The map shows receipt, not whether everyone liked or read the poem.
- Counts five distinct people and handles the duplicate path correctly.
- Names a valid limit, such as no evidence of reading, liking or agreement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team compares two poster designs. Plan A uses similar class groups and equal 30-minute periods. B gives one poster a day and the other a minute. C shows one to 100 people and the other to 5 without recording exposure. D changes the topic as well as the design.
2A · Multiple choice
Which plan gives the fairest stated design comparison?
- a: B: one day against one minute
- b: A: similar groups and equal periods
- c: C: unequal unrecorded exposure
- d: D: different topics and designs
A controls more relevant conditions while still requiring careful interpretation.
2B · Open ended
Choose a plan and justify it using two controlled conditions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because similar class groups reduce audience differences, and equal 30-minute periods give both designs comparable time to collect reactions.
- Identifies similar audiences as a useful comparison condition in A.
- Explains why the equal time window helps compare the designs.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional library compares two printed recommendation cards for the same week. Card A is beside the entrance and B is behind a closed cabinet. A gets more recorded selections.
3A · True or false
True or false? The larger selection count proves that readers prefer A’s wording, regardless of placement.
- true: True
- false: False
Placement changes the opportunity to encounter a card, so wording is not isolated.
3B · Short answer
Apply the exposure idea to explain the result and propose one fairer comparison.
Example of a full-credit answer: A was easier to see, so its higher count may reflect placement. Put both cards in similarly visible positions or rotate their positions over matched periods while recording exposure.
- Connects the result to unequal visibility rather than concluding a wording preference.
- Proposes a relevant placement/time comparison that reduces the exposure difference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional chart lists Cedar with 24 shares and Pine with 18. Cedar was shown to 240 viewers; Pine to 60. The caption says Cedar had the higher share rate.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete the corrected comparison.
Complete or match: Cedar share rate; Pine share rate; Higher share rate
- a: Cedar
- b: Pine
- c: 10%
- d: 30%
Cedar is 24/240=10%; Pine is 18/60=30%, so Pine has the higher rate.
4B · Open ended
Identify the caption’s error and calculate the correct rates.
Example of a full-credit answer: The caption confuses share totals with shares per viewer. Cedar is 10% and Pine is 30%; Pine has the higher rate even though Cedar has more shares.
- Identifies omission of exposure/denominator or confusion between count and rate.
- Calculates 10% for Cedar and 30% for Pine and gives the corrected comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club wants to test which of two accurate reading-event titles attracts interest. Both lead to the same event. It must avoid misleading promises and measure reactions during equal periods.
5A · Hotspot
Which planned measure lets the club compare reactions relative to exposure?
- a: Reactions divided by recorded viewers
- b: The number of letters in each title
- c: Only the largest raw reaction count
- d: How strongly the designer likes a title
A defined reaction-per-viewer rate uses the exposure denominator.
5B · Open ended
Propose a comparison plan and state one limit you would report with its result.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show the two accurate titles for equal periods to similar groups, record viewers and reactions, and compare rates. Report that group differences or a small sample may still affect the result; it does not guarantee future popularity.
- Proposes an ethical matched comparison with a clear reaction/exposure measure.
- States a relevant limitation or uncertainty instead of promising a universal winner.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.5 · How digital platforms earn money
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Paying to read
Fictional worked example
A fictional magazine collects 4 credits each from 6 subscribers. It carries no advertisements in this case.
Question: What is its subscription revenue?
Answer: 24 credits.
Why: Six subscriptions multiplied by 4 credits gives 24; this does not subtract the magazine’s costs.
Example 2 · A sale fee
Fictional worked example
A fictional marketplace takes 1 credit for each completed sale. Eight listings are posted, but only three sales complete.
Question: How much fee revenue follows?
Answer: 3 credits.
Why: The stated payment event is a completed sale, not a listing.
Example 3 · Free to view
| Party | Payment |
|---|---|
| Viewer | 0 entry credits |
| Sponsor | 12 banner credits |
Fictional worked example
A fictional video service charges viewers no entry price. A sponsor pays 12 credits to display a labelled banner.
Question: Does no entry price mean no income?
Answer: No. The sponsor provides the 12-credit income.
Why: Identify the payer rather than inferring the funding model from the viewer’s price.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A mixed model
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional drawing platform collects subscriptions and advertising payments. Its monthly record shows 20 subscription credits and 8 ad credits.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The platform uses more than one source of revenue.
- true: True
- false: False
The record explicitly includes both subscriptions and advertising.
Investigation: graph lab
F2 · Name the payment event
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional service offers three arrangements: readers pay monthly for access; advertisers pay for banner clicks; sellers pay when a sale completes.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete each funding label.
Complete or match: Monthly access payment; Banner-click payment; Completed-sale charge
- a: Transaction fee
- b: Donation
- c: Advertising
- d: Subscription
The payment event distinguishes the three models.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Read the click model
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model uses 100 views, an assumed 10% click rate and 2 credits per click. There is no subscription income. Its result is 10 expected clicks and 20 ad credits.
F3 · Matching
Match each quantity with its meaning in the fixed case.
Complete or match: Recorded model views; Expected model clicks; Estimated ad credits
- a: 10
- b: 100
- c: 20
- d: 2
Ten percent of 100 gives 10 expected clicks; multiplying by 2 gives 20 credits.
Investigation: ad lab
F4 · Income is not profit
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional app reports 45 credits of revenue. The source provides no information about equipment, staff or other costs.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is supported?
- a: Revenue is known but profit is not.
- b: All users paid the same amount.
- c: Profit must equal all 45 credits.
- d: The service has no operating costs.
Profit requires costs, which the source does not supply.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · Explain a design incentive
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional platform receives ad payments when an additional ad is shown. Its designers propose adding another automatic video after each clip. The source does not say what any viewer will do.
F5 · Short answer
Explain one financial reason for the proposal and one reason it may not serve every viewer’s needs.
Example of a full-credit answer: More automatic viewing could create more opportunities to show paid ads. Some viewers may want to stop or use their time for something else, so the income incentive does not decide what is best for them.
- Connects extra viewing with a possible increase in paid ad opportunities.
- Identifies a relevant viewer need or limit, without claiming every viewer reacts the same way.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: feed lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional site assumes 200 views, a 5% click rate and 3 credits per click, plus 10 subscription credits. The question uses these fixed assumptions.
1A · Hotspot
Select the total estimated revenue under the fixed assumptions.
- a: 40 credits
- b: 20 credits
- c: 610 credits
- d: 30 credits
200 × 5% gives 10 clicks; 10 × 3 + 10 = 40 credits.
1B · Short answer
Show the advertising calculation and explain why the total is an estimate.
Example of a full-credit answer: The ad calculation is 200 × 0.05 × 3 = 30 credits; adding subscriptions gives 40. The click rate is assumed, so actual clicks and income may differ.
- Correctly calculates the 30-credit ad component and 40-credit total.
- Explains that the assumed click rate limits the result to an estimate.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club needs predictable reader payments, not payments linked to ad clicks. Offer A charges each member monthly. B pays the club per ad click. C charges sellers per sale. No offer promises accurate content.
2A · Drag and drop
Place the contract beside its payment source.
Complete or match: Monthly member payments; Ad-click payments; Completed-sale payments
- a: Offer C
- b: Offer B
- c: No listed offer
- d: Offer A
A matches monthly member payments; B and C have different payment events.
2B · Open ended
Choose the offer that fits the stated payment preference and identify one thing the contract does not establish.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer A fits because it charges members monthly. The contract does not establish that content will be correct, that everyone can afford access, or that membership numbers will stay constant.
- Selects A and links it to monthly reader payments.
- Names a valid unresolved issue instead of treating the model as a quality guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional offline game library charges 2 credits per borrowed game. During a day it records 9 enquiries and 4 loans. Income is based only on loans.
3A · True or false
True or false? The library receives 8 credits under its stated rule.
- true: True
- false: False
Four loans at 2 credits each produce 8 credits; enquiries do not trigger payment.
3B · Short answer
Apply the payment-event idea to explain the income, and say why counting enquiries would mislead.
Example of a full-credit answer: Only the four loans trigger payment, giving 4 × 2 = 8 credits. The nine enquiries include people who may not borrow, so treating them as paid loans would count the wrong event.
- Correctly uses four loans at two credits to obtain eight credits.
- Explains why enquiries cannot be counted as completed paid loans.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional report says: “The platform received 80 ad clicks, so it sold 80 products and earned 80 credits of profit.” The contract pays 2 credits per click. No sales or costs are supplied.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete the corrected report.
Complete or match: Ad revenue from clicks; Number of product sales; Profit after costs
- a: Profit unknown: costs are missing
- b: Sales not established: no sales record
- c: 80 completed sales
- d: 160 credits
The click contract gives 160 revenue credits. Sales and profit require other evidence.
4B · Open ended
Identify the confusion about sales and correct the money claim using the available evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Clicks are not necessarily purchases, so 80 sales is unsupported. The stated ad revenue is 80 × 2 = 160 credits, while profit remains unknown because costs are absent.
- Distinguishes clicks from confirmed sales.
- Gives 160 credits of revenue and explains why profit cannot be calculated.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class magazine can charge at most 2 credits per month, must label any paid placement, and wants an option for readers who cannot pay. Students may propose more than one funding route. The full monthly price must be displayed clearly.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which two features meet the stated transparency requirements?
- a: Clearly label paid placements.
- b: Describe sponsored material as unpaid.
- c: Display the full monthly price.
- d: Hide fees until after joining.
The stated terms require clear prices and paid-placement labels.
5B · Open ended
Propose a funding plan within the price limit and explain how readers who cannot pay could access the magazine.
Example of a full-credit answer: Charge up to 2 credits for optional membership and label any sponsored space. Provide school-library copies or a funded free-access route for readers who cannot pay.
- Proposes a plan at or below the price cap with clear paid-placement disclosure if used.
- Explains a workable access route for readers who cannot pay.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.6 · How advertising affects content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Paid placement, real feature
Fictional worked example
A fictional sponsor pays for a backpack mention. A checked label says the bag has two pockets.
Question: Can the payment and the pocket count both be true?
Answer: Yes. The funding relationship and the feature are different facts.
Why: Payment creates an interest to notice; it does not erase a verified feature.
Example 2 · A comparison without a comparison
Fictional worked example
A fictional snack advert says “the crunchiest”, but supplies only a recording of its own snack.
Question: What evidence is missing?
Answer: A fair comparison with the alternatives covered by the claim.
Why: One product’s sound cannot establish that it ranks above all others.
Example 3 · A limited price
| Brush | Credits |
|---|---|
| Small | 3 |
| Large | 5 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional art shop advertises “3 credits”, with the clear condition “one small brush”. Large brushes cost 5.
Question: Which price applies to a large brush?
Answer: 5 credits.
Why: The advertised low price has a stated scope; reading the condition prevents overgeneralising.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the supplied relationship
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional gardening clip begins “Paid partnership with GreenPot”. Its creator also explains how to add drainage holes. No test of competing pots is supplied.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The supplied label establishes a sponsorship relationship.
- true: True
- false: False
The source explicitly states a paid partnership; it does not establish product superiority.
Investigation: provenance lab
F2 · The omitted trial
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional advert shows a paper plane flying 8 metres once and claims “always flies at least 8 metres”. The test log records 4, 6 and 8 metres.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which statement fits all three trials?
- a: The plane can never travel 6 metres.
- b: Every recorded flight reached 8 metres.
- c: All other planes travel less than 4 metres.
- d: Recorded flights ranged from 4 to 8 metres.
The complete log includes flights below eight metres.
Investigation: graph lab
F3 · Separate three kinds of information
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional product card says “Sponsored by BrightCup”; a ruler check records a height of 12 cm; the slogan says “The cup everyone needs”.
F3 · Matching
Match each statement to its role.
Complete or match: Sponsored by BrightCup; Height 12 cm; The cup everyone needs
- a: Promotional slogan
- b: Measured feature
- c: Independent durability test
- d: Funding disclosure
The relationship, measurement and promotional claim serve different purposes.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · An advertiser’s chosen emphasis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional shoes advert highlights colour, leaves out the measured weight, and places a sponsor label at the start. Its production note names all three choices.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each recorded choice beside its effect.
Complete or match: Colour close-up; No weight statement; Sponsor label
- a: Proves every claim correct
- b: Draws attention to colour
- c: Leaves weight information absent
- d: Reveals the paid relationship
The source specifies what each production choice does.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A narrow claim made broad
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sponsored pencil video reports that one pencil wrote for ten minutes in a classroom test. The caption says “All our pencils last all year”. No year-long testing is provided.
F5 · Short answer
Explain the gap between the test and the promise, and write a claim that stays within the supplied evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: A ten-minute trial of one pencil cannot support a claim about all pencils lasting a year. A supported statement is: “One pencil wrote for ten minutes in this classroom test.”
- Identifies the mismatch in duration or number of tested pencils.
- Rewrites the claim with the supplied one-pencil, ten-minute limits.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: verification lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sponsored bottle card supplies a verified capacity of 500 mL and says the sponsor selected the featured colour. It provides no leak test and no comparison with other brands.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which conclusions are supported?
- a: The stated checked capacity is 500 mL.
- b: The sponsor influenced the featured colour.
- c: The bottle is proved never to leak.
- d: All competing bottles are less useful.
The supplied records support capacity and colour selection only.
1B · Short answer
Explain one demonstrated influence of the sponsor and one performance claim that still needs evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The sponsor selected which colour appears. A claim that the bottle never leaks still needs relevant testing; capacity and payment records do not establish leak performance.
- Identifies sponsor selection of the featured colour.
- Names an unsupported performance or superiority claim and explains the need for relevant testing or comparison beyond the capacity and sponsorship records.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional notice must label payment, report its actual test, and show that the offer ends Friday. Draft A includes all three. B hides payment. C replaces the test with “best ever”. D removes the end date. The actual recorded test used a 2 kg load.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each omission to the stated draft.
Complete or match: Missing paid relationship; Missing actual test result; Missing offer end date
- a: Draft D
- b: Draft B
- c: Draft A
- d: Draft C
B omits payment, C replaces evidence with a slogan, and D omits the offer’s end date.
2B · Open ended
Choose the most transparent draft and justify it using two of the required disclosures.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A. It identifies that the message is paid and gives the actual 2 kg test result; it also states the Friday deadline.
- Selects A and explains one required disclosed fact.
- Explains a second distinct requirement that A satisfies.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional community newsletter recommends a concert. The organiser supplied free tickets to the reviewer, and the note clearly states this. A checked schedule gives a 4 pm start.
3A · Hotspot
Which statement correctly separates relationship and evidence?
- a: A disclosure guarantees everyone will enjoy the event.
- b: A free ticket makes every stated fact false.
- c: A checked time proves all recommendations impartial.
- d: The free ticket is relevant; the time needs its schedule.
The relationship should be visible, while the time is supported by the schedule.
3B · Open ended
Apply the advertising lesson to this recommendation: name the relevant relationship and one separate check a reader should make.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reviewer received a free ticket from the organiser, which may influence the review and is disclosed. A reader should separately check the schedule for the start time or another claim relevant to their decision.
- Identifies the free-ticket relationship as relevant without declaring automatic dishonesty.
- Names a separate claim-specific check rather than relying on the relationship alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “This is sponsored, so its statement that the mat is 2 metres long must be false.” An independent class measurement also records 2 metres.
4A · True or false
True or false? Sponsorship alone proves the stated length is false.
- true: True
- false: False
Payment does not override the relevant length measurement.
4B · Open ended
Explain the learner’s reasoning error and state the evidence-based conclusion about length.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats sponsorship as proof of falsehood instead of checking the particular claim. The supplied independent measurement supports the stated 2-metre length.
- Identifies the error of treating payment alone as proof of falsehood.
- Uses the supplied independent measurement to support the limited length claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional seed supplier funds a class post. The permitted evidence is that 7 of 10 seeds sprouted in one class trial. The post must disclose funding and avoid promises about every garden.
5A · Matching
Match each part to its function.
Complete or match: Supplier funded this post; Seven of ten sprouted in this trial; Other gardens may differ
- a: Guaranteed future result
- b: Funding disclosure
- c: Observed result
- d: Evidence limit
A transparent post distinguishes who paid, what occurred and what remains uncertain.
5B · Open ended
Write a short proposed post that includes the funding relationship and the result with its proper limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Sponsored by the seed supplier. In our class trial, 7 of 10 seeds sprouted. Other gardens and conditions may give different results.
- Clearly discloses that the seed supplier funded the post.
- Reports 7 of 10 in the class trial without a universal or guaranteed outcome.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.7 · How algorithms rank information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Order by time
Fictional worked example
Fictional notices arrive at 09:10, 09:30 and 09:20. The rule is most recent first.
Question: Which notice leads?
Answer: The 09:30 notice.
Why: The rule compares time, not length or popularity.
Example 2 · A tied score
Fictional worked example
Fictional cards Oak and Bay both score 6. Oak appears first in the source list. The declared tie rule preserves source order.
Question: Which comes first?
Answer: Oak.
Why: The tie is settled by the stated rule, not an invented quality difference.
Example 3 · High rank, narrow evidence
| Feature | Supplied fact |
|---|---|
| Rank | First |
| Evidence date | Last year |
| Needed date | Today |
Fictional worked example
A fictional top-ranked result says a bridge is open. Its only evidence is a photograph taken last year. The question concerns today.
Question: What is still needed?
Answer: Current evidence about today’s bridge status.
Why: Ranking did not repair the mismatch between old evidence and a current question.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Apply three transparent rules
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional list is newest-first in this order: A, B, C. A has 4 likes and relevance 9; B has 20 likes and relevance 3; C has 8 likes and relevance 6.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each description with the correct item in the fixed case.
Complete or match: First under newest-first; First under most likes; Middle under most likes
- a: A
- b: No item
- c: C
- d: B
A is first in the newest-first source order. B has the most likes (20), while C is between B and A with 8 likes.
Investigation: feed lab
F2 · A search result is not a verdict
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional search list puts a page first because its title repeats “library hours”. The page has no current date. Another result is a dated notice from the library. The ordering rule uses word matches only.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from the supplied rule?
- a: The top position does not establish current hours.
- b: Every lower result is irrelevant to the task.
- c: A matching title can help a result rank.
- d: First position proves the page has no errors.
The rule scores matching words, not current factual accuracy.
Investigation: search results lab
F3 · Separate signals and conclusions
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional record gives Post P 40 likes, publication on Wednesday and a topic score of 7. No accuracy check was conducted.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the signal descriptions.
Complete or match: Reaction-count signal; Publication-time signal; Topic-match signal
- a: Wednesday
- b: Topic score 7
- c: 40 likes
- d: Verified truth
The record lists reactions, date and a modelled topic score, but no truth check.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Choose the task-relevant order
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs the most recently issued bus-stop change. All four notices concern that stop. Their dates are Monday, Thursday, Tuesday and Wednesday.
F4 · Hotspot
Which dated notice should the class inspect first for the latest change?
- a: Tuesday notice
- b: Thursday notice
- c: Wednesday notice
- d: Monday notice
Among relevant notices, Thursday is the most recent; its contents still need reading.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · Explain a rank change
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional card A has 30 likes and topic score 2. B has 10 likes and score 8. A leads by likes; B leads by topic score. Both claims are unverified.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the leader changes, and state what neither ranking establishes.
Example of a full-credit answer: A leads when likes are compared; B leads when the supplied topic score is compared. The rule changed which signal matters. Neither ranking establishes that either claim is true.
- Connects the changed leader to the changed likes/topic-score rule.
- States that neither rule verifies factual accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: feed lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rule orders three posts by descending likes: Sprout 18, River 27, Kite 9. Every post is still awaiting evidence review.
1A · Hotspot
Select the first post under the stated rule.
- a: Kite
- b: River
- c: Sprout
- d: All three tied
River has the greatest supplied like count, 27.
1B · Short answer
Explain why that post leads and name the separate step needed before trusting its claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: River leads because 27 is the highest like count. Its claim still needs source and evidence checking; the ranking only counts likes.
- Uses River’s 27 likes to explain its position under the stated rule.
- Identifies a separate relevant evidence check before accepting its claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reader needs a map of the school garden, not a shop advert or a song. The prepared cards are A: garden map; B: garden-tool sale; C: garden song; D: unrelated sports timetable.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each task to the directly relevant card.
Complete or match: Find garden paths; Compare tool sale prices; Read garden-song lyrics
- a: Card C
- b: Card A
- c: Card D
- d: Card B
Format and purpose matter in addition to the shared word garden.
2B · Open ended
Choose the first card for the reader’s task and justify it with the needed information and format.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because it contains paths and labelled garden beds in a map, which directly serves finding locations. A sale or song shares the topic word but not the needed information.
- Selects A and identifies its location/path information.
- Explains why the map format fits the navigation task better than the alternatives.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional inventory lists torch A checked yesterday, torch B checked last month and torch C checked last week. The task is to inspect the least recently checked torch first. No item is claimed faulty.
3A · Multiple choice
Which torch comes first under the stated inspection rule?
- a: Torch C
- b: All three equally old
- c: Torch A
- d: Torch B
Last month is the least recent check, so B comes first.
3B · Open ended
Apply the ranking idea to explain the first choice and say what its position does not tell us.
Example of a full-credit answer: B comes first because it has the oldest stated check. That priority does not prove B is broken; a new inspection is needed to learn its condition.
- Connects B’s oldest check with the stated priority rule.
- Distinguishes inspection priority from evidence of a fault.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “This card is first under most likes, so a fact checker must have approved it.” The supplied algorithm uses only like counts and contains no fact-check step.
4A · True or false
True or false? The learner’s statement follows from the supplied algorithm.
- true: True
- false: False
No fact-check operation exists in the stated rule.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken inference and rewrite the conclusion to match the rule.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses popularity ranking with fact-check approval. The supported conclusion is only that the card has the most likes among these cards; its accuracy is not established.
- Identifies the confusion between popularity and verification.
- States the limited most-likes conclusion without adding an accuracy claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school feed must let readers find recent notices, show topic matches separately and identify paid placements. It must not label any ranking score “truth”.
5A · Matching
Match the label to the information it communicates.
Complete or match: How recent the notice is; How it matches the selected subject; Whether the supplied record marks payment
- a: Topic-match score
- b: Paid-placement label
- c: Truth guarantee
- d: Publication date
Each signal has its own meaning and does not substitute for fact-checking.
5B · Open ended
Propose an ordering control and a short explanation that makes its limit clear.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer “Newest first” using the publication date. Explain: “This order compares dates; it does not verify the claims. Read the source and check important information.”
- Proposes an explicit usable rule based on a named signal.
- Explains that the rule does not establish truth or replace evidence checking.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.8 · How recommendation systems work
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A useful shortcut
Fictional worked example
A fictional reading app knows a chosen category is mysteries and suggests three mystery books. The learner wants a mystery today.
Question: How might the list help?
Answer: It offers a starting set that fits the stated category preference.
Why: It saves browsing time but does not guarantee that every book suits the reader.
Example 2 · Outside the list
Fictional worked example
A fictional home page shows only music, but its catalogue includes maps and science.
Question: Can a learner conclude that science is unavailable?
Answer: No. The home page is a selection, not the entire catalogue.
Why: A direct catalogue search can reveal items omitted from recommendations.
Example 3 · A misunderstood click
| Observed | Not established |
|---|---|
| Opened insect article | General favourite topic |
| Homework task supplied | Long-term preference |
Fictional worked example
A fictional student opens an insect article to check a homework answer. A system treats the click as a topic-interest signal.
Question: What is uncertain?
Answer: Whether the student wants more insect articles outside the task.
Why: The observed action and the reason behind it are different information.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Look beyond the suggested row
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional shelf contains Map A, Map B, Story C and Music D. Its suggested row shows only Map A and Map B because map preference is highest.
F1 · Hotspot
Which statement correctly describes the omitted story?
- a: It exists in the catalogue but is not suggested.
- b: It is proved unavailable everywhere.
- c: It must have incorrect information.
- d: Every learner has rejected it.
The source explicitly includes Story C in the catalogue.
Investigation: recommend lab
F2 · Helpful and limited
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner wants a short beginner drawing lesson. A suggestion is labelled “Beginner drawing, 4 minutes”. The source gives no check of the lesson’s factual claims.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which conclusions are supported?
- a: The learner must follow the suggestion.
- b: The label matches the requested topic and level.
- c: The label proves every explanation is correct.
- d: The label gives a four-minute duration.
The labels establish topic, stated level and duration, not guaranteed accuracy or obligation.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Three routes to content
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reader can use a suggested row, type a catalogue query or browse all categories. The screen describes each route separately.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place the route beside its stated action.
Complete or match: Inspect preference-based selections; Enter words for a wanted item; Look through subject groups
- a: A truth certificate
- b: Suggested row
- c: Catalogue search
- d: Category browser
Each route changes discovery; none automatically verifies content.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · A click with another purpose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner opens three chess posts to help a cousin find tournament rules. The next suggestions are chess posts. The record says nothing about the learner’s own hobbies.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which interpretation best fits the supplied history?
- a: The clicks may reflect the cousin’s task.
- b: The system knows the learner’s full intention.
- c: Chess is proved the learner’s only hobby.
- d: Every chess suggestion must be correct.
The source supplies a task-specific reason for the clicks.
Investigation: feed lab
F5 · Plan a broader project search
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional “water” project list shows only swimming clips. The task needs water use in homes and gardens as well. Those categories exist in the catalogue.
F5 · Open ended
Propose a way to find the missing project topics and explain why the current row is insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: Browse or search the home-water and garden-water categories, or adjust the preference/variety controls. The swimming-only row leaves out two required project areas even though they exist.
- Proposes a relevant route to home and garden water content.
- Explains the gap between the narrow recommendation row and the broader project requirements.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: recommend lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy catalogue has Art A, Art B, Science C and Story D. List P shows A, B, C; List Q shows A, C, D. Both lists contain three items. No quality rating is supplied.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the comparison.
Complete or match: Contains two art items; Contains three categories; Establishes that all claims are correct
- a: List P
- b: Both prove accuracy
- c: Neither list
- d: List Q
P has two art items, Q has three categories, and neither verifies accuracy.
1B · Open ended
Explain one difference in what a learner encounters and one limit shared by both lists.
Example of a full-credit answer: P repeats art while Q includes art, science and stories, giving broader category exposure. Neither list establishes that its items are accurate or right for every learner.
- Accurately compares repeated art in P with three-category exposure in Q.
- States a valid shared limit concerning accuracy or individual suitability.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for two explanations of how shadows form. Plan A follows one suggestion and stops. B compares a suggestion with a relevant independently checked science source. C chooses only by like count.
2A · Matching
Match the plan to its stated method.
Complete or match: Stops after one suggested item; Adds a relevant checked source; Chooses by likes alone
- a: Plan B
- b: Plan C
- c: Plan A
- d: No listed plan
The source distinguishes one-item use, evidence comparison and popularity-only selection.
2B · Open ended
Choose the plan that best fits the two-explanation task and justify its source-checking advantage.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B because it compares two relevant explanations and includes a checked science source. It creates an opportunity to check claims instead of relying on the suggestion or likes alone.
- Selects B because it supplies the requested comparison of explanations.
- Explains why evidence/source comparison improves on relying solely on a recommendation signal.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum shop recommends only dinosaur books after a visitor inspects one. The visitor is choosing a gift for a friend who likes oceans. A catalogue also lists ocean books.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each item beside its role.
Complete or match: What the system currently suggests; What the buyer actually needs to satisfy; Where other available topics can be found
- a: Full catalogue
- b: Dinosaur row
- c: Ocean gift request
- d: Proof of identity
The recommendation signal and the gift recipient’s stated need differ.
3B · Open ended
Apply the active-choice lesson to propose a next step and explain why the original suggestion may not fit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Search or browse ocean books in the catalogue. The dinosaur suggestion reflects the inspected item, while the actual task is a gift for an ocean-interested friend.
- Proposes a relevant ocean-category search or browse.
- Explains the difference between the observed inspection and the real gift purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional screen recommends cooking videos to Ana after she checks a recipe for a school event. A classmate says, “The screen proves Ana only cares about cooking.”
4A · Multiple choice
Which correction best fits the evidence?
- a: The screen can identify every private preference.
- b: A task-related action does not establish all her interests.
- c: More suggestions prove that she agreed with every video.
- d: One recipe proves a lifelong single interest.
The supplied history explains a limited task, not a complete identity.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overgeneralisation and state a narrower supported conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: The classmate turns one task-related signal into a claim about all Ana’s interests. We can say that cooking suggestions followed her recipe search, but not that cooking is her only interest.
- Identifies the leap from one task/action to a complete claim about interests.
- Replaces it with a limited conclusion supported by the recorded sequence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner has 20 minutes for a local-birds project and needs one suggested video plus a separate reference check. The plan must leave time to record an answer and stop when the task is done.
5A · True or false
True or false? A recommendation plan can include a direct reference check and a stopping point.
- true: True
- false: False
The required sources and the stated time limit can be planned together.
5B · Open ended
Propose a twenty-minute plan meeting the source requirement and explain how you would decide whether to use the suggested claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use about 6 minutes for a suitable suggested video, 7 for the separate reference and 7 for comparison and notes. Use the claim only if the relevant evidence supports it; note any unresolved disagreement.
- Proposes a feasible plan of at most twenty minutes with both required sources and time for notes.
- Bases use of the suggested claim on evidence comparison rather than its recommended status.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.9 · How personalisation affects what people see
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A chosen language
Fictional worked example
A fictional map page has English and Filipino buttons. Selecting Filipino changes labels but not the marked school location.
Question: What was personalised?
Answer: The display language.
Why: The explicit setting changes presentation, not the location’s factual position.
Example 2 · A temporary interest
Fictional worked example
A fictional learner researches boats for one project. A toy system infers a boat preference from the searches.
Question: Why might the preference need review later?
Answer: The project may end while the inferred preference remains.
Why: A past task is not a permanent description of interests.
Example 3 · Necessary data
| Feature | Needed input |
|---|---|
| Larger text | Text-size choice |
| Language labels | Language choice |
Fictional worked example
A fictional reading page can enlarge text using a size setting. It asks whether a street address is needed.
Question: Is an address needed for this feature?
Answer: No. The size choice supplies the needed information.
Why: Match data collection to the stated purpose.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Explain two different screens
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional catalogue has the same six items for everyone. Jo selects “maps first”; Kim selects “stories first”. Their front rows differ because of those settings.
F1 · Multiple choice
What explains the stated difference?
- a: Every selected item is fact-checked.
- b: The catalogue contains no shared items.
- c: They chose different category settings.
- d: One learner must be unable to read.
The source directly identifies different chosen category priorities.
Investigation: recommend lab
F2 · Chosen or guessed
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional page records three changes: Lia selects large text; a tool infers sports interest after an opened article; Bo resets the topic filter to show all categories.
F2 · Matching
Match each action to its description.
Complete or match: Lia’s text-size selection; Tool’s sports-interest guess; Bo’s all-categories reset
- a: Explicit display choice
- b: Removal of a category filter
- c: Verified personal identity
- d: Inferred topic preference
The actions distinguish a direct choice, an inference and a reset.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Use only needed information
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task provides three features: language display needs a language choice; text enlargement needs a size choice; an all-school timetable needs no home address.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the feature-to-input mapping.
Complete or match: Change display language; Enlarge the letters; Show the all-school timetable
- a: Language choice
- b: No home address needed
- c: Private contact list
- d: Text-size choice
The fixed feature requirements do not call for private contact or address data.
Investigation: privacy lab
F4 · Useful but incomplete
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional local-event view shows only library events because that category is selected. The full calendar also includes sports and art. The selected view has accurate dates.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements are supported?
- a: The selected view can help find library events.
- b: Other categories may be missing from that view.
- c: Accurate dates require collecting a home address.
- d: The selected view proves sports events do not exist.
Filtering can aid a task while omitting items that remain in the full calendar.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · Explain an inference limit
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner opens a knitting guide to help a grandparent. The toy system changes the topic score for knitting from 1 to 5. The learner has not selected a permanent preference.
F5 · Short answer
Explain how the setting changed and why it may not represent the learner’s lasting interests.
Example of a full-credit answer: The system inferred interest from the opened knitting guide and raised the score. The action was to help a grandparent, so it does not establish a lasting personal interest.
- Connects the raised score to an inference from the opened guide.
- Uses the helping purpose to explain the limit of the lasting-interest inference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional catalogue gives music score 5, maps score 2 and stories score 1 for User A. User B sets maps 5, stories 3 and music 1. Higher category score appears earlier.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from the fixed profiles?
- a: B’s map items rank before B’s music.
- b: The scores prove the items are accurate.
- c: A’s music items rank before A’s maps.
- d: Both profiles must produce identical orders.
Each profile prioritises the category with its higher stated score.
1B · Short answer
Compare what the two users are likely to encounter first in this model and explain one fact the profiles cannot establish.
Example of a full-credit answer: A encounters music earlier while B encounters maps earlier. The profiles do not establish which items are accurate or the users’ complete identities.
- Correctly contrasts A’s music-first and B’s maps-first order.
- Names a valid limit such as no accuracy or complete-identity conclusion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional lesson page offers named language, text-size and topic controls. Its notice explains what each changes. A competing design changes all three without showing settings.
2A · Drag and drop
Place the named setting beside its direct effect.
Complete or match: Changes the wording language; Changes letter size; Changes which subject cards appear
- a: Identity detector
- b: Topic filter
- c: Text-size setting
- d: Language setting
The transparent design names the purpose of each independent control.
2B · Open ended
Choose the more understandable design and justify it using explanation and learner control.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose the visible-controls design. It tells learners which setting changes which feature, and it lets them review or adjust the choices when their task changes.
- Selects the visible design because it explains the changes.
- Explains the value of being able to review or adjust the relevant setting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum guide offers a chosen audio language and a chosen exhibition section. Mira selects the sea exhibit for a class task. The guide does not infer intelligence or ability from that choice.
3A · True or false
True or false? Choosing the sea exhibit proves Mira cannot understand other exhibits.
- true: True
- false: False
The selection follows a task and does not measure ability.
3B · Open ended
Apply the personalisation idea to explain the selection and propose how Mira could access another exhibit later.
Example of a full-credit answer: The guide adapts to Mira’s chosen sea section for the assignment. She could change the section control or open the full exhibit menu later; the selection is not a judgement of ability.
- Explains the section choice as task-based adaptation rather than an ability judgement.
- Proposes a relevant control or full-menu route to other exhibits.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner selects “art only” and sees two events. The complete calendar contains six events, including those two. The learner says, “The school has only two events.”
4A · Multiple choice
Which correction is supported?
- a: Two art events appear within six total events.
- b: The filter creates four new events.
- c: The complete calendar contains only art.
- d: All six events appear in the filtered row.
The selected view is a subset of the complete calendar.
4B · Open ended
Identify the reasoning error and state how to check the complete event count.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats a filtered subset as the full collection. Open the complete calendar or remove the art-only filter to see the six listed events.
- Identifies confusion between the filtered subset and the full calendar.
- Gives a correct full-calendar/filter-removal check and the supplied count of six.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reading tool should offer large text and a chosen reading topic. It may not ask for a home address, and learners must be able to return to all topics.
5A · Hotspot
Which control directly restores the full topic view?
- a: An “All topics” reset
- b: A larger advertisement panel
- c: A permanent single-topic lock
- d: A hidden address question
An all-topics reset removes the stated category restriction.
5B · Open ended
Propose the settings for this tool and explain how your design limits unnecessary data collection.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer text-size buttons, a topic selector and an All topics reset. Use those choices only; a home address is unnecessary for changing text size or topics and should not be requested.
- Proposes the required size/topic controls with a way back to all topics.
- Connects data minimisation to the feature purpose and excludes the unnecessary home address.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.10 · How echo chambers develop
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Four copies, one report
Fictional worked example
A fictional bulletin’s park count is copied unchanged by three blogs. All four name the same original tally.
Question: How many original tallies are supplied?
Answer: One.
Why: Distribution expanded, but no additional measurement is described.
Example 2 · Different evidence, same answer
Fictional worked example
Two fictional teams independently count chairs before an event; each records 24.
Question: Is their agreement the same as a copied count?
Answer: No. Two independent counting processes are described.
Why: Agreement from independent methods adds useful support, though counting errors remain possible.
Example 3 · An apparent conflict
| Time | Gate |
|---|---|
| 08:00 | Closed |
| 09:00 | Open |
Fictional worked example
One fictional post says the gate was closed at 8 am; another says it opened at 9 am. Both supply matching time-stamped records.
Question: Must one be false?
Answer: No. They describe different times.
Why: Compare the scope of statements before declaring a conflict.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Trace the repeated statement
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message A reports that the reading room moved. B and C repeat A’s wording and link to A. No independent room check is supplied.
F1 · Multiple choice
How many separate original reports are shown?
- a: No visible messages
- b: Two original reports
- c: One original report
- d: Three original reports
B and C share A as their stated origin; visibility is not independent reporting.
Investigation: origin lab
F2 · Distinguish routes
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional case gives three routes: A copies a notice; B independently phones the school office through its known number; C shares A without checking. The office supplies the current room number.
F2 · Drag and drop
Place each route beside its description.
Complete or match: Copies the original notice directly; Adds an office check; Copies a copy without checking
- a: Route A
- b: Route B
- c: A hidden fourth route
- d: Route C
Only B adds the stated independent check.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · A narrow recommendation row
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional feed shows three posts supporting one claim. All three use the same untested source. The collection also includes a directly relevant field report that has not appeared in the row.
F3 · Hotspot
Which next step most directly improves the evidence comparison?
- a: Inspect the relevant field report and its method.
- b: Count the three reposts as three new tests.
- c: Accept the claim because it appears repeatedly.
- d: Assume the missing report cannot be useful.
The field report may add relevant evidence; it must still be examined.
Investigation: recommend lab
F4 · Compare source independence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional table describes Source P as an original pond count, Q as a copy of P, and R as a separate pond count by another team on the same day.
F4 · Matching
Match each source to its method.
Complete or match: First team’s original count; Copy of the first team’s count; Second team’s separate count
- a: Source R
- b: Source Q
- c: An unspecified source
- d: Source P
P and R collect their own observations; Q repeats P.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · Broaden a one-circle discussion
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class chat uses only posts from its own gardening club to discuss why a tree’s leaves changed colour. Those posts repeat one guess. A current observation log and a botany explanation are available but unread.
F5 · Short answer
Propose two useful checks beyond the repeated guess and explain how they could improve the conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the current observation log to establish the tree’s actual conditions and compare a relevant botany explanation of possible causes. These add case evidence and scientific context instead of more copies of the guess.
- Proposes both a relevant observation check and a relevant explanatory-source check.
- Explains that these add evidence or context absent from repeated copies.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional collection contains A: an original survey; B: a repost of A; C: another repost of A; D: a separate interview project. The survey and interviews ask the same school-library question.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the origin comparison.
Complete or match: Number sharing the survey origin; Number of distinct original projects; What mere independence provides about certainty
- a: Four independent projects
- b: Two original projects
- c: No truth guarantee
- d: Three visible reports
A/B/C share one project; D is separate. Origin counting does not prove truth.
1B · Short answer
Explain the number of original projects and why their independence does not guarantee accuracy, even if their findings agree.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are two: the survey and the separate interviews; B and C repeat the survey. Both projects may have sampling or question limitations, so agreement alone is not certain proof about every student.
- Counts two origins and correctly treats B/C as survey copies.
- Names a relevant methodological or scope limitation even when independent projects agree.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional discussion claims the library is closed tomorrow. Available sources are P: another copy of the chat, Q: the library’s current dated notice, R: an unrelated sports opinion. The notice explicitly lists tomorrow’s hours.
2A · Matching
Match each source to its contribution.
Complete or match: Adds another copy of the claim; Adds a direct current schedule; Adds an unrelated opinion
- a: Source R
- b: Source P
- c: Source Q
- d: A guaranteed universal answer
Q supplies directly relevant current information; P repeats and R changes the subject.
2B · Open ended
Choose the most useful source and justify it using relevance and independence from the chat.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose Q because it directly states tomorrow’s library hours and is a current library notice rather than another copy of the chat.
- Selects Q and connects it to the exact date/opening-hours question.
- Explains that Q supplies a direct schedule outside the repeated chat source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rumour passes from Sol to Tin, then to Paz and Ren. All repeat Sol’s guess that the quiz was cancelled. The teacher’s schedule has not been checked.
3A · Multiple choice
Which statement best describes the evidence?
- a: The map proves the quiz is definitely cancelled.
- b: Each extra speaker makes the guess a new observation.
- c: Four speakers establish four teacher confirmations.
- d: Four speakers can still share one untested guess.
The network expands the audience without adding the missing schedule check.
3B · Open ended
Apply the origin-checking idea to explain the rumour and propose a suitable next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: All versions trace to Sol’s guess, so repetition does not confirm cancellation. Check the teacher’s current schedule or ask through the established class channel.
- Traces the repeated rumour to the single untested origin.
- Proposes a relevant direct teacher/schedule check through a known route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “To escape repeated claims, I should accept any opposite claim without checking.” The supplied plan instead requires relevant evidence and method checks for every source.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements correctly repair the plan?
- a: Accept every opposite slogan without a method.
- b: Seek relevant sources with different evidence.
- c: Apply evidence checks to the new sources too.
- d: Treat disagreement alone as a truth guarantee.
Broadening seeks better evidence, not automatic trust in the opposite position.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s error and propose a better broadening rule.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner replaces trust in repetition with trust in opposition. A better rule is to seek relevant independent evidence and inspect its method, scope and limits before changing the conclusion.
- Explains why being opposite is not sufficient evidence of truth.
- Proposes relevant source broadening with an evidence/method check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class must investigate a claim about increased playground shade. It has one copied newsletter claim and can consult a dated site plan plus a new observation. It must report unresolved differences instead of voting on truth.
5A · True or false
True or false? Counting the number of repeated posts is enough to replace the plan and observation.
- true: True
- false: False
The task requires relevant evidence about the place and conditions, not a vote of copies.
5B · Open ended
Propose a source-comparison plan and explain how you would handle a remaining disagreement.
Example of a full-credit answer: Trace the newsletter to its origin, inspect the dated plan and compare a new observation under stated conditions. If records differ, report which date or condition differs and leave the conclusion limited until the gap is resolved.
- Proposes comparing the original claim with both the plan and a relevant new observation.
- Handles disagreement by examining scope/conditions and reporting uncertainty rather than voting or hiding it.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL1.11 · How online content influences beliefs and behaviour
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An invitation is not attendance
Fictional worked example
A fictional club invitation records 25 views. Its attendance sheet lists 9 visitors.
Question: Which record answers how many attended?
Answer: The attendance sheet: 9.
Why: Views measure exposure; attendance needs its own record.
Example 2 · A strong feeling, a separate fact
Fictional worked example
A fictional post says “Wonderful news!” and gives a checked library reopening time.
Question: Does emotional wording make the time false?
Answer: No. Check the time’s evidence separately.
Why: Emotion can shape attention without deciding factual accuracy.
Example 3 · Two changes at once
| Week | Conditions |
|---|---|
| Before | No new poster; fewer bins |
| After | New poster; extra bins |
Fictional worked example
A fictional recycling count rises during a week when a new poster and extra bins are introduced.
Question: What can the record not isolate?
Answer: How much of the increase was caused by the poster alone.
Why: Access to extra bins is another plausible influence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the requested action
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school post says “Bring a labelled water bottle on the field trip.” It shows 30 likes. No record of packed bags is supplied.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from the source?
- a: Thirty learners are proved to have packed bottles.
- b: The requested action concerns a labelled bottle.
- c: Every reader must agree with the reminder.
- d: The like count does not establish packing completion.
The message states the request; the reactions do not verify completed action.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · A limited observation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner reads a checked explanation of a school recycling rule, then sorts paper correctly in a class exercise. The source records only this learner and this exercise.
F2 · True or false
True or false? The record establishes that every future reader will sort all waste correctly.
- true: True
- false: False
The evidence is limited to one learner and one recorded exercise.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Different measurements
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional campaign records 100 page views, 20 likes and 12 signed-up volunteers. Its records define each measure separately.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place each quantity beside the measured outcome.
Complete or match: Recorded page views; Recorded likes; Recorded volunteer sign-ups
- a: 100
- b: 12
- c: 20
- d: All viewers volunteered
Views, reactions and sign-ups are different outcomes.
Investigation: graph lab
F4 · Recognise persuasive features
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster contains the phrase “Join before Friday”, a cheering crowd illustration, and a stated checkable location “Hall B”. The source identifies the crowd as an illustration.
F4 · Matching
Match each feature to its direct role.
Complete or match: Join before Friday; Cheering crowd illustration; Hall B
- a: Illustrated social cue
- b: Checkable location detail
- c: Measured attendance total
- d: Deadline cue
The illustration is a persuasive feature, not an attendance measurement.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A post and a practical change
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional bicycle-club signup count rises from 6 to 14 after a new online invitation and the provision of free helmets begin in the same week. No comparison group is supplied.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the invitation alone cannot be credited for the increase, and name a comparison that could help investigate its influence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Free helmets began at the same time and could also affect signups. Compare similar groups with the same helmet access and different invitation exposure, while recording the same signup outcome and period.
- Identifies the simultaneous helmet change as a possible alternative influence.
- Proposes a relevant comparison that controls helmet access or otherwise separates the invitation’s influence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reading campaign records 80 page views, 24 reactions and 11 completed reading logs. These counts come from three different records and are not assumed to be unique people.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the outcome mapping.
Complete or match: Page-view events; Reaction events; Completed reading logs
- a: 80 confirmed readers
- b: 11
- c: 80
- d: 24
Only the log record measures completed reading logs; views need not be unique people.
1B · Open ended
Explain which record best answers the completion question and one limit of using page views instead.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the 11 completed logs to answer the recorded completion question. Eighty views do not establish 80 completed tasks and may include repeat views by the same person.
- Identifies the 11 completed logs as the relevant completion evidence.
- Explains that views are not task completion and/or may include repeats.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional popular post says a school event has moved indoors and urges immediate sharing. It gives no source. The organiser’s established noticeboard is available for checking.
2A · Multiple choice
Which next action best fits the evidence gap?
- a: Use last month’s location as today’s proof.
- b: Declare the claim false because it sounds urgent.
- c: Forward immediately because reactions are high.
- d: Check the organiser’s current notice before sharing.
A current source from the organiser can address the exact claim; popularity and urgency do not decide it.
2B · Open ended
Choose a response and justify it using the source gap and the possible effect of sharing.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the organiser’s current notice first because the post gives no source. Sharing an unchecked location could send people to the wrong place, so pause until the relevant detail is confirmed.
- Chooses a current organiser check and connects it to the missing source.
- Explains a relevant consequence of forwarding unverified location information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional library puts a new sign beside its return box and moves the box to the entrance on the same day. Returns rise. A manager says the sign alone caused the change.
3A · Hotspot
Which factor must also be considered?
- a: The sign must have been the only relevant change.
- b: More returns prove every visitor read the sign.
- c: The box became easier to reach.
- d: Each returned book is an independent test of the sign.
Moving the box could affect return convenience independently of the sign.
3B · Short answer
Apply the cause-checking idea to explain the manager’s error and propose a fairer test.
Example of a full-credit answer: The sign and box location changed together, so the increase cannot isolate the sign. Keep the box location the same while comparing sign versions during comparable periods, and record returns.
- Identifies the simultaneous location change as an alternative explanation.
- Proposes a comparison that keeps location comparable while testing the sign and measuring returns.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “Two hundred shares prove everyone believes this claim and that it is true.” The source reports only 200 sharing events, with no belief survey or evidence check.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which corrections are justified?
- a: The claim still needs relevant evidence checking.
- b: Sharing events do not measure everyone’s beliefs.
- c: Each share guarantees the sharer agrees.
- d: Two hundred events prove two hundred independent tests.
Sharing can occur for different reasons and does not itself verify a claim.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken belief inference and the mistaken truth inference.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner assumes that every sharing event means agreement and represents everyone. They also treat the share count as proof of truth even though no relevant evidence check is supplied.
- Explains why share events do not establish everyone’s agreement or beliefs.
- Explains why share counts do not establish factual truth.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants more reusable lunch containers. Its message must explain the request without shaming anyone, give a practical option for families without a container, and measure the response without publishing names.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each design feature to its purpose.
Complete or match: Invite use when available; Offer a school borrowing option; Record a class total without names
- a: Public ranking of families
- b: Clear request
- c: Access support
- d: Privacy-respecting measurement
The plan separates a useful request, an access option and an aggregate outcome measure.
5B · Open ended
Write a respectful proposed message and describe how you would measure its response without exposing individuals.
Example of a full-credit answer: “If you have a reusable container, bring it for lunch; you can borrow one from school if needed.” Count the class total using containers and report only totals, without names or family rankings.
- Proposes a clear non-shaming request with a practical borrowing/access option.
- Describes an aggregate response measure that does not publish learner names or family rankings.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.1 · Meaning and purpose of artificial intelligence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · No robot required
Fictional worked example
A fictional program receives a typed description and drafts a poem. It has no moving body.
Question: Can the described generation task be an AI task?
Answer: Yes. AI can operate as software without a robot body.
Why: Identify the stated computational task rather than its physical appearance.
Example 2 · An output needs review
Fictional worked example
A fictional image classifier labels a blue triangular card “red circle”. The actual card is supplied for checking.
Question: Which should the learner trust here?
Answer: The checked card features, while recording the classifier’s error.
Why: The output is a prediction to compare with evidence, not a replacement for that evidence.
Example 3 · Purpose first
| Task | Stated basis |
|---|---|
| Picture organisation | Anonymous object images |
| Prize decision | No criteria supplied |
Fictional worked example
A fictional teacher wants to organise anonymous object pictures. Another proposal asks the same tool to decide who deserves a prize without criteria.
Question: Which task is clearly defined?
Answer: Organising object pictures has a stated input and purpose.
Why: A consequential prize decision needs explicit criteria and human responsibility, not an unexplained output.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name the parts
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional speech tool receives a recording, applies its trained speech-recognition model and returns a written transcript.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the input-process-output mapping.
Complete or match: Input; Process; Output
- a: Model processing
- b: Written transcript
- c: A guaranteed truth record
- d: Recording
The transcript is the output of processing the supplied audio.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Describe the system
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional program predicts a picture label from learned examples. It runs on an ordinary computer and sometimes mislabels pictures.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which description fits the case?
- a: A living person hidden inside the computer
- b: A tool guaranteed correct because it is fast
- c: A machine with knowledge of every school topic
- d: Human-designed software making fallible predictions
The case describes learned software and explicitly records possible errors.
Investigation: training lab
F3 · One tool, one evaluated task
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sorter gets 18 of 20 labelled leaf pictures correct. It has never been evaluated on audio recordings. An additional demonstration leaf set records 16 correct labels out of 20; neither set tests audio.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The leaf-picture result alone establishes accuracy at recognising spoken instructions.
- true: True
- false: False
Speech recognition is a different task and was not evaluated.
Investigation: data balance lab
F4 · Generation or classification
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool receives “write a two-line welcome” and produces new wording. It is not choosing one of two supplied object categories.
F4 · Hotspot
Which function is directly described?
- a: Sorting objects into two fixed bins
- b: Confirming every visitor’s identity
- c: Measuring a real temperature
- d: Generating a draft text
The stated output is a newly generated text draft.
Investigation: prompt lab
F5 · A proposed classroom helper
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group wants software to suggest labels for anonymous drawings. A teacher will check labels before display. The system’s past accuracy is not supplied.
F5 · Short answer
State the system’s intended job and one check needed before relying on its labels.
Example of a full-credit answer: Its job is to suggest labels for anonymous drawings. Compare labels with a suitable checked set of drawings and have the teacher review proposed labels before display.
- Clearly identifies suggesting drawing labels as the intended job.
- Proposes a relevant correctness check or supervised review before reliance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: evidence lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional catalogue describes A: assigns a leaf type; B: estimates tomorrow’s number of book returns from past counts; C: drafts a story beginning.
1A · Matching
Match each function to its stated tool.
Complete or match: Classification; Numerical prediction; Text generation
- a: Tool B
- b: All tasks are identical
- c: Tool A
- d: Tool C
The outputs are a category, an estimate and generated text.
1B · Open ended
Explain how two of these outputs differ and why neither should automatically be treated as certain.
Example of a full-credit answer: A leaf category identifies a class while the returns estimate predicts a count, or the story tool generates wording. Predictions and generated content can be wrong or unsuitable, so each needs checks matched to its task.
- Correctly contrasts two stated output types.
- Explains that outputs need task-appropriate review rather than automatic certainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom display calls a pattern tool “a clever friend who always knows the answer”. The actual tool uses example data and sometimes makes errors.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which replacements are accurate?
- a: Its friendly name proves human understanding.
- b: Its errors disappear whenever it is called AI.
- c: People designed the tool for a stated pattern task.
- d: Its outputs can need checking and correction.
The design and test record support a limited software description.
2B · Open ended
Propose a clearer display sentence and justify why “always knows” should be removed.
Example of a full-credit answer: “This human-designed tool suggests answers from patterns; check its results.” Remove “always knows” because the test record includes errors and a friendly presentation does not prove certainty.
- Proposes a description identifying a human-designed task/output with review.
- Uses the error record to reject the certainty claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional garden device receives moisture readings, estimates whether watering is needed, and displays a suggestion. A gardener checks the soil and weather before acting.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the roles.
Complete or match: Information supplied to the system; Result shown by the model; Final contextual check
- a: Moisture readings
- b: Watering suggestion
- c: Gardener review
- d: Guaranteed plant health
Input, model output and human action remain distinct.
3B · Short answer
Apply the input-output idea to this helper and explain why the gardener’s check remains useful.
Example of a full-credit answer: Moisture readings are input and the watering suggestion is output. A gardener checks soil and weather because a reading or model may miss conditions relevant to whether watering is suitable.
- Correctly identifies the moisture input and watering-suggestion output.
- Explains a relevant contextual or error-checking reason for human review.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says “AI must have arms; this text program cannot be AI.” The supplied program generates sentences using a trained language model.
4A · Drag and drop
Place each supplied fact beside what it describes.
Complete or match: Ordinary computer with no arms; Generates sentences with a trained model; AI must have arms
- a: Unsupported definition
- b: Proof of perfect accuracy
- c: Physical form
- d: Software function
The learner’s definition adds an unjustified body requirement.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error and give a corrected description of the program.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses a robot body with AI. The program is software using a trained language model to generate text; it can do that without arms and its output still needs review.
- Identifies the mistaken requirement for a physical robot body.
- Correctly describes the stated trained text-generation function without claiming perfect performance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants an AI helper to sort anonymous drawings into “contains a circle” or “no circle”. The plan must preserve a teacher review step and may not judge the children’s abilities.
5A · Hotspot
Which output stays within the proposed task?
- a: A suggested circle/no-circle label
- b: A prediction of every future grade
- c: A permanent judgement of intelligence
- d: A claim about the artist’s private life
The authorised task concerns the drawing feature, not a person’s worth or future.
5B · Open ended
Propose the helper’s input and output, then explain a review boundary that protects the stated purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use anonymous drawing images as input and suggested circle/no-circle labels as output. A teacher checks the feature labels and the system must not turn them into judgements about children’s abilities.
- Specifies the anonymous drawing input and the two requested feature-label outputs.
- Includes human review and keeps the output from becoming an ability judgement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.2 · Difference between artificial intelligence and traditional software
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A stated threshold
Fictional worked example
A fictional library rule gives an alert when a learner has more than three borrowed books. A program applies that exact condition.
Question: Why is a written rule suitable?
Answer: The required condition is explicitly specified.
Why: No training examples are needed to discover a limit already given as a rule.
Example 2 · Learning varied shapes
Fictional worked example
A fictional system is trained on many labelled handwritten digits to recognise new handwriting.
Question: What is learned from examples?
Answer: Patterns relating different written shapes to digit labels.
Why: The system is not merely applying a single manually stated shape threshold.
Example 3 · A combined product
| Part | Task |
|---|---|
| Recognition model | Convert speech into words |
| Countdown program | Measure the stated duration |
Fictional worked example
A fictional voice timer uses speech recognition to produce “five minutes”, then a countdown program measures that duration.
Question: Must the whole product use one technique?
Answer: No. It combines a learned recognition component with a programmed timer.
Why: A product can contain several kinds of software.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name the development method
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional record describes A: a developer writes a threshold; B: a model is fitted from labelled examples; C: a user runs the already-fitted model on a new input.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the descriptions.
Complete or match: Action A; Action B; Action C
- a: Model training
- b: Guaranteed correctness
- c: Model use
- d: Rule programming
Writing a rule, fitting a model and using it are separate actions.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Calculate a rule output
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rule labels values below 5 as A and values 5 or above as B. The new input is 4. No learned examples change this rule.
F2 · Hotspot
Which label follows from the fixed rule for input 4?
- a: A
- b: Both labels necessarily
- c: B
- d: No rule is supplied
Four is below five, so the stated rule returns A.
Investigation: training lab
F3 · Inspect software components
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reading app has a model that recognises a photographed word, a written rule that checks whether the word is in a vocabulary list, and a screen that displays the result.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place each action beside its component.
Complete or match: Estimate the photographed word; Check the supplied vocabulary list; Show the resulting message
- a: Display screen
- b: Membership rule
- c: A human brain
- d: Recognition model
A product can combine learned estimation and direct rules.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Changing behaviour
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional update log says: Monday a developer changes the alert threshold; Tuesday a team retrains a handwriting model with corrected labels; Wednesday users submit new pictures to the unchanged model.
F4 · Matching
Match the day to the stated change.
Complete or match: Direct rule edit; Model retraining; Use without retraining
- a: Wednesday
- b: No stated day
- c: Monday
- d: Tuesday
The record explicitly separates editing a rule, retraining and ordinary use.
Investigation: provenance lab
F5 · Two methods disagree
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rule labels numbers below 5 as A. A nearest-example toy uses examples 1:A and 4:B. For input 3, the rule returns A while the nearest example returns B. The correct real-world label is not supplied.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the methods disagree and state what extra information is needed to decide which output is correct.
Example of a full-credit answer: The rule checks whether 3 is below 5, giving A. The nearest-example method finds 4:B closest, giving B. A trusted label or task-specific evidence for input 3 is needed to judge correctness.
- Correctly contrasts the threshold result A with the nearest-example result B.
- Identifies a trusted label or task evidence as necessary to evaluate correctness.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: training lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rule uses below 6 → A, otherwise B. A nearest-example model uses 2:A and 5:B. Input 4 gives rule A and nearest-example B.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow?
- a: The nearest-example method returns B for input 4.
- b: The rule method returns A for input 4.
- c: A disagreement proves that B is the true label.
- d: Both methods must return the same output.
Four is below six and is nearer to five than to two; correctness needs ground truth.
1B · Open ended
Show how each method reaches its output and explain why disagreement alone cannot select the correct one.
Example of a full-credit answer: The threshold gives A because 4<6; distance to 5:B is 1 and to 2:A is 2, so the toy gives B. The true task label is absent, so neither output is established as correct just by comparing methods.
- Correctly explains both stated computations.
- Distinguishes method output from correctness and notes the missing trusted label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional game rule awards a token exactly when a score is at least 10. The requirement is fixed and explicit. No recognition of varied images is needed.
2A · Hotspot
Which implementation most directly matches the requirement?
- a: A popularity vote on each score
- b: A changing threshold with no explanation
- c: A written score-at-least-ten rule
- d: A guess from unrelated pictures
An explicit numeric requirement can be implemented directly as a rule.
2B · Open ended
Choose an approach and justify it using the known requirement and the need for consistency.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a written rule checking score ≥10. The required threshold is already known, and applying it consistently is more direct than trying to infer a different threshold from examples.
- Selects a direct rule because the threshold is explicitly supplied.
- Explains consistent application of the same requirement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional timer first estimates spoken words, then asks the user to confirm the duration, then runs a fixed countdown. Recognition can confuse “four” and “forty”.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each task beside its stage.
Complete or match: Estimate the spoken words; Let the user check the duration; Measure the confirmed time
- a: A truth guarantee
- b: Recognition
- c: Countdown
- d: Confirmation
The learned and programmed components are connected by a useful review step.
3B · Short answer
Explain why this combines methods and propose a check for the four/forty error.
Example of a full-credit answer: Speech recognition estimates words using a model, while a written countdown routine measures the chosen duration. Display “4 minutes” or “40 minutes” and ask for confirmation before starting.
- Distinguishes model-based recognition from programmed countdown behaviour.
- Proposes explicit duration confirmation before acting on the possible recognition error.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster says “Traditional programs use software; AI uses magic instead of software.” The supplied examples show both running as computer programs.
4A · Multiple choice
Which replacement is accurate?
- a: Every automatic rule must learn from examples.
- b: Traditional programs are unable to use any data.
- c: Both are software; their decision methods can differ.
- d: AI needs no programs, data or human design.
Both use software; the case contrasts direct rules with learned behaviour.
4B · Open ended
Identify the false contrast and give a corrected comparison of the two methods in this case.
Example of a full-credit answer: The poster wrongly treats AI as something outside software. Both are software: the traditional example applies a directly written rule, while the learned model is fitted from examples.
- States that AI and the traditional program are both software.
- Correctly contrasts the directly written rule with learning from examples in the supplied case.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional library app must recognise a photographed book code, let a librarian correct it, and apply the written rule “at most two loans”. It must not infer the loan limit from appearance.
5A · True or false
True or false? The stated two-loan limit should be applied as a known rule after the code is checked.
- true: True
- false: False
The plan separates uncertain recognition from an explicit policy rule.
5B · Open ended
Propose the three-stage workflow and explain where human review belongs.
Example of a full-credit answer: Recognise the code, have a librarian confirm or correct it, then apply the fixed two-loan rule. Review belongs before the code affects the loan record because recognition may be wrong.
- Provides recognition → confirmation/correction → fixed-rule application in a sensible sequence.
- Explains why human review occurs before an uncertain recognition result changes a record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.3 · How artificial intelligence learns from data
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Nearest supplied example
Fictional worked example
A fictional toy has 1:A and 8:B. A new value is 6.
Question: Which label does the nearest-example rule give?
Answer: B.
Why: Six is two units from 8 and five units from 1; this explains the toy output, not real-world truth.
Example 2 · A hidden shortcut
Fictional worked example
A fictional shape model sees triangles only on yellow cards and squares only on blue cards.
Question: What risk does the data create?
Answer: The model may rely on colour instead of the intended shape.
Why: Add checked examples that separate colour from shape, then test new combinations.
Example 3 · Training and testing
| Set | Correct/total |
|---|---|
| Training | 10/10 |
| Separate test | 6/10 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional model gets 10/10 training cards correct but only 6/10 separate test cards correct.
Question: Which score describes the separate test?
Answer: 6 out of 10.
Why: Perfect performance on familiar examples does not erase the errors on new ones.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Apply the toy method
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional nearest-example toy uses 2:A and 9:B. Its new input is 7. The closest example supplies the output label.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which output follows from the stated method?
- a: No examples are supplied
- b: Both necessarily
- c: A
- d: B
Seven is two from nine and five from two, so the toy returns B.
Investigation: training lab
F2 · Identify the learning ingredients
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional leaf task uses photographed leaves as inputs, checked tree-type names as labels, and a separate collection of new photographs for evaluation.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the role mapping.
Complete or match: Training inputs; Training target labels; Evaluation material
- a: Leaf photographs
- b: Separate new photographs
- c: Unrelated popularity counts
- d: Checked tree-type names
Inputs, target labels and independent evaluation serve different roles.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Diagnose a colour shortcut
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy study shows all round objects on green cards and all angular objects on orange cards. The intended task is shape, not card colour. New examples vary both shape and colour. The new training set includes each shape on both colours. A separate checked test set contains unseen combinations not used to fit the model.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place each collection beside its role.
Complete or match: Creates the colour shortcut risk; Separates shape from card colour; Checks unseen combinations after learning
- a: New training set
- b: Old set
- c: Separate test set
- d: Unlabelled advertising set
The revised design varies the irrelevant colour and checks new combinations.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · A limited test result
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model correctly labels 19 of 20 clear object pictures. No dim-light pictures are included in the test. A second clear-photo set shown in the explorer records 18 correct out of 20; it also contains no dim-light cases.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The result alone proves equally good performance in dim light.
- true: True
- false: False
The test does not include the different dim-light condition.
Investigation: data balance lab
F5 · Choose an improvement
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom model often mislabels striped balls because its training set contains only plain balls. The task includes both kinds. The team can add checked striped-ball examples and keep other striped balls for testing.
F5 · Open ended
Propose a targeted training improvement and explain how to check whether it helps on new cases.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add correctly labelled striped-ball examples to the training set. Test the revised model on different striped-ball examples kept out of training, alongside relevant plain-ball cases.
- Adds checked examples targeting the missing striped-ball condition.
- Uses separate relevant examples to evaluate transfer after the change.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional nearest-example model has entries 1:A, 4:A and 8:B. New value 6 is equally distant from 4 and 8. The stated tie rule selects the first listed of the tied examples.
1A · Drag and drop
Place each number beside the described role.
Complete or match: First of the equally nearest examples; Other equally nearest example; Example five units from the input
- a: 6
- b: 1
- c: 8
- d: 4
Four and eight are both two away, and four appears earlier in the example list.
1B · Open ended
Give the output and explain how the distance and tie rule determine it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The output is A. Four and eight are both two units from six, and the first listed tied example is 4:A, so the stated tie rule selects A.
- Identifies the equal distance of two from examples 4 and 8.
- Applies the first-listed tie rule to give output A.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team has 30 training drawings and 10 separately labelled drawings that were not used in fitting the model. It wants evidence about new drawings.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which practices support the stated evaluation goal?
- a: Use the separately labelled drawings for testing.
- b: Count remembered training answers as proof of all new cases.
- c: Hide every error from the result summary.
- d: Report the number correct and the test conditions.
Separate testing and transparent reporting give more relevant evidence of transfer.
2B · Open ended
Choose the appropriate evaluation set and explain why its separation from training matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the ten separately labelled drawings. Because the model was not fitted using them, the result gives evidence about new cases rather than just its ability to reproduce training answers.
- Selects the ten held-out labelled drawings.
- Explains the distinction between new-case performance and replaying familiar training answers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional voice-command model was trained only on recordings in a quiet room. It will be used near a noisy fan. The team has consented fictional practice recordings for both conditions. The initial training counts are 80 quiet and zero noisy examples. Separate initial tests record 19 of 20 quiet commands and 12 of 20 noisy commands correct.
3A · Matching
Match each action to its purpose.
Complete or match: Broaden relevant training conditions; Measure new-case performance in noise; Find which commands are misheard
- a: Review recognition errors
- b: Keep separate noisy tests
- c: Add varied checked recordings
- d: Assume all rooms are identical
Training coverage, evaluation and error review address different parts of the changed setting.
3B · Short answer
Apply the training-and-test idea to propose an improvement and a relevant evaluation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add appropriately labelled noisy recordings to cover the new condition. Evaluate on different noisy recordings kept separate from training and inspect which commands remain mistaken.
- Targets the missing noisy condition with checked training examples.
- Uses separate noisy examples and error checking to evaluate the revised model.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “The model gets all twelve training cards right, so it will get every new card right.” Separate testing actually finds 7 correct out of 10.
4A · Hotspot
Which statement fits the records?
- a: Every future card is guaranteed correct.
- b: The test contains no errors at all.
- c: Training cards prove all possible conditions.
- d: Perfect training fit coexists with test errors.
The test includes three errors despite perfect performance on training cards.
4B · Open ended
Explain the reasoning error and report the separate-test result with an appropriate limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses fitting familiar examples with reliable transfer to every new example. The separate test is 7/10 correct, which describes that test and does not guarantee future results.
- Identifies the mistaken generalisation from training success to all new cases.
- Reports 7/10 and limits the conclusion to the tested conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants to classify toy leaves by shape. It may use only drawings, must include different colours within each shape category, and must reserve some checked drawings for testing.
5A · True or false
True or false? Using every drawing for training leaves no separate reserved test set.
- true: True
- false: False
A reserved test requires examples not used to fit the model.
5B · Open ended
Propose a training collection meeting the colour constraint and a separate test plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: Create checked drawings of each shape in several colours so colour alone does not identify the label. Reserve different labelled drawings, including new colour-shape examples, to test the fitted model and record errors.
- Proposes checked examples with varied colours within each shape category.
- Separates relevant labelled test drawings from training and records performance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.4 · Training data
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Many duplicates
Fictional worked example
A fictional dataset has 100 copies of one bright photograph and no dim photographs.
Question: Does its size establish broad lighting coverage?
Answer: No. Repetition does not add the missing condition.
Why: Count relevant variation as well as total entries.
Example 2 · Correct an entry
Fictional worked example
A fictional card visibly shows a five-point star but is labelled “circle”. The trusted category guide confirms the star.
Question: What should change?
Answer: Correct the label to star and record why.
Why: The review uses the actual example and the category guide, not the existing label alone.
Example 3 · Allowed use
| Collection | Supplied terms |
|---|---|
| Artist drawings | Classroom training allowed with credit |
| Family album | No permission supplied |
Fictional worked example
A fictional artist permits drawings for classroom training and asks for a credit line. A separate family album has no such permission.
Question: Which collection has the stated permission for this task?
Answer: The artist’s drawings, following the supplied credit condition.
Why: A useful-looking private collection is not automatically cleared for use.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A missing condition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model will recognise toy blocks in bright and shaded areas. Its 80 training drawings show bright conditions only. Separate illustrative tests record 18 of 20 bright cases and 9 of 20 shaded cases correct, as displayed in the explorer.
F1 · True or false
True or false? Eighty bright examples establish that shaded conditions are represented in training.
- true: True
- false: False
The source explicitly records zero shaded training examples.
Investigation: data balance lab
F2 · Read dataset fields
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional dataset record contains a leaf drawing, the checked label “oval”, and a note “drawn by class team; classroom use permitted”.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the field descriptions.
Complete or match: Leaf drawing; Checked word oval; Creator and allowed-use statement
- a: Input example
- b: A universal accuracy guarantee
- c: Target label
- d: Origin and permission note
The drawing, label and permission record answer different questions.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · Choose a targeted addition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sound dataset contains quiet bell recordings but no bell recordings with background rain. The intended setting includes both. All candidate new recordings have appropriate permission.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which addition most directly addresses the stated gap?
- a: Anonymous guesses without audio
- b: A list of unrelated song titles
- c: Checked bell recordings with background rain
- d: More copies of the same quiet recording
The missing relevant condition is a bell with background rain.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Separate collection jobs
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional workflow has Mira check labels, Len record allowed uses and Ari reserve a separate test collection. The jobs are all needed.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each person beside the assigned job.
Complete or match: Review label correctness; Record permitted use; Keep examples outside training for testing
- a: Mira
- b: No assigned person
- c: Len
- d: Ari
Quality, permission records and evaluation separation are distinct jobs.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A tempting private collection
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team needs pictures of plain geometric shapes. Someone proposes using classmates’ family photographs because many are available. No family permission is supplied, and shapes can be drawn instead.
F5 · Short answer
Propose an appropriate data collection and explain why the family photographs are unnecessary for this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use original shape drawings with checked labels and agreed classroom use. Family photos introduce personal material without supplied permission and are unnecessary when safe drawings meet the shape task.
- Proposes relevant shape drawings with checked labels or an equivalent appropriately permitted safe collection.
- Explains that family photographs are unnecessary and lack supplied permission/privacy justification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional audit finds Set A: 12 distinct permitted drawings covering several relevant shape categories, with checked labels; B: 40 copies of one drawing; C: 10 relevant pictures with unknown permission. The task needs varied shapes.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the audit summary.
Complete or match: Varied checked and permitted examples; Many entries but one repeated example; Relevant images with use rights not supplied
- a: All equally cleared
- b: Set B
- c: Set A
- d: Set C
A has supplied checks and permission; B lacks variety and C lacks a permission record.
1B · Short answer
Choose the most suitable starting set and name one remaining evaluation step.
Example of a full-credit answer: A is the best stated starting set because its examples are varied, checked and permitted. Evaluate a fitted model on separate relevant labelled drawings to learn whether it transfers.
- Selects A using its relevant variety and supplied quality/permission record.
- Proposes a separate relevant evaluation rather than treating A as a performance guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reviewer finds three crescent drawings labelled “circle”. A checked shape guide distinguishes crescents from circles. The original filenames do not contain reliable shape names.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which actions improve this labelled collection?
- a: Treat arbitrary filenames as definitive shape evidence.
- b: Correct the three labels using the checked guide.
- c: Keep wrong labels because they were typed first.
- d: Record the corrections and their reasons.
A reliable review corrects the entries and preserves the reason for the change.
2B · Open ended
Explain why correction is justified and why a change record is useful.
Example of a full-credit answer: The actual drawings and checked guide show crescents, so circle labels are wrong. A correction record lets later reviewers see what changed and verify the reason instead of guessing.
- Uses the drawing/guide evidence to justify the corrected crescent labels.
- Explains how a record supports later checking or understanding of the correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional recognition task will read printed labels from several classroom groups. The training set contains only one group’s very large block letters. Smaller letters are part of the intended use. The explorer’s initial record has 70 large-letter and zero smaller-letter training examples. Separate tests score 19 of 20 large-letter and 11 of 20 smaller-letter cases correctly.
3A · Multiple choice
Which proposal best addresses the identified coverage gap?
- a: Duplicate the existing large-letter set many times.
- b: Remove all tests of smaller lettering from the report.
- c: Collect unrelated home addresses instead of labels.
- d: Add permitted checked examples of relevant smaller lettering.
The addition should cover the missing relevant writing condition.
3B · Open ended
Propose a suitable data improvement and a separate check of the improved tool.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add appropriately permitted smaller-letter examples with checked text labels. Reserve other smaller-letter examples for evaluation and compare the new error pattern under the same task.
- Targets the missing smaller-letter condition with checked, appropriately permitted examples.
- Uses different relevant examples to evaluate the improvement and its errors.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional dataset contains 500 repeated copies of one umbrella drawing and 5 distinct coat drawings. A learner says “500 means umbrellas are fully covered”.
4A · Hotspot
Which fact most directly challenges the claim of broad umbrella variety?
- a: Only one distinct umbrella drawing is supplied.
- b: The number 500 is larger than the number 5.
- c: Each duplicate must add a new umbrella view.
- d: Coat variety automatically establishes umbrella variety.
A large duplicate count does not create distinct examples or conditions.
4B · Open ended
Explain the size-versus-variety error and suggest a relevant improvement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner counts repeated copies as if they were different umbrella examples. Add checked, permitted umbrella drawings with relevant variations such as shape, position or background, then test new cases.
- Distinguishes duplicate entry count from distinct relevant variation.
- Proposes a suitable addition of varied checked examples addressing the task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy model will recognise three kinds of classroom object drawings. Use only original drawings, include more than one view of each kind, and reserve some drawings for testing. Each record needs a label and creator/permission note.
5A · Matching
Match each record or action to its purpose.
Complete or match: What the training target is; Who made it and how it may be used; How transfer will be evaluated
- a: Checked category label
- b: Reserved test drawings
- c: A guaranteed perfect score
- d: Creator/permission note
Labels, allowed-use records and separate tests answer different questions.
5B · Open ended
Propose a collection meeting the coverage and record requirements, then explain how you would reserve evaluation data.
Example of a full-credit answer: Create several original views of each of the three object kinds and record checked labels plus creator/permission notes. Before fitting, set aside different labelled drawings of every kind for testing and do not use them as training examples.
- Proposes varied original examples for all three kinds with checked labels and use records.
- Separates relevant evaluation drawings from the fitting collection.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.5 · Patterns and predictions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Rule and reality
Fictional worked example
A fictional toy predicts attendees as twice the number of signed-up teams. Three teams give six predicted attendees; seven actually arrive.
Question: What is the prediction error in people?
Answer: The observation is one person higher than the prediction.
Why: The rule calculation and observed result are different quantities.
Example 2 · Same direction, different cause
Fictional worked example
A fictional week has more umbrellas and more wet pavements during rainy days.
Question: Do umbrellas necessarily cause wet pavements?
Answer: No. Rain is a plausible shared influence.
Why: Moving together alone does not establish the proposed cause.
Example 3 · An uncertain forecast
| Statement | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Estimate: 8–12 | Uncertainty is expressed |
| Observed: 11 | A later recorded result |
Fictional worked example
A fictional report estimates 8–12 book returns, rather than guaranteeing exactly 10.
Question: What does the range communicate?
Answer: The expected count is uncertain within the report’s stated assumptions.
Why: The range is not a promise that every possible outcome lies inside it unless that is explicitly established.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Apply an explicit prediction rule
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model predicts visitors as 3 times the number of activity stations. With 4 stations, it predicts 12 visitors. It is a classroom assumption, not a measured fact.
F1 · Hotspot
Which number is the model prediction for four stations?
- a: 7 visitors
- b: 12 visitors
- c: 4 visitors
- d: Exactly all future visitors
Three times four equals twelve under the supplied rule.
Investigation: graph lab
F2 · Prediction versus observation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model predicts 15 returns on Tuesday. The later checked return log records 13. No arithmetic mistake is found in applying the model.
F2 · True or false
True or false? A correctly calculated prediction can still differ from the later observation.
- true: True
- false: False
The rule was applied correctly, but its estimate did not exactly match the observed result.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Name the quantities
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rainfall-to-puddle toy receives 2 units of rain, predicts 6 puddles, and later observes 4 puddles. Its purpose is practice with model roles.
F3 · Matching
Match each value to its role.
Complete or match: Input to the toy model; Model prediction; Later observation
- a: 4 puddles
- b: 6 puddles
- c: A guaranteed future count
- d: 2 rain units
Input, estimated output and observed output are distinct.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · A shared influence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class notices that hat use and outdoor-game attendance both rise on sunny days. It has no experiment changing hats while holding weather constant.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which conclusions are justified?
- a: Hats are proved to cause every extra game visit.
- b: The weather must have no possible role.
- c: The record does not isolate hats as the cause.
- d: The two measures vary together in this record.
The observed association permits several explanations and does not isolate causation.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A changed setting
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional attendance rule was built from small indoor clubs. A team wants to use it for a large outdoor fair during unpredictable weather. No fair data are available.
F5 · Short answer
Explain one reason the prediction may not transfer and name relevant information to gather before relying on it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The fair differs in size and outdoor weather exposure from the small indoor clubs. Gather relevant past fair attendance and conditions, or make a clearly limited estimate with a plan to compare it against new observations.
- Identifies a relevant change in scale or outdoor/weather conditions.
- Names suitable new evidence for evaluating the rule in the fair setting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy rule predicts 4 returned books per open reading table. Three tables give a prediction of 12; the checked observation is 10.
1A · Multiple choice
Which statement accurately compares the two values?
- a: The prediction proves the log must be wrong.
- b: The prediction is two books above the observation.
- c: The observation is two books above the prediction.
- d: Prediction and observation are equal.
Twelve minus ten is two; a disagreement does not itself discredit the observation.
1B · Open ended
Show the calculation and explain why the model should not replace the checked observation.
Example of a full-credit answer: The model gives 4 × 3 = 12, which is 2 above the 10 recorded returns. It is an estimate under a simplified rule; the checked log records what actually happened in this case.
- Calculates the prediction and two-book overestimate correctly.
- Distinguishes a model estimate from the checked observed result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional picnic planner predicts 18–24 visitors from comparable events. The report lists weather as uncertain and supplies no guarantee. A separate booked-place count is 20. Report A says “Estimated 18–24 visitors; weather may change turnout.” Report B says “Exactly 24 visitors are guaranteed.” Record C says “Twenty booked places.”
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the descriptions.
Complete or match: Preserves the stated uncertainty; Adds an unsupported guarantee; Describes booked places
- a: All are guarantees
- b: Report B
- c: Report A
- d: Record C
A preserves the estimate, B overstates certainty, and C records bookings.
2B · Open ended
Choose the best prediction wording and justify it using the estimate and its uncertainty.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because it reports the supplied 18–24 estimate and keeps weather visible as a possible influence. It does not turn a modelled range or bookings into guaranteed attendance.
- Selects A and accurately preserves the 18–24 estimate.
- Explains why weather uncertainty prevents a guaranteed exact turnout claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rule built under a particular light condition predicts 2 cm growth each week. The class moves plants to a different light condition. No new growth measurements are supplied.
3A · True or false
True or false? The old rule is guaranteed to remain exact after the light condition changes.
- true: True
- false: False
The relevant condition changed, and transfer has not been checked.
3B · Open ended
Apply the prediction-limit idea to explain the uncertainty and propose a suitable check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The growth relationship was observed under different light, which may affect growth. Measure growth under the new condition over a stated period and compare it with the old predictions before relying on the rule.
- Connects changed light with uncertainty about transferring the old relationship.
- Proposes relevant new measurements and comparison with the prediction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional record shows more sunhats and more ice sales on hot days. A caption says “Sunhats cause ice sales”. No controlled comparison is supplied.
4A · Drag and drop
Place each statement beside its role.
Complete or match: More hats on hot days; More ice sales on hot days; Heat could affect both
- a: Observed hat pattern
- b: Observed ice-sales pattern
- c: Established hat-causes-sales law
- d: Possible shared influence
The data show two patterns and leave causal explanations open.
4B · Open ended
Identify the causal error and propose a more accurate caption.
Example of a full-credit answer: The caption treats association as proof that hats cause sales. A more accurate caption is: “Hat use and ice sales both rose on hot days; heat may affect both, and this record does not isolate the cause.”
- Identifies the unsupported leap from association to causation.
- Rewrites the claim to retain the observed pattern and a clear causal limit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club will estimate weekly book returns for four weeks. It must record predictions before each week, later count actual returns, and report errors without changing old predictions after seeing the result.
5A · Hotspot
Which record is essential for an honest prediction comparison?
- a: The original dated prediction and later observation
- b: Only the week with the best-looking result
- c: A popularity vote about the model’s name
- d: Only a prediction rewritten after the outcome
The original prediction must remain available for comparison with the observed outcome.
5B · Open ended
Propose a four-week recording plan and explain how you would report an unexpected result.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record each dated prediction before its week, then add the checked return count and the difference. Keep all four weeks, including unexpected results, and describe relevant conditions or limits without silently rewriting predictions.
- Proposes preserved before/after records for all four weeks with a comparison measure.
- Reports unexpected results transparently with relevant limits rather than hiding or rewriting them.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.6 · Generative artificial intelligence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Generating versus sorting
Fictional worked example
A fictional tool A writes a new welcome paragraph. Tool B labels a supplied picture “triangle”.
Question: Which task is generative in this case?
Answer: Tool A’s paragraph-writing task.
Why: Tool B performs classification; different AI tasks produce different kinds of output.
Example 2 · A plausible addition
Fictional worked example
A fictional prompt supplies “Exhibition on Thursday in Room 2”. The draft adds “Free snacks provided”, though no snack information was given.
Question: What should the reviewer do?
Answer: Remove the unsupported snack promise or verify it before inclusion.
Why: A fluent addition is not evidence that the promised service exists.
Example 3 · Fiction made clear
| Aspect | Stated fact |
|---|---|
| Place | Imaginary |
| Process | AI-assisted illustration |
Fictional worked example
A fictional class creates an imagined underwater city picture and labels it “AI-assisted illustration of an imaginary place”.
Question: Why is the label useful?
Answer: It describes the process and prevents presenting the picture as a real photograph of the city.
Why: Disclosure clarifies origin; the picture still needs review for its intended use.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify generation limits
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool drafts a poster using a supplied prompt. The record contains no fact-check report and no permission review for reuse.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which conclusions are justified?
- a: The output is a draft to inspect against the task.
- b: Factual and reuse checks remain separate questions.
- c: Generation proves that every detail is correct.
- d: Generation automatically grants every possible permission.
The process alone establishes neither accuracy nor blanket reuse permission.
Investigation: prompt lab
F2 · Classify the described task
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool receives “Write a short riddle about rain” and returns newly assembled wording. A separate fixed menu only displays one stored reminder.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which task is directly generative?
- a: Sorting a card into a supplied category
- b: Displaying a fixed stored reminder
- c: Producing the requested riddle draft
- d: Counting the number of menu buttons
The riddle task produces content in response to the prompt.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · A fictional scene is not a photograph
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class asks an image tool to invent a floating island. Its record labels the result “generated fantasy illustration”.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The generated picture establishes that a real floating island was photographed.
- true: True
- false: False
The source explicitly describes an invented generated illustration, not an observation.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · Review a generation workflow
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class rule says: provide the checked facts, inspect the generated draft, and disclose the AI assistance in the final record. The draft is not sent anywhere automatically.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each action beside its purpose.
Complete or match: Supply the checked event details; Compare draft claims with the details; Record that AI helped create the draft
- a: Guarantee universal originality
- b: Review factual fit
- c: Prepare the request
- d: Disclose the process
The workflow separates input quality, output checking and disclosure.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · An invented event promise
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated invitation includes the supplied “Saturday at 10” but adds “every visitor receives a free book”. No book giveaway is in the approved facts.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the book promise needs action and propose a safe revision based on the supplied facts.
Example of a full-credit answer: The promise is unsupported by the approved event facts and could mislead visitors. Remove it and keep the approved Saturday-at-10 information unless an organiser separately confirms a giveaway.
- Identifies the giveaway as an unsupported generated addition with a relevant consequence.
- Proposes removal or verification and a revision that preserves only the supplied facts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: verification lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt supplies “Map exhibition, Wednesday, Hall C”. The generated draft says “Map exhibition, Tuesday, Hall C”. The approved source remains Wednesday.
1A · Hotspot
Select the correction required by the approved source.
- a: Change Tuesday to Wednesday.
- b: Change Hall C to Hall D.
- c: Add a free prize promise.
- d: Remove every reference to maps.
The generated day differs from the checked source; the other event details do not require those changes.
1B · Open ended
Identify the factual error and explain why the approved source should guide the revision.
Example of a full-credit answer: The draft says Tuesday instead of Wednesday. The approved event record supplies Wednesday, while the generated draft is not independent evidence that the event changed.
- Identifies and corrects the Tuesday/Wednesday mismatch.
- Explains the evidence role of the approved source versus a generated draft.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class asks for an imaginary planet story, requires original student revision and a note describing AI assistance, and prohibits presenting invented events as news. Plan A generates ideas, then the student revises the fictional story and includes the assistance note. Plan B publishes the invented events as news. Plan C copies a draft without revision or an assistance note.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the plan comparison.
Complete or match: Meets revision and disclosure requirements; Presents fiction as news; Omits revision and assistance note
- a: Plan C
- b: All plans equally comply
- c: Plan A
- d: Plan B
A fits the stated fiction task; B misrepresents fiction and C omits required work.
2B · Open ended
Choose a plan and justify it using the project’s fiction and process requirements.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because the output remains an imaginary story rather than a news claim, and the student revises it and states the AI assistance as required.
- Selects A and preserves the work’s fictional status.
- Connects the choice to student revision and the required assistance disclosure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster needs a labelled drawing of a seedling. An image generator creates an attractive plant with an extra leaf label pointing at a root. The checked diagram guide shows the correct parts.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which actions are appropriate?
- a: Correct the root label before using the poster.
- b: Treat attractive colours as proof of scientific accuracy.
- c: Assume generated drawings never need checking.
- d: Check each label against the diagram guide.
A scientific illustration needs correct labels regardless of how appealing it looks.
3B · Short answer
Explain the error and propose a review step for the rest of the illustration.
Example of a full-credit answer: A root is labelled as a leaf. Correct that label and compare every other pointer and named part with the checked diagram guide before using the illustration.
- Identifies the root/leaf mismatch and a correct repair.
- Proposes a complete relevant label/pointer check against the trusted guide.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says “The tool generated this, so it must be unique and I can use it anywhere.” The source provides no similarity check or use terms.
4A · Matching
Match each question to the needed kind of information.
Complete or match: Was a generator used?; Could the output repeat existing material?; What uses are permitted?
- a: Creation-process record
- b: A confident tone
- c: Applicable use terms
- d: Relevant similarity/origin review
The fact of generation cannot answer all three questions.
4B · Open ended
Identify the two unsupported guarantees in the learner’s claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: Generation does not prove that no existing material is similar or repeated. It also does not provide blanket permission for every use; the relevant terms and context still need review.
- Rejects the unsupported uniqueness/originality guarantee.
- Rejects blanket permission and identifies a separate need to check relevant terms/context.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group must make a welcome story of at most 60 words using invented characters only. It may use AI for ideas, must check the word limit, and must add a short assistance note under the class rule.
5A · Drag and drop
Place each task beside its workflow stage.
Complete or match: Specify invented characters and the word limit; Check meaning and count the words; Include the required assistance note
- a: After removing all review
- b: During human review
- c: With the final work
- d: Before generation
Requirements guide the request, review checks them, and disclosure records the help.
5B · Open ended
Propose a workflow meeting the character and length limits, then explain how the final work will show the student’s responsibility.
Example of a full-credit answer: Request ideas using invented characters and a 60-word maximum, then choose and revise a draft and count its words. The student checks the result and includes the required AI-assistance note rather than treating the generated draft as automatically ready.
- Provides a sensible draft/revision check preserving invented characters and the 60-word limit.
- Explains student review and the required disclosure as part of responsibility for the final work.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.7 · Language models
Three worked examples
Example 1 · One word, two contexts
Fictional worked example
Fictional prompts say “The crane lifted the beam” and “The crane spread its wings”.
Question: What changes the likely meaning of crane?
Answer: The surrounding action: lifting suggests a machine; wings suggest a bird.
Why: Context guides interpretation without changing the spelling of the word.
Example 2 · Weighted alternatives
Fictional worked example
A fictional toy has three endings with weights 2, 1 and 1.
Question: What is the first ending’s share of the total weight?
Answer: 2 out of 4, or one half.
Why: The toy probability is weight divided by total weight; it is not a truth probability.
Example 3 · Smooth but wrong
| Source | Opening |
|---|---|
| Generated summary | 09:00 |
| Approved notice | 10:00 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional generated summary says the museum opens at nine. The approved notice states ten.
Question: What does smooth writing establish about the time?
Answer: Nothing sufficient; the time must be corrected to ten.
Why: Style and factual support are separate checks.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name the language-model ideas
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional lesson defines token as a text unit, context as supplied surrounding information, and output as the generated sequence.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the concept mapping.
Complete or match: Unit such as a word or word part; Information surrounding the request; Produced sequence of text
- a: Token
- b: Context
- c: Output
- d: Truth guarantee
These terms describe processing and generation, not automatic factual accuracy.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Read a toy probability
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional continuation toy has weights 3 for “began the story”, 2 for “asked a question”, and 1 for “closed the notebook”. These are prepared endings, not factual claims.
F2 · Multiple choice
What is the first ending’s share of the total weight?
- a: Always certain
- b: One sixth
- c: One third
- d: One half
Its weight is 3 of the total 6, or one half.
Investigation: token lab
F3 · Inspect a supplied-facts prompt
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional request asks for a notice using only “Club meets Friday; Room 6”. It also requests two short sentences. These are the complete approved facts.
F3 · Matching
Match each part to its role.
Complete or match: Write a club notice; Friday in Room 6; Use two short sentences
- a: Context facts
- b: Verified new event detail
- c: Task
- d: Output format
The prompt states what to do, which facts to use and how to present them.
Investigation: prompt lab
F4 · Check fluent misinformation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional language-model answer confidently says a class trip is on Wednesday. The signed class notice states Thursday. No newer change record is supplied.
F4 · Hotspot
Which conclusion best uses the evidence?
- a: Use Thursday from the approved notice.
- b: Confidence makes Wednesday more reliable.
- c: Both days must be equally correct.
- d: The notice must be wrong because it is shorter.
The approved notice supports Thursday; confidence is not an independent update.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A missing instruction condition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source says “Borrow the tablet only with the teacher’s permission.” A generated simplification says “Borrow the tablet.”
F5 · Open ended
Identify what the simplification lost and write a corrected short instruction.
Example of a full-credit answer: It lost the requirement for teacher permission. A corrected instruction is: “Ask the teacher’s permission before borrowing the tablet.”
- Identifies the omitted teacher-permission condition.
- Provides a concise instruction that preserves that condition and the borrowing action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated explanation is grammatically clear but says a five-sided shape has six sides. The supplied shape card shows and labels five sides.
1A · True or false
True or false? Clear grammar alone establishes that the shape description is correct.
- true: True
- false: False
The side count conflicts with the checked diagram despite fluent grammar.
1B · Open ended
Explain the difference between fluency and accuracy here and correct the factual claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The explanation is easy to read, but its side count is wrong. The supplied shape has five sides, so the factual statement should say five, not six.
- Distinguishes readable grammar from evidence-based factual accuracy.
- Corrects the count to five using the supplied shape card.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school needs a version of its notice for younger readers in no more than 40 words. The approved notice says “Science Club meets Thursday in Room 7.” The rewritten notice must preserve the day and place.
2A · Drag and drop
Place each instruction beside its main role.
Complete or match: Rephrase for younger readers; Keep the date and place unchanged; Use at most forty words
- a: Factual constraint
- b: Length constraint
- c: Audience/task instruction
- d: Permission to invent details
The instructions guide readability while preserving facts and length.
2B · Open ended
Propose a concise request and explain one check needed even after giving clear instructions.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Rephrase this notice for younger readers in at most 40 words; preserve its date and place and add no facts.” Afterwards compare the draft with the source because clear instructions do not guarantee compliance.
- Includes the audience, length and fact-preservation requirements in a clear request.
- Proposes checking the generated result against the source rather than assuming compliance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source instruction says “Wait until the bell stops.” A prepared translation is checked by a knowledgeable speaker and found to mean “Leave before the bell starts”. The review record is supplied; learners need not know the target language.
3A · Matching
Match each statement to its role.
Complete or match: Wait until the bell stops; Leave before the bell starts; Compare action and timing with the source
- a: Required meaning check
- b: A guarantee from fluent style
- c: Original instruction
- d: Reviewed translation meaning
The supplied review identifies an action and timing mismatch.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the translated draft should not be used and describe an appropriate correction check.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes waiting to leaving and reverses the timing condition. Have a knowledgeable speaker revise it to preserve “wait until the bell stops”, then check the revised meaning against the source.
- Identifies the changed action and timing meaning in the supplied review.
- Proposes qualified revision and a source-meaning comparison before use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy gives an ending weight 4 out of total 8. A learner says “That means its sentence is 50% true.” The weights only control which prepared ending is sampled.
4A · Hotspot
Which statement correctly describes the 4/8 value?
- a: It guarantees that ending on every draw.
- b: It is the toy chance of selecting that ending.
- c: It measures the author’s honesty.
- d: It proves half the ending’s claims are true.
Sampling probability concerns output selection, not factual truth.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s confusion and explain what the fraction actually means.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses selection probability with truth. Four of the eight total weight units give that ending a one-half chance on each toy draw; it says nothing about whether a claim in it is factual.
- Distinguishes probability of choosing text from probability of factual truth.
- Correctly interprets 4/8 as one-half selection chance in the supplied toy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a short explanation of library borrowing rules. It has an approved rule sheet, may use a language model to simplify wording, and must preserve every condition and include a review record.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which two practices meet the stated review purpose?
- a: Let the draft silently invent new borrowing rules.
- b: Compare every condition with the approved sheet.
- c: Record corrections made before the final version.
- d: Treat fluent wording as sufficient approval.
Meaning comparison and a correction record preserve accountability.
5B · Open ended
Propose the drafting-and-checking steps and explain how the review record will help.
Example of a full-credit answer: Supply the rule sheet and the simplification constraints, then have a teacher compare every condition and correct changes before release. Record the original condition, the correction and reviewer so later users can understand how the final wording was checked.
- Proposes source-based drafting followed by a complete condition-preserving human review.
- Explains a meaningful correction/reviewer record that supports later accountability.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.8 · Image generators
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Design idea, not evidence
Fictional worked example
A fictional class generates an imagined playground with a giant slide. No construction has occurred.
Question: Can the image prove the playground was built?
Answer: No. It is a proposed illustration.
Why: A creation record is different from evidence of a real completed event.
Example 2 · Check the required count
Fictional worked example
A fictional request asks for four labelled recycling boxes. A prepared draft contains three boxes.
Question: What should the reviewer do?
Answer: Request or make a revision that includes all four required boxes and check again.
Why: Appearance does not replace checking an explicit quantity requirement.
Example 3 · Origin and caption
| Record | Information |
|---|---|
| Capture date | Last year |
| Caption | Today’s weather |
Fictional worked example
A fictional record confirms that a park photo was taken last year. A new caption claims it shows today’s weather.
Question: What does the record challenge?
Answer: The caption’s claim about today.
Why: A genuine photograph can be paired with an inaccurate time claim.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Specify an image request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs an illustration showing a tree, a bench and a path, with no real people. It should be labelled as a design idea.
F1 · Drag and drop
Place each request part beside its purpose.
Complete or match: Tree, bench and path; No real people; Design idea
- a: Privacy boundary
- b: Status label
- c: Required objects
- d: Proof of construction
The request separates content, privacy and the image’s proposed status.
Investigation: prompt lab
F2 · Interpret a generation record
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional art log states that a class generated an imaginary purple lighthouse and then added its own caption. There is no photograph or location record.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements are supported?
- a: The class added a caption after generation.
- b: The picture proves every coast contains such a lighthouse.
- c: A real purple lighthouse has been verified.
- d: The picture is an imagined generated illustration.
The log supports the process and fictional status, not a real-world location.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · Three independent review questions
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional diagram review asks whether two drawn wheels are present, whether the axle label points correctly, and whether the final file includes the required AI-assistance note.
F3 · Matching
Match each review action to its purpose.
Complete or match: Count the two wheels; Verify the axle pointer; Include the AI-assistance note
- a: Automatic legal clearance
- b: Process disclosure
- c: Meaning check
- d: Quantity check
The checks address quantity, diagram correctness and the stated disclosure rule.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · A visual clue is not proof
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional picture has oddly shaped lettering. Its creation history is unknown. The source supplies no reliable origin record or original file.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is justified?
- a: No further source check could ever help.
- b: Every manually created image has perfect lettering.
- c: Odd lettering proves one exact generation process.
- d: The origin remains uncertain from this clue alone.
A visual oddity alone cannot reliably determine the creation method.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · Check a proposed garden drawing
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional request needs a tree on the left, a bench in the middle and a path on the right. A prepared draft places all three correctly, but a crop hides the path. The fixed full-frame case includes the path.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the cropped view is insufficient to check the whole request and state what to inspect before accepting the image.
Example of a full-credit answer: The crop can hide a required object, so the visible part alone does not establish whether the full design meets the specification. Inspect the complete frame and check the tree-left, bench-middle and path-right arrangement.
- Explains how cropping limits assessment of required objects or placement.
- Proposes a full-frame check of all three stated positions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: crop media lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generator creates a realistic-looking image of a school garden opening next year. The project record says it is a proposal and the event has not happened.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which conclusions are supported?
- a: It should not be presented as a photograph of a completed opening.
- b: Realistic appearance proves the event happened.
- c: The generation record establishes all future attendance.
- d: The image may illustrate a proposed event.
The record establishes a proposal, not evidence of an event that already occurred.
1B · Short answer
Explain the image’s appropriate role and propose a clear caption.
Example of a full-credit answer: It can illustrate the proposed garden opening, but it is not a record of an actual event. A clear caption is “AI-assisted illustration of a proposed future garden opening; the event has not yet happened.”
- Distinguishes a useful proposal illustration from evidence of a completed event.
- Provides a caption that makes the generated/proposed and not-yet-happened status clear.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom poster must show three labelled steps in handwashing. Review A checks only colours; B compares every step and label with the approved school poster; C counts how many people like the design.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the method mapping.
Complete or match: Checks colour appeal; Checks the required steps and labels; Counts reactions
- a: An unperformed clinical trial
- b: Review A
- c: Review C
- d: Review B
The task needs instruction accuracy, not just appeal or popularity.
2B · Open ended
Choose the most relevant review and justify it using the poster’s instructional purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B because viewers need the correct steps and labels. Comparing each with the approved school poster checks the information they will use, while attractive colours or likes cannot establish those details.
- Selects B and identifies the step/label comparison.
- Explains why instructional accuracy matters more directly than popularity or colour preference for this task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated map looks realistic but places the library east of the gate. The checked campus plan places it west. Both use a visible north arrow.
3A · True or false
True or false? The generated map’s realistic style is sufficient to override the checked campus plan.
- true: True
- false: False
Style is not location evidence; the checked plan contradicts the generated placement.
3B · Short answer
Explain the map error and propose a check before anyone uses it for directions.
Example of a full-credit answer: The library is on the wrong east/west side relative to the gate. Correct it using the checked plan and compare the other labelled locations and direction arrow before using the map.
- Identifies and corrects the east/west mismatch using the checked plan.
- Proposes checking other relevant locations/orientation before practical use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “This image has perfect hands, so it cannot be generated.” The source says only that the hands look ordinary; the origin is unknown.
4A · Hotspot
Which conclusion follows from the supplied evidence?
- a: The origin cannot be settled by the hand appearance alone.
- b: Ordinary hands prove a photograph.
- c: Every generated image has a visible error.
- d: A camera record is already supplied.
Neither ordinary nor unusual anatomy alone provides a reliable origin determination.
4B · Open ended
Identify the faulty assumption and propose a better origin check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner assumes generated images must have visible hand errors. Inspect a reliable creation history, original source or available provenance record; if none is available, keep the origin uncertain.
- Rejects the claim that generated images must show visible hand errors.
- Proposes relevant origin/provenance checking while preserving uncertainty when evidence is missing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional project needs an imagined reading corner with four seats, no real children, and a caption saying it is a design proposal. The class requires an AI-assistance note if a generator is used.
5A · Matching
Match each requirement to its review action.
Complete or match: Required object quantity; Privacy boundary; Status and process disclosure
- a: Read the proposal and assistance labels
- b: Count four seats
- c: Assume realism proves existence
- d: Check that no real child is depicted
Different requirements need different explicit checks.
5B · Open ended
Propose a request meeting the scene constraints and explain how you would review the final picture and caption.
Example of a full-credit answer: Request an imagined reading corner with four seats and no real children. Count the seats, inspect the depicted people, and include “Design proposal” plus the required AI-assistance note; revise any mismatch before use.
- Specifies the four-seat imagined scene and no-real-children constraint.
- Proposes explicit visual and caption/disclosure checks before use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.9 · Recommendation systems
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Score by category
Fictional worked example
A fictional toy lists A: art, B: maps, C: art. Art score is 4; maps score is 2; limit is 2; ties keep list order.
Question: What is recommended?
Answer: A then C.
Why: Both art items score four, and their original order is preserved.
Example 2 · A new item
Fictional worked example
A fictional catalogue adds a new astronomy book with zero recorded clicks. Its topic and author information are supplied.
Question: What does zero clicks establish?
Answer: No clicks have yet been recorded, not that the book is useless.
Why: A short history should not be mistaken for a quality judgement.
Example 3 · Different objective
| Goal | Possible effect |
|---|---|
| Score only | Repeated music |
| Variety first | Music plus history |
Fictional worked example
A fictional list has three high-score music items and one lower-score history item. A variety rule requires different categories first.
Question: Why could the history item appear?
Answer: It adds a different category under the stated selection goal.
Why: The system’s objective affects the selected list.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Compute a first suggestion
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy has A: science, B: art, C: maps. Scores are science 2, art 5 and maps 3. It sorts by score, highest first.
F1 · Hotspot
Which item ranks first in the fixed case?
- a: A
- b: C
- c: B
- d: All three tie
B belongs to art, which has the highest supplied score of five.
Investigation: recommend lab
F2 · Separate pipeline stages
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional recommendation pipeline first gathers available books, then assigns a fit score, then chooses the first three under its rule.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the stage mapping.
Complete or match: Gather available books; Assign fit values; Choose the three displayed items
- a: Scoring
- b: Candidate collection
- c: Selection
- d: Fact verification
The pipeline chooses suggestions; no fact-check stage is described.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Different kinds of signals
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional record lists an article’s topic “gardens”, a learner’s recorded open event, and the final suggestion position 2. These are not interchangeable.
F3 · Matching
Match each record to its role.
Complete or match: Article topic; One recorded opening; Suggestion position two
- a: Complete personal identity
- b: Ranked output
- c: Item feature
- d: Interaction signal
Topic, observed action and ranked result describe different parts of the system.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · A score is not a truth rating
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy gives music category score 5 and maps score 1. No factual review is part of its algorithm.
F4 · True or false
True or false? A score of five proves every claim in the music item is accurate.
- true: True
- false: False
The score controls category priority, not factual verification.
Investigation: recommend lab
F5 · An inferred signal can mislead
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy raises a gardening score after a learner opens a gardening article to investigate a suspected error. The algorithm records only the opening, not its purpose.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what signal the system used and what information it lacked.
Example of a full-credit answer: It used the recorded article opening as an interest signal. It lacked the reason for the action: checking a possible error rather than necessarily wanting more gardening material.
- Identifies the open event as the signal used for the inference.
- Explains the missing purpose and its limit on interpreting interest.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy lists A: maps, B: art, C: maps, D: stories in that order. Scores are maps 4, art 2, stories 1. Limit is 2; ties preserve original order; variety is off.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from the fixed rule?
- a: The ranking proves maps are factually correct.
- b: B must outrank every map item.
- c: A is the first recommendation.
- d: C is the second recommendation.
A and C share the highest category score, with A earlier in the original list.
1B · Short answer
Explain how the two-item list is selected and state one thing the scores do not measure.
Example of a full-credit answer: A and C both receive map score 4, above art 2 and stories 1. The tie keeps A before C and the limit selects those two. The scores do not measure factual accuracy or guaranteed usefulness.
- Correctly applies the category scores, tie order and two-item limit.
- Names a valid unmeasured property such as truth or guaranteed personal usefulness.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional toy gives Oak and Pine the same score. Oak appears earlier in the source list. The declared rule preserves original order for equal scores.
2A · Multiple choice
Which order follows from the rule?
- a: Both items must be removed
- b: Oak before Pine
- c: A new random order is required
- d: Pine before Oak
The declared tie rule keeps the earlier source item first.
2B · Open ended
Give the order and explain why it should not be described as proof that the first item is better.
Example of a full-credit answer: Oak comes before Pine because the tie rule preserves list order. Their equal scores provide no evidence that Oak is more accurate or better; the order is a rule for resolving a tie.
- Applies the stated tie rule to give Oak before Pine.
- Distinguishes tie-breaking order from a quality superiority claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional music recommender uses category scores: drums 5, strings 3, wind 1. Its list is D1 drums, D2 drums, S1 strings, W1 wind. With variety on and limit 3, it chooses different categories first. It processes items from highest score to lowest and keeps the stated list order when scores tie.
3A · Hotspot
Which list follows from the stated variety rule?
- a: D2, D1, W1
- b: D1, S1, W1
- c: W1, D2, D1
- d: D1, D2, S1
The first drums item is followed by strings and wind to include new categories.
3B · Short answer
Explain why W1 enters despite its lower score and name the tradeoff with score-only selection.
Example of a full-credit answer: The variety rule chooses a new wind category after drums and strings, so W1 enters. It gives broader category coverage while excluding the second high-score drums item that score-only selection would include.
- Connects W1’s inclusion to the different-category-first rule.
- Explains the tradeoff between category variety and retaining more top-category items.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “The system saw one click, so it knows exactly why the person clicked and what they always want.” The log contains only item ID and opening time.
4A · Drag and drop
Place each statement beside its role.
Complete or match: An item was opened at a stated time; The person may have been checking an error; The system estimates a topic interest
- a: Certain complete identity
- b: Possible unobserved reason
- c: Fallible inference
- d: Recorded evidence
An action log and an explanation of motives are different kinds of information.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and propose a more accurate description of the system’s conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: The system cannot know every motive or lasting preference from an ID and time. It can estimate possible interest from the opening while acknowledging that the reason and future preference are uncertain.
- Identifies the missing intent and overgeneralisation from a single interaction.
- Rephrases the result as a limited fallible inference rather than complete knowledge.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class catalogue needs three suggestions spanning different topics when possible. The team must state its score and tie rules and evaluate whether suggestions help the assigned project, not just count clicks.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the design record.
Complete or match: How item priority is calculated; How equal scores are ordered; How the team checks whether suggestions meet the project need
- a: Automatic truth guarantee
- b: Original-order tie rule
- c: Task-usefulness check
- d: Category-score rule
Selection rules and evaluation goals need to be explicit and distinct.
5B · Open ended
Propose a transparent selection rule meeting the three-item variety requirement and a useful evaluation method.
Example of a full-credit answer: Rank relevant items by declared category scores, keep original order on ties, choose new categories first and stop at three. Ask reviewers whether each suggestion contributes needed project information and record omissions or errors, rather than judging only click counts.
- Specifies an explicit three-item rule with category variety and understandable tie handling.
- Proposes task-relevant review of usefulness/omissions/errors beyond mere click counts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.10 · Voice assistants
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A misheard duration
Fictional worked example
A fictional transcript shows “set thirty minutes”, but the supplied request was “set three minutes”. No timer has started.
Question: What is the best next step?
Answer: Correct the duration to three and confirm it before starting.
Why: Recognition and action should be checked separately.
Example 2 · Voice and truth
Fictional worked example
A fictional assistant says a museum closes at six. The current museum notice states five.
Question: Does a natural-sounding voice settle the disagreement?
Answer: No. Use the current notice and correct the stated time.
Why: Voice style is not evidence of the schedule.
Example 3 · An ambiguous target
| Display name | Role |
|---|---|
| Sam | Library |
| Sam | Garden club |
Fictional worked example
A fictional contact list has “Sam, library” and “Sam, garden club”. A request names only Sam.
Question: What should a careful system ask?
Answer: Which Sam is intended?
Why: Clarifying the recipient avoids acting on an unsupported guess.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify the recognition error
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional request says “Set a timer for fifteen minutes”. The displayed transcript reads “fifty minutes”. The system has not started.
F1 · Multiple choice
What should be corrected before confirmation?
- a: Start fifty minutes because the screen already displays it.
- b: Change the duration to five minutes without checking the request.
- c: Confirm fifty minutes and wait until it ends to review the mismatch.
- d: The duration: fifty should be fifteen.
The recorded mismatch is in the duration, and confirmation has not occurred.
Investigation: clip lab
F2 · Trace the process
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional assistant receives audio, produces a transcript, interprets “start a timer”, and displays the requested duration for confirmation.
F2 · Hotspot
Which stage directly estimates words from audio?
- a: Interpreting the recognised words as a timer request
- b: Speech recognition
- c: Displaying the duration for confirmation
- d: Timer countdown
Speech recognition turns the supplied audio into estimated words.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Combine two methods
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional timer uses a trained speech model to recognise the requested number. After confirmation, a programmed clock counts down that duration.
F3 · True or false
True or false? One voice product can combine a trained model with directly programmed actions.
- true: True
- false: False
The case explicitly contains both speech recognition and a programmed countdown.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Choose the right check
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional checklist assigns transcript review to checking recognised words, recipient review to checking where a message would go, and source review to checking a factual spoken answer. Nothing is sent in this activity.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each review beside its purpose.
Complete or match: Did it recognise the intended words?; Would it act on the correct contact?; What supports the factual answer?
- a: Recipient review
- b: Source review
- c: Transcript review
- d: Voice-style judgement
The checks target different error types rather than relying on how natural a voice sounds.
Investigation: prompt lab
F5 · Two similar room names
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional assistant hears “show the schedule for Hall A” as “Hall Eight”. The school has both rooms. The screen shows Hall Eight, and no booking action occurs.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the risk of accepting the displayed target and propose a clarification.
Example of a full-credit answer: The assistant would show a different room’s schedule, so the user could plan with the wrong information. Clarify “Hall A, the letter A” and check the corrected room label before proceeding.
- Identifies that Hall Eight is a different target with a relevant wrong-schedule consequence.
- Proposes clear room disambiguation and verification of the corrected target.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional voice request says “remind me at four”. The confirmation screen says “Reminder at 4 am”. The intended time in the source is 4 pm. Nothing has been saved.
1A · Multiple choice
Which action best matches the supplied intention?
- a: Confirm 4 am because the voice was clear.
- b: Assume am and pm are interchangeable.
- c: Change am to pm before confirming.
- d: Delete the source intention from the record.
The requested hour needs the correct morning/afternoon distinction.
1B · Open ended
Explain the mismatch and state a complete corrected confirmation.
Example of a full-credit answer: The screen has morning instead of the intended afternoon. It should confirm “Reminder at 4 pm” before saving, so the ambiguous spoken hour does not lead to the wrong time.
- Identifies the 4 am versus 4 pm mismatch.
- Supplies a clear 4 pm confirmation before the action is saved.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional voice answer says the school library opens tomorrow at 8. The current dated library notice says 9. The assistant gives no newer source.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which responses are justified?
- a: Treat the assistant’s time as needing correction or verification.
- b: Trust eight because the voice sounds confident.
- c: Assume the notice became false when speech was generated.
- d: Use the current dated notice for the stated opening time.
The direct current notice supports nine; the spoken claim lacks a newer source.
2B · Open ended
Choose a time to use and justify the choice with source relevance and the limit of the spoken response.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use 9 from the dated library notice for tomorrow. It directly addresses the schedule, while the assistant’s unsupported voice response is not evidence of a newer change.
- Selects 9 using the current relevant library notice.
- Explains why a confident unsupported spoken answer does not override that notice.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional indoor voice guide recognises “Room B” as “Room D”. Its screen shows the recognised destination before presenting directions. The activity has no live location access.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the target-check record.
Complete or match: Intended destination; Displayed recognised destination; Appropriate next step
- a: Room D
- b: Room B
- c: Proceed without looking
- d: Clarify and recheck
The intended target and recognised target differ, so review is needed before directions.
3B · Open ended
Apply the confirmation principle to propose a safe next step and explain why it matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: Clarify “Room B, the letter B” and check the destination display before following directions. Accepting Room D would guide the visitor to a different room even if the directions to D were accurate.
- Proposes explicit target correction and rechecking before following directions.
- Explains the distinction between directions being accurate for the wrong target and meeting the intended task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says “It sounds like a person, so it must know my private timetable.” The assistant has no timetable connection in the supplied record.
4A · Hotspot
Which conclusion fits the record?
- a: The voice does not establish access to the timetable.
- b: All assistants know every learner’s schedule.
- c: Natural speech proves access to every private record.
- d: No timetable connection is needed if the voice sounds natural.
Speech style cannot supply missing data access.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken inference and explain what would be needed for a supported timetable answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses a human-like voice with access to private information. A supported answer needs the relevant authorised timetable data or a checked timetable supplied for the task; otherwise the system should say it lacks that information.
- Distinguishes voice presentation from data access or knowledge.
- Names relevant authorised schedule evidence and preserves the limitation when it is absent.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom helper may set a practice timer but must display the recognised duration for confirmation. It must not request names, passwords or recordings from this exercise.
5A · Matching
Match each design step to its purpose.
Complete or match: Lets the learner inspect what was heard; Lets the learner repair or stop a mismatch; Avoids unrelated personal information
- a: Correct or cancel controls
- b: Automatic public recording
- c: Recognised-duration display
- d: Minimal task inputs
The workflow makes the target visible and keeps unnecessary data out.
5B · Open ended
Propose the confirmation sequence and explain how the design keeps the task’s data needs small.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show the recognised duration, let the user correct or cancel it, and start only after the intended duration is confirmed. The practice needs only a duration, so it should not ask for names, passwords or recordings.
- Proposes visible confirmation with correction/cancellation before the timer starts.
- Limits requested information to the duration and excludes the unnecessary personal inputs.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.11 · Strengths of artificial intelligence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Fast but checked
Fictional worked example
A fictional sorter processes 40 shapes quickly and gets 36 correct.
Question: What strength is shown, and what limit remains?
Answer: It handles the prepared batch quickly, but four labels need correction.
Why: Report speed and accuracy separately instead of calling the output perfect.
Example 2 · Many options for a draft
Fictional worked example
A fictional tool proposes three titles for a school garden report. The learner chooses one that fits the evidence and rewrites it.
Question: How did the tool help?
Answer: It supplied alternatives for the learner to evaluate.
Why: Suggestion support can be useful without giving the tool final authority.
Example 3 · Count review time
| Workflow | Minutes |
|---|---|
| Manual | 12 |
| Tool plus review | 2 + 7 = 9 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional task takes 12 minutes manually. A tool takes 2 minutes plus 7 minutes of human review.
Question: Which workflow is faster in this supplied comparison?
Answer: The tool workflow takes 9 minutes, which is 3 minutes less.
Why: Include review time when comparing practical usefulness.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read distinct strengths
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional test records Tool A organising files quickly, Tool B suggesting readable headings, and Tool C transcribing clear audio. Each has a stated separate task.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the task mapping.
Complete or match: Organising supplied files; Suggesting headings; Transcribing clear audio
- a: Tool A
- b: All are universally best
- c: Tool B
- d: Tool C
The supplied results concern different tasks, not a universal ranking.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · A useful title assistant
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class tool proposes four headings for a report using approved facts. The class compares them, rejects one misleading heading and writes the final choice.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which benefits and responsibilities fit this case?
- a: The class checks meaning and chooses the final wording.
- b: Every suggested title must be published unchanged.
- c: The tool supplies alternatives to compare.
- d: Four suggestions establish four verified new facts.
The useful role is idea generation with human evaluation, not automatic publication.
Investigation: prompt lab
F3 · Match a tool to the evidence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool has been tested to group anonymous object images by shape. It has no test record for judging friendship, honesty or future achievement.
F3 · Hotspot
Which task is most directly supported by the stated test scope?
- a: Predicting every learner’s future career
- b: Determining honesty from a name
- c: Suggesting shape groups for similar object images
- d: Deciding which learner is the best friend
The demonstrated task concerns object-image shape grouping only.
Investigation: training lab
F4 · Measure the whole workflow
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional document task takes 14 minutes manually. A tool produces a draft in 3 minutes; reviewing it takes 6 minutes; correcting it takes 2 minutes.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each value beside its role.
Complete or match: Tool drafting time; Human review time; Correction time
- a: 14 AI-only minutes
- b: 2 minutes
- c: 3 minutes
- d: 6 minutes
The complete tool workflow includes all three stages, totalling eleven minutes.
Investigation: graph lab
F5 · A strength with an important exception
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional image sorter labels 18 of 20 clear pictures correctly but 10 of 20 blurred pictures correctly. Both kinds will appear in use.
F5 · Short answer
Describe one demonstrated strength and one adjustment needed for the intended mixed-picture use.
Example of a full-credit answer: It performs better on the clear test set, with 18/20 correct. Blurred pictures need additional checking or improved handling because 10/20 is much weaker and the intended use includes them.
- Uses the 18/20 clear-picture result to state a limited demonstrated strength.
- Addresses the weaker blurred condition with a relevant review/improvement step rather than a universal claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: data balance lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional spelling helper flags 9 of 10 deliberately misspelled words in a prepared test. It also flags one correctly spelled name. The teacher reviews all flags.
1A · True or false
True or false? The tool can be useful in this test while still making both missed-error and false-flag mistakes.
- true: True
- false: False
The record shows useful detections and two kinds of imperfect result.
1B · Open ended
Explain the demonstrated benefit and why teacher review still matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: The helper catches nine supplied misspellings, which can aid review. It misses one and wrongly flags a correct name, so the teacher must check both suggestions and possible omissions instead of accepting everything.
- Identifies the useful detection of nine misspellings.
- Explains review using the missed error and/or false flag without claiming perfection.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class compares two workflows for the same summary task. A takes 15 minutes manually. B takes 4 minutes for a tool draft and 8 for review and correction. Both meet the same checked criteria.
2A · Drag and drop
Place each value beside its meaning.
Complete or match: Complete manual workflow; Complete tool-and-review workflow; Time saved by B in the case
- a: 8 minutes total
- b: 3 minutes
- c: 15 minutes
- d: 12 minutes
B totals 4+8=12 minutes and is three minutes faster in this supplied comparison.
2B · Open ended
Choose the faster complete workflow and justify it without ignoring quality or review.
Example of a full-credit answer: B takes 12 minutes, compared with A’s 15, so it saves 3 minutes here. That comparison includes the 8-minute review and both outputs meet the same checked criteria; it is not a claim about all tasks.
- Correctly calculates B’s twelve-minute total and three-minute saving.
- Includes the quality/review conditions and limits the conclusion to the supplied comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum provides automatic draft captions for a quiet recorded explanation. A reviewer checks names, numbers and missing words before visitors use them.
3A · Matching
Match each stage to its contribution.
Complete or match: Produce a first transcript quickly; Find and correct important transcription errors; Make the corrected words available with the recording
- a: Unreviewed certainty
- b: Draft production
- c: Human checking
- d: Accessible final presentation
The workflow combines efficient drafting with meaning-sensitive review.
3B · Short answer
Explain the useful role of the tool and one review priority for visitor understanding.
Example of a full-credit answer: The tool can create an initial caption draft quickly. Review important names, numbers and omitted words against the recording so visitors receive the intended meaning rather than a convenient but inaccurate transcript.
- Identifies draft caption production as a useful support role.
- Names a meaning-relevant transcript check against the actual recording.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “This model sorted our toy shapes well, so it can fairly choose the school team without criteria.” No team-selection evidence or criteria are supplied.
4A · Hotspot
Which conclusion is supported?
- a: No human criteria are needed for selecting people.
- b: Any strong score proves universal decision skill.
- c: The shape test does not establish fair team selection.
- d: Sorting objects reveals every learner’s ability.
Task-specific success does not validate a different consequential use.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overgeneralisation and state what a responsible team-selection process needs.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner transfers success on objects to a different decision about people. Team selection needs relevant explicit criteria, appropriate evidence and responsible human review, not an unrelated shape-test score.
- Identifies the invalid transfer from the tested shape task to team selection.
- Names relevant criteria/evidence and human responsibility for the consequential decision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class may use a model to organise its own notes, but students must still explain the ideas and check every quoted fact against the lesson. The aim is learning, not only speed.
5A · Multiple choice
Which plan best preserves the stated learning goal?
- a: Use organised headings, then verify and explain the ideas.
- b: Submit the tool’s unexplained output as complete learning.
- c: Let the tool invent quotations without comparison.
- d: Remove all source checks to maximise speed.
The plan supports organisation while preserving student explanation and fact checking.
5B · Open ended
Propose the tool’s limited role and explain how you will check that students still understand the ideas.
Example of a full-credit answer: Let the tool suggest headings for the supplied notes. Students compare facts with the lesson, write their own explanations and answer a follow-up question or explain an example in their own words.
- Assigns a bounded organisation role with source checking.
- Includes a meaningful student explanation or application check rather than assuming output equals understanding.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.12 · Limitations of artificial intelligence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Missing date information
Fictional worked example
A fictional assistant has only last term’s timetable and no update connection. A question asks about tomorrow’s changed schedule.
Question: What limit should it state?
Answer: It lacks the current update needed for tomorrow’s answer.
Why: A dated source or authorised update is required.
Example 2 · Outside the test
Fictional worked example
A fictional object model is tested on bright indoor images but proposed for dark outdoor use.
Question: What has not been established?
Answer: Its performance in the new dark outdoor conditions.
Why: The test evidence has a scope; it does not automatically transfer.
Example 3 · Repeated guesses
| Record | What it supplies |
|---|---|
| Three responses | Same unsourced number |
| Venue capacity record | Not supplied |
Fictional worked example
A fictional tool gives the same unsupported event capacity in three responses.
Question: Does repetition verify capacity?
Answer: No. An actual venue or organiser record is still needed.
Why: Repeated generated text is not three independent counts.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name three limits
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task has A: no current timetable connection, B: an image model tested only in bright light, C: a prompt that omits which of two halls is meant.
F1 · Matching
Match the case to its limit.
Complete or match: No current source access; Untested lighting condition; Ambiguous target context
- a: Case A
- b: All prove the tool is useless
- c: Case C
- d: Case B
Each case needs a different remedy because the missing information differs.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Choose the next step
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional assistant faces three tasks: an ambiguous room name, a claim needing today’s notice, and a classification in an untested condition.
F2 · Drag and drop
Place the remedy beside its problem.
Complete or match: Two possible rooms; Today’s unverified schedule; Untested classification setting
- a: Ask for room clarification
- b: Invent a confident detail
- c: Test the new condition
- d: Check the current notice
The remedies address ambiguity, missing current evidence and untested performance.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · A model lacks a private record
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional helper has no access to learner attendance records. It is asked to name who was absent yesterday. The exercise supplies no names or attendance data.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which responses respect the information limit?
- a: State that the attendance data are not available.
- b: Invent names to make the answer look complete.
- c: Ask an authorised adult to use the proper record if needed.
- d: Assume access to every private school record.
Missing private data should remain missing rather than be guessed or exposed.
Investigation: privacy lab
F4 · Different evidence for different claims
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional review needs to check a generated date, a diagram label and an uncertain word meaning. Available references are a current event notice, a checked diagram guide and an appropriate dictionary.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the reference mapping.
Complete or match: Event date; Diagram part label; Word meaning in context
- a: Appropriate dictionary
- b: Current event notice
- c: Number of likes
- d: Checked diagram guide
The reference should directly address the type of claim.
Investigation: prompt lab
F5 · A missing task condition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt asks for “a route to the hall”. The school has North Hall and South Hall, and the learner needs South Hall. The assistant chooses North Hall without asking.
F5 · Short answer
Explain the missing information and propose a corrected request.
Example of a full-credit answer: The prompt does not identify which hall, so choosing North Hall is an unsupported assumption. A corrected request is “Give a route to South Hall from the stated starting point”, adding the starting point if it is also missing.
- Identifies the missing hall identity and the unsupported choice of North Hall.
- Provides a clear South Hall request and acknowledges any needed starting-point context.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional assistant is given only a paragraph about last year’s fair. It has no browsing or current-record connection. The question asks whether tomorrow’s fair is cancelled.
1A · Hotspot
Which answer fits the evidence limit?
- a: The assistant must have checked current notices because it gives an answer.
- b: The supplied information cannot establish tomorrow’s status.
- c: A date repeated from last year establishes tomorrow’s status.
- d: The fair is definitely still on because no cancellation appears in last year’s paragraph.
The available information concerns a different time and no current check is available.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the assistant cannot settle the question from this material and name a suitable next source.
Example of a full-credit answer: Last year’s paragraph does not establish tomorrow’s status, and no current source is connected. Check the organiser’s current notice or established school announcement route.
- Identifies the time mismatch and absence of current evidence.
- Names a suitable current organiser/school source for the exact status question.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model correctly labels 16/20 printed cards and has never been tested on handwriting. Its report says “Handwriting performance has not yet been evaluated.” A second printed-card test in the explorer records 17 of 20 correct; it also contains no handwriting.
2A · True or false
True or false? The limitation statement is appropriate because the supplied tests do not establish handwriting performance.
- true: True
- false: False
The tests are limited to printed cards, so the report correctly leaves handwriting performance open.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the limitation is useful and propose a relevant evaluation before handwriting use.
Example of a full-credit answer: It prevents readers from assuming the printed-card result applies to handwriting. Test the model on separate, appropriately permitted handwritten examples with checked labels and record errors before relying on it for that task.
- Connects the statement to preventing an unsupported transfer beyond the tested scope.
- Proposes a separate relevant handwriting evaluation with checked labels.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional drafting tool has been reviewed on one language only. A class wants to use it in another language, but no competent review of that language is supplied.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each record beside its role.
Complete or match: Reviewed drafts in the first language; Unreviewed drafts in the second language; Knowledgeable comparison of meaning and wording
- a: Unevaluated use
- b: Relevant next review
- c: Automatic language guarantee
- d: Existing evidence
Capability in one language does not settle quality in every other language.
3B · Open ended
Apply the tested-scope idea and propose a responsible way to evaluate the new-language output.
Example of a full-credit answer: The first-language review does not establish accuracy in the new language. Have a knowledgeable speaker compare the new draft with the source meaning, check natural wording and record issues before using important instructions.
- Identifies the gap between tested and untested language use.
- Proposes competent source-meaning and wording review of the new-language output.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional response begins “I am absolutely certain” and invents a room capacity. The supplied room record says capacity has not been entered yet. No measurement is available.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements correctly address the problem?
- a: A precise invented number is safer than admitting the gap.
- b: The capacity should remain unconfirmed until a relevant record is obtained.
- c: Certainty words prove that a hidden measurement occurred.
- d: Confident wording does not supply the missing measurement.
Tone cannot replace missing evidence, and invented precision should not be presented as a fact.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error and rewrite the answer to show the evidence limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The response invents a number and treats confidence as support. A better answer is “The supplied record does not establish capacity; check with the authorised room organiser before using a number.”
- Identifies the unsupported invented capacity rather than treating tone as proof.
- Provides a useful limitation statement and a relevant verification route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class helper may explain a supplied lesson but has no access to live school notices or private records. It must identify missing information and offer a suitable next step without inventing details.
5A · Multiple choice
Which response best respects the boundary for tomorrow’s unprovided schedule?
- a: “Tomorrow’s exact time is whatever sounds plausible.”
- b: “No person can ever check the missing schedule.”
- c: “I know every private schedule without access.”
- d: “I need the current school notice to answer that.”
A bounded helper names the missing source and a way to resolve it.
5B · Open ended
Propose a response rule for missing information and explain how users can correct or complete the answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: When the lesson lacks a fact, say what is missing and avoid inventing it. Direct the learner to the current official school notice or a trusted adult, then revise the answer using the supplied authorised information and retain the correction.
- Defines a clear no-invention response that states the relevant missing information.
- Provides a practical source/adult route and a way to update or correct the answer.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.13 · Why artificial intelligence can make mistakes
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An incorrect input
Fictional worked example
A fictional calculator receives 18 even though the worksheet says 13. It correctly doubles 18 to 36.
Question: What first needs correcting?
Answer: The entered input should be 13; the requested double would then be 26.
Why: A correct computation can still answer the wrong supplied input.
Example 2 · A feature is missing
Fictional worked example
A fictional toy sorter uses only weight. Two objects have equal weight but belong to different shape categories.
Question: Why can weight alone be insufficient?
Answer: It does not distinguish the shapes required by the task.
Why: A feature must contain relevant information, not merely be easy to measure.
Example 3 · Cause remains uncertain
| Item | Available? |
|---|---|
| Wrong output | Yes |
| Input and model details | No |
Fictional worked example
A fictional model gives a wrong label. No input image, training record or method description is available.
Question: Should a reviewer claim a definite training-label cause?
Answer: No. That is one possibility requiring evidence.
Why: A specific diagnosis needs a record that supports it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the earliest mismatch
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional spoken request is “set six minutes”. The transcript says “sixty minutes”; the timer then accurately counts sixty. The source records each stage.
F1 · Hotspot
Where is the first recorded mismatch?
- a: Every stage matches the intended request.
- b: The transcript changes six to sixty.
- c: The request contains the word minutes.
- d: The countdown stops at its selected duration.
The mismatch appears when speech becomes the wrong transcript.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · A missing training condition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sorter is trained only on upright symbols and makes errors on rotated symbols. No controlled experiment has yet isolated the cause. The team can collect relevant labelled rotated examples.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements are justified?
- a: Missing rotated examples are a plausible issue to investigate.
- b: Duplicating upright examples guarantees a complete repair.
- c: Separate tests are needed to evaluate a proposed improvement.
- d: The record proves every error has exactly one cause.
The evidence suggests a coverage gap but does not isolate every causal detail.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A confident error
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated answer confidently names Room 9. The supplied event notice states Room 7. No update exists in the record.
F3 · True or false
True or false? Confident wording prevents an AI answer from being factually wrong.
- true: True
- false: False
The confident answer conflicts with the checked event notice.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A one-feature limitation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model distinguishes toys using only length. Two toys both measure 5 units but one is a ball and one a block. Shape, not length, defines the target categories.
F4 · Multiple choice
What most directly limits this input representation?
- a: A single number proves the toy’s material.
- b: Every long toy is necessarily a block in real life.
- c: Equal lengths do not capture the needed shape difference.
- d: The model already has complete shape information.
The input feature omits the distinction used by the target task.
Investigation: training lab
F5 · Choose a targeted repair
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt asks “Explain how it works” without naming the object. The generated answer explains a bicycle, but the learner meant a pulley. No other context was supplied.
F5 · Short answer
Explain the input problem and write a more specific request.
Example of a full-credit answer: The original request omits the object, so the answer assumes the wrong subject. A clearer request is “Explain how a pulley helps lift a load, in simple language, with one example.”
- Identifies the missing object and the unsupported bicycle assumption.
- Provides a specific pulley request that supplies the needed subject and useful task detail.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional dataset record shows a square drawing mistakenly labelled “circle”. The model’s training log confirms it used that entry. This is one identified problem; other possible problems have not been investigated.
1A · Hotspot
Which problem is directly demonstrated?
- a: Every future output must be wrong.
- b: The model deliberately deceived the teacher.
- c: All other training labels are proved wrong.
- d: A wrongly labelled training example was used.
The records establish one label error, not the broader unsupported claims.
1B · Open ended
Explain the demonstrated problem and propose a repair with a check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The square was used with the wrong circle target, which could teach an unhelpful association. Correct and record the label, retrain as appropriate, and test separate square/circle examples rather than assuming all errors vanish.
- Identifies the square/circle label mismatch used in training.
- Proposes label correction with an appropriate separate evaluation of the revised model.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team sees many errors in dark photos but few in bright photos. It knows the input camera sometimes produces blur in darkness. It has not separated blur from lighting.
2A · Multiple choice
Which next investigation best addresses the uncertainty?
- a: Declare lighting the only possible cause without testing.
- b: Compare blur and lighting separately under matched conditions.
- c: Rename the model and assume the errors are repaired.
- d: Hide the dark-photo results from the report.
A comparison varying the possible influences separately is more informative than a single-cause guess.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the cause is not yet isolated and propose the comparison.
Example of a full-credit answer: Darkness and blur occur together in the record, so either or both could matter. Compare clear and blurred images at bright and dark levels with suitable checked labels, then inspect the error patterns.
- Identifies the confounding of darkness and blur.
- Proposes a relevant comparison that separates the two conditions and checks performance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source instruction says “Do not enter until the teacher arrives.” A first translation drops “not”; a later reader follows the altered instruction correctly. The review record identifies the omission.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the error trace.
Complete or match: Do not enter until the teacher arrives; Removal of the word not; Following the altered instruction
- a: Translation omission
- b: Original restriction
- c: Correct meaning preserved
- d: Downstream action
The meaning changed before the reader acted, so the workflow needs source comparison at translation review.
3B · Short answer
Apply stage-by-stage checking to identify the error and propose a prevention step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The translation stage removes “not”, reversing the restriction. Have a knowledgeable reviewer compare the translated action and timing with the source before learners use it.
- Identifies the dropped negation and its change to the instruction.
- Proposes competent source-meaning review before the downstream action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “I added one more copy of the same training photo, so all errors are fixed.” The model has not been retrained or retested after the addition.
4A · Drag and drop
Place each record beside the gap it reveals.
Complete or match: Limited change in data variety; No evidence the fitted model changed; No evidence the proposed repair works
- a: Proof of universal success
- b: Duplicate example only
- c: No recorded retraining
- d: No separate evaluation
A duplicate data edit alone does not demonstrate a changed model or successful transfer.
4B · Open ended
Explain why the guarantee is unsupported and propose a more useful repair process.
Example of a full-credit answer: A duplicate adds no new relevant condition, and there is no retraining or test evidence. Identify the actual error pattern, make a relevant data/method correction, update the model as needed and evaluate separate cases before reporting the result.
- Explains the missing model-update/evaluation evidence and/or limited value of the duplicate.
- Proposes diagnosis, targeted correction and relevant separate testing rather than a universal guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team must review a toy image model. Its log must retain the supplied input, expected label, actual output and relevant conditions. It must separate observed facts from guessed causes.
5A · Matching
Match each log section to its purpose.
Complete or match: Expected label compared with actual output; A proposed cause needing investigation; Result of a targeted separate test
- a: Observed mismatch
- b: Possible explanation
- c: Follow-up evidence
- d: Unquestionable intention
An error record separates what happened, why it may have happened and what a later test shows.
5B · Open ended
Propose a useful error-log entry structure and explain how it prevents unsupported causal claims.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record the input and conditions, checked expected label, actual output, possible cause, proposed repair and separate test result. Keep the possible-cause field labelled as a hypothesis until the follow-up evidence supports it.
- Includes enough input/expected/output/condition detail to inspect the mismatch and follow up.
- Explicitly separates observed error evidence from tentative causal explanations and later tests.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.14 · Artificial intelligence hallucinations
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An invented reference
Fictional worked example
A fictional complete class catalogue lists only Pond Life, Rock Guide and Cloud Notes. A generated answer cites Rainbow Stones as a book in that catalogue.
Question: Is the citation supported by this catalogue?
Answer: No. Rainbow Stones is absent from the supplied complete catalogue.
Why: The conclusion concerns this defined collection, not every book in the world.
Example 2 · A changed quotation
Fictional worked example
A fictional source says “The test needs repeating.” A generated answer quotes it as “The test proves everything.”
Question: What is wrong?
Answer: The quotation changes the original words and meaning.
Why: Quoted wording must be checked against the source, not judged by fluency.
Example 3 · A supported correction
| Record | Time |
|---|---|
| Draft | 2 |
| Current notice | 3 |
Fictional worked example
A fictional draft says an event begins at 2. The current organiser notice says 3.
Question: How should the draft be repaired?
Answer: Change the time to 3 and identify the organiser notice as the basis.
Why: Use the relevant evidence to correct the claim.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find an unsupported addition
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional approved notice gives “Science display, Friday, Hall A”. A generated draft adds “Everyone receives a telescope”. No giveaway information is supplied.
F1 · Hotspot
Which detail is unsupported by the approved facts?
- a: The event is on Friday.
- b: Everyone receives a telescope.
- c: The event is a science display.
- d: The event is in Hall A.
The giveaway promise appears only in the generated draft.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Choose a verification source
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional review needs to verify a quoted sentence, the count in a class table, and tomorrow’s event time.
F2 · Matching
Match each claim to the appropriate record.
Complete or match: Exact quoted sentence; Recorded class count; Tomorrow’s event time
- a: Current organiser notice
- b: Checked class table
- c: Original passage
- d: Confident generated wording
Each source directly addresses a different kind of claim.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A plausible but absent title
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional complete workshop reading list contains only Tools for Paper, Folded Shapes and Safe Glue. A generated answer cites Painted Metal as a title on that list.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which conclusions are justified?
- a: The answer should not present that list membership as verified.
- b: A plausible title is enough to establish list membership.
- c: The title is proved never to exist anywhere.
- d: The claimed inclusion on this reading list is incorrect.
The complete supplied list refutes membership, while saying nothing definitive about every possible publication.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Repeated generation is not independent evidence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model produces the same unsourced river length in three replies. No map, measurement or reference has been consulted.
F4 · Multiple choice
What is the strongest supported conclusion?
- a: The replies prove the river changed length.
- b: Repetition guarantees the number is correct.
- c: Three replies establish three separate measurements.
- d: The length still needs a relevant independent check.
Repeated text without a source adds no independent measurement.
Investigation: origin lab
F5 · Repair a fabricated quotation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional speaker’s complete statement is “Our first trial worked, but we need more trials.” A generated summary quotes the speaker as saying “Our idea always works”.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the claimed quotation is unsupported and give a faithful replacement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The speaker did not say “always”; the original limits success to the first trial and calls for more. Use the exact statement or a clear paraphrase: “The first trial worked, but more trials are needed.”
- Identifies the invented certainty and missing further-trial limitation.
- Provides an accurate quotation or labelled paraphrase preserving both the initial success and the need for more trials.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: clip lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source record states the fair is Monday, begins at 10, and has no listed prizes. The generated draft says Monday, begins at 11, and promises a bicycle prize.
1A · Drag and drop
Place each claim beside its status.
Complete or match: Matches the source; Contradicts the source time; Adds an unsupported promise
- a: Monday
- b: 11 o’clock
- c: Bicycle prize
- d: All claims are verified
The day is supported, time conflicts with the source, and prize is unverified.
1B · Short answer
Correct the time and explain how to handle the prize claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: Change the start to 10 using the source record. Remove the bicycle prize promise unless the organiser supplies a valid confirmation; its presence in the generated draft is not evidence.
- Corrects the contradicted start time to ten.
- Removes or appropriately verifies the unsupported prize promise before use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional page titled Seed Trial has this complete passage: “We planted twenty seeds. Twelve grew. We will repeat the trial.” A generated explanation cites Seed Trial but quotes it as “Every seed grew, so no further trial is needed.” Those quoted words do not occur in the supplied page.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which actions are appropriate?
- a: Compare the quoted wording with the actual passage.
- b: Treat a page title as proof of every sentence attributed to it.
- c: Accept the quote because it contains an author and date.
- d: Remove quotation marks or correct the claim only if a faithful paraphrase is supported.
Quotation accuracy requires the real passage, and a paraphrase must still preserve its supported meaning.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the citation format is insufficient and describe a faithful repair.
Example of a full-credit answer: A title and date do not show that the quoted words occur in the source. Replace the false quotation with the source’s actual wording, or write a clearly unquoted paraphrase that preserves the actual meaning and citation.
- Explains that a plausible citation format does not verify quoted content.
- Proposes an exact verified quotation or faithful unquoted paraphrase rather than merely removing quotation marks from an unsupported claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional image-generation record says “invent a future school bus”. A draft caption claims “Photograph of the bus delivered yesterday”. No delivery occurred in the supplied project record.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the correction record.
Complete or match: What the image record describes; What the caption wrongly adds; Appropriate final status label
- a: Clearly labelled illustration
- b: Unsupported delivery claim
- c: Verified delivery photograph
- d: Generated future concept
The creation and project records contradict presenting the image as a completed delivery.
3B · Open ended
Explain the invented factual claim and propose a corrected caption.
Example of a full-credit answer: The caption invents a delivery and presents generated art as a photograph. Use “Generated illustration of a proposed future school bus; no delivery is shown.”
- Identifies the unsupported real delivery/photograph claim.
- Provides a caption preserving the generated proposed status without inventing an event.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner adds “Never make mistakes” to a prompt and claims no further checks are needed. The next response includes a date that conflicts with the approved source.
4A · True or false
True or false? A request to avoid mistakes guarantees that every generated detail is correct.
- true: True
- false: False
The supplied response still contains an error; instructions do not replace verification.
4B · Open ended
Explain the guarantee error and name the required next check for the date.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats an instruction as proof of compliance. Compare the generated date with the approved source and correct the mismatch; even a clear no-invention instruction does not guarantee correctness.
- Distinguishes requesting accuracy from demonstrating output accuracy.
- Proposes checking and correcting the specific date against the approved source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class has already shared a generated notice with an unsupported free-ticket promise. The organiser confirms there is no free-ticket offer. The class must correct the same audience and keep a record of the change.
5A · Matching
Match each action to its purpose.
Complete or match: Establish the actual ticket terms; Inform readers who saw the wrong promise; Explain what changed and why
- a: Silent repetition
- b: Organiser check
- c: Visible correction
- d: Change record
The workflow verifies the actual terms, reaches affected readers and preserves accountability.
5B · Open ended
Propose a correction message and describe how to reach and document the affected audience.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Correction: our earlier notice wrongly promised free tickets. The organiser confirms there is no free-ticket offer.” Post it where the original audience saw the claim, update the notice, and record the organiser confirmation and correction date.
- Provides an explicit accurate correction naming the earlier false promise and confirmed terms.
- Reaches the original audience and keeps a meaningful source/change record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.15 · Bias in training data
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A convenience sample
Fictional worked example
A fictional voice dataset records only one quiet classroom, but the intended task includes several rooms and speaking styles.
Question: What risk should be investigated?
Answer: The data may not cover the intended variety of conditions and voices.
Why: Convenient collection can create coverage gaps without showing deliberate intent.
Example 2 · Equal totals, unequal variety
Fictional worked example
A fictional dataset has 20 distinct round objects and 20 copies of one square object.
Question: What do equal totals fail to establish?
Answer: Equal variety within the categories.
Why: Inspect the content of entries as well as their count.
Example 3 · An irrelevant label rule
| Basis | Description |
|---|---|
| Intended | Two relevant reasons |
| Used | Paper colour |
Fictional worked example
A fictional rubric judges whether an answer gives two reasons. A data worker labels by paper colour instead.
Question: Why is this a data problem?
Answer: The labels follow an irrelevant feature rather than the required content criteria.
Why: Training on more labels produced by the same rule would retain the shortcut.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read coverage counts
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional object model will be used on light and dark backgrounds. Its training set has 90 light-background examples and 10 dark-background examples. Separate tests each use 20 examples. The initial separate tests show 18 correct light-background labels and 13 correct dark-background labels.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the record descriptions.
Complete or match: Light-background training entries; Dark-background training entries; Separate test size for each background
- a: 10
- b: 90
- c: 20 each
- d: A guaranteed cause
The counts show training imbalance and equal-sized tests, not a complete causal diagnosis.
Investigation: data balance lab
F2 · Choose the missing relevant group
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional handwriting model will read block and joined-up letters. Training has block letters only. The task permits collecting original practice writing with appropriate permission.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which addition most directly addresses the stated coverage risk?
- a: Unrelated private photographs of learners
- b: Permitted checked joined-up writing examples
- c: A new logo for the same unchanged dataset
- d: Many copies of the existing block-letter sheet
The intended use includes joined-up writing, which is missing from training.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Inspect three data problems
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional audit finds Set A lacks rainy scenes, Set B labels by card colour instead of content, and Set C repeats one image many times.
F3 · Matching
Match the set to its stated problem.
Complete or match: Missing relevant condition; Irrelevant labelling shortcut; Low variety hidden by many entries
- a: Set A
- b: Set C
- c: Set B
- d: No documented set
Coverage, labelling method and duplicate variety are different problems.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · Do not infer intent from a count
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team discovers a dataset collected only from the nearest club because it was convenient. No evidence says the collectors intended to exclude other clubs.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements are justified?
- a: Convenience guarantees representation of every club.
- b: The count alone does not establish deliberate harmful intent.
- c: The collection may miss relevant variation in other clubs.
- d: Any imbalance proves deliberate deception.
A coverage risk can be identified without inventing motives.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A bad target for answer quality
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional training collection is meant to identify answers with two relevant reasons. The reviewer instead labels all blue cards “complete” and all yellow cards “incomplete”, regardless of the written answer.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the labels are unsuitable and propose a relevant repair.
Example of a full-credit answer: Paper colour does not show whether an answer gives the two relevant reasons, so the labels teach an irrelevant shortcut. Re-read the responses, relabel them using the stated content rubric and check agreement on difficult cases.
- Identifies the mismatch between colour-based labels and the two-reason content target.
- Proposes rubric-based relabelling with an appropriate consistency check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: evidence lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional symbol model has 80 upright and 5 rotated training examples. Separate tests score 18/20 upright and 10/20 rotated. The record does not isolate the cause of the difference.
1A · Hotspot
Which conclusion is supported?
- a: Training count alone proves the exact cause of every error.
- b: The two test results are identical.
- c: Rotated coverage is sparse and its test result is weaker.
- d: Increasing the displayed count guarantees a perfect score.
The records show a coverage gap and performance difference, while causation needs further investigation.
1B · Open ended
Describe the data risk and propose a way to test a targeted improvement.
Example of a full-credit answer: Rotated symbols are poorly represented and perform worse in the supplied test. Add checked relevant rotated examples, update the model as appropriate, and evaluate on different rotated and upright examples to see whether errors improve.
- Uses the sparse rotated coverage and weaker result to identify a plausible data risk without overstating cause.
- Proposes a targeted data improvement followed by separate relevant evaluation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rubric checks whether a solution names the correct shape and gives a valid reason. Reviewers currently see a decorative badge and sometimes use it instead of reading the answer. The badge is unrelated to the rubric.
2A · Drag and drop
Place each feature beside its role.
Complete or match: Correct shape and valid reason; Decorative badge; Second review of uncertain labels
- a: Irrelevant decorative cue
- b: Relevant answer criterion
- c: Consistency check
- d: Automatic fairness guarantee
The process should use task evidence and review ambiguous labels.
2B · Open ended
Propose a labelling procedure and justify why it reduces the identified shortcut risk.
Example of a full-credit answer: Hide or ignore the badge, read each answer against the same shape-and-reason rubric, and have another reviewer check uncertain cases. This makes labels depend on the required content rather than an unrelated decoration.
- Proposes rubric-based review with handling of uncertain labels.
- Explains how removing/ignoring the irrelevant badge targets the documented shortcut.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional practice voice tool will serve three speaking styles. Training includes styles A and B but no C; no real voices are collected in this activity. The team has a plan for authorised, consented future collection.
3A · Matching
Match each step to its purpose.
Complete or match: Find that C is absent; Add relevant C examples with appropriate consent; Check new-case performance in A, B and C
- a: Public sharing of voice identities
- b: Permitted targeted collection
- c: Separate style-by-style evaluation
- d: Coverage audit
A responsible plan addresses the missing style and checks effects without unnecessary exposure.
3B · Short answer
Apply the representation idea to propose a collection improvement and an evaluation across the intended users.
Example of a full-credit answer: Arrange authorised, appropriately consented examples of the missing style C with checked transcripts and privacy care. Test on separate relevant recordings from A, B and C and report errors by style instead of only one overall average.
- Targets the missing intended style with appropriately permitted, checked and privacy-conscious collection.
- Proposes separate evaluation across all intended styles with visible differences.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says, “Both categories have fifty entries, so the dataset cannot be biased.” One category contains fifty distinct objects; the other contains fifty duplicates of a single object.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which corrections are supported?
- a: Equal totals can hide different example variety.
- b: Fifty copies create fifty distinct object designs.
- c: Labels and collection methods also need inspection.
- d: Equal totals guarantee every relevant case is represented.
Equal entry counts do not establish equal variety or overall data quality.
4B · Open ended
Explain the error in the fairness claim and name a second check beyond totals.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats equal entry counts as complete evidence, even though category B has only one distinct object. Inspect labels, relevant conditions, origins or collection methods as well as distinct example coverage.
- Explains the duplicate-versus-variety problem despite equal totals.
- Names a relevant additional data-quality/coverage/label/collection check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class model must recognise three toy shapes under two background colours. Use original drawings only, check labels by shape, include every shape on both colours and reserve separate drawings for testing.
5A · True or false
True or false? Including all shape-colour combinations and checking labels can address the stated risks, but does not guarantee perfect future performance.
- true: True
- false: False
The plan targets known coverage and label risks while still requiring separate testing.
5B · Open ended
Propose the collection and explain how the test will check whether background colour creates a shortcut.
Example of a full-credit answer: Draw each of the three shapes on both colours and label the shape correctly. Reserve new drawings of every shape-colour combination for testing, compare errors across colours, and investigate if identical shape tasks receive different results.
- Includes all shapes on both backgrounds with checked shape-based labels.
- Uses separate combinations and comparison across colours to test for the irrelevant-colour shortcut.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.16 · Bias in artificial intelligence outputs
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Same content, different decoration
Fictional worked example
A fictional rubric checks two scientific reasons. Identical answers on green and orange cards receive different scores, with the tool citing only colour.
Question: What is the problem?
Answer: An irrelevant feature changes a content-based judgement.
Why: The score should be reviewed using the actual two-reason rubric.
Example 2 · Compare rates
Fictional worked example
A fictional model gets 8/10 clear labels and 12/20 faint labels correct.
Question: Which condition has the higher accuracy in this test?
Answer: Clear labels: 80%, compared with 60% for faint labels.
Why: Counts alone can mislead when test sizes differ.
Example 3 · Access is not a shortcut
| Feature | Same or different? |
|---|---|
| Question and rubric | Same |
| Text size | Different to support access |
Fictional worked example
A fictional learner uses enlarged text, but receives the same question and scoring criteria as classmates.
Question: Does the different display itself prove unfair scoring?
Answer: No. It can provide access to the same task.
Why: Relevant support differs from using an irrelevant feature to judge answer quality.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Inspect the scoring reason
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional rubric awards completeness for naming a cause and evidence. Two answers contain both. A tool scores one lower solely because its border is striped.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion follows from the stated criteria?
- a: Stripes prove weaker scientific reasoning.
- b: The rubric requires a plain border.
- c: The border-based score difference needs correction.
- d: Both answers omit the required evidence.
The border is irrelevant to the supplied completeness criteria.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Separate pattern and explanation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional audit tests 20 clear labels and 20 faint labels. It records 18 correct clear labels and 11 correct faint labels. A count record lists 50 training entries for each condition, but auditors have not examined the training examples themselves, camera processing or model settings.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements are justified?
- a: Equal training counts guarantee equal test outcomes.
- b: The output difference proves one specific person intended harm.
- c: The supplied test shows different error rates by condition.
- d: The exact internal cause still needs investigation.
Observed results support the pattern, but do not isolate its cause or anyone’s intention.
Investigation: data balance lab
F3 · Compare the right quantities
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional output audit records Group A: 9 correct out of 10; Group B: 12 correct out of 20. The groups are two print styles, and the task is identical.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place each value beside the correct result.
Complete or match: Group A correct rate; Group B correct rate; Higher correct rate in this test
- a: 90%
- b: Group B
- c: 60%
- d: Group A
Nine of ten is 90%; twelve of twenty is 60%, so A has the higher tested rate.
Investigation: graph lab
F4 · A useful controlled comparison
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team tests the same answer twice, changing only an irrelevant decorative icon. It keeps the prompt, rubric and answer words unchanged, and records the two scores.
F4 · True or false
True or false? This comparison can help investigate whether the irrelevant icon affects the output.
- true: True
- false: False
Holding the relevant task fixed while changing the icon targets that possible influence, though further checks may be needed.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A narrow set of suggested roles
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional story tool is asked for varied helper roles for four invented characters. Every draft assigns one character group only leadership and another only cleaning, despite no skill or preference information. The class has a requirement to avoid fixed group-role assumptions.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the unsupported pattern and propose a revision that fits the class requirement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The drafts repeatedly assign roles by a group label without relevant skills or preferences. Vary leadership, planning, cleaning and creative roles across the invented characters, using story-relevant reasons rather than fixed group assumptions.
- Identifies the repeated group-based role assignment without relevant supporting information.
- Proposes varied role assignments based on relevant story context rather than the unsupported group label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional transcription test has 20 examples per condition. Quiet speech scores 18 correct; speech near a fan scores 12. Both conditions are part of intended use.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the audit summary.
Complete or match: Quiet correct rate; Fan-condition correct rate; Condition needing stronger error review
- a: All conditions identical
- b: Near a fan
- c: 90%
- d: 60%
The two correct rates are 18/20 and 12/20; the fan condition has more errors.
1B · Short answer
Explain the output disparity and propose one response before relying on both conditions equally.
Example of a full-credit answer: The tool is 90% correct in quiet and 60% near a fan in these tests. Review fan-condition errors and use extra confirmation or improved handling, then test separately again rather than assuming equal reliability.
- Correctly compares the two tested rates and identifies the weaker condition.
- Proposes a relevant review, support or improvement with further evaluation before equal reliance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool awards one point to a response that gives both rubric requirements. Its reason says the decorative name tag looked “less serious”. A teacher can inspect the answer and correct the score.
2A · Matching
Match each record to its function.
Complete or match: Defines what earns credit; Shows what the learner supplied; Reveals the irrelevant name-tag reason
- a: Automatic final authority
- b: Learner response
- c: Approved rubric
- d: Tool explanation
A review compares content with approved criteria and checks whether the tool used an irrelevant cue.
2B · Open ended
Propose a justified review outcome and explain why the learner should have a correction route.
Example of a full-credit answer: Review the response against the two content requirements and award the rubric-supported score if both are present. The learner needs a correction route because an irrelevant decorative cue should not determine an educational result.
- Bases the reviewed score on the supplied content requirements rather than the name-tag cue.
- Explains the value of a correction/appeal route for an output that can affect the learner.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional project needs history, science and art sources. A recommender repeatedly returns only art items even though relevant history and science items are in its catalogue. Its current rule prioritises art score alone.
3A · Hotspot
Which change directly addresses the stated project omission?
- a: Treat the current rank as the complete catalogue.
- b: Declare all missing topics to be worthless.
- c: Increase only the number of repeated art items.
- d: Include relevant history and science sources in selection.
The task explicitly requires all three areas, and relevant omitted items exist.
3B · Short answer
Apply output review to explain the mismatch and propose an evaluation of a revised list.
Example of a full-credit answer: The art-only output omits two required project areas. Revise selection to include relevant history and science, then check whether the list actually covers all three areas with useful supported sources rather than just counting clicks.
- Identifies the omission relative to the stated three-area task.
- Proposes a revised selection and task-coverage/usefulness evaluation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional model is 19/20 correct on clear labels and 5/20 on faint labels. A report gives only “24 of 40 correct” and claims both conditions are equally reliable.
4A · Drag and drop
Place each value beside its role.
Complete or match: Clear-label result; Faint-label result; Combined result
- a: 5 of 20
- b: 19 of 20
- c: 24 of 40
- d: Equal condition performance
The combined total is accurate, but it hides a large difference and does not support equal reliability.
4B · Open ended
Explain why the equality claim is unsupported and propose a more informative report.
Example of a full-credit answer: The two conditions have very different results, 19/20 versus 5/20, despite the combined total. Report both condition results and sample sizes alongside the overall figure, and flag faint labels for review or improvement.
- Uses the unequal condition-specific results to reject the equal-reliability claim.
- Proposes reporting separate rates/counts with sample sizes and the relevant weaker-condition concern.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school tool suggests feedback but does not set final grades. The review plan must compare identical-content responses with different irrelevant decorations, preserve the rubric and allow learners to question a suggestion.
5A · True or false
True or false? One successful comparison proves that every possible output bias has been removed forever.
- true: True
- false: False
A single check has limited scope; suitable wider evaluation and ongoing review are still needed.
5B · Open ended
Propose the comparison procedure and explain how a learner can obtain a meaningful review.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use several identical-content pairs with different irrelevant decorations, compare feedback against the same rubric and record unexplained differences. Let a learner ask a teacher to inspect the response, explain the criteria and correct the suggestion before any final grade.
- Proposes controlled, rubric-based comparisons with recorded unexplained differences.
- Provides a meaningful human explanation/correction route before the consequential decision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL2.17 · Human responsibility for artificial intelligence decisions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A suggestion is not final authority
Fictional worked example
A fictional tool suggests a title that overstates a project result. The student checks the evidence and chooses a different title.
Question: Who remains responsible for the final wording?
Answer: The student and supervising reviewer under the class process.
Why: The tool’s suggestion does not remove the need for a human decision.
Example 2 · Review without evidence
Fictional worked example
A fictional reviewer must approve scores but cannot see responses or the rubric.
Question: Why is that review inadequate?
Answer: The reviewer lacks the information needed to judge or correct the score.
Why: A human name on approval is not enough without meaningful access and authority.
Example 3 · A correction route
| Step | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Compare response and rubric | Check the decision |
| Update the record | Repair the confirmed mistake |
Fictional worked example
A fictional learner questions a low score. The teacher compares the response with the rubric, finds a missed point and updates the record.
Question: What makes the route meaningful?
Answer: It allows evidence-based review and an actual correction.
Why: An appeal should do more than repeat the original output.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Assign human roles
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school uses a tool for draft feedback. Developers maintain the model; teachers review educational use; learners can ask questions through the class review route.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which statements follow from this process?
- a: Learners have a supported route to question feedback.
- b: Teachers remain responsible for the educational review.
- c: Children must repair the entire server themselves.
- d: The tool removes every human responsibility.
The process assigns roles and support rather than shifting all responsibility to the learner or the model.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Find meaningful review
Fixed fictional classroom case
In fictional Design A, the feedback reviewer can inspect the original answer, see the rubric, ask for clarification and change an unsupported score. In Design B, the reviewer can only press approve without seeing the answer.
F2 · Hotspot
Which design provides the stated meaningful review?
- a: An unchangeable score with no explanation
- b: Design A with evidence and correction authority
- c: Design B with a hidden answer and instant approval
- d: A public vote on learner names
A reviewer needs relevant evidence and authority to correct the decision.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Separate the records
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional review file stores the learner response, the rubric criteria and the teacher’s final decision with reasons. The AI suggestion is identified separately.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the role mapping.
Complete or match: Evidence of the answer; Criteria for judgement; Accountable final result and reasons
- a: Unquestionable model command
- b: Approved rubric
- c: Learner response
- d: Reviewed decision
The records support a traceable decision rather than treating the tool output as self-justifying.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · A score affects an opportunity
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional system suggests excluding a learner from an optional activity because of an unexplained model score. The school process requires a staff review with relevant criteria before any exclusion.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The required staff review should occur before the exclusion is applied.
- true: True
- false: False
The stated process requires human review before this consequential action.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · An unhelpful explanation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner asks why a score changed. The only reply is “Because the computer said so.” The teacher has the response, rubric and original suggestion available.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the reply is insufficient and propose a better explanation process.
Example of a full-credit answer: It gives no criteria or answer evidence and hides who reviewed the result. The teacher should compare the response with the rubric, explain the supported score and the tool’s limited role, and allow questions or correction.
- Identifies the missing criteria/evidence/accountable review in the computer-only reply.
- Proposes an evidence-based human explanation with an opportunity for questions or correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool suggests one point for an answer. The rubric awards two when a valid explanation and evidence are present. The teacher checks that both are present and changes the score to two.
1A · Drag and drop
Place each action beside its role.
Complete or match: Initial one-point proposal; Checking explanation and evidence; Recording two with reasons
- a: An unexplained permanent score
- b: Human evidence review
- c: Corrected final decision
- d: AI suggestion
The teacher uses the rubric and response rather than automatically accepting the suggestion.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the correction is justified and identify the record that makes it accountable.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both rubric requirements are present, so the teacher’s two-point correction follows the stated criteria. Keep the response, rubric and a note explaining which requirements were found and who reviewed the change.
- Justifies the two-point correction using both supplied rubric requirements.
- Identifies a meaningful evidence/reviewer/correction record rather than only a changed number.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school compares Plan A: automatic final scores with no appeal; B: teachers see responses and criteria, can correct scores and explain them; C: teachers must approve instantly with no information.
2A · Matching
Match each plan to its stated feature.
Complete or match: Final output with no appeal; Evidence-based correction and explanation; Approval without evidence or time
- a: Plan A
- b: Plan B
- c: Plan C
- d: No plan needs evidence
B supplies both meaningful review and correction authority.
2B · Open ended
Choose the responsible plan and justify it using evidence access and correction authority.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B. Teachers can compare the original responses with the rubric and can change an unsupported score, then explain the result rather than merely approving the model.
- Selects B because relevant response and rubric evidence are available.
- Explains why correction authority and explanation make the review meaningful.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional tool suggests which class gets a shared display area. The actual rule is to rotate fairly through the published schedule. A librarian must check the schedule and handle conflicts before confirming a booking.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct answers. Which practices meet the stated process?
- a: Treat the suggestion as superior to the actual rule.
- b: Check the suggestion against the published rotation.
- c: Remove every route to question a booking error.
- d: Let the librarian correct a conflicting suggestion.
The tool supports allocation but does not replace the published rule or responsible review.
3B · Short answer
Apply the human-responsibility idea to explain the librarian’s role and a route for a class to challenge an error.
Example of a full-credit answer: The librarian checks the suggestion against the rotation and resolves conflicts before confirming it. A class can show the relevant schedule entry through the established booking-review route so the librarian can explain and correct a mistaken allocation.
- Assigns the librarian evidence-based review and correction before confirmation.
- Provides a practical challenge route using the relevant schedule evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional notice says “No person can correct the AI score; the AI is responsible.” The school policy actually gives the teacher authority to review and amend scores using the rubric.
4A · Multiple choice
Which replacement matches the policy?
- a: No person chose how to use the system.
- b: Teachers can review and correct scores using the rubric.
- c: Every suggestion is permanently unchangeable.
- d: The learner must accept errors without explanation.
The stated policy assigns review and correction authority to teachers.
4B · Open ended
Identify the notice’s error and propose a corrected accountability statement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The notice denies the teacher’s actual review authority and shifts responsibility to the tool. Replace it with “AI scores are suggestions subject to teacher review; learners may request a rubric-based explanation and correction.”
- Identifies the contradiction with human review/correction authority in the school policy.
- Provides a corrected statement assigning human review and a learner explanation/correction route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class service may suggest feedback, must save the learner’s response and rubric for teacher review, and must let learners request a correction. Only authorised staff may inspect identifiable records.
5A · Hotspot
Which design feature directly supports both review and accountability?
- a: Public release of every learner’s answer and identity
- b: A final score with no explanation or appeal
- c: Authorised access to evidence with a recorded correction route
- d: Automatic approval even when evidence is missing
Evidence access should serve authorised review, with corrections recorded and privacy protected.
5B · Open ended
Propose the feedback-and-review sequence and explain how it protects both correction rights and learner records.
Example of a full-credit answer: Generate a suggestion, let an authorised teacher compare it with the response and rubric, and record the reviewed result. Learners can request an explanation or correction through a clear route; identifiable records stay restricted to authorised staff and changes are logged.
- Provides a tool-suggestion → evidence-based teacher-review sequence with a practical learner correction route.
- Protects identifiable records through authorised access while keeping a useful review/correction log.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.1 · Constructing effective search queries
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Name the meaning
Fictional classroom example
In a fictional catalogue, the word seal returns an animal guide and a guide to closing envelopes. A learner wants information about the animal’s habitat.
Question: What query would better express the need?
Answer: Seal animal habitat.
Why: The added meaning and needed information distinguish the animal from a closing strip.
Example 2 · Use the source’s wording
Fictional classroom example
A fictional school index labels its page “Lunch menu.” A student searches for “midday meals” and finds no local match.
Question: What useful revision could they try?
Answer: Try lunch menu, then inspect whether the page covers the needed day.
Why: A related phrase can match the index’s vocabulary without changing the task.
Example 3 · A careful starting question
| Need | Useful part |
|---|---|
| Subject | Puddle drying |
| Possible influence | Shade |
| Unknown | Effect on drying time |
Fictional classroom example
A fictional group wants to investigate whether shade affects the time a puddle takes to dry. No measurement has been collected.
Question: Which wording avoids assuming a result?
Answer: Shade and puddle drying time, or How does shade affect puddle drying time?
Why: The query names the relationship to investigate without claiming what the result must be.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Three useful keyword roles
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs instructions for looking after a young mangrove plant. The prepared query is “mangrove seedling care”: mangrove names the plant, seedling gives the growth stage, and care names the task.
F1 · Matching
Match each query word with its stated role.
Complete or match: Mangrove; Seedling; Care
- a: Needed task
- b: Proof that a result is true
- c: Plant name
- d: Growth stage
Each keyword describes a different part of the information need.
Investigation: search results lab
F2 · An animal or an object?
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional student needs to learn where bats rest during the day. A search for “bat” produces animal pages and sports-equipment pages. No result has been checked yet.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which revisions help express this information need?
- a: Assume the first sports result answers the question.
- b: Add animal to clarify the meaning.
- c: Add roost or daytime resting place.
- d: Add an unrelated favourite colour.
The useful additions identify the animal and its resting-place question.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A first result with missing evidence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional local search ranks a page first because its title contains all query words. The page has no named evidence for its main claim.
F3 · True or false
True or false? Its first position proves that the main claim is accurate.
- true: True
- false: False
A word-match rule does not check the truth of a claim.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Resolve three meanings
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional index uses crane for a bird, a lifting machine and a family name in a story. The three tasks are finding a bird habitat, a machine lifting limit and the named family’s story.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each information need to the focused query.
Complete or match: Bird habitat; Machine lifting limit; Story about the named family
- a: crane favourite colour
- b: crane bird habitat
- c: crane machine lifting limit
- d: Crane family story
The extra words distinguish the three intended meanings.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A query that finds nothing
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional local index has “Book borrowing rules,” “Bicycle loan rules” and “Book exhibition dates.” It requires every typed word. The query “book loans” matches none. The learner needs the book return period.
F5 · Open ended
Propose a better query and explain how it addresses the failed search without changing the information need.
Example of a full-credit answer: Try book borrowing rules. Borrowing is the index’s related term for loans, and the result concerns the return period for books.
- Proposes a query using book and a relevant borrowing/rules term.
- Explains the vocabulary mismatch and preserves the need for the book return period.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: search results lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional index has A: “School garden summer watering,” B: “School garden winter pruning,” and C: “School pond summer cleaning.” The task is watering the school garden during summer.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each title with the task it explicitly covers.
Complete or match: Title A; Title B; Title C
- a: All three answer the same task
- b: Summer pond cleaning
- c: Winter garden pruning
- d: Summer garden watering
Only A includes the required place, season and action.
1B · Open ended
Write the focused query for this task and explain why a query containing only school would be less helpful.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use school garden summer watering. School alone is shared by all three records and does not identify the required garden, season and action.
- Includes the relevant garden, summer and watering terms in a query.
- Explains that school alone fails to distinguish the three different tasks.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner needs the current opening hours of Brook Library. Candidate additions are the library name, opening hours, the learner’s private home address and the colour of the learner’s bag. Neither private detail is needed.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which details directly help express the search need?
- a: The learner’s private home address.
- b: Brook Library.
- c: The colour of the learner’s bag.
- d: Current opening hours.
The place and requested information are relevant; the personal details do not serve the search.
2B · Open ended
Propose a concise query and justify both a useful inclusion and a detail you would leave out.
Example of a full-credit answer: Search Brook Library current opening hours. The library name identifies the place; leave out the private home address because it is unnecessary for the hours question.
- Gives a query identifying the library and the needed opening-hours information.
- Explains why an unnecessary private or irrelevant detail should be excluded.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum archive indexes objects by material and use. A child needs a clay container used for storing grain. The catalogue uses the term jar rather than pot.
3A · Multiple choice
Which query best matches the supplied indexing and task?
- a: museum opening hours
- b: metal cooking pan
- c: old things in a building
- d: clay grain storage jar
The focused query includes material, use and the archive’s object term.
3B · Open ended
Explain how you adapted the search strategy to this archive and identify one feature of the result you would check.
Example of a full-credit answer: I used the archive’s term jar with clay and grain storage. I would check the object record to confirm its stated material and storage use rather than relying only on the title.
- Explains the use of the catalogue vocabulary plus relevant material/use terms.
- Names a relevant result-record check of the material, use or object description.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group has not studied a new school-bus route. One pupil searches “why the new route always makes every trip slower.” The group’s actual question is whether journey times changed.
4A · Hotspot
Which query keeps the outcome open while naming the research need?
- a: new school-bus route journey-time comparison
- b: why every new route must be slower
- c: proof that the route can never improve
- d: why all pupils already dislike the route
A comparison query names the subject without assuming an unmeasured universal result.
4B · Open ended
Identify the problem in the original query and rewrite it to investigate the actual question.
Example of a full-credit answer: The original wording assumes that all trips become slower before evidence is collected. Use new school-bus route journey-time comparison, then inspect relevant before-and-after data.
- Identifies the unsupported assumed universal outcome.
- Provides a neutral query about comparing journey times for the new route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a beginner guide to planting tomato seeds in containers. The plan must use relevant keywords, allow one revision after inspecting results, and avoid including pupil names or contact details.
5A · Dropdown selection
Match each needed detail with a suitable query element.
Complete or match: Plant; Growing situation; Reader level
- a: Pupil phone number
- b: Beginner guide
- c: Tomato seeds
- d: Containers
The three selected details express the task without unnecessary personal data.
5B · Open ended
Propose an initial query and a useful revision rule if the results do not answer the class’s need.
Example of a full-credit answer: Try beginner tomato seed planting containers. If the results focus on garden beds, keep tomato seeds and beginner but try pots as a related term for containers; read the results again and check the source.
- Gives a query covering tomato seeds, container planting and beginner needs.
- Proposes a relevant evidence-led revision while preserving the task and avoiding personal data.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.2 · Selecting appropriate search tools
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Locate a book
Fictional classroom example
A fictional school library catalogue lists title, author, shelf and availability for its own books. A learner wants the shelf for a known title.
Question: Which tool directly fits?
Answer: The school library catalogue.
Why: It organises the exact collection and provides the needed shelf field.
Example 2 · Check a total
Fictional classroom example
A fictional table has counts of 6, 7 and 5. A learner already understands what the counts represent and wants to check their sum.
Question: Which tool can directly check the arithmetic?
Answer: A calculator can check that the sum is 18.
Why: Arithmetic checking is different from deciding whether the counts were collected fairly.
Example 3 · Find a date in a file
| Need | Suitable route |
|---|---|
| Find a word in known PDF | Document search |
| Interpret the date | Read the surrounding entry |
Fictional classroom example
A fictional organiser supplies one dated PDF containing the confirmed exhibition schedule. A learner needs the word opening.
Question: What is a direct first step?
Answer: Search for opening inside the supplied PDF and read the matching entry.
Why: The known relevant document is a narrower and more direct starting point than an unrestricted search.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find a shelf location
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school library’s catalogue contains title, author and shelf fields. A learner needs the shelf for “River Sketches.” The prepared choices are catalogue, calculator, image-colour filter and unsourced AI draft.
F1 · Hotspot
Which tool directly provides the needed record type?
- a: An unsourced generated draft
- b: An image-colour filter
- c: The school library catalogue
- d: A calculator for arithmetic
The catalogue is defined to provide shelf fields for this collection.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Search one known document
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner has the correct current class handbook open. The task is to locate its paragraph containing the word borrowing.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which route most directly fits the task?
- a: Search the web for every school in the country
- b: Ask for an invented handbook paragraph
- c: Search for borrowing inside the current handbook
- d: Filter photographs by their dominant colour
The needed information is a word location inside an already identified document.
Investigation: search results lab
F3 · Two different needs
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs the library’s current opening hours and whether its own copy of “Sky Maps” is available to borrow. The library notice publishes hours; the catalogue records copy availability.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which routes directly fit the two stated needs?
- a: Use last year’s room review as the current schedule.
- b: Check the library catalogue for copy availability.
- c: Read the current library notice for hours.
- d: Assume a calculator knows whether the book is on loan.
Each needed fact has an identified record designed to provide it.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · The scope of an archive
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional village archive searches only its own digitised photograph collection. Its results screen clearly states this scope.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The tool can be useful without covering every photograph in the world.
- true: True
- false: False
A limited collection can be useful when its scope matches the task.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A current schedule question
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI draft gives a swimming-pool schedule without a source. The pool’s known official notice is dated this week. The class only needs the current opening time.
F5 · Short answer
Name the route you would use first and explain why the AI draft alone is insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the pool office’s current notice through the known route. The unsourced AI draft does not establish the present schedule and may be incorrect or stale.
- Selects the current responsible-source notice as the first route.
- Explains the missing current/source support in the AI draft.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional student already has a confirmed results report with a table containing 14, 9 and 7 collected tokens. The task is to locate the table and check its total. Document search and a calculator are available.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which tool uses serve this task?
- a: Use document search to locate the table.
- b: Use an image-colour filter to prove the total.
- c: Use a calculator to check the sum of the stated counts.
- d: Treat the calculator as proof that the collection method was fair.
Locating the table and calculating its sum are different jobs.
1B · Open ended
Describe the two-step route, give the checked total, and state one question that the calculator cannot answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Locate the table in the confirmed report, then add 14, 9 and 7 with a calculator to check 30. The calculator cannot establish whether the collection method was fair or the original counts were accurate.
- Provides the appropriate locate-then-calculate route with the correct total.
- States a valid limit involving original evidence, collection or interpretation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school offers a current lunch menu, a book catalogue and an event calendar. A pupil needs lunch choices, a book shelf and the exhibition date.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each need with its directly relevant record.
Complete or match: Lunch choices for a school day; Shelf for a library title; Date of the exhibition
- a: Unverified generated guess
- b: Book catalogue
- c: Current lunch menu
- d: Event calendar
The source roles in the case directly match the three different questions.
2B · Open ended
Choose a route for finding the exhibition date and justify it using both the record’s scope and the check you would make.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the event calendar because it records event dates. Check the exhibition’s exact name and that the calendar is the current edition.
- Selects the event calendar and connects it to event-date information.
- Identifies an appropriate exact-event/current-edition check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum’s photo catalogue records image title, creation year and original collection. A learner wants the origin of a particular historical photograph, not similar-looking pictures.
3A · Matching
Match each task with the appropriate described tool.
Complete or match: Find the supplied image’s original collection; Find pictures with a similar appearance; Add two supplied numbers
- a: Unverified guessed caption
- b: Image-similarity search
- c: Calculator
- d: Museum photo catalogue
The catalogue’s declared fields directly address origin; similarity alone does not.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the catalogue is the first route for the origin question and what a visually similar result would leave uncertain.
Example of a full-credit answer: The catalogue records the original collection for the identified image. A similar-looking result may be a copy or a different image and would not by itself establish the original record.
- Connects the catalogue’s origin field and image identifier to the task.
- Explains why visual similarity alone does not establish provenance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner searches one school catalogue for an exact title and finds no match. The catalogue covers only that school’s holdings. The learner concludes that the book has never existed anywhere.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each statement with its evidence status in this case.
Complete or match: No exact-title match in this catalogue; The book has never existed anywhere; Another catalogue or title spelling
- a: Unsupported broad conclusion
- b: Useful further check
- c: Observed result
- d: Established publication history
The narrow result does not justify the universal conclusion.
4B · Open ended
Identify the scope error and propose a sensible next check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats a search of one collection as a search of all books everywhere. Check the title spelling and another relevant catalogue or publication record.
- Explains the mismatch between one catalogue’s scope and the universal conclusion.
- Proposes a relevant title, catalogue or publication-record check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a verified local museum visit date and a simple route description. It has the museum’s known notice and a teacher-approved local map. No pupil accounts or home addresses are needed.
5A · Multiple choice
Which plan best meets the stated needs and limits?
- a: Use one unsourced AI guess for both date and route
- b: Use an old visitor diary without checking either source
- c: Post pupil home addresses to find a school trip date
- d: Use the current notice for the date and the approved map for the route
The plan pairs each need with a relevant supplied source and preserves the privacy limit.
5B · Open ended
Propose the two-step plan and explain how you would handle a missing or conflicting detail.
Example of a full-credit answer: Confirm the visit date in the current museum notice, then describe the school-to-museum route from the approved map. If a needed detail is absent or conflicts, ask the teacher or museum through the known route instead of inventing it.
- Uses the notice for the date and the approved map for the route without unnecessary personal data.
- Provides a responsible check or escalation for missing/conflicting information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.3 · Constructing clear prompts
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Name the action and input
Fictional classroom example
A fictional learner types “Help!” while holding two different cleanup plans. The intended job is to compare their time requirements.
Question: What clearer prompt could express the task?
Answer: Compare the time requirements of the supplied cleanup plans A and B.
Why: It names an action, two inputs and the feature to compare.
Example 2 · Remove a vague reference
Fictional classroom example
A fictional draft says “Explain that to them.” The task is explaining the class recycling rule to new members.
Question: How can the reference be made clear?
Answer: Explain the supplied class recycling rule to new members.
Why: The named rule and audience replace two uncertain references.
Example 3 · Resolve a conflict
| Instruction | Decision |
|---|---|
| Three reminders | Keep |
| Exactly one bullet | Remove conflicting limit |
Fictional classroom example
A fictional prompt asks for exactly three bullets and exactly one bullet in the same answer. The teacher needs three separate reminders.
Question: How should the prompt be corrected?
Answer: Request three separate reminder bullets and remove the one-bullet requirement.
Why: The corrected instruction follows the real need without conflicting output counts.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Three parts of a clear request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt says “Summarise the three supplied museum notices for new visitors.” Summarise is the action, the notices are the input, and new visitors are the audience.
F1 · Matching
Match each phrase with its role in the request.
Complete or match: Summarise; Three supplied museum notices; New visitors
- a: Input
- b: Action
- c: A guarantee of accuracy
- d: Audience
The phrases communicate different parts of the intended job.
Investigation: prompt lab
F2 · Repair unclear references
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional draft says “Do it for them. Use that. Guess any missing details.” The real task is comparing Poster A and Poster B for first-time visitors using only their stated time and venue.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each needed repair with its purpose.
Complete or match: Name Poster A and Poster B; Name first-time visitors; Flag missing details
- a: Identify the exact inputs
- b: Avoid unsupported filling of gaps
- c: Guarantee that every output will be correct
- d: Identify the intended readers
The repairs reduce ambiguity while preserving the evidence boundary.
Investigation: revision lab
F3 · Clarity and correctness are different
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt clearly asks for two sentences using a supplied opening time of 3 p.m. The prepared AI response is two sentences long but changes the time to 4 p.m.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The prompt’s clarity guarantees that this response is factually correct.
- true: True
- false: False
The response follows the length but contradicts the supplied time.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A bounded explanation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task is “Explain the supplied bike-parking rule to new pupils. Keep the rule’s two-bike limit. Do not add a fee that is not in the rule.”
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each instruction with what it controls.
Complete or match: Explain the supplied rule; Keep the two-bike limit; Do not add an unstated fee
- a: Requested action and input
- b: Required factual condition
- c: Permission to replace the rule
- d: Boundary for missing information
The prompt makes the job and its limits explicit.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · Write a clear invitation request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class will hold a paper-craft display on Friday at 2 p.m. in Room 8. New classmates need a two-sentence invitation. No price or registration requirement is supplied.
F5 · Open ended
Write a clear prompt using the supplied event facts and state a rule that prevents invented details.
Example of a full-credit answer: Write a two-sentence invitation for new classmates to the paper-craft display on Friday at 2 p.m. in Room 8. Use only these supplied facts and do not invent a price or registration requirement.
- Provides a clear invitation task, audience and the supplied Friday/2 p.m./Room 8 facts.
- Explicitly prevents inventing a price, registration condition or other missing facts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group supplies two notices named A and B and wants their event dates compared. One prompt says “Do the thing.” Another says “Compare the event dates in the supplied notices A and B.”
1A · Multiple choice
Which prompt most clearly expresses the stated task?
- a: Compare the event dates in the supplied notices A and B
- b: Do the thing with whatever seems useful
- c: Invent a new event date for each notice
- d: Compare the notices’ font sizes without checking their event dates
The selected prompt names the intended comparison and both supplied inputs.
1B · Open ended
Explain two features that make the selected prompt clear.
Example of a full-credit answer: It names the action and feature to compare: the event dates. It also identifies the exact inputs as the supplied notices A and B.
- Identifies the explicit action or comparison feature.
- Identifies the named input notices as removing ambiguity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner needs a three-step explanation of an existing handwashing poster for new club members. The request says to explain the supplied poster, preserve its steps and flag any unreadable text rather than guessing.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which reasons support using this prompt for the stated task?
- a: It permits replacing the poster with invented instructions.
- b: It guarantees that no human review is needed.
- c: It identifies the source and the explanation task.
- d: It states how to handle unreadable source text.
The prompt clarifies the task and a missing-information boundary without promising accuracy.
2B · Open ended
Justify the prompt by explaining the value of its named input and its unreadable-text instruction.
Example of a full-credit answer: Naming the supplied poster tells the tool what to explain. Flagging unreadable text preserves uncertainty so the learner can check it instead of using a made-up step.
- Explains how identifying the supplied poster limits the input to the relevant source.
- Explains why flagging unreadable text is preferable to inventing a missing step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom map lists Start: Gate A; turn right at the library; finish at the art room. A learner needs a plain-language route using only these labels. This is a prepared map exercise, not a real journey.
3A · Hotspot
Which request best transfers the clear-prompt method to this map task?
- a: Replace the art room with any place you prefer
- b: Invent a shortcut through a gate absent from the map
- c: Describe the supplied Gate A, library and art-room route in simple words
- d: Tell me where to go without naming a map
The clear request names the supplied route and the desired explanation.
3B · Open ended
Write a prompt that names the route and prevents an unsupported shortcut.
Example of a full-credit answer: Using the supplied map labels, describe the route from Gate A, turning right at the library and finishing at the art room. Use simple words and do not invent roads or gates not shown.
- Names the supplied start, turn landmark and destination in the route request.
- Explicitly limits the answer to shown map information instead of invented shortcuts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt review finds A: “Explain it” with no named input; B: “Write exactly two and exactly five sentences”; C: “Add the unknown ticket price by guessing.”
4A · Matching
Match each draft with its specific problem.
Complete or match: Draft A; Draft B; Draft C
- a: Unidentified input
- b: A verified current source
- c: Inventing an unsupported fact
- d: Conflicting instructions
Each draft fails in a different identifiable way.
4B · Open ended
Correct drafts A and C for an exhibition notice whose supplied facts contain the date and venue but no price.
Example of a full-credit answer: For A, say “Explain the supplied exhibition date and venue notice.” For C, say “If a ticket price is not stated, mark it as unknown and ask the organiser through the known route.”
- Replaces A’s vague input with the named supplied exhibition notice.
- Replaces C’s guessing instruction with an explicit unknown/verification instruction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reading club supplies a table with three meeting dates and rooms. A new member needs a short comparison of which meeting is earliest. The tool must use the table and must not add an unlisted meeting. The fictional table rows are 5 June: Room B2, 8 June: Room D4, and 11 June: Room C3, all in the same year.
5A · Dropdown selection
Match each design need with its prompt part.
Complete or match: Identify the evidence; Identify the decision; Prevent invented entries
- a: Find the earliest listed meeting
- b: Do not add unlisted meetings
- c: Use the supplied meeting table
- d: Choose a date without reading the table
The parts make the task, input and boundary visible for later checking.
5B · Open ended
Write a clear prompt meeting the task, then explain how a human could check the answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Using the supplied three-meeting table, identify the earliest meeting in plain words for a new member and do not add unlisted meetings. Check the chosen date and room against the table and compare all three dates.
- Provides the named input, earliest-meeting action and no-invention boundary.
- Describes checking the answer against all relevant dates and the corresponding room in the table.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.4 · Providing context in a prompt
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Space changes a plan
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class needs a book display. The approved space is one tabletop; the main walkway must stay clear.
Question: What context should accompany the planning request?
Answer: The one-table space and the clear-walkway condition.
Why: Those constraints directly affect which display arrangements are suitable.
Example 2 · Audience changes an explanation
Fictional classroom example
A fictional activity explains a map key to learners who have never used one. Their names are not needed.
Question: What audience context is useful?
Answer: The readers are beginners who need the symbols explained in simple words.
Why: Prior knowledge affects the explanation; identifying each learner adds nothing to this task.
Example 3 · Two versions
| Document | Status |
|---|---|
| Monday draft | Superseded |
| Wednesday notice | Approved current source |
Fictional classroom example
A fictional old draft lists a class visit on Monday. A later approved notice corrects it to Wednesday. Both are supplied with clear labels.
Question: How should the context identify the version to use?
Answer: Label the Wednesday notice as the approved current version and the Monday draft as superseded.
Why: The version labels prevent an old date from being treated as equally current.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · One resource changes the format
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a notice that every pupil can read tomorrow. The teacher’s facts say there is no working printer, but the class noticeboard already has a blank reusable writing surface. Pupil surnames are irrelevant.
F1 · Hotspot
Which context most directly rules out a newly printed handout tomorrow?
- a: Some pupils have long surnames
- b: There is no working printer
- c: A notice may have a title
- d: The class has discussed other topics
The unavailable printer is the relevant resource constraint.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Useful context without secrets
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for a simple explanation of a map legend for beginners. A draft suggests adding every pupil’s password to make the explanation personal.
F2 · True or false
True or false? The pupil passwords are needed to explain the map legend for beginners.
- true: True
- false: False
The audience’s prior knowledge is relevant; passwords are unnecessary and should not be shared.
Investigation: privacy lab
F3 · Choose the approved version
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source packet contains a cancelled rehearsal note for Room 1 and an approved updated note for Room 6. The request is to summarise the current rehearsal arrangement.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which context should the prompt identify as the source for the current room?
- a: A room from an unrelated old story
- b: The cancelled Room 1 note
- c: Any room the tool happens to suggest
- d: The approved Room 6 update
The packet explicitly identifies the updated approved arrangement.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · Choose only relevant planning context
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional display must fit a 90-centimetre table and use materials already supplied by the teacher. The group’s favourite snacks and private contact details do not change the task.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which details belong in the planning context?
- a: A claim that the tool knows the classroom without being told.
- b: The 90-centimetre table width.
- c: Every pupil’s private contact details.
- d: The limit to teacher-supplied materials.
Space and materials change what a feasible layout would be.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A plan that misses the reader
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional prompt asks “Explain our library rule” but omits that the readers are new members who do not know the term loan period. The supplied rule says books are borrowed for five days.
F5 · Short answer
Add the missing audience context and explain one feature the explanation should then include.
Example of a full-credit answer: State that the readers are new members unfamiliar with loan period. The explanation should define it as the time they may keep a borrowed book, while retaining the five-day rule.
- Adds the specific beginner/unfamiliar-term audience context.
- Explains the need to define the term while preserving the stated five-day condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club has twelve minutes to prepare a welcome display and only two tables. Plan A needs ten minutes and two tables; B needs twenty minutes and three tables; C needs fifteen minutes and one table; D needs ten minutes and four tables.
1A · Hotspot
Which plan fits both context limits?
- a: Plan C
- b: Plan A
- c: Plan B
- d: Plan D
Only A is within twelve minutes and uses no more than two tables.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the chosen plan fits and identify the two context details that made the choice possible.
Example of a full-credit answer: A fits because ten minutes is within twelve and two tables are available. The time limit and table count are the context needed to test feasibility.
- Uses the ten-versus-twelve-minute comparison correctly.
- Uses the two-table availability correctly and connects it to feasibility.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional request asks for a craft-session plan using two helpers, ten minutes and three supplied materials. A draft also includes an unrelated pupil’s home location. The location is not needed for the classroom task.
2A · Drag and drop
Match the context detail with its role.
Complete or match: Two helpers; Ten minutes; Unrelated home location
- a: Available people for the task
- b: Time limit
- c: Permission to ignore the material list
- d: Unnecessary private information
The first two details affect feasibility; the private location does not.
2B · Open ended
Explain why helper count and duration are useful context, and why the private location should be omitted.
Example of a full-credit answer: Helper count and duration determine what the group can do within its resources. The private location is unrelated to this classroom plan, so including it would expose information without helping the task.
- Connects helper count and duration to planning feasibility.
- Explains that the unrelated private location should be omitted because it is unnecessary.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional visitor group will hear a short announcement rather than read a screen. The required facts are the gallery name, closing time and staffed help desk. A proposal that relies only on coloured arrows will not communicate those spoken facts. The approved details are Orchid Gallery, closing at 4 p.m., with the staffed help desk at the gallery entrance.
3A · Matching
Match each context element with the response requirement.
Complete or match: Listeners hear the message; Closing time is required; Staffed help desk is required
- a: Name the help point
- b: Put essential information into spoken words
- c: Retain the stated time
- d: Rely entirely on an unseen colour
The listening context changes how essential information must be conveyed.
3B · Open ended
Describe the context you would add to a prompt and explain how it changes the suitable response.
Example of a full-credit answer: Say that visitors will hear, not read, the announcement: Orchid Gallery closes at 4 p.m., and its staffed help desk is at the entrance. The response must express these facts clearly in spoken words instead of depending on colour or a screen.
- Supplies the listening context and the Orchid Gallery, 4 p.m. closing, and entrance help-desk details.
- Explains why the output must communicate essential facts in words rather than visual-only cues.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil starts a new conversation with an AI tool and asks “Summarise the attached poster,” but no poster or poster text is supplied. The tool produces a confident description anyway.
4A · Multiple choice
What is the main problem with using the response as a summary?
- a: The tool was not given the poster content to summarise
- b: A detailed response always counts as a source record
- c: A new conversation automatically contains every earlier file
- d: The lack of an attachment proves the poster has no words
The response lacks the required input evidence even if it sounds confident.
4B · Open ended
Identify the context error and propose a safe repair.
Example of a full-credit answer: The request assumes that the tool has a poster that was never supplied. Provide the relevant permitted poster text or an approved non-private copy, or explain that the summary cannot be checked until the input is available.
- Identifies the absent poster/input rather than treating confidence as evidence.
- Proposes supplying permitted relevant content or withholding the unsupported summary until it can be checked.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher asks for a six-minute group task using four shared markers and one reusable board. It is for beginners. No names, contact details or personal histories are needed.
5A · Dropdown selection
Match each supplied need with the context to include.
Complete or match: Time available; Materials available; Prior knowledge
- a: Six minutes
- b: Private participant histories
- c: Beginner audience
- d: Four markers and one reusable board
The relevant context describes the task rather than identifying the participants.
5B · Open ended
Write a concise context block and explain one kind of information you intentionally leave out.
Example of a full-credit answer: For beginners, plan within six minutes using four shared markers and one reusable board. Leave out names and contact details because they do not affect the classroom task and are unnecessary personal information.
- Includes the beginner audience, six-minute limit and supplied resources.
- Names an unnecessary private detail to omit and explains its lack of relevance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.5 · Stating the desired output
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Compare like with like
| Hall | Opening time |
|---|---|
| Oak Hall | 8:00 |
| Pine Hall | 9:00 |
Fictional classroom example
A fictional record lists Oak Hall opening at 8:00 and Pine Hall opening at 9:00.
Question: What output instruction would make the times easy to compare?
Answer: Use a two-column table headed Hall and Opening time, with one row for each hall.
Why: The two headings and one-row-per-hall rule make the same feature visible for both places.
Example 2 · Keep a missing value visible
Fictional classroom example
A fictional seedling record says Seedling A is 12 centimetres tall. Seedling B has no recorded height.
Question: How should a prompt describe the missing height?
Answer: Use the columns Seedling and Height in centimetres; write not supplied for an unrecorded height.
Why: The unit makes the known number meaningful, and the missing-data label avoids inventing a measurement.
Example 3 · A short reminder with essential details
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice says the art club meets on Thursday in Room 4 and learners should bring a pencil.
Question: Specify a useful output for a small reminder card.
Answer: Write two short bullets for new art-club members. Keep Thursday, Room 4 and bring a pencil.
Why: A small format and the must-keep facts work together; the learner should still check the final card against the notice.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Specify a comparison table
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club record lists Red Team with 6 paper boats and Blue Team with 9 paper boats. The task is to compare the counts, using only this record.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which output instructions help meet this task?
- a: Keep the supplied counts of 6 and 9 unchanged.
- b: Replace missing details with guesses without marking them.
- c: Use columns Team and Number of paper boats.
- d: Add a private contact list for the teams.
The useful instructions organise the actual comparison and preserve the given counts.
Investigation: prompt lab
F2 · Repair an output request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A draft request says “Make a table of the supplied walking distances. Show the numbers. Guess absent distances.” The record uses metres, and one distance is not recorded.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each weakness with the relevant repair.
Complete or match: Unclear table headings; No rule for preserving values; Instruction to invent missing distances
- a: Round every distance up without being asked.
- b: Write not supplied for unrecorded values.
- c: Copy the supplied distances accurately.
- d: Name Route and Distance in metres.
Each repair addresses a different output requirement.
Investigation: revision lab
F3 · Choose a useful sequence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional seed-packet instruction has three steps: fill the pot, place the seed, then water gently. A beginner needs to follow the order.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which desired output best supports the task?
- a: Only the number of steps.
- b: The steps in reverse order.
- c: Three numbered steps in the supplied order.
- d: Unordered keywords without the actions.
The learner needs the actions and their order, not just a count or a group of words.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · Read the unit and missing-data rules
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional table specification requires the columns Plant and Height in centimetres. The record gives Fern: 14 centimetres and Moss: height not recorded. The response must use not supplied when a value is absent.
F4 · Matching
Match each output cell or heading with its required content.
Complete or match: Second column heading; Fern height cell; Moss height cell
- a: not supplied
- b: 14
- c: Height in centimetres
- d: 0 because no height was recorded.
The unit, known value and missing-data label have distinct roles.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A useful short announcement
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional visitor notice says: the model bridge display is in Hall B on Tuesday; visitors must enter through the side door. New visitors need a short spoken announcement.
F5 · Short answer
Specify a suitable length or format and name the facts that the output must keep.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use two short spoken sentences. Keep the model bridge display in Hall B on Tuesday and the instruction to enter through the side door.
- Specifies a short spoken format or comparably suitable format for listeners.
- Preserves Hall B, Tuesday and the side-door instruction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for a table with columns Item and Number needed. The supplied list says 4 paper sheets and 2 clips. No prices are supplied. Request A asks for Item and Number needed, using paper sheets: 4 and clips: 2. Request B asks for a story and changes the counts. Request C asks for a table of guessed prices. Request D asks for item names only.
1A · Hotspot
Select the request that meets the stated output specification.
- a: Request A
- b: Request D
- c: Request C
- d: Request B
A names the exact two fields and preserves both counts.
1B · Short answer
What two features make Request A fit this task?
Example of a full-credit answer: It asks for the two required columns, Item and Number needed, and keeps 4 paper sheets and 2 clips from the source.
- Identifies the required two-column structure.
- Uses the two correct item counts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional bus-display record lists Route Sun arriving at 10:00. Route Moon has no arrival time in the record. The requested table must not add facts.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match the table requirement with its example.
Complete or match: Known arrival value; Missing arrival value; Column names
- a: Route Moon: not supplied
- b: Route and Arrival time
- c: Route Sun: 10:00
- d: Route Moon: 10:30, guessed.
The label keeps the difference between a known time and an unknown time visible.
2B · Open ended
Explain why not supplied is better than a guessed arrival time and identify the later check needed.
Example of a full-credit answer: A guess could be mistaken for a real schedule. Keep not supplied until the responsible operator’s relevant timetable or notice provides a time.
- Explains that a guessed value would misrepresent unknown information as known.
- Proposes checking the relevant responsible timetable or notice before filling the value.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional materials record says Card A costs 3 classroom credits and can be folded once; Card B costs 5 classroom credits and can be folded twice. These are classroom tokens, not real prices. A group needs a compact comparison.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which requirements belong in this output request?
- a: Declare B longest-lasting without evidence.
- b: Keep the classroom-credit unit and stated fold limits.
- c: Hide A’s cost so B looks better.
- d: Use matching columns for the two materials.
A fair compact comparison keeps the same fields, units and supplied values for each material.
3B · Open ended
Propose the table headings and explain one fact-check you would apply to the finished table.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use Material, Cost in classroom credits and Fold limit. Check that A remains 3 credits and one fold and B remains 5 credits and two folds, with no unsupported durability claim.
- Names headings that allow the same two features to be compared for A and B.
- Describes at least one concrete source comparison, such as A’s 3-credit cost or B’s two-fold limit, without adding an unsupported claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source says the reading corner opens at 9:00 and closes at 11:00. A response correctly uses two bullet points, but its second bullet says the corner closes at 12:00.
4A · True or false
True or false? Because the response has the requested two bullets, it passes both the format and factual checks.
- true: True
- false: False
Two bullets satisfy the shape requirement, but 12:00 conflicts with the supplied closing time.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistake and give a check that prevents this kind of error.
Example of a full-credit answer: The response changes the closing time from 11:00 to 12:00. Compare each time with the source separately from checking that there are two bullets.
- Identifies the exact 11:00-to-12:00 factual error.
- Separates a source-based fact check from the format check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reading group needs a small comparison of two storybooks using only a supplied catalogue. The catalogue gives each title and page count, but does not give reading time. New readers should understand the table.
5A · Matching
Match each design step with its purpose.
Complete or match: Title and Page count columns; One row per book; No invented reading time
- a: Keep the output compact and consistent.
- b: Keep missing information honest.
- c: Assume every book takes the same time.
- d: Compare features actually recorded.
A good specification describes the finished form and protects the boundary of the evidence.
5B · Open ended
Write a short output specification and describe how you will check the finished response.
Example of a full-credit answer: Make a table for new readers with Title and Page count, one row per book, using only the catalogue. Do not invent reading times. Check every title and count against the catalogue and check the requested structure.
- Specifies an appropriate compact table using the supplied fields and a rule against invented reading time.
- Describes checking both source values and the requested output structure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.6 · Refining prompts
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A targeted vocabulary repair
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice says “The puzzle club will commence at 2:00 in Room 3.” New members do not know commence.
Question: What refinement would help?
Answer: Keep 2:00 and Room 3 unchanged. Replace commence with a familiar word such as start.
Why: The request fixes the identified reading difficulty while protecting the two useful facts.
Example 2 · Restore a missing action
Fictional classroom example
A fictional source says to label the envelope before placing it in the class tray. The draft says only “Place it in the tray.”
Question: How can the prompt be refined?
Answer: Include the instruction to label the envelope before placing it in the class tray, using the supplied order.
Why: The revision names the omitted action and the order needed to carry it out.
Example 3 · Check for a new error
Fictional classroom example
A fictional source gives a Friday meeting in Hall C. A revision adds Hall C but changes Friday to Saturday.
Question: Is the revision finished?
Answer: No. Hall C is restored, but Saturday must be corrected to Friday.
Why: Success on the requested repair does not excuse a newly introduced factual error.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match the problem to a repair
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source says a poster-making meeting is Tuesday in Room 5 and is for beginners. A draft says Wednesday, omits Room 5, and uses the word utilise.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each observed problem with its targeted instruction.
Complete or match: Wrong meeting day; Missing meeting place; Unfamiliar word utilise
- a: Change the meeting to an invented place.
- b: Use Tuesday from the source.
- c: Use a familiar word such as use.
- d: Include Room 5.
Each repair refers to an observed problem and the given task.
Investigation: revision lab
F2 · Keep what already works
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional draft correctly says “Library helpers meet Monday in Room 7.” The only requested change is to make the sentence friendlier for new helpers without changing its facts.
F2 · Matching
Match each part of a careful refinement with its purpose.
Complete or match: Keep Monday and Room 7; Make the welcome friendlier; Check the new sentence against the source
- a: Protect the correct facts.
- b: Look for accidental new errors.
- c: Change facts to make the sentence more exciting.
- d: Target the requested style change.
The repair has a target, a boundary and a review step.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Choose the most useful feedback
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source says fold the blue paper strip once. An AI draft says “Fold it,” and the reader does not know what it refers to.
F3 · Hotspot
Which refinement directly fixes the observed ambiguity?
- a: Name the blue paper strip and keep once.
- b: Add an invented second fold.
- c: Repeat try again without describing the problem.
- d: Make it sound impressive without naming the object.
The difficulty is the unnamed object; the source also supplies the number of folds to preserve.
Investigation: prompt lab
F4 · Inspect the revised version
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source says the model-boat display opens at 10:00 in Hall D. Draft 1 omits Hall D. Draft 2 adds Hall D but says 11:00.
F4 · Multiple choice
What should the learner do next?
- a: Accept Draft 2 because one problem was fixed.
- b: Remove both the time and place from every version.
- c: Change the source to match Draft 2.
- d: Keep Hall D, correct the time to 10:00, and recheck.
A successful place repair does not make the newly wrong time acceptable.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A useful second prompt
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for two short instructions for a seed display using only a supplied record. The AI returns two long paragraphs. The facts are correct, and both instructions are still required.
F5 · Short answer
Give a focused revision request and state what you would check afterwards.
Example of a full-credit answer: Rewrite the two paragraphs as two short numbered instructions while keeping both actions and the supplied facts. Then check that the length/format improved and no required action or fact was lost.
- Requests two short instructions while preserving both actions and source facts; numbering is acceptable but not required.
- Checks the improvement and the preservation of required information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class notice needs a date and a room. Its draft already has the correct date but omits the room from the source. A learner plans to ask only “Make it more exciting.” In this case the source says Friday in Room 6, while the draft says Friday and gives no room.
1A · True or false
True or false? Make it more exciting directly addresses the missing-room problem.
- true: True
- false: False
It does not say to restore the missing room; a targeted request should name that repair.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the proposed refinement is insufficient and write a better one.
Example of a full-credit answer: Making it exciting does not ask for the missing room. Ask the tool to add the room from the supplied source and keep the correct date unchanged.
- Identifies that the request does not target the omitted room.
- Provides a source-based room repair that protects the correct date.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message correctly says a drawing session lasts 15 minutes. The phrase “render your depiction” confuses beginners. Two suggestions are offered: A replaces that phrase with draw your picture and keeps 15 minutes; B changes the duration to 30 minutes and leaves the phrase.
2A · Multiple choice
Which suggestion should be accepted for the stated problem?
- a: Neither, because a draft can never be revised.
- b: Both, because every AI suggestion must be accepted.
- c: B, because changing any number is an improvement.
- d: A, because it simplifies the phrase and keeps the stated duration.
A repairs the language problem without inventing a new duration.
2B · Open ended
Justify the selected change and say why the other change should not be accepted.
Example of a full-credit answer: A replaces the difficult phrase with familiar wording while preserving 15 minutes. B invents 30 minutes, which is unsupported and does not fix the confusing phrase.
- Connects A to the specific language difficulty and preserved duration.
- Explains B’s unsupported time change and lack of relevance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum script must mention the clay bowl, say that visitors should stay behind the line, and use familiar words. The draft mentions the bowl but omits the line instruction and uses the word perambulate.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which changes address the stated problems?
- a: Remove the bowl even though the script must mention it.
- b: Invent permission to cross the line.
- c: Replace perambulate with a familiar word such as walk.
- d: Add the supplied stay-behind-the-line instruction.
The two useful changes restore a missing instruction and improve clarity while preserving the required object.
3B · Open ended
Write a revision request for this new format and explain how you would check it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Revise the spoken script to keep the clay bowl, include stay behind the line, and use walk instead of perambulate. Read it aloud and compare its facts and instruction with the supplied requirements.
- Includes the two needed repairs while preserving the clay bowl.
- Checks spoken clarity or ease of understanding, for example by reading aloud, and verifies the required information against the source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional source says a class has 18 cards. An AI response says 20. The learner keeps asking “Are you sure?” and accepts 20 because the response becomes more confident. No new evidence is provided.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each clue with what it means.
Complete or match: 18 in the source; Repeated confident 20; Compare with the record
- a: The supplied count to preserve.
- b: A repeated claim, not new evidence.
- c: The needed factual check.
- d: Confidence changes the source count.
Repeated confidence is not a substitute for consulting the supplied record.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error in the learner’s method and propose a useful next prompt or action.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats repeated confidence as evidence and ignores the record. Point to the supplied count of 18, request a correction using that record, and verify the revised answer against it.
- Explains why repetition or confidence does not verify the count.
- Uses the 18-card record in a targeted correction and subsequent check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group is making a poster from a notice. The poster must keep Saturday, Hall E and bring a notebook, and be easy for new members to read. The first draft is too wordy.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each step with its role in the refinement cycle.
Complete or match: Identify wordiness; Request three short bullets and keep the facts; Compare the revised poster with the notice
- a: Target the repair with boundaries.
- b: Check the result for old and new errors.
- c: Find the observed problem.
- d: Repeat until the answer sounds confident, without checking.
A useful cycle links a visible problem, a precise revision and an evidence check.
5B · Open ended
Propose the second prompt and a two-part check for the next draft.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use three short bullets with familiar words for new members. Keep Saturday, Hall E and bring a notebook from the notice. Check that the draft is shorter and readable, then verify that all three details remain correct.
- Provides a targeted prompt with the required facts protected.
- Checks both readability/length improvement and preservation of all three details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.7 · Comparing artificial intelligence responses
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A short answer can be complete
Fictional classroom example
A fictional task asks how many flags there are when one box has 7 and another has 5. Response A says 12 flags because 7 + 5 = 12. Response B gives a long story but says 14.
Question: Which response meets the task better?
Answer: Response A.
Why: Its calculation and unit agree with the supplied numbers; extra words do not repair B’s wrong total.
Example 2 · Correct but incomplete
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice says the story circle is Wednesday in Room 8. The task asks for both date and place. Response A gives Wednesday only; Response B gives Wednesday in Room 8.
Question: How should these responses be compared?
Answer: A has the correct day but omits the place. B includes both required facts correctly.
Why: Coverage and factual accuracy are distinct checks.
Example 3 · Three matching guesses
Fictional classroom example
Three generated replies say a fictional museum has 40 model boats. The actual supplied inventory lists 36.
Question: Does agreement among the replies establish 40?
Answer: No. The supplied inventory supports 36, and the generated replies need correction.
Why: Repeated generated claims are not independent checks of the inventory.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose by calculation and relevance
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for the total number of paper stars in two groups: 7 and 5. Reply A says 12 stars and shows 7 + 5 = 12. B says 14 stars. C says the stars are attractive but gives no total. D says 12 pencils.
F1 · Hotspot
Which reply meets the stated task?
- a: Reply C
- b: Reply A
- c: Reply B
- d: Reply D
A gives the correct total, calculation and item name.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Describe exact differences
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional notice says a craft meeting is Thursday in Room 6. Response A says Friday in Room 6. Response B says Thursday but omits the room. Response C says Thursday in Room 6.
F2 · Matching
Match each response with its specific finding.
Complete or match: Response A; Response B; Response C
- a: All three are equally complete and accurate.
- b: Omits the room.
- c: Contains the wrong day.
- d: Preserves both required details.
A precise comparison identifies the actual error or omission in each response.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Choose useful comparison criteria
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for a beginner-friendly explanation of a supplied map key, including all three symbols. The group must compare three prepared AI drafts. In the explorer, A covers all meanings clearly, B has clear wording but misses a meaning, and C covers all meanings but uses difficult wording. Its prepared ratings illustrate a checklist; they are not independent fact verification.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which criteria directly fit this comparison?
- a: Check all three meanings against the supplied map key.
- b: Check that the wording is understandable for the stated beginners.
- c: Prefer whichever draft is longest regardless of the task.
- d: Prefer whichever draft uses the most confident words regardless of accuracy.
The task requires correct symbol coverage and suitable wording; confidence and length alone do not show either.
Investigation: decision lab
F4 · Inspect agreement between generators
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional activity, three generated summaries repeat that a school display has 18 models. The original supplied inventory lists 16. The three replies do not show any independent inventory check.
F4 · Multiple choice
What is the sound next step?
- a: Accept 18 because three replies repeat it.
- b: Average 18 and 16 to invent a new inventory count.
- c: Ignore the inventory because it is less fluent.
- d: Check the inventory and correct the count to 16.
The inventory is the relevant supplied evidence; repeated unchecked replies do not verify 18.
Investigation: origin lab
F5 · Compare a complete and incomplete reply
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for both the location and start time of a model-train display. The notice says Hall F at 1:00. Reply A says Hall F at 1:00. Reply B says Hall F and adds a friendly welcome, but gives no start time.
F5 · Open ended
Which reply better meets the task, and what specific comparison supports your choice?
Example of a full-credit answer: A better meets the task because it includes both Hall F and 1:00 from the notice. B has the correct location but omits the required start time; friendliness does not supply that missing fact.
- Chooses A using the correct location and time from the notice.
- Identifies B’s missing required start time and separates it from style.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: verification lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for the day and material for a kite workshop. The source says Saturday and paper. Response A says Saturday and paper. B says Sunday and paper. C says Saturday only.
1A · Dropdown selection
Match each response with its precise comparison result.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: A fluent response cannot contain a factual error.
- b: Day matches; material is missing.
- c: Day is wrong; material matches.
- d: Day and material both match.
Using the same two requirements shows the differences clearly.
1B · Short answer
Name the best-fitting response and give the two source details that support your choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: A: it keeps Saturday and paper, the two details required by the task and supplied by the source.
- Selects A and uses the correct Saturday detail.
- Uses the required paper material as the second supporting detail.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional catalogue lists a storybook with 24 pages. A task asks for a simple one-sentence description using that count. Response A says “This storybook has 24 pages.” Response B says “Without any doubt, this extraordinary storybook has 42 pages.”
2A · Multiple choice
Which response should be preferred for this task?
- a: B, because without any doubt proves the count.
- b: Neither can be checked against a catalogue.
- c: B, because a longer sentence is always more accurate.
- d: A, because it is simple and keeps the catalogue count.
A meets the simple-sentence requirement and preserves 24 pages.
2B · Open ended
Explain why A is preferable and why confidence does not rescue B.
Example of a full-credit answer: A uses the catalogue’s 24 pages in a simple sentence. B’s confident wording supplies no evidence for 42 and contradicts the catalogue.
- Links A to both the given count and simple-sentence task.
- Explains why B’s confidence does not establish its unsupported count.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional chart records 2 newly completed models on Monday, 4 on Tuesday and 6 on Wednesday, with no model counted on more than one day. Summary A says the count rises by 2 each day. B says it stays constant. C says the three daily counts total 12.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each summary with its evidence check.
Complete or match: A: rises by 2 each day; B: stays constant; C: total is 12
- a: Conflicts with 2, 4 and 6.
- b: Every claim about the graph is an opinion.
- c: Matches both day-to-day changes.
- d: Matches 2 + 4 + 6.
Changes and totals can be checked directly against the supplied numbers.
3B · Open ended
Explain which summaries are supported and show the numerical checks you used.
Example of a full-credit answer: A is supported because 4 − 2 = 2 and 6 − 4 = 2. C is supported because 2 + 4 + 6 = 12. B is not supported because the counts differ.
- Checks the two increases and rejects the constant-count claim.
- Checks the total of 12 and identifies C as supported.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner asks two AI tools the same question about a notice. Both say the event is on Monday. The actual notice says Tuesday. The learner decides that two matching AI replies must outrank the notice.
4A · True or false
True or false? Two matching AI replies are enough to establish Monday despite the supplied Tuesday notice.
- true: True
- false: False
Agreement among unchecked generated replies is not verification of the event date.
4B · Open ended
Identify the reasoning error and explain the appropriate response to the disagreement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats agreement as proof without checking evidence. Consult the supplied organiser’s notice, retain Tuesday for this case and correct or reject the unsupported Monday replies.
- Identifies agreement without verification as the error.
- Uses the relevant notice to resolve this supplied disagreement and correct the replies.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class will compare two AI drafts of a visitor guide. The guide must use only a supplied room list, include the three named destinations and use familiar words. No opening times are provided. The three catalogue destinations are Map Room M2, Story Corner S1 and Art Gallery A4.
5A · Matching
Match each step with its role.
Complete or match: Use the same checklist for both drafts; Compare names with the room list; Leave unprovided opening times unknown
- a: Test factual accuracy.
- b: Choose by the number of confident adjectives.
- c: Avoid invented completeness.
- d: Make the comparison consistent.
A fair process uses task requirements and evidence, and keeps gaps visible.
5B · Open ended
Propose a comparison checklist and explain how you would decide if neither draft passes.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check each draft for all three destinations, correct room names, familiar wording and no invented opening times. If neither passes, revise the supported parts or write a new guide from the source, then check the new version again.
- Gives shared criteria covering required destinations, source accuracy, clear wording and missing times.
- Provides an evidence-based revise/reject decision with a fresh check of the resulting version.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.8 · Verifying generated information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Check a generated total
Fictional classroom example
A fictional activity has 4 packs containing 3 cards each. A generated answer says there are 15 cards.
Question: How should the total be checked?
Answer: Calculate 4 × 3 = 12 cards and correct 15 to 12.
Why: The supplied numbers and multiplication directly test the claim.
Example 2 · Check the right detail
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice says a display is in Room 9 on Thursday. A generated reply says Room 9 on Friday.
Question: Which parts pass and fail the check?
Answer: The room is correct. The day should be Thursday, not Friday.
Why: Verifying the room does not verify the day.
Example 3 · A citation that cannot be found
Fictional classroom example
A generated answer names a report, but the learner cannot find the report in the provided source collection.
Question: What can the learner honestly conclude?
Answer: The claim is not verified by that collection. Seek the original report or another relevant independent record before relying on it.
Why: A missing source does not establish either truth or falsity, and a citation label alone is not evidence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Check a simple generated calculation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional materials record says there are 4 trays with 3 paper models on each tray. A generated answer says there are 15 paper models.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which checked total should replace the generated claim?
- a: 12 paper models
- b: 4 paper models
- c: 15 paper models
- d: 7 paper models
Multiplying four groups by three models per group gives twelve models.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · Choose a check for each claim
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated visitor guide contains a meeting day, a total from 8 + 6, and a quotation from a supplied letter. The organiser’s notice, arithmetic and original letter are available.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each claim with the most direct check.
Complete or match: Meeting day; Total from 8 + 6; Quoted words from the letter
- a: Read the original letter in context.
- b: Recalculate the sum.
- c: Count how many AI replies repeat the sentence.
- d: Read the organiser’s relevant notice.
Different types of claim require evidence that directly addresses them.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Separate verified, contradicted and unknown
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional supplied record says there are 6 red tokens and 8 blue tokens. It gives no information about green tokens. Generated claims say A: red and blue total 14; B: red and blue total 16; C: there are 5 green tokens.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Match each generated claim with its status in this case.
Complete or match: A: 14 red and blue tokens in total; B: 16 red and blue tokens in total; C: 5 green tokens
- a: Contradicted by the supplied counts.
- b: Not established by this record.
- c: All absent details must be false.
- d: Supported by the supplied counts.
A missing green count is an evidence gap, while the red-and-blue totals can be calculated.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Inspect a result before relying on it
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI answer says a model-aircraft display opens at 2:00. A prepared search collection includes the responsible organiser’s notice saying 1:00, an unrelated concert listing, a copied unsupported 2:00 claim and a personal guess.
F4 · Hotspot
Which record most directly checks this event’s opening time?
- a: A personal guess about after lunch.
- b: A copied AI claim with no original record.
- c: The responsible organiser’s model-aircraft display notice.
- d: An unrelated concert listing.
The relevant organiser’s notice addresses the same display and gives 1:00; read it rather than relying on repeated claims.
Investigation: search results lab
F5 · Verify before sending a reminder
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional organiser’s notice says the cardboard-boat activity is on Friday in Room 1. A generated reminder says Thursday in Room 1. The learner plans to send the reminder to the class.
F5 · Short answer
Identify the correction and explain what comparison supports it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Change Thursday to Friday. Comparing the generated reminder with the organiser’s notice shows Friday in Room 1, so the room stays the same and the day changes.
- Corrects the day to Friday while preserving Room 1.
- Uses the organiser’s notice as the evidence for the correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class guide says the exhibition is Saturday, there are 3 tables with 4 models each, and the organiser wrote “Please use the side entrance.” The original notice and letter are supplied.
1A · Matching
Match the check with the detail it verifies.
Complete or match: Read Saturday in the notice; Calculate 3 × 4 = 12; Compare the original letter wording
- a: Exhibition day.
- b: Total number of models.
- c: Fluent wording verifies every detail.
- d: Quoted entrance instruction.
These checks address the individual date, calculation and quotation.
1B · Short answer
State the checked total with its calculation and name the source for the day.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are 12 models because 3 × 4 = 12. The organiser’s relevant notice supplies Saturday.
- Gives 12 models with the correct multiplication.
- Identifies the organiser’s notice as the source for Saturday.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated answer claims “Brook Town planted 300 trees this year” and cites the report Pine Town Tree Count. The supplied report’s relevant passage says “Pine Town planted 80 trees last year.” It contains no Brook Town planting record and no count for this year.
2A · True or false
True or false? The presence of a report title guarantees that the generated claim is supported by that report.
- true: True
- false: False
A citation must be opened and checked for the exact claim, population, place and conditions.
2B · Open ended
Explain why this citation does not verify the claim and what evidence is still needed.
Example of a full-credit answer: The opened report concerns a different town and does not state the claim. Find a relevant original record or independent evidence about the exact town and claim before treating it as verified.
- Identifies the source-scope and claim mismatch.
- Requests evidence that actually addresses the same place and claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom shop uses play credits. The supplied list says 3 credits per notebook and 2 credits per pencil. A generated answer says two notebooks and one pencil cost 10 credits.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which checks are appropriate for this claim?
- a: Keep the notebook and pencil quantities attached to the calculation.
- b: Accept 10 because the generated answer uses a currency-like word.
- c: Calculate 2 × 3 + 2 using the supplied play-credit prices.
- d: Replace the supplied prices with guessed real shop prices.
The source prices, quantities and unit determine the result in this fictional case.
3B · Short answer
Give the corrected total and show how the quantities and prices produce it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The total is 8 play credits: two notebooks cost 2 × 3 = 6, and one pencil adds 2.
- Calculates the notebook subtotal of 6 from the stated quantity and price.
- Adds the pencil’s 2 to obtain 8 play credits with the correct unit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated explanation gives a report title and a link ending in report-missing. The prepared collection contains no such report, and the supplied link has no original text available. No independent check has been found.
4A · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is justified by the available checks?
- a: The claim is certainly false solely because this collection lacks it.
- b: The claim is unverified; seek a relevant original or independent source.
- c: The claim is certainly true because a link was written.
- d: A copied claim verifies the missing report.
The missing original leaves an evidence gap; it does not establish either truth or falsity.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error in trusting the citation automatically and propose a responsible next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: A report title or unavailable link is not the report’s evidence. Mark the claim unverified, seek an accessible relevant original or independent source, and avoid presenting it as a checked fact meanwhile.
- Explains why the citation label or unavailable link does not verify the claim.
- Proposes an appropriate search/check and a clear unverified status while evidence is missing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group will publish a guide made with AI. It contains a room, an event date, a total number of displays and one claim whose source cannot be found. The original room list, organiser’s notice and display counts are available. Plan A checks each detail against its appropriate record, recalculates the total and marks the unsupported claim unverified. Plan B checks spelling only. Plan C asks the same AI to repeat its answer without consulting records. Plan D publishes without a source review.
5A · Hotspot
Which plan addresses all the stated verification needs?
- a: Plan D
- b: Plan A
- c: Plan C
- d: Plan B
A uses appropriate evidence, recalculates and keeps the unresolved claim visible.
5B · Open ended
Propose a brief verification record for the guide and explain what to do with the unsupported claim before publishing.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record each claim, the relevant source or calculation, the result of the check and any gap. Use the room list, event notice and display counts. Remove the unsupported claim or label it unverified and seek evidence before presenting it as a fact.
- Proposes a claim-by-claim record linking the available sources/calculation to check results.
- Handles the unsupported claim honestly before publication and identifies the need for further evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.9 · Tracing claims to original sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A three-step trail
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class post says 28 books were collected. It cites a newsletter, and the newsletter cites the signed collection sheet showing 28.
Question: Where does the count originate in this trail?
Answer: The signed collection sheet.
Why: The post and newsletter repeat the count; the collection sheet is the original supplied record.
Example 2 · The source says less
Fictional classroom example
A fictional report counts 12 bicycles outside one library at 9:00. A post says the whole town has only 12 bicycles.
Question: Does the original report support the post?
Answer: No. It describes bicycles at one library at one time, not every bicycle in the town.
Why: Tracing the claim reveals a change in place and scope.
Example 3 · Copies are not extra surveys
Fictional classroom example
Three fictional posts all cite Survey A. A fourth article cites a separately collected Survey B.
Question: How many declared survey origins are represented?
Answer: Two: Survey A and Survey B.
Why: The three copies of A do not become three independent surveys; both surveys still need evaluation.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose useful tracing steps
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI answer claims that a club collected 32 bottle caps and names a club report. The learner has not opened the report.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions help trace and check this claim?
- a: Treat the report title alone as proof of 32.
- b: Invent a page number if the report is unavailable.
- c: Check who counted the caps and which collection the report covers.
- d: Open the named report and locate the actual count.
Useful tracing reaches the actual evidence and examines the exact count and scope.
Investigation: prompt lab
F2 · Follow the chain
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class post copies a school newsletter. The newsletter cites a reading-club inventory sheet. The inventory sheet records 21 books, and both later texts repeat 21.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each record with its role in this trail.
Complete or match: Class post; School newsletter; Inventory sheet
- a: Points to the inventory sheet.
- b: Repeats the newsletter.
- c: Contains the original supplied count.
- d: An extra repost creates a new count.
The original count is on the inventory sheet, while the other records pass it along.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Separate repeated and independent origins
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional collection, Articles A and B both repeat Survey Cedar. Article C reports Survey Pine, which a different team collected separately. Both surveys need their methods checked.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Match each article with its origin relationship.
Complete or match: Article A; Article B; Article C
- a: Separately collected Survey Pine.
- b: Three articles automatically mean three separate surveys.
- c: First listed copy of Survey Cedar.
- d: Another copy of the same Survey Cedar.
Two copies of Cedar plus a separate Pine survey give two declared survey origins.
Investigation: origin lab
F4 · Inspect the original report’s boundaries
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional original report counted 9 kites in School A’s playground at noon on its observation day. It did not count other schools or other times.
F4 · Matching
Match each boundary with the detail supplied.
Complete or match: Observed place; Observed time; Observed count
- a: Every kite in the whole country.
- b: School A’s playground
- c: Noon on the observation day
- d: 9 kites
These details define the claim that the original observation can support.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · Recover the omitted words
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional original note says “We will hold the game outside if the teacher approves the weather conditions.” A repost quotes only “We will hold the game outside.”
F5 · Short answer
What important condition was lost, and how would tracing the original help correct the claim?
Example of a full-credit answer: The repost omits the condition that the teacher must approve the weather conditions. Reading the original note restores that condition, so the outside plan is not presented as unconditional.
- Identifies the teacher/weather approval condition.
- Explains that reading and restoring the original context corrects the unconditional claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: clip lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post says a display contains 27 models. It links to a newsletter, which names the display inventory. The supplied inventory records 25 models. A separate advertisement says many amazing models without a count.
1A · Hotspot
Which supplied record should be opened to inspect the original model count?
- a: The number of people who liked the post.
- b: The advertisement’s adjective amazing.
- c: The display inventory.
- d: The repost with 27 alone.
The inventory is the original count record identified by the trail and records 25.
1B · Short answer
Name the original count and explain why the post’s number needs correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The inventory records 25 models. The post’s 27 conflicts with that original supplied count, so the repost should be corrected using the inventory.
- Gives 25 models from the inventory.
- Connects the correction of 27 to the original record rather than popularity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional archive contains an authentic Year 1 bus timetable. The task asks about a Year 2 school trip, and the organiser has issued a new Year 2 timetable. The old and new departure times differ.
2A · True or false
True or false? Because the Year 1 timetable is an original record, it automatically establishes the departure time for the Year 2 trip.
- true: True
- false: False
Originality does not remove the need to check the relevant date and journey.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the old source is insufficient and name the record that should be checked for this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: The Year 1 timetable describes a different period and its time has changed. Check the organiser’s Year 2 timetable for the Year 2 trip and its exact departure details.
- Explains the mismatch between the old period and the Year 2 task.
- Selects the relevant Year 2 organiser timetable and checks its departure details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class post labels a picture “today’s empty garden.” The supplied original record says it was made by the school media club last term, before planting. An edit history shows the original caption was removed.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match the tracing detail with what it establishes.
Complete or match: School media club; Last term, before planting; Removed original caption
- a: A new upload date proves a new image was taken.
- b: Original image context.
- c: Edit that hid relevant context.
- d: Declared original creator.
Creator, original context and edit history help identify the unsupported today claim.
3B · Short answer
Explain why today’s empty garden is not supported by this image record.
Example of a full-credit answer: The original picture is from last term before planting, and the repost removed that context. A new upload and caption do not establish the garden’s condition today.
- Uses the original last-term/before-planting context.
- Explains why reposting or recaptioning does not establish a current condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says two articles independently confirm a quotation. On opening their links, both articles turn out to copy the same interview transcript; neither conducted a new interview.
4A · Multiple choice
What is the accurate description of this evidence trail?
- a: Two articles repeat one interview origin.
- b: The quotation is necessarily false because it was repeated.
- c: Every copied quotation becomes a new observation.
- d: The two articles establish two independent interviews.
The articles share an origin; repetition alone proves neither independence nor falsity.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error in the independence claim and describe a useful next check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both articles copy one interview, so they are not two independently collected interview records. Read the original transcript and context; if independent confirmation is needed, seek separate relevant evidence.
- Recognises the shared origin and rejects the two-independent-interviews claim.
- Proposes reading the original context and seeking genuinely separate evidence when needed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group is preparing a fact card using an AI-generated claim. They need to record where the claim originated, what passage supports it, and whether the source covers the same people and date. An unavailable source must stay marked unverified.
5A · Matching
Match each record field with its checking purpose.
Complete or match: Creator, title and original record location; Relevant passage and surrounding context; People, place, date and conditions
- a: Identify and reach the source.
- b: Check whether the claim fits the source’s scope.
- c: Check what the source actually says.
- d: Mark every cited claim true without opening it.
A useful trace record makes origin, support and scope visible.
5B · Open ended
Propose a source-tracing record and explain how to handle a trail that ends at an unavailable report.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record the claim, original creator/title/location, relevant passage and context, and the people/place/date/conditions covered. If the report cannot be accessed, mark the claim unverified and seek an accessible relevant original or separate evidence rather than inventing support.
- Includes origin, actual supporting passage/context and scope in the record.
- Handles an unavailable source with an honest unverified status and an appropriate further check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL3.10 · Using artificial intelligence without surrendering human judgement
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A suggestion meets a new constraint
Fictional classroom example
A fictional AI plan uses the school stage. The teacher says the stage is unavailable for repair.
Question: What should the group do?
Answer: Check the current room options with the teacher and choose or revise a feasible plan.
Why: The AI suggestion does not override the actual availability constraint.
Example 2 · A score leaves something out
Fictional classroom example
A fictional model ranks three displays using only setup speed. One fast display has labels too small for the intended visitors.
Question: Is the fastest display automatically best?
Answer: No. The group should also check readability and participation needs before choosing.
Why: The model’s score covers only its chosen criterion, not every requirement.
Example 3 · Responsibility after an error
Fictional classroom example
A fictional group publishes an incorrect time copied from an AI answer. The organiser’s notice had the correct time.
Question: What is a responsible response?
Answer: Check the notice, correct the published time and improve the review process.
Why: The group’s responsibility to check and correct remains even when a tool supplied the draft.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Separate tool support from human responsibility
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group asks AI for three exhibition layouts. The teacher knows the room’s safe-use rules, and the group can check labels against the source materials. The final arrangement needs the teacher’s approval.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each role with its task in this case.
Complete or match: AI tool; Student group; Teacher
- a: The AI suggestion removes the need for every human check.
- b: Check label facts against the sources.
- c: Suggest possible layouts.
- d: Check room rules and approve the arrangement.
The tool supports the work while people retain the relevant checking and approval roles.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · A quick decision still needs a check
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI tool instantly recommends using the library for a club event. The teacher’s current room list says the library is already booked. No other room has yet been checked.
F2 · True or false
True or false? The speed of the AI recommendation means the group can ignore the current booking record.
- true: True
- false: False
Speed does not make an unavailable room available or replace checking the record.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Match a concern to a human action
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI plan suggests small printed labels, an outdoor table and a photograph of pupils. The actual case says one visitor needs large text, the yard is closed, and no permission to publish the photograph has been given.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each concern with an appropriate action.
Complete or match: Visitor needs large text; Yard is closed; No photo publication permission
- a: Choose a permitted alternative instead of publishing the pupil photo.
- b: The AI recommendation cancels every stated constraint.
- c: Provide readable larger labels.
- d: Use a permitted available space.
Human review must account for actual access, availability and permission limits.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · Choose responsible uses of advice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group receives an AI ranking of class project ideas. The ranking uses speed and cost, but the task also requires every learner to participate. The teacher can help review access concerns.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions retain human judgement?
- a: Treat the top score as permission to ignore access needs.
- b: Inspect which criteria the ranking includes and omits.
- c: Ask the teacher and learners to review participation barriers before choosing.
- d: Claim the AI is responsible so the group need not review the plan.
The given ranking omits a stated requirement, so people must examine participation before deciding.
Investigation: decision lab
F5 · A private detail is requested
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI suggestion says a class should collect everyone’s home address to choose a poster layout. The layout task only needs the display size and audience. No home addresses are needed.
F5 · Short answer
What should the group refuse to provide, and what information is sufficient for the layout task?
Example of a full-credit answer: Do not provide classmates’ home addresses. Use the display size and the intended audience, and ask the teacher if any additional information is genuinely necessary.
- Rejects the unnecessary private home-address collection.
- Identifies display size and audience as sufficient task context, with responsible adult review if needed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: privacy lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional decision model compares three display ideas using setup speed and cost only. A has the highest model score. The real task also requires readable labels for every visitor, which the model has not assessed.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each detail with its meaning.
Complete or match: A has the highest declared score; Readability was not assessed; Review labels with intended visitors
- a: A high score guarantees every visitor can read the labels.
- b: A ranks first on the two model criteria.
- c: A real task requirement is still unchecked.
- d: A needed human check before the final choice.
The model supports a limited comparison, while the omitted requirement remains to be checked.
1B · Open ended
Explain what A’s high score does establish and what the group must still check.
Example of a full-credit answer: It ranks A first for the specified speed and cost scores. It does not establish readability; the group should inspect the labels with the intended visitors or appropriate access support before making the final choice.
- Limits the score’s meaning to the stated speed/cost criteria.
- Identifies the omitted readability requirement and a relevant human check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI tool recommends excluding a learner from a story-display team because it found spelling errors in a draft. The task values ideas and teamwork, and the teacher can review drafts and support needs. Response A asks the teacher to review ideas, teamwork evidence and support needs before deciding. Response B automatically excludes the learner based on spelling. Response C publicly exposes the learner’s draft errors to embarrass them. Response D says nobody is responsible because the tool recommended it.
2A · Hotspot
Which response best uses human judgement in this case?
- a: Response C
- b: Response A
- c: Response B
- d: Response D
A asks the responsible teacher to consider evidence relevant to the actual task and any needed support.
2B · Open ended
Justify the review route and explain why spelling alone is insufficient for this decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: The task concerns ideas and teamwork, so spelling errors alone do not measure all the relevant abilities. The teacher should hear the learner’s evidence, check support needs and make a reasoned, reviewable decision.
- Explains the mismatch between spelling alone and the stated task goals.
- Includes a responsible human review of relevant evidence and support needs.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI plan schedules an activity in the courtyard. The teacher’s latest notice closes the courtyard for repairs and offers Hall G as an approved alternative. The AI plan was drafted before that notice.
3A · Multiple choice
What should the group do?
- a: Use the closed courtyard because the AI wrote it first.
- b: Review and adapt the plan for the teacher-approved Hall G.
- c: Treat the earlier plan as proof that repairs do not exist.
- d: Let the AI draft cancel the teacher’s closure notice.
The current real-world restriction and approved alternative must guide the plan.
3B · Open ended
Explain how the changed context affects the decision and name a check before using Hall G.
Example of a full-credit answer: The courtyard closure makes the earlier location unsuitable. Adapt the activity to Hall G and check its available space and the teacher’s conditions before using it.
- Uses the current closure notice to revise the outdated location choice.
- Checks Hall G’s practical fit and relevant teacher conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team publishes an AI-written guide with a wrong event day. The organiser’s notice had the correct day, but nobody checked it. A teammate says “The AI wrote it, so we do not need to correct it.”
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions respond responsibly?
- a: Correct the guide using the organiser’s notice.
- b: Add a human source check before the next publication.
- c: Leave the error because AI-generated text cannot be edited.
- d: Claim tool involvement removes every human responsibility.
People using and publishing the guide should correct the error and improve their checking process.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error in the teammate’s reasoning and propose an immediate correction plus a future safeguard.
Example of a full-credit answer: Using AI does not remove the team’s responsibility for what it publishes. Correct the event day from the notice now and require a human check of dates and other important facts before future publication.
- Explains why tool involvement does not remove the team’s responsibility.
- Gives both the immediate source-based correction and a relevant future checking step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group will use AI to suggest three class-display plans. Their requirements are accurate facts, readable labels, permitted images and a setup that fits the available room. A teacher is available to review concerns.
5A · Matching
Match each part of the process with its purpose.
Complete or match: Source checks; Readability and image-permission checks; Room check and teacher review
- a: Keep the display facts accurate.
- b: Make a feasible, accountable choice.
- c: Respect access needs and allowed use.
- d: Approve a plan solely because an AI ranked it first.
A responsible process joins evidence, people’s needs, permission and real-world feasibility.
5B · Open ended
Propose a process for choosing a plan and explain who remains responsible if a problem is found.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use AI suggestions as options, then compare facts with sources, check readable labels and image permission, and confirm the room fit with the teacher. Record the reason for the choice and a way to raise concerns. The group and responsible teacher must review and correct problems; the tool’s ranking does not remove that responsibility.
- Includes evidence, readability, permission and feasibility checks before choosing.
- Identifies human responsibility, reasons and a review/correction route if a problem appears.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.1 · Identifying the author or creator
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A garden article
Fictional classroom example
A classroom newsletter says “Written by Lira; published by Seed Club.” Jun forwards it to a class group.
Question: Who is the named writer, and who shared it?
Answer: Lira is the writer; Jun shared it.
Why: The roles are stated separately. The newsletter’s publisher is Seed Club, which is a third role.
Example 2 · Two parts of a poster
Fictional classroom example
A fictional poster credits “Photograph: Noel. Caption: Bea.” Both appear below the image.
Question: Should the whole poster be credited only to Bea?
Answer: No. Noel made the photograph and Bea wrote the caption.
Why: Combining media can involve more than one creator. Retaining both roles avoids losing part of the credit.
Example 3 · An incomplete screenshot
Fictional classroom example
A screenshot shows a paragraph and a school badge but cuts off the byline. The full page is unavailable in this example.
Question: Can the badge identify the paragraph’s writer?
Answer: No. The writer remains unconfirmed.
Why: A badge can identify a publisher or copied design. It is not a substitute for a byline or original production record.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Writer, publisher and sharer
Fixed fictional classroom case
An invented page lists “Text by Joel; publisher: Brook Magazine.” Mira shares its link without changing the text.
F1 · Multiple choice
Who is credited with writing the text?
- a: An unnamed reader
- b: Joel
- c: Brook Magazine
- d: Mira
The page explicitly credits Joel for the text; forwarding and publishing are different roles.
Investigation: provenance lab
F2 · The coding-club page
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional page says “Words: Rhea; photograph: Ada; published by Coding Club.” The three labels describe different contributions.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Match each contribution to its named contributor.
Complete or match: Text writer; Photographer; Publisher
- a: Coding Club
- b: Rhea
- c: A reader who liked it
- d: Ada
The explicit contribution labels make these three roles distinct.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A familiar display name
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional account uses the display name “River Artist.” The original file and the account owner’s identity have not been checked.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The display name alone establishes the account owner’s real identity.
- true: True
- false: False
A nickname is an account label, not independent proof of a real person’s identity.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A revised story
Fixed fictional classroom case
The classroom version history says “Original story: Mara, Monday. Spelling edits: Peter, Tuesday. Site publisher: Lantern Club.” No new story events were added.
F4 · Matching
Match each named role in this history.
Complete or match: Original story writer; Spelling editor; Site publisher
- a: An unnamed commenter
- b: Mara
- c: Peter
- d: Lantern Club
The history names different contributions; a later edit does not erase the original writer.
Investigation: provenance lab
F5 · A copied walking guide
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional town blog reprints a walking guide with the note “Adapted from Paths Group; shortened by Kian.” Paths Group’s original record is available, but no individual group writer is named.
F5 · Open ended
Identify the original credited creator and the later contributor, then state one authorship detail still unknown.
Example of a full-credit answer: Paths Group is the original credited creator, and Kian shortened the copy. The individual writer within Paths Group is not identified.
- Correctly separates Paths Group’s original role from Kian’s shortening contribution.
- States that the individual group writer remains unknown rather than inventing a name.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: origin lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
An invented museum card says “Drawing: Inez; description: Museum Learning Team.” A volunteer posts a photo of the card. The facts in the description have not been checked in this case.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Use only the stated credits.
- a: The credits prove every descriptive claim is true.
- b: The Learning Team is credited for the description.
- c: The volunteer is credited as the drawing’s creator.
- d: Inez is credited for the drawing.
Credits identify contributions, not the truth of every accompanying statement.
1B · Short answer
Explain how the drawing and description should be credited, and why the volunteer’s post does not establish the description’s accuracy.
Example of a full-credit answer: Credit Inez for the drawing and the Museum Learning Team for the description. The volunteer shared the card; neither sharing nor a named creator replaces checking the description’s evidence.
- Assigns both creative contributions to the correct named creators.
- Separates authorship/sharing evidence from evidence that the description is accurate.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poem is reposted on four pages. Record A is its original publication with a named byline and dated archive entry. B lists its latest sharer. C counts likes. D guesses the writer from sentence length.
2A · Hotspot
Which record most directly identifies the poem’s credited writer?
- a: C: number of likes
- b: B: latest sharing account
- c: D: sentence-length guess
- d: A: original byline and archive
The original credited record directly concerns authorship; the other clues do not establish it.
2B · Open ended
Choose a record and explain why it is stronger than the sharing record; state one limit of what it proves.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because it gives the writer credited on the original publication, while B names a sharer. A byline alone may not verify a legal identity or prove the poem’s factual claims.
- Justifies A using original authorship credit and contrasts it with sharing.
- States a valid limit such as unverified real identity or no guarantee of factual accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A classroom audio story lists “Script: Dina; voice: Omri; editing: Paz.” These are the only three production roles in the supplied record.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each creator beside the correct audio contribution.
Complete or match: Words of the script; Spoken performance; Editing the recording
- a: The audience
- b: Paz
- c: Omri
- d: Dina
An audio item can combine writing, performance and editing by different people.
3B · Open ended
Explain why this story has more than one credited contributor, and propose one way a repost can preserve those roles.
Example of a full-credit answer: Dina wrote, Omri performed and Paz edited, so one name would omit contributions. The repost can retain a labelled credits panel or a link to the full original credits.
- Explains at least two distinct contributions with the correct names.
- Proposes a practical way to preserve the role-based credits when reposting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class page states “Edited by Sol; AI helped draft.” Its table contains 4 red tokens and 3 blue tokens, but the text says there are 9 tokens. A learner says the editor’s name makes 9 correct.
4A · Multiple choice
Which correction addresses the learner’s error?
- a: A byline replaces the need to read the table.
- b: An editor’s name makes 4 + 3 equal 9.
- c: A named editor does not change 4 + 3 = 7.
- d: AI assistance makes totals impossible to check.
The named human contribution does not remove the numerical mismatch.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken use of the editor credit, then give the corrected total using the table.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats an editor’s name as proof of accuracy. The table gives 4 + 3 = 7 tokens, so the text’s 9 needs correction.
- Explains that a named editor or AI disclosure does not prove a statement is accurate.
- Uses 4 + 3 to correct the total to 7 tokens.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A class will publish a fictional map with a separate photo and a revised caption. Its credit form must record who made each part, where the originals can be found, and what changed. Unconfirmed names must not be guessed.
5A · True or false
True or false? A form that preserves role labels and source locations is more traceable than one that lists only the latest sharer.
- true: True
- false: False
Role labels and original-source locations let readers follow separate contributions.
5B · Open ended
Propose a credit form that meets the three requirements, and explain what it should do when a creator is unconfirmed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use rows for map, photo and caption, with columns for creator/role, original source and changes. Mark an unknown creator as unconfirmed and look for the original record rather than guessing.
- Proposes a form recording contributors by part, original sources and changes.
- Provides an honest procedure for unconfirmed names without inventing identity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.2 · Identifying the intended audience
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A reminder for registered teams
Fictional classroom example
A fictional message says “Team captains: confirm your players by Friday using your team code.”
Question: Which audience is most directly addressed?
Answer: Captains of teams that already have a code.
Why: The role label and existing team code are stronger clues than a general sports picture.
Example 2 · Two museum pages
Fictional classroom example
One invented page defines “fossil” and suggests a first visit. Another lists specimen catalogue codes for researchers.
Question: Which version is aimed more directly at a beginner?
Answer: The first-visit page.
Why: It explains a term and anticipates a newcomer’s needs; the catalogue assumes specialist work.
Example 3 · Who saw the poster?
Fictional classroom example
A fictional repair workshop poster addresses adult volunteers, but a child sees it in a shared hallway.
Question: Did seeing it make the child its intended audience?
Answer: No. The intended role remains adult volunteer.
Why: Actual exposure can extend beyond the people a creator especially meant to address.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Actual reader and intended reader
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message begins “Caregivers: collect the activity pack after class.” A pupil reads it on the classroom display.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The pupil reading the first notice changes its intended audience from caregivers to pupils.
- true: True
- false: False
The explicit address still names caregivers; actual readers may differ.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Three versions of a garden notice
Fixed fictional classroom case
The fictional garden project provides A: “New visitors: follow the blue signs to the entrance.” B: “Watering volunteers: collect your assigned cans.” C: “Team leaders: check the final duty list.”
F2 · Dropdown selection
Match the reader’s role to its directly addressed version.
Complete or match: New visitor; Watering volunteer; Team leader
- a: All versions contain the same instruction
- b: Version B
- c: Version A
- d: Version C
The versions identify different readers and different required actions.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A beginner’s puzzle guide
Fixed fictional classroom case
Four fictional guide labels are supplied: A defines each symbol before the first puzzle; B lists advanced tournament scores; C records software update codes; D gives the organiser’s payment totals.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which guide most directly meets a first-time puzzler’s need to learn the symbols?
- a: C: software version update codes
- b: B: advanced tournament score records
- c: A: symbol definitions and a first example
- d: D: organiser payment totals
Only A teaches the symbols needed before beginning.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · Match the invitation details
Fixed fictional classroom case
An invented art event has three readers. Visitors need opening hours; stall holders need setup time; performers need rehearsal time. The official plan lists opening 10 a.m., setup 8 a.m. and rehearsal 9 a.m.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each time beside the reader who needs that event stage.
Complete or match: Stall holders setting up; Performers rehearsing; Visitors entering
- a: 9 a.m.
- b: 8 a.m.
- c: 7 p.m.
- d: 10 a.m.
The same event has different relevant information for each audience.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A caption is an access feature
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional animation introduces recycling symbols. It has captions, a spoken explanation and a labelled diagram. The page does not state an age group.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why captions alone do not establish the intended age group, and name one additional clue you would seek.
Example of a full-credit answer: Captions improve access for many viewers and do not reveal age by themselves. I would seek an explicit audience label, expected knowledge or the full introduction.
- Explains that an access feature such as captions is not proof of a particular age audience.
- Identifies a useful further clue about intended readers, such as a role label or expected knowledge.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: accessibility lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional robotics club asks a first-time member to find the room and bring only paper. Version A lists room 4, a map and “paper only.” B lists expert coding abbreviations. C gives last year’s scores. D gives sponsors’ prices.
1A · Hotspot
Which version directly meets the new member’s stated needs?
- a: C: last year’s competition scores
- b: B: unexplained coding abbreviations
- c: A: room, directions and what to bring
- d: D: sponsor product price list
A includes the practical first-visit information in the case.
1B · Open ended
Choose the version and use two specific audience needs to justify your choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because the new member needs to find room 4 and know to bring only paper. Its directions help a first visit.
- Chooses A and explains that its room/directions meet the navigation need.
- Explains that its bring-paper instruction meets the preparation need.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional cleanup has a public invitation and a volunteer briefing. The invitation gives date and meeting place. The briefing gives assigned areas and a named adult supervisor. Volunteers need both arrival information and their job information.
2A · Drag and drop
Match the stated need to the information that answers it.
Complete or match: Knowing when to arrive; Knowing where to work; Knowing whom to ask
- a: Number of likes on last year’s photo
- b: Assigned area
- c: Current event date
- d: Named adult supervisor
The briefing adds task-specific information rather than replacing the arrival facts.
2B · Open ended
Explain why volunteers need the briefing as well as the invitation, and identify one fact that should agree across both.
Example of a full-credit answer: The briefing adds assigned areas and the adult supervisor that volunteers need to do their jobs. The event date or meeting place should agree so the versions do not send helpers to different arrangements.
- Explains a volunteer-specific need supplied by the briefing.
- Identifies a shared factual detail that should remain consistent across versions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional library wants the same borrowing rule to reach newcomers who read a different language. The rule is “Borrow up to two books for seven days.” Plan A translates that rule and adds the same return-date example. B changes two books to five. C removes the loan period. D relies only on a decorative flag.
3A · Multiple choice
Which plan adapts the message while preserving the stated rule?
- a: A: translate the rule and retain its example
- b: B: change the permitted book count
- c: C: remove the seven-day loan period
- d: D: replace instructions with a flag
A adjusts language while keeping the factual borrowing conditions.
3B · Short answer
Explain how Plan A changes access without changing the borrowing rule.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes the language so the new readers can understand, while retaining the limit of two books and the seven-day period.
- Identifies translation as the access change for the stated audience.
- Correctly preserves both the two-book limit and seven-day period.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional safety poster uses bright yellow for visibility. It says “Delivery staff: use the loading entrance.” A learner says bright colours prove it is for small children.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions follow from the case?
- a: The yellow background overrides the role label.
- b: The role label directly addresses delivery staff.
- c: All bright posters are intended only for children.
- d: The colour alone does not establish a child audience.
An explicit role and action are stronger audience clues than a colour stereotype.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s faulty inference and replace it with an evidence-based audience statement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner infers age from colour alone. The poster addresses delivery staff because it names that role and gives a delivery entrance instruction.
- Identifies the unsupported colour-to-age assumption.
- Names delivery staff and cites the role label or delivery action as evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school exhibition needs a visitor notice and a helper notice. Visitors need the opening time, 1 p.m., and entrance, Gate B. Helpers need the setup time, noon, and reporting point, Room 2. Both notices must name the same exhibition.
5A · Matching
Match each detail to its specified role in the notices.
Complete or match: Visitor opening time; Helper setup time; Helper reporting point
- a: Room 2
- b: 1 p.m.
- c: Gate C
- d: Noon
The two audiences need different preparation details for the same event.
5B · Open ended
Write a short visitor notice and a short helper notice using all required details.
Example of a full-credit answer: Visitor notice: Exhibition opens at 1 p.m.; enter through Gate B. Helper notice: Exhibition helpers arrive at noon and report to Room 2.
- Writes a visitor notice naming the exhibition, 1 p.m. and Gate B.
- Writes a helper notice naming the exhibition, noon and Room 2.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.3 · Identifying purpose
Three worked examples
Example 1 · One garden, two messages
Fictional classroom example
Fictional card A explains how roots take up water. Card B says “Volunteer at our garden on Friday.”
Question: How do their purposes differ?
Answer: A explains a process; B recruits volunteers.
Why: Their topic is the same, but their words request different things from readers.
Example 2 · An informative advertisement
Fictional classroom example
A fictional advertisement lists a bag’s size and price, then says “Order now.”
Question: Can it have two purposes?
Answer: Yes. It supplies product information and encourages a purchase.
Why: The presence of facts does not remove the selling purpose.
Example 3 · Missing context
Fictional classroom example
A cropped fictional post says only “What a surprise!” without its picture or surrounding conversation.
Question: Can its exact purpose be established?
Answer: No. More context is needed.
Why: The phrase could express several reactions; inventing a hidden motive would exceed the evidence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Three clear actions
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional messages A lists bus departure times, B asks readers to buy a notebook, and C tells a make-believe dragon story.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each message to its main stated purpose.
Complete or match: A: departure times; B: buy a notebook; C: dragon story
- a: Inform travel planning
- b: Record a scientific measurement
- c: Entertain with fiction
- d: Encourage a purchase
The content and requested action reveal different purposes.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Find the request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster has four panels: A a decorative leaf, B “Bring reusable cups to reduce single-use cups,” C a border pattern, D a page number.
F2 · Hotspot
Which panel most directly shows the poster’s action purpose?
- a: A: decorative leaf
- b: D: page number
- c: C: border pattern
- d: B: bring reusable cups
The instruction in B directly asks the reader to act.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Facts inside a promotion
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional shop post lists a lunchbox’s capacity and adds “Choose our lunchbox.” No independent quality test is provided.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The capacity detail removes the post’s selling purpose.
- true: True
- false: False
Information and persuasion can appear in the same message.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Instructions, invitation and warning
Fixed fictional classroom case
Three invented labels say “Turn the handle clockwise,” “Join the library club,” and “Floor wet: walk carefully.”
F4 · Matching
Match each label with what it asks a reader to do.
Complete or match: Turn the handle; Join the library club; Wet-floor label
- a: Take a safety precaution
- b: Guess the creator’s private thoughts
- c: Participate in a group
- d: Operate something
The labels give observable requested actions.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · An exhibition invitation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post explains that the class exhibition contains recycled sculptures. It gives Friday, Room 5, and says “Come see what we made.”
F5 · Open ended
Identify two supported purposes and quote or paraphrase a clue for each.
Example of a full-credit answer: It informs readers about recycled sculptures and invites them to attend, shown by “Come” and the Friday/Room 5 details.
- Identifies informing about the exhibition and supports it with the sculpture detail.
- Identifies encouraging attendance and supports it with the invitation or practical attendance details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school site has a recipe’s numbered steps, a fun invented comic and a request to return borrowed games by Tuesday.
1A · Drag and drop
Place each section beside its directly supported purpose.
Complete or match: Numbered recipe; Invented comic; Return reminder
- a: Prompt a return action
- b: Entertain readers
- c: Teach a procedure
- d: Prove a secret motive
Purpose follows the section’s content and requested response.
1B · Short answer
Explain the purposes of the recipe and return note using one clue from each.
Example of a full-credit answer: The numbered recipe teaches how to make something; its ordered steps show this. The note prompts returning games by giving a return action and Tuesday deadline.
- Connects the recipe’s ordered steps with teaching a procedure.
- Connects the return action/deadline with prompting a return.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional refill-station post explains where the station is and asks pupils to refill bottles there. It does not sell bottles or report a measured reduction in waste.
2A · Hotspot
Which description accounts for both supported purposes?
- a: Sell a particular bottle brand
- b: Give location information and encourage refilling
- c: Prove an exact waste reduction
- d: Hide the station’s location
The post both supplies a location and asks for an action.
2B · Open ended
Justify the two-purpose description and name one claim the post does not establish.
Example of a full-credit answer: The location sentence informs; “Refill” encourages action. The post does not establish a measured amount of waste reduction.
- Explains both purposes using their distinct text clues.
- States a valid unsupported claim, such as an exact waste reduction or a selling purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
An invented audio announcement says “First, wash the model parts. Next, dry them. Then fit the base.” A learner assumes all audio is entertainment.
3A · Multiple choice
Which purpose is most directly supported?
- a: Sell a named product
- b: Guide a sequence of actions
- c: Report election results
- d: Entertain simply because it is audio
Instructions can be communicated through audio as well as text.
3B · Short answer
Explain the announcement’s purpose and why its audio format does not settle that purpose by itself.
Example of a full-credit answer: It teaches a procedure through ordered actions. Audio is a format that can carry instructions, stories or other purposes, so the content is the stronger clue.
- Uses the ordered action steps to identify instruction.
- Explains that format alone does not determine purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional community leaflet asks people to join a tree count and lists Saturday and Park Gate. The organiser’s current schedule also lists Saturday at Park Gate. A learner says asking people to act makes those details false.
4A · True or false
True or false? An action request alone proves the leaflet’s date and place are false.
- true: True
- false: False
Purpose and factual accuracy are separate questions; the supplied schedule supports the details.
4B · Open ended
Identify the faulty shortcut and state how the date and place should be checked.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats persuasion as proof of falsity. Compare the date and place with the organiser’s schedule; here both agree.
- Explains that encouraging action does not by itself make facts false.
- Uses the organiser’s schedule to check Saturday and Park Gate.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional puzzle afternoon is Wednesday at 2 p.m. in Room 3. Its card should explain the event and invite attendance without inventing prizes or guarantees.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which choices meet the design brief?
- a: Omit the place to make readers curious.
- b: Use a clear invitation such as “Join us.”
- c: State the puzzle event, time and Room 3.
- d: Invent a guaranteed prize to attract attention.
Useful information and a truthful invitation satisfy the two purposes.
5B · Open ended
Write a short event card with its information and invitation, then explain one unsupported promise you avoided.
Example of a full-credit answer: Puzzle afternoon is Wednesday at 2 p.m. in Room 3. Join us! I avoided promising prizes because none are in the event record.
- Includes the event, Wednesday, 2 p.m., Room 3 and an invitation.
- Identifies an unsupported promise avoided and explains the lack of evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.4 · Evaluating evidence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A count and a broad claim
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class counts 6 bicycles in its own rack on Monday. Someone claims the whole town owns only 6 bicycles.
Question: Does the count support the town claim?
Answer: No. It describes one rack at one time.
Why: The claim expands beyond the observed location and time.
Example 2 · A fairer paper test
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class compares two towels using 10 mL water on each, the same waiting time and three repeats.
Question: Why is this stronger than pouring different amounts?
Answer: The important conditions are kept alike and repeated.
Why: A difference is less easily explained by different amounts of water or a single unusual trial.
Example 3 · Repeated report
Fictional classroom example
Three invented blogs quote the same original library survey; none collects new responses.
Question: How many survey origins are represented?
Answer: One.
Why: Repeating a report increases its visibility, not the number of independent surveys.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match evidence to the claim
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional records show A: a clocked 12-minute walk, B: an inventory of the 18 library books on this shelf, C: a measured 2-litre bottle capacity.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each question with its relevant record.
Complete or match: How long did this walk take?; How many books are on this shelf?; What is this bottle’s capacity?
- a: Record C
- b: A popular logo
- c: Record A
- d: Record B
Each record directly measures the quantity asked about.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Parts of a fair test
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional test compares paper A and B. Each receives 5 mL water, waits 30 seconds and is tested four times.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Match each design feature with its role.
Complete or match: Same 5 mL amount; Same 30 seconds; Four trials
- a: Keeps water amount controlled
- b: Keeps waiting time controlled
- c: Guarantees all possible papers behave alike
- d: Checks repeat-to-repeat variation
These choices improve comparison without proving a universal result.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Evidence for opening time
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post claims the reading room opens at 9 a.m. A current signed room schedule gives 9 a.m.; an old photo shows a crowd; a poll asks favourite colours; a story mentions a dragon.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which supplied record most directly supports the claim?
- a: The favourite-colour poll
- b: The current room schedule
- c: The dragon story
- d: The undated crowd photograph
The current schedule directly addresses the opening time.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · What did the evidence leave open?
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional trial records 7 sprouting seeds out of 10 from Packet A, tested on one windowsill for one week. It does not test Packet B or other locations.
F4 · Matching
Match each untested issue to the relevant limitation.
Complete or match: How Packet B behaves; How another location affects growth; What happens next month
- a: Only one windowsill was used
- b: Every seed everywhere was tested
- c: Observation lasted one week
- d: Only Packet A was tested
The evidence is specific to its packet, place and duration.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · One poll, three posts
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional posts North, East and West all cite the same class poll of 20 pupils. North and East copy its result; West summarises it. No other poll is supplied.
F5 · Short answer
Explain how many independent poll origins are supplied and identify one limit on the conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: There is one poll origin, not three independent polls. It describes the 20 pupils in that class, not all children.
- Recognises that the three posts depend on one underlying poll.
- Names a valid limit such as the small, single-class group or no evidence for all children.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: origin lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional school records include A: a direct count of 24 returned games, B: a stopwatch record of a run lasting 6 minutes, C: a thermometer record of 22 degrees Celsius. A logo contains no measurement.
1A · Drag and drop
Connect each claim to the direct record.
Complete or match: Twenty-four games were returned; The run lasted six minutes; The reading was twenty-two degrees
- a: The school logo
- b: Record B
- c: Record A
- d: Record C
Relevant recorded observations support these specific claims.
1B · Open ended
Choose one record and explain the claim it supports, then name a wider claim it does not establish.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record A supports that 24 games were returned in this collection. It does not establish that every borrowed game in the school was returned.
- Correctly connects one supplied record to its specific claim.
- Identifies a sensible wider conclusion that exceeds that record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
The fictional question is whether Cloth A absorbs more water than Cloth B under the same conditions. Plan A uses equal sizes, equal water, equal time and repeats. B changes water amounts. C asks which colour looks nicer. D counts likes.
2A · Hotspot
Which plan most directly tests the stated absorbency question?
- a: Plan A: matched conditions and repeats
- b: Plan C: favourite colour vote
- c: Plan D: number of likes
- d: Plan B: different water amounts
A measures the outcome while keeping major conditions alike.
2B · Open ended
Justify Plan A using its controlled conditions and its repeated trials.
Example of a full-credit answer: Equal cloth sizes, water amounts and waiting times make the comparison fairer. Repeated trials reveal whether results vary and avoid relying on one attempt.
- Explains why at least one matched condition matters to a fair comparison.
- Explains that repeats reveal variation or reduce reliance on one unusual trial.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class asks 16 of its own pupils about a new reading corner. Ten prefer cushions. No pupils from other classes are surveyed.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each statement with its evidence status.
Complete or match: Ten surveyed pupils prefer cushions; Every class prefers cushions; Ask pupils from other classes next
- a: Supported by this tally
- b: Useful way to broaden the evidence
- c: Proof that cushions cause better reading
- d: Not established for other classes
The tally describes the surveyed group, and a broader claim needs broader evidence.
3B · Short answer
Give a conclusion supported by the tally and propose one way to investigate preferences across the school.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ten of the 16 surveyed classmates prefer cushions. Survey a suitably chosen range of pupils from other classes using the same question.
- States the 10-of-16 result without extending it to all pupils.
- Proposes collecting relevant responses from other classes with a consistent question.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional plant trial, Pot A gets more water and more light than Pot B. A grows taller. A post says this proves extra water alone caused the difference.
4A · True or false
True or false? The trial isolates water as the only possible explanation.
- true: True
- false: False
Light changed too, so the trial cannot separate its influence from water.
4B · Open ended
Identify the design problem and propose a fairer test of water amount.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both water and light changed, so the cause is unclear. Use comparable plants with the same light and other conditions, vary only water, and repeat.
- Identifies the additional light difference as a confounding change.
- Proposes controlling light/other conditions while varying water, with a sensible comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club claims its new queue signs reduce waiting. It has only a photo of the signs. The club can time comparable busy periods before and after and record queue sizes.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which additions would directly improve the evidence?
- a: Record queue sizes that could affect waiting.
- b: Measure waiting times before and after at comparable periods.
- c: Treat a photograph as proof that queues are faster.
- d: Count the signs’ decorative stars instead of waiting.
The claim concerns waiting, so relevant timings and conditions matter.
5B · Open ended
Propose a practical comparison and explain one condition or limitation that should be recorded.
Example of a full-credit answer: Time waits before and after the signs at comparable busy periods. Record queue sizes because a shorter queue could reduce waits even without the signs.
- Proposes measuring the relevant waiting outcome in a before/after or equivalent comparison.
- Identifies and explains a meaningful condition or limit, such as queue size or other changes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.5 · Evaluating accuracy
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A unit mix-up
Fictional classroom example
A fictional log counts 14 planted trees. A caption says 14 volunteers attended.
Question: Does the log verify the caption?
Answer: No. It counts trees, not volunteers.
Why: The number matches but the measured thing does not.
Example 2 · An updated time
Fictional classroom example
A fictional draft says a show begins at 3 p.m.; the organiser’s current update changes it to 4 p.m.
Question: Which time should a current notice use?
Answer: 4 p.m., with the update identified.
Why: The current record replaces the earlier draft for this event.
Example 3 · Check a total
Fictional classroom example
A fictional tally lists 6 blue cards and 5 green cards. A summary says 12 cards.
Question: What correction is supported?
Answer: There are 11 cards.
Why: Adding the two listed groups gives 6 + 5 = 11.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Correct the labels
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional inventory records 8 rulers, 5 pens and 3 erasers. The quantities refer to objects, not pupils.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each object to its recorded count.
Complete or match: Rulers; Pens; Erasers
- a: 5
- b: 3
- c: 16 pupils
- d: 8
The object labels determine what each count means.
Investigation: graph lab
F2 · Read the current notice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional organiser’s current notice says “Friday, 10 a.m., Hall A.” An earlier draft said Thursday. No venue change is recorded.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which details are supported for the current event?
- a: The venue is Hall A.
- b: The current event is on Thursday.
- c: The event starts at 10 p.m.
- d: The event is on Friday.
The current notice fixes the day, time and venue.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Check the sum
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional scoreboard lists 7 points in Round 1 and 6 in Round 2. A caption gives a total of 15.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which correction matches the record?
- a: 76 points
- b: 15 points
- c: 13 points
- d: 1 point
Seven plus six is thirteen.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A confident voice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional speaker confidently says the library closes at noon. The supplied current schedule lists 2 p.m.; no newer change is supplied.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Confidence alone makes noon more accurate than the current schedule’s 2 p.m.
- true: True
- false: False
The relevant current record supports 2 p.m.; confidence is not time evidence.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · What can be corrected?
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional chart records 4 red tiles and 8 yellow tiles. A post says “12 red tiles.” The author’s intentions are not recorded.
F5 · Open ended
Correct the colour-count claim by distinguishing the red count from the total, and explain what the record does not reveal about the author.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are 4 red tiles and 12 tiles in total. The record does not establish whether the author made an accidental error or intended to mislead.
- Corrects the red count to 4 while distinguishing the total of 12.
- States that the numerical evidence does not establish the author’s intent.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional trip timetable lists departure 8 a.m., arrival 9 a.m. and return departure 1 p.m. These labels refer to different stages.
1A · Drag and drop
Place the correct time beside each stage.
Complete or match: Outbound departure; Destination arrival; Return departure
- a: 8 a.m.
- b: 1 p.m.
- c: 9 p.m.
- d: 9 a.m.
Matching stage labels prevents swapping departure and arrival.
1B · Open ended
Write an accurate outbound-travel sentence and explain one label mistake to avoid.
Example of a full-credit answer: The group departs at 8 a.m. and arrives at 9 a.m. Do not describe 9 a.m. as its departure time because that is the arrival label.
- Correctly states both outbound departure and arrival times.
- Explains a specific label or a.m./p.m. mistake that would change the meaning.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sports hall has a current organiser notice stating “Practice: Tuesday, 3 p.m.” Alternatives are an undated screenshot, a fan’s guess and a decorative logo.
2A · Hotspot
Which clue most directly checks this practice time?
- a: Current organiser notice
- b: Undated screenshot
- c: Decorative logo
- d: Fan’s guess
The notice concerns the named event and current arrangements.
2B · Open ended
Justify the current notice and state a condition that could require checking again.
Example of a full-credit answer: It directly states this practice’s day and time. A later organiser update or a different event date would require another check.
- Connects the notice’s relevance and current status to the exact practice.
- Identifies a meaningful reason to recheck, such as a later update.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poll has 20 respondents. Twelve choose apples and eight choose bananas. The supplied calculation is 12/20 = 60% and 8/20 = 40%.
3A · Matching
Match each quantity with its accurate description.
Complete or match: Twelve of twenty; Eight of twenty; Twenty
- a: 40% chose bananas
- b: 60% chose apples
- c: 60% of all pupils in the country
- d: Total respondents
The percentages describe the supplied poll, not a larger population.
3B · Short answer
Correct a post that says “60% of all children choose apples,” using both the percentage and its proper scope.
Example of a full-credit answer: In this poll, 12 of 20 respondents, or 60%, chose apples. The record does not establish the preference of all children.
- Correctly connects 12 of 20 with 60%.
- Restricts the conclusion to the surveyed respondents.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional draft says “9 boxes, each with 2 crayons, total 20.” A proposed correction changes the total to 18 but also changes boxes to bags without evidence.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each change to its status.
Complete or match: 20 becomes 18; Boxes become bags; 2 becomes 3
- a: Every edit is accurate
- b: Supported calculation correction
- c: Contradicts the recorded amount
- d: Unsupported label change
A correction must keep the unchanged supported details.
4B · Open ended
Identify the useful correction and explain why the container label should stay unchanged.
Example of a full-credit answer: Change 20 to 18 because 9 × 2 = 18. Keep boxes because the record identifies boxes and gives no evidence for bags.
- Corrects the arithmetic to 18 with its calculation.
- Rejects the unsupported switch from boxes to bags.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club’s record lists 3 tables with 4 seats each, open Saturday from 1 to 3 p.m. A notice must state capacity and opening hours accurately.
5A · Multiple choice
Which notice matches all supplied facts?
- a: 12 tables; Friday, 1–3 p.m.
- b: 12 seats; Saturday, 1–3 p.m.
- c: 14 seats; Saturday, 1–3 p.m.
- d: 12 seats; Saturday, 1–3 a.m.
Both the calculation and all time labels must agree.
5B · Open ended
Write the notice and describe two checks you would perform before publishing it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The club room has 12 seats and opens Saturday from 1 to 3 p.m. Check 3 × 4 for capacity and compare the day/hours with the club record.
- Writes the correct capacity, day and hours.
- Describes both an arithmetic check and a comparison with the schedule.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.6 · Evaluating relevance
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A bus question
Fictional classroom example
A fictional task asks when Route 2 leaves today. One record has today’s Route 2 timetable; another describes the history of buses.
Question: Which directly answers the task?
Answer: Today’s Route 2 timetable.
Why: The history may be accurate but addresses a different question.
Example 2 · A picnic budget
Fictional classroom example
An invented budget lists sandwich prices and tablecloth colours. The task is to total sandwich costs.
Question: Which details are needed?
Answer: Sandwich quantities and prices.
Why: The tablecloth colours do not change the requested total.
Example 3 · Relevant but unchecked
Fictional classroom example
An anonymous fictional post names tomorrow’s fair and gives a time, without an organiser record.
Question: Is relevance enough to trust its time?
Answer: No. Check the organiser’s current information.
Why: It addresses the right event but its accuracy remains unverified.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match the task to the section
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional museum guide contains A: opening times, B: ticket prices, C: step-free entrances.
F1 · Matching
Match each task to the directly useful section.
Complete or match: Plan arrival time; Plan ticket budget; Find step-free access
- a: Section C
- b: Section A
- c: Section B
- d: A drawing of a mascot
Each section answers a different practical need.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Keep only the task details
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional workshop starts at 2 p.m., costs 3 credits and uses a blue logo. The task is to plan when to arrive and how much to bring.
F2 · Drag and drop
Classify each detail for the stated task.
Complete or match: 2 p.m.; 3 credits; Blue logo
- a: Needed for budget
- b: Not needed for either question
- c: Needed for arrival
- d: Proof of creator expertise
Relevance depends on the task, not how noticeable a detail is.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A current route question
Fixed fictional classroom case
The fictional task asks about this Monday’s school shuttle. Sources include Monday’s confirmed route map, Monday’s timetable, last year’s unrelated sports scores and a snack advertisement.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which sources directly help plan the journey?
- a: Last year’s unrelated sports scores.
- b: An unrelated snack advertisement.
- c: This Monday’s confirmed shuttle route map.
- d: This Monday’s shuttle timetable.
The route and departure times address the journey’s location and timing.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Matching word, wrong meaning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner searches for a computer mouse guide. Result A explains pointing and clicking. B describes a small animal’s food. C reports rainfall. D lists train times.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which result matches the intended meaning and task?
- a: B: small-animal food guide
- b: D: train timetable
- c: A: pointing and clicking guide
- d: C: rainfall record
A matches the computer-device meaning, not just the word mouse.
Investigation: search results lab
F5 · A missing access detail
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional concert page gives Friday, 4 p.m., Hall C and ticket cost. The task asks whether there is a step-free entrance. The page provides no access information.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the supplied details do not settle the access question and propose a targeted next check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Time, hall and price do not state whether an entrance is step-free. Check the venue’s access guide or ask the organiser about a step-free route with a trusted adult.
- Identifies the specific missing step-free-access information.
- Proposes a targeted, relevant venue/organiser check instead of guessing from unrelated details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional guide lists opening 10 a.m., 2-credit entry, East Gate step-free entry, and mascot name Pip. The visitor needs time, cost and step-free access.
1A · Matching
Match each visitor need with its relevant detail.
Complete or match: Arrival planning; Entry budget; Step-free route
- a: Mascot Pip
- b: 10 a.m.
- c: East Gate
- d: 2 credits
The chosen details answer the three stated needs.
1B · Short answer
Explain two of your selections by linking each detail to the visitor’s need.
Example of a full-credit answer: 10 a.m. tells the visitor when entry begins. East Gate answers the need for a step-free route; the 2-credit price would help budget.
- Correctly links one selected detail to its stated practical need.
- Correctly links a different selected detail to a different stated practical need.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional, well-sourced article explains how boats float. The question is whether tomorrow’s ferry departs at 8 or 9 a.m.; the article has no timetable.
2A · True or false
True or false? The article’s good evidence about floating makes it relevant evidence for the departure time.
- true: True
- false: False
Its evidence concerns a different question.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the article does not answer the task and identify the needed source.
Example of a full-credit answer: It explains floating, not tomorrow’s schedule. Check the ferry operator’s current timetable or service notice for that route and day.
- Distinguishes reliable information on a different topic from task-relevant information.
- Identifies a current route/day-specific schedule or service notice.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks for a beginner tutorial on folding a paper box. Video A shows each fold with captions. B compares finished box prices. C gives slow step diagrams. D advertises glue without folding steps.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which resources directly teach the required process?
- a: A: step-by-step captioned folds.
- b: B: finished box price comparison.
- c: D: glue promotion without folding steps.
- d: C: slow numbered fold diagrams.
A and C demonstrate the process needed by the learner.
3B · Open ended
Choose one relevant resource and explain why a price-comparison video is less useful for this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: A is relevant because it shows each fold for a beginner. Price comparisons may help buy boxes but do not teach the folding process.
- Links A or C to learning the required folding steps.
- Explains the different question answered by prices.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional search for this year’s Elm Festival bus stop returns A: current festival travel guide, B: last year’s festival poster, C: elm-tree biology. A learner chooses C because it repeats elm most often.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each result with its relevance.
Complete or match: Current festival travel guide; Last year’s poster; Tree biology article
- a: Different meaning of the topic
- b: Directly answers the stop question
- c: Wrong period and missing current stop
- d: Most repeated word is automatically best
The task’s meaning and date matter more than word counts.
4B · Open ended
Identify the search mistake and propose a query that keeps the task’s key details.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner counts keywords without checking meaning. Search “Elm Festival this year bus stop official travel guide” or equivalent.
- Identifies repeated-word matching without meaning/date as the mistake.
- Proposes a query including the event, current period and bus-stop/travel need.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional hiking-club visit needs departure 7 a.m., return 11 a.m., meeting point School Gate and adult supervision. Its mascot’s hat and logo shape are not needed for the travel plan.
5A · Hotspot
Which card best answers the travel-planning task?
- a: An old unrelated bus timetable
- b: School Gate, depart 7 a.m., return 11 a.m., adult supervision
- c: Only a generic mountain photograph
- d: Only mascot hat and logo shape
The card naming School Gate, departure, return and adult supervision includes all the needed travel facts.
5B · Open ended
Write a focused travel card and explain one detail you would leave out as irrelevant.
Example of a full-credit answer: Meet at School Gate; depart at 7 a.m. and return at 11 a.m. with adult supervision. Leave out the mascot’s hat because it does not affect the travel plan.
- Includes all four relevant travel conditions.
- Explains why a specified decorative detail does not answer the task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.7 · Evaluating credibility
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A self-awarded badge
Fictional classroom example
A fictional page displays “Number one trusted page” but supplies no author, evidence or independent assessment.
Question: Does the badge establish credibility?
Answer: No. It is an unsupported claim about the page.
Why: A source’s own praise is not independent verification.
Example 2 · A visible correction
Fictional classroom example
A fictional club report preserves its tally and labels a corrected sum with a date.
Question: Why is that useful?
Answer: Readers can inspect both the underlying tally and the correction.
Why: Transparency helps evaluation, although the corrected claim still needs checking.
Example 3 · A specialist’s unrelated claim
Fictional classroom example
A fictional music teacher gives an unsupported statement about water quality.
Question: Does music expertise settle the water question?
Answer: No. Relevant water evidence is needed.
Why: Credibility depends partly on the question and evidence, not only a respected title.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A popularity shortcut
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post has 5,000 likes but no source for its claimed new school opening time.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The like count alone verifies the opening time.
- true: True
- false: False
Engagement is not a schedule record.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · Three credibility clues
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional page A names its measurements and method, B discloses its sponsor, and C dates a correction to an earlier total.
F2 · Matching
Match each feature with what it helps readers inspect.
Complete or match: Measurements and method; Named sponsor; Dated correction
- a: Evidence trail
- b: Change to an earlier claim
- c: Guaranteed truth forever
- d: Possible interest
These are useful inspection clues, not certainty guarantees.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Choose a source for today’s hours
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional library’s current signed notice lists its hours. Alternatives are an undated fan post, a decorative badge and a guessed time.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which gives the strongest supplied basis for today’s library hours?
- a: The current library-issued notice
- b: The undated fan guess
- c: The decorative badge
- d: A guess with many exclamation marks
The notice is relevant, current and issued by the organisation setting the hours.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · Find the missing method
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional product page says “All pupils love this pencil.” Panel A gives a slogan, B a photo, C admits that no pupil survey was conducted, and D gives a border design.
F4 · Hotspot
Which panel most directly reveals a gap in the preference claim’s evidence?
- a: C: no pupil survey was conducted
- b: D: border design
- c: A: slogan repeated
- d: B: pencil photograph
The missing preference measurement is directly relevant to the claim.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · An interested but checkable source
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional bottle seller funds a capacity test, discloses this, and publishes a 500 mL measurement. A second, independent class measures the same bottle’s capacity using the stated method and also obtains 500 mL.
F5 · Open ended
Explain how you would consider the seller’s interest and the independent measurement when judging the capacity claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The seller benefits from sales, so inspect its method and disclosure. The separate class measurement adds independent support for this capacity, without proving every advertising claim.
- Recognises the commercial interest and need to inspect the evidence.
- Explains the value and limited scope of the independent capacity measurement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: origin lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional trail page identifies its guide author, dates its route check this month and links the route log. It does not document other trails.
1A · Dropdown selection
Match each feature with the question it helps answer.
Complete or match: Named guide; Dated route check; Linked route log
- a: What supports the description?
- b: How many likes prove it true?
- c: Who produced the information?
- d: How current is the record?
The features address responsibility, timeliness and evidence.
1B · Open ended
Use two features to justify cautious reliance on this route page.
Example of a full-credit answer: The dated route check helps assess whether the information is current, and the route log lets readers inspect its basis. Conditions may still change.
- Explains one relevant credibility feature rather than merely naming it.
- Explains a second distinct relevant credibility feature rather than merely naming it.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
Four fictional snack-survey pages show: A original responses, question and date; B a gold badge; C 800 likes; D an unnamed expert claim. All discuss the same survey.
2A · Hotspot
Which feature most helps a reader evaluate the survey claim?
- a: B: gold badge
- b: A: traceable question, date and responses
- c: C: like count
- d: D: unnamed experts
A lets readers inspect how the result was obtained.
2B · Open ended
Justify A and name one survey limitation you would still check.
Example of a full-credit answer: A supplies the underlying information and method details. I would still check who answered and whether the group fits the claim.
- Explains how traceable responses/question/date support evaluation.
- Identifies a real remaining issue such as sampling, question wording or scope.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional trip message has three details: a current local forecast from the forecasting office, a school organiser’s trip decision, and a pupil’s personal hope for sunshine.
3A · Matching
Match each source with the claim it is suited to support.
Complete or match: Forecasting office; Trip organiser; Pupil’s message
- a: Guaranteed weather with no uncertainty
- b: Current local weather forecast
- c: School’s trip arrangement
- d: That pupil’s expressed hope
Different sources have responsibility or knowledge for different claims.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the forecast and organiser should be used for different questions.
Example of a full-credit answer: The forecasting office provides weather information; the organiser states the school’s planned response. Neither the pupil’s hope nor the forecast alone determines the school arrangement.
- Assigns the weather question to the relevant forecast source.
- Assigns the school arrangement question to the organiser and keeps the roles distinct.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional review clearly discloses a free sample and supplies a checkable weight measurement. A learner says the free sample makes its stated weight automatically false.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each part with its proper interpretation.
Complete or match: Free sample; Scale record; Repeat measurement
- a: Possible influence on the reviewer
- b: An additional check you could perform
- c: The supplied measurement record to inspect
- d: Automatic proof of every claim
An incentive deserves scrutiny without deciding all facts by itself.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s mistake and propose a claim-specific check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats an interest as proof of falsity. Inspect the scale method or repeat the weight measurement under suitable conditions.
- Separates a commercial interest from automatic factual falsity.
- Proposes a relevant method or independent measurement check for weight.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class publishes its own playground count. It has the tally, date, location, method and one corrected total. It must help readers inspect the claim.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which features would improve transparency?
- a: Label and explain the corrected total.
- b: Claim the count covers every playground.
- c: Publish the date, method and tally.
- d: Hide the original evidence behind a trust slogan.
Traceable methods and visible corrections allow evaluation.
5B · Open ended
Propose one feature that shows the evidence or method and one that explains the correction or limits. Explain how each helps a reader check the report.
Example of a full-credit answer: Include the dated tally and method so readers can inspect the count. Add a labelled correction showing the changed total so earlier readers can update their understanding.
- Proposes an evidence/method feature and explains its checking purpose.
- Proposes a clear correction/limits feature and explains its purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.8 · Evaluating expertise
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Fame and repairs
Fictional classroom example
A fictional actor is popular; a mechanic has verified bicycle-repair training. The task concerns brake adjustment.
Question: Whose expertise is more relevant?
Answer: The mechanic’s bicycle-repair expertise.
Why: Popularity does not establish skill in brake repair.
Example 2 · A field mismatch
Fictional classroom example
A fictional marine biologist is asked to confirm a building’s electrical wiring.
Question: Does the biology qualification settle the wiring question?
Answer: No. Relevant electrical expertise is needed.
Why: Qualifications have a field and scope.
Example 3 · A careful expert
Fictional classroom example
A fictional soil researcher says a soil test is needed before identifying a nutrient shortage.
Question: Is the request for evidence a sign of ignorance?
Answer: No. It recognises what the available evidence cannot settle.
Why: Careful specialists do not have to pretend certainty.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A famous singer’s bridge claim
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional singer is very popular but no bridge-design training or evidence is supplied. The singer declares a bridge safe.
F1 · True or false
True or false? Popularity alone establishes bridge-safety expertise.
- true: True
- false: False
The relevant expertise concerns structural assessment, not audience size.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Find relevant plant experience
Fixed fictional classroom case
Four fictional profiles show A: botanist with verified local-plant identification work, B: champion chess player, C: fashion presenter, D: weather hobbyist. The task is identifying a garden plant.
F2 · Hotspot
Which profile provides the most relevant stated expertise?
- a: C: fashion presenter
- b: B: chess champion
- c: D: weather hobbyist
- d: A: botanist with plant-identification work
A’s documented field matches the question.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Different school questions
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional verified roles are: a librarian who manages catalogue records, a technician who maintains projectors, and a coach trained in the club’s game rules.
F3 · Matching
Match each question to its relevant supplied role.
Complete or match: Find a book’s catalogue location; Diagnose a projector connection; Explain this club’s game rule
- a: Technician
- b: Coach
- c: Librarian
- d: Most followed account
The stated role-specific experience answers different tasks.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · What does each clue establish?
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional profile shows a relevant qualification verified by its college, a large follower count, and a certificate for an unrelated craft session.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each clue with what it establishes.
Complete or match: Verified relevant qualification; Follower count; Unrelated craft certificate
- a: Evidence of relevant training
- b: Expertise in every subject
- c: Size of online audience
- d: Participation in that craft session
Clues have different scopes; none establishes universal expertise.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A disputed river claim
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional river researcher has relevant training but gives a pollution claim without current measurements. A water-sampling report is not yet available.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what the relevant training contributes and what further evidence the pollution claim still needs.
Example of a full-credit answer: River training is relevant knowledge for interpreting water evidence. The claim still needs current, suitable measurements from the river and a clear method.
- Recognises the relevance of the researcher’s field without treating it as certainty.
- Identifies current relevant measurements/methods as the missing claim evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional project needs plant selection, a step-free path and an organised book display. Supplied roles are horticulturist, access-design specialist and librarian.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each need with the best-fitting stated role.
Complete or match: Choose suitable plants; Plan step-free access; Organise the book display
- a: Librarian
- b: One celebrity for every question
- c: Access-design specialist
- d: Horticulturist
The project has several different knowledge needs.
1B · Short answer
Explain why two different roles are needed for plant selection and path access.
Example of a full-credit answer: The horticulturist supplies plant knowledge, while the access specialist addresses step-free paths. Expertise in one does not automatically cover the other.
- Correctly matches plant selection to horticultural knowledge.
- Correctly matches access design to its relevant specialist and distinguishes the fields.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional page claims expertise in astronomy. A lists verified telescope research, B lists a cooking award, C lists a large audience.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each record to what it supports.
Complete or match: Telescope research; Cooking award; Audience size
- a: Popularity rather than field expertise
- b: Cooking achievement
- c: Relevant astronomy experience
- d: Proof every astronomy statement is correct
Relevant experience supports expertise without guaranteeing every claim.
2B · Open ended
Justify which credential is relevant and state why it still does not prove every claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: A concerns astronomy work, unlike cooking or followers. A specific astronomy statement still needs appropriate observations and evidence.
- Explains the field match of the telescope research.
- States that relevant expertise does not remove the need to check specific claims.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school asks wheelchair users about obstacles on its grounds and a qualified designer about construction changes. Their roles are different and both can contribute.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which statements fit this situation?
- a: Users can describe obstacles they personally encounter.
- b: The designer can assess technical changes within their expertise.
- c: Lived experience automatically establishes every construction detail.
- d: Only famous people can identify access obstacles.
Direct experience and relevant technical expertise answer complementary questions.
3B · Short answer
Describe a useful contribution from users and a different useful contribution from the designer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Users can report where the route blocks or inconveniences them. The designer can assess feasible step-free changes using technical knowledge.
- Identifies a concrete contribution from direct user experience.
- Identifies a distinct relevant technical-design contribution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional advertisement asks viewers to buy a game and says “Doctor Vale confirms our game improves memory.” The supplied profile identifies Vale as a literature scholar. No memory study is provided.
4A · Matching
Match each issue with the needed interpretation.
Complete or match: Literature doctorate; No memory study; Game promotion
- a: Universal proof from a title
- b: Expertise in a different stated field
- c: Commercial purpose to consider
- d: Claim lacks supplied relevant study evidence
A title must be matched to the field, and the claim needs evidence.
4B · Open ended
Identify the field mismatch and explain what evidence would be more useful.
Example of a full-credit answer: The doctorate is in literature rather than memory research. A suitable study of the game’s effects, evaluated by relevant specialists, would be more useful.
- Identifies the mismatch between literature training and the memory-effect claim.
- Requests relevant study evidence or appropriate specialist evaluation of that evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a card for evaluating claimed expertise. It should check the field, verify a relevant record and ask for evidence supporting the particular claim.
5A · Multiple choice
Which card covers all three needs?
- a: Count followers and stop
- b: Believe anyone who sounds certain
- c: Match field, verify relevant record, inspect claim evidence
- d: Choose the longest title and stop
The card that matches the field, verifies a relevant record and inspects claim evidence checks all three needs.
5B · Open ended
Propose three questions for the card and explain how they avoid the fame shortcut.
Example of a full-credit answer: What field does the question require? What relevant training or work can be verified? What evidence supports this claim? These ask about knowledge and evidence rather than audience size.
- Includes field fit, verifiable relevant experience and specific claim evidence.
- Explains why the questions assess expertise rather than popularity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.9 · Identifying bias
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The winning-only record
Fictional classroom example
A fictional team won 3 games and lost 4. Its poster reports only the 3 wins.
Question: What selection could mislead?
Answer: Omitting the 4 losses hides the full record.
Why: The wins are real, but they alone do not describe the season.
Example 2 · Unequal time periods
Fictional classroom example
A fictional chart compares one shop’s monthly sales with another shop’s yearly sales.
Question: Why is the comparison unfair?
Answer: The periods differ.
Why: Use the same period before interpreting the difference.
Example 3 · Framing a delay
Fictional classroom example
A fictional event begins 5 minutes late. Two headlines say “Five-minute delay” and “Everything collapsed.”
Question: Which is closer to the supplied evidence?
Answer: Five-minute delay.
Why: The second adds a much broader unsupported impression.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Three ways presentation can lean
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional examples show A: reporting wins but omitting losses, B: calling a small delay a catastrophe, C: comparing one week with one year.
F1 · Matching
Match each example to its issue.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Selective omission
- b: Loaded wording
- c: Unmatched time periods
- d: Proof of a secret intention
These are observable presentation choices, not proof of private motives.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Find the omitted result
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional paper test has results A: 4 drops, B: 5 drops, C: 2 drops. A promoter displays only B and calls every test excellent. Panel D says “two lower results omitted.”
F2 · Hotspot
Which detail most directly exposes selective reporting?
- a: C: paper was tested
- b: D: two lower results were omitted
- c: B: one result was 5
- d: A: the chart uses labels
The missing trials change how consistent the results appear.
Investigation: graph lab
F3 · Repair the comparison
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional report compares Team Sun’s 8 wins in ten games with Team Rain’s 3 wins in four games. A fair report needs the number of games and both win records.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each quantity with its role.
Complete or match: 8 of 10; 3 of 4; 10 and 4
- a: Different numbers of games played
- b: Sun’s full win record
- c: Both teams played ten games
- d: Rain’s full win record
Raw wins and opportunities to win are different details.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Use a measured description
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional event had 20 planned activities; 19 ran and one was postponed. A headline says “Nothing happened.”
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each statement with its evidence status.
Complete or match: Nineteen activities ran; Nothing happened; Everyone was angry
- a: Supported by the record
- b: All headlines are equally accurate
- c: Contradicted by the record
- d: Not established by a supplied survey
The record supports a specific description, not sweeping claims.
Investigation: revision lab
F5 · A one-sided route review
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional route review praises its short distance but omits that it has stairs. The task is selecting a step-free route. The full route guide records both distance and stairs.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the important omission and how it changes the usefulness of the review for this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: The review omits stairs. That matters because the user needs step-free access; short distance alone cannot justify choosing this route.
- Identifies the omitted stairs as relevant information.
- Connects the omission to the stated step-free-route requirement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club survey records 9 members for Plan A, 7 for Plan B and 4 undecided. A summary mentions only the 9 for A.
1A · Matching
Match each full-record part with its count.
Complete or match: Plan A supporters; Plan B supporters; Undecided members
- a: Everyone supports A
- b: 9
- c: 4
- d: 7
The full record includes disagreement and uncertainty.
1B · Open ended
Write a fair one-sentence summary and explain why “everyone supports A” is inaccurate.
Example of a full-credit answer: Nine support A, seven support B and four are undecided. Everyone does not support A because eleven respondents did not choose it.
- Includes all three groups and their correct counts.
- Explains how the non-A responses contradict the universal claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional garden records compare A and B. Plan 1 compares both over the same month with equal plot sizes. Plan 2 selects A’s best week and B’s worst. Plan 3 hides B. Plan 4 uses likes.
2A · Multiple choice
Which plan is the fairest starting comparison?
- a: Plan 2: selected best and worst weeks
- b: Plan 1: same month and plot size
- c: Plan 4: compare likes
- d: Plan 3: omit B
Matching major conditions reduces an obvious source of distortion.
2B · Open ended
Justify the matched plan and name one further condition worth checking.
Example of a full-credit answer: The same month and equal areas make the comparison more comparable. Check watering, soil or plant types because those could also explain a difference.
- Explains why matched period or area matters.
- Names a relevant additional condition rather than assuming the comparison proves a cause.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional cleanup photo shows a pile of rubbish at the left. The full scene also shows pupils collecting it into bags. A crop removes all helpers and is captioned “Nobody is cleaning.”
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which observations challenge the caption?
- a: Cropping always makes every image false.
- b: The rubbish pile proves no one is helping.
- c: The crop removes relevant cleaning activity.
- d: The full scene includes helpers collecting rubbish.
The full context contradicts the caption without making every crop deceptive.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the crop changes the impression and propose a more accurate caption.
Example of a full-credit answer: Removing helpers makes the scene seem unattended. A better caption is “Rubbish is being collected by helpers,” or another description including the cleanup activity.
- Explains the effect of omitting visible helpers.
- Provides a caption consistent with the full scene.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional count records 30 returned books. An unsupported guess says 300. A learner says fairness requires presenting both as equally well supported.
4A · True or false
True or false? Fairness requires calling the count and unsupported guess equally supported.
- true: True
- false: False
Fair evaluation considers evidence strength, not equal treatment of every assertion.
4B · Open ended
Explain the learner’s error and state a fair way to report the two statements.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses equal space with equal evidence. Report the logged count of 30 and identify 300 as an unsupported claim requiring evidence.
- Distinguishes fairness from equal factual confidence in unequal evidence.
- Reports the count and the guess with their different support made clear.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional test group’s game review record lists enjoyable puzzles, confusing instructions and a 4-credit price. The review must help a new player make an informed choice.
5A · Hotspot
Which review best uses the complete record?
- a: Enjoyable puzzles; confusing instructions; four-credit price
- b: Only the confusing instructions
- c: A claim that every player dislikes it
- d: Perfect for everyone with no cost mentioned
The review including enjoyable puzzles, confusing instructions and the four-credit price combines the recorded strength, limitation and cost.
5B · Open ended
Write a short review using all three recorded features and explain how it avoids selective reporting.
Example of a full-credit answer: The test group enjoyed the puzzles but found the instructions confusing; the game costs four credits. It includes both a strength and a limitation plus the cost.
- Includes the puzzles, confusing instructions and correct price without universalising.
- Explains how including favourable and unfavourable relevant details reduces selective presentation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.10 · Identifying commercial influence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A paid recommendation
Fictional classroom example
A fictional creator receives three credits for recommending a pencil case.
Question: What interest should readers consider?
Answer: The creator benefits financially from the recommendation.
Why: That connection deserves disclosure and scrutiny; it does not settle every factual claim.
Example 2 · Free does not mean independent
Fictional classroom example
A fictional shop gives a reviewer a free bag. The reviewer discloses the gift.
Question: Is the gift relevant even without cash?
Answer: Yes. A free product can be a benefit.
Why: The audience should know the connection when assessing the review.
Example 3 · A measurable claim
Fictional classroom example
A fictional sponsored bottle review says it holds 600 mL. A separate class measurement agrees.
Question: What does that establish?
Answer: Support for the capacity under the tested conditions.
Why: It does not establish every other promotional promise.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify the benefit
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional agreements say A: a creator is paid per sale, B: a reviewer receives a free notebook, C: a page earns money for ad views.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each case with its commercial connection.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Sales commission
- b: Advertising income
- c: No possible financial relationship
- d: Free product benefit
Different benefits can influence what gets promoted.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Separate claim and connection
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional review says “The seller paid for this review. The bag weighs 200 grams. I like the colour.”
F2 · Matching
Match each sentence with its function.
Complete or match: Seller paid; 200 grams; I like the colour
- a: States a preference
- b: Makes a measurable claim
- c: Proves the bag suits everyone
- d: Discloses an incentive
The three statements do different jobs.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · An unexplained missing label
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional product post has no visible payment label. No agreement records are supplied.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The missing label proves the creator received no benefit.
- true: True
- false: False
Absence of a label does not establish absence of a relationship.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · What should be checked next?
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional advertisement claims a lamp lasts 100 classroom hours. It offers a colourful coupon but supplies no test. The task is checking the lifespan claim.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which would most directly help check the claim?
- a: A celebrity photograph
- b: The coupon’s colour
- c: More copies of the advertisement
- d: A relevant duration test with its conditions
The claim concerns operating duration, which needs matching test evidence.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A link that earns money
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reviewer writes “I receive one credit when you buy using this link.” The post also states a 10-credit price. No current shop record is supplied.
F5 · Short answer
Identify the incentive and explain how you would check the price separately.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reviewer benefits from purchases through the link. Check the current shop price and offer conditions rather than treating the commission as proof that ten credits is right or wrong.
- Identifies the sales-linked payment as a relevant incentive.
- Proposes checking current price/conditions while separating incentive from factual accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional game-review page earns two credits whenever a reader buys through its recommendation link. It calls the game “perfect for everyone” without test evidence.
1A · Multiple choice
Which connection is directly established?
- a: No business relationship exists
- b: The reviewer benefits from purchases through the link
- c: The game is proven perfect
- d: Every reader benefits financially
The agreement links the reviewer’s income to purchases.
1B · Short answer
Explain the reviewer’s incentive and identify the separate unsupported claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reviewer earns two credits per purchase, which can encourage promotion. “Perfect for everyone” is not supported by supplied testing.
- Identifies and explains the sales incentive.
- Identifies the universal suitability claim as unsupported independently of the incentive.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reviewer received a free ruler, measured its length against a reference ruler and reported a cracked edge. These are three different disclosures.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each detail with what it contributes.
Complete or match: Free ruler; Reference comparison; Cracked edge
- a: Guarantees every ruler is identical
- b: Reveals a benefit
- c: Reports an observed limitation
- d: Supports a measurement claim
Disclosure and evidence perform different roles.
2B · Open ended
Explain why both the gift disclosure and measurement record help readers.
Example of a full-credit answer: The gift disclosure reveals a possible influence. The comparison record helps readers inspect the length claim, even though it does not remove the gift relationship.
- Explains the relevance of the disclosed benefit.
- Explains the evidence value and limited scope of the measurement record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional free game earns revenue from adverts and optional paid costumes. It requires no purchase to play the basic level. A pupil says free means it cannot have commercial interests.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which facts challenge that conclusion?
- a: A free basic level proves no business model exists.
- b: The game can earn revenue from adverts.
- c: Optional costume purchases can produce income.
- d: Every player must buy a costume.
Free entry and commercial revenue can coexist; optional is not compulsory.
3B · Short answer
Explain two ways the game can earn money while the basic level remains free.
Example of a full-credit answer: It can earn advertising income and sell optional costumes. A pupil can still play the basic level without making those purchases.
- Identifies advertising as one revenue route.
- Identifies optional purchases as another while preserving that they are optional.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sponsored page reports a box width of 30 cm. An independent ruler measurement also gives 30 cm. A learner rejects 30 solely because a sponsor paid.
4A · Hotspot
Which response best addresses the error?
- a: Assume all other claims are verified too
- b: Treat every sponsored number as false
- c: Consider the sponsor and the independent width evidence separately
- d: Change the width without measuring
The supplied separate measurement supports this specific width.
4B · Open ended
Identify the faulty rule and state the limited conclusion the independent check supports.
Example of a full-credit answer: Paid means false is an invalid shortcut. The independent measurement supports a width of 30 cm for this box, not every statement on the page.
- Rejects automatic falsity based on payment alone.
- States the correct width and limits verification to the measured claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class review receives a free sketchpad. Its record says 20 sheets, rough paper and no durability test. The review must disclose the gift and stay within its evidence.
5A · Matching
Match each review need with the supported content.
Complete or match: Connection; Measured feature; Evidence limit
- a: Twenty sheets counted
- b: Guaranteed to last forever
- c: Free sketchpad from shop
- d: Durability not tested
The recommendation should reveal its benefit and evidence boundaries.
5B · Open ended
Write a short recommendation containing the connection, observed features and test limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The shop gave us this sketchpad free. We counted 20 sheets and observed rough paper, but we did not test durability.
- Clearly discloses the free product and accurately reports the sheet count/features.
- Explicitly states the durability limit without inventing a lifetime guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.11 · Identifying political influence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A shared-space proposal
Fictional classroom example
A fictional school club says “Use the spare room for quiet reading.”
Question: What decision is it trying to influence?
Answer: How the spare room will be used.
Why: It is a proposal about a shared resource, not a measured result.
Example 2 · Fact versus wish
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice says “There are four benches; we want two more.”
Question: Which part is checkable now?
Answer: The existing count of four benches.
Why: Wanting more is a preference; the current count can be verified.
Example 3 · Different interests
Fictional classroom example
Fictional art and sport clubs prefer different uses for a hall.
Question: Does disagreement prove one club is lying?
Answer: No. They may value different uses.
Why: Compare their factual claims and trade-offs separately from their preferences.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify parts of a proposal
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional student council message says “We represent the music club. Use Room 6 for practice. The room has twelve chairs.”
F1 · Matching
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Music club representatives; Use Room 6 for practice; Twelve chairs
- a: Proves the proposal is already adopted
- b: States a preferred decision
- c: Makes a checkable factual claim
- d: Identifies the speaking group
Speaker, request and evidence are distinct.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · A proposal is not a decision
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class group proposes a longer lunch break. The school has not approved a change.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which description matches the current status?
- a: An approved new timetable
- b: A measured improvement already achieved
- c: A proposal awaiting a decision
- d: A rule applying to every school
Requesting a change does not enact it.
Investigation: verification lab
F3 · Find the evidence question
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group wants a covered waiting area and claims thirty pupils wait outside daily. Panels show A: group badge, B: a tally by day, C: a slogan, D: a decorative umbrella.
F3 · Hotspot
Which panel most directly helps check the thirty-pupil claim?
- a: D: the umbrella design
- b: C: the slogan
- c: A: the group badge
- d: B: the daily tally
The tally can support or challenge the numerical claim.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Consider affected groups
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional courtyard proposal affects gardening pupils, ball-game players and people needing a step-free route. Each group supplies an experience relevant to its use.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each concern to the relevant use.
Complete or match: Sunny planting space; Safe ball-game area; Clear step-free path
- a: Popularity alone settles the layout
- b: Games
- c: Access through the courtyard
- d: Gardening
Different users reveal different practical needs.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A biased motive guess
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional library club supports more reading seats and says there are currently six seats. A post claims the club must be dishonest because the proposal benefits its members. No false statement or deception evidence is supplied.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the motive claim goes too far and propose a useful question about the proposal.
Example of a full-credit answer: Benefiting from reading seats shows an interest, not proof of lying. Ask whether the six-seat count is accurate or how the plan serves other users.
- Separates a group’s interest from proof of dishonesty.
- Asks a relevant factual or affected-user question about the proposal.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional community youth group asks to turn an unused corner into a garden. Its leaflet says “Please support a garden in this corner.” No decision has been made.
1A · Multiple choice
What is the leaflet trying to influence?
- a: Whether an existing garden should be closed
- b: The result of a completed garden test
- c: An already adopted national rule
- d: The future use of the unused corner
It seeks support for a shared-space proposal.
1B · Short answer
Identify the requested decision and distinguish it from an outcome already achieved.
Example of a full-credit answer: It asks people to choose a garden for the corner. No decision or completed garden result is established yet.
- Identifies the proposed use of the corner.
- Explains that a proposal is not an adopted decision or measured outcome.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
Two fictional school plans have the same budget limit. A shaded reading area costs 8 credits and keeps a clear path. A game area costs 10 credits and needs a path redesign. The limit is 10 credits.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each fact with its correct interpretation.
Complete or match: Eight-credit reading area; Ten-credit game area; Path redesign required
- a: Budget alone proves every other need is met
- b: Access issue to investigate
- c: Meets the limit exactly
- d: Two credits below the limit
Shared criteria clarify trade-offs without deciding every value question.
2B · Open ended
Explain one budget comparison and one access question that should be considered.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both plans fit the ten-credit limit, with the reading plan costing two less. The game plan needs a clear step-free route checked after redesign.
- Correctly compares the two costs with the common budget.
- Identifies the path/access issue as a separate condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school club will discuss meeting times. The organiser collects availability, explains the decision process and asks for respectful reasons. Private phone numbers are not needed.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each action with its purpose.
Complete or match: Collect availability; Explain decision process; Ask for respectful reasons
- a: Understand participation needs
- b: Make the procedure clear
- c: Demand private contact details publicly
- d: Compare preferences constructively
A shared decision can use relevant information without unnecessary exposure.
3B · Open ended
Propose a useful contribution and explain one privacy boundary.
Example of a full-credit answer: I could state which meeting times I can attend and why. I would not post private phone numbers because the timing decision does not require them.
- Proposes a relevant availability/reason contribution.
- Explains why an unnecessary private detail should not be public.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional campaign for a school garden says “This will make every pupil happier.” No pupil survey or completed garden exists.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which criticisms are supported?
- a: The word every extends beyond the supplied evidence.
- b: A hopeful proposal can never be discussed.
- c: The claimed result has not been measured here.
- d: All garden supporters are dishonest.
The problem is unsupported certainty, not the right to propose a garden.
4B · Open ended
Identify the evidence error and rewrite the promise more carefully.
Example of a full-credit answer: It treats an untested hope as a universal result. “We hope a garden will provide enjoyable activities; we should ask pupils and evaluate how it works” is more careful.
- Explains the missing outcome evidence or unsupported universal claim.
- Rewrites it as a limited proposal/hope with an appropriate evaluation idea.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class must choose between a quiet corner and a craft table. Relevant criteria are space, cost and access. No one should be insulted for preferring either.
5A · True or false
True or false? A prompt comparing the same criteria respectfully helps evaluate both proposals.
- true: True
- false: False
It keeps attention on evidence and shared needs rather than personal attacks.
5B · Open ended
Write a neutral discussion question using the criteria and explain how disagreement should be handled.
Example of a full-credit answer: How would a quiet corner and a craft table compare on space, cost and access? Invite reasons, listen to different needs and question claims without insulting people.
- Includes both proposals and the common space/cost/access criteria.
- Describes respectful, evidence-focused treatment of disagreement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.12 · Recognising persuasive techniques
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A crowd as a reason
Fictional classroom example
A fictional advert says “Everyone has this notebook, so you need it.”
Question: Which technique is used?
Answer: A bandwagon or popularity appeal.
Why: It uses others’ supposed choices instead of evidence about the notebook.
Example 2 · One experience
Fictional classroom example
A fictional reviewer says “I enjoyed this game.”
Question: Does that prove everyone will enjoy it?
Answer: No. It describes one person’s experience.
Why: A testimonial has a narrower scope than a universal claim.
Example 3 · A flashing timer
Fictional classroom example
A fictional page says “Buy in the next minute!” but supplies no quality test.
Question: What does the pressure fail to establish?
Answer: That the product works well.
Why: Urgency is separate from evidence about quality.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name the technique
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional messages say A “All your friends use it,” B “A famous actor recommends it,” C “Decide in ten seconds.”
F1 · Matching
Match each message with its main technique.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Celebrity endorsement
- b: Measured product performance
- c: Bandwagon
- d: Urgency
These clues identify appeals, not performance tests.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · An appealing but unsupported promise
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional advert says “The most amazing pen ever! One pupil loved it!” No comparison with other pens is supplied.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which statements are justified?
- a: One testimonial does not prove everyone will like it.
- b: One pupil’s preference represents all pupils.
- c: The universal ranking lacks a supplied comparison test.
- d: The enthusiastic words prove it is the best pen.
The evidence is narrower than the promotional claims.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Read the actual offer
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster says “Only today: three credits.” Its record confirms the one-day price but contains no evidence of superior quality.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Match each detail with what it establishes.
Complete or match: Confirmed one-day offer; Three credits; Best quality claim
- a: Supported price
- b: All deadlines are invented
- c: Not established by price or deadline
- d: Supported time condition
A genuine offer limit does not prove unrelated quality.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A relevant reason
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reading club invitation gives “Quiet space, three book choices, Thursday at noon.” Other versions say “Join or no one likes you,” “Everyone must agree,” or “Guaranteed perfect happiness.”
F4 · Multiple choice
Which invitation uses the supplied benefits responsibly?
- a: Perfect happiness guaranteed
- b: Join or nobody likes you
- c: Everyone must agree
- d: Quiet reading space and three book choices, Thursday noon
It makes a clear invitation using supported features.
Investigation: message lab
F5 · An actor’s recommendation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional actor recommends a water bottle. The actor’s relevant product-testing experience is not supplied. The post claims the bottle never leaks.
F5 · Open ended
Identify the persuasive technique and explain a useful evidence check for the leak claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: It uses celebrity endorsement. Inspect relevant leak tests and conditions; fame alone does not establish that the bottle never leaks.
- Identifies celebrity/authority-by-fame persuasion.
- Requests claim-specific leak evidence and does not treat fame as proof.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: evidence lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post says a backpack must be strong because many people bought it. No load or durability test is supplied.
1A · True or false
True or false? The number of buyers alone proves the backpack’s strength.
- true: True
- false: False
Popularity and physical strength are different claims.
1B · Open ended
Identify the appeal and explain what kind of evidence would test strength.
Example of a full-credit answer: The post uses popularity or bandwagon reasoning. A suitable load/durability test with stated conditions would address strength.
- Identifies popularity as the persuasive reason.
- Proposes a relevant physical performance test rather than more popularity data.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional helmet-design explanation offers A: a relevant qualified engineer citing a stated test, B: a singer’s preference, C: a follower count, D: a flashing slogan. The exercise asks which provides the strongest supplied basis to inspect, not a purchase decision.
2A · Multiple choice
Which offers the strongest supplied starting point for checking the design claim?
- a: D: flashing slogan
- b: C: follower count
- c: B: singer’s colour preference
- d: A: relevant engineer and stated test
Relevant expertise plus traceable testing is more useful than popularity alone.
2B · Open ended
Justify A and name one limitation you would still inspect.
Example of a full-credit answer: A combines relevant knowledge with a test readers can examine. Check the tested model, conditions and whether the conclusion matches the results.
- Explains the value of relevant expertise and a traceable test.
- Names a specific remaining test-scope or quality check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class poster says “Join the puzzle club: five puzzles to try on Friday.” A second says “All good pupils join.” A third says “An actor likes puzzles.”
3A · Dropdown selection
Match the sentence with its persuasive basis.
Complete or match: Five puzzles on Friday; All good pupils join; An actor likes puzzles
- a: Proof that every pupil should join
- b: Pressure through a personal label
- c: Specific supported activity detail
- d: Celebrity preference
The bases differ; clear details support an informed choice.
3B · Short answer
Choose a responsible sentence and explain why the personal-label sentence is unfair pressure.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the five-puzzle invitation because it gives a real activity and date. Calling only joiners good pupils pressures identity rather than explaining the activity.
- Chooses the specific invitation and explains its evidence-based usefulness.
- Explains the unfair link between joining and being a good person/pupil.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional advertisement compares its box’s 10-litre capacity with a rival’s 6-litre capacity but omits that its own box costs twice as much. The task is comparing value for a fixed budget.
4A · Hotspot
Which omission matters most to this task?
- a: The price difference
- b: The number of decorative stars
- c: The order of the brand names
- d: The border colour
Value for a budget needs the cost as well as capacity.
4B · Open ended
Explain how the selective comparison persuades and what information a fairer comparison should include.
Example of a full-credit answer: It emphasises the larger capacity while hiding the higher cost. Show both capacities and prices, and compare them against the buyer’s budget and needs.
- Identifies selective emphasis on capacity and omission of cost.
- Proposes including the relevant prices and capacities for the stated decision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional board-game afternoon offers three game stations, adult supervision, Tuesday at 1 p.m. in Hall B. It makes no promise of prizes or popularity.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each responsible message feature to its role.
Complete or match: Three supervised stations; Tuesday at 1 p.m.; Hall B
- a: Clear event time
- b: Clear event location
- c: Supported activity benefit
- d: Guaranteed prizes for everyone
An invitation can be appealing without unsupported rewards or social pressure.
5B · Open ended
Write a responsible invitation and name one persuasive shortcut you avoided.
Example of a full-credit answer: Try three game stations with adult supervision on Tuesday at 1 p.m. in Hall B. I avoided invented prize guarantees or pressure about being left out.
- Includes the supported stations, supervision, time and place.
- Identifies an avoided unsupported promise or social-pressure technique.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.13 · Recognising emotional manipulation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A friendship threat
Fictional classroom example
A fictional chain message says “Forward this or you are not my friend.”
Question: What pressure is being used?
Answer: Fear of losing friendship.
Why: The threat does not provide evidence that forwarding is useful or safe.
Example 2 · Concern with a check
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil is worried by an unconfirmed event cancellation.
Question: Can the pupil care and still pause?
Answer: Yes. Ask the organiser or a trusted adult before spreading it.
Why: A strong feeling does not replace a source check.
Example 3 · A respectful request
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice says “Please return shared art tools so the next group can use them.”
Question: Why is this more responsible than an insult?
Answer: It gives a reason and a clear action without attacking anyone.
Why: The request preserves a reader’s dignity and focuses on the shared need.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name the feeling used
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional messages say A “Only bad friends refuse to share,” B “A terrible disaster is certain unless you click,” C “You won a huge prize; send your details now.” No supporting evidence is supplied.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each message to its main pressure.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: A verified factual test
- b: Excitement about a reward
- c: Fear of disaster
- d: Guilt or fear of rejection
The emotions are visible; the claims still lack support.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Put the safe pause in order
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unknown message makes a pupil frightened and demands a secret reply. A classroom safety routine says: stop responding, tell a trusted adult, and check through a known source.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each stage to its action.
Complete or match: First; Next; Then
- a: Stop responding
- b: Tell a trusted adult
- c: Use a known source to check
- d: Keep the demand secret
The routine interrupts pressure and brings appropriate help.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Care without forwarding
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unverified post claims a pupil’s project was destroyed and names the pupil. It demands forwarding to prove kindness.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which responses are appropriate?
- a: Check with a trusted adult before spreading the claim.
- b: Treat refusal to forward as proof of cruelty.
- c: Offer support without publicising the pupil’s details.
- d: Forward the named claim immediately to prove kindness.
Support and verification can occur without amplifying personal information.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · An emotional story
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional story makes readers sad and cites no source for its factual claim. No evidence establishes whether it is true or false.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Because the story is emotional, its factual claim must be false.
- true: True
- false: False
Emotion alone establishes neither truth nor falsity.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A pressured invitation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club message says “Join today or everyone will think you are selfish.” The actual event is an optional one-hour cleanup on Saturday.
F5 · Short answer
Identify the pressure and rewrite the invitation using the real event details.
Example of a full-credit answer: It uses guilt and fear of others’ judgment. “You are invited to an optional one-hour cleanup on Saturday” gives the real details without a threat.
- Identifies the guilt/rejection pressure.
- Writes a respectful optional invitation retaining Saturday and one-hour duration.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post contains A: “The art display is Friday,” B: “Room 2,” C: “Share now or you are a terrible classmate,” D: “Work by the class.”
1A · Hotspot
Which sentence uses emotional pressure rather than event information?
- a: A: the display is Friday
- b: C: share or be a terrible classmate
- c: D: work by the class
- d: B: Room 2
C links a sharing action to a shaming personal label.
1B · Short answer
Explain the pressure and propose a non-shaming request.
Example of a full-credit answer: It threatens a negative identity if someone does not share. “If you wish, tell classmates about Friday’s display in Room 2” gives a voluntary request.
- Explains the share-or-shame mechanism.
- Proposes a respectful request without a threat or unsupported moral label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unfamiliar account warns that a school trip is cancelled and demands secrecy. A trusted teacher’s known channel is available; no official cancellation is supplied.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each goal to a suitable action.
Complete or match: Avoid amplifying the rumour; Get support; Check the trip status
- a: Tell a trusted adult
- b: Use only the unknown sender’s link
- c: Pause before forwarding
- d: Use the teacher’s known channel
The steps address both distress and the unverified factual claim.
2B · Open ended
Justify the pause and the known-channel check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Pausing prevents spreading a claim that is not confirmed. Checking through the teacher’s known channel can establish the trip’s status without trusting the unfamiliar sender.
- Explains how pausing limits spread or unsafe action.
- Explains why an independently known teacher channel is suitable for verification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message says a pupil has won a prize and must send a password to claim it. It uses an invented address, prize.example, and no real prize record. No password should be entered.
3A · Multiple choice
Which response addresses both excitement and risk?
- a: Forward the demand to classmates
- b: Send the password before excitement fades
- c: Pause, keep the password private and tell a trusted adult
- d: Assume a cheerful message cannot be risky
Positive emotion can also be used to pressure unsafe action.
3B · Short answer
Identify the emotion being used and explain the safe response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The message uses excitement about a prize. Keep the password private, do not use the message’s demand, and ask a trusted adult to help verify or report it.
- Identifies reward-related excitement as the pressure.
- Protects the secret and includes an appropriate trusted-adult/verification step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional fire-drill notice from the school gives verified time and supervised instructions. A learner dismisses it because it sounds serious, while accepting an anonymous cheerful rumour.
4A · Matching
Match each feature to its proper role.
Complete or match: Known school source; Confirmed drill details; Serious or cheerful tone
- a: Not a truth test by itself
- b: Relevant verification clue
- c: All serious warnings are manipulation
- d: Evidence about the event
Evaluate source and evidence, not emotional tone alone.
4B · Open ended
Identify the faulty rule and explain which features should guide the comparison.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats tone as a truth test. Use the known source and confirmed drill details; the cheerful rumour still lacks verification.
- Rejects tone alone as proof of reliability or unreliability.
- Uses the stated source and evidence differences to compare the messages.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs volunteers to sort books on Thursday for 20 minutes with a teacher. Participation is optional. The message must avoid guilt and unsupported claims.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which features belong in the responsible appeal?
- a: Invite help without judging pupils who cannot join.
- b: State the optional activity, time commitment and supervision.
- c: Invent classmates’ feelings to create guilt.
- d: Threaten rejection for non-participation.
A clear, voluntary request can express care without manipulation.
5B · Open ended
Write the appeal and explain how it preserves choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: If you can, join our optional book sort on Thursday for 20 minutes with the teacher. It gives the task and conditions without blaming pupils who do not participate.
- Includes book sorting, Thursday, 20 minutes and teacher supervision.
- Explains or demonstrates optional participation without shaming non-participants.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.14 · Recognising sponsored content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A visible disclosure
Fictional classroom example
A fictional video begins “Paid promotion for Sun Bag Shop.”
Question: What does this establish?
Answer: A paid promotional relationship with the shop is disclosed.
Why: It does not establish whether every product claim is accurate.
Example 2 · A vague label
Fictional classroom example
A fictional review says only “special partner,” with no description of a benefit.
Question: What remains unclear?
Answer: The nature of the relationship or payment.
Why: Readers need a clearer explanation before assuming independence.
Example 3 · The cropped repost
Fictional classroom example
A fictional screenshot removes a review’s “free product supplied” note.
Question: What context is lost?
Answer: The reviewer’s relevant benefit from the supplier.
Why: The remaining review may look independent even though the original disclosed a connection.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the disclosure
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional article has A: “Paid advertisement for Sketch Shop,” B: the title, C: a decorative star, D: the page number.
F1 · Hotspot
Which panel explicitly identifies sponsorship?
- a: D: page number
- b: B: article title
- c: C: decorative star
- d: A: paid advertisement for Sketch Shop
A states both payment and the sponsor.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Three relationship records
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional content records say A: paid by a shop for a review, B: received a free case from its maker, C: no benefit record is available.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each case to the supported description.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Disclosed free-product benefit
- b: Paid promotional relationship
- c: Relationship unconfirmed
- d: Proven independent because no record is shown
Missing evidence should remain uncertainty.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · Choose a clear disclosure
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional creator receives a free backpack from a shop. Four labels are proposed: A states that benefit and shop; B says “wow”; C says “partner” without explanation; D is a tiny star.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which label most clearly explains the actual relationship?
- a: A: shop named and free backpack stated
- b: C: unexplained partner
- c: D: a star without text
- d: B: wow
A tells readers who provided what benefit.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · What each review part does
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post reads “Sponsored by Cup Shop. Capacity: 400 mL. I like the handle.” No durability test is supplied.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Sponsored by Cup Shop; 400 mL capacity; I like the handle
- a: Proof of unlimited durability
- b: Explains the connection
- c: Claim to verify by measurement
- d: Personal preference
A connection, a fact claim and an opinion are different.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · Preserving a label
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional paid review for Case Shop praises a pencil case. A pupil wants to repost only the praise while removing the paid-review label.
F5 · Open ended
Explain what removing the label changes and propose a transparent summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: It hides the paid relationship and can make the praise appear independent. A transparent summary says the paid review for Case Shop praises the case, without claiming independent testing.
- Explains the loss of sponsorship context and possible impression of independence.
- Provides a summary that retains the paid/sponsor relationship.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: crop media lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reviewer receives five credits from a lunchbox maker, discloses it and states a 700 mL capacity. A separate class measurement confirms 700 mL. A repost copies the paid review without another measurement.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions are supported?
- a: Sponsorship proves the capacity is false.
- b: The review has a disclosed paid connection.
- c: The repost is a third independent test.
- d: A separate measurement supports the capacity claim.
Relationship and measurement evidence can be evaluated separately.
1B · Short answer
Explain both the sponsorship status and what the independent check verifies.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reviewer is paid by the maker. The separate class measurement supports the stated 700 mL capacity, not every possible lunchbox claim.
- Correctly identifies the paid relationship.
- States the capacity supported by the independent measurement and keeps its scope limited.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
The fictional Drawing Shop supplies a free drawing kit and pays a creator to demonstrate it. A label must disclose both benefits clearly.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each label to its transparency.
Complete or match: Paid and free kit both stated; I used a kit; Thanks, partner
- a: Omits the connection
- b: A disclosure guarantees product quality
- c: Leaves the benefit unclear
- d: Explains both benefits
Clear wording identifies the actual relationship, not a quality guarantee.
2B · Open ended
Write a suitable label and explain why “partner” alone is less useful.
Example of a full-credit answer: Drawing Shop paid for this demonstration and supplied the kit free. “Partner” alone does not tell readers about payment or the free kit.
- Clearly states the sponsor and both supplied benefits.
- Explains the missing relationship detail in the vague alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school game contains a segment paid for by a stationery shop. The segment is labelled before it begins. Its puzzle facts can still be checked.
3A · True or false
True or false? Content inside a game cannot be sponsored because it is not an article.
- true: True
- false: False
Sponsorship can occur in many formats, including game segments.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the segment is sponsored and name a check still needed for its factual claims.
Example of a full-credit answer: The shop paid for it, regardless of the game format. Check the puzzle facts against relevant records or calculations.
- Uses the payment relationship rather than format to identify sponsorship.
- Proposes an appropriate claim-specific factual check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional creator clearly labels a sponsored review and then claims a bag is waterproof without a test. A learner says the label proves that performance claim.
4A · Matching
Match each part to what it establishes.
Complete or match: Sponsored label; Waterproof sentence; Relevant water test
- a: Possible support for performance
- b: Performance claim needing evidence
- c: Label proves every claim
- d: Paid connection
Disclosing an interest does not transform a promise into a tested result.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s error and describe the missing evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats a relationship label as a performance test. The bag needs a suitable water-resistance test with stated conditions and results.
- Distinguishes transparency about sponsorship from proof of performance.
- Identifies a relevant test and its conditions/results as the gap.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sponsored art tutorial includes a paid label, three drawing steps and an untested claim that the pencil never breaks. A class summary should preserve context and avoid adopting the untested claim.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each summary feature to its purpose.
Complete or match: Retain paid label; Describe three steps; Mark never-breaks untested
- a: Summarise the actual instruction
- b: Avoid turning a promise into a verified fact
- c: Preserve the commercial connection
- d: Remove sponsorship to save space
A shorter summary should retain material context and limits.
5B · Open ended
Write a two-sentence summary preserving the sponsorship and the evidence limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: This sponsored tutorial demonstrates three drawing steps. It also claims the pencil never breaks, but no durability test is supplied.
- Clearly preserves sponsored status and the actual instructional content.
- Identifies the durability claim as untested rather than endorsing it.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.15 · Recognising misinformation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An accidental copy
Fictional classroom example
In a fictional case, Ana believes an old notice is current and accidentally shares its Thursday date. The organiser confirms Friday.
Question: What is supported about the share?
Answer: It is mistaken information shared without deceptive intent in this stated case.
Why: The case explicitly supplies the mistake and belief; the date should be corrected.
Example 2 · A real photo, wrong date
Fictional classroom example
A fictional genuine photo is from last year, but its caption says it shows today.
Question: Does an authentic photo make the caption accurate?
Answer: No. The date is wrong.
Why: Authenticity and contextual accuracy are separate.
Example 3 · Intent unknown
Fictional classroom example
A fictional post gives 18 when a tally totals 16. No record explains why.
Question: What can be concluded?
Answer: The total is wrong; the writer’s intent is unknown.
Why: Arithmetic checks the number, not the private reason for the error.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Different kinds of mismatch
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional records show A: yesterday’s hours labelled today, B: 6 + 3 written as 10, C: a photo of Park East captioned Park West.
F1 · Matching
Match each case with its factual problem.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Arithmetic error
- b: Wrong location label
- c: Wrong time context
- d: Proof every author meant harm
The evidence identifies errors, not intentions.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Check before sharing
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil receives an unverified room-change notice. The classroom routine is to pause, check the teacher’s current notice and share the confirmed correction if needed.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each stage to its action.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Pause forwarding
- b: Share the supported correction
- c: Accuse the sender before checking
- d: Check the current teacher notice
The sequence reduces further spread while establishing the fact.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · A copied wrong date
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional posts A, B and C all copy the same outdated Friday date from a draft. The current organiser notice says the event is Saturday.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions are supported?
- a: The three posts share one outdated origin.
- b: The current organiser notice should guide the event date.
- c: Every sharer is proved to intend deception.
- d: Three copies establish three independent confirmations.
Copies repeat the error; the current notice supplies the relevant date.
Investigation: origin lab
F4 · Identify a supported correction
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class count has 5 small boxes and 7 large boxes. A post mistakenly says 13 boxes. No intention evidence is supplied.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which correction stays within the evidence?
- a: Thirteen must be right because it was posted
- b: Every box count online is false
- c: The total is 12 and the writer is proved dishonest
- d: The total is 12; the reason for the mistake is unknown
Five plus seven is twelve; intent cannot be calculated from the tally.
Investigation: graph lab
F5 · An old image in a new message
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional verified archive dates a photo to last year’s sports day. A current post says it shows this morning’s sports day. The photographer and reposter’s motives are not provided.
F5 · Short answer
Explain the contextual error and state what remains unknown about the reposter.
Example of a full-credit answer: The photo is from last year, so it does not show this morning’s event as captioned. The reposter’s intent is unknown from these records.
- Identifies the mismatch between the archived date and current caption.
- Avoids guessing whether the reposter knowingly deceived anyone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: provenance lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional case, Ben genuinely believes last week’s classroom note is current and shares Room 3. The teacher’s current record says Room 7 today. Ben did not intend to mislead.
1A · Multiple choice
Which description fits all supplied facts?
- a: The teacher’s record concerns no room
- b: Confirmed deliberate deception; today’s room is 3
- c: Accidentally shared misinformation; today’s room is 7
- d: Both rooms are equally current
The case supplies both an incorrect share and an innocent mistaken belief.
1B · Open ended
Give a respectful correction and explain why deliberate deception is not established here.
Example of a full-credit answer: Today’s teacher notice says Room 7; the Room 3 note was for last week. Ben believed the old note was current and the case states no intent to mislead.
- Corrects the room using the current record and relevant date.
- Uses the stated mistaken belief rather than accusing Ben of deliberate deception.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional image is captioned “This is today’s river cleanup in our town.” A dated original shows it is from another town last year. Alternatives are the like count, filter colour and an unrelated opinion.
2A · Hotspot
Which evidence most directly challenges the current caption?
- a: An unrelated opinion about rivers
- b: The original’s different date and town
- c: The number of likes
- d: The filter colour
Origin and context directly test what the caption claims.
2B · Open ended
Justify the original-record check and explain why likes cannot settle the caption.
Example of a full-credit answer: The original identifies a different place and time, contradicting the caption. Likes show engagement, not where or when the photograph was made.
- Uses both date/place context to explain the mismatch.
- Distinguishes popularity from evidence about the photo’s context.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional table says “9 books borrowed by Group A.” A screenshot caption says “9 pupils absent.” The original row is clear, but no author intent is recorded.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each detail to its interpretation.
Complete or match: Original row; Screenshot caption; Missing intent record
- a: Proof of nine absent pupils
- b: Incorrect absence claim
- c: Reason for the error unknown
- d: Book-borrowing count
The number is reused with a different and unsupported label.
3B · Short answer
Explain why copying the number did not preserve accuracy and provide a correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: Nine counts borrowed books, not absent pupils. Correct the caption to “Group A borrowed nine books”; the table gives no absence count.
- Identifies the change in what the number measures.
- Restores the correct borrowing label and does not invent attendance data.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post gives a wrong ticket price. A current price list proves the error, but there is no evidence about the poster’s knowledge or intention.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each question with its answer from the case.
Complete or match: Is the stated price accurate?; Did the poster know it was wrong?; What should be shared next?
- a: Every error proves a lie
- b: The current price with its source
- c: No, it conflicts with the current list
- d: Not established
The case supports a correction without an accusation of intent.
4B · Open ended
Explain the unsupported accusation and propose a helpful response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The error establishes an inaccurate price, not that the poster knew it was wrong. Share the current price list and ask for the notice to be corrected respectfully.
- Separates established inaccuracy from unestablished knowledge/intent.
- Proposes a source-based correction without personal attack.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class accidentally shared a 3 p.m. opening time. The organiser’s current notice confirms 2 p.m. The correction must reach the same group and identify the reliable record.
5A · True or false
True or false? A useful correction should reach the original audience and identify the current supporting notice.
- true: True
- false: False
Those steps help readers replace the old detail with the supported one.
5B · Open ended
Write a correction and describe how it should reach people who saw the error.
Example of a full-credit answer: Correction: the organiser’s current notice says opening is 2 p.m., not 3 p.m. Post it in the same class channel and link or identify the current notice so earlier readers can update.
- Clearly corrects 3 p.m. to 2 p.m. and identifies the supporting organiser notice.
- Provides a practical route to reach the audience of the original error.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.16 · Recognising disinformation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Intent explicitly supplied
Fictional classroom example
In a fictional case, an editor knows a meeting is at 10 a.m. and writes “11 a.m.” after a verified instruction to make readers arrive late.
Question: Why is this deliberate deception?
Answer: The time is false and the supplied instruction establishes intent to mislead.
Why: Both the factual mismatch and the intention are evidenced.
Example 2 · An unexplained wrong date
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice gives the wrong date, but no record shows why.
Question: Can intent be established?
Answer: No. The date can be corrected; intention remains unknown.
Why: The error alone does not distinguish a mistake from deception.
Example 3 · Openly labelled fiction
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class creates an imaginary newspaper marked “Fiction for a story activity.”
Question: Is the invented story necessarily disinformation?
Answer: No. It is presented as fiction rather than a real report.
Why: The audience is told how to interpret it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the intent evidence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional case includes A: the true opening time is noon, B: the post says 1 p.m., C: a verified author note says “I know noon is correct; I will change it to make them late,” D: the post has many likes.
F1 · Hotspot
Which detail specifically establishes deceptive intent?
- a: A: the correct time alone
- b: B: the wrong time alone
- c: C: the verified note about knowingly making readers late
- d: D: the like count
The verified note links knowledge of the truth to a plan to mislead.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Different evidence states
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional Case A explicitly records an accidental typo. Case B records a verified plan to invent a false result. Case C has a wrong number but no intent record.
F2 · Matching
Match each case to the supported intent conclusion.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Every wrong number has the same cause
- b: Accidental error established
- c: Intent remains unknown
- d: Deliberate deception established
The supplied evidence differs between cases.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · A fabricated quotation record
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional case, a creator invents a headteacher quotation after a verified instruction to make it look authentic. The headteacher’s original speech contains no such words.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Match each record with its evidential role.
Complete or match: Original speech transcript; Invented quotation; Verified fabrication instruction
- a: Popularity proves authenticity
- b: Checks what was actually said
- c: Shows deceptive purpose
- d: Shows the false attributed content
The case provides both the false attribution and deliberate presentation as genuine.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · A labelled imaginary picture
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class generates a picture of a floating library and labels it “Imaginary scene for a story.” No real event is claimed.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which interpretation fits the case?
- a: Proven real event because it looks detailed
- b: Clearly labelled fiction, not evidence of deliberate factual deception
- c: Disinformation merely because a computer helped
- d: Proof all generated pictures are accurate
The picture is not being presented as a record of a real event.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · Unknown motive
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post misstates the number of planted trees as 50 when the record shows 15. No author message or other intent evidence is available.
F5 · Open ended
State what is established about the claim and what cannot be concluded about intention.
Example of a full-credit answer: The claim of 50 is inaccurate because the record shows 15. The evidence does not establish whether the author knowingly deceived readers or made a mistake.
- Correctly identifies the 50-versus-15 factual mismatch.
- Explicitly leaves deceptive intent unestablished.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional case, an organiser’s record says Room 9. A verified message shows a poster knows this and intentionally publishes Room 4 to send another group away.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which two facts support classifying this as disinformation?
- a: The published room conflicts with the correct record.
- b: Everyone who makes any room error is deceptive.
- c: The notice has a green border.
- d: The verified message establishes a plan to mislead.
Both falsity and deliberate deceptive intention are supplied.
1B · Short answer
Explain the classification using the factual mismatch and the intent evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Room 4 contradicts the Room 9 record. The verified message shows the poster knew the truth and intended to misdirect the group, so both elements are present.
- Uses the correct-versus-posted room mismatch.
- Uses the verified knowledge and misleading purpose to establish intent.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional sponsor pays for an event notice. Its date matches the organiser’s record; no deceptive instruction or false claim is supplied.
2A · True or false
True or false? The sponsorship alone establishes deliberate false information.
- true: True
- false: False
Payment is an interest, not proof of falsity or deceptive intent.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the classification is unsupported and identify what would be needed to establish deliberate deception.
Example of a full-credit answer: The supplied date is accurate and payment alone shows no deceptive intent. Evidence of a false/misleading claim and a deliberate plan to deceive would be needed.
- Explains why payment and the accurate supplied date do not establish disinformation.
- States the need for both misleading content and evidence of deceptive intention.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
In a fictional case, a creator knowingly captions an old photo as today’s event after a verified instruction to trick viewers. The dated archive confirms the photo is five years old.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each feature with its role.
Complete or match: Dated archive; Today caption; Verified instruction to trick viewers
- a: Creates the false time claim
- b: Real pixels guarantee a truthful caption
- c: Establishes deceptive intent
- d: Establishes the original time
A real image can be deliberately used in false context.
3B · Open ended
Explain why an authentic photo can still carry disinformation in this case.
Example of a full-credit answer: The image may be authentic, but its five-year-old date conflicts with the today caption. The verified instruction shows that the mismatch was used deliberately to trick viewers.
- Separates image authenticity from the false date/context claim.
- Uses the supplied deceptive-intent evidence rather than inferring it from editing alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil shares a mistaken date after openly saying they believed an outdated calendar. The case states that the mistake was unintentional. A classmate calls it a deliberate plot.
4A · Matching
Match each part with its specific role in this case.
Complete or match: Wrong date; Stated unintentional mistake; Deliberate-plot accusation
- a: Explicit evidence of an accidental cause
- b: An accusation contradicted by the stated intent evidence
- c: Proof that mistakes can never cause confusion
- d: An inaccurate detail that needs correction
Errors can matter without being intentional deception.
4B · Open ended
Identify the classmate’s reasoning error and propose a respectful correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The classmate ignores the stated accidental mistake and equates error with intent. Correct the date using the current calendar without alleging a plot.
- Explains the unjustified or contradicted intent accusation.
- Proposes a current-source correction without personal accusation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a checklist before labelling an item disinformation. It must check the claim, the relevant original evidence and what establishes deceptive intent. Children should use adult support for harmful cases.
5A · Multiple choice
Which checklist avoids guessing motives?
- a: Treat sponsorship as automatic deception
- b: Use spelling mistakes as proof of intent
- c: Check falsity and intent separately; mark missing evidence unknown
- d: Call every unpopular view a lie
A careful classification requires the relevant evidence for both questions.
5B · Open ended
Write the two central evidence questions and explain what to do when intent evidence is missing.
Example of a full-credit answer: What makes this claim false or misleading? What evidence shows an intention to deceive? If intent evidence is missing, describe the incorrect claim and say intent is unknown rather than label the person deceptive.
- Includes separate questions about factual misleadingness and deceptive intent.
- States an uncertainty-preserving response when intent is not established.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.17 · Recognising fabricated content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A copied logo
Fictional classroom example
A fictional forged notice copies a club logo, but the club’s verified record says it never issued that notice.
Question: Does the logo authenticate it?
Answer: No. The issuing record contradicts that assumption.
Why: Design features can be copied.
Example 2 · An invented attributed quotation
Fictional classroom example
A fictional speech says “We need more time.” A post quotes “We will cancel everything.”
Question: Does the original support the quote?
Answer: No. The words and meaning differ.
Why: An attributed quotation must match the relevant original.
Example 3 · Labelled invented data
Fictional classroom example
A fictional game uses a table labelled “Invented practice values.”
Question: Is it pretending to be a real survey?
Answer: No. Its status is disclosed.
Why: Inventing teaching data is different from presenting it as measured evidence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Check different fabricated records
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional Case A invents a quote not in the verified speech; B invents survey numbers with no survey; C copies a school logo onto a notice the school did not issue. These creation facts are supplied.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each case to the fabricated item.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Survey data
- b: Institutional notice
- c: A verified original record
- d: Quotation
The case supplies creation or original-source evidence, not appearance guesses.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Different checks for different records
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner wants to verify an attributed speech line, a school closure notice and a measured rainfall table.
F2 · Matching
Match each item with its appropriate starting check.
Complete or match: Speech line; School notice; Rainfall table
- a: Known school issuing channel
- b: Count decorative icons
- c: Measurement log and method
- d: Relevant original transcript
The checks concern the claimed origin of each item.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · A realistic table
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional table has neat headings and values to two decimal places. No collection record is supplied.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The table’s precise-looking numbers establish that people were actually surveyed.
- true: True
- false: False
A polished table can contain invented values; the collection record is missing.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Quote, summary and invention
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional original says “The walk is postponed until Friday.” A summary says the walk will happen later. An attributed quote says “The walk is cancelled forever,” which the verified original contradicts.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each version with its status.
Complete or match: Postponed until Friday; Will happen later; Cancelled forever
- a: A broad paraphrase
- b: Every wording is interchangeable
- c: Matches the original quotation
- d: Contradicted attributed quotation
Quoting and paraphrasing require different labels and faithful meaning.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A source cannot be found
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional quotation circulates with a famous-name credit. Post A has no link to an original; Posts B and C copy Post A without new evidence. The original is unavailable, and no independent record settles whether the words were said.
F5 · Open ended
State a careful conclusion and one useful next verification step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The attribution is unconfirmed; copied posts do not establish it. Seek the original publication or a reliable archive containing the relevant words rather than claim fabrication from absence alone.
- States uncertainty and does not equate inability to find a source with proof of fabrication.
- Proposes a relevant original/archive check rather than relying on copies.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: origin lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional survey page claims 100 pupils answered. The verified project log states that the author invented all figures for a story and then removed the fiction label. Other panels show colour, likes and title length.
1A · Hotspot
Which detail establishes that these figures were not collected from the claimed survey?
- a: The title is long
- b: The page uses bright colours
- c: The page has many likes
- d: The verified log says the figures were invented
The creation record directly concerns whether the survey occurred.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the figures are fabricated as survey evidence and distinguish their earlier fictional use.
Example of a full-credit answer: The log shows they were invented rather than collected from 100 pupils. In the story draft they were labelled fiction; removing that context and calling them survey results misrepresents them.
- Uses the verified invention record to reject the claimed survey origin.
- Distinguishes transparent fictional data from falsely presented measurement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post attributes “The pool is open all night” to a manager. The complete relevant announcement says “The pool closes at six.” Its provenance is verified.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which points challenge the attributed quote?
- a: The attributed all-night statement conflicts with that announcement.
- b: A repost count replaces the original wording.
- c: The manager’s name makes any attached words authentic.
- d: The relevant verified announcement gives a six o’clock closure.
The original wording directly tests the claimed quotation.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the original is stronger than repost counts and provide a faithful summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: The verified announcement contains the manager’s relevant words; reposts only repeat an attribution. A faithful summary is that the pool closes at six.
- Explains the direct original-source advantage over repeated copies.
- Summarises the six o’clock closure without introducing all-night opening.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional notice with a school logo says tomorrow is a holiday. The school’s known current channel and teacher both confirm a normal school day. No unknown link should be opened.
3A · Multiple choice
Which conclusion follows from the supplied records?
- a: The holiday notice is contradicted; use the confirmed normal schedule
- b: Open any attached unknown file to decide
- c: The logo overrides the known school record
- d: Many copies would create a holiday
Known issuing channels directly address the school’s schedule.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the logo is insufficient and state a safe action for a pupil.
Example of a full-credit answer: A copied logo does not establish school issuance. Follow the confirmed normal schedule and show the conflicting notice to a trusted teacher or caregiver.
- Explains the difference between appearance and verified issuance.
- Uses the confirmed schedule and an appropriate adult route without unsafe interaction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner cannot locate a quotation after one search and declares it certainly invented. The case contains no original transcript or other resolving evidence.
4A · Matching
Match each statement with its status.
Complete or match: One search found no original; The quotation is certainly fabricated; Seek date and original archive
- a: Limited search result
- b: Not established by that result
- c: Useful further verification
- d: Copies settle the exact wording
A failed search is not conclusive proof that no original exists.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and propose a better conclusion with a next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats a limited search as proof of invention. Say the attribution is unconfirmed and seek the speech date, context or a relevant archive.
- Explains why one failed search does not prove fabrication.
- States uncertainty and proposes a targeted original-source search.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants an invented weather bulletin for a storytelling exercise. It must not be mistaken for a real warning, and it should identify its teaching purpose.
5A · Dropdown selection
Match each design choice with its purpose.
Complete or match: Fictional practice label; Story-lesson explanation; No real-warning claim
- a: Use an authentic emergency seal to look real
- b: Avoids false official presentation
- c: Identifies educational purpose
- d: Establishes invented status
Clear context makes an invented teaching document interpretable.
5B · Open ended
Propose a heading and a sharing note that keep the bulletin transparent.
Example of a full-credit answer: Heading: Fictional weather bulletin for our story lesson. Note: These events are invented; do not share this as a real weather warning.
- Provides a clear fiction label and educational purpose in the heading.
- Provides a note preserving fictional status and avoiding real-warning misrepresentation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.18 · Recognising deepfakes
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An explicit production record
Fictional classroom example
A fictional project log confirms that a consented actor’s face was AI-altered for a scene labelled “synthetic demonstration.”
Question: Does the record establish AI alteration?
Answer: Yes, for this scene.
Why: The disclosed production record supplies evidence; labelling and permission are separate context.
Example 2 · A blurry edge
Fictional classroom example
A fictional clip has a blurry edge but no origin record.
Question: Does blur prove a deepfake?
Answer: No. Compression or other recording problems can cause blur.
Why: Appearance alone does not settle the creation method.
Example 3 · A supposed announcement
Fictional classroom example
An unfamiliar fictional clip claims a teacher cancelled class. The teacher’s known channel says no cancellation was issued.
Question: What should the pupil do?
Answer: Use the known school information and ask a trusted adult about the clip.
Why: A claim-specific check is stronger than guessing from the face.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A perfect-looking clip
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional video looks smooth and realistic, but no original recording or production record is supplied.
F1 · True or false
True or false? Realistic appearance alone establishes that the event was recorded as shown.
- true: True
- false: False
Synthetic media can be realistic; origin and event evidence are needed.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · A confirmed production method
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional studio record states that AI replaced an actor’s face in a scene, with permission and a synthetic label. The record is verified.
F2 · Multiple choice
What establishes AI face alteration in this case?
- a: The scene’s popularity
- b: The colour of its frame
- c: The verified production log
- d: A guess about the actor’s blinking
The production record directly states the method.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · Find the useful verification route
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional clip appears to show a headteacher announcing a trip change. Options are A: known school notice and teacher confirmation, B: count likes, C: guess from lip motion, D: trust the loudest comment.
F3 · Hotspot
Which is the strongest next check for the trip instruction?
- a: B: number of likes
- b: D: the loudest comment
- c: C: a lip-motion guess alone
- d: A: the known school channel and teacher
The known school route can confirm what instruction was actually issued.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Different evidence roles
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional media case has a creation log, a detector score and an independent event record.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each clue with its proper role.
Complete or match: Creation log; Detector score; Independent event record
- a: Limited automated clue
- b: Evidence about the claimed event
- c: Guaranteed truth from a percentage
- d: Evidence about production history
The clues address different questions and have limits.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A detector accusation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional detector labels a pupil’s genuine class recording “likely synthetic.” The case explicitly states the original recording is genuine and the detector is wrong.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what this case shows about detector results and propose a fair response.
Example of a full-credit answer: A detector can produce a false alarm. Check the original recording and relevant records, and do not accuse the pupil from the score alone.
- Recognises the detector’s false positive and limited certainty.
- Proposes evidence checking without an unsupported accusation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
Four fictional cases are supplied: A a verified AI face replacement presented as a real statement the actor did not make; B an ordinary brightness adjustment; C a labelled cartoon; D a blurry unverified clip.
1A · Multiple choice
Which case establishes the impersonating AI alteration described?
- a: B: brightness adjustment only
- b: C: labelled fictional cartoon
- c: A: verified AI face replacement and false statement presentation
- d: D: blur without production evidence
A supplies the relevant creation and presentation facts; blur alone does not.
1B · Short answer
Explain why A fits and why D remains unconfirmed.
Example of a full-credit answer: A’s verified log shows AI replacement used to make a person appear to state something they did not. D has only blur, which does not establish how the clip was made.
- Connects A’s verified AI impersonation method with the definition.
- Explains the evidential limit of D’s appearance clue.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional audio-video post claims a school manager changed pickup arrangements. The safe sources are the school’s known notice, a trusted teacher and the original full announcement if available.
2A · Matching
Match each check with what it helps establish.
Complete or match: Current school notice; Trusted teacher; Full announcement
- a: Official arrangement
- b: Whether an excerpt lost context
- c: Confirmation through a known person
- d: The most realistic face wins
The plan checks the instruction and context through suitable routes.
2B · Open ended
Explain why a known school route and the full announcement are useful for different reasons.
Example of a full-credit answer: The known route can confirm the actual arrangement. The full announcement can show whether a short excerpt omitted conditions or changed meaning.
- Explains the value of an independently known authority for the arrangement.
- Explains the role of full context in evaluating a clip.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unknown voice message sounds like a teacher and requests a pupil’s account secret. No real secret is shown. The known school channel has no such request.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which responses are appropriate?
- a: Send a real secret to test the voice.
- b: Keep the secret private and verify through a trusted adult.
- c: Voice similarity alone should not establish identity.
- d: A familiar voice makes every request safe.
A voice can be imitated; the requested secret should stay private.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the voice is insufficient and give a safe next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: A similar voice can be imitated and does not independently verify the sender. Keep the account secret private and ask a trusted adult using the known school route.
- Separates voice resemblance from verified identity.
- Protects the secret and uses an independent trusted verification route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional clip has a verified provenance record identifying its creator and edits. Its spoken claim says 4 + 4 = 9.
4A · True or false
True or false? The provenance record changes the correct sum from 8 to 9.
- true: True
- false: False
Production history cannot make an incorrect factual claim accurate.
4B · Open ended
Explain what the provenance record verifies and correct the separate factual claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: It verifies the recorded creator/edit history. The arithmetic still gives 8, so the spoken 9 is wrong.
- States provenance’s origin/history scope.
- Corrects 4 + 4 to 8 and keeps accuracy separate from provenance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a teacher-approved synthetic avatar for an imaginary story. It must use an authorised likeness or original character, disclose synthesis and avoid real-world impersonation claims.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each safeguard to its role.
Complete or match: Authorised likeness or original character; Imaginary-story label; Synthetic-avatar disclosure
- a: Respect representation and permission
- b: Explain production method
- c: Clarify fictional context
- d: Realism removes the need for disclosure
A safe demo makes its permissions, method and context clear.
5B · Open ended
Propose a two-sentence introduction that identifies the demo’s fictional nature and production safeguards.
Example of a full-credit answer: This is a synthetic-avatar demonstration for an imaginary story, not a real announcement. We use an original character or an appropriately authorised likeness and disclose the AI assistance.
- Clearly labels the synthetic method and fictional context.
- Includes authorised/original representation and avoids misleading real-person attribution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.19 · Recognising manipulated images
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The missing helpers
Fictional classroom example
A fictional full scene shows rubbish and people collecting it. A crop removes all helpers.
Question: Why could “Nobody helps” be misleading?
Answer: The full scene includes helpers.
Why: The crop hides evidence directly relevant to the caption.
Example 2 · A harmless margin crop
Fictional classroom example
A fictional worksheet photograph is cropped only to remove a blank border; every answer remains visible.
Question: Does this necessarily distort its answers?
Answer: No. The relevant content remains.
Why: Not all image edits change the evidence being used.
Example 3 · Two scenes combined
Fictional classroom example
A fictional art poster combines a mountain and a city and labels itself “Imaginary collage.”
Question: Is it claiming one real photograph?
Answer: No. Its combined nature is disclosed.
Why: Context distinguishes creative composition from false documentary presentation.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the missing context
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional full photo shows a queue on the left and two open service desks on the right. A left-only crop is captioned “No desk is open.”
F1 · Hotspot
Which full-scene detail contradicts the crop’s caption?
- a: The image’s rectangular shape
- b: The colour of the frame
- c: The existence of a queue
- d: The two open desks on the right
The omitted desks are directly relevant to whether any desk is open.
Investigation: crop media lab
F2 · A disclosed brightness edit
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional edit log says a photo’s brightness was increased so labels are readable. The objects and labels remain unchanged.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which interpretation matches the supplied log?
- a: Proof that the scene never existed
- b: A guaranteed deceptive deepfake
- c: Proof that all labels were invented
- d: A readability edit, with no stated object change
The log identifies a limited edit; it does not establish deception.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · Match edits to effects
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional records describe A cropping away a date label, B combining two different scenes, and C changing a caption from Park A to Park B.
F3 · Matching
Match each change with its direct effect.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Combines separate scenes
- b: Hides time context
- c: Changes the stated location
- d: Automatically proves the editor’s motive
Effects can be identified without guessing private intentions.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · What appearance can establish
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional image has an odd shadow, but no original or edit record is supplied. Another image has a verified log of an added tree.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions are justified?
- a: Every odd shadow proves AI generation.
- b: The verified log establishes the added tree in the second image.
- c: The odd shadow alone does not prove how the first image was made.
- d: A smooth image can never be edited.
Production evidence is stronger than unsupported visual certainty.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A full scene and a claim
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional scene has three planted beds and one bare bed. A crop shows only the bare bed and is captioned “The whole garden is empty.”
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the caption overreaches and write a caption consistent with the full scene.
Example of a full-credit answer: The crop shows one bare bed but omits three planted beds. A correct caption is “One bed is bare and three are planted.”
- Identifies the cropped-out planted beds and the unsupported whole-garden claim.
- Provides a caption accurately including the one-bare/three-planted context.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: crop media lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional original shows six people. A verified edit log says two people were digitally removed. The edited image is presented as a count of the original gathering.
1A · Multiple choice
Which count describes the original supplied scene?
- a: Six people
- b: Any count is equally supported
- c: Two people
- d: Four people because only four remain after editing
The original record has six; the edit removed two from view.
1B · Open ended
Explain why counting the edited image would misdescribe the original gathering and state the correct count.
Example of a full-credit answer: The edited image omits two of the six original people, so its four visible people are not the original count. The original gathering shown contains six.
- Explains how removal changes the available count evidence.
- States six as the original count and distinguishes it from four after editing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional photo claims to show a flooded courtyard today. Available checks include the original file’s date/place and the school’s current courtyard report. Likes and an image filter do not report the event.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which checks directly address the claim?
- a: Count likes as proof of flooding.
- b: Inspect the relevant original date and place.
- c: Compare with the school’s current courtyard report.
- d: Decide solely from the filter colour.
The claim concerns both image origin and a current condition.
2B · Open ended
Explain how the two useful checks answer different parts of the claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The original record helps establish where and when the image was made. The current report checks whether the courtyard is flooded today.
- Connects original provenance to date/place.
- Connects current independent information to today’s condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class combines a sea photograph, a drawn moon and a photograph of a toy boat into an art poster. It labels the poster “Imaginary collage.”
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each part with its stated source.
Complete or match: Sea; Moon; Boat
- a: Photograph of a toy boat
- b: One untouched voyage photograph
- c: Sea photograph
- d: Drawing of a moon
The elements come from different sources and are transparently combined.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the collage is not an untouched event photograph and write a useful label.
Example of a full-credit answer: It combines separate media rather than capturing one voyage. Label it “Imaginary collage using a sea picture, drawn moon and toy boat.”
- Explains that combining sources differs from one documentary capture.
- Provides a clear composite/fiction label retaining the relevant source elements.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional image is resized to fit a screen without removing any content or changing the caption. A learner calls it false solely because it was edited.
4A · True or false
True or false? Resizing alone proves the image is deceptive.
- true: True
- false: False
Editing methods have different effects; this record supplies no deceptive change.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overly broad rule and explain the relevant question to ask about an edit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats every edit as deception. Ask whether the change alters relevant content or context and how the image is presented.
- Rejects the claim that every edit necessarily makes content false.
- Focuses evaluation on meaning/context changes and presentation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class crops blank margins from a documentary event photo and makes a second poster by combining two scenes. The publication should explain meaningful changes and preserve accurate captions, including the event photo’s relevant date and place.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each image use with its appropriate note.
Complete or match: Blank-margin crop; Two-scene poster; Documentary event photo
- a: Composite illustration
- b: All images must be treated as live events
- c: Keep relevant date and place
- d: Relevant content retained after margin crop
Different uses need accurate context and method descriptions.
5B · Open ended
Write a note for the composite and explain one context detail to preserve for the event photo.
Example of a full-credit answer: This illustration combines two separate scenes and is not a single event photograph. Preserve the event photo’s relevant date and place so readers do not mistake its context.
- Clearly discloses the composite’s separate-scene nature.
- Explains preservation of a relevant date/place/context detail for documentary use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.20 · Recognising synthetic audio and video
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A useful computer voice
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class uses text-to-speech to read a verified exhibition guide and labels the narration.
Question: Is synthetic narration necessarily deceptive?
Answer: No. Its use is disclosed and the underlying text can be checked.
Why: Generation method and factual accuracy are separate questions.
Example 2 · A missing word
Fictional classroom example
A fictional full statement says “Do not enter the wet room.” An excerpt removes “Do not.”
Question: What changes?
Answer: The instruction is reversed.
Why: Ordinary cutting can mislead without generating new speech.
Example 3 · Natural sound
Fictional classroom example
A fictional clip sounds human, but no origin record is supplied.
Question: Does that prove a human recorded those words?
Answer: No. Sound alone does not establish production history.
Why: Relevant records or original-source confirmation are needed.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find a disclosed method
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional audio guide shows A: “Computer-generated voice reading our approved script,” B: a volume icon, C: a star count, D: a colourful background.
F1 · Hotspot
Which detail explicitly establishes the stated narration method?
- a: C: star count
- b: B: volume icon
- c: D: colourful background
- d: A: computer-generated voice disclosure
The production note states how the narration was created.
Investigation: provenance lab
F2 · Different media operations
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional records show A: a computer reads typed text, B: an editor removes the middle of a genuine recording, C: a camera records a speaker without the stated edits.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each case to its supplied method.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Every case has the same production method
- b: Recorded performance
- c: Excerpt editing
- d: Synthetic narration
The method must follow the supplied record, not appearance.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A condition removed
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional full statement says “The garden is open. If heavy rain begins, go indoors. Ask the teacher before returning.” An excerpt keeps only the first sentence.
F3 · Matching
Match each part with its role in the complete instruction.
Complete or match: Garden is open; If heavy rain begins, go indoors; Ask before returning
- a: Current starting condition
- b: Safety condition
- c: Open under every possible condition
- d: Required adult check
The full message limits the opening statement.
Investigation: clip lab
F4 · A robotic voice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional recording sounds robotic after compression. The verified capture record says it is a person’s genuine recording.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion fits the supplied evidence?
- a: All compressed audio is fictional
- b: The speaker’s words are automatically true
- c: The robotic sound does not override the genuine capture record
- d: Every robotic sound proves AI generation
Processing can affect sound without generating the performance.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · Synthetic voice, wrong sum
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional disclosed computer narrator reads “Three plus four equals eight.” The approved arithmetic task is 3 + 4.
F5 · Short answer
Correct the factual error and explain why the production disclosure does not settle accuracy.
Example of a full-credit answer: Three plus four equals seven. Saying the voice is computer-generated explains how it was spoken, not whether the arithmetic is correct.
- Corrects the sum to seven.
- Distinguishes disclosed synthetic production from factual verification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional guide uses a disclosed synthetic voice reading a human-checked script. Its schedule facts match the organiser’s record, but its pronunciation has not been reviewed.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions are supported?
- a: Pronunciation still needs review.
- b: The narration method is disclosed.
- c: Synthetic voice makes all schedule facts false.
- d: A checked script guarantees every spoken word is pronounced correctly.
Production disclosure and review status establish different parts of quality.
1B · Open ended
Explain one established strength and one remaining check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The narration is transparently disclosed and the script’s schedule was checked. Listen/read along to review pronunciation and confirm that the audio matches the script.
- Identifies a supplied strength such as disclosure or checked schedule facts.
- Identifies pronunciation/audio-to-script review as a remaining task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional full statement says “We considered cancelling the walk, but decided to continue on Friday.” A short excerpt includes only “cancelling the walk.”
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Considered cancelling; Decided to continue; On Friday
- a: An option discussed
- b: The actual decision
- c: The planned day
- d: The walk was definitely cancelled
The excerpt removes the contrast that states the final decision.
2B · Open ended
Explain the misleading excerpt and give a faithful summary of the whole statement.
Example of a full-credit answer: It presents a considered option without the actual decision. The group considered cancellation but decided the walk would continue on Friday.
- Identifies omission of the final decision as the distortion.
- Summarises continuation on Friday while preserving that cancellation was only considered.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional animation shows a proposed future school garden. A verified production note says it was generated from a design sketch. It is not a recording of a completed garden.
3A · Hotspot
Which label accurately describes the evidence?
- a: Generated preview of a proposed garden
- b: Live recording of a completed garden
- c: Proof the garden already benefits everyone
- d: A real-time camera feed
The animation visualises a proposal rather than documenting completion.
3B · Open ended
Explain the distinction between a design preview and evidence of completion.
Example of a full-credit answer: The generated animation shows what a proposed design could look like. It does not establish that construction occurred; a current site record would be needed.
- Identifies the animation as a proposal visualisation.
- States that real completion needs separate current evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unknown audio message sounds exactly like a coach and asks a pupil to reveal a secret code. There is no verified request through the club’s known channel.
4A · Matching
Match each feature with its interpretation.
Complete or match: Familiar sound; Secret-code request; Known adult route
- a: Resemblance, not independent identity proof
- b: Safer independent verification path
- c: Reason to protect information and seek help
- d: Natural sound guarantees safety
Realistic synthesis and imitation make independent checking important.
4B · Open ended
Identify the faulty inference and give a safe response without using any real code.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil would be mistaking voice resemblance for verified identity. Keep the code private and ask a trusted adult through the known club channel.
- Explains that familiar sound does not establish identity or authorisation.
- Protects the secret and uses an independent adult-supported check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class uses synthetic narration for a checked report whose approved script says “Twelve seedlings grew in our recorded class trial.” It plans a production note, accurate transcript and review of spoken facts. No real person’s voice is copied. The prepared message preview shows the report wording with a text alternative and caption.
5A · True or false
True or false? A clear production note and accurate transcript help readers interpret and access the synthetic report.
- true: True
- false: False
They disclose the method and provide text access, while factual review remains necessary.
5B · Open ended
Propose the production note and explain a review step for the transcript or audio.
Example of a full-credit answer: This report uses synthetic narration of our class-checked text. Compare the audio and transcript with the approved script, correcting numbers, omissions and meaningful pronunciation errors.
- Provides a clear synthetic-narration disclosure.
- Describes a concrete audio/transcript-to-script accuracy check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.21 · Recognising artificial intelligence-generated text
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The formal-style guess
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil uses careful grammar. Someone says this proves a machine wrote the paragraph.
Question: Is the conclusion supported?
Answer: No. Human writers can use careful grammar too.
Why: Style alone cannot establish authorship.
Example 2 · A disclosed mixed process
Fictional classroom example
A fictional process note says “AI suggested an outline; Lina wrote the final examples.”
Question: What can be concluded?
Answer: The disclosed process includes both AI assistance and Lina’s contribution.
Why: The note should be described accurately without extending it to unrecorded steps.
Example 3 · A wrong cited fact
Fictional classroom example
A fictional AI-assisted answer says a class counted 30 trees, but the cited tally lists 23.
Question: What needs correction?
Answer: The count should be 23.
Why: The factual check concerns the tally, regardless of how the sentence was drafted.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A style-only judgment
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional paragraph has headings, correct spelling and formal words. No process record or disclosure is supplied.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is warranted?
- a: The facts must all be false
- b: Human authorship is proved
- c: Authorship is not established by these style features
- d: AI authorship is proved
The features can appear in human, generated and mixed writing.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · A wrong detector flag
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom case explicitly records a pupil writing a paragraph unaided. A detector mistakenly labels it likely AI-generated.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which statements fit the case?
- a: The detector produced a false positive.
- b: Every human paragraph must receive a zero score.
- c: The score overrides the verified writing record.
- d: The score alone should not be treated as proof of cheating.
Detector estimates can be wrong; the case supplies stronger process evidence.
Investigation: message lab
F3 · Different writing contributions
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional project log says AI suggested headings, Neri wrote the paragraphs and Paolo checked quotations against originals.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each contribution with its supplied contributor.
Complete or match: Heading suggestions; Paragraph writing; Quotation verification
- a: Every stage was completed by one unknown source
- b: Paolo
- c: Neri
- d: AI tool
The log records a mixed process with distinct roles.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · Check a generated answer
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional generated answer says an event is Monday, has 14 participants and is in Hall B. The actual record says Monday, 12 participants and Hall B.
F4 · Matching
Match each answer part to its checked status.
Complete or match: Monday; 14 participants; Hall B
- a: Incorrect count; record says 12
- b: Supported venue
- c: One error makes every other statement false
- d: Supported day
Checking can identify correct and incorrect parts separately.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A convincing-looking reference
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI-generated answer gives a book title and page number. No book record or page is available in the case.
F5 · Open ended
State what remains unverified and propose two parts of a proper citation check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The source’s existence and support for the claim remain unverified. Locate the actual publication, then read the relevant page to see whether it supports the sentence.
- Identifies the need to establish that the cited source actually exists.
- Identifies the separate need to inspect whether it supports the associated claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: search results lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional essay openly discloses AI drafting help but states that 8 + 5 = 14. The calculation is directly checkable.
1A · True or false
True or false? Disclosing AI assistance makes the incorrect arithmetic accurate.
- true: True
- false: False
Transparency about the process does not change arithmetic.
1B · Short answer
Correct the calculation and explain the distinct purpose of the disclosure.
Example of a full-credit answer: Eight plus five is thirteen. The disclosure tells readers AI helped draft the text; it does not verify the calculation.
- Corrects the total to 13.
- Separates production transparency from factual accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher reviews whether a pupil used permitted AI brainstorming. Available evidence includes the pupil’s disclosed process log and dated drafts. Other clues are fancy vocabulary and a detector guess.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which are useful parts of a fair process review?
- a: Inspect relevant dated drafts and the pupil’s explanation.
- b: Discuss the disclosed process log.
- c: Treat fancy words as proof of misconduct.
- d: Treat a detector estimate as an unquestionable verdict.
Process evidence and a fair explanation are more useful than automatic style accusations.
2B · Open ended
Explain why process records are useful and state a limit that prevents overclaiming.
Example of a full-credit answer: Logs and drafts can show how work developed and which assistance was disclosed. They should be considered with the pupil’s explanation; no single missing or present feature proves every part of authorship.
- Explains the relevance of records to the writing process.
- States a valid limitation and avoids automatic guilt from absence or a detector score.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil writes an original paragraph, then uses a permitted AI tool to suggest a translation. The pupil and teacher check the meaning. The log records these steps.
3A · Hotspot
Which description matches the process?
- a: Human original writing with disclosed AI translation assistance and review
- b: No AI assistance occurred
- c: AI independently wrote every original idea
- d: Translation review proves every unrelated fact
The record separates original composition, assistance and review.
3B · Short answer
Write a transparent contribution note and identify what the review checked.
Example of a full-credit answer: I wrote the original paragraph and used AI to suggest a translation. My teacher and I checked that the translated meaning matched the original.
- Accurately distinguishes human original writing from AI translation assistance.
- States the meaning-consistency check without claiming unlimited verification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional AI-assisted text cites a report. One limited catalogue search finds no match. A learner declares the report certainly invented; no wider archive check is available.
4A · Multiple choice
Which conclusion fits the available evidence?
- a: The reference is unverified and needs further checking
- b: The citation proves the whole paragraph
- c: The report is certainly genuine
- d: The report is certainly invented
Failure to find a source in a limited search is not definitive proof of nonexistence.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and propose a better next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner turns a limited search failure into certainty. Seek the author, publisher or relevant archive and inspect the original if found; until then mark the citation unverified.
- Explains the limitation of the search and rejects unwarranted certainty.
- Proposes a targeted source-verification step while preserving uncertainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class permits AI brainstorming but requires pupils to write final explanations and check numbers. A pupil used AI for topic ideas, wrote the explanation and verified totals against a tally.
5A · Dropdown selection
Match each note part to its role.
Complete or match: AI suggested topic ideas; I wrote the explanation; Checked totals against tally
- a: A claim that every possible error is impossible
- b: Human contribution
- c: Assistance disclosure
- d: Factual verification step
The note describes actual work and evidence checks.
5B · Open ended
Write the contribution note and explain why it should avoid “AI checked everything.”
Example of a full-credit answer: AI suggested topic ideas; I wrote the final explanation and checked the totals against the original tally. “AI checked everything” overstates the recorded process and hides the pupil’s responsibility.
- Includes the supplied AI role, human writing and tally check accurately.
- Explains why the sweeping verification claim is unsupported or obscures responsibility.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.22 · Lateral reading
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A self-description checked elsewhere
Fictional classroom example
A fictional review site says it is independent. A verified ownership record shows a seller owns it.
Question: What does lateral reading reveal?
Answer: A commercial connection omitted from the self-description.
Why: The outside record adds information not established by the site’s own claim.
Example 2 · Several pages, one source
Fictional classroom example
A fictional learner opens five pages that all belong to one publisher.
Question: Are these five independent checks?
Answer: No. The pages share an owner and may share evidence.
Why: Tab count is not source independence.
Example 3 · Trace a shortened claim
Fictional classroom example
A fictional blog says a study proves all pupils prefer online games. The original study concerns one small class.
Question: What should the reader report?
Answer: The blog’s universal claim exceeds the study’s scope.
Why: The original allows the summary to be checked.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Plan a lateral check
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unfamiliar page claims “We are run by a school.” The checking plan is to note the operator name, consult a relevant independent school record and compare the findings.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each stage with its action.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Only inspect the page’s colours
- b: Compare with the original claim
- c: Check an independent relevant record
- d: Identify the claimed operator
Lateral reading seeks relevant information outside the original page.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Choose the outside check
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional site claims to be a museum. A: a verified museum directory lists registered museums; B: the site repeats its own claim; C: the site’s shop; D: its decorative banner.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which is the most useful outside check of the claimed operator?
- a: C: the same site’s shop
- b: D: the decorative banner
- c: B: the same site’s repeated claim
- d: A: the relevant independent museum directory
The directory can supply independent relevant information about status.
Investigation: search results lab
F3 · Useful lateral-reading moves
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post claims a study found that every pupil likes chess. The linked study and an independent discussion of its method are available.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions help evaluate the claim?
- a: Count repeated copies as separate studies.
- b: Treat the blog’s colours as proof.
- c: Inspect relevant independent analysis of the method.
- d: Read the original study’s sample and result.
These checks address the actual evidence and its interpretation.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Find the source behind copies
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional result list has A: an original school timetable, B and C: copies of that timetable, D: a comment with no source.
F4 · Hotspot
Which record is the original issuing source for the times?
- a: D: unsourced comment
- b: B: copied timetable
- c: C: another copied timetable
- d: A: school timetable
The origin trail identifies A as the issuing record.
Investigation: origin lab
F5 · An operator claim outside the page
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional product-review site calls itself independent. A verified ownership record says the product maker owns the site. No evidence yet settles the product’s quality.
F5 · Short answer
State the lateral-reading finding and explain what it does not by itself prove about product quality.
Example of a full-credit answer: The outside record establishes a maker ownership connection, contradicting the independence claim. That connection does not alone prove the product is good or bad; quality needs relevant tests.
- Identifies the outside ownership finding and its conflict with independence.
- Separates commercial connection from automatic conclusions about product performance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: provenance lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unfamiliar club page makes claims about its owner, an event time and a quoted report. Suitable outside records are a verified operator listing, organiser schedule and original report.
1A · Dropdown selection
Match each question with its most direct record.
Complete or match: Who operates the page?; When is the event?; What did the report actually say?
- a: Current organiser schedule
- b: Operator listing
- c: The page’s font size
- d: Original report
Each outside check targets a particular claim.
1B · Short answer
Explain two checks and the specific questions each would answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: The operator listing helps identify who runs the page. The original report checks whether the page accurately represented its findings; the schedule separately checks time.
- Correctly links one outside record to its exact question.
- Correctly links a second distinct record to a different question.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional page describes itself as the town’s official nature archive. Its own pages all repeat that claim. A verified town directory lists a different organisation, Field Centre, as the official archive.
2A · Multiple choice
Which finding adds the most relevant outside evidence?
- a: Its logo is larger
- b: The verified town directory identifies Field Centre
- c: The same-site FAQ repeats it again
- d: The unfamiliar site repeats its label
The independent directory can test the claimed official status.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the directory is a lateral check and why repetition on the original site is weaker.
Example of a full-credit answer: The directory is outside the source and gives relevant official-status information. Repetition within the same site does not independently verify its claim.
- Identifies the outside, relevant nature of the directory check.
- Explains the lack of independence in same-site repetition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional screenshot claims a park is closed but hides the date and original page. The park’s known current notice is available.
3A · True or false
True or false? Lateral reading can include checking the park’s known current notice outside the screenshot.
- true: True
- false: False
The current issuing source helps restore missing date and context.
3B · Open ended
Describe a useful outside check and explain why the screenshot alone is insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the park’s current notice through its known source. The screenshot hides its date and original context, so it may concern another period.
- Proposes the current known issuing source as a targeted check.
- Explains the missing date/origin limitation of the screenshot.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional learner opens four reports. All four cite the same company press release, and none conducts a separate test. The learner calls them four independent confirmations.
4A · Matching
Match each description with its proper conclusion.
Complete or match: Four reports; One shared release; No separate test
- a: Independent performance confirmation missing
- b: Four independent experiments
- c: One underlying source
- d: Four presentations of a claim
Lateral reading must inspect source relationships, not tab counts.
4B · Open ended
Explain the learner’s error and propose a check that would add different evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The four reports depend on one release, so they are not four independent tests. Seek a suitable separately conducted product test with its method and results.
- Identifies shared origin and the false independence count.
- Proposes a genuinely independent, claim-relevant evidence source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class must evaluate an unfamiliar learning app page. It wants to know the operator and whether a learning-result claim matches the cited study. Purchases and real logins are unnecessary.
5A · Hotspot
Which plan directly addresses both questions?
- a: Verify the operator externally and compare the claim with the original study
- b: Count app advertisements
- c: Inspect only colours and animations
- d: Ask for pupils’ passwords to investigate
The selected plan checks source identity and supporting evidence without unnecessary data.
5B · Open ended
Propose two concrete outside checks and explain what to record in the conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the operator in a relevant independent record and read the original study’s sample/results. Record which app claims match those findings and any scope limits or unresolved details.
- Proposes both operator verification and original-study comparison.
- Explains a conclusion based on support, limits and uncertainty rather than an unqualified trust label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.23 · Source triangulation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Three articles, one release
Fictional classroom example
Three fictional articles all cite the same shop announcement and conduct no tests.
Question: How many testing origins exist?
Answer: No independent test is supplied; the claim has one announcement origin.
Why: Different publications do not create independent evidence.
Example 2 · Different definitions
Fictional classroom example
A fictional event report counts 30 pupils; another counts 36 people including six adults.
Question: Must one report be wrong?
Answer: No. Their definitions differ.
Why: Thirty pupils plus six adults is consistent with 36 people.
Example 3 · Agreement with limits
Fictional classroom example
Two fictional groups independently count 12 trees in one courtyard.
Question: What is supported?
Answer: Agreement on 12 trees in that courtyard at the recorded time.
Why: The agreement does not establish tree counts in every courtyard.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify source relationships
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional Record A is an original bus schedule listing an 8 a.m. departure, B copies A, and C independently records a bus leaving at 8 a.m. on the observed day.
F1 · Matching
Match each record with its origin role.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Separate observed departure record
- b: Copy of the issuing schedule
- c: Original issuing schedule
- d: Three independent schedules
The records have different origins and evidential scopes.
Investigation: origin lab
F2 · Choose comparable sources
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task asks how many pupils attended today’s class event. Available records are today’s pupil register, last year’s attendance, today’s snack count and an unrelated sports ranking.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which most directly answers the stated attendance question?
- a: Today’s pupil attendance register
- b: Last year’s attendance
- c: Today’s snack portions alone
- d: Unrelated sports ranking
It matches the date, group and quantity asked about.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Two independent counts
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional teams A and B separately count chairs in the same room at the same time. Both record 18. A blog then copies A’s result.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions fit the records?
- a: Two independently collected counts agree on 18 chairs.
- b: Three independent counts were conducted.
- c: The agreement proves every room has 18 chairs.
- d: The blog adds a copy rather than a third count.
Agreement concerns this room and these two original counts.
Investigation: origin lab
F4 · Find the definition difference
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional Record A counts 24 pupils at a visit. Record B counts 28 people, explicitly including those pupils and four adults. Other panels show font, likes and border.
F4 · Hotspot
Which detail explains why 24 and 28 can both be accurate?
- a: A uses a different font
- b: B includes four adults as well as the pupils
- c: The border is wider
- d: B has more likes
The populations counted differ; 24 + 4 = 28.
Investigation: graph lab
F5 · An unresolved conflict
Fixed fictional classroom case
Two fictional current records give different opening times for the same workshop: Record A says 1 p.m. and Record B says 2 p.m. Both are dated today; their authority and update order are unclear. No organiser confirmation is supplied.
F5 · Short answer
State the appropriate level of certainty and propose the check that would best resolve the conflict.
Example of a full-credit answer: The opening time remains unresolved from these records. Ask the organiser through a known channel or locate its authoritative current notice, checking update order.
- Preserves uncertainty instead of choosing arbitrarily or by appearance.
- Proposes a relevant organiser/update-order check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: evidence lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional posts A, B and C all copy one park tally. Record D is a separate tally by another group. The two groups separately counted the same park this morning, and both underlying tallies report 14 benches.
1A · Multiple choice
How many independently collected tally origins are supplied?
- a: One because all agree
- b: Fourteen
- c: Four
- d: Two
The three dependent posts share tally 1; D supplies tally 2.
1B · Open ended
Explain the origin count and give a conclusion limited to the supplied evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are two independent tallies: A/B/C depend on the first and D supplies the second. Both support 14 benches in the counted park at the recorded time.
- Correctly traces the dependent posts and counts two original tallies.
- States agreement on 14 benches with appropriate place/time scope.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional old notice says a meeting is at 4 p.m.; five sites copy it. A current verified organiser update changes it to 3 p.m.
2A · True or false
True or false? Five copies of the old notice outweigh the current verified update simply because there are more pages.
- true: True
- false: False
The copies share outdated information; the current issuing update addresses the change.
2B · Open ended
Explain why page majority is misleading and state the current supported time.
Example of a full-credit answer: The five copies are not independent current decisions. The verified organiser update supersedes them and gives 3 p.m.
- Identifies dependency and outdated status as reasons not to vote by page count.
- Uses the current update to give 3 p.m.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional fair sold 40 tickets, scanned 35 at entry and served 32 snack portions. These records count different things.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each quantity with what it directly measures.
Complete or match: 40; 35; 32
- a: Entry scans
- b: Forty independently confirmed attendees
- c: Snack portions
- d: Tickets sold
The measures cannot be substituted without additional assumptions.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the snack count is not automatically attendance and identify the more direct attendance-related record.
Example of a full-credit answer: Some attendees may not take a snack, so 32 portions need not equal people attending. Entry scans are more directly related to attendance, though repeated or missing scans would still need checking.
- Explains a reasonable difference between snack portions and attendance.
- Selects entry scans while acknowledging relevant counting limitations.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
Two fictional science blogs report the same result from one original experiment. A third source independently repeats the method but gets a different result. A learner ignores it because two blogs agree.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each issue to its interpretation.
Complete or match: Two agreeing blogs; Different replication result; Ignoring the replication
- a: Selective use of evidence
- b: Agreement by copies settles the science
- c: One shared experimental origin
- d: Independent evidence requiring investigation
The independent conflict matters and should be examined rather than outvoted.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s mistake and propose a useful comparison between the experiments.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner counts copies as independent and ignores conflicting evidence. Compare the methods, conditions, measurements and uncertainty to investigate the different results.
- Identifies the false independence count or selective dismissal of the separate replication.
- Proposes a relevant method/condition/measurement comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class checks a claim that a new sign reduced wrong-door visits. It can inspect its own before/after count, a separately kept reception log and a survey of visitors. The case records three specific limitations: the class tally used before/after periods of different lengths; the reception log omits visits that were not reported to reception; the survey relies on selected visitors’ memories.
5A · Matching
Match each record with the specific limitation reported in this case.
Complete or match: Before/after tally; Reception log; Visitor survey
- a: Unreported visits may be missing
- b: Before/after periods have different lengths
- c: Responses may reflect memory or sample limits
- d: All three measures are identical
Complementary records can help while retaining different limitations.
5B · Open ended
Propose a conclusion rule using at least two independent records and explain how to handle disagreement.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare the class tally with the separately kept reception log for similar periods, using the survey as additional context. If they disagree, inspect definitions and missing records rather than declaring a majority winner.
- Uses at least two distinct relevant evidence origins.
- Explains an appropriate investigation of disagreement or limits instead of simple voting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL4.24 · Fact-checking
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A checkable part
Fictional classroom example
A fictional post says “Our wonderful fair starts at ten.”
Question: Which part can be checked against a schedule?
Answer: The ten o’clock start time.
Why: Wonderful expresses a judgment; the time is a factual claim.
Example 2 · Partly right
Fictional classroom example
A fictional notice gives Friday and 20 participants. The record gives Friday and 18.
Question: How should the result be described?
Answer: The day is supported; the participant count needs correction to 18.
Why: Do not label every part correct or incorrect together.
Example 3 · Unresolved evidence
Fictional classroom example
A fictional claim gives a private meeting’s attendance, but no relevant record is available.
Question: Should a checker invent a likely number?
Answer: No. Mark the attendance unverified and seek an appropriate record.
Why: A fact-check can honestly end with an unresolved finding.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the checkable claim
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional event post has A: “The most delightful day,” B: “Starts Saturday at 9 a.m.,” C: “Our favourite colours,” D: “An exciting atmosphere.”
F1 · Hotspot
Which statement can be checked directly against an event schedule?
- a: D: exciting atmosphere
- b: A: most delightful day
- c: B: Saturday at 9 a.m.
- d: C: favourite colours
The day and time are specific factual details.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · A search result is a starting point
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional search result snippet says a park opens at 7. The full current park notice has not been inspected.
F2 · True or false
True or false? The snippet alone establishes that the park currently opens at 7.
- true: True
- false: False
The original notice and applicable date still need checking.
Investigation: verification lab
F3 · Put the check in sequence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional claim says 11 books were returned. The tally shows 6 in one box and 4 in another. The routine is identify claim, inspect tally, calculate and conclude.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each stage with its result.
Complete or match: Original claim; Relevant tally; Checked conclusion
- a: Popularity settles the sum
- b: 11 books
- c: 10 books
- d: 6 and 4 books
A calculation from relevant evidence gives the correction.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · Different verdicts for one notice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional notice says Tuesday, Hall D, 30 participants. The record confirms Tuesday and Hall D; no participant count is available.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each claim part to its current status.
Complete or match: Tuesday; Hall D; 30 participants
- a: Supported day
- b: Every part is false because one is unverified
- c: Supported venue
- d: Unverified count
A missing record is different from a contradiction.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A wrong but unexplained price
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post gives an entry price of 6 credits. The current organiser list gives 4. No record establishes why the wrong price was posted.
F5 · Open ended
Write a source-based correction and state what remains unknown.
Example of a full-credit answer: The current organiser list gives entry as four credits, not six. The reason for the post’s error and the author’s intention are not established.
- Corrects the price to 4 and identifies the organiser list.
- States the intent/reason uncertainty without an unsupported accusation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: verification lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional announcement says “Wednesday, Hall A, 16 pupils.” The official schedule says Wednesday, Hall B, and the participant register confirms 16 pupils.
1A · Matching
Match each announcement part to the fact-check result.
Complete or match: Wednesday; Hall A; 16 pupils
- a: Venue incorrect; record says Hall B
- b: Day matches the event record
- c: Count matches the participant register
- d: All three details are wrong
Only the venue conflicts with the supplied records.
1B · Open ended
Write a corrected announcement and explain which original detail changed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Wednesday’s visit is in Hall B with 16 pupils. The venue changed from the incorrect Hall A; the day and count were already supported.
- Provides the correct day, Hall B and count.
- Identifies the venue as the specific corrected part while preserving supported details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post claims a class planted 25 trees yesterday. Available records are yesterday’s planting tally, a separate teacher count, an unrelated old forest photo with no count of this planting session, and a favourite-tree poll.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which records directly address the number planted?
- a: Yesterday’s planting tally.
- b: The separate count of that planting session.
- c: An unrelated old forest picture.
- d: The favourite-tree preference poll.
The useful records match the action, date and quantity in the claim.
2B · Open ended
Justify the two count records and explain one scope detail that must agree.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both count trees planted in the relevant session, and their origins are separate. Check that they refer to yesterday’s same location/session and not total existing trees.
- Explains why the two independent count records address the exact claim.
- Identifies a meaningful shared scope requirement such as date, location or planted-versus-existing trees.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional original report says 8 of 10 tested seeds sprouted in one tray. A headline says “Every seed everywhere will grow.”
3A · Hotspot
Which correction stays within the supplied evidence?
- a: Eight of ten tested seeds sprouted in this tray
- b: No seeds can ever grow
- c: Every seed everywhere will grow
- d: The trial proves all growing conditions are identical
The original has both exceptions and a limited testing context.
3B · Open ended
Explain two ways the headline exceeds the report.
Example of a full-credit answer: It says every seed even though two of ten did not sprout. It also extends one tray’s result to all seeds and conditions everywhere.
- Identifies the contradiction between every and the two non-sprouting seeds.
- Identifies the unsupported expansion from one trial to universal conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional checker confirms a concert’s date but cannot find its final attendance record. The checker labels the attendance claim false solely because the record is missing.
4A · True or false
True or false? Without a confirming or contradicting count, the attendance claim should remain unverified rather than automatically false.
- true: True
- false: False
Absence of supplied evidence does not establish the opposite number.
4B · Open ended
Identify the verdict error and state what evidence would help resolve the claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The checker confuses unverified with contradicted. A reliable final attendance register or comparable event count would help settle the number.
- Distinguishes lack of confirmation from evidence of falsity.
- Proposes a relevant final attendance record or direct count.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class must correct a post saying 21 seedlings grew. Its dated log shows 9 in Tray A and 8 in Tray B. The correction should be understandable and repeatable.
5A · Multiple choice
Which record lets another reader repeat the check?
- a: Only a confidence score
- b: Only the writer’s name
- c: Exact claim, dated tray counts, calculation and corrected conclusion
- d: Only a statement that someone is wrong
The full evidence trail shows how the conclusion follows.
5B · Open ended
Write the correction and list the evidence trail another reader should see.
Example of a full-credit answer: Correction: 17 seedlings grew, based on the dated log showing 9 in Tray A and 8 in Tray B. Include the original claim, log reference, counts and 9 + 8 = 17 calculation.
- Correctly states 17 and ties it to the dated tray log.
- Includes enough claim/count/calculation/source information for another reader to repeat the check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.1 · Appropriate online communication
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A complete question
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil writes “For Tuesday’s map task, should we label rivers too?”
Question: Why is this useful?
Answer: It identifies the task and asks a specific question.
Why: The recipient can respond without guessing the context.
Example 2 · A delayed response
Fictional classroom example
A fictional teammate replies the next day because their device was shared.
Question: Does the delay prove disrespect?
Answer: No. The supplied reason explains the delay.
Why: Avoid judging motives from response time alone.
Example 3 · The right audience
Fictional classroom example
A fictional project group needs a classroom meeting location.
Question: Should a member post their home address instead?
Answer: No. The classroom location is enough.
Why: Appropriate communication shares relevant information with the needed audience.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Parts of a useful message
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message says “Hello Ms Mira. For Thursday’s reading task, should we submit one summary? Thank you.”
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each part with its communication role.
Complete or match: Thursday’s reading task; One summary question; Greeting and thanks
- a: States the requested clarification
- b: Adds respectful courtesy
- c: Reveals a password
- d: Identifies context
The message supplies context, a question and a respectful tone.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Choose safe group details
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional art group needs to meet at Room 5 after class and bring paper. It does not need passwords or home addresses.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which details fit the stated group task?
- a: Post a member’s home address.
- b: Share an account password.
- c: Meet in Room 5 after class.
- d: Bring paper.
The meeting and material details are sufficient and relevant.
Investigation: privacy lab
F3 · A message-check routine
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil is about to send a task update. The class routine is to check the purpose, recipient and unnecessary private details.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each check with its focus.
Complete or match: Purpose check; Recipient check; Privacy check
- a: Most emojis wins
- b: Only necessary personal information
- c: Clear task meaning
- d: Correct audience
These checks address useful communication rather than decoration.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · Clarify an unclear reply
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teammate writes “Use that one.” Three files are open: map, table and title. No file is identified.
F4 · Matching
Match each reply with its likely effect.
Complete or match: Which file do you mean?; You never explain anything; Delete other files without asking
- a: All replies request the same information
- b: Makes a personal attack
- c: Seeks clarification
- d: Acts before meaning is clear
The first addresses ambiguity without blame.
Investigation: message lab
F5 · Correct a wrong room
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil accidentally sends “Meet in Room 2.” The project plan says Room 6. The message went to the project group.
F5 · Short answer
Write a respectful correction and identify where it should be sent.
Example of a full-credit answer: Sorry, I gave the wrong room. Please meet in Room 6, as the project plan states. Send it to the same project group that received Room 2.
- Corrects the room to 6 with respectful responsibility.
- Identifies the original project group as the needed audience.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group is making a poster due Friday. Lio finished the title, still needs the picture caption and wants the group to review it by Thursday.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each update detail to its role.
Complete or match: Title finished; Caption still needed; Review by Thursday
- a: Remaining task
- b: The poster was already submitted
- c: Completed work
- d: Requested action and timing
A useful update distinguishes progress, remaining work and next action.
1B · Open ended
Write a clear group update stating the completed title, the remaining caption and the requested review time in relation to the Friday deadline.
Example of a full-credit answer: The poster title is finished. The picture caption is still needed; please review it by Thursday so the poster is ready for Friday.
- Accurately states the completed title and remaining caption.
- Includes a clear Thursday review request linked to the Friday deadline.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional shared folder contains “Map final” and “Map revised.” A teammate writes “Use the latest map” without a date. Four replies are available.
2A · Hotspot
Which reply most directly helps the group proceed respectfully?
- a: Nobody should ask questions
- b: Your file names are always terrible
- c: Which file and date should we use?
- d: I will choose the first file without checking
It asks for the missing version detail without insulting the sender.
2B · Open ended
Justify the clarification using both the task problem and the tone.
Example of a full-credit answer: It asks for the exact file/date needed to avoid the wrong version. It focuses on the unclear instruction instead of attacking the teammate.
- Explains how the question resolves the version ambiguity.
- Explains its respectful focus on the task rather than the person.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil needs help with Question 3 of Monday’s graph task. The pupil tried reading the axis labels and still cannot identify the unit.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each useful detail with its purpose.
Complete or match: Question 3, Monday graph task; I checked the axis labels; Where is the unit?
- a: Home address
- b: States the remaining question
- c: Explains the attempt already made
- d: Identifies the exact task
The teacher needs task context, prior effort and the specific gap.
3B · Short answer
Write a message that includes the task, attempted step and remaining question.
Example of a full-credit answer: Hello, for Question 3 of Monday’s graph task, I checked the axis labels but cannot find the unit. Could you help me locate it?
- Identifies the exact task and the attempt to read axis labels.
- Asks clearly for help locating the unit in a respectful message.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teammate has not replied for one hour. The group agreed replies could take until the next afternoon. A pupil posts “You are ignoring us!”
4A · Multiple choice
Which response best fits the agreement?
- a: Publish their private details
- b: Accuse the teammate of ignoring everyone
- c: Wait within the agreed window or send a calm later reminder
- d: Demand an immediate reply despite the agreement
The response window has not passed; delay alone does not establish motive.
4B · Open ended
Identify the unsupported assumption and propose a message if a reminder later becomes needed.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil assumes bad intent before the agreed deadline. A later reminder could say, “Could you update us by the agreed time about your task?”
- Recognises that the delay does not establish intentional ignoring and the window remains open.
- Proposes a calm task-focused reminder consistent with the agreement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants rules for clear messages, reasonable reply times and privacy. It uses teacher-supervised channels.
5A · True or false
True or false? Rules can require clarity and respect while allowing reasonable response time and protecting private information.
- true: True
- false: False
These aims support useful communication without demanding constant availability.
5B · Open ended
Propose two concrete rules: one about clarity or response timing and one about privacy.
Example of a full-credit answer: Name the task and requested action, and use the class’s agreed response window. Share only necessary details in the intended teacher-supervised group; keep secrets and private addresses out.
- Provides a practical clarity or response-window rule.
- Provides a practical audience/data-minimisation privacy rule.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.2 · Respectful disagreement
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Challenge the count
Fictional classroom example
A fictional tally totals 12, but a teammate says 14.
Question: What is a respectful response?
Answer: “I get 12 from the tally. Can we add it together?”
Why: It challenges the number using evidence and invites checking.
Example 2 · Different preferences
Fictional classroom example
Two fictional pupils prefer different story endings. Neither ending breaks the task rules.
Question: Must one preference be false?
Answer: No. They can explain their reasons and compare the brief.
Why: Preferences differ from factual claims.
Example 3 · A personal attack
Fictional classroom example
A fictional reply says “Only foolish people choose that plan.”
Question: Why is it unhelpful?
Answer: It attacks people instead of explaining a problem with the plan.
Why: A useful response should identify evidence or a relevant criterion.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify response types
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional replies say A “The tally gives 15; can we check?”, B “You are useless,” C “I prefer blue because the labels are clearer.”
F1 · Matching
Match each reply with its type.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Evidence-focused clarification
- b: Preference with a task-related reason
- c: Personal attack
- d: All disagreement is bullying
The wording and function distinguish constructive challenge from attack.
Investigation: message lab
F2 · Choose constructive actions
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group disagrees about whether a graph should start at zero. It has the task instructions and the full data available.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions help?
- a: Compare both graphs with the task instructions.
- b: Call the other pupil dishonest without evidence.
- c: Explain how each scale affects the data’s appearance.
- d: Ask friends to ridicule the other design.
Shared criteria and evidence address the actual disagreement.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A respectful counterpoint
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional plan costs 12 credits, but the group budget is 10. A teammate supports it.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which reply respectfully addresses the actual problem?
- a: Your ideas are always silly
- b: Only my preference counts
- c: Budget never matters
- d: It is two credits over budget; can we reduce a cost?
It uses the supplied constraint and suggests a constructive next step.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · Respect and agreement
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil politely challenges a classmate’s incorrect 5 + 5 = 11 using the calculation 10.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Respectful disagreement requires accepting an incorrect factual claim.
- true: True
- false: False
Respect concerns how people are treated, not abandoning evidence.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A preference conflict
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group can choose a blue or green cover. Both meet the brief and are readable. One pupil likes blue; another likes green.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why this is mainly a preference disagreement and propose a fair next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both covers meet the same readability and brief requirements, so colour preference differs. The group could use its agreed vote or rotate choices rather than insult someone’s taste.
- Uses the shared compliance/readability facts to identify a preference difference.
- Proposes a fair agreed decision process without personal attack.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: decision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional draft gives Thursday as the event date, but the checked schedule says Friday. It also has a title that is too small to read clearly and an author who is new to the group. The date and title concern the draft’s quality; being new does not. The group should compare everyone’s ideas with the same brief.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each constructive focus with its purpose.
Complete or match: Title size; Friday in the schedule; Everyone’s ideas compared with the brief
- a: Address readability
- b: Include participants fairly
- c: Judge a person by being new
- d: Correct a factual detail
The response should address the work and fair process.
1B · Short answer
Write two respectful feedback sentences, one about the date and one about the title.
Example of a full-credit answer: The schedule says Friday, so please change Thursday to Friday. Could we make the title larger so it is easier to read?
- Corrects the date using the schedule without attacking the writer.
- Gives a clear readability suggestion about the title respectfully.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil writes “I disagree that all visitors prefer games; our survey includes people who chose quiet reading.” The survey records eight choosing games and five choosing quiet reading. The message contains no insult.
2A · True or false
True or false? This can be respectful even though it directly disagrees with the universal claim.
- true: True
- false: False
It challenges the claim using relevant contrary evidence, not a personal insult.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the challenge is respectful and why the survey matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: It addresses the statement rather than attacking the speaker. The five reading responses contradict the word all in the games claim.
- Identifies the claim-focused, non-attacking wording.
- Uses the reading responses to explain why the universal claim is unsupported.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team has a 20-minute presentation limit. Plan A takes 18 minutes; Plan B takes 24. The team can shorten B by removing a six-minute duplicate section.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each option to its timing status.
Complete or match: Plan A: 18 minutes; Plan B: 24 minutes; Task to remove to make B match A
- a: Two minutes below the limit
- b: Four minutes over the limit
- c: Both original plans take the same time
- d: Six-minute duplicate section
A factual constraint can guide a respectful revision.
3B · Short answer
Propose a respectful response to someone who prefers B and explain a workable revision.
Example of a full-credit answer: B has useful parts, but at 24 minutes it exceeds the limit by four. Could we remove the six-minute duplicate section so it becomes 18 minutes?
- Uses the correct 24-versus-20 constraint in a respectful response.
- Proposes the specific six-minute removal and correct 18-minute result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional discussion contains A “The sources use different dates,” B “Can we check the full report?”, C “You are too stupid to understand,” D “I prefer the simpler layout.”
4A · Hotspot
Which comment crosses from discussing ideas into a personal attack?
- a: D: I prefer the simpler layout
- b: C: you are too stupid to understand
- c: A: the sources use different dates
- d: B: check the full report
C targets the person rather than the claim or design.
4B · Open ended
Rewrite C as a useful evidence-focused question and state what to do if insults continue.
Example of a full-credit answer: Could we compare the dates and findings in the full reports? If insults continue, pause and ask a trusted adult or moderator for help.
- Replaces the insult with a relevant question about the evidence.
- Provides an appropriate pause/adult/moderator response to continuing attacks.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a routine for ordinary disagreements: understand the idea, provide a reason, check evidence and agree a next step. Threats require adult help.
5A · Matching
Match each move to its role.
Complete or match: Restate fairly; Give relevant evidence; Agree a test or process
- a: Win by humiliating the other person
- b: Move toward resolution
- c: Support a counterpoint
- d: Show understanding
The routine improves reasoning and cooperation.
5B · Open ended
Write a short routine with an evidence step and a safety boundary.
Example of a full-credit answer: Restate the idea, explain a relevant reason, compare evidence and agree how to decide. If there are threats or repeated personal attacks, pause and seek a trusted adult rather than continue the argument.
- Includes understanding, reasons/evidence and a constructive next step.
- States an appropriate adult-supported boundary for unsafe attacks.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.3 · Adapting messages to different audiences
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Visitor and helper
Fictional classroom example
A fictional exhibition opens at noon; helpers set up at 11 a.m.
Question: Should both audiences receive only noon?
Answer: No. Visitors need opening time; helpers also need setup time.
Why: Adaptation selects the information required by each role.
Example 2 · Explain a term
Fictional classroom example
A fictional beginner guide uses the term “archive,” meaning a collection of stored records.
Question: What useful change can be made?
Answer: Define archive the first time it appears.
Why: Explaining vocabulary changes access without changing the idea.
Example 3 · Colour plus words
Fictional classroom example
A fictional guide uses red for closed and green for open.
Question: How can it be more inclusive?
Answer: Add the words Closed and Open or clear symbols with labels.
Why: The instruction no longer depends only on colour perception.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Shorter but changed
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional borrowing rule is “Two books for five days.” An adapted version says “Five books for two days.”
F1 · True or false
True or false? The adapted version preserves the original rule merely because it uses the same words.
- true: True
- false: False
It swaps quantity and duration, changing both conditions.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · Match reader and detail
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional workshop has visitors arriving at 2 p.m., helpers setting up at 1 p.m. and presenters testing equipment at noon.
F2 · Matching
Match each reader to the relevant task time.
Complete or match: Visitors; Helpers; Presenters
- a: All arrive at the same time
- b: Noon equipment test
- c: 1 p.m. setup
- d: 2 p.m. opening
Each role has a distinct practical task.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Add an access feature
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional video needs a text route for viewers who cannot hear; a diagram needs a description for viewers who cannot see it; a colour-only status needs labelled words.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each need with a helpful feature.
Complete or match: Access to spoken words; Access to diagram meaning; Meaning without colour distinction
- a: Remove all instructions
- b: Written status labels
- c: Useful text description
- d: Accurate captions or transcript
The features supply information through more than one route.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F4 · Choose a beginner version
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional coding club asks for a newcomer instruction meaning “Click Save to keep your work.” Alternatives use unexplained technical codes, change Save to Delete or omit the action.
F4 · Hotspot
Which version best fits the newcomer while preserving the instruction?
- a: Execute an unexplained persistence command
- b: Click Delete to keep your work
- c: Do something with the file
- d: Click Save to keep your work
It names the correct action and explains its purpose in familiar language.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A translated invitation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional English source says “Free reading session, Friday at 3 p.m., Room 4.” A translated draft keeps Friday and Room 4 but changes free to a two-credit fee.
F5 · Short answer
Identify the changed fact and write an accurate short version preserving all event details.
Example of a full-credit answer: The fee was invented; the source says free. The reading session is free on Friday at 3 p.m. in Room 4.
- Identifies the unsupported two-credit fee and restores free entry.
- Preserves the reading event, Friday, 3 p.m. and Room 4.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school rule says “Return borrowed equipment by 4 p.m. on the same day.” A newcomer version says “Bring the equipment back before or at 4 p.m. today.” The borrowing is today.
1A · True or false
True or false? For today’s borrowing, the adapted version preserves the deadline while using simpler words.
- true: True
- false: False
By 4 p.m. includes at or before that time on the same day.
1B · Open ended
Explain what changed in presentation and what essential condition stayed the same.
Example of a full-credit answer: The wording became more familiar. The equipment still must be returned at or before 4 p.m. today, preserving the same-day deadline.
- Identifies a wording/presentation change rather than a factual change.
- Preserves the 4 p.m. same-day return condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional show opens to visitors at 5 p.m. Performers arrive at 4 p.m. for rehearsal; technicians arrive at 3 p.m. for checks.
2A · Matching
Match each notice detail to its intended reader.
Complete or match: Equipment checks at 3 p.m.; Rehearsal at 4 p.m.; Public opening at 5 p.m.
- a: Performers
- b: Technicians
- c: Visitors
- d: Everyone needs only the public time
Different preparation tasks require different details.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the performer and visitor notices should differ while describing the same event.
Example of a full-credit answer: Performers need the 4 p.m. rehearsal time to prepare; visitors need the 5 p.m. opening. Both should name the same show and retain accurate role-specific times.
- Explains the performer’s preparation need using 4 p.m.
- Explains the visitor’s entry need using 5 p.m. while preserving shared event identity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional chart of borrowed books has a blue bar for 6 storybooks and a green bar for 4 science books. A spoken version must convey the categories and quantities without relying on seeing colours.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each communication requirement with the useful content.
Complete or match: Name first category and count; Name second category and count; Avoid colour-only meaning
- a: Just say the blue one is bigger
- b: Six storybooks
- c: Use category names as well as colours
- d: Four science books
A spoken version needs meaningful labels and values.
3B · Open ended
Write a spoken summary and explain why “blue is bigger” is insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: Six storybooks and four science books were borrowed. “Blue is bigger” omits categories and counts and depends on seeing the chart colours.
- Provides both categories and correct counts in the summary.
- Explains the missing information and colour-dependence in the weak version.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional community craft notice says entry costs two credits and the event is Saturday at noon. An organiser assumes all older readers need childish wording and removes the fee. The actual brief only asks for larger text and clear contrast while preserving the event facts.
4A · Multiple choice
Which revision meets the actual brief?
- a: Replace all details with a cartoon
- b: Assume older readers cannot understand the event
- c: Larger readable text with the fee and time retained
- d: Remove the fee based on an age stereotype
The stated need concerns visual access, not changing or omitting facts.
4B · Open ended
Identify the unsupported assumption and propose a correct adaptation.
Example of a full-credit answer: The organiser stereotypes readers instead of using the stated access need. Increase text size and contrast while keeping the two-credit fee and Saturday-noon time.
- Identifies the age-based assumption as unsupported by the brief.
- Proposes the requested visual access changes while preserving the specified facts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional science display is Tuesday at 10 a.m. in Hall C. Visitors need those details; helpers also need to arrive at 9 a.m. and bring the labelled display cards.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which choices belong in the adaptations?
- a: Remove the helper task to make both messages identical.
- b: Tell visitors the public opening is 9 a.m.
- c: Give helpers the 9 a.m. arrival and labelled-card task.
- d: Keep Tuesday and Hall C consistent across both versions.
Shared facts stay consistent while role-specific instructions differ.
5B · Open ended
Write a visitor reminder and a helper reminder using the required details.
Example of a full-credit answer: Visitors: science display Tuesday at 10 a.m. in Hall C. Helpers: arrive Tuesday at 9 a.m. in Hall C with labelled display cards; opening is at 10 a.m.
- Writes an accurate visitor reminder with event, day, opening time and place.
- Writes an accurate helper reminder with earlier arrival, place and labelled-card task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.4 · Working on shared documents
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Comment versus edit
Fictional classroom example
A fictional reviewer has comment access to a report.
Question: Can they suggest a title change without editing the text directly?
Answer: Yes. They can leave a clear comment.
Why: Permissions can support review without giving full editing control.
Example 2 · An accidental deletion
Fictional classroom example
A fictional teammate accidentally deletes a paragraph. The version history retains it.
Question: What is a useful first recovery step?
Answer: Compare the history and restore the missing paragraph carefully.
Why: Recover the needed content without blindly discarding newer work.
Example 3 · A private class file
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class report needs access for three pupils and a teacher.
Question: Is a public edit link necessary?
Answer: No. Share appropriate access with the required group.
Why: Access should fit the task and audience.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A shared file is not ownerless
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group file contains a paragraph written by another pupil. No editing agreement permits deleting it without discussion.
F1 · True or false
True or false? Because a file is shared, any member may ignore the group agreement and erase others’ work.
- true: True
- false: False
Shared access still requires coordination and respect for agreed roles.
Investigation: message lab
F2 · Match permission to need
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher wants families to read a guide, a reviewer to suggest corrections and a writing partner to revise text.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each role with the needed permission.
Complete or match: Family reading the guide; Reviewer suggesting changes; Writing partner revising text
- a: Publish everyone’s private details
- b: Comment
- c: Edit
- d: View
Different tasks need different permissions.
Investigation: privacy lab
F3 · Useful review comments
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional report lists 8 + 4 as 13 and has a chart without a unit. Its data count books. The task requires accurate totals and labelled units.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which comments address the stated issues constructively?
- a: Please add the unit books to the chart.
- b: The writer is bad at everything.
- c: Delete all the work without discussing it.
- d: The total should be 12 because 8 + 4 = 12.
Specific evidence-based comments help repair the document.
Investigation: revision lab
F4 · Understand version records
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional history says Monday: paragraph added; Tuesday: correct caption added; Wednesday: paragraph accidentally deleted.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Match each history entry with its change.
Complete or match: Monday; Tuesday; Wednesday
- a: Accidental paragraph removal
- b: Paragraph creation
- c: Caption addition
- d: No useful content changed
The history helps identify what to recover and what to preserve.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · Restore carefully
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional report’s current version has a correct new chart but is missing yesterday’s conclusion. Yesterday’s whole version has the conclusion but an outdated chart.
F5 · Open ended
Propose a recovery action and explain why restoring the whole old file without checking could be harmful.
Example of a full-credit answer: Recover the missing conclusion from history into the current draft while keeping the correct new chart. A full restore could replace that chart with the outdated one.
- Proposes recovering the missing conclusion while preserving useful current work.
- Explains the specific risk of losing the new correct chart in a blind full restore.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: provenance lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group has a report with three sections. Two pupils repeatedly overwrite each other’s introduction. A third can review facts.
1A · Multiple choice
Which plan best reduces the stated conflict?
- a: Publish a public edit link to strangers
- b: Let everyone replace the introduction at once
- c: Agree section owners and use comments for cross-section suggestions
- d: Remove all version history
Clear ownership and review channels reduce competing changes.
1B · Short answer
Propose a practical division of work and a way to suggest changes to another person’s section.
Example of a full-credit answer: Assign one pupil to the introduction, another to results and a third to fact review. Use specific comments or agreed editing turns before changing another person’s section.
- Provides a concrete role/section allocation suited to the task.
- Provides a coordinated comment or editing-turn process for cross-section changes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional chart claims 17 when the source tally has 8 and 7. Comments are A “Please change the total to 15; 8 + 7 = 15,” B “Bad work,” C “I dislike you,” D “Looks colourful.”
2A · Hotspot
Which comment directly helps repair the factual issue?
- a: C: I dislike you
- b: B: bad work
- c: A: change the total to 15 using 8 + 7
- d: D: looks colourful
It identifies the exact correction and its evidence.
2B · Open ended
Explain why A is useful and rewrite B into a specific task-focused comment.
Example of a full-credit answer: A states the correct total and calculation. Replace “Bad work” with “Please check the total against the tally; 8 + 7 gives 15.”
- Explains specificity and supporting evidence in A.
- Rewrites the vague judgment into a clear respectful correction or check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants visitors to read a final checklist while only the teacher-approved group edits it. No visitor changes are needed.
3A · True or false
True or false? A view-only final checklist for visitors can meet the reading need while limiting editing to the approved group.
- true: True
- false: False
The audience’s task is reading, so public edit access is unnecessary.
3B · Open ended
Explain the two access levels and why they fit the roles.
Example of a full-credit answer: Visitors receive view access to the final checklist. The approved group keeps edit access because it is responsible for maintaining the content.
- Assigns reading/view permission to visitors.
- Assigns editing to the responsible approved group and explains the difference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reviewer flags a wrong venue: the draft says Hall A, while the current event record says Hall E. A teammate marks the comment resolved but leaves Hall A in the text.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each part with its proper status.
Complete or match: Text still says Hall A; Comment marked resolved; Change text to Hall E
- a: Closing a comment automatically changes all text
- b: Factual error remains
- c: Status does not match the text
- d: Needed correction
A status label is not the same as completing the correction.
4B · Open ended
Identify the workflow error and describe the correct next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The issue was marked resolved before the text was fixed. Change Hall A to Hall E using the event record, then check and resolve the comment.
- Explains the mismatch between resolved status and unresolved factual error.
- Provides the Hall E correction followed by verification/status update.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional shared report is ready to submit after checking facts, source credits, unresolved comments and the current version. One agreed member will submit.
5A · Matching
Match each check to its purpose.
Complete or match: Facts and source credits; Unresolved comments; Current version and submitter
- a: Accuracy and traceability
- b: Hide uncertainty to look finished
- c: Clear final handoff
- d: Outstanding review issues
A shared final review reduces avoidable errors and confusion.
5B · Open ended
Propose a two-part final check: one for content and one for the submission handoff.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check facts, credits and remaining comments against the brief. Then confirm the current file and the agreed submitter so the group does not send an outdated version.
- Includes concrete content checks such as facts, credits and unresolved comments.
- Includes current-version and submitter confirmation for a clear handoff.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.5 · Sharing responsibilities
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Same count, different effort
Fictional classroom example
A fictional team gives Bea one 30-minute diagram and Cal one 5-minute title.
Question: Are equal task counts enough to show equal workload?
Answer: No. The estimated effort differs substantially.
Why: Fair allocation should consider time and support, not only the number of tasks.
Example 2 · An unowned task
Fictional classroom example
A fictional plan lists “check sources” but names no owner.
Question: What should be added?
Answer: A responsible person and a deadline or check-in.
Why: Without ownership, a necessary task can be missed.
Example 3 · An honest update
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil has drawn a map but not added the required key.
Question: Should the whole task be marked done?
Answer: No. Report the map drawing as complete and the key as remaining.
Why: Status should reflect the agreed result.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read a task assignment
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional plan says “Rina: prepare the graph from the class tally by Thursday.”
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each assignment detail with its role.
Complete or match: Rina; Graph from class tally; Thursday
- a: Expected result
- b: Task owner
- c: Deadline
- d: An optional unknown responsibility
A clear assignment identifies who, what and when.
Investigation: collaboration lab
F2 · Equal task counts
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team gives one person a 40-minute report and another a 5-minute title. Both have one task.
F2 · True or false
True or false? One task each proves the estimated workloads are equal.
- true: True
- false: False
The estimates differ by 35 minutes despite equal task counts.
Investigation: graph lab
F3 · Choose an honest update
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster needs an image, title and source credit. The image and title are complete; the credit is missing.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which update matches the actual status?
- a: The deadline no longer matters
- b: Everything is complete
- c: Nothing has been started
- d: Image and title done; source credit still needed
A useful update distinguishes completed and unfinished requirements.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · Respond to a workload problem
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teammate says a 30-minute task exceeds the 15 minutes they have today. They ask early. The group can split the task or extend the agreed schedule with teacher approval.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which responses can help fairly?
- a: Demand private family details before offering any help.
- b: Consider a revised schedule with the appropriate approval.
- c: Discuss splitting the task into two clear parts.
- d: Mark the task complete even though it is unfinished.
The group can address the task constraint without inventing completion or demanding private details.
Investigation: collaboration lab
F5 · A hidden review task
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team plan assigns writing and illustration but nobody is assigned to check the figures. The finished draft has not been checked.
F5 · Open ended
Identify the responsibility gap and propose who should check the figures, when the check should happen and which record the checker needs.
Example of a full-credit answer: Figure checking is unassigned. Name a willing checker and an agreed review time before submission, with access to the original data.
- Identifies the missing owner for figure checking.
- Proposes an owner/check-in arrangement and access to the needed data before submission.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team has three 10-minute tasks and one 30-minute task. Two members each have 30 minutes available. Plan A assigns the three short tasks to one and the long task to the other.
1A · Multiple choice
Which statement about Plan A is correct?
- a: The member with three tasks always has triple the workload
- b: No one has enough time for any task
- c: The long task takes only ten minutes
- d: Both have 30 estimated minutes despite different task counts
Three ten-minute tasks and one thirty-minute task each total thirty minutes.
1B · Short answer
Explain the time comparison and name one factor besides time the group should consider.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both allocations total 30 minutes. The group should also consider skills, needed support, task dependencies or whether each person can access the materials.
- Correctly compares 3 × 10 with 30 minutes.
- Names a relevant additional fairness or feasibility factor.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional diagram is due Friday. By Wednesday, a pupil has completed the outline but lacks the data labels. The labels require the approved tally, which the pupil has not yet received. Four proposed updates range from a specific request for the tally today to silence until after the deadline.
2A · Hotspot
Which update best helps the team act?
- a: I refuse to name the unfinished part
- b: No update until after Friday
- c: Everything is done though labels are missing
- d: Outline done; please provide the approved tally today for Friday’s labels
The specific update identifies progress, a dependency and the needed action.
2B · Open ended
Justify the update using its progress information and its requested support.
Example of a full-credit answer: It states that the outline is finished so others know what remains. It asks for the approved tally today, which directly enables the required labels by Friday.
- Explains the value of accurately separating completed and remaining work.
- Connects the specific tally request and timing to completing the task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional presentation needs a speaker, a slide checker and a timekeeper. The speaker explains, the checker verifies content and the timekeeper monitors the limit.
3A · Matching
Match each responsibility to its purpose.
Complete or match: Speaker; Slide checker; Timekeeper
- a: Verify content accuracy
- b: Monitor duration
- c: Communicate the findings
- d: One role guarantees every need is handled
Different responsibilities support the same presentation.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the checker and timekeeper roles matter even if only the speaker is most visible.
Example of a full-credit answer: The checker helps prevent inaccurate claims, while the timekeeper helps the group stay within the limit. Both contribute to a successful presentation despite less visible work.
- Explains the checker’s accuracy contribution.
- Explains the timekeeper’s timing contribution and recognises shared responsibility.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional task requires a table with headings and units. A teammate enters numbers but marks it done before headings or units are added.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each detail with its status.
Complete or match: Numbers entered; Headings and units absent; Done label
- a: Completed part
- b: Premature status
- c: All requirements have been met
- d: Remaining required work
Completion depends on the agreed result, not only activity started.
4B · Open ended
Identify the status error and write an accurate update with a next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The task is marked done before its required headings and units exist. Update: numbers are entered; I will add the headings and units and then ask for a check.
- Explains the unmet requirements behind the premature status.
- Provides an honest update and a concrete completion/check step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team will produce a class guide with research, writing, illustration and review. The board must show ownership, estimated effort, status and a check-in date.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each board field with the question it answers.
Complete or match: Owner; Estimated minutes; Status and check-in date
- a: Who is the most popular member?
- b: What is happening and when will it be reviewed?
- c: Who is responsible?
- d: How much effort is expected?
The fields make workload and progress visible.
5B · Open ended
Propose a useful task-board row and explain how the group should respond if it becomes overloaded.
Example of a full-credit answer: Row: Sam, write the guide introduction, 20 estimated minutes, doing, review Thursday. If workload is too high, discuss splitting or reassigning a clear part and update the board rather than hiding the delay.
- Provides a row with task, owner, effort, status and review timing.
- Proposes a transparent agreed adjustment to workload or schedule.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.6 · Giving and receiving feedback
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Specific praise
Fictional classroom example
A fictional reviewer says “The numbered steps make the instructions easy to follow.”
Question: Why is this useful?
Answer: It identifies a successful feature and its effect.
Why: The writer knows what to preserve.
Example 2 · An actionable correction
Fictional classroom example
A fictional chart lacks the unit litres.
Question: What feedback helps?
Answer: “Please label the vertical axis litres so readers know what is measured.”
Why: It identifies the issue, action and reason.
Example 3 · A suggestion to question
Fictional classroom example
A fictional reviewer asks a pupil to remove source credits even though the brief requires them.
Question: Should the pupil automatically comply?
Answer: No. Explain that credits are required and keep them.
Why: Feedback must be evaluated against the task.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Useful feedback on a table
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional table has correct values but lacks headings and units. The task asks for a readable data table.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which comments help improve the table?
- a: Add clear column headings.
- b: Delete all numbers without checking.
- c: The writer is lazy.
- d: Include the correct measurement units.
The selected comments address concrete requirements of the table.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Choose evidence-based feedback
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional total says 19, but the source has 8 and 9. Four replies include a calculation, an insult, a vague cheer and an unrelated colour preference.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which comment directly addresses the factual error?
- a: I prefer purple borders
- b: You are hopeless
- c: Please change 19 to 17 because 8 + 9 = 17
- d: Everything is perfect
The calculation supports a specific correction.
Investigation: graph lab
F3 · Parts of a feedback message
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional reviewer writes “The title is clear. The map lacks a key. Please add one so readers understand the symbols.”
F3 · Matching
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Title is clear; Map lacks a key; Add a key for symbols
- a: Attacks the writer’s identity
- b: Identifies an issue
- c: Gives an action and reason
- d: Names a strength
The message separates a strength, a problem and a next step.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · A useful response sequence
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil receives a suggestion to enlarge a caption. The brief requires readability. The routine is understand, compare with the brief, revise and check.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each stage with its purpose.
Complete or match: Understand; Evaluate; Check after revision
- a: Confirm the issue is improved
- b: Accept every edit without thinking
- c: Check whether it fits the goal
- d: Identify the requested change
Feedback should be understood and evaluated, then checked after use.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A vague review
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional peer writes “Make this better” on a story summary. No particular issue is identified.
F5 · Short answer
Write a respectful clarification question and explain why it is more useful than guessing at changes.
Example of a full-credit answer: Which sentence is unclear, and what information would help? This identifies the actual issue so I can revise the relevant part without changing accurate information randomly.
- Asks respectfully for a specific location, issue or example.
- Explains how clarification focuses revision and avoids arbitrary changes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poster brief requires source credits. A reviewer suggests deleting them to create more space.
1A · True or false
True or false? The writer should automatically delete the required credits because any feedback must be accepted.
- true: True
- false: False
Suggestions must be checked against requirements and evidence.
1B · Open ended
Explain why this suggestion should be declined or adapted and propose a space-saving alternative.
Example of a full-credit answer: Credits are required, so removing them would break the brief. Shorten unnecessary wording or adjust spacing while keeping readable source information.
- Uses the explicit credit requirement to evaluate the suggestion.
- Offers a practical alternative that preserves the required credit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional graph says 12 pupils chose drawing, but the source has two non-overlapping tally rows: 7 pupils and 4 pupils choosing drawing, for a total of 11.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each feedback component with its role.
Complete or match: Graph says 12; 7 + 4 = 11; Change label to 11
- a: Actionable correction
- b: Specific issue
- c: Supporting evidence
- d: The writer is bad at everything
The correction is traceable and focused on one error.
2B · Open ended
Write the feedback and explain why it targets the work rather than the person.
Example of a full-credit answer: The graph label says 12, but the tally gives 7 + 4 = 11; please change it to 11. It identifies a checkable error without judging the writer’s character.
- Gives the correct issue, calculation and requested change.
- Explains the work-focused, non-personal nature of the feedback.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional audio guide is clear but lacks a transcript. The class brief requires a text version for people who cannot use audio.
3A · Hotspot
Which comment best fits the brief?
- a: Remove the guide because audio is always bad
- b: Add an accurate transcript so the instructions are available as text
- c: Change the route without evidence
- d: Make the voice louder instead of providing text
The missing transcript is a specific access requirement.
3B · Open ended
Write feedback naming a strength and the required access improvement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The spoken directions are clear. Please add an accurate transcript so people who cannot use the audio can read the same instructions.
- Names the supplied strength of clear spoken directions.
- Requests an accurate transcript and explains its access purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional report meets all criteria with a readable green cover. The brief permits any readable cover colour. A reviewer says “You must use orange because I like orange,” although the brief does not require orange.
4A · Dropdown selection
Match each statement with its status.
Complete or match: Any readable colour allowed; I like orange; Green meets criteria
- a: Reviewer preference
- b: Task requirement
- c: Orange is required by the brief
- d: Supported current compliance
A personal preference can be considered without being treated as a rule.
4B · Open ended
Explain the reviewer’s overstatement and write a respectful response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reviewer turns a preference into a requirement. “Thanks for the idea; the brief allows any readable colour, so we will keep green unless the group prefers a change.”
- Distinguishes the personal preference from the actual brief.
- Responds respectfully while evaluating rather than automatically accepting the suggestion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional team wants to improve a map with unclear symbols. It will gather a specific comment, add a key and ask a reader to try the revised map.
5A · Matching
Match each step with its purpose.
Complete or match: Specific symbol comment; Add labelled key; Reader tries revised map
- a: Locate the issue
- b: Act on the suggestion
- c: Check whether it worked
- d: Mark done before any change
Feedback is most useful when its effect on the next version is checked.
5B · Open ended
Propose a feedback comment and an after-revision check for this map.
Example of a full-credit answer: Please add a key explaining each symbol so readers can follow the map. After revising, ask a reader to identify a destination using the symbols and key.
- Provides a specific action and reason linked to unclear symbols.
- Proposes a concrete usability check after revision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.7 · Resolving online conflict
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An ambiguous file name
Fictional classroom example
Two fictional teammates argue over “the final file,” but each means a different document.
Question: What should happen first?
Answer: Identify the exact file and version.
Why: Clarifying the practical meaning can remove the disagreement.
Example 2 · A factual conflict
Fictional classroom example
A fictional timetable says 2 p.m.; one teammate remembers 3 p.m.
Question: How should they check?
Answer: Compare with the current organiser record.
Why: A relevant source is more useful than arguing about confidence.
Example 3 · A repair after overwriting
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil accidentally replaces a teammate’s paragraph.
Question: What is a constructive response?
Answer: Acknowledge it, restore the needed work and agree a safer editing process.
Why: Repair addresses the actual effect and reduces recurrence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Clarify before blaming
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teammate says “You used the wrong one.” Two chart versions are open and the message does not name either.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which response best starts resolving the misunderstanding?
- a: Everyone must take my side now
- b: I will delete your chart too
- c: Which chart version and date do you mean?
- d: You always complain
A specific question clarifies the issue without escalating.
Investigation: message lab
F2 · Match problem to method
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional conflicts involve A: different totals, B: unclear task ownership, C: two equally acceptable colour preferences.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each problem with a suitable method.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Use a fair agreed choice process
- b: Check the calculation and source
- c: Review or clarify the task assignment
- d: Publish private details to win
Different conflicts need different kinds of evidence or process.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · A safety boundary
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional online argument includes a threat. The pupil can contact a trusted teacher or caregiver.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The pupil must continue debating the threat rather than seek help.
- true: True
- false: False
A threatening exchange calls for pausing and trusted-adult support.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Parts of a repair
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil says “I replaced your title without asking. That caused confusion. I will restore it and discuss changes first.”
F4 · Matching
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Replaced title without asking; Caused confusion; Restore and discuss
- a: Proposes repair and prevention
- b: Names the action
- c: Acknowledges the effect
- d: Blames the affected teammate
A constructive apology takes responsibility and offers a practical change.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A public argument over a deadline
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group argues about whether a task was due Wednesday or Thursday. The agreed plan is available and says Thursday. No threat is present.
F5 · Short answer
Propose a calm resolution using the plan and explain one follow-up action.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the shared plan and clarify that the agreed deadline is Thursday. Then ask for a task-progress update or confirm who will finish which part by that time.
- Uses the shared Thursday deadline to resolve the factual disagreement calmly.
- Proposes a concrete task-focused follow-up rather than continued blame.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group’s record has 6 red counters and 8 blue counters. One pupil says 14 and another says 15. The disagreement has no threats.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions help resolve this factual conflict?
- a: State the corrected total without insulting either pupil.
- b: Add the recorded values together.
- c: Post an embarrassing screenshot to ridicule the mistake.
- d: Choose the louder pupil’s answer.
Calculation and respectful correction address the actual issue.
1B · Open ended
Give the checked total and write a respectful resolving message.
Example of a full-credit answer: Six plus eight is fourteen. “The tally gives 6 + 8 = 14; let us update the total to 14.”
- Correctly calculates the total as 14.
- Provides a respectful evidence-based resolution without personal attack.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group chat has repeated insults during a task dispute. A teacher can help the group review the work plan.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each action with its likely role.
Complete or match: Pause and ask teacher; Invite a pile-on; Expose private details
- a: Every conflict needs public humiliation
- b: Seek safer supported resolution
- c: Add a separate privacy harm
- d: Escalate the conflict
Adult support can help when ordinary discussion has broken down.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the pause is justified and what the teacher should help clarify.
Example of a full-credit answer: Repeated insults prevent a safe useful discussion. The teacher can help clarify the actual task, responsibilities and next steps from the agreed plan.
- Connects the repeated insults with the need to stop escalation or seek support.
- Identifies a concrete task/process issue for adult-supported clarification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil expected a caption by noon, but the writer understood the deadline as 2 p.m. The agreed task board says 2 p.m. The poster is due 4 p.m.
3A · Hotspot
Which response best uses the shared record?
- a: Ignore the final deadline entirely
- b: Remove the writer from the group immediately
- c: Accuse the writer of missing a noon deadline that was not agreed
- d: Confirm 2 p.m. and plan layout/review before 4 p.m.
The shared board resolves the timing misunderstanding and supports a practical plan.
3B · Open ended
Explain the misunderstanding and propose the next handoff.
Example of a full-credit answer: One pupil assumed noon, but the agreed caption time is 2 p.m. Confirm delivery then, place the caption and complete review before the 4 p.m. deadline.
- Uses the board to distinguish the assumption from the agreed 2 p.m. time.
- Proposes a feasible caption-to-layout-to-review handoff before 4 p.m.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil deletes a teammate’s paragraph, says “Sorry you are upset,” and refuses to restore it. Version history still has the paragraph.
4A · Multiple choice
Which response better repairs the action?
- a: Sorry you are upset; I will leave it deleted
- b: The teammate should stop caring about their work
- c: I deleted the paragraph; I will restore it and ask before major changes
- d: I will delete more to finish the argument
The response that names the deletion and promises restoration takes responsibility and offers a specific repair and prevention step.
4B · Open ended
Identify what is missing from the original apology and write a better one.
Example of a full-credit answer: It does not take responsibility or repair the deletion. “I deleted your paragraph without checking; I will restore it from history and discuss major changes first.”
- Identifies missing responsibility or practical repair.
- Provides an action-specific apology with restoration and/or a prevention step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional project group needs a routine for unclear instructions, factual disagreements and unsafe messages. It has a shared task board and a trusted teacher.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each situation with its appropriate route.
Complete or match: Unclear instruction; Different factual answers; Threats or repeated attacks
- a: Check relevant evidence together
- b: Force agreement by sharing secrets
- c: Ask a specific clarification
- d: Pause and seek trusted-adult support
The routine distinguishes ordinary problem solving from unsafe exchanges.
5B · Open ended
Propose a routine with one evidence-based step and one safety boundary.
Example of a full-credit answer: Clarify the issue, compare the shared plan or relevant evidence and record the agreed next action. If threats or repeated attacks occur, stop the exchange and ask a trusted teacher for help.
- Includes clarification/evidence and an actionable agreement step.
- States a clear stop-and-adult-support boundary for unsafe communication.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.8 · Responding to cyberbullying
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Repeated ridicule
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class chat repeatedly mocks one pupil’s drawing after the pupil asks it to stop.
Question: Why is this concerning?
Answer: It is repeated targeted humiliation, not an ordinary critique of the task.
Why: A trusted adult should help address it.
Example 2 · A disagreement without attack
Fictional classroom example
Two fictional pupils politely disagree about a chart colour.
Question: Is that alone cyberbullying?
Answer: No. The case describes a respectful preference disagreement.
Why: Context and behaviour matter.
Example 3 · Helpful bystander
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil receives a humiliating post about a classmate.
Question: What can the pupil do?
Answer: Do not forward it; support the classmate and seek trusted-adult help.
Why: Support should reduce the harmful audience rather than enlarge it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match behaviour with concern
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional cases show A: repeated cruel messages to one pupil, B: a respectful disagreement about a title, C: an urgent threat that an adult should assess.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each case with its appropriate interpretation.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Safety concern needing prompt adult help
- b: No one may ask for help without proof
- c: Repeated harmful targeting
- d: Ordinary respectful disagreement
Help is appropriate for harmful or threatening behaviour even while details are assessed.
Investigation: evidence lab
F2 · Choose a supportive response
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil says a group keeps posting cruel comments about them. A trusted teacher is available.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which reply is most supportive?
- a: You must solve this alone
- b: You must have caused it
- c: Forward it to everyone
- d: You do not deserve that; I can help you tell our teacher
It avoids blame and offers an appropriate support route.
Investigation: message lab
F3 · Preserve without publicising
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher asks for the relevant message, date and account label to assess a report. The class does not need the pupil’s home address or a public repost.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Match each action with its purpose or risk.
Complete or match: Share relevant evidence with trusted teacher; Post it to a public group; Collect unrelated home addresses
- a: Expand the harmful audience
- b: Support private assessment
- c: Add unnecessary privacy risk
- d: All evidence must be public
Evidence can be preserved for appropriate helpers without general exposure.
Investigation: privacy lab
F4 · Actions that reduce harm
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classmate is being repeatedly mocked in a chat. Safe school reporting and trusted-adult help are available.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions reduce rather than amplify the harm?
- a: Organise a retaliatory pile-on.
- b: Help the pupil reach a trusted adult.
- c: Publish the pupil’s private details for attention.
- d: Avoid forwarding the humiliating posts.
The selected actions limit spread and connect the pupil with support.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A blocking misconception
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil blocks a harmful account. Copies of earlier posts may still exist, and the pupil remains distressed.
F5 · Short answer
Explain one useful effect and one limit of blocking, then identify an appropriate support step.
Example of a full-credit answer: Blocking can reduce contact from that account, but it does not guarantee all copies vanish. Tell a trusted adult and use the school/reporting process for continued support.
- Explains both a useful blocking effect and the limit concerning existing copies/contact.
- Identifies trusted-adult or school-supported follow-up.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: verification lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil receives one serious threatening message from an unknown account. No repetition is yet recorded, and a caregiver is nearby.
1A · True or false
True or false? The pupil should wait for repeated messages before asking an adult for help with the threat.
- true: True
- false: False
A single serious threat can warrant prompt support; a label is not a barrier to help.
1B · Open ended
Explain why waiting is unnecessary and give a safe next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The threatening content is already a safety concern even without repetition. Stop engaging and tell the nearby trusted caregiver, who can help decide reporting and further safety steps.
- Recognises that a serious threat does not require repetition before help.
- Gives a non-confrontational trusted-adult response.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil wants to help a classmate targeted by humiliating posts. The classmate has not consented to a public story about the incident.
2A · Dropdown selection
Match each action with its consequence.
Complete or match: Private supportive check-in; Relevant report to trusted teacher; Public identifying story without permission
- a: Risk further exposure
- b: A kind intention removes all privacy risks
- c: Offer care without a wider audience
- d: Seek responsible help
Support should consider both help and the targeted person’s privacy.
2B · Open ended
Explain why a private check-in and adult report are preferable to a public identifying story.
Example of a full-credit answer: A private check-in can support the pupil without broadcasting the incident. A trusted teacher can assess relevant evidence and help, while a public story may spread humiliation and private details.
- Explains the privacy-preserving support value of a private check-in.
- Explains responsible adult help and the exposure risk of public identification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional supervised game chat repeatedly mocks a pupil’s accent and excludes them to hurt them. The platform has report/mute options and a teacher supervises.
3A · Matching
Match each role with an appropriate action.
Complete or match: Bystander peer; Trusted teacher; Report/mute tools
- a: Help assess and address the repeated targeting
- b: Ask the target to change their accent to deserve respect
- c: Limit or report harmful interaction
- d: Do not join or forward the mockery
Responsibility lies with harmful behaviour, not the pupil’s accent.
3B · Short answer
Describe a supportive peer action and an adult-supported reporting step.
Example of a full-credit answer: Refuse to join the mockery and reassure the pupil that they deserve respect. Tell the supervising teacher and use the platform’s report/mute options with guidance.
- Offers concrete non-blaming peer support that avoids amplification.
- Connects the case to trusted-adult and appropriate platform reporting/help.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil reposts a humiliating image to a larger group saying “Look how awful this bullying is.” The repost identifies the targeted child.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which conclusions fit the case?
- a: The targeted child is responsible for the larger audience.
- b: Good intentions do not remove the risk of further humiliation.
- c: A private report to an appropriate adult can avoid unnecessary amplification.
- d: Condemning a post makes every public repost harmless.
How evidence is shared matters, even when someone intends to help.
4B · Open ended
Identify the problem with the warning repost and propose a repair.
Example of a full-credit answer: It enlarges the audience for the humiliating image and identifies the child. Stop reposting, remove the unnecessary share where possible and ask a trusted adult to help report it privately.
- Identifies amplification and privacy harm from the repost.
- Proposes a practical stop-spread/removal/adult-reporting response without retaliation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a short card explaining how to respond to harmful online targeting. It should support the pupil, avoid spreading harmful content and identify a trusted-adult route.
5A · Hotspot
Which card best meets the brief?
- a: Keep every incident secret from adults
- b: Publish everyone’s names and addresses
- c: Support, do not amplify, seek trusted-adult help, report with guidance
- d: Retaliate until the bully stops
The card that combines support, non-amplification and adult help uses appropriate safety and reporting routes.
5B · Open ended
Write a short support card with a supportive statement and concrete safe actions.
Example of a full-credit answer: You do not deserve harmful targeting. Do not retaliate or forward humiliating content; tell a trusted teacher or caregiver and preserve/report relevant evidence privately with their guidance.
- Includes a non-blaming supportive message for the targeted pupil.
- Includes limiting spread/retaliation and an adult-supported evidence/reporting route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.9 · Recognising phishing
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Display name and address
Fictional classroom example
A fictional message displays “Library Office” but comes from rewards@book-prize.example and asks for a password. The known library domain is library.example.
Question: Which clues are concerning?
Answer: The sender domain differs and the message requests a password.
Why: The display name does not resolve those mismatches.
Example 2 · Polished wording
Fictional classroom example
A fictional scam message has perfect spelling and a copied logo.
Question: Does polish establish legitimacy?
Answer: No. It can still request unsafe actions or use a false identity.
Why: Appearance is not sufficient verification.
Example 3 · A visible link label
Fictional classroom example
A fictional message labels a link “class portal,” but the prepared destination is gifts.example rather than the known class.example.
Question: What should the reader notice?
Answer: The visible label and actual destination do not match the known portal.
Why: The mismatch warrants caution without opening the link.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify communication fields
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message displays School Desk, comes from notice@school-help.example and labels its link “school.example” while the destination is school-help.example. The known school domain in this case is school.example.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each field with the supplied value.
Complete or match: Display name; Actual sender domain; Independently known school domain
- a: school-help.example
- b: School Desk
- c: school.example
- d: A display label proves identity
The visible name and actual sender are different fields.
Investigation: phishing lab
F2 · Match clue to concern
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message says “Your account closes in one minute,” asks for a secret code and points to an unfamiliar destination. No real code is shown.
F2 · Matching
Match each clue with the concern it raises.
Complete or match: One-minute deadline; Secret-code demand; Unfamiliar destination
- a: Proof that a logo guarantees safety
- b: Possible sender or destination mismatch
- c: Risk to private account access
- d: Pressure to rush
The combined clues warrant caution and adult-supported verification.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Correct spelling
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional unexpected prize message uses perfect grammar but requests an account password. Its sender is unverified.
F3 · True or false
True or false? Perfect grammar alone establishes the message’s legitimacy.
- true: True
- false: False
Polished wording can appear in deceptive messages; the unsafe request remains.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · Choose the strongest concern
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message offers an unexpected reward and asks a child to send a password. Other details are a blue background, a short title and a greeting.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which detail most directly raises a security concern?
- a: The presence of a greeting
- b: The short title
- c: The blue background
- d: The request for the account password
A password request risks access regardless of decoration.
Investigation: message lab
F5 · An unexpected attachment
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional chat claiming to be a club sends an unexpected attachment and says “Do not ask your teacher.” The club’s usual teacher-supervised channel has no matching notice. No attachment is actually provided.
F5 · Open ended
Identify two concerning communication clues and state a safe response without opening anything.
Example of a full-credit answer: The unexpected attachment and instruction not to ask a teacher are concerning, especially with no usual-channel notice. Do not open it; show a trusted adult and check through the known club route.
- Identifies two supplied clues such as unexpected file, secrecy or no known-channel match.
- Keeps the attachment unopened and uses trusted-adult/known-route verification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: phishing lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message claims to be from reading.example, but its sender is help@reading-reward.example and its prepared link destination is reading-reward.example. It demands a secret code to keep a reading account. The independently known class service is reading.example.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each supplied detail to its role.
Complete or match: reading.example; reading-reward.example; Send a secret code
- a: Known service domain
- b: Sensitive-action request
- c: Display name is sufficient proof
- d: Different sender/destination domain
The mismatch and secret request are separate warning clues.
1B · Open ended
Explain two clues that make the message suspicious and identify a safe next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The sender/destination differs from reading.example and the message asks for a secret code. Keep the code private and ask a trusted teacher through the known service route.
- Uses both the domain mismatch and sensitive-code request.
- Proposes no secret disclosure and an independently known adult-supported check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional message claims a library fee is due. A: the known library account record says no fee; B: the message uses the logo; C: it uses polite words; D: it has many exclamation marks.
2A · Hotspot
Which clue most directly challenges the payment demand?
- a: B: the copied logo
- b: A: the known library record shows no fee
- c: C: polite wording
- d: D: exclamation marks
The account record addresses the claimed obligation through a known route.
2B · Open ended
Justify the known-record check and explain why the logo is weaker evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The known record directly shows whether the fee exists. A logo can be copied and does not establish an obligation or sender identity.
- Connects the known account record to verification of the exact demand.
- Explains the copyable-logo limitation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional game chat account calls itself Support and asks a pupil to reveal a password to receive a reward. The pupil has no verified reward notice.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which statements are correct?
- a: A reward makes sharing a password safe.
- b: Only email can contain deceptive requests.
- c: Phishing-like requests can arrive through chat as well as email.
- d: A Support display name does not authorise revealing a password.
The communication pattern matters across channels.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the same warning pattern applies in chat and give an adult-supported response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The account claims trusted status and uses a reward to request a secret, like other phishing messages. Keep the password private and show a trusted adult or moderator through the known reporting route.
- Identifies trusted-role imitation plus reward/secret request in chat.
- Protects the secret and names an appropriate trusted help/report route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil trusts an unfamiliar message because the displayed destination has a lock icon. The message still asks for an account secret and its identity is unverified.
4A · Matching
Match each clue with its actual meaning.
Complete or match: Lock icon; Unverified sender; Secret request
- a: Sensitive demand requiring caution
- b: A lock authorises sharing every secret
- c: Connection indicator, not proof of honesty
- d: Identity remains uncertain
Connection security and trustworthy purpose are different.
4B · Open ended
Identify the faulty inference and explain which message clues still require caution.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats a connection indicator as proof of honesty. The sender remains unverified and the account-secret demand remains a concern. Keep the secret private and ask a trusted adult to check the request through an independently known route.
- Distinguishes the lock/connection indicator from trustworthy identity or purpose.
- Names the unverified sender and/or secret demand as remaining concerns.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a short checklist for suspicious messages. It should inspect the claimed sender, actual destination, requested action and pressure, then direct pupils to adult support.
5A · Dropdown selection
Match each question with its checking focus.
Complete or match: Who is really sending this?; Where does this actually lead?; What am I being pressured to reveal or do?
- a: Request and urgency
- b: Does the colour look friendly?
- c: Destination
- d: Sender identity
The checklist inspects meaningful communication features.
5B · Open ended
Write a three-question recognition checklist and a safe response when several clues are concerning.
Example of a full-credit answer: Who is the actual sender? Where does the link really lead? What information or action is demanded, and is there pressure? If suspicious, do not open or reveal secrets; ask a trusted adult through a known route.
- Includes sender, destination and requested-action/pressure checks.
- Provides a cautious no-disclosure/no-unknown-opening response with trusted help.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.10 · Protecting others in digital spaces
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A wider audience
Fictional classroom example
A fictional pupil permits a photo in a small class project, but not a public poster.
Question: Does the first permission cover the poster?
Answer: No. The purpose and audience changed.
Why: Ask about the new use and follow adult guidance.
Example 2 · A private concern
Fictional classroom example
A fictional classmate privately says they are upset by comments.
Question: Should the listener post the conversation publicly to get attention?
Answer: No. Offer support and seek appropriate adult help without unnecessary exposure.
Why: Helping should not widen the audience for private details.
Example 3 · A safe report
Fictional classroom example
A fictional teacher needs the date and text of a harmful message.
Question: Is the target’s home address needed?
Answer: No. It is unrelated private information.
Why: Reports should contain relevant evidence, not extra sensitive data.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose protective sharing
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classmate allows their drawing to appear in the class folder with a first-name credit. They have not allowed public reposting or sharing their home address.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions fit the supplied permission?
- a: Add the pupil’s home address.
- b: Use only the agreed first-name credit.
- c: Post the drawing publicly without asking.
- d: Keep the drawing in the class folder.
The permission is limited to a stated audience and credit.
Investigation: privacy lab
F2 · Find the unnecessary disclosure
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional help request includes A: task name, B: error message, C: pupil’s home address, D: device type. The task is fixing a document-format problem; no location is needed.
F2 · Hotspot
Which detail should be removed as unnecessary private information?
- a: A: the task name
- b: C: the home address
- c: D: the relevant device type
- d: B: the relevant error message
The home address does not help solve this formatting problem.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Match help to role
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil is targeted by cruel comments. A friend can offer support, a teacher can assess the school issue and a platform report tool can flag harmful content.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Match each role with its appropriate contribution.
Complete or match: Friend; Trusted teacher; Report tool
- a: Offer respectful support
- b: Flag relevant harmful content
- c: Help assess and address the situation
- d: Publicly reveal private records
Different roles can help without expanding the harmful audience.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · A consent-aware sharing plan
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional club wants to share a group photo. The teacher asks the group to check permission, remove unnecessary identifying details and use the approved audience.
F4 · Matching
Match each step with its protective purpose.
Complete or match: Check permission; Remove extra identifiers; Use agreed audience
- a: Avoid unapproved wider sharing
- b: Assume a photo can be posted anywhere
- c: Respect the intended use
- d: Limit unnecessary exposure
Protection involves purpose, data and audience together.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A well-meant public story
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil posts a classmate’s private problem publicly to ask for help, without permission. The post includes the classmate’s name.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the privacy problem and propose a better help-seeking route.
Example of a full-credit answer: The post exposes a named classmate’s private problem without permission. Remove or stop spreading it where possible and seek help privately from a trusted adult, sharing only relevant details.
- Identifies unconsented public disclosure of the classmate’s personal information.
- Proposes reducing spread and using a private, appropriate adult-supported route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional group wants to show a software error to a teacher. The screenshot also shows another pupil’s private chat and personal contact information.
1A · Multiple choice
Which action best meets the help need while protecting the classmate?
- a: Add more private details for context
- b: Remove unrelated private details from the actual shared copy before sending it to the teacher.
- c: Post the entire screenshot publicly
- d: Forward the private chat to all pupils
The relevant error can be shown without exposing the private conversation or contact details. Check the actual shared file, not merely a covered preview.
1B · Open ended
Explain what should remain, what should be removed and how to check the actual screenshot copy before sending it to the teacher.
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep the relevant error and task context. With adult help if needed, remove the unrelated private chat and contact details from the actual copy to be shared; inspect that copy to confirm they cannot be read or uncovered. Send it only through the approved teacher-help route.
- Preserves the relevant error/task information needed for help.
- Removes the unrelated private conversation/contact information from the actual shared copy and verifies it is not merely hidden by a reversible cover.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional classmate is repeatedly mocked in a group. The classmate asks not to have the story posted publicly. A trusted teacher can help.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions respect the supplied needs?
- a: Ignore the classmate’s boundary to gain attention.
- b: Tell the classmate the mockery is their fault.
- c: Offer help reaching a trusted teacher.
- d: Avoid publicising the classmate’s story.
The case calls for privacy, support and appropriate help.
2B · Open ended
Explain the value of both the privacy boundary and the adult-support offer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Not posting the story avoids further exposure and respects the classmate’s request. A trusted teacher can help address the repeated targeting so the pupil is not left alone.
- Explains how limiting public sharing protects the classmate.
- Explains the practical value of trusted-adult support for repeated harm.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil agreed to their artwork in a class display. A club now wants it in a public fundraising advertisement. No permission for the new use is recorded.
3A · True or false
True or false? The new advertisement should be treated as automatically authorised by the earlier class-display permission.
- true: True
- false: False
The audience and purpose changed; appropriate new permission is needed.
3B · Open ended
Explain what changed and propose a consent-respecting next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The use moved from a class display to a public advertisement. Ask for appropriate permission for that specific use, with teacher/caregiver guidance, or choose authorised material instead.
- Identifies the changed purpose/audience.
- Proposes permission for the new scope or an authorised alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil reports a harmful comment to a teacher. The useful record includes the comment, date and account label. The draft also includes unrelated home addresses.
4A · Matching
Match each detail to its role.
Complete or match: Comment text; Date and account label; Unrelated home addresses
- a: Unnecessary private information
- b: Relevant incident evidence
- c: Relevant locating context
- d: Every private detail makes a report stronger
A report should be relevant and proportionate.
4B · Open ended
Identify the information to remove and explain what relevant evidence should remain.
Example of a full-credit answer: Remove unrelated home addresses. Keep the relevant comment, date and account label for the trusted teacher, with enough context to understand the incident.
- Identifies unrelated addresses as unnecessary data to remove.
- Preserves the relevant incident evidence and context for the appropriate adult.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a checklist before sharing content about another person. It should consider permission, audience, necessity and a safe help route if harm appears.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each question with its protective focus.
Complete or match: Is this use agreed?; Who can see it?; Is this detail needed?
- a: Permission
- b: Audience
- c: Data minimisation
- d: Would more exposure get more likes?
These questions reduce unnecessary exposure while allowing appropriate sharing.
5B · Open ended
Write a short checklist and describe what to do if a post could harm a classmate.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check permission for the use, the intended audience and whether each personal detail is needed. If it may harm a classmate, do not spread it; seek a trusted adult’s help and share only relevant evidence privately.
- Includes permission, audience and necessity checks.
- Provides a stop-spread and appropriate adult-supported response to potential harm.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.11 · Participating in community discussions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A relevant experience
Fictional classroom example
A fictional school forum asks how to improve library signs. A pupil says the arrows are hard to see from the entrance.
Question: Is this a relevant contribution?
Answer: Yes. It describes an experience connected to the sign problem.
Why: It should not be expanded into a claim about every reader without more evidence.
Example 2 · A claim and a preference
Fictional classroom example
A fictional comment says “There are two benches, and I would like another.”
Question: How should a summary separate it?
Answer: Two benches is a count claim; wanting another is a preference or proposal.
Why: The parts need different kinds of evaluation.
Example 3 · A premature decision
Fictional classroom example
A fictional forum has discussed a garden but no approval has occurred.
Question: Can the summary say the garden is approved?
Answer: No. It remains a proposal.
Why: Accurate process status matters to participants.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Stay with the shared question
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional supervised forum asks how to make classroom notices easier to read. Replies suggest larger text, discuss an unrelated game score, insult a pupil or reveal a home address.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which contribution directly addresses the discussion?
- a: A pupil’s home address
- b: An unrelated game score
- c: An insult about the writer
- d: Use larger text and clearer headings
The larger-text and clearer-headings proposal directly addresses the shared readability goal.
Investigation: message lab
F2 · Kinds of contribution
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional comments say A “I waited five minutes yesterday,” B “The log records an average wait of four minutes,” C “Could we add a second return tray?”
F2 · Dropdown selection
Match each comment to its role.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: All three are approved decisions
- b: Suggested action
- c: Recorded-data claim
- d: Personal experience
Experience, data and proposals contribute differently.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Popularity and representation
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional forum has 10 comments from one pupil and one comment each from two others. No survey of the whole class was conducted.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The most frequent commenter automatically represents every pupil’s view.
- true: True
- false: False
Comment frequency is not a representative survey or authority to speak for everyone.
Investigation: graph lab
F4 · Make a discussion more inclusive
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional forum about a playground route currently accepts only uncaptioned voice messages. The class can also offer readable text and a teacher-supported private route for sensitive access concerns.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which additions improve access or privacy?
- a: Require everyone to reveal private conditions publicly.
- b: Provide a readable text option for contributions.
- c: Exclude anyone who cannot use voice messages.
- d: Offer a trusted-teacher route for sensitive concerns.
The additions expand participation without unnecessary exposure.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F5 · A careful summary
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional discussion confirms a 10-credit budget. Some pupils prefer cushions; others prefer a table. No purchase decision has been made.
F5 · Open ended
Write a summary separating the agreed fact from the two unresolved preferences and unapproved choice, then propose a sensible next check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The group has a 10-credit budget. Pupils suggested cushions and a table, but no purchase has been approved; the next step is to compare costs and needs.
- States the agreed 10-credit budget accurately.
- Preserves the two preferences and unapproved decision status with a sensible next step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school discussion concerns a crowded book-return area. The record says one tray fills by noon. A pupil suggests a second tray and asks how it would be labelled.
1A · Matching
Match each part with its function.
Complete or match: Tray fills by noon; Add second tray; Ask about labels
- a: Relevant supporting observation
- b: Practical follow-up question
- c: Proof every problem is solved
- d: Proposed improvement
A constructive comment connects evidence, an idea and a next question.
1B · Open ended
Write a contribution using the observation and a practical proposal or question.
Example of a full-credit answer: The current tray fills by noon. Could we add a second tray, and how would we label them so returns remain organised?
- Uses the supplied noon/tray observation as relevant context.
- Adds a concrete connected proposal and/or implementation question.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional online survey reaches only pupils who joined the robotics chat. The topic is the whole school’s preferred lunchtime space. A repeated post copies the same poll result and adds no new respondents; other school groups have not been asked.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each feature with its implication.
Complete or match: Robotics-chat respondents; Copy of the poll; Other pupils not asked
- a: Every pupil has been represented
- b: One limited group
- c: No new participants
- d: School-wide preference remains uncertain
A discussion should not turn a narrow poll into a school-wide result.
2B · Open ended
Explain the representation limit and propose a more inclusive next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: Only robotics-chat pupils answered, so the poll does not establish the whole school’s preference. Invite input through supervised channels that reach different classes and access needs.
- Identifies the limited respondent group and unsupported whole-school scope.
- Proposes a broader accessible participation route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional supervised community board asks about park reading activities. A contributor can suggest a labelled book box, ask about maintenance or share a private neighbour’s address.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which contributions fit a constructive discussion?
- a: Suggest a labelled book box.
- b: Post a neighbour’s address without permission.
- c: Ask who would maintain it.
- d: Mock people with different interests.
The useful contributions address the topic and practical responsibility.
3B · Open ended
Write a useful contribution about the book-box idea and explain one privacy boundary for the discussion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Could a labelled book box work in the park, and who would maintain it? The discussion should not include a neighbour’s private address without permission because it is unnecessary for this proposal.
- Proposes the relevant book box and/or its practical maintenance question.
- Explains that an unrelated neighbour’s private address should not be publicly disclosed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional supervised forum has 40 comments: 18 from one pupil, 12 from another and 10 from a third. No other pupils contributed. A summary says 40 different pupils supported the proposal.
4A · Hotspot
Which correction addresses the summary’s mistake?
- a: Every comment automatically represents a different pupil
- b: Forty comments came from three pupils, not forty different pupils
- c: The largest comment count establishes official approval
- d: Three pupils prove the entire school agrees
Comment totals and the number of distinct participants are different.
4B · Open ended
Explain the counting error and propose a more inclusive next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The summary confuses 40 comments with 40 people; only three pupils contributed. Invite other pupils through accessible supervised routes and report actual distinct participation.
- Correctly distinguishes forty comments from three contributors.
- Proposes broader accessible participation and honest participant reporting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional supervised forum agrees that a path needs clearer signs. Members disagree about arrows versus a map. A teacher will check space and cost on Friday. No design has been approved.
5A · True or false
True or false? A good summary can record the agreed need, differing options and next check without pretending there is a final decision.
- true: True
- false: False
It preserves both progress and unresolved choices.
5B · Open ended
Write the summary with the agreed need and the remaining decision process.
Example of a full-credit answer: The group agrees the path needs clearer signs. Arrows and a map remain options; the teacher will check space and cost on Friday before a design is approved.
- Accurately states the shared need and both proposed options.
- Includes the Friday teacher check and preserves the unapproved status.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL5.12 · Digital civic participation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A supervised suggestion
Fictional classroom example
A fictional class asks its teacher to review a proposal for larger library labels.
Question: What makes this a participation activity?
Answer: Pupils contribute a relevant suggestion to a shared school decision.
Why: They use an appropriate supervised route rather than claiming to decide alone.
Example 2 · A limited poll
Fictional classroom example
A fictional lunchtime poll includes only one club’s members.
Question: Can it establish every pupil’s preference?
Answer: No. It describes the participating club members.
Why: The result needs its scope stated and broader input if a school-wide claim is intended.
Example 3 · A response with a constraint
Fictional classroom example
A fictional teacher supports clearer signs but says the proposed board is too large for the wall.
Question: What is a constructive next step?
Answer: Revise the design to fit the wall while preserving readable labels.
Why: Participation can involve adapting a proposal to practical constraints.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Parts of a participation message
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil writes “Visitors miss Room 4 because the sign is small. Our class observed six wrong-door visits. Could the teacher help review a larger sign?”
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Small Room 4 sign; Six observed wrong-door visits; Review a larger sign
- a: Proof a change is already approved
- b: Supporting class evidence
- c: Issue to address
- d: Practical request
The message contributes to a decision without claiming authority to make it.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Choose an appropriate channel
Fixed fictional classroom case
Fictional issues are A: unclear homework instructions, B: a school pathway sign, C: an unknown account asking for private data in a fake survey. Known teacher support is available.
F2 · Matching
Match each issue with its appropriate route.
Complete or match: A; B; C
- a: Use the school’s supervised suggestion process
- b: Do not provide data; show a trusted adult
- c: Use any unknown account that promises quick action
- d: Ask the task teacher through the known class channel
Routes should match responsibility and protect pupils.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Find the participation limit
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional poll about a whole-school garden receives responses from only the 12 members of one club. Panels show A: club-only sample, B: colourful chart, C: nice title, D: many emojis.
F3 · Hotspot
Which detail most directly limits a whole-school conclusion?
- a: A: only one club’s members answered
- b: D: the post has emojis
- c: C: the title is friendly
- d: B: the chart is colourful
The respondent group does not cover the rest of the school.
Investigation: graph lab
F4 · A suggestion is not an enacted rule
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class submits a proposal for a quiet lunchtime corner. The teacher has acknowledged it but no decision has been made.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Acknowledging receipt means the quiet corner is already approved.
- true: True
- false: False
Receipt and approval are different stages.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A realistic request
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants clearer signs. Its evidence is that five visitors asked for directions in one morning. It has no evidence about every visitor across the year.
F5 · Open ended
Write an evidence-based request and identify the limit of the observation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Our class observed five visitors asking for directions this morning. Could we review clearer signs with the teacher? This does not establish that every visitor is lost throughout the year.
- Connects the five-visitor observation to a practical supervised sign request.
- States the limited time/group scope without universalising.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional school discussion concerns a reading area. Pupils can submit a supervised suggestion, describe access needs without public private details and inspect the room’s size. They cannot approve spending themselves.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL correct statements. Which actions fit pupils’ role?
- a: Submit a respectful evidence-based suggestion through the supervised process.
- b: Demand that classmates reveal private details publicly.
- c: Consider the measured space and relevant access needs.
- d: Declare school spending approved without authority.
Pupils can contribute useful evidence and ideas while respecting roles and privacy.
1B · Open ended
Propose a useful contribution and explain one boundary on the pupils’ authority or data collection.
Example of a full-credit answer: Suggest a reading layout based on the measured room and access needs through the teacher. Pupils cannot approve spending or require public disclosure of private information.
- Proposes a relevant evidence-based supervised contribution.
- States a correct authority or privacy boundary.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional online poll is open only at a time when some pupils cannot use a device. A paper option and a later supervised session are possible.
2A · True or false
True or false? Offering an accessible alternative can help include pupils who cannot use the original online session.
- true: True
- false: False
The alternative addresses a participation barrier, though the final sample still needs describing.
2B · Open ended
Explain the barrier and propose one inclusive alternative without claiming everyone will respond.
Example of a full-credit answer: Some pupils lack device access at the original time. Offer a supervised later session or paper option, then report who actually participated rather than assume complete coverage.
- Identifies the time/device barrier and a suitable alternative.
- Preserves honest reporting of actual participation instead of claiming guaranteed universal response.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class submits a school-bin proposal Monday. On Tuesday staff acknowledge receipt. On Friday they request measurements before deciding.
3A · Dropdown selection
Match each stage with its meaning.
Complete or match: Submitted Monday; Acknowledged Tuesday; Measurements requested Friday
- a: Receipt confirmed
- b: More evidence needed before a decision
- c: Proposal already approved on Tuesday
- d: Suggestion delivered
The process records progress without confusing it with approval.
3B · Short answer
Explain the current status and propose a useful next contribution.
Example of a full-credit answer: The proposal is still pending because staff need measurements. With teacher guidance, provide the relevant bin/space measurements and identify how they were collected.
- Accurately states the pending decision and requested evidence.
- Proposes supplying relevant measurements through the supervised process.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional post has 200 likes for a playground idea. The users are not verified as school members and no formal vote has occurred. A pupil says this proves the whole school approved it.
4A · Hotspot
Which correction addresses the overclaim?
- a: A popular post changes the school rule immediately
- b: Likes show engagement, not verified whole-school approval
- c: Every like is automatically one school vote
- d: Only unliked ideas can be considered
Membership, representation and decision authority are not established by the metric.
4B · Open ended
Identify two reasons why the whole-school approval claim is unsupported.
Example of a full-credit answer: The people liking the post are not verified as school members, and no formal school decision or vote has occurred. Likes therefore do not establish whole-school approval.
- Identifies the unverified audience/representation issue.
- Identifies the absence of the authorised approval or voting process.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fixed fictional classroom case
A fictional class proposes clearer hallway signs after recording wrong-door visits. The teacher approves a small trial. The class should check whether the trial helps before making a broad success claim.
5A · Multiple choice
Which plan best evaluates the proposal’s effect?
- a: Declare success immediately because the signs look nice
- b: Assume approval guarantees every visitor finds the room
- c: Count unrelated game scores
- d: Compare wrong-door visits before and after in similar periods, noting limits
The selected plan measures the original problem under comparable conditions.
5B · Open ended
Propose a supervised participation-and-follow-up plan with a relevant measure and an honest limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Run the teacher-approved sign trial and compare wrong-door visits in similar before/after periods. Note that different visitor numbers or other changes may affect the result, so the trial does not prove success for every future situation.
- Includes the approved trial and a relevant comparable before/after measure.
- States a concrete condition or scope limitation on the conclusion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.1 · Identifying purpose and audience
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A welcome for new club members
Fictional teaching example
The fictional garden club welcomes pupils who have never visited its plot. They need to know where to meet and what the first session involves.
Question: Would a list of last year’s prizes meet the main need?
Answer: No. Give the meeting point and a short description of the first session.
Why: Past prizes may interest readers, but they do not answer the newcomers’ immediate questions.
Example 2 · One topic, two audiences
| Audience | Arrival | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Helpers | 2 p.m. | Set up |
| Visitors | 3 p.m. | View art |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional art show needs visitors and helpers. Visitors enter at 3 p.m.; helpers must arrive at 2 p.m. to set up.
Question: Why should the two messages have different arrival times?
Answer: The groups have different jobs: helpers prepare the room before visitors enter.
Why: Adapting information to purpose avoids sending either group to the wrong stage of the event.
Example 3 · A test that checks usefulness
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class creates a borrowing guide. Their goal is for new readers to find the loan period. One tester finds it in the heading; another says the colours are pretty.
Question: Which observation directly checks the stated goal?
Answer: The tester finding the loan period.
Why: The colour comment concerns appearance. Finding the required information shows whether the guide serves its purpose.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Who is the repair notice for?
Fictional classroom case
The fictional school tablet team writes: “Teachers: bring classroom tablets to Room 4 before Friday noon for the scheduled check.” The message is for teachers who hold classroom tablets, not families buying devices.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The intended audience is families who want to buy new devices.
- true: True
- false: False
The wording directly names the teachers, action and deadline.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · A purpose for a short guide
Fictional classroom case
A fictional guide is being made for pupils entering the computer room for the first time. Its stated goal is to show how to save a drawing in the class folder. The approved message says “Save, choose Class Drawings, then name your file.”
F2 · Hotspot
Which purpose matches the brief?
- a: Explain saving in the class folder
- b: Advertise the newest drawing app
- c: Celebrate the fastest classroom typist
- d: Rank every school drawing competition
Its purpose is the stated saving task, rather than an unrelated product promotion.
Investigation: prompt lab
F3 · Needed and distracting details
Fictional classroom case
A fictional family reading-night invitation must let families attend. The event is in the library at 5 p.m. on Tuesday; entry is free. The mascot’s favourite snack and the editor’s game score do not affect attendance.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The library location helps families attend.
- b: The starting time helps families attend.
- c: The editor’s game score is needed to enter.
- d: The mascot’s favourite snack replaces the time.
Place, time and entry conditions help families attend; unrelated personal details do not.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Explain the unfamiliar name
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club’s message says “Bring work to the CRC.” New pupils do not know that CRC means Community Reading Corner. The organizer wants the destination to be clear without changing the place.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Destination to name fully; Audience needing explanation; Detail that must stay accurate
- a: Community Reading Corner
- b: New pupils
- c: The actual destination
- d: A different meeting place
Expanding the abbreviation helps new readers while preserving the intended destination.
Investigation: revision lab
F5 · A poster that cannot be heard
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club announces its opening only through a spoken recording. Its intended audience includes a pupil who cannot hear the recording. The purpose is to tell all members the opening time and location. The confirmed details are Wednesday at 4 p.m. in Room 2.
F5 · Open ended
Name an addition that serves this audience and explain how it preserves the message’s purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add an accurate written version or captions giving the same opening time and location, so members who cannot hear the audio can obtain the attendance information.
- Proposes an accurate text alternative or captions containing the essential opening information.
- Explains that this lets the intended audience obtain the same attendance details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: accessibility lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom notice must help borrowers return a model kit. Return deadline: Thursday, 10 a.m. Destination: Science Desk, not the library. Readers are pupils who borrowed a kit.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Correct return destination; Correct deadline; Intended reader
- a: Science Desk
- b: Thursday, 10 a.m.
- c: Pupil who borrowed a kit
- d: School library
The borrowing task needs the stated destination and deadline, not an attractive but incomplete reminder.
1B · Short answer
Write one sentence that serves these borrowers, then explain which two attendance-style details make it usable.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Borrowers, return your kits to the Science Desk by Thursday at 10 a.m.” The destination and deadline tell them where and when to act.
- Includes the correct return action, Science Desk and Thursday 10 a.m. deadline.
- Explains how place and deadline help the named borrowers carry out the task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class invites grandparents to a story session. The brief says to avoid unexplained abbreviations and provide arrival details. Draft A says “SS@LC! Be there!” Draft B says “Story session: Learning Centre, Friday, 2 p.m.” Draft C gives only a decorative flower.
2A · Multiple choice
Which invitation best meets the brief for the grandparents?
- a: Story session: Learning Centre, Friday, 2 p.m.
- b: SS@LC! Be there!
- c: A flower picture with no event details.
- d: Story session: Learning Centre; arrive whenever you like.
B states the event, place and time without unexplained abbreviations.
2B · Open ended
Choose a draft and justify it with two features that match the audience brief.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B because it spells out the event and place, and includes Friday at 2 p.m. These features make the invitation usable without knowing club abbreviations.
- Chooses B and explains that full names avoid unexplained abbreviations.
- Uses its place/time information to explain how it meets the attendance purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional village reading booth has a poster for people already at the plaza. It says “Join us here at 4 p.m.” The same wording will be sent to families at home, who cannot see where “here” is. The booth is beside the plaza gate.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Missing detail for remote readers; Location to add; Time to retain
- a: Named location
- b: Beside the plaza gate
- c: 4 p.m.
- d: A larger decorative border
The audience is now away from the poster, so a location word that depended on being there must be replaced.
3B · Open ended
Rewrite the message for families at home, and explain why “here” became unclear.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Join the reading booth beside the plaza gate at 4 p.m.” People at home cannot infer the poster’s location, so the named place replaces “here.”
- Gives a usable message with the reading booth, plaza-gate location and 4 p.m. time.
- Explains that the new audience is not physically beside the poster, so “here” lacks a clear reference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional appointment notice aims to help families find their assigned slot. Draft X earns 40 likes but omits the slot list. Draft Y earns 8 likes and includes the correct list. An editor says X must serve the purpose better because it has more likes.
4A · Hotspot
Which draft supplies the information required by the stated purpose?
- a: Draft Y with the correct list
- b: Draft X with forty likes
- c: Either draft without a slot list
- d: Only a new decorative headline
Likes measure one form of engagement, not whether families can find their appointment information.
4B · Open ended
Identify the editor’s error and propose a direct test of the notice’s purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: The editor treats likes as proof that the information task is met. Ask test readers to find the correct assigned slot; a notice without the list cannot pass that test.
- Identifies that popularity is being confused with meeting the information purpose.
- Proposes checking whether intended readers can find their correct appointment slot.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club needs a digital reminder for volunteers who will sort books. Confirmed details: Saturday, 9 a.m., Room 6. Volunteers should bring a pencil. The organizer wants a short message that clearly names the action, time, place and needed item.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Audience; Required item; Meeting location
- a: Book-sorting volunteers
- b: A pencil
- c: Room 6
- d: People buying new books
A useful plan combines the purpose and audience with complete confirmed details.
5B · Open ended
Propose the reminder, then describe one audience test you would use before publishing.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Book-sorting volunteers: meet in Room 6 on Saturday at 9 a.m. Bring a pencil.” Ask a volunteer to state where and when to arrive and what to bring. Other clear versions are acceptable.
- Writes an accurate reminder for volunteers containing the sorting task, time, place and pencil requirement.
- Proposes a test of whether an intended reader can find and use those essential details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.2 · Selecting an appropriate format
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Comparing bus departures
| Point | Departure |
|---|---|
| Gate A | 7:30 |
| Gate B | 7:40 |
| Hall | 7:50 |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional school trip has three departure points and three times. Families need to find the time for their own point.
Question: Would a table or a long unbroken paragraph make the comparison easier to scan?
Answer: A clearly labelled table.
Why: Each row can link one departure point to one time without hiding the relationship inside a long paragraph.
Example 2 · A quiet waiting room
Fictional teaching example
A fictional waiting area asks visitors to keep sound off. An announcement must explain the order of three registration steps.
Question: What format could meet the setting?
Answer: A readable numbered text list or labelled picture sequence.
Why: The essential order remains available without requiring the visitor to play audio.
Example 3 · Showing a changing shadow
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class wants to show how a model shadow changes position during a demonstration.
Question: Why might a short video help, and what should accompany it?
Answer: A video can show change over time; a description or equivalent labelled sequence should provide the essential visual information.
Why: Movement is relevant to the task, but viewers still need an accessible way to understand the change.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A low-data announcement
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class must send tomorrow’s room change to families with limited data. The essential message is “Meet in Room 8 at 10 a.m.” A text notice is 1 unit in this classroom file-size model; a decorative video is 30 units and gives the same message.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The text notice preserves the essential meeting details.
- b: The text notice uses fewer of the stated data units.
- c: The video becomes necessary because it is larger.
- d: The smaller notice should omit the meeting time.
The short text carries the complete message using fewer of the stated file-size units.
Investigation: graph lab
F2 · Match forms to tasks
Fictional classroom case
A fictional guide team has three tasks: compare stall prices, locate the entrance and demonstrate a paper-folding sequence. Its available formats are a labelled price table, a simple map and a step-by-step picture strip.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Compare stall prices; Locate the entrance; Follow folding order
- a: Labelled price table
- b: Simple map
- c: Step-by-step picture strip
- d: Unlabelled decorative collage
Each format is chosen for an information task rather than for novelty.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · A format for finding a number
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club records membership counts: Art 18, Chess 12, Music 21. Readers mainly need the exact count for any named club, rather than a recording of a discussion.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which format best serves the stated exact-lookup task?
- a: Labelled table with all counts
- b: Long audio with scattered counts
- c: Unlabelled pictures without counts
- d: A title saying “Popular Clubs”
The task is exact lookup, so named rows with values directly serve it.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · Sound is not the whole message
Fictional classroom case
A fictional demonstration video shows which side of a model switch to press, but its audio only says “Press this side.” A viewer cannot see the picture. The demonstrated side is the left side.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The words “Press this side” fully explain the key visual to a listener who cannot see it.
- true: True
- false: False
An equivalent description must state the essential visual detail, not merely repeat vague audio.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F5 · Choose for a noisy booth
Fictional classroom case
A fictional fair booth must tell visitors how to sort three kinds of tokens. The booth is noisy and some visitors cannot hear its spoken recording. A board can display three labelled bins and the same instructions in text.
F5 · Open ended
Choose a suitable main format and explain how you would preserve access to the complete sorting instructions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a clear labelled board or diagram with the three shape-to-bin instructions in text. Visitors can obtain the essential instructions without hearing the recording.
- Chooses a visual/text format that suits the noisy setting.
- Explains that all three sorting relationships must remain available to visitors who cannot hear.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: accessibility lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional visitor needs to move from the gate to Room 3. The route is gate → hall → left corridor → Room 3. The task is finding a place, and the printed guide must work without internet.
1A · Multiple choice
Which format best supports the offline route-finding task?
- a: Printed labelled map with written directions.
- b: Printed song lyrics without a route.
- c: Unlabelled photograph with no route steps.
- d: Internet-only audio without a printed version.
A labelled route and text directions provide spatial information in an offline format.
1B · Short answer
Propose a format for the visitor and explain how it conveys both the route and the final destination.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a simple labelled map with the same route written as steps: gate, hall, left corridor, Room 3. The path and endpoint remain available without internet.
- Proposes an offline map or equivalent clear route sequence with accurate directions.
- Explains how the selected format identifies both the path and Room 3 as the endpoint.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional folding lesson needs to show three successive folds. Option A is a silent unlabelled photo. Option B is a numbered picture sequence with written steps. Option C is a long music clip. The class must be able to review each fold without sound.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Option meeting the brief; Essential ordering feature; Unneeded requirement
- a: Option B
- b: Numbered steps
- c: Playing sound
- d: Option C
B shows each fold in order and includes text, meeting the stated sound-free review requirement.
2B · Open ended
Choose a format and justify it using both the sequencing need and the sound-free access condition.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B. Numbered frames show the order, and written steps let the class review the process without listening to audio.
- Chooses B and explains how its numbered frames communicate the sequence.
- Explains how its written instructions meet the sound-free access requirement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class recorded a 40-unit video on planting a seed. Another class has a 5-unit transfer allowance. Three essential steps are fill the pot, place the seed and add the stated amount of water. A 3-unit picture-and-text sheet can contain all three.
3A · Hotspot
Which complete format fits the five-unit transfer allowance?
- a: Three-unit picture-and-text sheet with all steps.
- b: Six-unit written sheet with all steps.
- c: Four-unit decorative graphic with no steps.
- d: Original forty-unit demonstration video.
A complete three-step sheet fits the stated allowance; a smaller file is useful because it preserves the task information.
3B · Open ended
Adapt the material for the new class and explain what must be preserved despite the smaller size.
Example of a full-credit answer: Create the 3-unit sheet with all three steps in correct order and readable pictures/text. It fits 5 units while retaining the essential instructions.
- Proposes the complete picture-and-text sheet within the five-unit allowance.
- Specifies preserving all three accurate steps and their order, rather than merely reducing file size.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner says every timetable should become a video because videos are newer than tables. The timetable contains exact room and time pairs that visitors need to scan quickly.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Reasoning error; Relevant task; Useful table feature
- a: Choosing by novelty alone
- b: Quick exact lookup
- c: Aligned room-time rows
- d: Choosing by the lookup task
A format choice should be justified by the information task and access needs, not by which format seems newest.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error and describe a fair test of table and video versions for this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner assumes newer means better. Give readers both complete versions and ask them to find the same room-time pair accurately; compare whether each makes that task clear.
- Identifies novelty alone as an inadequate reason for choosing a format.
- Proposes comparing formats using the same exact-lookup task and complete information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club must invite families to a 2 p.m. workshop in Hall B. Some read on phones; others will see a printed notice. Both versions must include the time, place and “Bring a notebook.”
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Facts shared by both versions; Digital version; Offline version
- a: Time, place and notebook
- b: Short phone text
- c: Readable printed notice
- d: Different times in each version
Different formats can serve different access conditions while preserving the same essential facts.
5B · Open ended
Propose the two formats and explain how you would check that they communicate the same essential information.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a short phone message and a clear printed notice, each stating 2 p.m., Hall B and “Bring a notebook.” Compare both against the confirmed brief and ask readers to find those details.
- Proposes usable digital and printed formats containing all three required facts.
- Explains a consistency check against the same brief or reader task before publication.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.3 · Writing digital content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Replace a vague instruction
Fictional teaching example
A fictional message says “Put it there after that.” The writer means that a learner should put the completed drawing in the Art folder after saving it.
Question: How can the sentence become clear?
Answer: “After saving your drawing, put it in the Art folder.”
Why: The revision names the object, destination and order, so readers do not need the missing conversation.
Example 2 · Keep a limited result limited
| Testers | Found Help | Did not find Help |
|---|---|---|
| 10 | 8 | 2 |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class tested a menu with ten volunteers. Eight found the Help button. The draft says “Every user can always find Help.”
Question: What wording fits the evidence?
Answer: “Eight of the ten volunteers in our test found the Help button.”
Why: The revised sentence keeps the measured group and result instead of making a universal claim.
Example 3 · A meaningful link label
Fictional teaching example
A fictional page offers a document containing the sports-day schedule. Its link text is “Click here.”
Question: What label would explain the destination?
Answer: “Sports-day schedule.”
Why: Readers can identify the linked information from the label instead of guessing what “here” means.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Order the uploading directions
Fictional classroom case
A fictional offline class activity tells pupils to prepare a drawing file, choose that file in the activity, then check the displayed preview. The preview is checked before the teacher receives the final class work.
F1 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Step before choosing; Step after choosing; Object to choose
- a: Prepare the drawing file
- b: Check the displayed preview
- c: The intended drawing file
- d: An unrelated game screenshot
Naming the file and preserving the order makes the instructions usable.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · A heading that tells the topic
Fictional classroom case
A fictional information page has a section explaining how to return borrowed headphones. Possible headings are “Returning headphones,” “Wonderful things,” “My favourite music,” and “Everything you need.”
F2 · Hotspot
Which heading tells readers what this section contains?
- a: Returning headphones
- b: Wonderful things
- c: My favourite music
- d: Everything you need
A useful heading identifies this section’s actual subject.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Resolve an unclear date
Fictional classroom case
A fictional notice posted on Monday says “Bring forms tomorrow.” A family reads a saved copy on Thursday. The organizer’s intended deadline was Tuesday, 10 November, at noon.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Explicit intended date; Intended deadline time; Ambiguous word in the old notice
- a: Tuesday, 10 November
- b: Noon
- c: Tomorrow
- d: Thursday, 12 November
The explicit intended date removes the uncertainty caused by reading an old relative-time word.
Investigation: revision lab
F4 · Spelling and evidence are different
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club report correctly spells every word but claims that its activity helped all pupils. Only four volunteers were asked. The draft has no evidence about the other pupils.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Perfect spelling makes the claim about all pupils fully supported.
- true: True
- false: False
Proofreading and evidence checking answer different questions.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · Rewrite a cluttered reminder
Fictional classroom case
A fictional reminder must tell library helpers to arrive at Room 5 at 8 a.m. on Saturday. Its draft begins with six sentences about favourite books and ends with the arrival details.
F5 · Short answer
Write a clear opening sentence and explain why its order serves the reminder’s purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Library helpers, meet in Room 5 at 8 a.m. on Saturday.” Putting the action and arrival details first helps helpers find what they need without reading unrelated material.
- Writes a sentence containing the intended audience, room, time and day accurately.
- Explains that placing the action/details first serves the reader’s reminder task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: revision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional form test involves 12 pupils. Nine complete the form without help, while three need an explanation. The editor needs one accurate result sentence.
1A · Multiple choice
Which sentence matches the recorded test?
- a: Nine of twelve completed it without help.
- b: All future pupils will need no help.
- c: Three of twelve completed it without help.
- d: No pupil needed any explanation.
The measured result concerns this group, and the two counts add to twelve.
1B · Open ended
Write the result sentence and explain why it should not promise that all future readers will need no help.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Nine of the 12 pupils in our test completed the form without help; three needed an explanation.” This small test does not include all future readers.
- Reports the nine/three result and twelve-person test accurately.
- Explains the limit of extending a small tested group to every future reader.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional activity asks readers to name a file “River Map” and save it in the Geography folder. Draft A says “Save it properly.” Draft B says “Name the file River Map, then save it in Geography.” Draft C says “Choose any folder and name.”
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Draft matching both requirements; Required file name; Required destination
- a: Draft B
- b: River Map
- c: Geography folder
- d: Draft C
B states the name and destination instead of assuming the reader already knows them.
2B · Open ended
Choose the draft and justify it with the two required details.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B because it gives the exact file name River Map and the Geography folder, so a first-time reader can make the intended choices.
- Chooses B and identifies the exact required file name.
- Explains that specifying the Geography folder removes an important ambiguity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional demonstration poster says “Move the blue marker to the box on the right.” The same instruction must be given to a reader who cannot distinguish the colours but can identify shapes and read labels. The marker is the only round marker; the destination is labelled Finish.
3A · True or false
True or false? The instruction can use the round shape and Finish label instead of requiring colour information.
- true: True
- false: False
The new wording identifies the object and destination without depending on colour vision.
3B · Open ended
Rewrite the instruction for this reader and explain which original clue it replaces.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Move the round marker into the box labelled Finish.” The round shape and named destination replace a colour-only reference that the listener cannot use.
- Provides a clear instruction using round marker and Finish as the destination.
- Explains the need to replace the inaccessible colour-only reference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class survey finds that 7 of 10 participants prefer a new menu. An editor changes “Seven of ten participants preferred it” to “Everyone agrees the new menu is best,” calling this only a style improvement.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: What the original measured; Unsupported addition; Recorded number preferring it
- a: Preference in ten participants
- b: Agreement by everyone
- c: Seven participants
- d: A test of every possible reader
The edit changes the strength and scope of the claim; it is not merely a shorter style.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error and supply an accurate replacement sentence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The editor turns a limited preference result into a universal judgement. Keep “Seven of the ten surveyed participants preferred the new menu.”
- Identifies the unsupported expansion from a small preference survey to universal agreement/bestness.
- Provides a replacement preserving seven of ten and the preference result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class post incorrectly says the workshop starts at 11 a.m. The confirmed time is 10 a.m. The post has already been shared. The editor can update it and send a correction through the same class notice channel.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The correction should state the accurate 10 a.m. time.
- b: Earlier readers should be able to identify the changed detail.
- c: Leaving both times unexplained avoids confusion.
- d: Blaming readers replaces the need for a correction.
A correction should reach earlier readers and clearly identify the accurate detail.
5B · Open ended
Write the correction and propose one way to reduce confusion among people who saw the earlier post.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Correction: the workshop starts at 10 a.m., not 11 a.m.” Update the original and send the correction through the same class channel so earlier readers can find the change.
- Writes a clear correction distinguishing the correct 10 a.m. time from the old 11 a.m. error.
- Proposes updating/reaching earlier readers through an appropriate existing notice route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.4 · Creating images, audio and video
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A scene plan
Fictional teaching example
A fictional team makes a video about returning a book. They plan: show the return desk, place the book on the desk, then show the confirmation slip.
Question: Why plan these frames first?
Answer: The frames show the important action in a usable order.
Why: A storyboard helps the team capture the sequence that serves the instructional purpose.
Example 2 · A voice with no private name
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class records directions for a classroom model. The learning goal does not need a pupil’s full name.
Question: Should the spoken introduction add the pupil’s home address?
Answer: No. It is unnecessary personal information for the task.
Why: A useful recording can give the directions without adding identifying details.
Example 3 · The missing word
Fictional teaching example
A fictional speaker says “The bridge is not open today.” An edit removes “not.”
Question: Does the edited line preserve the meaning?
Answer: No. It changes a closed-bridge message into an open-bridge message.
Why: Checking the original context is necessary even when all remaining words were genuinely spoken.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Plan three recording stages
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class will film a model seed dispenser. It plans to show the empty tray, demonstrate one release and show the final seed count. These stages must be shown in that order.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: First planned frame; Middle planned action; Final planned evidence
- a: The empty tray
- b: One seed release
- c: The seed count
- d: An unrelated dance clip
The storyboard links initial state, action and result instead of selecting unrelated footage.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Choose what stays in the picture
Fictional classroom case
A fictional poster needs a picture of a handmade bridge model. An ID card with a pupil’s private details lies beside it. The private card is not needed to explain the bridge.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Needed picture subject; Unnecessary private detail; Safer preparation
- a: The handmade bridge model
- b: The pupil ID card
- c: Remove the card before capture
- d: Publish the ID card clearly
The model can be shown without exposing unrelated personal details.
Investigation: privacy lab
F3 · Compare original and edited speech
Fictional classroom case
A fictional audio guide says: “You may use the hall after the teacher unlocks it.” A shortened clip says only “You may use the hall.” The condition was deliberately cut for length, without changing the school rule.
F3 · True or false
True or false? The shortened clip gives all the conditions of the original permission.
- true: True
- false: False
The cut removes the condition and can mislead listeners about when entry is allowed.
Investigation: clip lab
F4 · Caption an important sound
Fictional classroom case
A fictional video teaches a model crossing signal. A beep tells the viewer when a blue light changes. The essential sound needs to be conveyed to viewers who cannot hear.
F4 · Hotspot
Which caption conveys the essential sound event?
- a: [Signal beeps] The blue light is now on.
- b: [Something happens somewhere off screen.]
- c: [Decorative colours fill the background.]
- d: [The final screen contains no message.]
Meaningful captions include relevant sounds as well as words.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F5 · Label a recreated scene
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class uses drawings to recreate a historical school celebration. No camera recording of the event is available. The team plans to animate the drawings.
F5 · Open ended
Give an honest label for the animation and explain why it should not be presented as footage of the original event.
Example of a full-credit answer: Label it “Student reconstruction using drawings.” It was created later to illustrate the event, so calling it original footage would misrepresent its origin.
- Proposes a label that clearly identifies the drawing-based reconstruction.
- Explains that the animation is later-created material, not a camera record of the event.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: provenance lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team records a 20-second instruction. In sample A the words are audible, with permission for the class project and no private contact details. In B music covers the words. In C the speaker’s private contact details are added even though they are not needed.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Sample A keeps the task instructions audible.
- b: Sample C adds personal details that the task does not need.
- c: Sample B becomes clearer when music covers the words.
- d: Permission for a class project requires publishing contact details.
A preserves the needed instructions and stated permission without the problems in B and C.
1B · Short answer
Choose the sample and explain how clarity and data minimisation affect your decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A: listeners can hear the instructions, and the recording omits unnecessary personal details. The other samples fail one of those checks.
- Chooses A and explains why audible instructions serve the purpose.
- Explains that excluding unnecessary private contact details reduces avoidable exposure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional first-aid-model video has a current script, a labelled diagram and captions. Review A checks only the opening music. Review B compares the final pictures, spoken script and captions against the teacher-approved demonstration. Review C counts likes.
2A · Multiple choice
Which review checks the final instructional consistency?
- a: Compare pictures, speech and captions with approved material.
- b: Check only whether the opening music sounds pleasant.
- c: Count likes without checking the actual instructions.
- d: Check that the file opens, without reviewing its content.
B checks whether the final media preserve the approved meaning.
2B · Open ended
Choose a review and justify it using two parts of the final media that should agree.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B. Compare the pictures with the approved spoken instructions, and check that captions express the same final information. Pleasant music or likes do not perform those checks.
- Chooses B and explains comparing pictures with approved instructions.
- Explains checking captions against the same final meaning rather than popularity or music quality.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional picture shows a square token entering the container labelled A and a round token entering B. The team now needs an audio explanation for a listener who cannot see the shapes.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Square token destination; Round token destination; Information the audio must preserve
- a: Container A
- b: Container B
- c: Both shape-to-container pairs
- d: Only the image colour
An equivalent explanation states the relationships that the visual originally carried.
3B · Open ended
Write the essential audio instructions and explain why “put these over there” would fail.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Put the square token in A and the round token in B.” Vague pointing words rely on seeing the picture and do not identify the two required destinations.
- States both shape-to-container pairs accurately.
- Explains that vague pointing words omit information a listener cannot obtain visually.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional full illustration shows three cleanup volunteers beside a pile collected over a month. A cropped version hides the label “One month’s collection” and is captioned “Today’s litter.” An editor says the crop cannot mislead because no object was added.
4A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Context omitted by the crop; Unsupported new time claim; Reason the edit can mislead
- a: One month’s collection
- b: Today’s litter
- c: It hides the collection period
- d: No possible change in meaning
A crop can remove essential context even without adding or inventing objects.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error and propose a caption or framing correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The editor overlooks the missing month-long time context. Restore the label/full frame or caption the image as one month’s collection, rather than today’s litter.
- Explains how omitting the collection period makes the new caption misleading.
- Proposes restoring the time context through accurate framing or a corrected caption.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a short video explaining how to label a model’s three parts. The brief requires the correct order, no identifiable pupils, and access to the spoken instructions without sound.
5A · True or false
True or false? A plan can show only the model and still explain the labelling sequence.
- true: True
- false: False
The plan meets the content, privacy and access requirements without unnecessary recording.
5B · Open ended
Propose a scene plan and explain how it meets the privacy and sound-free access requirements.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show each of the three parts receiving its label in order, keeping the frame on the model. Add matching captions or a transcript so the instructions can be read without sound.
- Proposes an ordered three-part labelling sequence.
- Explains keeping identifiable pupils out and providing equivalent captions/transcript for sound-free access.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.5 · Combining different media
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A folding guide
Fictional teaching example
A fictional guide has a labelled arrow showing the fold direction and text saying “fold the lower edge to line A.”
Question: Why combine these?
Answer: The arrow shows the movement while the words identify the exact edge and destination.
Why: Both parts serve the same step and reduce ambiguity.
Example 2 · The silent station
Fictional teaching example
A fictional museum display announces “touch the raised circle” in audio. Its text says only “try it.”
Question: What text should be added?
Answer: Add “touch the raised circle” in the visible instructions.
Why: A reader without sound needs the actual action, not a vague invitation.
Example 3 · The two harvest counts
| Part | Count |
|---|---|
| Record | 6 |
| Drawing | 6 |
| Caption | 9 |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional garden record lists 6 tomatoes. A drawing shows 6, but a caption says 9.
Question: Which part needs correction?
Answer: Change the caption to 6 after checking the record.
Why: The record and drawing support the count; the caption conflicts.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Plan a pond page
Fictional classroom case
The fictional page must teach the pond route, the sound of a frog call and the opening time, 10 am. Its plan assigns the route to a map, the call to an audio clip and the exact opening time to a text label.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Route through the site; Sound of the call; Exact opening time
- a: Map
- b: Audio clip
- c: Text label
- d: Unrelated animated border
Each medium is assigned a different useful job.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Caption the correct panel
Fictional classroom case
A fictional plant page has Panel A showing a seed on Monday, Panel B a small shoot on Thursday and Panel C leaves on Sunday. Captions must stay with their matching panels.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Panel A; Panel B; Panel C
- a: Seed on Monday
- b: Small shoot on Thursday
- c: Leaves on Sunday
- d: Flower on Tuesday
The supplied panel record fixes each caption.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · A complete silent route
Fictional classroom case
The fictional route page shows “Library: second door on the left” in both its narration and visible text. The diagram adds an arrow to that door. A silent reader can still locate the library.
F3 · True or false
True or false? A reader without sound can still find the stated library location.
- true: True
- false: False
The visible words preserve the location without requiring audio.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F4 · Find the number conflict
Fictional classroom case
A fictional sports notice uses a checked list of 8 teams. The chart labels 8 teams and the headline says “Eight teams join.” The audio script says “Eighteen teams join.”
F4 · Hotspot
Select the part that must be corrected to match the checked count.
- a: Audio script: eighteen teams
- b: Chart label: 8 teams
- c: Headline: eight teams
- d: Record: 8 teams
The audio script changes eight to eighteen.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A useful replacement
Fictional classroom case
A fictional page explains how to identify three recycling bins. Its video names Paper, Metal and Glass, but the printable version shows only three colours. Some readers cannot distinguish the colours.
F5 · Open ended
Give one change that makes the printed guide usable without colour, and explain what information it preserves.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add the words Paper, Metal and Glass to the matching bins. Readers can identify the correct material even without distinguishing the colours.
- Proposes names, symbols with a clear key, or equivalent non-colour labels for all bins.
- Explains that the change preserves which material belongs in which bin.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: accessibility lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional exhibit has three needs: show the engine’s parts, compare the sizes of three model engines and explain the order in which a model was built. The team chooses a labelled diagram, a size table and a numbered sequence respectively.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Identify engine parts; Compare exact sizes; Follow building order
- a: Labelled diagram
- b: Size table
- c: Numbered sequence
- d: Decorative sound loop
The combination separates locations, values and order.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the size table helps comparison, and name a check needed when the narration also gives a model’s size.
Example of a full-credit answer: The table places exact measurements together. Check that the narration uses the same measurement and unit as the checked table.
- Explains that side-by-side exact sizes support comparison.
- Requires matching the narration’s measurement and unit to the checked data.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
The fictional task is to follow three paper-craft steps in a quiet room. Version A has matching numbered pictures and brief text. B has music and no instructions. C has an unrelated cartoon. D has three pictures in reverse order.
2A · Multiple choice
Which version best supports the stated task?
- a: A: matching numbered pictures and text
- b: B: background music without steps
- c: C: an unrelated cartoon sequence
- d: D: pictures placed in reverse order
Version A gives both the sequence and the matching action.
2B · Open ended
Give two reasons for selecting Version A that relate to the task.
Example of a full-credit answer: Its numbered pictures show the correct order, and the brief text names each action without needing sound.
- Explains that matching numbered pictures support the required sequence.
- Explains that written actions work in the quiet room without audio.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional nature guide originally uses a 24-unit video. A visitor can download at most 4 units. A 3-unit page has the same four bird labels, still drawings and a written description of each call; a 2-unit music file has no bird information. All figures are invented file-size units.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The 3-unit page fits the 4-unit download limit.
- b: The page preserves the four bird labels.
- c: The 24-unit video fits the 4-unit limit.
- d: The music file provides all four bird labels.
The labelled page preserves the task information within the limit.
3B · Open ended
Explain which replacement meets the limit and identify one part of the original experience it cannot fully reproduce.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the 3-unit page because it fits within 4 units and retains the bird labels and call descriptions. Written descriptions do not reproduce the actual sound of each call.
- Selects the 3-unit page with the correct size comparison.
- Identifies a genuine limitation such as not hearing the calls or seeing movement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional bridge page has a drawing labelled “wooden model,” a record saying the model held 5 blocks and a headline “Steel bridge holds 50 blocks.” The student says the dramatic headline is fine because the picture is accurate.
4A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Material supported by the drawing; Supported load; Unreliable part
- a: Wooden model
- b: 5 blocks
- c: Headline
- d: Steel bridge carrying 50 blocks
A correct picture does not repair false words beside it.
4B · Open ended
Identify the student’s reasoning error and write a corrected headline.
Example of a full-credit answer: The accurate picture does not make the conflicting headline accurate. Use “Wooden model holds 5 blocks.”
- Explains that one accurate medium cannot validate another conflicting medium.
- Supplies a headline preserving wooden model and 5 blocks.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class must publish a one-page guide to a model village. Visitors need the school’s location and its 2 pm opening time. It must work when printed without colour and without sound. A labelled route drawing and the words “School opens at 2 pm” are available.
5A · True or false
True or false? A sound-only announcement meets the required printed-guide conditions.
- true: True
- false: False
Both essential details must survive print and silence.
5B · Open ended
Propose a combination of media that gives the location and time, and describe one test of its use without colour or sound.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a labelled route drawing with written directions and a prominent 2 pm time label. Ask a reader using a monochrome printout to identify the route and opening time.
- Proposes an aligned combination that includes both route/location and 2 pm time.
- Describes a monochrome and silent/text-only task test or equivalent check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.6 · Using artificial intelligence for brainstorming
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Three routes to an idea
Fictional teaching example
A fictional AI brainstorm offers a poster, a puppet story and a word puzzle for a friendship lesson.
Question: What should the class do next?
Answer: Compare the three with the lesson purpose, available time and classmates’ needs.
Why: Receiving different options expands choice; it does not select one automatically.
Example 2 · Private detail removed
Fictional teaching example
A fictional prompt includes a classmate’s home location even though it only asks for a classroom game.
Question: What should be changed?
Answer: Remove the home location and use a general classroom description.
Why: That personal detail is unnecessary for the creative task.
Example 3 · An invented material
Fictional teaching example
A fictional AI suggests “instant unbreakable paper” for a model. The supply list contains only ordinary paper and tape.
Question: How should this suggestion be labelled?
Answer: Needs checking or adaptation; it cannot be assumed available.
Why: Generated confidence does not establish that a material exists.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Sort the first suggestions
Fictional classroom case
For a fictional indoor paper fair, the class has paper, pencils and 20 minutes. Suggestion A is a paper riddle card using those materials in 10 minutes. B needs a projector that the class lacks. C says an unknown fact must be printed without checking.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Suggestion A; Suggestion B; Suggestion C
- a: Feasible with supplied materials
- b: Resource mismatch
- c: Needs fact checking
- d: Automatically approved by AI
The brief and evidence, not the label AI, decide the next step.
Investigation: prompt lab
F2 · Find the privacy-safe brief
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants ideas for a reading game. Brief A includes the purpose, age group and paper-only rule. B includes pupils’ real addresses. C includes account secrets. D asks for help using a classmate’s private messages.
F2 · Hotspot
Choose the brief that provides useful context without unnecessary personal information.
- a: A: purpose, age group, paper-only rule
- b: B: real pupil addresses and names
- c: C: account secrets and preferred games
- d: D: private messages from a classmate
The creative task needs a general brief, not personal records.
Investigation: privacy lab
F3 · Keep a broad starting list
Fictional classroom case
A fictional tool suggests three versions of a poster: blue poster, green poster and yellow poster. The class asked for different activity formats, including something visitors can do. The team can ask for a roleplay, a sorting game and a comic instead.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The first list mainly varies colour.
- b: A sorting game adds an activity visitors can do.
- c: Three colours guarantee three different learning methods.
- d: A suggested comic proves that every fact inside is correct.
Changing format gives a broader brainstorm than changing only colour.
Investigation: audience lab
F4 · A named source is still checked
Fictional classroom case
A fictional generated idea claims a school pond is 40 metres deep and names “Pond Report Z.” The supplied archive has no such report; no measurement is given. The team has not verified the depth.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The confident generated wording establishes the pond’s depth.
- true: True
- false: False
A generated source name is not a verified source.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · Improve a nearly useful idea
Fictional classroom case
A fictional brief asks for an inclusive ten-minute game using paper. An AI idea requires each learner to hear a spoken clue, but one learner cannot use audio. The game asks learners to choose a matching word from each clue. The clue text is available.
F5 · Open ended
Describe one adaptation that keeps the game usable without audio, and explain how the adaptation still serves the game’s purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: Print the clue text or show it on cards. Learners can still use the clue to choose the matching word without needing to hear it.
- Proposes a readable text or equivalent non-audio presentation of the clues.
- Explains that learners can still carry out the clue-matching task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: accessibility lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team has 15 minutes, six sheets of paper and no device. AI suggestion A is a 10-minute paper sorting task using four sheets. B is a 30-minute animation. C needs an online account. D needs ten sheets.
1A · Multiple choice
Which prepared suggestion meets all three limits?
- a: A: paper sorting task, four sheets, 10 minutes
- b: B: online animation, two sheets, 30 minutes
- c: C: account-based quiz, no sheets, 10 minutes
- d: D: paper model, ten sheets, 12 minutes
A fits the time, materials and no-device condition.
1B · Open ended
Explain why A fits the time and materials, and name one human check still needed before using its sorting content.
Example of a full-credit answer: A takes 10 of 15 minutes and four of six sheets. A person must check that the labels and correct groupings are accurate and understandable.
- Uses the correct time and sheet comparisons to justify feasibility.
- Identifies a relevant accuracy, clarity or accessibility check of the sorting content.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class asks for ways to teach map symbols. The first list has four nearly identical lectures. The teacher requests one board game and one illustrated story, then plans to compare the new ideas with the same learning goal.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The follow-up requests different activity formats.
- b: The learning goal remains teaching map symbols.
- c: The new request guarantees a suitable final activity.
- d: Human comparison is unnecessary after a second request.
The follow-up increases variety while retaining the purpose.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the second request improves the brainstorm, and why people must still compare its results.
Example of a full-credit answer: It asks for genuinely different formats instead of more lectures. People still need to check that either idea teaches map symbols and fits the class.
- Identifies the move from repeated lectures to distinct formats.
- Explains a remaining human check against learning purpose or classroom needs.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional plan for a classroom uses tiny printed cards and a quiet recorded explanation. It is moved to a windy outdoor display. The venue permits fixed boards; visitors may not hear audio. The team needs large secured labels, visible instructions and a small trial in the new location.
3A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Wind-related adaptation; Audio-related adaptation; Check in the new setting
- a: Secure the labels
- b: Show instructions in writing
- c: Try the outdoor version
- d: Repeat the indoor plan unchanged
The changed environment creates new constraints.
3B · Short answer
Describe one change for wind and one change for visitors who cannot hear the recording.
Example of a full-credit answer: Attach the cards securely to permitted boards and show the important instructions in readable text.
- Proposes securing or suitably replacing loose cards to address wind.
- Proposes written or visual instructions carrying the necessary spoken information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
In a fictional group, a tool suggests a game requiring pupils to reveal private family details. The team leader says, “It is the AI’s choice, so we are not responsible.” The class can instead use invented character cards.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Problem in the suggested game; Safer material available; Who chooses what to use
- a: Requests private family details
- b: Invented character cards
- c: The human team
- d: The tool alone
Using AI does not remove the team’s responsibility for its decision.
4B · Open ended
Identify the leader’s reasoning error and give a safer way to retain the activity.
Example of a full-credit answer: The team remains responsible for choosing to use the suggestion. Replace real family details with invented character cards and check the rules.
- Explains that human users remain responsible for deciding what to use.
- Proposes fictional details or an equivalent privacy-preserving adaptation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs an original paper activity about teamwork for a 12-minute session. No personal data may be used. They want three varied ideas, a reasoned choice and a small trial before making copies.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Number of requested starting ideas; Length of the session; Information boundary
- a: Three
- b: 12 minutes
- c: No personal data
- d: Publish the first output immediately
A useful process includes varied suggestions, human selection and testing.
5B · Open ended
Write a brief requesting varied ideas within the time and privacy limits, then describe how people will select and test one.
Example of a full-credit answer: Suggest three different paper activities about teamwork for a 12-minute session using invented information only. The class will compare suitability and accessibility, choose with reasons and test a small version before copying.
- Requests varied paper activities about teamwork within 12 minutes without personal data.
- Provides a human comparison and small trial before final production.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.7 · Revising artificial intelligence-generated content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Keep the condition
Fictional teaching example
A fictional record says the boat trip runs if the wind is calm. An AI draft says it always runs.
Question: How should it be revised?
Answer: State that the trip runs if the wind is calm.
Why: The condition affects what readers can expect.
Example 2 · A simpler accurate sentence
Fictional teaching example
A fictional draft says “Commence the activity subsequent to the demonstration.” The intended readers are ten.
Question: Give a clearer version.
Answer: Start the activity after the demonstration.
Why: Familiar words preserve the same order of events.
Example 3 · A correction log
Fictional teaching example
A fictional chart was labelled litres, but the measured quantity was millilitres.
Question: What should the editor record?
Answer: Changed the unit label from litres to millilitres using the measurement sheet.
Why: The log records both the change and its evidence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Mark three different edits
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI draft says “Meet Friday in Rm Q; 50 pupils joined.” The checked notice says Thursday, Room Q, and 15 pupils. The audience does not know the abbreviation Rm. The editor must correct the day, expand the room word and correct the count.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Friday to Thursday; Rm to Room; 50 to 15
- a: Day correction
- b: Clarity improvement
- c: Count correction
- d: Proof that no review is needed
Different editing purposes can occur in the same sentence.
Investigation: revision lab
F2 · Match claims to the record
Fictional classroom case
A fictional generated garden draft says the plot has 6 beds, opens at 9 am and is supervised by a librarian. The checked plan confirms 6 beds and 9 am, but names a garden teacher as supervisor.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Number to retain; Time to retain; Role to correct
- a: 6 beds
- b: 9 am
- c: Garden teacher
- d: Librarian
The supervisor claim conflicts with the checked plan.
Investigation: verification lab
F3 · Protect the uncertainty
Fictional classroom case
A fictional trial tested a paper roof once. It stayed dry for two minutes. The AI draft says “This roof will keep every building dry forever.”
F3 · Hotspot
Select the revision supported by the fixed evidence.
- a: In this trial the paper roof stayed dry for two minutes.
- b: Every building will stay dry forever with this roof.
- c: All paper roofs always remain dry in storms.
- d: The trial proves rain cannot pass through any roof.
The draft generalises far beyond the trial.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Check after simplifying
Fictional classroom case
A fictional draft says “Use the west door only when the main door is closed.” Revision A says “Use the west door only if the main door is closed.” Revision B says “Always use the west door.” The original condition is required by the checked access plan.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Revision A retains the condition about the main door.
- b: Revision B changes a conditional instruction into an always instruction.
- c: Shorter wording is accurate regardless of meaning.
- d: The access plan says the west door must always be used.
Simpler wording must preserve the condition that determines the action.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A private detail in the draft
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI draft for a public club poster includes a pupil’s private contact placeholder. The approved contact route is the school office, and the poster does not need individual pupil details.
F5 · Short answer
State one concrete edit to protect privacy and explain how readers can still get the needed help.
Example of a full-credit answer: Remove the pupil’s private contact and direct enquiries to the school office, which is the approved route.
- Removes the individual pupil’s private contact from the public draft.
- Provides the approved school office route so the poster still serves readers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: privacy lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class survey has 12 respondents: 7 choose a story, 5 choose a puzzle. The generated draft says “All 12 chose a story; no one chose a puzzle.” A revised report must keep both counts and limit its claim to this survey.
1A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Story responses; Puzzle responses; People included
- a: 7
- b: 5
- c: 12 survey respondents
- d: Every pupil in the town
The draft must reflect the recorded counts and the sample.
1B · Short answer
Write a corrected survey sentence and explain why “everyone in town” would still be unsupported.
Example of a full-credit answer: Among the 12 survey respondents, 7 chose a story and 5 chose a puzzle. The survey did not include everyone in town.
- States both correct counts and the 12-respondent context.
- Explains that the observed sample cannot establish a preference for everyone in town.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI draft uses “photosynthesis” in a lesson for beginners. The supplied lesson defines it as plants using light energy to make sugars from water and carbon dioxide. Edit A keeps the term and adds that explanation. Edit B replaces it with “plants eating sunlight.”
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Edit A explains the unfamiliar term using the supplied meaning.
- b: Edit B’s eating-sunlight wording can mislead readers about the process.
- c: Any shorter phrase is automatically a more accurate explanation.
- d: Beginners should never receive explanations of new words.
A explains the term without replacing the process with an inaccurate claim.
2B · Open ended
Give one reason to prefer A for accuracy and one reason to prefer it for the audience.
Example of a full-credit answer: A preserves the supplied process using light, water and carbon dioxide. It defines the unfamiliar term so beginners can follow it.
- Explains that A preserves the supplied scientific meaning.
- Explains that defining the term helps beginners understand.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional printed draft says “Choose the green button shown above.” It is being revised into an audio-only instruction. The actual interface has buttons labelled Start and Stop; the green button is Start.
3A · True or false
True or false? “Shown above” gives an audio-only listener a sufficient button name.
- true: True
- false: False
An audio instruction needs a usable name rather than a visual position.
3B · Open ended
Revise the instruction for the audio setting and explain which weakness your edit removes.
Example of a full-credit answer: Say “Choose the button labelled Start.” This removes dependence on seeing the green colour or the phrase shown above.
- Names the Start button clearly in the revised instruction.
- Explains removal of a visual-only colour or position reference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional editor corrects punctuation in an AI draft and declares it verified. The draft still says the trip is on 18 May; the confirmed schedule says 19 May. The teacher has not changed the schedule.
4A · Hotspot
Select the factual correction supported by the record.
- a: Change 18 May to 19 May.
- b: Change 19 May to 18 May.
- c: Keep 18 May because the commas are correct.
- d: Delete the schedule because the draft is fluent.
A surface edit does not establish factual accuracy.
4B · Open ended
Identify the editor’s mistaken reasoning and give the needed correction with its evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Checking punctuation does not verify the date. Change 18 May to 19 May using the confirmed schedule.
- Explains that punctuation review does not establish factual verification.
- Corrects the date to 19 May and identifies the schedule as evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team has an AI-generated exhibition guide, a confirmed room plan and an attendance table. It must publish readable instructions and state how AI helped. The teacher will review the final version before publication.
5A · Multiple choice
Which material should the team use to check room names?
- a: The confirmed room plan
- b: The number of likes on the draft
- c: The draft’s confident tone
- d: The chosen decorative font
The workflow joins evidence checks, meaningful revision and human review.
5B · Open ended
Propose a two-stage workflow: explain how the team will check and revise facts, then how it will review and disclose the final AI-assisted work.
Example of a full-credit answer: First compare each room and attendance claim with the supplied records and correct errors without changing their meaning. Then test readability, record the AI contribution and edits, and obtain the teacher’s final review.
- Includes record-based checking and correction of rooms and attendance.
- Includes a final human/readability review and an accurate AI-use disclosure or revision record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.8 · Checking accuracy before publication
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A checked sum
| Category | Count |
|---|---|
| Storybooks | 9 |
| Information books | 6 |
| Draft total | 16 |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional book count has 9 storybooks and 6 information books. A draft total says 16.
Question: What total should be published?
Answer: 15 books.
Why: Nine plus six is fifteen; a neat table does not validate an incorrect total.
Example 2 · An old image
Fictional teaching example
A fictional picture record says a playground photo was taken last year. A new caption says “the playground this morning.”
Question: What needs revision?
Answer: Remove or correct the claim that the picture was taken this morning.
Why: The image’s actual date does not support the new caption.
Example 3 · A quote with a limit
Fictional teaching example
A fictional speaker says, “We can open the hall if the repair is finished.” A draft quotes only “We can open the hall.”
Question: Why review it?
Answer: The missing condition makes opening sound unconditional.
Why: Accurate words in a shortened quotation can still misrepresent the full meaning.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Assign the right check
Fictional classroom case
A fictional exhibition announcement contains an opening time, a visitor total and a quote. The organiser’s dated plan confirms the time, the entry sheet records the total and the complete interview transcript records the quote.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Opening time; Visitor total; Exact quote
- a: Dated organiser plan
- b: Entry sheet
- c: Complete interview transcript
- d: Number of poster likes
Each checking source directly addresses a different claim.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Two sources, two dates
Fictional classroom case
A fictional Monday plan says the club meets in Room 2. A Tuesday correction from the same organiser moves it to Room 7 and explicitly replaces Monday’s plan. A Wednesday poster still says Room 2.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Current confirmed room; Superseded room; Authority for the change
- a: Room 7
- b: Room 2
- c: Tuesday organiser correction
- d: Whichever room has more mentions
The later explicit correction resolves this conflict.
Investigation: verification lab
F3 · Find the altered quotation
Fictional classroom case
A fictional interview transcript reads “The model worked in two of five trials.” A draft caption quotes “The model worked in every trial.” Other labels correctly say five trials and two successes.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the wording that accurately reports the speaker’s result.
- a: Worked in two of five trials
- b: Worked in every trial
- c: Worked in no trials
- d: Worked in fifty trials
The quotation must preserve the stated result.
Investigation: clip lab
F4 · Update all the media
Fictional classroom case
A fictional confirmed schedule moves a fair to 3 pm. The web heading already says 3 pm; the downloadable sheet says 2 pm and the recorded script says 2 pm. A final check must cover each version.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Version already matching the schedule; Printable version needing correction; Spoken version needing correction
- a: Web heading
- b: Downloadable sheet
- c: Recorded script
- d: All versions already correct
Changing only the web heading leaves two conflicting versions.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · A claim without a record
Fictional classroom case
A fictional draft states that every class prefers a new logo. The only supplied evidence is a vote from one class: 8 prefer it and 4 do not. Publication is due soon.
F5 · Open ended
Write a publishable sentence supported by this record and explain why the original claim is too broad.
Example of a full-credit answer: In this class vote, 8 pupils preferred the logo and 4 did not. One class’s mixed result does not establish that every class prefers it.
- States the 8 and 4 results with a one-class scope.
- Explains that the evidence does not support a claim about every class.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: graph lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional invitation says Saturday, 10 am, Studio 4. The organiser’s final plan says Saturday, 11 am, Studio 4. A second reviewer confirms that this is the latest plan.
1A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Date detail to retain; Time to use; Room detail to retain
- a: Saturday
- b: 11 am
- c: Studio 4
- d: Studio 9
Only the time conflicts with the confirmed final plan.
1B · Open ended
State the necessary correction and explain one way to prevent the old time from remaining in another version.
Example of a full-credit answer: Change 10 am to 11 am. Check the printable sheet, audio script and other copies against the final plan before release.
- Corrects the time to 11 am without changing supported details.
- Includes a practical check of other copies or formats for the old time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
Three fictional posts all say a new reading room opened today. Their source notes show they copied one undated draft by Club A. The organiser’s current notice says the room opens next week.
2A · Multiple choice
Why should the team trace the posts’ source?
- a: All three repeat one undated draft.
- b: Three posts always prove the claim.
- c: A popular post cannot contain an error.
- d: An undated draft is always the latest plan.
Repetition does not turn one draft into three independent checks.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the three posts are not three independent confirmations and state the revision supported by the organiser.
Example of a full-credit answer: They all copy the same undated Club A draft. Revise the announcement to say the reading room opens next week.
- Identifies the common copied origin as the reason they are not independent.
- Uses the current organiser notice to correct the opening claim to next week.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team turns a checked table into a video chart. The table records 4 red tiles and 6 blue tiles. The video chart swaps the labels, showing Red 6 and Blue 4. The total stays 10.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The chart should show Red 4.
- b: The chart should show Blue 6.
- c: A total of 10 proves that both chart labels are right.
- d: The checked table should be changed to match the incorrect chart.
Matching totals do not ensure that category labels are correct.
3B · Short answer
Describe what to correct in the chart and explain why checking only the total would miss this error.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show Red 4 and Blue 6. The swapped chart still adds to 10, so the total alone cannot check each label-count pair.
- Corrects both category-count pairs.
- Explains that swapping values preserves the total while changing category meaning.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional publisher says “The spellchecker found no mistakes, so the notice is accurate.” The notice gives the route as east; the checked route map says west. Both words are correctly spelled.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: What spellcheck tested; Direction supported by the map; Wrong direction in the notice
- a: Spelling
- b: West
- c: East
- d: Factual route accuracy
A spelling tool cannot establish which correctly spelled direction is appropriate.
4B · Open ended
Identify the publisher’s error and give the source-based correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The publisher confuses correct spelling with correct facts. Change east to west using the checked route map.
- Explains the difference between spelling checks and factual route checking.
- Corrects east to west and names the route map as evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club plans a public notice with a venue, a time and a photo. The final plan gives Hall C at noon. The photo record shows last year’s event. A teacher approves final publication and receives correction reports.
5A · True or false
True or false? Calling last year’s photo “today’s event” is accurate because the image itself is genuine.
- true: True
- false: False
The check must cover factual details and the image’s context.
5B · Open ended
Propose a check before release that covers the venue, time and photo, and name a clear correction process after release.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare Hall C and noon with the final plan and label the photo as last year’s event. Have the teacher approve the final notice and receive reports so the team can correct the public version and alert affected readers.
- Checks the venue/time against the final plan and accurately labels the old photo.
- Includes a responsible receiver/reviewer and an update or reader-notification step for corrections.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.9 · Maintaining originality
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The same broad idea
Fictional teaching example
Two fictional pupils both create a comic about sharing equipment. One writes a workshop story; the other creates a space adventure with different drawings and dialogue.
Question: Can both make an original contribution?
Answer: Yes. A shared broad idea does not make their specific expression identical.
Why: The characters, sequence, words and drawings show separate creative choices.
Example 2 · Only changed names
Fictional teaching example
A fictional learner copies a story’s sentences and sequence but changes Ana to Ben.
Question: What has the learner mainly changed?
Answer: A surface detail, not the copied expression and structure.
Why: Renaming a character alone does not establish independent authorship.
Example 3 · A visible addition
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class uses a permitted town map and adds its own measured walking times and explanation.
Question: What should its process note distinguish?
Answer: The borrowed map from the class’s measurements and explanation.
Why: The contribution can be original while the underlying map still needs its credit and terms.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A shared theme
Fictional classroom case
In a fictional class, Rui writes a new poem about rain with his own lines and images. Bea also writes a poem about rain, using different lines and images. Neither copies the other’s wording.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The shared rain theme alone proves that Bea copied Rui’s poem.
- true: True
- false: False
Sharing a general theme does not by itself establish copying.
Investigation: provenance lab
F2 · Name the contribution
Fictional classroom case
A fictional report contains a permitted base diagram by Maker A, measurements collected by the class and an explanation written by Lea. A credit line must keep these contributions distinct.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Base diagram creator; Measurement contributor; Explanation writer
- a: Maker A
- b: The class
- c: Lea
- d: Everything made by Lea
Honest authorship describes the different contributions.
Investigation: credit lab
F3 · Find a meaningful new step
Fictional classroom case
A fictional source explains how to organise a book corner. A pupil can copy its paragraph, replace three adjectives, remove its author name, or test two layouts and write an explanation using the results.
F3 · Hotspot
Which proposed action adds new evidence and reasoning?
- a: Test two layouts and explain the results
- b: Copy the source paragraph unchanged
- c: Replace only three adjectives
- d: Remove the source author’s name
A test and explanation adds a substantive contribution.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Describe the AI role
Fictional classroom case
A fictional process record says an AI suggested five poster titles. Mina chose one, drew all illustrations and wrote the checked text. The teacher’s rule requires describing AI assistance.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: AI contribution; Mina’s visual contribution; Mina’s text contribution
- a: Five title suggestions
- b: All illustrations
- c: Writing and checking the text
- d: AI conducted real-world observations
The record distinguishes suggestions from the learner’s work.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · Develop an original response
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class studies three permitted examples of bird-feeder posters. The assignment asks for a new poster for a shaded school courtyard. The class has its own observation that the feeder is hard to see from the walkway.
F5 · Open ended
Propose one original contribution using the class observation and explain how you would distinguish it from borrowed material.
Example of a full-credit answer: Create our own clear route diagram from the walkway to the feeder using the observation. Credit any example image or wording actually reused and label the diagram as our class’s work.
- Proposes a relevant new design, explanation or investigation based on the courtyard observation.
- Distinguishes the new contribution from borrowed material through appropriate credit or a process note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner receives a permitted outline of a garden. The learner measures shady areas at three times and adds a key explaining suitable places to observe shade. The outline remains credited to its maker.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Borrowed foundation; Learner’s new evidence; Learner’s new explanation
- a: Permitted garden outline
- b: Shade measurements at three times
- c: Observation-place key
- d: All material independently invented
The work adds evidence and explanation while retaining credit for its foundation.
1B · Open ended
Explain the learner’s original contribution and why the outline still needs its maker’s credit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner contributes measured shade information and a reasoned key. The outline was created by someone else, so the new additions do not erase that contribution or its stated credit requirement.
- Identifies both measured information and a relevant new explanation as the learner’s contribution.
- Explains that adding original work does not remove the borrowed outline’s required credit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team saves three drafts: first a permitted copied example for notes, then its own storyboard, then a final comic with newly drawn scenes and a credit for the borrowed starting idea. Another team saves only the final image.
2A · Hotspot
Which record most directly shows the team choosing its new scene sequence?
- a: Its own storyboard
- b: The final number of likes
- c: The file’s decorative name
- d: A claim that no review is needed
The history helps explain what was borrowed and what was developed.
2B · Open ended
Give two ways the saved drafts help explain the team’s contribution.
Example of a full-credit answer: The notes identify the source influence, while the storyboard and final drawings show the team’s own sequence and visual choices.
- Explains how source notes identify the borrowed influence.
- Explains how intermediate/final drafts show the team’s original decisions or expression.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional assignment changes from an illustrated story to an audio story. The learner’s original plot has a lost bell and three clues. The teacher permits the plot to be reused, but no recorded music has been cleared. The learner can record original narration and self-made sound effects.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Story element that can be retained; New original sound contribution; Material not yet cleared
- a: Lost-bell plot
- b: Self-made sound effects
- c: Recorded music from elsewhere
- d: All online music
The new format can build on the learner’s plot without inventing rights to external recordings.
3B · Open ended
Propose an original audio contribution and explain how to handle the uncleared music.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record narration and make appropriate sounds, such as a self-made bell clue. Omit the uncleared track or obtain suitable permission before using it.
- Proposes a relevant original narration or self-made sound contribution.
- Omits the uncleared music or requires checking/obtaining appropriate permission.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil copies a paragraph’s complete sequence and replaces only four words with synonyms. The pupil says this makes the whole paragraph independently written. The original source is not acknowledged.
4A · Multiple choice
What is the problem with the pupil’s claim?
- a: It mistakes surface changes for independent authorship.
- b: It keeps too many accurate facts in the paragraph.
- c: It uses a topic that nobody else may discuss.
- d: It includes fewer than ten unusual words.
Small wording substitutions do not make the copied work independently authored.
4B · Open ended
Identify the pupil’s error and describe a more honest way to produce a response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil confuses word substitution with independent authorship. Understand the source, write a genuinely new explanation or analysis, and acknowledge the source; quote any retained exact wording appropriately.
- Explains that a few synonyms do not establish an independently created paragraph.
- Proposes a substantive own explanation/analysis with appropriate source acknowledgement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team may use a credited base map under explicit permission. It must create a useful school exhibit about quiet reading places. The team can make its own observations, choose a clear visual system and explain its recommendations.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The team can add its own observations to the permitted map.
- b: The final exhibit should still credit the base map as required.
- c: Original labels remove every permission condition on the base map.
- d: Erasing the maker’s name proves that the whole exhibit is original.
An original contribution can add observations and reasoning to a permitted foundation.
5B · Open ended
Propose a concrete original addition to the map and a process note distinguishing the team’s work from the borrowed part.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add our observations of noise at agreed times with a clear key and explanations of suitable reading places. State that the base map is by its credited maker and the observations, symbols and explanations are ours.
- Proposes a task-relevant original observation, visual system and/or reasoned recommendation.
- Clearly distinguishes the credited base map from the team’s named contributions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.10 · Avoiding plagiarism
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Exact words, clearly labelled
Fictional teaching example
A fictional teacher permits quoting a short line from a class story. A learner uses that exact line, quotation marks and the story’s author and title.
Question: What does the labelling achieve?
Answer: It shows readers that the words are borrowed and identifies their source.
Why: The learner does not claim to have written the quoted line.
Example 2 · A paraphrase still has a source
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil understands an article’s idea and explains it with new wording and structure.
Question: Should the article still be acknowledged?
Answer: Yes, because the explanation uses the article’s idea.
Why: Changing expression does not erase the source contribution.
Example 3 · Permission without authorship
Fictional teaching example
A fictional artist permits a class to reuse an illustration with credit. A pupil labels it “drawn by me.”
Question: What is wrong?
Answer: The pupil falsely claims authorship despite having permission to reuse the image.
Why: Permission and honest acknowledgement answer different questions.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify the honest quotation
Fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom source permits use of its line “Small steps can build a habit” with the author and title. Version A marks the line as a quotation by Ivo in Habit Notes. B labels it “my original sentence.” C removes the author and title. D says only “from somewhere.”
F1 · Multiple choice
Which version honestly identifies the exact borrowed line?
- a: A: quotation marks, Ivo and Habit Notes
- b: B: labelled my original sentence
- c: C: the line with no source
- d: D: labelled from somewhere
A clearly marks and identifies the permitted quotation.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Sort the source notebook
Fictional classroom case
A fictional notebook has three labels: exact copied sentence, own observation and paraphrase of an article. The copied sentence needs quotation marking and source; the own observation needs an accurate observation record; the paraphrase needs acknowledgement of the article.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Exact copied sentence; Own observation; Paraphrase of the article
- a: Quotation marking and source
- b: Accurate observation record
- c: Acknowledgement of the article
- d: Claim every note as your own invention
Different note types need different honest labels.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Separate the two checks
Fictional classroom case
A fictional illustrator named Mika allows reuse of a drawing if credited. The class has that permission. Its draft omits the illustrator’s name and says a pupil drew it. The reuse permission exists, but the authorship statement is wrong.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Permission status in the case; Actual illustrator; Draft problem
- a: Reuse allowed with credit
- b: Mika
- c: False pupil-authorship claim
- d: Permission makes the pupil the artist
Allowed reuse does not change who created the drawing.
Investigation: permission lab
F4 · Spot a weak paraphrase claim
Fictional classroom case
The fictional source says “The covered shelf kept the paper dry.” A draft says “The sheltered shelf kept the paper dry” and claims to be an independent explanation. Only one word has changed.
F4 · Hotspot
What makes the pupil’s claim unreliable?
- a: Most wording and the structure remain borrowed.
- b: The sentence is shorter than a whole page.
- c: The pupil uses an ordinary word about shelves.
- d: The source sentence contains a true statement.
One synonym does not establish a genuine independent paraphrase.
Investigation: revision lab
F5 · Repair a source-free summary
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil writes a genuine summary of a permitted article called River Notes by Tali, but forgets to name the source. The summary contains no exact quotations.
F5 · Open ended
State how to repair the missing acknowledgement and explain why the summary still needs it despite using new wording.
Example of a full-credit answer: Name Tali’s River Notes and give its source location in the summary or source note. The ideas being summarised came from that article even though the wording is new.
- Provides a clear acknowledgement naming Tali and River Notes with an appropriate source note.
- Explains that a paraphrase/summary still draws on the source’s ideas.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: credit lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional group has a permitted exact quote by Nilo, a group-made chart and a paraphrase of Mara’s report. They need to label all three honestly before submission.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Nilo’s exact words; Group-made chart; Paraphrase of Mara’s report
- a: Quote and name Nilo’s source
- b: Identify the group and its data
- c: Acknowledge Mara’s report
- d: Label every part as entirely new
Readers should be able to distinguish each contribution.
1B · Short answer
Describe how the exact quote and the paraphrase should be labelled differently, while both acknowledging their sources.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mark Nilo’s exact words as a quotation and identify his source. Write the paraphrase in the group’s own wording without pretending it is a quote, and acknowledge Mara’s report.
- Requires quotation marking plus source identification for Nilo’s exact words.
- Requires own wording and acknowledgement of Mara’s report for the paraphrase.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional student notes the author and title when copying a sentence, labels it “exact wording,” and keeps her own interpretation in a separate column. Her teammate says the labels waste time.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The exact-wording label distinguishes copied text from own drafts.
- b: The author and title help identify the source later.
- c: Source labels make permission checks unnecessary.
- d: Deleting the labels makes copied wording independently authored.
Clear notes support honest drafting and later checking.
2B · Open ended
Give two reasons to keep the labels and source details.
Example of a full-credit answer: The exact-wording label prevents borrowed sentences being mistaken for original drafts. Author and title make it possible to acknowledge and trace the source later.
- Explains how labelling exact wording prevents accidental authorship confusion.
- Explains how source details support acknowledgement or tracing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team turns a permitted article into a narrated video summary. Its wording is new, but the main explanation comes from Article P by Sela. The teacher requires source acknowledgement in the video or accompanying transcript.
3A · Hotspot
Which source should the video acknowledge for its main explanation?
- a: Sela’s Article P
- b: Only the recording device
- c: Only the background colour
- d: No source because the format changed
Changing format does not erase the source of the explanation.
3B · Short answer
Propose an appropriate acknowledgement for the video and explain why new narration does not remove the need.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add a readable or spoken credit and a transcript source note naming Sela’s Article P. The explanation still comes from that work even though the team uses its own narration.
- Proposes a usable video/transcript credit identifying Sela and Article P.
- Explains that changing wording or medium does not remove the borrowed idea’s source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club permits copying its guide with credit. A pupil copies it and replaces the club’s byline with “Written entirely by me.” The pupil argues that permission makes this statement true.
4A · True or false
True or false? The permission makes “Written entirely by me” an accurate byline.
- true: True
- false: False
The stated permission allows use, not a false claim of authorship.
4B · Open ended
Identify the error and give a truthful replacement for the byline if the pupil added only a cover illustration.
Example of a full-credit answer: Permission does not mean the pupil wrote the guide. Use “Guide by the club; cover illustration by me,” with the required source credit.
- Explains that permission to reuse does not make the copier the author.
- Provides a byline separating the club’s guide from the pupil’s cover illustration.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team will combine its own survey, a permitted quotation and a summary of a source article. The teacher requires every member’s contribution and every outside source to be identifiable.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Own survey needs; Exact borrowed quotation needs; Article summary needs
- a: Accurate data and contributor record
- b: Quotation marking and source
- c: Source acknowledgement
- d: Only a detector percentage
A transparent writing process is more useful than treating a detector as proof of authorship.
5B · Open ended
Propose a note-taking step that separates own and borrowed work, and a final check covering quotations, summaries and permissions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep own survey records separately from source notes labelled exact quote or summary with creator/title details. Before submission, check quotation marks, summary acknowledgements, contributor credits and the supplied reuse terms.
- Proposes source-labelled notes that distinguish own data from quotes and summaries.
- Includes a final check of quotation marking, summary acknowledgement and permission conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.11 · Following copyright rules
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An explicit classroom limit
Fictional teaching example
A fictional artist permits an unchanged picture in a classroom display only. A class wants to put it in a public advertisement.
Question: Is the proposed use cleared by this permission?
Answer: No. The supplied permission covers the classroom display, not the public advertisement.
Why: Ask for permission for the new use or choose another asset.
Example 2 · CC BY with a change
Fictional teaching example
A fictional icon is supplied under CC BY 4.0 with creator and source information. A class recolours it for a shared guide.
Question: What should accompany the reuse?
Answer: Appropriate credit, the licence link or notice as required, and an indication that it was recoloured, while meeting the other terms.
Why: The licence permits adaptation but retains its conditions.
Example 3 · Two separate assets
Fictional teaching example
A fictional video’s photograph is cleared for the use; its soundtrack has no supplied permission.
Question: Is the whole video cleared by the photo permission?
Answer: No. The soundtrack needs its own check or replacement.
Why: Rights and permissions belong to the separate works used.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the supplied permission
Fictional classroom case
A fictional artist permits a class to copy an unchanged star drawing into a public guide if the artist and source are credited. Recolouring is not covered by this particular permission. The class plans an unchanged copy with the required credit.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The unchanged public copy is covered when its required credit is supplied.
- b: The stated permission does not cover recolouring.
- c: Viewing the drawing grants every possible reuse right.
- d: Crediting the creator removes the stated no-change limit.
Use the explicit terms for the specific proposed action.
Investigation: permission lab
F2 · Match the production record
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team records a diagram’s maker as Lani, its source as art.example/diagram and its reuse terms as “unchanged class display with credit.” The team will keep this record for its project.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Creator field; Source field; Permission scope
- a: Lani
- b: art.example/diagram
- c: Unchanged class display with credit
- d: Unrestricted use without conditions
These fields answer different permission and attribution questions.
Investigation: credit lab
F3 · Three assets, three decisions
Fictional classroom case
A fictional guide uses the team’s own sketch, a photo explicitly permitted for this guide with credit, and a song with no supplied terms. The sketch is available as own work, the photo requires its credit and the song needs clarification or replacement.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Team sketch; Permitted photo; Unclear song
- a: Own work available
- b: Include required credit
- c: Clarify or replace
- d: Assume all assets share one permission
A separate decision is needed for each asset.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · Choose the suitable licence conditions
Fictional classroom case
A fictional set provides these explicit case conditions: Asset A, CC BY 4.0, permits adaptation with its attribution and other terms; Asset B, CC BY-ND 4.0, does not permit sharing adaptations under that licence; Asset C has explicit classroom-only permission.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Asset permitting a shared adaptation with terms met; Asset not permitting shared adaptations under its licence; Asset limited by the supplied permission to the classroom
- a: A: CC BY 4.0
- b: B: CC BY-ND 4.0
- c: C: classroom-only permission
- d: All have identical reuse terms
The actual licence and scope determine the permitted use.
Investigation: permission lab
F5 · The change of audience
Fictional classroom case
A fictional picture permission allows a class-only slideshow. The team now wants a publicly downloadable version. No wider permission has been supplied.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the existing permission is insufficient for the new plan and give one workable next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The supplied permission covers class-only use, not public distribution. Ask for public-use permission or replace the image with suitable licensed or own material.
- Identifies the change from class-only use to public distribution as outside the supplied permission.
- Proposes obtaining appropriate permission or replacing/creating the material.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team wants to adapt a diagram into a new guide. Diagram A is CC BY 4.0 with complete credit information. Diagram B has explicit permission only for unchanged copies. Diagram C has no permission information. The team can meet A’s licence terms.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Suitable supplied adaptation permission; Unchanged-only permission; Permission needing clarification
- a: Diagram A
- b: Diagram B
- c: Diagram C
- d: All three automatically cleared
A is the asset with a supplied permission that fits the planned adaptation.
1B · Open ended
Explain why A fits the plan, then identify the creator/source, licence and change information the team should preserve in its reuse record.
Example of a full-credit answer: A permits adaptation when the CC BY terms are met. Preserve creator/source and licence information, and record that changes were made.
- Explains that A’s CC BY permission allows the planned adaptation subject to conditions.
- Names attribution/source/licence and change information sufficient to document the reuse.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional artist gives a club written permission to publish a drawing unchanged on its public notice board with a maker credit. The team saves the message, creator and source instead of relying on a teammate’s memory.
2A · Hotspot
Which record best establishes the supplied permission?
- a: The saved creator message
- b: A teammate’s uncertain memory
- c: The image’s popularity count
- d: The size of the downloaded file
The message records what the creator actually permitted.
2B · Open ended
Give one reason the saved message is useful and explain what to do if the team later wants to alter the drawing.
Example of a full-credit answer: It preserves the exact permitted use and condition. Check whether alteration is allowed and obtain suitable permission or choose another asset before sharing a changed version.
- Explains that the saved message provides evidence of scope/conditions.
- Requires checking or obtaining appropriate permission for the new alteration.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional photo permission explicitly covers free school posters only. The team wants to reuse it in a booklet sold at a fair. A second picture is available with explicit permission for this sold booklet and a required credit.
3A · Multiple choice
Which option is already covered by a supplied permission for the sold booklet?
- a: Second picture with its required credit
- b: First photo with no additional check
- c: Either picture without any credit
- d: A random online photo with no terms
The changed use needs permission that covers it.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the first permission does not establish the new use and propose a suitable choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: It covers free school posters, not the sold booklet. Use the second picture with its credit or obtain permission covering the first photo’s new use.
- Identifies the specific gap between free-poster permission and sold-booklet use.
- Selects the second picture with required credit or obtains suitable expanded permission.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional student finds an image with no supplied reuse permission. The student adds the creator’s name and says this makes every public reuse allowed. The teacher asks the student to check the actual terms.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: What the added name provides; What remains unestablished; Practical next step
- a: Attribution
- b: Permission for the planned use
- c: Check terms or choose a cleared alternative
- d: Unlimited reuse rights
Attribution identifies a contribution; it does not grant rights the creator has not supplied.
4B · Open ended
Identify the student’s mistake and give a practical correction to the workflow.
Example of a full-credit answer: The student confuses attribution with permission. Check the intended use against suitable terms or ask for permission, and use an alternative if it remains uncleared.
- Distinguishes attribution from permission.
- Proposes an actual permission check/request or a suitable replacement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class video will contain its own narration, a licensed drawing and an outside music clip. The music terms are unknown. The class will publish the video publicly after teacher review.
5A · True or false
True or false? The licensed drawing automatically clears the separate music clip for public use.
- true: True
- false: False
All components need appropriate checks before the final release.
5B · Open ended
Propose a checklist covering the outside drawing and music, and explain how the team should proceed if music permission remains unknown.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record each creator, source, permitted use, required credit and modifications. Keep the drawing within its terms; replace or omit the music if appropriate permission cannot be confirmed before release.
- Includes separate source/permission/credit checks for the drawing and music.
- Requires omission/replacement or confirmed suitable permission for the uncleared music.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.12 · Crediting sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A traceable illustration
Fictional teaching example
A fictional permission asks for the maker Nara and the source art.example/leaf. A credit says only “nice picture.”
Question: What should be added?
Answer: Identify Nara and the supplied source location.
Why: Those details identify the actual contribution and meet the stated condition.
Example 2 · An adaptation note
Fictional teaching example
A fictional team adds labels to a CC BY 4.0 diagram with its terms met.
Question: What change note is useful?
Answer: “Labels added by the class,” alongside the required attribution and licence information.
Why: It distinguishes the original diagram from the class’s additions.
Example 3 · Different roles
Fictional teaching example
A fictional report uses data gathered by Team A and a graph drawn by Beto.
Question: Give an honest credit.
Answer: Data: Team A. Graph: Beto.
Why: The two contributions are different and both remain visible.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Build the source line
Fictional classroom case
A fictional asset record lists title River Path, creator Mila, source maps.example/river and licence CC BY 4.0. The class added two route labels. The full licence terms are available to the teacher.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Creator; Source location; Modification note
- a: Mila
- b: maps.example/river
- c: Two route labels added by the class
- d: Everything originally drawn by the class
The credit distinguishes the source from the added labels.
Investigation: credit lab
F2 · Keep the roles separate
Fictional classroom case
A fictional audio guide has a script written by Paz, narration recorded by Ren and a permitted sound clip by Studio C. Its permission requires Studio C to be credited for the clip.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Script credit; Narration credit; Sound-clip credit
- a: Paz
- b: Ren
- c: Studio C
- d: Only the person who exported the file
Exporting the finished file does not make one person the creator of all parts.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Update a replacement image
Fictional classroom case
A fictional page originally used Oak Photo by Ava, then replaced it with Pine Drawing by Bela. The final page still credits Ava. The source record for the new drawing names Bela and art.example/pine.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Creator to credit for the final image; Final work; Old credit to replace
- a: Bela
- b: Pine Drawing
- c: Ava for Oak Photo
- d: Credit both as if both images remain
The final credit should match the work actually used.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · A licence name is not a source
Fictional classroom case
A fictional photo record provides creator Ibi and source photos.example/boat under CC BY 4.0. A pupil credits it only as “CC BY 4.0,” omitting the creator and source supplied in the record.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Writing only “CC BY 4.0” identifies the photo’s creator and source.
- true: True
- false: False
A licence identifies terms, not the actual creator or source.
Investigation: credit lab
F5 · An honest contribution line
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class adapts a permitted map by Olan. The class draws new walking-route arrows and writes an explanation. The map permission requires Olan and its source maps.example/town to be identified.
F5 · Open ended
Write a credit that distinguishes the original map from the class’s work and explain why the distinction matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: Base map by Olan, maps.example/town, used under the supplied permission. Route arrows and explanation added by our class. It shows which contribution belongs to Olan and which belongs to us.
- Identifies Olan and the supplied source while naming the class’s added arrows/explanation.
- Explains that the credit distinguishes original and added contributions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: credit lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional poster uses a drawing called Blue Kite by Suri at art.example/kite. Its permission requires Suri and the source, and the team must say if it changes colours. The team changed blue to yellow.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Creator and source; Original work title; Change to disclose
- a: Suri at art.example/kite
- b: Blue Kite
- c: Blue changed to yellow
- d: Made entirely by the poster team
The credit must reflect both origin and the actual change.
1B · Short answer
Write a credit meeting the supplied conditions and explain why a colour-change note helps the reader.
Example of a full-credit answer: Drawing by Suri, art.example/kite, used with permission; blue changed to yellow by our team. The note shows that the colour is our edit rather than the original creator’s choice.
- Includes Suri, the source and the blue-to-yellow change.
- Explains that the note distinguishes the team’s modification from the original work.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team chooses between “picture from the web” and “Moon Bridge by Fara, art.example/moon, used under the supplied permission.” The supplied permission requires the maker and source.
2A · True or false
True or false? The specific credit gives readers a more traceable source than “picture from the web.”
- true: True
- false: False
The specific line identifies the maker and lets a reader trace the work.
2B · Open ended
Give one reason the specific credit is more useful and one reason it still does not prove the image’s claims are true.
Example of a full-credit answer: It identifies Fara and the particular source. Crediting origin does not independently verify every claim a picture or its caption makes.
- Explains the usefulness of identifying the maker and traceable source.
- Distinguishes attribution/origin from factual accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team turns a credited article summary into an audio guide. The source is Trail Notes by Yani at reading.example/trail. The activity requires the source to be available in the audio or accompanying transcript.
3A · Hotspot
Which creator belongs in the source credit?
- a: Yani
- b: The microphone manufacturer
- c: Any listener who likes the audio
- d: The person who named the audio file
A new medium still needs an accessible acknowledgement.
3B · Open ended
Propose how to keep the source credit usable in the audio project and explain why a hidden filename alone is not enough.
Example of a full-credit answer: Include a spoken source credit and a readable transcript note with the source location. A hidden filename may never be seen by the listener and does not clearly associate the source with the explanation.
- Provides a usable spoken or accompanying readable credit identifying the work and creator/source.
- Explains that a hidden filename does not reliably inform listeners or identify the relevant contribution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional download page is posted by Club B but explicitly states “Illustration by Nelo.” A pupil credits Club B as the illustrator. The source page gives both roles clearly.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Nelo is identified as the illustrator.
- b: Club B is identified as the uploader.
- c: Uploading a work automatically makes the uploader its illustrator.
- d: The pupil should invent a new creator when two roles appear.
The record distinguishes making the image from distributing it.
4B · Open ended
Identify the credit error and write a corrected role description.
Example of a full-credit answer: Club B uploaded the work but Nelo illustrated it. Credit “Illustration by Nelo; shared on Club B’s page,” with the source and any required terms.
- Identifies confusion between uploader and illustrator.
- Correctly credits Nelo’s illustration and describes Club B’s sharing role if included.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional guide combines a photograph, a diagram and the team’s own table. Each outside asset has a creator/source/permission record. The team replaced the diagram in its final draft and added labels to the photograph.
5A · Multiple choice
Which record should determine the final diagram credit?
- a: The replacement diagram’s source record
- b: The removed diagram’s old caption
- c: The most famous creator’s name
- d: The picture with the most likes
Credits should match final assets and changes.
5B · Open ended
Propose a final check of the two outside assets and explain how the team’s own table should be distinguished.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare the final photo with its creator/source/terms and record the added labels; match the replacement diagram to its own credit record. Label the table as created by the team from its recorded data.
- Checks the changed photo and replacement diagram against their correct records.
- Distinguishes the team’s table/data contribution from outside assets.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.13 · Disclosing artificial intelligence use
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Titles only
Fictional teaching example
A fictional record says AI offered eight titles and the pupil wrote the report unaided from class measurements.
Question: Give a proportionate disclosure.
Answer: AI suggested titles; I selected one and wrote the report using our measurements.
Why: It names the limited assistance without claiming the entire report was generated.
Example 2 · A generated scene
Fictional teaching example
A fictional image shows an imagined underwater classroom created by a generator.
Question: How should it be labelled?
Answer: AI-generated illustration of an imagined underwater classroom.
Why: The label prevents it being presented as a photograph of an actual place.
Example 3 · A real revision record
Fictional teaching example
A fictional tool drafted a summary. A pupil checked it against the article and rewrote two incorrect sentences.
Question: What should the note explain?
Answer: AI drafted the first summary; the pupil checked the source and corrected the two sentences.
Why: The note identifies both assistance and human review.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose the accurate disclosure
Fictional classroom case
A fictional process log says AI suggested three activity names. Kai chose a name, wrote all instructions and checked them with a teacher. No images or instructions were generated.
F1 · Hotspot
Which note matches the process log?
- a: AI suggested names; Kai wrote and checked the instructions.
- b: AI generated all instructions and images.
- c: No AI assistance was used at any stage.
- d: A detector proved that the work had no human author.
The disclosure should match the actual process.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · What the record supports
Fictional classroom case
A fictional log says a generator made a landscape illustration. Lora selected one result and added a handwritten caption. The scene is imaginary and no photograph was taken.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The image should be identified as a generated illustration.
- b: Lora’s selection and caption are human contributions.
- c: The image is documented as Lora’s photograph.
- d: A generated image must depict an actual event.
Both source and human edits should be represented accurately.
Investigation: provenance lab
F3 · Match tasks to disclosure details
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team log lists brainstorming by AI, fact checking by the team and drawing by the team. The final note should identify these roles separately.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: AI role; Checking role; Drawing role
- a: Suggesting possible topics
- b: Team compared claims with records
- c: Team drew the final diagram
- d: AI verified all facts automatically
The note should follow the recorded roles.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · Place the label where it helps
Fictional classroom case
A fictional public page contains an AI-generated picture of a proposed library. It is not yet built. The page needs a nearby label identifying the picture as an imagined proposal, and a process note explains that humans reviewed the design.
F4 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Image label; Building status; Review note
- a: AI-generated imagined proposal
- b: Not yet built
- c: Humans reviewed the design
- d: Photograph of the finished library
Readers need to distinguish a proposal from evidence of a completed building.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F5 · Keep the note proportionate
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil’s record shows only an AI spelling check. The pupil wrote the explanation, selected the evidence and drew the diagram. The assignment requires disclosure of any AI assistance.
F5 · Short answer
Write an accurate disclosure and explain why “AI wrote my explanation” would be misleading.
Example of a full-credit answer: I wrote the explanation and drew the diagram; AI helped check spelling. Saying AI wrote it would overstate the recorded assistance and hide my actual writing role.
- Clearly discloses the spelling-only assistance while retaining the pupil’s writing/drawing role.
- Explains that claiming AI wrote the explanation overstates the tool’s contribution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: provenance lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI tool drafted the introduction to a water-saving guide. The team checked its claims against the supplied school-use table, changed an incorrect number and wrote the remaining sections itself. The draft said 40 containers; the supplied school-use table says 14 containers.
1A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: AI contribution; Team’s evidence check; Other writing
- a: Drafting the introduction
- b: Compared with the school-use table
- c: Team wrote the remaining sections
- d: AI wrote and verified everything
The final disclosure should match both generation and human review.
1B · Open ended
Write a disclosure naming the generated part and explain the relevant human check and correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: AI drafted the introduction. Our team checked it against the school-use table, corrected the number and wrote the remaining sections.
- Identifies the introduction as the AI-drafted part and the rest as team-written.
- Describes the table-based check and correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional gallery shows a generated reconstruction of an ancient room. The evidence does not establish the exact colours. The label beside it says “AI-generated reconstruction; colours are imagined.” Another note hidden in an unrelated file says only “AI.”
2A · Multiple choice
Which label best matches the evidence?
- a: AI-generated reconstruction; colours are imagined.
- b: Exact photograph of the ancient room.
- c: No human choices affected this image.
- d: All colours have been verified by the image itself.
The adjacent label helps readers interpret what the image can establish.
2B · Open ended
Give two reasons the adjacent label is more useful than the hidden “AI” note.
Example of a full-credit answer: It is visible with the relevant image, and it explains that the colours are imagined rather than verified historical evidence.
- Explains that proximity/accessibility connects the disclosure to the image.
- Explains that the label identifies the reconstruction and the specific colour uncertainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional written report discloses that AI suggested its outline. It is converted to a slideshow with recorded narration. The same outline is retained; the team wrote the report’s explanation itself and records the narration itself. The assignment requires the disclosure to remain accessible.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: AI help retained; New human contribution; Accessible place for details
- a: Outline suggestions
- b: Recorded narration
- c: Accompanying transcript
- d: No disclosure because the medium changed
The assistance remains relevant when the project changes medium.
3B · Open ended
Propose an accessible disclosure in the slideshow and explain how it should distinguish the recorded narration.
Example of a full-credit answer: Include a spoken or readable note and transcript stating that AI suggested the outline, while the team wrote and recorded the explanation. This avoids implying that the tool produced the human narration.
- Keeps the outline-assistance disclosure accessible in the new medium.
- Accurately distinguishes team writing/recording from AI outline suggestions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional page says “AI helped with this paragraph” but incorrectly reports 30 library desks; the checked inventory lists 13. The publisher says a disclosure means the wrong number may remain.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Correct desk count; Role of the AI note; Needed action
- a: 13
- b: Describe assistance
- c: Correct the number
- d: Disclosure makes all claims true
A process label does not validate incorrect content.
4B · Open ended
Identify the publisher’s error and state the needed correction while keeping an honest disclosure.
Example of a full-credit answer: The publisher confuses explaining AI use with verifying facts. Correct 30 to 13 using the inventory and keep a truthful note about the AI-assisted draft and human correction.
- Explains that disclosure does not establish factual accuracy or excuse an error.
- Corrects the count to 13 while retaining an accurate process note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional project uses AI for two brainstorm ideas and a first draft of one caption. The class changes the caption after checking a record, draws the final pictures and writes the remaining text. The teacher requires a short public process note.
5A · True or false
True or false? The record supports saying that AI generated all final pictures.
- true: True
- false: False
The note must reflect specific assistance and the class’s work.
5B · Open ended
Propose a short disclosure naming both AI contributions and explain one final check to keep it accurate.
Example of a full-credit answer: AI suggested two ideas and drafted one caption; our class checked and revised that caption, drew the pictures and wrote the remaining text. Compare this note with the final project and process log before release.
- Names both AI contributions and accurately identifies the class’s revision/creation roles.
- Provides a final comparison with the actual work or process log.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.14 · Creating inclusive content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A label beyond colour
Fictional teaching example
A fictional activity has green and red boxes for Start and Stop.
Question: What change helps readers who cannot distinguish the colours?
Answer: Add the words Start and Stop to the respective boxes.
Why: The action can be identified without colour alone.
Example 2 · A meaningful alternative
Fictional teaching example
A fictional image shows the hall behind the library. Its text alternative says only “photo.”
Question: What would be more useful in a route guide?
Answer: “The hall is behind the library.”
Why: It communicates the location information the route reader needs.
Example 3 · A smaller complete version
Fictional teaching example
A fictional video invitation needs a large download. A small text version includes the date, time, venue and joining instructions.
Question: Why is this a useful alternative?
Answer: It preserves the necessary information for readers with a limited connection.
Why: The alternative serves the same essential task without the large file.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match barriers with changes
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class notice has three barriers: spoken-only directions, colour-only team labels and an unexplained acronym. The prepared fixes are a transcript, written team names and an expanded phrase.
F1 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Spoken-only directions; Colour-only teams; Unexplained acronym
- a: Transcript of the directions
- b: Written team names
- c: Expanded phrase
- d: More background music
Each change addresses a different missing route to meaning.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F2 · A useful caption
Fictional classroom case
A fictional video shows a timer ending with a bell. The instruction says to stop placing blocks when the bell rings. Captions include “[bell rings—stop placing blocks]” at that moment.
F2 · True or false
True or false? The bell caption helps a reader without sound know when to stop.
- true: True
- false: False
The caption carries the task-changing meaning of the sound.
Investigation: clip lab
F3 · Keep translated facts aligned
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school invitation has a checked English version: Tuesday, 2 pm, Hall D. A reviewed second-language draft keeps Tuesday and Hall D but mistakenly changes the time to 3 pm. The translator confirms that the time should remain 2 pm.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Day to retain; Venue to retain; Time to correct to
- a: Tuesday
- b: Hall D
- c: 2 pm
- d: 3 pm
A translation must preserve the confirmed facts, including the time.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A low-connection choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional visitor has a 5-unit download allowance. The video guide needs 20 units, the complete labelled text guide needs 2 units and a decorative animation needs 4 units but omits the route. The required task is finding Room 6.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Complete guide within the allowance; Allowance; Required information
- a: 2-unit text guide
- b: 5 units
- c: Route to Room 6
- d: 4-unit decorative animation
An accessible alternative must meet both the connection limit and the information need.
Investigation: graph lab
F5 · Make a map usable without colour
Fictional classroom case
A fictional map marks the library with a blue square and the hall with a yellow square. Its key names only the colours. Some visitors use a monochrome printout.
F5 · Open ended
Propose one change to identify both places without colour and explain how to test that change.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add L—Library and H—Hall labels or distinct shapes with a word key. Ask a reader using a monochrome copy to find both places.
- Adds non-colour labels or distinguishable symbols with a clear key for both places.
- Tests identification of both locations on a monochrome/non-colour version.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: accessibility lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional computer activity asks pupils to “press the flashing thing on the right.” The control has a stable label, Begin. Some pupils cannot use visual flashing cues. The task is to start the activity.
1A · Hotspot
Which wording best identifies the required control?
- a: Activate the control labelled Begin.
- b: Press whichever object flashes most.
- c: Guess which right-side colour is intended.
- d: Activate any control without reading its label.
The stable label identifies the action without requiring the flashing effect.
1B · Short answer
Write a clearer instruction and explain which access barrier it removes.
Example of a full-credit answer: Activate the control labelled Begin. The reader no longer needs to identify a flashing visual object or its position to know which control to use.
- Uses the correct stable control label Begin in a clear action instruction.
- Explains removal of dependence on flashing/visual position cues.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional recording says the workshop begins at 4 pm in Room 8 and learners should bring paper. Its summary says only “there is a workshop.” A full transcript contains all three details.
2A · Multiple choice
Which alternative preserves the information needed to attend and prepare?
- a: Full transcript with time, room and material
- b: Summary saying only there is a workshop
- c: Decorative banner with no details
- d: Music clip containing no spoken instructions
The transcript carries the information needed to attend and prepare.
2B · Open ended
Explain how the full transcript helps readers both arrive at the workshop and prepare what to bring, using the stated details.
Example of a full-credit answer: It gives the 4 pm time and Room 8 location, and it tells learners to bring paper. The vague summary leaves out those attendance and preparation details.
- Identifies time/location information that the summary omits.
- Identifies the bring-paper preparation instruction that the summary omits.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional online notice uses an audio clip to explain a route and a clickable icon labelled only “here.” For a printed handout, the school supplies written directions: enter Gate A, follow the path to the hall, then turn left for the library.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The handout can include the three written route steps.
- b: A paper-only reader test checks whether the essential route survives.
- c: A printed “here” icon automatically plays the audio.
- d: The route may be omitted because the online version has sound.
The printed version must carry the directions in a form that works on paper.
3B · Short answer
Describe how to adapt the notice for print and give a task-based check of its usefulness.
Example of a full-credit answer: Print the three written route steps with clear labels or a labelled map. Ask a reader using only the paper to explain the route from Gate A to the library.
- Includes the essential written/labelled route in a print-usable form.
- Proposes a paper-only route-following or explanation test.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team increases font size but leaves every important category identified only by colour. It claims that one change makes the entire chart accessible to everyone. The chart has no text category names.
4A · True or false
True or false? Increasing font size alone guarantees that colour-only categories can be identified by every reader.
- true: True
- false: False
A useful improvement does not resolve every separate barrier.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and propose a change addressing the remaining barrier.
Example of a full-credit answer: Larger text alone does not prove access for everyone. Add category names or distinct labelled symbols so the bars can be identified without colour.
- Explains that one font change does not establish universal accessibility.
- Adds non-colour category identifiers addressing the specific remaining barrier.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club needs an announcement for a noisy fair and a low-connection class page. The essential facts are Friday, 1 pm, Hall A. It should be understandable without sound and should not rely on colour to identify the venue.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Essential schedule; Venue; Connection-friendly alternative
- a: Friday at 1 pm
- b: Hall A
- c: Small text version
- d: Sound-only colour-coded invitation
The design should preserve the same essential facts through its alternatives.
5B · Open ended
Propose an announcement meeting the sound, colour and connection constraints, and explain a concrete check before release.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use readable words Friday, 1 pm, Hall A with labelled directions and a small text version. Test it silently and in monochrome, asking a reader to state the time and venue from the small version.
- Includes all essential facts in readable non-audio/non-colour-dependent form with a small text alternative.
- Provides a relevant silent/monochrome/low-connection task test.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL6.15 · Creating responsible content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · True but unnecessary
Fictional teaching example
A fictional public poster gives the correct event time and also a pupil’s private contact placeholder. The school office can handle enquiries.
Question: What should change?
Answer: Keep the useful event details and use the school office route instead of the pupil’s private contact.
Why: Accuracy does not make unnecessary personal disclosure appropriate.
Example 2 · A useful limit
Fictional teaching example
A fictional model worked in 3 of 4 classroom tests. A poster says it is guaranteed to work everywhere.
Question: What is a more responsible claim?
Answer: The model worked in 3 of 4 classroom tests.
Why: The limited statement reports the evidence without promising untested results.
Example 3 · A post-publication correction
Fictional teaching example
A fictional invitation gives the wrong entrance. The team has already shared it with the class.
Question: What should happen?
Answer: Correct the invitation and tell the affected readers the correct entrance through the approved class channel.
Why: Updating a private draft alone would not reach people who saw the error.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose a responsible event notice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional art fair is Friday at noon in Hall B. The office handles enquiries. Notice A gives those details and the office route. B gives a pupil’s private contact. C invents free prizes. D omits the venue.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which notice best matches the supplied facts and approved contact arrangement?
- a: A: confirmed time, venue and office route
- b: B: pupil’s private contact without the venue
- c: C: an unsupported promise of free prizes
- d: D: a decorative notice without a location
A provides confirmed useful details without the unnecessary private contact or invented promise.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Find the unsupported headline
Fictional classroom case
A fictional trial finds that 6 of 8 pupils finish a puzzle. Headline A says “Six of eight finished in this trial.” B says “Every child will always succeed.” C labels the activity a classroom trial. D identifies eight participants.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the headline that goes beyond the evidence.
- a: Every child will always succeed
- b: Six of eight finished in this trial
- c: This was a classroom puzzle trial
- d: Eight pupils took part in the trial
The universal promise extends beyond the observed result.
Investigation: verification lab
F3 · Assign separate review jobs
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team prepares a video. Nia checks the date against the plan, Omi checks the drawing’s reuse terms and Pia checks captions against speech. Each check addresses a different responsibility.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Nia’s check; Omi’s check; Pia’s check
- a: Factual accuracy
- b: Permission for the drawing
- c: Access to the spoken information
- d: One check guarantees every other part
The team distributes distinct responsibilities rather than treating them as interchangeable.
Investigation: collaboration lab
F4 · An accurate but unapproved photo
Fictional classroom case
A fictional picture genuinely shows a club meeting, but the school’s stated arrangement does not permit public sharing of the pupils’ images. The team can use a permitted illustration instead.
F4 · True or false
True or false? Because the photo is genuine, the stated restriction on public sharing no longer matters.
- true: True
- false: False
Factual accuracy and the permission/consent arrangement are separate checks.
Investigation: privacy lab
F5 · A respectful disagreement
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil wants to post that the club’s proposed timetable excludes classmates who travel early. A draft names and mocks the planner. The actual concern is that the last session ends after the school transport leaves.
F5 · Open ended
Write a respectful comment focused on the timetable and explain why it is more responsible than mocking the planner.
Example of a full-credit answer: Could we move the last session earlier so classmates can catch school transport? It addresses the participation problem without attacking or exposing the planner.
- Proposes a respectful timetable-focused comment addressing the transport conflict.
- Explains that focusing on the issue avoids personal mockery or unnecessary exposure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional public poster has checked facts and correct credits, but a photograph is still awaiting permission under the school’s arrangement. A fully permitted class drawing is available. The poster can meet its purpose with the drawing.
1A · True or false
True or false? Checked facts and correct credits automatically resolve the photograph’s missing approval.
- true: True
- false: False
The team can complete the purpose with a cleared alternative.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the poster is not ready with the photo and propose a responsible way to meet the deadline.
Example of a full-credit answer: The required public-photo approval is still unresolved. Replace it with the permitted class drawing and review the final layout, or wait for approval before using the photo.
- Identifies the unresolved required photo permission despite other completed checks.
- Uses the permitted alternative or waits for proper approval with an appropriate final review.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional public invitation needs a place for enquiries. The teacher supplies the school office as the approved contact route. A student suggests adding pupils’ home locations to look friendly, although visitors do not need them.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Useful public enquiry route; Unnecessary personal detail; Purpose
- a: School office
- b: Pupils’ home locations
- c: Help visitors ask about the event
- d: Publish every detail to seem friendly
The office route serves the task without exposing unrelated personal information.
2B · Open ended
Explain how the office route serves the invitation and why home locations should be omitted.
Example of a full-credit answer: Visitors can get event information through the approved office route. Home locations do not help with the event and expose unnecessary personal details.
- Connects the school office route to the legitimate enquiry need.
- Explains that home locations are unnecessary and create avoidable personal exposure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class makes a playful drawing using invented characters. A teammate wants to replace one character with a real pupil’s embarrassing photo for public posting. The pupil has not agreed and the school requires permission for such images.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Using a real pupil’s unapproved photo changes the privacy risk.
- b: Keeping invented characters can retain the joke without that exposure.
- c: A class joke automatically grants permission for every public photo.
- d: A public audience removes the need to consider the pupil.
The purpose can be retained without exposing a real pupil.
3B · Short answer
Explain what changed in the risk and propose a version suitable for the public page.
Example of a full-credit answer: Replacing an invented character with a real unapproved embarrassing photo creates a privacy and consent problem for the pupil. Keep invented characters or another permitted non-identifying illustration.
- Identifies the new real-person privacy/consent or embarrassment risk.
- Proposes a permitted fictional/non-identifying alternative retaining the creative purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team published “Gate C” for an event whose checked entrance is Gate A. It corrects only an unpublished draft and says the problem is solved. The public notice still shows Gate C.
4A · Multiple choice
Which action directly addresses the remaining public error?
- a: Update the public notice and share the correction.
- b: Change only another private draft.
- c: Remove the checked entrance from the records.
- d: Add more decorations around Gate C.
A private revision does not repair the public notice people rely on.
4B · Open ended
Identify the failure in the team’s response and describe a repair that reaches affected readers.
Example of a full-credit answer: The team changed a private draft while leaving the public mistake. Update the public notice and communicate the Gate A correction through the approved channels used by affected readers.
- Explains that the private draft update leaves the public error unresolved.
- Includes correction of the public notice and notification to affected readers through an appropriate route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team is making a public guide to a school exhibition. It must state Room 9 at 10 am, use only approved media, be understandable without sound and provide a school-office correction route. A teacher reviews the final file.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Confirmed event facts; Access requirement; Correction route
- a: Room 9 at 10 am
- b: Essential information without sound
- c: School office
- d: Publish first and assume no review is needed
A responsible plan links accurate content, permission, access and an accountable review route.
5B · Open ended
Propose checks that cover the event facts, media and silent use, then explain who reviews and handles corrections.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare Room 9 and 10 am with the plan, check every media approval and test the readable version without sound. The teacher reviews the final file; correction reports go through the school office so the team can update the public guide.
- Covers confirmed event facts, media permissions and silent/text access in the pre-release checks.
- Identifies teacher final review and the office route followed by public correction when needed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.1 · Password security
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Two accounts, one exposed secret
Fictional teaching example
In a fictional account plan, Account A and Account B use the same secret. Account A’s secret becomes exposed.
Question: Why does Account B need attention?
Answer: The exposed secret may also be tried on B.
Why: Using unique secrets avoids this direct reuse connection.
Example 2 · A shared project
Fictional teaching example
A fictional group needs to edit one document. The teacher provides approved individual access.
Question: Should one pupil send everyone a personal password?
Answer: No. Use the approved individual document access.
Why: Sharing work does not require sharing the secret that controls a personal account.
Example 3 · An unexpected approval
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil receives a sign-in approval request without trying to sign in.
Question: What should the pupil do?
Answer: Do not approve it automatically; ask a trusted adult and check through the known account route.
Why: An unexpected request may relate to someone else’s attempted sign-in.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Keep the secret out of the poster
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class is making account-safety posters. The teacher asks for descriptions of safe habits only. A pupil suggests printing an actual password as a strong example. No real secret is needed for the task.
F1 · True or false
True or false? The class should use descriptions rather than an actual password in its public poster.
- true: True
- false: False
A public example should describe the habit without exposing a usable secret.
Investigation: privacy lab
F2 · Match the protection to its purpose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school guide explains: unique passwords reduce direct reuse after a leak; an approved password manager helps store different secrets; MFA adds another type of sign-in check.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Unique password; Approved password manager; MFA
- a: Reduce direct reuse after a leak
- b: Store different secrets
- c: Add another sign-in check
- d: Guarantee no attack is possible
These protections serve different purposes and none is an absolute guarantee.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Choose the proper help route
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil forgets a school account secret. The school’s approved route is to ask the teacher for account recovery. A stranger’s message asks the pupil to reply with old passwords. A classmate offers to post guesses publicly.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Approved help route; Unsafe stranger request; Unsafe public action
- a: Teacher-led account recovery
- b: Reply with old passwords
- c: Post password guesses
- d: Send secrets to any person called support
The supplied school arrangement provides a known recovery route.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · Extra protection is not permission to share
Fictional classroom case
A fictional account has MFA enabled. Its owner is asked by a teammate to send the password and approve an unfamiliar sign-in. The teacher provides a separate approved project-sharing feature.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The team can use the approved project-sharing feature.
- b: The owner should not automatically approve the unfamiliar sign-in.
- c: MFA makes it safe to send the password to any teammate.
- d: A request labelled urgent must be approved without checking.
MFA and secret protection should work together.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A reused password was exposed
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil learns that one account secret may have been exposed and remembers using the same secret for a second account. A trusted adult and official recovery routes are available.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the second account needs attention and describe a safe next step without giving any password.
Example of a full-credit answer: The same exposed secret may be tried on the second account. Tell the trusted adult and use the known official routes to secure the affected accounts with appropriate unique secrets.
- Explains the direct risk caused by reusing the exposed secret.
- Uses trusted adult help and a known official route to secure/review the accounts without sharing secrets.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school setup allows a pupil to use an approved manager with teacher help. Option A creates a new long unique secret. Option B reuses the secret from a previously exposed game account. No actual secrets are displayed.
1A · True or false
True or false? Reusing the exposed game secret is safer than creating a new unique one.
- true: True
- false: False
Reusing an exposed secret creates a known avoidable connection.
1B · Short answer
Explain why A is preferable to B and name one habit that still protects A after setup.
Example of a full-credit answer: A avoids reusing the exposed game secret. Keep the new secret private, protect the manager and use the approved MFA/account arrangements.
- Explains that A avoids reuse of the known exposed secret.
- Names a continuing protective habit such as privacy of the secret, manager protection or appropriate MFA.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional group has approved access for each member to a shared file. One member says sending her account password is faster. The shared access already lets everyone edit the file.
2A · Hotspot
Which option meets the group’s need without sharing an account secret?
- a: Approved individual access to the file
- b: A password posted in the group chat
- c: One password copied into every document
- d: An account secret sent to an unknown helper
The approved access meets the need without exposing a personal account.
2B · Open ended
Give a task-based reason to use the approved access and a security reason to avoid password sharing.
Example of a full-credit answer: Everyone can already edit the shared file using approved access. Keeping the account password private avoids giving others control of the personal account.
- Explains that approved access already supports the required editing.
- Explains the account risk of exposing or sharing a personal password.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil uses a school-approved account on a shared library computer. The school instructs users to sign out when finished and not leave personal accounts available for the next user. A password manager remains under the school’s approved arrangements.
3A · Multiple choice
Which finishing action follows the supplied school instructions?
- a: Save the work and sign out.
- b: Leave the account open for the next user.
- c: Write the secret beside the keyboard.
- d: Ask the next user to remember the secret.
The shared device changes who may reach an unattended signed-in account.
3B · Short answer
Explain the new risk on the shared computer and state a suitable finishing action.
Example of a full-credit answer: The next user may access an account left signed in. Save the work and sign out following the school’s instructions, checking that the account is no longer open.
- Identifies the next-user access risk of leaving the account signed in.
- Includes saving as appropriate and signing out/checking closure under the school arrangement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil keeps one familiar secret across several accounts and changes only its final number each month. The pupil claims this makes reuse and exposure harmless. No actual password is shown.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Continuing problem; Unsupported claim; Better direction
- a: Reused predictable base secret
- b: Exposure is harmless
- c: Long unique secrets with approved support
- d: Verified use of separate unique secrets
Predictable small changes do not remove reuse or exposure risk.
4B · Open ended
Identify the pupil’s reasoning error and propose a better account habit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats a predictable monthly change as if it removed the risk of reused or exposed secrets. Use different long hard-to-guess secrets through approved support and act promptly if one is exposed.
- Explains why predictable small changes do not make reuse/exposure harmless.
- Proposes unique long hard-to-guess secrets and/or an appropriate exposure response with approved support.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher asks for a checklist describing account setup and unexpected-request handling. It must not contain actual passwords or codes. The school supports an approved manager, MFA and teacher-led recovery.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Setup support; Recovery support; Information excluded
- a: Approved manager and MFA
- b: Teacher-led route
- c: Actual passwords and codes
- d: The public checklist title
The checklist teaches decisions without collecting sensitive information.
5B · Open ended
Propose a setup step for long unique secrets and an unexpected-message step that use the school’s support while keeping secrets out of the checklist.
Example of a full-credit answer: Set up long unique secrets with the approved manager and MFA under teacher guidance. Do not send secrets or approve unexpected requests; ask the teacher and use the known official route to check.
- Includes long unique secrets with appropriate approved setup support/MFA.
- Includes resisting secret requests or unexpected approvals and checking through trusted adult/known route, with no actual secrets.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.2 · Phishing
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The display name mismatch
Fictional teaching example
A fictional message displays “Library Office,” but the sender is stranger@prize.example and asks for an account code.
Question: What should the pupil do?
Answer: Pause and verify with the known library or teacher route without sending the code.
Why: The sender mismatch and secret request warrant checking.
Example 2 · Perfect spelling
Fictional teaching example
A fictional message has perfect grammar and demands an urgent private payment through an unfamiliar link.
Question: Does the writing prove it is safe?
Answer: No. Good grammar does not verify the sender or request.
Why: Safety depends on evidence and independent verification, not polished wording.
Example 3 · A known route
Fictional teaching example
A fictional school normally announces events on its approved class board. A strange message announces a changed fee.
Question: How can it be checked safely?
Answer: Ask the teacher or check the known class board without using the strange link.
Why: The checking route is independent of the suspicious message.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A fake support request
Fictional classroom case
A fictional message from help@bonus.example displays “School Support” and demands an account code within five minutes. The school’s established rule is to ask the teacher for account help; it never asks pupils to send codes in messages.
F1 · Multiple choice
What should the pupil do first?
- a: Pause and ask the teacher through the known route.
- b: Reply with the account code immediately.
- c: Forward the link to classmates to test it.
- d: Trust the display name without checking the request.
The supplied school rule and suspicious request make independent checking appropriate.
Investigation: phishing lab
F2 · Two clues that matter
Fictional classroom case
A fictional prize message says the pupil won a contest never entered, asks for private details and gives an unfamiliar destination at claim.example. Its sentences have no spelling errors.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The unentered contest makes the prize claim unexpected.
- b: The request for private details warrants caution.
- c: Correct spelling proves the sender is genuine.
- d: An unfamiliar link should be tested by entering private details.
The unexpected context and request require care despite polished text.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Choose an independent check
Fictional classroom case
A fictional message claims the school office changed the pickup place. It supplies a new contact link. The pupil already knows the teacher and the school’s approved notice board, which can confirm pickup arrangements.
F3 · Hotspot
Which route provides an independent check?
- a: The known teacher or approved notice board
- b: Only the message’s new contact link
- c: A reply to the same unknown sender
- d: The message’s own claim that it is official
An independent route does not depend on trusting the suspicious message.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · Match safe responses
Fictional classroom case
A fictional safety poster lists three situations: suspicious attachment, request for an account secret and unfamiliar urgent instruction. The school advises leaving the attachment closed, not sending the secret and checking with a trusted adult through a known route.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Suspicious attachment; Account-secret request; Unfamiliar urgent instruction
- a: Leave closed and report
- b: Do not send the secret
- c: Verify through a known adult route
- d: Try every link to see whether it works
These responses reduce exposure while a responsible adult checks the situation.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · A friend’s name is not enough
Fictional classroom case
A fictional message uses a friend’s familiar display name but unusually asks for an account password. The pupil can speak to that friend in class and has a teacher available.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the display name does not settle the message’s trustworthiness and give a safe way to check the unusual request.
Example of a full-credit answer: A display name can be copied or an account can be misused, so it does not verify the secret request. Do not send the password; speak to the friend or teacher through the known in-person route.
- Explains that a familiar display name alone does not establish sender/request authenticity.
- Refuses secret sharing and uses a known independent friend/teacher route to check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: phishing lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil receives an unexpected file labelled “new timetable” from an unverified sender. The school plan says do not open suspicious attachments, report to the teacher and confirm timetable changes on the known class board.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Attachment action; Report recipient; Timetable verification source
- a: Leave unopened
- b: Teacher
- c: Known class board
- d: Open first and ask later
The supplied plan separates avoiding exposure, reporting and verification.
1B · Open ended
Explain why opening the file first is unnecessary and describe the safe checking sequence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The timetable can be checked without opening an unverified attachment. Leave it closed, tell the teacher and confirm through the known class board.
- Explains that an independent timetable check avoids the need to open the attachment.
- Gives an appropriate sequence of leaving closed, reporting to teacher and verifying on the known board.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional message is neatly designed and uses correct grammar. It asks a pupil to approve a sign-in the pupil did not start and threatens that the account will vanish immediately. The teacher can check through the school’s account route.
2A · True or false
True or false? Good grammar alone makes it safe to approve the unexpected sign-in.
- true: True
- false: False
Appearance does not remove the concern about an unexpected approval.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the design is not sufficient proof and identify the action that should be paused while checking.
Example of a full-credit answer: Anyone can prepare polished wording; it does not verify this request. Do not approve the unexpected sign-in; ask the teacher through the known account route.
- Distinguishes polished appearance from verification of the sender/request.
- Pauses the unexpected sign-in approval and checks through the known route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional sticker on a notice board says “Scan now to keep your account.” It asks for account details on an unfamiliar destination. The school’s known poster beside it says account issues go to the teacher and never require a public-board code scan.
3A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Unverified request format; Safe independent route; Information not to enter
- a: QR sticker
- b: Ask the teacher
- c: Account details
- d: QR codes are always trusted
Changing the delivery format does not remove the need to verify the request.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the phishing-checking principle applies to the sticker and give the safe next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The sticker still directs the pupil to an unverified request for account details. Do not scan or enter details to test it; ask the teacher through the known school route.
- Identifies that a QR format can carry the same unverified sensitive-information request.
- Avoids interacting/entering details and checks through the established teacher route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil receives a suspicious prize link and sends it to the whole class asking everyone to try it. The teacher’s plan instead uses a private report to a trusted adult without opening the link.
4A · Hotspot
What is the main problem with asking the whole class to try the link?
- a: It may expose more pupils to the same unsafe request.
- b: It makes the original sender a verified teacher.
- c: It automatically removes the link’s risk.
- d: It proves the prize claim through popularity.
A warning can become another route distributing a harmful link.
4B · Open ended
Identify the risk in the pupil’s response and propose a safer way to alert the teacher and classmates if needed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Forwarding invites more people to interact with the suspicious link. Report privately to the teacher; the teacher can give a warning through the approved route without inviting clicks or spreading the active link.
- Explains how forwarding for others to try increases exposure.
- Uses a trusted-adult report and a safe warning method that does not invite interaction with the link.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a small response card for suspicious messages in any format. It must cover secret requests, unexpected links and independent verification, with no real passwords or personal details collected.
5A · Multiple choice
Which first instruction best fits the card?
- a: Pause before opening links or sending secrets.
- b: Try the link on a friend’s account.
- c: Share any requested code to show cooperation.
- d: Trust every familiar-looking display name.
A short card should support safe decisions rather than collecting evidence through risky interaction.
5B · Open ended
Propose two connected instructions: one that avoids exposure and one that verifies or reports with a trusted adult through an independently known route.
Example of a full-credit answer: Do not open unexpected links or attachments, send secrets or approve unfamiliar requests. Show the message to a trusted adult and verify using an independently known school/service route or approved reporting process.
- Includes concrete avoidance of risky interaction or secret sharing.
- Includes trusted-adult help and independent known-route verification/reporting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.3 · Online scams
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A fee for a free prize
Fictional teaching example
A fictional message promises a free tablet but requests a delivery fee before identifying a verifiable organiser.
Question: What is a safe response?
Answer: Do not pay; ask a trusted adult to verify the organiser independently.
Why: The exciting promise does not establish a genuine prize or justify payment.
Example 2 · A secret bargain
Fictional teaching example
A fictional seller says a pupil must not tell a parent about a deal.
Question: Why is that concerning?
Answer: It tries to remove the trusted support that could check the offer.
Why: Secrecy pressure is a reason to pause, not a reason to cooperate.
Example 3 · A familiar account, unusual request
Fictional teaching example
A fictional classmate’s account suddenly asks for a payment to unlock a game prize. The classmate can be contacted at school.
Question: How should the request be checked?
Answer: Speak through the known in-person route with adult help, without paying first.
Why: A familiar account name does not establish that an unusual request is genuine.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read beyond the headline
Fictional classroom case
A fictional offer has headline “Free drawing kit,” instruction “pay 20 credits before we name the organiser” and a timer “act in two minutes.” The teacher recommends adult checking before payments. Credits are imaginary classroom units.
F1 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Headline promise; Actual requested payment; Pressure tactic
- a: Free drawing kit
- b: 20 credits
- c: Two-minute deadline
- d: Verified school purchase
The request and pressure must be considered along with the promise.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Choose the safe first response
Fictional classroom case
A fictional message promises a rare game item if a pupil sends account access and invites three friends. No organiser has been verified. A trusted adult is available.
F2 · Multiple choice
What should the pupil do first?
- a: Pause and ask a trusted adult without sending access.
- b: Send access to test whether the item arrives.
- c: Invite friends to try the request first.
- d: Trust the offer because the reward is rare.
There is no need to surrender access to investigate the promise.
Investigation: message lab
F3 · Match evidence to its limit
Fictional classroom case
A fictional seller provides a glossy picture, five comments all copied from one source and a known school-office notice saying the school is not involved. The picture shows appearance, the comments repeat one origin and the office notice answers the claimed school connection.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Glossy picture establishes only; Copied comments represent; Known office notice addresses
- a: Appearance shown in the picture
- b: One repeated origin
- c: Claimed school involvement
- d: Guaranteed delivery and safety
Each piece of evidence supports only a limited conclusion.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Identify pressure and safer support
Fictional classroom case
A fictional offer says “Do not tell your teacher” and “Send private details now or lose the prize.” The pupil has not entered a contest. The school encourages bringing suspicious offers to a trusted adult.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The offer pressures the pupil to avoid teacher support.
- b: A trusted adult can help check without sending private details.
- c: Secrecy proves the organiser is honest.
- d: An unexpected prize requires immediate private-data sharing.
The message tries to block checking while asking for sensitive information.
Investigation: phishing lab
F5 · A countdown is not evidence
Fictional classroom case
A fictional shop page shows a countdown and says a bargain disappears in 30 seconds. The seller’s identity and delivery terms are unverified. A pupil is tempted to ask a friend to pay quickly.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the countdown does not establish a trustworthy offer and propose a safe next step involving the payment decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: A timer creates urgency but does not verify the seller or delivery terms. Do not ask a friend to pay; pause and involve a trusted adult to check through independent information or decline.
- Distinguishes urgency from evidence of seller/offer trustworthiness.
- Avoids payment/recruiting a friend and uses trusted adult independent checking or declines.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: attention lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional message claims the school sells badges through pay-now.example. The school office, contacted through its established route, confirms it has no such sale and asks pupils not to pay the message. The pupil has not paid.
1A · True or false
True or false? The independently contacted office confirms that the badge message is an official school sale.
- true: True
- false: False
The known school confirmation directly contradicts the claimed connection.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the office information is relevant and describe what the pupil should do with the message.
Example of a full-credit answer: It directly checks the offer’s claimed school link through the established route. Do not pay; report or handle the message according to the teacher’s process without spreading the payment link.
- Connects the office confirmation to the offer’s claimed school involvement.
- Avoids payment and follows an appropriate adult/reporting route without spreading the link.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional offer demands one credit to prove that a pupil is “serious,” then promises a large reward. There is no verified organiser or rule explaining the reward. The pupil says a small payment cannot matter.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Missing evidence; Risky proposed test; Safer choice
- a: Verified organiser and reward terms
- b: Paying before verification
- c: Pause and ask a trusted adult
- d: Small payments establish honesty
The size of a payment does not make the recipient or promise genuine.
2B · Open ended
Give one reason a test payment does not verify the promise and one safer way to handle the decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: A payment can be taken even if the promised reward is false. Pause and ask a trusted adult to verify the organiser and terms independently or decline.
- Explains why paying does not establish that the reward will be delivered.
- Uses adult-supported independent checking or declining before payment.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional voice message sounds like a club leader and urgently asks a pupil to send money. The club’s rule is that purchases go through a teacher. No voice identity has been independently verified.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Verification status; Known purchase route; Unsafe pressure
- a: Voice identity unverified
- b: Teacher
- c: Pay now without asking
- d: A familiar-sounding voice proves identity
A familiar sound does not replace independent verification of an unusual payment request.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the voice alone is insufficient and state the safe route for checking the request.
Example of a full-credit answer: A voice can be imitated or misunderstood, so it does not establish this payment request. Do not send money; ask the teacher through the established club-purchase route.
- Explains that apparent vocal familiarity alone does not verify identity/request.
- Avoids payment and checks through the established teacher route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional offer page says “500 people clicked,” and a pupil concludes all 500 received the promised prize. The supplied record counts only visits, with no delivery records.
4A · Multiple choice
What does the supplied 500 count measure?
- a: Clicks on the page
- b: Verified prizes delivered
- c: Confirmed honest organisers
- d: Successful school approvals
A visit count is not a count of completed deliveries; no documented deliveries here does not prove none ever happened.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken inference and name evidence needed to evaluate the delivery claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats clicks as proof of delivered prizes. A relevant verified delivery record or independently checked customer fulfilment information would be needed.
- Explains that clicks/visits do not establish prize delivery.
- Names relevant independent or verifiable fulfilment/delivery evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a poster about unexpected online offers. The poster must tell pupils what to pause, how to involve a trusted adult and how to avoid exposing friends. It must not ask children to investigate sellers.
5A · Hotspot
Which instruction belongs in the poster?
- a: Pause payment and ask a trusted adult.
- b: Investigate the seller alone with a test payment.
- c: Invite classmates to send details first.
- d: Treat every countdown as a reason to skip checking.
The plan should reduce exposure and direct decisions to appropriate support.
5B · Open ended
Propose an instruction about money/data and an instruction about help that also protects classmates.
Example of a full-credit answer: Do not pay or send private data to an unexpected unverified offer. Ask a trusted adult to check through a known route, and do not invite classmates to test or forward the offer.
- Pauses payment and/or private-data sharing before an unverified offer.
- Uses trusted adult independent checking while avoiding exposing classmates through testing/forwarding.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.4 · Privacy settings
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A class draft
Fictional teaching example
A fictional story draft needs comments only from classmates. The choices are owner only, class and public.
Question: Which audience fits the stated need?
Answer: Class.
Why: Owner only prevents the requested class feedback; public is broader than needed.
Example 2 · A microphone request
Fictional teaching example
A fictional tool is used only to read a text. It requests microphone access without explaining why.
Question: What is a reasonable response?
Answer: Pause and ask a trusted adult whether that permission is necessary.
Why: A permission request is not itself evidence that the current task needs it.
Example 3 · A saved screenshot
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class-only post is copied by a member before the owner deletes it.
Question: Does deletion prove every copy is gone?
Answer: No. The saved copy may still exist.
Why: Audience controls and deletion have limits once someone has copied content.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Who needs the draft?
Fictional classroom case
A fictional poem draft needs feedback from the writer’s class only. The audience options are owner, class and public. The writer chooses class and avoids adding private personal details.
F1 · True or false
True or false? Class access fits the stated need better than public access.
- true: True
- false: False
The class audience fits the defined feedback purpose.
Investigation: privacy lab
F2 · Choose a permission decision
Fictional classroom case
A fictional reading-only app request asks for exact location. The lesson needs only the displayed story, and the app gives no task-related explanation for the request. A trusted adult can review it.
F2 · Multiple choice
What is the most appropriate next step?
- a: Pause and ask an adult whether location is necessary.
- b: Allow all permissions because the prompt appears.
- c: Publish a real location to test the feature.
- d: Assume the request proves the app is malicious.
The case provides no reason this reading task needs location.
Investigation: message lab
F3 · Three different controls
Fictional classroom case
A fictional guide distinguishes post audience, microphone permission and editing access. Audience chooses who can read the post; microphone permission allows recording input; editing access chooses who can change the draft.
F3 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Post audience; Microphone permission; Editing access
- a: Who can read
- b: Recording input access
- c: Who can change the draft
- d: All three mean publish publicly
The controls govern different kinds of access.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · Review each field
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class profile has project title set public, team draft set class and private note set owner only. A public visitor should see only the project title in this model.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Public visitor can see; Class members can also see; Owner-only field
- a: Project title
- b: Team draft
- c: Private note
- d: Public visitor sees every field
The supplied settings determine visibility in the classroom model.
Investigation: privacy lab
F5 · Settings cannot replace permission
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil wants to post a classmate’s photo to a small class group. The classmate has said not to share it, and the school arrangement requires permission for this use. The pupil argues that class-only access removes the problem.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the setting does not solve the permission problem and propose a suitable alternative.
Example of a full-credit answer: Class-only access still shares the photo with other people and does not override the classmate’s refusal or school arrangement. Do not share it; use a permitted drawing or another agreed alternative.
- Explains that a smaller audience does not replace required consent/permission.
- Respects the refusal and proposes not sharing or using a permitted non-identifying alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: privacy lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school display needs the public project title “River exhibit” and the public opening time “10 am,” but its unfinished notes should remain class-only. The current settings make all three public.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The unfinished notes should be changed to class-only.
- b: The title and opening time can remain public for the stated display.
- c: Every internal note is needed by public visitors.
- d: An owner preview alone proves what every public visitor sees.
The required public purpose does not need unfinished internal notes.
1B · Short answer
State the setting change and describe a viewer check that confirms the intended result.
Example of a full-credit answer: Change unfinished notes to class-only. Preview as a public visitor to confirm that the title and 10 am remain visible while the notes are hidden.
- Narrows unfinished notes to class-only while retaining the required public fields.
- Checks the public preview for visible title/time and hidden unfinished notes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school recording tool needs microphone access for a supervised narration task. After recording, pupils will only read the finished text. The teacher’s process includes reviewing temporary permissions when the activity ends.
2A · Multiple choice
Why review the permission after recording?
- a: The later reading task has a different access need.
- b: Every recording automatically becomes public.
- c: Microphone permission guarantees privacy forever.
- d: A finished text cannot be read without a microphone.
The task change is a reason to review continuing access.
2B · Open ended
Explain why microphone access fit the first task and why it should be reviewed for the second.
Example of a full-credit answer: Recording narration uses microphone input. Reading the finished text does not require that input in this case, so the teacher should review and limit unnecessary ongoing access.
- Connects microphone access to the actual recording task.
- Explains the changed need and adult-guided review/limiting of unnecessary access.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team’s class-only guide gives the checked event route “Gate B to Hall F,” directs questions to the school office, and contains a private internal comment about a pupil. It is being prepared for a public website. The public purpose needs the route and school-office help, not the internal comment.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Information to retain; Information to remove; New audience
- a: Event route
- b: Private internal comment
- c: Public visitors
- d: Widen the setting without reviewing content
A broader audience requires reviewing the content as well as the menu.
3B · Open ended
Describe the content change needed before public sharing and a final audience check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Remove the private internal comment and retain the checked route and office help. Preview the public version to ensure only the intended information is visible.
- Removes unnecessary private internal information while preserving useful public content.
- Includes a public-view check of the final version.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil says, “Class-only means nobody can copy my post.” The supplied scenario says a class member can read and take a screenshot. The post includes information the pupil does not want circulated.
4A · True or false
True or false? The class-only setting guarantees that the screenshot described in the case cannot be made.
- true: True
- false: False
The setting limits direct access but does not prevent the stated copying action.
4B · Open ended
Identify the pupil’s mistaken assumption and propose a safer content choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil assumes audience controls block every copy. Omit sensitive details that are not needed for the class task and seek adult help before sharing uncertain information.
- Explains the distinction between limited direct access and possible onward copying.
- Proposes omitting unnecessary sensitive content or a comparably protective content decision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team has three project items: an owner-only planning note, a class-feedback draft and a final public invitation. It needs a review plan that matches each audience and checks for unnecessary device permissions.
5A · Hotspot
Which audience fits the draft that needs class feedback?
- a: Class members
- b: Public visitors by default
- c: Only unknown advertisers
- d: Nobody including the writer
The audience should follow the purpose of each stage.
5B · Open ended
Propose an audience plan for all three items and a check of what viewers and app permissions allow.
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep the planning note owner-only, the draft class-only and the reviewed invitation public. Preview the intended viewers and ask the teacher to review device permissions, removing or limiting those not needed for the task.
- Assigns the three audiences correctly according to the stated purposes.
- Includes viewer testing and adult-guided review of unnecessary device/app permissions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.5 · Personal-data protection
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A colour poll
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class wants counts of favourite colours. The draft form also asks for home addresses.
Question: Which field is unnecessary for this task?
Answer: Home address.
Why: The colour count can be obtained without identifying where pupils live.
Example 2 · A private sidebar
Fictional teaching example
A fictional project screenshot includes a private conversation in a sidebar.
Question: What should happen before sharing?
Answer: Create and check a version that excludes the private sidebar.
Why: The intended project content does not require exposing the conversation.
Example 3 · The approved route
Fictional teaching example
A fictional teacher requires a project identifier through the school’s approved form. A stranger asks for the same identifier plus account secrets.
Question: Which route should the pupil use?
Answer: The known approved school form, with adult help if uncertain.
Why: A different recipient and extra secret request are not justified by the school task.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Sort a minimal club poll
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class poll needs only a choice between Drama and Drawing. Its draft fields include activity choice, home location and an account secret. The teacher says no names or private details are needed.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Field needed for the poll; Unnecessary location field; Secret that must not be collected
- a: Activity choice
- b: Home location
- c: Account secret
- d: Every field in the draft is necessary
The stated purpose requires the activity choice only.
Investigation: privacy lab
F2 · Find the extra exposure
Fictional classroom case
A fictional photo shows a paper robot for a public exhibit. A visible card in the background contains a private contact placeholder. The contact is unrelated to explaining the robot and no real contact is supplied.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the part that must be removed from the actual public file or replaced before sharing.
- a: Private-contact card
- b: Paper robot model
- c: Generic project title
- d: Plain tabletop
The background detail is unrelated personal exposure.
Investigation: crop media lab
F3 · Use the approved recipient
Fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher asks for a project code through the known school form. A different message from an unknown sender asks for the code, home details and account secret. A trusted teacher can confirm the task.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which action matches the approved task?
- a: Use the known school form with teacher guidance.
- b: Send all requested secrets to the unknown helper.
- c: Post the home details publicly for checking.
- d: Ask a friend to supply a real password instead.
The legitimate task does not authorise sending extra sensitive data to an unknown recipient.
Investigation: phishing lab
F4 · Review the attachment
Fictional classroom case
A fictional student prepares two files: a public project explanation and an internal roster with private placeholders. Only the explanation is approved for the exhibition. The upload selection accidentally includes the roster.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Approved public file; File to exclude; Needed check
- a: Project explanation
- b: Internal roster
- c: Actual attachment selection
- d: Both files because they are nearby
The selected attachment must match the intended approved content.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · Protect a prompt
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team wants ideas for a class party game. Its draft prompt includes classmates’ home addresses and family information. The task can be described with group size, available paper and a 15-minute limit.
F5 · Short answer
State which information should be removed and explain what useful non-sensitive context can replace it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Remove home addresses and family details. Use the group size, paper materials and 15-minute limit, which help design the game without identifying classmates.
- Removes the home/family personal details from the prompt.
- Replaces them with relevant non-sensitive task context such as group size, materials and time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional library game only needs a team nickname to display scores. A draft form also requests a full birth date and home location. The teacher confirms those extra fields are unnecessary.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Field serving the score display; Unneeded date field; Unneeded location field
- a: Team nickname
- b: Full birth date
- c: Home location
- d: Collect everything for possible future use
The task has a defined minimal information need.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the nickname is sufficient and propose a change to the form that reduces exposure.
Example of a full-credit answer: The scoreboard only needs to distinguish teams, so a nickname is sufficient. Remove the birth-date and home-location fields rather than collecting them without a task need.
- Connects the nickname to the limited team-identification purpose.
- Removes the unnecessary birth-date and home-location fields.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional lesson teaches how to sort a table. It can use invented pet names and ages or a real class contact list. Both have rows and columns; no real contacts are needed to learn sorting.
2A · Hotspot
Which material best fits the stated lesson?
- a: Invented pets and ages
- b: A real class contact list
- c: A pupil’s account secrets
- d: Private family messages
Invented rows preserve the learning task without the personal information.
2B · Open ended
Give one learning reason and one privacy reason to choose the invented table.
Example of a full-credit answer: Its rows and columns allow the same sorting practice. It avoids exposing real classmates’ contact details that the lesson does not need.
- Explains that invented rows still support the sorting skill.
- Explains the avoided exposure of unnecessary real contact information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional screenshot was made for a private troubleshooting conversation. It shows a harmless project error plus a private account-name placeholder. The team now wants to use it in a public how-to guide. The error can be recreated in a fictional sample.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The public guide does not need the private account-name detail.
- b: A fictional recreation can preserve the instructional example.
- c: A private troubleshooting screenshot is automatically cleared for every public use.
- d: Keeping a personal identifier makes every explanation more accurate.
A broader use should not carry unnecessary private context into the public guide.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the original screenshot needs review and propose a suitable public version.
Example of a full-credit answer: It contains an account-name detail not needed by public readers. Recreate the error using fictional labels or produce and verify a version that removes all unnecessary personal information.
- Identifies the unnecessary personal detail and changed public audience.
- Proposes a fictional recreation or verified sanitised version preserving the instructional error.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil covers a private name with a movable shape in a document and assumes the name is permanently removed. The supplied case says recipients can move the shape and read the underlying text.
4A · True or false
True or false? The movable cover guarantees that recipients cannot read the underlying name.
- true: True
- false: False
The case explicitly distinguishes visual covering from removal.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken assumption and describe a safer file-preparation check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil mistakes a cover in the preview for deleting the underlying data. Remove or replace the private text in the actual shared file and have an adult check the exported version.
- Explains that covering visible text does not remove the underlying data in this case.
- Requires actual removal/replacement and verification of the shared/exported file.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom exhibit needs a count of which of three workshop times pupils prefer. The teacher confirms that anonymous selections are sufficient and will handle the approved collection. No contact details are needed.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Needed information; Identification need; Approved collector
- a: Preferred workshop time
- b: Anonymous choices are sufficient
- c: Teacher
- d: Collect home contacts for a possible future task
The form should be designed around the confirmed purpose.
5B · Open ended
Propose the form fields and explain how the collection route and review protect participants.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use only the three workshop-time choices without names or contacts. Have the teacher use the approved route and review the form and results so unnecessary identifying fields or details are not exposed.
- Limits fields to the anonymous workshop preference needed for the task.
- Uses the teacher-approved collection/review route with attention to excluding identifying information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.6 · Digital footprint
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A forwarded invitation
Fictional teaching example
A fictional invitation is posted in a class group, then saved by a family. The original is deleted.
Question: Could a trace remain?
Answer: Yes, the saved family copy may remain.
Why: The original account does not automatically control separately saved copies.
Example 2 · A dated correction
Fictional teaching example
A fictional post from Monday gives the wrong room. Tuesday’s correction gives the right room and explains the change.
Question: Which records matter when reading the claim?
Answer: Both the old post and the later correction.
Why: The correction provides context for the older error.
Example 3 · A useful contribution
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil posts a checked explanation and thanks a classmate for finding an error.
Question: What kind of trace does this create?
Answer: A record of a helpful contribution and responsible correction.
Why: A digital footprint can include positive actions as well as risks.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A copy outside the original
Fictional classroom case
A fictional post is shared by Ana to a class group. Ben saves a screenshot before Ana deletes the post. The case states Ben has not deleted the screenshot.
F1 · True or false
True or false? Deleting Ana’s original automatically deletes Ben’s already saved screenshot in this case.
- true: True
- false: False
The saved copy is separate from the deleted original.
Investigation: reach lab
F2 · Match actions and traces
Fictional classroom case
A fictional platform record lists three events: a pupil posts a review, a classmate forwards the review and the pupil later adds a correction. Each leaves a distinct recorded item in this case.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Posting the review; Forwarding it; Adding a correction
- a: Original review record
- b: Additional shared copy
- c: Correction record
- d: No record of any action
The trace depends on the action performed.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Dates change the context
Fictional classroom case
A fictional Monday post says a workshop is cancelled. A verified Tuesday organiser notice says it is rescheduled for Thursday. A Wednesday repost includes only the Monday text.
F3 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Earlier state; Later confirmed state; Repost problem
- a: Cancelled on Monday
- b: Rescheduled for Thursday
- c: Omits the Tuesday update
- d: Monday is automatically current forever
Interpreting the trace requires the latest relevant context.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · Find the unnecessary trace
Fictional classroom case
A fictional public project post includes the model name, a checked explanation, a source credit and a pupil’s private home-location placeholder. The project purpose does not need the home location.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the detail that should be omitted from this public project.
- a: Private home-location detail
- b: Generic model name
- c: Checked explanation
- d: Required source credit
Removing unrelated personal information reduces avoidable exposure.
Investigation: privacy lab
F5 · A repair with limits
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil removes an old inaccurate timetable from a class page. Two families already saved copies. The teacher can share a correction through the approved class channel.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why removal alone may be incomplete and propose a next step that reaches the affected readers.
Example of a full-credit answer: The saved family copies may remain after the original is removed. Ask the teacher to send the corrected timetable through the approved class channel and tell readers to replace the old copy.
- Explains that already saved copies can persist independently of the original.
- Provides an approved correction/notification step directed to affected readers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: reach lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class page contains a public project, an old event notice and an unneeded private-contact placeholder. The teacher confirms the event was held last month and asks the class to keep useful learning work, mark the event as past and remove the contact detail.
1A · Multiple choice
Which record should remain as useful learning content under the teacher’s plan?
- a: The checked project explanation
- b: The unnecessary private contact
- c: The old notice still labelled tomorrow
- d: An invented claim about future events
A careful review distinguishes useful records from misleading or unnecessary traces.
1B · Open ended
Propose two edits that reduce problems while preserving useful learning content.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mark the event notice as a past event with the confirmed context and remove the private-contact detail, while keeping the checked model explanation.
- Corrects the old event’s time context instead of leaving it as current.
- Removes the unnecessary private contact while retaining useful project content.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional screenshot shows a pupil writing “That answer is wrong.” The complete discussion shows the pupil then gives evidence, corrects their own misunderstanding and apologises. A classmate wants to judge the pupil using only the screenshot.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Fragment available first; Later context; Needed reading approach
- a: That answer is wrong
- b: Acknowledged misunderstanding and apologised
- c: Consider the complete exchange
- d: One fragment represents everything about the pupil
The fuller record changes how the isolated sentence should be interpreted.
2B · Open ended
Explain what the screenshot omits and why that matters for a fair interpretation.
Example of a full-credit answer: It omits the pupil’s correction and apology. Those later statements show changed understanding, so the fragment alone is incomplete evidence of the interaction.
- Identifies the omitted correction/apology.
- Explains why the fuller context changes or limits a judgement based on the fragment.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team uploads a finished guide to a public archive that retains project versions. The private draft includes unfinished notes and a classmate’s private placeholder. The team can upload a reviewed clean copy instead.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The reviewed clean copy serves the public guide’s purpose.
- b: Removing unnecessary private details before upload reduces avoidable traces.
- c: A decorative cover deletes the private contents of the file.
- d: A version-retaining archive makes all draft content safe to publish.
The wider, versioned context makes pre-upload review important.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the draft is unsuitable and describe a preparation step for the public record.
Example of a full-credit answer: It includes private and unfinished material not needed by readers. Prepare and inspect a clean final copy before uploading, with accurate content and required credits but no unnecessary personal details.
- Identifies the unnecessary private/unfinished material in the draft.
- Requires a reviewed clean public copy before upload rather than merely changing appearance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil says every digital trace can either be erased instantly everywhere or can never be changed at all. In the supplied platform, owners can edit their original posts, while independent screenshots may remain.
4A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Controllable record in this case; Record not automatically changed; Useful repair action
- a: Original post
- b: Independent screenshot
- c: Publish and communicate a correction
- d: Every trace behaves identically
Digital records can have different controls and retention; the extremes are misleading.
4B · Open ended
Identify the false either-or claim and explain a realistic repair in this case.
Example of a full-credit answer: Some records can be edited while other copies may remain; neither extreme fits all traces. Correct the original and communicate the correction through the approved route without claiming every screenshot has vanished.
- Explains that control differs across originals and independent copies.
- Proposes correction plus appropriate communication with realistic limits.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class is about to share a science explanation. It wants a useful public learning record, no unnecessary pupil details and a way to correct mistakes later. A teacher manages the public page.
5A · True or false
True or false? A useful footprint plan can combine careful publication with a realistic correction route.
- true: True
- false: False
A good plan shapes the intended record and prepares for repair.
5B · Open ended
Propose a pre-sharing review and a post-sharing correction plan that acknowledges possible copies.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check facts and credits and remove unnecessary personal information before sharing. If an error appears, ask the teacher to update the public page and notify affected readers, recognising that saved copies may need replacing separately.
- Includes factual/source review and removal of unnecessary personal details before sharing.
- Includes teacher-managed public correction/notification with awareness of independently saved copies.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.7 · Online reputation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Honest progress
Fictional teaching example
A fictional group member reports that her assigned chart needs one more check instead of falsely saying it is done.
Question: How can this support trust?
Answer: The team receives accurate information and can plan the remaining work.
Why: Trustworthy conduct is more than appearing finished.
Example 2 · Likes and reliability
Fictional teaching example
A fictional post has many likes but gives an unsupported claim about a pupil.
Question: Do likes establish that the claim is fair or true?
Answer: No. The evidence and context still need checking.
Why: Popularity measures attention, not the accuracy of a personal accusation.
Example 3 · A specific repair
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil wrongly credits himself for a partner’s drawing. He updates the project to name the partner and explains the correction.
Question: Why is this better than “sorry if anyone is upset”?
Answer: It identifies and fixes the actual authorship error.
Why: A repair should address what happened, not only the reaction.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match actions and trust
Fictional classroom case
A fictional project record shows three actions: reporting an unfinished task honestly, crediting the illustrator correctly and correcting a wrong number with its source. Each supports a different aspect of trust.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Honest task update; Correct illustrator credit; Source-based number correction
- a: Reliable progress information
- b: Recognition of another’s work
- c: Responsibility for accuracy
- d: A guarantee that nobody will ever disagree
These are concrete trustworthy behaviours, not promises about everyone’s opinion.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Popularity is not proof
Fictional classroom case
A fictional rumour about a club member receives 60 likes. No witness or record supports the rumour. The class has an approved teacher route for concerns.
F2 · True or false
True or false? The 60 likes prove the rumour about the club member is true.
- true: True
- false: False
Likes do not establish the truth of a personal claim.
Investigation: graph lab
F3 · Choose a trustworthy reply
Fictional classroom case
A fictional teammate points out that a report uses the wrong date. The checked plan confirms the teammate is right. Reply A acknowledges the error and corrects it. B mocks the teammate. C invents an excuse. D deletes the source record.
F3 · Hotspot
Choose the reply that best supports trustworthy behaviour.
- a: A: acknowledge and correct the date
- b: B: mock the person who noticed
- c: C: invent a reason to reject the plan
- d: D: erase the source record
Acknowledging and fixing a supported error is a concrete responsible response.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · A profile claim and its evidence
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil’s profile says “I completed the whole team model alone.” The task log shows three teammates designed, built and tested it together. The profile is attractive and has positive comments.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The task log shows contributions by three teammates.
- b: The claim of doing everything alone conflicts with the log.
- c: Positive comments make the solo-work claim accurate.
- d: An attractive profile replaces the need for evidence.
The contribution record matters more than how polished the profile looks.
Investigation: collaboration lab
F5 · Do not amplify humiliation
Fictional classroom case
A fictional embarrassing clip of a classmate is circulating. A pupil wants to repost it to announce that bullying is wrong. The school provides a private reporting route to a teacher.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why reposting may worsen the situation and describe a safer supportive response.
Example of a full-credit answer: Reposting can expose the classmate to more viewers even with a kind caption. Do not spread the clip; support the classmate and use the teacher’s private reporting route with only necessary evidence.
- Explains that a repost increases exposure/humiliation despite the intended warning.
- Uses support and the approved private adult-reporting route without spreading the clip.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: reach lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil’s public project labels a drawing as his own. The saved record shows it was drawn by Dena and permitted with credit. The pupil can edit the project and post a correction note.
1A · Multiple choice
Which action directly repairs the wrong authorship claim?
- a: Credit Dena and explain the correction.
- b: Keep the claim and add more decorations.
- c: Blame Dena for noticing the mistake.
- d: Ask friends to like the incorrect claim.
A repair should correct the record readers can see.
1B · Short answer
State the specific correction and explain how to acknowledge the mistake without blaming Dena.
Example of a full-credit answer: Change the credit to Dena and state that the earlier authorship label was incorrect. Say I made the credit error and have corrected it, without blaming the illustrator.
- Corrects the public illustrator credit to Dena.
- Acknowledges responsibility for the wrong credit without shifting blame to Dena.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional screenshot shows “This method is useless.” The full exchange shows a pupil quoting an unhelpful comment, then writing “Let us replace that with specific feedback.” A reader has only seen the screenshot.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Role of the harsh phrase; Pupil’s own proposal; Missing evidence in screenshot
- a: Quoted example of unhelpful feedback
- b: Use specific suggestions
- c: Surrounding discussion
- d: Proof the pupil insulted the method personally
The full context identifies quotation and the pupil’s actual purpose.
2B · Open ended
Explain what the fragment hides and why a judgement based on it alone could be unfair.
Example of a full-credit answer: It hides that the pupil quoted the phrase to criticise unhelpful feedback and suggest a better response. Treating the quote as the pupil’s own attack misrepresents the exchange.
- Identifies the omitted quotation context and corrective proposal.
- Explains how the isolated fragment could falsely attribute the attack to the pupil.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class-only task board lists contributions by four pupils. The team now writes a public project profile. It wants to explain the work without publishing private schedules or claiming that one person did everything.
3A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Useful public claim; Unnecessary private information; Claim to avoid
- a: Team shared the work
- b: Individual private schedules
- c: One pupil did everything
- d: Publish all private schedules as proof
Honest contribution information can be shared without irrelevant personal exposure.
3B · Open ended
Write a fair public contribution statement and name information that should stay out of it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Our team shared planning, building and testing of the model. Keep individual private schedules out of the public profile because they are not needed to describe the contribution.
- Accurately describes shared contribution rather than a false sole-author claim.
- Excludes private schedules or other unnecessary personal detail.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil apologises for spreading an incorrect claim, corrects the post and tells affected readers. A friend says this guarantees everyone must trust the pupil immediately. No evidence of readers’ reactions is supplied.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Established repair; Unsupported prediction; Useful continuing behaviour
- a: Apology, correction and notification
- b: Guaranteed immediate trust from everyone
- c: Consistent honest conduct
- d: Page design and decoration
Responsible repair is valuable but does not guarantee how everyone responds.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and explain what the pupil can realistically control next.
Example of a full-credit answer: The friend claims a guaranteed reaction without evidence. The pupil can keep correcting errors, respect others and act honestly over time, while allowing people to respond in their own way.
- Rejects the guaranteed immediate-trust claim as unsupported.
- Identifies controllable continuing responsible behaviours rather than controlling others’ reactions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team wants a profile showing its completed model. The record lists shared work, a corrected measurement and a permitted credited illustration. The profile must be accurate and should offer a school-approved correction route.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The profile should describe the team’s shared work accurately.
- b: The profile should use the corrected measurement.
- c: Invented awards are acceptable if they attract more likes.
- d: A permitted illustration may be claimed as the team’s own drawing.
A trustworthy profile is grounded in records and open to responsible correction.
5B · Open ended
Propose a profile plan covering contributions and accuracy, and explain how readers can raise an error without exposing private contacts.
Example of a full-credit answer: Describe the shared work, use the corrected measurement and credit the illustration. Direct correction questions to the school-approved office or teacher route rather than pupils’ private contacts.
- Includes accurate shared contributions, corrected information and appropriate creator credit.
- Provides an approved adult/school correction route without private pupil contact exposure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.8 · Responsible sharing
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A stale notice
Fictional teaching example
A fictional post says a club meets on Tuesday, but the current organiser notice says Wednesday.
Question: What should be shared?
Answer: The checked current Wednesday information with its source and date.
Why: Forwarding the old notice would spread an outdated instruction.
Example 2 · A private message
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil wants to forward a friend’s private worry to a group as an interesting story.
Question: What is a responsible choice?
Answer: Do not forward it for entertainment; respect privacy and seek adult support if there is a safety concern.
Why: Private disclosure is not permission for wider entertainment.
Example 3 · A correction to the same audience
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil sent a wrong venue to a class group and later finds the correct venue.
Question: What should the pupil do?
Answer: Correct the shared version and tell the class group the accurate venue through the approved route.
Why: The repair should reach people exposed to the original error.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Which notice is current?
Fictional classroom case
A fictional Monday club post says Room 3. A Tuesday organiser correction says Room 5 and replaces the earlier post. The class needs the current room for Wednesday.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the information to share for Wednesday’s meeting.
- a: Room 5 from the Tuesday correction
- b: Room 3 from the replaced Monday post
- c: Either room chosen by popularity
- d: A new room invented to avoid confusion
The explicit current correction should guide the new share.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · Match sharing questions
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class checklist asks three questions: Is the claim checked? Who needs to receive it? Does another person agree to the proposed image use under the school arrangement? These address evidence, audience and consent respectively.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Is the claim checked?; Who needs to receive it?; Is the image use agreed?
- a: Evidence
- b: Audience
- c: Consent arrangement
- d: Number of decorative stickers
Different checks address different responsibilities.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Choose a safe warning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class has received a suspicious prize link. The teacher asks for a warning that does not spread the link. Version A says “Do not interact with unexpected prize messages; ask the teacher.” B includes the link and asks classmates to try it.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which warning follows the teacher’s instruction?
- a: A: avoid interaction and ask the teacher
- b: B: share the link for everyone to test
- c: C: request secrets to verify the prize
- d: D: promise every unknown message is harmless
A warning should not become another route to the risky request.
Investigation: message lab
F4 · Keep the condition when forwarding
Fictional classroom case
A fictional organiser says “The outdoor game runs if the field is dry. Check the class board before leaving.” A forwarded version deletes “if the field is dry” and tells everyone the game definitely runs. The condition is still in force.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Condition in the organiser’s rule; Unsupported unconditional statement in the forward; Organiser’s suggested check
- a: Field is dry
- b: Game definitely runs
- c: Class board before leaving
- d: A decorative frame
Removing the condition changes the practical meaning.
Investigation: clip lab
F5 · A changed audience
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil has permission under the school’s arrangement to share a teammate’s recording within the class only. A public page asks for a copy. No public permission has been given.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the class permission does not settle the public request and propose a suitable response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The agreement covers the class, not the public page. Ask through the proper school process for permission for the new use, or decline and share a permitted non-identifying alternative.
- Identifies that the new public audience goes beyond the supplied class-only agreement.
- Requires appropriate new permission or declines/uses a permitted alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: privacy lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school notice says an exhibition opens in Hall G at 9 am. A copied version adds a pupil’s private contact placeholder. The approved office route is sufficient for questions; the public audience needs only the event details and that route.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Essential event information; Approved help route; Unnecessary private addition
- a: Hall G at 9 am
- b: School office
- c: Pupil contact
- d: Forward every available detail
A useful share can retain the necessary information while excluding unrelated personal data.
1B · Short answer
Describe what to share and explain why the added pupil contact should be omitted.
Example of a full-credit answer: Share Hall G at 9 am with the checked source and school-office route. Omit the pupil contact because the public task does not need it and the office already provides help.
- Retains the confirmed event facts and approved help route/source.
- Explains omission of unnecessary private contact in relation to the task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional health-fair notice, treated only as an event announcement, is from the school organiser and gives a date. A pupil wants to forward a screenshot without the source or date. The event details may change.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Keeping the date helps readers assess whether the notice is current.
- b: Keeping the source helps readers trace the organiser’s information.
- c: Cropping out the source proves that the notice is official.
- d: An event notice can never change after its first version.
The context helps recipients check currency and origin.
2B · Open ended
Give a reason to retain the date and a reason to retain the source when sharing.
Example of a full-credit answer: The date helps readers decide whether the details may be outdated. The source lets them trace the organiser’s current notice for confirmation.
- Explains the date’s relevance to currency.
- Explains the source’s role in tracing/verifying the organiser’s notice.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil receives an unverified claim about another pupil. The class discussion is meant to teach checking information, and the teacher permits using a made-up example instead of naming real people.
3A · True or false
True or false? The class must forward the real personal rumour publicly to practise verification.
- true: True
- false: False
The checking skill can be learned without amplifying a real-person rumour.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the invented example suits the new task and how to handle the real rumour if it raises concern.
Example of a full-credit answer: It lets classmates practise verification without targeting a real pupil. Do not circulate the rumour; bring the concern privately to the teacher through the approved route.
- Connects the fictional example to the verification learning goal without real-person exposure.
- Avoids circulation and uses an appropriate private teacher-reporting route for the real concern.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil reposts an embarrassing image with the caption “This is wrong.” The sharing model shows the repost reaching a new group that had not seen the image. The school provides a private reporting route.
4A · Hotspot
What caused the additional exposure in this case?
- a: Reposting the image to a new group
- b: Keeping the image out of the warning
- c: Privately telling the teacher
- d: Removing the image from a draft
A good intention does not stop the image itself reaching more people.
4B · Open ended
Identify why the response may increase harm and propose a safer warning or report.
Example of a full-credit answer: The repost shows the embarrassing image to new viewers despite its critical caption. Report privately to the teacher and, if a warning is needed, describe safe behaviour without reproducing the image.
- Explains that the image reaches a new audience despite the condemning caption.
- Uses private reporting and/or an image-free warning that avoids further exposure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional group wants to share school event notices accurately and respectfully. It has a confirmed organiser source, a teacher-managed class channel and a process for corrections. The routine must also reject unnecessary personal details.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Accuracy check; Privacy check; Repair route
- a: Source, date and conditions
- b: Exclude unnecessary personal details
- c: Correct through the same approved audience channel
- d: Share first and inspect later
The routine should cover before-sharing checks and a way to repair what was spread.
5B · Open ended
Propose one pre-sharing checklist covering accuracy and people, and one correction step for an error found later.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the source, date and conditions, confirm needed permissions and remove unnecessary personal details. If a shared item is wrong, update it and send the correction to the same affected audience through the teacher-managed channel.
- Includes source/current-context checks and appropriate permission/privacy consideration before sharing.
- Corrects the shared version and notifies the affected audience through the approved route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.9 · Consent
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A different audience
Fictional teaching example
A fictional school agreement permits a pupil’s poem recording within the class. A public channel asks to repost it.
Question: Does the class agreement settle this request?
Answer: No. The public use needs the appropriate new permission process.
Why: Audience is part of what was agreed.
Example 2 · A real alternative
Fictional teaching example
A fictional teacher offers either a voice recording or a written explanation for the same task, without a penalty.
Question: How does that support choice?
Answer: A learner can decline recording while still completing the learning task.
Why: Agreement is more meaningful when refusal does not exclude participation.
Example 3 · Respecting a refusal
Fictional teaching example
A fictional classmate says not to share her portrait. An object-only project photo can serve the display.
Question: What should the team choose?
Answer: Respect the refusal and use the permitted object-only alternative.
Why: The project purpose can be met without pressuring the classmate.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the agreed scope
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school record permits a pupil’s voice clip for class feedback only, with appropriate adult arrangements completed. It does not permit public posting or use in an advertisement.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Agreed purpose; Agreed audience; Unagreed extension
- a: Class feedback
- b: Class only
- c: Public advertisement
- d: The lesson’s page number
The supplied agreement has a specific purpose and audience.
Investigation: permission lab
F2 · Choose a request with real choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional group wants to record learners’ explanations. Request A states the class audience and allows a written alternative with the same participation credit. B says everyone must agree or the team loses points. C hides the audience. D treats silence as permission.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which request best supports a meaningful choice under the case rules?
- a: A: clear class use and equal written alternative
- b: B: agree or the team loses points
- c: C: agree without knowing the audience
- d: D: silence automatically counted as yes
A explains the use and offers a non-punitive alternative.
Investigation: audience lab
F3 · Find the change requiring review
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil agrees to an unedited class photo display. The team now proposes a public funny montage using the pupil’s face. The school requires approval for both the new audience and the changed portrayal.
F3 · Hotspot
Which action is required by the stated school arrangement before the montage?
- a: Review and obtain appropriate permission for the new use.
- b: Assume the old yes covers every future edit.
- c: Publish first to see whether the pupil objects.
- d: Count a lack of reply as agreement.
Both audience and portrayal differ from the original agreement.
Investigation: provenance lab
F4 · Match respectful responses
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class process provides three responses: if a pupil declines a portrait, use an object photo; if the audience changes, review permission; if a pupil raises a concern, tell the responsible teacher privately.
F4 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Portrait declined; Audience changed; Concern raised
- a: Use the object photo
- b: Review permission
- c: Tell the responsible teacher privately
- d: Pressure the pupil until they agree
The responses respect choice and the supplied school process.
Investigation: timeline lab
F5 · The quiet pupil
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team asks whether it may publish a classmate’s recording. The classmate does not reply. The school requires a clear recorded agreement through its adult-led process. A written summary without personal recording is available.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why silence is insufficient in this case and propose a suitable way to continue the project.
Example of a full-credit answer: The school requires a clear agreement and no reply provides none. Ask through the appropriate adult-led process without pressure, or use the permitted written summary instead.
- Connects the lack of reply to the missing required clear agreement.
- Uses the proper non-pressuring permission process or a permitted alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school record permits a portrait on a class-only exhibition page. A teammate wants to add it to a publicly accessible flyer. The school has a permitted image of the project object that can be used publicly.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The portrait agreement covers class-only viewing.
- b: The project-object image can serve as a publicly permitted alternative.
- c: The class-only agreement automatically covers a public flyer.
- d: A teammate can override the subject’s agreed audience without review.
The public flyer falls outside the stated portrait agreement.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the portrait should not be used under the existing agreement and describe a way to meet the flyer’s purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: The portrait was agreed only for class viewing. Use the permitted object image for the public flyer or obtain appropriate permission for the new portrait use before publication.
- Identifies the audience mismatch between class-only portrait permission and public flyer.
- Uses the cleared object image or completes the appropriate new permission process.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner does not want a recorded interview used in a class project. The assignment’s goal is explaining a design, and a written explanation receives the same credit. Other group members say refusing the recording means refusing to learn.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Learning goal; Equivalent permitted route; Unsupported group claim
- a: Explain the design
- b: Written explanation
- c: No recording means no learning
- d: A public performance
The task has an explicit alternative that preserves its learning goal.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the written alternative meets the task and why pressuring the learner is inappropriate.
Example of a full-credit answer: The written explanation can show the same design reasoning and receives equal credit. Pressure removes the meaningful choice the teacher’s arrangement provides.
- Connects written explanation to the same design-learning goal and permitted credit.
- Explains that pressure undermines the learner’s stated choice/refusal.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil previously agreed to a portrait in a teacher-managed class display. The school’s arrangement lets pupils request that their portrait stop being used in the ongoing display. The pupil now makes that request; the teacher can remove the displayed copy but cannot promise control of prior screenshots.
3A · Hotspot
What can the teacher directly do in the supplied case?
- a: Remove the portrait from the managed display.
- b: Guarantee deletion of every private screenshot.
- c: Override the request because it was once approved.
- d: Publish the request publicly to pressure the pupil.
Respecting the request and explaining technical limits can occur together.
3B · Short answer
Describe a respectful action on the ongoing display and explain what the teacher should not promise about copies.
Example of a full-credit answer: Remove the portrait from the teacher-controlled display under the school arrangement and use a permitted alternative. Do not promise that independent screenshots have all disappeared.
- Stops the ongoing controlled use as requested under the stated arrangement.
- Acknowledges that independent existing copies may remain without claiming total erasure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil shares a friend’s voice clip publicly without asking, saying “Friends always agree.” The friend had agreed only to a private practice exchange. The school requires permission for public sharing.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Actual agreement; Unagreed action; Faulty assumption
- a: Private practice exchange
- b: Public sharing
- c: Friendship means unlimited agreement
- d: Two-minute recording length
Friendship is not evidence of agreement to every new use.
4B · Open ended
Identify the assumption and propose a concrete repair through the school process.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil assumes friendship grants public permission, although the agreement was private. Tell the responsible teacher, remove the controlled public copy and seek a permitted alternative or proper new agreement without pressure.
- Identifies the false inference from friendship/private agreement to public permission.
- Includes adult-supported removal/limiting of the unagreed public use and a respectful next step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional project wants to record a two-minute explanation for class feedback. The school handles parent/guardian arrangements and requires pupils’ views to be respected. A written explanation is an equal alternative, and the teacher receives questions or removal concerns.
5A · True or false
True or false? The supplied plan offers an equal way to complete the task without recording.
- true: True
- false: False
The request should explain the specific use and preserve a real choice.
5B · Open ended
Write a brief request explaining the use and audience, then state the alternative and help route.
Example of a full-credit answer: May we record your two-minute explanation for class-only feedback under the school’s arrangements? You can choose an equal-credit written explanation instead, and ask the teacher about questions or concerns.
- Clearly states the specific two-minute recording purpose and class-only audience.
- Provides a non-penalised written alternative and teacher support/concern route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.10 · Copyright
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Free to read
Fictional teaching example
A fictional site lets everyone read a comic but supplies no copying permission.
Question: Does free access alone establish a right to republish the whole comic?
Answer: No. The planned reuse needs an appropriate permission or applicable basis.
Why: Viewing access and reuse rights are different questions.
Example 2 · A permitted remix
Fictional teaching example
A fictional drawing is CC BY 4.0 and the class can meet its terms.
Question: Can the class adapt and share it under that licence?
Answer: Yes, while meeting the licence’s attribution and other conditions.
Why: Copyright can be managed through permissions that allow creative reuse.
Example 3 · The broad idea
Fictional teaching example
A fictional author writes a story about a robot helping a neighbour. Another pupil invents a different story on that theme.
Question: Does the shared broad theme alone prove copying of the author’s expression?
Answer: No. Compare the actual expression rather than treating the theme as exclusive.
Why: General ideas and particular expression are distinct.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Two claims about access
Fictional classroom case
A fictional gallery allows anyone to view a drawing but says reuse requires permission. A pupil can create a separate own drawing or ask the artist about the intended reuse.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The gallery explicitly permits viewing.
- b: The pupil can ask about reuse or make an own drawing.
- c: Free viewing automatically clears republication under these terms.
- d: Removing the artist’s name supplies permission.
The terms distinguish access from reuse.
Investigation: permission lab
F2 · Match different issues
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class checklist distinguishes copyright permission, attribution and personal-image consent. It asks whether reuse is allowed, who created the work and whether the school’s sharing arrangement for the person depicted is satisfied.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Is reuse allowed?; Who created the work?; Is personal-image sharing agreed?
- a: Copyright permission
- b: Attribution
- c: School consent arrangement
- d: One credit line settles everything
The issues may overlap but do not replace each other.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Find the unsupported legal shortcut
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil wants to repost an uncleared comic and says “It is for school, so no rules can apply.” The teacher provides a different comic explicitly permitted for the activity.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the unsupported blanket claim.
- a: School purpose means no rules can apply.
- b: The alternative has explicit activity permission.
- c: The intended use should be checked against its terms.
- d: A teacher can help resolve unclear permission.
Neither blanket permission nor blanket prohibition follows from the word school.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Read three permission states
Fictional classroom case
A fictional source pack includes A, a drawing explicitly in the public domain in the case; B, a CC BY 4.0 diagram; and C, an illustration with permission only for class display. Other personal-image rights are not involved in these assets.
F4 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Verified public-domain work; Work with CC BY conditions; Class-display-limited permission
- a: A
- b: B
- c: C
- d: All three have identical conditions
Their supplied status and terms differ.
Investigation: permission lab
F5 · A licence does not settle every right
Fictional classroom case
A fictional photo is offered under a reuse licence, but it clearly identifies a pupil. The school has not approved the planned public image sharing, and the project can use an object-only drawing instead.
F5 · Short answer
Explain the remaining issue and propose a way to continue without assuming the licence resolves it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The school’s separate permission/consent arrangement for publishing the pupil’s image is unresolved. Obtain the appropriate approval or use the permitted object-only drawing.
- Distinguishes copyright reuse permission from the unresolved personal-image/school arrangement.
- Uses appropriate approval or a non-identifying permitted alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: privacy lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional creator permits a poem to be copied unchanged with the creator and title shown in a class booklet. A pupil wants to use the unchanged poem in that booklet and can include the required credit.
1A · Multiple choice
Which action matches the supplied permission?
- a: Copy unchanged with creator/title in the class booklet.
- b: Sell a changed version publicly without checking.
- c: Erase the creator and claim original authorship.
- d: Assume every future adaptation is covered.
The exact permitted use can proceed while respecting its conditions.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the planned class use is covered and name a change that would require rechecking the scope.
Example of a full-credit answer: It is an unchanged class-booklet copy with the required creator and title. A public commercial adaptation or another use outside those terms would need a new check.
- Matches the proposed unchanged credited class-booklet use to the supplied permission.
- Identifies a genuine change of action/audience/purpose beyond the scope that needs rechecking.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional illustrator chooses CC BY 4.0 so others can adapt a diagram while crediting its origin and meeting the licence’s conditions. A pupil says respecting the creator means refusing every permitted use.
2A · True or false
True or false? Respecting this creator can include adapting the work while meeting the supplied CC BY terms.
- true: True
- false: False
Respect can include using the freedoms the creator deliberately grants.
2B · Open ended
Explain why permitted adaptation can respect the creator and identify a condition the pupil must still meet.
Example of a full-credit answer: The creator chose a licence allowing adaptation. Respect that choice by giving appropriate credit and licence information and indicating changes, while meeting the other terms.
- Explains that the creator deliberately granted adaptation permission.
- Names relevant attribution/licence/change conditions rather than assuming unrestricted use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class discusses the broad idea of a flying bicycle. One pupil writes a new story with her own characters and events. Another copies an existing story’s paragraphs and drawings. The source has no supplied copying permission.
3A · Hotspot
Which action copies the source’s particular expression?
- a: Reproducing its paragraphs and drawings
- b: Inventing different characters and events
- c: Discussing the general flying-bicycle idea
- d: Choosing a new story title about travel
The reasoning must distinguish a general idea from the source’s particular expression.
3B · Short answer
Explain the difference between the two pupils’ actions and name the check needed for the copied material.
Example of a full-credit answer: One creates new expression around a broad idea; the other reproduces an existing story’s expression. The copied paragraphs and drawings need appropriate permission or another applicable basis checked with the teacher.
- Distinguishes broad idea/new expression from copying specific paragraphs/drawings.
- Requires an appropriate reuse check for the copied material rather than assuming it is cleared.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional drawing page has no visible copyright symbol and gives no reuse terms. A pupil concludes it is automatically public domain. The teacher has not verified its status.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: What is actually known; What remains unknown; Appropriate next action
- a: No visible symbol
- b: Copyright/reuse status
- c: Verify status or choose a cleared alternative
- d: Absence proves public domain
The absent symbol does not establish the broad conclusion.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken inference and propose a suitable next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats no visible symbol as proof of public-domain status. Ask the teacher to verify the status/terms or use a clearly permitted alternative instead.
- Explains that absence of a visible symbol does not establish public-domain status.
- Proposes status/permission verification or a suitably cleared alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a rule that respects creators without banning every reuse. Students may make own material, use clearly permitted assets with conditions met or ask for help about uncertain uses. The rule must also distinguish credit from permission.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Reusing someone else’s asset; Making a new asset yourself; Attribution versus permission
- a: Use suitable permission and meet conditions
- b: Create own material
- c: Credit is not permission
- d: Every online work is free to reuse
A balanced rule recognises actual permissions and uncertainty.
5B · Open ended
Propose a rule allowing responsible reuse, then explain what pupils should do when terms are unclear.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use your own work or material whose permission fits the planned use, meeting its credits and other conditions. If terms are unclear, ask the teacher or choose another asset; do not assume that credit or online access grants permission.
- Allows own work or clearly suitable permitted use with required conditions.
- Provides adult checking/alternative for unclear cases and distinguishes credit/access from permission.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.11 · Intellectual property
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Three records
Fictional teaching example
A fictional product has a story booklet, a granted patent for a mechanism and a brand sign.
Question: Match the broad IP categories.
Answer: Booklet expression: copyright. Granted invention right: patent. Distinguishing brand sign: trademark.
Why: The categories serve different functions; the supplied records establish the fictional case.
Example 2 · Owning a copy
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil buys a printed comic. The sale does not include permission to republish its pages.
Question: Does buying the copy alone establish republication rights?
Answer: No. Ownership of the physical copy is different from the creator’s reuse rights.
Why: The planned reproduction needs an appropriate basis.
Example 3 · A separate brand question
Fictional teaching example
A fictional company permits a class to use a diagram but does not permit claims of sponsorship.
Question: May the class add “officially sponsored” without another agreement?
Answer: No. The diagram permission does not establish sponsorship.
Why: Permission has a particular subject and scope.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose the correct category
Fictional classroom case
A fictional record states that the name Sunwheel distinguishes one maker’s bicycles from other makers’ goods. It is used as the maker’s brand sign. The question asks about that identifying function, not the bicycle mechanism.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which broad IP category concerns the brand sign’s distinguishing function?
- a: Trademark
- b: Patent for the steering mechanism
- c: Copyright in the booklet wording
- d: Ownership of a physical bicycle
The identifying sign has a different function from text or a patented mechanism.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Match the case records
Fictional classroom case
A fictional science kit record identifies a copyrighted comic guide, a granted patent on its latch mechanism and a trademark identifying the maker’s goods. These are supplied case facts, not claims that every similar item has these rights.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Comic guide expression; Granted latch-invention right; Maker’s distinguishing sign
- a: Copyright record
- b: Patent record
- c: Trademark record
- d: One identical permission for every element
The records concern different contributions and rights.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · What buying the object establishes
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil buys a model kit. The receipt transfers the physical kit; no licence to republish its illustrated manual is included. The pupil can ask the teacher about a permitted use of the manual.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The receipt establishes purchase of the physical kit.
- b: It does not supply permission to republish the whole illustrated manual.
- c: Buying one kit automatically transfers the manual’s authorship.
- d: The receipt clears every brand and invention use forever.
The supplied receipt covers the object, not all rights in its manual.
Investigation: evidence lab
F4 · Read the scope of an image permission
Fictional classroom case
A fictional company allows a class to use a product diagram in a school explanation with credit. The permission explicitly does not allow claiming company sponsorship. The class has made its own project name.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Permitted element and use; Company relationship expressly excluded; Available project identifier
- a: Diagram in school explanation with credit
- b: Official company sponsorship
- c: Own class project name
- d: One diagram permission approves every brand claim
The actual terms separate the illustration from sponsorship.
Investigation: permission lab
F5 · A broad idea and a granted right
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil imagines a backpack that unfolds into a seat and says this automatically gives them a patent everywhere. No application or grant record is supplied. The class can document and develop the idea with adult guidance.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the patent claim is unsupported and give an honest way to describe the project now.
Example of a full-credit answer: Having an idea does not by itself establish a granted patent, and no grant is supplied. Describe it as a proposed backpack-seat design and document its development while asking an adult about relevant next steps.
- Explains that an idea alone/no grant record does not establish a patent everywhere.
- Uses an honest proposed-design description and appropriate adult-guided development/checking.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional exhibit combines a poem, a supplier’s brand sign and a model mechanism with an explicitly recorded granted patent. The teacher asks pupils to identify the kind of contribution before checking use.
1A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Poem expression; Supplier’s distinguishing sign; Granted mechanism right
- a: Copyright
- b: Trademark
- c: Patent
- d: All permissions follow from the poem credit
Different elements require different questions and records.
1B · Short answer
Explain why identifying the element matters and give one example of a permission that would not automatically cover another element.
Example of a full-credit answer: The category helps locate the relevant scope and record. Permission to reproduce the poem would not automatically establish permission to use the supplier sign as an endorsement or rights involving the patented mechanism.
- Explains that different contributions require different relevant rights/permission checks.
- Gives a valid example of one element’s permission not automatically covering another.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class can choose its own tree-and-book badge or copy a company’s identifying sign while falsely labelling the project an official partnership. No partnership exists. Both choices could fit on the page.
2A · Hotspot
Which label accurately describes the project?
- a: Independent class project
- b: Official company partner
- c: Company-approved product
- d: Guaranteed corporate endorsement
The class can identify its work without inventing a brand connection.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the own badge is preferable in this case and what false impression the copied-sign proposal could create.
Example of a full-credit answer: The own badge honestly identifies the class’s work. The copied sign combined with an official-partner label could mislead readers into thinking the company endorses or sponsors the project.
- Connects the own badge to an honest independent class identity.
- Identifies the unsupported sponsorship/endorsement impression from the proposed copied sign and label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil has a legitimately purchased copy of a song for listening. The purchase record gives no permission to incorporate it into a public video. The class has its own original recorded tune explicitly approved for this public video.
3A · Multiple choice
Which soundtrack is explicitly approved for this public video?
- a: The original class tune
- b: The purchased song without another check
- c: Any popular song found online
- d: Any recording with its creator name erased
Owning a listening copy does not establish all rights for a different distribution.
3B · Open ended
Explain the difference between the two uses and propose a suitable soundtrack choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: Listening to the purchased copy differs from incorporating and distributing it in a public video. Use the approved class tune or obtain appropriate permission for the song’s new use.
- Distinguishes the listening copy from incorporation/distribution in a public video.
- Uses the approved original tune or obtains appropriate new-use permission.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team receives permission to reuse a diagram. It says this proves it owns the diagram, the brand name printed beside it and the underlying invention. The permission record grants only a specific diagram reuse with credit.
4A · True or false
True or false? The diagram-reuse permission transfers every brand and invention right to the team.
- true: True
- false: False
A limited permission is not a transfer of every related right.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and write an accurate statement of what the team may rely on.
Example of a full-credit answer: The team confuses limited reuse permission with ownership of unrelated rights. It may reuse the diagram for the specified purpose with credit; other proposed uses need their own relevant checks.
- Identifies the unjustified expansion from limited reuse to broad ownership.
- States the specific permitted diagram use with credit and the need to check other uses separately.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class will make a robot story, an original project badge and an explanation using a permitted diagram. It wants to avoid confusing its own contributions with someone else’s rights or implying sponsorship.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Own written contribution; Own identifying contribution; Outside asset to document
- a: Original story
- b: Distinctive class badge
- c: Permitted diagram
- d: A blanket claim of owning all robot ideas
The plan can support creativity while respecting the source asset’s actual scope.
5B · Open ended
Propose a way to label the class’s own work and a way to document the outside diagram without implying sponsorship.
Example of a full-credit answer: Label the story and badge as class-created, without claiming ownership of every robot idea. Record the diagram’s creator, source and permitted use, give its required credit and avoid an unsupported sponsor claim.
- Accurately identifies the class’s original story/badge without claiming all general ideas.
- Documents and credits the permitted diagram while avoiding unsupported sponsorship or broader rights claims.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.12 · Fairness
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The same small print
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class gives every learner an identical small-print sheet. One learner needs a readable larger version.
Question: Can a larger version support fairness?
Answer: Yes. It can provide access to the same learning task.
Why: Fair access does not always require identical presentation.
Example 2 · Compare rates
| Group | Correct | Tested |
|---|---|---|
| A | 8 | 10 |
| B | 8 | 20 |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional tool is correct on 8 of 10 examples in Group A and 8 of 20 in Group B.
Question: Are the success rates equal?
Answer: No. They are 80% and 40%.
Why: The same number correct has different meaning with different totals.
Example 3 · An irrelevant rule
Fictional teaching example
A fictional art club awards places according to who owns the newest phone, although all art is made with school paper.
Question: What fairness question should be asked?
Answer: Why should phone ownership determine access to a paper-art activity?
Why: The rule rewards a resource unrelated to the stated task.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match barriers to remedies
Fictional classroom case
A fictional project has three barriers: audio-only instructions for a learner who needs text, a deadline during one teammate’s agreed unavailable time and a tool error with no way to request review. Proposed remedies are a transcript, a compatible schedule and a human review route.
F1 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Audio-only barrier; Schedule conflict; Unreviewable tool error
- a: Complete transcript
- b: Compatible agreed schedule
- c: Human review route
- d: Identical treatment automatically fixes every barrier
Each remedy responds to a specific obstacle.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F2 · A transparent but irrelevant score
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club openly awards membership points only for owning an expensive device. The club’s task uses shared school paper and pencils. Everyone can read the rule, but the device is not needed for the task.
F2 · True or false
True or false? Because the device-ownership rule is public, it is automatically fair for this paper activity.
- true: True
- false: False
Making a rule visible does not make an irrelevant criterion fair.
Investigation: decision lab
F3 · Read the test groups
Fictional classroom case
A fictional voice tool is correct for 9 of 10 quiet recordings and 5 of 10 noisy recordings. The separate training-count controls in the explorer do not change these fixed test results automatically.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Quiet recording result; Noisy recording result; Group with more test errors
- a: 9 of 10 correct
- b: 5 of 10 correct
- c: Noisy recordings
- d: Both groups have the same result
The same test total makes the difference visible.
Investigation: data balance lab
F4 · Choose an opportunity-preserving response
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil’s spoken answer is repeatedly misread by a tool because the room is noisy. The learning goal is explaining a pattern, not microphone quality. The teacher can review a written answer or offer a quiet recording place.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which response best matches the learning goal and documented problem?
- a: Offer a written or quiet-recording route and review reasoning.
- b: Exclude the pupil because the tool misheard.
- c: Assume the transcript cannot be wrong.
- d: Award points only for owning a better microphone.
The alternative should measure the intended skill rather than the avoidable barrier.
Investigation: message lab
F5 · Equal minutes, unequal availability
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pair plans 20 minutes of work for each member. One member has only 10 minutes available before the agreed departure; the other has 30. The task has a 10-minute checking job and a 30-minute design job (10 minutes planning and 20 minutes drawing), and both jobs are suitable for either member. In the explorer, Ari has 10 minutes and Bia has 30.
F5 · Open ended
Propose a workable task allocation and explain why equal minutes are not the only fairness consideration here.
Example of a full-credit answer: Assign the 10-minute check to the member with 10 minutes and the 30-minute design to the member with 30, by agreement. The plan respects their stated availability and allows both to contribute instead of imposing an impossible equal schedule.
- Allocates the 10- and 30-minute tasks consistently with the stated availability.
- Explains that availability and meaningful participation matter alongside equal minutes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: collaboration lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional reading club has school books for all participants. Its stated purpose is to practise discussing stories. Proposed Rule A allocates turns so every member can speak; Rule B gives all turns to owners of new tablets. No tablet is needed.
1A · Hotspot
Which rule is best connected to the club’s stated purpose?
- a: A: give every member usable speaking turns
- b: B: all turns for new-tablet owners
- c: C: all turns for the loudest member
- d: D: turns decided by unrelated profile likes
The rule should support the actual opportunity rather than irrelevant ownership.
1B · Short answer
Explain why A fits the purpose and propose a way to check whether members can really participate.
Example of a full-credit answer: A gives members turns to discuss stories without needing a tablet. Observe whether each member has a usable opportunity to contribute and ask for feedback about any remaining barriers.
- Connects A to story discussion and removal of irrelevant device ownership.
- Proposes an actual participation check or feedback route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional tool correctly reads 18 of 20 typed answers and 6 of 10 photographed handwritten answers. The teacher wants to use it for feedback, but will review missed answers. These are separate fixed test groups.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The typed test success rate is 90%.
- b: The handwriting-photo test success rate is 60%.
- c: The groups have equal observed error rates.
- d: Changing a training-count slider automatically proves the error gap is fixed.
The rates show an access-related difference worth investigating.
2B · Open ended
Use the supplied results to explain why review is needed and propose a remedy that still assesses the same answer content.
Example of a full-credit answer: The tool is correct on 90% of typed tests but 60% of handwriting photos, so more handwritten responses may be missed. Offer typed/text entry or human review of photographed answers while judging the same reasoning.
- Correctly compares 90% versus 60% or equivalent 18/20 versus 6/10 results.
- Offers an alternative or human review preserving assessment of the same content.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club moves a discussion online. Some members have a low connection and cannot load a long video, but all can read a small text file. The goal is to respond to the same story, whose complete text is available.
3A · Multiple choice
Which material removes the stated connection barrier while keeping the story task?
- a: The small complete story text
- b: A larger decorative video
- c: Only a blank summary heading
- d: A demand to buy a faster connection
A complete text route can remove a connection barrier without changing the story task.
3B · Open ended
Propose a fair participation route and explain how to keep the learning requirement equivalent.
Example of a full-credit answer: Provide the complete story and questions as a small text file and allow responses through the agreed low-data route. Ask the same story-reasoning questions rather than lowering or changing the learning goal.
- Provides a complete low-data text route suited to the stated connection constraint.
- Preserves the same story content/reasoning requirement across routes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional tool correctly recognises 9 of 10 examples in Group A, 9 of 10 in Group B and 2 of 10 in Group C. A pupil says the first two good results mean Group C does not matter. The same activity is meant to serve all three groups.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Group needing particular review; C result; Activity’s intended users
- a: C
- b: 2 of 10 correct
- c: All three groups
- d: Good results for A and B erase C’s errors
Serving all groups requires attending to the group experiencing substantially more failures.
4B · Open ended
Identify the reasoning error and propose a response to Group C’s result.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil ignores unequal errors because other groups do well. Investigate C’s failures, offer a usable alternative and human review, and test whether a proposed improvement actually helps C.
- Explains that success for some groups does not cancel serious errors affecting another intended group.
- Provides investigation plus an appropriate alternative/review/testing response to C.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school display has limited computer time. Pupils need to create a short explanation, and some need an accessible input method. The teacher can schedule turns and review concerns. A ranking tool based only on typing speed has been proposed.
5A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Real learning goal; Relevant access need; Questionable sole criterion
- a: Create a short explanation
- b: Usable input method
- c: Typing speed
- d: The fastest typing score decides every right
A fair process should consider access to the actual task and provide review.
5B · Open ended
Propose a time/input arrangement that supports the stated goal, and explain how pupils can question an unfair outcome.
Example of a full-credit answer: Schedule usable turns and provide needed accessible input methods so pupils can show their explanations, rather than allocating everything by typing speed. Ask the teacher to review concerns and participation results and adjust the plan when evidence shows a barrier.
- Proposes workable access/time arrangements aligned with explanation rather than only typing speed.
- Includes a human concern/review route and evidence-based adjustment.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.13 · Inclusion
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Invitation versus participation
Fictional teaching example
A fictional club invites everyone but offers instructions only in an audio file. One member needs text.
Question: What additional step supports inclusion?
Answer: Provide an accurate written version of the same instructions.
Why: The invitation becomes useful when the member can access the task.
Example 2 · A keyboard route
Fictional teaching example
A fictional sorting activity has drag controls and also labelled keyboard-selectable choices.
Question: Why can the second route matter?
Answer: It lets someone who cannot use dragging still perform the same sorting task.
Why: An input alternative can preserve the learning goal.
Example 3 · One voice is not everyone
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class asks one pupil to decide what all speakers of a language believe.
Question: What should change?
Answer: Ask for that pupil’s own view without treating it as the view of the whole group.
Why: Respectful participation avoids making one person a stereotype or representative of everyone.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose a participation route
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class task asks learners to explain a pattern. A learner can type but cannot use the recording tool in the available setting. The teacher allows either a recorded or written explanation judged for the same reasoning.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which action supports the stated learning goal and access need?
- a: Accept the written explanation under the same reasoning criteria.
- b: Refuse every answer without a recording.
- c: Grade only the microphone quality.
- d: Require a private medical explanation in public.
The written route preserves the assessed reasoning.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · What the invitation misses
Fictional classroom case
A fictional event invites all pupils. Its map uses only colour labels and its instructions play only as audio. Some pupils need non-colour labels or text. The team can add named locations and a complete transcript.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Named locations help readers identify the route without colour alone.
- b: A complete transcript preserves the audio instructions in text.
- c: Inviting everyone makes every format automatically usable.
- d: Decorative animation necessarily replaces missing directions.
The changes provide essential information through additional routes.
Investigation: accessibility lab
F3 · Match the participation barriers
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club identifies three barriers: an oversized download, a mouse-only answer input and unexplained words. It offers a small complete text file, keyboard controls and a short glossary.
F3 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Oversized download; Mouse-only input; Unexplained words
- a: Small complete text file
- b: Keyboard controls
- c: Short glossary
- d: Require everyone to buy new equipment
Each support targets the stated barrier without changing the main goal.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · A respectful contribution request
Fictional classroom case
A fictional discussion includes several language groups. The teacher asks each pupil for their own view and offers written or spoken participation. A draft rule says one pupil must speak for every member of a whole language group.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Respectful scope; Available routes; Faulty assumption
- a: The pupil’s own view
- b: Written or spoken
- c: One person represents every group member
- d: A shared glossary
Inclusion does not require stereotyping a pupil as a whole group.
Investigation: message lab
F5 · Test more than a button
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team adds keyboard selection to a quiz. A tester can choose an option but cannot move to the Next control using the keyboard. The team claims the whole quiz is accessible.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the current test does not support the team’s claim and propose a concrete improvement and retest.
Example of a full-credit answer: The tester cannot complete the quiz because Next is unreachable by keyboard. Make Next keyboard-operable with a clear focus path and retest choosing, changing and continuing through the quiz.
- Identifies the unreachable Next control as a barrier to completing the whole task.
- Proposes keyboard-operable continuation and an end-to-end keyboard retest.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: timeline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team’s goal is to explain a community garden plan. One member has a low connection but can read and send small text files. The team currently shares only a large video. A complete text plan is available.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Usable shared material; Existing barrier; Goal to preserve
- a: Complete small text plan
- b: Large-video-only sharing
- c: Explain the garden plan
- d: No contribution allowed without video
The member can contribute using a complete low-data route.
1B · Short answer
Describe a concrete sharing change and explain how the member can contribute to the same project goal.
Example of a full-credit answer: Share the complete small text plan and accept text comments. The member can review the same garden details and contribute reasoning without loading the large video.
- Provides the complete low-data text plan or equivalent usable route.
- Explains meaningful contribution to the same garden-planning goal through text review/comments.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner struggles to use a page. A teammate guesses the learner is lazy. The learner explains that the controls have no labels readable by their assistive tool. The teacher can help label the controls.
2A · True or false
True or false? The supplied evidence supports investigating the missing labels rather than assuming laziness.
- true: True
- false: False
The supplied explanation identifies a design barrier rather than a motivation fact.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the lazy judgement is unsupported and give a respectful response to the actual barrier.
Example of a full-credit answer: The observation does not establish motivation, and the learner reports missing labels. Listen, ask the teacher to check/add meaningful labels and test whether the learner can complete the task.
- Distinguishes observed difficulty from an unsupported judgement about effort.
- Responds respectfully with a relevant label repair and task check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional announcement is moved from an English-only club to a club using two languages. The essential facts are Monday, 3 pm, Room 4. A competent adult reviewer checks the second-language version and finds it incorrectly says 4 pm.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Time to preserve in both versions; Venue to preserve; Needed action
- a: 3 pm
- b: Room 4
- c: Correct and review the translation
- d: Any fluent translation guarantees inclusion
A second-language version must preserve the actual task facts.
3B · Open ended
Explain what needs correcting and how to check whether both language audiences can use the announcement.
Example of a full-credit answer: Correct 4 pm to 3 pm in the second-language version. Have a competent reviewer compare essential facts and ask readers of each version to identify the time and venue.
- Corrects the translated time to 3 pm while preserving the meeting information.
- Includes competent meaning review and/or a practical comprehension check across versions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team adds music, animation and a dark background to a guide, then claims it is inclusive because it has three features. The confirmed meeting room is Room 6. The actual test shows that readers still cannot find the meeting room, and the page has no text room label.
4A · Hotspot
Which change directly addresses the observed problem?
- a: Add a readable room label and test finding it.
- b: Add another music track without room information.
- c: Count the animations again.
- d: Assume every reader prefers the dark background.
Feature count does not measure whether the needed information is accessible.
4B · Open ended
Identify the team’s reasoning error and propose a task-based improvement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The team equates more decoration with usable participation. Add a readable Room 6 label and clear directions, then ask readers to identify the room using the guide.
- Explains that decorative feature counts do not establish inclusive task access.
- Adds the missing room information and tests the intended finding task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class discussion must collect ideas about a school garden. Some pupils prefer writing, some can speak, and one has only a low-data connection. The teacher can collect small text contributions and spoken comments under the same respectful discussion rules.
5A · Multiple choice
Which plan best fits the stated participation needs?
- a: Accept small text and spoken contributions under shared rules.
- b: Require all pupils to stream a long video response.
- c: Count only the loudest voices.
- d: Exclude anyone who uses a different input method.
The design should provide several usable routes and check actual participation.
5B · Open ended
Propose participation routes meeting the stated needs and explain how the teacher can check whether ideas were heard.
Example of a full-credit answer: Accept small text messages and spoken comments without requiring everyone to use one format. Review whose ideas reached the discussion, ask privately about barriers and adjust the process when someone lacks a usable opportunity.
- Provides written low-data and spoken routes suited to the stated needs without pressure.
- Checks meaningful contribution/remaining barriers and proposes adjustment.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.14 · Transparency
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A visible ranking rule
Fictional teaching example
A fictional feed says “sorted by number of likes.”
Question: What does the label explain, and what does it not prove?
Answer: It explains popularity order; it does not prove the top post is accurate.
Why: The meaning of an input differs from the truth of content.
Example 2 · A relevant disclosure
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class poster uses an AI-generated imagined scene and labels it beside the image.
Question: Why is this useful transparency?
Answer: Readers can distinguish an imagined generated scene from a photograph of an actual event.
Why: The label changes how the visual should be interpreted.
Example 3 · A privacy boundary
Fictional teaching example
A fictional decision notice explains its criteria without publishing applicants’ private records.
Question: Can it still be transparent?
Answer: Yes. Relevant process explanations do not require exposing every personal detail.
Why: The purpose is understandable review, not unlimited data disclosure.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the visible rule
Fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom feed orders prepared posts by likes. Post A has 30 likes, B has 10 and C has 20. The model labels this “popularity order” and does not check truth.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The stated popularity rule uses likes.
- b: Post A comes first under the supplied like counts.
- c: Post A is proved true because it is first.
- d: The toy rule describes every real platform.
The model reveals one simple rule without claiming truth assessment.
Investigation: feed lab
F2 · Match useful explanations
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school page has three explanations: a source label names the creator; an AI note describes generated assistance; a review notice names the teacher who handles questions. Each supports a different understanding.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Creator label; AI contribution note; Teacher review notice
- a: Origin of the work
- b: How the tool helped
- c: Route for questions or corrections
- d: A guarantee that no mistake exists
These explanations make different parts of the process visible.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Show the model’s limits
Fictional classroom case
A fictional recommendation model uses only pupils’ selected topic preferences. It does not check factual accuracy or know every interest. A disclosure should identify both its input and those limits.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Which input does the model use?; Does the model check factual accuracy?; Does it know every interest a pupil has?
- a: Selected topic preferences
- b: No factual-accuracy check is performed.
- c: No; only selected topic preferences are supplied.
- d: Yes; every fact and every interest is known.
A truthful explanation states the limited input and scope.
Investigation: recommend lab
F4 · Choose a clear process label
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team uses AI to draft one caption, then checks and rewrites it. Label A states that exact process. B says “100% verified by AI.” C hides the information in an unrelated file. D falsely says no tool was used.
F4 · Hotspot
Which label makes the supplied process clear?
- a: AI drafted the caption; our team checked and rewrote it.
- b: 100% verified by AI with no possible errors.
- c: No AI was used in any part of this caption.
- d: Every detail is hidden in an unrelated file.
The label should describe the actual process without a guarantee it cannot establish.
Investigation: audience lab
F5 · Explain without exposing
Fictional classroom case
A fictional club allocates speaking turns using a published rotation. It can explain the rotation and review route without showing private notes about individual pupils. A student demands every private note in the name of transparency.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what information is useful to disclose and why the private notes need not be published for this purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: Explain the rotation rule and teacher review route so members understand and question turn allocation. Private support notes are not needed to explain that rule and would expose personal information.
- Identifies the rotation rule and review route as useful process information.
- Explains why unrelated private notes are unnecessary exposure rather than required transparency.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: privacy lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional display ranks three projects using only completed-check counts: A has 2, B has 4 and C has 3. The label says “ordered by checks completed; this is not an overall quality judgement.”
1A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: First under the stated rule; Input being counted; Conclusion excluded by the label
- a: B
- b: Completed checks
- c: Overall project quality
- d: Printed heading size
The explanation makes the output’s limited meaning clear.
1B · Short answer
Explain why B appears first and identify a judgement this ranking cannot settle.
Example of a full-credit answer: B has the most completed checks, four. The count alone does not establish that B is the best project in creativity, accuracy or every other quality.
- Connects B’s first position to its four completed checks.
- Names a relevant quality judgement not established by the count alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school exhibition receives free display boards from a maker. Its review page says so and separately reports the team’s measured board sizes. There is no evidence that the sponsor changed the measurements.
2A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The supplied-board relationship is relevant context to disclose.
- b: The measurement sheet can be checked for the size claims.
- c: A sponsor relationship automatically proves every measurement false.
- d: Disclosing sponsorship removes every need to check evidence.
Disclosure gives context while specific claims still depend on evidence.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the relationship is useful for readers to know and why it does not alone prove the measurements false.
Example of a full-credit answer: It reveals a material connection that may influence presentation or interests. The actual sizes must be checked against measurement evidence; the sponsorship alone does not establish that the recorded numbers are wrong.
- Explains relevance of the supplied-board relationship to interests/context.
- Distinguishes that relationship from evidence establishing truth or falsity of specific measurements.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional tool explanation says “ranking optimises weighted preference signals.” Its actual classroom rule is simpler: Nature cards receive the selected Nature weight, Games cards the Games weight, with original order breaking ties. The audience is ten-year-old learners.
3A · Hotspot
Which input actually orders the cards in this model?
- a: The selected topic preference weights
- b: A secret test of each card’s truth
- c: The pupil’s entire private history
- d: The number of words in the technical label
Transparency should be understandable to the affected audience.
3B · Short answer
Rewrite the rule in plain language and include its important truth-checking limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Cards from a topic with a higher selected preference number come earlier; tied cards keep their original order. This only orders preferences and does not check whether a card’s claims are true.
- Explains the preference-weight ordering and original-order tie rule accurately in plain language.
- States that the rule does not verify factual truth.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional game openly awards extra turns to pupils who own a new tablet. The game uses only shared paper. A pupil says the public rule makes the decision fair. The teacher can review the rule’s relevance.
4A · True or false
True or false? Publishing the tablet-ownership rule alone proves it is fair for the paper game.
- true: True
- false: False
Knowing the rule allows critique; it does not settle whether the rule is appropriate.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mistaken conclusion and explain the relevant fairness question.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil confuses a visible rule with a fair rule. Ask why new-tablet ownership should control turns in a paper activity and whether a participation-based rule would better serve the goal.
- Distinguishes transparency of a rule from its fairness.
- Questions the irrelevant device criterion in relation to equal/meaningful participation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class tool suggests group order using completed preparation tasks only. A teacher reviews mistakes. The notice must explain the input and limit, name the review route and avoid publishing private pupil notes.
5A · Multiple choice
Who is the supplied human review contact?
- a: The teacher
- b: Any unknown message sender
- c: The ranking number itself
- d: A public list of private pupil notes
The explanation should support understanding and review without unnecessary exposure.
5B · Open ended
Write a short notice explaining the input and limit, then state the review route and privacy boundary.
Example of a full-credit answer: The suggested order uses completed preparation-task counts, not overall ability or worth. Ask the teacher to review a missing or incorrect task record; private pupil notes are not published.
- Explains the completed-task input and a clear limit on interpreting the rank.
- Provides teacher review and avoids unnecessary private-note disclosure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.15 · Accountability
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A named correction role
Fictional teaching example
A fictional page has an editor and a teacher reviewer. A reader reports a wrong room.
Question: Who should be able to act?
Answer: The editor updates the page after the teacher checks the confirmed room.
Why: Clear roles turn a report into an actionable correction.
Example 2 · A tool-reading error
Fictional teaching example
A fictional tool reads a handwritten 7 as 1. The original answer image is available to the teacher.
Question: What should review examine?
Answer: The original answer and the tool’s transcription.
Why: Review needs evidence of what the learner actually submitted.
Example 3 · Repairing the saved record
Fictional teaching example
A fictional teacher confirms a score correction. The screen changes, but the saved report still shows the old score.
Question: Is the repair complete?
Answer: No. The relevant saved report must also be corrected through the approved process.
Why: The durable record may still affect the learner.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the role plan
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class project assigns Lia to check facts, Miro to publish the reviewed file and the teacher to handle concerns. The tool only suggests wording. No role is assigned to AI for final approval.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Lia is assigned to fact checking.
- b: The teacher is assigned to concern review.
- c: The wording tool is the final human approver.
- d: No one can be responsible because AI suggested wording.
The stated human roles govern the actual release and review.
Investigation: collaboration lab
F2 · Match a problem to a repair
Fictional classroom case
A fictional project has a wrong public time, a misread answer and a missing source credit. Appropriate repairs are updating and notifying the public audience, teacher review of the original answer and restoring the correct credit.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Wrong public time; Misread answer; Missing source credit
- a: Update notice and notify readers
- b: Review original answer and transcription
- c: Restore correct credit
- d: Only apologise without changing anything
The remedy should address the specific error.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Find the meaningful review
Fictional classroom case
A fictional scoring tool marks a correct handwritten answer wrong after misreading it. Option A asks the teacher to compare the original answer and the marking rule. B reruns the same transcript without looking at the answer. C says computers never err. D hides the concern.
F3 · Hotspot
Which option offers meaningful review?
- a: Teacher compares the original answer with the marking rule.
- b: Repeat the same transcript without inspecting the answer.
- c: Declare that tools cannot make mistakes.
- d: Hide the concern so nobody can ask about it.
A meaningful review examines the evidence behind the disputed result.
Investigation: verification lab
F4 · A correction with a record
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class published “Room 1.” The teacher confirms “Room 8.” The correction log records the old value, new value and checked organiser plan. The public page and saved handout both need updating.
F4 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Old incorrect value; Confirmed value; Evidence for change
- a: Room 1
- b: Room 8
- c: Organiser plan
- d: Only the private log needs changing
The log supports accountability, but the affected public versions must also be fixed.
Investigation: provenance lab
F5 · The AI excuse
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team publishes an AI-generated paragraph with an invented event time. The team had a correct organiser schedule but did not check it. It says “The AI wrote it, so nobody here is responsible.”
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the excuse is inadequate and propose a concrete repair using the available evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The team chose to publish without using its available check; AI assistance does not remove that responsibility. Compare the time with the organiser schedule, correct the public paragraph and alert affected readers if needed.
- Connects human publication/checking choices to responsibility despite AI assistance.
- Uses the schedule to correct the affected public information and relevant notification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil answers 12, but the tool transcript says 21 and marks it wrong. The teacher can see the original answer and the key says 12. The activity has a saved score report.
1A · True or false
True or false? The tool transcript alone should override the original answer and confirmed key.
- true: True
- false: False
The original answer and key establish a transcription-related marking error.
1B · Open ended
Explain the error and name the records that should be repaired after teacher review.
Example of a full-credit answer: The tool reversed 12 to 21, so the mark does not reflect the actual correct answer. Correct the displayed score and saved item/report data through the approved process.
- Identifies the 12-to-21 transcription error against the key.
- Includes correction of both the learner-visible score and relevant saved report/item record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class page says only “contact someone” when readers find an error. Another page names the teacher-managed office route, asks for the page title and a description of the suspected error, and says the editor can correct the page after review.
2A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Usable review route; Information useful in the concern; Person able to update after review
- a: Teacher-managed school office route
- b: Page title and suspected error
- c: Editor
- d: Any vague note is equally actionable
A clear route connects a report to someone with authority to review and act.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the clear route is more accountable and why it need not publish pupils’ private contacts.
Example of a full-credit answer: Readers know where to send the issue and who will review and correct it. The school office route serves that purpose without exposing individual pupils’ private contacts.
- Explains the connection between a usable report route, named review role and ability to act.
- Explains that the approved office route makes private pupil contacts unnecessary.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher confirms that an exhibition opens at 2 pm. The team corrects its web page from 1 pm to 2 pm, but a downloadable sheet and audio script still say 1 pm. Visitors use all three versions.
3A · Hotspot
Which set of versions still has the old time?
- a: Downloadable sheet and audio script
- b: Only the already-correct web page
- c: All checked records including the organiser plan
- d: None, because one page was changed
Accountable repair must reach the actual formats people rely on.
3B · Short answer
Identify which versions still need changes and explain how to reach readers who already saved the old information.
Example of a full-credit answer: Correct the downloadable sheet and audio script to 2 pm. Share the correction through the approved audience channel and ask users of old copies to replace them.
- Identifies both remaining versions and the correct 2 pm time.
- Includes notification/replacement guidance for readers of saved old versions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional group posts a wrong accusation about a classmate. It says sorry privately but leaves the false public statement visible. The teacher has confirmed the claim is false and can manage a correction.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: False record still visible; Repair already made; Remaining audience need
- a: Public statement
- b: Private apology
- c: Clear correction of the public claim
- d: Private apology automatically updates the public post
The public audience still has the false information.
4B · Open ended
Explain why the response is incomplete and propose an adult-supported repair that avoids repeating unnecessary harmful details.
Example of a full-credit answer: The apology does not correct the statement readers can still see. Work with the teacher to remove or correct the false post and notify the affected audience briefly without amplifying the accusation or exposing more private information.
- Identifies the mismatch between private apology and unrepaired public misinformation.
- Provides teacher-supported public correction/removal and appropriate audience notification without unnecessary amplification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team publishes a weekly class guide. Last week an old schedule was copied without checking. The new workflow needs a named fact checker, a final publisher and an error-review route. The teacher provides the confirmed schedule each week.
5A · Multiple choice
Which prevention step directly addresses the old-schedule failure?
- a: Compare every date with the current confirmed schedule.
- b: Reuse last week’s file without opening it.
- c: Add a colourful cover before checking dates.
- d: Assume the tool always chooses the newest plan.
The workflow should address the actual old-schedule failure and provide repair authority.
5B · Open ended
Propose a prevention step tied to last week’s failure and a clear process for reviewing and correcting future errors.
Example of a full-credit answer: Have the named checker compare every date with the current confirmed schedule before the publisher releases the reviewed guide. Send reported errors to the teacher, who checks evidence and directs updates to the public and saved versions with needed notification.
- Adds a specific current-schedule comparison before release with clear responsibility.
- Provides a named evidence-based review and correction route for affected versions/readers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.16 · Screen use and wellbeing
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Same minutes, different purposes
Fictional teaching example
Two fictional activities each take 20 minutes: a family video call and unwanted scrolling after a task.
Question: Does the equal duration prove equal value or effect?
Answer: No. Purpose, content and context also matter.
Why: Minutes alone do not explain the experience.
Example 2 · A simple time budget
| Part | Minutes |
|---|---|
| Available | 40 |
| Project | 20 |
| Transition | 5 |
| Remaining | 15 |
Fictional teaching example
A fictional 40-minute period includes a 20-minute project and 5-minute transition, leaving 15 minutes.
Question: How much remains?
Answer: 15 minutes.
Why: Forty minus twenty minus five equals fifteen; this is a plan, not a medical threshold.
Example 3 · Ask for support
Fictional teaching example
A fictional pupil finds that upsetting messages make it hard to leave a game calmly.
Question: What is a useful next step?
Answer: Tell a trusted adult and work together on the messages, reporting options and routine.
Why: Support should address the actual experience rather than shame the pupil.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the planned purpose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner plans 25 minutes to finish a digital poster, then an agreed 10-minute movement break. The remaining period is for family reading. The plan is a household arrangement, not a health rule for everyone.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The learner has a specific poster task.
- b: The plan includes a movement break before family reading.
- c: The numbers define a medical limit for every child.
- d: Only the smallest possible screen total can be a good plan.
The plan gives a purpose and preserves another agreed activity.
Investigation: attention lab
F2 · Match plan features
Fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher suggests a task goal, a stopping cue and a support route. The goal is write one paragraph, the cue is completion of the paragraph and the support route is ask the teacher if interruptions prevent progress.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Task goal; Stopping cue; Support route
- a: Write one paragraph
- b: Paragraph complete
- c: Ask the teacher
- d: Scroll until the feed ends
The three features make the activity purposeful and reviewable.
Investigation: timeline lab
F3 · Count invented interruptions
Fictional classroom case
In a fictional 50-minute period, a task takes 20 minutes. Four nonessential alerts each cost 2 minutes in the classroom model, autoplay adds 10 and a planned break takes 5. Total modelled time is 43 minutes, leaving 7.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Time assigned to alerts; Total modelled time; Time remaining
- a: 8 minutes
- b: 43 minutes
- c: 7 minutes
- d: All children lose exactly two minutes per alert
The arithmetic follows the supplied assumptions only.
Investigation: attention lab
F4 · Identify a supportive response
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil tells a parent that late game alerts interrupt their agreed wind-down routine. Response A listens and reviews alert settings together. B mocks the pupil. C demands secret account details be posted publicly. D says the concern cannot matter.
F4 · Hotspot
Choose the response that addresses the stated problem supportively.
- a: Review nonessential alerts and the plan together.
- b: Mock the pupil for asking for help.
- c: Post account secrets to prove what happened.
- d: Declare that no online activity can ever affect a routine.
A supportive response addresses the observed issue and keeps the pupil involved.
Investigation: message lab
F5 · The task is finished but autoplay continues
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner finishes an assigned video lesson in 15 minutes. Autoplay starts unrelated clips for another 20 minutes, crowding out an agreed craft activity. An adult can help change autoplay settings.
F5 · Open ended
Identify the source of the unplanned time and propose one adjustment that preserves both the lesson and the craft plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: The unrelated autoplay clips add 20 unplanned minutes after the lesson ends. Turn off unwanted autoplay with adult help and stop when the assigned lesson is complete, leaving time for the craft activity.
- Identifies the 20 minutes of unrelated autoplay as the unplanned extension.
- Proposes an appropriate autoplay/stopping adjustment preserving the lesson and the other agreed activity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: attention lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class has 60 minutes before a scheduled outdoor activity. Its digital task takes 30 minutes, a transition takes 10 and no alerts or autoplay are planned. The model leaves 20 minutes. These are schedule assumptions, not universal health limits.
1A · True or false
True or false? The 60-minute classroom budget establishes a medical screen limit for every ten-year-old.
- true: True
- false: False
The budget helps organise the stated period without making medical claims.
1B · Open ended
Explain the remaining-time calculation and name a useful stopping cue tied to the task.
Example of a full-credit answer: Sixty minus thirty minus ten leaves twenty minutes. Stop when the agreed digital task is complete or at the agreed transition point so the outdoor activity remains possible.
- Calculates or explains the 20-minute remainder from the supplied schedule.
- Provides a task/transition stopping cue that preserves the agreed outdoor activity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
Two fictional pupils each spend 30 minutes on a screen. One completes a planned drawing with a teacher; the other is upset by repeated hostile messages. No clinical assessment is provided. Both can speak to a trusted adult.
2A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Equal feature; Important difference; Appropriate support route
- a: 30-minute duration
- b: Activity and reported experience
- c: Trusted adult
- d: Equal duration proves equal wellbeing
Context and reported effects matter alongside the clock.
2B · Open ended
Explain why minutes alone cannot settle the comparison and describe a supportive next step for the upset pupil.
Example of a full-credit answer: The activities and experiences differ despite equal duration. Listen to the upset pupil, involve a trusted adult and use appropriate reporting or contact controls while adjusting the routine if needed.
- Explains that content/context/reported experience differ despite equal time.
- Gives supportive adult help and a relevant safe response to hostile messages without diagnosis.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner’s usual solo plan uses a 20-minute task block. A school group now has a 35-minute collaborative task and a teacher-planned break afterwards. The goal is to complete the project and maintain the wider agreed routine, not obey a made-up universal 20-minute rule.
3A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The group task has a different stated duration from the solo block.
- b: The learner can review the plan with the teacher.
- c: The old 20-minute block is a medical rule for every activity.
- d: Purpose and context are irrelevant whenever a screen is used.
A routine can adapt to a different purposeful task with adult guidance.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the plan may need adjustment and propose how to preserve a clear ending and other activities.
Example of a full-credit answer: The collaborative task has different timing and needs. Agree the 35-minute session and planned break with the teacher, use task completion as the ending and check that the wider schedule still works.
- Identifies the changed collaborative task/timing as a reason to review the routine.
- Proposes an adult-agreed clear ending/break and preservation of the wider schedule.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional chart records that a learner spent 45 minutes using a screen. A classmate declares the learner unhealthy from that number alone. The record gives no content, purpose, routine or personal context.
4A · Multiple choice
What does the chart actually establish?
- a: The recorded duration was 45 minutes.
- b: The learner has a diagnosed health problem.
- c: Every screen activity has the same effect.
- d: The learner must never use a screen again.
The chart provides duration, not a clinical conclusion.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overclaim and name two relevant kinds of context a supportive adult might discuss.
Example of a full-credit answer: The duration alone cannot establish a health diagnosis. A trusted adult could ask what the activity was for and whether it is affecting the learner’s agreed sleep, movement, schoolwork or relationships.
- Rejects diagnosing wellbeing from the single duration record.
- Names at least two relevant contexts such as purpose/content and impact on sleep/activity/schoolwork/relationships.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner has a 60-minute period containing a 25-minute homework task, a 10-minute transition and time for an agreed offline activity. Four alerts at 2 minutes each and 15 minutes of autoplay would make the model total 58 minutes. The learner can reduce nonessential alerts and switch off unwanted autoplay with adult guidance.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Required homework; Required transition; Avoidable additions in the model
- a: 25 minutes
- b: 10 minutes
- c: Alerts and autoplay
- d: A timer can decide every child’s health
The plan can reduce unplanned additions while preserving the purposeful task and other activity.
5B · Open ended
Propose adjustments that leave more room for the offline activity and describe how to review whether the plan worked.
Example of a full-credit answer: Turn off unwanted autoplay and reduce nonessential alerts with adult guidance, while keeping the 25-minute homework and 10-minute transition. Afterwards check whether the task finished and the offline activity happened, then adjust together if needed.
- Reduces the stated avoidable alerts/autoplay while preserving the required task/transition.
- Includes a supportive outcome review of task completion and the offline activity rather than a medical judgement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.17 · Attention manipulation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Autoplay after the goal
Fictional teaching example
A fictional learner finishes a six-minute how-to clip. The player immediately starts unrelated clips.
Question: What attention feature is operating?
Answer: Autoplay.
Why: It moves to another item without requiring a new deliberate selection.
Example 2 · A streak is not the lesson
Fictional teaching example
A fictional app says an optional visit is needed to keep a seven-day streak. The learner already completed the assigned work.
Question: Does the streak prove more work is educationally necessary?
Answer: No. It records repeated visits, not the need for that next task.
Why: The learner can compare the prompt with the actual learning goal.
Example 3 · A model of interruptions
Fictional teaching example
A fictional model assigns three alerts a two-minute cost each.
Question: How many extra model minutes are added?
Answer: Six minutes.
Why: The calculation uses stated assumptions and does not predict every real person’s response.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify the feature
Fictional classroom case
A fictional video player begins a new clip as soon as the assigned one ends, without the learner choosing another. The new clip is unrelated to the homework goal.
F1 · Hotspot
Which feature is described?
- a: Autoplay starts the next clip
- b: A user-selected assignment button
- c: A source citation panel
- d: A saved-answer correction tool
Autoplay creates continued viewing without a fresh task choice.
Investigation: audience lab
F2 · Choose a goal-aligned control
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner has a 20-minute writing task. Nonessential game alerts keep interrupting, while the teacher’s approved message route is needed. An adult can help adjust the game alerts separately.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which adjustment best fits the stated situation?
- a: Reduce game alerts while keeping the teacher route available.
- b: Keep every game alert because it appears on screen.
- c: Disable all school contact without adult review.
- d: Abandon the writing task whenever a game alert appears.
The adjustment targets the irrelevant interruptions while preserving necessary communication.
Investigation: attention lab
F3 · Match design and action
Fictional classroom case
A fictional feature set includes autoplay, an endless feed and an urgent countdown. Autoplay starts another item; the endless feed removes a clear final page; the countdown pressures an immediate choice.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Autoplay; Endless feed; Countdown
- a: Automatic next item
- b: No clear final page
- c: Urgency pressure
- d: Proof that every next item is useful
The features influence the pattern of interaction, not the truth or value of content.
Investigation: timeline lab
F4 · A badge and the learning goal
Fictional classroom case
A fictional app gives a badge for opening it every day. A pupil has already completed the teacher’s task but says losing the badge would prove no learning happened. The badge counts visits, not completed understanding checks.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The supplied visit badge measures daily visits rather than every aspect of understanding.
- true: True
- false: False
A visit record is not the same as evidence of learning.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · The missing stopping point
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learner plans to inspect three examples. A feed keeps adding examples without a final page, and the learner forgets the original limit. The teacher can help set a visible list of the three required examples.
F5 · Short answer
Explain how the feed design affects the planned stopping point and propose a control that restores a deliberate choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: The endless feed hides a natural ending, making the three-example limit easy to lose. Use the visible three-item list and pause after the third; ask whether another example serves the goal before continuing.
- Connects the endless feed to the missing/blurred stopping point.
- Provides a concrete three-item/pause control that restores a deliberate choice.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: prompt lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional 60-minute period includes a 25-minute task, three alerts at 2 minutes each, 14 minutes of autoplay and a 5-minute break. The model total is 50 minutes, leaving 10. With autoplay off, the same model leaves 24.
1A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Alert time; Remainder with autoplay; Remainder without autoplay
- a: 6 minutes
- b: 10 minutes
- c: 24 minutes
- d: Every child must respond exactly like the model
The 14-minute difference comes from the stated autoplay assumption.
1B · Short answer
Explain the change in remaining time and state one limit of applying this model to real people.
Example of a full-credit answer: Turning off the assumed 14 autoplay minutes increases the remainder from 10 to 24. Real people’s timing and responses vary; these costs are classroom assumptions, not measured effects for every learner.
- Explains the 14-minute increase from 10 to 24 under the supplied arithmetic.
- States that real behaviour/time costs vary and the model is illustrative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learning page offers Version A, which stops after each activity and asks whether to continue, and Version B, which automatically opens an unrelated promotion. The stated goal is completing one assigned activity before a planned break.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Design aligned with the stated stopping point; Assigned goal; Next planned step
- a: A
- b: One completed activity
- c: A break
- d: B because automatic means necessary
A visible pause supports the plan without deciding every future action for the learner.
2B · Open ended
Explain why A fits the goal and identify the attention pressure avoided compared with B.
Example of a full-credit answer: A marks completion of the assigned activity and leaves a choice to take the break. It avoids automatically moving the learner into an unrelated promotion after the goal is met.
- Connects A’s clear pause to the one-activity goal and planned break.
- Identifies avoidance of automatic unrelated continuation/promotional attention capture.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional classroom roleplay shows a shop timer saying “choose in 30 seconds.” The class task is to compare three supplied offers carefully, and no real purchase is allowed. The timer does not supply evidence about quality or value.
3A · Multiple choice
What does the countdown itself establish about product quality?
- a: Nothing; it creates urgency, not quality evidence.
- b: It proves the offer is best.
- c: It verifies every seller claim.
- d: It guarantees a safe purchase.
The same pause-and-purpose reasoning applies outside a feed or game.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the timer should not decide the comparison and propose a response within the no-purchase classroom task.
Example of a full-credit answer: The timer creates urgency but provides no evidence of fit, terms or value. Ignore the deadline as a ranking reason and compare the supplied information with the class criteria; make no real purchase.
- Distinguishes urgency from evidence relevant to the offer comparison.
- Uses deliberate supplied-criteria comparison within the no-real-purchase task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class model counts interruptions from optional game alerts. A pupil concludes every notification must always be blocked, including the teacher’s agreed emergency announcement route. The case distinguishes optional promotions from necessary school communication.
4A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The case separates optional promotions from necessary school communication.
- b: A selective adjustment can reduce game alerts while retaining the teacher route.
- c: The model proves every notification is always harmful.
- d: Ignoring the teacher’s agreed route is required to use the model.
The model does not justify ignoring purpose and context.
4B · Open ended
Identify the overgeneralisation and propose a more selective adjustment.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats optional game interruptions as proof about every alert. Reduce nonessential game promotions with adult guidance while retaining the agreed teacher communication route.
- Explains the unsupported generalisation from optional alerts to all notifications.
- Targets unnecessary alerts while preserving the stated necessary school route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional learning game must let pupils complete one puzzle and then choose whether to stop. The teacher wants understandable controls, no unrelated autoplay and a clear way to reduce optional reminders. Essential school instructions must remain available.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Completion goal; Unrelated content feature explicitly excluded by the requirements; Communication to preserve
- a: One puzzle
- b: Unrelated autoplay
- c: Essential school instructions
- d: Make exit hard to find
The design should support a deliberate choice after the stated task.
5B · Open ended
Propose controls for the ending and reminders, then describe a task-based test of the design.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show a clear Puzzle Complete screen with easy Stop and Continue choices, no unrelated autoplay and adult-reviewed optional reminder controls. Ask a pupil to finish one puzzle, stop and find essential school instructions without encountering forced extra content.
- Provides clear stopping/continuing controls, removes unrelated autoplay and makes optional reminders controllable.
- Tests the intended one-puzzle stopping task while preserving access to essential school instructions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.18 · Social effects of artificial intelligence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A benefit and a limit
Fictional teaching example
A fictional transcript tool provides text for a recorded lesson but misreads two important terms.
Question: How should its effect be described?
Answer: It offers a useful text route, but the terms need human checking and correction.
Why: A benefit and a limitation can exist at the same time.
Example 2 · Changing work, not proving every future job
Fictional teaching example
A fictional teacher uses a tool to make a first draft and then spends time reviewing it.
Question: What does this case establish?
Answer: The task division changed in this instance.
Why: It does not prove what will happen to every teacher or job.
Example 3 · An access alternative
Fictional teaching example
A fictional AI activity requires a connection one pupil lacks; a complete offline written task is available.
Question: What choice supports participation?
Answer: Provide the equivalent offline task and appropriate review.
Why: A tool’s benefits should not be available only to pupils with the required connection.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A helpful but imperfect transcript
Fictional classroom case
A fictional tool creates a lesson transcript that lets pupils read the speech. The teacher finds and corrects two misheard key words before the transcript is used for assessment.
F1 · True or false
True or false? A tool can provide an access benefit while still needing human correction.
- true: True
- false: False
The case supports both a benefit and a need for review.
Investigation: verification lab
F2 · Who faces a barrier?
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI story activity needs a large download. Eight pupils can access it; four cannot with their available connection. A complete small text version serves the same story-reasoning task.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Four pupils face the stated download barrier.
- b: A complete small text version can support the same story task.
- c: The tool’s availability to eight pupils proves equal access for all twelve.
- d: Those without the download should automatically receive no task.
The benefit for some does not remove the need to include the others.
Investigation: graph lab
F3 · Match roles in the new workflow
Fictional classroom case
A fictional notice workflow uses AI for a first draft, an editor for evidence checking and a teacher for final approval. The tool does not independently verify every claim or authorise publication.
F3 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: AI-related stage; Editor’s stage; Teacher’s stage
- a: First draft
- b: Evidence checking
- c: Final approval
- d: Every stage is delegated to the tool
The case establishes a division of tasks rather than disappearance of human responsibility.
Investigation: collaboration lab
F4 · Choose a balanced conclusion
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pilot shows that a tool saves preparation time for three teachers but produces wrong dates in two draft notices. All notices are checked before publication. The pilot covers only this school task.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion best fits the supplied pilot?
- a: It saved drafting time here, while date checks remained necessary.
- b: It proves every school task will be error-free.
- c: It proves all teachers are now unnecessary.
- d: It proves no AI use can ever help anyone.
The conclusion should preserve the benefit, limitation and narrow scope.
Investigation: evidence lab
F5 · A learner’s voice is misread
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI voice activity repeatedly misreads one learner’s answers. The teacher can accept a written explanation of the same concept and compare the original response with the tool output.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the social consequence of treating misreadings as lack of understanding and propose a fairer response.
Example of a full-credit answer: The learner could lose an opportunity or receive an unfair result because of the tool’s error. Offer the equivalent written route and teacher review of the original response before deciding the result.
- Identifies an unfair educational/opportunity consequence of equating misreading with lack of understanding.
- Provides an equivalent accessible response route and human evidence review.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: message lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school considers a tool that drafts instructions quickly. It sometimes invents materials, and the class supply list is available. The teacher proposes using it only for initial ideas followed by checking against the list. The teacher then reviews and approves the final instructions.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Potential benefit; Known risk; Required check
- a: Quicker initial drafts
- b: Invented materials
- c: Compare with class supply list
- d: Use every generated instruction without review
A limited role and specific evidence check address the observed risk.
1B · Short answer
Explain how the plan retains a benefit and how it addresses the known harm.
Example of a full-credit answer: It uses quick draft suggestions to start planning. Comparing all materials with the supply list and having the teacher review and approve the final instructions helps catch invented materials before they pass into the activity.
- Connects the draft role to the preparation-time benefit.
- Connects supply-list checking and human approval to the known invented-material risk.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional tool correctly recognises 9 of 10 prepared responses in Language A and 4 of 10 in Language B. These are small fictional tests, not claims about real languages. Both groups need the same opportunity to answer.
2A · Multiple choice
What concern is directly supported by these fictional results?
- a: Language B has more recognition errors in this test.
- b: Every real language B speaker always fails.
- c: The tool has equal accuracy in both test groups.
- d: Adding one training example guarantees every error disappears.
The small tests identify a difference requiring review, not a universal language judgement.
2B · Open ended
Use the results to explain a concern and propose a support for the group facing more errors.
Example of a full-credit answer: Language B has six errors out of ten while A has one, so unreviewed use could disadvantage B in this test. Provide teacher review or an equivalent response route and investigate before relying on the tool for important decisions.
- Accurately identifies the larger observed error rate for Language B without universalising to real languages.
- Provides a relevant human review/alternative and further investigation before consequential use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional writing tool is first offered as optional brainstorming help. A new plan would require every pupil to upload private family stories to receive participation credit. The learning goal can be met with invented stories and a non-tool route.
3A · Hotspot
Which new requirement creates the stated privacy and participation concern?
- a: Uploading private family stories for credit
- b: Using invented characters in a story
- c: Offering optional brainstorming help
- d: Providing an equivalent non-tool route
A change to compulsory sensitive sharing changes the social and privacy consequences.
3B · Open ended
Explain what changed in the concern and propose a plan that preserves participation without the unnecessary disclosure.
Example of a full-credit answer: The tool moved from optional help to a requirement to reveal private family information. Allow invented stories and an equivalent non-tool route judged by the same writing criteria.
- Identifies the shift to compulsory private-data sharing as the new concern.
- Offers invented data and/or an equivalent non-tool route preserving the learning opportunity without disclosure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional office uses AI to draft one type of message. An employee still checks facts and handles unusual cases. A pupil concludes every job in every office will disappear next month. No broader evidence is supplied.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Established change; Human work still present; Pupil’s specific prediction about next month
- a: One drafting task is assisted
- b: Fact checking and unusual cases
- c: Every office job disappears next month
- d: The case establishes every future job outcome
A narrow example does not justify a universal dated prediction.
4B · Open ended
Identify the reasoning error and write a conclusion supported by the case.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil generalises one task change into a prediction about all jobs. In this office, AI assists one message-drafting task while people still check facts and handle unusual cases; wider effects remain unestablished.
- Explains the unsupported leap from one task/case to all jobs at a fixed future time.
- States the limited observed task change and continuing human role.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional school will test AI draft assistance for class notices. The plan must check whether it helps preparation, whether dates are accurate, whether pupils have usable alternatives and who handles concerns. No private pupil details are needed for the test.
5A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The pilot should check dates against organiser records.
- b: The pilot should provide usable alternatives and a human concern route.
- c: One attractive draft proves all social effects are beneficial.
- d: Collecting private pupil details is necessary even though the test does not need them.
A pilot should examine benefits and consequences with review and alternatives.
5B · Open ended
Propose a pilot plan measuring a benefit and a risk, then explain how it will protect participation and handle concerns.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare preparation effort and check every date against the organiser record before publication. Provide an equivalent non-tool route where needed, avoid private pupil data and let the teacher review concerns and stop or revise the pilot if problems appear.
- Includes a concrete preparation-benefit measure and date-accuracy/risk check before publication.
- Includes access alternatives, appropriate privacy and a human concern/revision route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.19 · Environmental costs of digital systems
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Half an hour of operation
Fictional teaching example
A fictional device draws a constant 12 W for 30 minutes.
Question: How much operating energy is used?
Answer: 6 Wh.
Why: Thirty minutes is half an hour; 12 multiplied by one-half is 6.
Example 2 · An assumed emissions factor
Fictional teaching example
A fictional task uses 50 Wh, or 0.05 kWh. Its supplied factor is 200 g per kWh.
Question: What is the estimated operating emission?
Answer: 10 g under the stated factor.
Why: 0.05 multiplied by 200 is 10; this does not include manufacture or other omitted impacts.
Example 3 · A missing boundary
Fictional teaching example
A fictional report measures a tablet’s operating electricity but calls it the entire environmental footprint.
Question: What should the label say instead?
Answer: Measured operating electricity for the stated period.
Why: Manufacturing, network, water and disposal effects were not all measured.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Calculate the supplied operation
Fictional classroom case
In a fictional classroom comparison, Device A uses a constant 20 W for 60 minutes and Device B 10 W for 60 minutes. Both complete the same stated text-display task. Their operating energies are 20 Wh and 10 Wh; manufacture and network use are excluded.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which device uses less operating electricity for this stated task?
- a: Device B: 10 Wh
- b: Device A: 20 Wh
- c: Both use zero electricity
- d: The data cannot distinguish their stated operating energy
The same duration makes the supplied power comparison straightforward.
Investigation: resource lab
F2 · Find the missing part of a claim
Fictional classroom case
A fictional worksheet calculates 15 Wh for a device’s half-hour operation. It does not measure manufacturing, data networks, cooling water or disposal. Its title says “Complete lifetime environmental footprint.”
F2 · Hotspot
Which title accurately matches the measurement?
- a: Half-hour device operating electricity
- b: Complete lifetime environmental footprint
- c: Universal water use for every AI question
- d: Total worldwide impact of all devices
The measured boundary is much narrower than the title.
Investigation: evidence lab
F3 · Compare equal energy, different factors
Fictional classroom case
Two fictional operations each use 100 Wh, or 0.1 kWh. Supply A’s assumed factor is 300 g/kWh; Supply B’s is 600 g/kWh. Estimated operating emissions are therefore 30 g and 60 g. The figures are case assumptions, not real-location measurements.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Supply A gives 30 g under the supplied factor.
- b: Supply B gives 60 g under the supplied factor.
- c: The 100 Wh values prove identical emissions under every factor.
- d: The calculations include all manufacturing and water impacts.
The emissions estimate changes with the stated electricity factor.
Investigation: graph lab
F4 · Electricity does not give water by itself
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class records that a task used 40 Wh. It has no information about cooling system, location or water use. A pupil claims the task therefore used exactly one litre of water.
F4 · True or false
True or false? The supplied 40 Wh alone establishes exactly one litre of water use.
- true: True
- false: False
No water estimate follows without relevant additional evidence.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A smaller complete file
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class needs a text handout. Using the same fictional classroom file-size units, File A is a 30-unit video that reads the same words and File B is a 2-unit complete text file. Both serve the stated reading task. The record does not quantify network energy or total emissions.
F5 · Short answer
Choose a resource-efficient option for the stated task and explain a limit on the environmental claim you can make.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose the complete 2-unit text file because it meets the reading task with a smaller transfer. Without network or lifecycle measurements, we cannot calculate a precise total energy or emissions saving from the file sizes alone.
- Selects the complete smaller text file while preserving the required task.
- Acknowledges that precise network/lifecycle energy or emissions savings are not established by file size alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: audience lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
For the same fictional worksheet task, Computer A runs at a constant 50 W for 60 minutes and Tablet B at 10 W for 30 minutes. Both complete the task. A uses 50 Wh; B uses 5 Wh. This comparison excludes manufacturing and network costs.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: Tablet B uses 5 Wh under the supplied power and duration.
- b: Computer A uses 50 Wh under the supplied power and duration.
- c: The calculation proves Tablet B has no manufacturing impact.
- d: The 45 Wh difference is a universal saving for every possible task.
Power and duration both matter in the supplied comparison.
1B · Open ended
Explain why B uses less operating energy in this case and state one reason this does not prove the lowest total lifetime impact.
Example of a full-credit answer: B uses 10 W for half an hour, giving 5 Wh instead of A’s 50 Wh, a 45 Wh difference. Manufacturing, lifetime, network or other unmeasured effects could change a full lifecycle comparison.
- Uses the correct 5 Wh versus 50 Wh comparison or equivalent power-duration reasoning.
- Identifies an omitted lifecycle/system factor preventing a total-lifetime conclusion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional display uses 100 Wh, or 0.1 kWh. One report uses an assumed factor of 200 g/kWh and estimates 20 g; another uses 500 g/kWh and estimates 50 g. Both use the same electricity value and both label operation only.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Estimate under 200 g/kWh; Estimate under 500 g/kWh; Reason estimates differ
- a: 20 g
- b: 50 g
- c: Different assumed factors
- d: One must have used different device energy
The supplied factors explain the difference without changing electricity use.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the estimates differ and name the boundary both reports must keep visible.
Example of a full-credit answer: The same 0.1 kWh is multiplied by different factors, giving 20 g and 50 g. Both estimates cover only the stated operating electricity, not the whole lifecycle or water use.
- Explains the factor difference with correct 20 g and 50 g results.
- Keeps the operating-only boundary and omitted lifecycle/water effects explicit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional display draws a constant 40 W. It is needed for 30 minutes, using 20 Wh, but is accidentally left running for another 60 minutes, adding 40 Wh. The school allows an adult to switch it off after use.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Needed-period energy; Extra idle energy; Approved reduction
- a: 20 Wh
- b: 40 Wh
- c: Adult switches it off after use
- d: No electricity is used while a screen is idle
The unnecessary extra running time adds energy under the stated constant-power assumption.
3B · Short answer
Calculate the avoidable operating energy and propose an approved action that preserves the exhibition’s purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: The extra hour uses 40 Wh, which can be avoided by having the responsible adult switch the display off after the necessary 30-minute exhibition period.
- Identifies 40 Wh as the avoidable extra operating energy.
- Proposes school-approved adult switching off after the needed period without cutting the required exhibition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional post claims every AI request always uses exactly 2 Wh and the same amount of water. It gives no model, hardware, task, location or measurement record. A class worksheet instead supplies specific power and duration for one fictional task.
4A · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Problem with assigning the same energy figure to every task and system; Defensible worksheet scope; Missing water basis
- a: Missing system/task evidence and variation
- b: One supplied scenario
- c: Cooling or water-use data
- d: Every request is physically identical
A universal precise number is not established by the supplied evidence.
4B · Open ended
Identify why the claim is unsupported and describe the information a more careful estimate should state.
Example of a full-credit answer: Requests and systems can differ, and no measurement basis is provided. State the task, hardware/power, duration, relevant electricity factor and system boundary; include separate water evidence if making a water claim.
- Explains why an exact universal per-request energy/water claim is unsupported without relevant system/task evidence.
- Names concrete estimate assumptions/boundary and separate water evidence where needed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class uses a 30 W display for 60 needed minutes and sometimes leaves it on 30 extra minutes. It can reuse a checked explanation instead of generating ten duplicate drafts, but no per-generation energy is measured. The teacher manages device shutdown and safe equipment handling.
5A · Hotspot
Which saving can be calculated from the supplied device data?
- a: 15 Wh from avoiding the extra display period
- b: Exactly 1 litre of water per generation
- c: Zero environmental impact for the entire project
- d: A universal 2 Wh for every possible AI request
The class can quantify the idle-display saving while describing the unmeasured change carefully.
5B · Open ended
Propose one reduction with a supported numerical saving and one sensible action whose exact saving remains unknown.
Example of a full-credit answer: Have the teacher stop the extra 30-minute display period, avoiding 15 Wh under the stated assumptions. Reuse the checked explanation rather than generate unnecessary duplicates, while stating that the exact generation energy saving was not measured.
- Proposes avoiding the extra display period and correctly identifies 15 Wh saved.
- Proposes a sensible reuse/reduced-duplication action while acknowledging its exact environmental saving is unmeasured.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
MAIL7.20 · Ethical decision-making
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A useful alternative
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class wants to celebrate its model. One pupil refuses public portrait use; an approved object-only photograph is available.
Question: What option respects both the purpose and the stated boundary?
Answer: Use the approved model photo instead of the pupil’s portrait.
Why: The celebration does not require overriding the pupil’s refusal.
Example 2 · A high score with a missing requirement
Fictional teaching example
A fictional option earns the highest convenience score but lacks required permission.
Question: Does the score make it ready to use?
Answer: No. The missing permission must be resolved or another option chosen.
Why: A chosen scoring formula cannot cancel a requirement outside its criteria.
Example 3 · Waiting for evidence
Fictional teaching example
A fictional class has conflicting event times and a teacher who can confirm the current schedule.
Question: What is a responsible decision before sharing?
Answer: Wait for the confirmation, then share the checked time.
Why: A short pause prevents spreading an instruction the team cannot yet justify.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Name the ethical considerations
Fictional classroom case
A fictional team considers publishing a class photo. The purpose is celebrating a project, one pupil has declined public image use and an object-only image is available. The school requires permission for public pupil images.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Useful purpose; Relevant boundary; Available alternative
- a: Celebrate the project
- b: Required pupil-image permission
- c: Object-only image
- d: Popularity overrides every concern
The decision includes a purpose, a person’s stated choice and a workable alternative.
Investigation: timeline lab
F2 · Match questions to decision steps
Fictional classroom case
A fictional teacher asks: Who is affected? What evidence supports the claim? What other actions are available? The team is deciding whether to share an unverified timetable.
F2 · Matching
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Who is affected?; What supports the claim?; What else could we do?
- a: People and consequences
- b: Evidence
- c: Alternative actions
- d: Only count how excited the team feels
These questions organise different parts of ethical reasoning.
Investigation: prompt lab
F3 · Choose a permitted alternative
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class wants a public celebration post. An unapproved pupil portrait would get many likes. A permitted model photograph accurately shows the project. The school’s public-image rule is a requirement, not a popularity preference.
F3 · Hotspot
Which option is ready under the supplied school rule?
- a: Use the permitted model photograph.
- b: Publish the unapproved portrait for more likes.
- c: Treat silence as automatic approval.
- d: Ignore the rule because the post is positive.
The alternative achieves the purpose without overriding the stated requirement.
Investigation: permission lab
F4 · A clear reason to wait
Fictional classroom case
A fictional announcement has two conflicting times: an older post says 1 pm and an unverified repost says 2 pm. The organiser will confirm through the teacher shortly. Sharing now could send visitors at the wrong time.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which choice is best supported before confirmation arrives?
- a: Wait for the organiser’s confirmation through the teacher.
- b: Pick 1 pm because it appeared first.
- c: Pick 2 pm because it is a newer repost.
- d: Invent a third time to avoid choosing between them.
Waiting uses an available verification route before people rely on the notice.
Investigation: verification lab
F5 · A score leaves out consent
Fictional classroom case
A fictional decision model ranks a public pupil portrait highest for visual appeal and speed. It has no criterion for the school’s required public-image permission, which is missing. A permitted object drawing is available.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why the highest score does not settle the decision and propose a choice consistent with the stated requirement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The model omits required image permission, so its convenience score cannot override that boundary. Use the permitted drawing or wait for appropriate approval before considering the portrait.
- Identifies the omitted permission requirement and limits of the numeric ranking.
- Chooses the permitted alternative or waits for proper approval.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Investigation: decision lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional classroom case
A fictional pupil finds an unverified claim that a clubmate cheated. Sharing it could harm the clubmate’s reputation. The teacher can receive a private concern and review evidence; a public repost would not add verification.
1A · Multiple answers
Select ALL statements supported by this case.
- a: The claim is unverified in the supplied case.
- b: The teacher offers a private evidence-review route.
- c: A public repost automatically verifies the accusation.
- d: Counting classmates’ reactions proves whether cheating occurred.
The appropriate route addresses the concern while limiting unsupported public harm.
1B · Short answer
Explain a likely risk of the public repost and why the private review route is a better response to the uncertainty.
Example of a full-credit answer: The repost can damage the clubmate’s reputation by spreading an unverified accusation. Private teacher review can inspect evidence and decide appropriate next steps without unnecessarily amplifying it.
- Identifies reputational harm from spreading the unverified accusation.
- Connects private teacher review to evidence checking and reduced unnecessary amplification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional classroom case
A fictional online club can require a large video upload or accept a small written explanation of the same reasoning. Some members cannot upload large files. The purpose is to understand their ideas, and both formats can show that reasoning.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each precise clue with its response. Use each response at most once.
Complete or match: Purpose; Barrier; Goal-preserving alternative
- a: Understand members’ ideas
- b: Large-file upload unavailable to some
- c: Small written explanation
- d: Fastest upload equals best reasoning
The alternative respects the stated purpose while reducing an avoidable barrier.
2B · Open ended
Give one reason based on the goal and one reason based on the people affected for allowing both formats.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both can show the same reasoning the club wants to understand. A written route includes members whose connection cannot handle a large upload instead of excluding them for a resource barrier.
- Explains that both formats can demonstrate the same intended reasoning.
- Explains how the alternative protects participation for members with the stated connection barrier.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom case
A fictional AI assistant drafts ideas for a private class plan. The team wants to publish the draft as a public guide. It contains an unchecked event-time claim and a private pupil-detail placeholder. A teacher review and a clean factual rewrite are available.
3A · True or false
True or false? Because AI helped privately, its unchecked draft is automatically suitable for public publication.
- true: True
- false: False
The new use changes consequences and needs review.
3B · Short answer
Explain what changes are needed for accuracy and privacy before publication, and identify who should review the final guide.
Example of a full-credit answer: Verify the claim with the organiser and rewrite it accurately; remove unnecessary pupil details from the actual shared file. Have the teacher review the clean final guide before publication.
- Addresses both the unchecked claim through evidence and the private detail through removal.
- Identifies teacher/human review of the actual final public version before release.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Fictional classroom case
A fictional ranking tool suggests denying a pupil a turn because it misread the pupil’s preparation record. The correct original record shows that the pupil completed the required preparation, and the teacher can inspect it. A teammate says nobody should question the result because a computer made it.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete each row using the fixed case.
Complete or match: Known problem; Available evidence; Review role
- a: Misread preparation record
- b: Correct original record
- c: Teacher
- d: A computer result cannot be wrong
Responsibility includes checking relevant evidence when a consequential error is identified.
4B · Open ended
Identify the teammate’s reasoning error and propose a fair repair of the decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: The teammate treats automation as unquestionable authority despite a known input error. Ask the teacher to inspect the correct record, correct the input/result and restore the pupil’s appropriate opportunity under the rule.
- Explains why automation does not override the known misread evidence or human responsibility.
- Provides original-record review, correction and repair of the affected opportunity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional classroom case
A fictional class must decide whether to post an AI-assisted project video. It has a learning purpose, mixed media permissions, one unverified fact and a pupil who declines public portrait use. An object-only alternative has the necessary media permissions already checked. That alternative can meet the purpose after verifying or removing the unchecked fact and completing teacher review.
5A · Multiple choice
Which release choice best fits the supplied facts and requirements?
- a: Use the object-only version after factual and teacher review.
- b: Publish the declined portrait because the video looks better.
- c: Leave the unverified claim because AI drafted it.
- d: Remove every review route to prevent complaints.
The routine should meet the purpose while addressing facts, permissions and affected people.
5B · Open ended
Propose a reasoned release decision that handles the fact and portrait issues, then describe a review and correction route after release.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the permitted object-only version, respect the pupil’s refusal and verify or remove the unsupported claim before teacher review and release. Give readers the teacher-approved concern route so confirmed errors can be corrected in the public version and communicated to affected viewers.
- Respects the portrait refusal using a permitted alternative and resolves the unsupported fact before reviewed release.
- Provides a human concern/review route with correction of the affected public content and appropriate notification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Primary source notes
These primary institutional references support concept checking. All invented classroom data and toy-model settings are teaching examples, not results from the cited studies.
MAIL1.1–MAIL1.11 and MAIL2.1–MAIL2.17: 28 original classroom modules; MAIL3 is authored and sourced separately by root.
- OECD — PISA 2029 Media and Artificial Intelligence Literacy
- UNESCO IITE — Media and Information Literacy and Emerging Technologies
- UNESCO — Guidelines for the Governance of Digital Platforms
- UNESCO — Media and Information Literate Citizens: Think Critically, Click Wisely
- UNESCO — Media and Information Literacy Curriculum, Module 10
- Google — How Search Works: Ranking Results
- Google for Developers — Recommendation Systems
- Google for Developers — Recommendations: What and Why?
- Google for Developers — Machine Learning Crash Course
- Google for Developers — Overfitting
- Google for Developers — Introduction to Large Language Models
- Google Research — Photorealistic Text-to-Image Diffusion Models with Deep Language Understanding
- Google Cloud — Speech-to-Text Overview
- Google Cloud — Speech-to-Text Best Practices
- NIST — AI Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile (AI 600-1)
- NIST — AI Risk Management Framework: Characteristics of Trustworthy AI
- UNESCO — Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence
MAIL3.1–MAIL3.10: ten original age-10 modules on searching, prompting, verification and human judgement.
- Google Search Help — Refine Google searches
- Google Search Help — How to search on Google
- Google AI for Developers — Prompt design strategies
- NIST — Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile, AI 600-1
- OECD — PISA 2029 Media and Artificial Intelligence Literacy
MAIL4.1–MAIL4.24 and MAIL5.1–MAIL5.12: 36 original age-10 classroom modules.
- UNESCO — Disinformation
- FTC — Native Advertising: A Guide for Businesses
- NIST — Reducing Risks Posed by Synthetic Content, AI 100-4
- C2PA — Frequently Asked Questions
- Digital Inquiry Group — Civic Online Reasoning
- Digital Inquiry Group — Intro to Lateral Reading
- UNICEF — Cyberbullying: What Is It and How to Stop It
- FTC — How To Recognize and Avoid Phishing Scams
- W3C WAI — Transcripts
- W3C WAI — Captions/Subtitles
MAIL6.1–MAIL6.15 and MAIL7.1–MAIL7.20; primary concept checks, checked 2026-10-29. All assessment cases, names, permissions, counts and planning budgets are fictional and fully supplied. Legal permissions are case terms; wellbeing activities are planning, not clinical advice.
- Creative Commons — CC BY 4.0 deed
- Creative Commons — CC BY-SA 4.0 deed
- Creative Commons — CC BY-ND 4.0 deed
- Creative Commons — Frequently Asked Questions
- WIPO — Copyright protection
- WIPO — Copyright FAQ
- WIPO — What is intellectual property?
- W3C WAI — Writing for Web Accessibility
- W3C WAI — Accessibility Principles
- UNESCO — Guidance for generative AI in education and research
- CISA — Four Easy Ways to Stay Safe Online
- CISA — Passwords Tip Sheet
- UNICEF — Online privacy checklist for parents
- UNICEF — What you need to know about sharenting
- UNICEF — Digital Parenting
- IEA — Key Questions on Energy and AI, executive summary
- NIST SP 800-63B-4 — Authentication and Authenticator Management
- CISA — Phishing Tip Sheet