Science — PISA-style Practice, Set 2

Teacher guide · Original questions and answer keys

55 questions across 11 topics. Every topic contains five different question types, including one written response. The four objective types were selected from the seven requested objective formats when this set was authored. Question types remain fixed for this edition; answer options are shuffled for each new learner attempt.

Every question is worth 2 points. Single-choice, true/false and hot-spot questions earn 2 or 0. Matching, drag-and-drop and dropdown items earn 2 when all rows are correct, 1 when at least one but not all rows is correct, and 0 when none is correct. Multiple-answer items earn 2 for the exact correct set, 1 for a nonempty correct subset with no incorrect selection, and 0 if any incorrect option is selected or the response is blank.

Written answers are assessed by the AI language model using the specific rubric below: 0 wrong, irrelevant or blank; 1 partially correct; 2 fully correct. Blank responses receive 0 without a model request. Unavailable or invalid AI responses stay pending and are retried. AI estimates are not official PISA scores.

Learners open index.html after extracting the whole package. Results are prepared and sent automatically when the learner reaches Results. There is no final Submit button. The teacher guide is not linked from the learner assessment.

Greenhouse

Practice simulation, not historical observations. A climate model receives solar energy and loses infrared energy to space. Carbon dioxide absorbs some outgoing infrared radiation. At a steady temperature, incoming and outgoing energy are equal. The energy units below are arbitrary but identical for all runs. Clouds and surface properties are fixed.

RunCarbon dioxide (ppm)Incoming energyOutgoing energy at the stated temperatureModel surface temperature (°C)
A40010010015
B6001009715
C60010010017
D40010410015

Run C follows the adjustment of Run B. Parts per million (ppm) describe the proportion of carbon dioxide in air. A model helps test an explanation; its values are not a forecast for a particular place.

Question 1 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Why the model warms

Explain why the temperature initially rises in Run B and why Run C can reach a steady temperature even though its carbon dioxide concentration remains high.

Model response

Run B gains 3 energy units per interval because more energy arrives than escapes, so it warms. At the higher temperature in C, 100 units leave as 100 arrive. The balance stops further warming in this fixed model even though carbon dioxide remains at 600 ppm.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Explains either the energy gain in B or the restored energy balance in C, but does not correctly connect both stages.
2Explains that B gains energy because 100 units enter but only 97 leave, and that warming increases outgoing energy until it equals incoming energy in C; high carbon dioxide need not cause unlimited warming.

Other acceptable ideas: Energy entering exceeds energy leaving in B.; Warming continues until incoming and outgoing energy balance.; Equivalent descriptions of infrared emission increasing with temperature are valid.

Explanation: Run B gains 3 energy units per interval because more energy arrives than escapes, so it warms. At the higher temperature in C, 100 units leave as 100 arrive. The balance stops further warming in this fixed model even though carbon dioxide remains at 600 ppm.

Item ID: Science-Greenhouse-Q1

Question 2 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Choose the observation

A laboratory team checks three model inputs. Drag each measurement to the research question it directly answers.

Rows / targets:

  1. How much solar energy reaches the surface?
  2. How much infrared energy escapes upward?
  3. What fraction of air consists of carbon dioxide?
Correct answer: How much solar energy reaches the surface? → Solar-energy reading in energy units; How much infrared energy escapes upward? → Upward infrared-energy reading in energy units; What fraction of air consists of carbon dioxide? → Carbon dioxide reading in ppm

Explanation: The unit and kind of measurement must match the quantity under investigation; temperature alone does not measure every energy flow.

Item ID: Science-Greenhouse-Q2

Question 3 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

A fair comparison

Select all changes that would help isolate the effect of carbon dioxide in a new pair of model runs.

Correct answer: Use the same incoming solar energy in the two runs.; Use the same cloud and surface settings in the two runs.; Repeat the comparison at several carbon dioxide settings while recording the final temperature.

Explanation: Changing one factor while holding other relevant conditions constant makes the comparison interpretable. Testing several settings also checks whether the effect is consistent.

Item ID: Science-Greenhouse-Q3

Question 4 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

Interpreting an unexpected result

A new run uses the settings of A, but the surface reflects more incoming sunlight. Which extra measurement is most useful for explaining any temperature change?

Correct answer: The amount of sunlight reflected away

Explanation: The energy absorbed by the system changes when reflectivity changes. Measuring reflected solar energy helps determine how much incoming energy remains available for warming.

Item ID: Science-Greenhouse-Q4

Question 5 · True or False · 2 points

What was changed?

Comparing A with D isolates a change in carbon dioxide concentration.

Correct answer: False

Explanation: A and D both have 400 ppm carbon dioxide. Incoming energy differs, so their comparison concerns solar input rather than a carbon dioxide change.

Item ID: Science-Greenhouse-Q5

The Environmental Impact of Eating Meat

Fictional cafeteria audit for practice. Each meal supplies 20 g of protein and about 600 kilocalories (kcal) of food energy. Estimates cover farming and processing only; cooking, packaging and transport are excluded. The meals are not intended as complete daily diets. Carbon dioxide equivalent (CO₂e) combines estimated greenhouse-gas effects into one unit.

MealMain proteinEmissions (kg CO₂e per meal)Land (m² per meal)Cost (credits)
ABeef4.89.03.5
BChicken1.73.02.6
CBeans0.81.52.1
DLentils0.31.12.4

Question 1 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Match evidence to impact

Drag the most direct evidence to each cafeteria research question.

Rows / targets:

  1. Does a supplier require more agricultural land?
  2. Does a meal release more greenhouse gases during farming and processing?
  3. Does a meal supply the stated amount of protein?
Correct answer: Does a supplier require more agricultural land? → Mapped farm area allocated to the food produced; Does a meal release more greenhouse gases during farming and processing? → An inventory of greenhouse-gas releases for the stated production stages; Does a meal supply the stated amount of protein? → A nutritional analysis of one serving

Explanation: Land, emissions and nutritional service require different measurements. One measure cannot automatically stand in for all the others.

Item ID: Science-Meat-Q1

Question 2 · True or False · 2 points

Limits of a meal audit

This audit alone establishes that any person who eats only Meal D every day will have a nutritionally complete diet.

Correct answer: False

Explanation: The audit gives protein and energy for individual meals, not all nutrients or personal needs. It does not evaluate a complete daily diet.

Item ID: Science-Meat-Q2

Question 3 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Make the comparison meaningful

A supplier compares one kilogram of beef with one kilogram of watery vegetable soup. Explain why equal food mass alone may be an unfair comparison, and name one nutritional basis that would improve it.

Model response

A kilogram of soup and a kilogram of beef may provide very different amounts of protein and energy, partly because they contain different amounts of water. Comparing meals with similar nutritional value, such as the same protein and energy, gives a more meaningful basis. Environmental boundaries must still be applied consistently.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Identifies that equal mass can provide different amounts of useful nutrition, or names a relevant nutritional basis, but does not connect both ideas.
2Explains that equal masses can supply different amounts of protein, energy or other nutrients, and proposes a comparable nutritional service such as equal protein, equal energy or nutritionally comparable meals.

Other acceptable ideas: Equal kilograms do not necessarily provide equal nutrition.; Equal protein, equal energy, or a nutritionally comparable serving is acceptable.; No claim that one nutrient alone determines a complete healthy diet is needed.

Explanation: A kilogram of soup and a kilogram of beef may provide very different amounts of protein and energy, partly because they contain different amounts of water. Comparing meals with similar nutritional value, such as the same protein and energy, gives a more meaningful basis. Environmental boundaries must still be applied consistently.

Item ID: Science-Meat-Q3

Question 4 · Hot Spot · 2 points

Meet two constraints

Select the plotted meal that costs no more than 2.2 credits and emits less than 1 kg CO₂e per meal. Use the cost table as well as the graph.

Emissions and land use per meal0123450246810Emissions (kg CO₂e per meal)Land (m²)ABCD
Correct answer: Meal C: emissions 0.8 kg CO₂e, land 1.5 m²

Explanation: Meal C costs 2.1 credits and emits 0.8 kg CO₂e. D has lower emissions but costs 2.4 credits; A and B exceed the emissions limit.

Item ID: Science-Meat-Q4

Question 5 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Read the audit carefully

Select all statements supported by the stated audit.

Correct answer: Replacing one B meal with one D meal reduces estimated land use by 1.9 m².; An environmental comparison should state which production stages its numbers include.

Explanation: Meal D uses 1.1 m² compared with 3.0 for B, a difference of 1.9 m². Transport is excluded from the estimates. A low result for one measure does not prove zero impact everywhere.

Item ID: Science-Meat-Q5

Smoking

Invented study data for reasoning practice, not real risk estimates. Researchers follow adults in the same age band for ten years. No one is asked to begin smoking. People are grouped by their reported starting habits. Workplace exposures are not recorded.

GroupCigarettes per day at the startPeople followedNew cases of a specified lung disease
A02000030
B1–91000060
C10 or more400060

Scientific evidence from many real studies establishes that smoking causes serious disease, including cancer. This small invented example is used to practise judging the strengths and limits of one study.

Question 1 · True or False · 2 points

Compare like with like

Groups B and C have the same observed disease rate because each has 60 cases.

Correct answer: False

Explanation: The denominators differ. B has 60 cases among 10,000 people, while C has 60 among 4,000; C therefore has a higher observed rate.

Item ID: Science-Smoking-Q1

Question 2 · Hot Spot · 2 points

Use standardised rates

Select the bar whose observed rate is ten times the rate in Group A.

Cases per 10,000 people in ten years030609012015015Group A60Group B150Group C
Correct answer: Group C: 150 cases per 10,000

Explanation: Group A has 15 cases per 10,000. Ten times 15 is 150, the rate in Group C.

Item ID: Science-Smoking-Q2

Question 3 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

An ethical follow-up

Which design best gathers more human evidence without deliberately exposing people to tobacco smoke?

Correct answer: Follow consenting adults with different existing smoking histories and record relevant exposures over time.

Explanation: Following volunteers with existing exposure histories can add evidence while avoiding an experiment that assigns a harmful exposure.

Item ID: Science-Smoking-Q3

Question 4 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

An unmeasured difference

Name one unrecorded factor that could affect this study’s group comparison, and explain how recording or adjusting for it would improve the comparison.

Model response

Workplace exposure to harmful dust could differ among groups and also affect lung disease. Recording that exposure would allow researchers to compare people with similar exposure or adjust for it, reducing an alternative explanation for part of the observed difference. This does not overturn the wider evidence that smoking causes disease.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Names a relevant unrecorded factor, or explains the need to compare other exposures, but does not explain the connection to disease risk and the group comparison.
2Names a plausible factor such as workplace dust/chemical exposure, air pollution, past smoking duration or family history, and explains that differing levels could influence disease risk, so measuring and comparing/adjusting for it helps separate those effects from the smoking comparison.

Other acceptable ideas: Workplace chemicals or dust with a clear disease-risk explanation.; Air pollution, duration of previous smoking, or family history with an appropriate comparison explanation.; Age alone is not a strong example here unless differences within the stated age band are explicitly discussed.

Explanation: Workplace exposure to harmful dust could differ among groups and also affect lung disease. Recording that exposure would allow researchers to compare people with similar exposure or adjust for it, reducing an alternative explanation for part of the observed difference. This does not overturn the wider evidence that smoking causes disease.

Item ID: Science-Smoking-Q4

Question 5 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Strengthening an explanation

Select all evidence that would strengthen a scientific explanation of how tobacco smoke can harm health.

Correct answer: Similar results in independent, carefully designed studies with relevant differences between groups considered.; Experiments showing how smoke chemicals can damage cells, using suitable controls.

Explanation: Independent population findings and well-controlled biological evidence contribute different, complementary information. Popularity or an isolated anecdote cannot replace systematic evidence.

Item ID: Science-Smoking-Q5

Who should we believe?

Fictional sources. A company sells a cover for food boxes. Its post says, “Our cover always keeps food 30% cooler.” It describes one customer’s experience and provides no starting temperatures or test duration.

An independent class laboratory compares six pairs of identical boxes for 40 minutes. In each pair, one box has the cover and one does not. They use equal amounts of water at the same starting temperature and expose each pair to the same conditions. Covered boxes finish an average of 0.8 °C cooler; the paired differences range from 0.1 to 1.4 °C. The laboratory publishes its procedure and all measurements. This experiment does not test every food or weather condition.

Question 1 · Drop Down Selection · 2 points

Distinguish kinds of statements

For each statement, choose the kind of claim it makes.

Rows / targets:

  1. “The six covered boxes ended an average of 0.8 °C cooler.”
  2. “The cover will reduce the final temperature of a box we test tomorrow.”
  3. “The cover looks more attractive than the uncovered box.”
Correct answer: “The six covered boxes ended an average of 0.8 °C cooler.” → Reported observation; “The cover will reduce the final temperature of a box we test tomorrow.” → Prediction to be tested; “The cover looks more attractive than the uncovered box.” → Personal preference

Explanation: An observation reports measured results, a prediction concerns an untested outcome, and appearance preferences express a judgement rather than a temperature measurement.

Item ID: Science-Believe-Q1

Question 2 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

What the evidence supports

Which conclusion most closely matches the independent laboratory’s evidence?

Correct answer: The cover produced a small average difference under the tested conditions; other conditions need testing.

Explanation: The experiment supports a temperature difference under its tested conditions. Neither one trial series nor the stated result establishes a universal percentage improvement.

Item ID: Science-Believe-Q2

Question 3 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Plan a useful replication

Describe a fair follow-up test of the cover. State the comparison you would make and one condition you would keep the same, explaining why.

Model response

I would compare otherwise identical covered and uncovered boxes with the same amount of water. I would keep their starting temperature and exposure time the same, so a final difference is less likely to come from unequal initial conditions rather than the cover. Repeated pairs would improve the test.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Gives a cover/no-cover comparison or a relevant controlled condition, but does not connect a suitable control to a fair comparison.
2Compares covered and uncovered otherwise comparable boxes, names at least one relevant controlled condition such as starting temperature, contents, volume, exposure, box type or duration, and explains that controlling it prevents that factor from explaining the difference.

Other acceptable ideas: A no-cover comparison is needed.; One well-explained relevant control is sufficient; repeated trials are helpful but not mandatory for full credit.; Equivalent fair paired designs are acceptable.

Explanation: I would compare otherwise identical covered and uncovered boxes with the same amount of water. I would keep their starting temperature and exposure time the same, so a final difference is less likely to come from unequal initial conditions rather than the cover. Repeated pairs would improve the test.

Item ID: Science-Believe-Q3

Question 4 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Build a reproducible investigation

Drag each action to the stage of the investigation it belongs to.

Rows / targets:

  1. Before collecting results
  2. During the comparison
  3. After collecting results
Correct answer: Before collecting results → Write the method and decide which temperatures and times will be recorded.; During the comparison → Record every planned measurement, including results that disagree with the claim.; After collecting results → Share the method, data and uncertainty so another group can repeat the work.

Explanation: A reproducible investigation specifies its method, records results consistently, and exposes enough detail for independent checking.

Item ID: Science-Believe-Q4

Question 5 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Judge a scientific source

Select all source features that help you evaluate the cooling claim scientifically.

Correct answer: A full description of how temperatures were measured.; A declaration that the author sells the product.; Data that include the variability across repeated tests.

Explanation: Access to methods and data allows checking. Disclosure of commercial interest helps assess possible bias, although a conflict of interest alone does not prove a claim false.

Item ID: Science-Believe-Q5

Data Dinosaurs

Invented specimens and values for practice. Ages are inferred from the rock layers containing each fossil. Body lengths are reconstructed from skeletons. Masses are estimates from body-volume models, not direct weighings of living animals. A larger age in millions of years means an older fossil.

SpecimenAge (million years)Reconstructed length (m)Estimated mass (kg)
A16081000
B160125000
C12091200
D806800
E80146000

Some bones are missing, and the estimates have uncertainty. The catalogue includes only five specimens and cannot represent every dinosaur that existed.

Question 1 · True or False · 2 points

Compare ages carefully

Specimen C is older than Specimen D.

Correct answer: True

Explanation: C is dated to 120 million years ago and D to 80 million years ago. The larger age is further in the past.

Item ID: Science-Dino-Q1

Question 2 · Matching Type · 2 points

What each result measures

Match each research record to the kind of information it provides.

Rows / targets:

  1. A reconstruction reports 9 metres from head to tail.
  2. A body-volume model reports 1,200 kilograms.
  3. The fossil-bearing layer is dated to about 120 million years ago.
Correct answer: A reconstruction reports 9 metres from head to tail. → Estimated body length; A body-volume model reports 1,200 kilograms. → Estimated body mass; The fossil-bearing layer is dated to about 120 million years ago. → Estimated geological age

Explanation: Length, mass and age use different units and methods. A metre is not a unit of mass, and a kilogram does not express age.

Item ID: Science-Dino-Q2

Question 3 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Test an “always” claim

A learner claims, “Every younger specimen in the table is heavier than every older specimen.” Is this supported? Explain using one specific pair of specimens and their masses.

Model response

No. D is younger than A but is estimated at only 800 kg, compared with A at 1,000 kg. That one counterexample is enough to reject the claim that every younger specimen is heavier. Other valid counterexamples also receive full credit.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Rejects the claim without a valid specific comparison, or identifies an appropriate younger/lighter pair without clearly explaining why it contradicts the claim.
2Rejects the universal claim and cites a valid younger/lighter pair, with their masses or a clear numerical comparison, such as D (800 kg, 80 million years) versus A (1,000 kg, 160 million years), or C (1,200 kg) versus B (5,000 kg).

Other acceptable ideas: D versus A, B or C is a valid younger/lighter pair.; C versus B is also valid.; Do not demand a trend description beyond the requested counterexample.

Explanation: No. D is younger than A but is estimated at only 800 kg, compared with A at 1,000 kg. That one counterexample is enough to reject the claim that every younger specimen is heavier. Other valid counterexamples also receive full credit.

Item ID: Science-Dino-Q3

Question 4 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Limits of fossil data

Select all reasons to avoid treating this small catalogue as a complete history of dinosaur body size.

Correct answer: Some species or sizes may be poorly represented in the fossil record.; Estimated masses may change when more complete skeletons or better models become available.; The catalogue contains only five specimens.

Explanation: Incomplete preservation and modelling uncertainty affect estimates, and five specimens are not an exhaustive sample of dinosaurs.

Item ID: Science-Dino-Q4

Question 5 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

Check a reconstruction

Two teams estimate different masses from the same incomplete skeleton. What is the most useful next step?

Correct answer: Compare the teams’ reconstruction assumptions and test the models against more complete specimens.

Explanation: Comparing assumptions and testing methods on more complete specimens helps identify why estimates differ and whether either model is better supported.

Item ID: Science-Dino-Q5

Top Predators

Hypothetical sanctuary model. Eagles eat rabbits and snakes. Snakes eat mice. Rabbits eat grass, and mice eat seeds. For these questions, assume that increasing a predator reduces the prey it eats, and that other influences are initially unchanged. These are short-term model predictions, not guaranteed results for every real ecosystem.

A field team can count animals with repeated camera surveys, estimate grass cover in fixed ground plots, and record seeds remaining in marked patches. Weather, migration and disease can also change the populations.

Question 1 · True or False · 2 points

A direct interaction

In this model, an eagle eating a rabbit is a direct interaction.

Correct answer: True

Explanation: The predator and prey interact through feeding without another species in between; effects on grass involve an intermediate step.

Item ID: Science-Pred-Q1

Question 2 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

An indirect effect

According to the stated model, explain how increasing eagles could increase grass cover. Include the intermediate population in your explanation.

Model response

More eagles could reduce the rabbit population. With fewer rabbits grazing, less grass is eaten, so grass cover could increase. This is an indirect prediction through rabbits, assuming other factors remain unchanged.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Names one valid part of the chain, such as fewer rabbits or more grass, but does not connect eagles, rabbits and grazing correctly.
2Explains the complete conditional chain: more eagles reduce rabbits, fewer rabbits eat less grass, and grass can therefore increase.

Other acceptable ideas: Eagles increase → rabbits decrease → grazing decreases → grass increases.; Equivalent wording such as less herbivory is valid.; Real-world certainty must not be required.

Explanation: More eagles could reduce the rabbit population. With fewer rabbits grazing, less grass is eaten, so grass cover could increase. This is an indirect prediction through rabbits, assuming other factors remain unchanged.

Item ID: Science-Pred-Q2

Question 3 · Matching Type · 2 points

Collect relevant evidence

Match each model prediction with the field observation most directly suited to checking it.

Rows / targets:

  1. Rabbit abundance changes.
  2. Grass cover changes.
  3. Seeds remaining on the ground change.
Correct answer: Rabbit abundance changes. → Repeated rabbit counts using the same camera-survey effort; Grass cover changes. → Percentage grass cover in the same fixed plots; Seeds remaining on the ground change. → Seed counts in marked patches using the same sampling method

Explanation: Using the same sampling method over time makes each comparison more meaningful; one population measure does not directly measure all others.

Item ID: Science-Pred-Q3

Question 4 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Why a model may differ from a field result

Select all changes that could make field results differ from these simple predictions.

Correct answer: Large numbers of rabbits migrate into the sanctuary.; Rainfall changes substantially and affects grass growth.; A disease changes the mouse population.

Explanation: The model holds other influences fixed. Immigration and weather-driven growth can alter the real system independently of the stated feeding links.

Item ID: Science-Pred-Q4

Question 5 · Drop Down Selection · 2 points

Follow a second pathway

Use the same model to predict each change after eagle numbers rise. Select one answer in each row. Options may be used more than once.

Rows / targets:

  1. Number of snakes
  2. Number of mice
  3. Seeds remaining after feeding
Correct answer: Number of snakes → Decreases; Number of mice → Increases; Seeds remaining after feeding → Decreases

Explanation: More eagles reduce snakes. Fewer snakes allow mice to increase, and more mice consume more seeds, leaving fewer seeds in the ground patches.

Item ID: Science-Pred-Q5

Bird Migration

Fictional shorebird tracking records. Trained, authorised researchers use unique tags to identify individual birds. The same bird may be observed at more than one wetland. Volunteers record the date, site, observation duration and tag identity when visible.

BirdFirst recordMiddle recordLast record
XNorth wetland, 1 OctoberWest wetland, 3 OctoberSouth wetland, 7 October
YNorth wetland, 1 OctoberEast wetland, 4 OctoberSouth wetland, 8 October

On one survey morning, West has 80 sightings in four hours and East has 45 sightings in one hour. A sighting is a detection, not necessarily a different bird.

Question 1 · True or False · 2 points

Counting individuals

Adding all sightings at all wetlands necessarily gives the exact number of individual birds migrating.

Correct answer: False

Explanation: A single bird may be sighted repeatedly or at several wetlands, while other birds may be missed. Individual tags help distinguish sightings from unique birds.

Item ID: Science-BirdMigration-Q1

Question 2 · Hot Spot · 2 points

Locate a recorded stopover

Select the middle wetland recorded for Bird X but not for Bird Y.

Observed migration sitesNorthWestEastSouthDashed lines connect recorded sites; paths between sites are unknown.
Correct answer: West wetland

Explanation: The table records Bird X at West on 3 October. Bird Y’s middle record is East, so the unique recorded middle site for X is West.

Item ID: Science-BirdMigration-Q2

Question 3 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

A lower count in fog

A volunteer counts fewer birds on a foggy morning than on a clear morning. Explain one way fog could change the recorded count without changing the actual number of birds present.

Model response

Fog reduces visibility, so some birds present may not be seen or identified. The recorded count could decrease because detection is poorer, rather than because fewer birds are actually present.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Identifies reduced visibility or missed birds, but does not explain the resulting difference between detection and actual abundance.
2Explains that fog can hide birds or make detection/identification harder, so observers record fewer sightings even if the same number of birds is present.

Other acceptable ideas: Birds obscured by fog are missed, causing an undercount.; Difficulty identifying birds/tags can reduce the number recorded.; A clear factor-to-count explanation is required, not a claim that fog must kill birds.

Explanation: Fog reduces visibility, so some birds present may not be seen or identified. The recorded count could decrease because detection is poorer, rather than because fewer birds are actually present.

Item ID: Science-BirdMigration-Q3

Question 4 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Compare annual surveys

Select all actions that would make comparisons between this year’s and next year’s counts more reliable.

Correct answer: Use comparable dates, observation times and survey durations.; Record visibility and weather during each survey.; Train observers to use the same counting and identification rules.

Explanation: Comparable timing, effort and records of observation conditions help separate population changes from changes in how counts were collected.

Item ID: Science-BirdMigration-Q4

Question 5 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Organise a tracking record

Drag each action into the correct stage of a tag-based study. Only trained, authorised researchers handle birds.

Rows / targets:

  1. Establish the identity record
  2. Collect a later observation
  3. Reconstruct the sequence of sites
Correct answer: Establish the identity record → Record a unique tag identifier and the release date and site.; Collect a later observation → Record the tag identifier, date and location of a sighting.; Reconstruct the sequence of sites → Link records with the same identifier and order them by date.

Explanation: Unique identifiers link records to an individual. Dates then allow researchers to reconstruct the sequence of recorded sites without assuming the exact route between them.

Item ID: Science-BirdMigration-Q5

Running in Hot Weather

Invented exercise simulation for science practice. It models the same runner doing the same activity for 45 minutes without drinking. Sweat that evaporates removes heat from skin; sweat that drips off has not removed the same evaporative heat. Humid air can slow evaporation. These model outputs are not personalised safety limits or exercise advice.

RunAir temperature (°C)Relative humidity (%)Model water loss (kg)Final body temperature (°C)
A28300.937.5
B28801.038.2
C34301.338.0

The starting body temperature is 37.0 °C in all three runs. Relative humidity describes how close air is to saturation with water vapour at its temperature.

Question 1 · True or False · 2 points

Control the comparison

Comparing A and B changes humidity while holding the stated air temperature fixed.

Correct answer: True

Explanation: Both runs use 28 °C air. Their stated humidity settings are 30% and 80%, while the same runner and activity are modelled.

Item ID: Science-Run-Q1

Question 2 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Water loss and heat loss

Explain why replacing lost water by drinking does not, by itself, guarantee that a runner’s body temperature stays unchanged in very humid air.

Model response

Drinking replaces water lost from the body, but that is not the same as removing all the heat produced during exercise. In humid air, less sweat may evaporate effectively, so less heat is carried away. Temperature may still rise when heat gain exceeds heat loss.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Explains either that drinking replaces water or that humidity reduces evaporative cooling, but does not connect the two different balances.
2Distinguishes water balance from heat balance: drinking can replace lost water, but high humidity can limit sweat evaporation and heat removal, so body temperature can still rise if heat gain exceeds heat loss.

Other acceptable ideas: Drinking reduces a water deficit.; Evaporation, not merely producing sweat, removes substantial heat.; Full credit requires connecting the limited cooling to possible continued temperature rise.

Explanation: Drinking replaces water lost from the body, but that is not the same as removing all the heat produced during exercise. In humid air, less sweat may evaporate effectively, so less heat is carried away. Temperature may still rise when heat gain exceeds heat loss.

Item ID: Science-Run-Q2

Question 3 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

Apply a model carefully

Why should the table not be used to declare one fixed exercise duration safe for every person?

Correct answer: Real people vary in health, fitness, clothing and other conditions not represented by one model runner.

Explanation: The simulation represents one set of assumptions. People and conditions vary, so these few invented outputs cannot establish individual safety limits.

Item ID: Science-Run-Q3

Question 4 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Match the measurement

Drag the appropriate measurement to each observation a researcher wants to record.

Rows / targets:

  1. Change in the runner’s body mass
  2. The surrounding air’s humidity
  3. The runner’s body temperature
Correct answer: Change in the runner’s body mass → Mass measurement in kilograms; The surrounding air’s humidity → Relative-humidity measurement in percent; The runner’s body temperature → Temperature measurement in degrees Celsius

Explanation: Each measurement has a specific physical meaning. A change in mass is not a direct reading of body temperature or air humidity.

Item ID: Science-Run-Q4

Question 5 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Questions the simulator can address

Select all questions that can be investigated by changing only the stated environmental settings while keeping the runner and activity fixed.

Correct answer: How does predicted water loss change when humidity changes at 28 °C?; How does predicted final temperature change when air temperature changes at 30% humidity?

Explanation: The stated settings allow comparisons of air temperature and humidity within the model. They cannot establish a medical diagnosis or guarantee outcomes for all people.

Item ID: Science-Run-Q5

Slope-face Investigation

Invented valley measurements. Students compare two slopes during the same week. These are observations, not the result of randomly assigning slopes to treatments.

MeasureSlope ASlope B
Daily direct sunlight8 hours11 hours
Mean soil moisture30%18%
Weekly rainfall20 mm20 mm
Soil textureLoamSandy
Vegetation cover75%40%

Soil texture can affect how water drains and is retained. The students want to compare sensor readings at the same elevation and soil depth.

Question 1 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

Check an alternative explanation

Why can these observations alone not show that sunlight is the only cause of the difference in soil moisture?

Correct answer: The soil textures differ and can also influence water retention.

Explanation: The slopes differ in soil texture as well as sunlight. Different drainage or water retention could also contribute to the observed moisture difference.

Item ID: Science-Slope-Q1

Question 2 · Hot Spot · 2 points

Match elevation

Select the proposed site on Slope B that matches the elevation of the existing sensor on Slope A.

Choose a comparable sensor position100 mSlope ASlope BExisting sensorPQRAll new sensors would use the same soil depth.
Correct answer: Q: Slope B, 100 m

Explanation: Q lies on the same dashed 100 m elevation line as the existing sensor. P is on the valley floor and R is higher on Slope B.

Item ID: Science-Slope-Q2

Question 3 · Multiple Answers · 2 points

Improve the sampling

Select all actions that would improve the reliability of the slope comparison.

Correct answer: Measure both slopes at the same planned times over several days.; Use several comparable sampling sites on each slope.; Calibrate the sensors and use the same measurement depth.

Explanation: Repeated comparable measurements and multiple locations reduce dependence on one unusual time or place. Selectively discarding inconvenient values would bias the results.

Item ID: Science-Slope-Q3

Question 4 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Equal rain, unequal moisture

Give one scientifically plausible reason why soil moisture could differ even though the slopes receive the same rainfall. Explain how your factor could affect the amount of water remaining in the soil.

Model response

The sandy soil on B may drain water more rapidly than the loam on A, leaving less water in the measured soil after the same rain. Another valid explanation is that greater sunlight can increase evaporation and reduce water remaining. Either well-explained mechanism is sufficient.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Names a relevant factor such as soil texture, drainage, evaporation or plant uptake, but does not explain how it changes soil water.
2Names a plausible factor and explains the directional mechanism, for example sandy soil drains water more rapidly, or greater sunlight can increase evaporation, leaving less water in the soil.

Other acceptable ideas: Texture affects drainage or retention.; More evaporation can leave less soil water.; Differences in plant uptake or runoff are acceptable with a correct mechanism; do not require two factors.

Explanation: The sandy soil on B may drain water more rapidly than the loam on A, leaving less water in the measured soil after the same rain. Another valid explanation is that greater sunlight can increase evaporation and reduce water remaining. Either well-explained mechanism is sufficient.

Item ID: Science-Slope-Q4

Question 5 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Choose a field instrument

Drag the most suitable instrument to the students’ measurement task.

Rows / targets:

  1. Record sunlight energy arriving during the day
  2. Record the proportion of water in soil
  3. Collect and measure precipitation over the week
Correct answer: Record sunlight energy arriving during the day → Solar-radiation sensor and logger; Record the proportion of water in soil → Soil-moisture probe; Collect and measure precipitation over the week → Rain gauge

Explanation: The instrument must measure the intended variable: incoming radiation, soil water or rainfall. Using the right tool also requires consistent placement and calibration.

Item ID: Science-Slope-Q5

Meteoroids and Craters

Small rocks in space are called meteoroids. A meteor is the luminous event produced when material enters an atmosphere at high speed. A surviving fragment that reaches the ground is a meteorite. Some incoming material does not survive to the ground.

Invented classroom impact test. A teacher drops the same 10 g sphere into identical freshly levelled sand trays. The sphere is released without a push. Each value is a mean from repeated trials.

Release height (m)Mean crater diameter (cm)
0.23.1
0.44.2
0.65.0

For a real impact, crater size can depend on mass, speed, angle and the material struck. A sand-tray model does not reproduce every feature of a space impact.

Question 1 · Matching Type · 2 points

Identify the stage

Match each description to the correct scientific term.

Rows / targets:

  1. A small rocky object while it is still in space
  2. A bright streak produced during entry into an atmosphere
  3. A surviving rock fragment recovered on the ground
Correct answer: A small rocky object while it is still in space → Meteoroid; A bright streak produced during entry into an atmosphere → Meteor; A surviving rock fragment recovered on the ground → Meteorite

Explanation: The terms refer to different stages or phenomena. The meteor is the luminous event, while a meteorite is surviving material on the ground.

Item ID: Science-Meteoroids-Q1

Question 2 · Drag and Drop · 2 points

Separate the variables

Drag each quantity to its role in the stated classroom investigation.

Rows / targets:

  1. The quantity deliberately changed between trials
  2. The main outcome measured after each drop
  3. A quantity kept the same to make the comparison fair
Correct answer: The quantity deliberately changed between trials → The sphere’s release height; The main outcome measured after each drop → The crater’s diameter; A quantity kept the same to make the comparison fair → The sphere’s mass and identity

Explanation: Height is the manipulated variable, crater diameter is the measured response, and using the same sphere controls its mass and size.

Item ID: Science-Meteoroids-Q2

Question 3 · Drop Down Selection · 2 points

Reason through the drop

Compare a release from 0.60 m with one from 0.20 m in this same setup. Choose the expected change for each quantity. Ignore air resistance. Options may be used more than once.

Rows / targets:

  1. Gravitational potential energy relative to the sand at release
  2. Kinetic energy just before impact
  3. Mass of the sphere
Correct answer: Gravitational potential energy relative to the sand at release → Higher; Kinetic energy just before impact → Higher; Mass of the sphere → Unchanged

Explanation: A greater release height gives the same sphere more gravitational potential energy and therefore more kinetic energy just before impact; the sphere’s mass is unchanged.

Item ID: Science-Meteoroids-Q3

Question 4 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

A limit of crater evidence

A learner uses crater diameter alone to claim the exact mass of a meteorite. Explain why the claim is not justified, naming one other factor that can affect crater size.

Model response

Impact speed also affects the energy delivered and the crater formed. A smaller fast object and a larger slower object could produce similar crater sizes under suitable conditions. Without information about speed and other conditions, diameter alone cannot give one exact mass.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Names another relevant factor or states that diameter alone is insufficient, but does not explain why the mass cannot be uniquely inferred.
2Identifies another factor such as impact speed, angle or target material, and explains that it can change crater size independently of mass, so the same diameter can be consistent with different masses or conditions.

Other acceptable ideas: Speed, impact angle, or target material with a valid explanation.; Different combinations of mass and other factors can give similar crater sizes.; Do not require a calculation or an exhaustive list.

Explanation: Impact speed also affects the energy delivered and the crater formed. A smaller fast object and a larger slower object could produce similar crater sizes under suitable conditions. Without information about speed and other conditions, diameter alone cannot give one exact mass.

Item ID: Science-Meteoroids-Q4

Question 5 · True or False · 2 points

A flash does not prove a landing

Seeing a bright meteor proves that a meteorite reached the ground.

Correct answer: False

Explanation: The luminous event can occur even when the incoming material breaks up or is completely lost before reaching the ground.

Item ID: Science-Meteoroids-Q5

Sustainable Fish Farming

Fictional farm trial. Water flows from a fish tank through a settling tank, a biological filter and a seaweed tank before discharge. The settling tank removes settleable particles. The biological filter converts ammonia into nitrate. Growing seaweed takes up dissolved nutrients when sufficient light and other conditions are available.

Feed trialWild-fish ingredient (% of feed)Fish growth indexSurvival (%)
P3010098
Q109998
R07070

Feed trials use otherwise comparable conditions. Separate discharge measurements are: Setting 1, 10 litres per minute with 4 mg of a measured nutrient per litre; Setting 2, 20 litres per minute with 2 mg per litre. Litres per minute describe flow, while mg per litre describe concentration.

Question 1 · Multiple Choice · 2 points

Compare feed alternatives

Which feed trial offers the strongest evidence here for reducing use of wild-fish ingredients while retaining similar growth and survival to P?

Correct answer: Q, because it uses less wild-fish ingredient with similar measured performance.

Explanation: Q uses 10% rather than 30% wild-fish ingredients, while growth is 99 compared with 100 and survival is the same. R uses none but has much poorer growth and survival in this trial.

Item ID: Science-Fish-Q1

Question 2 · Hot Spot · 2 points

Measure the final effluent

Select the sampling tap that measures water after all three treatment stages, just before discharge.

Treatment system — water flows left to rightFishtankSettlingtankBiologicalfilterSeaweedtankABCDSample taps are at the outlet of the tank directly above.D leads to discharge.
Correct answer: Tap D at the outlet of seaweed tank

Explanation: D is at the outlet of the seaweed tank, downstream of settling and biological filtration. It therefore samples the final treated discharge.

Item ID: Science-Fish-Q2

Question 3 · Open Ended / Short Answer · 2 points

Concentration is not the whole load

Does Setting 2 release less of the measured nutrient per minute than Setting 1? Calculate or compare the nutrient mass released per minute and explain your conclusion.

Model response

No. Setting 1 releases 10 L/min × 4 mg/L = 40 mg/min. Setting 2 releases 20 L/min × 2 mg/L = 40 mg/min. Doubling the flow while halving the concentration leaves the nutrient mass released per minute unchanged.

ScoreCriteria
0Wrong, irrelevant, or no answer; no scientifically valid part of the requested explanation.
1Correctly calculates one release rate, or correctly says the total is unchanged without showing how flow and concentration combine.
2Calculates or clearly explains that 10 × 4 = 40 mg/min and 20 × 2 = 40 mg/min, then concludes that the released mass per minute is unchanged even though concentration is halved.

Other acceptable ideas: Both settings release 40 mg per minute.; Equivalent ratio reasoning without explicit units may receive full credit if the quantity and conclusion are unambiguous.; A lower concentration alone is insufficient evidence of a lower nutrient load.

Explanation: No. Setting 1 releases 10 L/min × 4 mg/L = 40 mg/min. Setting 2 releases 20 L/min × 2 mg/L = 40 mg/min. Doubling the flow while halving the concentration leaves the nutrient mass released per minute unchanged.

Item ID: Science-Fish-Q3

Question 4 · Drop Down Selection · 2 points

Follow different waste forms

Choose the most directly expected change at each stated treatment stage. Options may be used more than once.

Rows / targets:

  1. Settleable particles after the settling tank
  2. Ammonia after the biological filter is working effectively
  3. Dissolved nutrient concentration after effective seaweed uptake
Correct answer: Settleable particles after the settling tank → Decreases; Ammonia after the biological filter is working effectively → Decreases; Dissolved nutrient concentration after effective seaweed uptake → Decreases

Explanation: Settling removes settleable particles. Biological conversion decreases ammonia while producing nitrate. Seaweed growth can take up dissolved nutrients.

Item ID: Science-Fish-Q4

Question 5 · True or False · 2 points

Check more than appearance

Clear-looking discharge water alone proves that all dissolved nutrients have been removed.

Correct answer: False

Explanation: Dissolved nutrients may be present in clear water. Their removal needs appropriate concentration measurements, not just a visual judgement.

Item ID: Science-Fish-Q5

Sources and authorship

These are newly authored practice questions on the topics in the existing modules. They are not official OECD PISA assessment items. Fictional and simulated data are identified in the source material.