Teacher guide · 29 October 2026

Science: worked examples, formative practice and mastery

Original practice for the Science topics supplied by the teacher.

Learning sequence in every activity

  1. Four concept lesson pages introduce the topic for approximately 10-year-old learners.
  2. Three worked question-and-answer examples show a source, a question, its answer and why the answer works.
  3. Five formative questions use four distinct objective formats and one short-answer or open-ended response. Each has a scientific explorer, scoring and twelve feedback-language choices.
  4. Formative review shows the five item scores and a score out of 10. Learners can review or continue to mastery. An unavailable written AI score stays pending and can retry while they continue.
  5. Five mastery and critical-thinking pairs provide ten new questions and a separate score out of 20.
  6. Final summary shows formative /10, mastery /20, combined /30, and the current attempt’s saving and upload status. All fifteen responses are included in reporting.
Mastery pairThinking focusMaximum
1Applied Reasoning2 interactive + 2 written points
2Justify Choice4 points
3Transfer Application4 points
4Error Analysis4 points
5Design / Propose4 points

These five thinking stages are the requested teaching sequence, not the OECD PISA proficiency scale. The questions and numerical classroom cases are original practice, not official released PISA items. Scientific concepts are checked against the primary sources listed below. Formative scores and mastery scores describe different stages of practice; the combined total is for complete module reporting.

Scientific explorations

The activities adapt interaction patterns from the supplied TEACHAID MATH119 Concept Mastery R9 and TEACHAID 122 Concept First R12 collections. New embedded SVG workbenches cover particles and chemical changes, circuits, motion and forces, energy pathways, waves and rays, cells and body systems, genetics, ecosystems, Earth and space, measurement and evidence evaluation.

Thirty-four new Science workbench families are available, alongside suitable data, graph, sampling, chance, unit and coordinate tools from the Mathematics collection. Every topic uses at least three relevant interaction families in its formative section and three in its mastery section. Students can adjust controls, run trials or model steps, compare views A and B, and write investigation notes. The fixed question information remains visible: assessment scores refer to those stated facts, not an unrecorded random outcome or an accidentally changed setting.

These are simplified learning models with explicit assumptions. A classroom erosion index is not a real soil-loss forecast; a greenhouse radiation diagram is not an equilibrium climate model; a hypothetical health comparison is not a vaccine-effectiveness estimate. Energy and matter budgets are conserved within their stated model boundaries. Advanced topics are introduced through small, concrete cases for young learners. All practical experiments should follow the teacher’s approved classroom procedures; the activities themselves use virtual models.

Question-type selection is seeded and balanced during authoring. Each formative quiz has four different objective formats plus one written item. Each mastery section has five different objective formats paired with written reasoning. Together, the sections use all seven objective formats. Hotspots use appropriate plotted values, coordinates or angle diagrams where the labels have an unambiguous geometric meaning; other questions use labelled answer regions. Options vary in order when a new attempt begins. The five thinking levels stay in the requested sequence. Drag-and-drop items include click-and-place and dropdown alternatives; movable model handles also have ordinary controls.

The collection follows the teacher’s 166-topic list and draws on the OECD PISA 2025 Science Framework: explaining phenomena; evaluating enquiry and interpreting evidence; and evaluating and using scientific information for decisions. Formal PISA assessment targets 15-year-olds. These are age-adapted foundations for approximately 10-year-old learners, not an official PISA assessment or a validated proficiency scale. OECD PISA 2025 Science Framework.

Opening and completing a module

  1. Use Extract All on the ZIP. Open START_HERE.html or any individual activity HTML.
  2. Complete consent. Choose Region, Division and School, check the school code, and enter the learner initials, section and grade.
  3. Read the concepts and worked examples, then complete the formative quiz. The formative review leads to mastery.
  4. Use the question’s scientific workbench and investigation notebook. The stated question data remain fixed while the explorer changes. Drag-and-drop items also support selecting a token then its target.
  5. At the last question, open Results. Saving and uploading are automatic; no separate Submit button is required.
  6. Try Again reloads this standalone file and starts with fresh consent. Prior saved reports remain available to the reporting service.

Every activity is one complete HTML. It works without companion assets, a local web server, an installer or an executable. Use a current browser with JavaScript, IndexedDB and gzip DecompressionStream support. Lessons, sources and objective questions work offline. Live AI feedback, nonblank written scoring and uploads need internet access.

Scoring and multilingual feedback

Single-choice, true/false and hotspot items receive 2 for a correct answer and 0 otherwise. Matching, dropdown and drag-and-drop items receive 2 for all correct mappings, 1 for some correct mappings, and 0 for none. Multiple-answer items receive 2 for the exact correct set, 1 for a nonempty correct subset with no incorrect choice, and 0 if any incorrect option is selected.

Each written item has two explicit content requirements. A response meeting both receives an AI estimate of 2; one receives 1; neither, an irrelevant response, or a blank receives 0. The model is given the full source, question, reference answer, learner response and rubric. Equivalent reasoning and valid alternative proposals are accepted. Spelling and grammar are not scored unless meaning is unclear.

Blank written responses receive 0 locally. Nonblank responses use the existing AI scoring service. Missing, invalid or failed AI results stay pending; they are never converted into a zero or N/A. Final performance reports wait for all required estimates. Changing a written answer invalidates its previous AI score.

The feedback choices are English, Filipino, Ilocano, Pangasinan, Kapampangan, Bikol, Waray, Cebuano, Hiligaynon, Maranao, Maguindanaon and Tausug. Each selected-language request carries complete question context and the learner’s answer. The display rejects clearly English output for another selected language and some obvious mismatches; it does not certify fluency. Regional-language accuracy and AI grading quality depend on the deployed model and require teacher or proficient-speaker review. This update does not install or upgrade a server model.

Saving, recovery and dashboard data

The established Mathematics/Reading consent, school directory and reporting services are retained. One feedback instruction now asks for scientific reasoning and the supplied evidence. Draft responses and AI request evidence save before transmission. Completed results are frozen before their three report bodies are queued. Each activity and each attempt has its own identifier. Science uses new activity and content identifiers so records from other modules or editions cannot be mistaken for this attempt.

The staging endpoint remains https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/moodle-staging-upload.php. The supplied CSV schemas remain unchanged: 29 utilization/completion columns, 28 base and identity quiz-performance columns (29 when endpoint-request evidence is attached), and 73 item-response columns. The item-response report contains fifteen item rows. Each item’s response JSON identifies its formative or mastery phase and carries that phase’s score and maximum, with the full item context, response, rubric, simulation settings, snapshots and investigation notes and seven-page lesson progress. The performance report total is out of 30.

Live feedback uses https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/pisa-multilingual-feedback.php; written scoring uses https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/moodle-ai-feedback.php. The same existing server configuration is used. No production server changes are included in these files.

Final-summary saving and upload indicator

IndicatorMeaning
Answers saved on this deviceResponses are retained while AI scores or final report preparation are pending.
Saved on this deviceThe completed attempt and all three report bodies are saved locally.
Queued for upload · 0/3 confirmedThe saved reports are waiting for server receipts. Upload retries automatically.
Partly uploaded · 1/3 or 2/3 confirmedThe named reports have receipts. The remaining reports stay queued.
Upload confirmed by teachaid.ph · 3/3All three current-attempt receipts match the saved filenames and SHA-256 hashes.
Waiting for AI scores / Saving needs attentionThe final reports are not yet ready. Keep the activity open for automatic retry.

Completion, Performance and Item responses have separate status labels. Confirmation means the staging server received the reports; subsequent dashboard processing is a separate server step. Receipts from older attempts cannot mark this attempt as uploaded.

Allow browser storage and use the same browser profile when reopening pending work. Do not clear its activity data while reports or AI scores are pending. Copying an HTML file does not copy learner records. Retry runs while the activity is open and connected, or when it is reopened.

Access and presentation

The supplied Frontlearners logo, school directory, consent controls, watermark and supplied expiry remain embedded. The expiry remains 31 May 2027 at 23:59:59 device-local. The runtime is encoded to make casual inspection harder; this is not tamper-proof access control. Progress blocks track actual lessons, examples and questions within the same topic. All navigation stays in one tab.

Topic answer keys and written rubrics

Use these references to review student reasoning. Worked-example answers are teaching material; they are not scored. Quiz sources differ from the worked examples.

S1.1 · Particle model of matter

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A squeezed air box

Worked example information

A closed model box contains 18 identical dots before and after its volume is reduced.

Question: What changed, and what stayed the same?

Answer: The spacing decreased; the number of represented particles stayed 18.

Why: A smaller container need not contain less matter. The same particles occupy less available space.

Example 2 · A model is not a photograph

Worked example information

A pupil draws oxygen particles blue and nitrogen particles orange.

Question: Are real air particles large coloured balls?

Answer: No. Colours and sizes are symbols in this model.

Why: The key distinguishes particle types; it does not give their real visible appearance.

Example 3 · Follow a disappearing drop

Worked example information

A tiny drop evaporates into a closed jar. No material leaves the jar.

Question: Has the water vanished from the system?

Answer: No. Water particles now mix through the air in the jar.

Why: The particles changed their arrangement and movement; the closed jar retains the water.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Count before and after

Fixed question information

A closed box is drawn with 16 gas particles at the start. After compression it still contains 16; the available volume is smaller.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Particle count after compression; Change in average spacing

  • a: Smaller spacing
  • b: Larger spacing
  • c: 8
  • d: 16
Answer: Particle count after compression → 16; Change in average spacing → Smaller spacing

Compression changes the available space, not the count in this closed model.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F2 · A warmer dot movie

Fixed question information

Two drawings use the same 20 gas particles and equal volumes. In the warmer drawing the average speed is higher.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Feature that increases; Number of particles in each drawing

  • a: Average particle speed
  • b: Particle size doubles
  • c: 20 particles
  • d: 10 particles
Answer: Feature that increases → Average particle speed; Number of particles in each drawing → 20 particles

Heating changes average motion while the same particles remain.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F3 · Solid and gas motion

Fixed question information

Model A shows dots vibrating around fixed positions. Model B shows dots moving freely through a box.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Solid model; Gas model

  • a: Both are stationary
  • b: A
  • c: Neither model
  • d: B
Answer: Solid model → A; Gas model → B

Solid particles move by vibration; gas particles move through the container.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Same amount, more room

Fixed question information

A gas model expands from a small to a large closed box. Both drawings have 24 dots of the same kind.

F4 · Hotspot

Which quantity remains exactly 24 after the expansion?

  • a: Available volume
  • b: Number of particle types
  • c: Size of each particle
  • d: Number of particles
Answer: Number of particles

The same 24 particles spread through a larger volume.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a gas syringe

Fixed question information

A virtual closed syringe holds air. Its plunger moves inward and the trapped gas occupies less space. No air leaks.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the trapped air occupies less space. State what happens to particle spacing and particle number.

Example of a full-credit answer: There is less space between the particles. Their number stays the same because none escape.

  1. Explains reduced spacing between particles.
  2. States that particle number is unchanged in the closed syringe.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

Box A has 12 identical gas particles in 60 model volume units. Box B has the same 12 in 30 units.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Closer spacing; Equal quantity in both

  • a: Box A
  • b: 6 particles
  • c: Box B
  • d: 12 particles
Answer: Closer spacing → Box B; Equal quantity in both → 12 particles

The same particle count occupies half as much space in B.

1B · Short answer

Which box is more crowded, and why does that not mean it contains more matter?

Example of a full-credit answer: B is more crowded because its volume is smaller. Both contain the same 12 identical particles, so the represented amount is equal.

  1. Identifies B as more crowded using its smaller volume.
  2. Explains equal matter using the same count and type of particles.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Animation A warms sealed gas by moving its 20 dots faster. Animation B warms it by deleting ten dots. The dot key stays fixed.

2A · Multiple choice

Which animation better represents warming?

  • a: Both A and B
  • b: B
  • c: Neither A nor B
  • d: A
Answer: A

The sealed gas keeps its particles while average motion increases.

2B · Open ended

Choose an animation and give two reasons based on the closed container and warming.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is better. It keeps all particles in the sealed box and increases their average movement when warmed.

  1. Chooses A because particle number is preserved.
  2. Links warming to increased average particle motion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A closed flexible bag contains 10 model particles. It expands without adding or losing gas; its volume doubles.

3A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Final particle count; Average spacing

  • a: 10
  • b: Greater
  • c: Smaller
  • d: 20
Answer: Final particle count → 10; Average spacing → Greater

Expansion increases available space without adding matter.

3B · Short answer

Describe the new particle drawing. Include the count and arrangement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw the same 10 particles spread through the larger bag, with greater average spacing.

  1. Keeps 10 particles of the same kind.
  2. Shows or describes greater spacing in the larger bag.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

Rafi says, “Gas compresses because every particle shrinks to half its original size.” The closed model keeps the same dots and dot size.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Main change: Smaller atoms
  • b: Main change: Less space between particles
  • c: Particle size in this model: Unchanged
  • d: Particle size in this model: Zero after squeezing
Answer: Main change: Less space between particles; Particle size in this model: Unchanged

The model changes spacing, not the particles themselves.

4B · Open ended

Identify Rafi’s mistake and replace it with a particle explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: He confuses empty space with particle size. The particles keep their size while the gaps between them get smaller.

  1. Rejects shrinking individual particles as the model explanation.
  2. Explains compression through reduced gaps.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

You must show cool and warm gas in equal sealed boxes. Use exactly 15 dots of one type in each and arrows to show motion.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Warm drawing count: 30.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

The same dot key and count preserve matter; motion arrows show warming.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two drawings. Explain one feature that must stay the same and one that should change.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both boxes have 15 same-size dots. The warm box has longer average motion arrows to show faster particles.

  1. Keeps equal count/type and fixed drawing key.
  2. Uses a clear motion change to represent greater average speed when warm.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.2 · Properties of matter

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Same volume, different mass
Block measurements
BlockMass (g)Volume (cm³)
A105
B205

Worked example information

Blocks A and B each occupy 5 cm³. A has mass 10 g; B has mass 20 g.

Question: Which is denser?

Answer: B: 4 g/cm³, compared with A: 2 g/cm³.

Why: Equal volumes let us compare mass directly; division gives the density.

Example 2 · Two jobs in one object

Worked example information

A tray needs a heat-conducting base and a slow-conducting handle. Copper conducts heat well; wood conducts it slowly.

Question: Which material fits each job?

Answer: Copper base and wooden handle.

Why: The choice follows the required thermal property, not colour or price alone.

Example 3 · A larger piece

Worked example information

A uniform sample has mass 8 g and volume 4 cm³. A larger piece of the same material has mass 16 g and volume 8 cm³.

Question: Did density change?

Answer: No; both are 2 g/cm³.

Why: Both mass and volume doubled, so their ratio stayed the same.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read a property table

Fixed question information

Classroom samples: A has mass 24 g and volume 8 cm³. B has mass 8 g and volume 8 cm³.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: A density; B density

  • a: 3 g/cm³
  • b: 24 g/cm³
  • c: 1 g/cm³
  • d: 8 g/cm³
Answer: A density → 3 g/cm³; B density → 1 g/cm³

Divide each mass by its volume.

Scientific explorer: material lab

F2 · Choose a measuring tool

Fixed question information

A balance measures mass. A marked cylinder measures liquid volume. A ruler measures length.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which tool measures mass?

  • a: Balance
  • b: Stopwatch
  • c: Thermometer
  • d: Marked cylinder
Answer: Balance

Match the tool to the quantity.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F3 · Conducting or insulating

Fixed question information

In an identical low-voltage virtual circuit, sample K completes a conducting path and sample L does not.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Conductor: K.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

A conducting path allows current in this setup.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F4 · Keep the comparison fair

Fixed question information

A class compares heat transfer through equal-size rods made of different materials. Both start at the same temperature and receive the same heating time.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changed variable; One controlled variable

  • a: Rod length changes between tests
  • b: Heating time
  • c: Rod material
  • d: Only the student name
Answer: Changed variable → Rod material; One controlled variable → Heating time

Changing only material makes the comparison more informative.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F5 · Explain a double-size block

Fixed question information

A uniform block has mass 15 g and volume 5 cm³. A second block of the same material has mass 30 g and volume 10 cm³.

F5 · Open ended

Do the two blocks have the same density? Show both calculations.

Example of a full-credit answer: Yes. 15 ÷ 5 = 3 g/cm³ and 30 ÷ 10 = 3 g/cm³.

  1. Calculates 3 g/cm³ for the smaller block.
  2. Calculates the same density for the larger block and compares them.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: material lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

In this idealised task, a solid object floats in a liquid when its average density is below the liquid’s 1 g/cm³. Sample A: 6 g, 12 cm³; sample B: 12 g, 6 cm³.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Sample that floats; Density of B

  • a: 0.2 g/cm³
  • b: B
  • c: 2 g/cm³
  • d: A
Answer: Sample that floats → A; Density of B → 2 g/cm³

A has density 0.5; B has density 2.

1B · Open ended

Choose the floating sample and justify it using both density and the stated liquid value.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has density 6 ÷ 12 = 0.5 g/cm³, below the liquid’s 1 g/cm³.

  1. Calculates A’s density as 0.5 g/cm³.
  2. Uses the stated less-than-1 condition to justify floating.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

For a virtual warm-container handle, choose a material that transfers heat slowly and is strong enough. A: slow, strong; B: fast, strong; C: slow, weak.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Suitable material; Reason B fails

  • a: Fast heat transfer
  • b: C
  • c: A
  • d: Too weak
Answer: Suitable material → A; Reason B fails → Fast heat transfer

A meets both conditions; B fails the thermal requirement and C the strength requirement.

2B · Short answer

Choose a material and explain why the two alternatives each fail a requirement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A. B transfers heat quickly, while C is too weak.

  1. Chooses A using the slow-transfer and strength requirements.
  2. Identifies the separate failure of B and C.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A torch needs an inner conducting contact and an outer insulating cover. In virtual tests, X conducts charge and Y does not.

3A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Outer cover: Y
  • b: Outer cover: Only shiny samples
  • c: Inner contact: Neither sample
  • d: Inner contact: X
Answer: Outer cover: Y; Inner contact: X

Different electrical jobs require different properties.

3B · Open ended

Place X and Y in the torch design and explain the role of each.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use X for the contact to carry current. Use Y for the outside cover to limit charge movement through the cover.

  1. Assigns X to the conducting contact with reason.
  2. Assigns Y to the insulating cover with reason.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

Liza finds a 40 g sample occupies 10 cm³. She says its density is 400 g/cm³ because she multiplied mass and volume.

4A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Correct density: 400 g/cm³.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Density is mass per volume: 40 ÷ 10 = 4.

4B · Short answer

Identify Liza’s operation error and give the corrected density with units.

Example of a full-credit answer: She multiplied instead of dividing. Density is 40 ÷ 10 = 4 g/cm³.

  1. Identifies division of mass by volume as the correct operation.
  2. Gives 4 g/cm³.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

You have equal-size virtual rods and a temperature display. Compare how quickly energy reaches the far end when one end is warmed.

5A · Hotspot

Which variable is the intended change?

  • a: Rod length every time
  • b: Rod colour only
  • c: Material
  • d: Far-end temperature
Answer: Material

Hold geometry and heating conditions fixed; measure a relevant response.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison. Name two conditions to keep the same and describe what you would measure.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep rod size and starting/heating conditions the same. Compare far-end temperature after the same heating time.

  1. Names two relevant equal conditions, such as size, starting temperature or heating time.
  2. Measures a thermal response at a comparable location/time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.3 · States of matter

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A bowl replaces a cup

Worked example information

A learner transfers 100 mL of water from a tall cup into a wide bowl without spilling.

Question: What changes?

Answer: Shape changes; volume remains about 100 mL.

Why: A liquid takes the container’s shape while retaining its volume.

Example 2 · The pouring puzzle

Worked example information

Dry rice pours out of a bag. Each grain keeps its shape.

Question: Does pouring prove the rice is liquid?

Answer: No. Rice is a collection of solid grains.

Why: The movement of a collection does not determine the state of each grain.

Example 3 · A sealed gas box

Worked example information

A gas moves from a small connected chamber into a larger empty one. No gas escapes.

Question: Where does it spread?

Answer: Through the available space in both chambers.

Why: Gas particles travel between collisions and spread through connected space.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify three models

Fixed question information

A keeps shape and volume. B changes shape but keeps volume. C fills its container.

F1 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Solid model; Liquid model

  • a: All three
  • b: B
  • c: C
  • d: A
Answer: Solid model → A; Liquid model → B

Shape and volume together identify the models.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F2 · Compare close particles

Fixed question information

In diagram L, close particles move past neighbours. In diagram G, particles move freely with large gaps.

F2 · Hotspot

Which represents liquid?

  • a: Neither has motion
  • b: L
  • c: G
  • d: Both are gas
Answer: L

Liquids are close-packed but mobile; gases have larger gaps.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F3 · Count a transferred liquid

Fixed question information

A sealed transfer moves 60 mL of liquid into a different-shaped container. None spills or evaporates.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Final volume: 120 mL.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

The liquid changes shape while keeping its volume.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A bag of beads

Fixed question information

A bag of beads changes outside shape when poured. Each bead keeps its shape and volume.

F4 · Multiple choice

What state are the beads?

  • a: Gas
  • b: A mixture of liquid and gas
  • c: Solid
  • d: Liquid
Answer: Solid

A collection of solids can flow past one another.

Scientific explorer: material lab

F5 · Air and water syringes

Fixed question information

Two closed virtual syringes start with equal volume, one containing air and one water. The air volume reduces much more under a comparable push.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why air compresses more readily than water using particle spacing and the absence of leaks.

Example of a full-credit answer: Air has larger gaps between particles. Compression reduces the gaps while the same trapped particles remain.

  1. Explains larger initial gaps in the gas.
  2. States particles remain trapped while gaps decrease.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A display needs a material that keeps its own shape on a shelf. Sample P keeps shape and volume; Q flows to its tray’s shape; R spreads through the box.

1A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Chosen sample; State of Q

  • a: Liquid
  • b: P
  • c: Q
  • d: Gas
Answer: Chosen sample → P; State of Q → Liquid

P behaves as a solid, while Q behaves as a liquid.

1B · Short answer

Choose a sample and explain the two observations that identify its state.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose P because it keeps both its own shape and its volume. These are solid-like properties.

  1. Chooses P based on maintaining shape.
  2. Uses maintained volume to justify its solid state.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Movie A has solid particles vibrating near fixed positions. Movie B has every solid particle travelling across the container.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Better solid model; B resembles

  • a: No motion anywhere
  • b: B
  • c: Gas motion
  • d: A
Answer: Better solid model → A; B resembles → Gas motion

Solids have vibration without gas-like free travel.

2B · Open ended

Choose the better movie and explain why “solids have no motion” is also incorrect.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is better because particles remain near positions. They still vibrate, so motion does not stop.

  1. Chooses A with position-based reasoning.
  2. Explicitly recognises vibration rather than no motion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A sealed 80 mL oil sample is moved from a narrow tube into a wider vessel without loss.

3A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Final volume; Shape after transfer

  • a: 80 mL
  • b: Original tube shape
  • c: Wider vessel shape
  • d: 40 mL
Answer: Final volume → 80 mL; Shape after transfer → Wider vessel shape

A liquid’s volume is retained while its shape follows its new container.

3B · Short answer

Predict the oil’s shape and volume and link each to liquid behaviour.

Example of a full-credit answer: It takes the wider vessel’s shape but remains about 80 mL because liquids keep volume when none is lost.

  1. Predicts the new container’s shape.
  2. Predicts 80 mL and links it to retained liquid volume.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says, “The empty-looking air in a closed bottle is not matter because it has no fixed shape.” Air has measurable mass and occupies the bottle.

4A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Evidence for matter: Mass and occupied space.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Matter need not have fixed shape; gases have mass and occupy space.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim using two properties of air.

Example of a full-credit answer: Air is matter because it has mass and takes up space, even though it takes the container’s shape.

  1. Uses air’s mass as evidence.
  2. Uses occupied space and rejects fixed shape as a requirement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

You must distinguish a solid block, a liquid sample and a gas using virtual observations. Do not rely on colour.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Poor observation: Colour alone
  • b: Useful observation: Whether volume fills the container
  • c: Poor observation: Both always keep shape
  • d: Useful observation: Both have no mass
Answer: Poor observation: Colour alone; Useful observation: Whether volume fills the container

Both liquids and gases can flow, but gases fill available volume.

5B · Open ended

Propose a two-step sorting rule using shape and volume.

Example of a full-credit answer: First identify the sample keeping its own shape as solid. Of the others, the one retaining volume is liquid and the one filling available space is gas.

  1. Uses retained own shape to identify the solid.
  2. Uses retained versus container-filling volume to distinguish liquid and gas.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.4 · Changes of state

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Cold lid droplets

Worked example information

Water vapour in a sealed jar touches a cooler lid and forms drops.

Question: What change occurs?

Answer: Condensation: gas becomes liquid.

Why: Energy transfers from the vapour as droplets form.

Example 2 · A melting temperature record
Model melting record
MinuteTemperature (°C)
10
20
30

Worked example information

A classroom model records 0°C while pure ice melts at fixed ordinary pressure. Energy continues to enter.

Question: Why can the temperature stay level?

Answer: Energy is used in the change from solid to liquid.

Why: A state-change interval is different from simply warming one state.

Example 3 · A drying paintbrush

Worked example information

Water on a brush slowly leaves as vapour in a room well below 100°C.

Question: Must it have boiled?

Answer: No. Evaporation can occur below boiling temperature.

Why: Surface particles can leave a liquid over a range of temperatures.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the arrows

Fixed question information

Arrow A: solid water → liquid water. Arrow B: liquid water → solid water.

F1 · Hotspot

What is arrow A called?

  • a: Evaporation
  • b: Condensation
  • c: Melting
  • d: Freezing
Answer: Melting

The names depend on the starting and ending states.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Vapour on a cold tile

Fixed question information

Water vapour cools on a tile and forms liquid drops.

F2 · Multiple choice

What is the change?

  • a: From vapour to surroundings
  • b: Melting
  • c: Into vapour only
  • d: Condensation
Answer: Condensation

Gas becomes liquid and releases energy.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F3 · Warm but not boiling

Fixed question information

Two identical wet cloths are compared in a virtual task. A dries at 25°C; B is still wet. Neither liquid boils.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Process; Where it occurs

  • a: Evaporation
  • b: Liquid surface
  • c: Only inside bubbles
  • d: Freezing
Answer: Process → Evaporation; Where it occurs → Liquid surface

Evaporation does not require boiling.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Melting in a closed bag

Fixed question information

A sealed bag and its ice have total mass 90 g. The ice melts; nothing leaks.

F4 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Final mass: 45 g.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

A closed-system state change conserves mass.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · Explain outside droplets

Fixed question information

A sealed cold bottle is dry at first. Drops later form on its outside from humid room air. The bottle does not leak.

F5 · Open ended

Where did the outside water come from, and what state change produced it?

Example of a full-credit answer: It came from water vapour in the surrounding air. The vapour cooled and condensed into liquid on the cold surface.

  1. Identifies surrounding air’s water vapour as the source.
  2. Explains gas-to-liquid condensation on the cold surface.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A sealed container totals 120 g before melting and has no leaks. Afterward all ice has become liquid.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Final total mass; Energy direction for melting

  • a: 60 g
  • b: 120 g
  • c: Out of the ice
  • d: Into the ice
Answer: Final total mass → 120 g; Energy direction for melting → Into the ice

The same matter remains while energy enables melting.

1B · Open ended

Predict mass and explain why melting does not halve the amount of matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total remains 120 g. The particles are rearranged into liquid but none leave the sealed container.

  1. Predicts 120 g total mass.
  2. Explains retained particles/matter in the closed system.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Explanation A says room-temperature water can evaporate at its surface. Explanation B says drying proves that all the water reached boiling temperature.

2A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Mistaken requirement in B: Boiling is necessary
  • b: Better explanation: B
  • c: Better explanation: A
  • d: Mistaken requirement in B: Surface evaporation is possible
Answer: Mistaken requirement in B: Boiling is necessary; Better explanation: A

Evaporation occurs below boiling.

2B · Short answer

Choose an explanation and use the drying conditions to reject the other.

Example of a full-credit answer: A fits. The water dried at room temperature, and surface evaporation can occur without boiling.

  1. Chooses A with surface evaporation reasoning.
  2. Rejects boiling as necessary under the stated conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

After warm moist air reaches a cool mirror, tiny liquid droplets appear. No liquid was splashed onto it.

3A · Multiple choice

Which change forms the droplets?

  • a: Gas
  • b: Condensation
  • c: Solid
  • d: Melting
Answer: Condensation

Water vapour cools and becomes liquid.

3B · Open ended

Explain the mirror’s droplets using the starting state and energy transfer.

Example of a full-credit answer: Water starts as vapour in the air. It transfers energy to the cooler surface and condenses into liquid.

  1. Identifies gas/vapour as the starting state.
  2. Links cooling/energy loss to liquid formation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A model of a pure substance melts at a constant temperature while a heater supplies energy. Dina says, “A flat temperature means no energy was supplied.”

4A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Role of energy; Temperature during interval

  • a: Creating new atoms
  • b: Changing the state
  • c: Constant
  • d: Rising every second
Answer: Role of energy → Changing the state; Temperature during interval → Constant

Energy changes particle arrangement during melting.

4B · Short answer

Explain Dina’s error and what the energy is doing.

Example of a full-credit answer: Temperature is not the only sign of energy transfer. Energy is entering and enabling the solid-to-liquid change while temperature stays constant.

  1. Rejects the claim that constant temperature means no energy transfer.
  2. Identifies melting/state change as the energy use.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Design a sealed virtual model showing liquid water become vapour and then liquid again. No water may be added or lost.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Final process; Total water matter

  • a: Freezing
  • b: Unchanged
  • c: Condensation
  • d: Destroyed
Answer: Final process → Condensation; Total water matter → Unchanged

Evaporation followed by condensation moves energy but preserves the sealed water.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two changes and explain how to keep the amount of water unchanged.

Example of a full-credit answer: Add energy so some liquid evaporates, then cool the vapour so it condenses. Keep the system sealed to prevent water loss.

  1. Includes evaporation followed by condensation with correct energy directions.
  2. Keeps the system closed and explains conservation of water matter.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.5 · Elements, compounds and mixtures

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Pairs can still be an element

Worked example information

A model shows only O–O pairs, with O meaning oxygen.

Question: How is the sample classified?

Answer: An element.

Why: Each pair contains only one kind of atom; pairing alone does not make a compound.

Example 2 · A repeated two-colour group

Worked example information

Every group in a pure sample is H–O–H.

Question: Why is this a compound?

Answer: Each repeated group contains two different elements in a fixed ratio.

Why: Hydrogen and oxygen are joined; this differs from separate substances sharing a container.

Example 3 · Salt and water

Worked example information

Dissolved salt is mixed with water in two jars, one saltier than the other.

Question: Why can both be mixtures?

Answer: Mixture proportions can vary.

Why: A mixture need not have the single fixed ratio that defines a pure compound.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read simple symbols

Fixed question information

A contains only He atoms. B contains only H₂O molecules. He is helium; H and O are different elements.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Compound sample: Neither contains matter
  • b: Compound sample: B
  • c: Element sample: A
  • d: Element sample: Both are mixtures
Answer: Compound sample: B; Element sample: A

A has one atom kind; B has different atoms chemically joined.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F2 · Separate substance groups

Fixed question information

A jar contains separate O₂ groups and N₂ groups. No oxygen-nitrogen bonds are shown.

F2 · Multiple choice

How is the jar classified?

  • a: Two
  • b: Mixture
  • c: Pure compound
  • d: One
Answer: Mixture

Separate substances coexist without becoming one compound.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Choose a physical method

Fixed question information

A virtual tray contains iron pieces and nonmagnetic sand. Iron is attracted to a magnet; sand is not.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Useful tool: Thermometer.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

The different magnetic behaviour enables separation.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F4 · Read a fixed formula

Fixed question information

Each water molecule is H₂O: two H atoms and one O atom.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Hydrogen atoms; Oxygen atoms

  • a: 1
  • b: 3
  • c: 2
  • d: 4
Answer: Hydrogen atoms → 2; Oxygen atoms → 1

The formula records a 2-to-1 atom ratio.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F5 · Classify a uniform drink model

Fixed question information

A model drink contains water and dissolved sugar. Its sugar amount can be changed without making a new single substance.

F5 · Short answer

Is this drink a mixture or pure compound? Give two reasons from the information.

Example of a full-credit answer: It is a mixture: water and sugar remain different substances, and their proportions can vary.

  1. Identifies different substances together as a mixture.
  2. Uses variable composition to justify the classification.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A contains only Cu atoms. B contains only CO₂ groups. C contains both Cu atoms and CO₂ groups. C means carbon and Cu means copper.

1A · Hotspot

Which is a pure compound?

  • a: B
  • b: A
  • c: All three
  • d: C
Answer: B

B has one compound type; C contains two substance types.

1B · Short answer

Classify A and C and explain how their particle contents differ.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is an element because it has only copper atoms. C is a mixture because copper and carbon dioxide are present together.

  1. Classifies A as an element using one atom kind.
  2. Classifies C as a mixture using its separate substance types.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Rule A calls every two-atom group a compound. Rule B checks whether joined atoms are different elements. A sample contains only N₂.

2A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Reliable rule: B
  • b: Reliable rule: A
  • c: N₂ classification: Compound
  • d: N₂ classification: Element
Answer: Reliable rule: B; N₂ classification: Element

The kinds of atoms matter; two equal atoms still represent an element.

2B · Open ended

Choose a rule and explain why N₂ defeats the other rule.

Example of a full-credit answer: B is reliable. N₂ has two atoms but both are nitrogen, so it is an element rather than a compound.

  1. Chooses the different-element criterion in B.
  2. Uses two identical nitrogen atoms to refute A.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A sealed model contains separate CO₂ and O₂ molecules. Every CO₂ has carbon and oxygen; every O₂ has oxygen only.

3A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Whole sample; CO₂ by itself

  • a: Mixture
  • b: Single atom
  • c: Compound
  • d: Pure element
Answer: Whole sample → Mixture; CO₂ by itself → Compound

The whole sample combines two substances.

3B · Short answer

Classify the whole sample and explain why containing a compound does not make the whole jar pure.

Example of a full-credit answer: The jar is a mixture. CO₂ is a compound, but O₂ is also present as a separate substance.

  1. Classifies the jar as a mixture.
  2. Explains that CO₂ and O₂ are separate substance types.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

Nico says, “Salt water is a compound because it looks the same throughout.” The amount of salt can vary and the water can be separated by a suitable physical process.

4A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Classification; Weak evidence in the claim

  • a: Uniform appearance
  • b: Element
  • c: Fixed atom ratio
  • d: Mixture
Answer: Classification → Mixture; Weak evidence in the claim → Uniform appearance

Uniform appearance alone does not establish a compound.

4B · Open ended

Identify the mistake and give one stronger reason for the correct classification.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uniform appearance is not enough. Salt water is a mixture because its proportions can vary or because its components can be physically separated.

  1. Rejects appearance as proof of a compound.
  2. Gives a valid mixture reason from variable composition or physical separation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Make one diagram for a pure compound and one for a mixture. Use circles labelled A and B as two different element types. Joined circles mean bonded atoms.

5A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Compound feature; Mixture feature

  • a: Only same atoms joined
  • b: Different substance types together
  • c: All atoms disappearing
  • d: Different atom types joined
Answer: Compound feature → Different atom types joined; Mixture feature → Different substance types together

A consistent key distinguishes bonds from simple proximity.

5B · Open ended

Describe both diagrams and explain one difference in their particle arrangement.

Example of a full-credit answer: For a pure compound, repeat identical A–B groups only. For a mixture, show separate A particles and B particles, or A–B groups with another substance.

  1. Proposes a pure compound with repeated bonded different-element groups.
  2. Proposes a mixture with at least two distinguishable substance types.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.6 · Chemical bonds

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · An energy account

Worked example information

A model needs 25 units to break selected bonds and releases 40 when new bonds form.

Question: What is the net energy transfer?

Answer: 15 units released.

Why: The release exceeds the input by 40 − 25 = 15; breaking the old bonds still needed energy.

Example 2 · Two bond symbols

Worked example information

Diagram X shows a shared electron pair. Diagram Y shows positive and negative ions attracting.

Question: Which represents covalent bonding?

Answer: X; Y represents ionic attraction.

Why: Electron sharing and attraction between charged ions are different simplified bonding pictures.

Example 3 · Count through rearrangement

Worked example information

A model begins with four H atoms and two O atoms. It forms two H₂O groups.

Question: Were atoms created?

Answer: No. Each water group has two H and one O, so totals remain four H and two O.

Why: Bond changes rearrange existing atoms.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read an attraction model

Fixed question information

Covalent model C shows shared electrons. Ionic model I shows positive and negative ions attracting.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Sharing model; Ion-attraction model

  • a: I
  • b: Both are repulsion
  • c: Neither model
  • d: C
Answer: Sharing model → C; Ion-attraction model → I

The representations describe two different bonding patterns.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F2 · Energy directions

Fixed question information

Separating two bonded atoms needs 10 model energy units. Joining them in the reverse process releases 10.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Energy-input process; Energy-release process

  • a: Atom deletion
  • b: Bond breaking
  • c: Bond formation
  • d: Particle colouring
Answer: Energy-input process → Bond breaking; Energy-release process → Bond formation

Opposite steps have opposite energy directions.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F3 · Track atom counts

Fixed question information

A reaction drawing has six H and three O atoms before and after connections change.

F3 · Multiple choice

How many H atoms remain?

  • a: 9
  • b: 6
  • c: 12
  • d: 3
Answer: 6

Bonds rearrange without changing element counts.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Read a ball-and-stick model

Fixed question information

Large coloured balls show atom types; lines show bonds. The picture is explicitly not to scale.

F4 · Hotspot

What do the lines represent?

  • a: Wooden rods
  • b: Atom types
  • c: Bonds
  • d: Actual visible paint
Answer: Bonds

The key explains symbols, not literal objects.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain an energy release

Fixed question information

An imagined reaction requires 50 energy units to break bonds and releases 80 when new bonds form.

F5 · Open ended

Find the net energy release and explain why it does not mean breaking bonds releases energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: The net release is 30 units. Breaking required 50, while formation released 80, so the larger release came from forming new bonds.

  1. Calculates a net release of 30 units.
  2. Distinguishes energy input for breaking from release during formation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

Model A needs 30 units for bond breaking and releases 50 on formation. Model B needs 70 and releases 40.

1A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Net-release model: A
  • b: Net-release model: B
  • c: Net input for B: 110 units
  • d: Net input for B: 30 units
Answer: Net-release model: A; Net input for B: 30 units

A releases 20; B takes in 30.

1B · Open ended

Explain the energy direction for both models with subtraction.

Example of a full-credit answer: A releases 50 − 30 = 20 units. B needs a net input of 70 − 40 = 30 units.

  1. Finds A’s 20-unit net release.
  2. Finds B’s 30-unit net input.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Explanation A says opposite ions repel. Explanation B says opposite ions attract. The model shows positive sodium ions next to negative chloride ions.

2A · Multiple choice

Which explanation matches the model?

  • a: B
  • b: Neither A nor B
  • c: A
  • d: Both A and B
Answer: B

Opposite electric charges attract.

2B · Short answer

Choose the explanation and state why “sharing one electron pair” is not the ionic description given here.

Example of a full-credit answer: B is correct because opposite ions attract. This ionic model shows charged ions, not a shared electron pair between two atoms.

  1. Uses opposite-charge attraction to choose B.
  2. Distinguishes the stated ionic model from covalent sharing.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

Each fictional X₂Y group contains two X atoms and one Y atom. Three such groups form without losing atoms.

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: X atoms needed; Y atoms needed

  • a: 2
  • b: 3
  • c: 9
  • d: 6
Answer: X atoms needed → 6; Y atoms needed → 3

Multiply each group’s atom count by three.

3B · Open ended

Count each atom kind and explain what must be preserved if the groups rearrange.

Example of a full-credit answer: Three groups contain six X and three Y atoms. Rearranging bonds must keep those totals in a closed ordinary reaction.

  1. Gives six X and three Y.
  2. Explains conservation of both atom kinds through rearrangement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

Mia says, “A fuel reaction gives energy out, so breaking its bonds must release energy.” New bonds also form during the reaction.

4A · Hotspot

What actually requires input?

  • a: Deleting electrons
  • b: Forming bonds
  • c: Breaking bonds
  • d: Forming atoms
Answer: Breaking bonds

Overall energy comes from comparing both steps.

4B · Short answer

Correct Mia’s claim and explain how a reaction can still release energy overall.

Example of a full-credit answer: Breaking bonds needs energy. The reaction releases energy overall when forming new bonds releases more than the breaking step needs.

  1. Correctly states that bond breaking needs energy.
  2. Explains net release as formation release exceeding breaking input.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Create a model reaction with bond-breaking input and bond-formation release. It must release exactly 20 energy units overall. All values must be positive.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Required relationship: Release = input + 20.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

A 20-unit net release means release exceeds input by 20.

5B · Open ended

Propose two positive values and check that they give the required net release.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 40 units input and 60 released. 60 − 40 = 20 units net release.

  1. Proposes positive breaking-input and formation-release values.
  2. Shows release exceeds input by exactly 20.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.7 · Chemical reactions

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Melting or reacting?

Worked example information

Sample A is ice becoming water. Sample B is iron forming rust in moist air.

Question: Which gives evidence of a new substance?

Answer: B, rust formation.

Why: A remains water; B involves a different material formed by chemical change.

Example 2 · Check the count

Worked example information

A drawing shows two H₂ groups plus one O₂ group forming two H₂O groups.

Question: Are H and O counts conserved?

Answer: Yes: four H and two O occur on each side.

Why: Changing connections does not require creating atoms.

Example 3 · Bubbles are a clue

Worked example information

A clear liquid bubbles while boiling. The escaping gas is identified as the same substance in gas form.

Question: Must this be a chemical reaction?

Answer: No. It can be a state change.

Why: Substance identity matters more than the mere presence of bubbles.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Starting and finishing substances

Fixed question information

A model reaction begins with hydrogen and oxygen and forms water.

F1 · Multiple choice

What are the starting substances called?

  • a: Reactants
  • b: Indicators
  • c: Products
  • d: Containers
Answer: Reactants

Reactants change into products.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F2 · Separate physical and chemical changes

Fixed question information

An ice cube melts without changing water molecules. An iron sample reacts with oxygen to form rust.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Chemical change; Physical change

  • a: Neither stated case
  • b: Both stated cases
  • c: Rusting
  • d: Melting ice
Answer: Chemical change → Rusting; Physical change → Melting ice

Rusting changes substance identity; melting does not.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Track a reaction model

Fixed question information

Two H₂ groups and one O₂ group form two H₂O groups.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Hydrogen atoms per side; Oxygen atoms per side

  • a: 8
  • b: 4
  • c: 2
  • d: 6
Answer: Hydrogen atoms per side → 4; Oxygen atoms per side → 2

Two H₂ groups contain four H; one O₂ contains two O.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F4 · Question a single clue

Fixed question information

A pupil sees bubbles but has not identified the gas or the starting liquid.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Missing useful information: Gas identity
  • b: Conclusion: More evidence is needed
  • c: Missing useful information: Only the cup colour
  • d: Conclusion: A reaction is certain
Answer: Missing useful information: Gas identity; Conclusion: More evidence is needed

Bubbles can come from chemical reactions or physical changes.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a sealed transformation

Fixed question information

A sealed virtual system starts with 8 X atoms and 4 Y atoms. New XY₂ and other groups may form, but no atom enters or leaves.

F5 · Short answer

What two atom totals must any final drawing preserve? Explain why changing connections does not remove atoms.

Example of a full-credit answer: It must keep 8 X atoms and 4 Y atoms. Chemical changes rearrange existing atoms rather than destroying them.

  1. Preserves both given atom totals.
  2. Explains rearrangement without atom destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A learner proposes H₂ + O₂ → H₂O. Count atoms using the formulas exactly as written.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Unequal element; Hydrogen count on each side

  • a: 4
  • b: Hydrogen
  • c: 2
  • d: Oxygen
Answer: Unequal element → Oxygen; Hydrogen count on each side → 2

Oxygen counts are 2 on the left and 1 on the right.

1B · Short answer

Explain what is wrong and provide a balanced version without changing substance formulas.

Example of a full-credit answer: Oxygen is not balanced. Use 2 H₂ + O₂ → 2 H₂O, giving four H and two O on both sides.

  1. Identifies unequal oxygen counts.
  2. Supplies correct coefficients preserving H₂, O₂ and H₂O formulas.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Report A says only that a liquid changed colour after food colouring was added. Report B identifies a new substance absent before the process.

2A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Limitation of A: Colour can change by mixing
  • b: Stronger report: A
  • c: Stronger report: B
  • d: Limitation of A: All colour changes are reactions
Answer: Limitation of A: Colour can change by mixing; Stronger report: B

Identifying a new substance is stronger than a nonspecific appearance clue.

2B · Open ended

Choose a report and explain why the other observation is not enough by itself.

Example of a full-credit answer: B is stronger because a new substance is identified. A might just mix dye into the liquid without creating a new substance.

  1. Chooses B for new-substance evidence.
  2. Explains a non-reaction alternative for A.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A closed model starts with two AB groups and one C₂ group. It finishes with two AC groups and one B₂ group.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Final B atoms: 1.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

The same A, B and C counts are rearranged.

3B · Short answer

Show that the proposed change conserves A, B and C.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both sides contain two A, two B and two C atoms; only their partners change.

  1. Correctly counts two atoms of each kind on both sides.
  2. Explains that changed partners represent rearrangement, not new atoms.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

Tomas says, “All bubbles prove a new substance formed.” A teacher’s record shows boiling water gives water vapour, still H₂O.

4A · Hotspot

What process is the counterexample?

  • a: A new element
  • b: Boiling
  • c: H₂O
  • d: Rusting
Answer: Boiling

Bubbles can result from physical state change.

4B · Open ended

Identify the overclaim and use the boiling record to correct it.

Example of a full-credit answer: “All bubbles” is too strong. Boiling makes water vapour with the same H₂O identity, so bubbles alone cannot prove a reaction.

  1. Rejects bubbles as sufficient proof in every case.
  2. Uses unchanged H₂O during boiling as the counterexample.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual program compares equal reactant amounts at two temperatures. It reports product amount after a chosen time. No real chemicals are used.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changed factor; Useful outcome

  • a: Display colour
  • b: Temperature
  • c: Product after equal time
  • d: Reactant amounts too
Answer: Changed factor → Temperature; Useful outcome → Product after equal time

A controlled design separates temperature from other changes.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison and state what evidence would answer the temperature question.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep reactant amounts and measuring time equal; vary temperature only. Repeat runs and compare the product amounts at that time.

  1. Controls reactant amount/time while varying temperature.
  2. Uses repeated comparable product measurements as evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.8 · Conservation of matter

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Salt remains present

Worked example information

A sealed system contains 80 g water and 5 g salt, excluding container mass. All salt dissolves without loss.

Question: What is the mixture mass?

Answer: 85 g.

Why: The salt remains as particles in the mixture, so its mass is included.

Example 2 · The open dish

Worked example information

An open dish loses 3 g while water evaporates.

Question: Where can the missing dish mass be?

Answer: In water vapour that entered the surrounding air.

Why: The dish is an open system; matter crossed its boundary.

Example 3 · Gas captured
Final parts
PartMass (g)
Liquid and solid40
Captured gas5

Worked example information

A model reaction starts with 45 g of materials. It leaves 40 g liquid/solid and 5 g gas in a sealed bag.

Question: Is mass conserved?

Answer: Yes: 40 + 5 = 45 g.

Why: Counting only the liquid and solid would miss the gas.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A sealed mass account

Fixed question information

A sealed system has total mass 75 g before a reaction. Nothing enters or escapes.

F1 · Multiple choice

What mass is expected afterward?

  • a: Closed
  • b: 50 g
  • c: Open
  • d: 75 g
Answer: 75 g

A closed ordinary reaction conserves total mass.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Add dissolved matter

Fixed question information

A model combines 60 g water and 4 g salt with no loss.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Mixture mass: 60 g
  • b: Salt contribution: 4 g
  • c: Mixture mass: 64 g
  • d: Salt contribution: 0 g
Answer: Salt contribution: 4 g; Mixture mass: 64 g

Dissolving spreads particles but preserves their mass.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Count the gas

Fixed question information

Products include 18 g solid and 7 g gas, all inside a sealed container. Container mass is excluded.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Total product mass; Gas contribution

  • a: 11 g
  • b: 7 g
  • c: 18 g
  • d: 25 g
Answer: Total product mass → 25 g; Gas contribution → 7 g

Gas has mass and must be counted.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Open or closed

Fixed question information

Container A is sealed against matter transfer. Container B allows water vapour to escape.

F4 · Hotspot

Which is closed?

  • a: Both open
  • b: A
  • c: B
  • d: Neither has matter
Answer: A

The boundary determines whether matter can cross.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain a shrinking puddle

Fixed question information

Water evaporates from an open puddle. No water is chemically destroyed.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why puddle mass can fall without violating conservation. Name where the water goes and why the puddle is an open system.

Example of a full-credit answer: Water becomes vapour in the air. The puddle is open because this matter can cross its boundary.

  1. Identifies water vapour in surrounding air.
  2. Explains matter crossing the open system boundary.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A sealed reaction starts with 52 g reactants. Final liquid and solid total 47 g; the remaining product is gas.

1A · Hotspot

What gas mass completes the account?

  • a: 47 g
  • b: 52 g
  • c: 5 g
  • d: 99 g
Answer: 5 g

52 − 47 = 5 g must be in the other included product.

1B · Open ended

Calculate gas mass and explain why leaving gas out would mislead us.

Example of a full-credit answer: The gas is 5 g. Excluding it would compare only part of the final system with all the starting matter.

  1. Finds 5 g by subtraction.
  2. Explains the incomplete-system comparison caused by excluding gas.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Setup A weighs a sealed reaction bag before and after. Setup B weighs an open cup while gas can escape. Both use the same balance.

2A · Multiple choice

Which setup directly tracks closed-system mass?

  • a: No gas has mass
  • b: B
  • c: A
  • d: Escaping gas
Answer: A

A includes retained gas and the rest of the system.

2B · Short answer

Choose a setup and identify one precaution that makes the comparison trustworthy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use A because it retains all matter. Check the seal and weigh the same complete bag with the same balance before and after.

  1. Chooses A using retention of all matter.
  2. Names a relevant precaution such as checking leaks or keeping the weighing boundary unchanged.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

An open iron sample starts at 10 g and later rusted material totals 13 g. In this task, no material falls off; oxygen from air joins the sample.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Oxygen mass added: 3 g.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

The gain is matter from the surrounding air.

3B · Open ended

Explain the mass gain and why it does not mean atoms were created.

Example of a full-credit answer: 3 g of oxygen entered from the air. The sample is open, so it gains existing matter from outside.

  1. Calculates the 3 g gain.
  2. Explains oxygen transfer from surroundings rather than atom creation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

After 6 g sugar dissolves in 90 g water without loss, Ben reports 90 g because “invisible sugar has no mass.”

4A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Mixture mass; Sugar mass still present

  • a: 96 g
  • b: 0 g
  • c: 90 g
  • d: 6 g
Answer: Mixture mass → 96 g; Sugar mass still present → 6 g

Invisible dissolved particles still contribute mass.

4B · Short answer

Identify Ben’s mistake and calculate the correct mass.

Example of a full-credit answer: He treats dissolved sugar as gone. It remains present, so 90 + 6 = 96 g.

  1. Explains that dissolved sugar remains matter.
  2. Gives 96 g with correct addition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual change forms solid, liquid and gas. Your design must test total mass without allowing any material to escape.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required inclusion; Comparison object

  • a: All products including gas
  • b: Same whole container
  • c: Only visible solid
  • d: Different containers
Answer: Required inclusion → All products including gas; Comparison object → Same whole container

A complete consistent boundary prevents omitted matter.

5B · Open ended

Propose the weighing procedure and state how you would handle unexpected small differences.

Example of a full-credit answer: Weigh the same sealed container before and after, including gas. Record differences and check leaks and balance uncertainty rather than changing the data.

  1. Describes the same closed complete system before and after.
  2. Investigates uncertainty/leaks while preserving recorded measurements.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.9 · Acids and bases

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Sort three labels
Measured labels
SamplepH
A2
B7
C11

Worked example information

A is pH 2, B is pH 7 and C is pH 11 in a room-temperature model.

Question: Classify A, B and C.

Answer: A acidic; B neutral; C basic.

Why: Compare each number with 7.

Example 2 · An indicator interval

Worked example information

A teacher’s chart puts orange in the pH 4–5 range. A sample is orange.

Question: May we report exactly pH 4.00?

Answer: No. The evidence gives the chart’s range.

Why: Measurement precision must match the instrument.

Example 3 · A misleading safety claim

Worked example information

A stream sample has pH 7 but has not been tested for microbes or pollutants.

Question: Is drinking safety established?

Answer: No.

Why: pH measures one property; it cannot rule out all other hazards.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify labelled samples

Fixed question information

Room-temperature model: A pH 3; B pH 9.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Acidic sample: Both neutral
  • b: Basic sample: B
  • c: Acidic sample: A
  • d: Basic sample: Neither
Answer: Basic sample: B; Acidic sample: A

Compare the values with 7.

Scientific explorer: ph lab

F2 · Read the neutral marker

Fixed question information

The supplied indicator chart marks pH 7 as neutral; pH 5 is acidic.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which pH is neutral?

  • a: 9
  • b: 12
  • c: 5
  • d: 7
Answer: 7

The neutral reference is 7 for this task.

Scientific explorer: ph lab

F3 · Match chart and evidence

Fixed question information

The supplied chart labels red as acidic and blue as basic. Sample X is red; Y is blue.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Basic sample; Acidic sample

  • a: Y
  • b: Both are identical
  • c: Both are neutral
  • d: X
Answer: Basic sample → Y; Acidic sample → X

Use the specified chart, not a remembered unrelated chart.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Choose a safe source

Fixed question information

A learner can read a teacher’s pH record or taste an unknown liquid. Only recorded measurements are allowed.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Allowed method; Unsafe method

  • a: Taste the liquid
  • b: Guess from colourlessness
  • c: Read the pH record
  • d: Inspect the printed chart
Answer: Allowed method → Read the pH record; Unsafe method → Taste the liquid

Unknown solutions must not be tasted.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain an acidic result

Fixed question information

A model sample measures pH 4 at room temperature. No safety tests beyond pH were done.

F5 · Short answer

Classify the sample and explain why the measurement does not establish drinking safety.

Example of a full-credit answer: It is acidic because 4 is below 7. pH alone does not test all possible contaminants.

  1. Uses pH below 7 to classify it as acidic.
  2. States a specific limitation of pH for drinking safety.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: ph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

Dataset A is pH 6; B is pH 8 at the same stated temperature. These are fictional samples, not swimming advice.

1A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Acidic sample: Both neutral.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

A is below 7 and B above 7.

1B · Short answer

Explain both categories and why averaging them does not tell the pH after mixing real samples.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is acidic and B basic. Real mixing depends on chemical amounts and strengths, so the numerical mean is not a reliable mixing rule.

  1. Correctly classifies A and B.
  2. Rejects a simple pH average as sufficient to predict a real mixture.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

An indicator places a sample between pH 5 and 6. Report A says “about pH 5–6”; report B says “exactly 5.000.”

2A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Better report; Problem in B

  • a: Unsupported precision
  • b: Too little decimal detail
  • c: B
  • d: A
Answer: Better report → A; Problem in B → Unsupported precision

The indicator supplies a range, not three-decimal accuracy.

2B · Open ended

Choose a report and explain how the instrument limits the claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: A matches the measured range. The indicator cannot justify three decimal places.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Connects limited indicator resolution to the unsupported exactness in B.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A new indicator’s key says purple is basic and yellow acidic. An unknown sample is purple.

3A · Hotspot

How should it be classified?

  • a: The supplied colour key
  • b: Taste
  • c: Basic
  • d: Acidic
Answer: Basic

Colours are meaningful only with their own chart.

3B · Short answer

Classify the sample and explain why a different indicator’s chart should not replace the given key.

Example of a full-credit answer: It is basic using the purple label in this chart. Another indicator may use different colours for the same category.

  1. Classifies as basic from the provided key.
  2. Explains indicator-specific colour interpretation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A label says pH 7. Jo concludes it is safe to drink, although the label provides no contaminant tests.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Justified statement: Neutral pH only
  • b: Unjustified statement: Safe to drink
  • c: Unjustified statement: The label reports pH 7
  • d: Justified statement: All tests passed
Answer: Justified statement: Neutral pH only; Unjustified statement: Safe to drink

One property does not establish full safety.

4B · Open ended

Identify Jo’s reasoning error and give a justified replacement statement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Jo treats one property as a complete safety test. The sample has neutral pH, but drinking safety is unknown.

  1. Identifies the overreach from pH to overall safety.
  2. Provides a neutral-pH-only conclusion with safety unresolved.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual station must classify three labelled samples without touching or mixing them. It provides pH readings and a room-temperature category key.

5A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Needed evidence; Unnecessary unsafe action

  • a: pH and its category key
  • b: Tasting
  • c: Sample volume only
  • d: Container colour only
Answer: Needed evidence → pH and its category key; Unnecessary unsafe action → Tasting

A clear key makes classification consistent.

5B · Open ended

Propose a safe two-step procedure and describe how to report an uncertain colour interval.

Example of a full-credit answer: Read each pH/indicator result against its supplied key. Record acidic, neutral or basic; if the chart gives a range, report that range rather than inventing decimals.

  1. Uses measurements and matching key without contact/mixing.
  2. Reports uncertainty at the instrument’s stated precision.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.10 · Energy changes during reactions

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Net release

Worked example information

Reaction model A takes in 20 units and releases 55.

Question: What is its net change?

Answer: 35 units released.

Why: 55 − 20 = 35; both steps are counted.

Example 2 · Net input

Worked example information

Model B takes in 80 units and releases 50.

Question: Is it endothermic or exothermic overall?

Answer: Endothermic, with 30 units taken in overall.

Why: The input exceeds release by 30.

Example 3 · Compare temperature changes
Model surrounding temperatures
SetupStart (°C)End (°C)
A2025
B2018

Worked example information

Equal surroundings start at 20°C. A finishes at 25°C; B at 18°C.

Question: Which surroundings gained thermal energy in the model?

Answer: A’s; its temperature rose.

Why: The record is consistent with energy transfer to A’s surroundings.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Energy words

Fixed question information

A transfers energy to surroundings overall. B takes energy from surroundings overall.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: A classification; B classification

  • a: Exothermic
  • b: Neutral pH
  • c: No energy change
  • d: Endothermic
Answer: A classification → Exothermic; B classification → Endothermic

The words describe net energy-transfer direction.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F2 · Subtract both steps

Fixed question information

A classroom model uses 30 energy units in bond breaking and releases 65 in formation.

F2 · Multiple choice

What is the net release?

  • a: 35 units
  • b: 95 units
  • c: 65 units
  • d: 30 units
Answer: 35 units

65 − 30 = 35.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F3 · Read a warming record

Fixed question information

Surrounding water rises from 22°C to 27°C in an insulated model observation.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Temperature rise: 5°C
  • b: Direction to the water: Energy leaves
  • c: Temperature rise: 49°C
  • d: Direction to the water: Energy enters
Answer: Temperature rise: 5°C; Direction to the water: Energy enters

The positive temperature change is 27 − 22.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Hold conditions equal

Fixed question information

Two virtual reactions are compared for temperature change. Equal reactant amounts and initial temperatures are used.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Useful comparison; Controlled quantity

  • a: Temperature change
  • b: Final colour only
  • c: Different amounts each run
  • d: Initial temperature
Answer: Useful comparison → Temperature change; Controlled quantity → Initial temperature

Equal conditions make the changes more comparable.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F5 · Explain cooling

Fixed question information

A virtual reaction takes 90 energy units in and releases 60. Surroundings supply the net input.

F5 · Open ended

Calculate the net input and explain why the surroundings may cool.

Example of a full-credit answer: The reaction takes 90 − 60 = 30 units overall from its surroundings, so those surroundings can lose thermal energy and cool.

  1. Calculates 30 units net input.
  2. Links energy taken from surroundings to possible cooling.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A: input 45, release 75 units. B: input 85, release 65 units.

1A · Hotspot

Which releases energy overall?

  • a: 20 units
  • b: B
  • c: 150 units
  • d: A
Answer: A

A releases 30; B takes in 20.

1B · Open ended

Compare the two net transfers with correct directions.

Example of a full-credit answer: A releases 30 units; B takes in 20 units. Each is the difference between release and input, with direction stated.

  1. Finds A’s 30-unit release.
  2. Finds B’s 20-unit input.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Plan A compares equal amounts at the same starting temperature. Plan B doubles one amount and starts it warmer.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Better plan: A.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Changing amounts and starting temperature mixes possible causes.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and identify two conditions that make its comparison fairer.

Example of a full-credit answer: A keeps amounts and starting temperatures equal, so those factors do not explain the difference.

  1. Chooses A and names equal amount.
  2. Names equal starting temperature and its role in the comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A virtual warming device needs 50 units to change bonds and releases 95 when new bonds form. The excess reaches a surrounding pad.

3A · Multiple choice

What net energy reaches the pad?

  • a: 145 units
  • b: 50 units
  • c: 45 units
  • d: 95 units
Answer: 45 units

95 − 50 = 45 in the simplified energy account.

3B · Open ended

Explain how the device can warm the pad without creating energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Formation releases 95 units while breaking needs 50, leaving 45 transferred to the pad. The chemical system’s energy decreases; energy is transferred, not created.

  1. Gives the correct 45-unit net transfer.
  2. Explains conservation through energy transfer from the chemical system.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A pupil says any temperature fall proves a chemical reaction. Another observation shows an ordinary evaporation process also cools a surface.

4A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Conclusion; Needed additional evidence

  • a: Every cooling is chemical
  • b: Substance identity change
  • c: Only colour of the cup
  • d: Temperature change alone is insufficient
Answer: Conclusion → Temperature change alone is insufficient; Needed additional evidence → Substance identity change

Energy changes can accompany physical processes.

4B · Short answer

Identify the overclaim and state what other evidence is needed to argue for a reaction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cooling alone is not proof because evaporation can cool. Evidence of different substances forming is needed.

  1. Uses physical evaporation as a counterexample.
  2. Calls for evidence of new substance formation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Propose positive input and release values for a virtual reaction that takes exactly 15 units from surroundings overall.

5A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required relationship; Net label

  • a: Input = release + 15
  • b: Endothermic
  • c: Release = input + 15
  • d: Exothermic
Answer: Required relationship → Input = release + 15; Net label → Endothermic

Net input means input exceeds release.

5B · Open ended

Give valid values and explain the expected energy direction at the surroundings.

Example of a full-credit answer: Input 50 and release 35 gives 15 units taken from surroundings; they lose that energy.

  1. Provides positive values with input minus release equal to 15.
  2. Explains energy moving from surroundings into the reaction overall.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.11 · Electrical conductivity

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Open the switch

Worked example information

An ideal circuit has a source, resistor and switch. The switch is open.

Question: What steady current flows?

Answer: Zero in this model.

Why: The conducting path is incomplete.

Example 2 · Compare equal voltage
Ideal model values
ResistorResistance (Ω)Voltage (V)
A36
B66

Worked example information

Two ideal resistors use 6 V. A is 3 Ω; B is 6 Ω.

Question: Which has larger current?

Answer: A: 2 A, compared with B: 1 A.

Why: Current is voltage divided by resistance.

Example 3 · Different jobs

Worked example information

A cable must carry charge inside while limiting charge passage through its outside.

Question: What two properties are useful?

Answer: Conducting core and insulating cover.

Why: The chosen properties fit two different purposes.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Complete the path

Fixed question information

Virtual circuit A is closed; B has an open switch. Both otherwise contain conducting parts.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Complete circuit: A
  • b: Broken path: Neither has a source
  • c: Complete circuit: Both paths complete
  • d: Broken path: B
Answer: Complete circuit: A; Broken path: B

The switch determines path continuity.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F2 · Calculate model current

Fixed question information

A closed ideal circuit has 4 V and 8 Ω. Use current = voltage ÷ resistance.

F2 · Multiple choice

What is the current?

  • a: 8 Ω
  • b: 32 A
  • c: 2 A
  • d: 0.5 A
Answer: 0.5 A

4 ÷ 8 = 0.5.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F3 · Classify tested materials

Fixed question information

In the same test, copper allows charge movement and dry plastic strongly resists it.

F3 · Hotspot

Which is the conductor?

  • a: Neither material
  • b: Both always conduct
  • c: Copper
  • d: Dry plastic
Answer: Copper

The properties are based on the given test.

Scientific explorer: material lab

F4 · Choose a fair geometry

Fixed question information

A test compares equal-length, equal-thickness samples at the same voltage.

F4 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Changed factor: Voltage too.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Geometry and voltage should not confound the comparison.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain resistance

Fixed question information

At 6 V, ideal resistor A is 3 Ω and B is 12 Ω.

F5 · Short answer

Calculate each current and explain which resistor allows more current.

Example of a full-credit answer: A gives 6 ÷ 3 = 2 A; B gives 6 ÷ 12 = 0.5 A. A has lower resistance and larger current.

  1. Calculates both currents correctly.
  2. Connects lower resistance with larger current at the same voltage.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

In identical virtual tests, A carries 0.6 A and B carries nearly zero at the same voltage and geometry.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Better contact; Evidence

  • a: Larger measured current
  • b: B
  • c: Colour alone
  • d: A
Answer: Better contact → A; Evidence → Larger measured current

The measured current answers the stated conducting job.

1B · Short answer

Choose the contact and explain why equal test conditions matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: A conducts more current. Equal voltage and dimensions make material a more plausible cause of the difference.

  1. Chooses A using the current evidence.
  2. Explains a relevant controlled condition and its purpose.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Design A has conducting metal inside and dry insulating plastic outside. Design B reverses these roles.

2A · Multiple choice

Which fits the intended path?

  • a: B
  • b: A
  • c: Carry all current outside
  • d: Limit unwanted charge movement
Answer: A

Conductor and insulator have distinct jobs.

2B · Open ended

Choose a design and explain the job of each material.

Example of a full-credit answer: A: the metal carries charge along the wire, and the insulating cover limits charge movement through the outside.

  1. Explains the conducting core.
  2. Explains the insulating cover.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

Teacher-provided data show salt solution conducts more current than pure water in the same virtual setup. The model states dissolved ions can move.

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Charge carriers; Fair comparison condition

  • a: Wooden particles
  • b: Same voltage
  • c: Mobile ions
  • d: Different sources
Answer: Charge carriers → Mobile ions; Fair comparison condition → Same voltage

Some liquids conduct through moving ions.

3B · Short answer

Explain why the salt solution can conduct and name one variable to keep equal in a comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its dissolved ions carry charge. Keep voltage or electrode spacing/geometry the same.

  1. Identifies mobile dissolved ions as charge carriers.
  2. Names a relevant controlled circuit condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

For an ideal 3 V, 6 Ω closed circuit, Kai multiplies to get 18 A.

4A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Current; Correct operation

  • a: Voltage divided by resistance
  • b: 18 A
  • c: 0.5 A
  • d: Voltage plus resistance
Answer: Current → 0.5 A; Correct operation → Voltage divided by resistance

The stated relation is I = V/R.

4B · Open ended

Identify Kai’s calculation error and give the corrected current.

Example of a full-credit answer: Kai multiplied instead of dividing. 3 ÷ 6 = 0.5 A.

  1. Identifies division as the required operation.
  2. Gives 0.5 A.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual laboratory provides a fixed low-voltage source, equal-size samples, a switch and a current meter.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Useful reading: Current through each sample.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Equal conditions and current measurement compare conductivity.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair test and explain how the measurements guide your conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: Test each equal-size sample in the same closed circuit at the same voltage. Compare current; larger current under these conditions indicates lower resistance.

  1. Describes controlled dimensions, circuit and voltage.
  2. Uses comparable current readings to justify a relative conduction conclusion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.12 · Thermal conductivity

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Equal-capacity blocks

Worked example information

An isolated model joins equal-heat-capacity blocks at 70°C and 30°C.

Question: What common temperature do they approach?

Answer: 50°C.

Why: The total temperature sum stays 100 in this equal-capacity model, so each approaches half.

Example 2 · The fair rod test
Rod test
RodStart (°C)Far end (°C)
A2035
B2024

Worked example information

Rods A and B are equal size and start at 20°C. After equal heating time, far ends are 35°C and 24°C.

Question: Which transferred energy more readily in this test?

Answer: A.

Why: A’s far end warmed more under the same stated conditions.

Example 3 · Insulation is not a heater

Worked example information

Two equal warm cups begin at 50°C. After the same time, insulated cup X is 44°C and bare cup Y is 36°C.

Question: Did X create heat?

Answer: No. It lost thermal energy more slowly.

Why: Its temperature still fell; the insulation changed the transfer rate.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Follow the thermal direction

Fixed question information

A 65°C object touches a 25°C object in an isolated model.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Energy direction: Cool to warm
  • b: Energy direction: Warm to cool
  • c: Warmer object: 25°C object
  • d: Warmer object: 65°C object
Answer: Energy direction: Warm to cool; Warmer object: 65°C object

Net conduction goes from higher to lower temperature.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F2 · Choose an equal-capacity endpoint

Fixed question information

Equal-capacity blocks at 60°C and 20°C exchange energy with no outside loss.

F2 · Hotspot

What temperature do they approach?

  • a: 20°C
  • b: 40°C
  • c: 60°C
  • d: 80°C
Answer: 40°C

The equal-capacity average is 40°C.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F3 · Read rod results

Fixed question information

Equal rods receive the same heating. A’s far end rises 12°C; B’s rises 4°C.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Better thermal conductor; Slower transfer

  • a: A
  • b: Both identical
  • c: B
  • d: Neither changes
Answer: Better thermal conductor → A; Slower transfer → B

A has the larger comparable warming response.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Choose a useful cover

Fixed question information

Cover P slows heat transfer; cover Q transfers heat quickly. The goal is slower cooling.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Cover choice; Role

  • a: Q
  • b: Slow energy transfer
  • c: Create energy
  • d: P
Answer: Cover choice → P; Role → Slow energy transfer

A low-conductivity cover reduces the transfer rate.

Scientific explorer: material lab

F5 · Explain the model limit

Fixed question information

A two-block model predicts the average starting temperature only because heat capacities are equal and no energy leaves.

F5 · Open ended

Why should the average-temperature rule not be used blindly for any two real objects? State both model assumptions.

Example of a full-credit answer: The rule assumes equal heat capacities and an isolated exchange with no energy entering or leaving. Real objects may not meet either assumption.

  1. States equal heat capacities are required.
  2. States no external energy transfer is required.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

Two equal-capacity blocks start at 80°C and 40°C in isolation.

1A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Initial transfer direction: 40°C block to 80°C block
  • b: Initial transfer direction: 80°C block to 40°C block
  • c: Final common temperature: 120°C
  • d: Final common temperature: 60°C
Answer: Initial transfer direction: 80°C block to 40°C block; Final common temperature: 60°C

The average is 60, and initial net transfer is warm to cool.

1B · Open ended

Predict the temperature and explain why it lies between the two starting values.

Example of a full-credit answer: They approach 60°C. The hot block loses energy while the cold one gains it, with no external energy added.

  1. Gives 60°C under the stated assumptions.
  2. Explains redistribution rather than external gain or loss.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Identical cups start at 55°C. After 10 minutes, sleeve A gives 48°C and sleeve B gives 40°C. Room conditions are equal.

2A · Multiple choice

Which sleeve slowed cooling more?

  • a: B
  • b: 15°C
  • c: 7°C
  • d: A
Answer: A

A lost fewer degrees over the same interval.

2B · Short answer

Choose a sleeve and justify using temperature changes rather than just labels.

Example of a full-credit answer: A cooled by 7°C while B cooled by 15°C, so A slowed cooling more under these conditions.

  1. Calculates or identifies both relevant drops.
  2. Limits the conclusion to the same-time, same-condition comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A model lunchbox must slow thermal transfer through its wall. Material X has transfer index 1 and Y index 5 for equal-size panels; lower is slower.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Material: Y.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

The smaller given transfer index fits the goal.

3B · Open ended

Choose a panel and name one design condition to control when comparing it with the alternative.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose X. Keep panel thickness or area equal so the comparison reflects material rather than geometry.

  1. Chooses X using its lower transfer index.
  2. Names a relevant controlled geometry/starting condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A student says, “Cold flows from the cool block into the warm one.” The isolated blocks become closer in temperature.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Transferred quantity; Net direction

  • a: Cooler to warmer
  • b: Warmer to cooler
  • c: Cold substance
  • d: Energy
Answer: Transferred quantity → Energy; Net direction → Warmer to cooler

Cooling and warming are explained by energy transfer.

4B · Short answer

Correct both the thing said to flow and its direction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Energy is transferred, not a substance called cold. Net transfer is from the warmer block to the cooler block.

  1. Replaces flowing cold with energy transfer.
  2. States the correct warmer-to-cooler direction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Two virtual sleeves must be compared using identical warm containers. A temperature display and timer are available.

5A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Measured outcome; One fixed condition

  • a: Temperature after equal time
  • b: Starting temperature
  • c: Different starting masses
  • d: Sleeve name only
Answer: Measured outcome → Temperature after equal time; One fixed condition → Starting temperature

Same conditions allow a meaningful rate comparison.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair method with two controls and one measurement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use equal containers and water amounts at the same starting temperature. Keep room conditions and time equal, then compare temperature drops.

  1. Names at least two relevant equal conditions.
  2. Measures comparable temperature change after equal time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.13 · Chemical processes in everyday life

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · The coating comparison

Worked example information

Equal virtual iron samples are exposed for equal time. Coated A forms less rust than bare B.

Question: What mechanism could explain the difference?

Answer: The coating reduces contact with oxygen and water.

Why: The controlled comparison is consistent with a protective barrier, without proving every coating works.

Example 2 · Two changes in one scene

Worked example information

Wax first melts. Separately, wax vapour reacts with oxygen and produces new substances.

Question: Which step is chemical?

Answer: The vapour reacting with oxygen.

Why: Melting changes state; combustion changes substance identity. This is a description, not a home experiment.

Example 3 · Read a rate table
Fictional product record
Time (min)Product units
12
24
36

Worked example information

Equal model samples produce 2, 4 and 6 units of product after 1, 2 and 3 minutes.

Question: What average rate does this model show?

Answer: 2 product units per minute.

Why: Equal increases in equal times show a constant rate in this limited dataset.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Sort daily changes

Fixed question information

A: an ice cube melts. B: iron forms rust. The iron produces substances with different composition.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Chemical process; Physical process

  • a: Both are only physical
  • b: A
  • c: Neither changes
  • d: B
Answer: Chemical process → B; Physical process → A

Substance identity distinguishes the changes.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read a rust comparison

Fixed question information

Equal virtual nails spend equal time in the same conditions. Coated C has 1 rust-index unit; bare D has 5. These are fictional index readings.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Less-rust sample; Greater-rust sample

  • a: No comparison possible
  • b: Both equal
  • c: D
  • d: C
Answer: Less-rust sample → C; Greater-rust sample → D

The given controlled readings favour C for this trial.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Follow a reaction route

Fixed question information

A teacher’s model states that a sugar is changed by yeast into different substances including carbon dioxide. It is a chemical process, not a culturing activity.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Carbon dioxide role: Product.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Starting and formed substances have different roles.

Scientific explorer: reaction lab

F4 · Compare product formation

Fixed question information

A virtual process produces 3 units after 1 minute and 9 units after 3 minutes.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Average rate: 12 units/min
  • b: Product at 3 minutes: 6 units
  • c: Product at 3 minutes: 9 units
  • d: Average rate: 3 units/min
Answer: Product at 3 minutes: 9 units; Average rate: 3 units/min

The data increase by three per minute.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F5 · Explain a protective layer

Fixed question information

Equal metal pieces are compared. A coating reduces contact with air and water; the coated piece develops less rust in the given record.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the coating could reduce rust and name one condition that must be equal for a fair comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: It reduces contact with water and oxygen. Keep metal type/size, exposure time or surrounding conditions equal.

  1. Links protection to reduced contact with relevant reactants.
  2. Names a relevant equal comparison condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

Equal model samples form 4, 8 and 12 product units at 1, 2 and 3 minutes. Assume the same pattern only through minute 4.

1A · Multiple choice

What is the predicted minute-4 amount?

  • a: 12 units/min
  • b: 20 units
  • c: 4 units/min
  • d: 16 units
Answer: 16 units

The stated short-term pattern adds four units each minute.

1B · Short answer

Predict minute 4 and explain why this does not prove the rate stays constant forever.

Example of a full-credit answer: 16 units follow the stated pattern. Real reactions can slow as reactants are used up, and the task only extends the pattern to minute 4.

  1. Predicts 16 from the four-unit increments.
  2. States the limited prediction scope or changing reactant supply.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Report A says a cut apple has smaller pieces. Report B identifies different compounds during browning. Both are teacher-provided descriptions.

2A · Hotspot

Which better establishes chemical change?

  • a: A
  • b: Atom destruction
  • c: Physical size change
  • d: B
Answer: B

New compound evidence is stronger than size change.

2B · Open ended

Choose a report and explain what distinguishes it from the other process.

Example of a full-credit answer: B identifies new substances, indicating chemical change. A only changes the size of the original material.

  1. Chooses B for new-substance evidence.
  2. Contrasts A as a size change without established new substances.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A model outdoor metal box needs less contact with rain. A continuous intact coating covers the metal; a scratched coating leaves exposed areas.

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Less exposed; More exposed region

  • a: None of the stated regions
  • b: Intact coating
  • c: All regions equally
  • d: Scratch
Answer: Less exposed → Intact coating; More exposed region → Scratch

The intact barrier covers the material; a gap allows contact.

3B · Short answer

Propose a maintenance action and explain the mechanism it is meant to preserve.

Example of a full-credit answer: Inspect and repair damaged coating using appropriate adult guidance. Keeping the barrier intact reduces contact between metal and rain/air.

  1. Proposes maintaining or repairing the protective barrier.
  2. Links the action to reduced environmental contact.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A pupil says, “Every time two things mix, a new compound forms.” The task gives salt dissolved in water as a variable-composition mixture.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Counterexample; Why it matters

  • a: Salt-water mixture
  • b: Every mixture is pure
  • c: Composition can vary
  • d: Atoms are destroyed
Answer: Counterexample → Salt-water mixture; Why it matters → Composition can vary

Mixing need not form one new compound.

4B · Open ended

Identify the overclaim and explain why the supplied example challenges it.

Example of a full-credit answer: “Every mixing” is too broad. Salt water can contain different proportions of separate substances, so mixing alone does not prove a new compound.

  1. Rejects the universal mixing claim.
  2. Uses variable-composition salt water as a mixture counterexample.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Use virtual equal-size metal samples to compare two protective coatings. A rust-index reading is available after a chosen time.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Main changed factor: Exposure time as well
  • b: Outcome: Sample label alone
  • c: Outcome: Rust index after equal exposure
  • d: Main changed factor: Coating type
Answer: Outcome: Rust index after equal exposure; Main changed factor: Coating type

A controlled response comparison can test the coating difference.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair repeated comparison and state a cautious conclusion you could draw.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use equal metal samples, coating thickness and exposure conditions; repeat each coating. Compare rust index after equal time, limiting the conclusion to tested coatings and conditions.

  1. Specifies relevant controls and repeated comparable measurements.
  2. Uses the measured rust index with a limited, evidence-based conclusion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S1.14 · Environmental effects of chemicals

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Follow the runoff

Worked example information

In a fictional map, rain carries material from a storage area to a drain and then a pond.

Question: Where could prevention interrupt the route earliest?

Answer: At the storage area, by preventing release.

Why: An upstream action can stop material entering the connected pathway.

Example 2 · Compare concentrations
Fictional water results
LocationConcentration (units/L)
Upstream2
Downstream7

Worked example information

Teacher-provided model data: upstream 2 units/L; downstream 7 units/L, sampled at the same time.

Question: What difference is observed?

Answer: Downstream is 5 units/L higher.

Why: The difference is evidence to investigate, not proof of its source.

Example 3 · Moving is not removing

Worked example information

A filter captures a model pollutant from water into a solid cartridge.

Question: Has the matter vanished?

Answer: No. It is now in the cartridge.

Why: The captured material still needs suitable handling; separation changes location.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Trace a pathway

Fixed question information

A fictional route is storage yard → drain → stream. Rain carries material along the arrows.

F1 · Hotspot

What is the first source location?

  • a: Unconnected room
  • b: Moon
  • c: Stream
  • d: Storage yard
Answer: Storage yard

The route identifies source, pathway and receiver.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read comparable data

Fixed question information

A model records 3 units/L upstream and 8 units/L downstream at the same time.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Observed increase; Upstream reading

  • a: 5 units/L
  • b: 24 units/L
  • c: 3 units/L
  • d: 11 units/L
Answer: Observed increase → 5 units/L; Upstream reading → 3 units/L

8 − 3 = 5; this is an observed difference, not a proven cause.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Distinguish separation

Fixed question information

A virtual treatment transfers 6 pollutant units from water into a filter. No chemical destruction is modelled.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Location: Nowhere.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Matter is relocated, not erased.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Compare prevention choices

Fixed question information

Plan A stops 8 of 10 fictional release units at the source. Plan B stops 3 of 10. Other conditions are equal.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which stops more in this model?

  • a: B
  • b: 2 units
  • c: A
  • d: 8 units
Answer: A

A leaves 10 − 8 = 2 units released.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a limited finding

Fixed question information

Two fictional sites differ in pollutant reading, but rainfall and land use also differ. No controlled source test was done.

F5 · Open ended

State one justified finding and one reason the pollution source is not yet proven.

Example of a full-credit answer: The measured readings differ. Rainfall, land use or other untested factors could explain the difference, so a source is not proven.

  1. States the observed difference without overstating it.
  2. Identifies a relevant alternative/confounding factor or missing source test.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fictional facility would release 20 material units. A proposed method prevents 15 units from entering the drain.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Remaining release; Prevented amount

  • a: 35 units
  • b: 20 units
  • c: 5 units
  • d: 15 units
Answer: Remaining release → 5 units; Prevented amount → 15 units

20 − 15 = 5 remains in the release pathway.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the remaining release and explain why prevention must be tracked separately from destruction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Five units remain. The other 15 were prevented from entering the drain; the information does not say the material was destroyed.

  1. Calculates 5 units.
  2. Distinguishes prevented release from destruction of matter.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

The task requires release at most 4 units and cost at most 6 tokens. Plan A: release 3, cost 5. Plan B: release 2, cost 8. Plan C: release 6, cost 3.

2A · Multiple choice

Which meets both conditions?

  • a: A
  • b: Release exceeds limit
  • c: Cost exceeds limit
  • d: C
Answer: A

A alone fits both stated constraints.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify it against both limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: A releases 3 units, at most 4, and costs 5 tokens, at most 6.

  1. Checks A against the release limit.
  2. Checks A against the cost limit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A virtual filter starts with water containing 12 pollutant units. After filtering, water has 4 units and the cartridge has 8.

3A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Whole-model total; Captured in cartridge

  • a: 12 units
  • b: 8 units
  • c: 0 units
  • d: 4 units
Answer: Whole-model total → 12 units; Captured in cartridge → 8 units

4 + 8 = 12; filtering changes location.

3B · Open ended

Explain the result using a complete matter account and one next handling concern.

Example of a full-credit answer: All 12 units remain: 4 in water and 8 in the cartridge. The cartridge still needs appropriate disposal or treatment.

  1. Accounts for all 12 units across both locations.
  2. Recognises that captured material still requires suitable handling.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A poster says, “Any natural chemical is safe in any amount.” The task states that effects depend on substance, amount and exposure.

4A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Error; Relevant factor

  • a: Colour of the word
  • b: Amount and exposure
  • c: Unsupported universal safety claim
  • d: All natural things are harmful
Answer: Error → Unsupported universal safety claim; Relevant factor → Amount and exposure

Origin alone does not establish effects.

4B · Short answer

Correct the poster and identify two pieces of information needed for evaluating an effect.

Example of a full-credit answer: Natural origin does not guarantee safety. Identify the substance and the amount/exposure pathway before judging effects.

  1. Rejects universal safety based on natural origin.
  2. Names two relevant factors, such as substance, amount or exposure route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A fictional school model wants less material entering its drain. A storage cover can be installed. Model rainfall, storage amount and collection time can be held equal.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Measured outcome: Paint colour only
  • b: Useful comparison: Different rainfall each run
  • c: Useful comparison: Covered versus uncovered
  • d: Measured outcome: Material reaching drain
Answer: Useful comparison: Covered versus uncovered; Measured outcome: Material reaching drain

Comparable runoff measurements test the actual goal.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison and name one limitation of applying its result elsewhere.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compare covered and uncovered storage under equal rainfall, amounts and time, repeating each. Measure material reaching the drain. Real sites may have different materials, weather or drainage.

  1. Designs controlled repeated measurements of drain-bound material.
  2. States a relevant limit on generalising the fictional model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.1 · Position

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Where is the book cart?

Worked-example information

The classroom door is 0 m. A cart is 4 m to its right. Right is positive.

Question: What is the cart’s position?

Answer: +4 m relative to the door.

Why: The origin and positive direction give the number meaning.

Example 2 · A different starting mark

Worked-example information

A bench is at 9 m on a walkway whose gate is 0 m. A tree is at 4 m on the same scale.

Question: Where is the bench relative to the tree?

Answer: 5 m to the right of the tree.

Why: Changing the origin changes the coordinate: 9 − 4 = 5 m.

Example 3 · Read a two-direction map

Worked-example information

A map’s fountain is 4 squares right and 1 square up from its origin. Coordinates are written (right, up).

Question: What coordinate marks it?

Answer: (4, 1).

Why: The first number gives the horizontal position; the second gives the vertical position.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A signed walkway

Fixed case information

The gate is 0 m, the library is 6 m right of it, and the garden is 3 m left. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Library position; Garden position; Gate position

  • a: +6 m
  • b: −3 m
  • c: 0 m
  • d: −6 m
Answer: Library position → +6 m; Garden position → −3 m; Gate position → 0 m

Positions need a reference point; left and right use opposite signs.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

F2 · A moving cart

Fixed case information

A cart starts at −2 m and moves 7 m right without turning. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Final position: +5 m
  • b: Starting position: −2 m
  • c: Final position: +9 m
  • d: Starting position: +2 m
Answer: Final position: +5 m; Starting position: −2 m

Add the signed change to the starting coordinate: −2 + 7 = 5.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F3 · Find the fountain

Fixed case information

A map uses (right, up) coordinates. The fountain is 2 squares right and 3 squares up from the origin.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies fountain coordinate in this case?

  • a: (2, 3)
  • b: (3, 2)
  • c: (−2, 3)
  • d: (2, −3)
Answer: (2, 3)

Coordinate order matters; the first entry is horizontal.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

F4 · Move the reference point

Fixed case information

On a straight path, the gate is at 0 m, a tree at 8 m and a bench at 10 m. Use the tree as the new origin and keep right positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Bench position from tree: +2 m.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Subtract the new origin’s old coordinate: 10 − 8 = 2.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain the finishing point

Fixed case information

A stage prop starts at 3 m, moves 6 m right and then 2 m left. The stage’s left edge is 0 m and right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Give the prop’s final position and explain how both movement directions enter your calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives +7 m relative to the left edge. Uses 3 + 6 − 2 or equivalent signed-position reasoning.

  1. Gives +7 m relative to the left edge.
  2. Uses 3 + 6 − 2 or equivalent signed-position reasoning.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A trolley starts at +4 m relative to a loading gate, travels 9 m right and then 3 m left. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Final position; Position change; Total distance

  • a: +10 m
  • b: +6 m
  • c: 12 m
  • d: +16 m
Answer: Final position → +10 m; Position change → +6 m; Total distance → 12 m

Final position includes the original 4 m coordinate: 4 + 9 − 3 = 10.

1B · Short answer

Find the final position and show how the starting point affects it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives +10 m relative to the gate. Includes the starting 4 m and the signed movements in a correct calculation.

  1. Gives +10 m relative to the gate.
  2. Includes the starting 4 m and the signed movements in a correct calculation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Map A gives an origin, a one-metre grid and positive directions. Map B shows the same dots but supplies no scale or reference point.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? More useful coordinate map: Map B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A position description needs an agreed reference and units.

2B · Open ended

Choose a map and justify it using two pieces of information it supplies.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Map A and explains why its origin/reference is needed. Explains how its scale/units or positive directions make the coordinates interpretable.

  1. Chooses Map A and explains why its origin/reference is needed.
  2. Explains how its scale/units or positive directions make the coordinates interpretable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A marker is at 12 cm on a lab-bench scale. A new zero mark is placed at the old 5 cm position. The positive direction stays the same.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies marker on new scale in this case?

  • a: +7 cm
  • b: +17 cm
  • c: −7 cm
  • d: +12 cm
Answer: +7 cm

The same location has a new coordinate: 12 − 5 = 7 cm.

3B · Short answer

Give the marker’s new coordinate and explain why the marker did not have to move.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives +7 cm relative to the new zero. Explains that changing the reference changes the coordinate while the physical location can stay fixed.

  1. Gives +7 cm relative to the new zero.
  2. Explains that changing the reference changes the coordinate while the physical location can stay fixed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A robot starts at 5 m, moves 6 m right and 2 m left. A pupil writes 5 + 6 + 2 = 13 m as its final position.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Correct final position; Mistake; Correct signed operation

  • a: +9 m
  • b: Adding the leftward segment
  • c: 5 + 6 − 2
  • d: +13 m
Answer: Correct final position → +9 m; Mistake → Adding the leftward segment; Correct signed operation → 5 + 6 − 2

The leftward movement reduces the coordinate when right is positive.

4B · Open ended

Identify the sign error and give the corrected calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that the 2 m leftward movement must be subtracted. Gives 5 + 6 − 2 = 9 m relative to the origin.

  1. Explains that the 2 m leftward movement must be subtracted.
  2. Gives 5 + 6 − 2 = 9 m relative to the origin.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Start at 0 m. Design a journey that moves right then left, finishes at +6 m and travels 10 m altogether. Both segments must be positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Rightward segment; Leftward segment; Final position

  • a: 8 m
  • b: 2 m
  • c: +6 m
  • d: 10 m
Answer: Rightward segment → 8 m; Leftward segment → 2 m; Final position → +6 m

The two checks are 8 − 2 = 6 and 8 + 2 = 10.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two segments and check both the final position and total distance.

Example of a full-credit answer: Proposes 8 m right then 2 m left. Checks the +6 m final position and 10 m total path length.

  1. Proposes 8 m right then 2 m left.
  2. Checks the +6 m final position and 10 m total path length.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.2 · Distance

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Out and back

Worked-example information

A learner walks 5 m to a shelf and 5 m back to the starting point.

Question: How far was walked?

Answer: 10 m.

Why: Distance counts both legs even though the finishing point equals the start.

Example 2 · Read an odometer

Worked-example information

A model cycle’s distance counter changes from 148 km to 156 km.

Question: How much distance was added?

Answer: 8 km.

Why: Subtract the starting counter reading from the ending reading.

Example 3 · Around a track

Worked-example information

A small virtual track is 20 m per lap. A vehicle completes three laps.

Question: What distance does it cover?

Answer: 60 m.

Why: Three complete laps each contribute 20 m.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Every route segment counts

Fixed case information

A library route goes 4 m along one aisle and then 3 m along a connecting aisle. The straight line between the endpoints is 5 m.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Route distance: 7 m.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Distance follows the travelled route: 4 + 3 = 7 m.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · A counter records distance

Fixed case information

A model bicycle’s distance counter reads 25 km before a trip and 33 km afterward.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Trip distance: 8 km
  • b: Starting reading: 25 km
  • c: Trip distance: 58 km
  • d: Starting reading: 33 km
Answer: Trip distance: 8 km; Starting reading: 25 km

The increase is 33 − 25 = 8 km.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Repeated laps

Fixed case information

One lap of a virtual track is 18 m. A car completes four whole laps.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies total distance in this case?

  • a: 72 m
  • b: 22 m
  • c: 36 m
  • d: 54 m
Answer: 72 m

Multiply the lap length by four.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · A return journey

Fixed case information

A messenger walks 6 m from a desk to a cabinet and 6 m back to the desk.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Distance travelled; Final change in position; Return segment

  • a: 12 m
  • b: 0 m
  • c: 6 m
  • d: −12 m
Answer: Distance travelled → 12 m; Final change in position → 0 m; Return segment → 6 m

Returning does not cancel the path length.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F5 · Explain a bent path

Fixed case information

A robot travels 3 m east and then 4 m north. The supplied map marks the direct start-to-finish line as 5 m.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Give the travelled distance and explain why the answer is not the map’s 5 m direct line.

Example of a full-credit answer: Adds 3 + 4 to give 7 m. Explains that distance follows the actual two-leg path, while 5 m joins the endpoints directly.

  1. Adds 3 + 4 to give 7 m.
  2. Explains that distance follows the actual two-leg path, while 5 m joins the endpoints directly.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A delivery cart follows three consecutive legs of 12 m, 5 m and 7 m. No other movement is made.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Total distance: 24 m
  • b: Number of legs: Three
  • c: Total distance: 14 m
  • d: Number of legs: Two
Answer: Total distance: 24 m; Number of legs: Three

All three travelled lengths count: 12 + 5 + 7 = 24.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the total and explain why every listed leg belongs in the sum.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives 24 m. Adds all three route segments because each was travelled.

  1. Gives 24 m.
  2. Adds all three route segments because each was travelled.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Route A has legs of 6 m and 8 m. Route B has legs of 4 m, 9 m and 3 m. Both reach the same destination.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Shorter route; A distance; B distance

  • a: Route A
  • b: 14 m
  • c: 16 m
  • d: Route B
Answer: Shorter route → Route A; A distance → 14 m; B distance → 16 m

A totals 14 m and B totals 16 m.

2B · Short answer

Choose a route and justify it by calculating both totals and stating how much shorter it is.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates A as 14 m and B as 16 m. Chooses A because it is 2 m shorter.

  1. Calculates A as 14 m and B as 16 m.
  2. Chooses A because it is 2 m shorter.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A park map represents 2 m for each grid step. A route follows three steps east and four north.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Total route distance; Total grid steps; Distance per step

  • a: 14 m
  • b: Seven
  • c: 2 m
  • d: 7 m
Answer: Total route distance → 14 m; Total grid steps → Seven; Distance per step → 2 m

Seven travelled steps at 2 m each give 14 m.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the real route length and explain how the map scale is used.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives 14 m. Adds seven route steps and multiplies by 2 m per step.

  1. Gives 14 m.
  2. Adds seven route steps and multiplies by 2 m per step.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A walker goes 12 m forward and 5 m back. A pupil subtracts to report a distance of 7 m.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies correct distance in this case?

  • a: 17 m
  • b: 7 m
  • c: −7 m
  • d: 60 m
Answer: 17 m

The return leg adds travelled length even though it reduces displacement.

4B · Short answer

Explain the mistaken quantity and calculate the distance.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that 12 − 5 gives displacement, not total distance. Adds 12 + 5 to give 17 m.

  1. Explains that 12 − 5 gives displacement, not total distance.
  2. Adds 12 + 5 to give 17 m.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Propose a route made of three positive-length legs, with total distance exactly 18 m. You may choose the directions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Required total; Required leg count; Allowed segment size

  • a: 18 m
  • b: Three
  • c: Positive length
  • d: 6 m total
Answer: Required total → 18 m; Required leg count → Three; Allowed segment size → Positive length

Any three positive lengths summing to 18 m meet the stated distance requirement.

5B · Open ended

Propose three leg lengths and verify the required total.

Example of a full-credit answer: Proposes three positive lengths, for example 5 m, 6 m and 7 m. Shows their sum is 18 m; direction does not subtract from distance.

  1. Proposes three positive lengths, for example 5 m, 6 m and 7 m.
  2. Shows that the three positive route lengths sum to 18 m.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.3 · Displacement

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Finish left of the start

Worked-example information

A toy starts at +4 m and ends at +1 m. Right is positive.

Question: What is its displacement?

Answer: −3 m, or 3 m left.

Why: Final minus initial position gives 1 − 4 = −3 m.

Example 2 · A loop in the playground

Worked-example information

A pupil follows a 40 m closed route and finishes at the starting mark.

Question: What is the displacement?

Answer: Zero.

Why: The endpoints coincide even though the travelled distance is 40 m.

Example 3 · A lift changes height

Worked-example information

A lift moves from height 2 m to height 8 m. Up is positive.

Question: What is its displacement?

Answer: +6 m upward.

Why: The reference direction changed from horizontal to vertical, but final minus initial still applies.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read two endpoints

Fixed case information

A cart starts at −4 m and finishes at +3 m. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Displacement; Initial position; Final position

  • a: +7 m
  • b: −4 m
  • c: +3 m
  • d: −7 m
Answer: Displacement → +7 m; Initial position → −4 m; Final position → +3 m

Final minus initial is 3 − (−4) = 7 m.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F2 · A loop ends where it began

Fixed case information

A robot follows one closed 24 m loop and stops at its start.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Displacement; Distance; Endpoint relation

  • a: 0 m
  • b: 24 m
  • c: Same start and finish
  • d: 48 m
Answer: Displacement → 0 m; Distance → 24 m; Endpoint relation → Same start and finish

Displacement uses endpoints, so a complete loop has zero displacement.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Direct change and a bent route

Fixed case information

A map gives a two-leg route of 3 m east and 4 m north. The direct start-to-finish arrow is labelled 5 m northeast.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies displacement magnitude in this case?

  • a: 5 m
  • b: 7 m
  • c: 1 m
  • d: 12 m
Answer: 5 m

The direct arrow describes displacement; the two travelled legs describe distance.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

F4 · Use a negative sign

Fixed case information

An object starts at +2 m and finishes at −5 m. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies displacement in this case?

  • a: −7 m
  • b: +7 m
  • c: −3 m
  • d: +3 m
Answer: −7 m

The change is −5 − 2 = −7 m.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F5 · Explain a leftward change

Fixed case information

A stage marker starts at 8 m and finishes at 1 m. Right is positive. The route between those points is not supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Give the displacement and explain why the full route is unnecessary for that calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives −7 m or 7 m left. Uses final minus initial position and explains that displacement depends on endpoints.

  1. Gives −7 m or 7 m left.
  2. Uses final minus initial position and explains that displacement depends on endpoints.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A cart starts at −2 m, travels past several stations and finishes at +4 m. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · True or false

True or false? Displacement: +6 m.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The displacement is 4 − (−2) = 6 m regardless of intermediate stops.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the displacement and explain the role of the intermediate stops.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives +6 m or 6 m right. Uses the endpoints and notes that intermediate stops do not change that endpoint difference.

  1. Gives +6 m or 6 m right.
  2. Uses the endpoints and notes that intermediate stops do not change that endpoint difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A traveller starts at 3 m and ends at 11 m after a winding route. Method A calculates 11 − 3. Method B adds all route segments.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Method for displacement; Displacement; Quantity found by B

  • a: Method A
  • b: +8 m
  • c: Distance
  • d: Method B
Answer: Method for displacement → Method A; Displacement → +8 m; Quantity found by B → Distance

A directly compares final and initial positions.

2B · Open ended

Choose a method, calculate the displacement, and explain why the other method answers a different question.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A and calculates +8 m. Explains that summing all route segments finds distance rather than displacement.

  1. Chooses A and calculates +8 m.
  2. Explains that summing all route segments finds distance rather than displacement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual lift starts 2 m above a reference platform and finishes 6 m below it. Up is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies displacement in this case?

  • a: −8 m
  • b: +8 m
  • c: −4 m
  • d: +4 m
Answer: −8 m

The new context uses the same rule: −6 − 2 = −8 m.

3B · Short answer

Find the displacement and interpret its sign in this vertical setting.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates −8 m. Explains that negative means 8 m downward because up is positive.

  1. Calculates −8 m.
  2. Explains that negative means 8 m downward because up is positive.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A marker moves from 2 m to 9 m, with right positive. A pupil calculates 2 − 9 = −7 m for displacement.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Correct displacement; Error; Correct order

  • a: +7 m
  • b: Initial minus final
  • c: Final minus initial
  • d: −7 m
Answer: Correct displacement → +7 m; Error → Initial minus final; Correct order → Final minus initial

The endpoints were subtracted in reverse order.

4B · Open ended

Identify the subtraction error and give the corrected result with direction.

Example of a full-credit answer: States that final position must come first. Gives 9 − 2 = +7 m, meaning 7 m right.

  1. States that final position must come first.
  2. Gives 9 − 2 = +7 m, meaning 7 m right.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Plan a straight journey that moves right and then left, travels exactly 12 m and finishes where it started. Both segments must be positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Rightward leg: 6 m right
  • b: Leftward leg: 6 m left
  • c: Rightward leg: 12 m right
  • d: Leftward leg: 3 m back
Answer: Rightward leg: 6 m right; Leftward leg: 6 m left

Equal opposite legs give zero displacement; 6 + 6 gives 12 m distance.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two segments and verify both the distance and displacement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Proposes 6 m right then 6 m left. Checks 12 m distance and zero final-minus-initial displacement.

  1. Proposes 6 m right then 6 m left.
  2. Checks 12 m distance and zero final-minus-initial displacement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.4 · Speed

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A toy train

Worked-example information

A train covers 24 m in 8 s.

Question: What is its average speed?

Answer: 3 m/s.

Why: Average speed is total distance divided by total elapsed time: 24 ÷ 8.

Example 2 · Remember the pause

Worked-example information

A cart travels 15 m in 5 s and then waits for 5 s. The recorded journey includes the wait.

Question: What is its average speed over all 10 s?

Answer: 1.5 m/s.

Why: The full elapsed time is 10 s, so 15 ÷ 10 = 1.5 m/s.

Example 3 · Equal routes, different times
Model runners
RunnerDistance (m)Time (s)
A3010
B3015

Worked-example information

Two model runners each cover 30 m. A takes 10 s and B takes 15 s.

Question: Which has the greater average speed?

Answer: A: 3 m/s, compared with B: 2 m/s.

Why: For the same distance, less time gives a greater average speed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A straight train run

Fixed case information

A toy train covers 18 m in 6 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Average speed: 3 m/s.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Divide 18 by 6 to find 3 m/s.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F2 · Two equal track lengths

Fixed case information

Model runner A covers 20 m in 5 s. B covers 20 m in 10 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: A average speed; B average speed; Faster runner

  • a: 4 m/s
  • b: 2 m/s
  • c: A
  • d: 1 m/s
Answer: A average speed → 4 m/s; B average speed → 2 m/s; Faster runner → A

Use the same distance-over-time rule for both runners.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · A recorded wait

Fixed case information

A delivery robot moves 12 m during 4 s, then waits 2 s. The whole recorded trip includes both parts.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies whole-trip average speed in this case?

  • a: 2 m/s
  • b: 3 m/s
  • c: 6 m/s
  • d: 0 m/s
Answer: 2 m/s

The waiting time is part of the stated 6 s interval.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · A shorter-unit calculation

Fixed case information

A virtual snail moves 24 cm in 8 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Average speed: 3 cm/s
  • b: Distance unit: Centimetres
  • c: Average speed: 3 m/s
  • d: Distance unit: Metres
Answer: Average speed: 3 cm/s; Distance unit: Centimetres

The distance was measured in centimetres, so the result is cm/s.

Scientific explorer: unit lab

F5 · Explain a return trip

Fixed case information

A swimmer in a model moves 10 m to a marker and 10 m back in 10 s altogether.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Calculate average speed and explain why returning to the start does not make it zero.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates (10 + 10) ÷ 10 = 2 m/s. Explains that average speed uses travelled distance, not the zero endpoint change.

  1. Calculates (10 + 10) ÷ 10 = 2 m/s.
  2. Explains that average speed uses travelled distance, not the zero endpoint change.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A delivery model travels 15 m in 5 s and another 9 m in 1 s, with no pause between them.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies whole-trip average speed in this case?

  • a: 4 m/s
  • b: 8 m/s
  • c: 24 m/s
  • d: 0.33 m/s
Answer: 4 m/s

Add distances and times before dividing: 24 ÷ 6 = 4 m/s. The two stage speeds are different.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the whole-trip average speed and show both totals used.

Example of a full-credit answer: Adds the distances to 24 m and times to 6 s. Divides to obtain 4 m/s.

  1. Adds the distances to 24 m and times to 6 s.
  2. Divides to obtain 4 m/s.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A robot covers 16 m while moving for 4 s, then stops for 4 s. Report A gives 16 ÷ 8 for the whole 8 s journey. Report B gives 16 ÷ 4 for the whole journey.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Correct whole-trip report: Report A
  • b: Whole-trip average speed: 2 m/s
  • c: Correct whole-trip report: Report B
  • d: Whole-trip average speed: 4 m/s
Answer: Correct whole-trip report: Report A; Whole-trip average speed: 2 m/s

The question includes the entire interval, including the stop.

2B · Short answer

Choose a report, give the whole-trip average speed, and justify why the stopped time belongs in its calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Report A and gives 2 m/s. Explains that the stated whole journey includes all 8 s, even when no distance is added.

  1. Chooses Report A and gives 2 m/s.
  2. Explains that the stated whole journey includes all 8 s, even when no distance is added.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual conveyor carries a parcel 150 cm in 5 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Average speed; Distance; Elapsed time

  • a: 30 cm/s
  • b: 150 cm
  • c: 5 s
  • d: 30 m/s
Answer: Average speed → 30 cm/s; Distance → 150 cm; Elapsed time → 5 s

Use the stated centimetres: 150 ÷ 5 = 30 cm/s.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the speed and explain which distance unit must appear in the answer.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives 30 cm/s. Explains that centimetres were divided by seconds; 30 m/s would use the wrong unit.

  1. Gives 30 cm/s.
  2. Explains that centimetres were divided by seconds; 30 m/s would use the wrong unit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A toy moves 20 m in 5 s. A pupil calculates 5 ÷ 20 = 0.25 and writes 0.25 m/s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Correct average speed: 4 m/s.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Speed is distance per time; the reversed division has a different unit.

4B · Short answer

Identify the reversed operation and give the correct speed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that the pupil divided time by distance instead of distance by time. Gives 20 ÷ 5 = 4 m/s.

  1. Explains that the pupil divided time by distance instead of distance by time.
  2. Gives 20 ÷ 5 = 4 m/s.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Design a model trip lasting exactly 20 s with average speed 3 m/s. You may divide it into two stages, but their distances and times must be positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Required total distance; Required total time; Target average speed

  • a: 60 m
  • b: 20 s
  • c: 3 m/s
  • d: 23 m
Answer: Required total distance → 60 m; Required total time → 20 s; Target average speed → 3 m/s

Total distance must equal 3 × 20 = 60 m.

5B · Open ended

Propose two stages and verify the complete trip’s distance, time and average speed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Proposes positive stage distances totalling 60 m and times totalling 20 s, such as 30 m in 10 s twice. Checks 60 ÷ 20 = 3 m/s; the stage speeds need not be identical.

  1. Proposes positive stage distances totalling 60 m and times totalling 20 s, such as 30 m in 10 s twice.
  2. Verifies that the total distance divided by total time is 3 m/s. Accept valid stages with equal or different speeds.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.5 · Velocity

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A directed change

Worked-example information

A cart moves from 1 m to 9 m in 4 s. Right is positive.

Question: What is its average velocity?

Answer: +2 m/s, or 2 m/s right.

Why: Displacement is 9 − 1 = 8 m; 8 ÷ 4 = 2 m/s.

Example 2 · Same place after a trip

Worked-example information

A swimmer travels 12 m out and 12 m back in 12 s.

Question: What are average velocity and average speed?

Answer: Average velocity is 0 m/s; average speed is 2 m/s.

Why: The displacement is zero, while the distance is 24 m.

Example 3 · Downward motion

Worked-example information

A lift goes from height 8 m to height 2 m in 3 s. Up is positive.

Question: What is its average velocity?

Answer: −2 m/s, meaning 2 m/s downward.

Why: The signed displacement is −6 m and the elapsed time is 3 s.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A cart moves right

Fixed case information

A cart starts at 2 m and ends at 10 m after 4 s. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies average velocity in this case?

  • a: +2 m/s
  • b: −2 m/s
  • c: +3 m/s
  • d: +8 m/s
Answer: +2 m/s

Average velocity is (10 − 2) ÷ 4 = +2 m/s.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F2 · A lift moves down

Fixed case information

A virtual lift starts at height 9 m and ends at 3 m after 3 s. Up is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Average velocity; Displacement; Direction

  • a: −2 m/s
  • b: −6 m
  • c: Down
  • d: +2 m/s
Answer: Average velocity → −2 m/s; Displacement → −6 m; Direction → Down

The endpoint change is 3 − 9 = −6 m, then divide by 3 s.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

F3 · A closed swimming route

Fixed case information

A model swimmer travels 8 m out and 8 m back in 8 s, finishing at the starting point.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Average velocity: 0 m/s
  • b: Average speed: 2 m/s
  • c: Average velocity: 2 m/s
  • d: Average speed: 1 m/s
Answer: Average velocity: 0 m/s; Average speed: 2 m/s

Average velocity uses zero displacement, whereas speed uses the 16 m path.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F4 · Velocity needs direction

Fixed case information

Two model carts each travel steadily at speed 3 m/s on one straight track. Cart A moves right and cart B left. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? A velocity: +3 m/s.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Equal speeds can have opposite velocities because direction matters.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain a sign and an interval

Fixed case information

A robot starts at +5 m and finishes at −3 m after 4 s. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Calculate the average velocity and explain the meaning of its sign.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives −2 m/s from −8 m divided by 4 s. Explains that the negative sign means the net change is leftward.

  1. Gives −2 m/s from −8 m divided by 4 s.
  2. Explains that the negative sign means the net change is leftward.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A model cart starts at −2 m, travels 14 m right and 4 m left, taking 5 s altogether. Right is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Average velocity; Displacement; Final position

  • a: +2 m/s
  • b: +10 m
  • c: +8 m
  • d: +3.6 m/s
Answer: Average velocity → +2 m/s; Displacement → +10 m; Final position → +8 m

The signed change is 14 − 4 = 10 m; 10 ÷ 5 = 2 m/s.

1B · Short answer

Calculate average velocity and show why total path length is not its numerator.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives +2 m/s from the +10 m displacement over 5 s. Explains that the 18 m path is distance for average speed, not displacement for velocity.

  1. Gives +2 m/s from the +10 m displacement over 5 s.
  2. Explains that the 18 m path is distance for average speed, not displacement for velocity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A toy boat goes 6 m east and 6 m west in 6 s, returning to the start. Report A gives average velocity 0 m/s. Report B gives 2 m/s east.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Correct report: Report A
  • b: Whole-trip displacement: 0 m
  • c: Correct report: Report B
  • d: Whole-trip displacement: 12 m east
Answer: Correct report: Report A; Whole-trip displacement: 0 m

Returning to the start makes displacement and average velocity zero.

2B · Open ended

Choose a report and explain what the other report actually calculates.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A because displacement is zero. Explains that 12 ÷ 6 = 2 m/s is average speed, not an eastward whole-trip velocity.

  1. Chooses A because displacement is zero.
  2. Explains that 12 ÷ 6 = 2 m/s is average speed, not an eastward whole-trip velocity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A lift moves from height 2 m to height 14 m in 6 s. Up is positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Average velocity; Displacement; Direction

  • a: +2 m/s
  • b: +12 m
  • c: Up
  • d: −2 m/s
Answer: Average velocity → +2 m/s; Displacement → +12 m; Direction → Up

Vertical motion follows the same signed displacement-over-time rule.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the average velocity and interpret it in the vertical coordinate system.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives +2 m/s from (14 − 2) ÷ 6. States that positive means the net change is upward.

  1. Gives +2 m/s from (14 − 2) ÷ 6.
  2. States that positive means the net change is upward.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A runner moves 9 m right and 3 m left in 3 s. A pupil uses (9 + 3) ÷ 3 = 4 m/s as average velocity to the right.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Correct average velocity; Displacement; Quantity equal to 4 m/s

  • a: +2 m/s
  • b: +6 m
  • c: Average speed
  • d: +4 m/s
Answer: Correct average velocity → +2 m/s; Displacement → +6 m; Quantity equal to 4 m/s → Average speed

Velocity uses the signed change, (9 − 3) ÷ 3 = 2 m/s.

4B · Open ended

Identify the mistaken numerator and calculate the corrected average velocity.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that the pupil used total distance instead of displacement. Gives (9 − 3) ÷ 3 = +2 m/s.

  1. Explains that the pupil used total distance instead of displacement.
  2. Gives (9 − 3) ÷ 3 = +2 m/s.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Design a straight trip starting at 0 m and lasting 5 s. It must travel 30 m altogether and have average velocity +2 m/s, moving right then left with both segments positive.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies rightward segment in this case?

  • a: 20 m right
  • b: 10 m right
  • c: 20 m left
  • d: 30 m right
Answer: 20 m right

A +2 m/s average over 5 s needs +10 m displacement. The segments must also sum to 30 m.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two segments and verify both the distance and average velocity.

Example of a full-credit answer: Proposes 20 m right and 10 m left, totalling 30 m. Checks displacement +10 m and +10 ÷ 5 = +2 m/s.

  1. Proposes 20 m right and 10 m left, totalling 30 m.
  2. Checks displacement +10 m and +10 ÷ 5 = +2 m/s.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.6 · Acceleration

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Starting and ending speeds

Worked example information

A cart keeps moving right from 1 to 7 m/s over 2 s.

Question: What is average acceleration?

Answer: 3 m/s² right.

Why: The velocity change is 6 m/s, divided by 2 s.

Example 2 · A steady cart
Velocity record
Time (s)Velocity (m/s)
05
15
25

Worked example information

Velocity readings at 0, 1 and 2 s are all 5 m/s right.

Question: What is acceleration?

Answer: 0 m/s².

Why: Velocity did not change.

Example 3 · Slowing while moving right

Worked example information

Velocity falls from 9 to 3 m/s in 3 s. Right is positive.

Question: What is average acceleration?

Answer: −2 m/s².

Why: (3 − 9) ÷ 3 = −2; the velocity change points left.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Compute a change

Fixed question information

A cart goes from 2 to 10 m/s right in 4 s. Right is positive.

F1 · Multiple choice

What is its average acceleration?

  • a: 8 m/s
  • b: 2 m/s²
  • c: 12 m/s
  • d: 2.5 m/s²
Answer: 2 m/s²

(10 − 2) ÷ 4 = 2.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F2 · Read constant velocity

Fixed question information

A velocity graph is horizontal at 6 m/s over 3 seconds.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Acceleration: 2 m/s²
  • b: Velocity: 18 m/s
  • c: Acceleration: 0 m/s²
  • d: Velocity: 6 m/s
Answer: Acceleration: 0 m/s²; Velocity: 6 m/s

A horizontal velocity record shows no change.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Compare masses

Fixed question information

Both carts have 6 N net force. A has mass 2 kg and B 3 kg. Use a = F/m.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: A acceleration; B acceleration

  • a: 12 m/s²
  • b: 18 m/s²
  • c: 3 m/s²
  • d: 2 m/s²
Answer: A acceleration → 3 m/s²; B acceleration → 2 m/s²

Divide the same force by each mass.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F4 · Slowing motion

Fixed question information

A rightward cart changes from 8 to 4 m/s in 2 s.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Acceleration; Velocity change

  • a: −2 m/s²
  • b: 2 m/s²
  • c: 4 m/s
  • d: −4 m/s
Answer: Acceleration → −2 m/s²; Velocity change → −4 m/s

The final-minus-initial change is negative.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F5 · Explain fast and steady

Fixed question information

A cart moves steadily right at 12 m/s for 5 s.

F5 · Open ended

Can the cart be moving quickly while its acceleration is zero? Explain using the velocity record.

Example of a full-credit answer: Yes. It keeps the same 12 m/s velocity, so its velocity change and acceleration are zero even while it moves.

  1. States that the cart can be moving with zero acceleration.
  2. Uses unchanged velocity to explain zero acceleration.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A cart goes from 3 to 15 m/s right in 4 s.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Acceleration; Velocity change

  • a: 3.75 m/s²
  • b: 3 m/s²
  • c: 18 m/s
  • d: 12 m/s
Answer: Acceleration → 3 m/s²; Velocity change → 12 m/s

(15 − 3) ÷ 4 = 3.

1B · Open ended

Find acceleration and show why subtracting the starting velocity is necessary.

Example of a full-credit answer: The change is 15 − 3 = 12 m/s, not 15. Dividing by 4 s gives 3 m/s².

  1. Calculates 3 m/s².
  2. Uses the 12 m/s change rather than final velocity alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Cart A changes by 8 m/s in 2 s; B changes by 8 m/s in 4 s, both rightward.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Larger acceleration: A.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

The same change over less time is a larger acceleration.

2B · Short answer

Choose a cart and justify using both ratios.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is 8/2 = 4 m/s²; B is 8/4 = 2 m/s². A changes velocity more rapidly.

  1. Calculates both accelerations.
  2. Uses the shorter time per equal velocity change to justify A.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A 12 N net force acts on 3 kg. A second trial uses the same force on 6 kg.

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: First acceleration; Loaded acceleration

  • a: 72 m/s²
  • b: 4 m/s²
  • c: 2 m/s²
  • d: 36 m/s²
Answer: First acceleration → 4 m/s²; Loaded acceleration → 2 m/s²

Doubling mass halves acceleration for this same net force.

3B · Open ended

Predict the loaded trolley’s acceleration and explain the comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: The loaded trolley has 12/6 = 2 m/s², half the initial 4, because the same net force acts on twice the mass.

  1. Gives loaded acceleration 2 m/s².
  2. Explains the equal-force, doubled-mass comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

For a change from 4 to 10 m/s in 3 s, Ari calculates 10 ÷ 3 as acceleration.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Acceleration: 10/3 m/s²
  • b: Acceleration: 2 m/s²
  • c: Required velocity change: 6 m/s
  • d: Required velocity change: 14 m/s
Answer: Acceleration: 2 m/s²; Required velocity change: 6 m/s

Subtract the initial velocity before dividing.

4B · Short answer

Identify the missing step and give a corrected calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Ari forgot initial velocity. (10 − 4) ÷ 3 = 2 m/s².

  1. Identifies missing subtraction of initial velocity.
  2. Gives the correct 2 m/s² calculation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual cart starts at 2 m/s right. For 3 seconds its velocity must rise by 2 m/s each second.

5A · Hotspot

What is its final velocity?

  • a: 3 m/s²
  • b: 2 m/s²
  • c: 8 m/s
  • d: 6 m/s
Answer: 8 m/s

Three equal increases of 2 add 6 to the starting 2.

5B · Open ended

Propose the velocity readings at 0, 1, 2 and 3 s and verify the acceleration.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 2, 4, 6 and 8 m/s. Each one-second change is 2 m/s, so acceleration is 2 m/s².

  1. Gives the four consistent velocity readings.
  2. Checks equal changes per second as 2 m/s².

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.7 · Forces

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two friends and one trolley
Forces on the trolley
Force sourceForce
Maia5 N right
Leo3 N right
Floor2 N left

Worked example information

On one trolley, Maia pushes 5 N right and Leo pushes 3 N right. Floor resistance is 2 N left.

Question: What is the trolley’s net horizontal force?

Answer: 6 N right.

Why: The rightward forces add to 8 N; subtract the 2 N opposing force.

Example 2 · Clay can change shape

Worked example information

A virtual hand presses a model clay cube. Its height falls from 6 to 4 units while its base widens.

Question: What force effect is directly shown?

Answer: Deformation: the clay changes shape.

Why: A change in shape is a force effect even when the object does not move far across the table.

Example 3 · Name the receiver

Worked example information

A virtual magnet pulls a steel piece toward itself. At the same time the steel piece pulls the magnet toward itself.

Question: Do those two forces act on one object and cancel there?

Answer: No. One acts on the steel piece and the other on the magnet.

Why: A net-force diagram includes forces on one chosen object, not both members of an interaction pair.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Push or distant pull

Fixed question information

A model hand pushes a cart by touching it. A magnet attracts a steel piece across a gap. A thermometer measures temperature, not force.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Noncontact interaction: Magnet pulling steel
  • b: Contact interaction: Temperature reading
  • c: Noncontact interaction: Hand needing no contact
  • d: Contact interaction: Hand pushing cart
Answer: Noncontact interaction: Magnet pulling steel; Contact interaction: Hand pushing cart

The hand acts through contact; the magnet can attract across a gap.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F2 · One object, two arrows

Fixed question information

A toy cart has 9 N rightward push and 4 N leftward resistance. Only these horizontal forces act on this cart.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Net force; Opposing resistance

  • a: 13 N right
  • b: 5 N right
  • c: 4 N left
  • d: 9 N left
Answer: Net force → 5 N right; Opposing resistance → 4 N left

Subtract opposing magnitudes: 9 − 4 = 5 N right.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F3 · Stretching evidence

Fixed question information

A fictional spring model records extensions of 1, 2 and 3 cm under pulls of 2, 4 and 6 N. The data describe this limited model range.

F3 · Hotspot

Which measured extension belongs to a 4 N pull?

  • a: 4 cm
  • b: 6 cm
  • c: 2 cm
  • d: 3 cm
Answer: 2 cm

Read the stated 4 N row: the extension is 2 cm.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Whose force is it?

Fixed question information

A hand pushes a cart 5 N right. The cart pushes the hand 5 N left. No other horizontal force acts on the cart in this idealised case.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Force on cart; Force on hand

  • a: Both forces on cart
  • b: Neither object feels a force
  • c: Hand pushes 5 N right
  • d: Cart pushes 5 N left
Answer: Force on cart → Hand pushes 5 N right; Force on hand → Cart pushes 5 N left

The receiver of each force determines which object’s diagram includes it.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · A bent strip

Fixed question information

A virtual thin strip bends when a load is applied. It returns to its initial shape when the load is removed. The model remains in its stated elastic range.

F5 · Short answer

Describe the force effect and explain what the unloading observation tells us about this model strip.

Example of a full-credit answer: The force bends the strip. Returning to its original shape shows elastic recovery within the tested range.

  1. Identifies bending or change in shape caused by the applied force.
  2. Uses recovery after unloading as evidence for elastic rather than permanent deformation in this range.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A library trolley receives 6 N right from one student and 4 N right from another. A measured floor resistance is 3 N left. Consider only these horizontal forces.

1A · Hotspot

What is the trolley’s net horizontal force?

  • a: 13 N right
  • b: 3 N right
  • c: 7 N left
  • d: 7 N right
Answer: 7 N right

Add the two rightward pushes before subtracting the resistance: 6 + 4 − 3 = 7.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the net force and explain why the two pushes are added before the resistance is subtracted.

Example of a full-credit answer: The net force is 7 N right. Both pushes act right on the same trolley, so they add; the leftward resistance opposes them.

  1. Calculates 7 N to the right.
  2. Explains addition of same-direction forces and subtraction of the opposing force on the same object.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

In a fictional test, record A shows a strip returning to its starting shape after a pull is removed. B gives its paint colour. C gives the label font.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Relevant record: B.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Shape observations before and after unloading address elastic recovery.

2B · Open ended

Justify the useful record and explain why it does not show the strip can withstand unlimited force.

Example of a full-credit answer: A directly records recovery after a pull. It tests only the stated range; a larger force might cause permanent deformation or damage.

  1. Uses the before/after shape recovery as the relevant evidence.
  2. Limits the conclusion to the tested force range rather than all possible loads.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A virtual steel cart is pulled toward a magnet across a gap. The magnet provides 8 N left and the model track provides 2 N right. These are the only horizontal forces.

3A · Multiple choice

What is the steel cart’s net horizontal force?

  • a: 10 N left
  • b: 6 N right
  • c: 6 N left
  • d: 2 N right
Answer: 6 N left

The 2 N rightward resistance opposes the 8 N leftward magnetic force.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the net force and explain why no hand contact is needed for the main pull.

Example of a full-credit answer: The net force is 6 N left. Magnetic attraction acts across the gap, so the magnet need not touch the cart.

  1. Calculates 6 N left from the two stated forces.
  2. Explains that magnetic attraction can act without direct contact.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says, “The cart pushes my hand back equally, so my push has zero effect on the cart.” The hand-on-cart force is 5 N right; the cart-on-hand force is 5 N left. No other horizontal cart force is included.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Force in cart diagram; Force on other object

  • a: No force acts on either object
  • b: Hand-on-cart force
  • c: Both forces on the cart
  • d: Cart-on-hand force
Answer: Force in cart diagram → Hand-on-cart force; Force on other object → Cart-on-hand force

The equal opposite interaction forces have different receiving objects.

4B · Open ended

Identify the diagram error and state the correct net horizontal force on the cart in this idealised case.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner combines forces on different objects. Only the 5 N hand-on-cart force belongs here, so the cart has 5 N right net force.

  1. Explains that the interaction pair acts on different objects and cannot cancel in the cart diagram.
  2. States the cart’s net force is 5 N right under the given assumptions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual trolley has fixed 2 N leftward resistance. The design target is 4 N net force right. Two students may share the rightward push; their positive pushes add.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required combined push; Fixed resistance

  • a: 6 N right
  • b: 2 N left
  • c: 8 N right
  • d: 4 N right
Answer: Required combined push → 6 N right; Fixed resistance → 2 N left

The combined push must be 4 + 2 = 6 N right.

5B · Open ended

Propose two positive rightward pushes that meet the target and show the net-force check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 2 N and 4 N right. Their total is 6 N, and 6 − 2 = 4 N right. Other positive pairs totalling 6 N are valid.

  1. Proposes two positive same-direction pushes totalling 6 N.
  2. Checks the opposing 2 N resistance to obtain 4 N net right.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.8 · Balanced and unbalanced forces

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A supported book
Book force diagram
ForceMagnitudeDirection
Gravity6Down
Table support6Up

Worked example information

A book rests on a horizontal table. Gravity on it is 6 N down and support is 6 N up; these are its two vertical forces.

Question: What is its net vertical force?

Answer: 0 N.

Why: The two forces have equal size and opposite directions on the same book.

Example 2 · Moving with a zero net force

Worked example information

A virtual trolley is already moving right at 3 m/s. Its drive force is 4 N right and resistance is 4 N left on a straight level track.

Question: What motion is consistent with these unchanged balanced forces?

Answer: Continuing right at 3 m/s.

Why: Zero net force means no change in velocity; it does not require the trolley to be at rest.

Example 3 · Turning at unchanged speed

Worked example information

A virtual train follows a curved track at a constant speed. Its direction changes.

Question: Can its total force be zero throughout the turn?

Answer: No. Changing velocity direction requires a nonzero net force.

Why: Speed alone omits direction. The turn demonstrates acceleration even without a speed increase.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Book and table

Fixed question information

A resting book has gravity 10 N down and table support 10 N up. No other vertical forces are included.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Net vertical force; Individual support force

  • a: 10 N up
  • b: 20 N down
  • c: 0 N
  • d: No force exists
Answer: Net vertical force → 0 N; Individual support force → 10 N up

Opposite 10 N forces balance on the book.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · A steady moving cart

Fixed question information

A model cart moves right along a straight track. Its drive is 3 N right and resistance is 3 N left throughout the interval.

F2 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Velocity behaviour: No change in velocity.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Balanced forces permit unchanged motion, including an already moving cart.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F3 · A curved path

Fixed question information

A virtual rider travels at constant speed around a curve. The direction of motion changes from east toward north.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changing feature; Net-force requirement

  • a: No velocity change
  • b: Nonzero net force
  • c: Zero net force is required
  • d: Direction
Answer: Changing feature → Direction; Net-force requirement → Nonzero net force

Direction is part of velocity, so the turning motion has acceleration.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Unequal horizontal arrows

Fixed question information

An empty model cart has 8 N right and 3 N left acting on it. Right is positive.

F4 · Hotspot

What is the net horizontal force?

  • a: 11 N right
  • b: 5 N left
  • c: 5 N right
  • d: 0 N
Answer: 5 N right

The larger rightward force exceeds the opposing one by 5 N.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F5 · Slowing without instant reversal

Fixed question information

A ball is moving left. During a short interval its only net horizontal force is 2 N right. It has not yet stopped.

F5 · Open ended

Explain the initial change in speed and why the ball need not immediately move right.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its leftward speed decreases because the force is opposite its motion. Velocity changes over time, so it can still move left while slowing.

  1. Predicts initial slowing of the leftward motion because net force points right.
  2. Distinguishes gradual velocity change from an instantaneous reversal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: force lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A classroom sign hangs at rest. Two vertical strings each pull upward with 6 N. Its weight is 12 N downward. There are no other vertical forces.

1A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Net vertical force; Total upward support

  • a: 24 N up
  • b: 12 N
  • c: 0 N
  • d: 6 N down
Answer: Net vertical force → 0 N; Total upward support → 12 N

The two supports add to 12 N upward, balancing 12 N down.

1B · Open ended

Combine the string forces and explain why the sign can remain at rest despite three nonzero forces.

Example of a full-credit answer: The strings provide 6 + 6 = 12 N up, balanced by 12 N down. Net force is zero, so its resting velocity need not change.

  1. Adds both supports and obtains zero net vertical force.
  2. Explains that balanced nonzero forces allow an initially resting object to remain at rest.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A cart moves along a straight line through positions 0, 4, 8 and 12 m at times 0, 1, 2 and 3 s. Diagram A has zero net force; B has constant net force right; C has constant net force left.

2A · Multiple choice

Which diagram is consistent with the straight-line position record?

  • a: B: constant nonzero force right
  • b: C: constant nonzero force left
  • c: All three diagrams equally fit
  • d: A: zero net force
Answer: A: zero net force

Equal position changes over equal times on a straight line show constant velocity.

2B · Short answer

Justify the force-diagram choice using the motion data.

Example of a full-credit answer: A fits because the cart moves 4 m right every second, so velocity does not change and the net force is zero.

  1. Uses the equal 4 m changes over equal one-second intervals as evidence of constant velocity.
  2. Connects unchanged velocity with diagram A’s zero net force.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A model package rests on a support. In setting Earth its weight and support are each 12 N. In setting Moon they are each 2 N. Both settings include only these vertical forces.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Moon net force: 4 N down.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

The equal opposite 2 N forces balance, even though their magnitudes differ from Earth’s.

3B · Open ended

Explain whether the package can remain at rest in both settings and whether zero net force means gravity is absent.

Example of a full-credit answer: It can remain at rest in both because support balances weight. Gravity still acts: 12 N in the first model and 2 N in the second.

  1. Explains rest in both settings using balanced support and weight.
  2. Explicitly distinguishes zero net force from absence of gravity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner writes “A cart going around a circle at constant speed has balanced forces because its speed is unchanged.” The cart’s direction changes throughout the motion.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Changing velocity feature: Direction
  • b: Force conclusion: Balanced forces are proved
  • c: Force conclusion: Net force is nonzero
  • d: Changing velocity feature: Speed must always increase
Answer: Changing velocity feature: Direction; Force conclusion: Net force is nonzero

A changing direction is acceleration even at constant speed.

4B · Short answer

Identify the missing part of velocity and correct the force conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner ignored direction. Circular motion changes velocity direction, so the cart needs a nonzero net force toward the curve’s inside.

  1. Identifies changing direction as the omitted part of velocity.
  2. Corrects balanced forces to a nonzero net force causing the turn.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A model delivery cart is already moving right. It experiences fixed 3 N leftward resistance. You may choose one constant rightward drive force, and you want unchanged velocity along the straight track.

5A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required drive; Resulting net force

  • a: 6 N right
  • b: 3 N right
  • c: 0 N drive
  • d: 0 N
Answer: Required drive → 3 N right; Resulting net force → 0 N

Equal opposing forces keep the current velocity unchanged.

5B · Open ended

Propose the drive force and describe motion measurements that would check your goal.

Example of a full-credit answer: Set the drive to 3 N right. Record position at equal time intervals; equal rightward distances on the straight track support constant velocity.

  1. Chooses 3 N right to balance the fixed leftward resistance.
  2. Proposes equal-time position/distance observations that check constant straight-line velocity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.9 · Friction

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Reverse the motion

Worked example information

A virtual book slides left relative to a stationary table. The stated sliding-friction magnitude is 3 N.

Question: What direction is friction on the book?

Answer: 3 N right.

Why: It opposes the book’s relative sliding along the table, so the direction reverses when the slide reverses.

Example 2 · Grip below its limit
Grip account
QuantityValue
Applied push2 N right
Available limit5 N
Friction needed for rest2 N left

Worked example information

A resting model box has a 2 N rightward push. The surface can provide up to 5 N static friction before slipping. No other horizontal forces act.

Question: What friction balances this particular push?

Answer: 2 N left, not automatically 5 N.

Why: Static friction supplies the amount needed for balance within its limit.

Example 3 · Braking energy

Worked example information

A virtual wheel loses 40 J of motion energy. A complete account records 32 J thermal transfer and 8 J sound/deformation transfer.

Question: Has any of the 40 J been destroyed?

Answer: No: 32 + 8 = 40 J is accounted for.

Why: “Lost from motion” means transferred to other pathways, not removed from the total energy account.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Which way is friction?

Fixed question information

A block slides right relative to a fixed surface in trial A and left in trial B. Sliding friction opposes each relative slide.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Trial A friction; Trial B friction

  • a: Always along the slide
  • b: Left
  • c: Always upward
  • d: Right
Answer: Trial A friction → Left; Trial B friction → Right

The friction direction changes when the relative sliding direction changes.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Compare steady pulls

Fixed question information

Equal model sleds move at the same steady speed. The required horizontal pull is 2 N on surface P, 5 N on Q and 3 N on R. In each trial pull balances sliding resistance.

F2 · Hotspot

Which tested surface has the smallest sliding resistance?

  • a: Q
  • b: P
  • c: R
  • d: All three are equal
Answer: P

The smallest balancing pull is 2 N on P.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Grip without slipping

Fixed question information

A model crate remains at rest under a 3 N rightward push. Its static-friction limit is 7 N. No other horizontal forces act.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Actual static friction; Maximum available grip

  • a: 7 N
  • b: 3 N left
  • c: 0 N because it is resting
  • d: 7 N left in every case
Answer: Actual static friction → 3 N left; Maximum available grip → 7 N

The needed balancing force is 3 N, below the stated limit.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F4 · A brake’s energy account

Fixed question information

A virtual brake removes 50 J from motion during an interval. The complete model records 45 J thermal transfer and 5 J sound/deformation transfer.

F4 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Thermal destination: Energy destroyed forever.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

All fifty joules are accounted for in other pathways.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F5 · A shoe pushes on the ground

Fixed question information

In a simplified walking step, the shoe pushes backward on the ground without slipping. The ground exerts forward static friction on the shoe.

F5 · Short answer

State friction’s direction on the shoe and explain why “friction always acts backward” is wrong.

Example of a full-credit answer: Friction on the shoe is forward here. Its direction resists the contact’s slipping tendency, not always the overall travel direction.

  1. States the source’s forward friction force on the shoe.
  2. Explains direction using relative slipping/tendency at contact rather than a universal backward rule.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A model block is already sliding left. There is 4 N sliding friction right and a separate 1 N pull left. These are its only horizontal forces during the interval.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Net force; Current sliding direction

  • a: 3 N right
  • b: Left
  • c: 5 N left
  • d: 3 N left
Answer: Net force → 3 N right; Current sliding direction → Left

4 N right opposed by 1 N left leaves 3 N right.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the net force and explain the initial effect on the block’s leftward motion.

Example of a full-credit answer: The net force is 3 N right. It opposes the current leftward velocity, so the block initially slows.

  1. Calculates 3 N right from the stated forces.
  2. Predicts initial slowing because acceleration opposes the current motion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A model drawer needs low sliding resistance. Equal drawers at equal load and steady speed require 2 N on P and 6 N on Q. Each value is the average of repeated comparable pulls.

2A · Multiple choice

Which tested surface better meets the low-resistance drawer goal?

  • a: P
  • b: Q
  • c: Both are equally resistant
  • d: Neither can be compared from the supplied force readings
Answer: P

The smaller balancing pull indicates less sliding resistance for these controlled tests.

2B · Open ended

Justify the drawer choice and explain why the same choice need not be best for a shoe’s grip.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose P because it needs only 2 N rather than 6 N. A shoe may require more available static grip to prevent slipping, a different goal.

  1. Chooses P using the equal-condition smaller steady-pull evidence.
  2. Distinguishes low sliding resistance from the separate goal of preventing shoe slip.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A model display box rests on a level shelf. A 4 N rightward push is applied. The contact can provide up to 6 N static friction, and there are no other horizontal forces.

3A · Hotspot

What actual friction force can keep the box at rest?

  • a: 6 N left
  • b: 4 N right
  • c: 4 N left
  • d: 0 N
Answer: 4 N left

Four newtons left is enough and lies within the six-newton limit.

3B · Short answer

State the friction force needed for rest and explain why using the full 6 N limit would be incorrect here.

Example of a full-credit answer: It needs 4 N left. Static friction adjusts to balance the applied push up to its limit; applying 6 N would create an unbalanced total.

  1. States the needed 4 N left static friction.
  2. Explains adjustment below the maximum and why the maximum is not automatically the actual force.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says, “The brake destroyed 60 J of motion energy.” The fixed model records 50 J thermal energy gain and 10 J other transfers, with no missing pathway.

4A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Energy description; Thermal share

  • a: 50 J
  • b: Destroyed completely
  • c: Transferred to other pathways
  • d: 70 J produced
Answer: Energy description → Transferred to other pathways; Thermal share → 50 J

Fifty plus ten equals the sixty-joule decrease in motion energy.

4B · Open ended

Identify the mistaken claim and give the corrected full energy account.

Example of a full-credit answer: Energy was transferred, not destroyed. The 60 J appears as 50 J thermal gain plus 10 J other transfers.

  1. Rejects destruction and explains transfer from motion to other forms/stores.
  2. Gives the balanced 50 + 10 = 60 J account.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual tester can change track material, block mass and pulling speed. The question is which of two track materials gives lower sliding resistance for the same block moving at steady speed.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Changed factor: Track material
  • b: Changed factor: Block mass and speed together
  • c: Measured outcome: Favourite track colour
  • d: Measured outcome: Steady pulling force
Answer: Changed factor: Track material; Measured outcome: Steady pulling force

Keep mass and speed equal while comparing the needed balancing pulls.

5B · Open ended

Propose a controlled two-surface test and explain the evidence you would use for the lower-friction choice.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use the same block mass and steady speed on each surface. Repeat force readings and choose the surface requiring the smaller average steady pull.

  1. Changes surface while holding relevant block/load and steady-speed conditions equal.
  2. Uses repeated comparable pulling-force measurements and selects the lower required force.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.10 · Gravity

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Weight in a stated field

Worked example information

A classroom model uses g = 10 m/s² for a 3 kg object.

Question: What is its weight?

Answer: 30 N.

Why: 3 × 10 = 30; kilograms and newtons describe different quantities.

Example 2 · The same mass elsewhere

Worked example information

A 4 kg object is moved from a field of 10 m/s² to one of 2 m/s².

Question: What happens to mass and weight?

Answer: Mass stays 4 kg; weight changes from 40 N to 8 N.

Why: The field affects force, not the amount of matter.

Example 3 · Double the separation

Worked example information

For fixed point masses, a model force is 12 units at one separation.

Question: What is it at twice that separation?

Answer: 3 units.

Why: The inverse-square model gives one quarter, not one half.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the interaction

Fixed question information

Two separated masses attract through gravity without touching.

F1 · Hotspot

What is the interaction direction?

  • a: No force across any gap
  • b: Repulsion
  • c: Attraction
  • d: Direction alternates automatically
Answer: Attraction

Gravity attracts masses and acts across space.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F2 · Calculate model weight

Fixed question information

Use g = 10 m/s² and mass 5 kg.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Weight; Mass

  • a: 50 kg
  • b: 50 N
  • c: 5 kg
  • d: 0.5 N
Answer: Weight → 50 N; Mass → 5 kg

Weight is 5 × 10 N.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F3 · Read a distance model

Fixed question information

Fixed point masses have force index 4 at separation 1 and index 1 at separation 2.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Farther force index; Nearer force index

  • a: 8
  • b: 2
  • c: 1
  • d: 4
Answer: Farther force index → 1; Nearer force index → 4

The supplied inverse-square comparison weakens with distance.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Compare a virtual vacuum

Fixed question information

Two objects of different mass are released together at the same place with no air resistance.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which gravitational acceleration comparison applies?

  • a: Equal
  • b: Heavier always greater
  • c: No air resistance
  • d: Different release heights
Answer: Equal

Mass alone does not change free-fall acceleration in this model.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F5 · Explain mass and weight

Fixed question information

A 2 kg object weighs 20 N in field A and 4 N in field B. Its material is unchanged.

F5 · Open ended

What stays the same and what changes? Explain with the different quantities and units.

Example of a full-credit answer: Mass stays 2 kg. Weight changes from 20 N to 4 N because gravitational force differs by location.

  1. Keeps mass 2 kg in both fields.
  2. Explains changing weight in newtons as changing gravitational force.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A model field has g = 4 m/s². A crate has mass 6 kg.

1A · Hotspot

What is its weight?

  • a: 24 N
  • b: 1.5 N
  • c: 6 kg
  • d: 24 kg
Answer: 24 N

6 × 4 = 24 N.

1B · Open ended

Calculate weight and explain why the answer should not be written in kilograms.

Example of a full-credit answer: Weight is 24 N. It is a force, while the crate’s mass is 6 kg.

  1. Computes 24 N.
  2. Distinguishes force units from mass units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Plan A drops equal-shape objects of different masses in a virtual vacuum from equal height. Plan B compares a feather and stone in moving air from different heights.

2A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Better plan; Major problem in B

  • a: A
  • b: Several variables differ
  • c: Too many controls
  • d: B
Answer: Better plan → A; Major problem in B → Several variables differ

A removes major competing explanations.

2B · Short answer

Choose the plan and name two controlled conditions that make its conclusion stronger.

Example of a full-credit answer: A controls release height and removes air resistance; those cannot explain a timing difference.

  1. Chooses A with equal-height reasoning.
  2. Explains removal of air resistance or equivalent relevant control.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

An object’s mass is 3 kg. World P has g = 8 m/s²; Q has g = 2 m/s².

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Q weight; P weight

  • a: 6 N
  • b: 1.5 N
  • c: 3 N
  • d: 24 N
Answer: Q weight → 6 N; P weight → 24 N

Weight uses the local field value.

3B · Open ended

Compare both weights and state what happens to the mass.

Example of a full-credit answer: Weights are 24 N on P and 6 N on Q. Mass stays 3 kg.

  1. Calculates both weights correctly.
  2. Preserves the 3 kg mass.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner claims a 4 kg ball must accelerate twice as fast as a 2 kg ball in the same virtual vacuum. Both start together at equal height.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Acceleration comparison: Twice as large
  • b: Changed quantity: Mass disappears
  • c: Changed quantity: Gravitational force
  • d: Acceleration comparison: Equal
Answer: Changed quantity: Gravitational force; Acceleration comparison: Equal

Both weight and inertia scale with mass in this ideal model.

4B · Short answer

Correct the acceleration claim and explain why a larger weight does not establish a larger free-fall acceleration.

Example of a full-credit answer: Their accelerations are equal. The heavier ball has more gravitational force but also more mass to accelerate, so the ratio is unchanged.

  1. States equal acceleration under the given conditions.
  2. Explains the force-to-mass balance or equivalent reasoning.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Use fixed virtual masses at separations 1, 2 and 4 units. Measure attraction using the same force-index scale.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Controlled property: Both masses.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Changing separation while masses stay fixed tests its role.

5B · Open ended

Propose the comparison and state the pattern predicted by the inverse-square model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep both masses fixed; compare force at 1, 2 and 4. Relative to distance 1, forces should be 1, 1/4 and 1/16.

  1. Specifies fixed masses and controlled distance changes.
  2. Gives the decreasing inverse-square relative pattern correctly.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.11 · Magnetic forces

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read the facing poles

Worked example information

Magnet A presents N and magnet B presents S across a gap.

Question: What interaction is expected?

Answer: Attraction.

Why: Unlike poles face each other.

Example 2 · A misleading material rule
Virtual material test
SampleStrong attraction observed
Iron clipYes
Aluminium stripNo

Worked example information

Virtual test results: iron clip attracted; aluminium strip not strongly attracted. Both are metals.

Question: Is “all metals strongly attract” justified?

Answer: No.

Why: The second tested metal is a counterexample.

Example 3 · One change at a time

Worked example information

Two trials use the same magnets and N–S orientation, but gaps 1 and 3 units.

Question: What variable is being compared?

Answer: Separation.

Why: Magnets and orientation are controlled, so the intended change is the gap.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Compare facing poles

Fixed question information

Pair A is N facing N. Pair B is N facing S.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which pair repels?

  • a: B
  • b: Neither interacts
  • c: Both attract
  • d: A
Answer: A

Like poles repel; unlike poles attract.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F2 · Read a material test

Fixed question information

In teacher-provided virtual data, iron sample I is strongly attracted and plastic P is not.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Attracted sample; Not attracted in this test

  • a: I
  • b: Neither attracted
  • c: Both attracted
  • d: P
Answer: Attracted sample → I; Not attracted in this test → P

Use the measured material behaviour.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Change the gap

Fixed question information

The same N–S magnets are compared at small and large gaps.

F3 · Hotspot

What is the changed variable?

  • a: Gap
  • b: Both poles reversed
  • c: Material every time
  • d: Pole orientation
Answer: Gap

Keeping orientation fixed isolates distance.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F4 · Use a compass model

Fixed question information

A small compass is moved among positions near a fixed bar magnet. Its needle direction changes.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Investigated feature; Variable moved

  • a: Compass position
  • b: Magnetic field direction
  • c: Magnet identity each time
  • d: Air temperature only
Answer: Investigated feature → Magnetic field direction; Variable moved → Compass position

The needle responds to the local magnetic influence.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain repulsion evidence

Fixed question information

Two labelled north poles face across a gap and move apart when released in a virtual test.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the magnets move apart and why contact is not required.

Example of a full-credit answer: Like north poles repel. Their magnetic interaction acts across the gap before they touch.

  1. Links separation motion to like-pole repulsion.
  2. States magnetic forces act across a gap without contact.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: field lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fixed north pole first faces north, then the other magnet is rotated to face south. Gap stays equal.

1A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Before rotation: Repulsion
  • b: After rotation: No force ever
  • c: After rotation: Attraction
  • d: Before rotation: Both attraction
Answer: Before rotation: Repulsion; After rotation: Attraction

Changing the facing pole changes like to unlike.

1B · Short answer

Predict both interactions and identify the one controlled condition that makes the comparison clear.

Example of a full-credit answer: First repel, then attract. Keeping the gap the same isolates pole orientation.

  1. Predicts repulsion then attraction correctly.
  2. Identifies equal gap as a relevant control.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Data: iron pieces are attracted; plastic and aluminium pieces are not strongly attracted in this setup. Claim A says this magnet can separate iron from this mixture. Claim B says it separates every metal.

2A · Hotspot

Which claim matches the data?

  • a: Iron
  • b: Aluminium
  • c: A
  • d: B
Answer: A

A stays within the tested materials.

2B · Open ended

Choose a claim and explain the limit imposed by the aluminium result.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is supported. Aluminium is a tested metal without strong attraction, so B’s all-metals claim fails.

  1. Chooses A using observed sorting behaviour.
  2. Uses aluminium as the specific counterexample to B.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A compass is kept at one position. A nearby bar magnet is rotated; the compass needle turns.

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changed variable; Controlled feature

  • a: Compass location changes
  • b: Compass position
  • c: Magnet orientation
  • d: Magnet identity changes
Answer: Changed variable → Magnet orientation; Controlled feature → Compass position

Rotating the source changes the local field direction.

3B · Short answer

Explain a reasonable magnetic cause of the needle turn and one condition to control in a repeat.

Example of a full-credit answer: The magnet’s orientation changes the field at the compass. Keep the compass location or magnet distance fixed when repeating.

  1. Links needle direction to changed local magnetic field.
  2. Names a relevant controlled position/distance condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A pupil says every metal must be strongly attracted to a classroom magnet. A virtual copper sample shows no strong attraction in the same test. An iron comparison sample shows strong attraction in that same setup.

4A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Evidence role: Counterexample.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

A single valid counterexample defeats the universal claim.

4B · Open ended

Identify the overgeneralisation and replace it with a conclusion matching the evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: “Every metal” is too broad. Some materials, such as tested iron, attract strongly; the tested copper does not.

  1. Rejects the all-metals generalisation.
  2. States a material-specific conclusion consistent with the supplied test.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual apparatus can vary magnet gap and pole orientation. You want to investigate gap only.

5A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Fixed setting; Changed setting

  • a: Both settings
  • b: Facing poles
  • c: Gap
  • d: Neither setting
Answer: Fixed setting → Facing poles; Changed setting → Gap

Change one factor to isolate its effect.

5B · Open ended

Propose a repeated comparison and name what you would observe.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep the same magnets and facing poles; try several gaps and repeat. Observe direction and relative strength or motion under the same release conditions.

  1. Controls magnets/orientation while changing gap.
  2. Uses a relevant repeated comparable observation of magnetic effect.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.12 · Electrical forces

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read two signs

Worked example information

Charges X and Y are both negative.

Question: Do they attract or repel?

Answer: Repel.

Why: They are like charges.

Example 2 · Transfer three electrons

Worked example information

In a closed model, A gains three electrons from B.

Question: What happens to B?

Answer: It loses three electrons and becomes more positive relative to its starting state.

Why: Charge transfer is counted on both objects.

Example 3 · Increase separation

Worked example information

Fixed point charges have relative force 20 at separation d.

Question: What is the force magnitude at 2d?

Answer: 5 in the same relative units.

Why: Inverse square gives one quarter; the signs still determine the direction.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Compare sign pairs

Fixed question information

Pair A is positive-positive. Pair B is positive-negative.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Repelling pair; Attracting pair

  • a: Both attract
  • b: Neither has charge
  • c: A
  • d: B
Answer: Repelling pair → A; Attracting pair → B

Like charges repel and unlike charges attract.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F2 · Track electrons

Fixed question information

Object X gains four electrons from Y in a closed two-object model.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: More positive: Y
  • b: More negative: Both gain four
  • c: More positive: Neither changes
  • d: More negative: X
Answer: More positive: Y; More negative: X

Electrons move from Y to X, preserving the two-object account.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Read inverse-square data

Fixed question information

Fixed charges have force index 9 at separation 1 and 1 at separation 3.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Farther magnitude; Nearer magnitude

  • a: 1
  • b: 9
  • c: 27
  • d: 3
Answer: Farther magnitude → 1; Nearer magnitude → 9

Tripled separation gives one ninth of the magnitude.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Keep a distance test fair

Fixed question information

A virtual test changes only the gap between two fixed charges.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Controlled quantity; Changed quantity

  • a: Charge amounts
  • b: Both amounts each trial
  • c: Separation
  • d: Both signs each trial
Answer: Controlled quantity → Charge amounts; Changed quantity → Separation

Fixed charges isolate the distance effect.

Scientific explorer: field lab

F5 · Explain neutral attraction

Fixed question information

A charged rod approaches a neutral object. In the supplied model, charges inside the neutral object shift slightly without changing its total charge.

F5 · Open ended

Explain how the object can remain neutral while its charges rearrange.

Example of a full-credit answer: Equal positive and negative totals remain overall, but their locations shift. The rod can attract the nearer unlike charges more strongly.

  1. Distinguishes zero net charge from absence of charged particles.
  2. Explains internal separation/rearrangement without creating net charge.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fixed positive charge first faces negative, then faces positive at the same distance.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Second interaction; First interaction

  • a: Repulsion
  • b: Attraction
  • c: Both repulsion
  • d: No interaction
Answer: Second interaction → Repulsion; First interaction → Attraction

The sign relationship changes from unlike to like.

1B · Open ended

Predict both directions and explain why the changed sign matters.

Example of a full-credit answer: The first pair attracts because signs differ. The second repels because both are positive.

  1. Correctly predicts first attraction.
  2. Correctly predicts second repulsion using like signs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Account A says rubbing moves electrons from one object to another. Account B says it creates extra electrons from empty space.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Valid account: B.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Charging transfers existing charge rather than creating it.

2B · Short answer

Choose an account and explain how to check both objects together.

Example of a full-credit answer: A. Count equal electron loss and gain across the two objects; their combined charge is unchanged.

  1. Chooses transfer of existing electrons.
  2. Checks equal loss/gain and unchanged combined charge.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

Fixed point charges have force magnitude 12 units at distance d. The distance doubles.

3A · Multiple choice

What is the new magnitude?

  • a: 3 units
  • b: 12 units
  • c: 6 units
  • d: 24 units
Answer: 3 units

Doubling distance gives 1/2² of the original.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the new magnitude and explain what determines whether the force attracts or repels.

Example of a full-credit answer: It becomes 3 units. Charge signs determine attraction or repulsion; distance changed the magnitude.

  1. Calculates one quarter of 12 as 3.
  2. Separates sign-based direction from distance-based magnitude.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says a neutral object has no charged particles. The model shows equal positive and negative totals inside it.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Neutral meaning; Particles inside

  • a: No particles
  • b: Positive and negative
  • c: Only positive
  • d: Zero net charge
Answer: Neutral meaning → Zero net charge; Particles inside → Positive and negative

Equal opposite totals cancel in the net account.

4B · Short answer

Correct the claim and explain why equal opposite charge totals matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: A neutral object can contain charged particles. Equal positive and negative totals make its net charge zero.

  1. Recognises charged particles can be present.
  2. Explains net cancellation of equal opposite charge totals.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Create one attracting and one repelling pair using positive/negative point charges. Keep their amounts and separations equal.

5A · Hotspot

Which signs give attraction?

  • a: Positive and negative
  • b: Negative and negative
  • c: No signs needed
  • d: Positive and positive
Answer: Positive and negative

Unlike signs attract; like signs repel.

5B · Open ended

Specify both pairs and explain why equal gaps and amounts are useful controls.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use + with − for attraction and + with + for repulsion. Equal amounts and gaps isolate the sign relationship.

  1. Proposes one correct unlike and one correct like pair.
  2. Explains the controls isolate sign rather than distance or amount.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.13 · Motion graphs

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read a position slope

Worked example information

Position is 1 m at 0 s and 7 m at 3 s, with constant velocity between.

Question: What velocity does the line show?

Answer: 2 m/s in the positive direction.

Why: Position changes by 6 m in 3 s.

Example 2 · Read a horizontal segment
Position record
Time (s)Position (m)
15
25
35

Worked example information

Positions at 1, 2 and 3 s are all 5 m. In this model, straight horizontal segments join the readings.

Question: What happened to position in that interval?

Answer: It remained at 5 m.

Why: A horizontal position–time line means no change in position.

Example 3 · Change the vertical label

Worked example information

A horizontal graph is labelled velocity and sits at 6 m/s.

Question: Is the object at rest?

Answer: No. It moves with constant 6 m/s velocity.

Why: Zero slope means zero acceleration here, not zero velocity.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read the labelled point

Fixed question information

A position–time table gives (0 s, 2 m), (1 s, 5 m), (2 s, 8 m).

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Position at 1 s; Position at 2 s

  • a: 5 m
  • b: 3 m
  • c: 2 m
  • d: 8 m
Answer: Position at 1 s → 5 m; Position at 2 s → 8 m

Read the matching time-position pair.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Find the straight-line rate

Fixed question information

A constant-velocity route changes position from 0 to 12 m in 4 s.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Velocity; Position change

  • a: 3 m/s
  • b: 12 m
  • c: 4 m/s
  • d: 48 m/s
Answer: Velocity → 3 m/s; Position change → 12 m

Slope is 12/4.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F3 · Interpret a flat position line

Fixed question information

Position stays at 7 m from 2 s to 5 s.

F3 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Displacement; Elapsed time

  • a: 5 s
  • b: 0 m
  • c: 3 s
  • d: 7 m
Answer: Displacement → 0 m; Elapsed time → 3 s

Position does not change; time interval is 5 − 2.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Interpret a flat velocity line

Fixed question information

Velocity is 4 m/s from 0 s through 3 s in a straight-line model.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Acceleration: 4 m/s²
  • b: Velocity: 4 m/s
  • c: Velocity: 0 m/s
  • d: Acceleration: 0 m/s²
Answer: Velocity: 4 m/s; Acceleration: 0 m/s²

Velocity height is nonzero, while its change is zero.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F5 · Explain the axes

Fixed question information

Two graphs have identical horizontal lines. A’s vertical axis is position at 3 m; B’s is velocity at 3 m/s.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why A and B do not describe the same motion.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has constant position, so it is at rest over the interval. B has a constant nonzero velocity, so it moves steadily.

  1. Interprets A as unchanged position/rest.
  2. Interprets B as constant nonzero velocity/motion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

Position changes from 4 m at 2 s to 16 m at 6 s along a straight graph segment.

1A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Velocity; Elapsed time

  • a: 3 m/s
  • b: 6 s
  • c: 4 s
  • d: 2 m/s
Answer: Velocity → 3 m/s; Elapsed time → 4 s

(16 − 4)/(6 − 2) = 12/4 = 3.

1B · Short answer

Calculate velocity and explain why you use elapsed time rather than the final clock reading.

Example of a full-credit answer: The interval is 4 s, not 6 s. Position changes 12 m, so velocity is 3 m/s.

  1. Finds 3 m/s from the two differences.
  2. Explains final time minus initial time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Two straight position–time lines begin at 0. After 3 s, A is 12 m and B is 6 m.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Faster line: A.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

A has twice the position change in the same time.

2B · Open ended

Choose a line and justify using both slopes.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is 12/3 = 4 m/s; B is 6/3 = 2 m/s. A has the greater slope.

  1. Calculates both velocities.
  2. Links the comparison to slope, not simply graph decoration.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

Position at 0, 1, 2 and 3 s is 0, 4, 4 and 1 m respectively. Straight segments connect readings.

3A · Hotspot

During which interval is it stationary?

  • a: 2–3 s
  • b: 0–3 s only
  • c: 1–2 s
  • d: 0–1 s
Answer: 1–2 s

Position stays 4 between 1 and 2, then decreases.

3B · Short answer

Describe the stop and the later direction using the record.

Example of a full-credit answer: It stops during 1–2 s because position stays 4 m. During 2–3 s, position decreases from 4 to 1 m, so motion is in the negative direction.

  1. Identifies the stop with unchanged position evidence.
  2. Identifies later negative-direction motion with decreasing position evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner sees a rising position–time line and says the road must go uphill. The graph contains only time and position along a straight horizontal track.

4A · Multiple choice

What does the rising line show?

  • a: Increasing position with time
  • b: Increasing hill height
  • c: No movement
  • d: Road height
Answer: Increasing position with time

Position–time height is not physical elevation.

4B · Open ended

Identify the mistaken interpretation and give the correct meaning of the rising line.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner treats the graph as a road picture. It shows position increasing over time along the chosen direction, not uphill elevation.

  1. Rejects graph-as-route/elevation interpretation.
  2. Explains increasing position in the positive direction over time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Create positions for times 0, 1, 2 and 3 s. Start at 0 m; be at 4 m after 1 s; remain there until 2 s; finish at 6 m.

5A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Position at 2 s; Final position

  • a: 2 m
  • b: 6 m
  • c: 8 m
  • d: 4 m
Answer: Position at 2 s → 4 m; Final position → 6 m

The stop requires equal positions at 1 and 2 s.

5B · Open ended

Give all four readings and explain which segment shows the stop.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 0, 4, 4 and 6 m. The 1–2 s segment is horizontal because position stays 4 m.

  1. Gives all four correct readings.
  2. Explains the horizontal stop segment using constant position.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S2.14 · Effects of forces on objects

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Slowing a moving cart

Worked example information

A cart moves right, while its net force points left.

Question: How can its speed initially change?

Answer: It can decrease.

Why: Acceleration opposite the initial velocity reduces speed until conditions change.

Example 2 · Measure extension

Worked example information

A virtual band is 10 cm before loading and 14 cm during loading.

Question: What is its extension?

Answer: 4 cm.

Why: Extension is change in length, not the final length.

Example 3 · Balanced pulls, changed shape

Worked example information

Equal opposite forces pull on both ends of a flexible band. Its centre stays still but it stretches.

Question: Are forces absent because the centre is still?

Answer: No. The forces balance overall but can deform the band.

Why: Net motion and internal shape change are different effects.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Describe a force effect

Fixed question information

A rightward-moving cart experiences a leftward net force and has not yet stopped.

F1 · Multiple choice

What happens initially?

  • a: Always speeds up
  • b: Left
  • c: Slows down
  • d: Right
Answer: Slows down

Acceleration opposes the current velocity.

Scientific explorer: force lab

F2 · Find extension

Fixed question information

A model spring starts at 8 cm and becomes 11 cm under a load.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Extension; Starting length

  • a: 11 cm
  • b: 3 cm
  • c: 8 cm
  • d: 19 cm
Answer: Extension → 3 cm; Starting length → 8 cm

Subtract the original length.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F3 · Read a bending observation

Fixed question information

Virtual strip A returns to its original shape after release. Strip B remains bent.

F3 · Hotspot

Which shows recovery in this test?

  • a: B
  • b: Both unchanged
  • c: A
  • d: Neither
Answer: A

Recovery is observed after force removal.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Distinguish turning from speeding

Fixed question information

A model object travels in a circle at constant speed. Its direction keeps changing.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changing quantity; Constant quantity

  • a: No motion quantity
  • b: Speed
  • c: Speed magnitude doubles
  • d: Velocity direction
Answer: Changing quantity → Velocity direction; Constant quantity → Speed

Velocity includes direction as well as speed.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain balanced deformation

Fixed question information

A flexible virtual band is pulled equally in opposite directions. Its centre stays at the same location, but its length increases.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why a stationary centre does not mean no forces act, and describe the shape effect.

Example of a full-credit answer: Equal opposite pulls balance, so the centre need not accelerate. Those pulls still stretch the band.

  1. Explains balanced nonzero forces rather than no forces.
  2. Recognises stretching as a possible shape effect.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: force lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A model spring is 12 cm unloaded and 18 cm under a stated load.

1A · Hotspot

What is extension?

  • a: 18 cm
  • b: 30 cm
  • c: 12 cm
  • d: 6 cm
Answer: 6 cm

18 − 12 = 6.

1B · Open ended

Find extension and explain why the loaded length alone is not the extension.

Example of a full-credit answer: Extension is 6 cm, the increase from 12 to 18. The full 18 cm includes the original length.

  1. Calculates 6 cm.
  2. Distinguishes change in length from total length.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Plan A tests equal-size strips with equal loads and measures bend. Plan B changes strip material, thickness and load together.

2A · Multiple choice

Which plan isolates material better?

  • a: A
  • b: Multiple changing factors
  • c: B
  • d: Too much control
Answer: A

A reduces competing explanations.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and identify two relevant controls.

Example of a full-credit answer: A controls dimensions and applied load while material changes.

  1. Chooses A with equal-dimension reasoning.
  2. Names equal load and explains its role in fair comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A cart moves left. The goal is to reduce its speed before it stops, using a horizontal net force.

3A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Initial motion direction: No direction
  • b: Initial motion direction: Left
  • c: Needed net direction: Right
  • d: Needed net direction: Left forever
Answer: Initial motion direction: Left; Needed net direction: Right

A force opposite initial motion can slow the cart.

3B · Open ended

Choose the direction and explain why reversing the journey reverses the required slowing-force direction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use rightward net force because the cart moves left. Slowing requires acceleration opposite the current motion, not always leftward.

  1. Chooses rightward net force.
  2. Explains direction relative to motion rather than a fixed side.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says a turning car cannot accelerate because its speed stays constant. This is a virtual circular-motion example.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changing quantity; Unchanged stated quantity

  • a: Speed
  • b: Position stays fixed
  • c: Velocity direction
  • d: No quantity
Answer: Changing quantity → Velocity direction; Unchanged stated quantity → Speed

Acceleration includes directional changes.

4B · Short answer

Identify the missing part of velocity and explain the correction.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner ignores direction. Velocity changes when direction changes, so constant-speed turning still involves acceleration.

  1. Identifies direction as part of velocity.
  2. Links changing direction to acceleration despite constant speed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A program lets you set load on identical spring models. Measure unloaded and loaded lengths; stay within its stated elastic range.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Response quantity: Loaded minus unloaded length.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Extension directly measures the force-related length change.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair series of trials and include a check for recovery.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep spring type fixed, vary load within the allowed range and calculate extension each time. Remove each load to check return to original length; repeat trials.

  1. Uses controlled spring type with measured extensions across loads.
  2. Includes unloading/recovery and repeat checks.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.1 · Forms of energy

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Raised or moving

Worked example information

Object A is held high and still; B rolls along a track.

Question: Which description fits each?

Answer: A has a gravitational store relative to Earth; B has kinetic energy.

Why: Visible motion is not the only way a system can store energy.

Example 2 · A stretched band

Worked example information

A virtual elastic band is stretched and held.

Question: What store has increased?

Answer: The elastic energy store.

Why: Work done stretching changes the band’s state even while it is held still.

Example 3 · Warm without travelling

Worked example information

A warm block stays on a table. Its particles are moving microscopically.

Question: Why is “not moving across the table” insufficient to say it has no energy?

Answer: The block’s thermal state involves particle motion and interactions.

Why: Whole-object motion and microscopic thermal motion are different descriptions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Battery fan

Fixed question information

A battery powers a fan that moves air and warms. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Transfer to motor; Desired fan output

  • a: Air movement
  • b: Unrelated sound source
  • c: Chemical store
  • d: Electrical transfer
Answer: Transfer to motor → Electrical transfer; Desired fan output → Air movement

Electrical transfer; Air movement. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F2 · Lamp

Fixed question information

A powered lamp receives energy electrically and produces light plus thermal transfer. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Lamp input; Desired lamp output

  • a: Wind input
  • b: Light output
  • c: New matter
  • d: Electrical input
Answer: Lamp input → Electrical input; Desired lamp output → Light output

Electrical input; Light output. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Solar cell

Fixed question information

A model solar cell takes light and supplies electrical energy to a circuit. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

F3 · Multiple choice

What energy enters the solar cell?

  • a: Gravity only
  • b: Light input
  • c: Electrical output
  • d: Sound input
Answer: Light input

Light input; Electrical output. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F4 · Brake

Fixed question information

A moving model wheel slows because of friction and the wheel/surface warms. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Thermal pathway change: New energy appears
  • b: Thermal pathway change: Thermal transfer increases
  • c: Motion-energy change: Motion decreases
  • d: Motion-energy change: Energy is destroyed
Answer: Thermal pathway change: Thermal transfer increases; Motion-energy change: Motion decreases

Motion decreases; Thermal transfer increases. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F5 · Generator

Fixed question information

A turning model handle drives a generator connected to a lamp. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

F5 · Short answer

Describe the energy pathway and identify one output or store change besides the desired result.

Example of a full-credit answer: Work on the turning handle supplies mechanical energy to the generator, which transfers energy electrically to the lamp. Light is produced and some energy also reaches the surroundings by heating or sound.

  1. Identifies the stated source/input and main useful pathway.
  2. Names a relevant additional output or source-store decrease without energy creation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A torch’s battery provides energy through a circuit to a light source that also warms. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

1A · Hotspot

What happens to the battery’s chemical store?

  • a: Light is an output
  • b: Chemical store decreases
  • c: Battery mass doubles
  • d: Charge disappears
Answer: Chemical store decreases

Chemical store decreases; Light is an output. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

1B · Short answer

Describe the energy pathway and identify one output or store change besides the desired result.

Example of a full-credit answer: The battery’s chemical store decreases as energy transfers electrically through the circuit. The lamp gives light and also warms, so the additional thermal transfer belongs in the account.

  1. Identifies the stated source/input and main useful pathway.
  2. Names a relevant additional output or source-store decrease without energy creation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A room heater’s stated goal is warming the room. It takes electrical input. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

2A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Thermal output for this goal: All heat is waste
  • b: Input pathway: Electrical input supplies energy
  • c: Thermal output for this goal: Thermal output is useful
  • d: Input pathway: Energy created inside
Answer: Input pathway: Electrical input supplies energy; Thermal output for this goal: Thermal output is useful

Thermal output is useful; Electrical input supplies energy. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

2B · Open ended

Explain why thermal transfer is useful here and why the same transfer might be unwanted in a lamp.

Example of a full-credit answer: Warming is the heater’s purpose. A lamp’s purpose is light, so room heating may be unwanted for that different task.

  1. Connects usefulness to the heater’s stated goal.
  2. Contrasts a lighting goal without claiming all heat is always waste.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

Moving air turns a turbine that drives a generator and supplies a circuit. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs. In this virtual description, moving parts also warm slightly.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Turbine energy source: Coal is always required.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Moving air is the source; Electrical output is produced. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

3B · Short answer

Describe the energy pathway and identify one output or store change besides the desired result.

Example of a full-credit answer: Moving air supplies motion to the turbine, which drives the generator and transfers energy electrically. Some energy also warms the moving parts; it has not been created by the generator.

  1. Identifies the stated source/input and main useful pathway.
  2. Names a relevant additional output or source-store decrease without energy creation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A toy stops while its wheels, track and nearby air warm slightly. A learner says the energy has vanished. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

4A · Multiple choice

Where does the toy’s energy go as it stops?

  • a: Energy is destroyed
  • b: Motion energy decreases
  • c: All energy stays as motion
  • d: Energy transfers to surroundings
Answer: Energy transfers to surroundings

Energy transfers to surroundings; Motion energy decreases. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

4B · Open ended

Identify the learner’s mistake and name two destinations for the toy’s former motion energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: The energy did not vanish. It transferred to thermal motion of the wheels/track/air, and possibly sound.

  1. Rejects energy destruction when the toy stops.
  2. Names two relevant receiving objects/pathways from the source or sound.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A fictional device must use sunlight to move a wheel through a solar cell and motor. These are teacher-provided descriptions of a virtual device; include any stated extra outputs.

5A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required component order; Desired output

  • a: No energy input
  • b: Solar cell before motor
  • c: Wheel motion is the goal
  • d: Motor before light source
Answer: Required component order → Solar cell before motor; Desired output → Wheel motion is the goal

Solar cell before motor; Wheel motion is the goal. Trace the stated source through its components and count other transfers.

5B · Open ended

Propose the ordered components and include an additional output expected from a real motor.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use sunlight → solar cell → electrical circuit → motor → wheel motion. Include thermal transfer from the motor.

  1. Provides a valid ordered solar-cell/circuit/motor/motion pathway.
  2. Includes a plausible additional thermal or sound transfer without creating energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.2 · Energy sources

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A two-source supply
Fictional interval supply
SourceEnergy units
Solar4
Wind3
Demand9

Worked example information

A fictional school model needs 9 units. Solar supplies 4 and wind 3 in the stated interval.

Question: What shortage remains?

Answer: 2 units.

Why: 4 + 3 = 7; demand is 9, so the gap is 2.

Example 2 · A fixed reserve

Worked example information

A model fuel reserve has 24 units. Plan A uses 4 per day; B uses 3. No stock is added.

Question: How long can each plan last?

Answer: A lasts 6 days; B lasts 8.

Why: Divide the same stock by each daily use.

Example 3 · Equal-service comparison

Worked example information

Two fictional sources each provide 5 energy units. A’s emissions index is 2; B’s is 9.

Question: Which has the smaller stated index for this equal service?

Answer: A.

Why: This compares the given measure only; it does not establish that every environmental effect is smaller.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify a source

Fixed question information

A solar cell receives sunlight and supplies a circuit.

F1 · Hotspot

What is the primary source?

  • a: Sunlight
  • b: New matter
  • c: Electricity
  • d: The wire
Answer: Sunlight

Use the source’s stated property, amount and conditions; do not infer a stronger claim.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F2 · Read a condition

Fixed question information

Moving water turns a turbine connected to a generator.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Turbine driver; Generator output

  • a: Electrical energy
  • b: Electricity from nowhere
  • c: Moving water
  • d: Water atoms destroyed
Answer: Turbine driver → Moving water; Generator output → Electrical energy

Use the source’s stated property, amount and conditions; do not infer a stronger claim.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F3 · Check the classification

Fixed question information

A model coal-fired system uses coal to heat water and drive a turbine.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Fuel source; Intermediate process

  • a: Coal
  • b: Heating water
  • c: Creating coal
  • d: The plug
Answer: Fuel source → Coal; Intermediate process → Heating water

Use the source’s stated property, amount and conditions; do not infer a stronger claim.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Compare a consequence

Fixed question information

A wind model has no stored energy and reports zero wind during an interval.

F4 · Multiple choice

What limits output in that interval?

  • a: Stored energy
  • b: A larger label
  • c: No moving wind
  • d: No electricity exists anywhere
Answer: No moving wind

Use the source’s stated property, amount and conditions; do not infer a stronger claim.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain supply and limits

Fixed question information

A fictional model needs 10 energy units at night. Direct solar output is 0; stored energy supplies 6. No other source is available.

F5 · Open ended

Calculate unmet demand and explain why a renewable source can still need storage or another source.

Example of a full-credit answer: Four units remain unmet. Solar is renewable but direct output is not available in this night interval, so timing matters.

  1. Calculates a 4-unit gap.
  2. Distinguishes renewability from constant availability.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fictional system needs 12 units in one interval. Source A provides 5 and B 4. Storage can supply at most 3.

1A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Needed storage; Direct supply

  • a: 9 units
  • b: 3 units
  • c: 21 units
  • d: 1 unit
Answer: Needed storage → 3 units; Direct supply → 9 units

5 + 4 + 3 = 12.

1B · Open ended

Explain whether the model can meet demand, show the complete supply account, and state how much spare supply or unused storage remains.

Example of a full-credit answer: Yes, exactly: 5 + 4 + 3 = 12. It uses the full allowed storage and has no spare supply in this interval.

  1. Correctly accounts for all three supplies as 12.
  2. Recognises storage is fully used and no spare margin remains.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Requirements: at least 8 energy units and at most 10 emissions-index units. Plan A: supply 9, index 8. B: supply 7, index 3. C: supply 10, index 14. All values are fictional.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Feasible plan; B fails on

  • a: Supply
  • b: C
  • c: Emissions index
  • d: A
Answer: Feasible plan → A; B fails on → Supply

A meets both stated constraints.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify it against both conditions, then identify why one alternative fails.

Example of a full-credit answer: A gives 9 ≥ 8 and index 8 ≤ 10. B lacks supply or C exceeds the index limit.

  1. Checks A against both constraints.
  2. Correctly identifies B’s supply shortfall or C’s excessive index.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

Yesterday a solar model supplied 7 units. In today’s stated cloudy interval it supplies 3. Demand remains 8 and stored energy is 4.

3A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Remaining gap: 1 unit
  • b: Available total: 11 units
  • c: Available total: 7 units
  • d: Remaining gap: 4 units
Answer: Remaining gap: 1 unit; Available total: 7 units

Today’s values, not yesterday’s, determine the account.

3B · Open ended

Calculate today’s gap and explain why yesterday’s output cannot be assumed for every interval.

Example of a full-credit answer: 3 + 4 = 7, leaving 1. Output depends on stated conditions, which changed between intervals.

  1. Calculates the 1-unit shortage.
  2. Links variable source availability to the changed conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says “renewable” proves a source has constant output and no environmental effects. The teacher’s model lists variable supply and construction materials.

4A · Multiple choice

What does the label establish?

  • a: Source replenishment
  • b: No materials needed
  • c: All effects are zero
  • d: Constant impact-free output
Answer: Source replenishment

Renewability is one source property, not every performance claim.

4B · Short answer

Identify both overclaims and replace them with a careful statement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Renewable describes replenishment. Supply can vary, and building/operating the system can still affect the environment.

  1. Rejects guaranteed constant output.
  2. Rejects zero environmental impact and explains the limited meaning of renewable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Choose whole units of solar and fuel in a fictional interval. Need exactly 10 energy units. Solar can provide at most 6 with index 1 per unit; fuel has index 3 per unit. Total index must be at most 20.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Feasible mix: 6 solar + 4 fuel.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Six plus four meets demand; index 6 + 12 = 18.

5B · Open ended

Propose a valid mix and verify supply, solar limit and emissions-index limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 5 solar and 5 fuel: supply 10, solar ≤ 6, index 5 + 15 = 20.

  1. Proposes nonnegative whole quantities totalling 10 with solar at most 6.
  2. Correctly verifies an index at most 20 using the given rates.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.3 · Energy transfer

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Warm rod

Worked example information

One end of a stationary metal rod is warmed; energy moves along the rod through particle interactions.

Question: Which mechanism is described?

Answer: Conduction.

Why: The rod material does not flow from end to end.

Example 2 · Circulating air

Worked example information

A model room shows warm air rising and cooler air moving in.

Question: Which mechanism carries energy with moving air?

Answer: Convection.

Why: Bulk fluid movement transports energy.

Example 3 · Across space

Worked example information

Sunlight travels to a spacecraft through near-vacuum.

Question: Which mechanism can do this?

Answer: Radiation.

Why: Electromagnetic radiation does not require a material medium.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify a rod pathway

Fixed question information

A stationary rod transfers energy from its warm end toward its cooler end by particle interactions.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Net thermal direction: Cool to warm
  • b: Net thermal direction: Warm to cool
  • c: Mechanism: Convection
  • d: Mechanism: Conduction
Answer: Net thermal direction: Warm to cool; Mechanism: Conduction

No bulk fluid motion is involved.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F2 · Identify an air loop

Fixed question information

A virtual air loop carries warmer air upward and cooler air downward under the given conditions.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Mechanism; Moving material

  • a: Conduction only
  • b: Empty space
  • c: Convection
  • d: Air
Answer: Mechanism → Convection; Moving material → Air

The air itself circulates.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Energy in a vacuum

Fixed question information

Light travels from a source to a detector across a vacuum.

F3 · Hotspot

Which transfer can cross the gap?

  • a: Convection
  • b: Radiation
  • c: Conduction
  • d: Mechanical work through a material link
Answer: Radiation

Radiation can propagate through vacuum.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F4 · Mechanical transfer

Fixed question information

A model motor raises a weight using a rope. The motor does work on the load.

F4 · Multiple choice

What mechanism transfers energy to the raised load?

  • a: Mechanical work
  • b: No transfer
  • c: Convection only
  • d: Radiation only
Answer: Mechanical work

A force acting through movement can transfer energy mechanically.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F5 · Explain contact heating

Fixed question information

Equal-capacity blocks start at 60°C and 20°C. They touch in an isolated model.

F5 · Short answer

Name the transfer mechanism and explain its initial direction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Conduction transfers energy through contact from the 60°C block to the 20°C block.

  1. Identifies conduction through contact.
  2. Gives the warmer-to-cooler net direction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A detector receives energy from a lamp across an empty sealed gap. There is no material for conduction or fluid flow.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Mechanism; Excluded transfer requiring bulk fluid motion

  • a: Convection
  • b: Radiation
  • c: Conduction
  • d: Radiation needs air
Answer: Mechanism → Radiation; Excluded transfer requiring bulk fluid motion → Convection

The vacuum condition rules out material mechanisms.

1B · Short answer

Explain the mechanism and use the empty-gap condition to reject one alternative.

Example of a full-credit answer: Radiation crosses the gap. Conduction or convection cannot carry the energy across it because they need matter.

  1. Identifies radiation.
  2. Uses absence of matter to reject conduction or convection.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A model wall layer reduces conduction through its material. Air can still pass through a separate open gap.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Justified claim: Conduction through the layer is reduced.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Improving one pathway does not close every route.

2B · Open ended

Explain why the layer helps but does not establish complete insulation.

Example of a full-credit answer: It slows conduction through the wall. The open gap still permits energy carried by moving air.

  1. Identifies reduced conduction as the benefit.
  2. Identifies the remaining air-motion pathway.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A motor drives a belt that raises boxes. The system receives 80 J; 50 J raises boxes and 30 J reaches surroundings.

3A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Useful transfer; Other transfer

  • a: 110 J
  • b: 30 J
  • c: 50 J
  • d: 80 J destroyed
Answer: Useful transfer → 50 J; Other transfer → 30 J

Both outputs complete the 80 J account.

3B · Short answer

Name the useful transfer mechanism and account for the remaining energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Mechanical work lifts the boxes using 50 J. The other 30 J transfers to surroundings; it is not destroyed.

  1. Identifies mechanical transfer to lifted boxes.
  2. Accounts for 30 J to surroundings without destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A pupil says thermal energy always travels upward. In a model, a warm block touches a cooler block placed below it.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Reason: Temperature difference
  • b: Reason: Cold is heavier
  • c: Direction: Into the cooler lower block
  • d: Direction: Always upward
Answer: Reason: Temperature difference; Direction: Into the cooler lower block

Conduction follows the temperature difference, not an always-up rule.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim and distinguish it from a warm-air convection example.

Example of a full-credit answer: Energy conducts downward here from warm to cool. Warm air rising is a particular convection process involving fluid motion, not a rule for all transfers.

  1. Correctly explains conduction to the lower cooler block.
  2. Distinguishes fluid convection from a universal upward rule.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Two virtual panels have equal area and thickness, with equal warm/cool temperatures on opposite sides. Compare energy transferred in the same time.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Outcome; Fixed condition

  • a: Different temperature gaps
  • b: Energy transferred in equal time
  • c: Panel thickness
  • d: Panel colour only
Answer: Outcome → Energy transferred in equal time; Fixed condition → Panel thickness

Equal geometry and temperature difference isolate material effects.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison and name the mechanism it mainly investigates.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep dimensions, temperature difference and time equal; compare transferred energy for each material. This mainly investigates conduction through the panels.

  1. Describes relevant equal conditions and a comparable transfer measurement.
  2. Identifies conduction as the main mechanism.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.4 · Energy transformation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A sealed warming pouch

Worked-example information

A fictional, sealed classroom pouch undergoes a chemical change. Its chemical energy store decreases while the pouch and nearby air gain thermal energy; no electrical circuit is involved.

Question: Describe the main transformation without inventing electricity.

Answer: Energy from the chemical system is transferred into thermal energy of the pouch and surroundings.

Why: The observed warming is explained by the chemical change and its energy account. A circuit is not required for every transformation.

Example 2 · A pendulum at three positions

Worked-example information

A virtual pendulum is released from a raised position. It moves fastest near its lowest point, then rises on the other side. In this example friction is ignored.

Question: How does its energy change from the first high point to the low point and then upward?

Answer: Gravitational energy changes into motion energy on the way down, then motion energy changes back into gravitational energy on the way up.

Why: The same system changes its balance of stores as position and speed change. The idealised no-friction condition explains why this example omits warming.

Example 3 · Two buzzer outputs
Buzzer record
PathwayEnergy (J)
Electrical input12
Sound output3
Thermal output9

Worked-example information

A fictional buzzer receives 12 J electrically. It produces 3 J of sound and transfers 9 J thermally, with no change in its stored energy.

Question: Which transformations occur, and is the account complete?

Answer: Electrical input produces sound and thermal outputs; 3 + 9 = 12 J.

Why: The sound is the intended result, but the warming must also be included. Counting both branches accounts for the supplied input.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A falling weight lights a lamp

Fixed case information

In a fictional device a raised weight falls, turns a shaft connected to a generator, and supplies a small LED through a circuit. The generator and lamp also warm slightly.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Starting store; Intermediate transfer; Intended final output

  • a: Gravitational energy
  • b: Electrical energy
  • c: Light
  • d: New matter
Answer: Starting store → Gravitational energy; Intermediate transfer → Electrical energy; Intended final output → Light

The falling weight supplies motion to the generator; electrical transfer then supplies light and warming.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Solar warming without a solar cell

Fixed case information

In a fictional solar-water model, a dark panel receives 100 light-energy units, absorbs 80, reflects 10 and transmits 10. The absorbed energy warms water through the panel. There is no photovoltaic cell or electrical circuit.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Original input: Light from the Sun
  • b: Intended result: Water gains thermal energy
  • c: Original input: Electrical input from a battery
  • d: Intended result: Water supplies electrical output
Answer: Original input: Light from the Sun; Intended result: Water gains thermal energy

This route transfers absorbed sunlight into warming; it does not require photovoltaic conversion to electricity.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F3 · A wound band releases a cart

Fixed case information

In a fictional toy, winding a band stores 15 J elastically. After release, the cart has 10 J of motion energy and 5 J has transferred to warming and sound; no external energy enters during release.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Store before release; Store in the moving cart; Additional transfers after release

  • a: Elastic energy in the wound band
  • b: Kinetic energy
  • c: 5 J of warming and sound
  • d: Chemical fuel in the track
Answer: Store before release → Elastic energy in the wound band; Store in the moving cart → Kinetic energy; Additional transfers after release → 5 J of warming and sound

The band’s elastic store decreases while the cart gains motion and the surroundings receive other transfers.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F4 · From a speaker membrane to the air

Fixed case information

A fictional loudspeaker receives energy through an electrical circuit. Its membrane vibrates, making nearby air vibrate and producing a sound wave. Some input also warms the speaker.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Sound starts with: Air creating energy without a source.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The electrical input drives membrane motion, which transfers energy into a sound disturbance; the air does not create a new supply.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F5 · Recovering some braking energy

Fixed case information

A fictional braking system loses 18 J of cart motion energy. Its generator supplies 12 J electrically and transfers 6 J to warming and sound. A charger puts 8 of those 12 J into a battery’s chemical store and transfers the other 4 J thermally.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Describe the ordered transformations and state how much is stored in the battery and how much takes other pathways.

Example of a full-credit answer: Motion energy drives a generator, then electrical transfer charges the battery chemically. The battery stores 8 J and the other 10 J is warming/sound: 6 + 4 = 10.

  1. Traces motion energy through electrical transfer into the battery’s chemical store.
  2. Accounts for 8 J stored and 10 J in other transfers (6 + 4), without destroying or creating energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional storage model uses 50 J of electrical input to raise water. It stores 35 J gravitationally and transfers 15 J thermally. Later the falling water’s 35 J drives a generator that returns 21 J electrically and transfers 14 J thermally. No other stores change.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

How much energy takes thermal pathways over the two stages combined?

  • a: 29 J
  • b: 14 J
  • c: 15 J
  • d: 71 J
Answer: 29 J

The two thermal branches total 15 + 14 = 29 J; returned electricity is 21 J, so the complete account is 50 J.

1B · Open ended

Trace the ordered energy changes through storage and release, then give the complete account of the original 50 J.

Example of a full-credit answer: Electricity raises the water and increases its gravitational store. The falling water later drives a generator. The original 50 J ends as 21 J returned electricity plus 15 + 14 = 29 J thermal transfer.

  1. Describes electrical input raising water into a gravitational store, then falling-water motion driving electrical output.
  2. Correctly gives 29 J thermal transfer and 21 J returned electricity, totalling 50 J.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A virtual kit defines a wind rotor as a motion receiver, a generator as mechanical-input to electrical-output, and a lamp as an electrical-input light source. Plan A: wind rotor → generator → lamp. Plan B: wind rotor → lamp directly, with no electrical converter. Plan C: battery → motor → rotor. The required original source is wind and the goal is light.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Plan meeting source and output requirements; Generator’s required role; Missing stage in Plan B

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Mechanical input to electrical output
  • c: Electrical conversion before the lamp
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Plan meeting source and output requirements → Plan A; Generator’s required role → Mechanical input to electrical output; Missing stage in Plan B → Electrical conversion before the lamp

A contains the required conversion between rotor motion and the lamp’s electrical input. C begins with a battery instead of the specified wind source.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify why its component order works, including the generator’s role.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A: wind turns the rotor, which drives the generator, which supplies the lamp. The generator provides the missing mechanical-to-electrical conversion; the lamp cannot use the rotor’s motion directly in this kit.

  1. Chooses A and traces wind-driven rotor motion to the lamp through the generator.
  2. Explains that the generator converts the mechanical input into the electrical transfer the lamp needs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional special tile converts compression work into electrical energy. A step supplies 24 J mechanically. The tile supplies 6 J electrically and transfers 18 J thermally. A buzzer uses the 6 J to produce 2 J of sound and 4 J of additional thermal transfer.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Energy entering the tile; Transfer from tile to buzzer; Intended final output

  • a: Mechanical input
  • b: Electrical energy
  • c: Sound energy
  • d: Energy from empty space
Answer: Energy entering the tile → Mechanical input; Transfer from tile to buzzer → Electrical energy; Intended final output → Sound energy

The stated new device links mechanical input to electrical transfer and then sound. The final sound is 2 J and total thermal transfer is 18 + 4 = 22 J.

3B · Open ended

Apply the pathway method to the tile and buzzer, then calculate final sound energy and total thermal transfer.

Example of a full-credit answer: The step provides mechanical energy; the tile supplies electrical energy to the buzzer, which makes sound. There are 2 J of sound and 18 + 4 = 22 J of thermal transfer.

  1. Traces mechanical compression through electrical transfer to sound at the buzzer.
  2. Correctly accounts for 2 J sound and 22 J thermal transfer, totalling the original 24 J.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A fictional battery supplies 30 J to a motor. The motor provides 18 J of rotation and 12 J of warming. A generator uses the 18 J to return 9 J electrically to the battery and transfers 9 J thermally. A learner says this refills all 30 J and can run forever without another source.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which stated observation shows that the original battery input is not completely refilled?

  • a: Only 9 J returns from the original 30 J
  • b: 9 J completely refills 30 J
  • c: The generator creates the missing 21 J
  • d: Output grows on every turn
Answer: Only 9 J returns from the original 30 J

Only nine joules returns; twelve plus nine joules goes to thermal pathways. A lossy loop does not refill its input store completely.

4B · Short answer

Identify the error in the endless-loop claim and account for the energy that does not return to the battery.

Example of a full-credit answer: The battery gets only 9 J back, so its original 30 J is not restored. The missing-from-return 21 J is the two thermal outputs, 12 + 9 J; energy is conserved but the loop needs a new input.

  1. Rejects full refill or endless operation because only 9 J returns after 30 J is supplied.
  2. Accounts for the other 21 J as 12 + 9 J of thermal transfer, without energy destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual kit must collect sunlight in the day and produce sound later in darkness. Available parts: a solar cell (light → electrical transfer), rechargeable battery (stores energy chemically when charged), speaker (electrical transfer → sound and warming), heater and wind rotor. The battery begins empty; no wind, hand input or light is available at night.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Required store for the later interval: Charged rechargeable battery
  • b: Required night-time output component: Speaker
  • c: Required store for the later interval: No store is needed
  • d: Required night-time output component: Heater instead of the speaker
Answer: Required store for the later interval: Charged rechargeable battery; Required night-time output component: Speaker

A solar cell can charge the battery during daylight; the stored energy later supplies the speaker and its additional warming output.

5B · Open ended

Propose the ordered daytime and night-time pathway, explain why storage is needed, and include an additional output besides sound.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use sunlight → solar cell → charging circuit → battery during the day. At night the battery supplies the speaker because sunlight is unavailable. The speaker gives sound and also warms, both using stored energy originally supplied by sunlight.

  1. Gives a valid solar-cell charging → battery storage → night-time speaker route and explains the lack of night-time sunlight.
  2. Includes speaker warming or another justified extra transfer and keeps it supplied by the stored original solar input.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.5 · Conservation of energy

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · The unwinding spring
The unwinding spring
Final shareEnergy (J)
Spring remaining5
Motion10
Warming9

Fictional worked-example information

A fictional spring toy begins with 24 J in its spring and no motion. Later, 5 J remains in the spring, the toy has 10 J of motion energy, and the toy and surroundings have gained 9 J through warming. No other transfer crosses the chosen outer boundary.

Question: Does the complete before-and-after account balance?

Answer: Yes. The final shares total 5 + 10 + 9 = 24 J.

Why: Only part of the initial spring energy becomes motion. Counting the remaining spring store and the warming prevents us from mistaking a smaller motion value for energy disappearance.

Example 2 · Two blocks, one outer boundary

Fictional worked-example information

Two imaginary blocks touch inside an insulated box. The warmer block loses 12 J and the cooler block gains 12 J. No energy crosses the outer box boundary during this interval. The numbers describe energy changes, not temperatures.

Question: How can the blocks change while the pair’s total stays the same?

Answer: One decreases by exactly the amount the other increases.

Why: The transfer crosses each block’s boundary but remains inside the boundary around both blocks. Their individual changes are −12 J and +12 J; the change for the pair is zero.

Example 3 · The charging store

Fictional worked-example information

A fictional light-powered storage box starts with 15 J stored. During one interval 40 J enters as light, and 10 J leaves through warming and operating its indicator. The remaining incoming energy stays in the box. There are no other transfers in this model.

Question: How much energy is stored at the end?

Answer: 45 J, because 15 + 40 − 10 = 45.

Why: The starting store must be included. Checking 15 + 40 = 45 + 10 accounts for both incoming energy and the part that leaves, rather than treating every incoming joule as an immediate output.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · The torch’s missing pathway

Fixed fictional scientific information

A virtual torch lamp receives 18 J of electrical energy in one interval. It sends out 5 J as light. Its stored energy does not change, and the only other output is energy transferred by warming nearby materials.

F1 · Multiple choice

How much energy follows the warming pathway?

  • a: 5 J
  • b: 13 J
  • c: 18 J
  • d: 23 J
Answer: 13 J

With no stored-energy change, the outputs must total 18 J. The warming transfer is 18 − 5 = 13 J.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F2 · An insulated exchange

Fixed fictional scientific information

During a prepared model interval, a warm block loses 8 J and a cooler block gains 8 J. No energy enters or leaves the boundary around both blocks. Do not treat these energy amounts as temperature readings.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL correct statements. Use the boundary around both blocks.

  • a: The warm block’s energy decreases by 8 J.
  • b: The pair’s total energy is unchanged.
  • c: The cooler block loses 8 J.
  • d: The contact creates 8 J of new energy.
Answer: The warm block’s energy decreases by 8 J.; The pair’s total energy is unchanged.

The internal transfer produces equal and opposite changes. It does not add energy to the pair.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F3 · The pendulum at its lowest point

Fixed fictional scientific information

An ideal pendulum–Earth model ignores friction and air resistance. At a high point its gravitational store is 30 J and its motion store is 0 J. At the lowest point these shares are 0 J and 30 J. No energy crosses the system boundary.

F3 · True or false

True or false? The system has less total energy at the bottom because its height is smaller.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Both positions total 30 J. In this ideal model the gravitational decrease becomes a motion increase.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Three paths through a pane

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional pane receives 100 J of visible light. It reflects 30 J back, transmits 50 J through the pane and absorbs 20 J. During this short interval the absorbed energy increases the pane’s thermal store; no other transfer is included.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place each labelled pathway beside its meaning.

Complete or match: Leaves back toward the source; Passes through to the far side; Increases the pane’s thermal store

  • a: Absorbed: 20 J
  • b: Reflected: 30 J
  • c: Transmitted: 50 J
  • d: Destroyed: 20 J
Answer: Leaves back toward the source → Reflected: 30 J; Passes through to the far side → Transmitted: 50 J; Increases the pane’s thermal store → Absorbed: 20 J

Reflected, transmitted and absorbed shares total 100 J. Absorption changes where energy is stored; it does not delete it.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F5 · Account for the spring-car remainder

Fixed fictional scientific information

A different fictional spring-car system begins with 36 J stored in its spring. Later, 10 J remains in the spring and 18 J is in motion. The rest has increased the thermal stores of the car, track and air inside the chosen system. No energy crossed its outer boundary.

F5 · Short answer

Calculate the thermal-store increase and explain why the 10 J still in the spring must remain in the account.

Example of a full-credit answer: The thermal increase is 36 − 10 − 18 = 8 J. The 10 J is still stored in the spring, so it is part of the final total even though it has not become motion.

  1. Calculates the 8-J thermal increase from all three final shares.
  2. Explains that the remaining 10 J is a real stored part of the final energy, not an output that can be omitted.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed fictional scientific information

In a virtual waterwheel interval, the raised water–Earth gravitational store decreases by 80 J. The generator transfers 45 J to an electrical load, and the wheel’s motion store increases by 15 J. The remaining energy warms the wheel, water and surroundings. No other changes or transfers are included.

1A · Hotspot

Select the destination of the energy not yet included in the 45-J and 15-J records.

  • a: Raised water: original energy source
  • b: Electrical load: 45 J received
  • c: Wheel motion: 15 J increase
  • d: Wheel, water and surroundings: warming
Answer: Wheel, water and surroundings: warming

The missing destination is warming. Its share is 80 − 45 − 15 = 20 J.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the warming share and explain why the wheel’s 15-J increase must also count, even though it remains stored in the wheel.

Example of a full-credit answer: The warming share is 20 J. The wheel has gained 15 J of stored motion energy; adding that to 45 J electrical transfer and 20 J warming accounts for the 80-J decrease.

  1. Calculates 20 J using 80 − 45 − 15.
  2. Explains that the 15-J store increase is part of the complete energy account, even though it has not left the wheel.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional rechargeable stage light receives no external energy during an interval. Its battery’s chemical store decreases by 50 J while 12 J leaves as light and 38 J warms nearby materials. Report A says that zero incoming energy means the outputs were created. Report B says the battery-store decrease supplies the outputs.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its single best response.

Complete or match: Supported report; Energy store being used; Energy leaving as light

  • a: Report A
  • b: Battery chemical store
  • c: 12 J
  • d: Report B
Answer: Supported report → Report B; Energy store being used → Battery chemical store; Energy leaving as light → 12 J

Report B accounts for 50 J leaving the battery store as 12 J light and 38 J warming.

2B · Open ended

Choose a report and justify it with the 50-J account and the distinction between external input and stored energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Report B is supported: 12 + 38 = 50 J. No external input is needed during this interval because the light uses energy already stored in its battery.

  1. Chooses B and checks that the two outputs total the 50-J battery-store decrease.
  2. Explains that zero external input does not rule out using energy stored inside the system.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed fictional scientific information

In a fictional ball–Earth–floor–air model, a released ball begins with 40 J in its gravitational store and no motion. At the highest point after the bounce it again has no motion, but its gravitational store is only 25 J. The other 15 J has spread into warming and sound within the larger system. No energy enters or leaves that larger boundary.

3A · Drag and drop

Place the energy amounts beside the matching part of the rebound account.

Complete or match: Gravitational store before release; Gravitational store at rebound peak; Warming and sound within the larger system

  • a: 15 J
  • b: 65 J
  • c: 40 J
  • d: 25 J
Answer: Gravitational store before release → 40 J; Gravitational store at rebound peak → 25 J; Warming and sound within the larger system → 15 J

At the rebound peak, 25 + 15 = 40 J. The ball’s smaller returned gravitational share does not mean the total has vanished.

3B · Short answer

Explain the lower rebound using the 40-J and 25-J stores, and identify where the remaining energy is recorded.

Example of a full-credit answer: The ball returns with 15 J less gravitational energy: 40 − 25 = 15. That share is in warming and sound in the floor, ball and air, so the larger system still accounts for 40 J.

  1. Connects the lower rebound to the 15-J reduction in the ball–Earth gravitational store.
  2. Accounts for the 15 J as warming and sound elsewhere in the larger system, rather than destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed fictional scientific information

A virtual cart initially has 54 J of motion energy and stops. Its brakes and wheels gain 40 J of thermal energy; another 14 J is transferred to nearby air and sound. These are the complete recorded destinations. A learner says friction destroyed the cart’s 54 J because it stopped.

4A · True or false

True or false? The cart stopping establishes that friction destroyed all 54 J.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The motion store decreased, but the recorded destinations still total 40 + 14 = 54 J.

4B · Open ended

Identify the error and write a complete corrected account using both recorded destinations.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses the loss of motion energy with destruction of total energy. The 54 J is accounted for by 40 J warming the brakes/wheels plus 14 J transferred to air and sound.

  1. Rejects the idea that stopping or friction destroys the total energy; identifies a change of store or transfer.
  2. Correctly accounts for the full 54 J as 40 + 14 J.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional light-and-sound exhibit receives 60 J per run and has no net stored-energy change. It needs at least 12 J of light, exactly 8 J of sound and a positive thermal transfer. One candidate uses 20 J light, 8 J sound and 32 J warming. You may propose other nonnegative amounts that meet the requirements.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete the ledger for the supplied candidate, before making your own design.

Complete or match: Candidate light output; Candidate sound output; Candidate thermal transfer

  • a: 32 J
  • b: 20 J
  • c: 60 J
  • d: 8 J
Answer: Candidate light output → 20 J; Candidate sound output → 8 J; Candidate thermal transfer → 32 J

The supplied candidate balances because 20 + 8 + 32 = 60 J and meets all stated requirements.

5B · Open ended

Propose a different complete light/sound/thermal split. Check the 60-J total and all three output requirements.

Example of a full-credit answer: One alternative is 16 J light, 8 J sound and 36 J thermal transfer. The total is 60 J; light is at least 12 J, sound is exactly 8 J and the thermal transfer is positive. Other valid splits, including non-integer values, are acceptable.

  1. Proposes a different split with light at least 12 J, sound exactly 8 J and a positive thermal transfer.
  2. Checks that the proposed three shares total 60 J with no unexplained source or loss.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.6 · Energy dissipation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A fan coasts to a stop
Coasting-fan record
PathwayEnergy (J)
Bearing warming12
Air motion5
Sound3

Worked-example information

A fictional fan has 20 J of motion energy just after its power is switched off. As it stops, 12 J warms its bearings, 5 J becomes air motion that later dissipates, and 3 J travels as sound.

Question: Why does stopping not mean losing energy from the complete account?

Answer: The 20 J is accounted for by the three other pathways: 12 + 5 + 3.

Why: The organised spinning motion ends while energy spreads into the surroundings. The air motion and sound can later transfer their energy thermally as well.

Example 2 · A task changes the judgement

Worked-example information

A fictional computer warms a small test chamber. In test A the goal is keeping the computer cool; in test B the chamber is deliberately warmed by capturing that output.

Question: Must the warming be called useless in both tests?

Answer: No. It is unwanted for keeping the computer cool but can help the chamber-warming task.

Why: Energy conservation is unchanged. The useful label changes with the purpose, and capturing some warmth does not promise complete recovery as electricity.

Example 3 · Compare cooling fairly

Worked-example information

Two identical virtual water containers start at 40°C in the same 20°C room. After the same interval, covered P is 38°C and uncovered Q is 32°C. Their water masses and materials are equal.

Question: Which retained more thermal energy under these conditions, and what comparison supports it?

Answer: P; its temperature fell by 2°C while Q’s fell by 8°C.

Why: With the stated equal mass and material, the smaller fall indicates less energy transferred out in this model. It does not show that P created energy or will never cool.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Successively lower bounces

Fixed case information

A fictional ball reaches 100 cm before its first drop, then rebounds to 60 cm and later to 36 cm. For this same ball in the same gravity, raised energy is proportional to height. The floor and air warm and sound is produced during the bounces.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Raised-energy share at first rebound; Share no longer in that raised store after first bounce; Height at the later rebound

  • a: 60% of the initial amount
  • b: 40% of the initial amount
  • c: 36 cm
  • d: 100% of the initial amount
Answer: Raised-energy share at first rebound → 60% of the initial amount; Share no longer in that raised store after first bounce → 40% of the initial amount; Height at the later rebound → 36 cm

The first rebound height is 60 out of 100, so 60% remains in that raised store; the rest follows other energy pathways.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Two blocks reach a common temperature

Fixed case information

Two identical-capacity fictional blocks start at 60°C and 20°C. They exchange energy with each other inside an insulated system, do no work, and eventually both reach 40°C. No energy leaves the pair.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? At the common temperature: All thermal energy has vanished.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Equal temperatures remove the difference that drives net heating between the blocks; they do not remove the blocks’ energy.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

F3 · Warming the intended water

Fixed case information

A fictional heater’s purpose is warming water in a nursery model. Of its 30 J input, 18 J increases the water’s thermal energy and 12 J reaches an empty corridor. These are separate complete pathways.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which transfer directly fulfils this heater’s stated purpose?

  • a: 18 J into the nursery water
  • b: 12 J into the empty corridor
  • c: All thermal transfer is always useless
  • d: No energy remains
Answer: 18 J into the nursery water

Warming the target water is useful for this purpose; corridor warming is outside the goal, although both shares still exist.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F4 · A smoother bearing, same delivered task

Fixed case information

Two fictional motors each deliver 30 J of the same mechanical task. The old bearing needs 40 J input and transfers 10 J thermally. The smooth bearing needs 35 J input and transfers 5 J thermally. Stored energy does not change.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Mechanical task in either design; Input saving with the smooth bearing; Lower-dissipation choice

  • a: 30 J
  • b: 5 J
  • c: Smooth bearing
  • d: 5 J of mechanical task
Answer: Mechanical task in either design → 30 J; Input saving with the smooth bearing → 5 J; Lower-dissipation choice → Smooth bearing

The useful task stays at 30 J while both input and unwanted thermal transfer fall by 5 J.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · After the bell becomes quiet

Fixed case information

A fictional bell receives 16 J. At first, 12 J warms the bell and 4 J travels as sound. Later, all 4 J of sound is absorbed by the room’s walls and becomes thermal energy. No energy leaves the bell-and-room boundary.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Account for all 16 J after the sound fades, and explain why quiet does not mean no energy or an automatic new ringing cycle.

Example of a full-credit answer: The bell has gained 12 J thermally and the walls 4 J, making 16 J in total. The energy is spread out; quiet does not mean no energy, and this dispersed warmth does not by itself start the original ringing again.

  1. Accounts for 12 J in the bell and 4 J in the walls, totalling 16 J of thermal energy increase.
  2. Explains that the energy is dispersed rather than destroyed and does not spontaneously return as organised ringing without an input.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional cart loses all 60 J of its motion energy while stopping. The brake gains 35 J thermally, the road gains 20 J thermally, and 5 J travels as sound. There are no other pathways in this fixed record.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which destination receives the largest share of the cart’s former motion energy?

  • a: Brake warming: 35 J
  • b: Road warming: 20 J
  • c: Sound: 5 J
  • d: Destroyed energy: 60 J
Answer: Brake warming: 35 J

The brake receives the largest share. All receiving pathways sum to the original 60 J; none has vanished.

1B · Open ended

Give the complete stopping-energy account and explain why the dispersed energy does not automatically make the cart move again.

Example of a full-credit answer: 35 J warms the brake, 20 J warms the road and 5 J travels as sound, totalling 60 J. The energy is spread out rather than destroyed; it does not spontaneously gather back into forward cart motion.

  1. Accounts for 35 + 20 + 5 = 60 J in the stated receiving pathways.
  2. Explains that energy remains but is spread into thermal motion/sound rather than organised cart motion, so restarting needs an appropriate input.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Two fictional boxes contain equal masses of the same water and start at 60°C in the same 20°C room. After equal time, insulated A is 50°C and less-insulated B is 35°C. The goal is to keep the water warm without additional heating.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Better retention in this test: Box A
  • b: Larger temperature decrease: 25°C in Box B
  • c: Better retention in this test: Box B
  • d: Larger temperature decrease: 10°C in Box A
Answer: Better retention in this test: Box A; Larger temperature decrease: 25°C in Box B

A drops 10°C while B drops 25°C. With the supplied mass, material and other controls, A has lost less thermal energy.

2B · Short answer

Choose a box using both temperature drops and explain one stated control that makes the comparison fair.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A: its fall is 60 − 50 = 10°C instead of B’s 60 − 35 = 25°C. Equal masses of the same water and equal starting/room conditions make the retention comparison fair.

  1. Chooses A and correctly compares its 10°C fall with B’s 25°C fall.
  2. Explains a relevant shared condition such as equal water mass/material, starting temperature, room or interval; does not claim no transfer occurs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional heat-powered device can operate only using a temperature difference between two blocks. After it is disconnected, two equal-capacity blocks at 70°C and 10°C exchange energy directly inside an insulated pair until both are 40°C; no work is done during this equalisation. Reconnecting the device gives it only these two equal-temperature blocks, with no other source.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Why does the reconnected model lack its required driving condition?

  • a: Both blocks are at the same temperature
  • b: All thermal energy was destroyed
  • c: Both blocks contain zero energy
  • d: The blocks turned into a vacuum
Answer: Both blocks are at the same temperature

The pair conserves energy during equalisation, but at 40°C and 40°C it has no temperature difference to drive the defined device.

3B · Open ended

Explain what prevents the reconnected device from working with only these blocks and what happened to the energy during equalisation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both blocks are 40°C, so their difference is zero and the defined device has no hot-to-cool drive. Energy stayed in the insulated pair during equalisation, but became more evenly spread.

  1. Identifies equal 40°C temperatures and zero temperature difference as the missing driving condition.
  2. States the pair’s energy is conserved but more evenly spread; lack of the driving difference does not mean zero energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Two fictional containers each receive 50 J above a common starting state. Plain P transfers 28 J to the room and retains 22 J. Insulated Q transfers 10 J to the room and retains 40 J. A learner says Q created 18 J because it retains 18 J more. No other energy source enters either container.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Difference in retained energy; Reason for the difference; Retained plus outgoing energy for Q

  • a: 18 J
  • b: Reduced transfer to the room
  • c: 50 J
  • d: New energy created by insulation
Answer: Difference in retained energy → 18 J; Reason for the difference → Reduced transfer to the room; Retained plus outgoing energy for Q → 50 J

The additional retained 18 J equals the reduction in transfer out: 28 − 10. Both complete accounts still total the same 50 J input.

4B · Short answer

Identify the error in the creation claim and use both complete energy accounts to explain the 18 J difference.

Example of a full-credit answer: Insulation created no energy: Q transfers 18 J less to the room and therefore retains 18 J more. P has 22 + 28 = 50 J and Q has 40 + 10 = 50 J, the same input.

  1. Rejects energy creation and identifies 18 J less transfer to the room as the reason Q retains more.
  2. Correctly checks both accounts: 22 + 28 = 50 J and 40 + 10 = 50 J.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A fictional powered cart has a 40 J input budget. It must raise a load by at least 28 J of gravitational energy and then end stopped. The model counts three separate pathways: load raising, bearing warming and final-brake warming. The required final brake takes 5 J. Ordinary bearings take 12 J; smooth bearings take 4 J. Removing the brake fails the stopping requirement.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Bearing choice meeting the full task; Component that must remain; Energy available to raise the load with the valid choice

  • a: Smooth bearings
  • b: Final brake
  • c: 31 J
  • d: Ordinary bearings
Answer: Bearing choice meeting the full task → Smooth bearings; Component that must remain → Final brake; Energy available to raise the load with the valid choice → 31 J

Smooth bearings leave 40 − 4 − 5 = 31 J for raising, above 28 J, while the retained brake performs the required stopping task.

5B · Open ended

Propose a bearing-and-brake design, verify that enough energy remains for raising, and explain why the brake’s warming should not simply be removed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use smooth bearings and keep the final brake. This leaves 40 − 4 − 5 = 31 J for raising, which exceeds 28 J. The brake’s warming accompanies the required stop, so removing it would fail the task even if a loss number looked smaller.

  1. Chooses smooth bearings with the brake retained and verifies 40 − 4 − 5 = 31 J, meeting the 28 J raising requirement.
  2. Explains that braking is a required stopping function, so not every frictional or thermal pathway is unwanted for the full task.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.7 · Renewable energy

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Source and conversion device
Roles in the route
PartRole
SunlightRenewable source
Photovoltaic panelConversion device
Electrical outputTransferred energy

Worked-example information

A virtual rooftop panel receives sunlight and converts some of its energy into electrical output. The Sun continues to provide light through natural processes; the panel also transfers energy thermally.

Question: Which part is the renewable source and which is the conversion device?

Answer: Sunlight is the renewable energy source; the photovoltaic panel is the conversion device.

Why: Naming the source is different from naming the machine. The panel transforms supplied light energy and does not create an unlimited supply of its own.

Example 2 · A regrowing plot

Worked example information

A fictional plot starts with 16 biomass units. During one season 5 new units grow and 3 are harvested; no other flow is included.

Question: What stock remains?

Answer: 18 units.

Why: 16 + 5 − 3 = 18; regrowth exceeds harvest by 2.

Example 3 · Storage remembers an earlier input

Worked example information

A model battery is charged with solar electricity in daylight. At dusk it delivers 4 usable units, while direct solar output is zero.

Question: What supplied the energy that the battery releases?

Answer: Earlier solar input stored in the battery.

Why: The battery transfers stored energy to a later time; it does not produce new sunlight or create energy.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Wind classification and a still hour

Fixed question information

Moving air is naturally replenished. A fictional turbine produces no electricity during one still hour.

F1 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Wind source classification: Non-renewable.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Wind remains renewable even when this hour has no usable wind output.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · A day–night solar record

Fixed question information

The model records 8 energy units from direct solar panels by day and 0 at night. There is no storage or other source.

F2 · Multiple choice

What direct solar output is recorded at night?

  • a: 12 units
  • b: 4 units
  • c: 8 units
  • d: 0 units
Answer: 0 units

The given night reading is zero; the day reading is eight. No storage is supplied.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Harvest and renewal

Fixed question information

A model biomass store starts at 20 units. Four regrow and six are harvested during one year, with no other changes.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Ending stock; Net stock change

  • a: 2-unit increase
  • b: 18 units
  • c: 24 units
  • d: 2-unit decrease
Answer: Ending stock → 18 units; Net stock change → 2-unit decrease

20 + 4 − 6 = 18; removing more than regrows lowers the stock by two.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A river benefit and concern

Fixed question information

A fictional hydropower plan supplies 5 electrical energy units per interval. Its barrier also blocks a named fish-migration route. These are separate findings. For the separate pathway illustration, each energy unit is 1 J: the model receives 8 J mechanically from moving water and gives 5 J electrically plus 3 J as thermal and sound transfer during the interval.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Measured energy service; Recorded ecological concern

  • a: 5 electrical units per interval
  • b: Unlimited energy without conditions
  • c: No possible environmental effects
  • d: Blocked fish-migration route
Answer: Measured energy service → 5 electrical units per interval; Recorded ecological concern → Blocked fish-migration route

The output is a service measure; the blocked route is a different impact that also needs attention.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F5 · Why the average is insufficient

Fixed question information

A wind model produces 2, 9, 1 and 8 energy units in four equal intervals. A task needs 5 in each interval. There is no storage. Total supply and total demand are both 20.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the equal daily totals do not meet every interval’s need. Use one shortage from the record and name a timing solution to investigate.

Example of a full-credit answer: Interval 1 is 3 units short, and interval 3 is 4 short. A storage proposal would need enough usable energy already charged before each shortage, including the first one; alternatively, investigate moving a suitable task to a surplus interval. Equal totals alone do not ensure simultaneous supply.

  1. Identifies a correct interval shortage using the fixed data.
  2. Explains a relevant task-timing change or storage response that is available before the shortage, rather than assuming an average guarantees supply.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

During daylight, 6 solar energy units enter a model battery. Exactly 1 unit transfers to surroundings before useful discharge. The evening light needs 4 units; there is no other loss in this toy account.

1A · Hotspot

How much energy is available for discharge?

  • a: 5 units
  • b: 1 unit
  • c: 4 units
  • d: 6 units
Answer: 5 units

6 − 1 = 5 usable units; supplying four leaves one in this stated account.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the usable stored energy and decide whether the evening light’s demand can be met.

Example of a full-credit answer: The battery can deliver 5 units after the 1-unit loss. That meets the 4-unit demand and leaves 1 unit in the stated model.

  1. Calculates 5 usable units from the input and loss.
  2. Compares 5 with the 4-unit demand and correctly concludes the light can be supplied.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

For three equal intervals, site A supplies 6, 0, 6 energy units and site B supplies 4, 4, 4. The task needs 4 in each interval. No storage is available. Both sites use renewable wind.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Site meeting 4 units in every interval: Site B.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

B supplies four in each interval. A’s equal total does not remove its middle-interval shortage.

2B · Open ended

Justify the better site for this no-storage task using the timing records.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B because each of its three readings meets the 4-unit demand. A has the same 12-unit total but zero in the middle interval, so it cannot meet that interval without a change.

  1. Chooses B using its interval-by-interval supply.
  2. Explains why A’s equal total is insufficient because of its middle-interval gap.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A fictional river turbine supplies 10 units in a wet-season interval but 3 in an equally long dry-season interval. Demand is 5 in each. All quantities are usable electrical energy units.

3A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Dry-interval shortage; Wet-interval surplus

  • a: 13 units
  • b: 2 units
  • c: 7 units
  • d: 5 units
Answer: Dry-interval shortage → 2 units; Wet-interval surplus → 5 units

Dry demand minus supply is 5 − 3 = 2; wet supply minus demand is 10 − 5 = 5.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the dry-season gap and propose one change that a plan should investigate.

Example of a full-credit answer: The dry interval is 2 units short. Investigate reducing or moving an appropriate task, storage that can actually bridge the interval, or another suitable supply; a renewable label does not remove seasonality.

  1. Calculates the 2-unit dry-interval shortage.
  2. Proposes a relevant response that recognises seasonal supply or storage requirements.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

An advertisement calls a biomass plot unlimited because it is renewable. The model begins with 30 units, regrows 5 each year and harvests 8 each year; other flows are excluded.

4A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Annual stock change; Harvest that balances the stated annual regrowth

  • a: 8 units per year
  • b: 3-unit decrease
  • c: 5 units per year
  • d: 3-unit increase
Answer: Annual stock change → 3-unit decrease; Harvest that balances the stated annual regrowth → 5 units per year

Harvest exceeds regrowth by 3. Harvesting five balances this model’s five-unit regrowth, but does not establish every environmental effect.

4B · Open ended

Correct the advertisement using the two annual rates and state a limit of the simple stock check.

Example of a full-credit answer: The stock shrinks because 8 units are removed while only 5 regrow. Balancing the rates helps preserve the stock in this model, but soil, habitats, emissions and other effects still need evidence.

  1. Uses the 8-versus-5 rates to reject the unlimited-stock claim.
  2. States that a balanced stock is not a complete environmental or sustainability assessment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A school model has 6 usable solar units in the morning and 6 in the afternoon, but zero at night. Watering uses 4 units and can be scheduled in daylight. A previously charged model battery is confirmed to deliver 2 usable units at night; evening lights need exactly 2.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Supply that can meet the stated night-light demand: The verified 2-unit battery discharge
  • b: Supply that can meet the stated night-light demand: An uncharged battery with no input
  • c: Task that can use direct daylight supply: Watering in the morning or afternoon
  • d: Task that can use direct daylight supply: Watering at night with no supply
Answer: Supply that can meet the stated night-light demand: The verified 2-unit battery discharge; Task that can use direct daylight supply: Watering in the morning or afternoon

Watering can occur during either six-unit solar interval. The verified store supplies the two-unit evening light; its energy had to be charged earlier.

5B · Open ended

Propose a timetable that meets the two tasks and identify one reading you would check before using the plan.

Example of a full-credit answer: Water in a daylight interval using 4 of its 6 units, and reserve the confirmed 2 usable battery units for the evening light. Check actual solar output or usable battery delivery before relying on the plan.

  1. Schedules watering in a supplied daylight interval and lights from the verified battery.
  2. Names a relevant supply or usable-storage measurement to verify the plan.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.8 · Non-renewable energy

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Trips from a fixed store
Boat fuel account
QuantityValue
Stored fuel18
Fuel per trip3
Complete trips6

Worked example information

A virtual boat starts with 18 fuel units. Each identical trip uses 3; the model has no refill.

Question: How many complete trips can it make?

Answer: 6 trips.

Why: 18 ÷ 3 = 6 under the stated constant-use rule.

Example 2 · A delivery is not geological renewal

Worked-example information

A fictional store begins with 20 fuel units, uses 8, then receives 5 units delivered from another depot. No fuel forms naturally during this short interval.

Question: How much is stored at the end, and did the delivery make the resource renewable?

Answer: 17 units remain; the delivery moved existing fuel rather than rapidly forming new fuel.

Why: 20 − 8 + 5 = 17. A refill from elsewhere changes this store’s account, while the resource’s natural replenishment time is unchanged.

Example 3 · A lower emissions measure is a different question

Worked-example information

Two fictional plants deliver the same useful energy. One burning natural gas has a supplied emissions index of 4; one burning coal has an index of 9. Both fuels formed through slow geological processes.

Question: Does the lower index make natural gas a renewable fuel?

Answer: No. It has the lower supplied index in this comparison, but it remains non-renewable.

Why: The environmental index and the replenishment category answer different questions. A lower value for one stated impact does not change how rapidly the fuel forms.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Two use rates from one fuel store

Fixed question information

A model begins with 30 fuel units and no replenishment. Plan A uses 5 each day; plan B uses 10 each day.

F1 · Multiple choice

How long can the store supply plan A?

  • a: 6 days
  • b: 30 days
  • c: 3 days
  • d: 2 days
Answer: 6 days

30 ÷ 5 = 6 days, while 30 ÷ 10 = 3 days.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Formation and use

Fixed question information

The reference says coal forms through geological processes over millions of years. The model extracts and uses its coal much faster than replacement occurs.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Coal formation time in the reference: One afternoon
  • b: Resource category relative to present use: Renewable at the daily use rate
  • c: Coal formation time in the reference: Millions of years
  • d: Resource category relative to present use: Non-renewable
Answer: Coal formation time in the reference: Millions of years; Resource category relative to present use: Non-renewable

The long formation time compared with rapid use makes this coal source non-renewable.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Uranium is not a fossil fuel

Fixed question information

Uranium is a finite mined fuel for nuclear reactions. The reference explicitly states that it did not form from ancient biomass.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Uranium’s fossil-fuel classification: Not a fossil fuel.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Uranium is non-renewable in this account but not a fossil fuel.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Equal work, different fuel use

Fixed question information

Two virtual pumps deliver the same water service each day. A uses 4 fuel units and B uses 6. Each is assigned a separate 24-unit store, with no refill. For the pathway illustration, each fictional fuel unit supplies 10 J and the equal daily water task receives 20 J of useful mechanical work; the rest is thermal transfer.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Pump A duration; Pump B duration

  • a: 6 days
  • b: 4 days
  • c: 24 days
  • d: 2 days
Answer: Pump A duration → 6 days; Pump B duration → 4 days

24 ÷ 4 = 6 and 24 ÷ 6 = 4. The water service is stated to be equal.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F5 · A larger discovery is not renewal

Fixed question information

A fictional survey revises a known fuel store from 20 to 40 units. Use remains 4 units per day, and the fuel’s formation process remains far slower than use.

F5 · Open ended

Calculate the two toy durations and explain why the revised estimate does not make the fuel renewable.

Example of a full-credit answer: The old estimate supports 20/4=5 days; the new estimate supports 40/4=10. More known fuel changes the estimated duration but not the slow formation process.

  1. Calculates the 5-day and 10-day durations.
  2. Explains that discovery or a revised stock estimate does not speed natural replenishment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A virtual service centre begins with 48 fuel units. Its essential equipment uses 6 on day one and 10 on day two. No fuel arrives or forms inside the model store.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Remaining fuel; Total fuel used

  • a: 32 units
  • b: 16 units
  • c: 64 units
  • d: 48 units
Answer: Remaining fuel → 32 units; Total fuel used → 16 units

Use totals 6 + 10 = 16; 48 − 16 = 32 remain.

1B · Open ended

Show the fuel account and explain how the no-refill condition affects it.

Example of a full-credit answer: 48 − 6 − 10 = 32 units remain. Only the stated uses are subtracted; no replacement is added because the model supplies none.

  1. Calculates 32 units remaining from both days.
  2. Uses the no-refill condition correctly instead of assuming automatic replacement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Card C describes coal made through geological changes to ancient organic material. Card U describes uranium mined for nuclear fuel. Card W describes naturally replenished moving air. Uranium’s stock is finite on the usage time scale and is not derived from ancient biomass.

2A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Non-renewable but not fossil; Fossil-fuel example

  • a: Card U
  • b: Card W
  • c: All three are fossil fuels
  • d: Card C
Answer: Non-renewable but not fossil → Card U; Fossil-fuel example → Card C

Coal and uranium share the finite-resource classification but have different origins.

2B · Short answer

Justify the classification of uranium using replenishment and origin.

Example of a full-credit answer: The uranium supply is finite on the usage time scale, so it is non-renewable in this account. It is not derived from ancient organic material, so it is not a fossil fuel.

  1. Uses finite replenishment relative to use to explain non-renewable.
  2. Uses its non-biomass origin to explain why it is not fossil.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A fictional fuel store contains 36 units. A heating task normally uses 3 per day but uses 6 per day during a stated cold spell. Assume each rate stays constant for its separate calculation.

3A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Duration at 6 units per day: 18 days
  • b: Duration at 6 units per day: 6 days
  • c: Duration at 3 units per day: 12 days
  • d: Duration at 3 units per day: 36 days
Answer: Duration at 6 units per day: 6 days; Duration at 3 units per day: 12 days

36 ÷ 3 = 12; doubling the daily use to six halves the duration to six days.

3B · Open ended

Calculate both durations and explain what changed without claiming that the stock itself changed.

Example of a full-credit answer: The same 36-unit stock lasts 12 days at 3 per day and 6 days at 6 per day. The use rate doubled; the initial stock and replenishment assumption did not change.

  1. Calculates 12 days and 6 days.
  2. Explains the change through use rate while keeping the initial stock fixed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner argues that burned coal must be renewable because its carbon atoms still exist. The source says combustion changes coal into other substances including carbon dioxide; the original usable coal stock decreases. The virtual atom explorer represents one fuel component as C + O₂ → CO₂, not a complete formula for coal. Its energy amounts are fictional teaching settings, not actual combustion data.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Carbon atoms after combustion; Original usable coal stock

  • a: Destroyed into nothing
  • b: Instantly restored to its original fuel quantity
  • c: Still present in reaction products
  • d: Decreased
Answer: Carbon atoms after combustion → Still present in reaction products; Original usable coal stock → Decreased

The atoms persist, but the original fuel has been transformed; that is not rapid natural replenishment.

4B · Short answer

Correct the argument by distinguishing conserved atoms from a renewable usable fuel supply.

Example of a full-credit answer: Carbon atoms remain in products such as carbon dioxide, but the burned coal is no longer the same usable stock. Coal’s geological formation is too slow to replace present use on a human time scale.

  1. Distinguishes atoms remaining in products from the original usable fuel stock.
  2. Connects the non-renewable classification to slow replenishment relative to use.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Four virtual pumps each deliver the required daily water amount. A uses 12 fuel units daily, B uses 8, C uses 10 and D uses 16. A 40-unit store must cover five days, with no refill.

5A · Hotspot

Which pump fits the full five-day fuel budget?

  • a: Pump C
  • b: Pump A
  • c: Pump D
  • d: Pump B
Answer: Pump B

B uses 8 × 5 = 40. A, C and D need 60, 50 and 80, all exceeding the stock.

5B · Open ended

Propose the five-day choice, show its budget and name a service check that keeps the comparison fair.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B: 8 × 5 = 40 fuel units. Verify that it still delivers the required water each day; saving fuel by failing the service would not be a fair equal-work comparison.

  1. Selects B with the correct 40-unit five-day calculation.
  2. Names verification of the same required water service or useful output.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.9 · Energy efficiency

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A small lifting pump

Fictional worked-example information

A fictional pump receives 30 J of electrical energy in one run. It transfers 18 J into raising water. The other 12 J warms the pump and surroundings, with no net stored-energy change in the device. The stated useful task is raising the water.

Question: What is its useful energy efficiency?

Answer: 60%, because 18 ÷ 30 × 100% = 60%.

Why: The numerator contains the output that performs the named task. The 12-J warming transfer still belongs to the complete energy account, but is not counted as useful water-lifting output.

Example 2 · A warm casing does not heat the target water
A warm casing does not heat the target water
DestinationEnergy (J)Useful for this task?
Target water24Yes
Casing and room16No

Fictional worked-example information

A virtual water-heating device receives 40 J. Its target water gains 24 J, while the casing and room gain 16 J. The designer wants to warm the water, and no other change is included. An observer suggests counting the warm room as useful too.

Question: Which energy belongs in the numerator for the stated task?

Answer: The 24 J reaching the target water, giving 60% efficiency.

Why: Usefulness follows the goal. The full 40 J is conserved, but the 16 J in the casing and room did not reach the target water during this test.

Example 3 · Equal reading service

Fictional worked-example information

Two fictional lamp arrangements provide the same required reading light at the same desk for one hour. Arrangement A uses 72 energy units and B uses 48. The values come from a matched model comparison, not an actual electricity bill or a real lamp rating.

Question: Which arrangement uses energy more efficiently for this service, and how much input does it save?

Answer: B. It provides the same service using 24 fewer units.

Why: The useful service and duration are held equal, so the input comparison is meaningful. A lower input would not prove an improvement if B had provided much dimmer or shorter lighting instead.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read the motor’s useful share

Fixed fictional scientific information

A virtual motor receives 50 J electrically and produces 30 J of useful motion during a run. The other 20 J warms its surroundings. Its useful task is the recorded motion and its stored energy does not change.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the panel showing the motor’s useful energy efficiency.

  • a: 40% useful
  • b: 30% useful
  • c: 60% useful
  • d: 100% useful
Answer: 60% useful

30 ÷ 50 × 100% = 60%. The 20-J thermal transfer is conserved but does not serve this motion task.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F2 · The bigger output trap

Fixed fictional scientific information

Robot driver A provides 12 J of useful motion from 40 J input. Driver B provides 18 J from 90 J input. Both records use the same definition of useful motion. A learner chooses B solely because 18 J is larger than 12 J.

F2 · True or false

True or false? B is more efficient because it produces more useful joules.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A is 12/40 = 30% efficient, while B is 18/90 = 20%. B has more useful output but a smaller useful share.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · A solar water-warming panel

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional panel receives 80 J of sunlight. It reflects 20 J, transfers 32 J into its target water and increases its casing’s thermal store by 28 J. The task is to warm the water. All numbers cover the same interval.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place the value beside its meaning for the stated water-warming task.

Complete or match: Useful energy reaching the water; Useful energy efficiency; Combined reflected and casing energy

  • a: 60%
  • b: 48 J
  • c: 32 J
  • d: 40%
Answer: Useful energy reaching the water → 32 J; Useful energy efficiency → 40%; Combined reflected and casing energy → 48 J

Useful efficiency is 32/80 = 40%. The other 48 J is reflected or retained in the casing; it is not destroyed.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F4 · Evaluate the new lifting drive

Fixed fictional scientific information

A prepared old drive receives 60 J per lifting run and gives 24 J of useful lifting energy. A new drive receives the same 60 J and gives 36 J of useful lifting energy. Neither drive changes its own stored energy during a run.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL correct statements. Judge the improvement from the fixed records.

  • a: The new drive has 60% useful efficiency.
  • b: The new drive provides more useful lifting energy per input joule.
  • c: The new drive creates 12 J of extra energy.
  • d: Both drives are 100% efficient because energy is conserved.
Answer: The new drive has 60% useful efficiency.; The new drive provides more useful lifting energy per input joule.

The old useful share is 40%, and the new share is 60%. Their total accounts still include all other transfers.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · One job and three jobs

Fixed fictional scientific information

Identical virtual robots need 20 J input for each equal job and provide 10 J useful motion per job. Robot A completes one job: 20 J input and 10 J useful. Robot B completes three jobs: 60 J input and 30 J useful. Nothing about the per-job settings changes.

F5 · Short answer

Calculate each robot’s efficiency and explain why B’s larger total input does not show lower efficiency.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both are 50% efficient: 10/20 and 30/60 each equal one half. B uses more total energy because it completes three equal jobs, not because its useful share is lower.

  1. Calculates or clearly identifies both useful energy efficiencies as 50%.
  2. Distinguishes the greater number of equal jobs from a change in the useful-output/input ratio.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional solar toy receives 100 J of sunlight. Its panel produces 20 J of electrical energy and transfers the other 80 J elsewhere. The motor receives those same 20 J, produces 15 J of useful motion and transfers 5 J elsewhere. There is no net stored-energy change at either stage.

1A · Drag and drop

Place the percentage beside the correct boundary.

Complete or match: Solar panel: electrical output / sunlight input; Motor: motion output / electrical input; Whole chain: motion output / sunlight input

  • a: 75%
  • b: 15%
  • c: 95%
  • d: 20%
Answer: Solar panel: electrical output / sunlight input → 20%; Motor: motion output / electrical input → 75%; Whole chain: motion output / sunlight input → 15%

The stage efficiencies are 20% and 75%, while the whole chain is 15/100 = 15%. Adding stage percentages is not a valid whole-chain calculation.

1B · Short answer

Explain why the whole-chain efficiency is 15%, not 95%, and account for the total energy outside the useful motion output.

Example of a full-credit answer: The final 15 J must be compared with the original 100 J, so the whole chain is 15%. The other transfers total 80 + 5 = 85 J. The intermediate 20 J passes from panel to motor and is not a new supply to add again.

  1. Uses final output/original input and explains that the intermediate 20 J or stage percentages must not be added as new energy.
  2. Accounts for 85 J of other transfers as 80 + 5 J, with 15 J useful completing the 100-J total.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional airflow task needs at least 40 J of useful air-motion energy in five minutes. Tested plan A gives 40 J using 100 J input. Plan B gives 40 J using 80 J input. Plan C gives 20 J using 60 J input. Plan D has no measured output or input. Choose the measured plan that meets the task with the least input.

2A · Hotspot

Select the measured plan that meets the useful-output requirement with the least input.

  • a: A: 40 J useful from 100 J input
  • b: B: 40 J useful from 80 J input
  • c: C: 20 J useful from 60 J input
  • d: D: no input or output measurements
Answer: B: 40 J useful from 80 J input

B meets the 40-J task using less input than A. C’s lower input accompanies an insufficient output; D cannot be assessed.

2B · Open ended

Justify your choice by comparing B with A, then explain why C’s smaller input does not make it suitable.

Example of a full-credit answer: B supplies the required 40 J using 80 J rather than A’s 100 J. C uses only 60 J but provides 20 J, below the required 40 J, so it does not complete this task.

  1. Uses the equal 40-J useful result and the 80-J versus 100-J inputs to justify B over A.
  2. Explains that C fails the required useful output, citing 20 J versus at least 40 J.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed fictional scientific information

A virtual crane must give 30 J of useful lifting energy to the same load and height. Motor M is 50% efficient and needs 60 J input. Motor N is 75% efficient. These fixed model efficiencies apply to this run, and neither motor has a net store change.

3A · Multiple choice

How much input does motor N need to provide the required 30 J of useful lifting energy?

  • a: 22.5 J
  • b: 75 J
  • c: 40 J
  • d: 90 J
Answer: 40 J

75% of 40 J is 30 J. The required input is 30 ÷ 0.75 = 40 J.

3B · Short answer

Show how 40 J input meets N’s 30-J target, and calculate the input saving compared with M for the same lift.

Example of a full-credit answer: Three quarters of 40 J is 30 J, so N meets the target. M needs 60 J and N needs 40 J, a saving of 20 J for the same useful lift.

  1. Shows that 75% of 40 J equals the required 30 J, or uses the equivalent inverse calculation.
  2. Calculates a 20-J input saving by comparing 60 J and 40 J for the same useful lifting task.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed fictional scientific information

In a virtual oven interval, 80 J enters. The target food gains 48 J, the room receives 24 J and the oven walls store another 8 J. The task is to warm the food. A learner adds all three destinations and says this proves 100% food-heating efficiency.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete the account for the stated food-warming task.

Complete or match: Useful energy reaching the food; Food-heating efficiency; Energy in room and wall destinations

  • a: 100%
  • b: 32 J
  • c: 60%
  • d: 48 J
Answer: Useful energy reaching the food → 48 J; Food-heating efficiency → 60%; Energy in room and wall destinations → 32 J

Only 48 J serves the specified food task. 48/80 = 60%, while 24 + 8 = 32 J remains in other destinations.

4B · Open ended

Identify the learner’s error and calculate the correct food-heating efficiency using the stated task.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses a complete conservation account with useful output. The food receives 48 J from 80 J input, so useful food-heating efficiency is 60%; the other 32 J is conserved elsewhere but does not warm the target food in this interval.

  1. Explains why adding every destination does not make all energy useful for warming the target food.
  2. Calculates 48/80 × 100% = 60%, using food energy rather than all destinations in the numerator.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed fictional scientific information

A fictional display has an 80-J maximum input budget per run. Its motor converts 75% of its own input into useful motion; its lamp converts 50% of its own input into useful light. The display needs at least 30 J motion and at least 10 J light. The efficiencies are fixed model assumptions, the inputs are separate, and unused budget need not be spent.

5A · Matching

Match each minimum-input calculation for this fixed model.

Complete or match: Least motor input for 30 J motion; Least lamp input for 10 J light; Minimum combined input meeting both tasks

  • a: 60 J
  • b: 80 J
  • c: 20 J
  • d: 40 J
Answer: Least motor input for 30 J motion → 40 J; Least lamp input for 10 J light → 20 J; Minimum combined input meeting both tasks → 60 J

Motor input must be at least 40 J and lamp input at least 20 J. Their minimum total is 60 J, leaving some of the 80-J budget unused.

5B · Open ended

Propose motor and lamp input amounts. Calculate both useful outputs, and check that they meet their targets while the total input stays within 80 J.

Example of a full-credit answer: One plan uses 40 J for the motor and 20 J for the lamp. The outputs are 30 J motion and 10 J light, and the combined input is 60 J, within 80 J. A different valid plan is 48 J and 24 J, producing 36 J motion and 12 J light from 72 J total. Other valid allocations are acceptable.

  1. Proposes inputs and correctly applies 75% and 50% to show motion at least 30 J and light at least 10 J.
  2. Checks that the two proposed inputs together are no more than 80 J; unused budget is allowed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.10 · Electricity generation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Hand-powered light

Worked example information

A learner turns a virtual handle that drives a generator and lamp.

Question: What supplies the energy?

Answer: Mechanical work on the handle.

Why: The generator converts supplied energy; the lamp is an output device.

Example 2 · Solar without a turbine

Worked example information

Light reaches a photovoltaic cell connected to a load.

Question: Must steam be involved?

Answer: No.

Why: The cell converts light directly into electrical output in this model.

Example 3 · Account for losses
Generator energy account
PathwayEnergy (J)
Mechanical input100
Electrical output80
Other transfers20

Worked example information

A turbine model receives 100 J of mechanical input and provides 80 J electrical output. Stores do not change.

Question: How much goes to other transfers?

Answer: 20 J.

Why: 100 − 80 remains in other pathways, such as warming and sound.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Find the turbine driver

Fixed question information

Moving river water turns a turbine connected to a generator.

F1 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Input source; Generator output

  • a: Electrical energy
  • b: Moving water
  • c: Empty space
  • d: New matter
Answer: Input source → Moving water; Generator output → Electrical energy

The water’s motion provides mechanical input.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read a photovoltaic route

Fixed question information

A photovoltaic cell receives light and supplies a circuit; there is no turbine.

F2 · Multiple choice

What is converted into electrical output?

  • a: Sunlight absent
  • b: Turbine
  • c: Steam only
  • d: Light
Answer: Light

This stated pathway does not need a turbine.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F3 · Track the output account

Fixed question information

A model generator receives 60 J mechanical input and supplies 45 J electrically with no store change.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Electrical output: 45 J
  • b: Other output: 15 J
  • c: Electrical output: 0 J
  • d: Other output: 105 J
Answer: Electrical output: 45 J; Other output: 15 J

The complete output total equals input.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F4 · Read a source interval

Fixed question information

A wind model supplies 6 units when windy and 1 in a low-wind interval.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Low-wind output; Windy output

  • a: 0 units always
  • b: 1 unit
  • c: 7 units
  • d: 6 units
Answer: Low-wind output → 1 unit; Windy output → 6 units

Use the stated interval data.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a stopped handle

Fixed question information

A hand-generator model has no battery or other energy store. The handle stops and its motion dies away.

F5 · Open ended

Why can the lamp not keep receiving energy indefinitely? Name the missing input and the storage condition.

Example of a full-credit answer: Mechanical input stopped, and no energy store is available after the motion ends. Continuing output would lack an energy source.

  1. Identifies stopped mechanical input.
  2. Uses the absence of an available store to reject indefinite output.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A model turbine receives 150 J of mechanical input. The generator transfers 110 J electrically, and stores do not change.

1A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Other transfer: 260 J.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

150 − 110 = 40.

1B · Open ended

Complete the energy account and name one plausible other pathway.

Example of a full-credit answer: 40 J goes to other transfers, such as thermal energy to surroundings or sound.

  1. Calculates 40 J.
  2. Names a plausible pathway while conserving energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Diagram A: wind → turbine → generator → circuit. Diagram B: generator → new energy from nothing → circuit.

2A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Valid diagram; B’s error

  • a: Energy creation
  • b: A
  • c: B
  • d: Too many arrows
Answer: Valid diagram → A; B’s error → Energy creation

A identifies an input; B invents energy.

2B · Short answer

Choose a diagram and explain the roles of turbine and generator.

Example of a full-credit answer: A. The turbine obtains motion from wind and turns the generator; the generator converts mechanical input to electrical transfer.

  1. Explains turbine’s role in receiving/driving motion.
  2. Explains generator conversion without energy creation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

System P uses moving water to turn a turbine connected to a generator. System Q uses light and a photovoltaic cell.

3A · Hotspot

Which uses a mechanical turbine pathway?

  • a: Q
  • b: Both must use steam
  • c: Neither supplies electricity
  • d: P
Answer: P

Different sources and devices can reach electrical output.

3B · Open ended

Compare the two pathways by naming each input and conversion device.

Example of a full-credit answer: P uses moving water to drive a turbine/generator. Q uses light in a photovoltaic cell.

  1. Correctly describes P’s mechanical generator route.
  2. Correctly describes Q’s photovoltaic route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says every way of generating electricity first boils water. The source describes wind turbines and photovoltaic cells.

4A · Multiple choice

What is the claim’s problem?

  • a: Steam is an input in both examples
  • b: All examples agree
  • c: Counterexamples exist
  • d: Boiling is universal
Answer: Counterexamples exist

The word every is contradicted by the stated routes.

4B · Short answer

Reject the overclaim using both supplied examples.

Example of a full-credit answer: Wind can turn a generator directly, and photovoltaic cells use light without boiling water.

  1. Uses the wind route as one counterexample.
  2. Uses photovoltaic conversion as the second.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Design a virtual system powered by flowing water. Include the device that turns and the device that produces electrical output, then the lamp.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Component order; Primary input

  • a: Moving water
  • b: Lamp → water → no source
  • c: Water → turbine → generator → lamp
  • d: New energy
Answer: Component order → Water → turbine → generator → lamp; Primary input → Moving water

A complete pathway names the input and conversion stages.

5B · Open ended

Propose the ordered pathway and include one additional output besides light.

Example of a full-credit answer: Flowing water turns a turbine, which drives a generator supplying the lamp. Some energy also transfers as heat or sound.

  1. Gives the correct source/turbine/generator/lamp order.
  2. Includes a plausible additional transfer without violating conservation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.11 · Household energy consumption

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Convert then multiply

Worked example information

A fictional device uses 200 W continuously for 3 h.

Question: What energy does it use?

Answer: 0.6 kWh.

Why: 200 W = 0.2 kW; 0.2 × 3 = 0.6 kWh.

Example 2 · Compare brief and long use

Worked example information

Fictional device A uses 2 kW for 0.25 h. Device B uses 0.15 kW for 6 h.

Question: Which uses more energy?

Answer: B uses 0.9 kWh, compared with A’s 0.5 kWh.

Why: A uses 2 × 0.25 = 0.5 kWh; B uses 0.15 × 6 = 0.9 kWh. The lower-power device runs much longer, so power alone does not rank total energy.

Example 3 · Add two devices
Fictional use
DevicePower (kW)Time (h)
Lamp0.12
Fan0.152

Worked example information

A model lamp uses 0.1 kW for 2 h; a fan uses 0.15 kW for 2 h.

Question: What is their combined use?

Answer: 0.5 kWh.

Why: 0.2 + 0.3 = 0.5 kWh.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Convert a label

Fixed question information

A classroom appliance label is 400 W. There are 1000 W in 1 kW.

F1 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Power: 0.4 kW.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

400/1000 = 0.4.

Scientific explorer: unit lab

F2 · Calculate a running interval

Fixed question information

A fictional device uses constant 0.3 kW for 4 h.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Energy; Running time

  • a: 1.2 kWh
  • b: 7 h
  • c: 4 h
  • d: 0.075 kWh
Answer: Energy → 1.2 kWh; Running time → 4 h

Multiply 0.3 × 4.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Compare identical devices

Fixed question information

Two identical 0.2 kW devices run for 2 h and 5 h.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Its energy: 1 kWh
  • b: Higher-use interval: 5 h
  • c: Its energy: 0.1 kWh
  • d: Higher-use interval: 2 h
Answer: Its energy: 1 kWh; Higher-use interval: 5 h

The longer run uses 0.2 × 5 = 1.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F4 · Use the watt definition

Fixed question information

A 10 W virtual lamp runs for 8 s at constant power. One W is one J/s. A separate fictional output record assigns 24 J to useful light and 56 J to thermal transfer over those 8 seconds.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Input energy; Power

  • a: 80 J
  • b: 8 W
  • c: 18 J
  • d: 10 W
Answer: Input energy → 80 J; Power → 10 W

10 × 8 = 80 J.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F5 · Explain a power comparison

Fixed question information

Device A uses 0.5 kW for 1 h. Device B uses 0.2 kW for 4 h. Both serve fictional classroom tasks.

F5 · Short answer

Which uses more energy? Calculate both values and explain why power alone would mislead.

Example of a full-credit answer: B uses 0.8 kWh versus A’s 0.5. B has lower power but runs longer.

  1. Calculates both 0.5 and 0.8 kWh.
  2. Uses duration to explain why B consumes more despite lower power.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fictional fan uses 0.1 kW for 6 h and a lamp 0.05 kW for 4 h.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Total energy; Fan energy

  • a: 0.6 kWh
  • b: 0.8 kWh
  • c: 0.15 kWh
  • d: 1.0 kWh
Answer: Total energy → 0.8 kWh; Fan energy → 0.6 kWh

0.1×6 + 0.05×4 = 0.8.

1B · Short answer

Find total use and show each contribution.

Example of a full-credit answer: Fan: 0.6 kWh; lamp: 0.2 kWh; total 0.8 kWh.

  1. Calculates both device contributions.
  2. Adds them correctly as 0.8 kWh.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Two fictional lamps provide the same required light. A uses 20 W and B 10 W. Each runs for 5 h. For the pathway explorer, this fictional model assigns 4 J of useful light per second to each lamp, with the remaining input transferred thermally. A watt is one joule per second.

2A · Multiple choice

Which uses less energy for the stated service?

  • a: A
  • b: Both use the same energy
  • c: B
  • d: The given power and time cannot be compared
Answer: B

B uses 0.01 × 5 = 0.05 kWh; A uses twice as much.

2B · Open ended

Choose a lamp and justify using equal service and calculated energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose B. It supplies the same required light and uses 0.05 kWh instead of A’s 0.1 kWh.

  1. Calculates/compares 0.05 versus 0.1 kWh.
  2. Uses the equal-lighting condition to make the comparison fair.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A device draws 0.6 kW only while running. In a 5 h period, it runs for 2 h and otherwise draws zero in this model.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Energy: 1.2 kWh.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Use active time: 0.6×2.

3B · Short answer

Calculate energy and explain why multiplying by all 5 h is wrong under the stated assumption.

Example of a full-credit answer: Energy is 1.2 kWh. The device draws running power for only 2 h and zero for the remaining 3 h.

  1. Calculates 1.2 kWh.
  2. Uses the stated active/inactive time condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A student uses 0.4 kW for 3 h but writes “1.2 kW/h” as energy.

4A · Hotspot

What is the correct energy unit and result?

  • a: 1.2 kWh
  • b: 1.2 kW/h
  • c: 1.2 kW
  • d: 1.2 Wh
Answer: 1.2 kWh

Energy uses the product of power and time.

4B · Open ended

Correct the unit and explain the operation that produces it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The answer is 1.2 kWh. Multiplying 0.4 kW by 3 h gives kilowatt-hours, not kilowatts per hour.

  1. Gives 1.2 kWh.
  2. Explains multiplication of units rather than division.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A fictional 0.1 kW task light is required for exactly 3 h, but its old schedule runs 6 h. Keep the required 3 h of lighting.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Time interval to retain; Time interval to remove

  • a: The three unnecessary hours
  • b: The three required hours
  • c: All required lighting
  • d: The complete six-hour schedule
Answer: Time interval to retain → The three required hours; Time interval to remove → The three unnecessary hours

Three unnecessary hours can be removed while retaining the task.

5B · Open ended

Propose a schedule that meets the need and calculate its saving compared with the old schedule.

Example of a full-credit answer: Run it during the required 3 h and switch it off for the other 3. Use falls from 0.6 to 0.3 kWh, saving 0.3 kWh.

  1. Preserves all required lighting while removing unnecessary runtime.
  2. Correctly computes the 0.3 kWh saving.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S3.12 · Environmental effects of energy production

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Operating emissions are only one stage
Two parts of a toy lifecycle account
PartIndex units
Operation2
Other included stages5

Worked example information

A fictional device has 2 index units during operation and 5 from the other included lifecycle stages.

Question: What is the total for the stated account?

Answer: 7 index units.

Why: 2 + 5 = 7. Reporting only two would omit the other included stages.

Example 2 · A quieter boundary

Worked example information

Under the same measurement method and time, a virtual sound barrier reduces a generator’s boundary sound level. No water or air-emission measurements are supplied.

Question: Which conclusion stays within the record?

Answer: The measured boundary sound level decreased under those conditions.

Why: The sound result does not establish an improvement in unmeasured water or air outcomes.

Example 3 · Equal service reveals a trade-off

Worked example information

Two virtual systems each deliver 10 useful energy units. A uses 4 water units and has an air index of 7; B uses 6 water units and has an air index of 3.

Question: Does either system have the lower value on both measures?

Answer: No. A uses less water; B has the lower air index.

Why: The decision needs stated priorities and evidence for both effects, not a claim that one number settles everything.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Normalise an emissions index

Fixed question information

A fictional electricity model supplies 4 electrical energy units and records 8 emissions-index units. The comparison rate is index units divided by electrical output.

F1 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Index per electrical output unit: 1.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

8 divided by 4 gives 2 index units per electrical output unit.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Include the stated lifecycle stages

Fixed question information

A toy lifecycle inventory lists operation=2, equipment making=4, fuel transport=3 and end-of-use handling=1 index units for the same service. No listed stage may be omitted.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Total across all four listed stages; Operation-only value

  • a: 2 index units
  • b: 8 index units
  • c: 6 index units
  • d: 10 index units
Answer: Total across all four listed stages → 10 index units; Operation-only value → 2 index units

The listed total is 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 = 10; operation alone is two.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Match a project to a local effect

Fixed question information

A river-energy barrier blocks a documented fish-migration route. Separately, a solar-panel factory obtains mined material. These are different records of effects at different stages.

F3 · Hotspot

Which recorded effect belongs to the river barrier?

  • a: Material extraction
  • b: Traffic noise at an unstudied road
  • c: A change in classroom light colour
  • d: Fish-migration obstruction
Answer: Fish-migration obstruction

Fish-route obstruction is the stated river effect; material extraction belongs to the panel-supply record.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Match measurements to questions

Fixed question information

The class records a carbon-dioxide mass per electrical output unit and a cooling-water outlet-minus-inlet temperature difference. Neither is a measure of a logo’s colour or advertisement count.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Carbon-dioxide comparison measure; Cooling-water thermal measure

  • a: Outlet-minus-inlet temperature difference
  • b: Logo colour
  • c: Mass per electrical output unit
  • d: Advertisement count
Answer: Carbon-dioxide comparison measure → Mass per electrical output unit; Cooling-water thermal measure → Outlet-minus-inlet temperature difference

The first measure is gas mass per service; the second is a temperature difference.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A warmer-water record has limits

Fixed question information

A virtual stream record gives 22°C immediately upstream of an outlet and 28°C downstream during one interval. No counts, survival records or other biological measurements are supplied.

F5 · Open ended

State the measured temperature change and explain what extra evidence would be needed before claiming that fish died because of it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Downstream is 6°C warmer in this record. A fish-death claim would need biological observations and a suitable repeated/comparison design that examines other conditions, not temperature readings alone.

  1. Calculates or identifies the 6°C downstream temperature increase.
  2. Requests relevant biological and causal-comparison evidence before asserting fish death from the change.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

For the same electricity service, virtual system A has an operating index of 2 plus an other-lifecycle-stage index of 8. B has an operating index of 6 plus an other-stage index of 1. These are the complete categories of this toy index account.

1A · True or false

True or false: the two systems have equal total lifecycle-index values for the stated electricity service.

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

A totals 10 and B totals 7. A has the lower operating value but the higher total in the given account.

1B · Open ended

Calculate both totals and state a conclusion limited to what this index measures.

Example of a full-credit answer: A is 2+8=10 and B is 6+1=7, so B has the lower listed lifecycle index for equal service. This does not establish that B also has every lower water, habitat or other environmental effect.

  1. Calculates and compares 10 versus 7 correctly.
  2. Limits the conclusion to the supplied index and service rather than all environmental outcomes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Two fictional solar proposals each supply 6 energy units over the stated interval. A uses an existing suitable roof and clears no new habitat. B clears 2 hectares of the stated habitat. Their other effects have not been compared.

2A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Lower new habitat-clearing option; Option clearing 2 hectares

  • a: Neither gives energy
  • b: Both clear 2 hectares
  • c: Site B
  • d: Site A
Answer: Lower new habitat-clearing option → Site A; Option clearing 2 hectares → Site B

A gives the same stated service with less new clearing; the record does not compare every other effect.

2B · Short answer

Justify a preference for A for the land-clearing goal and state the scope of that preference.

Example of a full-credit answer: A supplies the same 6 units without the 2 hectares of new clearing. This supports A on the stated land goal; materials, other habitat effects and other lifecycle outcomes still need their own evidence.

  1. Uses equal output and less new clearing to justify A.
  2. Recognises that the preference is limited to the stated land measure.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A virtual exhaust control changes a particle index from 10 to 2. The carbon-dioxide index remains 20 before and after. Output is kept equal. Particles and carbon dioxide are separately measured.

3A · Multiple choice

Which measured index decreased?

  • a: Both indices
  • b: Carbon-dioxide index
  • c: Neither index
  • d: Particle index
Answer: Particle index

The particle measure fell; the carbon-dioxide measure stayed at twenty. One control’s effect must not be assumed for another substance.

3B · Open ended

Explain what improved and why the record does not establish reduced carbon-dioxide emissions.

Example of a full-credit answer: The particle index fell from 10 to 2. Carbon dioxide remained at 20 for equal output, so this record gives no carbon-dioxide reduction from that control.

  1. Identifies the measured particle reduction.
  2. Uses the unchanged carbon-dioxide record to reject an unsupported reduction claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A wind project does not burn fuel in its generator during operation. Its supplied site record nevertheless documents clearing vegetation for an access road. A learner claims the renewable label proves zero environmental effect at every stage.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Documented local environmental change: No vegetation was cleared
  • b: Fuel burned at this generator during operation: Coal is burned in the generator
  • c: Fuel burned at this generator during operation: None in the supplied record
  • d: Documented local environmental change: Vegetation clearing for a road
Answer: Fuel burned at this generator during operation: None in the supplied record; Documented local environmental change: Vegetation clearing for a road

The source supports no operating fuel burn and also documents road clearing; the renewable label does not cancel that local effect.

4B · Short answer

Correct the learner’s claim using both the operating fact and the road record.

Example of a full-credit answer: The generator’s operation does not burn fuel here, but constructing its access road cleared vegetation. Renewable describes the source; impacts must still be assessed at the relevant places and stages.

  1. Preserves the supported no-operating-fuel-burn fact.
  2. Uses the documented clearing or lifecycle distinction to reject zero impact everywhere.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

Compare two virtual electricity systems at the same 8-unit output. For each, measure a carbon-dioxide index and the outlet-minus-inlet cooling-water temperature difference. Keep the inlet temperature and observation interval equal.

5A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required equal service; Physical cooling-water measure

  • a: 8 electrical output units
  • b: Outlet-minus-inlet temperature difference
  • c: Equipment logo colour
  • d: The number of advertisements
Answer: Required equal service → 8 electrical output units; Physical cooling-water measure → Outlet-minus-inlet temperature difference

Equal output makes the service comparable. Water-temperature rise and the carbon-dioxide index answer different environmental questions.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison that records both effects, and explain how a trade-off would be reported.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use the same output, inlet temperature and interval, and repeat the two measurements for each system. If one lowers the carbon index but raises water-temperature change, report both instead of claiming it improves every effect.

  1. Includes both relevant measurements under comparable output and conditions.
  2. Explains how to report a possible opposing change or limit rather than hide a trade-off.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.1 · Light

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Reading a card

Worked example information

In a dark model box, a white card receives no light. Turning on a lamp sends light to the card and then to an eye detector.

Question: Why does the detector see the card after the lamp is on?

Answer: The card reflects some lamp light into the detector.

Why: The card need not produce its own light; the path includes source, reflecting object and receiver.

Example 2 · Screen account
Fixed energy shares
PathUnits
Reflected15
Absorbed25
Transmitted60

Worked example information

A fictional clear screen receives 100 light-energy units: 15 reflect and 25 are absorbed.

Question: How many units are transmitted?

Answer: 60 units pass through.

Why: 100 − 15 − 25 = 60. Reflection, absorption and transmission account for the input.

Example 3 · A vacuum comparison

Worked example information

A model chamber can contain air or be empty. A lamp and detector remain connected by an unobstructed path.

Question: Must removing the air stop the light?

Answer: No; light can cross the vacuum.

Why: Air particles are not required to carry electromagnetic waves. This differs from sound.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Object and source

Fixed question information

A model lamp emits light. A plain notebook reflects lamp light. A camera receives the reflected light.

F1 · Hotspot

Which object emits the light used in this viewing path?

  • a: Notebook
  • b: Camera
  • c: Lamp
  • d: Empty shelf
Answer: Lamp

The lamp emits; the notebook redirects some light to the camera.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Window pathways

Fixed question information

A fictional panel receives 100 units: 30 reflect, 20 absorb, and the rest pass through.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Transmission; Absorption

  • a: 20 units
  • b: 50 units
  • c: 70 units
  • d: 80 units
Answer: Transmission → 50 units; Absorption → 20 units

100 − 30 − 20 = 50 transmitted units.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F3 · Space message

Fixed question information

A lamp sends a light signal across a vacuum to a detector. The path contains no obstacle.

F3 · Multiple choice

Does this light signal need air in the gap?

  • a: Yes; light always needs air.
  • b: It needs liquid water instead of air.
  • c: It can cross only if sound travels with it.
  • d: No; light can cross a vacuum.
Answer: No; light can cross a vacuum.

Light is electromagnetic and can propagate without a material medium.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F4 · Reflecting ray

Fixed question information

A virtual mirror has an incoming light ray at 35° to the normal. The normal is perpendicular to the mirror.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Reflected angle: 35°
  • b: Angle reference: Normal
  • c: Angle reference: Mirror surface
  • d: Reflected angle: 55°
Answer: Reflected angle: 35°; Angle reference: Normal

Reflection uses equal incident and reflected angles measured from the normal.

Scientific explorer: optics lab

F5 · Explain a shadow

Fixed question information

An opaque model card is between a small lamp and a screen. Much less light reaches the screen area directly behind the card.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the opaque card can make a shadow, then name one position you could change and the positions you would keep fixed in a fair comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: The card blocks light travelling to part of the screen. Move the card while keeping the lamp and screen fixed.

  1. Explains the shadow as reduced light reaching the screen because of the card.
  2. Names a relevant source/card/screen position to vary while holding the others fixed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fictional label cover receives 100 light units: 10 reflect, 15 absorb, and the rest transmit. A visitor needs transmitted light to see the label.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Transmission; Other pathways combined

  • a: 25 units
  • b: 75 units
  • c: 90 units
  • d: 115 units
Answer: Transmission → 75 units; Other pathways combined → 25 units

The two other shares total 25, leaving 75.

1B · Short answer

Calculate transmitted units and explain why absorbed units are still part of the energy account.

Example of a full-credit answer: 100 − 10 − 15 = 75 transmit. Absorbed energy transfers to the cover.

  1. Correctly calculates 75 transmitted units.
  2. Explains that absorption transfers energy to the material rather than destroying it.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

At the same visible wavelength and thickness, cover A transmits 80 of 100 units and B transmits 30. Their other properties are not compared.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Chosen cover; Evidence for A

  • a: A
  • b: 30 transmitted units
  • c: B
  • d: 80 transmitted units
Answer: Chosen cover → A; Evidence for A → 80 transmitted units

A transmits the larger measured amount under the stated conditions.

2B · Open ended

Choose a cover for transmitting more visible light and give a limit of this comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because 80 exceeds 30. These results do not compare strength or other wavelengths.

  1. Chooses A supported by the 80 versus 30 transmission evidence.
  2. States a valid limit such as untested strength, thicknesses or wavelengths.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A spacecraft sends a light pulse through a vacuum to another craft. Neither craft needs air in the space between them.

3A · Hotspot

Which statement explains the light link between the spacecraft?

  • a: Light always requires water.
  • b: The empty gap creates the signal.
  • c: Air must fill all the space between craft.
  • d: Light can cross a vacuum.
Answer: Light can cross a vacuum.

Light does not require a material medium.

3B · Short answer

Explain why a light signal can cross this gap and why an ordinary sound signal cannot cross the same empty gap.

Example of a full-credit answer: Light is electromagnetic and can cross a vacuum. Sound needs matter to carry its disturbance.

  1. Explains that light can propagate through vacuum.
  2. Contrasts sound as requiring a material medium.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner draws eye → book and says eyes send out light so the book becomes visible. In this model the only emitting object is the desk lamp.

4A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Emitter: Book creates all light.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

A valid viewing path goes lamp → book → eye.

4B · Open ended

Identify the error and replace it with the complete light path.

Example of a full-credit answer: Eyes are receivers here, not emitters. Light goes from lamp to book and reflects into the eye.

  1. Rejects the claim that eyes emit the light responsible for seeing this book.
  2. Gives lamp → book → eye with reflection at the book.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual window test can change panel material and lamp brightness. The goal is to compare two materials for visible-light transmission. A detector measures transmitted units.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Changed factor: Lamp brightness in every trial
  • b: Measured outcome: Student favourite colour
  • c: Measured outcome: Transmitted units
  • d: Changed factor: Panel material
Answer: Measured outcome: Transmitted units; Changed factor: Panel material

Change material while holding thickness, light and detector arrangement fixed.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair two-material test and state the measurement you would compare.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use equal-thickness panels with the same lamp, wavelength and detector positions. Compare transmitted units for each panel.

  1. Changes only material while controlling relevant thickness/light/geometry conditions.
  2. Measures and compares transmitted light for both panels.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.2 · Sound

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Pitch chart
Two tones
ToneFrequency (cycles/s)
A150
B300

Worked example information

Model tone A has frequency 150 cycles/s and B has 300 cycles/s. Their amplitudes are equal.

Question: Which tone has the higher pitch?

Answer: Tone B has the higher pitch.

Why: B vibrates more times each second. Equal amplitude keeps the comparison focused on frequency.

Example 2 · Changing amplitude

Worked example information

A virtual tone keeps frequency fixed at 250 cycles/s while its amplitude increases.

Question: What changes most directly: pitch or loudness?

Answer: Loudness increases under the same listening conditions; pitch stays associated with the unchanged frequency.

Why: Amplitude and frequency are different properties; one can change without the other.

Example 3 · A returned pulse

Worked example information

A classroom sound model uses speed 10 distance-units/s. A reflecting wall is 15 units away.

Question: How long does the there-and-back journey take?

Answer: 3 seconds.

Why: The sound travels 15 + 15 = 30 units, so time = 30 ÷ 10. This is a scaled model, not real air speed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Two pitches

Fixed question information

Virtual tone A has frequency 2 cycles/s and B has 4 cycles/s in a slowed classroom model. Both amplitudes are 2 units.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which model tone has the higher frequency and therefore the higher pitch-related setting?

  • a: A
  • b: Both have the same frequency.
  • c: Neither has a frequency.
  • d: B
Answer: B

B has more cycles each second; the simulation is deliberately slowed.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F2 · A medium is needed

Fixed question information

A fictional chamber contains a sound source and receiver. One trial contains air and another is a perfect vacuum.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Sound-carrying trial: Air-filled
  • b: Missing requirement in vacuum: Coloured light
  • c: Sound-carrying trial: Vacuum-only
  • d: Missing requirement in vacuum: Material medium
Answer: Sound-carrying trial: Air-filled; Missing requirement in vacuum: Material medium

Sound requires matter between source and receiver.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Independent properties

Fixed question information

A fixed model records frequency 3 cycles/s in both trials. Amplitude is 1 unit in A and 3 in B.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Recorded property that changed; Recorded property that stayed the same

  • a: Frequency
  • b: Both amplitude and frequency
  • c: Amplitude
  • d: Neither recorded property
Answer: Recorded property that changed → Amplitude; Recorded property that stayed the same → Frequency

The source states equal frequency and different amplitudes.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Reflected signal

Fixed question information

Three identical virtual sound pulses hit equal panels. The model reflected-energy totals are A: 30, B: 10, C: 20 units.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Least reflection; Reflection from B

  • a: 10 units
  • b: A
  • c: B
  • d: 30 units
Answer: Least reflection → B; Reflection from B → 10 units

Ten is the lowest reflected amount; this alone does not measure every pathway.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain the moving pattern

Fixed question information

A sound wave travels along a row of air particles in a model. Each particle moves back and forth near its own position.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what travels through the row and describe how an individual particle moves.

Example of a full-credit answer: The sound disturbance transfers energy along the row. A particle moves back and forth near its own position.

  1. Identifies the sound disturbance/energy as travelling through the medium.
  2. Describes local back-and-forth particle motion rather than one-way travel with the wave.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A scaled classroom model has sound speed 8 distance-units/s and a wall 12 units from the source. A pulse returns to the source after reflecting.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Round-trip distance; Return time

  • a: 1.5 s
  • b: 24 units
  • c: 12 units
  • d: 3 s
Answer: Round-trip distance → 24 units; Return time → 3 s

The pulse travels to the wall and back: 24 ÷ 8 = 3 s.

1B · Open ended

Find the return time and explain why the distance is doubled.

Example of a full-credit answer: Time is 3 s because the pulse travels 12 units outward and 12 back, for 24 units.

  1. Calculates 3 s using 24 ÷ 8.
  2. Explains the outward and returning legs, not just the one-way distance.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Two virtual tones will test whether frequency affects pitch. Tone A uses frequency 2 and amplitude 2; B uses frequency 4 and amplitude 2 in scaled units.

2A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changed property; Controlled property

  • a: Amplitude
  • b: Both amplitude and frequency
  • c: Room material
  • d: Frequency
Answer: Changed property → Frequency; Controlled property → Amplitude

The tones differ in frequency while amplitude is fixed.

2B · Short answer

Explain why this is a fair pitch comparison and predict which tone has higher pitch.

Example of a full-credit answer: Amplitude and other listening conditions stay fixed while frequency changes. B has the higher pitch because its frequency is larger.

  1. Identifies frequency as changed with amplitude/conditions controlled.
  2. Predicts B has higher pitch and links this to greater frequency.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A virtual underwater detector receives a sound pulse through water. A second identical gap contains a perfect vacuum.

3A · Hotspot

Which gap can carry this ordinary sound pulse?

  • a: The perfect-vacuum gap.
  • b: Both gaps equally without a medium.
  • c: Neither gap because sound cannot cross water.
  • d: The water-filled gap.
Answer: The water-filled gap.

Sound travels through water but requires matter.

3B · Open ended

Explain the underwater result and predict the vacuum result with a reason.

Example of a full-credit answer: Water particles transmit the disturbance, so sound can arrive. The vacuum has no material to carry the sound.

  1. Explains that water is a material medium for sound.
  2. Predicts no ordinary sound across the vacuum because matter is absent.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says, “Tripling amplitude always triples pitch.” The model frequency remains 3 cycles/s before and after the amplitude change.

4A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Fixed property: Frequency.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Frequency is unchanged; amplitude affects loudness under the same conditions.

4B · Short answer

Identify the mistaken link and describe the expected pitch and loudness changes under equal conditions.

Example of a full-credit answer: Amplitude does not set pitch. Pitch stays associated with the same frequency, while larger amplitude generally increases loudness.

  1. Rejects amplitude increase as automatically increasing pitch and notes unchanged frequency/pitch.
  2. Links the larger amplitude to greater loudness under otherwise similar conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual room test compares panels P and Q. A detector measures reflected sound-energy units after equal pulses at one chosen frequency. For this decision rule, a panel is preferred when it reflects fewer sound units under matched conditions; identify what would support choosing P.

5A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Supporting result; Important control

  • a: P reflects fewer units than Q
  • b: Different pulse energy every trial
  • c: P has a nicer label
  • d: Same source frequency
Answer: Supporting result → P reflects fewer units than Q; Important control → Same source frequency

Compare reflected units under equal sound and geometry conditions.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison and explain what result would support the lower-reflection choice.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use equal-size panels at the same positions with equal pulses and frequency. Repeat readings; choose the panel with consistently fewer reflected units in this test.

  1. Specifies relevant controls for panel size, pulse/frequency or geometry.
  2. Compares measured reflected sound, preferably repeated, and selects the smaller result within tested conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.3 · Radio waves

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Spacecraft signal

Worked example information

A model spacecraft sends a radio pulse across empty space to an antenna. The antenna produces an electrical signal.

Question: Why can the first part of this path work without air?

Answer: Radio waves are electromagnetic and can cross a vacuum.

Why: The antenna later converts the received signal; no sound wave is required across the empty gap.

Example 2 · Two bands, one panel
Panel transmission
BandTransmitted units
Radio75
Visible10

Worked example information

A fictional panel receives 100 energy units in separate tests. It transmits 75 radio units and 10 visible-light units.

Question: Does low visible transmission prove low radio transmission?

Answer: No; this panel transmits much more of the tested radio band.

Why: Interaction depends on wavelength as well as material. The two measured shares differ.

Example 3 · Scaled wavelength

Worked example information

A classroom radio-wave drawing has speed 12 units/s and frequency 4 cycles/s.

Question: What wavelength belongs to this drawing?

Answer: 3 distance units.

Why: Wavelength = speed ÷ frequency = 12 ÷ 4. These are scaled teaching values, not an actual radio speed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Trace the receiver

Fixed question information

A model communication chain is transmitter → radio wave across space → antenna → electrical signal → speaker sound.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Across-space carrier; Speaker output

  • a: Visible ink
  • b: Radio wave
  • c: Air carried from the transmitter
  • d: Sound
Answer: Across-space carrier → Radio wave; Speaker output → Sound

The radio path and final sound are different parts of the chain.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Panel radio account

Fixed question information

A fictional radio-band panel receives 100 units, absorbs 15 and reflects 25.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Transmitted; Absorbed

  • a: 15 units
  • b: 140 units
  • c: 60 units
  • d: 85 units
Answer: Transmitted → 60 units; Absorbed → 15 units

Transmission is 100 − 15 − 25 = 60.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F3 · Scaled radio spacing

Fixed question information

In a scaled wave drawing the speed is 12 distance-units/s and frequency is 3 cycles/s.

F3 · Hotspot

What is the wavelength in this scaled drawing?

  • a: 3 units
  • b: 9 units
  • c: 4 units
  • d: 36 units
Answer: 4 units

Twelve divided by three gives four distance units per cycle.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F4 · Receiver threshold

Fixed question information

A fictional receiver needs at least 30 signal units. Fixed measured values are path A: 45 and path B: 20.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Working path; Threshold

  • a: 20 units
  • b: 30 units
  • c: A
  • d: B
Answer: Working path → A; Threshold → 30 units

Forty-five is at least thirty; twenty is below the threshold.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a space call

Fixed question information

An astronaut’s microphone turns voice vibrations into an electrical signal; a transmitter encodes that signal onto radio waves. The radio crosses a vacuum.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the radio crosses the vacuum and name one conversion needed for the original voice message.

Example of a full-credit answer: Radio is electromagnetic and needs no air. The microphone converts voice vibrations into an electrical signal that can be encoded for transmission.

  1. States radio can cross vacuum as electromagnetic radiation.
  2. Describes a valid microphone/transmitter/receiver conversion linking voice to the radio message.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A classroom radio screen receives 100 units: 35 reflect, 20 absorb and the remainder transmit. The model receiver requires at least 40 transmitted units.

1A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Receiver threshold: 40 units
  • b: Transmission: 55 units
  • c: Transmission: 45 units
  • d: Receiver threshold: 35 units
Answer: Receiver threshold: 40 units; Transmission: 45 units

Forty-five transmit, which exceeds the required forty.

1B · Short answer

Calculate transmission and decide whether the stated receiver requirement is met.

Example of a full-credit answer: 100 − 35 − 20 = 45 transmit, so the 40-unit requirement is met.

  1. Calculates 45 transmitted units.
  2. Compares 45 with 40 and correctly concludes that the requirement is met.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A test compares frequencies A and B through the same panel. Each input is 100 units; received values are A: 70, B: 40. The goal is larger received signal through this panel.

2A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Chosen setting: B.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

A gives the larger measured signal for this panel and setup.

2B · Open ended

Justify the setting and name one condition that limits generalising the choice.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because 70 exceeds 40 with equal input. Another panel, distance or arrangement might behave differently.

  1. Chooses A using the equal-input 70 versus 40 evidence.
  2. Identifies an untested material, distance or other condition as a limit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A scaled drawing compares two electromagnetic waves in a vacuum at the same speed. Wave X has frequency 2 units and Y has frequency 4 units.

3A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Shorter wavelength; Shared condition

  • a: Same speed
  • b: X
  • c: Y
  • d: Y has twice the speed
Answer: Shorter wavelength → Y; Shared condition → Same speed

At equal speed, greater frequency means shorter wavelength.

3B · Short answer

Compare the wavelengths of X and Y, stating the factor between them, and explain why increasing frequency at the same speed changes wavelength.

Example of a full-credit answer: Y has half X’s wavelength because frequency doubles while speed stays fixed. Both obey speed = frequency × wavelength.

  1. States Y has the shorter wavelength, specifically half for these values.
  2. Explains the fixed-speed frequency–wavelength trade-off instead of claiming a speed increase.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A poster says, “Wireless radios send ordinary sound through a vacuum.” A diagram shows radio waves between two antennas.

4A · Multiple choice

What wave travels between the antennas in the corrected explanation?

  • a: Ordinary sound waves.
  • b: Water waves in empty space.
  • c: Seismic waves.
  • d: Electromagnetic radio waves.
Answer: Electromagnetic radio waves.

Radio crosses the gap; speaker vibrations make sound after reception.

4B · Open ended

Identify the incorrect wave claim and explain where sound can be produced in the receiving system.

Example of a full-credit answer: The gap carries electromagnetic radio, not ordinary sound. A receiving speaker vibrates the nearby air to produce sound.

  1. Corrects the gap carrier to radio/electromagnetic waves.
  2. Explains local production of sound by a speaker vibrating a material medium.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual radio tester can change the panel and input signal. It reports received units. The goal is to compare panels P and Q fairly at one frequency.

5A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Outcome; Controlled factor

  • a: Received radio units
  • b: Input frequency
  • c: Different input power each time
  • d: Favourite station name
Answer: Outcome → Received radio units; Controlled factor → Input frequency

Received signal under equal input conditions supports a fair comparison.

5B · Open ended

Propose controlled trials for P and Q and explain the decision rule for better transmission.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep frequency, input energy, distance and panel thickness equal. Repeat each panel test and choose the one with more received units under these conditions.

  1. Specifies relevant equal input and setup controls while changing the panel.
  2. Compares received measurements and bases the choice on greater transmission.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.4 · Electromagnetic radiation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Arrange three bands
Relative order
BandWavelength order
RadioLonger
VisibleMiddle of these three
X-rayShorter

Worked example information

The supplied wavelength order is radio longer than visible, and visible longer than X-rays.

Question: Which listed band has the shortest wavelength?

Answer: X-rays.

Why: The order compares wavelength, not wave speed in vacuum.

Example 2 · Equal vacuum speed

Worked example information

Two electromagnetic waves travel in a vacuum. Their frequencies are f and 2f.

Question: How do their wavelengths compare?

Answer: The wave with frequency 2f has half the wavelength.

Why: Both have the same speed and speed = frequency × wavelength.

Example 3 · Choose a measurement

Worked example information

A fictional instrument detects infrared radiation but does not measure visible colour.

Question: Can its display alone identify the object’s visible paint colour?

Answer: No. A visible-light measurement is also needed.

Why: Instrument sensitivity limits what a reading establishes; a coloured display may encode infrared data.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Spectrum family

Fixed question information

A card lists radio, visible light and sound. Radio and visible light are electromagnetic; sound is a mechanical wave.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which listed invisible wave is electromagnetic?

  • a: Sound in air
  • b: Radio
  • c: Sound in water
  • d: Seismic waves
Answer: Radio

Radio belongs to the electromagnetic family; sound requires a material medium.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F2 · Wavelength order

Fixed question information

For this question, bands are ordered from longer to shorter wavelength: radio, infrared, visible, ultraviolet.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Shortest listed; Longest listed

  • a: Radio
  • b: Visible
  • c: Infrared
  • d: Ultraviolet
Answer: Shortest listed → Ultraviolet; Longest listed → Radio

The supplied order places ultraviolet last and radio first.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Infrared film

Fixed question information

A fictional film receives 100 infrared units, reflects 10 and absorbs 70.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Transmitted: 90 units.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

100 − 10 − 70 = 20 transmitted infrared units.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F4 · Instrument limits

Fixed question information

Detector A records visible light only. Detector B records a chosen infrared band only. The task is measuring that infrared band.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Appropriate detector; Target band

  • a: B
  • b: Sound
  • c: Infrared
  • d: A
Answer: Appropriate detector → B; Target band → Infrared

B responds to the radiation specified by the task.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Invisible is not absent

Fixed question information

A fictional sensor registers radio radiation in a dark box. Human eyes see no visible light in it.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why darkness does not contradict the radio reading and name the relevant limit of human sight.

Example of a full-credit answer: Radio can be present without visible light. Human eyes detect only the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum.

  1. States that invisible radio radiation can be present in the dark box.
  2. Explains that human vision does not detect all electromagnetic bands.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A classroom electromagnetic drawing uses speed 12 units/s. Wave A has frequency 2 cycles/s; wave B has frequency 6 cycles/s.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: B wavelength; A wavelength

  • a: 6 units
  • b: 12 units
  • c: 2 units
  • d: 72 units
Answer: B wavelength → 2 units; A wavelength → 6 units

Wavelengths are 12 ÷ 6 = 2 and 12 ÷ 2 = 6.

1B · Open ended

Calculate B’s wavelength and explain why it is shorter than A’s at the same speed.

Example of a full-credit answer: B has wavelength 2 units. Its frequency is higher while speed is fixed, so each repeating cycle occupies less distance.

  1. Calculates B wavelength as 2 units.
  2. Explains the inverse frequency–wavelength relationship at fixed speed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

For equal input and thickness, screens P and Q transmit respectively 10 and 60 units of the tested ultraviolet band. The design goal is less transmission of that band; no exposure-safety claim is requested.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Selected screen; P transmission

  • a: Q
  • b: P
  • c: 60 units
  • d: 10 units
Answer: Selected screen → P; P transmission → 10 units

P has lower measured transmission for the chosen band.

2B · Short answer

Justify P or Q for the stated goal and explain one limit of this evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: P transmits fewer ultraviolet units: 10 versus 60. It does not establish performance in every other band or make a complete safety assessment.

  1. Chooses P using its smaller measured transmission.
  2. States a valid scope limit such as other bands, conditions or complete safety assessment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A spacecraft detector measures X-rays from a distant source across a near-vacuum. X-rays belong to the electromagnetic spectrum.

3A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Detected band: Ordinary sound
  • b: Reason: Electromagnetic waves can cross vacuum
  • c: Reason: X-rays are sound
  • d: Detected band: X-ray
Answer: Reason: Electromagnetic waves can cross vacuum; Detected band: X-ray

X-rays share the electromagnetic ability to cross vacuum.

3B · Open ended

Explain why air is not needed and why a normal visible camera is not automatically the correct detector.

Example of a full-credit answer: X-rays are electromagnetic and can cross vacuum. A detector must respond to X-rays; a visible-only camera responds to a different band.

  1. Explains vacuum propagation for electromagnetic X-rays.
  2. Links detector choice to the required radiation band.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner claims ultraviolet travels faster than radio in vacuum because ultraviolet has higher frequency. Both are electromagnetic waves in the same vacuum.

4A · Hotspot

What is the correct speed comparison in vacuum?

  • a: Ultraviolet is faster than radio.
  • b: Radio is faster than ultraviolet.
  • c: Radio and ultraviolet have equal speeds.
  • d: Neither radio nor ultraviolet can travel.
Answer: Radio and ultraviolet have equal speeds.

Frequency changes are accompanied by wavelength changes, not different vacuum speeds.

4B · Short answer

Correct the speed claim and explain how wavelength differs for the higher-frequency wave.

Example of a full-credit answer: Their vacuum speeds are equal. Ultraviolet’s higher frequency corresponds to shorter wavelength.

  1. States equal electromagnetic wave speeds in vacuum.
  2. Explains that higher frequency corresponds to shorter wavelength at this speed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual material test can measure transmitted units for visible and infrared radiation. Each trial starts with 100 units and the same panel thickness.

5A · Multiple choice

Which category must identify whether a trial uses visible or infrared radiation?

  • a: Panel serial number
  • b: Detector distance
  • c: Panel thickness
  • d: Radiation band
Answer: Radiation band

Band and equal test conditions allow a meaningful comparison.

5B · Open ended

Design a table or test with both bands and explain what differing results would show.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use rows for visible and infrared with the same 100-unit input and thickness; record transmitted units. Different shares show the panel interacts differently with the tested bands.

  1. Includes both named bands with equal input and relevant material conditions.
  2. Interprets different transmission results as band-dependent interaction, without claiming all bands behave alike.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.5 · Seismic waves

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read the gap
Model arrivals
WaveTime (s)
P6
S10

Worked example information

A fictional station records the P arrival at 6 s and the S arrival at 10 s after a model release.

Question: What is the P–S arrival gap?

Answer: 4 seconds.

Why: 10 − 6 = 4. The gap compares arrivals at the same station.

Example 2 · A liquid layer

Worked example information

A diagram sends idealised P and S body waves toward a liquid layer. The given rule is that P can pass through liquid but S cannot propagate through it.

Question: Which wave can continue as the same type through the liquid?

Answer: P can; S cannot travel through the liquid as an S wave.

Why: The two waves depend on different material responses. Real boundaries can also reflect and convert waves.

Example 3 · Particle versus wave

Worked example information

In a model, a disturbance crosses 20 distance units. A marked rock particle oscillates only a small distance around its starting position.

Question: Must the marked particle travel all 20 units?

Answer: No; its local motion passes the disturbance onward.

Why: The propagation of a mechanical wave differs from transporting all the material with it.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · First arrival

Fixed question information

In a fictional solid-path model, P travels faster than S along the same route from one simultaneous release.

F1 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: First arrival; Later arrival

  • a: Neither wave needs material
  • b: S
  • c: Both must always arrive together
  • d: P
Answer: First arrival → P; Later arrival → S

The faster P wave covers the common route sooner.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F2 · Read a station

Fixed question information

A fictional record lists P arrival at 4 s and S arrival at 7 s.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Time gap; P arrival

  • a: 3 s
  • b: 11 s
  • c: 4 s
  • d: 7 s
Answer: Time gap → 3 s; P arrival → 4 s

7 − 4 = 3 s is the gap.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Liquid crossing

Fixed question information

A source card states P waves can travel through solids and liquids; S waves can travel through solids but not liquids.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Blocked wave type: Both always pass
  • b: Blocked wave type: S
  • c: Wave able to pass liquid: P
  • d: Wave able to pass liquid: Both are electromagnetic
Answer: Blocked wave type: S; Wave able to pass liquid: P

An S wave requires shear response that a liquid does not provide.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Ground motion evidence

Fixed question information

A virtual station records a ground-motion disturbance after a model release. The activity supplies no rule for when the next earthquake will occur.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Supported observation; Unsupported next-event timing claim

  • a: A disturbance was recorded
  • b: No disturbance was recorded
  • c: Exact next-earthquake date
  • d: Earth contains no liquids
Answer: Supported observation → A disturbance was recorded; Unsupported next-event timing claim → Exact next-earthquake date

A recorded event does not establish an exact future prediction.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain travelling shaking

Fixed question information

In a virtual rock row, each marked point oscillates around its place while the wave pattern moves from left to right.

F5 · Short answer

Explain what travels along the row and what happens to a marked piece of rock.

Example of a full-credit answer: The seismic disturbance transfers energy along the row. The marked rock oscillates locally rather than travelling the whole wave path.

  1. Describes the wave disturbance/energy moving through the material.
  2. Describes local rock motion rather than bulk transport along the entire path.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A simplified model route is 24 distance units. P speed is 6 units/s and S speed is 4 units/s; both start together and keep those speeds.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: P travel time; S travel time

  • a: 6 s
  • b: 4 s
  • c: 10 s
  • d: 2 s
Answer: P travel time → 4 s; S travel time → 6 s

Travel time is distance ÷ speed: 24/6 = 4 and 24/4 = 6.

1B · Short answer

Calculate both arrival times and explain which arrives first.

Example of a full-credit answer: P takes 4 s and S takes 6 s. P arrives first because it is faster over the same distance.

  1. Calculates the pair 4 s for P and 6 s for S.
  2. Explains P arrives first using its larger speed over the equal route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Under one fixed classroom travel model, station A has a P–S gap of 2 s and B has a gap of 5 s. In this model a larger gap means a longer source-to-station route.

2A · Hotspot

Which route is longer under the supplied arrival-gap rule?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Both routes are equal.
  • d: Neither route has any length.
Answer: B

The supplied model connects the greater gap with the longer route.

2B · Open ended

Justify the longer-route choice and state a limitation of extending it to real Earth.

Example of a full-credit answer: B has the longer model route because its gap is 5 rather than 2 s. Real Earth has varied materials and needs suitable travel models and more measurements.

  1. Chooses B using the larger gap and supplied model rule.
  2. Identifies material/speed variation, model assumptions or additional station evidence as a real-world limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A new layered-planet model contains a solid outer layer and a liquid inner layer. It uses the same P/S material rules supplied in the lesson.

3A · Multiple choice

Which body-wave type can travel through both layers as that wave type?

  • a: P
  • b: S
  • c: Both P and S
  • d: Neither P nor S
Answer: P

The P rule applies to both solids and liquids.

3B · Short answer

Predict the two wave types’ behaviour at the liquid and explain why this can help infer interior material.

Example of a full-credit answer: P can propagate through liquid; S cannot. Missing S transmission compared with P is consistent with a liquid layer in this simplified model.

  1. Correctly predicts P passage and no S propagation through liquid.
  2. Connects the contrasting observations to evidence about layer material within the model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

After watching a virtual wave move across a screen, a learner says, “This proves a real earthquake will happen here at noon tomorrow.” The simulation has no future-event input.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Supported purpose; Missing information supporting a future event time

  • a: Guaranteed local earthquake safety
  • b: Evidence-based future-time prediction
  • c: Wave propagation model
  • d: Recorded past arrival
Answer: Supported purpose → Wave propagation model; Missing information supporting a future event time → Evidence-based future-time prediction

The display illustrates propagation rather than predicting real event times.

4B · Open ended

Identify the reasoning error and state a scientifically justified use of the tool.

Example of a full-credit answer: A propagation demonstration cannot establish an exact future earthquake. It can help compare wave motion, speeds or arrivals under stated assumptions.

  1. Rejects the unsupported exact future-event prediction.
  2. Names a valid use such as investigating propagation or arrival comparisons with model limits.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A simulator can change route length, wave speed and release time. The question is how route length affects arrival time at a fixed speed.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Changed factor: Route length.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Vary route length while keeping speed and release conditions the same.

5B · Open ended

Propose a controlled virtual comparison and describe the expected arrival-time pattern.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use several lengths with the same speed and start time; record travel times. Longer routes take more time at fixed speed.

  1. Changes route length with relevant speed/start controls and measures time.
  2. Predicts longer travel time for longer route at the same speed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.6 · Wave properties

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find wavelength
Crest positions
CrestPosition
First2
Second7
Third12

Worked example information

A scaled wave has crests at horizontal positions 2, 7 and 12 distance units.

Question: What wavelength is shown?

Answer: 5 distance units.

Why: The matching crest separation is 7 − 2 = 5 and again 12 − 7 = 5.

Example 2 · Count frequency

Worked example information

A model sensor records 18 complete cycles in 6 seconds.

Question: What is the frequency?

Answer: 3 Hz.

Why: 18 ÷ 6 = 3 cycles each second. Hertz describes cycles per second.

Example 3 · Middle line matters

Worked example information

A drawing has a crest at +4 units and a trough at −4 units, with middle line 0.

Question: Is amplitude 4 or 8 units?

Answer: Amplitude is 4 units.

Why: Amplitude is measured from the middle to a crest or trough; the full crest-to-trough height is 8.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Measure a wave

Fixed question information

A scaled model has speed 12 units/s and frequency 3 Hz. Its amplitude is 2 units.

F1 · Multiple choice

What is its wavelength?

  • a: 2 units
  • b: 9 units
  • c: 36 units
  • d: 4 units
Answer: 4 units

12 ÷ 3 = 4 units; amplitude is a separate measure.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F2 · Count a detector

Fixed question information

A fictional detector records 20 complete cycles in 5 seconds.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Frequency; Total cycles

  • a: 100 Hz
  • b: 4 Hz
  • c: 25 Hz
  • d: 20 cycles
Answer: Frequency → 4 Hz; Total cycles → 20 cycles

Divide twenty complete cycles by five seconds.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F3 · Crest and trough

Fixed question information

A model wave has middle line 0, crest +3 units and trough −3 units.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Amplitude: 0 units
  • b: Amplitude: 3 units
  • c: Crest-to-trough height: 6 units
  • d: Crest-to-trough height: 9 units
Answer: Amplitude: 3 units; Crest-to-trough height: 6 units

Amplitude is the maximum distance from the middle line.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F4 · Change one property

Fixed question information

A fixed-speed classroom wave changes from frequency 2 Hz to 4 Hz. Its original wavelength was 6 units.

F4 · Hotspot

What is the new wavelength?

  • a: 6 units
  • b: 24 units
  • c: 3 units
  • d: 12 units
Answer: 3 units

Speed remains 12 units/s, so the new wavelength is 12/4 = 3.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Separate height and spacing

Fixed question information

Two scaled waves have frequency 2 Hz and speed 8 units/s. A has amplitude 1; B has amplitude 3.

F5 · Open ended

Explain which property differs and calculate the wavelength shared by both waves.

Example of a full-credit answer: Amplitude differs, 1 versus 3. Both wavelengths are 8 ÷ 2 = 4 units because speed and frequency match.

  1. Identifies amplitude as the differing property without changing frequency or speed.
  2. Calculates the shared wavelength as 4 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A scaled wave travels at 10 units/s with frequency 2 Hz and amplitude 3 units.

1A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Wavelength; Amplitude

  • a: 3 units
  • b: 20 units
  • c: 5 units
  • d: 8 units
Answer: Wavelength → 5 units; Amplitude → 3 units

10 ÷ 2 = 5; the amplitude does not enter this calculation.

1B · Open ended

Calculate wavelength and explain why the amplitude value is not used in that calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Wavelength is 10 ÷ 2 = 5 units. Amplitude describes displacement from the middle, a different property.

  1. Correctly calculates 5-unit wavelength.
  2. Distinguishes amplitude from the speed/frequency relation used to find wavelength.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A study of frequency uses two virtual waves with speed fixed at 12 units/s and amplitude fixed at 2 units. Frequencies are 2 and 6 Hz.

2A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Shorter-wavelength frequency; Its wavelength

  • a: 2 Hz
  • b: 6 units
  • c: 6 Hz
  • d: 2 units
Answer: Shorter-wavelength frequency → 6 Hz; Its wavelength → 2 units

At equal speed, 6 Hz gives wavelength 12/6 = 2.

2B · Short answer

Justify the shorter-wavelength choice and explain why the controls help.

Example of a full-credit answer: Six Hz gives 2 units, shorter than the 6-unit wavelength at 2 Hz. Equal speed and amplitude keep the comparison focused on frequency.

  1. Supports the 6-Hz choice with the calculated or compared wavelengths.
  2. Explains the value of holding speed and relevant other conditions fixed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

In a scaled water-wave model, neighbouring crests are 3 units apart and 4 crests pass a point each second as complete cycles.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Speed: 7 units/s.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Multiply 3-unit wavelength by 4 cycles/s.

3B · Open ended

Calculate wave speed and distinguish the travelling pattern from an individual water particle.

Example of a full-credit answer: Speed is 3 × 4 = 12 units/s. A particle oscillates locally while the wave pattern propagates.

  1. Calculates 12 units/s from frequency times wavelength.
  2. Distinguishes pattern/energy propagation from local particle motion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner measures crest +5 and trough −5 about middle line 0, then writes “amplitude = 10”.

4A · Hotspot

What is the correct amplitude?

  • a: 10 units
  • b: 0 units
  • c: 15 units
  • d: 5 units
Answer: 5 units

Ten is the full crest-to-trough height; amplitude is half of it here.

4B · Short answer

Identify the measurement error and give the corrected amplitude with its reference line.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner used crest-to-trough height. Amplitude is 5 units measured from middle line 0 to a crest or trough.

  1. Identifies confusion between total crest-to-trough height and amplitude.
  2. Gives 5 units with measurement from the middle line.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual design must have speed 12 units/s, wavelength 3 units and amplitude 2 units. Controls allow frequency and amplitude to be set separately.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Required frequency; Required amplitude

  • a: 2 units
  • b: 6 Hz
  • c: 3 Hz
  • d: 4 Hz
Answer: Required frequency → 4 Hz; Required amplitude → 2 units

Frequency is 12/3 = 4 Hz; amplitude uses its separate control.

5B · Open ended

Propose the required frequency/amplitude settings and show how you check the wavelength target.

Example of a full-credit answer: Set frequency 4 Hz and amplitude 2 units. Then wavelength is 12 ÷ 4 = 3 units.

  1. Sets frequency 4 Hz and amplitude 2 units.
  2. Checks the wavelength with the fixed-speed equation, giving 3 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.7 · Reflection

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Equal angles
Mirror record
QuantityAngle
Incident to normal40°
Reflected to normal40°

Worked example information

A virtual ray arrives at a flat mirror at 40° to the normal.

Question: What is its reflected angle to the normal?

Answer: 40°.

Why: Both angles use the same normal reference, so the law gives equality.

Example 2 · A different reference

Worked example information

A ray makes 20° with the mirror surface. The surface is 90° from the normal.

Question: What is the ray’s angle to the normal?

Answer: 70°.

Why: 90° − 20° = 70°. A surface angle cannot be copied directly as the normal angle.

Example 3 · A visible page

Worked example information

A white page is rough compared with a polished mirror and is visible from several viewing directions.

Question: Why can the page be visible without a clear mirror image?

Answer: Its many small surface orientations spread reflected light in many directions.

Why: Some light reaches different eyes, while the organised ray pattern needed for a clear mirror image is disrupted.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Mirror angle

Fixed question information

A fixed flat-mirror record shows incident angle 30° to the normal.

F1 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Reflected angle; Reference line

  • a: Normal
  • b: 30°
  • c: Mirror edge
  • d: 60°
Answer: Reflected angle → 30°; Reference line → Normal

The two normal angles are equal.

Scientific explorer: optics lab

F2 · Surface reference

Fixed question information

An incoming ray makes 35° with a flat mirror’s surface.

F2 · Multiple choice

What incident angle does it make with the normal?

  • a: 125°
  • b: 90°
  • c: 55°
  • d: 35°
Answer: 55°

The normal is perpendicular to the surface, so 90 − 35 = 55.

Scientific explorer: optics lab

F3 · Repeated angle record

Fixed question information

A fictional virtual-mirror table lists incident angles 10°, 20°, 40° and corresponding reflected angles 10°, 20°, 40°.

F3 · Hotspot

Which normal-angle rule matches all three data pairs?

  • a: Reflected angle equals incident angle.
  • b: Reflected angle is twice incident angle.
  • c: Reflected angle is always 90°.
  • d: Reflected angle decreases as incident angle increases.
Answer: Reflected angle equals incident angle.

The matched pairs show equality when both angles are measured from the normal.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Surface texture

Fixed question information

A polished surface gives an organised reflected ray pattern. A rough surface has many tiny tilted parts and spreads the reflected pattern.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Organised pattern surface; Spreading pattern surface

  • a: Rough creates new light
  • b: Rough
  • c: Polished
  • d: Neither reflects any light
Answer: Organised pattern surface → Polished; Spreading pattern surface → Rough

Small orientations explain the different overall patterns.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain the reference

Fixed question information

A learner records an incoming angle of 60° from the mirror surface and calls it the incident angle to the normal.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the normal angle and explain why copying the surface angle is a mistake.

Example of a full-credit answer: The normal angle is 90 − 60 = 30°. The normal is perpendicular to the mirror surface, so the two reference angles differ.

  1. Calculates or states the correct 30° angle to the normal.
  2. Explains that surface and normal are perpendicular reference lines.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: optics lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A virtual ray strikes a fixed mirror at 45° to the surface. Detector A is 45° to the normal on the reflected side; B is 20° to that normal.

1A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Detector on path: A.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

The incident normal angle is 90 − 45 = 45°, equal to the reflected one.

1B · Short answer

Identify the detector and explain the angle calculation that supports it.

Example of a full-credit answer: A lies on the path. The incoming normal angle is 45°, so reflection also gives 45° to the normal.

  1. Selects detector A at the stated reflected-side direction.
  2. Uses complementary surface/normal angles and equal reflection angles correctly.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

In a classroom model, surface P is smooth and flat; Q has many small, differently tilted parts. The goal is a clear reflected image.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Chosen surface; Reason to compare

  • a: Q
  • b: P
  • c: Q creates extra light
  • d: Organisation of reflected rays
Answer: Chosen surface → P; Reason to compare → Organisation of reflected rays

A smooth surface supports an organised reflected image.

2B · Open ended

Justify the surface choice and explain why the other surface can still be visible.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose P for an organised reflected image. Q still reflects light, but it spreads in many directions so some reaches the eye.

  1. Chooses smooth P and links it to organised rays/clear image.
  2. Explains that rough Q can still reflect light to an eye.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A simplified sound-ray model reflects from a flat wall. Its incident angle is 25° to the wall normal. The same angle-of-reflection rule is supplied for this model.

3A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Reflected normal angle; Surface normal relation

  • a: Perpendicular
  • b: 65°
  • c: Parallel
  • d: 25°
Answer: Reflected normal angle → 25°; Surface normal relation → Perpendicular

The specified reflection law also predicts equal angles in this sound-ray model.

3B · Short answer

Predict the reflected angle and state what makes this a useful but simplified sound model.

Example of a full-credit answer: The reflected angle is 25°. A ray shows travel direction, but real sound also spreads and depends on wavelength and surface properties.

  1. Predicts 25° measured from the normal.
  2. Identifies a relevant simplification such as ignoring spreading, diffraction or surface details.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says a rough page is visible because it breaks the reflection law. The model shows different small surface normals.

4A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Local rule: Equal angles about each local normal
  • b: Whole-page pattern: The page is a light source
  • c: Local rule: Angles need not obey any rule
  • d: Whole-page pattern: Many directions
Answer: Local rule: Equal angles about each local normal; Whole-page pattern: Many directions

Different local normals produce spreading while each local reflection follows the law.

4B · Open ended

Identify the error and explain how the rough page can spread reflected light while obeying the law.

Example of a full-credit answer: The law is not broken. Each small surface part has its own normal and reflects with equal angles, so the combined directions spread.

  1. Rejects the claim that visibility requires breaking the law.
  2. Explains different local normals plus equal local reflection angles.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual mirror test can rotate the incoming ray and mirror independently. The question is whether reflected normal angle follows incident normal angle for a fixed mirror.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Changed variable; Controlled condition

  • a: Mirror orientation
  • b: Both references without labels
  • c: Only the page colour
  • d: Incoming ray angle
Answer: Changed variable → Incoming ray angle; Controlled condition → Mirror orientation

Vary incident angle while keeping the mirror and reference normal fixed.

5B · Open ended

Propose three angle trials and describe the result pattern that supports the reflection law.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep the mirror fixed and try 15°, 30° and 45° to the normal. Measure reflected angles; matching 15°, 30° and 45° supports equality.

  1. Gives several incident-angle trials with a fixed mirror and normal reference.
  2. Predicts or checks equal incident/reflected normal angles across trials.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.8 · Refraction

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Toward the normal
Boundary angles
PositionAngle to normal
Outside50°
Inside30°

Worked example information

A transmitted ray enters a slower-light block obliquely. Its normal angle changes from 50° outside to 30° inside.

Question: Does it bend toward or away from the normal?

Answer: Toward the normal.

Why: The angle to the normal becomes smaller: 30° is less than 50°.

Example 2 · Straight-on entry

Worked example information

A ray enters a slower material exactly along the normal. Its speed decreases.

Question: Must the ray visibly bend?

Answer: No. It can continue along the same normal line while changing speed.

Why: Normal incidence is a special case; direction does not change even though speed does.

Example 3 · Wavelength change

Worked example information

A scaled wave has frequency 5 Hz on both sides of a stationary boundary. Its speeds are 20 and 15 units/s.

Question: What wavelengths occur on the two sides?

Answer: 4 units before and 3 units after.

Why: Divide each speed by the unchanged frequency: 20 ÷ 5 = 4 and 15 ÷ 5 = 3. Wavelength changes while frequency stays fixed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Entering a slower block

Fixed question information

An oblique ray crosses from air into a clear block where light is slower. It is transmitted.

F1 · Multiple choice

How does the transmitted ray bend at this oblique entry?

  • a: Toward the normal.
  • b: Away from the normal.
  • c: It must travel exactly along the boundary.
  • d: It keeps the same oblique direction despite the speed change.
Answer: Toward the normal.

Slower transmitted light has a smaller normal angle for this oblique entry.

Scientific explorer: optics lab

F2 · Angle record

Fixed question information

A fictional transmitted-ray record has incident normal angle 45° and refracted normal angle 28°.

F2 · Hotspot

Which bending direction matches the angle change?

  • a: Away from the normal.
  • b: No direction change.
  • c: Back along the entire incoming path.
  • d: Toward the normal.
Answer: Toward the normal.

The refracted angle is smaller than the incident one.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Normal entry

Fixed question information

A ray enters a slower clear material along the normal. The boundary is stationary.

F3 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Direction: Must turn 90°.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Normal entry can change speed without turning the ray.

Scientific explorer: optics lab

F4 · Two stationary media

Fixed question information

A scaled light-wave model crosses a stationary boundary. Its frequency stays 2 Hz; speed drops from 10 to 6 units/s.

F4 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: New wavelength; Frequency

  • a: 2 Hz
  • b: 5 units
  • c: 12 units
  • d: 3 units
Answer: New wavelength → 3 units; Frequency → 2 Hz

The new wavelength is 6 ÷ 2 = 3 units.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F5 · Explain the apparent bend

Fixed question information

A straight model rod crosses a water surface. Light from the underwater part changes direction as it travels from water to air before reaching an eye.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the rod can appear bent and state whether that observation alone proves the rod changed shape.

Example of a full-credit answer: Light changes direction at the water–air boundary, shifting the apparent position of the underwater part. The appearance does not prove a physical bend.

  1. Explains the apparent displacement using a changed light path at the boundary.
  2. Distinguishes appearance from an actual change in the rod’s shape.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A scaled wave crosses a stationary boundary at frequency 4 Hz. Its speed changes from 12 to 8 units/s.

1A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: New wavelength; Old wavelength

  • a: 32 units
  • b: 4 units
  • c: 2 units
  • d: 3 units
Answer: New wavelength → 2 units; Old wavelength → 3 units

At constant 4 Hz, the wavelength changes from 12/4 to 8/4.

1B · Open ended

Calculate both wavelengths and explain which property stays unchanged at the stationary boundary.

Example of a full-credit answer: The wavelengths are 3 units before and 2 units after. Frequency remains 4 Hz.

  1. Correctly calculates 3-unit and 2-unit wavelengths.
  2. Identifies unchanged frequency across the stationary boundary.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

In a fixed record a transmitted ray goes from normal angle 20° inside a slower-light block to 32° in a faster-light material outside.

2A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Bending; Speed change

  • a: Away from normal
  • b: Toward normal
  • c: Frequency must increase
  • d: Increases
Answer: Bending → Away from normal; Speed change → Increases

The normal angle increases as the transmitted ray enters the faster-light material.

2B · Short answer

Justify the bending description using the angles and explain its relation to the supplied speed change.

Example of a full-credit answer: The ray bends away because 32° exceeds 20°. That fits transmission into the faster-light material.

  1. Uses the increasing normal angle to justify away-from-normal bending.
  2. Connects the bending with the stated increase in speed for this transmitted ray.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A prism’s first face is treated as a flat boundary. A ray enters along the normal from air into a higher-index material.

3A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Direction at first face; Speed inside

  • a: Lower
  • b: Along the same normal
  • c: A mandatory 90° turn
  • d: Same speed as vacuum
Answer: Direction at first face → Along the same normal; Speed inside → Lower

Normal entry remains straight even though the higher-index material slows light.

3B · Open ended

Predict direction and speed at this first face, explaining why a speed change need not mean bending here.

Example of a full-credit answer: It continues along the normal and slows. At normal incidence the path is symmetric, so no sideways bending occurs.

  1. Predicts unchanged straight direction along the normal.
  2. Predicts lower speed and explains normal incidence as the no-bending case.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says, “When light slows at a stationary boundary, its frequency must halve.” The fixed model gives frequency 3 Hz on both sides and speed 12 then 6 units/s.

4A · Hotspot

Which distance between repeating wave features halves in this model?

  • a: Wavelength
  • b: Frequency
  • c: Amplitude
  • d: Source-to-boundary distance
Answer: Wavelength

Wavelength changes from 4 to 2 units while frequency remains 3 Hz.

4B · Short answer

Identify the error and use the model numbers to state the correct changed property.

Example of a full-credit answer: Frequency remains 3 Hz. Wavelength halves from 12/3 = 4 to 6/3 = 2 units.

  1. Corrects the claim by retaining frequency at 3 Hz.
  2. Calculates or states the wavelength change from 4 to 2 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual tester compares clear materials P and Q. It can change incident angle and material. It records refracted angle to the normal for transmitted rays.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Changed factor: Incident angle changed without control
  • b: Measured outcome: Refracted normal angle
  • c: Changed factor: Material P or Q
  • d: Measured outcome: Unlabelled surface angles
Answer: Measured outcome: Refracted normal angle; Changed factor: Material P or Q

Use the same incident medium, angle and light frequency while changing material.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair material test and explain what a smaller refracted normal angle would show for oblique entry from the same faster medium.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep incident medium, angle and light frequency fixed; compare P and Q. A smaller refracted angle indicates stronger bending toward the normal and slower light in that material under these conditions.

  1. Changes material with relevant incident-angle/medium/frequency controls and measures normal angles.
  2. Correctly interprets a smaller refracted angle as more toward-normal bending for the stated entry conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.9 · Absorption

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Missing share
Energy account
PathUnits
Reflected15
Transmitted45
Absorbed40

Worked example information

A model receives 100 energy units: 15 reflect and 45 transmit.

Question: How much is absorbed?

Answer: 40 energy units.

Why: 100 − 15 − 45 = 40, so all three paths total 100.

Example 2 · Different totals

Worked example information

A screen absorbs 30 of 60 incoming units in a fictional test.

Question: What fraction and percentage are absorbed?

Answer: One half, or 50%.

Why: 30 ÷ 60 = 0.5. The absorbed units are not the same number as the percentage here.

Example 3 · Warming is not enough

Worked example information

Two objects absorb equal energy. One has half the mass of the other; their materials are the same and losses are ignored.

Question: Must their temperature increases be equal?

Answer: No. The smaller mass can have a larger temperature increase.

Why: A temperature comparison depends on mass and heat capacity as well as absorbed energy.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Absorption account

Fixed question information

A fictional visible-light screen receives 100 units, reflects 25 and transmits 35.

F1 · Multiple choice

How many units are absorbed?

  • a: 60 units
  • b: 35 units
  • c: 40 units
  • d: 75 units
Answer: 40 units

100 − 25 − 35 = 40 absorbed units.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F2 · Energy after absorption

Fixed question information

In a classroom model an object absorbs 20 light-energy units and gains thermal energy. It does not emit or lose energy during this short account.

F2 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Energy destination; Energy source

  • a: Object’s thermal store
  • b: Nowhere; destroyed
  • c: Incident light
  • d: The object creates energy
Answer: Energy destination → Object’s thermal store; Energy source → Incident light

The model transfers the light energy to the object’s thermal energy.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F3 · Two absorbers

Fixed question information

At the same band, thickness and 100-unit input, material A absorbs 65 units and B absorbs 30.

F3 · Hotspot

Which material absorbs more under these controlled conditions?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: They absorb equal amounts.
  • d: Neither material absorbs any radiation.
Answer: A

The controlled fixed data show 65 exceeds 30.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Different wavelength tests

Fixed question information

A fictional film absorbs 70 of 100 units in the infrared test and 20 of 100 in the visible test.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Greater-absorption band: Visible
  • b: Greater-absorption band: Infrared
  • c: Visible absorption: 20 units
  • d: Visible absorption: 70 units
Answer: Greater-absorption band: Infrared; Visible absorption: 20 units

The specified infrared absorption is greater; this is a band-dependent result.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F5 · Explain a warming claim

Fixed question information

Two objects start at the same temperature but have different masses. They are exposed to the same lamp for the same time. One warms more; absorbed energy is not measured.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the warming result alone cannot prove greater absorption and name one improvement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Different masses can warm differently for equal energy. Use equal mass and material heat capacity or measure absorbed energy directly.

  1. Identifies mass/heat-capacity or related thermal-response confounding.
  2. Proposes an appropriate control or direct absorption measurement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A model infrared coating receives 100 units, reflects 18 and transmits 22.

1A · Hotspot

What absorbed amount completes the account?

  • a: 40 units
  • b: 122 units
  • c: 60 units
  • d: 82 units
Answer: 60 units

100 − 18 − 22 = 60.

1B · Short answer

Calculate absorption and explain where this absorbed energy goes.

Example of a full-credit answer: Sixty units are absorbed. They transfer to the coating, for example increasing its thermal energy.

  1. Calculates the 60-unit absorption correctly.
  2. Describes energy transfer to the material rather than destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

For a fictional collector’s tested sunlight band, equal panels P and Q absorb 80 and 45 units from equal 100-unit inputs. The goal is greater absorbed energy in the panel.

2A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Selected panel; Evidence for P

  • a: 80 absorbed units
  • b: P
  • c: 45 absorbed units
  • d: Q
Answer: Selected panel → P; Evidence for P → 80 absorbed units

P absorbs more of the specified input.

2B · Open ended

Justify the panel choice and give one additional factor needed for a real device comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: P absorbs more, 80 versus 45 units. A real design also needs information such as heat loss, durability or useful energy delivery.

  1. Chooses P using the equal-input absorption evidence.
  2. Names a relevant additional real-device factor beyond absorption alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A fictional radio-band sheet receives 100 units and absorbs 35. The remaining 65 units are reflected or transmitted.

3A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Absorbed-energy fate: Transfers to the sheet.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

Absorption transfers energy regardless of whether the radiation is visible.

3B · Short answer

Explain the absorbed energy’s fate and why an invisible radio band can still transfer energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: The 35 units transfer to the sheet. Radio is electromagnetic radiation and carries energy even though our eyes cannot see it.

  1. Identifies transfer of the absorbed 35 units into the sheet.
  2. Explains that invisibility does not prevent electromagnetic radiation from carrying energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner totals 25 reflected and 30 transmitted units from 100 incoming units, then claims “45 units were destroyed”. The material absorbs the remaining radiation.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Remaining-energy description; Reflected plus transmitted

  • a: Absorbed by material
  • b: 55 units
  • c: 145 units created
  • d: Destroyed without a trace
Answer: Remaining-energy description → Absorbed by material; Reflected plus transmitted → 55 units

Absorption accounts for the remaining energy.

4B · Open ended

Identify the error and give the full corrected three-path account.

Example of a full-credit answer: The energy was absorbed, not destroyed. 25 reflected + 30 transmitted + 45 absorbed = 100 units.

  1. Rejects destruction and identifies absorption as energy transfer.
  2. Gives the complete correct 25 + 30 + 45 = 100 account.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual tool compares coatings A and B at one infrared band. It can measure incident, reflected and transmitted energy. The goal is to calculate and compare absorption.

5A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Absorption rule; Useful control

  • a: Same band and input
  • b: Input plus all output shares
  • c: Input minus reflection minus transmission
  • d: Different band for each coating
Answer: Absorption rule → Input minus reflection minus transmission; Useful control → Same band and input

Subtract the two unabsorbed pathways from the fixed input.

5B · Open ended

Propose controlled measurements and state the absorption calculation for each coating.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use the same band, input, thickness and interval. Record reflection and transmission, then subtract both from input for A and B.

  1. Specifies relevant shared band/input/material-size or time conditions.
  2. Measures the needed shares and correctly computes input minus reflected minus transmitted energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.10 · Interactions between radiation and matter

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Three shares
Radiation pathways
PathUnits
Reflection20
Transmission50
Absorption30

Worked example information

A virtual panel receives 100 units: 20 reflect, 50 transmit and 30 absorb.

Question: Does the three-path account balance?

Answer: Yes; 20 + 50 + 30 = 100 units.

Why: All listed pathways share one input and measurement interval.

Example 2 · A band-sensitive window

Worked example information

A fictional detector measures infrared. Window A transmits 15 infrared units and B transmits 75 from equal 100-unit inputs.

Question: Which window supports more infrared reaching the detector?

Answer: Window B.

Why: Its measured infrared transmission is greater. Visible appearance was not the decision criterion.

Example 3 · A sensor account

Worked example information

A fictional sensor absorbs 40 light units. It gives 10 units of electrical output and 30 units of thermal transfer, with no stored-energy change.

Question: Has the sensor created or lost energy in this account?

Answer: Neither; the 40 absorbed units are accounted for by 10 + 30 output units.

Why: A conversion into electricity is one pathway, not permission to ignore the others.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify pathways

Fixed question information

A model sends some incident radiation back from a boundary, lets some continue through and transfers some energy to the material.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Transfer into material; Passes through material

  • a: Absorption
  • b: Reflection
  • c: Transmission
  • d: Creation
Answer: Transfer into material → Absorption; Passes through material → Transmission

Absorption and transmission describe different outcomes for incoming radiation.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F2 · Not fully transparent

Fixed question information

A fictional visible screen receives 100 units and transmits 60, reflects 15 and absorbs 25.

F2 · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Transmission: 100 units.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Only the transmitted share crosses the screen in this model.

Scientific explorer: radiation lab

F3 · Different bands

Fixed question information

One fictional sheet transmits 80 units of radio and 5 units of visible light for equal 100-unit inputs.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Higher transmission band; Visible transmission

  • a: Radio
  • b: Every band transmits equally
  • c: Visible
  • d: 5 units
Answer: Higher transmission band → Radio; Visible transmission → 5 units

The measured transmission depends on the band.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Sensor output

Fixed question information

A fictional light sensor receives 50 energy units: 10 reflect, 5 transmit and 35 absorb. Of the absorbed amount, 15 becomes electrical output and 20 thermal output.

F4 · Hotspot

How much electrical energy does it output?

  • a: 50 units
  • b: 15 units
  • c: 20 units
  • d: 35 units
Answer: 15 units

Only fifteen of the absorbed units are assigned to electrical output.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F5 · Explain a material choice

Fixed question information

A virtual mirror needs strong visible reflection. Material P reflects 80 of 100 visible units; Q reflects 25. Their behaviour in other bands is not tested.

F5 · Open ended

Justify the material choice and explain why it does not establish the best material for a radio window.

Example of a full-credit answer: P suits visible reflection because 80 exceeds 25. A radio window needs radio-transmission evidence, which this visible-reflection test does not provide.

  1. Chooses P supported by the visible-reflection comparison.
  2. Distinguishes the radio-transmission task and identifies missing band/pathway evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

A fictional panel receives 100 radiation units. It reflects 12, transmits 48 and absorbs the rest.

1A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Absorption: 40 units.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: True

The remaining 100 − 12 − 48 = 40 units transfer to matter.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the absorbed share and distinguish it from the transmitted share.

Example of a full-credit answer: Forty units are absorbed into the material; 48 pass through. Absorption transfers energy to matter, while transmission continues beyond it.

  1. Calculates the correct 40-unit absorption.
  2. Explains the material-energy transfer versus pass-through distinction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

A detector needs at least 50 infrared units through its window from a 100-unit input. A transmits 65 infrared units; B transmits 35. Both meet the stated size requirement.

2A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Qualifying window; Required minimum

  • a: 50 units
  • b: B
  • c: A
  • d: 35 units
Answer: Qualifying window → A; Required minimum → 50 units

A exceeds fifty, whereas B does not.

2B · Short answer

Justify the choice against the numerical requirement and name a further property that could matter in a real design.

Example of a full-credit answer: A qualifies because 65 is at least 50. Durability, cost or behaviour at other needed wavelengths may also matter.

  1. Selects A and explicitly checks 65 against the 50-unit threshold.
  2. Names an additional relevant property without claiming it has already been measured.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A new fictional sensor absorbs 60 units of light energy. It outputs 18 units electrically and the remainder thermally, with no stored-energy change.

3A · Multiple choice

How much thermal energy is transferred?

  • a: 78 units
  • b: 42 units
  • c: 60 units
  • d: 18 units
Answer: 42 units

Sixty minus eighteen leaves forty-two units.

3B · Open ended

Calculate thermal output and explain how the sensor can produce electricity without creating energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Thermal output is 42 units. The sensor converts incoming absorbed energy; 18 + 42 accounts for the original 60.

  1. Calculates 42 thermal units.
  2. Explains conversion with a balanced 60-unit total rather than energy creation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says a panel that transmits 90 visible units must also transmit 90 radio units. No radio measurement is supplied.

4A · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Radio conclusion; Known visible result

  • a: Definitely 90 radio units
  • b: Definitely zero radio units
  • c: 90 transmitted units
  • d: Not determined by these data
Answer: Radio conclusion → Not determined by these data; Known visible result → 90 transmitted units

Different bands can interact differently; the radio value remains unmeasured.

4B · Short answer

Identify the unjustified assumption and propose the missing test.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner assumes equal behaviour across bands. Measure radio transmission through the same panel with a stated input and setup.

  1. Rejects automatic equality of visible and radio transmission.
  2. Proposes a direct, appropriately controlled radio-transmission measurement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A virtual material station uses 100 units of one chosen radiation band. It can report reflected and transmitted amounts. The goal is to compare three energy pathways for two materials.

5A · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Calculated share: Absorption
  • b: Calculated share: A new energy source
  • c: Required accounting total: Unlimited extra output
  • d: Required accounting total: 100 units
Answer: Calculated share: Absorption; Required accounting total: 100 units

Absorption is the remainder after reflection and transmission.

5B · Open ended

Design a results table for the two materials and state how you will check that each energy account is complete.

Example of a full-credit answer: Give each material a row with input, reflection, transmission and absorption. Calculate absorption as 100 minus the two measured outputs; verify all three shares sum to 100 for the same band and conditions.

  1. Includes both materials and all relevant labelled input/pathway quantities under comparable conditions.
  2. Uses the correct remainder calculation and checks the 100-unit balance.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S4.11 · Greenhouse-gas absorption of radiation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Incoming sunlight budget
Sunlight account
PathUnits
Reflected25
Surface absorption75

Worked example information

A single-pass teaching diagram receives 100 sunlight units and reflects 25. The remainder reaches and is absorbed by its idealised surface.

Question: How many sunlight units reach this surface?

Answer: 75 units.

Why: 100 − 25 = 75. This first account concerns sunlight, not the later infrared pathway.

Example 2 · Outgoing infrared split

Worked example information

A separate fixed classroom infrared stream contains 60 units. A model layer absorbs one third of it; the rest passes directly through.

Question: How many infrared units are absorbed and pass directly through?

Answer: 20 are absorbed and 40 pass directly through.

Why: One third of the 60-unit outgoing infrared stream is 20; the remaining 40 pass directly through. Apply the fraction to this infrared stream rather than to an unstated sunlight total.

Example 3 · What a model cannot say

Worked example information

A diagram changes its infrared absorption setting from 20% to 60% but contains no temperature equation.

Question: Can it establish an exact 4°C future temperature rise?

Answer: No. It illustrates a mechanism without calculating that temperature result.

Why: An exact temperature forecast would need additional physical calculations, conditions and evidence.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Two radiation arrows

Fixed question information

A fixed diagram shows sunlight arriving at the surface and infrared leaving the warmed surface.

F1 · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Absorbed outgoing band; Primary incoming arrow

  • a: Sound from Earth
  • b: Infrared
  • c: Sunlight
  • d: All incoming light is blocked
Answer: Absorbed outgoing band → Infrared; Primary incoming arrow → Sunlight

The greenhouse mechanism concerns absorption of some outgoing infrared.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Sunlight reflection account

Fixed question information

A single-pass classroom model receives 100 sunlight units and reflects 30. The remaining sunlight reaches the idealised surface.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select ALL statements that follow from the fixed question information.

  • a: Reflected sunlight: 30 units
  • b: Sunlight reaching surface: 70 units
  • c: Sunlight reaching surface: 130 units
  • d: Reflected sunlight: 60 units
Answer: Reflected sunlight: 30 units; Sunlight reaching surface: 70 units

Sunlight reaching the surface is 100 − 30 = 70 units.

Scientific explorer: greenhouse lab

F3 · Infrared absorption step

Fixed question information

A fixed single-pass model surface emits 80 infrared units. The atmosphere absorbs 50% of this stream and the rest passes directly through.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place a tile for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Absorbed infrared; Surface infrared stream

  • a: 50 units
  • b: 100 units
  • c: 80 units
  • d: 40 units
Answer: Absorbed infrared → 40 units; Surface infrared stream → 80 units

Half of the stated 80-unit infrared stream is 40 units.

Scientific explorer: greenhouse lab

F4 · Re-emission directions

Fixed question information

In a simplified diagram, an atmospheric layer absorbs 40 infrared units and then emits 20 upward and 20 downward. This equal split is a teaching assumption.

F4 · Hotspot

What happens to the absorbed energy in this model account?

  • a: It is permanently destroyed.
  • b: It is re-emitted upward and downward.
  • c: It is all re-emitted only downward.
  • d: It is all re-emitted only upward.
Answer: It is re-emitted upward and downward.

Twenty plus twenty accounts for the forty absorbed units.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain the greenhouse mechanism

Fixed question information

Two classroom atmosphere models have equal incoming sunlight and reflection. B absorbs more of the outgoing infrared than A. The diagram does not calculate temperature.

F5 · Short answer

Explain the greenhouse mechanism shown and give one limit of the diagram.

Example of a full-credit answer: The atmosphere absorbs outgoing infrared and emits some back toward the surface as well as outward. This simplified diagram does not calculate an exact future temperature.

  1. Describes outgoing-infrared absorption with re-emission including toward the surface.
  2. States a relevant limit such as no exact temperature, repeated exchanges or full climate forecast.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: greenhouse lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed question information

In a teaching model, 100 sunlight units arrive, 20 reflect and 80 reach the surface. The surface emits 80 infrared units in this single pass. The layer absorbs 25% of that infrared.

1A · Multiple choice

How many infrared units does the layer absorb?

  • a: 80 units
  • b: 25 units
  • c: 20 units
  • d: 60 units
Answer: 20 units

One quarter of 80 is 20; the other 60 pass directly through this first layer step.

1B · Short answer

Calculate absorbed infrared and explain why 25% is applied to 80 rather than 100.

Example of a full-credit answer: The layer absorbs 20 units. The stated percentage acts on the 80-unit outgoing infrared stream, not the original 100 sunlight units.

  1. Calculates 20 units as 25% of 80.
  2. Distinguishes the outgoing-infrared denominator from incoming sunlight.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed question information

Runs A and B each receive 100 sunlight units and reflect 30. Their infrared absorption settings are 20% and 60%. Other single-pass assumptions are equal.

2A · Matching

Match each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Larger absorption run; Controlled sunlight reflection

  • a: B
  • b: 30 units
  • c: A
  • d: 60 reflected sunlight units
Answer: Larger absorption run → B; Controlled sunlight reflection → 30 units

Only the infrared absorption fraction differs in this comparison.

2B · Open ended

Justify which run absorbs more outgoing infrared and explain why fixed sunlight conditions matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: B has 60% rather than 20% infrared absorption. Equal sunlight and reflection let us attribute this model difference to the changed absorption setting.

  1. Chooses B using the 60% versus 20% infrared shares.
  2. Explains the role of equal incoming/reflected sunlight in isolating the comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed question information

A fictional planet receives the same sunlight in two runs. In run Y its atmospheric gas absorbs selected outgoing infrared wavelengths more strongly. The model includes re-emission in both directions.

3A · Hotspot

Which outgoing radiation band is involved in the changed interaction?

  • a: Radio
  • b: Infrared
  • c: Ultraviolet
  • d: Visible
Answer: Infrared

The same infrared absorption/re-emission mechanism can be considered in a different model atmosphere.

3B · Short answer

Apply the mechanism to this planet and state why the information alone does not give an exact surface temperature.

Example of a full-credit answer: More outgoing infrared is absorbed and re-emitted, including downward. Exact temperature requires a complete energy-balance calculation and other conditions.

  1. Applies absorption/re-emission of outgoing infrared including a downward component.
  2. Identifies the missing full energy balance or other relevant factors needed for an exact temperature.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed question information

A learner says greenhouse gases form a solid lid that blocks all sunlight and destroys outgoing infrared. The supplied model shows sunlight reaching the surface and infrared absorption followed by emission.

4A · Dropdown selection

Choose an answer for each description using the fixed question information.

Complete or match: Correct mechanism; Sunlight pathway

  • a: Some reaches the surface
  • b: Infrared absorption and re-emission
  • c: All sunlight is blocked
  • d: Solid lid destroys energy
Answer: Correct mechanism → Infrared absorption and re-emission; Sunlight pathway → Some reaches the surface

The atmosphere is not a solid lid, and absorption does not destroy energy.

4B · Open ended

Correct both the sunlight claim and the infrared-energy claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Some sunlight reaches the surface; it is not all blocked. Greenhouse gases absorb some outgoing infrared and emit infrared again, rather than destroying energy.

  1. Rejects blocking of all sunlight and allows sunlight to reach the surface.
  2. Corrects destruction to infrared absorption and re-emission with energy retained in the account.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed question information

A single-pass tool can set sunlight reflection and infrared absorption independently. The question is how infrared absorption changes directly escaping infrared for a fixed surface-emitted stream.

5A · True or false

Is this claim true or false for the fixed information? “Changed factor: Sunlight reflection and input together.”

  • t: True
  • f: False
Answer: False

Hold sunlight/reflection and other model assumptions fixed, then compare escaping infrared.

5B · Open ended

Propose controlled runs and state the expected directly escaping-infrared pattern plus a limit of the conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keep incoming sunlight and reflection fixed; try infrared absorption 20%, 40% and 60%. Direct escape decreases as absorption increases in this single pass. This does not calculate the full equilibrium temperature.

  1. Describes controlled runs varying infrared absorption and correctly predicts decreased direct escape.
  2. States a meaningful limit such as single-pass assumptions or no full temperature prediction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.1 · Cell structure and function

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two different boundaries

Example information

A model leaf cell has an outer rigid wall and a thin selective membrane inside it.

Question: Which boundary helps maintain shape, and which controls much of the exchange?

Answer: The wall helps maintain shape; the membrane controls much of the exchange.

Why: A cell can have both boundaries because their jobs differ.

Example 2 · A root is still a plant

Example information

A root-cell image has a wall, membrane, nucleus and vacuole, but no chloroplast is visible.

Question: Does the missing chloroplast prove this is an animal cell?

Answer: No. Many root cells lack chloroplasts.

Why: The wall and other evidence must be considered; one absent feature is not enough to reject a plant cell.

Example 3 · Labels reveal a model’s purpose
Labels reveal a model’s purpose
PartModelled job
MembraneExchange
NucleusGenetic information
MitochondrionUsable energy from food

Example information

Three classroom cards say: membrane—exchange; nucleus—genetic information; mitochondrion—usable energy from food.

Question: Which card helps explain why a working muscle cell needs food?

Answer: The mitochondrion card.

Why: Food supplies chemical energy used in cellular processes; the other cards describe different jobs.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A labelled pond cell

Fixed scientific information

A model of a single-celled pond organism labels a membrane that controls exchange, a nucleus containing DNA, and cytoplasm containing many reactions.

F1 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which part controls exchange?; Which part contains most DNA in this model?; Where do many reactions occur?

  • a: Membrane
  • b: Nucleus
  • c: Cytoplasm
  • d: Cell wall
Answer: Which part controls exchange? → Membrane; Which part contains most DNA in this model? → Nucleus; Where do many reactions occur? → Cytoplasm

Which part controls exchange: Membrane. Which part contains most DNA in this model: Nucleus. Where do many reactions occur: Cytoplasm.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F2 · Green leaf workshop

Fixed scientific information

A leaf-cell model has chloroplasts for photosynthesis, a wall for firm support and a large vacuole for storage. Its membrane remains inside the wall.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which part carries out photosynthesis?” → “Chloroplast”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which part carries out photosynthesis: Chloroplast. Which part gives firm outer support: Cell wall. Which large compartment stores water: Vacuole.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · Comparing models

Fixed scientific information

Model A represents an animal cell with no wall; model B represents a green leaf cell with chloroplasts; model C represents a root cell with a wall but no visible chloroplasts.

F3 · Hotspot

Which model represents the green leaf cell?

  • a: Model B
  • b: Model A
  • c: Model C
  • d: All three are animal cells
Answer: Model B

Which model represents the green leaf cell: Model B. Which represents an animal cell: Model A. Which represents the root cell: Model C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · A microscope drawing

Fixed scientific information

A fictional class uses red for nuclei, a blue line for membranes and small orange ovals for mitochondria. Colours are drawing keys, not measured cell colours.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which symbol represents the selective boundary?; Which symbol represents most genetic information?; Which symbol represents energy-releasing organelles?

  • a: Blue line
  • b: Red region
  • c: Orange ovals
  • d: The page border
Answer: Which symbol represents the selective boundary? → Blue line; Which symbol represents most genetic information? → Red region; Which symbol represents energy-releasing organelles? → Orange ovals

Which symbol represents the selective boundary: Blue line. Which symbol represents most genetic information: Red region. Which symbol represents energy-releasing organelles: Orange ovals.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A damaged boundary

Fixed scientific information

In a virtual cell, damage to its selective membrane allows substances to enter and leave without normal control. The nucleus is still present.

F5 · Short answer

Identify the damaged part and explain why the intact nucleus does not replace its job.

Example of a full-credit answer: The membrane is damaged. The nucleus holds genetic information; it cannot act as the cell’s selective boundary.

  1. Identifies the cell membrane.
  2. Explains that a nucleus and membrane have different jobs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A virtual cell keeps its DNA but loses control of entry and exit. A repair kit offers membrane repair, nucleus repair or chloroplast repair.

1A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which repair addresses the observed problem?” → “Membrane repair”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which repair addresses the observed problem: Membrane repair. Which repair targets genetic-information storage: Nucleus repair. Which repair targets photosynthesis: Chloroplast repair.

1B · Short answer

Choose the repair and connect the observed failure to that part’s normal job.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repair the membrane because the failure is uncontrolled exchange and the membrane normally regulates exchange.

  1. Chooses membrane repair.
  2. Connects uncontrolled entry/exit with loss of membrane function.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Model A has accurate labels and shows wall outside membrane. Model B swaps those labels. Model C has no labels. All are flat pictures.

2A · Multiple choice

Which model best explains the two boundaries?

  • a: Model A
  • b: Model B
  • c: Model C
  • d: Every model is exact
Answer: Model A

Which model best explains the two boundaries: Model A. Which model mislabels the boundaries: Model B. Which model cannot identify parts clearly: Model C.

2B · Open ended

Justify choosing Model A and name one limitation it still has.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its boundaries are labelled in the right order. It is flat and simplified, while a real cell is three-dimensional and more complex.

  1. Uses correct boundary labels/order as evidence.
  2. States a valid limitation such as flatness or omitted details.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A root-tip model shows cells with walls and nuclei but no chloroplasts. The root absorbs water below ground; green leaves above ground capture light.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which structure still identifies a plant boundary?; Which structure holds most cell DNA?; Which leaf structure captures light for photosynthesis?

  • a: Cell wall
  • b: Nucleus
  • c: Chloroplast
  • d: Animal fur
Answer: Which structure still identifies a plant boundary? → Cell wall; Which structure holds most cell DNA? → Nucleus; Which leaf structure captures light for photosynthesis? → Chloroplast

Which structure still identifies a plant boundary: Cell wall. Which structure holds most cell DNA: Nucleus. Which leaf structure captures light for photosynthesis: Chloroplast.

3B · Short answer

Explain why the root cells can lack chloroplasts and still belong to a plant.

Example of a full-credit answer: Root cells below ground do different jobs from green leaf cells. Their walls and place in the plant are consistent with plant cells, so a chloroplast is not required in every plant cell.

  1. Explains that root and leaf cells have different roles/light exposure.
  2. Rejects the claim that every plant cell must contain chloroplasts.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A guide says “the wall controls every exchange, so a plant cell has no membrane.” The correct reference places a selective membrane inside a supporting wall.

4A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which part controls much of exchange?; Which part provides rigid support?; Which arrangement is correct?

  • a: Membrane
  • b: Wall
  • c: Membrane inside wall
  • d: Wall replaces membrane
Answer: Which part controls much of exchange? → Membrane; Which part provides rigid support? → Wall; Which arrangement is correct? → Membrane inside wall

Which part controls much of exchange: Membrane. Which part provides rigid support: Wall. Which arrangement is correct: Membrane inside wall.

4B · Open ended

Identify the guide’s mistake and write a corrected explanation using both boundaries.

Example of a full-credit answer: The guide incorrectly removes the membrane. A plant cell has a selective membrane inside its supporting cell wall.

  1. Identifies the false claim that a wall replaces the membrane.
  2. Correctly states membrane exchange and wall support or their arrangement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A model must show a selective boundary and where most DNA is held. Available labels are membrane, nucleus and chloroplast. Use a key to explain symbols.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which label belongs on the selective boundary? → Membrane
  • b: Which label belongs on the DNA-holding region? → Nucleus
  • c: Which label belongs on the selective boundary? → Chloroplast
  • d: Which label represents photosynthesis in a leaf? → Paint colour alone
Answer: Which label belongs on the selective boundary? → Membrane; Which label belongs on the DNA-holding region? → Nucleus

Which label belongs on the selective boundary: Membrane. Which label belongs on the DNA-holding region: Nucleus. Which label represents photosynthesis in a leaf: Chloroplast.

5B · Open ended

Propose how to show the membrane’s job and the nucleus’s job in a model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw a labelled membrane with arrows for controlled entry and exit. Draw a labelled nucleus with a DNA-information card.

  1. Proposes a representation linking membrane with controlled exchange.
  2. Proposes a representation linking nucleus with genetic information.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.2 · Cellular respiration

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Breathing or respiration?

Example information

A chest expands to draw in air. Inside a muscle cell, glucose and oxygen are used to release usable energy.

Question: Which event is cellular respiration?

Answer: The chemical process inside the muscle cell.

Why: Breathing transports gases; respiration transfers energy from food in cells.

Example 2 · Seed evidence
Seed evidence
Virtual chamberStart O₂End O₂
Seeds2016
Empty control2020

Example information

A fictional virtual seed chamber changes from 20 to 16 oxygen units. An empty chamber stays at 20. Temperature and time are equal.

Question: How much oxygen was used in the seed chamber?

Answer: 4 units.

Why: Subtract 16 from 20. The control makes a background change less likely, although a model is still simplified.

Example 3 · A plant at night

Example information

At night a plant has stored sugar and oxygen. There is no light for photosynthesis.

Question: Can its cells still release usable energy?

Answer: Yes, by cellular respiration.

Why: Respiration does not need light directly; it can use stored food and oxygen.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Separate two processes

Fixed scientific information

A diagram shows air entering lungs, oxygen reaching muscle cells, and glucose being used in those cells. It labels air movement breathing and energy release cellular respiration.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which process releases usable energy from food?” → “Cellular respiration”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which process releases usable energy from food: Cellular respiration. Which process moves air into lungs: Breathing. Which material supplies food energy here: Glucose.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F2 · A reaction’s inputs

Fixed scientific information

The aerobic-respiration model uses glucose and oxygen and produces carbon dioxide and water. Energy is transferred, not created.

F2 · Hotspot

Which gas is an input?

  • a: Oxygen
  • b: Carbon dioxide
  • c: Water
  • d: Nitrogen as the fuel
Answer: Oxygen

Which gas is an input: Oxygen. Which gas is a product: Carbon dioxide. Which liquid is a product: Water.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F3 · Virtual seed comparison

Fixed scientific information

In a fictional model, seed chamber A goes from 18 to 13 oxygen units, while empty chamber B stays at 18. Both run for the same time.

F3 · Multiple choice

How much oxygen did A use?

  • a: 5 units
  • b: 0 units
  • c: Chamber A
  • d: 18 units used
Answer: 5 units

How much oxygen did A use: 5 units. How much did B use: 0 units. Which chamber contains respiring seeds: Chamber A.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Two processes in a leaf

Fixed scientific information

A leaf respires in light and dark. Photosynthesis requires light; a midday gas reading can include both processes.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which process continues in darkness?; Which process directly requires light?; What can a midday reading combine?

  • a: Respiration
  • b: Photosynthesis
  • c: Both processes
  • d: Neither process
Answer: Which process continues in darkness? → Respiration; Which process directly requires light? → Photosynthesis; What can a midday reading combine? → Both processes

Which process continues in darkness: Respiration. Which process directly requires light: Photosynthesis. What can a midday reading combine: Both processes.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Energy without daylight

Fixed scientific information

A fictional germinating bean seed underground has stored food and receives oxygen. It has no green leaves yet.

F5 · Open ended

Name the process that supplies usable energy and identify the material that provides its chemical energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cellular respiration supplies usable energy from the seed’s stored food.

  1. Names cellular respiration.
  2. Identifies stored food as the source of chemical energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A virtual chamber with germinating seeds uses 6 oxygen units in one hour; an empty chamber uses 0. Both began with 24 units and were held at the same temperature.

1A · Hotspot

What is the seed chamber’s final oxygen amount?

  • a: 18 units
  • b: 24 units
  • c: Seed chamber
  • d: 30 units
Answer: 18 units

What is the seed chamber’s final oxygen amount: 18 units. What is the control’s final amount: 24 units. Which chamber changed because of the modelled seeds: Seed chamber.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the seed chamber’s final oxygen amount and explain what the comparison suggests.

Example of a full-credit answer: 24 minus 6 is 18 units. The seeds use oxygen in the model, consistent with aerobic respiration, while the empty control does not.

  1. Calculates 18 oxygen units remaining.
  2. Connects the difference from the control to seed oxygen use/respiration.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Record A measures oxygen use in light and dark with a control. Record B only lists leaf colour. Record C only counts pot labels.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which record most directly tests gas use?; Which record describes appearance?; Which record describes labels?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Record C
  • d: All are equally direct
Answer: Which record most directly tests gas use? → Record A; Which record describes appearance? → Record B; Which record describes labels? → Record C

Which record most directly tests gas use: Record A. Which record describes appearance: Record B. Which record describes labels: Record C.

2B · Short answer

Choose a record and explain why its control improves the conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: Record A measures a relevant gas. Its control helps separate organism-related change from background change.

  1. Chooses A because it measures oxygen use.
  2. Explains the role of the control in identifying background change.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

An animal’s muscle cells receive oxygen and glucose during movement. Blood carries carbon dioxide away. Heat is also released.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What supplies the chemical energy?; Which gas is needed for aerobic respiration?; Which gas is carried away as a product?

  • a: Glucose
  • b: Oxygen
  • c: Carbon dioxide
  • d: New energy from nowhere
Answer: What supplies the chemical energy? → Glucose; Which gas is needed for aerobic respiration? → Oxygen; Which gas is carried away as a product? → Carbon dioxide

What supplies the chemical energy: Glucose. Which gas is needed for aerobic respiration: Oxygen. Which gas is carried away as a product: Carbon dioxide.

3B · Open ended

Explain how the muscle gets usable energy and describe where some energy goes besides movement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cellular respiration transfers chemical energy from glucose using oxygen. Some energy is transferred as heat to the surroundings.

  1. Connects food and oxygen to cellular respiration/usable energy.
  2. Identifies heat transfer as another energy destination.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner writes “Plants only photosynthesise; they never respire.” The reference says plant cells need usable energy day and night.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which process supplies usable energy from stored food?” → “Respiration”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which process supplies usable energy from stored food: Respiration. Which process can store light energy in sugar: Photosynthesis. When do plant cells respire: Day and night.

4B · Short answer

Identify the error and explain what can happen in a leaf during daylight.

Example of a full-credit answer: Plants do respire. In daylight a green leaf may both photosynthesise and respire.

  1. Corrects the claim that plants never respire.
  2. Explains that both processes can occur in a lit leaf.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Use a virtual seed chamber and empty chamber. Both must have equal starting oxygen, temperature and duration. Compare oxygen before and after; no real animals or sealed living samples are used.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which chamber is the control? → Empty chamber
  • b: Which measurement is relevant? → Oxygen before and after
  • c: Which chamber is the control? → Temperature
  • d: Which condition must be held equal? → Pot decoration
Answer: Which chamber is the control? → Empty chamber; Which measurement is relevant? → Oxygen before and after

Which chamber is the control: Empty chamber. Which measurement is relevant: Oxygen before and after. Which condition must be held equal: Temperature.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair virtual comparison and state the result that would be consistent with seed respiration.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use equal conditions for seeds and an empty control. More oxygen loss with seeds than with the control would be consistent with respiration in the model.

  1. Specifies a seed/control comparison with at least one relevant equal condition.
  2. Predicts greater oxygen use in the seed chamber as relevant evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.3 · Photosynthesis

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Where does carbon come from?

Example information

A leaf uses water and carbon dioxide to make sugar in light. Carbon dioxide contains carbon; water does not.

Question: Which input supplies carbon atoms for the sugar?

Answer: Carbon dioxide.

Why: The atoms are rearranged into new substances; soil is not the main carbon source for photosynthesis.

Example 2 · One limiting input
One limiting input
InputIndex
Light6
Water2
Carbon dioxide5

Example information

A fictional minimum-rule model has light 6, water 2 and carbon dioxide 5. Its output index is the smallest input.

Question: What is the output index and limiting input?

Answer: Index 2, limited by water.

Why: The stated rule chooses 2; adding light alone cannot raise the minimum.

Example 3 · Keep the comparison fair

Example information

Two virtual plants receive equal water and carbon dioxide. One receives light, the other is dark. Their temperature and observation time match.

Question: Why is this a useful comparison?

Answer: It changes light while holding other stated conditions equal.

Why: This makes the effect of the selected light condition easier to interpret in the model.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A leaf’s material inputs

Fixed scientific information

The photosynthesis model combines carbon dioxide from air and water from roots using light, producing sugar and oxygen.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which material supplies carbon?” → “Water”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which material supplies carbon: Carbon dioxide. Which material comes through roots: Water. Which product is food: Sugar.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

F2 · Chloroplast job cards

Fixed scientific information

The model labels chloroplasts as photosynthesis sites, roots as water-absorbing parts and leaves as places where gas exchange occurs.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which cell part carries out photosynthesis?

  • a: Chloroplast
  • b: Root
  • c: Leaf
  • d: Rock
Answer: Chloroplast

Which cell part carries out photosynthesis: Chloroplast. Which plant part absorbs water: Root. Which broad plant part exchanges gases here: Leaf.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · A minimum-rule model

Fixed scientific information

For this classroom model, output equals the smallest resource index. Light=7, water=4, carbon dioxide=6. The numbers are illustrative, not measured sugar masses.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which resource limits output? → Water
  • b: What is the output index? → 4
  • c: Which resource limits output? → Light
  • d: Which resource has the largest index? → 7 grams of real sugar
Answer: Which resource limits output? → Water; What is the output index? → 4

Which resource limits output: Water. What is the output index: 4. Which resource has the largest index: Light.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Track energy and gases

Fixed scientific information

Photosynthesis transfers light energy into chemical energy. It releases oxygen. Respiration also occurs in plants and transfers energy from food.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which energy input powers photosynthesis?; Which gas can be released by photosynthesis?; Which process uses food for cell energy?

  • a: Light energy
  • b: Oxygen
  • c: Respiration
  • d: Energy creation
Answer: Which energy input powers photosynthesis? → Light energy; Which gas can be released by photosynthesis? → Oxygen; Which process uses food for cell energy? → Respiration

Which energy input powers photosynthesis: Light energy. Which gas can be released by photosynthesis: Oxygen. Which process uses food for cell energy: Respiration.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F5 · Light is not enough

Fixed scientific information

A virtual photosynthesis model has plenty of light and carbon dioxide but a water index of zero. Its output rule is the minimum of the three input indices.

F5 · Short answer

Predict the output index and explain why adding more light alone will not change it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The index stays zero because water remains the missing input, even with more light.

  1. Predicts an output index of zero.
  2. Explains that water remains limiting when only light increases.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional minimum-rule plant has light=3, water=8 and carbon dioxide=7. Raising light to 6 changes no other input.

1A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the starting output index?; What is the new output index?; Which input was changed?

  • a: 3
  • b: 6
  • c: Light
  • d: 8 grams
Answer: What is the starting output index? → 3; What is the new output index? → 6; Which input was changed? → Light

What is the starting output index: 3. What is the new output index: 6. Which input was changed: Light.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the new index and explain why it rises in this particular model.

Example of a full-credit answer: The new minimum is 6, so the index becomes 6. Light was limiting and has increased while the other inputs remain above it.

  1. Calculates index 6 from the stated rule.
  2. Explains removal of part of the light limitation with other resources sufficient.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Plan A changes light only. Plan B changes light and water together. Plan C compares unrelated species at different temperatures. Each measures an output index.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan best isolates light?; Which changes two resource inputs?; Which changes species and temperature?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: No controls needed
Answer: Which plan best isolates light? → Plan A; Which changes two resource inputs? → Plan B; Which changes species and temperature? → Plan C

Which plan best isolates light: Plan A. Which changes two resource inputs: Plan B. Which changes species and temperature: Plan C.

2B · Open ended

Justify Plan A and name one condition that must remain equal.

Example of a full-credit answer: A isolates the light change. Water, carbon dioxide, temperature, species or duration should remain equal.

  1. Explains that only light is deliberately changed.
  2. Names a relevant condition held equal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional clear tank model supplies a water plant with dissolved carbon dioxide, water and light. A dark cover removes light but leaves the other inputs unchanged.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which input does the cover remove? → Light
  • b: Which carbon source is available? → Dissolved carbon dioxide
  • c: Which input does the cover remove? → Respiration
  • d: Which process can still use stored food? → Soil carbon only
Answer: Which input does the cover remove? → Light; Which carbon source is available? → Dissolved carbon dioxide

Which input does the cover remove: Light. Which carbon source is available: Dissolved carbon dioxide. Which process can still use stored food: Respiration.

3B · Short answer

Explain how the plant could photosynthesise underwater and why a dark cover changes that process.

Example of a full-credit answer: It can use dissolved carbon dioxide and water when light reaches its green parts. The cover removes the light energy required for photosynthesis.

  1. Identifies dissolved carbon dioxide/water as inputs available underwater.
  2. Connects darkness to missing light energy for photosynthesis.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A poster says “Photosynthesis creates energy and roots supply all the carbon.” The reference states light energy is transferred and carbon dioxide supplies carbon to sugar.

4A · Multiple choice

Which statement correctly describes energy?

  • a: Light energy is transferred
  • b: Carbon dioxide
  • c: Water
  • d: Energy appears from nothing
Answer: Light energy is transferred

Which statement correctly describes energy: Light energy is transferred. Which source supplies the sugar’s carbon: Carbon dioxide. Which input is absorbed by roots: Water.

4B · Open ended

Correct both scientific mistakes in the poster.

Example of a full-credit answer: Photosynthesis transfers light energy into chemical energy rather than creating energy. Carbon dioxide, not root-absorbed water, supplies carbon for sugar.

  1. Corrects energy creation to energy transfer/storage.
  2. Identifies carbon dioxide as the carbon source.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual investigation must vary one photosynthesis input and measure an output for equal time. Record both settings and results, then repeat.

5A · Hotspot

What should be deliberately changed?

  • a: One input
  • b: Settings and output
  • c: Repeated comparisons
  • d: All settings at once
Answer: One input

What should be deliberately changed: One input. What should be recorded: Settings and output. What improves reliability: Repeated comparisons.

5B · Open ended

Propose a one-input investigation and describe how you will collect comparable evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Vary light while keeping water and carbon dioxide equal. Record the output over the same interval at each light level and repeat the comparison.

  1. Specifies one changed input and relevant equal conditions.
  2. Specifies comparable output measurements and repeat observations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.4 · Cell growth and reproduction

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · More cells for repair

Example information

A fictional skin patch has 5 damaged cells replaced by 5 newly produced cells.

Question: Must the whole person reproduce for the patch to be repaired?

Answer: No. Body-cell division can provide replacement cells.

Why: A new body cell is part of the same organism, not a new person.

Example 2 · Count rounds
Count rounds
RoundCells
Start2
14
28

Example information

A toy population starts with 2 cells. Every cell divides once per round and none die.

Question: How many cells are present after two rounds?

Answer: 8 cells.

Why: The counts are 2 → 4 → 8; two rounds means two doublings.

Example 3 · Share the instructions

Example information

A paper model has one DNA card. It must finish with two cells, each containing a full card.

Question: What must happen before separating the cells?

Answer: Make a copy of the DNA card.

Why: The copying step represents supplying genetic information to both daughter cells.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A repair sequence

Fixed scientific information

The model sequence is grow, copy DNA, then divide. Each daughter cell needs genetic information.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which step supplies a second information set?” → “Copy DNA”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which step supplies a second information set: Copy DNA. Which step produces two cells: Divide. Which step increases cell material beforehand: Grow.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F2 · A toy doubling table

Fixed scientific information

A fictional model starts with 4 cells. All divide once each round, with no deaths: start=4, round1=8, round2=16.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: How many after one round? → 8 cells
  • b: How many after two rounds? → 16 cells
  • c: How many after one round? → 4 cells
  • d: How many at the start? → 12 cells after two rounds
Answer: How many after one round? → 8 cells; How many after two rounds? → 16 cells

How many after one round: 8 cells. How many after two rounds: 16 cells. How many at the start: 4 cells.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Two forms of growth

Fixed scientific information

Observation A records cells getting larger. B records more cells after division. C records only greater microscope magnification; the specimen is unchanged.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which observation records increased cell number?

  • a: Observation B
  • b: Observation A
  • c: Observation C
  • d: All are cell reproduction
Answer: Observation B

Which observation records increased cell number: Observation B. Which records larger individual cells: Observation A. Which changes only the image: Observation C.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F4 · Cell or organism?

Fixed scientific information

A dividing single-celled organism can produce new organisms. A dividing body cell adds cells to an existing animal. A stone is not a cell.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which case can make another single-celled organism?; Which case can repair animal tissue?; Which example is nonliving matter?

  • a: Single-cell division
  • b: Body-cell division
  • c: Stone
  • d: A new person from each skin cell
Answer: Which case can make another single-celled organism? → Single-cell division; Which case can repair animal tissue? → Body-cell division; Which example is nonliving matter? → Stone

Which case can make another single-celled organism: Single-cell division. Which case can repair animal tissue: Body-cell division. Which example is nonliving matter: Stone.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · A missing copying step

Fixed scientific information

A virtual body-cell model separates before copying its only DNA set, leaving one new cell without the represented instructions.

F5 · Open ended

Identify the missing step and explain why it matters to both new cells.

Example of a full-credit answer: DNA should be copied before separation so both new cells receive genetic instructions.

  1. Identifies copying DNA as the missing step.
  2. Explains that both daughter cells need genetic information.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy population begins with 3 cells. Each divides once per round and none die. The first two rounds give 6 and 12 cells.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: How many after two rounds? → 12 cells
  • b: How many after one round? → 6 cells
  • c: How many after two rounds? → 3 cells
  • d: Which starting count was used? → 9 cells after two rounds
Answer: How many after two rounds? → 12 cells; How many after one round? → 6 cells

How many after two rounds: 12 cells. How many after one round: 6 cells. Which starting count was used: 3 cells.

1B · Open ended

Show the calculation for two rounds and name one assumption needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: 3 × 2 × 2 = 12. The model assumes every cell divides each round and none die.

  1. Calculates 12 using two doublings.
  2. States all cells divide or no cells die as a necessary assumption.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Model A copies its information card and distributes one copy to each new cell. B gives all cards to one cell. C removes the cards before division.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which model represents information sharing best?; Which gives information to only one new cell?; Which discards the information?

  • a: Model A
  • b: Model B
  • c: Model C
  • d: All three are equal
Answer: Which model represents information sharing best? → Model A; Which gives information to only one new cell? → Model B; Which discards the information? → Model C

Which model represents information sharing best: Model A. Which gives information to only one new cell: Model B. Which discards the information: Model C.

2B · Short answer

Justify Model A and identify one thing paper cards cannot show.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both new cells get information in A. Paper cards do not show the real molecular copying process or all the structures involved.

  1. Explains that each new cell receives information.
  2. Identifies a valid simplification or limitation of the card model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A one-celled organism divides to make two organisms. In an animal, division adds cells to a growing tissue while the animal remains one organism.

3A · Multiple choice

Which case increases organism number?

  • a: One-celled organism
  • b: Growing animal tissue
  • c: Number of animals
  • d: Every division makes a new animal
Answer: One-celled organism

Which case increases organism number: One-celled organism. Which case increases tissue cell number: Growing animal tissue. Which quantity can stay one during tissue growth: Number of animals.

3B · Open ended

Explain why the same word “division” has different outcomes in these examples.

Example of a full-credit answer: The single cell is the whole organism, so division can make another organism. An animal’s body cell is only one part, so its division adds cells within the same animal.

  1. Connects single-cell division with a whole new single-celled organism.
  2. Explains that body-cell division adds cells within an existing multicellular organism.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner starts with 5 model cells and writes “two rounds means 5+2=7.” The stated rule doubles all cells each round, with no deaths.

4A · Hotspot

What is the correct count after two rounds?

  • a: 20 cells
  • b: 10 cells
  • c: Multiply by 2
  • d: Add 2 once
Answer: 20 cells

What is the correct count after two rounds: 20 cells. What is the count after one round: 10 cells. Which operation describes each round: Multiply by 2.

4B · Short answer

Identify the wrong operation and give the corrected two-round calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner added the number of rounds. Each round doubles the count: 5 × 2 × 2 = 20.

  1. Identifies adding rounds as the error instead of repeated doubling.
  2. Gives a correct calculation ending in 20 cells.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A classroom model must show DNA copying before division and track cell counts. Use cards and tokens, not living microbe cultures.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which cards represent inherited instructions?; Which tokens represent cells?; Which record tracks each round?

  • a: DNA cards
  • b: Cell tokens
  • c: Count table
  • d: Unknown microbial cultures
Answer: Which cards represent inherited instructions? → DNA cards; Which tokens represent cells? → Cell tokens; Which record tracks each round? → Count table

Which cards represent inherited instructions: DNA cards. Which tokens represent cells: Cell tokens. Which record tracks each round: Count table.

5B · Open ended

Propose how the model will distribute instructions and how you will check cell counts.

Example of a full-credit answer: Copy the DNA card before splitting each cell token, then give one copy to each new token. Record the total after every round and check the doubling rule.

  1. Explains copying and one information set per daughter cell.
  2. Proposes a round-by-round count record and check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.5 · Microorganisms

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A useful fungus

Example information

A food-production diagram uses baker’s yeast, a single-celled fungus, to help dough rise.

Question: Does the example show that every microbe causes disease?

Answer: No. It shows a useful role for one microorganism.

Why: A conclusion about all microbes cannot follow from one role or one species.

Example 2 · Decomposer evidence
Decomposer evidence
Model dayLitter units
012
49
86

Example information

A fictional leaf-litter model records remaining material: day 0, 12 units; day 4, 9; day 8, 6.

Question: What trend does this model show?

Answer: Remaining litter decreases.

Why: It is consistent with material being broken down; the data do not mean matter has vanished.

Example 3 · A virus needs a host

Example information

A reference card says a virus cannot make new copies using only nutrient water; it must enter suitable host cells.

Question: Why is a virus different from a bacterial cell?

Answer: It depends on host-cell machinery for reproduction.

Why: Bacteria are cells; a virus is not a complete cellular system.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Sort three agents

Fixed scientific information

The reference identifies yeast as a fungus, a bacterium as a cell, and a virus as an agent that requires host cells to reproduce.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which example is a single-celled fungus?; Which reference example is a bacterial cell?; Which requires host cells for reproduction?

  • a: Yeast
  • b: Bacterium
  • c: Virus
  • d: All are identical
Answer: Which example is a single-celled fungus? → Yeast; Which reference example is a bacterial cell? → Bacterium; Which requires host cells for reproduction? → Virus

Yeast is a single-celled fungus; the bacterium is the bacterial cell; the virus needs suitable host cells to reproduce.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F2 · Roles in a community

Fixed scientific information

Card A shows bacteria decomposing leaves. B shows yeast in food production. C shows a pathogen causing disease.

F2 · Hotspot

Which card shows nutrient return from litter?

  • a: Card A
  • b: Card B
  • c: Card C
  • d: Every role is harmful
Answer: Card A

Which card shows nutrient return from litter: Card A. Which shows a food-production role: Card B. Which shows a disease-causing role: Card C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Virtual population counts

Fixed scientific information

A toy microbial model starts with 6 cells, gains 6 new cells and loses 2 in one interval. The calculation is 6+6−2.

F3 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final count?; How many new cells were added?; How many were lost?

  • a: 10 cells
  • b: 6 cells
  • c: 2 cells
  • d: 14 cells
Answer: What is the final count? → 10 cells; How many new cells were added? → 6 cells; How many were lost? → 2 cells

What is the final count: 10 cells. How many new cells were added: 6 cells. How many were lost: 2 cells.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F4 · Choose safe evidence

Fixed scientific information

The class can use a prepared image, a virtual model or a published reference. It must not handle unidentified growth.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which option shows recorded magnified appearance?; Which option tests a simplified rule?; Which option explains established concepts?

  • a: Prepared image
  • b: Virtual model
  • c: Published reference
  • d: Taste unknown growth
Answer: Which option shows recorded magnified appearance? → Prepared image; Which option tests a simplified rule? → Virtual model; Which option explains established concepts? → Published reference

Which option shows recorded magnified appearance: Prepared image. Which option tests a simplified rule: Virtual model. Which option explains established concepts: Published reference.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · One useful example

Fixed scientific information

A teacher shows a reliable example of a bacterium helping break down dead leaves. A learner says this proves every bacterium is harmless.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the conclusion is too broad and state what the example actually shows.

Example of a full-credit answer: One useful bacterium does not establish that all bacteria are harmless. It shows that some bacteria can help decompose dead material.

  1. Rejects the generalisation from one example to all bacteria.
  2. States the demonstrated useful decomposition role.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: population lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional microbe model starts with 12 cells. During one interval 8 cells are added and 3 are lost. No cells enter or leave otherwise.

1A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final population?; Which change increases the population?; Which change decreases it?

  • a: 17 cells
  • b: 8 added cells
  • c: 3 lost cells
  • d: 23 cells
Answer: What is the final population? → 17 cells; Which change increases the population? → 8 added cells; Which change decreases it? → 3 lost cells

What is the final population: 17 cells. Which change increases the population: 8 added cells. Which change decreases it: 3 lost cells.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the final count and explain why this does not predict every real microbe population.

Example of a full-credit answer: 12+8−3=17. Real birth and loss rates depend on species and conditions, unlike the fixed toy assumptions.

  1. Calculates 17 cells.
  2. States that real conditions/rates differ from the fixed model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Claim A says some microbes help decomposition and cites observed litter breakdown. B says all microbes are harmful from one illness story. C says every virus is a bacterium.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which claim fits its evidence? → Claim A
  • b: Which overgeneralises from one story? → Claim B
  • c: Which claim fits its evidence? → Claim C
  • d: Which confuses viruses with bacteria? → All claims fit
Answer: Which claim fits its evidence? → Claim A; Which overgeneralises from one story? → Claim B

Which claim fits its evidence: Claim A. Which overgeneralises from one story: Claim B. Which confuses viruses with bacteria: Claim C.

2B · Open ended

Justify Claim A and name the limit of its evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: It links a specific useful role to observed breakdown. It does not show that every microbe has that role or is harmless.

  1. Links decomposition claim to appropriate evidence.
  2. Restricts the conclusion rather than generalising to all microbes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A garden has decomposing leaves, growing plants and occasional plant disease. Microorganisms can contribute to nutrient return or disease depending on their kind.

3A · Multiple choice

Which role returns materials from dead leaves?

  • a: Decomposition
  • b: Pathogen activity
  • c: Appropriate evidence
  • d: A smell alone
Answer: Decomposition

Which role returns materials from dead leaves: Decomposition. Which role can damage a living plant: Pathogen activity. What is needed to identify the organism: Appropriate evidence.

3B · Short answer

Explain why removing every microorganism is not a sensible goal for this garden.

Example of a full-credit answer: Some microbes help break down litter and return nutrients. Harmful agents must be identified; all microbes do not have the same role.

  1. Identifies a beneficial microbial role.
  2. Explains why harmful and helpful microbes must be distinguished.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

An advertisement claims “Antibiotics destroy every virus.” The reference says antibiotics act against certain bacteria and do not treat viral infections.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which agents can some antibiotics treat?” → “Viruses”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which agents can some antibiotics treat: Certain bacteria. Which agents are not treated by antibiotics: Viruses. Who should guide treatment decisions: Qualified health professional.

4B · Open ended

Correct the advertisement and explain why bacteria and viruses should not be treated as the same thing.

Example of a full-credit answer: Antibiotics do not treat viral infections. Bacteria are cells, whereas viruses reproduce using suitable host cells, so their biology differs.

  1. Rejects the claim that antibiotics treat viruses.
  2. States a relevant biological distinction between bacteria and viruses.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

The display must compare a helpful microbial role with a harmful one, using verified prepared sources. Learners cannot culture or touch unknown growth.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which source can show appearance safely?; Which source can establish a role?; Which display text explains what a simplified model leaves out?

  • a: Prepared image
  • b: Verified reference
  • c: Model caption
  • d: Unknown live culture
Answer: Which source can show appearance safely? → Prepared image; Which source can establish a role? → Verified reference; Which display text explains what a simplified model leaves out? → Model caption

A prepared image records appearance; a verified reference can explain an established role; a model caption explains the model and its omissions.

5B · Open ended

Propose two contrasting roles for the display and a safe evidence method.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show decomposers returning nutrients and a named pathogen causing disease. Use verified references and prepared images rather than growing unknown microbes.

  1. Includes one helpful and one harmful microbial role.
  2. Uses safe prepared/verified evidence rather than unsafe culturing.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.6 · Plant systems

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Follow a water drop

Example information

A diagram labels root uptake, stem xylem and leaf surfaces.

Question: What is the represented route of absorbed water?

Answer: Root → stem xylem → leaf.

Why: The labels describe a connected transport route; the diagram does not show every branch.

Example 2 · Sugar has destinations

Example information

A leaf produces sugar. A root tip is growing below ground. Phloem can transport sugar from the leaf toward the root.

Question: Why can the root grow without photosynthesising there?

Answer: It can receive sugar made elsewhere in the plant.

Why: Transport connects the plant’s sources of sugar with places using it.

Example 3 · A fair water record
A fair water record
PlantWater used
A6
B9

Example information

Two fictional model plants start with 30 water units. After equal time A has used 6 and B has used 9 under different stated conditions.

Question: How much more water did B use?

Answer: 3 units.

Why: 9−6=3 compares the measured amounts; it does not alone identify which condition caused the difference.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Plant organ jobs

Fixed scientific information

Roots absorb water, stems contain transport tissues and green leaves carry out much of the plant’s photosynthesis.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which part absorbs water?; Which part links roots and leaves through transport tissues?; Which part commonly captures light?

  • a: Roots
  • b: Stem
  • c: Green leaves
  • d: A label sticker
Answer: Which part absorbs water? → Roots; Which part links roots and leaves through transport tissues? → Stem; Which part commonly captures light? → Green leaves

Which part absorbs water: Roots. Which part links roots and leaves through transport tissues: Stem. Which part commonly captures light: Green leaves.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Transport labels

Fixed scientific information

Xylem carries water and minerals. Phloem transports sugars. Stomata are pores for gas exchange in leaf surfaces.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which tissue carries water and minerals?; Which tissue transports sugar?; Which structures are surface pores?

  • a: Xylem
  • b: Phloem
  • c: Stomata
  • d: Petal pigment
Answer: Which tissue carries water and minerals? → Xylem; Which tissue transports sugar? → Phloem; Which structures are surface pores? → Stomata

Which tissue carries water and minerals: Xylem. Which tissue transports sugar: Phloem. Which structures are surface pores: Stomata.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

F3 · Virtual water uptake

Fixed scientific information

In a fictional model, plant A takes up 4 water units, B takes up 7 and C takes up 5 in the same interval.

F3 · Hotspot

Which plant takes up the most?

  • a: Plant B
  • b: Plant A
  • c: Plant C
  • d: All equal
Answer: Plant B

Which plant takes up the most: Plant B. Which takes up the least: Plant A. Which takes up 5 units: Plant C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Two exchanges

Fixed scientific information

Opening stomata can allow carbon dioxide entry and water-vapour loss. Closing them can reduce both. Light provides energy for photosynthesis.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which gas can enter for photosynthesis?; What can leave through the pores?; What supplies photosynthesis energy?

  • a: Carbon dioxide
  • b: Water vapour
  • c: Light
  • d: Soil as light
Answer: Which gas can enter for photosynthesis? → Carbon dioxide; What can leave through the pores? → Water vapour; What supplies photosynthesis energy? → Light

Which gas can enter for photosynthesis: Carbon dioxide. What can leave through the pores: Water vapour. What supplies photosynthesis energy: Light.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F5 · A root receives food

Fixed scientific information

A virtual plant has green leaves that make sugar and roots that are not exposed to light. Phloem links these parts.

F5 · Open ended

Explain how the roots can receive food and why roots still need their own cellular respiration.

Example of a full-credit answer: Phloem brings sugar made in green parts. Root cells respire to release usable energy from that sugar for their activities.

  1. Identifies sugar transport through phloem from producing regions.
  2. Explains that root cells use respiration for usable energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: body lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A virtual plant has blocked xylem between roots and leaves. Its phloem pathway remains open. Root uptake occurs, but less water reaches leaves.

1A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which supply is directly reduced?; Which tissue is blocked?; Which tissue remains open?

  • a: Water to leaves
  • b: Xylem
  • c: Phloem
  • d: Extra sunlight
Answer: Which supply is directly reduced? → Water to leaves; Which tissue is blocked? → Xylem; Which tissue remains open? → Phloem

Which supply is directly reduced: Water to leaves. Which tissue is blocked: Xylem. Which tissue remains open: Phloem.

1B · Open ended

Explain the leaf effect and identify the route interrupted.

Example of a full-credit answer: The leaves receive less water because xylem normally carries water from roots through the stem toward them.

  1. Predicts reduced leaf water supply.
  2. Connects the effect to the interrupted root–xylem–leaf route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Plan A varies light but holds plant kind, water and time equal. Plan B varies light and water. Plan C compares a tree with a seedling.

2A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which plan best isolates light?” → “Plan A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which plan best isolates light: Plan A. Which changes both light and water: Plan B. Which compares very different plant sizes: Plan C.

2B · Short answer

Justify the fairer plan and name a useful response to measure.

Example of a full-credit answer: Plan A holds other stated conditions equal. A consistent measure such as new leaf area or growth over equal time could compare responses.

  1. Explains why A isolates light more fairly.
  2. Proposes a measurable plant response over comparable conditions/time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A green leaf supplies sugars, a developing fruit uses or stores them, and roots supply water. Phloem transports sugar between relevant regions.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which region supplies the sugar here?; Which region uses or stores it?; Which tissue transports it?

  • a: Green leaf
  • b: Developing fruit
  • c: Phloem
  • d: Water alone makes sugar
Answer: Which region supplies the sugar here? → Green leaf; Which region uses or stores it? → Developing fruit; Which tissue transports it? → Phloem

Which region supplies the sugar here: Green leaf. Which region uses or stores it: Developing fruit. Which tissue transports it: Phloem.

3B · Open ended

Explain how a fruit can receive sugar and why roots remain important.

Example of a full-credit answer: Phloem brings sugar from producing leaves. Roots absorb water and minerals needed by the connected plant.

  1. Explains sugar transport from leaves to fruit via phloem.
  2. Identifies root water/mineral uptake as another necessary role.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Plants drink sugar from soil through xylem.” The reference says roots absorb water and minerals; green parts make sugar, which phloem transports.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What do roots commonly absorb? → Water and minerals
  • b: Where is sugar commonly made? → Green parts
  • c: What do roots commonly absorb? → Phloem
  • d: Which tissue transports sugar? → Xylem carries all soil sugar
Answer: What do roots commonly absorb? → Water and minerals; Where is sugar commonly made? → Green parts

What do roots commonly absorb: Water and minerals. Where is sugar commonly made: Green parts. Which tissue transports sugar: Phloem.

4B · Short answer

Correct the source-of-sugar mistake and the transport-tissue mistake.

Example of a full-credit answer: Green parts make sugar by photosynthesis rather than normally drinking it from soil. Phloem transports sugar, while xylem carries water and minerals.

  1. Correctly identifies photosynthesis as the sugar source.
  2. Distinguishes phloem sugar transport from xylem water/mineral transport.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A plant diagram must show water moving from roots toward leaves and sugar moving from a producing leaf toward a growing root. Label the transport tissues.

5A · Multiple choice

Which label belongs on the water route?

  • a: Xylem
  • b: Phloem
  • c: Leaf
  • d: Soil makes all food
Answer: Xylem

Which label belongs on the water route: Xylem. Which belongs on the sugar route: Phloem. Which is the sugar-producing organ here: Leaf.

5B · Open ended

Propose labelled arrows for both required routes.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show root → xylem in stem → leaf for water. Show producing leaf → phloem → growing root for sugar.

  1. Gives a correct labelled water route.
  2. Gives a correct labelled sugar route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.7 · Animal systems

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · One journey, several systems

Example information

In a human model, food is digested, nutrients enter blood, and blood carries them to cells.

Question: Which two systems are connected in this journey?

Answer: Digestive and circulatory systems.

Why: Breaking food into nutrients and transporting nutrients are different linked jobs.

Example 2 · Different organs, common need
Different organs, common need
AnimalGas-exchange structure
FishGills
HumanLungs

Example information

A fish uses gills and a human uses lungs for gas exchange.

Question: What is shared and what differs?

Answer: Both exchange gases; their respiratory structures differ.

Why: A common need does not require identical organs.

Example 3 · Responding to a signal

Example information

A model shows a nerve signal followed by muscle contraction.

Question: Does the signal itself carry the muscle’s food supply?

Answer: No. Signals coordinate the response; other pathways deliver nutrients.

Why: The model separates information transfer from material transport.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three linked jobs

Fixed scientific information

A human model assigns food breakdown to digestion, material transport to circulation and gas exchange to respiration.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which system breaks food down?; Which system transports materials?; Which system exchanges gases?

  • a: Digestive
  • b: Circulatory
  • c: Respiratory
  • d: A label system
Answer: Which system breaks food down? → Digestive; Which system transports materials? → Circulatory; Which system exchanges gases? → Respiratory

Which system breaks food down: Digestive. Which system transports materials: Circulatory. Which system exchanges gases: Respiratory.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Response and removal

Fixed scientific information

Nerves carry coordinating signals, muscles contract and kidneys help remove wastes from blood.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which structures carry coordinating signals?” → “Nerves”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which structures carry coordinating signals: Nerves. Which structures contract for movement: Muscles. Which organs help remove wastes: Kidneys.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · Animal comparisons

Fixed scientific information

Card A: fish—gills. Card B: human—lungs. Card C: earthworm—gas exchange through moist skin. These are simplified main routes.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which card describes gills? → Card A
  • b: Which describes lungs? → Card B
  • c: Which card describes gills? → Card C
  • d: Which describes moist skin exchange? → All have human lungs
Answer: Which card describes gills? → Card A; Which describes lungs? → Card B

Which card describes gills: Card A. Which describes lungs: Card B. Which describes moist skin exchange: Card C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Read a connected diagram

Fixed scientific information

A diagram sends oxygen from lungs to blood to muscle cells. A separate line sends nerve signals to muscles.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which part exchanges gases with air?; Which pathway carries oxygen?; Which pathway coordinates a response?

  • a: Lungs
  • b: Blood
  • c: Nerve signals
  • d: Food pipe as a nerve
Answer: Which part exchanges gases with air? → Lungs; Which pathway carries oxygen? → Blood; Which pathway coordinates a response? → Nerve signals

Which part exchanges gases with air: Lungs. Which pathway carries oxygen: Blood. Which pathway coordinates a response: Nerve signals.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · The organs are not enough

Fixed scientific information

A virtual animal model has working gas-exchange organs and muscles, but the connecting material-transport pathway is interrupted.

F5 · Short answer

Predict a problem for the muscles and explain why working organs alone are insufficient.

Example of a full-credit answer: The muscles may not receive enough oxygen and nutrients. The organs need a connected transport pathway to deliver materials.

  1. Identifies reduced oxygen/nutrient supply to muscles.
  2. Explains the importance of connections between organs/systems.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: body lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A model has intact lungs and muscle cells but a blocked blood-flow route between them. Gas exchange into blood still occurs at the lungs.

1A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which function is directly interrupted?; Which structure still exchanges gases?; Which pathway normally connects them?

  • a: Delivery to muscles
  • b: Lungs
  • c: Blood circulation
  • d: More food labels
Answer: Which function is directly interrupted? → Delivery to muscles; Which structure still exchanges gases? → Lungs; Which pathway normally connects them? → Blood circulation

Which function is directly interrupted: Delivery to muscles. Which structure still exchanges gases: Lungs. Which pathway normally connects them: Blood circulation.

1B · Short answer

Explain why muscle function can be affected even when the lungs still work.

Example of a full-credit answer: Oxygen must be transported from lungs to muscle cells. A blocked circulation route prevents adequate delivery despite functioning gas exchange.

  1. Identifies oxygen transport as the interrupted link.
  2. Explains that lung function alone cannot deliver oxygen to muscles.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Model A labels organs and arrows for their connections. B labels organs without connections. C draws one large organ doing every job.

2A · Hotspot

Which model best explains cooperation?

  • a: Model A
  • b: Model B
  • c: Model C
  • d: No labels are needed
Answer: Model A

Which model best explains cooperation: Model A. Which omits the links: Model B. Which wrongly combines all jobs: Model C.

2B · Open ended

Justify Model A and name a limitation of any simple system diagram.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its arrows show how systems exchange materials or information. It leaves out much real anatomy and detail.

  1. Uses the represented connections as a reason for choosing A.
  2. Identifies a valid simplification of the diagram.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fish’s gills exchange gases with water. Blood carries oxygen to muscles. Nerves coordinate swimming muscles.

3A · Multiple choice

Which structure exchanges gases here?

  • a: Gills
  • b: Blood
  • c: Nerves
  • d: Human lungs in every fish
Answer: Gills

Which structure exchanges gases here: Gills. Which transports oxygen: Blood. Which coordinates swimming: Nerves.

3B · Short answer

Explain one similarity and one difference between this fish and a human oxygen-delivery model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both use circulation to carry oxygen to cells. The fish exchanges gases mainly at gills, while the human model uses lungs.

  1. Identifies the shared oxygen-transport role.
  2. Correctly distinguishes gills from human lungs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A chart says “The heart digests food; the stomach pumps blood.” The reference assigns blood pumping to the heart and food processing to the stomach.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which organ pumps blood? → Heart
  • b: Which organ processes food? → Stomach
  • c: Which organ pumps blood? → Coordinated functions
  • d: Which feature links organs in a system? → One organ does everything
Answer: Which organ pumps blood? → Heart; Which organ processes food? → Stomach

Which organ pumps blood: Heart. Which organ processes food: Stomach. Which feature links organs in a system: Coordinated functions.

4B · Open ended

Correct both labels and explain why accurate roles matter in a system model.

Example of a full-credit answer: The heart pumps blood and the stomach processes food. Correct roles are needed to explain how materials move and are used across systems.

  1. Correctly assigns both heart and stomach functions.
  2. Explains that accurate roles are needed to understand system connections.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A display must show oxygen reaching a muscle and a signal coordinating its contraction. Include separate material and information routes.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which route carries oxygen?; Which route carries the coordinating signal?; Which part contracts?

  • a: Blood route
  • b: Nerve route
  • c: Muscle
  • d: One unlabeled arrow
Answer: Which route carries oxygen? → Blood route; Which route carries the coordinating signal? → Nerve route; Which part contracts? → Muscle

Which route carries oxygen: Blood route. Which route carries the coordinating signal: Nerve route. Which part contracts: Muscle.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two labelled routes for the display.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show lungs → blood → muscle for oxygen. Show a nerve signal → muscle for contraction, clearly distinguishing information from materials.

  1. Includes a correct oxygen-delivery route.
  2. Includes a separate correct nerve-signal route to muscle.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S5.8 · Relationships between organisms and their environments

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A resource is limited

Example information

Two seedlings share one small light opening. Both need light; shading increases as they grow.

Question: What relationship may occur?

Answer: Competition for light.

Why: The organisms share a resource that may not be sufficient for both.

Example 2 · A food arrow

Example information

A classroom chain is leaf → caterpillar → bird.

Question: What does the arrow from leaf to caterpillar mean?

Answer: The caterpillar obtains food from the leaf.

Why: Arrows trace food and energy toward the consumer, not which organism is larger.

Example 3 · Equal observation effort
Equal observation effort
PatchMinutesInsects observed
Shade104
Sun109

Example information

Fictional counts record 4 insects in shade and 9 in sun, each during 10 minutes.

Question: What comparison can be made?

Answer: More insects were observed in the sunny patch during those equal periods.

Why: The count does not alone prove sunlight caused the difference; other conditions may differ.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify surroundings

Fixed scientific information

A pond example includes fish and algae as living components, water temperature as a nonliving condition and the pond as a habitat.

F1 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which example is a nonliving condition?; Which example is a living organism?; Which term names the organism’s living place?

  • a: Water temperature
  • b: Algae
  • c: Habitat
  • d: All conditions are organisms
Answer: Which example is a nonliving condition? → Water temperature; Which example is a living organism? → Algae; Which term names the organism’s living place? → Habitat

Which example is a nonliving condition: Water temperature. Which example is a living organism: Algae. Which term names the organism’s living place: Habitat.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F2 · Read relationship cards

Fixed scientific information

A shows two plants competing for light. B shows a caterpillar eating a leaf. C shows a flowering plant and pollinating insect both benefiting in this example.

F2 · Hotspot

Which card shows competition?

  • a: Card A
  • b: Card B
  • c: Card C
  • d: Every interaction is identical
Answer: Card A

Which card shows competition: Card A. Which shows feeding: Card B. Which shows mutual benefit: Card C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Compare equal counts

Fixed scientific information

A fictional survey counts 6 insects in patch A, 10 in B and 8 in C, each for 15 minutes using the same method.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which patch has the largest observed count?; Which has the smallest observed count?; Which has 8 observed insects?

  • a: Patch B
  • b: Patch A
  • c: Patch C
  • d: The counts prove one cause
Answer: Which patch has the largest observed count? → Patch B; Which has the smallest observed count? → Patch A; Which has 8 observed insects? → Patch C

Which patch has the largest observed count: Patch B. Which has the smallest observed count: Patch A. Which has 8 observed insects: Patch C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Needs and measures

Fixed scientific information

A virtual plant needs light and water. Growth is measured as new leaf number. A constant observation interval allows comparison.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which input supplies photosynthesis energy?

  • a: Light
  • b: New leaf number
  • c: Equal intervals
  • d: Pot colour alone
Answer: Light

Which input supplies photosynthesis energy: Light. Which measurement records the stated growth response: New leaf number. Which timing feature improves comparison: Equal intervals.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

F5 · Competition needs a resource

Fixed scientific information

A fictional garden has two plants using the same small water supply. A learner calls this competition but gives no reason.

F5 · Open ended

Name the competed-for resource and explain why competition is plausible.

Example of a full-credit answer: The resource is water. Both plants need it and the shared supply is limited.

  1. Identifies water as the resource.
  2. Explains shared need together with limited availability.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy habitat has food for 12 animals. It currently contains 15 of the same kind, with no extra food arriving. The model assumes equal food needs.

1A · Hotspot

How many animals exceed the model food capacity?

  • a: 3 animals
  • b: Food
  • c: Equal food needs
  • d: All 15 must survive
Answer: 3 animals

How many animals exceed the model food capacity: 3 animals. What resource is limiting: Food. Which assumption makes the subtraction useful: Equal food needs.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the excess and explain why the model indicates competition rather than a guaranteed outcome for named animals.

Example of a full-credit answer: 15−12=3 animals exceed capacity. Limited shared food can create competition, but the model does not identify which animals survive or move.

  1. Calculates an excess of 3.
  2. Explains resource competition without claiming certain individual outcomes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Study A counts equal areas for equal times repeatedly. B counts one area for 5 minutes and another for 30. C only asks which patch looks prettier.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which study gives the fairest count comparison? → Study A
  • b: Which has unequal observation time? → Study B
  • c: Which study gives the fairest count comparison? → Study C
  • d: Which measures preference rather than organism count? → Any single glance
Answer: Which study gives the fairest count comparison? → Study A; Which has unequal observation time? → Study B

Which study gives the fairest count comparison: Study A. Which has unequal observation time: Study B. Which measures preference rather than organism count: Study C.

2B · Short answer

Justify Study A and state one limitation its counts may still have.

Example of a full-credit answer: Equal effort and repeats improve comparison. Some organisms may remain hidden or other habitat differences may still affect the counts.

  1. Explains the value of equal sampling effort or repetition.
  2. Identifies a remaining limitation such as detectability or confounding conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional shore plant provides shelter for small animals and helps hold sediment. Clearing it removes both features; no replacement habitat is provided.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which animal resource may be lost?” → “Sediment holding”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which animal resource may be lost: Shelter. Which physical protection may be reduced: Sediment holding. Which action caused both changes: Plant clearing.

3B · Open ended

Explain one living-system effect and one nonliving-environment effect of clearing the plant.

Example of a full-credit answer: Animals can lose shelter. Sediment can become less stable because roots no longer help hold it.

  1. Identifies shelter loss or another source-grounded effect on organisms.
  2. Identifies reduced sediment stability/greater erosion risk.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

Two patches differ in shade, moisture and soil. More snails are observed in one patch. A learner says “Shade alone caused the difference.”

4A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which conclusion is justified?; Which conditions also differ?; What would improve a test of shade?

  • a: Several explanations remain
  • b: Moisture and soil
  • c: Control other conditions
  • d: Shade is proven alone
Answer: Which conclusion is justified? → Several explanations remain; Which conditions also differ? → Moisture and soil; What would improve a test of shade? → Control other conditions

Which conclusion is justified: Several explanations remain. Which conditions also differ: Moisture and soil. What would improve a test of shade: Control other conditions.

4B · Short answer

Explain the error and propose a way to test shade more fairly.

Example of a full-credit answer: The patches differ in more than shade, so shade alone is not established. Compare similar settings with moisture, soil and effort controlled while varying shade.

  1. Identifies confounding conditions/unsupported sole-cause claim.
  2. Proposes controlling relevant conditions while comparing shade.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A school garden lacks shelter for a target insect. A proposed strip must use suitable local plants and be checked by equal-time observations before and after planting.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What action addresses the stated need?; What measurement checks use of the strip?; What comparison provides a baseline?

  • a: Add suitable plant shelter
  • b: Equal-time insect counts
  • c: Before-and-after records
  • d: An unmeasured promise
Answer: What action addresses the stated need? → Add suitable plant shelter; What measurement checks use of the strip? → Equal-time insect counts; What comparison provides a baseline? → Before-and-after records

What action addresses the stated need: Add suitable plant shelter. What measurement checks use of the strip: Equal-time insect counts. What comparison provides a baseline: Before-and-after records.

5B · Open ended

Propose the action and explain how to check whether the target insects use it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Add a suitable local plant strip for shelter. Count target insects for equal times before and after, repeat observations and compare with an unchanged area if possible.

  1. Proposes appropriate shelter using suitable plants.
  2. Proposes comparable repeated observations with a baseline or comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.1 · Circulatory system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Vessel direction

Example information

Vessel P goes away from the heart; vessel Q returns to it.

Question: Which is an artery and which is a vein?

Answer: P is an artery; Q is a vein.

Why: Direction defines these vessel types, rather than the diagram’s colour.

Example 2 · A pump calculation
A pump calculation
BeatsUnits per beatTotal units
6318

Example information

A fictional pump moves 3 model units per beat for 6 beats.

Question: How much fluid does it move?

Answer: 18 model units.

Why: 3×6=18. These units describe a toy pump, not a human measurement.

Example 3 · Exchange site

Example information

A diagram connects a broad artery to many tiny capillaries beside cells, then to a vein.

Question: Where does much tissue exchange occur?

Answer: At the capillaries.

Why: Their thin walls and close contact with tissues enable exchange in the model.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three transport roles

Fixed scientific information

Heart contractions pump blood. Blood carries materials. Vessels provide the connected routes.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which structure pumps?

  • a: Heart
  • b: Blood
  • c: Vessels
  • d: Stomach as the pump
Answer: Heart

Which structure pumps: Heart. What carries materials: Blood. What provides routes: Vessels.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Name by direction

Fixed scientific information

A goes away from the heart, B goes toward it, and C is a tiny exchange vessel beside body cells.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What type is A?” → “Artery”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

What type is A: Artery. What type is B: Vein. What type is C: Capillary.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F3 · A toy pump

Fixed scientific information

A virtual pump delivers 4 units each beat for 5 beats. It starts its delivery count at zero.

F3 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What total is delivered?; How many beats occurred?; What was delivered each beat?

  • a: 20 units
  • b: 5 beats
  • c: 4 units
  • d: 9 units
Answer: What total is delivered? → 20 units; How many beats occurred? → 5 beats; What was delivered each beat? → 4 units

What total is delivered: 20 units. How many beats occurred: 5 beats. What was delivered each beat: 4 units.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Follow the loop

Fixed scientific information

The simplified route is heart → lungs → heart → body cells → heart. Lungs exchange gases; body cells use oxygen.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Where does blood gain oxygen in this route?; Where is oxygen used?; Which organ pumps between the loops?

  • a: Lungs
  • b: Body cells
  • c: Heart
  • d: Food pipe
Answer: Where does blood gain oxygen in this route? → Lungs; Where is oxygen used? → Body cells; Which organ pumps between the loops? → Heart

Where does blood gain oxygen in this route: Lungs. Where is oxygen used: Body cells. Which organ pumps between the loops: Heart.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · A colour mistake

Fixed scientific information

A student labels a vessel artery because it is red in a diagram. The key only says red represents oxygen-rich blood.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why colour alone is insufficient and state the information needed to identify an artery.

Example of a full-credit answer: An artery is defined by carrying blood away from the heart. The direction must be known; the chosen colour only represents oxygen content here.

  1. Explains that colour/oxygen content alone does not define artery.
  2. States away-from-heart direction as the criterion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: body lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional pump delivers 6 units per beat. Route A stays open for 4 beats; route B is blocked. The model has no other outlet.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How much reaches A?; How much reaches blocked B?; Which feature prevents B receiving fluid?

  • a: 24 units
  • b: 0 units
  • c: Blocked route
  • d: 10 units
Answer: How much reaches A? → 24 units; How much reaches blocked B? → 0 units; Which feature prevents B receiving fluid? → Blocked route

How much reaches A: 24 units. How much reaches blocked B: 0 units. Which feature prevents B receiving fluid: Blocked route.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the amount delivered to A and explain why a working pump is not enough for B.

Example of a full-credit answer: 6×4=24 units reach A. B needs an open pathway as well as a working pump.

  1. Calculates 24 model units.
  2. Explains that the blockage prevents delivery despite pumping.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Diagram A labels flow direction and capillary exchange. B labels arteries only by colour. C ends every vessel in empty space.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which diagram best explains circulation?; Which uses an unreliable vessel rule?; Which omits a connected return route?

  • a: Diagram A
  • b: Diagram B
  • c: Diagram C
  • d: All are equally complete
Answer: Which diagram best explains circulation? → Diagram A; Which uses an unreliable vessel rule? → Diagram B; Which omits a connected return route? → Diagram C

Which diagram best explains circulation: Diagram A. Which uses an unreliable vessel rule: Diagram B. Which omits a connected return route: Diagram C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A with one useful feature and state one simplification still present.

Example of a full-credit answer: A shows direction or exchange clearly. It still simplifies branching and real vessel anatomy.

  1. Identifies labelled direction or capillary exchange as useful.
  2. States a realistic limitation of the simplified diagram.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A vessel carries blood from heart to lungs. A second returns blood from lungs to heart. Oxygen content changes in lung capillaries.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is the outgoing vessel type? → Artery
  • b: What is the returning type? → Vein
  • c: What is the outgoing vessel type? → Lung capillaries
  • d: Where does gas exchange occur? → Oxygen is made in the heart
Answer: What is the outgoing vessel type? → Artery; What is the returning type? → Vein

What is the outgoing vessel type: Artery. What is the returning type: Vein. Where does gas exchange occur: Lung capillaries.

3B · Short answer

Name both vessel types and explain why oxygen content does not reverse these names.

Example of a full-credit answer: The outgoing vessel is an artery and the returning one is a vein. Their names follow direction relative to the heart, not oxygen content.

  1. Correctly names artery and vein for the two routes.
  2. Explains the direction-based definition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Blood visits the lungs once and never returns to the heart.” The provided loop is heart → lungs → heart → body → heart.

4A · Hotspot

Where does blood go after lungs?

  • a: Heart
  • b: Body
  • c: Repeated circulation
  • d: One trip only
Answer: Heart

Where does blood go after lungs: Heart. Where does the next main route lead: Body. What pattern describes the route: Repeated circulation.

4B · Open ended

Correct the missing connection and explain why circulation is a repeated system.

Example of a full-credit answer: Blood returns from lungs to heart, then travels to the body and back. Repeated movement continually transports materials between organs and cells.

  1. Restores lung→heart→body connection.
  2. Explains continuing/repeated material transport.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Use a pump, two labelled loops and an exchange station in each loop. This is a paper or digital model, not a medical device.

5A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What represents the heart?” → “Pump”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

What represents the heart: Pump. What represents tissue exchange: Exchange stations. What shows the route direction: Arrows.

5B · Open ended

Propose the lung loop and body loop with their exchange roles.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show heart→lungs→heart for gas exchange, and heart→body cells→heart for delivery and collection. Label arrows for direction.

  1. Gives the lung loop and its gas-exchange role.
  2. Gives the body loop and its tissue-delivery/exchange role.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.2 · Respiratory system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Opposite gas directions

Example information

In a normal gas-exchange model, oxygen travels from air sac to blood and carbon dioxide travels from blood to air sac.

Question: Do both gases move in the same direction?

Answer: No. The modelled directions are opposite.

Why: Read the arrow labels rather than assuming every arrow means air movement.

Example 2 · Count equal intervals
Count equal intervals
AnimationCycles in one minute
A12
B18

Example information

A fictional breathing animation shows 12 cycles in one minute and 18 cycles in another equal minute.

Question: What is the difference?

Answer: 6 cycles per minute.

Why: Equal intervals allow direct comparison; these are animation values, not health cut-offs.

Example 3 · A moving diaphragm

Example information

A virtual diaphragm moves down and increases chest space.

Question: Which breathing phase does this represent?

Answer: Inhalation.

Why: Increased volume lowers pressure relative to outside so air can enter in this simplified model.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three respiratory features

Fixed scientific information

The windpipe conducts air, alveoli exchange gases and the diaphragm helps change chest volume.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which feature exchanges gases?” → “Alveoli”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which feature exchanges gases: Alveoli. Which conducts air toward branching airways: Windpipe. Which muscle helps change chest volume: Diaphragm.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Gas labels

Fixed scientific information

Oxygen enters blood from alveoli. Carbon dioxide leaves blood for alveoli. Nitrogen makes up much of inhaled air but is not the main gas used in aerobic respiration.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which gas enters blood for aerobic respiration?; Which waste gas enters alveoli from blood?; Which named gas makes up much of inhaled air but is not the main gas used in aerobic respiration?

  • a: Oxygen
  • b: Carbon dioxide
  • c: Nitrogen
  • d: All gases have one job
Answer: Which gas enters blood for aerobic respiration? → Oxygen; Which waste gas enters alveoli from blood? → Carbon dioxide; Which named gas makes up much of inhaled air but is not the main gas used in aerobic respiration? → Nitrogen

Oxygen enters blood for aerobic respiration. Carbon dioxide moves from blood to alveoli. Nitrogen makes up much of inhaled air but is not the principal gas consumed in aerobic respiration.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · Pressure model

Fixed scientific information

Model A increases chest volume and draws air in. B decreases volume and lets air out. C holds volume unchanged.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which model represents inhalation? → Model A
  • b: Which represents exhalation? → Model B
  • c: Which model represents inhalation? → Model C
  • d: Which keeps its volume unchanged? → Lungs create air
Answer: Which model represents inhalation? → Model A; Which represents exhalation? → Model B

Which model represents inhalation: Model A. Which represents exhalation: Model B. Which keeps its volume unchanged: Model C.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F4 · Separate the processes

Fixed scientific information

Breathing moves air. Gas exchange transfers gases between air and blood. Cellular respiration transfers energy from food inside cells.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which process moves air?; Which moves gases across the alveolar barrier?; Which releases usable energy from food?

  • a: Breathing
  • b: Gas exchange
  • c: Cellular respiration
  • d: Food digestion in lungs
Answer: Which process moves air? → Breathing; Which moves gases across the alveolar barrier? → Gas exchange; Which releases usable energy from food? → Cellular respiration

Which process moves air: Breathing. Which moves gases across the alveolar barrier: Gas exchange. Which releases usable energy from food: Cellular respiration.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · An incomplete oxygen story

Fixed scientific information

A poster shows oxygen entering lungs but no pathway from lungs to body cells. Blood normally transports oxygen after gas exchange.

F5 · Open ended

Add the missing transport step and explain why lung entry alone does not supply every body cell.

Example of a full-credit answer: Oxygen must cross into blood, which carries it to body cells. Air entering the lungs does not itself reach every cell.

  1. Adds gas transfer into blood and/or blood transport.
  2. Explains why air entry alone is insufficient for distant cells.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: body lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional virtual exchange starts with 10 oxygen tokens in alveolar air. Four move into blood. No other tokens enter or leave during this step.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many oxygen tokens remain in air?; How many moved into blood?; Which gas normally moves the other way?

  • a: 6 tokens
  • b: 4 tokens
  • c: Carbon dioxide
  • d: 14 tokens remain
Answer: How many oxygen tokens remain in air? → 6 tokens; How many moved into blood? → 4 tokens; Which gas normally moves the other way? → Carbon dioxide

How many oxygen tokens remain in air: 6 tokens. How many moved into blood: 4 tokens. Which gas normally moves the other way: Carbon dioxide.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the remaining tokens and describe the normal direction of carbon dioxide transfer.

Example of a full-credit answer: 10−4=6 oxygen tokens remain. Carbon dioxide normally travels from blood toward alveolar air for exhalation.

  1. Calculates 6 remaining oxygen tokens.
  2. States blood→alveolar air direction for carbon dioxide.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A uses many small sacs and a thin barrier. B uses one sealed solid block. C shows blood pouring into the airway.

2A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which model best represents normal exchange?” → “Model A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which model best represents normal exchange: Model A. Which lacks an exchange surface: Model B. Which wrongly shows blood entering the airway: Model C.

2B · Short answer

Justify Model A and name a limitation of the representation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its many sacs and thin barrier represent a large exchange area. It is still simplified and cannot show all living structures or regulation.

  1. Relates thin barrier or many sacs to exchange.
  2. States a valid model limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A running animation shows muscles using oxygen and producing carbon dioxide. Blood connects them to the lungs; the animation is not a health test.

3A · Multiple choice

Which gas do muscles use for aerobic respiration?

  • a: Oxygen
  • b: Carbon dioxide
  • c: Circulation
  • d: Airway reaches every cell
Answer: Oxygen

Which gas do muscles use for aerobic respiration: Oxygen. Which gas do they release to blood: Carbon dioxide. Which system links muscles and lungs: Circulation.

3B · Open ended

Explain why respiratory and circulatory functions must cooperate during this animation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The lungs exchange gases with blood, and circulation delivers oxygen to muscles while returning carbon dioxide. Neither route alone completes the job.

  1. Explains lung gas exchange.
  2. Explains blood delivery/return between muscles and lungs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A student writes “The diaphragm rises, chest volume shrinks and air enters.” The reference describes inhalation as diaphragm contraction downward, larger volume and inward airflow.

4A · Hotspot

Which movement of the diaphragm represents inhalation?

  • a: Diaphragm downward
  • b: It increases
  • c: Inward
  • d: Volume shrinks first
Answer: Diaphragm downward

Which movement represents inhalation: Diaphragm downward. How does chest volume change: It increases. Which direction does air move: Inward.

4B · Short answer

Correct the diaphragm/volume error and connect the change to inward airflow.

Example of a full-credit answer: During inhalation the diaphragm moves down and volume increases. The pressure difference then allows air to flow inward.

  1. Corrects diaphragm direction and/or increased chest volume.
  2. Connects increased volume to pressure difference/inward airflow.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A diagram must distinguish oxygen transfer from carbon dioxide transfer and keep air and blood pathways separate.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which arrow should point air sac→blood? → Oxygen arrow
  • b: Which should point blood→air sac? → Carbon dioxide arrow
  • c: Which arrow should point air sac→blood? → Air and blood pathways
  • d: Which boundaries remain distinct? → Whole blood crosses into air
Answer: Which arrow should point air sac→blood? → Oxygen arrow; Which should point blood→air sac? → Carbon dioxide arrow

Which arrow should point air sac→blood: Oxygen arrow. Which should point blood→air sac: Carbon dioxide arrow. Which boundaries remain distinct: Air and blood pathways.

5B · Open ended

Propose both labelled gas arrows for the diagram.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw oxygen from alveolar air into blood and carbon dioxide from blood into alveolar air, with separate labelled compartments.

  1. Correct oxygen direction.
  2. Correct carbon dioxide direction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.3 · Digestive system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Breakdown or absorption?

Example information

Card A breaks a large food molecule into smaller molecules. Card B moves nutrients across the intestinal wall.

Question: Which is digestion and which is absorption?

Answer: A is digestion; B is absorption.

Why: Changing molecule size and crossing a boundary are separate linked processes.

Example 2 · A token model
A token model
TokensCount
Start in gut15
Absorbed9
Remain6

Example information

A fictional model starts with 15 nutrient tokens in the gut. Nine are absorbed during one step.

Question: How many remain in the gut after that step?

Answer: 6 tokens.

Why: 15−9=6. Tokens simplify absorption and are not nutritional advice.

Example 3 · Which route is this?

Example information

A diagram shows a pancreas sending digestive juices into the small intestine while food stays in the tract.

Question: Does food pass through the pancreas in this diagram?

Answer: No. The pancreas arrow represents digestive juices.

Why: The arrow’s labelled material determines its meaning.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Organ sequence

Fixed scientific information

The provided route is mouth → oesophagus → stomach → small intestine → large intestine. Food is mixed in the stomach and many nutrients are absorbed in the small intestine.

F1 · Multiple choice

Where are many nutrients absorbed?

  • a: Small intestine
  • b: Stomach
  • c: Oesophagus
  • d: Heart
Answer: Small intestine

Where are many nutrients absorbed: Small intestine. Which organ mixes food with juices: Stomach. Which tube links mouth to stomach: Oesophagus.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Three process labels

Fixed scientific information

Chewing changes food-piece size. Chemical digestion breaks large molecules. Absorption transfers nutrients across the gut wall.

F2 · Hotspot

Which process transfers nutrients across the wall?

  • a: Absorption
  • b: Chewing
  • c: Chemical digestion
  • d: Blood pumping
Answer: Absorption

Which process transfers nutrients across the wall: Absorption. Which changes piece size: Chewing. Which breaks large food molecules: Chemical digestion.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · A virtual absorption step

Fixed scientific information

A model begins with 20 nutrient tokens. Twelve cross the gut boundary and eight remain in the tract.

F3 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “How many were absorbed?” → “8 tokens”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

How many were absorbed: 12 tokens. How many remain: 8 tokens. How many were present initially: 20 tokens.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Label the material

Fixed scientific information

Arrow A carries food from stomach to intestine. B carries digestive juice from pancreas to intestine. C carries absorbed nutrients in blood.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which arrow carries food contents along the digestive tract?; Which carries digestive juice?; Which carries absorbed nutrients?

  • a: Arrow A
  • b: Arrow B
  • c: Arrow C
  • d: All arrows carry whole meals
Answer: Which arrow carries food contents along the digestive tract? → Arrow A; Which carries digestive juice? → Arrow B; Which carries absorbed nutrients? → Arrow C

A carries food contents along the tract; B carries pancreatic digestive juices into the intestine; C carries absorbed nutrients in blood.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A missing absorption step

Fixed scientific information

A learner’s diagram breaks food into nutrients but sends them straight out of the body. It omits transfer across the small-intestine wall.

F5 · Short answer

Name the missing process and explain why the body needs it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Absorption is missing. It moves digested nutrients into transport pathways so cells can receive and use them.

  1. Names absorption.
  2. Explains nutrient transfer into the body/transport to cells.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: body lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional gut model starts with 24 nutrient tokens. It absorbs 15 in one interval and has no further input during that interval.

1A · Hotspot

How many remain in the gut?

  • a: 9 tokens
  • b: 15 tokens
  • c: Absorption
  • d: 39 tokens remain
Answer: 9 tokens

How many remain in the gut: 9 tokens. How many entered the body’s transport pathway: 15 tokens. Which process describes that crossing: Absorption.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the remaining tokens and explain why absorbed tokens have not disappeared.

Example of a full-credit answer: 24−15=9 remain. The 15 absorbed tokens moved into a different compartment representing the body’s transport system.

  1. Calculates 9 remaining tokens.
  2. Explains transfer of absorbed matter rather than disappearance.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A distinguishes food route, digestive juices and absorbed nutrients. B sends whole food through every organ. C has no direction arrows.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which model best explains the different routes?; Which wrongly sends food through all organs?; Which omits movement direction?

  • a: Model A
  • b: Model B
  • c: Model C
  • d: All routes are the same
Answer: Which model best explains the different routes? → Model A; Which wrongly sends food through all organs? → Model B; Which omits movement direction? → Model C

Which model best explains the different routes: Model A. Which wrongly sends food through all organs: Model B. Which omits movement direction: Model C.

2B · Open ended

Justify Model A and give one example of a route it should distinguish.

Example of a full-credit answer: A labels what moves. It should distinguish pancreatic juices entering the intestine from food moving along the tract or nutrients entering blood.

  1. Explains value of separate labelled material routes.
  2. Provides a correct example of distinct routes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

After digestion, nutrients cross the intestinal wall and blood delivers them to muscle cells. The muscle cells use some nutrients for energy and building material.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Where does absorption occur in this example? → Intestinal wall
  • b: What transports nutrients onward? → Blood
  • c: Where does absorption occur in this example? → Muscle cells
  • d: Which cells use them here? → Food remains forever in stomach
Answer: Where does absorption occur in this example? → Intestinal wall; What transports nutrients onward? → Blood

Where does absorption occur in this example: Intestinal wall. What transports nutrients onward: Blood. Which cells use them here: Muscle cells.

3B · Short answer

Explain how digestive and circulatory functions connect in this example.

Example of a full-credit answer: Digestion prepares absorbable nutrients and absorption moves them across the gut wall. Blood then transports them to muscle cells.

  1. Explains digestion/absorption role.
  2. Explains circulatory delivery to the destination cells.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A poster says “All nutrients are absorbed in the stomach; the small intestine only stores waste.” The reference identifies the small intestine as a major site of digestion and nutrient absorption.

4A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which organ absorbs many nutrients?; Which organ mixes food earlier?; Which process takes nutrients across the wall?

  • a: Small intestine
  • b: Stomach
  • c: Absorption
  • d: Small intestine only stores waste
Answer: Which organ absorbs many nutrients? → Small intestine; Which organ mixes food earlier? → Stomach; Which process takes nutrients across the wall? → Absorption

Which organ absorbs many nutrients: Small intestine. Which organ mixes food earlier: Stomach. Which process takes nutrients across the wall: Absorption.

4B · Open ended

Correct the poster’s small-intestine claim and distinguish absorption from mixing.

Example of a full-credit answer: The small intestine digests food and absorbs many nutrients. Absorption transfers nutrients across the wall; mixing moves and combines gut contents.

  1. Corrects the small intestine’s role.
  2. Distinguishes absorption from mechanical mixing.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A display must show food breakdown and the next step that supplies distant cells. Use labelled arrows and keep undigested waste separate.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which process breaks food molecules down?; Which moves nutrients into the body?; Which carries many nutrients to distant cells?

  • a: Digestion
  • b: Absorption
  • c: Circulation
  • d: All matter becomes waste
Answer: Which process breaks food molecules down? → Digestion; Which moves nutrients into the body? → Absorption; Which carries many nutrients to distant cells? → Circulation

Which process breaks food molecules down: Digestion. Which moves nutrients into the body: Absorption. Which carries many nutrients to distant cells: Circulation.

5B · Open ended

Propose a labelled path from digested food to a body cell and show where undigested material differs.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show digested nutrients crossing the small-intestine wall into transport and reaching a body cell. Undigested material remains in the tract and continues toward the large intestine.

  1. Gives absorption and transport route to cells.
  2. Distinguishes undigested material remaining in the digestive tract.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.4 · Reproductive system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two cells join

Example information

A classroom sequence shows an egg cell joining a sperm cell, then one starting cell beginning divisions.

Question: What event begins the sequence?

Answer: Fertilisation.

Why: It joins genetic information from the two reproductive cells; later divisions develop one organism.

Example 2 · Read the organ labels
Read the organ labels
StructureRole
OvariesEgg cells
TestesSperm cells
UterusEmbryo development

Example information

A reference table assigns eggs to ovaries, sperm to testes and embryo development to the uterus.

Question: Which organ is associated with embryo development?

Answer: The uterus.

Why: The table separates production of reproductive cells from development.

Example 3 · A timeline is not a deadline

Example information

Two fictional learners read a puberty timeline with a note: timing varies among individuals.

Question: Can the timeline determine exactly when either learner will change?

Answer: No.

Why: A broad developmental model does not predict an individual schedule.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the reproductive cells

Fixed scientific information

The reference names egg and sperm as reproductive cells. Their joining is fertilisation. Function key: ovaries produce egg cells; testes produce sperm cells; the uterus supports embryo development during pregnancy.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which event joins the reproductive cells?; Which cell is produced by ovaries?; Which cell is produced by testes?

  • a: Fertilisation
  • b: Egg cell
  • c: Sperm cell
  • d: Food digestion
Answer: Which event joins the reproductive cells? → Fertilisation; Which cell is produced by ovaries? → Egg cell; Which cell is produced by testes? → Sperm cell

Which event joins the reproductive cells: Fertilisation. Which cell is produced by ovaries: Egg cell. Which cell is produced by testes: Sperm cell.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Match organ functions

Fixed scientific information

Ovaries produce eggs, testes produce sperm and the uterus can house a developing embryo during pregnancy.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which organ houses embryo development?; Which organs produce eggs?; Which organs produce sperm?

  • a: Uterus
  • b: Ovaries
  • c: Testes
  • d: Lungs
Answer: Which organ houses embryo development? → Uterus; Which organs produce eggs? → Ovaries; Which organs produce sperm? → Testes

Which organ houses embryo development: Uterus. Which organs produce eggs: Ovaries. Which organs produce sperm: Testes.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · A simplified sequence

Fixed scientific information

The model order is fertilisation, early cell divisions, then continuing embryo development. It is not a scale drawing of time.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which event occurs first?

  • a: Fertilisation
  • b: Cell division
  • c: Embryo
  • d: A separate baby per cell
Answer: Fertilisation

Which event occurs first: Fertilisation. Which process increases the early cell count: Cell division. What is the early developing organism called: Embryo.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Puberty information cards

Fixed scientific information

Card A says timing varies. B explains hormones as chemical signals. C recommends respectful questions with a trusted adult or health professional.

F4 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which card addresses different timing?” → “Card B”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which card addresses different timing: Card A. Which explains chemical signals: Card B. Which describes an appropriate route for personal questions: Card C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · A stage-model limit

Fixed scientific information

A digital timeline shows three developmental stages in equally sized boxes. It says the drawing is not to time scale.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why equal boxes do not mean equal durations and state one useful purpose of the model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Equal boxes are a layout choice, not a timing measurement. The model can show the order of stages.

  1. Rejects equal box size as evidence of equal durations.
  2. Identifies sequence/order as a useful purpose.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A classroom poster has empty labels beside the egg-producing organs, sperm-producing organs and embryo-development organ. Use the supplied function key. Function key: ovaries produce egg cells; testes produce sperm cells; the uterus supports embryo development during pregnancy.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which label belongs beside the egg-producing organs? → Ovaries
  • b: Which belongs beside the sperm-producing organs? → Testes
  • c: Which label belongs beside the egg-producing organs? → Uterus
  • d: Which belongs beside the development organ? → Kidneys
Answer: Which label belongs beside the egg-producing organs? → Ovaries; Which belongs beside the sperm-producing organs? → Testes

Which label belongs beside the egg-producing organs: Ovaries. Which belongs beside the sperm-producing organs: Testes. Which belongs beside the development organ: Uterus.

1B · Open ended

Explain the different roles of ovaries and uterus using the key.

Example of a full-credit answer: Ovaries produce egg cells. The uterus is where an embryo can implant and develop during pregnancy.

  1. States ovaries produce egg cells.
  2. States the uterus’s role in embryo development.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says puberty timing varies and personal concerns deserve trusted guidance. B gives every child the same deadline. C ranks children by development speed.

2A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which explanation respects biological variation?” → “Explanation A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which explanation respects biological variation: Explanation A. Which invents one fixed deadline: Explanation B. Which makes an inappropriate ranking: Explanation C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and explain why a general model cannot judge one child’s health.

Example of a full-credit answer: A acknowledges variation. A broad model lacks individual information and cannot replace qualified evaluation.

  1. Uses variation in timing as justification.
  2. Explains the limit of general models for individual health judgement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

In a simplified flowering-plant model, a sperm cell joins an egg cell. The structures differ from human organs, but fertilisation still joins reproductive cells.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the shared event?; What joins an egg in this model?; What differs between plant and human models?

  • a: Fertilisation
  • b: Sperm cell
  • c: Reproductive structures
  • d: Plants have human organs
Answer: What is the shared event? → Fertilisation; What joins an egg in this model? → Sperm cell; What differs between plant and human models? → Reproductive structures

What is the shared event: Fertilisation. What joins an egg in this model: Sperm cell. What differs between plant and human models: Reproductive structures.

3B · Open ended

Identify one shared biological process and one reason not to copy human organ labels onto the plant.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both can involve egg and sperm joining in fertilisation. Plants have different reproductive structures rather than ovaries/testes/uterus arranged as human organs.

  1. Identifies fertilisation as a shared process.
  2. Explains that reproductive structures differ between the organisms.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “After fertilisation, every cell division creates a separate baby.” The reference says repeated divisions form many cells of one developing organism.

4A · Hotspot

What usually increases during early divisions?

  • a: Cell number
  • b: One developing organism
  • c: Fertilisation
  • d: A new baby every division
Answer: Cell number

What usually increases during early divisions: Cell number. What do these cells form parts of: One developing organism. Which event occurred before these divisions: Fertilisation.

4B · Short answer

Identify the mistake and state the correct role of cell division in this model.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner confuses new cells with new organisms. Divisions increase the cells making up one developing organism.

  1. Identifies the cell-versus-organism confusion.
  2. Explains cell-number increase within one developing organism.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A school display must show fertilisation and later development, label structures accurately and state that timing diagrams are simplified. It must not compare classmates’ bodies.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What should identify each structure?; What should show stage order?; What should explain timing limits?

  • a: Accurate labels
  • b: Sequence arrows
  • c: Model note
  • d: Personal rankings
Answer: What should identify each structure? → Accurate labels; What should show stage order? → Sequence arrows; What should explain timing limits? → Model note

What should identify each structure: Accurate labels. What should show stage order: Sequence arrows. What should explain timing limits: Model note.

5B · Open ended

Propose a scientifically labelled sequence and a note that prevents misuse of the display.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show egg+sperm→fertilisation→cell divisions→embryo development. Add that stages are simplified, not a personal timetable, and individual questions need respectful trusted guidance.

  1. Provides a correct biological sequence.
  2. Includes a valid limitation/respect note avoiding personal judgement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.5 · Excretory system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two kinds of waste

Example information

A card shows carbon dioxide made in cells and undigested material left in the gut.

Question: Do they leave by the same route?

Answer: No. Carbon dioxide leaves mainly through lungs; undigested material follows the digestive tract.

Why: The origin and substance determine the route.

Example 2 · Urine’s journey
Urine’s journey
StructureRole
KidneyForms urine
UreterTransports urine
BladderStores urine
UrethraExit route

Example information

The model lists kidney, ureter, bladder and urethra.

Question: Which structure stores urine?

Answer: The bladder.

Why: Ureters transport urine into storage; the urethra is the exit route.

Example 3 · A selective return

Example information

A token model filters 10 tokens, returns 7 useful tokens to blood and leaves 3 for its waste stream.

Question: Did all filtered tokens become waste?

Answer: No. Seven were returned.

Why: The model illustrates selective return after filtration, not simple disposal of everything.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Different removal routes

Fixed scientific information

Kidneys remove dissolved metabolic wastes from blood. Lungs remove carbon dioxide. The digestive tract eliminates undigested material.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which organs filter blood for urine formation?” → “Lungs”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which organs filter blood for urine formation: Kidneys. Which remove carbon dioxide: Lungs. Which route removes undigested food remains: Digestive tract.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Urinary pathway

Fixed scientific information

Urine travels kidney→ureter→bladder→urethra. Blood returns from the kidney through blood vessels.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which structure stores urine? → Bladder
  • b: Which tube carries urine to storage? → Ureter
  • c: Which structure stores urine? → Urethra
  • d: Which is the exit tube? → Artery to bladder
Answer: Which structure stores urine? → Bladder; Which tube carries urine to storage? → Ureter

Which structure stores urine: Bladder. Which tube carries urine to storage: Ureter. Which is the exit tube: Urethra.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · A virtual waste count

Fixed scientific information

A toy compartment has 14 waste tokens. Its model kidney removes 9 in one step. No more tokens enter.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many remain?; How many were removed?; How many were present initially?

  • a: 5 tokens
  • b: 9 tokens
  • c: 14 tokens
  • d: 23 remain
Answer: How many remain? → 5 tokens; How many were removed? → 9 tokens; How many were present initially? → 14 tokens

How many remain: 5 tokens. How many were removed: 9 tokens. How many were present initially: 14 tokens.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Selective return

Fixed scientific information

A model returns useful water and nutrient tokens to blood, sends selected waste tokens toward urine and records both routes.

F4 · Multiple choice

Where do useful returned tokens go?

  • a: Blood
  • b: Urine route
  • c: Selective return
  • d: Everything must leave
Answer: Blood

Where do useful returned tokens go: Blood. Where do selected waste tokens go: Urine route. What makes the process more than disposal: Selective return.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · A wrong arrow

Fixed scientific information

A learner draws a blood arrow from the kidney into the bladder. The reference says the bladder stores urine; blood remains in blood vessels.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the arrow’s material label and explain where blood should go instead.

Example of a full-credit answer: The kidney-to-bladder route carries urine through a ureter. Blood leaves through blood vessels and continues circulating.

  1. Corrects the route to urine via ureter.
  2. Keeps blood within vessels/continuing circulation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: body lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional compartment contains 18 waste tokens. A model removes 11, returns useful tokens on another route and adds no new waste during the step.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: How many waste tokens remain? → 7 tokens
  • b: How many waste tokens were removed? → 11 tokens
  • c: How many waste tokens remain? → They rejoin blood
  • d: What happens to useful returned tokens? → 29 waste tokens remain
Answer: How many waste tokens remain? → 7 tokens; How many waste tokens were removed? → 11 tokens

How many waste tokens remain: 7 tokens. How many waste tokens were removed: 11 tokens. What happens to useful returned tokens: They rejoin blood.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the remaining waste and explain why useful returned substances are a different part of the model.

Example of a full-credit answer: 18−11=7 waste tokens remain. Useful substances are returned to the blood rather than all being counted as removed waste.

  1. Calculates 7 remaining waste tokens.
  2. Distinguishes useful return from waste removal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A separates blood vessels from the urine route and labels the bladder. B sends whole blood into the bladder. C says kidneys only store urine.

2A · Hotspot

Which diagram matches the reference?

  • a: Diagram A
  • b: Diagram B
  • c: Diagram C
  • d: All routes are identical
Answer: Diagram A

Which diagram matches the reference: Diagram A. Which confuses blood with urine: Diagram B. Which gives kidneys the bladder’s role: Diagram C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A using two correctly distinguished functions or routes.

Example of a full-credit answer: It keeps blood circulating in vessels and shows urine travelling to the bladder for storage.

  1. Identifies the correct blood-vessel route.
  2. Identifies urine transport/storage separately.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A muscle cell produces carbon dioxide during respiration. Blood carries it to lungs, where it can leave the body.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Where is this waste produced?; What carries it toward the lungs?; Which organs release it to exhaled air?

  • a: Muscle cells
  • b: Blood
  • c: Lungs
  • d: Bladder removes every gas
Answer: Where is this waste produced? → Muscle cells; What carries it toward the lungs? → Blood; Which organs release it to exhaled air? → Lungs

Where is this waste produced: Muscle cells. What carries it toward the lungs: Blood. Which organs release it to exhaled air: Lungs.

3B · Short answer

Explain why this is excretion even though it does not use the urinary route.

Example of a full-credit answer: Carbon dioxide is a waste from cellular reactions. It leaves through the lungs, showing that excretion uses more than one organ system.

  1. Identifies carbon dioxide as metabolic waste.
  2. Explains its removal by lungs rather than the urinary route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A poster says “Kidneys throw away every filtered substance.” The reference describes return of useful substances and much water to blood.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What happens to many useful filtered substances?” → “Water balance”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What happens to many useful filtered substances: Return to blood. What is one kidney regulation role: Water balance. Which output carries selected wastes: Urine.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim and explain why selective return is useful.

Example of a full-credit answer: Many filtered substances are returned to blood. This conserves needed materials while helping remove wastes and regulate water/salts.

  1. Corrects the claim by describing return to blood.
  2. Explains conservation/regulation of useful materials.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A diagram must show blood passing through a kidney and continuing circulation, and urine leaving the kidney for storage and exit. Use different labelled arrows.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which route must remain in vessels?; Which route passes through ureter?; Which organ stores urine?

  • a: Blood route
  • b: Urine route
  • c: Bladder
  • d: Unlabelled mixed route
Answer: Which route must remain in vessels? → Blood route; Which route passes through ureter? → Urine route; Which organ stores urine? → Bladder

Which route must remain in vessels: Blood route. Which route passes through ureter: Urine route. Which organ stores urine: Bladder.

5B · Open ended

Propose both routes with enough labels to avoid mixing blood and urine.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw blood vessel→kidney→blood vessel. Separately draw kidney→ureter→bladder→urethra for urine.

  1. Gives a correct blood-through-kidney route remaining in vessels.
  2. Gives the correctly ordered urine route.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.6 · Nutrition

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Different roles

Example information

A model labels protein for tissue building, carbohydrate for energy and water for transport.

Question: Which is needed even though it supplies no food energy?

Answer: Water.

Why: A nutrient’s importance is not determined only by energy value.

Example 2 · Compare equal servings
Compare equal servings
LabelShown amountNutrient-X units
A50 g4
B100 g6

Example information

Fictional label A has 4 nutrient-X units per 50 g; B has 6 per 100 g.

Question: Which has more per 100 g?

Answer: A has 8 units per 100 g, compared with B’s 6.

Why: Double A’s quantity before comparing; this does not judge the foods’ complete nutritional value.

Example 3 · A claim that goes too far

Example information

An advertisement says one snack supplies every person’s complete needs for life. It provides no full nutrient evidence.

Question: Why is the claim unreliable?

Answer: It ignores varied needs and lacks sufficient evidence.

Why: A single broad promise cannot replace information about a complete diet and individual circumstances.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Nutrient role cards

Fixed scientific information

The reference describes protein in tissue building/repair, carbohydrate as an energy source and water in transport. These are selected roles, not the only roles.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which card concerns tissue building?” → “Protein”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which card concerns tissue building: Protein. Which card names an energy source: Carbohydrate. Which card names a non-energy transport need: Water.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Make a varied model

Fixed scientific information

Menu A contains several food groups. B contains only one snack. C is a list of packaging colours, not foods or nutrients.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which menu illustrates variety?

  • a: Menu A
  • b: Menu B
  • c: List C
  • d: Colour guarantees balance
Answer: Menu A

Which menu illustrates variety: Menu A. Which has only one food: Menu B. Which is not nutritional information: List C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Serving calculation

Fixed scientific information

A fictional label gives 5 units of nutrient X per model serving. Two equal servings are used; no other food is counted.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many X units are in two servings?; How many are in one serving?; What quantity was doubled?

  • a: 10 units
  • b: 5 units
  • c: Number of servings
  • d: 7 units
Answer: How many X units are in two servings? → 10 units; How many are in one serving? → 5 units; What quantity was doubled? → Number of servings

How many X units are in two servings: 10 units. How many are in one serving: 5 units. What quantity was doubled: Number of servings.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Source choices

Fixed scientific information

A provides a clear label and quantity; B promises a universal cure without a method; C describes nutrient roles with stated limits.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which source allows a quantity comparison? → Source A
  • b: Which source makes an unsupported cure promise? → Source B
  • c: Which source allows a quantity comparison? → Source C
  • d: Which source gives bounded educational information? → Every advert is evidence
Answer: Which source allows a quantity comparison? → Source A; Which source makes an unsupported cure promise? → Source B

Which source allows a quantity comparison: Source A. Which source makes an unsupported cure promise: Source B. Which source gives bounded educational information: Source C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A fair label comparison

Fixed scientific information

Label A gives a nutrient amount per 25 g and B gives it per 100 g. A learner compares the printed numbers without converting.

F5 · Open ended

Identify the comparison problem and describe a fair method.

Example of a full-credit answer: The numbers refer to different food quantities. Convert both to the same amount, such as 100 g, before comparing.

  1. Identifies unequal reference quantities.
  2. Proposes conversion to the same amount.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Fictional product P has 3 nutrient-X units per 50 g. Q has 5 per 100 g. Compare only X per 100 g, not overall diet quality.

1A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “How many X units does P have per 100 g?” → “5 units”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

How many X units does P have per 100 g: 6 units. How many does Q have per 100 g: 5 units. Which has more X per 100 g: Product P.

1B · Open ended

Compare the equal quantities and state one limit of the conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: P has 6 versus Q’s 5 units per 100 g. This compares only nutrient X and does not establish which food or diet is best for every person.

  1. Correctly calculates and compares 6 versus 5 units.
  2. Limits the conclusion to X/equal quantity rather than overall personal nutrition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A explains several nutrient roles and food variety. B claims one food replaces all meals. C ranks students by body shape.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which display is suitable nutrition education? → Display A
  • b: Which makes an unsupported complete-replacement claim? → Display B
  • c: Which display is suitable nutrition education? → Display C
  • d: Which judges people rather than nutrition evidence? → All are equally useful
Answer: Which display is suitable nutrition education? → Display A; Which makes an unsupported complete-replacement claim? → Display B

Which display is suitable nutrition education: Display A. Which makes an unsupported complete-replacement claim: Display B. Which judges people rather than nutrition evidence: Display C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A using its scientific content and explain why it should acknowledge different needs.

Example of a full-credit answer: A includes different nutrient roles and variety. People’s needs and circumstances differ, so one fixed menu is not suitable for everyone.

  1. Identifies accurate roles/variety as a strength.
  2. Recognises differing individual needs or circumstances.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A school card must compare two fictional drinks. Their labels use different serving sizes; no allergies or personal needs are known.

3A · Hotspot

What must be matched first?

  • a: Serving quantity
  • b: Listed nutrient amounts
  • c: Individual suitability
  • d: One universal recommendation
Answer: Serving quantity

What must be matched first: Serving quantity. What can the labels establish: Listed nutrient amounts. What remains unknown: Individual suitability.

3B · Open ended

Describe how to compare the labels and why you cannot prescribe one drink to every learner.

Example of a full-credit answer: Convert to equal quantities and compare the listed nutrients. Individual needs and other information are missing, so the label comparison is not a universal prescription.

  1. Uses equal quantities for the comparison.
  2. Explains missing individual information prevents universal advice.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Water gives no food energy, so the body does not need it.” The reference describes water in transport and chemical processes.

4A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the scientific correction?; Which role does the reference name?; Which statement is the learner’s mistaken assumption?

  • a: Water is still needed
  • b: Transport
  • c: All biological functions
  • d: Only energy matters
Answer: What is the scientific correction? → Water is still needed; Which role does the reference name? → Transport; Which statement is the learner’s mistaken assumption? → Only energy matters

Water remains necessary and supports transport. The learner’s mistake is assuming “Only energy matters”.

4B · Short answer

Identify the reasoning error and name a useful role of water.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner assumes energy is the only reason a substance matters. Water is needed for transport and many body processes.

  1. Rejects energy as the sole measure of usefulness.
  2. Names a correct water function.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

The lesson must teach equal-quantity comparisons and avoid universal diet promises. Use fictional labels, not personal weight goals.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which activity teaches a fair comparison?; Which note limits the scope of the measured nutrient comparison?; Which feature respects different needs?

  • a: Convert serving amounts
  • b: Only listed nutrients compared
  • c: No universal prescription
  • d: Rank classmates by size
Answer: Which activity teaches a fair comparison? → Convert serving amounts; Which note limits the scope of the measured nutrient comparison? → Only listed nutrients compared; Which feature respects different needs? → No universal prescription

Which activity teaches a fair comparison: Convert serving amounts. Which note limits the conclusion: Only listed nutrients compared. Which feature respects different needs: No universal prescription.

5B · Open ended

Propose a label-comparison activity and a clear limitation note.

Example of a full-credit answer: Give labels with different serving amounts and ask learners to convert both to 100 g. State that the result compares selected nutrients only and does not prescribe an individual diet.

  1. Proposes equal-quantity label comparison.
  2. Includes a valid limit about selected nutrients/individual needs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.7 · Disease

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A symptom is not a diagnosis

Example information

A fictional card lists tiredness without other information. Several conditions can cause tiredness.

Question: Can the class identify one disease from this card?

Answer: No.

Why: The evidence is insufficient; a classroom activity is not a diagnostic assessment.

Example 2 · Compare rates fairly
Compare rates fairly
GroupCasesPeople
A420
B880

Example information

Fictional records show 4 cases among 20 people in A and 8 among 80 in B.

Question: Which has the larger recorded fraction?

Answer: A: 4/20=20%; B: 8/80=10%.

Why: Counts alone would hide the different group sizes. These are imaginary data.

Example 3 · Risk is not a promise

Example information

A research summary says an exposure increases the chance of a condition.

Question: Does that mean every exposed person develops it?

Answer: No.

Why: An increased probability is different from certainty for every individual.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Kinds of health information

Fixed scientific information

A describes a symptom someone feels, B reports a measured test result, and C states a diagnosis made after professional evaluation.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which is the experienced symptom? → Card A
  • b: Which is a measurement? → Card B
  • c: Which is the experienced symptom? → Card C
  • d: Which is a professional conclusion? → All cards prove the same thing
Answer: Which is the experienced symptom? → Card A; Which is a measurement? → Card B

Which is the experienced symptom: Card A. Which is a measurement: Card B. Which is a professional conclusion: Card C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Classifying disease ideas

Fixed scientific information

A reference distinguishes infection involving a pathogen, non-communicable disease not passed directly between people, and risk as likelihood rather than certainty.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which term refers to pathogen involvement?” → “Infection”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which term refers to pathogen involvement: Infection. Which term means likelihood: Risk. Which category is not directly caught from another person: Non-communicable disease.

Scientific explorer: health lab

F3 · Fictional group record

Fixed scientific information

Group A has 3 cases among 30 people; B has 6 among 30; C has 0 among 30 during the same fictional interval.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which group has the most recorded cases?

  • a: Group B
  • b: Group A
  • c: Group C
  • d: C can never have illness
Answer: Group B

Which group has the most recorded cases: Group B. Which has three cases: Group A. Which has no recorded cases in that interval: Group C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Evidence boundaries

Fixed scientific information

Source A reports a comparison and its limitations. B gives one story as proof of every cause. C says a health professional should assess individual concerns.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which source describes research limits?; Which overgeneralises from one story?; Which addresses individual evaluation appropriately?

  • a: Source A
  • b: Source B
  • c: Source C
  • d: No evaluation is needed
Answer: Which source describes research limits? → Source A; Which overgeneralises from one story? → Source B; Which addresses individual evaluation appropriately? → Source C

Which source describes research limits: Source A. Which overgeneralises from one story: Source B. Which addresses individual evaluation appropriately: Source C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A claim from one story

Fixed scientific information

A fictional learner felt better after trying a new routine and concludes the routine cures every disease. No comparison or diagnosis was made.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the cure claim is unsupported and name one kind of evidence needed to investigate it.

Example of a full-credit answer: One improvement can have several causes and cannot establish a cure for all diseases. A suitable controlled comparison with clear outcomes and qualified oversight would be needed.

  1. Rejects the broad causal/cure claim from one anecdote.
  2. Identifies relevant comparative research or measured evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Fictional group P records 5 cases among 25 people; Q records 6 among 60. Both use the same case definition and interval.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is P’s recorded fraction? → 20%
  • b: What is Q’s recorded fraction? → 10%
  • c: What is P’s recorded fraction? → Group P
  • d: Which group has the higher recorded fraction? → Q must have higher risk from count alone
Answer: What is P’s recorded fraction? → 20%; What is Q’s recorded fraction? → 10%

What is P’s recorded fraction: 20%. What is Q’s recorded fraction: 10%. Which group has the higher recorded fraction: Group P.

1B · Short answer

Compare the fractions and explain why raw case counts alone are misleading here.

Example of a full-credit answer: P is 5/25=20%, Q is 6/60=10%. The denominators differ, so the larger raw count does not mean the larger proportion.

  1. Correctly calculates/compares 20% and 10%.
  2. Explains the importance of different group sizes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says the fictional data show a group difference but not its cause. B blames one unmeasured factor. C diagnoses every person from a group average.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which conclusion matches the evidence limit?; Which invents a cause?; Which misuses a group average?

  • a: Conclusion A
  • b: Conclusion B
  • c: Conclusion C
  • d: All conclusions are justified
Answer: Which conclusion matches the evidence limit? → Conclusion A; Which invents a cause? → Conclusion B; Which misuses a group average? → Conclusion C

Which conclusion matches the evidence limit: Conclusion A. Which invents a cause: Conclusion B. Which misuses a group average: Conclusion C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and identify information needed before making a cause claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: A stays within the observed comparison. Other exposures, comparable groups, timing or a suitable study design would be needed to investigate cause.

  1. Explains why the observed difference alone does not establish cause.
  2. Names relevant additional evidence/design information.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A poster will explain disease categories to children. It must avoid diagnosing classmates, revealing health details or promising that one habit prevents all disease.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which content is appropriate?; Which data protect privacy?; Which route is appropriate for personal concerns?

  • a: General scientific categories
  • b: Fictional anonymous examples
  • c: Trusted adult and professional
  • d: Classmate diagnosis list
Answer: Which content is appropriate? → General scientific categories; Which data protect privacy? → Fictional anonymous examples; Which route is appropriate for personal concerns? → Trusted adult and professional

Which content is appropriate: General scientific categories. Which data protect privacy: Fictional anonymous examples. Which route is appropriate for personal concerns: Trusted adult and professional.

3B · Short answer

Explain how the poster can be informative while respecting privacy and medical limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use general concepts and fictional anonymous examples. Direct individual concerns to trusted adults or qualified professionals instead of diagnosing anyone.

  1. Uses general/fictional information to protect privacy.
  2. Acknowledges individual medical-evaluation limits.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A student writes “If a factor increases risk, every exposed person becomes ill.” The reference defines risk as likelihood, with outcomes varying.

4A · Multiple choice

What does risk describe?

  • a: Likelihood
  • b: Certainty
  • c: Different outcomes
  • d: One guaranteed outcome
Answer: Likelihood

What does risk describe: Likelihood. What does the student incorrectly assume: Certainty. What can happen among exposed people: Different outcomes.

4B · Open ended

Correct the statement and explain the distinction between group risk and an individual outcome.

Example of a full-credit answer: An increased risk means illness is more likely in a group under stated conditions. It does not guarantee what happens to each individual.

  1. Replaces certainty with increased likelihood.
  2. Distinguishes group patterns from guaranteed individual outcomes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A school card must state a health claim, describe its evidence and give a limitation. It uses a fictional study and offers no treatment instructions.

5A · Hotspot

What should explain how evidence was obtained?

  • a: Method summary
  • b: Outcome summary
  • c: Limitation note
  • d: Universal cure promise
Answer: Method summary

What should explain how evidence was obtained: Method summary. What should report the measured result: Outcome summary. What should prevent overclaiming: Limitation note.

5B · Open ended

Propose what evidence the card should report and one clear limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Report the groups, measurement and comparison outcome. State that a fictional group pattern cannot diagnose an individual or establish every possible cause.

  1. Includes relevant method/comparison/outcome information.
  2. States an appropriate limit on causal or individual claims.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.8 · Infectious disease

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Vector or pathogen?

Example information

A fictional diagram shows a mosquito carrying a microscopic disease-causing agent.

Question: Which is the vector?

Answer: The mosquito.

Why: The vector carries the agent; it is not identical to the pathogen.

Example 2 · Count events, not illness
Count events, not illness
Model conditionExposure events
Before18
After fictional 50% reduction9

Example information

A toy model starts with 18 exposure events. A fictional measure reduces these by half.

Question: How many events remain, and what do they represent?

Answer: 9 exposure events remain.

Why: These are opportunities for exposure, not nine confirmed infections.

Example 3 · Choose a route-specific question

Example information

An example concerns unsafe drinking water, but a proposed investigation measures only room ventilation.

Question: Does that measure directly address the stated pathway?

Answer: No.

Why: The evidence and preventive action should match the route being studied.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Agent and route cards

Fixed scientific information

The example labels a microscopic agent as pathogen, the carrying mosquito as vector and the person receiving exposure as host.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which term names the disease-causing agent?” → “Pathogen”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which term names the disease-causing agent: Pathogen. Which term names the mosquito carrier: Vector. Which term names the exposed organism: Host.

Scientific explorer: health lab

F2 · Different routes

Fixed scientific information

A describes inhalation of infectious particles; B describes contaminated water; C describes a vector carrying an agent. The diagrams concern different example diseases.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which card represents an air route? → Card A
  • b: Which represents a water route? → Card B
  • c: Which card represents an air route? → Card C
  • d: Which represents a vector route? → All infections share one route
Answer: Which card represents an air route? → Card A; Which represents a water route? → Card B

Which card represents an air route: Card A. Which represents a water route: Card B. Which represents a vector route: Card C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · A toy exposure calculation

Fixed scientific information

The fictional model starts with 40 exposure events. Its chosen measure removes 25% of those events, or 10 events.

F3 · Hotspot

How many events remain?

  • a: 30 events
  • b: 10 events
  • c: Exposure opportunities
  • d: 30 confirmed illnesses
Answer: 30 events

How many events remain: 30 events. How many are removed: 10 events. What did the starting count represent: Exposure opportunities.

Scientific explorer: health lab

F4 · Evidence and care

Fixed scientific information

A virtual model explores assumed transmission. A laboratory test measures a sample. A professional evaluation considers individual evidence. These roles differ.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which uses an assumed teaching rule?; Which measures a biological sample?; Which considers an individual’s circumstances?

  • a: Virtual model
  • b: Laboratory test
  • c: Professional evaluation
  • d: Classroom game as diagnosis
Answer: Which uses an assumed teaching rule? → Virtual model; Which measures a biological sample? → Laboratory test; Which considers an individual’s circumstances? → Professional evaluation

Which uses an assumed teaching rule: Virtual model. Which measures a biological sample: Laboratory test. Which considers an individual’s circumstances: Professional evaluation.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · One measure is not universal

Fixed scientific information

A learner says improving drinking-water safety will stop every infectious disease. The source includes air, water and vector routes.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the claim is too broad and name one other route it does not directly address.

Example of a full-credit answer: Safer water addresses a water pathway, but infections can use other routes such as air or vectors. It cannot guarantee prevention of every infection.

  1. Rejects the universal guarantee and limits the water measure to relevant pathways.
  2. Names another valid route such as air or vector transmission.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: health lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional exposure model begins with 60 events. A selected measure removes one third of them. It does not calculate infection probability after exposure.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many events are removed?; How many remain?; What outcome is not calculated?

  • a: 20 events
  • b: 40 events
  • c: Confirmed infections
  • d: 60 starting exposure events
Answer: How many events are removed? → 20 events; How many remain? → 40 events; What outcome is not calculated? → Confirmed infections

How many events are removed: 20 events. How many remain: 40 events. What outcome is not calculated: Confirmed infections.

1B · Open ended

Calculate remaining events and explain why the result is not an illness forecast.

Example of a full-credit answer: 60−20=40 exposure events remain. The model does not calculate whether exposed people become infected or ill.

  1. Calculates 40 remaining events.
  2. Distinguishes exposure events from confirmed infection/illness.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

Example A concerns mosquito breeding water. Plan A removes suitable standing-water breeding sites safely with adult/community action. Plan B only changes poster colours. Plan C guarantees zero disease without evidence.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan addresses the stated vector pathway?; Which only changes appearance?; Which makes an unsupported guarantee?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: Every plan is equivalent
Answer: Which plan addresses the stated vector pathway? → Plan A; Which only changes appearance? → Plan B; Which makes an unsupported guarantee? → Plan C

Which plan addresses the stated vector pathway: Plan A. Which only changes appearance: Plan B. Which makes an unsupported guarantee: Plan C.

2B · Short answer

Justify the route-matched plan and state why it is not a guarantee of zero illness.

Example of a full-credit answer: Reducing breeding sites addresses the mosquito vector pathway. Other exposures and factors remain, so the action reduces risk rather than guaranteeing zero disease.

  1. Connects breeding-site reduction to the vector pathway.
  2. Rejects absolute protection and notes remaining factors/routes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional investigation changes from an air-transmission example to an unsafe-water example. The new question concerns water quality and access to safe water.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What should the new evidence measure?; What should prevention address?; What must not be assumed unchanged?

  • a: Water-related conditions
  • b: The water pathway
  • c: Transmission route
  • d: Air controls answer every question
Answer: What should the new evidence measure? → Water-related conditions; What should prevention address? → The water pathway; What must not be assumed unchanged? → Transmission route

What should the new evidence measure: Water-related conditions. What should prevention address: The water pathway. What must not be assumed unchanged: Transmission route.

3B · Open ended

Explain what must change in the investigation and why the old air-route conclusion cannot simply be copied.

Example of a full-credit answer: Measure the water pathway and relevant prevention. Different transmission routes require different evidence, so an air-model result does not automatically answer a water question.

  1. Identifies water-relevant evidence or prevention.
  2. Explains the limit of transferring a result across different routes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A student says “Our simulation showed 12 exposure events, so 12 people have a disease.” The simulation only counts possible exposure events and can count several events for one person.

4A · Multiple choice

What did the reported total of 12 specifically count?

  • a: Exposure events
  • b: Confirmed infections
  • c: Distinct ill people
  • d: Laboratory diagnoses
Answer: Exposure events

What did the model count: Exposure events. What did it not establish: Disease diagnoses. What can happen to one person in the count: Repeated events.

4B · Short answer

Identify two reasons the student’s conclusion does not follow.

Example of a full-credit answer: Exposure does not guarantee infection or illness, and several events can involve the same person. The model provides no diagnoses.

  1. Explains that exposure is not a confirmed illness.
  2. Explains that event counts need not equal numbers of people.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

The display must name a transmission route, show one matching preventive action and avoid treatment instructions or promises of perfect protection.

5A · True or false

True or false: the display may promise perfect protection from every infectious disease.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

False. The source requires a route-matched action and a clear limit, not a guarantee of perfect protection.

5B · Open ended

Propose a route-matched action and a limitation to place beside it.

Example of a full-credit answer: For a water pathway, improve access to verified safe water and monitor relevant quality information. State that this addresses that pathway and does not prevent every infection.

  1. Gives a scientifically matched route/action pair.
  2. Includes an appropriate limitation without a universal guarantee.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.9 · Non-communicable disease

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Direct transmission?

Example information

A reference card says diabetes is a non-communicable condition.

Question: Can ordinary classroom contact directly transmit diabetes?

Answer: No.

Why: This condition is not spread between classmates like a communicable infection.

Example 2 · Same fraction, different counts
Same fraction, different counts
GroupCasesPeople
A660
B12120

Example information

Fictional group A has 6 cases among 60 people; B has 12 among 120.

Question: Which has the larger fraction?

Answer: They are equal at 10%.

Why: Divide by the group size before comparing.

Example 3 · An environmental measure

Example information

A proposal improves air quality around a school. It claims to reduce a risk, not remove every cause of illness.

Question: Why is the limited wording more scientific?

Answer: It matches one addressed factor without promising a universal outcome.

Why: Many factors influence non-communicable conditions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Definitions and limits

Fixed scientific information

Non-communicable means not directly spread between people. Risk means likelihood. Prevention aims to reduce chance or harm, not promise certainty.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which term means likelihood?” → “Non-communicable”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which term means likelihood: Risk. Which category is not directly transmitted: Non-communicable. Which activity aims to reduce chance or harm: Prevention.

Scientific explorer: health lab

F2 · Different influences

Fixed scientific information

Card A describes inherited influences, B describes air pollution, and C describes access to health services. Each may affect health in different ways.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which card describes air pollution as an environmental exposure?

  • a: Card B
  • b: Card A
  • c: Card C
  • d: Only one influence exists
Answer: Card B

Which card concerns environment: Card B. Which concerns inherited influences: Card A. Which concerns access to care: Card C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Fictional proportions

Fixed scientific information

A has 4 cases among 40 people, B has 8 among 80, and both use the same definition and interval.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is A’s fraction?; How do the fractions compare?; Which group is larger?

  • a: 10%
  • b: They are equal
  • c: Group B
  • d: B has twice the fraction
Answer: What is A’s fraction? → 10%; How do the fractions compare? → They are equal; Which group is larger? → Group B

What is A’s fraction: 10%. How do the fractions compare: They are equal. Which group is larger: Group B.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Responsible messages

Fixed scientific information

A says reduce a known risk. B promises no future disease. C blames every person who becomes ill.

F4 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which message is appropriately limited?; Which promises certainty?; Which unfairly blames people?

  • a: Message A
  • b: Message B
  • c: Message C
  • d: All are evidence-based
Answer: Which message is appropriately limited? → Message A; Which promises certainty? → Message B; Which unfairly blames people? → Message C

Which message is appropriately limited: Message A. Which promises certainty: Message B. Which unfairly blames people: Message C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A prevention guarantee

Fixed scientific information

A poster says “Cleaner air means no one can ever have a non-communicable disease.” The reference says many factors can contribute.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the guarantee and name another category of influence that may matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cleaner air can reduce an environmental risk, not eliminate every disease. Inherited factors, age, other exposures or access to care may also matter.

  1. Limits the cleaner-air claim to risk reduction.
  2. Names another valid contributing influence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: health lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Fictional group P has 9 cases among 90 people; Q has 8 among 40. The same definition and period are used.

1A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is P’s proportion?; What is Q’s proportion?; Which has the higher recorded proportion?

  • a: 10%
  • b: 20%
  • c: Group Q
  • d: P is higher because 9 exceeds 8
Answer: What is P’s proportion? → 10%; What is Q’s proportion? → 20%; Which has the higher recorded proportion? → Group Q

What is P’s proportion: 10%. What is Q’s proportion: 20%. Which has the higher recorded proportion: Group Q.

1B · Short answer

Compare the proportions and explain why counts alone reverse the impression.

Example of a full-credit answer: P is 10% and Q is 20%. P’s larger population gives a larger count despite a smaller proportion.

  1. Correctly calculates/compares 10% and 20%.
  2. Explains the denominator/group-size issue.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A includes several influences and acknowledges limits. B says one food prevents every condition. C says a risk factor guarantees illness.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which explanation fits complex causes? → Explanation A
  • b: Which makes a universal food claim? → Explanation B
  • c: Which explanation fits complex causes? → Explanation C
  • d: Which confuses risk with certainty? → Every claim is justified
Answer: Which explanation fits complex causes? → Explanation A; Which makes a universal food claim? → Explanation B

Which explanation fits complex causes: Explanation A. Which makes a universal food claim: Explanation B. Which confuses risk with certainty: Explanation C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and explain why one-factor guarantees are unreliable.

Example of a full-credit answer: A recognises several interacting influences. One factor does not account for all causes or individual outcomes, so guarantees exceed the evidence.

  1. Identifies multiple influences as a strength.
  2. Explains why one factor cannot guarantee every outcome.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A school proposes a smoke-free entrance and clearer health information. It does not collect pupils’ diagnoses or prescribe treatment.

3A · Multiple choice

Which factor does the entrance policy address?

  • a: Environmental exposure
  • b: Clear health information
  • c: Individual treatment
  • d: All disease eliminated
Answer: Environmental exposure

Which factor does the entrance policy address: Environmental exposure. Which activity improves understanding: Clear health information. What remains outside the classroom plan: Individual treatment.

3B · Short answer

Explain one potential benefit and one limit of this plan.

Example of a full-credit answer: The plan may reduce harmful exposure and improve understanding. It does not eliminate every cause of disease or replace individual care.

  1. Identifies a plausible stated environmental/information benefit.
  2. States a valid limit on prevention or individual care.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “A classmate has a non-communicable disease, so we will catch it by sitting nearby.” The reference defines the category as not directly transmitted between people.

4A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which correction fits the definition?; Which idea caused the error?; Which response is appropriate?

  • a: Ordinary contact does not transmit it
  • b: Confusing disease categories
  • c: Respectful inclusion
  • d: Avoid the classmate
Answer: Which correction fits the definition? → Ordinary contact does not transmit it; Which idea caused the error? → Confusing disease categories; Which response is appropriate? → Respectful inclusion

Which correction fits the definition: Ordinary contact does not transmit it. Which idea caused the error: Confusing disease categories. Which response is appropriate: Respectful inclusion.

4B · Open ended

Correct the scientific mistake and propose a respectful classroom response.

Example of a full-credit answer: A non-communicable condition is not directly caught by sitting nearby. Include the classmate and respect their privacy rather than avoiding or blaming them.

  1. Corrects the transmission misconception.
  2. Proposes respectful inclusion/privacy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A message must describe one environmental risk reduction and clearly state a limitation. It must avoid personal medical advice or blame.

5A · Hotspot

Which specific target should the risk-reduction action name?

  • a: The addressed risk factor
  • b: A universal guarantee
  • c: Privacy and different needs
  • d: Diagnosis from a poster
Answer: The addressed risk factor

What should be named: The addressed risk factor. What should be avoided: A universal guarantee. What should be respected: Privacy and different needs.

5B · Open ended

Write a message that includes an action and a scientifically accurate limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cleaner air can reduce harmful exposure for the community. It does not remove every disease risk, and personal concerns still need qualified guidance.

  1. States a plausible risk-reduction action.
  2. Includes a correct limitation without blame or universal protection.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.10 · Disease prevention

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Match the pathway

Example information

A fictional scenario concerns a water-related exposure. The choices are safer water access or brighter classroom wall paint.

Question: Which action directly addresses the stated pathway?

Answer: Safer water access.

Why: It acts on the relevant route; wall colour does not.

Example 2 · Successive toy reductions
Successive toy reductions
StepExposure events
Start32
After first half16
After second half8

Example information

A fictional model has 32 exposure events. One measure halves them; a second halves the remainder.

Question: How many remain?

Answer: 8 events.

Why: 32→16→8. The model is not a real disease forecast.

Example 3 · Measure whether access works

Example information

A school installs a handwashing station but records that it lacks water on several days.

Question: Why count usable days rather than installed stations alone?

Answer: A station must function to provide access.

Why: Implementation evidence matters as well as the number of objects installed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Different prevention routes

Fixed scientific information

The reference matches safer water with water-related exposure, ventilation with air exchange and vaccination with immune preparation.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which action concerns immune preparation?” → “Vaccination”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which action concerns immune preparation: Vaccination. Which concerns water access: Safer water. Which concerns air exchange: Ventilation.

Scientific explorer: health lab

F2 · Plan components

Fixed scientific information

A plan names its action, measures whether it is available and states remaining uncertainties.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which component says what will be done?; Which checks whether it is available?; Which prevents overclaiming?

  • a: Action
  • b: Access indicator
  • c: Limitation
  • d: Universal guarantee
Answer: Which component says what will be done? → Action; Which checks whether it is available? → Access indicator; Which prevents overclaiming? → Limitation

Which component says what will be done: Action. Which checks whether it is available: Access indicator. Which prevents overclaiming: Limitation.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · A toy layered model

Fixed scientific information

The model begins with 24 exposure events. A first measure halves them to 12; a second removes 3 of the remaining events.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: How many remain after both steps? → 9 events
  • b: How many remain after the first step? → 12 events
  • c: How many remain after both steps? → 3 events
  • d: How many does the second step remove? → 0 events guaranteed
Answer: How many remain after both steps? → 9 events; How many remain after the first step? → 12 events

How many remain after both steps: 9 events. How many remain after the first step: 12 events. How many does the second step remove: 3 events.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Safe investigation choices

Fixed scientific information

A uses virtual data. B reviews anonymous records with permission. C deliberately exposes pupils to a harmful agent. Only safe approaches are allowed.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which approach uses simulated information?; Which uses appropriately protected existing information?; Which approach is unacceptable?

  • a: Approach A
  • b: Approach B
  • c: Approach C
  • d: Approach D: draw a labelled organ diagram
Answer: Which approach uses simulated information? → Approach A; Which uses appropriately protected existing information? → Approach B; Which approach is unacceptable? → Approach C

Which approach uses simulated information: Approach A. Which uses appropriately protected existing information: Approach B. Which approach is unacceptable: Approach C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · An installed but unusable station

Fixed scientific information

A fictional school counts five handwashing stations, but only two have water and soap on the observation day.

F5 · Open ended

State a more useful access measure and explain why the total installed count is incomplete.

Example of a full-credit answer: Count the stations that are usable with water and soap: two that day. Installed stations without these supplies do not provide the intended access.

  1. Identifies usable stations with required supplies, giving 2 if calculating.
  2. Explains why installed count alone overstates functional access.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy model begins with 40 exposure events. Measure A removes 10, then B removes half of the remaining events.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many remain after A?; How many remain after B?; What is the total removed?

  • a: 30 events
  • b: 15 events
  • c: 25 events
  • d: Half of the original after B
Answer: How many remain after A? → 30 events; How many remain after B? → 15 events; What is the total removed? → 25 events

How many remain after A: 30 events. How many remain after B: 15 events. What is the total removed: 25 events.

1B · Open ended

Show the two-step calculation and name the model’s main limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: 40−10=30, then 30÷2=15 remain. These are fictional event-reduction assumptions, not predicted illnesses or a real intervention’s effectiveness.

  1. Correctly calculates 15 through the two stated steps.
  2. States the fictional/non-predictive nature of the model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A checks whether every station has water and soap each day. B counts buildings only. C promises no illness after installing a sign.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan checks usable access?; Which measures a less relevant total?; Which makes an unsupported promise?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: None of these plans
Answer: Which plan checks usable access? → Plan A; Which measures a less relevant total? → Plan B; Which makes an unsupported promise? → Plan C

Which plan checks usable access: Plan A. Which measures a less relevant total: Plan B. Which makes an unsupported promise: Plan C.

2B · Short answer

Justify Plan A and name an additional useful check.

Example of a full-credit answer: It measures whether the facility can actually be used. Also check accessibility, maintenance or whether supplies remain available over time.

  1. Connects water/soap checks to functional access.
  2. Names a relevant additional implementation measure.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A plan shifts from water safety to indoor air quality. Relevant questions now concern air exchange, pollutant sources and appropriate local guidance.

3A · Multiple choice

Which exposure category is the revised plan addressing?

  • a: Air-related exposure
  • b: Water-related exposure
  • c: Vector-borne exposure
  • d: Food-related exposure
Answer: Air-related exposure

Which pathway is now central: Air-related exposure. Which feature may need measurement: Air exchange. What should guide the plan: Relevant professional guidance.

3B · Open ended

Explain one change needed in the evidence and why the previous water plan cannot simply be copied.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use measures relevant to air exchange or pollutant sources. The pathway differs, so water-specific evidence does not establish an air measure’s effect.

  1. Names an air-relevant measurement or action.
  2. Explains route-specific limits of transfer.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says two successive 50% reductions remove all 100 starting events. The rule halves the remaining events each time.

4A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many remain after the first step?; How many remain after the second?; What total percentage was removed?

  • a: 50 events
  • b: 25 events
  • c: 75%
  • d: 100% removed
Answer: How many remain after the first step? → 50 events; How many remain after the second? → 25 events; What total percentage was removed? → 75%

How many remain after the first step: 50 events. How many remain after the second: 25 events. What total percentage was removed: 75%.

4B · Short answer

Identify the error and give the correct two-step result.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner added percentages that apply to different bases. 100→50→25 remain, so 75% are removed in the toy model.

  1. Identifies the changing-base/addition error.
  2. Gives 25 remaining or 75% removed with correct reasoning.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

The chosen school problem is unreliable access to handwashing supplies. The plan must improve access and measure it without gathering pupils’ private diagnoses.

5A · Hotspot

What action fits the problem?

  • a: Maintain water and soap
  • b: Usable station-days
  • c: Private diagnoses
  • d: Unverified health promises
Answer: Maintain water and soap

What action fits the problem: Maintain water and soap. What indicator fits the action: Usable station-days. What information is unnecessary for this indicator: Private diagnoses.

5B · Open ended

Propose the action and a practical way to check it over time.

Example of a full-credit answer: Assign routine replenishment of water and soap and check accessibility. Record usable station-days each week to see whether access becomes more reliable.

  1. Proposes maintenance/replenishment that addresses the stated access problem.
  2. Proposes a repeated, relevant access indicator.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.11 · Vaccination

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Recognising a target

Example information

A model shows immune memory recognising target A more quickly after preparation. Target B has a different shape.

Question: Does this demonstrate equal protection against every target?

Answer: No. The model concerns the matching target A.

Why: Specific recognition differs from a universal defence against every possible agent.

Example 2 · Read the measured outcome
Read the measured outcome
Study fieldWhat it says
MeasuredSevere cases
Not establishedZero infections

Example information

A fictional study reports fewer severe cases in one group but does not measure every infection.

Question: Can its result prove that no infections occurred?

Answer: No.

Why: The measured outcome is severe disease, not all infections.

Example 3 · One case is not the whole pattern

Example information

A vaccinated person develops the target illness. A learner claims this one event proves no vaccine benefit exists.

Question: What is missing from that reasoning?

Answer: A fair comparison of outcomes across groups.

Why: Risk reduction can coexist with some cases; individual examples cannot estimate the group benefit alone.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Immune-preparation roles

Fixed scientific information

The model labels a target cue, an immune response and memory retained for a later matching encounter.

F1 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which feature helps a later matching response?; Which feature is recognised?; Which feature acts after recognition?

  • a: Immune memory
  • b: Target cue
  • c: Immune response
  • d: An antibiotic for every virus
Answer: Which feature helps a later matching response? → Immune memory; Which feature is recognised? → Target cue; Which feature acts after recognition? → Immune response

Which feature helps a later matching response: Immune memory. Which feature is recognised: Target cue. Which feature acts after recognition: Immune response.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Different health tools

Fixed scientific information

A vaccine prepares immune recognition. Certain antibiotics treat certain bacterial infections. A diagnosis evaluates an individual condition. These are distinct roles.

F2 · Hotspot

Which tool prepares immune recognition?

  • a: Vaccine
  • b: Antibiotic
  • c: Diagnosis
  • d: One tool does every job
Answer: Vaccine

Which tool prepares immune recognition: Vaccine. Which can treat certain bacterial infections: Antibiotic. Which evaluates a person’s condition: Diagnosis.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · A fictional response chart

Fixed scientific information

A teaching chart labels first encounter, memory formation and later matching encounter. It makes no claim about a real time or dose.

F3 · True or false

True or false: this model places memory formation before the first encounter.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

False. The supplied order is first encounter, then memory formation, then a later matching encounter.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Bounded claims

Fixed scientific information

A says protection can reduce risk. B says no vaccinated person can ever be ill. C says one illness case proves zero benefit.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which claim allows meaningful but imperfect protection?

  • a: Claim A
  • b: Claim B
  • c: Claim C
  • d: All three are equivalent
Answer: Claim A

Which claim allows meaningful but imperfect protection: Claim A. Which claims perfect protection: Claim B. Which overgeneralises from one case: Claim C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Outcome mismatch

Fixed scientific information

A fictional vaccine study measures severe illness over a stated period. Its summary does not measure every mild infection.

F5 · Short answer

State what the study can inform and explain why it cannot establish zero infections.

Example of a full-credit answer: It can inform comparisons of severe illness over that period. It did not measure all infections, so zero infection is not established.

  1. Identifies the studied severe-illness outcome and/or period.
  2. Explains that unmeasured infections cannot be assumed absent.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Fictional groups A and B each contain 100 people observed for the same interval and outcome. A records 4 severe cases; B records 10. Other study details are not supplied.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which group has fewer recorded severe cases?; How many fewer cases are recorded?; What is not established by these numbers alone?

  • a: Group A
  • b: 6 cases
  • c: The cause of the difference
  • d: Both groups contain 100 people
Answer: Which group has fewer recorded severe cases? → Group A; How many fewer cases are recorded? → 6 cases; What is not established by these numbers alone? → The cause of the difference

Which group has fewer recorded severe cases: Group A. How many fewer cases are recorded: 6 cases. What is not established by these numbers alone: The cause of the difference.

1B · Short answer

Compare the recorded result and state why additional study details are needed before attributing the cause.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has 6 fewer severe cases. We need details such as group comparability and assignment to assess whether a particular intervention explains the difference.

  1. Correctly compares 4 versus 10/6 fewer severe cases.
  2. Identifies missing design/comparability evidence for a causal claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A explains immune preparation and acknowledges variable protection. B promises a cure for every disease. C uses only a popularity count as evidence.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation matches vaccine principles?; Which makes a universal cure promise?; Which substitutes popularity for evidence?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All statements are equally reliable
Answer: Which explanation matches vaccine principles? → Explanation A; Which makes a universal cure promise? → Explanation B; Which substitutes popularity for evidence? → Explanation C

Which explanation matches vaccine principles: Explanation A. Which makes a universal cure promise: Explanation B. Which substitutes popularity for evidence: Explanation C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A using its mechanism and its limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: It describes preparation of immune recognition or memory and does not promise perfect protection for every person or disease.

  1. Identifies immune preparation/memory as the relevant mechanism.
  2. Identifies variable/imperfect/specific protection as an appropriate limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A model has immune memory for target P. A new target Q is different. The source gives no evidence that P memory recognises Q.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which target has established memory here? → Target P
  • b: Which target’s recognition is unknown? → Target Q
  • c: Which target has established memory here? → Relevant evidence
  • d: What is needed before claiming cross-protection? → Automatic protection against every target
Answer: Which target has established memory here? → Target P; Which target’s recognition is unknown? → Target Q

Which target has established memory here: Target P. Which target’s recognition is unknown: Target Q. What is needed before claiming cross-protection: Relevant evidence.

3B · Short answer

Explain why protection against Q cannot simply be assumed and identify the evidence question to ask.

Example of a full-credit answer: Specific recognition of P does not prove recognition of Q. Ask whether measured immune responses or appropriate studies show protection against Q.

  1. Distinguishes target-specific memory from assumed universal protection.
  2. States a relevant question about response/protection against Q.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A student writes “A vaccine either prevents every case or is useless.” The reference explains risk reduction, outcome differences and variable responses.

4A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which idea corrects the false choice?; Which evidence is needed?; Which detail matters when reading results?

  • a: Risk can be reduced without reaching zero
  • b: Fair group comparisons
  • c: The measured outcome
  • d: One case proves zero value
Answer: Which idea corrects the false choice? → Risk can be reduced without reaching zero; Which evidence is needed? → Fair group comparisons; Which detail matters when reading results? → The measured outcome

Which idea corrects the false choice: Risk can be reduced without reaching zero. Which evidence is needed: Fair group comparisons. Which detail matters when reading results: The measured outcome.

4B · Open ended

Identify the reasoning error and explain how some illness can coexist with benefit.

Example of a full-credit answer: The student treats protection as all-or-nothing. A vaccine can reduce the frequency or severity of disease even when some cases still occur.

  1. Identifies the false all-or-nothing assumption.
  2. Explains reduced frequency/severity despite nonzero cases.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A card must explain immune preparation, state a limit and direct personal decisions to qualified guidance. It must not invent doses or schedules.

5A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which explanation belongs on the card?” → “Target-related immune memory”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which explanation belongs on the card: Target-related immune memory. Which limit should be clear: Protection is not universal or absolute. Where should personal questions go: Qualified health guidance.

5B · Open ended

Write a mechanism statement and a limitation statement for the card.

Example of a full-credit answer: Vaccines help prepare immune responses and memory for particular targets. Protection varies and does not guarantee zero illness; personal decisions need qualified guidance.

  1. Accurately describes immune preparation/memory.
  2. States a specific/variable/imperfect protection limit without prescribing treatment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.12 · Public health

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Individual or population?

Example information

A clinician evaluates one person. A community team repairs shared water points used by many households.

Question: Which action most directly illustrates public-health infrastructure?

Answer: Repairing the shared water points.

Why: It changes a condition affecting a population while individual care has a different focus.

Example 2 · Equal proportions
Equal proportions
AreaUnavailableTotal
A840
B1260

Example information

Fictional area A has 8 unavailable water points out of 40; B has 12 out of 60.

Question: Which has the larger unavailable fraction?

Answer: They are equal at 20%.

Why: The totals differ because the denominators differ.

Example 3 · An average hides a gap

Example information

A district has 10 stations: 9 in one area and 1 in another equally populated area.

Question: What should planners inspect beyond the district total?

Answer: Whether both areas have usable, reachable access.

Why: A total alone does not show how the service is distributed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Public-health functions

Fixed scientific information

A monitors anonymous group patterns, B improves shared water access and C assesses one person in a clinic.

F1 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which action improves shared infrastructure?; Which tracks population patterns?; Which is individual clinical care?

  • a: Action B
  • b: Action A
  • c: Action C
  • d: All are identical tasks
Answer: Which action improves shared infrastructure? → Action B; Which tracks population patterns? → Action A; Which is individual clinical care? → Action C

Which action improves shared infrastructure: Action B. Which tracks population patterns: Action A. Which is individual clinical care: Action C.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F2 · Counts and fractions

Fixed scientific information

A fictional area has 6 unusable water points among 30. The relevant fraction is unusable divided by total.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the unusable fraction?; What is the denominator?; What is the numerator?

  • a: 20%
  • b: 30 water points
  • c: 6 unusable points
  • d: 6%
Answer: What is the unusable fraction? → 20%; What is the denominator? → 30 water points; What is the numerator? → 6 unusable points

What is the unusable fraction: 20%. What is the denominator: 30 water points. What is the numerator: 6 unusable points.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Access conditions

Fixed scientific information

Station A has water and soap and is reachable. B is installed but dry. C is behind a locked gate during the stated access hours.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which station meets the stated access conditions?

  • a: Station A
  • b: Station B
  • c: Station C
  • d: Installed means usable
Answer: Station A

Which station meets the stated access conditions: Station A. Which lacks water: Station B. Which is inaccessible at the stated time: Station C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Planning records

Fixed scientific information

A plan records baseline conditions, the repair action and follow-up usability under the same definition.

F4 · Hotspot

Which record describes the starting situation?

  • a: Baseline
  • b: Repair action
  • c: Follow-up
  • d: No measurement needed
Answer: Baseline

Which record describes the starting situation: Baseline. Which record describes the intervention: Repair action. Which record checks later conditions: Follow-up.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A missing denominator

Fixed scientific information

A headline says community P has more recorded cases than Q, but does not state how many people live in either community.

F5 · Open ended

Identify the missing information and explain why it matters for a fair comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: The population sizes are missing. More cases may reflect a larger population rather than a larger recorded fraction or rate.

  1. Identifies population/group sizes as missing.
  2. Explains the count-versus-proportion comparison problem.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: population lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Fictional area P has 18 usable stations out of 20; Q has 12 out of 20. They use the same usability definition and observation day.

1A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is P’s usable fraction?; What is Q’s usable fraction?; How many more usable stations does P have?

  • a: 90%
  • b: 60%
  • c: 6 stations
  • d: Both have equal usability
Answer: What is P’s usable fraction? → 90%; What is Q’s usable fraction? → 60%; How many more usable stations does P have? → 6 stations

What is P’s usable fraction: 90%. What is Q’s usable fraction: 60%. How many more usable stations does P have: 6 stations.

1B · Open ended

Compare the usable fractions and state one further access question planners should ask.

Example of a full-credit answer: P has 90% and Q 60% usable. Planners should also check location, reachability, population served or reliability over time.

  1. Correctly compares 90% and 60%.
  2. Names a relevant additional access/distribution question.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A counts usable station-days with a clear definition. B counts posters printed. C declares everyone healthy without measurement.

2A · Hotspot

Which indicator matches reliable station access?

  • a: Indicator A
  • b: Indicator B
  • c: Claim C
  • d: Every indicator measures access
Answer: Indicator A

Which indicator matches reliable station access: Indicator A. Which measures communication output only: Indicator B. Which has no supporting measurement: Claim C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and explain why printed-poster counts are insufficient for this goal.

Example of a full-credit answer: Usable station-days track the availability of the service. Posters do not show whether stations function or are accessible.

  1. Connects A to service reliability/access.
  2. Explains the mismatch between poster output and the access outcome.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A team changes from repairing water points to reducing a nearby air-pollution source. Relevant evidence concerns emissions, exposure and who is affected.

3A · True or false

True or false: an unchanged count of water stations directly measures the new air-pollution outcome.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

False. The indicator must match air-related exposure or pollution; water-station counts concern a different service.

3B · Open ended

Propose a relevant indicator and explain why the water-station count is insufficient.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use a suitable measure of the pollution source or exposure under consistent conditions. Water-station counts do not measure the new air-quality problem.

  1. Proposes a relevant air-pollution/source/exposure indicator.
  2. Explains the need to match indicator to the new goal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

After a fictional repair project, recorded illness falls. The season, reporting effort and several other actions also changed. A report says the repair alone caused the fall.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is justified? → The recorded count fell
  • b: What is not established? → Repair alone caused it
  • c: What is justified? → Only the repair changed
  • d: What complicates interpretation? → Every change has one proven cause
Answer: What is justified? → The recorded count fell; What is not established? → Repair alone caused it

What is justified: The recorded count fell. What is not established: Repair alone caused it. What complicates interpretation: Other changes occurred.

4B · Short answer

Identify the overclaim and name one way to strengthen evaluation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The report attributes the entire change to repairs despite other changes. Use comparable groups or stable methods and examine alternative explanations over repeated periods.

  1. Identifies unsupported sole-cause attribution/confounding.
  2. Proposes a relevant stronger comparison or method.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

One neighbourhood has fewer usable water points. A plan must improve that gap and measure whether access becomes reliable, without using identifiable health records.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which action targets the stated gap?; Which indicator fits reliability?; Which data approach protects privacy?

  • a: Repair underserved-area points
  • b: Usable station-days
  • c: Anonymous service records
  • d: Publish private diagnoses
Answer: Which action targets the stated gap? → Repair underserved-area points; Which indicator fits reliability? → Usable station-days; Which data approach protects privacy? → Anonymous service records

Which action targets the stated gap: Repair underserved-area points. Which indicator fits reliability: Usable station-days. Which data approach protects privacy: Anonymous service records.

5B · Open ended

Propose a targeted action and a privacy-respecting progress measure.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repair and maintain points in the underserved area. Compare anonymous usable station-days and reachability before and after under the same definition.

  1. Targets the stated underserved-area access gap.
  2. Uses a relevant repeated anonymous measure.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S6.13 · Evaluating health claims

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Testimonial versus comparison

Example information

An advert says one customer improved after a product. It gives no comparison and no measured outcome definition.

Question: Does the story establish the product caused the improvement?

Answer: No.

Why: Other explanations remain, and one story cannot estimate a general effect.

Example 2 · Check the population
Check the population
EvidenceClaim
Isolated cell measurementBenefit for every child
Small model settingUniversal real-world outcome

Example information

A fictional experiment measures a chemical change in isolated cells. An advert claims it proves better health for every child.

Question: What is the unsupported jump?

Answer: From a cell experiment to a universal child-health benefit.

Why: The study population and outcome do not match the claim.

Example 3 · Funding is context

Example information

A study is funded by a company that sells the product. It reports its method and limitations.

Question: Does funding alone prove the result is false?

Answer: No.

Why: The interest should be disclosed and methods plus independent evidence examined.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Claim strength

Fixed scientific information

A says two variables are associated. B says an action reduces risk under studied conditions. C says a product cures every illness.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which claim asserts a universal cure?” → “Claim A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which claim asserts a universal cure: Claim C. Which describes an association: Claim A. Which gives a bounded risk claim: Claim B.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Source features

Fixed scientific information

Source A provides a method and limitations. B gives only a testimonial. C gives only a popularity count.

F2 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which source allows method evaluation?; Which is one personal story?; Which substitutes popularity for evidence?

  • a: Source A
  • b: Source B
  • c: Source C
  • d: Fame proves effectiveness
Answer: Which source allows method evaluation? → Source A; Which is one personal story? → Source B; Which substitutes popularity for evidence? → Source C

Which source allows method evaluation: Source A. Which is one personal story: Source B. Which substitutes popularity for evidence: Source C.

Scientific explorer: health lab

F3 · Needed comparison details

Fixed scientific information

A study summary lists 3 cases in one group and 9 in another but omits group sizes and observation periods.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which missing value is needed for proportions? → Group size
  • b: Which missing detail is needed for time comparability? → Observation period
  • c: Which missing value is needed for proportions? → Raw case counts
  • d: What information is already supplied? → The counts prove every cause
Answer: Which missing value is needed for proportions? → Group size; Which missing detail is needed for time comparability? → Observation period

Which missing value is needed for proportions: Group size. Which missing detail is needed for time comparability: Observation period. What information is already supplied: Raw case counts.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Conflict and verification

Fixed scientific information

A source discloses a seller’s funding, describes its methods and invites comparison with independent research.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which detail identifies a possible interest?; Which detail permits scientific appraisal?; Which check can corroborate the result?

  • a: Seller funding
  • b: Methods
  • c: Independent research
  • d: Funding alone proves falsehood
Answer: Which detail identifies a possible interest? → Seller funding; Which detail permits scientific appraisal? → Methods; Which check can corroborate the result? → Independent research

Which detail identifies a possible interest: Seller funding. Which detail permits scientific appraisal: Methods. Which check can corroborate the result: Independent research.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A vague promise

Fixed scientific information

A fictional product claims to “boost all health” but defines no outcome, target group or test.

F5 · Short answer

Identify two kinds of information needed before the claim can be evaluated.

Example of a full-credit answer: It needs a clear measurable outcome and a relevant study method/comparison for the claimed group.

  1. Requests a defined measurable health outcome or target population.
  2. Requests relevant study/comparison evidence rather than a slogan.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional advert reports 2 cases among 20 users and 3 among 60 non-users, with the same interval but no other design details.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is the users’ recorded fraction? → 10%
  • b: What is the non-users’ fraction? → 5%
  • c: What is the users’ recorded fraction? → Comparable study design
  • d: What is missing for a strong cause claim? → Fewer cases proves benefit
Answer: What is the users’ recorded fraction? → 10%; What is the non-users’ fraction? → 5%

What is the users’ recorded fraction: 10%. What is the non-users’ fraction: 5%. What is missing for a strong cause claim: Comparable study design.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the fractions and explain why the smaller raw case count does not show a benefit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Users have 10% versus 5% among non-users. The denominators differ; raw counts alone cannot establish benefit, and causal interpretation also needs design details.

  1. Correctly calculates/compares 10% and 5%.
  2. Explains denominator and/or study-design limitation of the benefit claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A reports a relevant comparison, measurements and limitations. B relies on a celebrity. C hides all methods but promises a cure.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which source is most assessable scientifically?; Which relies on fame?; Which hides methods and overpromises?

  • a: Source A
  • b: Source B
  • c: Source C
  • d: All are equally strong
Answer: Which source is most assessable scientifically? → Source A; Which relies on fame? → Source B; Which hides methods and overpromises? → Source C

Which source is most assessable scientifically: Source A. Which relies on fame: Source B. Which hides methods and overpromises: Source C.

2B · Open ended

Justify choosing A with two evidence features.

Example of a full-credit answer: A describes a relevant comparison and measurable outcomes, and states limitations that help judge the scope.

  1. Identifies the relevant comparison/method.
  2. Identifies measured outcomes or stated limitations as a second strength.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional study involves adults with one defined condition. A seller claims the same result for every child with any condition. No child study is provided.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which population was actually studied?; Which population claim goes beyond the evidence?; Which check is needed?

  • a: Adults with one condition
  • b: Every child
  • c: Evidence relevant to children
  • d: All ages and conditions are identical
Answer: Which population was actually studied? → Adults with one condition; Which population claim goes beyond the evidence? → Every child; Which check is needed? → Evidence relevant to children

Which population was actually studied: Adults with one condition. Which population claim goes beyond the evidence: Every child. Which check is needed: Evidence relevant to children.

3B · Short answer

Explain the unsupported transfer and state what evidence would be relevant.

Example of a full-credit answer: The study’s adults and condition do not match all children and conditions. Evidence for the relevant child population, outcome and safety would be needed under appropriate professional research.

  1. Identifies the mismatch in population/condition or scope.
  2. Requests appropriately relevant evidence rather than assuming transfer.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “The seller funded this study, so every result is definitely false.” The source discloses funding and methods but no independent replication is yet shown.

4A · Multiple choice

What does the funding indicate?

  • a: A possible conflict of interest
  • b: Methods and evidence
  • c: Independent corroboration
  • d: Automatic proof of falsehood
Answer: A possible conflict of interest

What does the funding indicate: A possible conflict of interest. What should be evaluated: Methods and evidence. What could strengthen confidence: Independent corroboration.

4B · Open ended

Correct the reasoning and propose a useful next check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Funding signals an interest, not automatic falsity. Examine the methods and seek independent evidence addressing the same question.

  1. Distinguishes conflict of interest from proof of falsehood.
  2. Proposes method review or independent corroboration.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A card must help learners evaluate a fictional health claim without recommending treatment. Include evidence questions and a suitable response when information is missing.

5A · Hotspot

Which question checks whether the studied population and outcome match the claim?

  • a: Who and what were studied?
  • b: What comparison was used?
  • c: Claim not established yet
  • d: Try the treatment on classmates
Answer: Who and what were studied?

Which question checks relevance: Who and what were studied?. Which question checks method: What comparison was used?. Which response fits insufficient evidence: Claim not established yet.

5B · Open ended

Propose two checks that would prevent overclaiming, including one about evidence and one about scope.

Example of a full-credit answer: Check the method, comparison and measured outcome. Check whether the studied population and result match the exact claim; do not generalise beyond them.

  1. Proposes a relevant evidence/method check.
  2. Proposes a scope/population/outcome match check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.1 · Genes

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Instruction and product

Example information

A model shows a DNA gene used to produce a protein that helps a chemical reaction.

Question: Which is the information region and which is the product?

Answer: The gene is the information region; the protein is its product in this model.

Why: A gene and its product are related but not interchangeable.

Example 2 · A nested model
A nested model
LevelRelationship
NucleusContains chromosomes in this cell
ChromosomeContains many DNA regions
GeneA functional information region

Example information

The classroom diagram places several genes along one chromosome inside a nucleus.

Question: Does one chromosome equal one gene?

Answer: No. It can contain many genes.

Why: The levels represent different structures.

Example 3 · A model with limits

Example information

A fictional plant trait follows one A/a rule. A student applies it to every human ability.

Question: Why is that transfer invalid?

Answer: The toy rule does not describe complex human traits.

Why: Many genes and environmental factors can contribute to real outcomes.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Information levels

Fixed scientific information

A reference says a gene is a DNA region, a protein can be a gene product and an allele is a version of a gene.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which term means a gene version?

  • a: Allele
  • b: Gene
  • c: Protein
  • d: A whole person
Answer: Allele

Which term means a gene version: Allele. Which is the information region: Gene. Which can be a functional product: Protein.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F2 · Follow a cell diagram

Fixed scientific information

The diagram puts chromosomes in a nucleus and marks several genes along a chromosome. It shows only selected features.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which structure holds the drawn chromosomes?; Which structure contains the marked genes?; Which labels indicate selected DNA regions?

  • a: Nucleus
  • b: Chromosome
  • c: Genes
  • d: One gene equals the whole nucleus
Answer: Which structure holds the drawn chromosomes? → Nucleus; Which structure contains the marked genes? → Chromosome; Which labels indicate selected DNA regions? → Genes

Which structure holds the drawn chromosomes: Nucleus. Which structure contains the marked genes: Chromosome. Which labels indicate selected DNA regions: Genes.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F3 · Fictional allele cards

Fixed scientific information

The model labels A and a as versions of one gene, B as a version of another gene and water level as an environmental factor.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which pair are versions of the same model gene? → A and a
  • b: Which label refers to another gene here? → B
  • c: Which pair are versions of the same model gene? → Water level
  • d: Which factor is environmental? → Every label is a chromosome
Answer: Which pair are versions of the same model gene? → A and a; Which label refers to another gene here? → B

Which pair are versions of the same model gene: A and a. Which label refers to another gene here: B. Which factor is environmental: Water level.

Scientific explorer: genetics lab

F4 · A bounded explanation

Fixed scientific information

A says genes and environment can both matter. B says one gene determines every trait. C says genes are the same as proteins.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation recognises multiple influences?; Which overgeneralises one-gene control?; Which confuses information with product?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All explanations are equivalent
Answer: Which explanation recognises multiple influences? → Explanation A; Which overgeneralises one-gene control? → Explanation B; Which confuses information with product? → Explanation C

Which explanation recognises multiple influences: Explanation A. Which overgeneralises one-gene control: Explanation B. Which confuses information with product: Explanation C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Same version, different growth

Fixed scientific information

Two fictional seedlings have the same listed gene version, but one receives enough water and the other does not. Their growth differs.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the different growth does not prove the listed gene versions differ, and identify a relevant alternative factor.

Example of a full-credit answer: The source already says the listed version is the same. Water differs and can affect growth, so an environmental explanation is possible.

  1. Recognises that growth differences do not establish different listed gene versions.
  2. Identifies water/environment as a relevant influence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A cell model labels region P on DNA, product Q made using its information and compartment R holding the drawn chromosomes. P is a functional gene region; Q is a protein.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is region P? → Gene
  • b: What is product Q? → Protein
  • c: What is region P? → Nucleus
  • d: What is compartment R? → All are the same object
Answer: What is region P? → Gene; What is product Q? → Protein

What is region P: Gene. What is product Q: Protein. What is compartment R: Nucleus.

1B · Short answer

Explain the relationship between P and Q without saying they are identical.

Example of a full-credit answer: P contains information used in producing Q. Q is a functional protein product, while P is a DNA region.

  1. Connects gene information to production of the protein.
  2. Distinguishes DNA region from protein product.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says this is a one-gene fictional trait with stated rules. B says all human traits follow it. C says the letters are the organisms themselves.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which note states a useful limit?; Which makes an unsupported universal claim?; Which confuses symbols with organisms?

  • a: Note A
  • b: Note B
  • c: Note C
  • d: No limit is needed
Answer: Which note states a useful limit? → Note A; Which makes an unsupported universal claim? → Note B; Which confuses symbols with organisms? → Note C

Which note states a useful limit: Note A. Which makes an unsupported universal claim: Note B. Which confuses symbols with organisms: Note C.

2B · Open ended

Justify Note A and name an influence that real traits may include beyond one model gene.

Example of a full-credit answer: It tells us exactly what the simplified rule covers. Other genes or environmental conditions can also affect real traits.

  1. Explains that the note bounds the simplified model.
  2. Names other genes or environment as an additional influence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A leaf cell has DNA information used to produce many proteins. Light and water conditions can affect its activity and growth.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which material stores the gene information?” → “DNA”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which material stores the gene information: DNA. Which products do many genes help specify: Proteins. Which inputs are environmental: Light and water.

3B · Short answer

Explain how genes and environment can both matter in this cell.

Example of a full-credit answer: Genes provide information for functional products. Environmental light and water influence the conditions in which the cell uses those products and grows.

  1. Identifies the gene-information contribution.
  2. Identifies a relevant environmental contribution.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner writes “A gene, its protein and the whole chromosome are the same object.” The reference distinguishes each level.

4A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which object is a region of DNA?; Which object contains many genes?; Which object can be made using gene information?

  • a: Gene
  • b: Chromosome
  • c: Protein
  • d: They are interchangeable
Answer: Which object is a region of DNA? → Gene; Which object contains many genes? → Chromosome; Which object can be made using gene information? → Protein

Which object is a region of DNA: Gene. Which object contains many genes: Chromosome. Which object can be made using gene information: Protein.

4B · Open ended

Correct two relationships in the learner’s statement.

Example of a full-credit answer: A gene is one DNA region within a chromosome, which contains many regions. A protein is a product made using information, not the gene itself.

  1. Correctly relates gene and chromosome.
  2. Correctly distinguishes gene information from protein product.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A display must show genes within chromosomes and distinguish a gene’s information from its product. It must not imply one gene explains every human trait.

5A · Hotspot

Which label belongs on the larger DNA structure?

  • a: Chromosome
  • b: Gene
  • c: Protein
  • d: Whole-person destiny
Answer: Chromosome

Which label belongs on the larger DNA structure: Chromosome. Which label belongs on a selected functional DNA region: Gene. Which label can name a resulting product: Protein.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two required relationships for your display.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw several gene regions along a chromosome. Draw a separate arrow from one gene’s information to its protein product, with a note that the model is simplified.

  1. Shows genes as regions within chromosomes.
  2. Separates gene information from a functional product.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.2 · Chromosomes

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Pair arithmetic
Pair arithmetic
ModelPairsChromosomes
Fictional body cell510

Example information

A fictional species has 5 chromosome pairs in its body-cell model.

Question: How many chromosomes are represented?

Answer: 10.

Why: Each pair contains two, so 5×2=10.

Example 2 · Restore a set

Example information

A model reproductive cell has 4 chromosomes. Another compatible reproductive cell also has 4.

Question: How many are represented after joining?

Answer: 8.

Why: The model combines two reduced sets; it does not use the human count.

Example 3 · Avoid a ranking

Example information

Species A’s model has 12 chromosomes and B’s has 20.

Question: Does B’s larger count prove it is more intelligent?

Answer: No.

Why: Chromosome number is not a scale of intelligence or complexity.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · DNA structures

Fixed scientific information

A reference places genes along chromosomes in a nucleus and identifies DNA as the information molecule.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which structure contains many genes? → Chromosome
  • b: Which compartment holds the drawn chromosomes? → Nucleus
  • c: Which structure contains many genes? → A single protein product
  • d: Which molecule carries their information? → One protein is a whole chromosome
Answer: Which structure contains many genes? → Chromosome; Which compartment holds the drawn chromosomes? → Nucleus

Which structure contains many genes: Chromosome. Which compartment holds the drawn chromosomes: Nucleus. Which molecule carries their information: DNA.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F2 · Fictional pairs

Fixed scientific information

A fictional body-cell model has 6 pairs, each with two chromosomes. Its reproductive-cell model has one from each pair.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many in the body-cell model?; How many in the reproductive-cell model?; What does each pair contain?

  • a: 12 chromosomes
  • b: 6 chromosomes
  • c: Two chromosomes
  • d: 18 chromosomes in every cell
Answer: How many in the body-cell model? → 12 chromosomes; How many in the reproductive-cell model? → 6 chromosomes; What does each pair contain? → Two chromosomes

How many in the body-cell model: 12 chromosomes. How many in the reproductive-cell model: 6 chromosomes. What does each pair contain: Two chromosomes.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Human reference counts

Fixed scientific information

The reference states 46 chromosomes in a typical human nucleated body cell and 23 in each normal egg or sperm. These are cell-type-specific counts.

F3 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which count matches the body-cell reference?” → “46”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which count matches the body-cell reference: 46. Which count matches an egg or sperm: 23. What must be named when interpreting the count: Cell type.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Copying model

Fixed scientific information

A model first copies the DNA information, then separates it into two new cells. A label notes the shapes are simplified.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which step provides copies?

  • a: DNA copying
  • b: Distribution
  • c: Simplified shapes
  • d: Discard one whole set
Answer: DNA copying

Which step provides copies: DNA copying. Which step shares copies between new cells: Distribution. Which note describes the picture’s limits: Simplified shapes.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Pairs versus total

Fixed scientific information

A student reads “7 pairs” in a fictional chromosome model and records 7 chromosomes.

F5 · Open ended

Correct the count and explain the meaning of a pair.

Example of a full-credit answer: The model contains 14 chromosomes because each of the 7 pairs contains two.

  1. Gives 14 chromosomes.
  2. Explains two chromosomes per pair.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional species has 8 chromosomes in its body-cell model. Each reproductive cell has 4. Fertilisation joins two compatible reproductive cells.

1A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “How many after joining?” → “4 chromosomes”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

How many after joining: 8 chromosomes. How many come from each reproductive cell: 4 chromosomes. What event joins the sets: Fertilisation.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the combined count and explain why the reduced reproductive sets matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: 4+4=8, restoring the body-cell count. Reduced sets prevent the count from doubling at each fertilisation in this model.

  1. Calculates a restored count of 8.
  2. Explains the role of reduced sets in maintaining the model count.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A labels pairs and cell type. B uses X shapes without explaining copying state. C ranks species by number.

2A · Hotspot

Which diagram gives the clearest counting information?

  • a: Diagram A
  • b: Diagram B
  • c: Diagram C
  • d: More is always better
Answer: Diagram A

Which diagram gives the clearest counting information: Diagram A. Which leaves shape meaning ambiguous: Diagram B. Which makes an unsupported ranking: Diagram C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and identify one label needed to avoid a counting misunderstanding.

Example of a full-credit answer: A states which cell is shown and which chromosomes form pairs. The diagram should also explain whether its shapes show copied chromosomes.

  1. Identifies cell type/pair labels as useful.
  2. Names a relevant copying-state or count-unit clarification.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

Species P has 3 pairs in its body-cell model; species Q has 9 pairs. These are fictional species, not human examples.

3A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many chromosomes are in P’s body-cell model?; How many are in Q’s model?; Which unsupported conclusion ranks organisms’ abilities?

  • a: 6
  • b: 18
  • c: An intelligence ranking
  • d: Two chromosomes per pair
Answer: How many chromosomes are in P’s body-cell model? → 6; How many are in Q’s model? → 18; Which unsupported conclusion ranks organisms’ abilities? → An intelligence ranking

P has 3 pairs, so 6 chromosomes; Q has 9 pairs, so 18. These counts do not rank intelligence or other abilities.

3B · Open ended

Compare the totals and explain why human counts should not replace them.

Example of a full-credit answer: P has 6 and Q 18. Chromosome counts differ among species, so the human reference is not a universal rule.

  1. Correctly calculates 6 and 18.
  2. Explains species-specific counts rather than universal human numbers.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says each daughter cell must keep two complete body-cell sets after every ordinary division. The model copies one set, then distributes a complete set to each daughter.

4A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What does each daughter receive in the model?; Why is DNA copied?; What follows copying?

  • a: One complete body-cell set
  • b: To supply both daughter cells
  • c: Distribution of copies
  • d: Permanent doubling each time
Answer: What does each daughter receive in the model? → One complete body-cell set; Why is DNA copied? → To supply both daughter cells; What follows copying? → Distribution of copies

What does each daughter receive in the model: One complete body-cell set. Why is DNA copied: To supply both daughter cells. What follows copying: Distribution of copies.

4B · Short answer

Correct the claim and explain the purpose of copying before division.

Example of a full-credit answer: Each daughter receives the usual complete set, not a permanent double set. Copying supplies enough information for both daughters when the cell divides.

  1. Corrects permanent doubling in each daughter.
  2. Explains copying as preparation for distributing information to two cells.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Use a fictional species with 4 pairs in body cells and 4 chromosomes per reproductive cell. The model must distinguish pairs, totals and fertilisation.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What total belongs on the body-cell card?; What total belongs on a reproductive-cell card?; Which calculation belongs at fertilisation?

  • a: 8 chromosomes
  • b: 4 chromosomes
  • c: 4+4=8
  • d: 4 pairs equals 4 total
Answer: What total belongs on the body-cell card? → 8 chromosomes; What total belongs on a reproductive-cell card? → 4 chromosomes; Which calculation belongs at fertilisation? → 4+4=8

What total belongs on the body-cell card: 8 chromosomes. What total belongs on a reproductive-cell card: 4 chromosomes. Which calculation belongs at fertilisation: 4+4=8.

5B · Open ended

Propose labels for the body-cell set and for the joining reproductive sets.

Example of a full-credit answer: Label the body cell 4 pairs=8 chromosomes. Label each reproductive cell 4 chromosomes and show 4+4=8 at fertilisation.

  1. Correctly labels pairs and total for the body cell.
  2. Correctly labels reduced sets and their combined total.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.3 · Heredity

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Same appearance, different pairs

Example information

In the fictional rule, AA and Aa are purple and aa is white.

Question: Can two purple seeds have different genotypes?

Answer: Yes: AA and Aa.

Why: The visible trait does not uniquely determine the allele pair.

Example 2 · Read four boxes
Read four boxes
EntryGenotype
1Aa
2aa
3Aa
4aa

Example information

An Aa×aa square has Aa, aa, Aa and aa as four equally likely entries.

Question: What is the chance of aa?

Answer: 2/4, or 50%.

Why: Count the two aa entries among four; this is a probability, not a fixed family quota.

Example 3 · A run of the same result

Example information

A toy Aa×Aa generator produces three purple offspring.

Question: Must the next one be white?

Answer: No.

Why: Each new model outcome follows its probability; earlier colours do not force the next result.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Genotype and phenotype

Fixed scientific information

The fictional rule gives purple for AA/Aa and white for aa. Genotype means allele pair; phenotype means the observed colour.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which term names the allele pair?” → “Phenotype”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which term names the allele pair: Genotype. Which term names observed colour: Phenotype. Which pair gives white here: aa.

Scientific explorer: genetics lab

F2 · Parent contributions

Fixed scientific information

In this model an Aa parent can contribute A or a. An aa parent contributes a only. Each offspring receives one allele from each parent.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which parent can contribute A?; Which contributes only a?; How many model alleles does an offspring receive?

  • a: Aa parent
  • b: aa parent
  • c: Two
  • d: Every offspring receives four
Answer: Which parent can contribute A? → Aa parent; Which contributes only a? → aa parent; How many model alleles does an offspring receive? → Two

Which parent can contribute A: Aa parent. Which contributes only a: aa parent. How many model alleles does an offspring receive: Two.

Scientific explorer: probability lab

F3 · Four equally likely boxes

Fixed scientific information

An Aa×Aa square has AA, Aa, Aa, aa. Use only this fictional rule.

F3 · Hotspot

What is the chance of aa?

  • a: 1/4
  • b: 1/2
  • c: 3/4
  • d: All four must appear in each family
Answer: 1/4

What is the chance of aa: 1/4. What is the chance of Aa: 1/2. What is the chance of AA or Aa combined: 3/4.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Model boundaries

Fixed scientific information

A says this one-gene game has explicit rules. B says dominant means morally better. C says every human trait follows the same square.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which statement properly limits the model? → Statement A
  • b: Which misuses the word dominant? → Statement B
  • c: Which statement properly limits the model? → Statement C
  • d: Which overextends the model? → All statements are scientific
Answer: Which statement properly limits the model? → Statement A; Which misuses the word dominant? → Statement B

Which statement properly limits the model: Statement A. Which misuses the word dominant: Statement B. Which overextends the model: Statement C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · A small sample

Fixed scientific information

A fictional Aa×aa model gives a 50% chance of aa for each offspring. One run of four offspring happens to contain three aa.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why this result is possible and distinguish probability from a guaranteed count.

Example of a full-credit answer: Random runs can vary, so three aa in four is possible. A 50% chance describes each trial or a long-run expectation, not exactly two in every four.

  1. Recognises chance variation in a small sample.
  2. Distinguishes 50% probability from an exact required count.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: genetics lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

For the fictional trait, AA is crossed with aa. The first parent supplies A only and the second supplies a only; Aa is purple.

1A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which genotype is possible for every offspring here?; Which visible colour follows the stated rule?; Which allele comes from the aa parent?

  • a: Aa
  • b: Purple
  • c: a
  • d: aa from this cross
Answer: Which genotype is possible for every offspring here? → Aa; Which visible colour follows the stated rule? → Purple; Which allele comes from the aa parent? → a

Which genotype is possible for every offspring here: Aa. Which visible colour follows the stated rule: Purple. Which allele comes from the aa parent: a.

1B · Short answer

Explain the genotype and phenotype using the parental contributions.

Example of a full-credit answer: Every offspring receives A from AA and a from aa, making Aa. The stated complete-dominance rule makes Aa purple.

  1. Derives Aa from one allele from each parent.
  2. Applies the stated rule to give purple.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says 25% aa per offspring for Aa×Aa. B promises exactly one aa in every four. C says aa becomes impossible after one aa occurs.

2A · Hotspot

Which statement matches the probability model?

  • a: Statement A
  • b: Statement B
  • c: Statement C
  • d: Previous results determine the next one
Answer: Statement A

Which statement matches the probability model: Statement A. Which invents a fixed quota: Statement B. Which wrongly removes future possibilities: Statement C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and explain why B can fail in a small run.

Example of a full-credit answer: A describes each outcome’s chance. Small random samples vary, so a group of four may not contain exactly one aa.

  1. Identifies per-offspring chance.
  2. Explains small-sample random variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A new model uses B/b for a fictional stripe marker: BB and Bb are striped, bb is plain. Bb×bb gives Bb,bb,Bb,bb.

3A · Multiple choice

What is the chance of plain?

  • a: 1/2
  • b: bb
  • c: Striped
  • d: The A/a letters must be used forever
Answer: 1/2

What is the chance of plain: 1/2. Which genotype produces plain: bb. Which visible outcome does Bb have: Striped.

3B · Short answer

Explain how the same probability method applies and what rule must be checked before naming the appearance.

Example of a full-credit answer: Count two bb boxes among four to get one half. Check the new B/b phenotype rule before deciding that bb is plain.

  1. Correctly uses the four outcomes to obtain one half.
  2. States that the marker’s own genotype-to-phenotype rule must be read.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Dominant alleles are always most common and best.” The reference says dominance describes how alleles affect a phenotype in a specified combination.

4A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What does dominance describe here?; Which term describes how common an allele is in a population?; Which judgement of worth is not established by dominance?

  • a: Phenotype in a combination
  • b: Population frequency
  • c: Overall superiority
  • d: Reproductive-cell type
Answer: What does dominance describe here? → Phenotype in a combination; Which term describes how common an allele is in a population? → Population frequency; Which judgement of worth is not established by dominance? → Overall superiority

Dominance describes the expressed phenotype in a stated allele combination. Population frequency describes how common an allele is; dominance does not establish overall superiority.

4B · Open ended

Correct both parts of the learner’s claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Dominance does not tell us how common an allele is, and it does not mean the organism or trait is better overall. It describes the modelled phenotype relationship.

  1. Rejects automatic greater frequency.
  2. Rejects automatic superiority and/or explains phenotype relationship.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Use the Aa×aa model with equal chances from the Aa parent. Repeat many random draws, replace allele cards each time and record genotype counts.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which action keeps trial chances consistent?; Which record measures outcomes?; Which approach reveals chance variation?

  • a: Replace cards each trial
  • b: Genotype counts
  • c: Repeated runs
  • d: Force exactly half the outcomes
Answer: Which action keeps trial chances consistent? → Replace cards each trial; Which record measures outcomes? → Genotype counts; Which approach reveals chance variation? → Repeated runs

Which action keeps trial chances consistent: Replace cards each trial. Which record measures outcomes: Genotype counts. Which approach reveals chance variation: Repeated runs.

5B · Open ended

Propose how to run the demonstration and how to describe results without promising an exact half.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw one allele from each parent with replacement and record each genotype. Compare several runs with the 50% expectation while noting that counts vary.

  1. Gives a consistent random trial method with replacement/reset.
  2. Compares observed counts with probability while allowing variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.4 · Gene expression

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Same information, different use
Same information, different use
CellProduct units
A2
B7

Example information

Two fictional cells contain gene G. Cell A makes 2 product units and B makes 7.

Question: What difference is directly shown?

Answer: The measured product amounts differ.

Why: The data do not establish different DNA sequences.

Example 2 · Switch analogy

Example information

A diagram dims a lamp to represent lower gene activity.

Question: Does the model mean a gene is literally an electrical lamp?

Answer: No.

Why: The analogy represents one feature—different output levels—and leaves out molecular details.

Example 3 · Choose a measurement

Example information

A study question asks whether a condition changes the amount of protein P. One record measures P; another records pot colour.

Question: Which record addresses the question?

Answer: The protein-P measurement.

Why: The measurement must match the claimed expression outcome.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Presence and activity

Fixed scientific information

Both model cells contain gene G. A produces 3 product units; B produces 8. The sequence is stated to be unchanged.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which cell has higher measured output?” → “Cell B”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which cell has higher measured output: Cell B. Which has lower output: Cell A. What is held unchanged: Gene sequence.

Scientific explorer: cell lab

F2 · Expression terms

Fixed scientific information

The reference distinguishes DNA information, use of that information and the resulting product. Many gene products are proteins.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which term describes use of the information? → Gene expression
  • b: Which material holds the gene information? → DNA
  • c: Which term describes use of the information? → Protein
  • d: Which can be the resulting product? → Chromosome disappearance
Answer: Which term describes use of the information? → Gene expression; Which material holds the gene information? → DNA

Which term describes use of the information: Gene expression. Which material holds the gene information: DNA. Which can be the resulting product: Protein.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Read an activity chart

Fixed scientific information

Synthetic expression units are 1 in condition X, 5 in Y and 3 in Z. All use the same measurement scale.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which condition has the greatest measured output?

  • a: Condition Y
  • b: Condition X
  • c: Condition Z
  • d: All have equal output
Answer: Condition Y

Which condition has the greatest measured output: Condition Y. Which has the least: Condition X. Which has 3 units: Condition Z.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Study choices

Fixed scientific information

Plan A changes one condition in the same model cell type. B changes condition and cell type. C measures no product.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan most clearly isolates the chosen condition?; Which includes a confounding cell-type change?; Which lacks the relevant measurement?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: Every plan proves the mechanism
Answer: Which plan most clearly isolates the chosen condition? → Plan A; Which includes a confounding cell-type change? → Plan B; Which lacks the relevant measurement? → Plan C

Which plan most clearly isolates the chosen condition: Plan A. Which includes a confounding cell-type change: Plan B. Which lacks the relevant measurement: Plan C.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F5 · Output without mutation

Fixed scientific information

A fictional model gene keeps the same DNA sequence but its product amount rises from 4 to 9 units after a condition changes.

F5 · Open ended

State what changed and explain why mutation is not established.

Example of a full-credit answer: The measured product amount increased. The source states the DNA sequence is unchanged, so altered expression does not establish a mutation.

  1. Identifies increased product/expression output.
  2. Distinguishes expression change from DNA-sequence mutation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

The same model cell produces 6 units of protein P in condition A and 10 in B. The DNA sequence remains the same.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How much larger is B’s output?; Which condition has higher output?; Which feature stays unchanged?

  • a: 4 units
  • b: Condition B
  • c: DNA sequence
  • d: A new gene must have appeared
Answer: How much larger is B’s output? → 4 units; Which condition has higher output? → Condition B; Which feature stays unchanged? → DNA sequence

How much larger is B’s output: 4 units. Which condition has higher output: Condition B. Which feature stays unchanged: DNA sequence.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the difference and give the appropriate biological description.

Example of a full-credit answer: 10−6=4 more units. The model shows changed gene expression/product output, not a demonstrated DNA-sequence change.

  1. Calculates an increase of 4 units.
  2. Describes expression/product change without falsely inferring mutation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A records protein P under equal methods. B records only drawing colour. C assumes all cells use every gene equally.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which record addresses product output?; Which concerns appearance of a drawing?; Which claim assumes that all genes are used equally without evidence?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Claim C
  • d: All three records
Answer: Which record addresses product output? → Record A; Which concerns appearance of a drawing? → Record B; Which claim assumes that all genes are used equally without evidence? → Claim C

Which record addresses product output: Record A. Which concerns appearance of a drawing: Record B. Which is an unsupported assumption: Claim C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and name one condition that should be controlled for comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: A measures the relevant product. Keep cell type, measurement method, duration or other stated conditions comparable.

  1. Connects the measurement to product output.
  2. Names a relevant controlled/comparable factor.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional muscle-cell model and nerve-cell model contain the same listed gene set but show different activity patterns. They perform different functions.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is shared in the model?” → “Activity pattern”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What is shared in the model: Listed gene set. What differs: Activity pattern. What does the difference help explain: Different cell functions.

3B · Open ended

Explain how shared information can coexist with different cell functions.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cells can use different amounts or subsets of shared gene information. Different functional products help them perform different jobs.

  1. Explains differential expression of shared information.
  2. Connects resulting products/activity with different functions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “The bar became taller, so the DNA letters definitely changed.” The chart measures protein quantity only.

4A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What does the bar measure?; Which genetic measurement is absent from this product-quantity record?; What conclusion is justified?

  • a: Protein quantity
  • b: DNA sequence
  • c: Product amount changed
  • d: Mutation is certain
Answer: What does the bar measure? → Protein quantity; Which genetic measurement is absent from this product-quantity record? → DNA sequence; What conclusion is justified? → Product amount changed

What does the bar measure: Protein quantity. What is not directly measured: DNA sequence. What conclusion is justified: Product amount changed.

4B · Short answer

Identify the unsupported inference and state what additional measurement would address it.

Example of a full-credit answer: A protein-output change does not prove a DNA mutation. DNA-sequence evidence would be needed to assess whether the letters changed.

  1. Rejects mutation inferred from output alone.
  2. Identifies DNA-sequence evidence as relevant to the mutation claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Investigate whether one selected condition changes product P in the same virtual cell type. Use the same measurement interval and scale, and repeat.

5A · Hotspot

What should be deliberately changed?

  • a: One selected condition
  • b: Product P
  • c: Cell type and method
  • d: Change every factor at once
Answer: One selected condition

What should be deliberately changed: One selected condition. What should be measured: Product P. What should be held constant: Cell type and method.

5B · Open ended

Propose the comparison and describe the evidence record needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compare two levels of one condition while holding cell type and method equal. Record repeated product-P measurements on the same scale and compare them.

  1. Specifies one changed condition and relevant controls.
  2. Specifies repeated comparable product measurements.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.5 · Genetic variation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Compare DNA strings

Example information

A fictional marker has sequence ACGT in one individual and ACAT in another.

Question: How many displayed positions differ?

Answer: One position: the third letter.

Why: This establishes a sequence difference, not its biological effect.

Example 2 · Count variants
Count variants
VariantIndividuals
P6
Q4

Example information

A toy sample contains variant P in 6 individuals and Q in 4.

Question: What fraction carries Q in this simplified one-marker record?

Answer: 4/10, or 40%.

Why: The denominator is the ten sampled individuals; the record does not describe every possible gene.

Example 3 · A context-dependent effect

Example information

A fictional inherited coat colour hides well on dark ground but stands out on pale ground.

Question: Is the colour universally best?

Answer: No. Its effect depends on the environment.

Why: Variation can have different consequences under different conditions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three variation terms

Fixed scientific information

The reference calls a DNA-letter change mutation, reshuffling existing versions recombination and a gene version an allele.

F1 · Hotspot

Which term means a DNA-sequence change?

  • a: Mutation
  • b: Recombination
  • c: Allele
  • d: A chosen future need
Answer: Mutation

Which term means a DNA-sequence change: Mutation. Which means reshuffling existing versions: Recombination. Which means a version of a gene: Allele.

Scientific explorer: genetics lab

F2 · Read the strings

Fixed scientific information

Fictional strings are P=AAAA, Q=AATA and R=AATT. Compare each with P.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which string differs from P at one position?; Which differs at two positions?; Which is the reference string?

  • a: String Q
  • b: String R
  • c: String P
  • d: All strings identical
Answer: Which string differs from P at one position? → String Q; Which differs at two positions? → String R; Which is the reference string? → String P

Which string differs from P at one position: String Q. Which differs at two positions: String R. Which is the reference string: String P.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · A sample of variants

Fixed scientific information

A toy record lists variant X in 8 individuals, Y in 5 and Z in 2, for 15 individuals total.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which variant is most frequent in the sample?; Which is least frequent?; Which occurs in five individuals?

  • a: Variant X
  • b: Variant Z
  • c: Variant Y
  • d: Rare means impossible
Answer: Which variant is most frequent in the sample? → Variant X; Which is least frequent? → Variant Z; Which occurs in five individuals? → Variant Y

Which variant is most frequent in the sample: Variant X. Which is least frequent: Variant Z. Which occurs in five individuals: Variant Y.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Which information is passed?

Fixed scientific information

A model separates changes confined to body cells, changes in reproductive-cell information and changes in the environment. Only the second is stated to enter offspring DNA.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which change is stated to enter offspring DNA? → Reproductive-cell change
  • b: Which is confined to the parent’s body here? → Body-cell change
  • c: Which change is stated to enter offspring DNA? → Environmental change
  • d: Which change is confined to parental body cells in this model? → Reproductive-cell change
Answer: Which change is stated to enter offspring DNA? → Reproductive-cell change; Which is confined to the parent’s body here? → Body-cell change

Which change is stated to enter offspring DNA: Reproductive-cell change. Which is confined to the parent’s body here: Body-cell change. Which is not itself a DNA sequence: Environmental change.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Variation is not always visible

Fixed scientific information

Two fictional plants have a documented DNA difference but the measured flower colour is the same.

F5 · Short answer

State what the evidence establishes and explain why identical colour does not erase it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The DNA sequences differ. A sequence difference need not affect the measured colour, so the identical colour does not prove identical DNA.

  1. Identifies a documented genetic difference.
  2. Explains that a variant may not affect the measured visible trait.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: genetics lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy sample has 12 individuals with marker A and 8 with marker B. Each individual is recorded in one of these two categories.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What fraction is marker B? → 40%
  • b: What is the sample size? → 20 individuals
  • c: What fraction is marker B? → Marker A
  • d: Which marker is more frequent in this sample? → B is absent from the population
Answer: What fraction is marker B? → 40%; What is the sample size? → 20 individuals

What fraction is marker B: 40%. What is the sample size: 20 individuals. Which marker is more frequent in this sample: Marker A.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the B fraction and state why the sample does not describe every possible population exactly.

Example of a full-credit answer: 8/20=40%. Sampling variation and the selection method can make the sample differ from the wider population.

  1. Calculates 40%.
  2. Identifies sampling variation/selection as a limit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says a sequence change can have different effects depending on context. B says every mutation is harmful. C says organisms choose needed mutations.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation is accurate?; Which wrongly assumes all changes are harmful?; Which falsely assigns purposeful mutation?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All mutations have one effect
Answer: Which explanation is accurate? → Explanation A; Which wrongly assumes all changes are harmful? → Explanation B; Which falsely assigns purposeful mutation? → Explanation C

Which explanation is accurate: Explanation A. Which wrongly assumes all changes are harmful: Explanation B. Which falsely assigns purposeful mutation: Explanation C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and give two possible effect categories.

Example of a full-credit answer: Changes can be helpful, harmful or neutral depending on the situation. Therefore one effect cannot be assigned to every mutation.

  1. Acknowledges context-dependent or varied effects.
  2. Gives at least two valid effect categories.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional brown variant is harder for predators to see on dark ground; a pale variant is harder to see on light ground. The variants already exist.

3A · Multiple choice

Which variant is less visible on dark ground?

  • a: Brown variant
  • b: Pale variant
  • c: Background environment
  • d: One colour is always best
Answer: Brown variant

Which variant is less visible on dark ground: Brown variant. Which is less visible on light ground: Pale variant. What changes the relative advantage: Background environment.

3B · Short answer

Explain how environmental change can alter the value of existing variation.

Example of a full-credit answer: A background change alters which inherited colour is less visible. The variants do not need to appear by choice for their relative survival advantage to change.

  1. Connects environment with changed relative advantage.
  2. Recognises the variants existed beforehand rather than being chosen into existence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Any change in a parent’s skin cells is automatically in all offspring.” The model distinguishes body cells from the genetic material in reproductive cells.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which information directly enters offspring in the model?” → “Skin-cell-only change”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which information directly enters offspring in the model: Reproductive-cell DNA. Which change is not automatically passed: Skin-cell-only change. What evidence is needed: Presence in transmitted DNA.

4B · Open ended

Correct the automatic-inheritance claim and identify the relevant information to check.

Example of a full-credit answer: A change confined to skin cells is not automatically inherited. Check whether the variant is in the genetic material passed through reproductive cells.

  1. Rejects automatic inheritance of skin-cell-only change.
  2. Identifies transmitted/reproductive-cell DNA as relevant.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual population has three marker variants. The survey must estimate their frequencies and avoid selecting only one visible group.

5A · Hotspot

Which method is preferable?

  • a: Broad random sampling
  • b: Counts for every variant
  • c: Total sampled
  • d: Select only the common variant
Answer: Broad random sampling

Which method is preferable: Broad random sampling. Which record is needed: Counts for every variant. Which denominator is required: Total sampled.

5B · Open ended

Propose a sampling method and a frequency calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw a broad random sample from the virtual population and count all marker categories. Divide each category count by the total sampled and repeat samples to inspect variation.

  1. Proposes a method that does not deliberately exclude variants.
  2. Gives count/total frequency calculation or repeated frequency comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.6 · Environmental influences on traits

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Same genotype, different water

Example information

Two fictional seedlings have the same stated genotype. One receives a model water index of 2, the other 6, with other conditions equal. Their growth indices differ.

Question: What influence is being examined?

Answer: Water conditions.

Why: The inherited information is held equal in the model.

Example 2 · Compare changes fairly
Compare changes fairly
PlantStart cmEnd cm
A47
B810

Example information

Plant A grows from 4 to 7 cm; B grows from 8 to 10 cm over equal time.

Question: Which gains more height?

Answer: A gains 3 cm; B gains 2 cm.

Why: Final height alone would miss the larger growth change in A.

Example 3 · Not a new gene

Example information

A virtual plant changes its gene activity after light changes, while its DNA sequence remains fixed.

Question: Does this demonstrate a new mutation?

Answer: No.

Why: Expression and environmental response can change without a sequence change.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify influences

Fixed scientific information

The model labels inherited allele pair G, light level L and measured growth H. G is genetic, L environmental and H an outcome.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which is the environmental input?” → “Light level L”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which is the environmental input: Light level L. Which is inherited information: Allele pair G. Which is the measured outcome: Growth H.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

F2 · Controlled comparisons

Fixed scientific information

A keeps genotype equal and varies water. B varies genotype and water. C measures no growth.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which focuses most clearly on water?; Which changes two possible influences?; Which lacks the outcome measurement?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: Every plan proves water alone
Answer: Which focuses most clearly on water? → Plan A; Which changes two possible influences? → Plan B; Which lacks the outcome measurement? → Plan C

Which focuses most clearly on water: Plan A. Which changes two possible influences: Plan B. Which lacks the outcome measurement: Plan C.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F3 · Fictional growth data

Fixed scientific information

With the same model genotype, growth is 2 cm at low water, 5 cm at medium water and 4 cm at high water over equal time.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which condition gives greatest growth here? → Medium water
  • b: Which gives least growth here? → Low water
  • c: Which condition gives greatest growth here? → High water
  • d: Which gives 4 cm growth? → More water always increases growth
Answer: Which condition gives greatest growth here? → Medium water; Which gives least growth here? → Low water

Which condition gives greatest growth here: Medium water. Which gives least growth here: Low water. Which gives 4 cm growth: High water.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Time-scale cards

Fixed scientific information

A shows a plant changing growth during one week. B shows inherited variant frequencies changing over generations. C shows only a larger photograph.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which shows an individual response?

  • a: Card A
  • b: Card B
  • c: Card C
  • d: Every change is evolution
Answer: Card A

Which shows an individual response: Card A. Which shows population inherited change: Card B. Which may only change image size: Card C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A confounded comparison

Fixed scientific information

Plant P has genotype A and low light; Q has genotype B and high light. Their final sizes differ.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why light alone is not established as the cause and propose a clearer comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both genotype and light differ. Compare the same genotype at different light levels while holding other relevant conditions equal.

  1. Identifies genotype and light as changed/confounded factors.
  2. Proposes a same-genotype controlled light comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Same-genotype model plants start at 5 cm. After equal time, low-light plants reach 7 cm and medium-light plants reach 11 cm; other stated conditions match.

1A · Hotspot

What is low-light growth?

  • a: 2 cm
  • b: 6 cm
  • c: Medium-light group
  • d: Final size proves a universal rule
Answer: 2 cm

What is low-light growth: 2 cm. What is medium-light growth: 6 cm. Which group grows more in this model: Medium-light group.

1B · Open ended

Calculate both growth changes and limit the conclusion to the given model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Low light gives 7−5=2 cm; medium light gives 11−5=6 cm. The model favours medium light under these stated conditions, not every light level for every plant.

  1. Calculates 2 cm and 6 cm.
  2. Restricts the conclusion to the stated model/conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A records several same-genotype plants under controlled light. B compares unrelated plants in different soils. C gives one unlabeled photograph.

2A · Multiple choice

Which record best tests the light condition?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Record C
  • d: A photograph proves all causes
Answer: Record A

Which record best tests the light condition: Record A. Which changes several influences: Record B. Which lacks measurements and conditions: Record C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and explain the value of using several plants.

Example of a full-credit answer: A controls genotype and the light comparison. Several plants reveal natural variation and reduce reliance on one unusual result.

  1. Identifies control/comparable conditions.
  2. Explains repetition or multiple plants as evidence about variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

The question changes from light to temperature. The virtual plants keep the same genotype, light, water and observation time while temperature varies.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which factor is deliberately changed?; Which inherited feature is held equal?; Which outcome can answer a growth question?

  • a: Temperature
  • b: Genotype
  • c: Growth change
  • d: Change every condition
Answer: Which factor is deliberately changed? → Temperature; Which inherited feature is held equal? → Genotype; Which outcome can answer a growth question? → Growth change

Which factor is deliberately changed: Temperature. Which inherited feature is held equal: Genotype. Which outcome can answer a growth question: Growth change.

3B · Open ended

Explain how the fair-comparison method transfers and name the outcome to record.

Example of a full-credit answer: Change temperature alone while keeping relevant conditions equal. Measure growth over the same interval using the same units.

  1. Describes one changed factor with relevant controls.
  2. Specifies comparable growth measurements.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “The shaded plant needed taller stems, so it chose a new gene.” The source reports an individual growth response without a DNA sequence change.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What was observed? → Growth response
  • b: What was not shown? → A new DNA variant
  • c: What was observed? → A new inherited DNA-sequence change
  • d: Which influence changed? → The plant chose its DNA
Answer: What was observed? → Growth response; What was not shown? → A new DNA variant

What was observed: Growth response. What was not shown: A new DNA variant. Which influence changed: Light environment.

4B · Short answer

Correct the purposeful-gene explanation and state what the evidence actually shows.

Example of a full-credit answer: The plant did not choose a new gene. The evidence shows an environmental growth response, not a demonstrated new inherited DNA variant.

  1. Rejects choosing a needed new gene.
  2. Describes observed response without inferring an unmeasured DNA change.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Test a water condition using virtual plants of one stated genotype. Use comparable containers, light and time, with repeated observations.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is changed?; What is measured?; What is held equal?

  • a: Water condition
  • b: Growth over equal time
  • c: Genotype and other conditions
  • d: Every condition changes
Answer: What is changed? → Water condition; What is measured? → Growth over equal time; What is held equal? → Genotype and other conditions

What is changed: Water condition. What is measured: Growth over equal time. What is held equal: Genotype and other conditions.

5B · Open ended

Propose the controlled comparison and explain how repetition will be used.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compare two water levels with genotype, light and duration equal. Use repeated plants/runs and compare growth measurements, including variation.

  1. Specifies water variation and relevant controls.
  2. Uses repeated comparable growth observations to assess variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.7 · Adaptation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Feature, challenge, mechanism

Example information

A fictional animal has broad feet that spread its weight over soft mud. Narrower feet in the same model sink farther.

Question: How can broad feet help here?

Answer: They spread pressure and reduce sinking in the stated conditions.

Why: The explanation connects a feature to a specific environmental problem.

Example 2 · Different backgrounds
Different backgrounds
BackgroundDark survivors out of 10
Dark8
Pale3

Example information

A toy comparison gives dark variants 8 survivors out of 10 on dark ground and 3 out of 10 on pale ground.

Question: Is dark colour equally advantageous in both settings?

Answer: No. The modelled result differs by background.

Why: The numbers are fictional and show a context-dependent advantage.

Example 3 · One lifetime versus generations

Example information

A plant bends toward light during growth. A separate dataset tracks inherited leaf traits across many generations.

Question: Which dataset directly addresses inherited population change?

Answer: The multi-generation inherited-trait dataset.

Why: An individual response alone does not demonstrate evolutionary adaptation.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Adaptation explanation parts

Fixed scientific information

In this fictional inherited-feature model, a broad foot is the inherited feature, soft mud is the environmental challenge, and reduced sinking is a possible benefit.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which part is the inherited feature in this model?; Which part is the environmental challenge?; Which part is the proposed benefit?

  • a: Broad foot
  • b: Soft mud
  • c: Reduced sinking
  • d: A chosen future goal
Answer: Which part is the inherited feature in this model? → Broad foot; Which part is the environmental challenge? → Soft mud; Which part is the proposed benefit? → Reduced sinking

Which part is the inherited feature in this model: Broad foot. Which part is the environmental challenge: Soft mud. Which part is the proposed benefit: Reduced sinking.

Scientific explorer: selection lab

F2 · Different time scales

Fixed scientific information

A shows temporary individual adjustment, B shows inherited variants changing across generations, C shows no biological change.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which card addresses evolutionary adaptation?; Which addresses an individual response?; Which shows no change?

  • a: Card B
  • b: Card A
  • c: Card C
  • d: All changes are inherited
Answer: Which card addresses evolutionary adaptation? → Card B; Which addresses an individual response? → Card A; Which shows no change? → Card C

Which card addresses evolutionary adaptation: Card B. Which addresses an individual response: Card A. Which shows no change: Card C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Toy survival comparison

Fixed scientific information

On dark ground the fictional model records 9 dark and 4 pale survivors from 10 of each variant. Both colours were present beforehand.

F3 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which variant survives more often here?” → “Pale variant”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which variant survives more often here: Dark variant. Which survives less often here: Pale variant. When did the variants first occur in this scenario: Before the comparison.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Trade-off cards

Fixed scientific information

Feature A helps swimming but is less useful for climbing. B helps climbing but not swimming. C is an untested drawing.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which feature best fits the stated swimming task?

  • a: Feature A
  • b: Feature B
  • c: Feature C
  • d: One feature is best at everything
Answer: Feature A

Which feature best fits the stated swimming task: Feature A. Which fits climbing: Feature B. Which has no tested function yet: Feature C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A missing mechanism

Fixed scientific information

A fictional report says a certain plant leaf shape is “good” in dry conditions but gives no explanation.

F5 · Short answer

State what kind of mechanism evidence is missing and why the environment must be named.

Example of a full-credit answer: The report needs evidence of how the leaf feature affects a relevant outcome, such as water loss, under stated conditions. Its usefulness may differ in another environment.

  1. Requests a feature-to-function mechanism or relevant measured outcome.
  2. Explains context dependence on the environment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy model starts with 20 dark and 20 pale insects. On dark bark, 15 dark and 5 pale survive. Both colours are inherited in this fictional model.

1A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which variant has higher survival here?; How many total survivors remain?; Which environment was tested?

  • a: Dark
  • b: 20
  • c: Dark bark
  • d: Dark is best everywhere
Answer: Which variant has higher survival here? → Dark; How many total survivors remain? → 20; Which environment was tested? → Dark bark

Which variant has higher survival here: Dark. How many total survivors remain: 20. Which environment was tested: Dark bark.

1B · Short answer

Use the counts to explain a possible advantage and state its scope.

Example of a full-credit answer: Dark insects have 15/20 survivors compared with 5/20 pale, so dark colour has an advantage in this model on dark bark. This does not show it is best in every setting.

  1. Uses the survival comparison to identify the dark advantage.
  2. Restricts the conclusion to this environment/model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A links a measured feature to survival under a named condition. B says animals want a trait, so they inherit it. C assumes every visible part has a known benefit without testing.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation uses relevant evidence?; Which falsely makes need direct inheritance?; Which invents untested functions?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All stories are equally strong
Answer: Which explanation uses relevant evidence? → Explanation A; Which falsely makes need direct inheritance? → Explanation B; Which invents untested functions? → Explanation C

Which explanation uses relevant evidence: Explanation A. Which falsely makes need direct inheritance: Explanation B. Which invents untested functions: Explanation C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and name one additional kind of evidence that would strengthen an inherited-adaptation claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: A links feature and outcome in the right environment. Evidence that the feature is inherited and affects reproduction across generations would strengthen the claim.

  1. Identifies feature–environment–outcome evidence.
  2. Requests inheritance or multi-generation reproductive evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

The same fictional dark and pale variants now live on pale ground. The model records 4 dark and 14 pale survivors from 20 each.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which variant survives more often now? → Pale
  • b: What changed between comparisons? → Background
  • c: Which variant survives more often now? → Relative advantage
  • d: What must be reconsidered? → The old advantage is permanent
Answer: Which variant survives more often now? → Pale; What changed between comparisons? → Background

Which variant survives more often now: Pale. What changed between comparisons: Background. What must be reconsidered: Relative advantage.

3B · Short answer

Explain why the earlier dark-ground conclusion must be revised for this setting.

Example of a full-credit answer: Survival now favours pale variants, so the environment changes the relative advantage. A feature’s usefulness is not fixed across all backgrounds.

  1. Uses the new pale-survival advantage.
  2. Explains environmental dependence of advantage.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner writes “The insect saw dark bark and decided to pass a dark gene to its babies.” The model states inherited dark and pale variants existed already.

4A · Multiple choice

Which inherited colour variation existed before the bark comparison?

  • a: Both dark and pale variants
  • b: Only dark variants
  • c: Only pale variants
  • d: No inherited colour variation
Answer: Both dark and pale variants

Both inherited colours existed before the comparison. The new condition can affect success; it does not make an insect choose a needed gene.

4B · Open ended

Correct the explanation using existing variation and differential success.

Example of a full-credit answer: The insect did not choose a needed gene. Existing inherited variants can leave different numbers of offspring under the environment, changing the population over generations.

  1. Rejects purposeful acquisition/choice of a needed inherited trait.
  2. Explains existing variation and differential survival/reproduction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Test whether a fictional inherited colour affects survival on two backgrounds. Begin with equal colour counts and use the same model conditions except background.

5A · Hotspot

What should be changed between runs?

  • a: Background
  • b: Starting colour counts
  • c: Survival by colour
  • d: Release real animals into danger
Answer: Background

What should be changed between runs: Background. What should be held equal: Starting colour counts. What outcome should be recorded: Survival by colour.

5B · Open ended

Propose the comparison and a limitation to report.

Example of a full-credit answer: Run equal starting colour groups on dark and pale virtual backgrounds, record survival by colour and repeat. State that assumed survival rules do not prove a real species’ evolutionary history.

  1. Specifies controlled virtual comparison with relevant outcome.
  2. States a valid model/evolutionary-history limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.8 · Natural selection

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Count the inherited contribution
Count the inherited contribution
TypeSurvivorsOffspring eachTotal offspring
A428
B3412

Example information

A toy model has 4 surviving type-A organisms with 2 offspring each and 3 type-B survivors with 4 offspring each.

Question: Which contributes more offspring?

Answer: B contributes 12; A contributes 8.

Why: Survivor count alone would give an incomplete picture.

Example 2 · A changing fraction

Example information

A population starts with 10 A and 10 B. Later 15 of 20 descendants are A.

Question: How did the A fraction change?

Answer: From 50% to 75%.

Why: The denominator is needed to describe frequency.

Example 3 · Not a deliberate choice

Example information

A model population already includes resistant and non-resistant variants before a challenge.

Question: Must an individual choose resistance for selection to act?

Answer: No.

Why: Existing heritable differences can lead to different reproductive success.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Required ingredients

Fixed scientific information

The reference names inherited variation, different survival/reproductive success and changes over generations as parts of selection.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which ingredient provides differences passed onward?; Which ingredient changes descendant contribution?; Which time scale concerns population change?

  • a: Inherited variation
  • b: Reproductive success
  • c: Generations
  • d: Organisms choosing future needs
Answer: Which ingredient provides differences passed onward? → Inherited variation; Which ingredient changes descendant contribution? → Reproductive success; Which time scale concerns population change? → Generations

Which ingredient provides differences passed onward: Inherited variation. Which ingredient changes descendant contribution: Reproductive success. Which time scale concerns population change: Generations.

Scientific explorer: selection lab

F2 · Survivor arithmetic

Fixed scientific information

A toy round begins with 10 A and 10 B. Eight A and four B survive under the stated conditions.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which type has more survivors?

  • a: Type A
  • b: 12
  • c: 4
  • d: All twenty survive
Answer: Type A

Which type has more survivors: Type A. How many survivors are there in total: 12. How many B survive: 4.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Reproduction matters

Fixed scientific information

A model records 5 A survivors with 1 offspring each and 3 B survivors with 3 offspring each.

F3 · Hotspot

Which type contributes 9 offspring?

  • a: Type B
  • b: Type A
  • c: Offspring contribution
  • d: Survival count alone is enough
Answer: Type B

Which type contributes 9 offspring: Type B. Which contributes 5 offspring: Type A. What is being compared: Offspring contribution.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Possible mechanisms

Fixed scientific information

Card A describes differential success of inherited variants, B describes random sampling loss, and C describes new arrivals bringing variants.

F4 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which card describes selection?; Which describes chance change?; Which describes movement of variants?

  • a: Card A
  • b: Card B
  • c: Card C
  • d: All changes have one cause
Answer: Which card describes selection? → Card A; Which describes chance change? → Card B; Which describes movement of variants? → Card C

Which card describes selection: Card A. Which describes chance change: Card B. Which describes movement of variants: Card C.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F5 · A selection claim without inheritance

Fixed scientific information

A dataset shows one group surviving better, but gives no information about whether the differing feature is inherited or affects offspring.

F5 · Open ended

Name two pieces of evidence needed for a stronger natural-selection explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Check that the relevant feature is heritable and that it affects contribution to later generations through reproduction.

  1. Requests evidence of heritability.
  2. Requests evidence about reproductive/descendant contribution.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: selection lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy population starts with 20 A and 20 B. Half of A and one quarter of B survive. Every survivor has two offspring with its inherited type.

1A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “How many A offspring result?” → “10”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

How many A offspring result: 20. How many B offspring result: 10. What is the total offspring count: 30.

1B · Open ended

Calculate both offspring counts and explain the changed type ratio.

Example of a full-credit answer: A:20×1/2×2=20; B:20×1/4×2=10. Different survival under the model makes A two thirds of offspring despite equal starting counts.

  1. Calculates 20 A and 10 B offspring.
  2. Connects the changed ratio to differential survival and inherited reproduction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A uses heritable differences plus measured offspring contribution. B says organisms wished for a trait. C says the environment intentionally designed a new gene.

2A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation fits natural selection?; Which relies on wishing?; Which gives the environment a designing intention?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: Every story explains the data
Answer: Which explanation fits natural selection? → Explanation A; Which relies on wishing? → Explanation B; Which gives the environment a designing intention? → Explanation C

Which explanation fits natural selection: Explanation A. Which relies on wishing: Explanation B. Which gives the environment a designing intention: Explanation C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A by identifying the two links needed between variation and population change.

Example of a full-credit answer: The feature must be inherited, and it must affect how many descendants carry it into later generations.

  1. Identifies heritability.
  2. Identifies differential descendant contribution.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A model switches backgrounds. Previously A survived more; now B survives more. Both types remain heritable and each survivor produces the same number of offspring.

3A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which type now has the model advantage?; What changed?; What remains part of the mechanism?

  • a: Type B
  • b: Environment
  • c: Inherited variation
  • d: The old winner must always win
Answer: Which type now has the model advantage? → Type B; What changed? → Environment; What remains part of the mechanism? → Inherited variation

Which type now has the model advantage: Type B. What changed: Environment. What remains part of the mechanism: Inherited variation.

3B · Open ended

Predict the direction of frequency change under the new rule and explain the condition on your prediction.

Example of a full-credit answer: B is expected to become more common if the new survival difference and equal reproduction continue. The prediction follows the changed model conditions, not a permanent ranking.

  1. Predicts increased B frequency under the stated assumptions.
  2. States that the prediction depends on continuing conditions/model assumptions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Natural selection always favours the strongest individual.” In the toy record, smaller type B leaves more surviving offspring than larger type A.

4A · Multiple choice

Which measurement directly counts inherited contribution to the next generation?

  • a: Number of surviving offspring
  • b: Body size alone
  • c: Running strength alone
  • d: Age of the oldest individual alone
Answer: Number of surviving offspring

Surviving offspring count measures contribution to the next generation. In the supplied record, smaller type B leaves more such offspring than larger type A.

4B · Short answer

Correct the statement and use the record to explain your correction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Selection concerns reproductive success under the conditions, not strength or size alone. B leaves more surviving offspring in this record.

  1. Rejects universal strength/size ranking.
  2. Uses greater B offspring contribution as evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual experiment must begin with both inherited variants, record survival and offspring, and compare at least two environmental settings without harming real organisms.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which count measures inherited contribution to the next generation? → Offspring by variant
  • b: What should be present initially? → Both inherited variants
  • c: Which count measures inherited contribution to the next generation? → Environmental settings
  • d: What should be compared? → Make a needed trait by wishing
Answer: Which count measures inherited contribution to the next generation? → Offspring by variant; What should be present initially? → Both inherited variants

What should be recorded beyond survival: Offspring by variant. What should be present initially: Both inherited variants. What should be compared: Environmental settings.

5B · Open ended

Propose the measurements and a fair comparison for the virtual experiment.

Example of a full-credit answer: Start with equal variant counts in each environment, keep other rules equal, and record survival and inherited offspring counts. Repeat to inspect chance variation.

  1. Proposes relevant survival and offspring measurements by variant.
  2. Proposes comparable starting conditions/controls across environments.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.9 · Evolution

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Growth or evolution?

Example information

One seedling grows taller in a month. Separately, a population’s inherited marker frequency changes across ten generations.

Question: Which record concerns evolutionary change?

Answer: The inherited population-frequency record.

Why: The seedling’s growth is an individual developmental change.

Example 2 · Track a frequency
Track a frequency
GenerationA countPopulation
1840
62040

Example information

A fictional population has 8 marker-A individuals out of 40 in generation 1 and 20 out of 40 in generation 6.

Question: How does the A frequency change?

Answer: From 20% to 50%.

Why: The result describes an inherited-marker pattern; the table alone does not reveal the mechanism.

Example 3 · Use independent clues

Example information

A proposed relationship fits both a set of anatomical observations and DNA comparisons.

Question: Why is that stronger than one resemblance alone?

Answer: Independent evidence checks the explanation from different directions.

Why: Agreement improves confidence but still requires careful interpretation of each source.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Time-scale distinctions

Fixed scientific information

A describes one animal growing, B describes inherited frequencies across generations and C describes a photograph becoming larger.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which describes evolution?; Which describes individual growth?; Which changes only a representation?

  • a: Record B
  • b: Record A
  • c: Record C
  • d: All size changes are evolution
Answer: Which describes evolution? → Record B; Which describes individual growth? → Record A; Which changes only a representation? → Record C

Which describes evolution: Record B. Which describes individual growth: Record A. Which changes only a representation: Record C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Mechanism cards

Fixed scientific information

A records an inherited feature linked with unequal descendant contribution, B records random loss in a small population, and C records arrivals carrying new variants.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which card fits natural selection?” → “Card A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which card fits natural selection: Card A. Which fits chance change: Card B. Which fits movement between populations: Card C.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F3 · A generation table

Fixed scientific information

A fictional inherited marker is present in 6 of 20 individuals initially and 12 of 20 later.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is its initial frequency?; What is its later frequency?; What is the increase in percentage points?

  • a: 30%
  • b: 60%
  • c: 30 points
  • d: Every individual chose the marker
Answer: What is its initial frequency? → 30%; What is its later frequency? → 60%; What is the increase in percentage points? → 30 points

What is its initial frequency: 30%. What is its later frequency: 60%. What is the increase in percentage points: 30 points.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Evidence sources

Fixed scientific information

A contains dated fossil observations, B compares DNA sequences, and C compares anatomical structures of living organisms.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which source examines preserved past remains? → Source A
  • b: Which examines genetic information? → Source B
  • c: Which source examines preserved past remains? → Source C
  • d: Which examines body structures? → One slogan replaces evidence
Answer: Which source examines preserved past remains? → Source A; Which examines genetic information? → Source B

Which source examines preserved past remains: Source A. Which examines genetic information: Source B. Which examines body structures: Source C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A cause not yet shown

Fixed scientific information

A fictional population’s inherited marker becomes more common over five generations. The record gives no survival, reproduction, migration or sampling information.

F5 · Short answer

State what the table shows and explain why the mechanism is still uncertain.

Example of a full-credit answer: It shows a change in inherited-marker frequency over generations. Several mechanisms could cause it, so the table alone does not identify selection or another cause.

  1. Identifies inherited-frequency change across generations.
  2. Explains that mechanism cannot be identified without additional evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Generation 1 has 10 A individuals out of 50; generation 5 has 18 A out of 30. Counts and population sizes both change.

1A · Multiple choice

What is the first A frequency?

  • a: 20%
  • b: 60%
  • c: 40 points
  • d: Only 8 percentage points
Answer: 20%

What is the first A frequency: 20%. What is the later A frequency: 60%. What is the increase in percentage points: 40 points.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the frequencies and explain why count difference alone is not the frequency change.

Example of a full-credit answer: 10/50=20% and 18/30=60%. The increase is 40 percentage points; the count difference of 8 ignores the changed denominators.

  1. Correctly calculates 20% and 60%.
  2. Explains denominator-based frequency comparison rather than raw count difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A combines inheritance records with measured survival and offspring. B says evolution always aims at perfection. C says one individual decided to evolve.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation uses mechanism evidence?; Which invents an ideal goal?; Which confuses individual intention with population change?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All explanations are equally scientific
Answer: Which explanation uses mechanism evidence? → Explanation A; Which invents an ideal goal? → Explanation B; Which confuses individual intention with population change? → Explanation C

Which explanation uses mechanism evidence: Explanation A. Which invents an ideal goal: Explanation B. Which confuses individual intention with population change: Explanation C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and explain one problem with a goal-directed story.

Example of a full-credit answer: A links inherited variation with descendant contribution. A goal-directed story invents intention or guaranteed perfection that the evidence does not require.

  1. Identifies mechanism/inheritance evidence.
  2. Rejects purpose/perfection as an unsupported assumption.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A population initially has 5 B and 15 A. Ten B individuals arrive and reproduce under the same rules as residents. No selection difference is stated.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the immediate new B count?; What is the immediate total population?; Which event directly changed the mixture?

  • a: 15
  • b: 30
  • c: Arrivals
  • d: Selection alone is proven
Answer: What is the immediate new B count? → 15; What is the immediate total population? → 30; Which event directly changed the mixture? → Arrivals

What is the immediate new B count: 15. What is the immediate total population: 30. Which event directly changed the mixture: Arrivals.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the new B fraction and identify the source-grounded mechanism.

Example of a full-credit answer: 15/30=50% B. Arrival of individuals carrying B changes the mixture; no survival advantage is established.

  1. Calculates 50% B after arrivals.
  2. Identifies movement/gene flow rather than unsupported selection.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A poster ranks living species from “unfinished” to “perfect” using chromosome count. The reference describes branching ancestry and context-dependent traits.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which pattern better represents ancestry? → Branching relationships
  • b: What does chromosome count not establish? → A perfection ranking
  • c: Which pattern better represents ancestry? → Environmental context
  • d: What influences trait usefulness? → One universal progress ladder
Answer: Which pattern better represents ancestry? → Branching relationships; What does chromosome count not establish? → A perfection ranking

Which pattern better represents ancestry: Branching relationships. What does chromosome count not establish: A perfection ranking. What influences trait usefulness: Environmental context.

4B · Open ended

Correct the ranking idea and explain why a single count cannot order species by evolutionary worth.

Example of a full-credit answer: Evolution has branching histories, not a ladder of perfect species. Chromosome number does not measure worth, intelligence or universal adaptation.

  1. Replaces the ladder with branching ancestry/no universal perfection.
  2. Rejects chromosome count as a ranking of evolutionary worth.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A display must show inherited frequencies over generations and identify evidence relevant to a possible mechanism. It must distinguish observations from explanations.

5A · Hotspot

Which record directly tracks inherited marker frequency across generations?

  • a: Generation-frequency table
  • b: Survival and offspring data
  • c: Mechanism remains a hypothesis until tested
  • d: Intentions of organisms
Answer: Generation-frequency table

Which record shows the population pattern: Generation-frequency table. Which record can test selection: Survival and offspring data. Which label prevents overclaiming: Mechanism remains a hypothesis until tested.

5B · Open ended

Propose the population record and one additional mechanism check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Record inherited marker counts and total population over several generations. Check survival and offspring by marker, or document arrivals and chance sampling, before assigning a mechanism.

  1. Includes counts/denominators over generations.
  2. Proposes relevant evidence distinguishing mechanisms.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.10 · Biotechnology

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · An older biological tool

Example information

A food-production diagram uses yeast’s existing metabolism to change dough. It shows no direct DNA editing.

Question: Is it still an example of biotechnology?

Answer: Yes.

Why: It uses a living system for a useful process; gene editing is not required by the definition.

Example 2 · Choose parents or edit DNA?
Choose parents or edit DNA?
PlanMechanism
AChoose parents
BDirect DNA change

Example information

Plan A selects plants as parents. Plan B deliberately changes a chosen DNA sequence using a laboratory method.

Question: How do their mechanisms differ?

Answer: A is selective breeding; B is genetic engineering.

Why: Naming the mechanism is more precise than calling both the same procedure.

Example 3 · One promising measurement

Example information

A fictional virtual process produces 14 units instead of 10. It has no safety or quality measurements.

Question: What can be concluded?

Answer: Output increased in the model; safety and quality remain unestablished.

Why: A benefit measure does not answer different questions automatically.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three biotechnology methods

Fixed scientific information

The reference distinguishes fermentation using microbes, selective breeding choosing parents and genetic engineering directly changing genetic information.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which method chooses parents? → Selective breeding
  • b: Which uses microbial processing? → Fermentation
  • c: Which method chooses parents? → Genetic engineering
  • d: Which directly changes genetic information? → Every method is identical
Answer: Which method chooses parents? → Selective breeding; Which uses microbial processing? → Fermentation

Which method chooses parents: Selective breeding. Which uses microbial processing: Fermentation. Which directly changes genetic information: Genetic engineering.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Identify components

Fixed scientific information

A model uses a microorganism as the biological tool, sugar as an input and a useful product as its output. The model is not a practical culturing protocol.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which component is the biological tool?” → “Sugar”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which component is the biological tool: Microorganism. Which is the input: Sugar. Which is the intended output: Useful product.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Fictional output data

Fixed scientific information

Virtual method A produces 8 units, B produces 12 and C produces 10 under the same stated conditions.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which has greatest model output?; Which has least output?; Which produces 10 units?

  • a: Method B
  • b: Method A
  • c: Method C
  • d: Highest output proves complete safety
Answer: Which has greatest model output? → Method B; Which has least output? → Method A; Which produces 10 units? → Method C

Which has greatest model output: Method B. Which has least output: Method A. Which produces 10 units: Method C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Evaluation questions

Fixed scientific information

A asks about output quantity, B asks about unwanted effects and C asks about cost/access. These are distinct evaluation dimensions.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which question concerns productivity?

  • a: Question A
  • b: Question B
  • c: Question C
  • d: One number answers all questions
Answer: Question A

Which question concerns productivity: Question A. Which concerns possible harm: Question B. Which concerns practical availability: Question C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Not all methods edit DNA

Fixed scientific information

A learner says a controlled process using ordinary yeast is not biotechnology because no gene was edited.

F5 · Open ended

Correct the definition and identify the biological system used.

Example of a full-credit answer: Biotechnology can use existing living processes without editing DNA. Here yeast is the biological system used for a useful process.

  1. Explains that biotechnology does not require direct gene editing.
  2. Identifies yeast/living microbial activity as the tool.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

In a fictional virtual process, method P produces 15 units and Q produces 21 from equal input amounts. No other outcomes are measured.

1A · Hotspot

How much greater is Q’s output?

  • a: 6 units
  • b: Method Q
  • c: Complete safety
  • d: Q is best in every respect
Answer: 6 units

How much greater is Q’s output: 6 units. Which method has greater measured output: Method Q. Which conclusion remains untested: Complete safety.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the output difference and state one evaluation question left unanswered.

Example of a full-credit answer: 21−15=6 units. Safety, product quality, environmental effects, cost or another unmeasured outcome still needs evidence.

  1. Calculates a 6-unit difference.
  2. Names a relevant unmeasured evaluation dimension.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says parents are selected and offspring traits checked. B says plants wished for a useful gene. C says every microorganism is dangerous.

2A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which description fits selective breeding?; Which invents purposeful genetic change?; Which overgeneralises about microbes?

  • a: Description A
  • b: Description B
  • c: Description C
  • d: All are accurate mechanisms
Answer: Which description fits selective breeding? → Description A; Which invents purposeful genetic change? → Description B; Which overgeneralises about microbes? → Description C

Which description fits selective breeding: Description A. Which invents purposeful genetic change: Description B. Which overgeneralises about microbes: Description C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A by explaining the biological process and one limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Parents with selected features are bred and offspring evaluated. Outcomes still vary; it is not a guarantee that every offspring has every desired feature.

  1. Describes parent selection and inherited offspring variation.
  2. States a valid limit on guaranteed outcomes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A process uses a purified enzyme made by cells to help a reaction. No living organism remains in the final reaction vessel. An enzyme is a biological molecule.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What biological part is used?; Where was it produced in this example?; Why can the process count as biotechnology?

  • a: Enzyme
  • b: Cells
  • c: It uses a biological part
  • d: Only whole organisms ever count
Answer: What biological part is used? → Enzyme; Where was it produced in this example? → Cells; Why can the process count as biotechnology? → It uses a biological part

What biological part is used: Enzyme. Where was it produced in this example: Cells. Why can the process count as biotechnology: It uses a biological part.

3B · Open ended

Explain why this can be biotechnology and how it differs from using whole growing microbes.

Example of a full-credit answer: It uses a biological enzyme for a useful process. The reaction uses the isolated part rather than living, reproducing whole organisms.

  1. Connects biological-part use to biotechnology.
  2. Distinguishes isolated enzyme from whole living microbes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A report says “The new process has a higher yield, so it is proven safe for every use.” Only yield was measured in a virtual comparison.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is supported?” → “Higher model yield”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

What is supported: Higher model yield. What is not established: Safety for every use. What is needed next: Relevant additional tests.

4B · Short answer

Identify the logical error and name one appropriate next evaluation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The report substitutes a productivity result for safety evidence. Test relevant quality, contamination, environmental or other safety outcomes with an appropriate design.

  1. Distinguishes yield evidence from universal safety.
  2. Proposes a relevant additional evaluation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A proposed biotechnology must be compared with an existing method for both a benefit and a concern. Use virtual or supplied data, not unknown organism cultures.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What should measure the intended benefit?; What should examine the concern?; What makes comparison interpretable?

  • a: Relevant performance outcome
  • b: Possible unwanted effect
  • c: Comparable conditions
  • d: Release first, ask later
Answer: What should measure the intended benefit? → Relevant performance outcome; What should examine the concern? → Possible unwanted effect; What makes comparison interpretable? → Comparable conditions

What should measure the intended benefit: Relevant performance outcome. What should examine the concern: Possible unwanted effect. What makes comparison interpretable: Comparable conditions.

5B · Open ended

Propose one benefit measure and one concern measure for a specific hypothetical application.

Example of a full-credit answer: For a crop model, compare yield under equal conditions and also examine effects on a selected non-target organism. Other justified application-specific measures are acceptable.

  1. Gives a specific application with a relevant benefit measure.
  2. Gives a relevant concern/risk measure for that application.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S7.11 · Benefits and risks of biotechnology

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Benefit and concern differ

Example information

A fictional crop model uses less water than a comparison but has not measured effects on nearby insects.

Question: What benefit is shown and what remains uncertain?

Answer: Reduced model water use is shown; insect effects remain unknown.

Why: Evidence for one outcome does not answer another.

Example 2 · Compare a trade-off
Compare a trade-off
OptionWater unitsYield units
A1020
B818

Example information

Option A uses 10 water units and yields 20 units. B uses 8 and yields 18.

Question: Does B improve both measured quantities?

Answer: No. It uses less water but also yields less in this model.

Why: A decision must consider the trade-off and the goal.

Example 3 · A small test’s limit

Example information

A trial records no unwanted effect in a small sample during a short period.

Question: Does that prove no effect can occur anywhere?

Answer: No.

Why: Rare, delayed or condition-dependent effects may not appear in the limited test.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Outcome categories

Fixed scientific information

A trial measures crop yield, water use and effects on a non-target insect. Each outcome addresses a different question.

F1 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which measure addresses productivity?; Which addresses resource use?; Which addresses a possible ecological concern?

  • a: Crop yield
  • b: Water use
  • c: Non-target insect effect
  • d: One result answers everything
Answer: Which measure addresses productivity? → Crop yield; Which addresses resource use? → Water use; Which addresses a possible ecological concern? → Non-target insect effect

Which measure addresses productivity: Crop yield. Which addresses resource use: Water use. Which addresses a possible ecological concern: Non-target insect effect.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Comparison design

Fixed scientific information

Plan A uses comparable plots with equal stated inputs. B uses different soils and water amounts. C uses no existing-method comparison.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which plan has the clearest comparison? → Plan A
  • b: Which has multiple confounding conditions? → Plan B
  • c: Which plan has the clearest comparison? → Plan C
  • d: Which lacks a comparison option? → Any higher number proves benefit
Answer: Which plan has the clearest comparison? → Plan A; Which has multiple confounding conditions? → Plan B

Which plan has the clearest comparison: Plan A. Which has multiple confounding conditions: Plan B. Which lacks a comparison option: Plan C.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F3 · Fictional option table

Fixed scientific information

Option P uses 12 water units and gives 24 yield units. Q uses 9 water units and gives 21 yield units.

F3 · Hotspot

Which option uses less water?

  • a: Option Q
  • b: Option P
  • c: A trade-off decision
  • d: Q improves every outcome
Answer: Option Q

Which option uses less water: Option Q. Which gives more total yield: Option P. What kind of decision is needed: A trade-off decision.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Interpreting uncertainty

Fixed scientific information

A says no harm was observed in this limited test. B says harm is impossible everywhere. C requests relevant monitoring in other conditions.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which statement describes the observation accurately?; Which overclaims certainty?; Which seeks further evidence?

  • a: Statement A
  • b: Statement B
  • c: Statement C
  • d: A separate cost estimate
Answer: Which statement describes the observation accurately? → Statement A; Which overclaims certainty? → Statement B; Which seeks further evidence? → Statement C

Which statement describes the observation accurately: Statement A. Which overclaims certainty: Statement B. Which seeks further evidence: Statement C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · One outcome is missing

Fixed scientific information

A proposal gives strong yield data but no information about a specified environmental concern. Its author says the yield alone settles the decision.

F5 · Short answer

Explain what the yield evidence establishes and what additional evidence is needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: It establishes the measured productivity comparison. Evidence about the named environmental concern is still needed before claiming the entire decision is settled.

  1. Limits yield evidence to productivity.
  2. Requests evidence for the distinct environmental concern.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional new process uses 7 water units for 21 product units; the comparison uses 10 water units for the same 21. Quality and environmental effects are not measured.

1A · Multiple choice

How much water is saved in this comparison?

  • a: 3 units
  • b: 21 product units
  • c: Quality and environmental effects
  • d: Every risk is removed
Answer: 3 units

How much water is saved in this comparison: 3 units. Which output is held equal: 21 product units. Which issue remains unmeasured: Quality and environmental effects.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the saving and give a bounded conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: 10−7=3 water units are saved for the same measured output. This shows a resource-use benefit under the model conditions, not complete safety or superiority.

  1. Calculates a 3-unit saving.
  2. Restricts the conclusion to the measured benefit/conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A compares benefits, concerns and alternatives with stated limits. B says every new technology is safe. C says every biological technology is harmful.

2A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which review is application-specific?; Which makes an automatic-safety claim?; Which makes an automatic-harm claim?

  • a: Review A
  • b: Review B
  • c: Review C
  • d: Labels replace evidence
Answer: Which review is application-specific? → Review A; Which makes an automatic-safety claim? → Review B; Which makes an automatic-harm claim? → Review C

Which review is application-specific: Review A. Which makes an automatic-safety claim: Review B. Which makes an automatic-harm claim: Review C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A using two features of a responsible comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: It examines relevant benefits and concerns for the particular application and compares realistic alternatives while acknowledging limits.

  1. Identifies relevant benefit/concern evidence.
  2. Identifies alternatives or clearly stated limits as a second feature.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A technology tested in a contained food-production system is proposed for an outdoor setting. Exposure routes and neighbouring organisms differ.

3A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What changed?; What new evidence may be needed?; What should not be assumed?

  • a: Use environment
  • b: Outdoor effects and exposure
  • c: Identical risk in every setting
  • d: Measured product output in the contained test
Answer: What changed? → Use environment; What new evidence may be needed? → Outdoor effects and exposure; What should not be assumed? → Identical risk in every setting

What changed: Use environment. What new evidence may be needed: Outdoor effects and exposure. What should not be assumed: Identical risk in every setting.

3B · Short answer

Explain why the original evidence remains useful but insufficient for every new claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: It informs the contained process. Outdoor conditions introduce different exposures and ecological interactions that need relevant evidence.

  1. Recognises the original evidence’s bounded value.
  2. Identifies new setting-specific exposure/ecological evidence needs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A report observes no harm in 12 short model trials and concludes “risk is exactly zero forever.” No rare or long-term outcomes were examined.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is supported?” → “Zero risk forever”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What is supported: No harm observed in those trials. What is not established: Zero risk forever. What limits the conclusion: Small short-duration test.

4B · Open ended

Identify the overclaim and give one reason the test could miss an effect.

Example of a full-credit answer: No observed harm in this small short test does not prove zero risk everywhere. Rare effects, delayed effects or other conditions may not be captured.

  1. Rejects the universal zero-risk conclusion.
  2. Names a valid reason effects could be missed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A fictional crop proposal meets its yield goal but lacks data on a named non-target insect. The task is to recommend a next evidence step, not to release organisms.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which outcome is already measured?; Which concern needs evidence?; Which next step fits the uncertainty?

  • a: Yield
  • b: Non-target insect effect
  • c: Controlled relevant evaluation
  • d: Unconditional release now
Answer: Which outcome is already measured? → Yield; Which concern needs evidence? → Non-target insect effect; Which next step fits the uncertainty? → Controlled relevant evaluation

Which outcome is already measured: Yield. Which concern needs evidence: Non-target insect effect. Which next step fits the uncertainty: Controlled relevant evaluation.

5B · Open ended

Propose a conditional next step and state what result would matter to the decision.

Example of a full-credit answer: Continue appropriate controlled evaluation of non-target insect outcomes against a comparison. Use those results alongside yield and other relevant evidence before deciding on wider use.

  1. Proposes controlled evaluation of the specified missing concern.
  2. Explains how the new evidence would inform a conditional decision.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.1 · Habitats

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · One missing requirement

Example information

A fictional insect needs shade, leaf food and shelter. Site A has food and shade but no shelter.

Question: Which stated requirement is missing?

Answer: Shelter.

Why: Several suitable features do not compensate automatically for every missing need.

Example 2 · Equal visits
Equal visits
VisitObserved insects
12
25
33

Example information

A class observes a habitat for 10 minutes on three days and records 2, 5 and 3 target insects.

Question: Why are three visits useful?

Answer: They show variation in observed use.

Why: A single count would not describe every visit.

Example 3 · Define the target

Example information

A pond design suits a freshwater plant but is offered as an identical habitat for a dry-land cactus.

Question: What is wrong with that reasoning?

Answer: It ignores the organisms’ different requirements.

Why: Habitat suitability is organism-specific.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Needs at a site

Fixed scientific information

The target insect needs leaf food, a shaded refuge and a dry crevice for shelter. Each is listed separately.

F1 · Hotspot

Which feature supplies food?

  • a: Leaves
  • b: Shaded refuge
  • c: Dry crevice
  • d: Painted sign
Answer: Leaves

Which feature supplies food: Leaves. Which reduces direct sunlight: Shaded refuge. Which provides the named shelter: Dry crevice.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F2 · Types of features

Fixed scientific information

A model labels a shrub as living, water temperature as nonliving and the whole used place as habitat.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which is a nonliving condition?” → “Water temperature”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which is a nonliving condition: Water temperature. Which is a living feature: Shrub. Which term describes the used place and conditions: Habitat.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Fictional site counts

Fixed scientific information

Equal 10-minute visits find 3 insects at A, 7 at B and 5 at C.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which site has the largest observed count?

  • a: Site B
  • b: Site A
  • c: Site C
  • d: One count proves permanent absence
Answer: Site B

Which site has the largest observed count: Site B. Which has the smallest: Site A. Which has five insects: Site C.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A requirement checklist

Fixed scientific information

Site P meets food, shelter and moisture needs. Q lacks shelter. R lacks food. These are the complete requirements of the toy example.

F4 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which site meets all stated requirements?; Which lacks shelter?; Which lacks food?

  • a: Site P
  • b: Site Q
  • c: Site R
  • d: Every attractive site is suitable
Answer: Which site meets all stated requirements? → Site P; Which lacks shelter? → Site Q; Which lacks food? → Site R

Which site meets all stated requirements: Site P. Which lacks shelter: Site Q. Which lacks food: Site R.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · One empty visit

Fixed scientific information

A survey finds no target insect during one brief visit to a suitable-looking patch.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why this does not prove permanent absence and propose an improved observation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The insect may be hidden or active at another time. Repeat comparable visits at relevant times and record conditions.

  1. Identifies limited detection/time as a reason absence is not proven.
  2. Proposes repeated comparable observations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A fictional frog needs fresh water, damp shelter and insect food. Site A has all three; B has only water and food; C has damp shelter and food but no fresh water.

1A · Hotspot

Which site meets all stated needs?

  • a: Site A
  • b: Site B
  • c: Site C
  • d: All sites equally meet the list
Answer: Site A

Which site meets all stated needs: Site A. Which lacks damp shelter: Site B. Which lacks fresh water: Site C.

1B · Short answer

Choose a site and justify it with two requirements from the source.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose A because it supplies fresh water and damp shelter, as well as the listed food.

  1. Chooses A using a correct stated requirement.
  2. Uses a second correct stated requirement as evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A repeats equal-time observations across relevant periods. B visits only once for one minute. C judges photographs by colour.

2A · Multiple choice

Which plan best studies habitat use?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: Colour proves occupancy
Answer: Plan A

Which plan best studies habitat use: Plan A. Which has very limited observation: Plan B. Which substitutes appearance for use evidence: Plan C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and state one limitation that may remain.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repeated comparable visits capture variation. Some animals may still stay hidden or use the site outside observed periods.

  1. Explains the value of repeated comparable visits.
  2. Identifies a remaining detection/time limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A shaded wet patch suits the stated moisture-loving insect. A new target requires dry shelter and open sunny ground.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What must be identified before judging the new habitat?; Which requirement belongs to the new target?; What should be reassessed?

  • a: Target organism’s needs
  • b: Dry shelter
  • c: Habitat suitability
  • d: The old site is automatically ideal
Answer: What must be identified before judging the new habitat? → Target organism’s needs; Which requirement belongs to the new target? → Dry shelter; What should be reassessed? → Habitat suitability

What must be identified before judging the new habitat: Target organism’s needs. Which requirement belongs to the new target: Dry shelter. What should be reassessed: Habitat suitability.

3B · Short answer

Explain why the old recommendation must be checked again and name one new requirement.

Example of a full-credit answer: The new organism has different needs, so the wet shaded site may not suit it. Check for dry shelter or sunny ground.

  1. Explains organism-specific suitability.
  2. Names a new stated requirement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “No animals in one picture means this place is not a habitat.” The reference explains that habitat concerns conditions and use, including organisms not visible in a photo.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What does the picture directly show? → No visible animals at that moment
  • b: What does it not prove? → No organisms ever use the site
  • c: What does the picture directly show? → Repeated observations
  • d: What could improve knowledge? → A photo reveals all life
Answer: What does the picture directly show? → No visible animals at that moment; What does it not prove? → No organisms ever use the site

What does the picture directly show: No visible animals at that moment. What does it not prove: No organisms ever use the site. What could improve knowledge: Repeated observations.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim and identify evidence needed to assess actual use.

Example of a full-credit answer: The photo only records visible features at one time. Repeated observations and signs of the target organism would better assess use.

  1. Limits the photo evidence to its time/visibility.
  2. Proposes relevant additional observations or signs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A target insect has food but lacks shelter in a school patch. Use appropriate local materials and observe without releasing new organisms.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which action addresses the stated gap?; Which evidence checks use?; Which instruction explicitly prevents bringing unfamiliar organisms into the patch?

  • a: Add suitable shelter
  • b: Repeated target-insect observations
  • c: Do not release unknown species
  • d: Paint shelter without checking use
Answer: Which action addresses the stated gap? → Add suitable shelter; Which evidence checks use? → Repeated target-insect observations; Which instruction explicitly prevents bringing unfamiliar organisms into the patch? → Do not release unknown species

Which action addresses the stated gap: Add suitable shelter. Which evidence checks use: Repeated target-insect observations. Which action avoids an introduction risk: Do not release unknown species.

5B · Open ended

Propose a shelter change and a fair way to check it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Add a suitable sheltered refuge, keeping the food source. Compare repeated equal-time insect observations before and after, ideally with an unchanged patch.

  1. Proposes appropriate shelter addressing the gap.
  2. Proposes comparable evidence of use with a baseline or comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.2 · Populations

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A population boundary

Example information

A pond has 12 of snail species A and 7 of species B on one survey date.

Question: Do the 19 snails form one same-species population?

Answer: No. The record contains two species populations.

Why: The species definition matters.

Example 2 · A local budget
A local budget
EventCount
Start20
Births5
Arrivals2
Deaths3
Departures1

Example information

A toy population starts at 20, gains 5 births and 2 arrivals, and loses 3 deaths and 1 departure.

Question: What is the new count?

Answer: 23.

Why: 20+5+2−3−1=23.

Example 3 · Density differs from count

Example information

Site A has 8 snails in 2 m²; B has 12 in 6 m².

Question: Which has greater observed density?

Answer: A: 4 per m² versus B: 2 per m².

Why: The larger raw count occurs in the larger surveyed area.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A defined population

Fixed scientific information

The record is one frog species, inside pond P, on a stated survey day.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which detail defines the organism group?; Which defines the spatial boundary?; Which defines the time?

  • a: Frog species
  • b: Pond P
  • c: Survey day
  • d: All life everywhere
Answer: Which detail defines the organism group? → Frog species; Which defines the spatial boundary? → Pond P; Which defines the time? → Survey day

Which detail defines the organism group: Frog species. Which defines the spatial boundary: Pond P. Which defines the time: Survey day.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Additions and losses

Fixed scientific information

The model has births inside the area, arrivals from outside and departures to outside.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which event adds newborn individuals? → Births
  • b: Which adds individuals from outside? → Arrivals
  • c: Which event adds newborn individuals? → Departures
  • d: Which removes individuals by movement? → Every decline is death
Answer: Which event adds newborn individuals? → Births; Which adds individuals from outside? → Arrivals

Which event adds newborn individuals: Births. Which adds individuals from outside: Arrivals. Which removes individuals by movement: Departures.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F3 · One model interval

Fixed scientific information

Start=18; births=4; deaths=2; arrivals=2; departures=3. All events are known.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final count?; What is the total number added?; What is the total number lost?

  • a: 19 individuals
  • b: 6 individuals
  • c: 5 individuals
  • d: 28 individuals
Answer: What is the final count? → 19 individuals; What is the total number added? → 6 individuals; What is the total number lost? → 5 individuals

What is the final count: 19 individuals. What is the total number added: 6 individuals. What is the total number lost: 5 individuals.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Count and density

Fixed scientific information

A survey finds 15 organisms in 3 m². Count is 15, area is 3 m² and density is 5 per m².

F4 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is the density?” → “15 organisms”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What is the density: 5 per m². What is the count: 15 organisms. What is the area: 3 m².

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A local decline

Fixed scientific information

The observed count of one bird species falls after several birds are seen leaving the defined area. No death record is supplied.

F5 · Open ended

Give a source-grounded explanation for part of the decline and explain why deaths are not established.

Example of a full-credit answer: Departures can reduce the local count. A count decline without death evidence does not prove the missing birds died.

  1. Identifies departure/emigration as a plausible contribution.
  2. Distinguishes absence from evidence of death.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy population starts at 30. There are 6 births, 4 arrivals, 3 deaths and 5 departures in one interval.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is the final population? → 32
  • b: How many individuals are added? → 10
  • c: What is the final population? → 8
  • d: How many are lost? → 48
Answer: What is the final population? → 32; How many individuals are added? → 10

What is the final population: 32. How many individuals are added: 10. How many are lost: 8.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the new count and show how movement is included.

Example of a full-credit answer: 30+6+4−3−5=32. Four arrivals add individuals and five departures remove them from the defined area.

  1. Calculates 32.
  2. Correctly explains arrival and departure contributions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A counts the same species, area and duration repeatedly. B doubles the area without noting it. C changes the species definition.

2A · Multiple choice

Which survey best compares counts over time?

  • a: Survey A
  • b: Survey B
  • c: Survey C
  • d: All counts are comparable
Answer: Survey A

Which survey best compares counts over time: Survey A. Which changes the surveyed area: Survey B. Which changes the organism group: Survey C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A using two matching features.

Example of a full-credit answer: It keeps the species and area consistent and uses comparable observation effort, so changes are easier to interpret.

  1. Identifies one relevant constant definition/effort feature.
  2. Identifies a second relevant constant feature.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

Patch P has 24 snails in 6 m²; Q has 18 in 3 m². Both records use the same species and method.

3A · Hotspot

What is P’s density?

  • a: 4 per m²
  • b: 6 per m²
  • c: Patch Q
  • d: P has higher density because 24 is larger
Answer: 4 per m²

What is P’s density: 4 per m². What is Q’s density: 6 per m². Which has higher density: Patch Q.

3B · Open ended

Compare the densities and explain why the larger count need not mean greater density.

Example of a full-credit answer: P is 24/6=4 and Q is 18/3=6 per m². P’s count covers a larger area.

  1. Correctly calculates/compares both densities.
  2. Explains the area denominator.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A toy model adds five individuals per step for three steps. A learner concludes the real population will increase by five forever.

4A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is directly described?; What may change in nature?; Which prediction about this population goes beyond the three toy steps?

  • a: Three toy steps
  • b: Births, losses and resources
  • c: Endless fixed growth
  • d: A finite three-step observation
Answer: What is directly described? → Three toy steps; What may change in nature? → Births, losses and resources; Which prediction about this population goes beyond the three toy steps? → Endless fixed growth

What is directly described: Three toy steps. What may change in nature: Births, losses and resources. What is not established: Endless fixed growth.

4B · Short answer

Identify the overextension and name one factor that could change future growth.

Example of a full-credit answer: The learner extends a fixed short model indefinitely. Resources, deaths, births or movement can change the real population’s rate.

  1. Rejects indefinite extrapolation from the toy rule.
  2. Names a relevant changing factor.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A record must define a species, area and time and distinguish counts from explanations of change.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What identifies the organisms?; What fixes the boundary?; What tracks the interval?

  • a: Species name
  • b: Mapped area
  • c: Survey dates
  • d: An unlabeled total
Answer: What identifies the organisms? → Species name; What fixes the boundary? → Mapped area; What tracks the interval? → Survey dates

What identifies the organisms: Species name. What fixes the boundary: Mapped area. What tracks the interval: Survey dates.

5B · Open ended

Propose the record headings and one additional observation needed to explain changes.

Example of a full-credit answer: Record species, area, date, method and count. Also record evidence of births, deaths or movement rather than assuming a cause from count alone.

  1. Includes clear species/area/time/count information.
  2. Adds a relevant process observation to explain change.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.3 · Communities

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Population or community?

Example information

A record lists one snail species and also algae, insects and fish in the same pond.

Question: Which term fits all these living populations together?

Answer: Community.

Why: The single snail species is one population within it.

Example 2 · Same total, different composition
Same total, different composition
SiteRecorded groups
A12 grasses
B4 grasses, 4 shrubs, 4 ferns

Example information

Site A has 12 plants of one grass species. Site B has 4 of that grass species, 4 of one shrub species and 4 of one fern species.

Question: Do both sites have the same recorded species mixture?

Answer: No, although both totals are 12.

Why: Composition cannot be recovered from the total alone.

Example 3 · Trace an indirect link

Example information

A simple web has plants feeding insects, and insects feeding birds.

Question: Why might a plant decline affect birds?

Answer: It could reduce food for insects and then food for birds.

Why: The prediction follows two links and is conditional, not certain.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Organisation levels

Fixed scientific information

One snail is an organism; snails of one species in a pond form a population; several species populations form the community.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which level includes several species populations?; Which includes one species in the pond?; Which is one individual?

  • a: Community
  • b: Population
  • c: Organism
  • d: Temperature population
Answer: Which level includes several species populations? → Community; Which includes one species in the pond? → Population; Which is one individual? → Organism

Which level includes several species populations: Community. Which includes one species in the pond: Population. Which is one individual: Organism.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F2 · Community members

Fixed scientific information

The source lists photosynthetic algae, animal snails and bacteria as living members. Bacteria are single-celled organisms without a nucleus; dissolved oxygen is a nonliving condition.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which named group is a producer in this example?; Which named group is an animal?; Which named group consists of cells without a nucleus?

  • a: Algae
  • b: Snails
  • c: Bacteria
  • d: Dissolved oxygen as an organism
Answer: Which named group is a producer in this example? → Algae; Which named group is an animal? → Snails; Which named group consists of cells without a nucleus? → Bacteria

Which named group is a producer in this example: Algae. Which named group is an animal: Snails. Which named group consists of cells without a nucleus: Bacteria.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Composition record

Fixed scientific information

Survey A has one recorded species, B has three and C has five, using equal effort. These are observed species counts.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which survey recorded the most species? → Survey C
  • b: Which recorded the fewest? → Survey A
  • c: Which survey recorded the most species? → Survey B
  • d: Which recorded three? → All totals reveal complete communities
Answer: Which survey recorded the most species? → Survey C; Which recorded the fewest? → Survey A

Which survey recorded the most species: Survey C. Which recorded the fewest: Survey A. Which recorded three: Survey B.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Interaction labels

Fixed scientific information

A records feeding, B records competition for limited light and C records a mutually beneficial pollination relationship.

F4 · Hotspot

Which card shows competition?

  • a: Card B
  • b: Card A
  • c: Card C
  • d: Every interaction is predation
Answer: Card B

Which card shows competition: Card B. Which shows feeding: Card A. Which shows mutual benefit: Card C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A missing community description

Fixed scientific information

A survey reports “30 living things” without naming any species or categories.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the total is insufficient to describe the community and name information to add.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total hides composition. Add the species present and their counts or abundances.

  1. Explains that a total hides species composition.
  2. Requests species identities and/or counts by species.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Both fictional samples contain 20 individuals. P has 20 of species A; Q has 5 each of species A, B, C and D.

1A · Multiple choice

Which sample has more observed species?

  • a: Sample Q
  • b: 4
  • c: Total individuals
  • d: Equal totals mean equal composition
Answer: Sample Q

Which sample has more observed species: Sample Q. How many species are observed in Q: 4. Which feature is equal: Total individuals.

1B · Short answer

Explain how the communities differ despite equal totals.

Example of a full-credit answer: P contains one observed species, while Q contains four. Both have 20 individuals, so abundance total and species richness describe different features.

  1. Identifies one versus four observed species.
  2. Distinguishes total abundance from composition/richness.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A records several species groups with equal sampling effort. B counts only one easy-to-see species. C records water colour without living-organism data.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which best describes community composition?; Which describes only one population?; Which lacks community-member records?

  • a: Survey A
  • b: Survey B
  • c: Survey C
  • d: One species describes all life
Answer: Which best describes community composition? → Survey A; Which describes only one population? → Survey B; Which lacks community-member records? → Survey C

Which best describes community composition: Survey A. Which describes only one population: Survey B. Which lacks community-member records: Survey C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and state one reason it may still miss members.

Example of a full-credit answer: A records multiple populations. Hidden, rare or seasonally absent organisms may be missed despite equal effort.

  1. Explains multiple-species recording as appropriate.
  2. Identifies a valid detection/sampling limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

The stated web is grass→insect→bird and grass→snail→bird. Birds can use both listed prey types. No other links are given.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which species is a shared producer?” → “Grass”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which species is a shared producer: Grass. Which consumer has two listed prey types: Bird. Which other prey can birds use if insects decline: Snail.

3B · Short answer

Explain a possible buffer against insect decline and why it is not a guaranteed outcome.

Example of a full-credit answer: Birds have a listed alternative prey, snails. Whether that compensates depends on snail availability and other conditions.

  1. Identifies the alternative snail feeding link.
  2. States an availability/condition limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

In one pond at a stated time, one fish species and one photosynthetic algal species each form a population. A learner incorrectly adds sunlight as a third population. Sunlight is energy from a nonliving source.

4A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which listed item is not a population?; Which listed item is an animal group?; Which listed item is a producer group?

  • a: Sunlight
  • b: Fish
  • c: Algae
  • d: All three are living populations
Answer: Which listed item is not a population? → Sunlight; Which listed item is an animal group? → Fish; Which listed item is a producer group? → Algae

Which listed item is not a population: Sunlight. Which listed item is an animal group: Fish. Which listed item is a producer group: Algae.

4B · Open ended

Correct the population list and explain how sunlight still matters.

Example of a full-credit answer: Fish and algae can represent populations when species/boundaries are defined; sunlight is not a population. It supplies energy to photosynthetic producers in the ecosystem.

  1. Identifies sunlight as nonliving/not a population.
  2. Explains its relevant energy role despite exclusion from the community population list.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Compare two school patches using equal areas and time. Record which species or defined organism categories are present and their counts.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which record captures composition?; Which captures abundance?; Which improves comparability?

  • a: Names of observed groups
  • b: Counts by group
  • c: Equal effort
  • d: One unlabelled total
Answer: Which record captures composition? → Names of observed groups; Which captures abundance? → Counts by group; Which improves comparability? → Equal effort

Which record captures composition: Names of observed groups. Which captures abundance: Counts by group. Which improves comparability: Equal effort.

5B · Open ended

Propose the recording table and a method feature that makes the comparison fair.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use rows for each identified group and columns for counts in each patch. Sample equal areas for equal time with the same method and repeat.

  1. Proposes identities and counts by group.
  2. Includes comparable effort/method or repetition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.4 · Ecosystems

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Community plus conditions

Example information

A pond record includes algae, fish, microbes, water and temperature, together with feeding and gas exchange.

Question: Why is this an ecosystem description?

Answer: It includes living and nonliving components and their interactions.

Why: A species list alone would describe only part of the system.

Example 2 · A water budget
A water budget
FlowUnits
Rain input20
Evaporation loss7
Outflow loss5

Example information

A toy pond receives 20 water units and loses 7 by evaporation and 5 by outflow in one interval.

Question: What is the net change?

Answer: An increase of 8 units.

Why: 20−7−5=8 tracks matter across the chosen boundary.

Example 3 · A connected change

Example information

A fictional vegetation model links plant cover with shade and shelter.

Question: Why might removing plants affect more than plant count?

Answer: It changes conditions and resources used by other organisms.

Why: Ecosystem components are connected through several pathways.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Components of a pond

Fixed scientific information

The source labels algae as living, water temperature as nonliving and feeding as an interaction.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which is a living component?

  • a: Algae
  • b: Water temperature
  • c: Feeding
  • d: Only the fish matter
Answer: Algae

Which is a living component: Algae. Which is a nonliving condition: Water temperature. Which is an interaction: Feeding.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F2 · Matter and energy routes

Fixed scientific information

Rain brings water into a pond; outflow carries water away; sunlight provides an energy input for photosynthesis.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which is a matter input?” → “Water outflow”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which is a matter input: Rainwater. Which is a matter output: Water outflow. Which is the named energy input: Sunlight.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F3 · A toy boundary budget

Fixed scientific information

A model gains 15 water units and loses 6 during one step. The starting storage is 40.

F3 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final storage?; What is the net gain?; What was the starting storage?

  • a: 49 units
  • b: 9 units
  • c: 40 units
  • d: 61 units
Answer: What is the final storage? → 49 units; What is the net gain? → 9 units; What was the starting storage? → 40 units

What is the final storage: 49 units. What is the net gain: 9 units. What was the starting storage: 40 units.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Different investigation features

Fixed scientific information

A measures plant cover, B measures water clarity and C records animal observations. Together they describe more than one component.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which record concerns vegetation?; Which concerns a physical water feature?; Which concerns observed animals?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Record C
  • d: One record is the entire ecosystem
Answer: Which record concerns vegetation? → Record A; Which concerns a physical water feature? → Record B; Which concerns observed animals? → Record C

Which record concerns vegetation: Record A. Which concerns a physical water feature: Record B. Which concerns observed animals: Record C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A drawn boundary

Fixed scientific information

A class draws a line around a pond in a map. Rain enters and a stream leaves across this line.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the mapped ecosystem is not a closed container and identify one input and one output.

Example of a full-credit answer: Matter crosses the study boundary: rainwater enters and stream water leaves. The map line defines study scope, not a sealed container.

  1. Explains that a study boundary does not stop exchanges.
  2. Names rain input and stream/outflow output.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: water lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy ecosystem water store begins at 50 units. Rain adds 18, evaporation removes 6 and outflow removes 9 in one interval.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is final storage? → 53 units
  • b: What is total loss? → 15 units
  • c: What is final storage? → 3-unit increase
  • d: What is the net change? → 83 units
Answer: What is final storage? → 53 units; What is total loss? → 15 units

What is final storage: 53 units. What is total loss: 15 units. What is the net change: 3-unit increase.

1B · Open ended

Calculate final storage and explain why both losses must be counted.

Example of a full-credit answer: 50+18−6−9=53. Evaporation and outflow are separate routes carrying water out of the chosen store.

  1. Calculates 53 units.
  2. Explains the two distinct outward flows.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A connects organisms with physical conditions and exchanges. B lists only favourite animals. C treats a drawn boundary as impermeable despite a stream.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation represents a system?; Which omits nonliving conditions?; Which misreads the study boundary?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All are equally complete
Answer: Which explanation represents a system? → Explanation A; Which omits nonliving conditions? → Explanation B; Which misreads the study boundary? → Explanation C

Which explanation represents a system: Explanation A. Which omits nonliving conditions: Explanation B. Which misreads the study boundary: Explanation C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A with one living–nonliving link and one boundary exchange.

Example of a full-credit answer: Plants use water or light, and rain or outflow crosses the boundary. These links explain more than an isolated species list.

  1. Gives a correct living–nonliving interaction.
  2. Gives a valid input or output across the boundary.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A garden receives sunlight, rain and added compost. Plants and decomposers interact with soil; water and harvested material can leave.

3A · Multiple choice

Which input arrives as light energy?

  • a: Sunlight
  • b: Compost
  • c: Decomposers
  • d: Every input is energy only
Answer: Sunlight

Which input arrives as light energy: Sunlight. Which input is matter: Compost. Which living group breaks down organic material: Decomposers.

3B · Open ended

Explain one matter pathway and one energy pathway in this garden.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compost matter can be decomposed and its nutrients reused by plants. Sunlight is transformed into chemical energy and later transferred, with heat dissipation.

  1. Describes a valid matter pathway.
  2. Describes a distinct valid energy pathway.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says removing plants changes only the plant count. The model states plants also provide shade, shelter and food.

4A · Hotspot

Which stated effect concerns direct sunlight reaching the site?

  • a: Shade
  • b: Shelter
  • c: Food
  • d: No other component can respond
Answer: Shade

Which stated effect concerns direct sunlight reaching the site: Shade. Which stated resource provides animals a place to hide: Shelter. Which feeding resource can change: Food.

4B · Short answer

Correct the claim using two links from the source.

Example of a full-credit answer: Removing plants can reduce shade and animal shelter or food. These connections allow effects beyond the plant population itself.

  1. Explains one stated connected effect.
  2. Explains a second stated connected effect.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Investigate plant-cover change in a virtual pond. Record at least one nonliving condition and one response of living organisms while keeping comparison methods equal.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which measure is a nonliving condition?; Which measure is a living response?; Which design feature aids comparison?

  • a: Water temperature
  • b: Observed animal use
  • c: Equal methods and intervals
  • d: Only photograph colour
Answer: Which measure is a nonliving condition? → Water temperature; Which measure is a living response? → Observed animal use; Which design feature aids comparison? → Equal methods and intervals

Which measure is a nonliving condition: Water temperature. Which measure is a living response: Observed animal use. Which design feature aids comparison: Equal methods and intervals.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two measurements and how the comparison will be kept fair.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compare water temperature and animal observations at different cover levels using equal time, area and other stated model conditions.

  1. Includes one relevant nonliving and one living measurement.
  2. Specifies comparable methods/conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.5 · Food chains

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read arrow direction

Example information

The chain is leaf → caterpillar → bird.

Question: Which organism eats the caterpillar?

Answer: The bird.

Why: The arrow carries food-related matter and energy toward the consumer.

Example 2 · Use a stated fraction
Use a stated fraction
LevelToy energy units
Starting food80
Next level20

Example information

A toy chain transfers one quarter of 80 energy units to its next level.

Question: How many units reach that level?

Answer: 20 units.

Why: 80÷4=20 follows the given model rule, not a universal natural percentage.

Example 3 · A chain is incomplete

Example information

A bird eats insects in one displayed chain but also eats seeds in the full source.

Question: Does the chain show the bird’s whole diet?

Answer: No.

Why: It displays one path within a larger set of feeding relationships.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A pond chain

Fixed scientific information

The stated chain is algae→small water animal→fish. Each arrow points from food to consumer.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which organism eats the small water animal?; Which is the producer?; Which eats the producer?

  • a: Fish
  • b: Algae
  • c: Small water animal
  • d: Arrow means predator becomes plant
Answer: Which organism eats the small water animal? → Fish; Which is the producer? → Algae; Which eats the producer? → Small water animal

Which organism eats the small water animal: Fish. Which is the producer: Algae. Which eats the producer: Small water animal.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F2 · Role labels

Fixed scientific information

In grass→grasshopper→frog, grass produces food, grasshopper eats grass and frog eats grasshopper.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which is the primary consumer?” → “Grasshopper”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which is the primary consumer: Grasshopper. Which is the producer: Grass. Which is the secondary consumer: Frog.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · A toy transfer

Fixed scientific information

A classroom chain passes 10% of 200 units to the next level and 10% of that amount onward.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What reaches the first consumer level?; What reaches the next level?; What was the starting amount?

  • a: 20 units
  • b: 2 units
  • c: 200 units
  • d: 200 units at every level
Answer: What reaches the first consumer level? → 20 units; What reaches the next level? → 2 units; What was the starting amount? → 200 units

What reaches the first consumer level: 20 units. What reaches the next level: 2 units. What was the starting amount: 200 units.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Dead material pathways

Fixed scientific information

The source identifies dead leaves as material, decomposers as organisms using that material and heat as dispersed energy from life processes.

F4 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which organisms use dead material?; Which item is matter from plants?; Which item is an energy transfer?

  • a: Decomposers
  • b: Dead leaves
  • c: Heat
  • d: Energy cycles into new sunlight
Answer: Which organisms use dead material? → Decomposers; Which item is matter from plants? → Dead leaves; Which item is an energy transfer? → Heat

Which organisms use dead material: Decomposers. Which item is matter from plants: Dead leaves. Which item is an energy transfer: Heat.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · A backwards arrow

Fixed scientific information

A learner draws frog→grasshopper while saying the frog eats the grasshopper. The diagram rule is food→consumer.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the arrow and explain what it represents.

Example of a full-credit answer: The arrow should be grasshopper→frog. It shows food-related matter and energy transferring from the eaten organism to its consumer.

  1. Corrects the arrow direction.
  2. Explains food/matter/energy transfer toward the consumer.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

The given chain is seed plant→insect→lizard. A toy model transfers 20% of 500 energy units to insects and 10% of the insect amount to lizards.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How many units reach insects?; How many reach lizards?; Which is the producer?

  • a: 100 units
  • b: 10 units
  • c: Seed plant
  • d: 500 units reach every level
Answer: How many units reach insects? → 100 units; How many reach lizards? → 10 units; Which is the producer? → Seed plant

How many units reach insects: 100 units. How many reach lizards: 10 units. Which is the producer: Seed plant.

1B · Short answer

Calculate both transfers and state why the same percentages should not be assumed everywhere.

Example of a full-credit answer: 500×20%=100, then 100×10%=10. The percentages are stated classroom assumptions; real efficiencies vary.

  1. Correctly calculates 100 and 10 units.
  2. Identifies the fractions as model-specific rather than universal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A uses food→consumer arrows and diet-based roles. B points arrows only toward larger animals. C calls every animal a producer.

2A · Multiple choice

Which chain uses the stated convention?

  • a: Chain A
  • b: Chain B
  • c: Chain C
  • d: Every convention means the same thing
Answer: Chain A

Which chain uses the stated convention: Chain A. Which uses size instead of feeding: Chain B. Which mislabels producers: Chain C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A using arrow direction and role definition.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its arrows point from food to consumers. Producers and consumer levels are assigned from how food is obtained, not size.

  1. Correctly explains arrow direction.
  2. Correctly explains diet-based roles.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A bird eats seeds directly in one path and plant-eating insects in another. The bird has different positions on the two paths.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What role does the bird have when eating seeds? → Primary consumer
  • b: What role when eating plant-eating insects? → Secondary consumer
  • c: What role does the bird have when eating seeds? → Different feeding paths
  • d: Why can the role differ? → A permanent level based only on size
Answer: What role does the bird have when eating seeds? → Primary consumer; What role when eating plant-eating insects? → Secondary consumer

What role does the bird have when eating seeds: Primary consumer. What role when eating plant-eating insects: Secondary consumer. Why can the role differ: Different feeding paths.

3B · Short answer

Explain both roles using the bird’s food in each path.

Example of a full-credit answer: Eating a producer’s seeds makes the bird a primary consumer on that path. Eating an insect that eats plants makes it secondary on the other.

  1. Connects seed eating to primary consumption.
  2. Connects plant-eating insect consumption to secondary role.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Every level receives all the starting energy, because energy is conserved.” The source states energy spreads as heat and only some becomes food for the next level.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which phrase names the chemical energy available to the next consumer as food?” → “Heat to surroundings”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which phrase names the chemical energy available to the next consumer as food: Energy available in next-level food. Where does some energy go: Heat to surroundings. What principle still holds overall: Energy conservation.

4B · Open ended

Explain why conservation does not mean equal food energy at every level.

Example of a full-credit answer: Energy is conserved across the whole system, but some is transferred as heat or other pathways. Only part remains available as food biomass for the next consumer.

  1. Distinguishes whole-system conservation from the food-pathway amount.
  2. Identifies heat/other transfers reducing next-level available food energy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Use three named organisms with a documented producer→plant eater→predator relationship. Label arrows and explain that it is one path, not a complete web.

5A · Hotspot

Which label belongs at the first food-producing step?

  • a: Producer
  • b: Food to consumer
  • c: One feeding path only
  • d: Complete diet of every organism
Answer: Producer

Which label belongs at the first food-producing step: Producer. Which arrow direction is required: Food to consumer. Which note states the scope: One feeding path only.

5B · Open ended

Propose a valid chain and a limitation note.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use grass→grasshopper→frog, with arrows toward consumers. State that real organisms can have other food links not shown.

  1. Gives a scientifically valid producer-to-consumer chain with correct arrows.
  2. States the incomplete-path/alternative-food limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.6 · Food webs

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two paths to a bird

Example information

The web is grass→grasshopper→bird and grass→snail→bird.

Question: How many listed prey types does the bird have?

Answer: Two: grasshopper and snail.

Why: Both arrows end at the bird.

Example 2 · A shared resource

Example information

Two fictional fish species both eat the same limited water-insect group.

Question: What interaction may arise?

Answer: Competition for the limited food.

Why: Sharing food matters to competition when supply is limiting.

Example 3 · Trace an indirect effect
Trace an indirect effect
LinkMeaning
Algae→small animalSmall animal eats algae
Small animal→fishFish eats small animal

Example information

The web lists algae→small animal→fish. Algae decline.

Question: What is one possible indirect effect on fish?

Answer: Their small-animal food may become less available.

Why: The reasoning passes through the consumer between algae and fish.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read an alternative-food web

Fixed scientific information

The web is leaves→caterpillar→bird and seeds→bird. All arrows follow food→consumer.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which consumer has two listed foods?; Which food reaches the bird through the caterpillar?; Which food reaches the bird directly?

  • a: Bird
  • b: Leaves
  • c: Seeds
  • d: Every food passes through caterpillars
Answer: Which consumer has two listed foods? → Bird; Which food reaches the bird through the caterpillar? → Leaves; Which food reaches the bird directly? → Seeds

Which consumer has two listed foods: Bird. Which food reaches the bird through the caterpillar: Leaves. Which food reaches the bird directly: Seeds.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F2 · Count direct links

Fixed scientific information

The listed links are grass→snail, grass→insect and insect→lizard. There is no supplied snail→lizard link.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which consumer directly eats grass in one listed link? → Snail
  • b: Which consumer directly eats insect? → Lizard
  • c: Which consumer directly eats grass in one listed link? → Grass
  • d: Which producer feeds both small consumers? → Lizard directly eats every organism
Answer: Which consumer directly eats grass in one listed link? → Snail; Which consumer directly eats insect? → Lizard

Which consumer directly eats grass in one listed link: Snail. Which consumer directly eats insect: Lizard. Which producer feeds both small consumers: Grass.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Shared food

Fixed scientific information

A and B are bird species that both use a limited insect resource. C is a plant supplying nectar to a different consumer.

F3 · Hotspot

Which pair may compete for the stated insects?

  • a: Birds A and B
  • b: Insects
  • c: Plant C
  • d: Competition requires no shared need
Answer: Birds A and B

Which pair may compete for the stated insects: Birds A and B. Which resource is stated to be limited: Insects. Which example supplies nectar: Plant C.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F4 · Prediction labels

Fixed scientific information

A describes a direct food loss, B follows two feeding links and C guarantees exact counts without a population model.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which prediction is indirect?

  • a: Prediction B
  • b: Prediction A
  • c: Prediction C
  • d: Every arrow predicts exact abundance
Answer: Prediction B

Which prediction is indirect: Prediction B. Which concerns one direct link: Prediction A. Which overstates the web’s precision: Prediction C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A missing link

Fixed scientific information

A learner adds a frog→bird feeding link to a supplied web even though neither the diagram nor text states that the bird eats frogs.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the added link is an assumption and how it should be handled.

Example of a full-credit answer: The source does not provide that feeding relationship. Omit it from source-based conclusions or clearly label it as a hypothesis needing evidence.

  1. Identifies the link as unsupported by the supplied source.
  2. Proposes omission or explicit hypothesis/evidence checking.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

The web lists grass→insect→bird and pond plant→snail→bird. Insects decline while snails remain available under the stated scenario.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which prey is the stated available alternative to insects? → Snails
  • b: Which producer feeds those snails? → Pond plant
  • c: Which prey is the stated available alternative to insects? → Insects
  • d: Which prey is stated to decline? → Bird population is guaranteed to rise
Answer: Which prey is the stated available alternative to insects? → Snails; Which producer feeds those snails? → Pond plant

Which prey is the stated available alternative to insects: Snails. Which producer feeds those snails: Pond plant. Which prey is stated to decline: Insects.

1B · Open ended

Explain the alternative food route and state why exact bird numbers still cannot be predicted.

Example of a full-credit answer: Pond plants feed snails, which birds can eat. We lack amounts, needs and other conditions to predict an exact bird count.

  1. Traces the correct alternative route.
  2. Identifies missing quantitative/condition information.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says a consumer may be affected through a stated food link. B guarantees extinction from one missing food despite alternatives. C invents an unlisted prey link.

2A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which claim stays within the model?; Which ignores alternative foods?; Which adds unsupported evidence?

  • a: Claim A
  • b: Claim B
  • c: Claim C
  • d: All claims follow the arrows
Answer: Which claim stays within the model? → Claim A; Which ignores alternative foods? → Claim B; Which adds unsupported evidence? → Claim C

Which claim stays within the model: Claim A. Which ignores alternative foods: Claim B. Which adds unsupported evidence: Claim C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and identify one additional observation that could improve its prediction.

Example of a full-credit answer: A follows a stated feeding relationship. Measuring the food resource or alternative prey abundance would help assess the effect.

  1. Uses the stated link as evidence.
  2. Proposes relevant resource/alternative-food observation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

Algae feed small crustaceans and snails. Fish eat crustaceans; a bird eats fish and snails. The arrows still mean food→consumer.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which consumer has both fish and snails as food?” → “Fish”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which consumer has both fish and snails as food: Bird. Which consumer feeds directly on crustaceans: Fish. Which producer begins the two listed paths: Algae.

3B · Open ended

Trace one two-link route from algae and explain why the arrow rule remains the same.

Example of a full-credit answer: Algae→crustaceans→fish is a route. The arrows still trace feeding transfer toward consumers, regardless of habitat.

  1. Gives a valid two-link route from algae.
  2. Explains the consistent food-to-consumer convention.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says two organisms cannot be connected unless one eats the other. The source states two bird species share a limited insect food.

4A · Multiple choice

Which ecological term names the birds’ shared limited-resource interaction?

  • a: Competition
  • b: Limited insect food
  • c: Both birds eat insects
  • d: One bird must eat the other
Answer: Competition

Which ecological term names the birds’ shared limited-resource interaction: Competition. Which resource links them: Limited insect food. Which direct feeding statement is supplied: Both birds eat insects.

4B · Short answer

Correct the claim and explain the indirect connection.

Example of a full-credit answer: The birds can compete without eating each other. They both use the same limited insect resource, so one’s use can affect availability for the other.

  1. Identifies competition without predation between the birds.
  2. Explains the shared limited-resource mechanism.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

The supplied facts are grass eaten by insects and snails, insects eaten by frogs, and both frogs and snails eaten by birds. Include only these links.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which consumer has frogs and snails as food?; Which consumer eats insects?; Which producer feeds insects and snails?

  • a: Birds
  • b: Frogs
  • c: Grass
  • d: Every pair must be connected
Answer: Which consumer has frogs and snails as food? → Birds; Which consumer eats insects? → Frogs; Which producer feeds insects and snails? → Grass

Which consumer has frogs and snails as food: Birds. Which consumer eats insects: Frogs. Which producer feeds insects and snails: Grass.

5B · Open ended

Propose the complete set of arrows and name a limitation of the model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Draw grass→insects, grass→snails, insects→frogs, frogs→birds and snails→birds. State that the web gives feeding links, not exact population forecasts or all ecosystem interactions.

  1. Gives the supplied feeding links with correct direction, without invented links.
  2. States a valid scope/forecast limitation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.7 · Movement of matter

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A closed transfer
A closed transfer
StoreBeforeAfter
Air127
Plants813

Example information

A toy model starts with 12 carbon tokens in air and 8 in plants. Five move from air to plants.

Question: What are the new stores and total?

Answer: Air 7, plants 13; total 20.

Why: The transfer changes location, not the total.

Example 2 · A leaf’s matter

Example information

Dead leaves lose visible mass during decomposition while gases and dissolved substances leave the measured leaf pile.

Question: Does that prove atoms were destroyed?

Answer: No.

Why: The leaf-pile boundary excludes matter that has moved into gases or water.

Example 3 · Different inputs

Example information

A plant receives mineral nutrients through roots and light energy at leaves.

Question: Are these the same kind of input?

Answer: No. Nutrients are matter; sunlight supplies energy.

Why: Matter and energy require separate labels and budgets.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Named pathways

Fixed scientific information

Photosynthesis transfers carbon from carbon dioxide into organic material; feeding transfers food matter to consumers; decomposition processes dead material.

F1 · Hotspot

Which pathway uses carbon dioxide to build organic material?

  • a: Photosynthesis
  • b: Feeding
  • c: Decomposition
  • d: Atoms disappear on eating
Answer: Photosynthesis

Which pathway uses carbon dioxide to build organic material: Photosynthesis. Which transfers food matter to a consumer: Feeding. Which processes dead material: Decomposition.

Scientific explorer: carbon lab

F2 · Three stores

Fixed scientific information

The model records carbon in air, living plants and soil organic matter as separate stores.

F2 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which store contains the model atmospheric carbon?; Which contains living producer carbon?; Which contains the stated ground organic matter?

  • a: Air
  • b: Plants
  • c: Soil
  • d: Heat as carbon matter
Answer: Which store contains the model atmospheric carbon? → Air; Which contains living producer carbon? → Plants; Which contains the stated ground organic matter? → Soil

Which store contains the model atmospheric carbon: Air. Which contains living producer carbon: Plants. Which contains the stated ground organic matter: Soil.

Scientific explorer: carbon lab

F3 · A token transfer

Fixed scientific information

A closed model has 30 tokens in air and 20 in plants. Six move air→plants with no other change.

F3 · Multiple choice

What is the new air store?

  • a: 24 tokens
  • b: 26 tokens
  • c: 50 tokens
  • d: 56 total tokens
Answer: 24 tokens

What is the new air store: 24 tokens. What is the new plant store: 26 tokens. What is the total: 50 tokens.

Scientific explorer: carbon lab

F4 · Matter or energy

Fixed scientific information

A card lists mineral nutrients as matter, sunlight as energy input and heat as energy transfer to surroundings.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which is matter? → Mineral nutrients
  • b: Which is the named incoming energy? → Sunlight
  • c: Which is matter? → Heat
  • d: Which is dispersed energy transfer? → All three are soil nutrients
Answer: Which is matter? → Mineral nutrients; Which is the named incoming energy? → Sunlight

Which is matter: Mineral nutrients. Which is the named incoming energy: Sunlight. Which is dispersed energy transfer: Heat.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A local mass loss

Fixed scientific information

A virtual compost pile becomes lighter while carbon dioxide leaves into the surrounding air. The measurement weighs only the pile.

F5 · Short answer

Explain the local mass decrease and why it does not violate conservation of matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: Matter leaves the pile as gas, so the pile’s measured mass falls. Counting the surroundings as well would include transferred matter.

  1. Identifies gas leaving the measured pile.
  2. Explains the boundary/total-matter conservation distinction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A closed model begins with air 40, plants 30 and soil 20 carbon tokens. Photosynthesis moves 7 air→plants; respiration then moves 4 plants→air. Soil stays unchanged.

1A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final air store?; What is the final plant store?; What is the total across all stores?

  • a: 37
  • b: 33
  • c: 90
  • d: 101 tokens
Answer: What is the final air store? → 37; What is the final plant store? → 33; What is the total across all stores? → 90

What is the final air store: 37. What is the final plant store: 33. What is the total across all stores: 90.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the two changed stores and explain the unchanged total.

Example of a full-credit answer: Air=40−7+4=37; plants=30+7−4=33. Transfers are internal, so 37+33+20 remains 90.

  1. Calculates air 37 and plants 33.
  2. Explains internal transfers conserve the combined 90-token total.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A labels stores and all supplied input/output arrows. B deletes gas leaving a pile. C says decomposers create new atoms.

2A · Multiple choice

Which diagram can support a matter budget?

  • a: Diagram A
  • b: Diagram B
  • c: Diagram C
  • d: Unseen means destroyed
Answer: Diagram A

Which diagram can support a matter budget: Diagram A. Which omits an outward route: Diagram B. Which violates the matter explanation: Diagram C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and explain why a gas arrow matters even when gas is not visible.

Example of a full-credit answer: All routes are needed to account for matter. Invisible gas still contains atoms and can carry matter across the boundary.

  1. Identifies complete routes/stores as necessary.
  2. Explains that gas carries matter despite invisibility.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A plant takes carbon from air, an insect eats plant material and a bird eats the insect. Respiration can return carbon dioxide to air.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which organism first incorporates the air carbon here?” → “Plant”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which organism first incorporates the air carbon here: Plant. Which consumer receives plant matter directly: Insect. Which process can return carbon dioxide: Respiration.

3B · Short answer

Trace a possible carbon route and explain why the atom is not destroyed by feeding.

Example of a full-credit answer: Air carbon can enter plant material, then insect and bird material, and later carbon dioxide. Feeding rearranges and transfers matter rather than destroying its atoms.

  1. Gives a source-grounded route through at least plant and consumer.
  2. Explains transfer/rearrangement rather than atom destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “Nutrients and usable energy both cycle forever without new inputs.” The reference distinguishes recycled matter from energy spreading as heat.

4A · Hotspot

What can cycle through different forms?

  • a: Matter
  • b: Usable energy
  • c: Sunlight
  • d: Heat becomes nutrients automatically
Answer: Matter

What can cycle through different forms: Matter. What becomes less available after dispersal: Usable energy. What supplies energy to many ecosystems: Sunlight.

4B · Open ended

Correct the matter/energy confusion using both parts of the statement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Matter such as nutrients can be reused through cycles. Energy flows through the system and disperses as heat, so ongoing processes need energy inputs.

  1. Correctly describes matter recycling.
  2. Correctly distinguishes energy flow/dissipation and input needs.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Use labelled air, plant and soil stores. Every internal movement must subtract tokens from one store and add the same number to another.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What must each internal arrow preserve?; What should the boxes represent?; What should an outside arrow identify?

  • a: Total tokens
  • b: Carbon stores
  • c: Boundary input or output
  • d: Add tokens without a source
Answer: What must each internal arrow preserve? → Total tokens; What should the boxes represent? → Carbon stores; What should an outside arrow identify? → Boundary input or output

What must each internal arrow preserve: Total tokens. What should the boxes represent: Carbon stores. What should an outside arrow identify: Boundary input or output.

5B · Open ended

Propose one valid internal transfer and a check for conservation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Move a counted number from air to plants, subtracting and adding the same amount. Add all store counts before and after to check that a closed model’s total is unchanged.

  1. Describes equal subtraction/addition in an internal carbon transfer.
  2. Proposes a before/after total check for the closed model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.8 · Flow of energy

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · An energy budget
An energy budget
PathwayEnergy units
New biomass20
Other transfers60
Input80

Example information

A toy process receives 80 units, stores 20 in new biomass and transfers 60 by other pathways including heat.

Question: Is any energy missing from the stated budget?

Answer: No. 20+60=80.

Why: The accounting includes more than the food available to the next consumer.

Example 2 · Two transfers

Example information

A toy path passes 20% of 300 units to one level and 10% of that amount to the next.

Question: What reaches the second level?

Answer: 6 units.

Why: 300×0.20=60, then 60×0.10=6; use the current level as each percentage base.

Example 3 · An alternative source

Example information

A reference describes bacteria using chemical energy near a dark seafloor vent.

Question: Must this example start with local sunlight?

Answer: No.

Why: The stated chemical source shows that not every ecosystem pathway is photosynthetic.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the energy forms

Fixed scientific information

The diagram shows sunlight entering a leaf, chemical energy stored in food and heat transferred during life processes.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which is the incoming source in this example?; Which form is stored in food?; Which transfer spreads into surroundings?

  • a: Sunlight
  • b: Chemical energy
  • c: Heat
  • d: New energy created from nothing
Answer: Which is the incoming source in this example? → Sunlight; Which form is stored in food? → Chemical energy; Which transfer spreads into surroundings? → Heat

Which is the incoming source in this example: Sunlight. Which form is stored in food: Chemical energy. Which transfer spreads into surroundings: Heat.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F2 · A useful-output budget

Fixed scientific information

Input is 120 units. The selected biomass output is 30; all other stated transfers total 90.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is the selected biomass amount?” → “90 units”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What is the selected biomass amount: 30 units. What is the other-transfer amount: 90 units. What is the total input: 120 units.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

F3 · A stated efficiency

Fixed scientific information

A toy food pathway transfers one fifth of 250 units to the next level.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: How much reaches the next level?; What fraction is transferred?; What is the starting amount?

  • a: 50 units
  • b: 20%
  • c: 250 units
  • d: Every real chain uses this fraction
Answer: How much reaches the next level? → 50 units; What fraction is transferred? → 20%; What is the starting amount? → 250 units

How much reaches the next level: 50 units. What fraction is transferred: 20%. What is the starting amount: 250 units.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F4 · Matter and energy distinctions

Fixed scientific information

A labels nutrients as matter cycling, B labels energy moving through feeding and C labels heat dispersing.

F4 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which label describes matter reuse?; Which describes food-energy flow?; Which describes dissipation?

  • a: Label A
  • b: Label B
  • c: Label C
  • d: All usable energy cycles unchanged
Answer: Which label describes matter reuse? → Label A; Which describes food-energy flow? → Label B; Which describes dissipation? → Label C

Which label describes matter reuse: Label A. Which describes food-energy flow: Label B. Which describes dissipation: Label C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · An accounting error

Fixed scientific information

A student sees 40 units stored in biomass from 100 input units and says the other 60 units were destroyed. The model records them as heat and other transfers.

F5 · Open ended

Correct the statement and explain why only 40 units are counted in the selected food pathway.

Example of a full-credit answer: The 60 units were transferred elsewhere, not destroyed. The chosen food pathway includes only biomass energy available for that next transfer.

  1. Corrects destruction to other energy transfers.
  2. Explains the limited selected-biomass accounting.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: energy lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy path begins with 800 food-energy units. The first transfer is 25%; the second is 10% of the first level’s received amount.

1A · Multiple choice

How much reaches the first level?

  • a: 200 units
  • b: 20 units
  • c: 10%
  • d: 80 units at the second level
Answer: 200 units

How much reaches the first level: 200 units. How much reaches the second: 20 units. What is the second transfer percentage: 10%.

1B · Open ended

Show both calculations and explain why the second percentage uses 200 rather than 800.

Example of a full-credit answer: 800×25%=200; 200×10%=20. The second step receives energy from the first level, not directly from the original pool.

  1. Calculates 200 then 20 units.
  2. Explains the sequential percentage base.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A accounts for biomass, heat and other transfers. B shows biomass alone and calls the rest destroyed. C doubles output without another input.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which diagram can conserve the stated input? → Diagram A
  • b: Which confuses omitted routes with destruction? → Diagram B
  • c: Which diagram can conserve the stated input? → Diagram C
  • d: Which invents energy without input? → Every diagram balances
Answer: Which diagram can conserve the stated input? → Diagram A; Which confuses omitted routes with destruction? → Diagram B

Which diagram can conserve the stated input: Diagram A. Which confuses omitted routes with destruction: Diagram B. Which invents energy without input: Diagram C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A using conservation and the next-consumer pathway.

Example of a full-credit answer: A includes all energy destinations. Only part is in biomass for the next consumer, while the rest still exists in heat or other transfers.

  1. Explains complete energy accounting.
  2. Distinguishes next-consumer biomass from other transfers.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

Decomposers obtain chemical energy from dead organic material. They use it and transfer heat while returning some nutrient matter to the environment.

3A · Hotspot

What energy source do they use here?

  • a: Dead organic material
  • b: Heat
  • c: Nutrients
  • d: They recreate all sunlight
Answer: Dead organic material

What energy source do they use here: Dead organic material. What energy transfer spreads to surroundings: Heat. What can be returned for reuse as matter: Nutrients.

3B · Open ended

Explain one energy transfer and one matter transfer in decomposition.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chemical energy in dead material is used and dissipated as heat. Nutrient atoms can return to environmental stores and be reused.

  1. Describes energy use/heat transfer.
  2. Describes nutrient matter return/reuse separately.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A diagram sends all heat from consumers straight back into plant food without any external energy source. The reference says usable energy disperses and producers need an energy input.

4A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What does the diagram wrongly recycle completely?; What input is missing in the sunlight example?; What can cycle through different substances?

  • a: Usable energy
  • b: Light energy
  • c: Matter
  • d: Heat becomes food without a process
Answer: What does the diagram wrongly recycle completely? → Usable energy; What input is missing in the sunlight example? → Light energy; What can cycle through different substances? → Matter

What does the diagram wrongly recycle completely: Usable energy. What input is missing in the sunlight example: Light energy. What can cycle through different substances: Matter.

4B · Short answer

Correct the diagram’s energy loop and keep the valid matter idea separate.

Example of a full-credit answer: Show an energy input such as sunlight, food-energy transfers and heat dispersal. Matter can cycle, but dispersed usable energy is not fully returned to producer food.

  1. Adds/recognises source and heat-dispersal energy flow.
  2. Distinguishes matter cycling from a false complete energy loop.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A model receives 200 energy units. You may choose an amount for new biomass, but must label all remaining transfers so the budget balances.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What must the total outputs equal?; Which output could feed the next consumer?; What can represent a remaining energy transfer?

  • a: 200 units
  • b: New biomass
  • c: Heat
  • d: Unaccounted disappearing energy
Answer: What must the total outputs equal? → 200 units; Which output could feed the next consumer? → New biomass; What can represent a remaining energy transfer? → Heat

What must the total outputs equal: 200 units. Which output could feed the next consumer: New biomass. What can represent a remaining energy transfer: Heat.

5B · Open ended

Propose a balanced numerical split and explain the labels.

Example of a full-credit answer: For example, 50 units in new biomass and 150 in other transfers including heat add to 200. Biomass is the selected next-food pathway; other energy is transferred elsewhere.

  1. Gives a valid nonnegative split summing to 200.
  2. Correctly distinguishes biomass from other transfers without energy destruction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.9 · Biodiversity

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Equal totals, different richness
Equal totals, different richness
SampleIndividualsSpecies
P121
Q123

Example information

Sample P has 12 organisms of one species. Q has 4 each of three species.

Question: Which sample has greater observed species richness?

Answer: Q, with three species rather than one.

Why: Both totals are 12, but richness counts species.

Example 2 · Equal richness, different evenness

Example information

Sample A has 9 of species X and 1 of Y; B has 5 of each.

Question: Which is more even?

Answer: B.

Why: The two species have equal abundance in B, while both samples have richness two.

Example 3 · A survey limit

Example information

A short survey records no rare nocturnal animal during daylight.

Question: Does that prove the species is absent?

Answer: No.

Why: The timing and detectability limit the observation.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three diversity levels

Fixed scientific information

A compares DNA variants within one species, B counts species and C compares forest, grassland and wetland ecosystems.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which record concerns genetic diversity?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Record C
  • d: All are only animal counts
Answer: Record A

Which record concerns genetic diversity: Record A. Which concerns species diversity: Record B. Which concerns ecosystem diversity: Record C.

Scientific explorer: genetics lab

F2 · Richness calculation

Fixed scientific information

A sample contains 6 of species A, 3 of B and 1 of C, for 10 individuals.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is observed species richness?; What is total abundance?; Which species is most abundant?

  • a: 3 species
  • b: 10 individuals
  • c: Species A
  • d: 6 species
Answer: What is observed species richness? → 3 species; What is total abundance? → 10 individuals; Which species is most abundant? → Species A

What is observed species richness: 3 species. What is total abundance: 10 individuals. Which species is most abundant: Species A.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Evenness comparison

Fixed scientific information

P contains 8 A and 2 B; Q contains 5 A and 5 B. Both have 10 individuals and two species.

F3 · Hotspot

Which sample is more even?

  • a: Sample Q
  • b: Species richness
  • c: Species A
  • d: P has more species
Answer: Sample Q

Which sample is more even: Sample Q. Which feature is equal at two: Species richness. Which species dominates P: Species A.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Survey design

Fixed scientific information

A uses equal area/time in both sites, B surveys one site longer and C counts only brightly coloured species.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which survey improves comparability?; Which has unequal effort?; Which systematically omits some organisms?

  • a: Survey A
  • b: Survey B
  • c: Survey C
  • d: Any count is a complete inventory
Answer: Which survey improves comparability? → Survey A; Which has unequal effort? → Survey B; Which systematically omits some organisms? → Survey C

Which survey improves comparability: Survey A. Which has unequal effort: Survey B. Which systematically omits some organisms: Survey C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · One level is not all levels

Fixed scientific information

A report lists four species in a plot and claims it has measured every kind of biodiversity.

F5 · Short answer

Explain the scope of the species count and name another biodiversity level it does not directly measure.

Example of a full-credit answer: It records observed species richness in that plot. It does not directly measure genetic variation within species or diversity of ecosystems.

  1. Limits the record to observed species diversity/richness in scope.
  2. Names genetic or ecosystem diversity as another level.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Site A has 16 individuals of one species. Site B has 4 individuals of each of four species. Sampling effort is equal.

1A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which site has greater observed richness?; How many species are recorded in B?; Which site has one recorded species?

  • a: Site B
  • b: 4
  • c: Site A
  • d: Equal totals mean equal richness
Answer: Which site has greater observed richness? → Site B; How many species are recorded in B? → 4; Which site has one recorded species? → Site A

Which site has greater observed richness: Site B. How many species are recorded in B: 4. Which site has one recorded species: Site A.

1B · Short answer

Compare richness and explain why the equal individual totals do not erase the difference.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has one species and B has four, although each has 16 individuals. Richness counts different species, not total individuals.

  1. Correctly compares one and four species.
  2. Distinguishes species richness from abundance total.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A says varied roles may help under some disturbances, depending on evidence. B promises all diverse systems survive anything. C assumes every introduced species helps.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which claim recognises relevant limits? → Claim A
  • b: Which guarantees survival under all conditions? → Claim B
  • c: Which claim recognises relevant limits? → Claim C
  • d: Which ignores introduction risks? → Introductions need a risk assessment
Answer: Which claim recognises relevant limits? → Claim A; Which guarantees survival under all conditions? → Claim B

Which claim recognises relevant limits: Claim A. Which guarantees survival under all conditions: Claim B. Which ignores introduction risks: Claim C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and identify one condition that would need evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Different roles may provide alternatives, but the type of disturbance and the species/functions present matter. Evidence must address that specific situation.

  1. Recognises a plausible diversity–function benefit without guarantee.
  2. Names a relevant disturbance/species/function condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A conservation plan protects one forest patch. A second plan considers forest, wetland and grassland habitats with their distinct communities.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which level is directly broadened by the second plan?” → “Ecosystem diversity”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which level is directly broadened by the second plan: Ecosystem diversity. Which habitat type is included alongside forest and grassland: Wetland. What must still be assessed: Actual conservation effects.

3B · Short answer

Explain what diversity level the second plan addresses and why labels alone do not prove success.

Example of a full-credit answer: It considers ecosystem variety. Monitoring condition and living communities is still needed to show that the habitats are effectively conserved.

  1. Identifies ecosystem diversity.
  2. Explains need for evidence of condition/effective conservation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A team sees only two species during a brief visit and reports “Only two species exist here.” Hidden, nocturnal and seasonal organisms were not surveyed.

4A · Multiple choice

What is directly established?

  • a: Two species were observed
  • b: Only two exist
  • c: Broader repeated sampling
  • d: Absence from one visit proves absence
Answer: Two species were observed

What is directly established: Two species were observed. What is not established: Only two exist. What would improve the survey: Broader repeated sampling.

4B · Open ended

Correct the statement and propose one way to improve coverage.

Example of a full-credit answer: Report two observed species in that visit. Repeat at different relevant times or sample additional habitats using consistent methods.

  1. Uses observation-limited wording.
  2. Proposes relevant wider/repeated sampling.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

Compare two patches for observed species richness and abundance using equal effort. Do not collect or release unknown organisms.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which table field lists the distinct kinds of organism observed?; Which field records abundance?; Which field documents comparability?

  • a: Species identities
  • b: Count per species
  • c: Area and observation time
  • d: Only the prettiest organism
Answer: Which table field lists the distinct kinds of organism observed? → Species identities; Which field records abundance? → Count per species; Which field documents comparability? → Area and observation time

Which table field lists the distinct kinds of organism observed: Species identities. Which field records abundance: Count per species. Which field documents comparability: Area and observation time.

5B · Open ended

Propose the table and one fair-sampling rule.

Example of a full-credit answer: List species or clearly defined groups with counts in each patch. Use equal areas, times and methods, and repeat observations when possible.

  1. Includes identities and counts by species/group.
  2. Includes a relevant equal-effort/repetition rule.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.10 · Pollution

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Not visible is not absent

Example information

A water image looks clear, but the source gives no chemical or microbial test results.

Question: Can it establish drinking-water safety?

Answer: No.

Why: Appearance does not measure every possible contaminant.

Example 2 · A dilution model
A dilution model
StateUnitsLitresUnits/L
Before1243
After1262

Example information

A tank contains 12 fictional pollutant units in 4 litres. Clean water increases volume to 6 litres without removal.

Question: What are the concentrations before and after?

Answer: 3 units/L, then 2 units/L.

Why: The total remains 12; dilution changes the denominator.

Example 3 · Follow the route

Example information

A fictional runoff diagram carries material from an exposed soil patch into a stream.

Question: What should a prevention plan examine?

Answer: The source and the runoff pathway.

Why: A plausible route guides measurement, but does not by itself establish every downstream effect.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Source and route

Fixed scientific information

A model labels a leaking container as source, runoff as pathway and a pond as receiving location. No handling of the substance is proposed.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which is the possible source?; Which is the transport pathway?; Which is the receiving location?

  • a: Leaking container
  • b: Runoff
  • c: Pond
  • d: The label colour
Answer: Which is the possible source? → Leaking container; Which is the transport pathway? → Runoff; Which is the receiving location? → Pond

Which is the possible source: Leaking container. Which is the transport pathway: Runoff. Which is the receiving location: Pond.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F2 · Forms of pollution

Fixed scientific information

A describes unwanted loud noise, B describes particles in air and C describes contamination in water.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which example is energy-related noise pollution?” → “Example B”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which example is energy-related noise pollution: Example A. Which concerns airborne particles: Example B. Which concerns water: Example C.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F3 · Concentration calculation

Fixed scientific information

A toy sample has 15 pollutant units in 5 litres. These are fictional units with no safety threshold.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the concentration?; What is the total pollutant amount?; What is the water volume?

  • a: 3 units/L
  • b: 15 units
  • c: 5 litres
  • d: 3 means safe to drink
Answer: What is the concentration? → 3 units/L; What is the total pollutant amount? → 15 units; What is the water volume? → 5 litres

What is the concentration: 3 units/L. What is the total pollutant amount: 15 units. What is the water volume: 5 litres.

Scientific explorer: ratio lab

F4 · Different actions

Fixed scientific information

A stops a leak, B intercepts a transport route and C measures the receiving water. Each has a different role.

F4 · Hotspot

Which action controls the source?

  • a: Action A
  • b: Action B
  • c: Action C
  • d: All actions destroy matter
Answer: Action A

Which action controls the source: Action A. Which acts on the pathway: Action B. Which checks conditions: Action C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Dilution is not destruction

Fixed scientific information

A virtual tank contains the same 20 pollutant tokens before and after clean water is added, but the tokens are spread through more water.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what changes and what does not.

Example of a full-credit answer: Concentration decreases because volume increases. The total pollutant amount remains 20 tokens because none was removed.

  1. Identifies decreased concentration from increased volume.
  2. Identifies unchanged total pollutant amount.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: ratio lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Sample P has 18 fictional units in 6 L; Q has 12 units in 3 L. No health-safety conclusions are permitted from these units.

1A · Hotspot

What is P’s concentration?

  • a: 3 units/L
  • b: 4 units/L
  • c: Sample Q
  • d: P is higher because 18 is larger
Answer: 3 units/L

What is P’s concentration: 3 units/L. What is Q’s concentration: 4 units/L. Which has higher concentration: Sample Q.

1B · Open ended

Compare concentrations and explain why total amount alone gives the wrong impression.

Example of a full-credit answer: P=18/6=3 and Q=12/3=4 units/L. Q has less total pollutant but less water, giving a higher concentration.

  1. Correctly calculates/compares 3 and 4 units/L.
  2. Explains the volume denominator.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A measures a named contaminant using consistent methods. B relies only on water colour. C assumes a nearby factory caused every change without measurements.

2A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which evidence most directly addresses the named contaminant?” → “Record A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which evidence most directly addresses the named contaminant: Record A. Which misses invisible possibilities: Record B. Which makes an unsupported cause claim: Claim C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and name one comparison that could help investigate a source.

Example of a full-credit answer: A measures the relevant substance. Comparable upstream/downstream or before/after records with other conditions checked could help investigate its route.

  1. Connects measurement to the named contaminant.
  2. Proposes a relevant controlled/comparable source investigation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A study shifts from water contamination to excessive noise near a habitat. Relevant measurements concern sound level and timing, not litres of water.

3A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which measurement describes how loud the sound is?; Which timing detail may matter?; Which old measure does not address the new problem?

  • a: Sound level
  • b: Duration of noise
  • c: Water concentration
  • d: Every pollution problem uses litres
Answer: Which measurement describes how loud the sound is? → Sound level; Which timing detail may matter? → Duration of noise; Which old measure does not address the new problem? → Water concentration

Which measurement describes how loud the sound is: Sound level. Which timing detail may matter: Duration of noise. Which old measure does not address the new problem: Water concentration.

3B · Open ended

Propose relevant evidence and explain why the old water calculation is insufficient.

Example of a full-credit answer: Measure sound level and duration in comparable conditions. Water concentration describes a different substance pathway and cannot establish the noise exposure.

  1. Names relevant noise level/timing evidence.
  2. Explains the mismatch with water concentration.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A learner says “The water is clear and diluted, so it is definitely safe.” No validated contaminant testing or safety criteria are supplied.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What does clarity establish? → Appearance only
  • b: What does dilution change? → Concentration
  • c: What does clarity establish? → Drinking-water safety
  • d: What has dilution done? → Destroyed all pollutant matter
Answer: What does clarity establish? → Appearance only; What does dilution change? → Concentration

What does clarity establish: Appearance only. What does dilution change: Concentration. What is not established: Drinking-water safety.

4B · Short answer

Identify two limits of the learner’s evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Clarity cannot detect every contaminant. Dilution alone neither removes all hazards nor demonstrates that appropriate safety criteria are met.

  1. Explains the limit of visual clarity.
  2. Explains the limit of dilution without appropriate testing/criteria.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A fictional site has litter carried into a drain by runoff. The proposal must reduce the source and check the drain without learners handling unsafe waste.

5A · Multiple choice

Which action reduces the source?

  • a: Prevent and contain litter
  • b: Observed drain-litter counts
  • c: Observation without touching unknown waste
  • d: Move litter to another habitat
Answer: Prevent and contain litter

Which action reduces the source: Prevent and contain litter. Which indicator checks the pathway: Observed drain-litter counts. Which requirement concerns safe practice: Observation without touching unknown waste.

5B · Open ended

Propose a source action and a safe measurable check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Improve litter containment and collection with responsible adult management. Record comparable drain observations before and after, without handling unknown waste.

  1. Proposes source reduction/containment rather than relocation.
  2. Proposes a relevant safe repeated/comparative check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.11 · Habitat destruction

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Area lost
Area lost
StateArea in hectares
Before30
Removed8
Remaining22

Example information

A fictional habitat covers 30 hectares. A plan removes 8 hectares and leaves 22.

Question: What fraction of the starting area remains?

Answer: 22 out of 30 hectares.

Why: Subtract the removed area; the calculation alone says nothing about connectivity.

Example 2 · Equal area, different routes

Example information

Plan A keeps two suitable patches connected. Plan B keeps the same total area but separates them with an impassable barrier in this toy model.

Question: Which plan permits movement between the patches?

Answer: Plan A.

Why: Connectivity matters separately from total area.

Example 3 · A missing resource

Example information

An insect needs a particular leaf food and crevice shelter. A replacement patch provides shelter but removes every food plant.

Question: Has the replacement met both requirements?

Answer: No. The stated food resource is missing.

Why: Appearance alone does not establish habitat suitability.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Describe the change

Fixed scientific information

A removes habitat area, B splits remaining habitat into isolated pieces and C reconnects two suitable patches.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which action describes habitat loss? → Action A
  • b: Which describes fragmentation? → Action B
  • c: Which action describes habitat loss? → Action C
  • d: Which improves the stated connection? → All changes have identical effects
Answer: Which action describes habitat loss? → Action A; Which describes fragmentation? → Action B

Which action describes habitat loss: Action A. Which describes fragmentation: Action B. Which improves the stated connection: Action C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Area budget

Fixed scientific information

A toy patch starts at 40 hectares. Twelve are removed and 28 remain.

F2 · Hotspot

How much area remains?

  • a: 28 hectares
  • b: 12 hectares
  • c: 40 hectares
  • d: 52 hectares remain
Answer: 28 hectares

How much area remains: 28 hectares. How much is removed: 12 hectares. What was the starting area: 40 hectares.

Scientific explorer: percent lab

F3 · Measure two features

Fixed scientific information

The map records habitat area in hectares, a usable connection between patches and the number of equal-time visits.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which describes habitat amount?; Which describes access between patches?; Which describes survey effort?

  • a: Area in hectares
  • b: Usable connection
  • c: Number of visits
  • d: Paint colour proves suitability
Answer: Which describes habitat amount? → Area in hectares; Which describes access between patches? → Usable connection; Which describes survey effort? → Number of visits

Which describes habitat amount: Area in hectares. Which describes access between patches: Usable connection. Which describes survey effort: Number of visits.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · A target requirement

Fixed scientific information

A fictional bird needs nesting cover and insect food. P provides both, Q only cover and R only food.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which patch meets both listed requirements?

  • a: Patch P
  • b: Patch Q
  • c: Patch R
  • d: Every tree meets every need
Answer: Patch P

Which patch meets both listed requirements: Patch P. Which lacks insect food: Patch Q. Which lacks nesting cover: Patch R.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · An incomplete replacement

Fixed scientific information

A learner claims that replacing a wetland with a lawn is equal replacement because both are green.

F5 · Short answer

Identify what the claim ignores and name one habitat feature that should be compared.

Example of a full-credit answer: Colour does not establish equivalent habitat. Compare water conditions, food, shelter or breeding features needed by the wetland organisms.

  1. Rejects colour as sufficient evidence of equivalent habitat.
  2. Names a relevant organism-linked habitat feature.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: water lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Both plans retain 18 hectares. In the stated model, Plan A has an open suitable link between two patches; Plan B has a barrier that the target animal cannot cross.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which plan permits the stated movement? → Plan A
  • b: What amount is equal in both? → 18 hectares
  • c: Which plan permits the stated movement? → Impassable barrier
  • d: What blocks movement in B? → Equal area guarantees equal access
Answer: Which plan permits the stated movement? → Plan A; What amount is equal in both? → 18 hectares

Which plan permits the stated movement: Plan A. What amount is equal in both: 18 hectares. What blocks movement in B: Impassable barrier.

1B · Short answer

Choose a plan for the movement goal and explain why area alone cannot decide.

Example of a full-credit answer: A meets the stated movement goal because its suitable link is open. Equal retained area does not describe whether the animal can pass between patches.

  1. Uses the open link to justify A for the stated goal.
  2. Distinguishes habitat amount from connectivity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A records target-food plants and repeated animal use. B records only ribbon colour. C assumes a planted sign proves recovery.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which check relates to habitat function?; Which measures only decoration?; Which substitutes a label for evidence?

  • a: Check A
  • b: Check B
  • c: Claim C
  • d: Any planting guarantees recovery
Answer: Which check relates to habitat function? → Check A; Which measures only decoration? → Check B; Which substitutes a label for evidence? → Claim C

Which check relates to habitat function: Check A. Which measures only decoration: Check B. Which substitutes a label for evidence: Claim C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A using its two evidence types.

Example of a full-credit answer: Food-plant records test whether a resource has returned. Repeated use observations test whether the target animal uses the site.

  1. Connects plant evidence to a required resource.
  2. Connects repeated animal observations to actual use.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A fictional fish must move upstream to its breeding habitat. A new barrier blocks that route, though the upstream water area is unchanged.

3A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which feature is directly disrupted?; Which amount is stated as unchanged?; Which need is reached through the route?

  • a: Upstream access
  • b: Upstream water area
  • c: Breeding habitat
  • d: Unchanged area proves no impact
Answer: Which feature is directly disrupted? → Upstream access; Which amount is stated as unchanged? → Upstream water area; Which need is reached through the route? → Breeding habitat

Which feature is directly disrupted: Upstream access. Which amount is stated as unchanged: Upstream water area. Which need is reached through the route: Breeding habitat.

3B · Short answer

Explain the possible effect and propose a relevant feature to evaluate in a remedy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Blocked access can prevent reaching the breeding habitat. Evaluate whether an appropriate safe passage restores movement under the relevant conditions.

  1. Links the barrier to access to breeding habitat.
  2. Proposes evaluating a suitable passage or removal of the movement obstacle.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

One brief count after clearing records fewer birds. The report says “Every missing bird died.” Movement, detection and other dates were not checked.

4A · Hotspot

What was observed?

  • a: Fewer birds in one count
  • b: Movement elsewhere
  • c: Every missing bird died
  • d: Absence always proves death
Answer: Fewer birds in one count

What was observed: Fewer birds in one count. What possible process was not checked: Movement elsewhere. What does the report overclaim: Every missing bird died.

4B · Open ended

Correct the conclusion and name one useful additional observation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The count records fewer observed birds on that visit, not the fate of each bird. Repeated comparable counts or movement observations could improve the evidence.

  1. Separates reduced observation from proof of death.
  2. Proposes relevant repeated or movement evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

The virtual map has two suitable patches separated by a gap. The target animal needs covered movement and leaf food. A plan must keep those resources and check use.

5A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which feature addresses movement?” → “Suitable covered link”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which feature addresses movement: Suitable covered link. Which resource must remain available: Leaf food. Which evidence tests the plan: Comparable use observations.

5B · Open ended

Propose the link and a way to test whether it works.

Example of a full-credit answer: Create a suitable covered link with access to the stated food, without damaging the existing patches. Compare repeated target-animal use observations before and after, ideally with a comparison route.

  1. Proposes a suitable connection preserving stated needs.
  2. Proposes relevant comparable monitoring of movement/use.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.12 · Invasive species

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Origin is not enough

Example information

Species X was introduced but no harmful effect is documented. Species Y was introduced, established and is documented to reduce native nesting sites.

Question: Which record supports the invasive label in this example?

Answer: Y.

Why: The record includes a harmful effect, not only arrival.

Example 2 · A one-step population
A one-step population
EventCount
Start12
Births5
Arrivals2
Losses3
Final16

Example information

A fictional introduced population starts at 12, gains 5 births and 2 arrivals, and loses 3 individuals.

Question: What is the final toy count?

Answer: 16.

Why: 12+5+2−3=16; this stated budget is not a real invasion forecast.

Example 3 · Check the pathway

Example information

A proposal releases aquarium plants into a pond to avoid throwing them away.

Question: Why is this a poor prevention plan?

Answer: It creates a possible introduction pathway.

Why: Use appropriate responsible disposal guidance rather than release into a natural habitat.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Three different records

Fixed scientific information

A is introduced with no documented harm. B is introduced and established with documented native-species harm. C is a native species.

F1 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which record supports the invasive label used here?; Which shows introduction but not established harm?; Which is described as native?

  • a: Record B
  • b: Record A
  • c: Record C
  • d: Every unfamiliar species is invasive
Answer: Which record supports the invasive label used here? → Record B; Which shows introduction but not established harm? → Record A; Which is described as native? → Record C

Which record supports the invasive label used here: Record B. Which shows introduction but not established harm: Record A. Which is described as native: Record C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Identify mechanisms

Fixed scientific information

Organism A consumes native eggs, organism B shares a limited food source and organism C changes the physical shelter structure.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which mechanism is predation?

  • a: Mechanism A
  • b: Mechanism B
  • c: Mechanism C
  • d: Every effect has the same mechanism
Answer: Mechanism A

Which mechanism is predation: Mechanism A. Which is competition: Mechanism B. Which changes habitat: Mechanism C.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F3 · A fictional budget

Fixed scientific information

The count starts at 20, gains 6 births and 1 arrival, and loses 4 individuals. All events are specified.

F3 · Hotspot

What is the new count?

  • a: 23
  • b: 7
  • c: 4
  • d: 31
Answer: 23

What is the new count: 23. How many are added: 7. How many are lost: 4.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F4 · Prevention and evaluation

Fixed scientific information

Plan A blocks an unwanted transport pathway, B releases aquarium organisms and C monitors target and non-target counts.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan prevents a stated introduction route?; Which creates a release pathway?; Which checks possible wider effects?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: Release first and identify later
Answer: Which plan prevents a stated introduction route? → Plan A; Which creates a release pathway? → Plan B; Which checks possible wider effects? → Plan C

Which plan prevents a stated introduction route: Plan A. Which creates a release pathway: Plan B. Which checks possible wider effects: Plan C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · An insufficient label

Fixed scientific information

A notice says “This plant is new to our class, so it must be an invasive species.” No origin or impact record is supplied.

F5 · Open ended

Identify two kinds of information missing from that conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: We need evidence about whether it was introduced outside its natural range and evidence of establishment/spread with harmful ecological effects. Being unfamiliar to a class is insufficient.

  1. Requests relevant origin/introduction information.
  2. Requests evidence of establishment/spread and ecological harm.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

An introduced snail eats native eggs in the stated food web. Native-egg abundance falls, while other environmental changes have not been ruled out.

1A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which direct interaction is specified?; What observation is reported?; What still limits causal certainty?

  • a: Predation on native eggs
  • b: Fewer native eggs
  • c: Other changes not ruled out
  • d: One pattern proves the only cause
Answer: Which direct interaction is specified? → Predation on native eggs; What observation is reported? → Fewer native eggs; What still limits causal certainty? → Other changes not ruled out

Which direct interaction is specified: Predation on native eggs. What observation is reported: Fewer native eggs. What still limits causal certainty: Other changes not ruled out.

1B · Open ended

Explain the plausible mechanism and the limit on the conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: Eating eggs could contribute to the decline. The observation does not establish that predation is the only cause because other changing conditions remain possible.

  1. Uses the stated predation link as a plausible mechanism.
  2. Recognises untested alternatives and avoids sole-cause certainty.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A consults relevant experts and compares target/non-target effects. B introduces another unknown predator. C uses an untested chemical without oversight.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan includes appropriate evidence and oversight?; Which adds an unknown species risk?; Which introduces an unassessed chemical risk?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: Any rapid action is harmless
Answer: Which plan includes appropriate evidence and oversight? → Plan A; Which adds an unknown species risk? → Plan B; Which introduces an unassessed chemical risk? → Plan C

Which plan includes appropriate evidence and oversight: Plan A. Which adds an unknown species risk: Plan B. Which introduces an unassessed chemical risk: Plan C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A by explaining its oversight and monitoring features.

Example of a full-credit answer: Relevant expertise helps choose a suitable response. Checking target and non-target effects tests both the intended result and possible unintended harm.

  1. Explains the value of relevant guidance/oversight.
  2. Explains target and non-target monitoring.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A lesson studied aquarium releases. A new virtual case has seeds transported on equipment between sites. No equipment-cleaning technique is prescribed.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is the new movement pathway?” → “Prevent unwanted introduction”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What is the new movement pathway: Seeds carried on equipment. Which idea transfers from the aquarium case: Prevent unwanted introduction. What should guide the specific procedure: Relevant local guidance.

3B · Open ended

Explain the shared prevention idea and why the method needs adjustment.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both cases involve transport into a new habitat. Equipment movement differs from aquarium release, so prevention procedures should fit that route and local guidance.

  1. Identifies prevention of movement/introduction as the shared principle.
  2. Explains that route-specific methods/guidance are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A toy population grows from 10 to 15 in one fixed interval. A learner says every introduced species will grow by five forever and cause equal harm.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What does the model show? → One specified count change
  • b: What is not established? → Endless identical growth
  • c: What does the model show? → Ecological harm
  • d: What also needs separate evidence? → A toy count proves every invasion
Answer: What does the model show? → One specified count change; What is not established? → Endless identical growth

What does the model show: One specified count change. What is not established: Endless identical growth. What also needs separate evidence: Ecological harm.

4B · Short answer

Correct both the growth and harm claims.

Example of a full-credit answer: The stated one-step budget cannot establish an unlimited growth rule in nature. Harm also depends on actual interactions and evidence, not population increase alone.

  1. Rejects indefinite universal growth from one model step.
  2. Separates count change from demonstrated ecological harm.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual transport project needs to reduce unwanted introductions and detect possible effects without learners handling unknown organisms.

5A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which action addresses entry?; Which record tracks occurrence?; Which record examines impact?

  • a: Check the transport pathway
  • b: Identified species observations
  • c: Target and native-organism trends
  • d: Release organisms for a test
Answer: Which action addresses entry? → Check the transport pathway; Which record tracks occurrence? → Identified species observations; Which record examines impact? → Target and native-organism trends

Which action addresses entry: Check the transport pathway. Which record tracks occurrence: Identified species observations. Which record examines impact: Target and native-organism trends.

5B · Open ended

Propose a prevention step and a safe evidence check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use appropriate expert-guided pathway controls. Record safely observed, identified species and comparable native-community indicators over time, reporting concerns through a trusted adult.

  1. Proposes relevant prevention at the pathway with suitable guidance.
  2. Proposes safe comparable occurrence/impact monitoring.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.13 · Extinction

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Local and global scope

Example information

A species has no remaining individuals in Lake A but has 40 living individuals in Lake B.

Question: Is the species globally extinct?

Answer: No. It survives in Lake B.

Why: The Lake A loss is local in the given record.

Example 2 · A complete toy world
A complete toy world
PopulationLiving individuals
A6
B9
Total15

Example information

A fictional species has exactly two known populations: A has 6 individuals and B has 9. No others exist in this fully specified toy world.

Question: What is the total living population?

Answer: 15.

Why: 6+9=15; the model is fully specified, unlike an incomplete field search.

Example 3 · No daytime observation

Example information

A brief daytime search detects no nocturnal species.

Question: What conclusion is justified?

Answer: None was detected during that search.

Why: The method and timing do not establish global extinction.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Different conservation statements

Fixed scientific information

A species is gone from one island but survives elsewhere. Another has living individuals at high risk. A third has no living individuals anywhere.

F1 · Hotspot

Which description is local disappearance?

  • a: Gone from one island only
  • b: Living individuals at high risk
  • c: No living individuals anywhere
  • d: Not seen once means extinct
Answer: Gone from one island only

Which description is local disappearance: Gone from one island only. Which describes risk while still living: Living individuals at high risk. Which defines extinction: No living individuals anywhere.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Survey information

Fixed scientific information

A record lists place and date, observation effort and the number detected.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which information defines survey scope? → Place and date
  • b: Which describes the search amount? → Observation effort
  • c: Which information defines survey scope? → Number detected
  • d: Which is the direct result? → One result covers every place
Answer: Which information defines survey scope? → Place and date; Which describes the search amount? → Observation effort

Which information defines survey scope: Place and date. Which describes the search amount: Observation effort. Which is the direct result: Number detected.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F3 · Complete toy counts

Fixed scientific information

A fully known fictional species has 4 individuals in population P, 7 in Q and none elsewhere.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the total living count?; How many live in P?; How many live in Q?

  • a: 11
  • b: 4
  • c: 7
  • d: Globally extinct
Answer: What is the total living count? → 11; How many live in P? → 4; How many live in Q? → 7

What is the total living count: 11. How many live in P: 4. How many live in Q: 7.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Pressure and response

Fixed scientific information

A removes needed habitat, B protects remaining habitat and C records repeated living-population counts.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which is a possible threat?

  • a: Action A
  • b: Action B
  • c: Action C
  • d: A photograph replaces a living population
Answer: Action A

Which is a possible threat: Action A. Which reduces the stated habitat threat: Action B. Which monitors population status: Action C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Endangered does not mean extinct

Fixed scientific information

A fictional species has 25 living individuals and faces a serious habitat threat. A learner calls it already extinct.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the word choice and explain the difference between risk and extinction.

Example of a full-credit answer: It is still living and may be at serious risk. Extinction means no living individuals remain anywhere; a threat or small count is not the same event.

  1. States that living individuals rule out extinction in this record.
  2. Distinguishes serious risk from completed global loss.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: population lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

In a completely specified toy world, population A falls from 8 to 0 and B remains at 12. These are the only two populations.

1A · Multiple choice

How many living individuals remain globally?

  • a: 12
  • b: Population A
  • c: Global extinction
  • d: Zero in A means zero everywhere
Answer: 12

How many living individuals remain globally: 12. Where has a local disappearance occurred: Population A. What is not yet true: Global extinction.

1B · Short answer

Explain the local change and why the species is not globally extinct.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has lost its local population, but 12 living individuals remain in B. Global extinction would require none anywhere.

  1. Identifies the local loss at A.
  2. Uses the surviving 12 at B to reject global extinction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A uses repeated suitable surveys across known habitats. B relies on one brief unsuitable visit. C repeats a rumour without observations.

2A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which record offers stronger search evidence?; Which has narrow unsuitable coverage?; Which supplies no direct search evidence?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Record C
  • d: No survey needs limits
Answer: Which record offers stronger search evidence? → Record A; Which has narrow unsuitable coverage? → Record B; Which supplies no direct search evidence? → Record C

Which record offers stronger search evidence: Record A. Which has narrow unsuitable coverage: Record B. Which supplies no direct search evidence: Record C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and explain why it should still state limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repeated suitable coverage reduces missed detections compared with one brief visit. It should still report places, methods and possible unsurveyed or hard-to-detect individuals.

  1. Explains the value of repeated relevant coverage.
  2. Recognises remaining scope/detection limitations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A rare plant is absent from one meadow but living plants are recorded in two other meadows. A saved photograph exists from the first meadow.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What demonstrates continuing life? → Living plants in other meadows
  • b: What records past appearance only? → Saved photograph
  • c: What demonstrates continuing life? → Local absence
  • d: What loss is described for the first site? → A photograph is a living population
Answer: What demonstrates continuing life? → Living plants in other meadows; What records past appearance only? → Saved photograph

What demonstrates continuing life: Living plants in other meadows. What records past appearance only: Saved photograph. What loss is described for the first site: Local absence.

3B · Short answer

Explain which evidence answers the extinction question and the photograph’s limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The living plants show that the species is not globally extinct. The photograph records earlier appearance but does not itself maintain living individuals.

  1. Uses living plants elsewhere to establish survival.
  2. Distinguishes a record from living organisms.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A model shows a small population and labels one possible threat. A learner announces an exact extinction date without further data.

4A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “What is supported by the model?” → “An exact extinction date”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

What is supported by the model: A possible risk to examine. What is unsupported: An exact extinction date. What could improve understanding: Population and threat monitoring.

4B · Open ended

Identify the overclaim and name a relevant missing evidence type.

Example of a full-credit answer: A small count and one threat do not determine an exact date. Repeated survival/reproduction records, threat levels or population changes would help assess risk.

  1. Rejects the unsupported exact date.
  2. Names a relevant population-process or threat evidence type.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A fictional species still survives but loses nesting habitat. A plan must address that pressure and check living populations.

5A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which action addresses the named threat?; Which observation tracks the living population?; Which additional outcome concerns reproduction?

  • a: Protect suitable nesting habitat
  • b: Comparable individual counts
  • c: Successful nesting records
  • d: Store pictures and stop monitoring
Answer: Which action addresses the named threat? → Protect suitable nesting habitat; Which observation tracks the living population? → Comparable individual counts; Which additional outcome concerns reproduction? → Successful nesting records

Which action addresses the named threat: Protect suitable nesting habitat. Which observation tracks the living population: Comparable individual counts. Which additional outcome concerns reproduction: Successful nesting records.

5B · Open ended

Propose a habitat action and a living-population indicator.

Example of a full-credit answer: Protect or restore the suitable nesting areas with appropriate expertise. Track comparable counts or successful nesting over repeated periods, checking other changes as well.

  1. Proposes an action tied to the nesting-habitat threat.
  2. Proposes a relevant repeated living-population/reproduction indicator.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.14 · Ecosystem services

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Identify the link

Example information

A fictional orchard has flowers that depend on animal pollen transfer. Pollinators visit and move pollen between compatible flowers.

Question: What benefit can this process support?

Answer: Plant reproduction and fruit production in this orchard.

Why: The link is pollen transfer; the record does not promise every flower becomes fruit.

Example 2 · A water budget
A water budget
Budget partWater units
Input50
Stored15
Released35

Example information

A toy wetland receives 50 water units, stores 15, and releases 35 in the stated interval.

Question: How much is temporarily stored?

Answer: 15 units.

Why: The input equals storage increase plus release; this does not establish drinking-water safety.

Example 3 · Different kinds of benefit

Example information

A coastal site supports fish habitat and a community learning trail.

Question: Why would counting only harvested fish miss something?

Answer: It would omit the educational or cultural benefit of the trail.

Why: Different benefits need different indicators.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Match process and benefit

Fixed scientific information

The orchard relies on animal pollen transfer; the hillside uses plant cover to retain soil; the park provides a place for nature learning.

F1 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which process supports the orchard’s pollination benefit?” → “Animal pollen transfer”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which process supports the orchard’s pollination benefit: Animal pollen transfer. Which feature can reduce soil loss: Plant cover. Which benefit concerns education: Nature-learning place.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Two water quantities

Fixed scientific information

A toy ecosystem receives 80 water units, temporarily stores 25 and releases 55. The budget covers one interval.

F2 · Multiple choice

How much is released?

  • a: 55 units
  • b: 25 units
  • c: 80 units
  • d: 105 units released
Answer: 55 units

How much is released: 55 units. How much is stored: 25 units. What is the total input: 80 units.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Different indicators

Fixed scientific information

An evaluation records fruit harvest in baskets, soil loss in collected model units and visitor learning with a relevant quiz.

F3 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which indicator concerns a food product?; Which concerns soil retention?; Which concerns an educational outcome?

  • a: Fruit baskets
  • b: Soil-loss units
  • c: Relevant quiz results
  • d: One indicator measures every service
Answer: Which indicator concerns a food product? → Fruit baskets; Which concerns soil retention? → Soil-loss units; Which concerns an educational outcome? → Relevant quiz results

Which indicator concerns a food product: Fruit baskets. Which concerns soil retention: Soil-loss units. Which concerns an educational outcome: Relevant quiz results.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Claims and limits

Fixed scientific information

A says vegetation can influence runoff under suitable conditions. B says every wetland makes all water safe. C says a mangrove guarantees protection from any storm.

F4 · Hotspot

Which claim includes a relevant limit?

  • a: Claim A
  • b: Claim B
  • c: Claim C
  • d: All natural processes remove all risk
Answer: Claim A

Which claim includes a relevant limit: Claim A. Which overclaims water safety: Claim B. Which overclaims storm protection: Claim C.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F5 · Explain rather than name

Fixed scientific information

A proposal says “Protect this vegetation because it provides a service,” but does not name a process or a benefit.

F5 · Open ended

Give one plausible process–benefit link and one condition or limit to check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Plant cover can help retain soil, reducing erosion under suitable conditions. The effect depends on factors such as cover, slope and rainfall and should be measured.

  1. Provides a scientifically plausible process linked to a benefit.
  2. Names a relevant condition, limit or measurement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

Site P receives 60 water units, stores 20 and releases 40 during the interval. Site Q receives the same input, stores 5 and releases 55.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which site stores more in this interval? → Site P
  • b: How much more does P store? → 15 units
  • c: Which site stores more in this interval? → Site Q
  • d: Which releases 55 units? → Storage proves all contaminants removed
Answer: Which site stores more in this interval? → Site P; How much more does P store? → 15 units

Which site stores more in this interval: Site P. How much more does P store: 15 units. Which releases 55 units: Site Q.

1B · Open ended

Compare storage and explain one conclusion that the budget cannot establish.

Example of a full-credit answer: P stores 15 more units than Q during this interval. The budget does not measure contaminants or establish drinking-water safety.

  1. Correctly compares the 20 and 5 units as a 15-unit difference.
  2. Identifies a relevant unmeasured outcome such as water quality/safety.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

For plants that need animal pollen transfer, A explains pollen movement between compatible flowers. B says insects manufacture sunlight. C says every visit guarantees a fruit.

2A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which explanation gives the relevant mechanism?; Which invents an energy source?; Which makes an unjustified guarantee?

  • a: Explanation A
  • b: Explanation B
  • c: Explanation C
  • d: All plants need identical pollinators
Answer: Which explanation gives the relevant mechanism? → Explanation A; Which invents an energy source? → Explanation B; Which makes an unjustified guarantee? → Explanation C

Which explanation gives the relevant mechanism: Explanation A. Which invents an energy source: Explanation B. Which makes an unjustified guarantee: Explanation C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A and explain why the guarantee in C is too strong.

Example of a full-credit answer: A connects pollinators to pollen transfer. Fruit formation also depends on successful fertilisation and other conditions, so a visit alone is not a guarantee.

  1. Explains the pollen-transfer mechanism.
  2. Names relevant additional conditions or rejects visit-equals-guarantee.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A community uses a riverside area for learning about local plants and shared history. A study previously measured only harvested food.

3A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What additional benefit is now relevant?; Which earlier indicator is incomplete for it?; What could directly investigate it?

  • a: Learning and cultural experience
  • b: Harvested-food amount
  • c: Appropriate visitor-learning evidence
  • d: Only sold products count as benefits
Answer: What additional benefit is now relevant? → Learning and cultural experience; Which earlier indicator is incomplete for it? → Harvested-food amount; What could directly investigate it? → Appropriate visitor-learning evidence

What additional benefit is now relevant: Learning and cultural experience. Which earlier indicator is incomplete for it: Harvested-food amount. What could directly investigate it: Appropriate visitor-learning evidence.

3B · Open ended

Propose an appropriate indicator and explain why food totals are insufficient.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use relevant learning records or community accounts of the educational/cultural use. Food quantity measures a different benefit and cannot describe this use by itself.

  1. Proposes evidence suited to the educational/cultural benefit.
  2. Explains why a food-product indicator misses that benefit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A drawing shows wetland plants slowing water. A learner concludes all contaminants have been removed and no testing is needed.

4A · Multiple choice

What does the drawing represent?

  • a: Slower water movement
  • b: Removal of all contaminants
  • c: Appropriate contaminant measurements
  • d: A drawing certifies drinking water
Answer: Slower water movement

What does the drawing represent: Slower water movement. What is not demonstrated: Removal of all contaminants. What would address water quality: Appropriate contaminant measurements.

4B · Short answer

Identify the mismatch and state what additional evidence is needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Slower flow is not a measurement of every contaminant. Relevant validated water-quality testing and criteria would be needed for a safety claim.

  1. Distinguishes flow regulation from universal contaminant removal.
  2. Requests relevant water-quality evidence/criteria.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A fictional park plan should support both nature learning and habitat condition. A visitor total alone cannot establish either learning quality or habitat quality.

5A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which evidence addresses learning?; Which addresses habitat condition?; Which records activity without proving quality?

  • a: Relevant learning observations
  • b: Suitable habitat indicators
  • c: Visitor total
  • d: The busiest site must be the healthiest
Answer: Which evidence addresses learning? → Relevant learning observations; Which addresses habitat condition? → Suitable habitat indicators; Which records activity without proving quality? → Visitor total

Which evidence addresses learning: Relevant learning observations. Which addresses habitat condition: Suitable habitat indicators. Which records activity without proving quality: Visitor total.

5B · Open ended

Propose one measure for each benefit and explain how to compare over time.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use a relevant learning task or feedback and record suitable vegetation/organism indicators. Compare with a baseline using consistent methods over repeated periods.

  1. Gives suitable measures for both learning and habitat condition.
  2. Includes a baseline and consistent repeated comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.15 · Human effects on ecosystems

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two pathways from paving

Example information

A fictional site replaces absorbent ground with paving. Its toy water model reduces infiltration while rainfall stays the same.

Question: What can happen to runoff in this budget?

Answer: It can increase when less input enters the ground and other flows stay fixed.

Why: The balance identifies a pathway; actual sites need measurements.

Example 2 · Use a comparison
Use a comparison
SiteBeforeAfterChange
Restored203515
Comparison18235

Example information

Vegetation cover changes from 20 to 35 units at a restored site and from 18 to 23 at an unchanged comparison site.

Question: What are the observed increases?

Answer: 15 and 5 units.

Why: The difference between changes is 10 units, but interpretation still depends on comparable conditions.

Example 3 · One result misses a trade-off

Example information

A plan reports more visitors but supplies no habitat observations.

Question: Does the visitor increase establish habitat improvement?

Answer: No.

Why: Visitor activity and habitat condition require different evidence.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify the pathway

Fixed scientific information

A diagram shows vegetation removed, less shelter available and fewer shelter-using organisms observed. These are a proposed pathway and a reported count, not proof of the sole cause.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which is the human action?; Which is the immediate habitat change?; Which is the observed biological record?

  • a: Vegetation removal
  • b: Less shelter
  • c: Fewer organisms observed
  • d: The count proves no other cause exists
Answer: Which is the human action? → Vegetation removal; Which is the immediate habitat change? → Less shelter; Which is the observed biological record? → Fewer organisms observed

Which is the human action: Vegetation removal. Which is the immediate habitat change: Less shelter. Which is the observed biological record: Fewer organisms observed.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · A toy runoff balance

Fixed scientific information

Rain input is 50 units. Infiltration is 15 and evaporation is 10, leaving runoff of 25.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is runoff?; What enters the ground?; What returns by evaporation?

  • a: 25 units
  • b: 15 units
  • c: 10 units
  • d: 75 units runoff
Answer: What is runoff? → 25 units; What enters the ground? → 15 units; What returns by evaporation? → 10 units

What is runoff: 25 units. What enters the ground: 15 units. What returns by evaporation: 10 units.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F3 · Types of action

Fixed scientific information

A prevents litter entering a stream, B removes suitable habitat and C records water condition over time.

F3 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which action reduces a pollution source?” → “Action B”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Which action reduces a pollution source: Action A. Which removes a living resource area: Action B. Which gathers outcome evidence: Action C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Compare changes

Fixed scientific information

A treated patch increases from 8 to 13 observed organisms; a comparison patch increases from 7 to 9. Effort is equal.

F4 · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the treated-patch increase?; What is the comparison increase?; What is the difference between increases?

  • a: 5
  • b: 2
  • c: 3
  • d: The entire change is proved to be treatment
Answer: What is the treated-patch increase? → 5; What is the comparison increase? → 2; What is the difference between increases? → 3

What is the treated-patch increase: 5. What is the comparison increase: 2. What is the difference between increases: 3.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · More than a slogan

Fixed scientific information

A proposal says “Human activity is always bad for every ecosystem,” without considering the type of action.

F5 · Short answer

Give a counterexample and explain what evidence should still be checked.

Example of a full-credit answer: Protection of suitable habitat or reduction of a pollution source can improve a relevant condition. Monitor the intended ecological outcome and unintended effects rather than assuming every action succeeds.

  1. Gives a plausible beneficial action tied to ecosystem condition.
  2. Requires relevant outcome/unintended-effect evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

In a toy model, both sites receive 80 rain units and lose 20 by evaporation. Site A infiltrates 40; B infiltrates 15. Runoff is the remainder.

1A · Hotspot

What is A’s runoff?

  • a: 20 units
  • b: 45 units
  • c: Site B
  • d: A has more because infiltration is larger
Answer: 20 units

What is A’s runoff: 20 units. What is B’s runoff: 45 units. Which site has more runoff: Site B.

1B · Short answer

Compare runoff and explain how infiltration affects the remaining budget.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has 80−20−40=20; B has 80−20−15=45. With equal rain and evaporation, lower infiltration leaves more runoff.

  1. Correctly calculates/compares 20 and 45 units.
  2. Explains the equal-input budget relationship.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A uses repeated comparable before/after measures and an unchanged comparison. B uses one celebratory photograph. C records only the plan’s promise.

2A · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which study most directly tests measured change?; Which gives a narrow visual snapshot?; Which describes intention without outcome data?

  • a: Study A
  • b: Study B
  • c: Record C
  • d: A promise measures success
Answer: Which study most directly tests measured change? → Study A; Which gives a narrow visual snapshot? → Study B; Which describes intention without outcome data? → Record C

Which study most directly tests measured change: Study A. Which gives a narrow visual snapshot: Study B. Which describes intention without outcome data: Record C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A by explaining repeated measurement and the comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repeated measurements reveal variation and trends. The comparison helps identify wider changes that could also occur without the action.

  1. Explains why repeated comparable measurements help.
  2. Explains the role of the unchanged comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

An earlier project protected nesting trees. A new project reduces a known litter source entering a stream. The new goal is fewer litter items reaching the stream.

3A · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which outcome matches the new goal?” → “Litter items reaching the stream”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which outcome matches the new goal: Litter items reaching the stream. Which earlier measure is not sufficient for this goal: Nesting-tree count. Which feature should stay consistent in monitoring: Observation effort and location.

3B · Short answer

Propose relevant monitoring and explain why the old tree measure is insufficient.

Example of a full-credit answer: Count litter reaching the same stream section with comparable effort before and after. Tree counts address another habitat feature, not this stated pollution pathway.

  1. Proposes comparable litter-pathway monitoring.
  2. Explains the mismatch between tree count and the new goal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A project aims to improve habitat cover. Cover improves after restoration, but rainfall and season also change. The report says restoration is proven to be the only cause.

4A · Multiple choice

Which observation concerns the intended habitat outcome?

  • a: Improved habitat cover
  • b: Rainfall and season changes
  • c: The only cause is proven
  • d: Timing alone proves exclusive cause
Answer: Improved habitat cover

Which observation concerns the intended habitat outcome: Improved habitat cover. What alternative influence is stated: Rainfall and season changes. What is overclaimed: The only cause is proven.

4B · Open ended

Correct the causal claim and propose stronger evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: The change is consistent with benefit but does not isolate restoration as the only cause. Repeated comparable records and suitable comparison sites can help test alternatives.

  1. Distinguishes sequence/association from exclusive causal proof.
  2. Proposes relevant comparison/repetition or control of alternatives.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual recreation area needs suitable habitat and visitor access. A plan must reduce disturbance to a nesting zone while retaining a usable route for people.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which feature protects the nesting zone? → Appropriate buffer from nests
  • b: Which feature meets access needs? → Usable alternative route
  • c: Which feature protects the nesting zone? → Nesting and route-use records
  • d: Which evidence evaluates both goals? → Exclude every consideration except visitor number
Answer: Which feature protects the nesting zone? → Appropriate buffer from nests; Which feature meets access needs? → Usable alternative route

Which feature protects the nesting zone: Appropriate buffer from nests. Which feature meets access needs: Usable alternative route. Which evidence evaluates both goals: Nesting and route-use records.

5B · Open ended

Propose a plan that addresses both needs and a way to evaluate it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Place a suitable buffer around the nesting zone and an accessible alternative route with appropriate guidance. Monitor nesting disturbance/success and whether people can use the route as intended.

  1. Proposes a coherent plan addressing habitat and access.
  2. Includes relevant evidence for both stated goals.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.16 · Conservation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Match action to pressure

Example information

A fictional bird lacks safe nesting cover but has enough food.

Question: Which proposal directly addresses the stated gap?

Answer: Protect or restore suitable nesting cover.

Why: Adding food alone does not address the identified missing requirement.

Example 2 · A small planning budget
A small planning budget
ItemTokens
Budget12
Protection7
Monitoring3
Unspent2

Example information

A virtual plan has 12 tokens. Habitat protection costs 7 and monitoring costs 3.

Question: Can both fit, and what remains?

Answer: Yes. They cost 10, leaving 2 tokens.

Why: The budget checks feasibility under the stated fictional costs.

Example 3 · Inputs versus outcomes

Example information

A report counts 20 conservation signs but has no organism or habitat data.

Question: What is missing?

Answer: Evidence of an ecological outcome.

Why: Installed signs are an action record, not proof of improved living conditions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Match the action to the threat

Fixed scientific information

Case A lacks nesting shelter, B receives litter from a known source and C has isolated suitable patches needing a connection.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which case needs suitable nesting shelter? → Case A
  • b: Which needs pollution-source reduction? → Case B
  • c: Which case needs suitable nesting shelter? → Case C
  • d: Which needs a suitable connection? → One identical action fits every threat
Answer: Which case needs suitable nesting shelter? → Case A; Which needs pollution-source reduction? → Case B

Which case needs suitable nesting shelter: Case A. Which needs pollution-source reduction: Case B. Which needs a suitable connection: Case C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Token budget

Fixed scientific information

A virtual budget is 15 tokens. Protection costs 8 and monitoring costs 4, for a total cost of 12.

F2 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “How much remains?” → “12 tokens”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

How much remains: 3 tokens. What is the combined cost: 12 tokens. What is the budget: 15 tokens.

Scientific explorer: operation lab

F3 · Complementary approaches

Fixed scientific information

A protects living habitat, B stores suitable seeds under expert care and C monitors organism counts in the habitat.

F3 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which preserves the living setting?; Which stores plant material?; Which measures population observations?

  • a: Approach A
  • b: Approach B
  • c: Approach C
  • d: Stored seeds recreate every interaction
Answer: Which preserves the living setting? → Approach A; Which stores plant material? → Approach B; Which measures population observations? → Approach C

Which preserves the living setting: Approach A. Which stores plant material: Approach B. Which measures population observations: Approach C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Evidence of success

Fixed scientific information

Record A measures target-species use repeatedly, B counts signs installed and C lists money spent.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which directly checks target-species use?; Which records a communication action?; Which records a financial input?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: Record C
  • d: Spending alone proves recovery
Answer: Which directly checks target-species use? → Record A; Which records a communication action? → Record B; Which records a financial input? → Record C

Which directly checks target-species use: Record A. Which records a communication action: Record B. Which records a financial input: Record C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Goal and indicator

Fixed scientific information

A plan aims to restore suitable nesting habitat, but its only reported indicator is the number of posters printed.

F5 · Open ended

Explain the mismatch and propose a relevant indicator.

Example of a full-credit answer: Poster count records an activity, not nesting habitat condition. Measure suitable nesting-cover availability or repeated evidence of nesting use/success with a consistent method.

  1. Distinguishes an activity count from the intended ecological outcome.
  2. Proposes a relevant habitat or nesting-use indicator.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

The virtual budget is 14 tokens. Suitable-habitat protection costs 8 and repeated monitoring costs 4. Together they address protection and checking outcomes.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: What is the total cost? → 12 tokens
  • b: What remains? → 2 tokens
  • c: What is the total cost? → 14 tokens
  • d: What is the stated budget? → The plan is over budget
Answer: What is the total cost? → 12 tokens; What remains? → 2 tokens

What is the total cost: 12 tokens. What remains: 2 tokens. What is the stated budget: 14 tokens.

1B · Open ended

Check feasibility and explain the purpose of the monitoring expense.

Example of a full-credit answer: 8+4=12, so the plan fits and leaves 2. Monitoring checks whether the intended habitat or population outcome occurs rather than assuming success.

  1. Correctly calculates cost and feasibility.
  2. Explains the ecological-outcome purpose of monitoring.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A target plant loses habitat to repeated clearing. Plan A protects suitable remaining habitat and monitors condition. B only changes a logo. C introduces an unknown species.

2A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which plan directly addresses the stated threat?; Which changes presentation without habitat action?; Which adds an unassessed introduction?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: A colourful logo repairs habitat
Answer: Which plan directly addresses the stated threat? → Plan A; Which changes presentation without habitat action? → Plan B; Which adds an unassessed introduction? → Plan C

Which plan directly addresses the stated threat: Plan A. Which changes presentation without habitat action: Plan B. Which adds an unassessed introduction: Plan C.

2B · Short answer

Justify A using its protection and evidence components.

Example of a full-credit answer: It reduces the habitat-clearing pressure by protecting suitable areas. Monitoring checks whether habitat condition and the target plant improve or persist.

  1. Links protection to the stated clearing threat.
  2. Links monitoring to relevant conservation outcomes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A seed bank stores suitable seeds of one species. A new goal is to conserve that species together with its pollinators and soil relationships in the wild.

3A · Multiple choice

Which added action directly addresses the wider goal?

  • a: Protect suitable living habitat
  • b: Seeds of one species
  • c: Wild ecological relationships
  • d: One stored seed is a whole ecosystem
Answer: Protect suitable living habitat

Which added action directly addresses the wider goal: Protect suitable living habitat. What does the existing bank store: Seeds of one species. What lies beyond storage alone: Wild ecological relationships.

3B · Open ended

Explain why habitat work complements the bank and name one relationship to consider.

Example of a full-credit answer: The bank preserves some plant material but not all living interactions. Habitat work can support pollinators or soil organisms and suitable conditions needed by the plant.

  1. Explains the complementary limits of storage versus living habitat.
  2. Names a relevant relationship/condition for the wider goal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A project spent its entire budget and installed ten signs. It declares a population recovered without measuring any living individuals or habitat conditions.

4A · Hotspot

What is established?

  • a: Actions and spending occurred
  • b: Population recovery
  • c: Relevant ecological monitoring
  • d: Spending automatically causes recovery
Answer: Actions and spending occurred

What is established: Actions and spending occurred. What is not measured: Population recovery. What is needed next: Relevant ecological monitoring.

4B · Short answer

Correct the claim and propose one suitable outcome measure.

Example of a full-credit answer: The record shows implementation, not proven recovery. Use comparable target-species counts, reproduction or habitat-condition observations over time.

  1. Distinguishes implementation evidence from recovery evidence.
  2. Proposes a relevant repeated ecological outcome measure.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual 10-token budget must address suitable shelter and include monitoring. Shelter improvement costs 6 tokens, monitoring 3, and a decorative arch 5. Other valid low-cost designs must meet both required goals.

5A · True or false

True or false? The listed shelter-improvement and monitoring plan costs 9 tokens and meets both required goals within the 10-token budget.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Shelter improvement costs 6 and monitoring costs 3: together they cost 9, within the 10-token budget, and cover both required goals.

5B · Open ended

Propose a feasible plan and explain how it tests the intended benefit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose shelter improvement and monitoring for 9 tokens. Use comparable repeated observations of shelter condition and target-organism use to test benefit.

  1. Proposes a within-budget plan covering shelter and monitoring.
  2. Explains relevant outcome evidence rather than decoration/spending alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S8.17 · Sustainability

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A renewable toy stock
A renewable toy stock
Budget partTokens
Start40
Renewal7
Use9
Final38

Example information

A resource stock starts at 40 tokens, renews by 7 and is used by 9 during one interval.

Question: What is the final stock?

Answer: 38 tokens.

Why: 40+7−9=38, so this fixed interval reduces the stock by 2.

Example 2 · A stable number has limits

Example information

A toy stock gains and loses 5 tokens, leaving its number unchanged. No habitat data are supplied.

Question: Does the stable stock prove every ecological effect is harmless?

Answer: No.

Why: The budget measures one quantity and omits other possible effects.

Example 3 · Compare repeated use

Example information

Container A uses one fictional material unit per use. B uses 6 units to make and lasts 10 uses; cleaning is not included.

Question: Which has lower counted material per ten uses?

Answer: B: 6 units versus A: 10.

Why: This limited material comparison does not establish a complete life-cycle advantage without cleaning, energy and other relevant data.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A stock balance

Fixed scientific information

A toy renewable stock starts at 30, gains 8 and loses 5 in one interval.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final stock?; What is the net change?; What amount is removed?

  • a: 33
  • b: Increase of 3
  • c: 5
  • d: Unlimited forever
Answer: What is the final stock? → 33; What is the net change? → Increase of 3; What amount is removed? → 5

What is the final stock: 33. What is the net change: Increase of 3. What amount is removed: 5.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F2 · Different actions

Fixed scientific information

A prevents an unnecessary single-use item, B repairs an existing item and C processes collected material into usable material.

F2 · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which is source reduction?; Which extends an existing item’s life?; Which is recycling?

  • a: Action A
  • b: Action B
  • c: Action C
  • d: All materials recycle without energy
Answer: Which is source reduction? → Action A; Which extends an existing item’s life? → Action B; Which is recycling? → Action C

Which is source reduction: Action A. Which extends an existing item’s life: Action B. Which is recycling: Action C.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Rates matter

Fixed scientific information

Plan P renews 6 units and removes 9, Q renews 6 and removes 6, and R renews 6 and removes 4 in the stated interval.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which plan reduces the stock?

  • a: Plan P
  • b: Plan Q
  • c: Plan R
  • d: Renewable means removal never matters
Answer: Plan P

Which plan reduces the stock: Plan P. Which keeps the stock numerically stable: Plan Q. Which increases it: Plan R.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A balanced evaluation

Fixed scientific information

A record measures resource use, B records who can access an essential service and C measures a relevant habitat indicator.

F4 · True or false

Is this pairing correct for the source? “Which record tracks consumption?” → “Record A”.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Which record tracks consumption: Record A. Which addresses practical access: Record B. Which checks an ecological outcome: Record C.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Renewable is not unlimited

Fixed scientific information

A learner says a resource can never run low because it is renewable, even when removals exceed renewal every interval.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the claim using the stock budget and name one reason renewal must be checked over time.

Example of a full-credit answer: If removals exceed additions, the stock falls. Renewal can change with weather, population condition or other ecological factors, so its rate needs monitoring.

  1. Explains depletion when use exceeds renewal.
  2. Names a relevant changing condition or reason to monitor renewal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed scientific information

A toy stock starts at 60 units. Renewal adds 9 and use removes 12. No other flows are present.

1A · Drag and drop

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: What is the final stock?; What is the net decline?; What amount was used?

  • a: 57 units
  • b: 3 units
  • c: 12 units
  • d: 81 units
Answer: What is the final stock? → 57 units; What is the net decline? → 3 units; What amount was used? → 12 units

What is the final stock: 57 units. What is the net decline: 3 units. What amount was used: 12 units.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the result and explain what repeating those fixed rates would do before other limits arise.

Example of a full-credit answer: 60+9−12=57. Each such interval would reduce the stock by 3, so the stated use rate does not maintain this stock; real rates may change.

  1. Calculates 57 units.
  2. Explains repeated net loss under the fixed assumptions without promising a real forecast.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed scientific information

A compares material, energy, useful lifetime and access under stated assumptions. B uses only package colour. C assumes the word green proves every benefit.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all correct question-and-answer pairings for this source.

  • a: Which comparison examines relevant processes? → Comparison A
  • b: Which relies on appearance? → Comparison B
  • c: Which comparison examines relevant processes? → Claim C
  • d: Which treats a label as proof? → Check measured material and energy use
Answer: Which comparison examines relevant processes? → Comparison A; Which relies on appearance? → Comparison B

Which comparison examines relevant processes: Comparison A. Which relies on appearance: Comparison B. Which treats a label as proof: Claim C.

2B · Open ended

Justify A and explain why it may still have limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: It examines actual resource and use factors rather than appearance. Its conclusion still depends on complete data, the use pattern and which impacts are included.

  1. Explains the relevance of actual resource/lifetime/access factors.
  2. Recognises scope, data or assumption limits.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed scientific information

A toy water store starts at 50 units, gains 10 recharge units and loses 7 through use. The model does not describe drinking-water quality.

3A · Hotspot

What is the final stock?

  • a: 53 units
  • b: Recharge
  • c: Drinking-water quality
  • d: A larger store proves safe water
Answer: 53 units

What is the final stock: 53 units. What process adds to storage: Recharge. What is outside the stated model: Drinking-water quality.

3B · Short answer

Apply the resource-budget idea and explain one limit of this transfer.

Example of a full-credit answer: 50+10−7=53 units. The budget transfers to water quantity, but quality and other ecological effects need separate evidence.

  1. Correctly applies the stock balance to obtain 53.
  2. Identifies a relevant unmeasured quality/ecological limit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed scientific information

A poster says “Recycling needs no energy and returns every material perfectly forever.” The source states recycling can reuse recovered material, collection and processing require resources, and recovery can be incomplete.

4A · Matching

Match each scientific question to its answer using the source. Each answer is used at most once.

Complete or match: Which process needs resources?; What can be incomplete?; Which claim is unsupported?

  • a: Collection and processing
  • b: Material recovery
  • c: Perfect recycling forever
  • d: Recycling can reuse recovered material
Answer: Which process needs resources? → Collection and processing; What can be incomplete? → Material recovery; Which claim is unsupported? → Perfect recycling forever

Which process needs resources: Collection and processing. What can be incomplete: Material recovery. Which claim is unsupported: Perfect recycling forever.

4B · Open ended

Correct both parts of the poster while retaining a reasonable benefit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Recycling can recover useful material and reduce some new-material demand. It still needs collection/processing energy and does not necessarily recover all material perfectly.

  1. Recognises resource/energy needs despite a plausible recovery benefit.
  2. Rejects complete perfect recovery as a universal guarantee.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed scientific information

A virtual store begins at 40 units and renews by 8 per interval. Essential use needs at least 5 units. First examine a proposal using 6 units. Then design a plan that meets the essential need without reducing the stock in this fixed model and includes monitoring.

5A · Multiple choice

What is the final stock after using 6 units?

  • a: 42 units
  • b: 5 units
  • c: 8 units
  • d: 54 units
Answer: 42 units

What is the final stock after using 6 units: 42 units. What is the minimum essential need: 5 units. What is the stated renewal: 8 units.

5B · Open ended

Propose a valid use amount and explain what to monitor if real conditions change.

Example of a full-credit answer: For example, use 6 units: it meets the 5-unit essential need and is below renewal of 8, so stock becomes 42. Monitor actual renewal, use, stock and relevant ecological/access effects.

  1. Chooses a use amount from 5 through 8 and explains both constraints.
  2. Proposes relevant monitoring of changing resource conditions and/or wider effects.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.1 · Atmosphere

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A bag is not empty

Worked-example information

A teacher seals air inside a flexible bag. The bag bulges when gently pressed.

Question: What does the bulge show?

Answer: The air occupies space.

Why: The air remains inside the bag and pushes back. Invisible does not mean absent.

Example 2 · Pressure at two heights
Recorded pressure
StationPressure units
Low98
Hill92

Worked-example information

Fictional readings: low station 98 units; hill station 92 units. Both use the same checked sensor.

Question: How much lower is the hill reading?

Answer: 6 pressure units.

Why: Subtract 92 from 98. The comparison is about these readings, not an exact rule for every hill.

Example 3 · A foggy window

Worked-example information

Warm room air touches a cooler window. Clear droplets appear on the glass.

Question: What change produced the droplets?

Answer: Water vapour condensed into liquid water.

Why: The glass cooled nearby water vapour. The water did not pass through the glass.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Air in a syringe

Fixed case information

In a sealed virtual syringe, pushing the plunger makes the same air occupy less space. No gas escapes, and the compressed air pushes back against the plunger.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Quantity unchanged; Quantity reduced; Observed effect

  • a: Number of air particles
  • b: Space occupied by air
  • c: Air resists compression
  • d: Number of clouds
Answer: Quantity unchanged → Number of air particles; Quantity reduced → Space occupied by air; Observed effect → Air resists compression

The sealed sample keeps its particles while their spacing can change.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F2 · Hill pressure readings

Fixed case information

Fictional readings made with one checked sensor: shore 101, hill 95, mountain 84 pressure units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies smallest reading in this case?

  • a: Mountain
  • b: Shore
  • c: All equal
  • d: Pressure always increases with height
Answer: Mountain

The mountain has the smallest measured value; the trend is in this dataset.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Cloud and vapour

Fixed case information

A source card states: water vapour is an invisible gas; a cloud contains tiny droplets or ice; rain is falling liquid water.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies invisible gas in this case?

  • a: Water vapour
  • b: Cloud droplets
  • c: Dry soil
  • d: Solid rock
Answer: Water vapour

The water forms differ even though all involve the same substance.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Compare temperature fairly

Fixed case information

A class compares two shaded courtyards at noon. One thermometer reads 29°C and the other 31°C. Both were checked against the same reference.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Warmer courtyard: The 31°C courtyard.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The comparison controls time and direct sunlight while comparing temperatures.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · What does three days show?

Fixed case information

A fictional class records 28°C, 30°C and 29°C at noon on three days. It claims this proves the location is warming every year.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain one limit of the class claim and describe the additional records needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Three days do not establish a yearly climate trend. Comparable measurements over many years are needed.

  1. Three days do not establish a yearly climate trend.
  2. Comparable measurements over many years are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A closed flexible balloon is carried upward in a simplified model. Outside pressure decreases; no air enters or leaves. Its volume grows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Cause of easier expansion: Lower outside pressure
  • b: Particle count inside: Unchanged
  • c: Cause of easier expansion: More particles enter
  • d: Particle count inside: Lower particle count
Answer: Cause of easier expansion: Lower outside pressure; Particle count inside: Unchanged

The flexible balloon expands against a smaller outside push without gaining particles.

1B · Short answer

Explain why the balloon can grow and what happens to the number of particles inside.

Example of a full-credit answer: Lower outside pressure allows the flexible balloon to expand. The sealed balloon keeps the same number of particles.

  1. Lower outside pressure allows the flexible balloon to expand.
  2. The sealed balloon keeps the same number of particles.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A class wants to compare shaded air temperature across a week. Plan A uses one sensor at noon in one shaded place. Plan B changes sensor, location and time daily.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Stronger comparison; Reason; Essential record

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Fewer changing measurement conditions
  • c: Date and temperature with units
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Stronger comparison → Plan A; Reason → Fewer changing measurement conditions; Essential record → Date and temperature with units

Plan A makes the readings more comparable; it does not guarantee a perfect instrument.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger plan and justify it with one controlled feature.

Example of a full-credit answer: Plan A is the stronger comparison. It holds the sensor, shaded location or time constant.

  1. Plan A is the stronger comparison.
  2. It holds the sensor, shaded location or time constant.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

In a new classroom case, a dry cold bottle is placed in humid air. Droplets form on its outside. The bottle is closed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies water source in this case?

  • a: Water vapour in nearby air
  • b: Water passing through the plastic
  • c: Evaporation
  • d: Invisible gas only
Answer: Water vapour in nearby air

Cooling nearby water vapour can produce liquid droplets on the outside.

3B · Short answer

Explain where the outside water came from and name its change of state.

Example of a full-credit answer: It came from water vapour in the surrounding air. The vapour condensed to liquid on the cold surface.

  1. It came from water vapour in the surrounding air.
  2. The vapour condensed to liquid on the cold surface.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner draws greenhouse gases as a solid ceiling that blocks every incoming ray of sunlight. The reference says they absorb and emit selected infrared wavelengths.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies error in sketch in this case?

  • a: A solid ceiling blocking all sunlight
  • b: A complete description
  • c: Only sound waves
  • d: All energy is destroyed
Answer: A solid ceiling blocking all sunlight

The gas interaction is selective and does not make a solid ceiling.

4B · Open ended

Identify the mistake and replace it with a more accurate description.

Example of a full-credit answer: Greenhouse gases are not a solid ceiling blocking all sunlight. They absorb and emit some infrared radiation released by Earth.

  1. Greenhouse gases are not a solid ceiling blocking all sunlight.
  2. They absorb and emit some infrared radiation released by Earth.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

The class has two identical virtual sealed syringes with equal particle counts. It may change volume while keeping temperature fixed. The goal is to investigate air compression.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Variable to change; Condition to keep; Useful observation

  • a: Volume
  • b: Temperature
  • c: Resistance or pressure at each volume
  • d: Particle count in only one syringe
Answer: Variable to change → Volume; Condition to keep → Temperature; Useful observation → Resistance or pressure at each volume

Changing volume while keeping the gas sample and temperature comparable isolates compression.

5B · Open ended

Propose two volumes to compare and state one condition you will keep the same.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compare volumes of 80 and 50 model units while keeping temperature and particle count unchanged.

  1. Proposes two different syringe volumes to compare.
  2. Keeps temperature or the sealed particle count the same.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.2 · Hydrosphere

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Three forms, one substance

Worked-example information

A drawing shows mountain ice, a river and invisible water vapour above a field.

Question: Which parts belong to the hydrosphere?

Answer: All three.

Why: The name includes water in solid, liquid and gas forms.

Example 2 · Pond bookkeeping
Water budget
PartLitres
Start40
Input12
Output7
Final45

Worked-example information

A model pond starts with 40 L, receives 12 L and loses 7 L. No other flow is included.

Question: What volume remains?

Answer: 45 L.

Why: 40 + 12 − 7 = 45. The answer depends on the stated model boundary.

Example 3 · Two clear samples

Worked-example information

Sealed sample A is labelled fresh water. Sealed sample B is labelled salt water. Both are clear.

Question: Can clarity distinguish their salt content?

Answer: No.

Why: Dissolved salt can be invisible; the labels contain information that appearance alone cannot provide.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the water store

Fixed case information

A diagram labels a salty ocean, frozen mountain ice and water filling small spaces beneath the ground.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies water below ground in this case?

  • a: Groundwater
  • b: Empty air only
  • c: Dry rock only
  • d: A flame
Answer: Groundwater

All three are parts of the hydrosphere.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F2 · Small reservoir balance

Fixed case information

A classroom tank starts with 30 L. An inlet adds 8 L and an outlet removes 5 L. These are the only flows in this model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies final amount in this case?

  • a: 33 L
  • b: 17 L
  • c: 43 L
  • d: 3 L
Answer: 33 L

30 + 8 − 5 = 33 L; inflow and outflow have different signs.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Water arriving as rain

Fixed case information

A toy landscape receives 100 water units. Sixty infiltrate and ten evaporate. The remaining thirty run off.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Water entering soil; Water becoming vapour; Water running over land

  • a: 60 units
  • b: 10 units
  • c: 30 units
  • d: 100 units
Answer: Water entering soil → 60 units; Water becoming vapour → 10 units; Water running over land → 30 units

The three pathways account for all 100 starting units.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F4 · A water-quality statement

Fixed case information

A virtual sample is clear. Its dissolved-salt test reads high. No microbe test is available.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Known observation: The sample is clear
  • b: Known test result: High dissolved salt
  • c: Known observation: Guaranteed safe to drink
  • d: Known test result: No dissolved material
Answer: Known observation: The sample is clear; Known test result: High dissolved salt

Clear appearance does not answer every water-quality question.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · A shrinking store

Fixed case information

A model groundwater store receives 4 units per step but loses 7 to pumping. It starts with 50 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

State whether the store rises or falls, calculate its change in one step, and explain using the two flows.

Example of a full-credit answer: The store falls by 3 units in the step. Pumping of 7 units exceeds recharge of 4 units.

  1. The store falls by 3 units in the step.
  2. Pumping of 7 units exceeds recharge of 4 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A model tank begins with 24 L. Rain adds 9 L; garden use removes 6 L; evaporation removes 2 L. There is no leak.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Water left; Total loss; Water added

  • a: 25 L
  • b: 8 L
  • c: 9 L
  • d: 41 L
Answer: Water left → 25 L; Total loss → 8 L; Water added → 9 L

The final amount is 24 + 9 − 6 − 2 = 25 L.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the water left and explain which flows you subtracted.

Example of a full-credit answer: The final amount is 25 L. Subtracts garden use and evaporation from the starting amount plus rain.

  1. The final amount is 25 L.
  2. Subtracts garden use and evaporation from the starting amount plus rain.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A fictional school has a leaking tap losing 6 L daily. A repair stops the leak. Painting the tank changes its colour but the measured leak remains 6 L daily.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Action with measured saving: Repair the leak.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The evidence links repair to the stated loss; appearance is not a volume saving.

2B · Short answer

Choose the action and justify it with a measurement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses repairing the leaking tap. Uses the reduction from 6 L daily to zero as evidence.

  1. Chooses repairing the leaking tap.
  2. Uses the reduction from 6 L daily to zero as evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A model snow store has 18 water-equivalent units. Snowfall adds 5 units, and melting transfers 8 units to a stream. No other transfer occurs.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies snow store after transfer in this case?

  • a: 15 units
  • b: 31 units
  • c: 5 units
  • d: Water vanishing
Answer: 15 units

Melting moves water into another store; 18 + 5 − 8 = 15.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the remaining snow-store amount and explain where the melted water went.

Example of a full-credit answer: The snow store has 15 water-equivalent units. The 8 melted units moved into the stream rather than disappearing.

  1. The snow store has 15 water-equivalent units.
  2. The 8 melted units moved into the stream rather than disappearing.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Lina says, “Both jars are clear, so both must be safe to drink.” The records include only photographs, with no chemical or microbe tests.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Unsupported conclusion: Both are safe to drink
  • b: Available evidence: Appearance only
  • c: Unsupported conclusion: Both look clear
  • d: Available evidence: Complete laboratory results
Answer: Unsupported conclusion: Both are safe to drink; Available evidence: Appearance only

A photograph cannot rule out invisible contamination.

4B · Short answer

Explain the flaw and name a safer way to gather the missing evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Clear appearance alone cannot prove water is safe. Use appropriate water-quality test reports or trusted testing rather than tasting.

  1. Clear appearance alone cannot prove water is safe.
  2. Use appropriate water-quality test reports or trusted testing rather than tasting.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

The school needs 12 model water units daily. Its sustainable daily supply in this case is 15 units. Current demand is 18 because a leak wastes 6. Plan a way to meet needs without exceeding supply.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Necessary useful demand; Avoidable loss; Available supply

  • a: 12 units
  • b: 6 units
  • c: 15 units
  • d: 18 useful units
Answer: Necessary useful demand → 12 units; Avoidable loss → 6 units; Available supply → 15 units

Fixing the leak reduces demand to 12, within the stated 15-unit supply.

5B · Open ended

Propose a plan that meets useful needs and show that its daily use fits the supply.

Example of a full-credit answer: Proposes stopping the 6-unit leak while keeping the 12-unit useful demand. Shows that 12 units is no greater than the 15-unit daily supply.

  1. Proposes stopping the 6-unit leak while keeping the 12-unit useful demand.
  2. Shows that 12 units is no greater than the 15-unit daily supply.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.3 · Geosphere

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Four systems in one handful

Worked-example information

A soil model shows mineral grains, water, air and a worm.

Question: Which part is directly a geosphere material?

Answer: The mineral grains.

Why: The example also connects to hydrosphere, atmosphere and biosphere.

Example 2 · A pebble journey
Process clues
EventProcess
Breaks in placeWeathering
Moves in streamErosion
SettlesDeposition

Worked-example information

A pebble breaks from rock, is carried by a stream, then settles on a riverbank.

Question: Which stage is deposition?

Answer: The settling stage.

Why: Breaking, transport and settling are different processes.

Example 3 · A diagram is not a clock

Worked-example information

An animation moves a plate several centimetres on screen in a second.

Question: Can this establish real plate speed?

Answer: No.

Why: A display scale and timescale are needed; animation speed can be chosen for visibility.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Choose the solid material

Fixed case information

A classroom tray contains granite chips, liquid water, air and a living seedling.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Geosphere sample; Hydrosphere sample; Biosphere sample

  • a: Granite chips
  • b: Liquid water
  • c: Living seedling
  • d: Air only
Answer: Geosphere sample → Granite chips; Hydrosphere sample → Liquid water; Biosphere sample → Living seedling

The granite is a rocky part of the geosphere.

Scientific explorer: material lab

F2 · Plate-boundary arrows

Fixed case information

A diagram shows two plates moving away from one another. A second shows them sliding past. A third shows them moving together.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Away from one another; Sliding past; Moving together

  • a: Divergent boundary
  • b: Transform boundary
  • c: Convergent boundary
  • d: No plate movement
Answer: Away from one another → Divergent boundary; Sliding past → Transform boundary; Moving together → Convergent boundary

Boundary names describe relative plate motion.

Scientific explorer: plate lab

F3 · Three sediment events

Fixed case information

A rock cracks in place. Water carries its sand downhill. The sand later settles where flow slows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Cracking in place: Erosion.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Identify the action, not just the material.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Cover and erosion data

Fixed case information

Fictional equal-slope trays receive equal rain. Bare tray loses 12 model sediment units; covered tray loses 4.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies smaller measured loss in this case?

  • a: Covered tray
  • b: Bare tray
  • c: 16 units
  • d: Different rain totals
Answer: Covered tray

Cover is the deliberately changed feature in the stated comparison.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · What the model leaves out

Fixed case information

A toy erosion index uses rain, slope and plant cover. It omits soil type. Two real sites have different soils.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Name a missing factor and explain one limit it creates.

Example of a full-credit answer: Soil type is missing from the model. The model cannot by itself predict exact loss for real sites with different soils.

  1. Soil type is missing from the model.
  2. The model cannot by itself predict exact loss for real sites with different soils.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional seafloor diagram shows a central ridge, plates moving apart, and newly formed rock at the ridge.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Boundary type; Relative motion; New rock location

  • a: Divergent
  • b: Apart
  • c: At the ridge
  • d: Transform
Answer: Boundary type → Divergent; Relative motion → Apart; New rock location → At the ridge

The ridge and outward arrows agree with a divergent boundary model.

1B · Short answer

Identify the boundary and use two stated clues to explain your answer.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies a divergent boundary. Uses plates moving apart and new rock at the central ridge as evidence.

  1. Identifies a divergent boundary.
  2. Uses plates moving apart and new rock at the central ridge as evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A group tests plant cover. Plan A keeps soil, slope and rain equal. Plan B changes cover, soil and rainfall together.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies stronger design in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Cloud colour
  • d: No possible alternative cause
Answer: Plan A

Plan A better isolates cover in this classroom comparison.

2B · Open ended

Choose a plan and explain why it gives clearer evidence about cover.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Explains that holding soil, slope and rain constant limits alternative causes.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Explains that holding soil, slope and rain constant limits alternative causes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional rock sample contains compacted sand layers. A class is told the grains were deposited, buried and joined over time.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Rock-forming route: Sediment becomes rock
  • b: Earlier material: Loose sand
  • c: Rock-forming route: Cooling liquid lava
  • d: Earlier material: Fresh water vapour
Answer: Rock-forming route: Sediment becomes rock; Earlier material: Loose sand

The supplied history describes sedimentary rock formation.

3B · Short answer

Explain the rock-forming route and identify the observation that fits it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Describes deposited sediment being buried and joined into rock. Uses the compacted or joined sand layers as evidence.

  1. Describes deposited sediment being buried and joined into rock.
  2. Uses the compacted or joined sand layers as evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “The arrows in this one diagram tell us an earthquake will happen here tomorrow.” The diagram shows only plate motion direction.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Unsupported part: Motion direction.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Motion direction alone cannot predict an earthquake date.

4B · Open ended

Identify the unsupported claim and state what the arrows actually establish.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rejects the claim that the diagram predicts an earthquake tomorrow. States that the arrows show relative motion direction only.

  1. Rejects the claim that the diagram predicts an earthquake tomorrow.
  2. States that the arrows show relative motion direction only.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A classroom may choose plant cover while keeping rain at 5 and slope at 4 in a toy model. Its erosion index is rain × slope × uncovered fraction. Aim for an index no greater than 5.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Cover that meets target; Bare-slope index; Feature to keep fixed

  • a: 75% cover
  • b: 20
  • c: Rain and slope
  • d: 0% cover
Answer: Cover that meets target → 75% cover; Bare-slope index → 20; Feature to keep fixed → Rain and slope

At 75% cover, the uncovered fraction is 0.25 and 5 × 4 × 0.25 = 5.

5B · Open ended

Propose a cover level that meets the target and show the model calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 75% cover. The index is 5 × 4 × 0.25 = 5.

  1. Proposes 75% or greater cover within 100%.
  2. Calculates an erosion index of 5 or less using the stated formula.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.4 · Biosphere

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A root connects systems

Worked-example information

A root takes water and mineral nutrients from moist soil.

Question: Which systems are connected by the living root?

Answer: Biosphere, hydrosphere and geosphere.

Why: The root is living, the water is a water store, and mineral material comes from the solid Earth.

Example 2 · Snails in a plot
Population changes
EventSnails
Start12
Arrivals2
Departures3
Final11

Worked-example information

A marked plot starts with 12 snails. Two arrive and three leave. No births or deaths occur.

Question: How many remain?

Answer: 11 snails.

Why: 12 + 2 − 3 = 11. The boundary is the marked plot.

Example 3 · A leaf does not vanish

Worked-example information

A leaf breaks down with help from decomposers.

Question: Does its matter disappear?

Answer: No. Its matter moves into organisms, gases and other environmental stores.

Why: Decomposition changes and transfers matter rather than removing it from existence.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A mangrove connection

Fixed case information

A mangrove seedling takes water from mud and carbon dioxide from air. Light supplies energy for photosynthesis.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies living component in this case?

  • a: Mangrove seedling
  • b: Sunlight alone
  • c: Dry glass
  • d: An electric wire
Answer: Mangrove seedling

The living plant exchanges materials with other Earth systems.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

F2 · A pond food route

Fixed case information

A simplified pond route is algae → small snails → fish. Arrows show food matter and energy moving to the consumer.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Producer: Algae
  • b: Consumer of algae: Small snails
  • c: Producer: Fish
  • d: Consumer of algae: Only sunlight
Answer: Producer: Algae; Consumer of algae: Small snails

The arrows point from food to the organism eating it.

Scientific explorer: foodweb lab

F3 · Count the marked plot

Fixed case information

A fictional plot has 20 insects. Four are born, three die, two arrive and one leaves in a model step.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies final population in this case?

  • a: 22 insects
  • b: 30 insects
  • c: 10 insects
  • d: 20 insects
Answer: 22 insects

20 + 4 − 3 + 2 − 1 = 22.

Scientific explorer: population lab

F4 · Living and nonliving records

Fixed case information

A field notebook records grass cover, soil moisture and air temperature. The study asks how living plants connect with nonliving conditions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Living measure: Air temperature.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

These observations describe different but connected system features.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · A limited plant claim

Fixed case information

In a fictional garden, shaded seedlings survived 8 out of 10 while unshaded seedlings survived 5 out of 10. Soil and watering were not recorded.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

State what the counts show and explain why shade alone is not established as the cause.

Example of a full-credit answer: The shaded group had higher observed survival, 8/10 versus 5/10. Unrecorded soil or watering could also explain part of the difference.

  1. The shaded group had higher observed survival, 8/10 versus 5/10.
  2. Unrecorded soil or watering could also explain part of the difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A model wetland has 30 frogs. Six hatch, two die, three arrive and five leave during a stated period.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: New population: 32 frogs
  • b: Total additions: 9 frogs
  • c: New population: 46 frogs
  • d: Total additions: 23 frogs
Answer: New population: 32 frogs; Total additions: 9 frogs

The boundary budget gives 30 + 6 − 2 + 3 − 5 = 32.

1B · Open ended

Find the final population and explain how movement was included.

Example of a full-credit answer: The final population is 32 frogs. Adds the three arrivals and subtracts the five departures as well as births and deaths.

  1. The final population is 32 frogs.
  2. Adds the three arrivals and subtracts the five departures as well as births and deaths.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A class proposes restoring native plants beside a pond. Check A records plant survival and insects with the same method each month. Check B records only the poster colour.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies useful check in this case?

  • a: Check A
  • b: Check B
  • c: Poster colour only
  • d: Changing the counted area each time
Answer: Check A

The chosen records relate to habitat function and living organisms.

2B · Short answer

Choose the useful check and explain how it relates to the restoration goal.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Check A. Explains that plant survival or comparable insect records provide evidence about the living habitat.

  1. Chooses Check A.
  2. Explains that plant survival or comparable insect records provide evidence about the living habitat.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional rooftop garden stores rainwater, grows vegetables and provides flowers for insects. It uses containers filled with mineral soil.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Biosphere component; Hydrosphere component; Geosphere material

  • a: Vegetables and insects
  • b: Stored rainwater
  • c: Mineral soil
  • d: The empty air only
Answer: Biosphere component → Vegetables and insects; Hydrosphere component → Stored rainwater; Geosphere material → Mineral soil

A new location still contains interactions among living things, water and mineral material.

3B · Open ended

Describe one biosphere–hydrosphere connection and one biosphere–geosphere connection in this rooftop garden.

Example of a full-credit answer: The living plants use stored rainwater, connecting biosphere and hydrosphere. Their roots take mineral nutrients from the soil, connecting biosphere and geosphere.

  1. Describes living plants using stored rainwater, connecting biosphere and hydrosphere.
  2. Describes living plants using mineral nutrients or a suitable soil support connection, connecting biosphere and geosphere.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “When a leaf decays, all its energy is recycled forever in the food web.” The reference says nutrients can cycle, while energy transfers and spreads to surroundings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Incorrect phrase; What can cycle; Energy outcome

  • a: All energy is recycled forever
  • b: Nutrient matter
  • c: Some spreads to surroundings
  • d: Number of feeding links
Answer: Incorrect phrase → All energy is recycled forever; What can cycle → Nutrient matter; Energy outcome → Some spreads to surroundings

Matter cycling and energy flow must not be treated as identical.

4B · Short answer

Correct the claim by distinguishing matter from energy.

Example of a full-credit answer: States that nutrient matter can be reused through cycles. States that energy transfers through the system and increasingly spreads to surroundings rather than cycling forever.

  1. States that nutrient matter can be reused through cycles.
  2. States that energy transfers through the system and increasingly spreads to surroundings rather than cycling forever.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class can observe two equal garden plots for four weeks. One receives a new native-flower patch; the other stays unchanged. No animals are captured. Design a way to compare insect visits.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Useful response measure; Feature to keep equal; Changed feature

  • a: Insect visits in a fixed time
  • b: Observation time and area
  • c: Native-flower patch
  • d: Poster size
Answer: Useful response measure → Insect visits in a fixed time; Feature to keep equal → Observation time and area; Changed feature → Native-flower patch

Comparable counts make a habitat observation more informative without handling animals.

5B · Open ended

Propose how to count visits and give one condition to keep comparable.

Example of a full-credit answer: Counts insect visits for the same stated time in each plot, repeated across the weeks. Keeps observation area, time of day or counting method comparable.

  1. Counts insect visits for the same stated time in each plot, repeated across the weeks.
  2. Keeps observation area, time of day or counting method comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.5 · Water cycle

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · The drying cloth

Worked-example information

A damp cloth becomes drier in a warm room without boiling.

Question: What process removes liquid water?

Answer: Evaporation.

Why: Some water leaves the liquid as vapour; boiling is not necessary.

Example 2 · Follow 50 units
Water paths
PathUnits
Infiltration20
Evaporation5
Runoff25

Worked-example information

A toy landscape receives 50 water units. Twenty infiltrate, five evaporate and twenty-five run off.

Question: Is the model budget complete?

Answer: Yes, for the three stated paths.

Why: 20 + 5 + 25 = 50. The total matches the input.

Example 3 · A cloud droplet

Worked-example information

A parcel of moist air cools and tiny liquid droplets form.

Question: Which process occurred?

Answer: Condensation.

Why: Water vapour changed into liquid droplets; a cloud is not simply invisible vapour.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the transfer

Fixed case information

A diagram shows liquid lake water becoming vapour, vapour forming droplets, and droplets falling.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies liquid becoming gas in this case?

  • a: Evaporation
  • b: Condensation
  • c: A rock cycle
  • d: Photosynthesis
Answer: Evaporation

The names distinguish state change from falling water.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Trace rain on a surface

Fixed case information

A toy model receives 80 water units. Half infiltrates, one eighth evaporates, and the remaining three eighths run off.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Infiltrating amount; Evaporating amount; Runoff amount

  • a: 40 units
  • b: 10 units
  • c: 30 units
  • d: 80 units
Answer: Infiltrating amount → 40 units; Evaporating amount → 10 units; Runoff amount → 30 units

Half of 80 is 40, one eighth is 10 and three eighths is 30.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F3 · Equal-rain surfaces

Fixed case information

Fictional data with equal rain: open soil infiltrates 30 units; paving infiltrates 5 units. Other included conditions are held equal.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Greater infiltration; Difference; Controlled input

  • a: Open soil
  • b: 25 units
  • c: Equal rain
  • d: Paving
Answer: Greater infiltration → Open soil; Difference → 25 units; Controlled input → Equal rain

The data compare infiltration under equal rain.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A model water store

Fixed case information

A model lake starts with 50 water units, receives 10 through a stream and loses 6 by evaporation. These are the only stated flows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Final lake amount: 54 units
  • b: Input path: Stream inflow
  • c: Final lake amount: 66 units
  • d: Input path: An unnamed new source
Answer: Final lake amount: 54 units; Input path: Stream inflow

50 + 10 − 6 = 54; evaporated water enters the air.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F5 · Explain outside droplets

Fixed case information

A dry cold cup is placed in warm humid air. Droplets appear outside, while the cup remains sealed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Name the process and explain where the droplet water came from.

Example of a full-credit answer: The process is condensation. The water came from vapour in the surrounding air.

  1. The process is condensation.
  2. The water came from vapour in the surrounding air.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: heat lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy catchment receives 100 units. Infiltration is 35 and evaporation is 15. The rest is runoff; no other store changes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies runoff in this case?

  • a: 50 units
  • b: 150 units
  • c: 35 units
  • d: 15 units
Answer: 50 units

100 − 35 − 15 = 50 runoff units.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the runoff and show why the total still balances.

Example of a full-credit answer: Runoff is 50 units. Shows that 35 + 15 + 50 equals 100.

  1. Runoff is 50 units.
  2. Shows that 35 + 15 + 50 equals 100.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A team asks whether cover changes runoff. Trial A uses equal trays, slopes and rain but different covers. Trial B changes rain and slope as well as cover.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Clearer test; Deliberate change; Main weakness of B

  • a: Trial A
  • b: Surface cover
  • c: Several variables change
  • d: Trial B
Answer: Clearer test → Trial A; Deliberate change → Surface cover; Main weakness of B → Several variables change

Trial A makes a difference easier to connect to cover.

2B · Open ended

Choose the clearer trial and justify it using one controlled condition.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Trial A. Identifies equal tray size, slope or rain as reducing another possible cause.

  1. Chooses Trial A.
  2. Identifies equal tray size, slope or rain as reducing another possible cause.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

In a mountain model, snow melts into a stream. Later liquid from the stream evaporates.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? First state change: Melting.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The same water can follow more than one change of state.

3B · Short answer

Describe the two state changes in order, including the states involved.

Example of a full-credit answer: Snow changes from solid to liquid by melting. Liquid water changes to gas by evaporation.

  1. Snow changes from solid to liquid by melting.
  2. Liquid water changes to gas by evaporation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “The puddle vanished because water was destroyed.” No liquid leaked away; the class observed slow evaporation.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Mistake: Calling the water destroyed
  • b: Actual change: Liquid to gas
  • c: Mistake: The puddle became smaller
  • d: Actual change: Gas to solid
Answer: Mistake: Calling the water destroyed; Actual change: Liquid to gas

Evaporation changes water’s state and location.

4B · Open ended

Explain the error and give the scientific replacement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Water was not destroyed. It evaporated into water vapour in the air.

  1. Water was not destroyed.
  2. It evaporated into water vapour in the air.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A toy surface receives 100 units of rain. Evaporation remains 10%. Choose an infiltration percentage so runoff is no more than 30 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Minimum infiltration; Fixed evaporation; Maximum runoff

  • a: 60%
  • b: 10%
  • c: 30 units
  • d: 20%
Answer: Minimum infiltration → 60%; Fixed evaporation → 10%; Maximum runoff → 30 units

At least 60 units must infiltrate because 100 − 10 − 30 = 60.

5B · Open ended

Propose an infiltration percentage and show it keeps runoff within the limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Choose 65% infiltration: runoff is 100 − 65 − 10 = 25 units.

  1. Chooses 60% to 90% infiltration, compatible with 10% evaporation.
  2. Calculates runoff of no more than 30 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.6 · Carbon cycle

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A net plant gain

Worked-example information

A toy plant store starts at 10 carbon units. Photosynthesis adds 6 and respiration removes 2.

Question: What is its final store?

Answer: 14 carbon units.

Why: 10 + 6 − 2 = 14; both processes operate.

Example 2 · Two connected stores
Carbon stores
StoreBeforeAfter
Air5046
Plants2024

Worked-example information

Model air has 50 carbon units and plants have 20. Four units move from air to plants.

Question: What are the new amounts?

Answer: Air 46; plants 24.

Why: The total stays 70 because this transfer remains inside the model boundary.

Example 3 · Energy is different

Worked-example information

A diagram uses one arrow for sunlight entering a leaf and another for carbon dioxide entering it.

Question: Do both arrows carry carbon atoms?

Answer: No. The carbon dioxide arrow carries carbon; sunlight transfers energy.

Why: Clear labels prevent a matter-and-energy mix-up.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Stores and transfers

Fixed case information

A model has air, plants and soil. Photosynthesis moves carbon from air into plants. Respiration moves carbon from plants to air.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies photosynthesis destination in this case?

  • a: Plants
  • b: Air only
  • c: Sunlight only
  • d: An empty number line
Answer: Plants

The arrows identify carbon transfers between stores.

Scientific explorer: carbon lab

F2 · A one-step plant budget

Fixed case information

A plant store begins at 12 carbon units, takes in 5 and releases 3.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Final plant store: 20 units.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

12 + 5 − 3 = 14.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Name the carbon arrow

Fixed case information

Three labelled processes are supplied: photosynthesis puts carbon into plant sugars; respiration returns carbon dioxide; decomposition changes dead matter and transfers carbon.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Air to plant sugars; Food to carbon dioxide; Breakdown of remains

  • a: Photosynthesis
  • b: Respiration
  • c: Decomposition
  • d: Refraction
Answer: Air to plant sugars → Photosynthesis; Food to carbon dioxide → Respiration; Breakdown of remains → Decomposition

Each process describes a different part of carbon movement.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · A balanced carbon model

Fixed case information

A closed toy model has 40 units in air, 35 in plants and 25 in soil. There are no boundary transfers.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Total model carbon; Number of named stores; Effect of internal transfer

  • a: 100 units
  • b: Three
  • c: Total stays unchanged
  • d: 75 units
Answer: Total model carbon → 100 units; Number of named stores → Three; Effect of internal transfer → Total stays unchanged

Internal transfers can redistribute the fixed total.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F5 · Plants at night

Fixed case information

In a dark setting at night with no light source, a plant continues cellular respiration. Photosynthesis requires light.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why a plant can release carbon dioxide at night and why photosynthesis is limited.

Example of a full-credit answer: Cellular respiration can continue and release carbon dioxide. Photosynthesis is limited because light is absent.

  1. Cellular respiration can continue and release carbon dioxide.
  2. Photosynthesis is limited because light is absent.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy system starts with air 60 and plants 20 carbon units. Photosynthesis transfers 8 from air to plants, and respiration returns 3. Soil stays at 20.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies final plant carbon in this case?

  • a: 25 units
  • b: 31 units
  • c: 65 units
  • d: 105 units
Answer: 25 units

The net transfer is five units from air to plants; total carbon stays 100.

1B · Open ended

Find the final plant amount and explain why total model carbon does not change.

Example of a full-credit answer: Plants end with 25 units. The processes transfer carbon within the model, so air, plants and soil still total 100.

  1. Plants end with 25 units.
  2. The processes transfer carbon within the model, so air, plants and soil still total 100.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Diagram A separates carbon arrows from sunlight-energy arrows. Diagram B labels sunlight “carbon arriving from the Sun.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: More accurate diagram: Diagram A
  • b: Material carrying carbon: Carbon dioxide
  • c: More accurate diagram: Diagram B
  • d: Material carrying carbon: Only a shadow
Answer: More accurate diagram: Diagram A; Material carrying carbon: Carbon dioxide

Sunlight supplies energy while carbon dioxide supplies carbon for photosynthesis.

2B · Short answer

Choose the better diagram and explain the difference between its two kinds of arrow.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Diagram A. Distinguishes carbon atoms carried in substances from energy carried by sunlight.

  1. Chooses Diagram A.
  2. Distinguishes carbon atoms carried in substances from energy carried by sunlight.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A sealed teaching model begins with 18 carbon units in dead leaves and 2 in air. Decomposition transfers 6 leaf units to air; ignore other stores in this model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Leaf carbon remaining; Air carbon after transfer; Total carbon

  • a: 12 units
  • b: 8 units
  • c: 20 units
  • d: 24 units
Answer: Leaf carbon remaining → 12 units; Air carbon after transfer → 8 units; Total carbon → 20 units

The transfer changes the stores but not their total.

3B · Open ended

Calculate both final stores and explain whether carbon was destroyed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Leaves have 12 units and air has 8 units. No carbon was destroyed; the total remains 20.

  1. Leaves have 12 units and air has 8 units.
  2. No carbon was destroyed; the total remains 20.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “Plants only take carbon dioxide in; they never return any.” The source describes both photosynthesis and respiration.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Incorrect word; Carbon-taking process; Carbon-returning process

  • a: Never
  • b: Photosynthesis
  • c: Respiration
  • d: Both processes
Answer: Incorrect word → Never; Carbon-taking process → Photosynthesis; Carbon-returning process → Respiration

Plants can take in carbon through photosynthesis and return some through respiration.

4B · Short answer

Explain the mistake and name a process returning carbon dioxide.

Example of a full-credit answer: The claim ignores that plants also release carbon dioxide. Names cellular respiration as a carbon-returning process.

  1. The claim ignores that plants also release carbon dioxide.
  2. Names cellular respiration as a carbon-returning process.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class needs a closed carbon model with three stores: air, plants and soil. The total must be 100 units. Show one transfer of 5 units without creating or losing carbon.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies required total in this case?

  • a: 100 units
  • b: 105 units
  • c: 95 units
  • d: Only add at the destination
Answer: 100 units

A valid transfer reduces its source and increases its destination equally.

5B · Open ended

Propose starting stores that total 100 and show the stores after one 5-unit transfer.

Example of a full-credit answer: Start with air 50, plants 30 and soil 20. Move 5 from air to plants: 45, 35 and 20.

  1. Starting air, plant and soil stores are nonnegative and total 100, with enough carbon at the source.
  2. Transfers 5 by subtracting from one store and adding to another, keeping the total 100.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.7 · Biogeochemical cycles

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · One arrow, two store changes

Worked-example information

A model moves 3 nutrient units from soil into plants.

Question: How do the two stores change?

Answer: Soil loses 3; plants gain 3.

Why: The tracked matter is transferred, not created.

Example 2 · Inside and outside a boundary
Garden nutrient budget
PartUnits
Start20
Input4
Runoff output2
Final22

Worked-example information

A garden model holds 20 nutrient units. Fertilizer adds 4 from outside, and runoff removes 2.

Question: What total remains inside?

Answer: 22 units.

Why: 20 + 4 − 2 = 22. These are boundary transfers.

Example 3 · A root needs the right form

Worked-example information

A source says plant roots absorb dissolved nitrate; air contains nitrogen gas.

Question: Are these identical chemical forms?

Answer: No.

Why: Both contain nitrogen, but organisms interact with different nitrogen-containing substances.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the tracked material

Fixed case information

Three diagrams track water molecules, carbon atoms and nitrogen atoms. Each has labelled stores and arrows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies water-cycle material in this case?

  • a: Water
  • b: Sunlight
  • c: Sound energy
  • d: A time interval
Answer: Water

Cycles must identify what material is being tracked.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Nutrients crossing a boundary

Fixed case information

A model plot starts with 15 nutrient units, receives 5 and loses 3 by runoff.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Final plot amount; External input; Runoff output

  • a: 17 units
  • b: 5 units
  • c: 3 units
  • d: 23 units
Answer: Final plot amount → 17 units; External input → 5 units; Runoff output → 3 units

15 + 5 − 3 = 17.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Root uptake route

Fixed case information

A diagram shows nitrogen gas in air, a microbial transformation step, dissolved nitrogen compounds in soil water and root uptake.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Plant uptake material: Pure sunlight.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The simplified route includes a change into usable compounds before root uptake.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F4 · Matter and energy labels

Fixed case information

A learning board shows sunlight entering a plant, water entering roots and carbon dioxide entering leaves.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Energy input; Water input; Carbon input

  • a: Sunlight
  • b: Root water uptake
  • c: Carbon dioxide
  • d: A pencil mark
Answer: Energy input → Sunlight; Water input → Root water uptake; Carbon input → Carbon dioxide

Sunlight is an energy transfer; the other arrows carry substances.

Scientific explorer: photosynthesis lab

F5 · Explain a nutrient transfer

Fixed case information

In a closed toy system, soil has 18 nitrogen units and plants have 7. Plants take up 4 from soil.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State both final stores and explain why the total remains unchanged.

Example of a full-credit answer: Soil becomes 14 units and plants 11 units. An internal transfer conserves the total of 25 units.

  1. Soil becomes 14 units and plants 11 units.
  2. An internal transfer conserves the total of 25 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A model starts with soil 30, plants 20 and dead matter 10 nutrient units. Five move soil→plants and three move plants→dead matter.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Final plant amount: 22 units
  • b: Final soil amount: 25 units
  • c: Final plant amount: 28 units
  • d: Final soil amount: 35 units
Answer: Final plant amount: 22 units; Final soil amount: 25 units

Plants gain five and lose three; all stores still total 60.

1B · Short answer

Find the plant store and demonstrate that total matter is conserved.

Example of a full-credit answer: The plant store becomes 22 units. Final stores 25, 22 and 13 sum to the original 60.

  1. The plant store becomes 22 units.
  2. Final stores 25, 22 and 13 sum to the original 60.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Two equal plots receive the same rain. One has a buffer strip. Recorded nutrient runoff is 2 units with the strip and 7 without it; repeat tests are still needed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Lower observed runoff; Observed difference; Appropriate caution

  • a: Plot with the strip
  • b: 5 units
  • c: Repeat comparable tests
  • d: Plot without the strip
Answer: Lower observed runoff → Plot with the strip; Observed difference → 5 units; Appropriate caution → Repeat comparable tests

The strip is associated with lower runoff in this controlled model case.

2B · Open ended

Choose the promising plan and justify it while stating a limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses a buffer strip using the 2-versus-7 runoff comparison. Notes that repeated comparable tests or wider conditions are still needed.

  1. Chooses a buffer strip using the 2-versus-7 runoff comparison.
  2. Notes that repeated comparable tests or wider conditions are still needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual aquarium contains 40 nutrient units. Food adds 6 from outside; removed waste carries out 4. Internal transfers among organisms are not boundary flows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? New total inside: 42 units.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

40 + 6 − 4 = 42; internal transfers do not add new total nutrient matter.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the new total and explain why a fish eating inside the aquarium is not another external input.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total becomes 42 nutrient units. Eating transfers existing material within the boundary rather than adding new material from outside.

  1. The total becomes 42 nutrient units.
  2. Eating transfers existing material within the boundary rather than adding new material from outside.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A poster says, “The Sun supplies new nitrogen atoms as light, and energy returns unchanged forever.” The source distinguishes matter from energy.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: First error; Correct sunlight role; Second error

  • a: Light is labelled nitrogen matter
  • b: Energy input
  • c: Energy returns unchanged forever
  • d: Time spent observing
Answer: First error → Light is labelled nitrogen matter; Correct sunlight role → Energy input; Second error → Energy returns unchanged forever

Light transfers energy; nutrient matter follows chemical routes, and energy spreads to surroundings.

4B · Open ended

Correct both errors in the poster.

Example of a full-credit answer: Sunlight supplies energy, not nitrogen atoms to plants. Energy is transferred and dissipated to surroundings, not recycled unchanged forever.

  1. Sunlight supplies energy, not nitrogen atoms to plants.
  2. Energy is transferred and dissipated to surroundings, not recycled unchanged forever.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Make a closed three-store model: soil, plants and dead matter, totalling 50 units. Show a 5-unit transfer from a store that has enough material.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies starting total in this case?

  • a: 50 units
  • b: 55 units
  • c: 50 units created
  • d: Only increase the destination
Answer: 50 units

A valid model names a material and accounts for both ends of a transfer.

5B · Open ended

Propose three starting amounts and show the new amounts after your transfer.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use soil 25, plants 15, dead matter 10. Transfer 5 soil→plants to get 20, 20, 10.

  1. Starting amounts are nonnegative, total 50 and provide at least 5 at the source.
  2. Moves exactly 5 between named stores and keeps the final total 50.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.8 · Weather

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Match an instrument

Worked-example information

A station records air temperature and rainfall.

Question: Which tool measures each?

Answer: A thermometer measures temperature; a rain gauge measures rainfall.

Why: The tools measure different quantities and use different units.

Example 2 · Read three days
Daily rainfall
Daymm
Mon4
Tue9
Wed2

Worked-example information

Fictional rainfall is Monday 4 mm, Tuesday 9 mm and Wednesday 2 mm.

Question: Which day was wettest and what was the total?

Answer: Tuesday; 15 mm in total.

Why: The largest daily bar is 9, and 4 + 9 + 2 = 15.

Example 3 · A short record

Worked-example information

A station reports a windy afternoon.

Question: Does this mean its climate is always windy?

Answer: No.

Why: A single afternoon describes weather; climate requires long-term patterns.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Weather measurements

Fixed case information

A record lists 28°C, 6 mm of rain and an eastward wind direction at one station.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies temperature reading in this case?

  • a: 28°C
  • b: 6 mm
  • c: 28 kilograms
  • d: Earth’s age
Answer: 28°C

Each value must be matched to its physical quantity.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Temperature through a day

Fixed case information

Fictional shaded temperatures are 24°C at 6 a.m., 29°C at noon and 27°C at 6 p.m.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Warmest observation; Lowest observation; Noon-to-evening change

  • a: Noon
  • b: 6 a.m.
  • c: Decrease by 2°C
  • d: All equal
Answer: Warmest observation → Noon; Lowest observation → 6 a.m.; Noon-to-evening change → Decrease by 2°C

The highest supplied value is 29°C and the final step decreases by two.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Rainfall collection period

Fixed case information

Gauge A collects for 24 hours and records 10 mm. Gauge B collects for 48 hours and records 14 mm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies why totals differ in scope in this case?

  • a: Different collection periods
  • b: Identical collection periods
  • c: 10 years
  • d: 14 minutes
Answer: Different collection periods

Raw totals cover different durations; the time window must be considered.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · A forecast claim

Fixed case information

A fictional forecast states that rain is possible tomorrow but not certain. A class has indoor and outdoor activity plans.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Meaning of possible: Rain may or may not occur
  • b: A robust option: Keep an indoor alternative
  • c: Meaning of possible: Rain is guaranteed
  • d: A robust option: Ignore every forecast
Answer: Meaning of possible: Rain may or may not occur; A robust option: Keep an indoor alternative

A forecast can guide preparation without promising one exact outcome.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a biased sensor

Fixed case information

A checked reference reads 25°C. A classroom sensor reads 27°C on each of three repeats under the same conditions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Describe the difference and explain why repeating alone has not removed it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The classroom sensor reads 2°C above the reference. The same bias persists across repeats; repetition alone does not correct calibration.

  1. The classroom sensor reads 2°C above the reference.
  2. The same bias persists across repeats; repetition alone does not correct calibration.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional station records 3, 0, 7 and 2 mm on four consecutive days, using equal 24-hour periods.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Total rainfall; Wettest daily amount; Dry-day amount

  • a: 12 mm
  • b: 7 mm
  • c: 0 mm
  • d: 10 mm
Answer: Total rainfall → 12 mm; Wettest daily amount → 7 mm; Dry-day amount → 0 mm

3 + 0 + 7 + 2 = 12 mm.

1B · Open ended

Calculate total rainfall and explain why the zero must stay in the record.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total is 12 mm. Zero represents a measured dry period and preserves the complete four-day record.

  1. The total is 12 mm.
  2. Zero represents a measured dry period and preserves the complete four-day record.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A records in the same shaded ventilated location at noon. Plan B alternates a sunlit wall and an air-conditioned room at random times.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: More comparable outdoor record; Controlled feature; Weakness of Plan B

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Location and time
  • c: Changing exposure and setting
  • d: Plan B
Answer: More comparable outdoor record → Plan A; Controlled feature → Location and time; Weakness of Plan B → Changing exposure and setting

Plan A better compares like with like.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify it with the measurement conditions.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Explains that consistent outdoor exposure, location or time reduces confounding.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Explains that consistent outdoor exposure, location or time reduces confounding.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A school compares wind flags for five minutes at two open sites at the same time. One flag points west, showing wind moving toward the west.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies movement shown in this case?

  • a: Toward the west
  • b: Toward the east
  • c: Five years
  • d: Only flag colour
Answer: Toward the west

The question specifies movement direction; it does not use the meteorological from-direction naming convention.

3B · Open ended

State the movement direction and one condition making the two observations comparable.

Example of a full-credit answer: The wind movement is toward the west as stated. Both are observed for five minutes at the same time, or both are in open sites.

  1. The wind movement is toward the west as stated.
  2. Both are observed for five minutes at the same time, or both are in open sites.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

After two cooler mornings, a learner announces, “The whole planet’s climate is cooling.” Only one school’s morning temperatures were measured.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies overreach in this case?

  • a: A global climate claim
  • b: A local observation
  • c: All countries over decades
  • d: One extra thermometer colour
Answer: A global climate claim

The evidence is far narrower than the global long-term claim.

4B · Short answer

Identify the mismatch and describe more appropriate evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Two local mornings cannot establish a global climate trend. Comparable long-term records from many locations are needed.

  1. Two local mornings cannot establish a global climate trend.
  2. Comparable long-term records from many locations are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class can record one weather quantity for seven days. It has a checked thermometer, clock and shaded observation site. Design a comparable record.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · True or false

True or false? Suitable quantity: Rock age.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A defined quantity, unit and consistent method make the log useful.

5B · Open ended

Specify the daily measurement and one condition to keep consistent.

Example of a full-credit answer: Records air temperature in °C each day with dates/times. Keeps the same shaded location, instrument or time of day.

  1. Records air temperature in °C each day with dates/times.
  2. Keeps the same shaded location, instrument or time of day.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.9 · Climate

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Weather or climate?

Worked-example information

A card says “Rain at 3 p.m. today.” Another says “Typical rainy months over many years.”

Question: Which is about climate?

Answer: The long-term pattern of rainy months.

Why: The first card describes a specific event.

Example 2 · Two comparable periods
Period means
PeriodMean °C
Earlier25.2
Later25.8

Worked-example information

Fictional 30-year mean temperatures are 25.2°C and 25.8°C, measured comparably.

Question: How much did the mean increase?

Answer: 0.6°C.

Why: 25.8 − 25.2 = 0.6. This describes the supplied location and periods.

Example 3 · A changing sequence

Worked-example information

Fictional yearly values are 10, 12, 11, 14 and 13 index units.

Question: Did the value increase every year?

Answer: No.

Why: The record contains decreases as well as increases; a broad pattern is different from a step-by-step guarantee.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify the time scale

Fixed case information

One record gives today’s noon temperature. Another summarizes rainfall across 30 years at the same station.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Climate record; Weather observation; Necessary context

  • a: Thirty-year rainfall summary
  • b: Today’s noon temperature
  • c: Place and time period
  • d: Only a classroom colour
Answer: Climate record → Thirty-year rainfall summary; Weather observation → Today’s noon temperature; Necessary context → Place and time period

Climate uses long-term patterns; individual conditions are weather.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Comparable period means

Fixed case information

Fictional mean annual temperatures for comparable periods are 24.5°C and 25.0°C.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies mean increase in this case?

  • a: 0.5°C
  • b: 49.5°C
  • c: 2°C
  • d: 5°C
Answer: 0.5°C

Subtract the earlier comparable mean from the later mean.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Average and extremes

Fixed case information

Two fictional seasons both average 10 rain units per day. Season A has daily values 9,10,11; B has 0,10,20.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? More variable season: Season A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The same mean can hide different variability.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F4 · A useful climate comparison

Fixed case information

Plan A compares the same season and statistic across equal-length periods. Plan B compares one summer maximum with one winter mean.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies more comparable plan in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Everything is identical
  • d: Only font size
Answer: Plan A

Comparable definitions are needed before interpreting a difference.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Short cold spell

Fixed case information

A town has four unusually cool days in a fictional record. A poster claims that this alone disproves any long-term warming.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the poster overreaches and name the kind of record needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Four cool days are short-term weather evidence, not a long-term climate test. A comparable long-term temperature record is needed.

  1. Four cool days are short-term weather evidence, not a long-term climate test.
  2. A comparable long-term temperature record is needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional station’s comparable 30-year mean rainfall changes from 120 to 105 mm per month. The number of rainy months varies within both periods.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Change in mean: Decrease by 15 mm
  • b: What is compared: Monthly rainfall means
  • c: Change in mean: Increase by 15 mm
  • d: What is compared: Daily maximum temperatures
Answer: Change in mean: Decrease by 15 mm; What is compared: Monthly rainfall means

120 − 105 = 15, but period means do not describe every month.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the change and state one conclusion the means do not justify.

Example of a full-credit answer: The mean decreased by 15 mm per month. The means do not prove that every month or year became drier.

  1. The mean decreased by 15 mm per month.
  2. The means do not prove that every month or year became drier.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A fictional regional trend report combines checked records from many stations over decades. A second report uses one afternoon at one school.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Stronger regional evidence; Weakness of second report; Useful quality check

  • a: Many checked long-term stations
  • b: Too short and local
  • c: Comparable measurement methods
  • d: One school afternoon
Answer: Stronger regional evidence → Many checked long-term stations; Weakness of second report → Too short and local; Useful quality check → Comparable measurement methods

The wider, longer and checked record better matches a regional climate claim.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger record and justify it using time and geographic coverage.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the checked multi-station record. It covers decades and many locations, matching the regional long-term claim.

  1. Chooses the checked multi-station record.
  2. It covers decades and many locations, matching the regional long-term claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A school’s fictional long-term record shows most rain in months 6–9, but individual years vary. It plans rainwater storage.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Useful climate pattern; Needed caution; Planning use

  • a: Rain is concentrated in months 6–9
  • b: Years can differ
  • c: Store some wet-season water
  • d: Every day will rain
Answer: Useful climate pattern → Rain is concentrated in months 6–9; Needed caution → Years can differ; Planning use → Store some wet-season water

Long-term patterns guide planning without guaranteeing each year.

3B · Short answer

Propose how the pattern could guide storage and state one uncertainty.

Example of a full-credit answer: Suggests storing water during typically wetter months for later use. Notes that rainfall timing or amount may differ in an individual year.

  1. Suggests storing water during typically wetter months for later use.
  2. Notes that rainfall timing or amount may differ in an individual year.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “Greenhouse gases warm Earth by creating new energy.” The source states they absorb and emit infrared radiation while total energy is accounted for.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Error; Correct process; Useful boundary idea

  • a: Energy is created
  • b: Absorption and emission of infrared
  • c: Incoming and outgoing energy
  • d: Infrared is involved
Answer: Error → Energy is created; Correct process → Absorption and emission of infrared; Useful boundary idea → Incoming and outgoing energy

The gases change energy transfer pathways rather than creating energy.

4B · Open ended

Identify the error and give a more accurate explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rejects the claim that greenhouse gases create energy. Explains that they absorb and emit some outgoing infrared radiation, changing energy transfer.

  1. Rejects the claim that greenhouse gases create energy.
  2. Explains that they absorb and emit some outgoing infrared radiation, changing energy transfer.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Two towns provide annual mean temperature records for the same 30 years. You may compare all years or select only each town’s hottest year. Design a fair summary.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · True or false

True or false? Better dataset choice: All comparable years.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Using the complete comparable period avoids selecting just extreme values.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison and give one check needed before drawing conclusions.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use the same full 30-year period and comparable statistics for both towns. Check measurement methods, missing values or units before interpreting the comparison.

  1. Uses the same full 30-year period and comparable statistics for both towns.
  2. Names a relevant quality check, such as measurement methods, missing values or units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.10 · Plate tectonics

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read the arrows

Worked-example information

A sketch shows two plates moving away from a central line.

Question: What boundary is represented?

Answer: A divergent boundary.

Why: The arrows indicate relative separation.

Example 2 · Distance over time
Position change
Yearscm moved
00
515

Worked-example information

A fictional position model shows 15 cm of movement in five years.

Question: What average speed is represented?

Answer: 3 cm per year.

Why: 15 ÷ 5 = 3; the model must label both distance and time.

Example 3 · A coastline is not enough

Worked-example information

A map shows a coast but no plate-boundary key.

Question: Can the coastline alone locate a plate boundary?

Answer: No.

Why: Plate boundaries need geological evidence or an appropriate map layer, not only land–sea edges.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify movement

Fixed case information

Three sketches show separation, approach and sliding past.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies separation in this case?

  • a: Divergent
  • b: Convergent
  • c: Stationary atmosphere
  • d: Evaporation
Answer: Divergent

Boundary types describe relative plate movement.

Scientific explorer: plate lab

F2 · Measure model speed

Fixed case information

A fictional plate marker moves 8 cm in four years at a steady model rate.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Average speed: 32 cm/year.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Speed is distance divided by time.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · A subduction example

Fixed case information

A supplied cross-section shows oceanic lithosphere sinking beneath another plate at a convergent boundary.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Sinking plate in this case; Boundary motion; Process name

  • a: Oceanic plate
  • b: Toward one another
  • c: Subduction
  • d: A cloud layer
Answer: Sinking plate in this case → Oceanic plate; Boundary motion → Toward one another; Process name → Subduction

The named case is subduction; other convergence settings may differ.

Scientific explorer: plate lab

F4 · Find evidence of motion

Fixed case information

A team compares a plate marker’s position using the same reference system in years 1, 2 and 3. Its position changes steadily.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Observed evidence of movement; Needed common feature; Colour detail unrelated to movement

  • a: Repeated position changes
  • b: Reference system
  • c: Marker paint colour
  • d: Identical coordinates on every visit
Answer: Observed evidence of movement → Repeated position changes; Needed common feature → Reference system; Colour detail unrelated to movement → Marker paint colour

Repeated comparable positions provide evidence about motion.

Scientific explorer: coordinate lab

F5 · Explain a transform sketch

Fixed case information

Two blocks slide horizontally past one another. The model does not show one block sinking or the blocks moving apart.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Name the boundary and explain the motion clue.

Example of a full-credit answer: The boundary is transform. The two plates slide past each other rather than separating or converging.

  1. The boundary is transform.
  2. The two plates slide past each other rather than separating or converging.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: plate lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A model shows plates moving apart and new rock forming along the central ridge. Markers on opposite sides move farther apart over time.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies boundary in this case?

  • a: Divergent
  • b: Convergent
  • c: Decreasing separation
  • d: A cloud boundary
Answer: Divergent

Independent clues agree with plates separating at a ridge.

1B · Open ended

Identify the boundary and explain two clues supporting it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies divergence. Uses outward motion plus new central rock or increasing marker separation.

  1. Identifies divergence.
  2. Uses outward motion plus new central rock or increasing marker separation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Record A gives positions in one coordinate system on dated visits. Record B gives undated photos taken at unknown scales.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies better speed record in this case?

  • a: Record A
  • b: Record B
  • c: No dates needed
  • d: Too many measured positions
Answer: Record A

Calculating speed requires comparable distances and known intervals.

2B · Short answer

Choose the record and justify why it permits a speed estimate.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Record A. It provides comparable positions and dates to calculate distance over elapsed time.

  1. Chooses Record A.
  2. It provides comparable positions and dates to calculate distance over elapsed time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A new sketch shows two continental plates pushing together and thickening crust into mountains. Neither is drawn as an oceanic plate.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Boundary; Observed result; Why old subduction sketch is incomplete

  • a: Convergent
  • b: Crust thickening
  • c: Different plate materials and setting
  • d: Transform
Answer: Boundary → Convergent; Observed result → Crust thickening; Why old subduction sketch is incomplete → Different plate materials and setting

Convergence includes different settings; continental collision can thicken crust.

3B · Open ended

Identify the shared boundary motion and explain why the oceanic subduction picture need not fit exactly.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both cases involve plates moving together. This case uses continental collision and thickening rather than the specific sinking oceanic-plate example.

  1. Both cases involve plates moving together.
  2. This case uses continental collision and thickening rather than the specific sinking oceanic-plate example.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

An animation moves a plate 3 screen centimetres in one second. A learner reports that real plates always move at 3 cm per second. No real-time scale was supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Error: Treating animation time as real time
  • b: Missing information: Distance and time scales
  • c: Error: Using a diagram at all
  • d: Missing information: Only plate colour
Answer: Error: Treating animation time as real time; Missing information: Distance and time scales

An animation can speed up a slow process for visibility.

4B · Short answer

Explain the error and state what is needed to estimate real speed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Screen animation speed cannot be assumed to equal real plate speed. A distance scale and real elapsed time or actual dated measurements are needed.

  1. Screen animation speed cannot be assumed to equal real plate speed.
  2. A distance scale and real elapsed time or actual dated measurements are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Build a model that clearly distinguishes a transform boundary from a divergent one. You can use two labelled pieces and direction arrows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Transform arrows; Divergent arrows; Required label

  • a: Opposite directions parallel to the boundary
  • b: Away from the boundary
  • c: Model motion and scale limits
  • d: Toward the same point
Answer: Transform arrows → Opposite directions parallel to the boundary; Divergent arrows → Away from the boundary; Required label → Model motion and scale limits

A clear model uses arrows to distinguish sliding from separation.

5B · Open ended

Describe the pieces and arrows for both boundaries and include one limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Correctly shows sliding past for transform and moving apart for divergent. States that the model exaggerates speed, simplifies shapes or cannot predict an earthquake time.

  1. Correctly shows sliding past for transform and moving apart for divergent.
  2. States that the model exaggerates speed, simplifies shapes or cannot predict an earthquake time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.11 · Earthquakes

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two position names

Worked-example information

A diagram marks the underground starting point F and surface point E directly above it.

Question: Which is the epicentre?

Answer: E.

Why: The epicentre is the surface location above the focus.

Example 2 · Arrival-time difference
Arrival records
StationSeconds
A12
B17

Worked-example information

Fictional wave arrivals at two classroom stations are 12 s and 17 s after a shared start.

Question: What is the time difference?

Answer: 5 seconds.

Why: 17 − 12 = 5; a common time reference is essential.

Example 3 · A forecast is not a date

Worked-example information

A map describes shaking likelihood over many years.

Question: Does it predict a particular earthquake tomorrow?

Answer: No.

Why: A long-term likelihood statement and an exact short-term prediction answer different questions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Earthquake positions

Fixed case information

A cross-section labels the underground rupture-start point and the surface point directly above it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Underground start; Surface point above; Rock fracture with movement

  • a: Focus
  • b: Epicentre
  • c: Fault
  • d: Cloud centre
Answer: Underground start → Focus; Surface point above → Epicentre; Rock fracture with movement → Fault

The position labels must not be swapped.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · A wave model

Fixed case information

A virtual spring carries a disturbance from left to right. Coils move locally; they do not all travel to the far end.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies what travels along the spring in this case?

  • a: Disturbance
  • b: Every coil to the far end
  • c: Vanish completely
  • d: An exact earthquake forecast
Answer: Disturbance

The model distinguishes local motion from the travelling disturbance.

Scientific explorer: wave lab

F3 · Compare arrival times

Fixed case information

Two fictional station records use one start clock. A records a wave at 8 s and B at 13 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Earlier arrival; Difference; Required common reference

  • a: Station A
  • b: 5 s
  • c: Start clock
  • d: Station B
Answer: Earlier arrival → Station A; Difference → 5 s; Required common reference → Start clock

A arrives first; 13 − 8 = 5.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Read a hazard legend

Fixed case information

A fictional map legend says dark shading means higher modelled shaking likelihood over 50 years. It gives no exact event date.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Meaning of dark shading: Higher modelled likelihood.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The legend defines a probability context, not a timetable.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a prediction claim

Fixed case information

An online card says a particular cloud proves an earthquake will happen tomorrow. It gives no tested method, location accuracy or event size.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the claim is unreliable and identify a better information source.

Example of a full-credit answer: A cloud photo without a validated method does not establish an exact earthquake prediction. Uses an authoritative geological or local hazard agency rather than the unsupported post.

  1. A cloud photo without a validated method does not establish an exact earthquake prediction.
  2. Uses an authoritative geological or local hazard agency rather than the unsupported post.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

In a fictional common-clock record, Station A detects a wave after 6 s and Station B after 10 s. The source and path model are otherwise specified as comparable.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies arrival difference in this case?

  • a: 4 s
  • b: 16 s
  • c: Both first
  • d: Neither detected a wave
Answer: 4 s

The recorded difference is 10 − 6 = 4 seconds.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the arrival difference and explain why both clocks need a shared reference.

Example of a full-credit answer: The difference is 4 seconds. A common clock prevents clock offsets from being mistaken for travel-time differences.

  1. The difference is 4 seconds.
  2. A common clock prevents clock offsets from being mistaken for travel-time differences.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A school can use its official hazard information and approved drill plan, or an anonymous post claiming an exact event tomorrow from a cloud photo.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Stronger planning basis; Weak source; Reason

  • a: Official hazard information and drill plan
  • b: Anonymous cloud prediction
  • c: Established methods and accountable guidance
  • d: No preparation is ever useful
Answer: Stronger planning basis → Official hazard information and drill plan; Weak source → Anonymous cloud prediction; Reason → Established methods and accountable guidance

Preparedness can use credible hazard evidence without an exact date.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger basis and explain why it is useful despite timing uncertainty.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the official hazard information and approved plan. It guides preparedness based on credible evidence even without an exact earthquake date.

  1. Chooses the official hazard information and approved plan.
  2. It guides preparedness based on credible evidence even without an exact earthquake date.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A new virtual model uses a row of linked blocks to show a disturbance passing along. Each block moves briefly near its starting position.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Transferable idea; Block behaviour; Limit

  • a: A disturbance travels
  • b: Local movement
  • c: Blocks are not real layered Earth
  • d: All blocks cross the room
Answer: Transferable idea → A disturbance travels; Block behaviour → Local movement; Limit → Blocks are not real layered Earth

A different model can illustrate the same wave concept while having limits.

3B · Short answer

Explain the wave idea represented and one limitation of the model.

Example of a full-credit answer: The disturbance/energy travels while blocks move locally. The blocks simplify Earth’s materials, geometry, scale or wave behaviour.

  1. The disturbance/energy travels while blocks move locally.
  2. The blocks simplify Earth’s materials, geometry, scale or wave behaviour.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner labels a rupture-start point 12 km underground “epicentre” and the surface point directly above it “focus.” The diagram supplies both positions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Correct label for the underground rupture start; Correct label for the surface point directly above; Evidence

  • a: Focus
  • b: Epicentre
  • c: Underground versus surface positions
  • d: A river source
Answer: Correct label for the underground rupture start → Focus; Correct label for the surface point directly above → Epicentre; Evidence → Underground versus surface positions

The underground start is the focus; the surface point above is the epicentre.

4B · Open ended

Correct both labels and explain the position difference.

Example of a full-credit answer: Labels the underground starting point as focus. Labels the surface point directly above as epicentre.

  1. Labels the underground starting point as focus.
  2. Labels the surface point directly above as epicentre.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Two virtual model buildings have the same height and materials. You may change base width. Both receive the same programmed shaking. Design a comparison of stability.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Variable to change: Base width
  • b: Condition to keep: Shaking and other building features
  • c: Variable to change: Everything at once
  • d: Condition to keep: Different shaking each time
Answer: Variable to change: Base width; Condition to keep: Shaking and other building features

A controlled virtual comparison can investigate one design feature without forecasting real building safety.

5B · Open ended

Describe the comparison and state what result you will measure, including a limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compares different base widths while keeping the shaking and other features the same. Records tilt/falling and notes that model performance does not certify real buildings.

  1. Compares different base widths while keeping the shaking and other features the same.
  2. Records tilt/falling and notes that model performance does not certify real buildings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.12 · Volcanoes

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two names for location

Worked-example information

A model shows molten material below ground and the same material flowing at the surface.

Question: Which is magma and which is lava?

Answer: Below ground: magma. At the surface: lava.

Why: The names distinguish location.

Example 2 · Several monitoring records
Gas index
VisitIndex
First3
Second6

Worked-example information

Fictional gas readings rise from 3 to 6 index units while ground movement is also recorded.

Question: What is the change in the gas index?

Answer: An increase of 3 units.

Why: The arithmetic describes the record; it does not by itself predict an eruption.

Example 3 · After the eruption

Worked-example information

Rain washes loose volcanic sediment into a channel weeks after a fictional eruption.

Question: Why can a hazard remain?

Answer: Deposits can still be mobilised by rain.

Why: The end of eruptive activity does not instantly remove all loose material.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Locate the molten material

Fixed case information

A labelled cross-section shows molten material in a chamber and molten material on the surface.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies below-surface molten material in this case?

  • a: Magma
  • b: Lava
  • c: Only water vapour
  • d: Burned paper ash
Answer: Magma

Magma/lava names depend on location; volcanic ash is fragmented material.

Scientific explorer: body lab

F2 · Read an index record

Fixed case information

A fictional monitoring index reads 2, 4 and 5 units on three dated visits using the same method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Overall change; Largest reading; Unsupported claim about eruption timing

  • a: Increase by 3 units
  • b: 5 units
  • c: Exact eruption tomorrow
  • d: Decrease by 3 units
Answer: Overall change → Increase by 3 units; Largest reading → 5 units; Unsupported claim about eruption timing → Exact eruption tomorrow

The index increased; exact eruption timing does not follow from these numbers alone.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · A rain-mobilised deposit

Fixed case information

Loose volcanic sediment lies on a slope. In a virtual model, heavier rain moves more material into a channel when other settings stay fixed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Transporting agent; Material moved; Relevant route

  • a: Rainwater runoff
  • b: Loose volcanic sediment
  • c: Downslope channel
  • d: Only starlight
Answer: Transporting agent → Rainwater runoff; Material moved → Loose volcanic sediment; Relevant route → Downslope channel

Rain can transport loose material; this toy model is not a real hazard forecast.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

F4 · Evidence from several tools

Fixed case information

A fictional monitoring team compares gas readings, ground movement and seismic records, noting instrument checks and dates.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies stronger evidence practice in this case?

  • a: Combine checked records
  • b: One undated photo
  • c: Only a logo colour
  • d: Choose only the most dramatic reading
Answer: Combine checked records

Multiple checked observations provide a fuller picture than a single image.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Ash is not paper dust

Fixed case information

A source describes volcanic ash as tiny fragments of rock, minerals and volcanic glass. A learner says it is simply soft burned-paper ash.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Correct the comparison and identify the source information that matters.

Example of a full-credit answer: Volcanic ash is not simply burned-paper ash. It includes tiny rock, mineral or volcanic-glass fragments.

  1. Volcanic ash is not simply burned-paper ash.
  2. It includes tiny rock, mineral or volcanic-glass fragments.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: material lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual volcano record shows molten material moving below ground, then reaching the surface. No specific eruption style is supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Before reaching surface: Magma
  • b: After reaching surface: Lava
  • c: Before reaching surface: Lava at all depths
  • d: After reaching surface: Only cloud droplets
Answer: Before reaching surface: Magma; After reaching surface: Lava

The location distinguishes the terms, while eruption style requires more information.

1B · Open ended

Name the material before and after it reaches the surface and explain the naming rule.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses magma below surface and lava at surface. Explains that the change in term refers to location, not creation of a new element.

  1. Uses magma below surface and lava at surface.
  2. Explains that the change in term refers to location, not creation of a new element.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Report A gives dated gas, ground and seismic records with uncertainty. Report B predicts an exact eruption from one dramatic image and gives no method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: More credible report; Useful feature; Weakness of B

  • a: Report A
  • b: Dated multiple measurements
  • c: No tested method or broader evidence
  • d: Report B
Answer: More credible report → Report A; Useful feature → Dated multiple measurements; Weakness of B → No tested method or broader evidence

The record-based report is more transparent about evidence and limits.

2B · Short answer

Choose the better report and justify it using evidence and uncertainty.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Report A because it provides multiple dated measurements. Recognises that reporting uncertainty is appropriate rather than promising an exact time.

  1. Chooses Report A because it provides multiple dated measurements.
  2. Recognises that reporting uncertainty is appropriate rather than promising an exact time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional river receives loose volcanic deposits. Rainfall rises while the deposits remain available. A model shows more sediment moving downstream.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Continuing hazard pathway: Only fresh lava forever.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Deposits can move after an eruption; real hazard decisions require local evidence.

3B · Open ended

Explain why a hazard can continue and state one limit of the classroom model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rain can mobilise remaining loose volcanic deposits into channels. The toy model cannot predict actual local flow timing, size or safety.

  1. Rain can mobilise remaining loose volcanic deposits into channels.
  2. The toy model cannot predict actual local flow timing, size or safety.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “The gas index doubled, so an eruption is guaranteed at noon.” The source reports only two index readings, 3 and 6, and no validated timing rule.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which part of the learner’s quoted conclusion goes beyond the two gas-index readings?

  • a: Guaranteed noon eruption
  • b: Index doubled
  • c: Index stayed equal
  • d: A louder alarm sound
Answer: Guaranteed noon eruption

A numerical change is real in the record, but the exact-time claim is not established.

4B · Short answer

Separate the supported observation from the unsupported conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: The index doubled from 3 to 6. Those readings alone do not guarantee an eruption at noon.

  1. The index doubled from 3 to 6.
  2. Those readings alone do not guarantee an eruption at noon.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class studies rainfall effects on loose sediment in virtual trays. It can choose rainfall, slope and sediment amount. Design a fair comparison with a measurable outcome.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Variable to change; Conditions to keep; Response to measure

  • a: Rainfall amount
  • b: Slope and starting sediment
  • c: Sediment transported
  • d: All settings together
Answer: Variable to change → Rainfall amount; Conditions to keep → Slope and starting sediment; Response to measure → Sediment transported

Changing rainfall alone makes the toy comparison easier to interpret.

5B · Open ended

Propose the controlled comparison and the outcome you would record. State one limit on applying this toy result to a real volcanic hazard.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compares different rainfall settings while holding slope and starting sediment comparable. Records transported sediment or its clearly labelled model index without calling it a real forecast.

  1. Compares different rainfall settings while holding slope and starting sediment comparable.
  2. Records transported sediment or its clearly labelled model index without calling it a real forecast.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.13 · Erosion

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Breaking or travelling?

Worked-example information

A stone cracks on a hillside; later rain carries fragments downhill.

Question: Which stage is erosion?

Answer: The transport downhill.

Why: Cracking in place is weathering; carrying fragments is erosion.

Example 2 · Compare sediment loss
Sediment loss
Trayg
Bare18
Covered6

Worked-example information

Equal virtual trays lose 18 g without cover and 6 g with cover under the same rain.

Question: What is the measured reduction?

Answer: 12 g.

Why: 18 − 6 = 12; this is evidence for the stated test.

Example 3 · An index is not kilograms

Worked-example information

A toy erosion display changes from index 20 to index 10.

Question: Can we call that 10 kg saved?

Answer: No.

Why: An index needs a validated conversion before it can represent kilograms.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify the process

Fixed case information

A sequence shows rock cracking, fragments carried by water and fragments settling.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Transport stage: Erosion
  • b: Breaking in place: Weathering
  • c: Transport stage: Weathering
  • d: Breaking in place: Photosynthesis
Answer: Transport stage: Erosion; Breaking in place: Weathering

Transport is the defining action for erosion.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read cover data

Fixed case information

Fictional equal-condition trays lose 16, 10 and 4 g at 0%, 50% and 100% cover.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Lowest loss; Highest loss; Observed pattern

  • a: 100% cover
  • b: 0% cover
  • c: Loss decreases as cover increases
  • d: All losses equal
Answer: Lowest loss → 100% cover; Highest loss → 0% cover; Observed pattern → Loss decreases as cover increases

The pattern is supported by this supplied dataset.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Change one factor

Fixed case information

A virtual test of slope uses the same soil, cover and rainfall but slopes of 2, 4 and 6 model units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies changed factor in this case?

  • a: Slope
  • b: Rainfall alone
  • c: Everything changes
  • d: Colour of the labels
Answer: Slope

Changing only slope makes its effect clearer in this model.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

F4 · A transport measurement

Fixed case information

A class weighs transported dry model sediment with a checked balance. Repeats are 5, 6 and 4 g.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies mean transport in this case?

  • a: 5 g
  • b: 15 g
  • c: One thousand
  • d: Degrees Celsius
Answer: 5 g

(5 + 6 + 4) ÷ 3 = 5 g.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F5 · Explain a model limit

Fixed case information

A toy erosion model uses rain, slope and cover but ignores grain size. A learner applies its exact index to two different natural soils.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Name the missing factor and explain why it limits the claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Grain size or related soil properties are missing. Different soils may erode differently, so the index is not an exact universal prediction.

  1. Grain size or related soil properties are missing.
  2. Different soils may erode differently, so the index is not an exact universal prediction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy model defines erosion index = rain × slope × uncovered fraction. Rain is 6, slope is 5 and cover is 60%.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Erosion index; Uncovered fraction; Rain times slope

  • a: 12
  • b: 0.4
  • c: 30
  • d: 18
Answer: Erosion index → 12; Uncovered fraction → 0.4; Rain times slope → 30

The uncovered fraction is 0.4, so 6 × 5 × 0.4 = 12.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the index and state why it is not a real soil-loss mass.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates 12. Recognises that the stated formula produces a toy index, not measured grams or kilograms.

  1. Calculates 12.
  2. Recognises that the stated formula produces a toy index, not measured grams or kilograms.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A uses equal rain, soil and slope with different cover. Plan B gives the covered tray less rain and a gentler slope.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Clearer test: Plan B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Plan A reduces alternative explanations for the result.

2B · Open ended

Choose a plan and identify a confounding change in the other plan.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Identifies less rain or a gentler slope in Plan B as another possible cause.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Identifies less rain or a gentler slope in Plan B as another possible cause.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual dry-sand model shows moving air carrying loose grains. No water is present.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Process; Transported material; Shared feature with stream erosion

  • a: Erosion by wind
  • b: Loose sand
  • c: Material moves
  • d: Condensation
Answer: Process → Erosion by wind; Transported material → Loose sand; Shared feature with stream erosion → Material moves

Erosion can use different transport agents; movement of material is shared.

3B · Short answer

Explain why this is still erosion and identify the changed transport agent.

Example of a full-credit answer: Sand is transported from one place to another, so it is erosion. The agent is wind/moving air rather than flowing water.

  1. Sand is transported from one place to another, so it is erosion.
  2. The agent is wind/moving air rather than flowing water.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A class increases rain and steepens slope together. Sediment loss rises. It claims rain alone caused the whole increase.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Flaw; Other possible cause; Better next test

  • a: Two factors changed
  • b: Steeper slope
  • c: Change rain with slope fixed
  • d: Only rain changed
Answer: Flaw → Two factors changed; Other possible cause → Steeper slope; Better next test → Change rain with slope fixed

The comparison does not separate rainfall from slope effects.

4B · Open ended

Identify the flaw and propose a clearer follow-up.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rain and slope both changed, so rain alone is not isolated. Changes rainfall while keeping slope and other relevant conditions comparable.

  1. Rain and slope both changed, so rain alone is not isolated.
  2. Changes rainfall while keeping slope and other relevant conditions comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

In a toy model rain = 4 and slope = 5. The class wants erosion index no greater than 6. The index equals rain × slope × uncovered fraction.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Minimum required cover: 70%
  • b: Bare index: 20
  • c: Minimum required cover: 20%
  • d: Bare index: 100
Answer: Minimum required cover: 70%; Bare index: 20

At 70% cover, 4 × 5 × 0.30 = 6.

5B · Open ended

Propose a cover percentage that works and show its index.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 80% cover: 4 × 5 × 0.2 = 4.

  1. Proposes 70% to 100% cover.
  2. Correctly calculates an index of 6 or less from the stated rule.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.14 · Deposition

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A quieter channel

Worked-example information

A stream enters a wider, slower-flowing pool and some sand settles.

Question: What process does the settling represent?

Answer: Deposition.

Why: The sand is being stored at a new location after transport.

Example 2 · Balance the sediment
Sediment budget
PartUnits
In25
Out9
Deposited16

Worked-example information

A model section receives 25 units and sends 9 onward, with no other changes.

Question: How much is deposited?

Answer: 16 units.

Why: 25 − 9 = 16.

Example 3 · One grain, two actions

Worked-example information

Sand settles on Monday and is carried away by stronger flow on Tuesday.

Question: Was Monday’s deposition permanent?

Answer: No.

Why: A later event can remobilise a deposit.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the settling stage

Fixed case information

A grain is loosened from rock, carried downstream and finally settles in a pool.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Final stage; Middle stage; First process

  • a: Deposition
  • b: Transport by erosion
  • c: Weathering or loosening
  • d: Evaporation
Answer: Final stage → Deposition; Middle stage → Transport by erosion; First process → Weathering or loosening

The final action stores the transported grain.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · A simple sediment budget

Fixed case information

A model reach receives 18 sediment units and passes 7 onward. No stored material is removed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Deposited amount; Incoming amount; Outgoing amount

  • a: 11 units
  • b: 18 units
  • c: 7 units
  • d: 25 units
Answer: Deposited amount → 11 units; Incoming amount → 18 units; Outgoing amount → 7 units

18 − 7 = 11 units remain.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Model settling rules

Fixed case information

The supplied model says gravel settles when flow falls below level 4; sand settles below level 2; finer silt needs stiller water.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: First named material to settle on slowing; Sand threshold; Finest named material

  • a: Gravel
  • b: Below level 2
  • c: Silt
  • d: Above every speed
Answer: First named material to settle on slowing → Gravel; Sand threshold → Below level 2; Finest named material → Silt

The answer follows the model’s explicitly stated thresholds.

Scientific explorer: material lab

F4 · A trap changes supply

Fixed case information

A fictional sediment trap receives 30 units, stores 20 and lets 10 continue downstream.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies stored in trap in this case?

  • a: 20 units
  • b: 40 units
  • c: 30 units stored
  • d: 0 units accounted
Answer: 20 units

The trap changes where sediment goes while conserving the stated total.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F5 · Explain repeated movement

Fixed case information

A virtual beach gains sand during one calm interval, then loses some during a later storm interval.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Name the two processes and explain why the first deposit was not necessarily permanent.

Example of a full-credit answer: The calm interval deposited sand; the storm interval eroded some. A later event can transport material that was previously deposited.

  1. The calm interval deposited sand; the storm interval eroded some.
  2. A later event can transport material that was previously deposited.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A model river section starts with 5 stored sediment units. During a step, 24 enter and 9 leave. No other source or loss occurs.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Final stored amount: 20 units
  • b: Net new deposit: 15 units
  • c: Final stored amount: 38 units
  • d: Net new deposit: 10 units
Answer: Final stored amount: 20 units; Net new deposit: 15 units

5 + 24 − 9 = 20, a net gain of 15.

1B · Open ended

Calculate final storage and distinguish it from the new amount deposited.

Example of a full-credit answer: Final storage is 20 units. Net new deposition is 15 units, added to the original 5.

  1. Final storage is 20 units.
  2. Net new deposition is 15 units, added to the original 5.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A changes flow speed with the same sediment mix and channel. Plan B changes flow, grain size and channel shape together.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies clearer flow test in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: All factors change
  • d: No possible confounding
Answer: Plan A

Plan A better isolates flow speed as the investigated factor.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and explain why the other gives less clear evidence about speed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Plan B also changes sediment or channel shape, creating alternative causes.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Plan B also changes sediment or channel shape, creating alternative causes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

In a virtual dune example, wind carries sand and slows behind an obstacle. Some grains settle there.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies process behind obstacle in this case?

  • a: Deposition
  • b: Evaporation
  • c: Only groundwater
  • d: Empty space
Answer: Deposition

Settling after wind transport is deposition just as settling after water transport is.

3B · Open ended

Explain the shared process and identify the different transport agent.

Example of a full-credit answer: Sand is laid down after transport, so deposition occurs. The agent is wind rather than a stream.

  1. Sand is laid down after transport, so deposition occurs.
  2. The agent is wind rather than a stream.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A model sends in 40 units. A learner measures 25 leaving and says the other 15 were destroyed. The model records 15 in a new deposit.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Correct explanation: 15 units were deposited.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Stored and outgoing material together match the input.

4B · Short answer

Identify the mistake and use the budget to correct it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The missing-from-outflow sediment was deposited, not destroyed. 25 outgoing plus 15 deposited equals the 40 incoming units.

  1. The missing-from-outflow sediment was deposited, not destroyed.
  2. 25 outgoing plus 15 deposited equals the 40 incoming units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A model channel receives 50 sediment units. A design should deposit at least 20 while allowing at least 15 to continue, with no other storage change. First evaluate a candidate depositing 30 units; then propose any valid amounts for your own design.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Deposited amount in the stated candidate; Onward amount for that candidate; Balance total

  • a: 30 units
  • b: 20 units
  • c: 50 units
  • d: 45 units deposited
Answer: Deposited amount in the stated candidate → 30 units; Onward amount for that candidate → 20 units; Balance total → 50 units

30 deposited and 20 onward meet both limits and conserve the total.

5B · Open ended

Propose deposited and onward amounts and show they meet both limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: Deposit 25 and send 25 onward; both limits are met and the sum is 50.

  1. Chooses deposited and onward amounts summing to 50.
  2. Deposition is at least 20 and onward amount at least 15.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.15 · Natural resources

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A renewal budget

Worked-example information

A toy forest store gains 6 wood units and loses 4 each step.

Question: What is its net change?

Answer: An increase of 2 units.

Why: Renewal exceeds use in this model step.

Example 2 · Recover material
Recovery model
PartMetal units
Input20
Recovered15
Unrecovered5

Worked-example information

A classroom recycling model receives 20 metal units and recovers 15.

Question: How much is unrecovered?

Answer: 5 units.

Why: 20 − 15 = 5; collection and process losses matter.

Example 3 · A limited comparison

Worked-example information

Two fictional options supply 10 energy units. Their impact indices are 3 and 7.

Question: Which has the smaller stated impact index?

Answer: The option with index 3.

Why: That answer uses the supplied criterion; it does not prove the option is best in every respect.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify resource renewal

Fixed case information

The source lists sunlight arriving daily, a mineral deposit forming over geological time and a forest that can regrow under suitable management.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Very slow replacement: Mineral deposit
  • b: Daily incoming energy: Sunlight
  • c: Very slow replacement: Sunlight
  • d: Daily incoming energy: A plastic label
Answer: Very slow replacement: Mineral deposit; Daily incoming energy: Sunlight

Renewal timescale distinguishes these examples.

Scientific explorer: energy mix lab

F2 · Use exceeds renewal

Fixed case information

A toy resource store begins at 40 units. Renewal adds 4 and use removes 7 per step.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies net change in this case?

  • a: Decrease by 3
  • b: Increase by 3
  • c: 51 units
  • d: No withdrawal occurs
Answer: Decrease by 3

40 + 4 − 7 = 37.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F3 · Count recovered metal

Fixed case information

A process takes 30 metal units, recovers 24 and loses 6 from the recovery stream.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Recovered amount; Unrecovered amount; Total input

  • a: 24 units
  • b: 6 units
  • c: 30 units
  • d: 36 units
Answer: Recovered amount → 24 units; Unrecovered amount → 6 units; Total input → 30 units

The budget accounts for recovered and unrecovered material.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A resource-choice table

Fixed case information

Fictional plans A and B each supply 12 units. A has impact index 4; B has index 9. No cost or reliability data are supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Lower stated impact: Plan A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The stated table permits one comparison, not an all-purpose ranking.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain renewable limits

Fixed case information

A virtual woodland grows 3 resource units per year but a plan removes 5 each year. The starting store is finite. A learner says the resource is unlimited because it regrows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Calculate the annual net change, explain why the plan depletes the store, and correct the learner’s unlimited-resource claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Removal exceeds regrowth by 2 units per year in the model. Renewable resources can still be depleted locally or used unsustainably.

  1. Removal exceeds regrowth by 2 units per year in the model.
  2. Renewable resources can still be depleted locally or used unsustainably.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: population lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy store starts with 60 units. It gains 8 and loses 11 in one period.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Final store; Net decrease; Total available before use

  • a: 57 units
  • b: 3 units
  • c: 68 units
  • d: 79 units
Answer: Final store → 57 units; Net decrease → 3 units; Total available before use → 68 units

60 + 8 − 11 = 57.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the final amount and explain whether this use rate maintains the store.

Example of a full-credit answer: The final store is 57 units. This rate reduces the store because use exceeds renewal by 3.

  1. The final store is 57 units.
  2. This rate reduces the store because use exceeds renewal by 3.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A fictional task needs at least 10 energy units with impact index at most 5. Plan A supplies 12 with index 4; B supplies 8 with index 2; C supplies 12 with index 9.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Plan meeting both limits; B fails because; C fails because

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Too little energy
  • c: Impact index too high
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Plan meeting both limits → Plan A; B fails because → Too little energy; C fails because → Impact index too high

Only Plan A meets both stated constraints.

2B · Open ended

Choose the plan and justify it against both limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. It supplies at least 10 units and has an impact index no greater than 5.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. It supplies at least 10 units and has an impact index no greater than 5.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional closed pond begins with 40 fish. Ten young fish join the counted population and 6 are removed during a model period; ignore other changes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Final population: 44 fish.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

40 + 10 − 6 = 44 under the stated simple assumptions.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the population and state why this is not a real fishery guarantee.

Example of a full-credit answer: The model ends with 44 fish. Real populations include changing reproduction, deaths, movement or conditions omitted by the model.

  1. The model ends with 44 fish.
  2. Real populations include changing reproduction, deaths, movement or conditions omitted by the model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “Recycling 100 objects means every material unit is recovered.” The record says 80 of 100 material units were recovered.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Recovered fraction; Unrecovered fraction; Claim error

  • a: 80%
  • b: 20%
  • c: Assuming complete recovery
  • d: 100%
Answer: Recovered fraction → 80%; Unrecovered fraction → 20%; Claim error → Assuming complete recovery

The record explicitly shows incomplete recovery.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim with the numbers and explain the distinction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Only 80 of 100 units were recovered; 20 were not. Collecting or processing objects does not guarantee full recovery of all material.

  1. Only 80 of 100 units were recovered; 20 were not.
  2. Collecting or processing objects does not guarantee full recovery of all material.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A renewable model store gains 9 units each period. A community needs at least 7 useful units. Propose use that meets needs without reducing the store; ignore other flows.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies feasible use range in this case?

  • a: 7 to 9 units
  • b: 10 to 12 units
  • c: 0 units renewed
  • d: Only 3 units needed
Answer: 7 to 9 units

Using no more than 9 and at least 7 meets both model constraints.

5B · Open ended

Propose a use amount and show why it meets both constraints.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 8 units: it meets the 7-unit need and leaves a net gain of 1.

  1. Chooses a use amount from 7 through 9 units, inclusive.
  2. Shows useful need is met and use does not exceed renewal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.16 · Mineral extraction

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A model ore share

Worked-example information

A box contains 25 counters; 5 represent useful mineral units.

Question: What fraction is useful in this model?

Answer: 5/25, or one fifth.

Why: The denominator is all counters in the ore model.

Example 2 · Recovery is a second fraction
Useful-material budget
PartUnits
Available10
Recovered7
Unrecovered3

Worked-example information

Ten useful units enter a process and 7 are recovered.

Question: What percentage is recovered?

Answer: 70%.

Why: 7 ÷ 10 × 100 = 70.

Example 3 · Equal output, different water

Worked-example information

Two fictional methods recover 8 metal units. A uses 12 water units; B uses 20.

Question: Which uses less stated water for the same output?

Answer: Method A.

Why: That comparison does not answer other questions about waste, cost or ecological effects.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Separate the material streams

Fixed case information

A model process receives 40 material units and produces 8 useful product units plus 32 residue units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Useful product; Residue; Input

  • a: 8 units
  • b: 32 units
  • c: 40 units
  • d: 48 units
Answer: Useful product → 8 units; Residue → 32 units; Input → 40 units

The two output streams account for the input.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Calculate recovery

Fixed case information

A sample contains 12 useful units. A process recovers 9 and leaves 3 unrecovered.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Recovery percentage; Recovered amount; Unrecovered amount

  • a: 75%
  • b: 9 units
  • c: 3 units
  • d: 25%
Answer: Recovery percentage → 75%; Recovered amount → 9 units; Unrecovered amount → 3 units

9/12 = 3/4 = 75%.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Compare water demand

Fixed case information

Fictional methods A, B and C recover equal product. Water demand is 10, 16 and 13 units respectively.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Lowest demand: Method A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Equal product lets the stated water demands be compared directly.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Evidence about a sample

Fixed case information

A prepared report shows a water sample looks clear but has a high dissolved-substance reading. No biological test is supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies appearance in this case?

  • a: Clear
  • b: Guaranteed harmless
  • c: Nothing is dissolved
  • d: Every risk is ruled out
Answer: Clear

Appearance and test results describe different properties.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain two percentages

Fixed case information

A fictional ore is 20% useful material by mass. A process recovers 80% of that useful material.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what each percentage is a percentage of.

Example of a full-credit answer: 20% refers to useful material as a share of the whole ore mass. 80% refers to recovered material as a share of the useful material initially present.

  1. 20% refers to useful material as a share of the whole ore mass.
  2. 80% refers to recovered material as a share of the useful material initially present.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: material lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A 100-unit ore model contains 20 useful units. The process recovers 75% of those useful units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Useful units recovered; Useful units unrecovered; Useful units initially present

  • a: 15
  • b: 5
  • c: 20
  • d: 75
Answer: Useful units recovered → 15; Useful units unrecovered → 5; Useful units initially present → 20

75% of 20 is 15, leaving 5 useful units unrecovered.

1B · Open ended

Calculate recovered and unrecovered useful material and show your denominator.

Example of a full-credit answer: Recovers 15 useful units and leaves 5 useful units. Applies 75% to the 20 useful units, not the whole 100-unit ore.

  1. Recovers 15 useful units and leaves 5 useful units.
  2. Applies 75% to the 20 useful units, not the whole 100-unit ore.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A fictional task requires at least 8 product units using no more than 15 water units. Plan A gives 9 product with 14 water; B gives 10 with 20; C gives 6 with 10.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies meets both limits in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: All three plans
Answer: Plan A

Plan A satisfies both numerical constraints.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify it against both requirements.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. It gives at least 8 product units while using at most 15 water units.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. It gives at least 8 product units while using at most 15 water units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A recycling model begins with 50 useful metal units in old products and recovers 40. The remaining 10 are not recovered by this process.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Recovery: 80%
  • b: Recovered metal: 40 units
  • c: Recovery: 20%
  • d: Recovered metal: 125%
Answer: Recovery: 80%; Recovered metal: 40 units

The same recovery logic applies to material in old products.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the recovery rate and explain how this can affect demand for new extraction.

Example of a full-credit answer: The recovery rate is 80%. Recovered metal can replace some newly extracted material, though recovery is incomplete and processing still has impacts.

  1. The recovery rate is 80%.
  2. Recovered metal can replace some newly extracted material, though recovery is incomplete and processing still has impacts.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “Method X recovers the most metal, so it must be best in every way.” The table gives no water, waste or land-disturbance data.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which part of the learner’s quoted claim is unsupported by the metal-yield record?

  • a: Best in every way
  • b: Metal yield is listed
  • c: All effects are measured
  • d: Only letter style matters
Answer: Best in every way

The known yield cannot settle unmeasured trade-offs.

4B · Short answer

Explain the overreach and name two additional measurements or criteria.

Example of a full-credit answer: Highest metal yield alone does not establish best overall performance. Names two relevant criteria such as water use, waste, land disturbance or energy use.

  1. Highest metal yield alone does not establish best overall performance.
  2. Names two relevant criteria such as water use, waste, land disturbance or energy use.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Two virtual extraction methods will process identical samples. You can record product yield and water use. Design a comparison before choosing a method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Input to keep equal; First result; Second result

  • a: Ore amount and composition
  • b: Useful product recovered
  • c: Water used
  • d: Different ores for each
Answer: Input to keep equal → Ore amount and composition; First result → Useful product recovered; Second result → Water used

Comparable inputs and two outcomes reveal a clearer trade-off.

5B · Open ended

Describe the controlled input and two results you will record.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses equal ore amount and composition for the two methods. Records useful product recovered and water used, with consistent units.

  1. Uses equal ore amount and composition for the two methods.
  2. Records useful product recovered and water used, with consistent units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.17 · Water resources

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Enough volume, wrong type

Worked-example information

A task needs 10 fresh-water units; a nearby store holds 100 salty units and 8 fresh units.

Question: Does total volume alone meet the task?

Answer: No. Only 8 units match the stated fresh-water need.

Why: Water type matters as well as total volume.

Example 2 · Daily demand
Daily use
PartUnits
Useful need8
Leak3
Before repair11
After repair8

Worked-example information

A classroom model uses 8 units for useful needs and wastes 3 through a leak.

Question: What demand remains after fixing the leak?

Answer: 8 units.

Why: The repair removes the 3-unit avoidable loss.

Example 3 · A limited quality test

Worked-example information

A report says cloudiness decreased, but no microbe result is available.

Question: What can be concluded?

Answer: Cloudiness decreased; full safety is not established.

Why: One measured property cannot answer every quality question.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read the purpose

Fixed case information

A fictional task needs 12 fresh-water units daily. A source offers 10 fresh units and 30 salty units; no treatment process is included.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Matching supply: 10 fresh units
  • b: Unmet fresh-water need: 2 units
  • c: Matching supply: 40 matching units
  • d: Unmet fresh-water need: No shortfall
Answer: Matching supply: 10 fresh units; Unmet fresh-water need: 2 units

The task specifies fresh water and no treatment.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · A daily budget

Fixed case information

A model store starts at 45 units. Supply adds 10 and use removes 13 in one day.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Final store; Net change; Daily input

  • a: 42 units
  • b: Decrease by 3
  • c: 10 units
  • d: 68 units
Answer: Final store → 42 units; Net change → Decrease by 3; Daily input → 10 units

45 + 10 − 13 = 42.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F3 · Find avoidable use

Fixed case information

A school model uses 9 units for required activities and 4 through a leak. Repair removes only the leak loss.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Demand after repair; Daily saving; Demand before repair

  • a: 9 units
  • b: 4 units
  • c: 13 units
  • d: 5 units
Answer: Demand after repair → 9 units; Daily saving → 4 units; Demand before repair → 13 units

Useful demand remains; avoidable loss is removed.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Distinguish test results

Fixed case information

Prepared reports list cloudiness, salt content and a microbe test. Only cloudiness was measured in a sample.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Known property; Unknown chemical property; Unknown biological property

  • a: Cloudiness
  • b: Salt content
  • c: Microbe result
  • d: Complete drinking safety
Answer: Known property → Cloudiness; Unknown chemical property → Salt content; Unknown biological property → Microbe result

The available test has limited scope.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a storage limit

Fixed case information

A virtual tank holds 24 units and loses a net 4 units each week. There is no later refill in the stated model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State how long the store lasts and identify the assumption behind the calculation.

Example of a full-credit answer: It lasts six weeks under the model. The calculation assumes a constant net loss of 4 units weekly and no refill.

  1. It lasts six weeks under the model.
  2. The calculation assumes a constant net loss of 4 units weekly and no refill.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Daily supply is 14 units. Useful demand is 11 and a leak wastes 5. A repair removes the full leak.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Demand after repair; Surplus after repair; Original shortfall

  • a: 11 units
  • b: 3 units
  • c: 2 units
  • d: 16 units
Answer: Demand after repair → 11 units; Surplus after repair → 3 units; Original shortfall → 2 units

Before repair demand is 16; after repair it is 11, below supply 14.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the repaired demand and explain whether it fits supply.

Example of a full-credit answer: Demand becomes 11 units. It fits the 14-unit supply with 3 units remaining.

  1. Demand becomes 11 units.
  2. It fits the 14-unit supply with 3 units remaining.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A compares equal school days with similar attendance before and after repair. Plan B compares one holiday with one busy school day.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies more informative comparison in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Random attendance
  • d: Exactly equal demand
Answer: Plan A

Comparable activity levels reduce another explanation for changes in use.

2B · Open ended

Choose the comparison and explain one reason it is fairer.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Similar attendance or day type makes demand more comparable.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Similar attendance or day type makes demand more comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A toy village stores 30 units before a dry period. Each of three dry weeks has supply 5 and demand 9. No other flows occur.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies final reserve in this case?

  • a: 18 units
  • b: 42 units
  • c: 14 units weekly
  • d: 30 units created
Answer: 18 units

Three weeks use 3 × 4 = 12 reserve units; 30 − 12 = 18.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the final reserve and explain how storage helps with timing.

Example of a full-credit answer: The reserve ends at 18 units. Stored water covers the weekly gap between current supply and demand.

  1. The reserve ends at 18 units.
  2. Stored water covers the weekly gap between current supply and demand.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A model filter reduces visible particles from 20 to 4 units. A learner says all chemical and biological hazards are therefore gone. No such tests were made.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Supported result: Every hazard is gone.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Particle removal alone does not establish complete quality.

4B · Open ended

Separate the supported result from the unsupported safety claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: The record supports reduced visible particles. It does not show all dissolved substances or microbes were removed; appropriate tests are missing.

  1. The record supports reduced visible particles.
  2. It does not show all dissolved substances or microbes were removed; appropriate tests are missing.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A model supply is 20 units per day. Essential uses need 15. Optional uses can be 0–8, and a 3-unit leak can be repaired. Propose a plan without drawing down storage.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Maximum optional use after repair; Essential demand; Supply

  • a: 5 units
  • b: 15 units
  • c: 20 units
  • d: 8 units without limits
Answer: Maximum optional use after repair → 5 units; Essential demand → 15 units; Supply → 20 units

After repair, 15 plus no more than 5 optional units stays within supply.

5B · Open ended

Propose leak and optional-use choices and show total demand fits supply.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repair the leak and use 3 optional units: 15 + 3 = 18, within supply 20.

  1. Repairs the leak and chooses optional use from 0 to 5, or gives another feasible complete budget including the leak.
  2. Meets the 15 essential units and keeps total daily use at or below 20.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.18 · Aquifers

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two properties

Worked-example information

Sample A has many disconnected pores. Sample B has connected spaces through which water passes easily.

Question: Which description directly indicates greater permeability?

Answer: Sample B.

Why: Permeability concerns passage through connected spaces, not just the amount of empty space.

Example 2 · One model step
Groundwater budget
PartUnits
Start70
Recharge5
Pumping8
Final67

Worked-example information

A toy aquifer starts at 70 units, receives 5 and loses 8 to pumping.

Question: What remains?

Answer: 67 units.

Why: 70 + 5 − 8 = 67.

Example 3 · One source, two wells

Worked-example information

A diagram shows two wells tapping one connected layer.

Question: Could pumping from one affect the other?

Answer: Yes, depending on the aquifer and pumping conditions.

Why: The wells are not necessarily independent just because they have separate openings.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Find groundwater in the diagram

Fixed case information

A model shows water filling connected pores below the water table, with soil and rock remaining in place.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Water location; Useful transmitting layer; Misleading underground-tunnel picture

  • a: Pores and fractures
  • b: Aquifer
  • c: Only a giant empty river cave
  • d: Only empty sky
Answer: Water location → Pores and fractures; Useful transmitting layer → Aquifer; Misleading underground-tunnel picture → Only a giant empty river cave

Groundwater commonly occupies spaces in material.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F2 · Recharge versus pumping

Fixed case information

A toy store starts at 50, receives 6 and loses 9 in one period.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies final store in this case?

  • a: 47 units
  • b: 65 units
  • c: 15 units gained
  • d: 9 units added
Answer: 47 units

50 + 6 − 9 = 47.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Different material properties

Fixed case information

A card defines porosity as the amount of space and permeability as ease of flow through connected space.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies storage-space property in this case?

  • a: Porosity
  • b: Permeability
  • c: Only colour
  • d: Perfectly sealed pores
Answer: Porosity

Having spaces and connecting them are different properties.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Read a well record

Fixed case information

Fictional groundwater levels relative to one reference are 12, 11 and 9 m on three dates. Lower numbers mean lower water level in this record.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Overall change; Last level; Required reference

  • a: Fall by 3 m
  • b: 9 m
  • c: Same measurement datum
  • d: Rise by 3 m
Answer: Overall change → Fall by 3 m; Last level → 9 m; Required reference → Same measurement datum

12 to 9 is a decrease of 3 under the supplied convention.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a quantity-only result

Fixed case information

A model balances recharge and pumping at 5 units per step. These are its only flows, and no water-quality data are supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

State what the budget supports and one question it cannot answer.

Example of a full-credit answer: The specified flows give no net storage change. The budget cannot establish water quality or drinking-water safety.

  1. The specified flows give no net storage change.
  2. The budget cannot establish water quality or drinking-water safety.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy aquifer starts at 80 units. Each of three steps adds 4 and removes 7. No other flows are included.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies final store in this case?

  • a: 71 units
  • b: 89 units
  • c: 59 units
  • d: 80 units unchanged
Answer: 71 units

The store loses 3 each step, or 9 in three steps.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the final store and explain the repeated change.

Example of a full-credit answer: The final store is 71 units. Each step loses 3 because pumping 7 exceeds recharge 4; three steps lose 9.

  1. The final store is 71 units.
  2. Each step loses 3 because pumping 7 exceeds recharge 4; three steps lose 9.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A measures both wells from the same reference on matched dates and records pumping. Plan B compares undated levels with different reference zeros.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Stronger method; Helpful accompanying record; Weakness of B

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Pumping amounts
  • c: Incomparable reference and time
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Stronger method → Plan A; Helpful accompanying record → Pumping amounts; Weakness of B → Incomparable reference and time

Consistent level references and dates are needed.

2B · Short answer

Choose the stronger method and justify it with two comparable-record features.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Uses matched dates and a common level reference, with pumping records as useful context.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Justifies Plan A using two relevant comparable-record features, such as matched dates and a common level reference. Pumping records may add context.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Two school gardens use wells shown in the same connected aquifer. Garden A doubles pumping; Garden B’s level then falls. Other possible causes were not measured.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Plausible connection; What observation shows; What remains uncertain

  • a: Shared aquifer
  • b: B’s level fell after A increased pumping
  • c: Whether pumping alone caused it
  • d: Guaranteed independent stores
Answer: Plausible connection → Shared aquifer; What observation shows → B’s level fell after A increased pumping; What remains uncertain → Whether pumping alone caused it

Connection makes an effect plausible, but timing alone does not isolate a cause.

3B · Open ended

Explain why the gardens may be connected and why the observation does not prove the sole cause.

Example of a full-credit answer: Their wells tap the same connected aquifer, so pumping can affect shared water levels. Other factors such as recharge or other withdrawals were not measured.

  1. Their wells tap the same connected aquifer, so pumping can affect shared water levels.
  2. Other factors such as recharge or other withdrawals were not measured.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner draws every aquifer as a huge empty tunnel. The source diagram shows most water held in connected pores and cracks in rock or sediment.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Misconception: Every aquifer is an empty tunnel.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Some underground channels exist, but the blanket tunnel picture is wrong.

4B · Short answer

Identify the overgeneralisation and describe a more typical aquifer model.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rejects the claim that every aquifer is a huge empty tunnel. Shows groundwater in connected pores or fractures within rock/sediment.

  1. Rejects the claim that every aquifer is a huge empty tunnel.
  2. Shows groundwater in connected pores or fractures within rock/sediment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A model recharge is 8 units per period. Natural discharge is already accounted for in that available recharge figure. Required use is at least 6. Choose pumping that does not lower storage.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Feasible pumping: 6 to 8 units
  • b: Available recharge: 8 units
  • c: Feasible pumping: 9 to 12 units
  • d: Available recharge: 0 recharge
Answer: Feasible pumping: 6 to 8 units; Available recharge: 8 units

Pumping can meet the need without exceeding the stated available recharge.

5B · Open ended

Propose a pumping amount and show that it meets both constraints.

Example of a full-credit answer: Pump 7: it meets the 6-unit need and leaves a net gain of 1.

  1. Chooses a pumping amount from 6 through 8 units per period, inclusive.
  2. Shows pumping meets the minimum need and does not exceed recharge.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.19 · Natural hazards

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Hazard and exposure

Worked-example information

A fictional flood zone covers a field but not a hilltop. A sports activity is planned on the field.

Question: Which feature shows exposure?

Answer: The activity is located in the marked flood zone.

Why: The flood process is the hazard; the activity’s location creates exposure.

Example 2 · Read the legend
Map key
ColourMeaning
RedHigher modelled flood likelihood
GreenLower modelled flood likelihood

Worked-example information

A map key says red means higher modelled flood likelihood, not a specific date.

Question: Does red mean flooding at noon tomorrow?

Answer: No.

Why: The legend states likelihood, not exact timing.

Example 3 · Reduce one part of risk

Worked-example information

Two model buildings experience equal shaking. The better-secured model loses fewer attached objects.

Question: Which part of risk was reduced in this comparison?

Answer: Vulnerability of the model setup.

Why: The shaking hazard was held equal while the response changed.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Separate the terms

Fixed case information

A fictional river may flood. A classroom is beside it. Its low floor allows water to enter easily.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Hazard: The school name.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The terms describe different contributors to possible harm.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F2 · Read a fictional map

Fixed case information

Zone A has higher modelled flood likelihood; Zone B lower. The map concerns flooding only and gives no exact event date.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Higher flood zone; Lower flood zone; Information outside this flood map’s stated scope

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Earthquake risk or exact flood date
  • d: Both identical
Answer: Higher flood zone → A; Lower flood zone → B; Information outside this flood map’s stated scope → Earthquake risk or exact flood date

Map scope limits the claims it can support.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Compare exposed groups

Fixed case information

In a fictional exercise, 30 people are in Zone A and 10 in Zone B. The task counts people in the higher-likelihood zone A.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Higher-zone exposure; Other-zone count; Total people

  • a: 30 people
  • b: 10 people
  • c: 40
  • d: 20 people
Answer: Higher-zone exposure → 30 people; Other-zone count → 10 people; Total people → 40

Exposure depends on where people are located in the supplied scenario.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A useful record

Fixed case information

A preparedness team keeps dated official notices and approved school procedures. Another relies only on undated reposts.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Stronger information trail: Dated official notices
  • b: Helpful school document: Approved procedure
  • c: Stronger information trail: Undated reposts
  • d: Helpful school document: Only a colourful banner
Answer: Stronger information trail: Dated official notices; Helpful school document: Approved procedure

Authority, date and scope help assess relevance.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain preparedness under uncertainty

Fixed case information

A fictional forecast says a downpour is possible during an outdoor event. The school reserves an indoor alternative; the day later stays dry.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the alternative can be sensible and what the dry result does not prove.

Example of a full-credit answer: The alternative prepares for a possible disruptive outcome. A dry day does not prove the forecast promised rain or that preparation was useless.

  1. The alternative prepares for a possible disruptive outcome.
  2. A dry day does not prove the forecast promised rain or that preparation was useless.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional map places Playground A inside a higher flood-likelihood zone and Hall B outside it. Both fit the class; the task concerns reducing flood exposure only.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Lower-exposure choice; Reason; Limit

  • a: Hall B
  • b: Outside the marked higher zone
  • c: Other risks are not assessed
  • d: Playground A
Answer: Lower-exposure choice → Hall B; Reason → Outside the marked higher zone; Limit → Other risks are not assessed

The map supports the specified flood-exposure comparison, not universal safety.

1B · Short answer

Choose the site and explain both the map evidence and its limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Hall B because it lies outside the marked higher flood-likelihood zone. Notes that other hazards or real-world conditions are not assessed by this fictional map.

  1. Chooses Hall B because it lies outside the marked higher flood-likelihood zone.
  2. Notes that other hazards or real-world conditions are not assessed by this fictional map.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A team tests securing objects during virtual shaking. Plan A uses equal shaking with secured versus unsecured objects. Plan B also changes shaking strength.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies clearer test in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Unrelated poster colour
  • d: Everything is controlled
Answer: Plan A

Plan A isolates the securing action more clearly.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger comparison and explain what it can investigate.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Equal shaking allows comparison of the effect of securing objects on displacement in the model.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Equal shaking allows comparison of the effect of securing objects on displacement in the model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional school map marks shaded area S and unshaded area U. During the supplied observation, S reads 30°C and U 35°C. Both have equal capacity.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Cooler measured site; Difference; Evidence scope

  • a: S
  • b: 5°C
  • c: That observation and those sites
  • d: U
Answer: Cooler measured site → S; Difference → 5°C; Evidence scope → That observation and those sites

The measurement supports a local comparison for that time.

3B · Short answer

Use the readings to choose a cooler site, calculate the temperature difference, and state one limit of the comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses S using the 5°C lower reading. Notes that readings apply to the stated time/sites and do not establish every future condition.

  1. Chooses S using the 5°C lower reading.
  2. Notes that readings apply to the stated time/sites and do not establish every future condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A map marks Zone C as lower likelihood. The legend defines this as a smaller but nonzero model likelihood. A learner says, “Lower means no event can ever occur.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Misread word: Lower as zero
  • b: Correct meaning: Smaller stated likelihood
  • c: Misread word: The zone label
  • d: Correct meaning: Guaranteed occurrence
Answer: Misread word: Lower as zero; Correct meaning: Smaller stated likelihood

Lower likelihood and impossibility are different concepts.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim and explain the difference between lower and zero likelihood.

Example of a full-credit answer: Lower likelihood does not mean impossible. It means a smaller chance under the map’s assumptions, with some possibility still remaining.

  1. Lower likelihood does not mean impossible.
  2. It means a smaller chance under the map’s assumptions, with some possibility still remaining.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

For a fictional flood scenario, the class has an official notice, an approved school plan and two labelled model venues. Propose a check before choosing a venue.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies first information check in this case?

  • a: Notice date and scope
  • b: Anonymous rumour only
  • c: Only wall colour
  • d: A guessed real route
Answer: Notice date and scope

A sound check connects current relevant information to the approved procedure.

5B · Open ended

Propose two specific checks that connect the information to the venue decision.

Example of a full-credit answer: Checks the notice’s authority, date and relevance to the area/hazard. Uses the relevant map and approved plan to compare venue exposure without inventing real routes.

  1. Checks the notice’s authority, date and relevance to the area/hazard.
  2. Uses the relevant map and approved plan to compare venue exposure without inventing real routes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S9.20 · Human-created environmental hazards

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find the pathway

Worked-example information

A fictional diagram shows loose waste beside a drain, rainwater entering the drain and a downstream pond.

Question: What connects the source to the pond?

Answer: Runoff through the drain.

Why: The pathway identifies where material can move.

Example 2 · Compare a model index
Model index
StageIndex
Before18
After7

Worked-example information

A toy pollution index falls from 18 to 7 after an intervention.

Question: What is the decrease?

Answer: 11 index units.

Why: 18 − 7 = 11. This is not a statement that the real water is safe.

Example 3 · Two measurements matter

Worked-example information

A fictional treatment lowers one index but doubles water use.

Question: Why might a decision need both results?

Answer: They reveal a trade-off.

Why: Improvement in one measured outcome does not describe every effect.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Source pathway receptor

Fixed case information

A virtual scenario shows waste beside a road, runoff carrying it through a drain and a pond receiving it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies source in this case?

  • a: Roadside waste
  • b: Only sunlight
  • c: An unrelated star
  • d: A dry classroom shelf
Answer: Roadside waste

The chain explains possible movement from source to environment.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read an index change

Fixed case information

A fictional environmental index is 16 before and 9 after a model action. Lower is better for this index only.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Decrease: 7 units
  • b: Later index: 9 units
  • c: Decrease: 25 units
  • d: Later index: 16 units after
Answer: Decrease: 7 units; Later index: 9 units

16 − 9 = 7; one index has limited scope.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Compare with equal rain

Fixed case information

Plan A compares two virtual surfaces under equal rainfall. Plan B compares a dry day before with heavy rain after an action.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? More comparable test: Plan A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Rainfall can alter runoff and must be considered.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F4 · A limited quality report

Fixed case information

A prepared report gives a low visible-particle count but no dissolved-substance or microbe results.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Known property; Missing chemical result; Missing biological result

  • a: Visible-particle count
  • b: Dissolved substances
  • c: Microbes
  • d: Guaranteed safe water
Answer: Known property → Visible-particle count; Missing chemical result → Dissolved substances; Missing biological result → Microbes

An incomplete report cannot establish all aspects of quality.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain lower versus zero

Fixed case information

A toy hazard index decreases from 10 to 3. A learner says it is now exactly zero.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Calculate the index decrease and state its final value. Explain the mistake in calling it exactly zero.

Example of a full-credit answer: The index fell by 7 to a final value of 3. Reduced does not mean zero or complete elimination.

  1. The index fell by 7 to a final value of 3.
  2. Reduced does not mean zero or complete elimination.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy model releases 40 material units. A source-control action prevents 25% of release; the rest enters the model pathway.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Release prevented; Release remaining; Starting release

  • a: 10 units
  • b: 30 units
  • c: 40 units
  • d: 25 units
Answer: Release prevented → 10 units; Release remaining → 30 units; Starting release → 40 units

One quarter of 40 is 10, leaving 30.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the remaining release and explain why the action does not eliminate it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Thirty units remain after preventing ten. Preventing 25% leaves 75%, so the release is reduced but not eliminated.

  1. Thirty units remain after preventing ten.
  2. Preventing 25% leaves 75%, so the release is reduced but not eliminated.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Fictional plans must reduce an index to 5 or less and use at most 12 water units. A gives index 4 with water 10; B gives index 2 with water 18; C gives index 7 with water 8.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Meets both conditions; B fails; C fails

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Water-use limit
  • c: Index target
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Meets both conditions → Plan A; B fails → Water-use limit; C fails → Index target

Only A meets both specified constraints.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify the choice using both limits.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Its index 4 is at most 5 and water use 10 is at most 12.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Its index 4 is at most 5 and water use 10 is at most 12.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A new virtual case shows airborne dust from a disturbed surface moving toward nearby plants. The movement is by air rather than a drain.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies source in this case?

  • a: Disturbed dusty surface
  • b: The plants only
  • c: An underground pipe
  • d: A distant planet
Answer: Disturbed dusty surface

The source–pathway–receiver approach applies to airborne material too.

3B · Open ended

Identify the changed pathway and propose one model-level action that interrupts it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies moving air carrying dust as the pathway. Proposes reducing loose dust at the source or a suitable model barrier/cover, without claiming guaranteed real safety.

  1. Identifies moving air carrying dust as the pathway.
  2. Proposes reducing loose dust at the source or a suitable model barrier/cover, without claiming guaranteed real safety.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

An index falls after a barrier is added, but rainfall also drops from 60 to 20 units. A learner credits the entire change to the barrier.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Flaw; Alternative explanation; Needed comparison

  • a: Rainfall changed too
  • b: Less rain may transport less material
  • c: Comparable rain with and without barrier
  • d: Only the barrier changed
Answer: Flaw → Rainfall changed too; Alternative explanation → Less rain may transport less material; Needed comparison → Comparable rain with and without barrier

The before-and-after record has a confounding change.

4B · Short answer

Explain the flaw and propose a clearer comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rainfall changed as well as the barrier, so the whole effect cannot be assigned to the barrier alone. Compares with and without the barrier under equal or carefully matched rain conditions.

  1. Rainfall changed as well as the barrier, so the whole effect cannot be assigned to the barrier alone.
  2. Compares with and without the barrier under equal or carefully matched rain conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class studies a virtual runoff-control action. It can record rainfall, runoff volume and one labelled pollution index before and after. Design a check that does not overclaim safety.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies useful context measure in this case?

  • a: Rainfall
  • b: Only poster colour
  • c: No observations
  • d: All safety is guaranteed
Answer: Rainfall

Comparable multiple records show whether the targeted outcome changes and what remains unknown.

5B · Open ended

Describe the records and one limitation you will include in the conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: Records comparable before/after rainfall, runoff and the targeted index, with repeats where possible. States that the measured index does not establish all chemical/biological hazards or real-world safety.

  1. Records comparable before/after rainfall, runoff and the targeted index, with repeats where possible.
  2. States that the measured index does not establish all chemical/biological hazards or real-world safety.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.1 · Earth, Moon and Sun relationships

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · The turning globe

Worked-example information

A fixed lamp lights one side of a virtual globe. A marked point turns into the unlit side.

Question: What does this represent?

Answer: Night beginning at that location as Earth rotates.

Why: The light source stays fixed while the location turns away.

Example 2 · Sort the motions
Motion guide
MotionDescription
Earth rotationSpin about its axis
Earth revolutionOrbit around Sun
Moon revolutionOrbit around Earth

Worked-example information

A model labels a spin, a path around the Sun and a path around Earth.

Question: Which belongs to the Moon’s revolution?

Answer: The path around Earth.

Why: The objects and reference centre must be identified.

Example 3 · A larger picture is not a larger Moon

Worked-example information

Two textbook sketches draw the Moon at different sizes without scale bars.

Question: Can the pictures show that the real Moon grew?

Answer: No.

Why: Drawn size alone is not a measurement of physical size.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the objects

Fixed case information

A source card identifies the Sun as a light-emitting star, Earth as a planet and the Moon as a natural satellite reflecting sunlight.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies light-emitting star in this case?

  • a: Sun
  • b: Moon
  • c: A cloud
  • d: An ocean
Answer: Sun

The roles of star, planet and satellite differ.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

F2 · Choose the daily motion

Fixed case information

A marked point on a virtual Earth moves from the sunlit side to the dark side during one spin.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Motion causing the change; Observed cycle; Reference feature

  • a: Rotation
  • b: Day and night
  • c: Earth’s axis
  • d: Revolution around the Sun
Answer: Motion causing the change → Rotation; Observed cycle → Day and night; Reference feature → Earth’s axis

A daily lit/unlit change follows Earth’s spin.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

F3 · Read model distances

Fixed case information

A fictional model lists Sun–planet distances A=2, B=5 and C=9 model units. These are teaching values, not real planet distances.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Farthest model planet: A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The supplied numerical scale, not icon size, determines distance.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F4 · A phase explanation

Fixed case information

A diagram shows the Moon at different orbital positions, with sunlight illuminating one half and an observer on Earth.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: What changes for observer: Visible sunlit fraction
  • b: Main light source: Sun
  • c: What changes for observer: The Moon breaks apart
  • d: Main light source: Earth makes all moonlight
Answer: What changes for observer: Visible sunlit fraction; Main light source: Sun

Phase changes reflect viewing geometry.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

F5 · Explain a model limit

Fixed case information

A phase model enlarges the Moon and shortens the Earth–Moon distance. Its instructions say “not to scale.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State one useful feature of the model and one thing it cannot measure accurately.

Example of a full-credit answer: It can show illumination or changing viewing geometry. It cannot supply accurate real sizes or distances without a scale.

  1. It can show illumination or changing viewing geometry.
  2. It cannot supply accurate real sizes or distances without a scale.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fixed virtual lamp represents the Sun. Earth spins while its centre stays in place. A school marker crosses from light to darkness.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies best explanation in this case?

  • a: Earth’s rotation
  • b: Sun switches off
  • c: The Moon breaks
  • d: Earth finishes a yearly orbit
Answer: Earth’s rotation

Rotation changes which side faces the light source.

1B · Short answer

Explain the change at the school marker without saying the Sun switches off.

Example of a full-credit answer: Earth rotates so the school marker turns away from the Sun. The Sun continues shining while that location experiences night.

  1. Earth rotates so the school marker turns away from the Sun.
  2. The Sun continues shining while that location experiences night.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Model A shows Sun direction, Moon orbit and Earth-view appearance. Model B only stretches a Moon picture from circle to crescent.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Better explanatory model: Model A
  • b: Useful relationship: Position and visible illumination
  • c: Better explanatory model: Model B
  • d: Useful relationship: Only screen width
Answer: Better explanatory model: Model A; Useful relationship: Position and visible illumination

A position-and-light model explains why the appearance changes.

2B · Open ended

Choose a model and justify it with the relationship it represents.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Model A. It connects Moon position, sunlight direction and the observer’s visible lit portion.

  1. Chooses Model A.
  2. It connects Moon position, sunlight direction and the observer’s visible lit portion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional moon orbits a fictional planet and reflects its star’s light. Its orbit changes the observer’s view of the lit half.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Expected phenomenon; Light source; Physical shape change required

  • a: Changing phases
  • b: The star
  • c: None
  • d: The moon must make sunlight
Answer: Expected phenomenon → Changing phases; Light source → The star; Physical shape change required → None

The same illumination geometry can apply beyond Earth’s Moon.

3B · Short answer

Explain why phases could occur there and what supplies the light.

Example of a full-credit answer: The orbit changes the view of the illuminated portion. The moon reflects light from its star rather than making that light itself.

  1. The orbit changes the view of the illuminated portion.
  2. The moon reflects light from its star rather than making that light itself.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “Day and night happen because Earth goes around the Sun once each day.” The source distinguishes daily rotation from yearly revolution.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Time-scale error in the claim; Correct daily motion; Year-related motion

  • a: Yearly revolution used for daily cycle
  • b: Rotation
  • c: Revolution around Sun
  • d: Rotation used correctly
Answer: Time-scale error in the claim → Yearly revolution used for daily cycle; Correct daily motion → Rotation; Year-related motion → Revolution around Sun

Rotation explains the daily cycle; Earth’s revolution takes about a year.

4B · Open ended

Correct both the motion and its time-scale relationship.

Example of a full-credit answer: Day and night result mainly from Earth’s daily rotation. Earth’s revolution around the Sun is the approximately yearly motion.

  1. Day and night result mainly from Earth’s daily rotation.
  2. Earth’s revolution around the Sun is the approximately yearly motion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

You must explain day and night with a virtual lamp, globe and marked school. State what moves and what observation demonstrates the explanation.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies object to rotate in this case?

  • a: Globe
  • b: Switch off the lamp each time
  • c: Only a dark cloth
  • d: Moon changes shape
Answer: Globe

The model should keep the source shining while the globe turns.

5B · Open ended

Describe the motion and the observation you will show, and identify a scale limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keeps the lamp shining and rotates the globe to move the school marker between lit and unlit sides. Notes that toy sizes, distances or speed are not necessarily to real scale.

  1. Keeps the lamp shining and rotates the globe to move the school marker between lit and unlit sides.
  2. Notes that toy sizes, distances or speed are not necessarily to real scale.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.2 · Moon phases

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Waxing or waning?
Prepared sequence
VisitVisible lit %
120
235
350

Worked-example information

Prepared observations show illuminated fractions 20%, 35% and 50% in sequence.

Question: Is the visible lit portion waxing or waning?

Answer: Waxing.

Why: The fractions increase with time.

Example 2 · Quarter appearance

Worked-example information

A first-quarter diagram shows half the visible disk lit.

Question: Is that inconsistent with its name?

Answer: No.

Why: Quarter names cycle position; the visible disk is about half illuminated.

Example 3 · A cloud gap

Worked-example information

A class cannot see the Moon for two cloudy nights.

Question: Did the Moon stop changing phase?

Answer: No.

Why: Clouds block observation, not the Moon’s orbit.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Phase meanings

Fixed case information

A card defines new as little visible sunlit face, full as almost all the visible face lit, and quarter as about half the visible disk lit.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies almost fully lit visible face in this case?

  • a: Full Moon
  • b: New Moon
  • c: Only a solar eclipse
  • d: A broken Moon
Answer: Full Moon

The labels refer to the visible illuminated fraction.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

F2 · Increasing illumination

Fixed case information

A fictional prepared sequence is 5%, 25%, 50% and 80% visible illumination.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Trend; Last fraction; Physical Moon shape

  • a: Waxing
  • b: 80%
  • c: Still approximately spherical
  • d: Waning
Answer: Trend → Waxing; Last fraction → 80%; Physical Moon shape → Still approximately spherical

The increasing lit fraction is waxing; it does not change the Moon’s physical shape.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Order the named phases

Fixed case information

The supplied order is new → first quarter → full → last quarter → new.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: After first quarter in this list: Full
  • b: After full in this list: Last quarter
  • c: After first quarter in this list: New immediately
  • d: After full in this list: A new planet
Answer: After first quarter in this list: Full; After full in this list: Last quarter

Use the supplied major-phase order; intermediate crescent/gibbous phases are omitted.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Different explanations

Fixed case information

The source states ordinary phases use changing viewpoint; a lunar eclipse uses Earth’s shadow; clouds can hide observations.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Ordinary phase cause; Lunar eclipse cause; Observation blockage

  • a: Changing view of sunlit half
  • b: Earth’s shadow
  • c: Clouds
  • d: Earth’s shadow every night
Answer: Ordinary phase cause → Changing view of sunlit half; Lunar eclipse cause → Earth’s shadow; Observation blockage → Clouds

These three mechanisms must be separated.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain the quarter name

Fixed case information

A learner sees a half-lit disk labelled first quarter and claims the label must be wrong.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what is visible and what the word quarter refers to.

Example of a full-credit answer: About half the visible disk is illuminated. Quarter refers to position in the phase cycle, not a quarter of the visible disk.

  1. About half the visible disk is illuminated.
  2. Quarter refers to position in the phase cycle, not a quarter of the visible disk.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared visible illumination falls from 90% to 65% to 40% on successive visits.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies phase trend in this case?

  • a: Waning
  • b: Waxing
  • c: No change
  • d: No sequence is supplied
Answer: Waning

The visible illuminated fraction decreases across the three recorded visits, so the sequence is waning.

1B · Open ended

Identify the trend and explain why this does not mean the Moon is shrinking.

Example of a full-credit answer: The sequence is waning because visible illumination decreases. The Moon stays physically whole; the observer sees less of its sunlit half.

  1. The sequence is waning because visible illumination decreases.
  2. The Moon stays physically whole; the observer sees less of its sunlit half.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Explanation A links orbit position, sunlight and Earth’s viewpoint. B says Earth’s shadow causes every ordinary crescent.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies better explanation in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Both explanations
  • d: Neither explanation
Answer: A

A distinguishes ordinary phases from special shadow events.

2B · Short answer

Choose the explanation and justify it using the phase/eclipse distinction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Ordinary phases come from viewing the lit half differently; Earth’s shadow explains a lunar eclipse.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Ordinary phases come from viewing the lit half differently; Earth’s shadow explains a lunar eclipse.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A class records 30%, misses two cloudy nights, then records 70%. The source says the Moon continued its normal orbit.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Supported comparison: Illumination decreased.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The observations show endpoints, while the missing nights remain unobserved.

3B · Open ended

State what the log supports and what the cloud gap prevents you from describing directly.

Example of a full-credit answer: Visible illumination increased from 30% to 70% between recorded visits. The exact appearances on the missed nights were not directly recorded.

  1. Visible illumination increased from 30% to 70% between recorded visits.
  2. The exact appearances on the missed nights were not directly recorded.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner labels a normal first-quarter phase “half the Moon inside Earth’s shadow.” The source says no lunar eclipse is occurring.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Incorrect cause; Correct cause; Visible lit fraction

  • a: Earth’s shadow
  • b: Viewing geometry
  • c: About one half
  • d: About one quarter
Answer: Incorrect cause → Earth’s shadow; Correct cause → Viewing geometry; Visible lit fraction → About one half

With no eclipse, the ordinary phase is not explained by Earth’s shadow.

4B · Short answer

Correct the cause and explain the half-lit appearance.

Example of a full-credit answer: Earth’s shadow is not causing this ordinary first-quarter phase. From Earth we see about half of the Moon’s illuminated hemisphere projected as a half-lit disk.

  1. Earth’s shadow is not causing this ordinary first-quarter phase.
  2. From Earth we see about half of the Moon’s illuminated hemisphere projected as a half-lit disk.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Use prepared or safely observed Moon records over several weeks. You need to distinguish changing illumination from missing observations.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Essential entry; Missing-night entry; Useful comparison

  • a: Date and visible appearance
  • b: Cloudy or not observed
  • c: Sequence over time
  • d: Only one undated drawing
Answer: Essential entry → Date and visible appearance; Missing-night entry → Cloudy or not observed; Useful comparison → Sequence over time

Dated records and honest gaps allow a meaningful sequence.

5B · Open ended

Propose two recording rules that make the diary scientifically useful.

Example of a full-credit answer: Records dates and sketches or estimated visible illuminated fractions consistently. Marks missed/cloudy observations honestly and compares the dated sequence rather than inventing data.

  1. Records dates and sketches or estimated visible illuminated fractions consistently.
  2. Marks missed/cloudy observations honestly and compares the dated sequence rather than inventing data.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.3 · Seasons

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Opposite hemispheres

Worked-example information

A supplied diagram shows the Northern Hemisphere tilted toward the Sun and the Southern tilted away.

Question: Which has the summer-like sunlight pattern?

Answer: The Northern Hemisphere.

Why: It receives more direct sunlight and longer daylight in the simplified seasonal comparison.

Example 2 · Compare daylight
Daylight example
Season recordHours
Shorter-day9
Longer-day15

Worked-example information

Fictional daylight durations at a temperate site are 9 h in one season and 15 h in another.

Question: What is the difference?

Answer: 6 hours.

Why: 15 − 9 = 6; these are supplied example values, not every location.

Example 3 · A local rainfall question

Worked-example information

A class wants to identify its school’s rainiest months.

Question: What record is more useful: local long-term rainfall or only an Earth-tilt diagram?

Answer: Local long-term rainfall.

Why: Tilt explains a broad sunlight mechanism but not the full regional rainfall pattern.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read the tilt

Fixed case information

In a simplified diagram, the north end of Earth’s axis leans toward the Sun.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies summer-like hemisphere in this case?

  • a: Northern
  • b: Southern
  • c: Both summer everywhere
  • d: Earth switching off rotation
Answer: Northern

Opposite hemispheres receive different seasonal sunlight patterns.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

F2 · Daylight comparison

Fixed case information

A fictional temperate-site record shows 10 h daylight in Period A and 14 h in Period B.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Longer daylight: Period B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

14 − 10 = 4 hours.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Keep the axis direction

Fixed case information

A model Earth moves to four positions around a lamp. Its axis should keep approximately the same direction in space.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Feature held approximately fixed; Changing relation; Incorrect method

  • a: Axis direction in space
  • b: Tilt toward or away from the Sun
  • c: Always point north toward the lamp
  • d: Keep the lamp shining
Answer: Feature held approximately fixed → Axis direction in space; Changing relation → Tilt toward or away from the Sun; Incorrect method → Always point north toward the lamp

A fixed spatial tilt direction produces different seasonal orientations.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Local rainfall evidence

Fixed case information

A fictional school’s comparable monthly rainfall means are 40, 90 and 160 mm for months A, B and C.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Wettest supplied month: C
  • b: Driest supplied month: A
  • c: Wettest supplied month: A
  • d: Driest supplied month: All equal
Answer: Wettest supplied month: C; Driest supplied month: A

The local dataset answers the rainfall question.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain opposite seasons

Fixed case information

The source states Northern and Southern Hemispheres have opposite seasonal timing while sharing almost the same Earth–Sun distance.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the distance-only story is insufficient and name the better mechanism.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both hemispheres share Earth’s distance from the Sun, so that alone cannot explain opposite seasons. Axial tilt changes sunlight angle and day length differently in the hemispheres.

  1. Both hemispheres share Earth’s distance from the Sun, so that alone cannot explain opposite seasons.
  2. Axial tilt changes sunlight angle and day length differently in the hemispheres.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: orbit lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

At a fictional temperate site, winter-like daylight is 8 h and summer-like daylight is 16 h. The question concerns daylight only.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Increase; Summer-like duration; Outcome that cannot be calculated in degrees Celsius

  • a: 8 h
  • b: 16 h
  • c: Exact air temperature
  • d: 24 h
Answer: Increase → 8 h; Summer-like duration → 16 h; Outcome that cannot be calculated in degrees Celsius → Exact air temperature

16 − 8 = 8 hours; temperature depends on more than this duration alone.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the daylight increase and explain why it does not directly give a temperature.

Example of a full-credit answer: Daylight increases by 8 hours. Temperature also depends on sunlight angle and environmental factors; hours alone are not °C.

  1. Daylight increases by 8 hours.
  2. Temperature also depends on sunlight angle and environmental factors; hours alone are not °C.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Model A keeps the axis pointing in one spatial direction during the orbit. Model B keeps the north pole leaning toward the lamp at every position.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: More accurate seasonal setup; Problem in B; Key feature

  • a: Model A
  • b: No alternating tilt relation
  • c: Fixed spatial axis direction
  • d: Model B
Answer: More accurate seasonal setup → Model A; Problem in B → No alternating tilt relation; Key feature → Fixed spatial axis direction

A produces alternating hemispheric sunlight conditions.

2B · Open ended

Choose the model and explain why the other misses the annual change.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Model A. Model B keeps the same hemisphere toward the Sun at every position instead of changing the relation through the orbit.

  1. Chooses Model A.
  2. Model B keeps the same hemisphere toward the Sun at every position instead of changing the relation through the orbit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional planet has a tilted axis that keeps its direction through a circular orbit. Its two hemispheres receive opposite changes in sunlight angle and day length.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies expected broad pattern in this case?

  • a: Opposite seasonal timing
  • b: Identical seasons everywhere
  • c: No tilt
  • d: A different star each month
Answer: Opposite seasonal timing

A circular orbit can still have tilt-driven seasonal differences.

3B · Short answer

Explain how this world can have seasons despite a circular orbit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Its fixed axial tilt changes the hemispheres’ sunlight angle and daylight duration through the orbit. A changing star-distance is not required in the stated circular-orbit model.

  1. Its fixed axial tilt changes the hemispheres’ sunlight angle and daylight duration through the orbit.
  2. A changing star-distance is not required in the stated circular-orbit model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “The tilt diagram proves it will rain at our Philippine school tomorrow.” The diagram contains no local weather data.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Unsupported claim; Changing seasonal relationship explained by the diagram; Missing information

  • a: Tomorrow’s local rain
  • b: Broad seasonal sunlight geometry
  • c: Relevant local weather observations and forecast
  • d: Earth has a tilt
Answer: Unsupported claim → Tomorrow’s local rain; Changing seasonal relationship explained by the diagram → Broad seasonal sunlight geometry; Missing information → Relevant local weather observations and forecast

A broad seasonal model cannot determine a specific local rain event.

4B · Open ended

Explain the mismatch and identify the evidence needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: A seasonal tilt diagram does not predict tomorrow’s local rainfall. Relevant local weather observations and a current forecast are needed.

  1. A seasonal tilt diagram does not predict tomorrow’s local rainfall.
  2. Relevant local weather observations and a current forecast are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Use a virtual lamp and tilted globe. Show two opposite orbital positions, keep the lamp on and hold the tilt direction in space. What will you compare?

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies useful comparison in this case?

  • a: Northern versus southern sunlight
  • b: Only globe colour
  • c: North always toward lamp
  • d: Exact rain tomorrow
Answer: Northern versus southern sunlight

The model should show opposite hemispheric geometry while preserving tilt direction.

5B · Open ended

Describe the two-position demonstration and one limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compares hemispheric illumination at opposite orbital positions while preserving the tilt direction. States that sizes/times may be simplified or that local weather is not predicted.

  1. Compares hemispheric illumination at opposite orbital positions while preserving the tilt direction.
  2. States that sizes/times may be simplified or that local weather is not predicted.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.4 · Solar system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find Earth’s neighbours

Worked-example information

A planet list reads Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune.

Question: Which two planets neighbour Earth in this order?

Answer: Venus and Mars.

Why: The question concerns order from the Sun, not the closest planet at every moment.

Example 2 · A distance model
Model scale
Distance unitsDisplay cm
21
84
126

Worked-example information

A fictional display uses 1 cm for 2 distance units. An object is 12 units from the centre.

Question: Where should its marker be?

Answer: 6 cm from the centre.

Why: 12 ÷ 2 = 6.

Example 3 · Not all bright points are stars

Worked-example information

A planet appears bright because sunlight reflects from it.

Question: Does brightness alone make it a star?

Answer: No.

Why: How the light is produced or reflected matters, not only appearance.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify the objects

Fixed case information

The source identifies Sun as a star, Earth as a planet, Moon as a natural satellite and Pluto as a dwarf planet.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Star: Sun.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

These labels identify different object roles.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read planet order

Fixed case information

The supplied order is Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies fourth planet in order in this case?

  • a: Mars
  • b: Venus
  • c: Mercury
  • d: Jupiter
Answer: Mars

Count positions in the supplied order rather than using icon size.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F3 · Compare model distances

Fixed case information

Fictional orbital distances are A=3, B=7 and C=12 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Largest distance; Smallest distance; B-to-C difference

  • a: C
  • b: A
  • c: 5 units
  • d: All equal
Answer: Largest distance → C; Smallest distance → A; B-to-C difference → 5 units

Distance values determine the order and gaps.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · A model with enlarged icons

Fixed case information

A poster spaces objects using a distance scale but enlarges the planet icons so they can be seen. The legend discloses this.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Accurate represented feature; Deliberately altered feature; Needed disclosure

  • a: Scaled distances
  • b: Icon sizes
  • c: Different size and distance scales
  • d: All sizes exact
Answer: Accurate represented feature → Scaled distances; Deliberately altered feature → Icon sizes; Needed disclosure → Different size and distance scales

Separate scales can be useful when stated clearly.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain nested systems

Fixed case information

Earth is a planet in the solar system. The solar system lies in the Milky Way, which contains many stars and other matter.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain how Earth, the solar system and the Milky Way are related.

Example of a full-credit answer: Earth is a planet within the solar system. The solar system is within the much larger Milky Way galaxy.

  1. Earth is a planet within the solar system.
  2. The solar system is within the much larger Milky Way galaxy.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional model uses 1 cm for 4 distance units. Objects A and B are at 8 and 28 units from the star.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: B display distance: 7 cm
  • b: A display distance: 2 cm
  • c: B display distance: 28 cm
  • d: A display distance: 20 cm
Answer: B display distance: 7 cm; A display distance: 2 cm

Divide each distance by four; the resulting gap is 7 − 2 = 5 cm.

1B · Open ended

Calculate both display positions and the gap between them.

Example of a full-credit answer: Places A at 2 cm and B at 7 cm. Calculates a 5 cm gap using the common scale.

  1. Places A at 2 cm and B at 7 cm.
  2. Calculates a 5 cm gap using the common scale.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Model A labels its enlarged objects and proportional distances. Model B claims evenly spaced icons show exact real spacing but supplies no scale.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? More honest model: Model A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

A clear model communicates what its visual features mean.

2B · Short answer

Choose a model and justify the choice using its treatment of scale.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. It explains which distances are scaled and which object sizes are enlarged.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. It explains which distances are scaled and which object sizes are enlarged.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional star has planets at 2, 6 and 18 distance units. The task is to compare distance ratios, not actual exoplanet measurements.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies outer-to-inner ratio in this case?

  • a: 9
  • b: 16
  • c: 24
  • d: 3
Answer: 9

The outer-to-inner distance ratio is 18 ÷ 2 = 9.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the outer-to-inner ratio and explain why equal icon gaps would be misleading.

Example of a full-credit answer: The outer distance is nine times the inner distance. The numerical gaps are unequal, so equal spacing would not represent them on a linear scale.

  1. The outer distance is nine times the inner distance.
  2. The numerical gaps are unequal, so equal spacing would not represent them on a linear scale.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner labels the Sun and eight planets “the whole Milky Way.” The source says the Milky Way contains many stars and planetary systems.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Error in the learner’s label; Correct smaller system; Larger category containing many planetary systems

  • a: Calling one planetary system an entire galaxy
  • b: Solar system
  • c: A galaxy containing many stars
  • d: One cell
Answer: Error in the learner’s label → Calling one planetary system an entire galaxy; Correct smaller system → Solar system; Larger category containing many planetary systems → A galaxy containing many stars

The learner has confused a planetary system with a galaxy.

4B · Short answer

Correct the label and explain the difference in membership.

Example of a full-credit answer: The Sun and its associated planets belong to the solar system. The Milky Way contains many stars and systems, including ours.

  1. The Sun and its associated planets belong to the solar system.
  2. The Milky Way contains many stars and systems, including ours.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A classroom strip is 30 cm long. Fictional objects lie 10, 30 and 60 distance units from a star at one end. Choose a scale that fits all and label enlarged symbols honestly.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Scale that fits exactly; Farthest marker; Required note

  • a: 1 cm represents 2 units
  • b: 30 cm
  • c: Object icons enlarged separately
  • d: 1 cm represents 1 unit
Answer: Scale that fits exactly → 1 cm represents 2 units; Farthest marker → 30 cm; Required note → Object icons enlarged separately

At two units per centimetre, the farthest object fits at 30 cm.

5B · Open ended

Propose a workable scale and state how you will label object size.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 2 units/cm: markers are 5, 15 and 30 cm; label planet icons as enlarged.

  1. Chooses a scale that places the 60-unit object within 30 cm, with correct positions.
  2. Discloses if object symbols are enlarged or use a different scale from distances.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.5 · Stars

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Star or reflector?

Worked-example information

Object A produces light through its own stellar processes; Object B reflects a nearby star’s light.

Question: Which is described as a star?

Answer: Object A.

Why: The source of the light distinguishes the roles.

Example 2 · Equal output, different distance
Toy brightness
OutputDistanceReceived units
3634

Worked-example information

A toy light rule says received brightness is output divided by distance squared. Output is 36 units; distance is 3 units.

Question: What brightness does the toy rule give?

Answer: 4 units.

Why: 36 ÷ 3² = 4. The assumptions exclude absorption.

Example 3 · A caption changes interpretation

Worked-example information

An astronomy image says colours were assigned to different measured wavelengths.

Question: Must it look exactly that way to unaided eyes?

Answer: No.

Why: Assigned colours communicate data and need the caption.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify the stellar process

Fixed case information

A source says a stable Sun-like star fuses hydrogen nuclei into helium and releases energy.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Main stable-stage process; Starting nuclei named; Product named

  • a: Nuclear fusion
  • b: Hydrogen
  • c: Helium
  • d: Burning wood
Answer: Main stable-stage process → Nuclear fusion; Starting nuclei named → Hydrogen; Product named → Helium

Fusion differs from ordinary chemical combustion.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Read a temperature table

Fixed case information

Fictional stars A, B and C have surface temperatures 3000, 6000 and 12000 K.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Hottest listed star: C
  • b: Coolest listed star: A
  • c: Hottest listed star: A
  • d: Coolest listed star: All equal
Answer: Hottest listed star: C; Coolest listed star: A

Compare the supplied temperature values; these are teaching stars.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Separate two brightness ideas

Fixed case information

A card defines luminosity as emitted energy per time and apparent brightness as received light at the observer.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies intrinsic output in this case?

  • a: Luminosity
  • b: Apparent brightness
  • c: Only the observer’s name
  • d: No separation exists
Answer: Luminosity

Emission and reception are related but different quantities.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F4 · Read an image caption

Fixed case information

A fictional scientific image assigns red to one infrared band and blue to another. These are display colours, not claimed naked-eye colours.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Quantities represented by the display colours; Document explaining the colour key; Natural-colour claim not justified by this method

  • a: Measured-band labels
  • b: Image caption
  • c: Exact naked-eye appearance
  • d: The image uses assigned display colours
Answer: Quantities represented by the display colours → Measured-band labels; Document explaining the colour key → Image caption; Natural-colour claim not justified by this method → Exact naked-eye appearance

The labels explain what the chosen display colours encode.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a nearby bright object

Fixed case information

Two fictional stars have equal luminosity. One is nearer, and the supplied model has no absorption. The nearer one appears brighter.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain the brightness difference and identify the property kept equal.

Example of a full-credit answer: The nearer star’s light is spread over a smaller area at the observer, so it appears brighter in the model. The two stars have equal luminosity.

  1. The nearer star’s light is spread over a smaller area at the observer, so it appears brighter in the model.
  2. The two stars have equal luminosity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy rule gives received brightness = luminosity ÷ distance². Star A has luminosity 80 and distance 4; Star B has luminosity 20 and distance 2. Ignore absorption.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

What received brightness does the model give for Star A?

  • a: 5 units
  • b: 20 units
  • c: 10 units
  • d: 4 units
Answer: 5 units

80/16 = 5 and 20/4 = 5; intrinsic outputs differ despite equal received values.

1B · Short answer

Calculate both received brightness values and explain what this says about apparent brightness versus luminosity.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both received values are 5 units under the rule. Equal apparent brightness does not require equal luminosity because distances differ.

  1. Both received values are 5 units under the rule.
  2. Equal apparent brightness does not require equal luminosity because distances differ.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Record A provides calibrated spectra and a stated temperature model. Record B guesses temperature from an unlabeled decorative colour image.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Stronger evidence; Useful method; Weakness of B

  • a: Record A
  • b: Calibrated spectrum
  • c: Colour meaning is unknown
  • d: Record B
Answer: Stronger evidence → Record A; Useful method → Calibrated spectrum; Weakness of B → Colour meaning is unknown

A measured spectrum with an explained model is more informative than unexplained colours.

2B · Open ended

Choose the record and justify the role of its measurement information.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Record A. It supplies calibrated spectral evidence and an interpretation method, unlike unknown display colours.

  1. Chooses Record A.
  2. It supplies calibrated spectral evidence and an interpretation method, unlike unknown display colours.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Two equal virtual lamps are placed at distances 1 and 3. The toy inverse-square rule excludes absorption.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Far-to-near brightness ratio: 1/9.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Tripling distance spreads the same output over nine times the area in this model.

3B · Short answer

State the brightness ratio and explain why this lamp model is relevant to stars.

Example of a full-credit answer: The farther lamp has one ninth the received brightness. It illustrates how distance affects received light from equal-output sources under the stated assumptions.

  1. The farther lamp has one ninth the received brightness.
  2. It illustrates how distance affects received light from equal-output sources under the stated assumptions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “The Sun needs air from Earth to keep its chemical fire burning.” The source describes nuclear fusion in the Sun’s core.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Main error: Treating the Sun as an air-fed chemical fire
  • b: Relevant process: Nuclear fusion
  • c: Main error: The Sun emits energy
  • d: Relevant process: Only evaporation
Answer: Main error: Treating the Sun as an air-fed chemical fire; Relevant process: Nuclear fusion

The Sun’s stable shining is not an oxygen-fed fire supplied by Earth.

4B · Open ended

Identify the misconception and give the correct energy-source description.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rejects an Earth-air-fed chemical fire. Names nuclear fusion in the Sun’s core as its main stable-stage energy source.

  1. Rejects an Earth-air-fed chemical fire.
  2. Names nuclear fusion in the Sun’s core as its main stable-stage energy source.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Use two identical virtual light sources to investigate distance. You can change distance and measure received brightness. No absorption is included.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Variable to change; Condition to keep; Outcome to measure

  • a: Distance
  • b: Source luminosity
  • c: Received brightness
  • d: Source type and distance together
Answer: Variable to change → Distance; Condition to keep → Source luminosity; Outcome to measure → Received brightness

Holding output equal isolates the distance relationship in the model.

5B · Open ended

Describe a fair comparison and state one limit of using it for real stars.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keeps the light sources’ output equal while comparing distances and recording received brightness. Notes real stars may differ in luminosity or have intervening absorption, and the toy model is simplified.

  1. Keeps the light sources’ output equal while comparing distances and recording received brightness.
  2. Notes real stars may differ in luminosity or have intervening absorption, and the toy model is simplified.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.6 · Galaxies

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Nested locations

Worked-example information

A card reads Earth → solar system → Milky Way.

Question: What does the sequence mean?

Answer: Earth lies in the solar system, which lies in the Milky Way.

Why: It shows containment, not the order of creation.

Example 2 · Two light-travel distances
Fictional objects
ObjectLight-years
Near20
Far80

Worked-example information

Fictional objects are 20 and 80 light-years away. Ignore motion during travel.

Question: Which light has travelled longer, and by how much?

Answer: The 80-light-year object’s light, by about 60 years.

Why: The travel-time comparison follows the given distances.

Example 3 · Turn a disk

Worked-example information

A circular model is viewed from above and then from its edge.

Question: Why does its outline change?

Answer: The viewing angle changes.

Why: The object need not change its physical shape.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Place the systems

Fixed case information

The source says Earth is a planet, the solar system contains the Sun and associated objects, and the Milky Way contains many stars including the Sun.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies planet in this case?

  • a: Earth
  • b: Milky Way
  • c: A single leaf
  • d: Only Earth’s Moon
Answer: Earth

These are different organisation scales.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Compare teaching diameters

Fixed case information

Fictional galaxy models A, B and C have labelled diameters 20, 50 and 100 scale units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Largest diameter; Smallest diameter; B diameter

  • a: C
  • b: A
  • c: 50 units
  • d: All equal
Answer: Largest diameter → C; Smallest diameter → A; B diameter → 50 units

Read numerical diameters instead of screen icon size.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F3 · Viewpoint changes appearance

Fixed case information

A disk model looks round face-on and narrow edge-on. Its dimensions have not changed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Cause of appearance change: Viewpoint.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Projection can change appearance without physical loss.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · A light-year label

Fixed case information

A display defines light-year as the distance light travels in one year.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Quantity measured: Distance
  • b: Useful context: Large space separations
  • c: Quantity measured: Time only
  • d: Useful context: Human body mass
Answer: Quantity measured: Distance; Useful context: Large space separations

The word year appears in its definition, but the unit measures distance.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F5 · Explain an image limit

Fixed case information

A galaxy image has no distance estimate or scale bar. A learner claims its screen width gives its exact real diameter.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the claim cannot follow and identify the missing information.

Example of a full-credit answer: Screen width alone does not establish real diameter. A distance/scale relation and suitable measurement method are needed.

  1. Screen width alone does not establish real diameter.
  2. A distance/scale relation and suitable measurement method are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Two fictional galaxy diagrams have physical diameter labels A=40,000 units and B=120,000 units. The display icons are equal width.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies b-to-a diameter ratio in this case?

  • a: 3
  • b: 1
  • c: Both physical sizes equal
  • d: A is larger
Answer: 3

120,000 ÷ 40,000 = 3; equal icons need not mean equal objects.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the diameter ratio and explain the equal-width icons.

Example of a full-credit answer: B’s labelled diameter is three times A’s. Equal screen widths can use different scales and do not prove equal real size.

  1. B’s labelled diameter is three times A’s.
  2. Equal screen widths can use different scales and do not prove equal real size.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A disk-galaxy model appears narrow in one view. Explanation A says it may be edge-on; B says its stars must all have disappeared because it looks thin.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Better supported possibility; Evidence to seek; Problem with B

  • a: Edge-on view
  • b: Other shape and orientation information
  • c: Confuses projection with disappearance
  • d: All stars disappeared
Answer: Better supported possibility → Edge-on view; Evidence to seek → Other shape and orientation information; Problem with B → Confuses projection with disappearance

Viewing angle is a plausible explanation that should be checked with more evidence.

2B · Short answer

Choose the better explanation and describe why it is more cautious.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the possible edge-on orientation. It explains the projection without asserting unobserved material disappearance and allows further checking.

  1. Chooses the possible edge-on orientation.
  2. It explains the projection without asserting unobserved material disappearance and allows further checking.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A diagram contains three galaxies, each with many stars. One star has a planetary system.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Member of the stated three-galaxy group; Central luminous object of the planetary system; Object orbiting that star

  • a: A galaxy
  • b: A star
  • c: A planet
  • d: A single proton only
Answer: Member of the stated three-galaxy group → A galaxy; Central luminous object of the planetary system → A star; Object orbiting that star → A planet

The hierarchy remains valid in a different named system.

3B · Open ended

Explain two containment relationships in this fictional group.

Example of a full-credit answer: A planetary system is associated with one star within a galaxy. The galaxy is one of the three members of the group.

  1. A planetary system is associated with one star within a galaxy.
  2. The galaxy is one of the three members of the group.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “This galaxy is 2 million light-years old,” using a distance label as its age. No age measurement is supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Error; Distance stated by the corrected label; Missing property

  • a: Distance used as age
  • b: 2 million light-years away
  • c: Galaxy’s age
  • d: A distance is supplied
Answer: Error → Distance used as age; Distance stated by the corrected label → 2 million light-years away; Missing property → Galaxy’s age

A light-year distance is not itself an object’s formation age.

4B · Short answer

Correct the label and explain why it does not establish the galaxy’s age.

Example of a full-credit answer: The label means a distance of 2 million light-years. Distance/light-travel information does not by itself tell when the galaxy formed.

  1. The label means a distance of 2 million light-years.
  2. Distance/light-travel information does not by itself tell when the galaxy formed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class wants to compare two galaxy models’ shapes and sizes. It has diameter numbers and illustrations drawn at different scales.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Needed size comparison: A common scale or numeric ratios
  • b: Needed shape label: Viewpoint information
  • c: Needed size comparison: Equal icon width only
  • d: Needed shape label: No captions
Answer: Needed size comparison: A common scale or numeric ratios; Needed shape label: Viewpoint information

A good display separates physical size from viewpoint and artistic rendering.

5B · Open ended

Propose how to display size and one note preventing a shape misinterpretation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses a common diameter scale or clearly labelled numeric ratios. Labels viewpoint and/or notes that shape appearance can depend on orientation and simplification.

  1. Uses a common diameter scale or clearly labelled numeric ratios.
  2. Labels viewpoint and/or notes that shape appearance can depend on orientation and simplification.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.7 · Planet formation

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Merge two pieces

Worked-example information

A closed toy model combines masses 4 and 7 units with no loss.

Question: What is the new mass?

Answer: 11 units.

Why: The masses add even though two objects become one.

Example 2 · Count and mass differ
Before merging
PieceMass units
A1
B2
C3

Worked-example information

Three pieces of masses 1, 2 and 3 merge into one.

Question: What happens to object count and total mass?

Answer: Count changes from 3 to 1; total mass stays 6.

Why: The two quantities must not be confused.

Example 3 · A rule is not a universal fact

Worked-example information

A simulation makes all collisions stick.

Question: Does that establish every real collision sticks?

Answer: No.

Why: It is a chosen model assumption; real collisions can have other outcomes.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Order a growth model

Fixed case information

A simplified model begins with small solids, forms larger clumps and then larger gravitationally bound bodies.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? First material: A fully formed planet first.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Accretion describes growth by gathering material.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · A closed merger

Fixed case information

Two toy bodies with masses 5 and 8 merge with no mass loss.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: New mass; Starting object count; Final object count

  • a: 13 units
  • b: Two
  • c: One
  • d: 3 units
Answer: New mass → 13 units; Starting object count → Two; Final object count → One

5 + 8 = 13 while object count decreases.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Temperature zones

Fixed case information

A supplied disk model has inner zone 700 K and outer zone 150 K. Its rule permits a named model ice to remain solid only below 200 K.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Zone allowing that ice; Colder temperature; Rule threshold

  • a: Outer zone
  • b: 150 K
  • c: Below 200 K
  • d: Inner zone
Answer: Zone allowing that ice → Outer zone; Colder temperature → 150 K; Rule threshold → Below 200 K

Apply the given temperature rule to the stated model.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Different collision outcomes

Fixed case information

A source says collisions may merge pieces, bounce or break pieces. A toy simulation uses only merging.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies included outcome in this case?

  • a: Merging
  • b: Every outcome included
  • c: No physical interaction
  • d: Complete proof of all planets
Answer: Merging

The chosen simulation rule does not include every real collision outcome.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a number change

Fixed case information

Four toy particles of 2 mass units each merge into one body. No matter leaves the model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain what changed and what stayed the same.

Example of a full-credit answer: The number of bodies changed from four to one. Total mass stayed 8 units because no matter left.

  1. The number of bodies changed from four to one.
  2. Total mass stayed 8 units because no matter left.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy body starts at 9 mass units. It collects pieces of 4 and 6, while 2 units escape the model boundary.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Final body mass; Collected mass; Escaping mass

  • a: 17 units
  • b: 10 units
  • c: 2 units
  • d: 21 units
Answer: Final body mass → 17 units; Collected mass → 10 units; Escaping mass → 2 units

9 + 4 + 6 − 2 = 17.

1B · Short answer

Calculate final mass and explain why the closed-model sum must be adjusted.

Example of a full-credit answer: The final mass is 17 units. Subtracts the 2 units that leave the chosen boundary.

  1. The final mass is 17 units.
  2. Subtracts the 2 units that leave the chosen boundary.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Statement A says the model explores sticking collisions without claiming all collisions stick. B says the model proves every planet formed by exactly its animation.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies more defensible statement in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Both statements
  • d: Neither statement
Answer: A

Stating a model’s assumption keeps its interpretation within evidence.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger statement and justify why its limit matters.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Real collisions and histories vary, so a sticking-only model cannot prove every exact formation history.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Real collisions and histories vary, so a sticking-only model cannot prove every exact formation history.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional disk has zones at 180 K and 260 K. Its supplied material rule says solid grains of type X persist below 220 K.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Zone retaining X: 180 K zone.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The rule transfers to new values: 180 is below 220, 260 above.

3B · Short answer

Identify where X can remain solid and explain using the threshold.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the 180 K zone. 180 K is below 220 K while 260 K is above it under the supplied rule.

  1. Chooses the 180 K zone.
  2. 180 K is below 220 K while 260 K is above it under the supplied rule.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says, “Six particles merged into two clumps, so four units of mass disappeared.” The particles had unequal masses and no material escaped.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Error: Confusing count with mass
  • b: Conserved quantity: Total mass
  • c: Error: No error
  • d: Conserved quantity: Only object count conserved
Answer: Error: Confusing count with mass; Conserved quantity: Total mass

A difference in object count is not a mass loss.

4B · Open ended

Explain the count–mass confusion and state the correct conservation claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Subtracting object counts does not calculate mass loss. With no escaping material, the total mass remains unchanged after merging.

  1. Subtracting object counts does not calculate mass loss.
  2. With no escaping material, the total mass remains unchanged after merging.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Use six counters with known masses. Your toy rule may merge colliding counters but must conserve mass unless a labelled piece leaves.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Record before; Record after; Required disclosure

  • a: Each starting mass
  • b: Mass of each clump and any loss
  • c: Chosen collision rule
  • d: Only counter colour
Answer: Record before → Each starting mass; Record after → Mass of each clump and any loss; Required disclosure → Chosen collision rule

A transparent model records material and makes its assumption visible.

5B · Open ended

Propose a mass-checking procedure and state one limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Adds starting masses and compares them with final clumps plus any labelled departing mass. Notes the toy collision rule simplifies real accretion or does not reproduce an entire planet history.

  1. Adds starting masses and compares them with final clumps plus any labelled departing mass.
  2. Notes the toy collision rule simplifies real accretion or does not reproduce an entire planet history.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.8 · Stellar evolution

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Different lifetimes
Model lifetimes
StarTime units
A12
B90

Worked-example information

A fictional teaching table gives star A a lifetime of 12 units and B a lifetime of 90 units.

Question: How much longer does B last in the table?

Answer: 78 units longer.

Why: Subtract 12 from 90; these are invented teaching values.

Example 2 · Choose the branch

Worked-example information

A source gives the Sun-like route as main sequence → red giant → shed outer layers → white dwarf.

Question: What comes after outer layers are shed?

Answer: A white dwarf remains.

Why: The stated route must not be replaced with the high-mass supernova route.

Example 3 · A misleading animation

Worked-example information

Four life-stage cards each stay on screen for two seconds. No physical time scale is provided.

Question: Does each real stage last the same time?

Answer: No.

Why: Equal display time is a design choice, not a measurement of stellar duration.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Order early stages

Fixed case information

The supplied sequence is contracting gas → protostar → sustained hydrogen fusion in a main-sequence star.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Before sustained fusion; Energy process in main sequence; Gathering force

  • a: Protostar
  • b: Nuclear fusion
  • c: Gravity
  • d: White dwarf first
Answer: Before sustained fusion → Protostar; Energy process in main sequence → Nuclear fusion; Gathering force → Gravity

The stage names and processes have different roles.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Compare fictional lifetimes

Fixed case information

A teaching table lists a high-mass model at 8 lifetime units and a lower-mass model at 120.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Longer-lived model: Lower-mass model
  • b: Shorter lifetime: 8 units
  • c: Longer-lived model: High-mass model
  • d: Shorter lifetime: 128 units
Answer: Longer-lived model: Lower-mass model; Shorter lifetime: 8 units

The supplied data show that more mass need not mean longer life.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Follow the Sun-like branch

Fixed case information

The source route is main sequence → red giant → shedding outer layers → white dwarf.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies late compact remnant in this case?

  • a: White dwarf
  • b: Black hole in every case
  • c: A new Moon
  • d: All matter disappears
Answer: White dwarf

Use the stated Sun-like route.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F4 · Interpret a snapshot

Fixed case information

A prepared image identifies a star as a red giant. It does not show every earlier stage directly.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies directly represented stage in this case?

  • a: Red giant
  • b: Every stage directly filmed
  • c: No evidence can be used
  • d: A complete future schedule
Answer: Red giant

A snapshot and an inferred history are different kinds of information.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a branch error

Fixed case information

A learner puts the Sun on a diagram saying every star ends as a black hole. The supplied Sun-like route ends with a cooling white dwarf.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Correct the Sun’s ending and identify the property that helps explain the different routes.

Example of a full-credit answer: The Sun-like route leaves a white dwarf, not a black hole. Starting mass strongly affects the stellar pathway.

  1. The Sun-like route leaves a white dwarf, not a black hole.
  2. Starting mass strongly affects the stellar pathway.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Fictional stars P and Q have lifetimes 6 and 48 time units. P is the more massive model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Longer-lived star; Lifetime ratio Q to P; Unsupported rule

  • a: Q
  • b: 8
  • c: More mass always means longer life
  • d: P
Answer: Longer-lived star → Q; Lifetime ratio Q to P → 8; Unsupported rule → More mass always means longer life

48 ÷ 6 = 8, and the table contradicts the stated always-rule.

1B · Open ended

Compare the lifetimes and explain why more fuel alone is an incomplete explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Q lasts eight times as long in the supplied table. A massive star can use fuel much faster, so fuel amount alone does not determine lifetime.

  1. Q lasts eight times as long in the supplied table.
  2. A massive star can use fuel much faster, so fuel amount alone does not determine lifetime.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Diagram A has separate Sun-like and high-mass branches. Diagram B gives every star the same black-hole ending.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Better diagram: A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The branch structure represents a physical difference.

2B · Short answer

Choose the diagram and explain the scientific reason for its branches.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Mass affects life history and outcomes, so a single black-hole ending is inappropriate.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Mass affects life history and outcomes, so a single black-hole ending is inappropriate.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A source explicitly assigns fictional star T to the Sun-like pathway: giant, outer-layer shedding, white dwarf. No numerical age is given.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Expected remnant in source: White dwarf
  • b: Preceding event: Outer-layer shedding
  • c: Expected remnant in source: Black hole necessarily
  • d: Preceding event: All material erased
Answer: Expected remnant in source: White dwarf; Preceding event: Outer-layer shedding

Apply the assigned pathway without inventing a date.

3B · Open ended

State the expected remnant and one fact the supplied pathway cannot tell you.

Example of a full-credit answer: A white dwarf is the expected remnant under the assigned pathway. The pathway alone does not supply the exact age or date of transition.

  1. A white dwarf is the expected remnant under the assigned pathway.
  2. The pathway alone does not supply the exact age or date of transition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner measures equal gaps between stage icons and concludes the real stages have equal durations. The caption says “order only; no time scale.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Error; What diagram supplies; Needed for duration

  • a: Graphic spacing treated as duration
  • b: Stage order
  • c: Labelled time information
  • d: Star names only
Answer: Error → Graphic spacing treated as duration; What diagram supplies → Stage order; Needed for duration → Labelled time information

A sequence diagram does not automatically measure time.

4B · Short answer

Identify the error and explain what additional information a duration comparison requires.

Example of a full-credit answer: Equal icon spacing cannot establish equal real stage durations. Needs explicit time labels or suitable duration data.

  1. Equal icon spacing cannot establish equal real stage durations.
  2. Needs explicit time labels or suitable duration data.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Create an exhibit with one Sun-like route and one much-more-massive route. It must explain a difference and warn that the pictures are not a clock.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Essential structure; Reason for difference; Needed caption

  • a: Two labelled branches
  • b: Mass affects evolution
  • c: Sequence not to time scale
  • d: One ending for all
Answer: Essential structure → Two labelled branches; Reason for difference → Mass affects evolution; Needed caption → Sequence not to time scale

The exhibit should communicate both pathways and the diagram’s limit.

5B · Open ended

Propose the two branches and one clear timing warning.

Example of a full-credit answer: Includes a Sun-like giant-to-white-dwarf branch and a high-mass possible supernova-to-compact-remnant branch. States that spacing or animation time is not the real duration of each stage.

  1. Includes a Sun-like giant-to-white-dwarf branch and a high-mass possible supernova-to-compact-remnant branch.
  2. States that spacing or animation time is not the real duration of each stage.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.9 · Origin of the solar system

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Sort two histories
Approximate timeline
EventBillion years ago
Early hot universe13.8
Solar-system formation4.6

Worked-example information

A source gives the universe’s age as about 13.8 billion years and solar-system formation about 4.6 billion years ago.

Question: Which event is later?

Answer: Solar-system formation.

Why: A smaller number of years ago is more recent.

Example 2 · Keep a disk budget

Worked-example information

A fictional disk model has 100 mass units: 92 gather centrally, 6 enter orbiting bodies and 2 leave the boundary.

Question: Is its mass accounting complete?

Answer: Yes: 92 + 6 + 2 = 100.

Why: The toy values illustrate accounting, not the Sun’s measured mass share.

Example 3 · Evidence or animation?

Worked-example information

A telescope records a disk around a young star; a classroom animation shows one possible development.

Question: Which is the direct observation?

Answer: The telescope’s disk record.

Why: The animation represents a model that must be checked.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the starting material

Fixed case information

The supplied formation model begins with interstellar gas and dust that gathers under gravity. The rotating material develops a disk.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Starting material; Gathering interaction; Resulting broad structure

  • a: Gas and dust
  • b: Gravity
  • c: Rotating disk
  • d: Finished planets only
Answer: Starting material → Gas and dust; Gathering interaction → Gravity; Resulting broad structure → Rotating disk

The model links starting material and a gathering process.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Compare ages

Fixed case information

The source gives universe age about 13.8 billion years and solar-system age about 4.6 billion years.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Older system: Universe.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The universe predates the solar system in the supplied estimates.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Material paths

Fixed case information

A toy formation budget allocates 90 mass units centrally, 7 to orbiting bodies and 3 outside the boundary.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Largest share; Orbiting share; Accounted total

  • a: Central object
  • b: 7 units
  • c: 100 units
  • d: Orbiting bodies
Answer: Largest share → Central object; Orbiting share → 7 units; Accounted total → 100 units

90 + 7 + 3 = 100 in this fictional budget.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F4 · Sort the clues

Fixed case information

A prepared evidence pack contains a young-star disk image, meteorite dates and a decorative painting with no measurements.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies direct disk evidence in this case?

  • a: Telescope image
  • b: Decorative painting
  • c: Only a frame colour
  • d: A dated material sample
Answer: Telescope image

Different evidence types answer different questions.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain an animation’s status

Fixed case information

A twenty-second video shows cloud, disk and planets. The label says it illustrates a scientific model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain what the video can illustrate and what its running time cannot establish.

Example of a full-credit answer: It can illustrate a formation sequence or relationships among stages. Its twenty-second duration does not measure real formation time.

  1. It can illustrate a formation sequence or relationships among stages.
  2. Its twenty-second duration does not measure real formation time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional disk starts with 80 mass units. It leaves 5 in small bodies and loses 3 beyond the boundary; the rest enters a central object and planets.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies mass in central object and planets in this case?

  • a: 72 units
  • b: 88 units
  • c: 75 units
  • d: 8 units retained in the main bodies
Answer: 72 units

80 − 5 − 3 = 72; no mass is created.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the main-body mass and explain why the departing material must be counted.

Example of a full-credit answer: The main bodies contain 72 mass units. The 3 units crossed the model boundary and cannot also remain in the main bodies.

  1. The main bodies contain 72 mass units.
  2. The 3 units crossed the model boundary and cannot also remain in the main bodies.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Explanation A combines disk observations, ancient material dates and a physical growth model. B uses only a beautiful picture and says its exact story cannot be questioned.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Stronger explanation: A
  • b: Useful check: Compare predictions with measurements
  • c: Stronger explanation: B
  • d: Useful check: Choose the prettiest image
Answer: Stronger explanation: A; Useful check: Compare predictions with measurements

The strength comes from relevant evidence and testability.

2B · Open ended

Choose the explanation and identify how its claim can be checked.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Its predicted structures or timing can be compared with disk observations and dated material evidence.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Its predicted structures or timing can be compared with disk observations and dated material evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A telescope detects gas and dust in a flattened rotating disk around a young star. The record does not yet identify planets or their future paths.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Supported observation; Plausible research question; Future numerical property not yet established

  • a: A disk is present
  • b: Whether bodies are forming
  • c: Exact future planet count
  • d: A complete planet history is known
Answer: Supported observation → A disk is present; Plausible research question → Whether bodies are forming; Future numerical property not yet established → Exact future planet count

A disk supports investigation without fixing every future outcome.

3B · Short answer

State what is observed and one future claim that remains unestablished.

Example of a full-credit answer: A gas-and-dust disk around a young star is observed. The exact future number or paths of planets are not established by that record alone.

  1. A gas-and-dust disk around a young star is observed.
  2. The exact future number or paths of planets are not established by that record alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A poster says the Sun formed at the same time as the universe. Its own data list 13.8 billion years for the universe and 4.6 billion years for the solar system.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Error; Later event; Difference in supplied ages

  • a: Different formation times treated as equal
  • b: Solar-system formation
  • c: 9.2 billion years
  • d: Both dates are equal
Answer: Error → Different formation times treated as equal; Later event → Solar-system formation; Difference in supplied ages → 9.2 billion years

The poster contradicts its stated estimates.

4B · Open ended

Correct the event order and support the correction with the supplied ages.

Example of a full-credit answer: The universe’s early history came before solar-system formation. Uses 13.8 versus 4.6 billion years, or their 9.2-billion-year difference.

  1. The universe’s early history came before solar-system formation.
  2. Uses 13.8 versus 4.6 billion years, or their 9.2-billion-year difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Make a three-stage cloud–disk–growing-bodies display. It must identify one real kind of evidence and one limitation of the model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies required stage order in this case?

  • a: Cloud then disk then growing bodies
  • b: Planets before starting material
  • c: Only decoration
  • d: The exact whole history was filmed
Answer: Cloud then disk then growing bodies

A display should show both the explanation and how it is supported.

5B · Open ended

Propose the stages and an evidence/limitation caption.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives a sensible cloud–disk–accreting-body sequence. Names relevant evidence and notes a limit such as simplified timing or unobserved historical detail.

  1. Gives a sensible cloud–disk–accreting-body sequence.
  2. Names relevant evidence and notes a limit such as simplified timing or unobserved historical detail.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.10 · Origin and scale of the universe

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A travel-time comparison
Local teaching example
ObjectDistance in light-years
P7
Q19

Worked-example information

In a fictional non-expanding local example, light travels from objects 7 and 19 light-years away.

Question: How much longer has the second light travelled?

Answer: About 12 years longer.

Why: Subtract 7 from 19 under the stated simplified assumptions.

Example 2 · Read a ratio scale

Worked-example information

Three scale values are 2, 20 and 200.

Question: What factor links adjacent values?

Answer: Ten.

Why: Each value is ten times the previous one, although the numerical differences are unequal.

Example 3 · Put the address in order

Worked-example information

Cards say Earth, Milky Way and solar system.

Question: What is the nesting order from smaller system to larger?

Answer: Earth → solar system → Milky Way.

Why: The planet is part of the planetary system, which is within the galaxy.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Build a cosmic address

Fixed case information

The source places Earth in the solar system and the solar system in the Milky Way.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies planet in this case?

  • a: Earth
  • b: Milky Way
  • c: A galaxy-sized planet
  • d: Only Earth’s atmosphere
Answer: Earth

The labels name different scales of structure.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Compare scale values

Fixed case information

A fictional logarithmic display has markers 1, 10 and 100 distance units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Adjacent factor: Two.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Equal ratio steps do not have equal additive differences.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F3 · Identify quantity units

Fixed case information

A record gives age 6 years, distance 6 light-years and mass 6 kilograms for three different fictional examples.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Distance unit; Age unit; Mass unit

  • a: Light-year
  • b: Year
  • c: Kilogram
  • d: Metre per second
Answer: Distance unit → Light-year; Age unit → Year; Mass unit → Kilogram

The number alone does not identify the measured quantity.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Earlier light

Fixed case information

In a simplified nearby case, objects A and B are 4 and 15 light-years away, with motion ignored.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Longer light-travel time: B
  • b: Travel-time difference: 11 years
  • c: Longer light-travel time: A
  • d: Travel-time difference: 19 years difference
Answer: Longer light-travel time: B; Travel-time difference: 11 years

More distance means longer travel time under these local assumptions.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain an observation limit

Fixed case information

A caption says “observable universe.” A learner changes it to “everything that exists inside a solid wall.” The source gives no evidence of a wall or of the total extent.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain the meaning of observable and identify the unsupported addition.

Example of a full-credit answer: Observable refers to the region accessible to observation through arriving light. A solid outer wall or total extent is not established by that caption.

  1. Observable refers to the region accessible to observation through arriving light.
  2. A solid outer wall or total extent is not established by that caption.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A scale display labels structures A=5, B=50 and C=500 fictional distance units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies c-to-a ratio in this case?

  • a: 100
  • b: 10
  • c: 495
  • d: 1
Answer: 100

C ÷ A = 500 ÷ 5 = 100. This ratio is different from the additive difference, 500 − 5 = 495 units.

1B · Open ended

Calculate C’s scale relative to A and distinguish that ratio from a difference.

Example of a full-credit answer: C is 100 times A. A ratio uses division; the additive difference C−A would be 495 units.

  1. C is 100 times A.
  2. A ratio uses division; the additive difference C−A would be 495 units.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Caption A says “20 light-years away; distance, not formation age.” B says “20 light-years old, so it formed 20 years ago.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies clearer caption in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Body temperature
  • d: A has no units
Answer: A

Travel distance does not establish when an object formed.

2B · Short answer

Choose the caption and explain the distinction it protects.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. A light-year measures distance; light travel time is not automatically the age since the object formed.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. A light-year measures distance; light travel time is not automatically the age since the object formed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

In a fictional nearby system, a pulse leaves an object 9 light-years away. Motion and expansion are ignored. Another object is 3 light-years away.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Longer journey; Travel-time difference; Scope of rule

  • a: 9-light-year object
  • b: 6 years
  • c: Simplified local example
  • d: 3-light-year object
Answer: Longer journey → 9-light-year object; Travel-time difference → 6 years; Scope of rule → Simplified local example

The simplified comparison is valid only within the stated assumptions.

3B · Open ended

Compare the travel times and state the assumption that keeps the calculation simple.

Example of a full-credit answer: The farther light takes about 6 years longer. The example ignores motion and cosmic expansion or treats it as a local simplified case.

  1. The farther light takes about 6 years longer.
  2. The example ignores motion and cosmic expansion or treats it as a local simplified case.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner sees equally spaced labels 1, 10 and 100 and says both numerical gaps are 9.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Error; Actual second gap; Shared multiplicative step

  • a: Equal picture gaps treated as equal additions
  • b: 90
  • c: Times ten
  • d: Both gaps really are 9
Answer: Error → Equal picture gaps treated as equal additions; Actual second gap → 90; Shared multiplicative step → Times ten

The second subtraction is 100 − 10 = 90.

4B · Short answer

Correct the second gap and explain what equal spacing means on this labelled scale.

Example of a full-credit answer: The second numerical gap is 90 units. Equal spacing here represents equal multiplication by ten, not equal added distance.

  1. The second numerical gap is 90 units.
  2. Equal spacing here represents equal multiplication by ten, not equal added distance.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Your guide must distinguish planet, planetary system and galaxy; label a distance unit; and warn that screen icons are simplified.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · True or false

True or false? Needed hierarchy: All three are planets.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A guide needs clear quantities and scope.

5B · Open ended

Propose the hierarchy and a caption that prevents a scale or unit mistake.

Example of a full-credit answer: Correctly places Earth within the solar system within the Milky Way. Uses a distance unit and states that icon size/gaps are simplified or that distance is not formation age.

  1. Correctly places Earth within the solar system within the Milky Way.
  2. Uses a distance unit and states that icon size/gaps are simplified or that distance is not formation age.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S10.11 · Big Bang theory

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Stretch a toy grid
Toy expansion
StartFinishIncrease
242
5105

Worked-example information

In a fictional grid, separations 2 and 5 units both double.

Question: What are the new separations?

Answer: 4 and 10 units.

Why: Multiplying by two gives the same scale factor but different increases.

Example 2 · Order broad events

Worked-example information

Cards show early hot state, atoms, first stars and the much later solar system.

Question: Which card must come before the first stars?

Answer: The early hot stage and the formation of atoms.

Why: The broad sequence does not begin with finished stars.

Example 3 · An analogy has an edge

Worked-example information

A stretching-paper model has a torn edge.

Question: Does that prove the universe has a torn outer edge?

Answer: No.

Why: The edge belongs to the paper analogy, not to evidence about cosmic structure.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify the central idea

Fixed case information

The source describes an early hot, dense universe that expanded and cooled. It rejects a bomb exploding into an existing empty room.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Central process; Earlier condition; Rejected picture

  • a: Expansion and cooling
  • b: Hot and dense
  • c: Bomb in a pre-existing room
  • d: Earth’s yearly revolution
Answer: Central process → Expansion and cooling; Earlier condition → Hot and dense; Rejected picture → Bomb in a pre-existing room

The model concerns the universe’s development and space-scale change.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Scale a grid

Fixed case information

A fictional teaching grid doubles separations A=3 and B=7 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? New B separation: 14 units.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Apply the same multiplicative expansion factor.

Scientific explorer: space scale lab

F3 · Compare evidence roles

Fixed case information

The evidence pack lists galaxy-light patterns, cosmic microwave background and light-element amounts as independent kinds of support.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Early radiation evidence: Cosmic microwave background
  • b: Composition evidence: Light-element amounts
  • c: Early radiation evidence: A classroom wall colour
  • d: Composition evidence: Only a cartoon explosion
Answer: Early radiation evidence: Cosmic microwave background; Composition evidence: Light-element amounts

The evidence types address different parts of the explanation.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Read a toy trend

Fixed case information

A toy expansion table has initial separations 1, 2, 3 and increases 2, 4, 6 after a common stretch.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Largest increase; Common increase-to-start ratio; Status of values

  • a: Pair starting at 3
  • b: Two
  • c: Fictional demonstration
  • d: Pair starting at 1
Answer: Largest increase → Pair starting at 3; Common increase-to-start ratio → Two; Status of values → Fictional demonstration

The increase grows with starting separation in this toy rule.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain the edge limitation

Fixed case information

An expanding balloon-surface analogy uses dots on the surface. A learner claims its centre and outside air prove a central explosion point and surrounding air for the universe.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State one useful feature and one misleading feature of the analogy.

Example of a full-credit answer: Growing separations between surface dots can illustrate expansion. The balloon’s centre, outside air or physical surface must not be taken as direct evidence of those cosmic features.

  1. Growing separations between surface dots can illustrate expansion.
  2. The balloon’s centre, outside air or physical surface must not be taken as direct evidence of those cosmic features.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy map changes separations 4→12 and 9→27 units during one step.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Shared scale factor; Larger absolute increase; Its increase

  • a: Three
  • b: The 9-unit pair
  • c: 18 units
  • d: Two
Answer: Shared scale factor → Three; Larger absolute increase → The 9-unit pair; Its increase → 18 units

Both multiply by three; the farther pair gains more distance.

1B · Short answer

Find the shared factor and explain why the absolute increases differ.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both separations triple. The same multiplication applied to the larger starting separation produces a larger increase: 18 versus 8.

  1. Both separations triple.
  2. The same multiplication applied to the larger starting separation produces a larger increase: 18 versus 8.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Explanation A connects expansion-related light patterns, background radiation and light-element data. B says an explosion drawing alone proves its exact history.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Stronger explanation; Positive evidence feature provided by A; Weakness of B

  • a: A
  • b: Several relevant evidence types
  • c: Drawing alone is not a measurement
  • d: B
Answer: Stronger explanation → A; Positive evidence feature provided by A → Several relevant evidence types; Weakness of B → Drawing alone is not a measurement

Different measured clues can test a common physical explanation.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger explanation and explain why the evidence combination helps.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Different types of observations check different predictions of the same explanation, unlike an illustration alone.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Different types of observations check different predictions of the same explanation, unlike an illustration alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Dots on a toy strip have separations 5 and 10. Stretching makes them 10 and 20 while the ink dots stay the same size.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Changed quantity: Separation between dots
  • b: Unchanged feature: Dot size
  • c: Changed quantity: Dot mass necessarily doubles
  • d: Unchanged feature: All structures must expand
Answer: Changed quantity: Separation between dots; Unchanged feature: Dot size

The intended analogy separates distances from object sizes.

3B · Short answer

Explain what the strip represents and why it does not imply that every bound object grows.

Example of a full-credit answer: It represents growing separations with a common scale factor. The dots stay the same size; bound real systems are not required to stretch with cosmic expansion.

  1. It represents growing separations with a common scale factor.
  2. The dots stay the same size; bound real systems are not required to stretch with cosmic expansion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner puts present-day Earth, trees and the Sun in the earliest hot stage. The source orders early hot state → atoms → stars/galaxies → much later solar system.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies error in this case?

  • a: Later structures placed too early
  • b: The event order has no mistake
  • c: Atoms and stars were given the same size
  • d: The supplied order has no solar-system stage
Answer: Later structures placed too early

Modern structures formed through later processes.

4B · Open ended

Identify the timeline error and give a corrected broad sequence.

Example of a full-credit answer: The Sun, Earth and trees were not already present in the earliest hot stage. Places the early hot state before atoms, stars/galaxies and the much later solar system.

  1. The Sun, Earth and trees were not already present in the earliest hot stage.
  2. Places the early hot state before atoms, stars/galaxies and the much later solar system.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Use a grid with three labelled dots to show all separations multiplied by two. Include one warning about what the demo does not establish.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies required distance change in this case?

  • a: Every chosen separation doubles
  • b: Only one random gap changes
  • c: Only dot colour
  • d: It proves a bomb location
Answer: Every chosen separation doubles

A valid demonstration has a stated rule and explicit limits.

5B · Open ended

Propose two before/after distances following the rule and name one limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use 2→4 and 5→10 units; the grid’s edge is not evidence of an edge to the universe.

  1. Provides two valid distance pairs in which each final value is twice its initial value.
  2. States an appropriate limit, such as no proof of a cosmic edge, outside space, explosion centre or exact cosmic history.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.1 · Formulating scientific questions

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Make growth specific

Worked-example information

A student asks, “Do plants change?” Available records compare bean seedling height on days 1 and 8 under two light schedules.

Question: What is a more focused question?

Answer: How does the light schedule affect bean seedling height change from day 1 to day 8?

Why: It names the factor, organism, outcome and interval.

Example 2 · Choose a measurable best
Model comparison
CoverRise °C
A3
B7

Worked-example information

Fictional cover A gives a 3°C model temperature rise; B gives 7°C. The goal is the smallest rise.

Question: Which question does this table answer?

Answer: Which of these covers gives the smaller temperature rise in this model?

Why: Best is defined by a measured outcome.

Example 3 · Match the record

Worked-example information

A question asks whether a wider paper wing changes falling time. The record lists only wing colours.

Question: Can the record answer the question?

Answer: No.

Why: It needs wing widths and measured falling times, with a comparable release method.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Choose a testable ramp question

Fixed case information

A virtual kit changes ramp height and measures a cart’s travel distance on one surface.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Question matching kit; Measured outcome; Compared factor

  • a: How does ramp height affect travel distance?
  • b: Travel distance
  • c: Ramp height
  • d: Which ramp is nicest?
Answer: Question matching kit → How does ramp height affect travel distance?; Measured outcome → Travel distance; Compared factor → Ramp height

The question matches both an adjustable factor and a measured outcome.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Define the time window

Fixed case information

A prepared plant study compares two light schedules and measures height after six days.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Required time phrase; Outcome; Comparison

  • a: After six days
  • b: Seedling height
  • c: Two light schedules
  • d: Whenever we remember
Answer: Required time phrase → After six days; Outcome → Seedling height; Comparison → Two light schedules

The time window makes the growth question specific.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Remove a leading assumption

Fixed case information

A draft says “Why does the red model cover always work best?” Best is intended to mean least heat gain.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Neutral question; Unjustified word; Needed criterion

  • a: Which cover gives least heat gain in this model?
  • b: Always
  • c: Heat gain
  • d: Why must red win?
Answer: Neutral question → Which cover gives least heat gain in this model?; Unjustified word → Always; Needed criterion → Heat gain

The revised question allows the measurements to determine the result.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Choose a useful record

Fixed case information

A question asks how model water loss changes across three surface areas. Available records list area and water loss.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies necessary paired record in this case?

  • a: Area and water loss
  • b: Sticker colour only
  • c: Kilometres for volume
  • d: Measured water loss
Answer: Area and water loss

The record must connect factor values to the outcome.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Refine a broad question

Fixed case information

A virtual helicopter tool can change paper-wing width between 2 and 6 cm and record fall time from a fixed height. A draft asks “What happens?”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Write a focused question and identify one condition that should stay comparable.

Example of a full-credit answer: The question links wing width to fall time for the virtual helicopter. Keeps release height, material or release method comparable.

  1. The question links wing width to fall time for the virtual helicopter.
  2. Keeps release height, material or release method comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual tool permits soil-cover settings of 0%, 50% and 100% and measures runoff after the same rain input.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies suitable factor in this case?

  • a: Soil-cover percentage
  • b: Only the border colour
  • c: Age of the computer
  • d: Different rain every time
Answer: Soil-cover percentage

The tool supports a question linking cover and runoff under equal rain.

1B · Short answer

Write a question the kit can investigate and include the shared rain condition.

Example of a full-credit answer: Asks how soil-cover percentage affects runoff amount. Specifies equal rain input or comparable rainfall for the cover settings.

  1. Asks how soil-cover percentage affects runoff amount.
  2. Specifies equal rain input or comparable rainfall for the cover settings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Question A asks “Which cup is good?” B asks “Which of these three virtual cup covers gives the smallest temperature drop after five minutes?”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies stronger question in this case?

  • a: B
  • b: A
  • c: Favourite picture
  • d: No time needed
Answer: B

B provides a measurement and a time window.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger question and explain two features that make it answerable.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses B. Explains that the measured temperature drop and five-minute interval give a clear evidence target.

  1. Chooses B.
  2. Explains that the measured temperature drop and five-minute interval give a clear evidence target.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Prepared sound records list distance from a model source and a relative sound-level reading. The source setting stays fixed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Investigable relationship: Distance and sound-level reading.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

A measurable question can be built from the two recorded variables.

3B · Short answer

Formulate a question for these records and name the condition that makes the comparison useful.

Example of a full-credit answer: Asks how the sound-level reading changes with distance. Keeps or recognises the same source setting.

  1. Asks how the sound-level reading changes with distance.
  2. Keeps or recognises the same source setting.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A study measures model boat travel time over 2 m. Its question asks which boat carries the heaviest load, but no load data are collected.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Main flaw: Outcome does not match question
  • b: Measured quantity: Travel time
  • c: Main flaw: Every needed outcome is present
  • d: Measured quantity: Load mass was measured
Answer: Main flaw: Outcome does not match question; Measured quantity: Travel time

Speed/travel time does not establish load capacity.

4B · Open ended

Explain the mismatch and propose one valid repair.

Example of a full-credit answer: The collected travel times do not measure load capacity. Either changes the question to travel time/speed or adds a suitable safe capacity measure.

  1. The collected travel times do not measure load capacity.
  2. Either changes the question to travel time/speed or adds a suitable safe capacity measure.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

You have a virtual shade model with three shade levels and a surface thermometer. You may make twelve readings, over one fixed model period.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Useful question focus; Outcome record; Manageable scope

  • a: Shade level and temperature change
  • b: Start and end temperatures
  • c: Three levels in one stated period
  • d: All climate everywhere
Answer: Useful question focus → Shade level and temperature change; Outcome record → Start and end temperatures; Manageable scope → Three levels in one stated period

A manageable plan uses defined settings and measurements.

5B · Open ended

Propose a focused question and a record that would answer it. Include repeat comparisons within the allowance of twelve temperature readings.

Example of a full-credit answer: Asks how the three shade levels affect temperature change during the fixed period. Records comparable starting/ending temperatures by shade level, with repeats within the reading allowance.

  1. Asks how the three shade levels affect temperature change during the fixed period.
  2. Records comparable starting/ending temperatures by shade level, with repeats within the reading allowance.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.2 · Developing hypotheses

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Reason and prediction

Worked-example information

A learner proposes that wider fins increase air resistance in a virtual falling model, predicting longer fall time at equal mass and height.

Question: Which part is the prediction?

Answer: Wider fins will give a longer fall time under the stated controls.

Why: The air-resistance idea is the explanatory reason.

Example 2 · Compare a prediction
Prepared loss record
CoverLoss units
A2
B5

Worked-example information

A fictional prediction says cover A loses less water than B. Prepared losses are A=2 and B=5 units.

Question: Does this result agree with the prediction?

Answer: Yes, in this comparison.

Why: Two is less than five; the result is support, not universal proof.

Example 3 · A useful disagreement

Worked-example information

A model predicts identical outputs at two settings, but repeated checked records differ.

Question: What is a scientific next step?

Answer: Check the method and revise or test the explanation further.

Why: Disagreement can expose a missing factor; it should not be hidden.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Find a testable explanation

Fixed case information

A virtual insulation question asks why one container loses heat more slowly. Proposal A says its covering reduces energy transfer; B says an untestable invisible wish decides every outcome.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies testable proposal in this case?

  • a: Covering reduces energy transfer
  • b: An invisible wish decides all
  • c: Only cover name
  • d: Every result proves it
Answer: Covering reduces energy transfer

A useful explanation connects to measurable consequences.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Separate prediction from reason

Fixed case information

A source hypothesises that rougher tracks increase friction. It predicts shorter rolling distance for the same released cart.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Prediction; Proposed reason; Shared starting condition

  • a: Shorter rolling distance
  • b: More friction
  • c: Same release
  • d: The rough track is prettier
Answer: Prediction → Shorter rolling distance; Proposed reason → More friction; Shared starting condition → Same release

The prediction is an observable consequence of the proposed mechanism.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Read support cautiously

Fixed case information

The prediction is that model filter A removes more visible particles than B. In one matched trial, A removes 8 and B removes 5 of 10 starting particles.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Agreement with prediction; Observed difference; Needed caution

  • a: Supported in this trial
  • b: 3 particles
  • c: More trials and conditions may differ
  • d: Proved for every filter
Answer: Agreement with prediction → Supported in this trial; Observed difference → 3 particles; Needed caution → More trials and conditions may differ

The particle comparison supports a limited prediction only.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Keep challenging evidence

Fixed case information

A checked result disagrees with a prediction. The record contains the original prediction and all readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Appropriate next step: Delete every surprise.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Honest records allow the explanation and method to be evaluated.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Write a justified prediction

Fixed case information

A toy model states that adding shade reduces incoming light while other conditions stay equal. Surface temperature change is measured over five model minutes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

State a prediction and explain it using the supplied mechanism.

Example of a full-credit answer: Predicts a smaller temperature rise with more shade under equal conditions. Explains that shade reduces incoming light/energy in the toy model.

  1. Predicts a smaller temperature rise with more shade under equal conditions.
  2. Explains that shade reduces incoming light/energy in the toy model.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual membrane model proposes that larger open area allows more water through per equal time, all else equal. Areas are 2 and 4 square units. No exact flow rule is given.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · True or false

True or false? Expected comparison: Less flow necessarily.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A direction can be predicted without inventing an exact factor.

1B · Open ended

Give a testable prediction and explain why an exact doubling is not required by the source.

Example of a full-credit answer: Predicts greater flow for the larger open area with other conditions equal. The source gives a directional explanation but no exact numerical law establishing doubling.

  1. Predicts greater flow for the larger open area with other conditions equal.
  2. The source gives a directional explanation but no exact numerical law establishing doubling.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A says a rough surface shortens a model cart’s travel because friction is greater. B says the cart travels whatever distance it travels, which always proves B.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: More useful hypothesis; Reason it is testable; Problem with B

  • a: A
  • b: It predicts a comparison that could disagree
  • c: It fits every outcome without explanation
  • d: B
Answer: More useful hypothesis → A; Reason it is testable → It predicts a comparison that could disagree; Problem with B → It fits every outcome without explanation

A predicts a measurable difference that could fail to occur, rather than restating every possible result.

2B · Short answer

Choose the hypothesis and explain what makes it scientifically more useful.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. It supplies a reason and a measurable predicted difference that evidence could challenge.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. It supplies a reason and a measurable predicted difference that evidence could challenge.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A hypothesis predicts less heat loss with thicker model insulation. In a new virtual material, measured losses at equal time are thin=7, medium=5, thick=3 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies observed direction in this case?

  • a: Loss decreases with thickness
  • b: Loss increases
  • c: Universal proof
  • d: All materials were tested
Answer: Loss decreases with thickness

The pattern transfers the prediction to a new specified case.

3B · Open ended

State whether the results support the hypothesis and limit the conclusion appropriately.

Example of a full-credit answer: The decreasing losses support the predicted direction. Limits support to this model/material and conditions, without claiming all materials are proven.

  1. The decreasing losses support the predicted direction.
  2. Limits support to this model/material and conditions, without claiming all materials are proven.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner gets one result agreeing with a seedling-light hypothesis and writes “proved forever for every plant.” Only one species and one week were tested.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Overclaim: Forever for every plant
  • b: Actual scope: One species over one week
  • c: Overclaim: A prediction matched
  • d: Actual scope: All species were tested
Answer: Overclaim: Forever for every plant; Actual scope: One species over one week

Support under one condition is narrower than universal certainty.

4B · Short answer

Explain the overclaim and rewrite the conclusion at the supported scope.

Example of a full-credit answer: One matching result from one species/week cannot prove the claim for all plants forever. States that the result supports the hypothesis under the tested conditions and further tests are needed.

  1. One matching result from one species/week cannot prove the claim for all plants forever.
  2. States that the result supports the hypothesis under the tested conditions and further tests are needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual parachute tool can vary canopy area while holding mass and drop height constant. Measure fall time. Propose a hypothesis with a reason and a result that would challenge its prediction.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies adjustable factor in this case?

  • a: Canopy area
  • b: All factors at once
  • c: Only colour preference
  • d: No result could disagree
Answer: Canopy area

The explanation must lead to a prediction that can be checked.

5B · Open ended

Propose a reasoned hypothesis and identify evidence that would challenge it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Links larger canopy area to longer fall time through greater air resistance, with mass/height comparable, or gives another coherent testable proposal. Names a checked repeated contrary or no-difference result that would challenge the prediction.

  1. Links larger canopy area to longer fall time through greater air resistance, with mass/height comparable, or gives another coherent testable proposal.
  2. Names a checked repeated contrary or no-difference result that would challenge the prediction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.3 · Identifying independent variables

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A named outcome is not the setting

Worked-example information

A study titled “Water loss” changes exposed area and measures volume lost after ten minutes.

Question: What is the independent variable?

Answer: Exposed area.

Why: Water loss is the outcome; area is deliberately set.

Example 2 · Count levels
Distance settings
Trial groupDistance m
A1
B3
C5

Worked-example information

A virtual lamp test uses distances 1, 3 and 5 m with the same lamp output.

Question: How many levels of distance are tested?

Answer: Three.

Why: They are settings of one factor.

Example 3 · A bundled change

Worked-example information

One cart uses a high ramp and rough track; another uses a low ramp and smooth track.

Question: Is height isolated?

Answer: No.

Why: Both height and track surface change, so either could affect the result.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Find the changed setting

Fixed case information

A virtual spring test sets attached model masses to 1, 2 and 3 units and measures extension. The same spring is used.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Independent variable: Attached mass
  • b: Measured outcome: Extension
  • c: Independent variable: Extension
  • d: Measured outcome: Time of page opening
Answer: Independent variable: Attached mass; Measured outcome: Extension

Mass is deliberately varied; extension responds.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Recognise variable levels

Fixed case information

A prepared cooling comparison uses cover thicknesses 1, 2 and 4 mm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Independent factor; Number of levels; Level unit

  • a: Cover thickness
  • b: Three
  • c: Millimetres
  • d: Temperature drop
Answer: Independent factor → Cover thickness; Number of levels → Three; Level unit → Millimetres

The settings are levels of one chosen factor.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · A categorical factor

Fixed case information

Virtual carts are tested on felt, card and rubber tracks with equal ramp height.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies independent variable in this case?

  • a: Track material
  • b: Cart travel distance
  • c: Only a number can be a level
  • d: All heights differ
Answer: Track material

Categories can be deliberate experimental settings.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Identify a bundled change

Fixed case information

Group A has 2-hour light and 5-unit water; B has 6-hour light and 9-unit water. Height is the outcome.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies factors changed together in this case?

  • a: Light and water
  • b: Only light changes
  • c: Pot colour measured
  • d: All other factors are equal
Answer: Light and water

The design does not isolate light alone.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain from a method

Fixed case information

A model study called “Cooling curves” changes fan speed while keeping cup, starting temperature and time fixed; it records temperature drop.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Identify the independent variable and explain using the procedure.

Example of a full-credit answer: The independent variable is fan speed. It is deliberately changed between trials while temperature drop is measured under comparable conditions.

  1. The independent variable is fan speed.
  2. It is deliberately changed between trials while temperature drop is measured under comparable conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional virtual shade study sets shade cover to 0%, 40% and 80% and records surface temperature after an equal interval.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies independent variable in this case?

  • a: Shade-cover percentage
  • b: Surface temperature
  • c: Two levels
  • d: The file name
Answer: Shade-cover percentage

Shade percentage is the assigned factor.

1B · Short answer

Name the independent variable and explain how the levels create a comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Names shade-cover percentage. Uses the 0%, 40% and 80% assigned settings as three levels of one factor.

  1. Names shade-cover percentage.
  2. Uses the 0%, 40% and 80% assigned settings as three levels of one factor.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A changes only paper-wing length with equal mass and release height. Plan B changes wing length, paper mass and release height together.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Clearer one-factor plan: B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A better isolates the deliberately chosen factor.

2B · Open ended

Choose the plan and justify it by distinguishing the chosen factor from controls.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Wing length varies while mass and height stay comparable, reducing alternative causes.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Wing length varies while mass and height stay comparable, reducing alternative causes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual seed model compares three named soil types using equal seed variety, water and duration. It measures germination count.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Independent factor; Outcome; One controlled condition

  • a: Soil type
  • b: Germination count
  • c: Seed variety
  • d: Only elapsed screen time
Answer: Independent factor → Soil type; Outcome → Germination count; One controlled condition → Seed variety

A categorical setting can serve as the independent variable.

3B · Short answer

Identify the independent variable and explain why non-numerical labels can be valid levels.

Example of a full-credit answer: The independent variable is soil type. A variable may have clearly defined categories; the types are chosen comparison settings.

  1. The independent variable is soil type.
  2. A variable may have clearly defined categories; the types are chosen comparison settings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner calls measured water loss the independent variable. The method deliberately changes exposed area and then measures loss over equal time.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Mislabelled quantity; Actual independent variable; Correct role of loss

  • a: Water loss
  • b: Exposed area
  • c: Dependent variable
  • d: A clock’s colour
Answer: Mislabelled quantity → Water loss; Actual independent variable → Exposed area; Correct role of loss → Dependent variable

The role follows what is changed versus measured.

4B · Open ended

Correct both variable roles and link them to the procedure.

Example of a full-credit answer: Exposed area is the independent variable because it is set. Water loss is the dependent variable because it is measured as the outcome.

  1. Exposed area is the independent variable because it is set.
  2. Water loss is the dependent variable because it is measured as the outcome.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual erosion tool allows slope settings from 1 to 9. You want to study slope while rain and cover stay comparable. Choose three distinct settings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies chosen factor in this case?

  • a: Slope setting
  • b: Only cover colour
  • c: One repeated value only
  • d: Change rain with slope
Answer: Slope setting

Distinct levels and stable other settings define a useful comparison.

5B · Open ended

Propose three permitted slope levels and identify two conditions to keep comparable.

Example of a full-credit answer: Use slopes 2, 5 and 8; keep rain and cover unchanged.

  1. Gives three distinct slope values between 1 and 9.
  2. Keeps rain and cover equal or comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.4 · Identifying dependent variables

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Define growth

Worked-example information

A seedling starts at 4 cm and ends at 9 cm.

Question: What is its height change?

Answer: 5 cm.

Why: Subtract initial height from final height; final height alone is not the change.

Example 2 · Which cart went farther?
Prepared distances
Cart testDistance cm
A28
B35

Worked-example information

Two fictional cart records measure from the same starting line: A=28 cm, B=35 cm.

Question: What dependent variable was compared?

Answer: Travel distance in centimetres.

Why: Both records use the same measurement definition.

Example 3 · Not a safety test

Worked-example information

A model filter study measures visible particle count only.

Question: Can its outcome establish that water contains no harmful microbes?

Answer: No.

Why: That biological property was not measured.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the measured outcome

Fixed case information

A virtual spring method changes attached mass and records extension in centimetres.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Dependent variable: Spring extension
  • b: Outcome unit: Centimetres
  • c: Dependent variable: Attached mass
  • d: Outcome unit: Kilograms for extension
Answer: Dependent variable: Spring extension; Outcome unit: Centimetres

Extension is the recorded response.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Define change

Fixed case information

A fictional plant record has initial height 6 cm and final height 11 cm over a fixed week.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Height change: 17 cm.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Change requires final minus initial.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Match instrument and outcome

Fixed case information

A question asks how long a virtual paper spinner takes to fall. The available tools are a timer, ruler and colour chart.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Appropriate tool; Outcome; Suitable unit

  • a: Timer
  • b: Fall time
  • c: Seconds
  • d: Colour chart
Answer: Appropriate tool → Timer; Outcome → Fall time; Suitable unit → Seconds

A timing question needs a timing outcome.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F4 · Mark missing honestly

Fixed case information

A planned temperature record is lost for trial 3. Other trials have values. No evidence shows trial 3 was zero degrees.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Proper entry; Incorrect assumption that missing means zero; Explanation for the missing entry

  • a: Missing reading
  • b: Invented zero
  • c: Reason the reading is unavailable
  • d: Temperature unit °C
Answer: Proper entry → Missing reading; Incorrect assumption that missing means zero → Invented zero; Explanation for the missing entry → Reason the reading is unavailable

Missing and zero represent different information.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain an operational definition

Fixed case information

Two teams study seedling growth. A records final height; B records final minus initial height over seven days. Starting heights differ.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Choose the more appropriate growth outcome and explain why.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses height change from final minus initial height. It accounts for different starting heights over the same interval.

  1. Uses height change from final minus initial height.
  2. It accounts for different starting heights over the same interval.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual seedling grows from 3 to 8 cm; another from 7 to 10 cm over equal time. The stated outcome is height change.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies greater change in this case?

  • a: First seedling
  • b: Second seedling
  • c: 11 cm
  • d: 17 cm
Answer: First seedling

Compare changes rather than final heights.

1B · Open ended

Compare the height changes and explain why the taller final seedling need not have grown more.

Example of a full-credit answer: The first changed by 5 cm, compared with 3 cm for the second. The second started taller, so its larger final height is not a larger change.

  1. The first changed by 5 cm, compared with 3 cm for the second.
  2. The second started taller, so its larger final height is not a larger change.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A times every virtual fall from release to first ground contact. B starts timing at different moments for different trials.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies more comparable method in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Whenever noticed
  • d: After a random delay
Answer: A

A consistent operational definition makes times comparable.

2B · Short answer

Choose the method and justify it using its start and finish rules.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. The same release-to-first-contact interval is measured in every trial.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. The same release-to-first-contact interval is measured in every trial.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Initial water amounts differ between two virtual dishes. The question asks which loses more water in an hour. Start/end amounts are A=30/24 and B=20/17 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Greater loss: Dish B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Calculate losses from both start and end records.

3B · Open ended

Define and calculate the outcome, then identify the greater loss.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses initial minus final volume: A loses 6 and B loses 3 units. Concludes A loses more during the stated hour.

  1. Uses initial minus final volume: A loses 6 and B loses 3 units.
  2. Concludes A loses more during the stated hour.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner measures only a model material’s surface temperature and concludes it is the strongest material. No force or deformation is measured.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Error; Actual outcome; Needed strength evidence

  • a: Temperature used to infer unmeasured strength
  • b: Surface temperature
  • c: A defined force/deformation test
  • d: Every property was measured
Answer: Error → Temperature used to infer unmeasured strength; Actual outcome → Surface temperature; Needed strength evidence → A defined force/deformation test

A measured property does not automatically establish another.

4B · Short answer

Explain the mismatch and name a suitable additional kind of evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Temperature alone does not measure or establish mechanical strength. Needs a defined strength-related measure such as force at a specified deformation or failure in a virtual/prepared test.

  1. Temperature alone does not measure or establish mechanical strength.
  2. Needs a defined strength-related measure such as force at a specified deformation or failure in a virtual/prepared test.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual shade test compares three shade levels for ten model minutes. You want temperature rise, not just final temperature.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Needed starting record; Needed ending record; Calculation

  • a: Initial temperature
  • b: Temperature at ten minutes
  • c: Final minus initial
  • d: Only shade label
Answer: Needed starting record → Initial temperature; Needed ending record → Temperature at ten minutes; Calculation → Final minus initial

A temperature-rise outcome requires both readings and a common interval.

5B · Open ended

Specify the outcome calculation and two record details that make it comparable.

Example of a full-credit answer: Defines temperature rise as final minus initial temperature. Uses the same ten-minute interval and temperature unit/reference method across shade levels.

  1. Defines temperature rise as final minus initial temperature.
  2. Uses the same ten-minute interval and temperature unit/reference method across shade levels.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.5 · Identifying control variables

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Spot the missing control

Worked-example information

A virtual cooling test compares lids, but one cup starts at 50°C and the other at 30°C.

Question: What additional condition should be matched?

Answer: Starting temperature.

Why: Different starting temperatures can affect cooling and obscure the lid comparison.

Example 2 · Check the record
Prepared setup
GroupHeight cmSame cart
A2Yes
B4Yes
C6Yes

Worked-example information

Three ramp groups use the same cart, a 20-cm release path and heights 2, 4 and 6 cm.

Question: Which listed value is intentionally varied?

Answer: Ramp height.

Why: The other listed conditions are kept comparable.

Example 3 · Same factor, new role

Worked-example information

Study A changes airflow while holding area fixed. Study B changes area while holding airflow fixed.

Question: Does airflow have the same role in both?

Answer: No.

Why: It is varied in A and controlled in B.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Keep the cart test comparable

Fixed case information

A ramp-height study uses one cart and one surface, releases without a push and measures distance.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies important release control in this case?

  • a: No added push
  • b: Different push each time
  • c: Only result colour
  • d: An unmeasured preference
Answer: No added push

A push would create an alternative explanation.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Match starting conditions

Fixed case information

A virtual cup comparison studies cover type. All cups start with 20 water units at 40°C and run for five minutes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies controlled starting temperature in this case?

  • a: 40°C
  • b: Different temperatures
  • c: Every amount different
  • d: No fixed interval
Answer: 40°C

These controls make the cover comparison more meaningful.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Separate group from condition

Fixed case information

A model study has a no-cover reference group and a covered group. Both receive 6 light units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Reference group; Controlled light input; Varied treatment

  • a: No-cover group
  • b: 6 units in both
  • c: Cover presence
  • d: The number six as a group
Answer: Reference group → No-cover group; Controlled light input → 6 units in both; Varied treatment → Cover presence

A group and a condition are different design features.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Record a broken control

Fixed case information

A virtual seed study plans equal water, but the log shows A=5 units and B=9 units. Light also differs.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Broken control: Water amount
  • b: Interpretation problem: Water and light both differ
  • c: Broken control: Every condition is equal
  • d: Interpretation problem: Only leaf labels differ
Answer: Broken control: Water amount; Interpretation problem: Water and light both differ

The water difference can provide another explanation.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a factor’s changing role

Fixed case information

Study A tests airflow with area fixed. Study B tests area with airflow fixed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Name airflow’s role in each study and explain why it changes.

Example of a full-credit answer: Airflow is varied in A and controlled in B. The studies investigate different factors, so the planned role changes.

  1. Airflow is varied in A and controlled in B.
  2. The studies investigate different factors, so the planned role changes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual seed test changes light duration and measures height change after seven days. It can set seed variety, water and pot colour.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies strong biological control in this case?

  • a: Seed variety
  • b: Different seed variety
  • c: Water changes freely
  • d: Starting height is unimportant
Answer: Seed variety

Controls should target plausible alternative causes.

1B · Short answer

Name two relevant controls and explain the alternative explanations they reduce.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keeps seed variety and water amount comparable. Explains that different seed types or water availability could affect growth independently of light duration.

  1. Names two relevant controls, such as seed variety and water amount; scientifically justified alternatives are accepted.
  2. Explains how the chosen controls reduce plausible alternative causes of height change, such as genetic variety or water availability.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A uses matched model cups with equal starting temperature and volume; B uses different volumes and temperatures for each lid.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Stronger comparison; Useful matched condition; Problem in B

  • a: A
  • b: Starting temperature and volume
  • c: Several factors differ with lid
  • d: B
Answer: Stronger comparison → A; Useful matched condition → Starting temperature and volume; Problem in B → Several factors differ with lid

A reduces alternative causes of a cooling difference.

2B · Open ended

Choose the plan and explain why its starting conditions matter.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Starting temperature and volume can affect cooling, so matching them helps isolate lid effects.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Starting temperature and volume can affect cooling, so matching them helps isolate lid effects.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual mirror test changes surface material and measures reflected light. Incoming light, angle and detector distance can be set.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Needed input control; Geometry control; Varied factor

  • a: Incoming light
  • b: Angle and detector distance
  • c: Surface material
  • d: Change all light sources
Answer: Needed input control → Incoming light; Geometry control → Angle and detector distance; Varied factor → Surface material

Equal input and geometry support a material comparison.

3B · Short answer

Propose two controlled conditions and connect them to a fair reflected-light comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keeps incoming light comparable. Keeps relevant geometry such as angle/detector distance comparable so material is the intended difference.

  1. Names two relevant controlled conditions among incoming light, angle and detector distance.
  2. Explains how keeping those conditions comparable reduces alternative causes of a reflected-light difference while material changes.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says “We have a reference group, so it does not matter that it gets twice the water.” The question concerns soil-cover effect on seedling growth.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Having a reference group removes the need to keep water amounts comparable.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A reference group still needs appropriate comparable conditions.

4B · Open ended

Explain the error and propose the control needed to improve the test.

Example of a full-credit answer: A reference group does not remove other differences automatically. Match water amounts so cover is not bundled with a water difference.

  1. A reference group does not remove other differences automatically.
  2. Match water amounts so cover is not bundled with a water difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual paper-spinner study changes blade length. You can control mass, release height, release method and timer rule. State at least two controls and how to check one.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Varied factor; Possible controls; Needed verification

  • a: Blade length
  • b: Mass and release height
  • c: Record actual setup values
  • d: Change every factor
Answer: Varied factor → Blade length; Possible controls → Mass and release height; Needed verification → Record actual setup values

Controls should be implemented and documented.

5B · Open ended

Propose two relevant controls and a concrete check for one of them.

Example of a full-credit answer: Keeps at least two of mass, release height, release method and timing rule comparable. Describes a check such as recording equal mass/height or applying the same release/timing procedure each trial.

  1. Keeps at least two of mass, release height, release method and timing rule comparable.
  2. Describes a check such as recording equal mass/height or applying the same release/timing procedure each trial.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.6 · Designing fair tests

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find the unfair timing

Worked-example information

Virtual cup A is checked after two minutes; B after eight minutes. The question compares covers.

Question: What should change in the plan?

Answer: Use the same elapsed time for both covers.

Why: Otherwise cooling duration is an alternative explanation.

Example 2 · Equal starts, different outcomes
Prepared matched test
SurfaceDistance cm
A18
B12

Worked-example information

Prepared model surfaces A and B use the same cart and height. Distances are A=18 cm and B=12 cm.

Question: Does the unequal outcome prove an unfair test?

Answer: No.

Why: A fair comparison may reveal a difference.

Example 3 · A changing instrument

Worked-example information

A sensor’s baseline drifts during the day. A is always tested early and B late.

Question: Why consider balanced order?

Answer: It reduces the link between condition and time of day.

Why: Order can otherwise imitate a treatment difference.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Spot a fair cart setup

Fixed case information

The question compares track material. Plan A keeps cart, height and release rule equal; B gives the rough track an extra push.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies fairer plan in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Cart result only
  • d: Both are identical
Answer: A

An extra push supplies another cause of distance change.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Match the interval

Fixed case information

A cooling comparison checks cover A at 3 minutes and B at 9 minutes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Needed repair; Unwanted factor; Intended comparison

  • a: Use equal elapsed time
  • b: Cooling duration
  • c: Cover type
  • d: Keep different intervals
Answer: Needed repair → Use equal elapsed time; Unwanted factor → Cooling duration; Intended comparison → Cover type

Different durations make the cover comparison ambiguous.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Read repeated fair results

Fixed case information

Fictional matched trials give A distances 10, 11, 9 and B distances 6, 7, 5 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: A mean: 10 cm
  • b: B mean: 6 cm
  • c: A mean: 30 cm
  • d: B mean: 18 cm
Answer: A mean: 10 cm; B mean: 6 cm

Repeats show variation while retaining a comparable method.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F4 · Balance order

Fixed case information

A sensor drifts slightly later in a session. One plan tests A,A,A then B,B,B; another alternates A,B,B,A.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: More balanced order; Possible hidden factor; Useful record

  • a: A,B,B,A
  • b: Time-related drift
  • c: Trial order
  • d: A,A,A then B,B,B
Answer: More balanced order → A,B,B,A; Possible hidden factor → Time-related drift; Useful record → Trial order

Balancing order can reduce its association with the condition.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a fair result

Fixed case information

Two virtual lids receive equal starting volume, temperature and cooling time. Their drops differ by 2°C in repeated trials. A learner says a fair test must give equal drops.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why different outcomes can occur in a fair test and name one relevant matched condition.

Example of a full-credit answer: A fair procedure can reveal a real difference; it does not require equal outcomes. Names equal starting volume, starting temperature or cooling interval as a relevant control.

  1. A fair procedure can reveal a real difference; it does not require equal outcomes.
  2. Names equal starting volume, starting temperature or cooling interval as a relevant control.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual spinner test compares blade width. Wide blades are dropped from 3 m; narrow blades from 1 m. The same mass is used.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Needed common setting; Intended factor; Already matched factor

  • a: Release height
  • b: Blade width
  • c: Mass
  • d: Keep unequal heights
Answer: Needed common setting → Release height; Intended factor → Blade width; Already matched factor → Mass

Height affects fall time and should be matched.

1B · Open ended

Identify the unfair difference and propose a corrected setup.

Example of a full-credit answer: The unequal release heights confound the blade-width comparison. Uses the same permitted height for both while retaining width as the varied factor.

  1. The unequal release heights confound the blade-width comparison.
  2. Uses the same permitted height for both while retaining width as the varied factor.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Virtual filters A and B receive equal starting particle counts and equal liquid amounts. The same counting method is used. A second plan gives B half as many starting particles.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Stronger comparison: Equal-input plan
  • b: Relevant input control: Starting particle count
  • c: Stronger comparison: Unequal-input plan
  • d: Relevant input control: Different amounts deliberately
Answer: Stronger comparison: Equal-input plan; Relevant input control: Starting particle count

Equal starting challenge and consistent counting support a filter comparison.

2B · Short answer

Choose the fairer plan and justify it using inputs and measurement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the equal-input plan. Explains that the same starting challenge and counting method make the filter outcomes comparable.

  1. Chooses the equal-input plan.
  2. Explains that the same starting challenge and counting method make the filter outcomes comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual study compares surfaces under a lamp. Reflectance readings are taken with the same incoming light, angle and detector distance. The only intended change is material.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies varied factor in this case?

  • a: Material
  • b: Incoming light only
  • c: Different detector placement
  • d: Change every condition
Answer: Material

The fairness principles transfer to optical measurements.

3B · Open ended

Explain why the geometry and input must stay comparable when changing material.

Example of a full-credit answer: Angle/detector distance can change the reading independently of material. Incoming light must stay comparable so different supplied light does not explain the result.

  1. Angle/detector distance can change the reading independently of material.
  2. Incoming light must stay comparable so different supplied light does not explain the result.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Matched trial times are A:4,5,6 s and B:5,6,7 s. A report compares only A’s fastest 4 s with B’s slowest 7 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Reporting error; Fairer summary; Full mean difference

  • a: Selective extreme comparison
  • b: Use all planned trials
  • c: 1 second
  • d: All trials fairly represented
Answer: Reporting error → Selective extreme comparison; Fairer summary → Use all planned trials; Full mean difference → 1 second

The chosen extremes exaggerate the typical difference.

4B · Short answer

Explain how the report exaggerates the result and give a fairer comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: It selects favourable extremes instead of comparable summaries of all trials. Uses means A=5 s and B=6 s or otherwise fairly reports all readings and their spread.

  1. It selects favourable extremes instead of comparable summaries of all trials.
  2. Uses means A=5 s and B=6 s or otherwise fairly reports all readings and their spread.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual tool allows dish area, starting volume, airflow and duration to vary, and measures water loss. Investigate area using three levels and at least two trials at each.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · True or false

True or false? Varied factor: Everything varies together.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A fair plan separates the intended factor from likely alternatives.

5B · Open ended

Propose the comparison settings and explain how controls and repeats make it useful.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses three distinct area levels with comparable starting volume, airflow and duration. Includes at least two trials per level and records the same loss outcome for all.

  1. Uses three distinct area levels with comparable starting volume, airflow and duration.
  2. Includes at least two trials per level and records the same loss outcome for all.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.7 · Designing controlled experiments

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find the reference

Worked-example information

A virtual test compares covered pots with uncovered pots under equal water and light.

Question: Which group is the reference for the cover treatment?

Answer: The uncovered pots.

Why: They show the no-cover condition for the same stated inputs.

Example 2 · Independent units
Design counts
GroupPotsReadings per pot
Covered43
Uncovered43

Worked-example information

A study uses four pots per group and takes three readings from each.

Question: How many independently treated pots are there per group?

Answer: Four.

Why: Twelve readings per group do not turn into twelve pots.

Example 3 · A selection problem

Worked-example information

All initially tallest seedlings enter the treatment group.

Question: Why is that a problem?

Answer: The groups differ before treatment.

Why: Later height differences might reflect starting differences, so assignment should improve.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the reference condition

Fixed case information

A virtual cooling experiment tests a new cover against no cover with equal cups, water, starts and duration.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies reference condition in this case?

  • a: No cover
  • b: Only the treatment cup
  • c: Different starting volumes
  • d: Cover colour preference
Answer: No cover

The reference supplies a baseline comparison.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Count experimental units

Fixed case information

A model study uses 5 separate pots in each group and measures each twice.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Independent pots per group; Readings per group; Readings per pot

  • a: Five
  • b: Ten
  • c: Two
  • d: Ten independent pots
Answer: Independent pots per group → Five; Readings per group → Ten; Readings per pot → Two

Units receiving treatments and repeated readings are distinct.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Choose an assignment rule

Fixed case information

There are twelve comparable virtual seedlings. A assigns six at random to each group; B selects the tallest six for treatment.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Less selection-prone rule; Problem with B; Useful baseline record

  • a: Random assignment
  • b: Starting height linked to group
  • c: Initial height
  • d: Growth after seven days
Answer: Less selection-prone rule → Random assignment; Problem with B → Starting height linked to group; Useful baseline record → Initial height

Random assignment reduces systematic selection differences.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Read a matched comparison

Fixed case information

Fictional independent pots have growth changes: treatment 5,6,7 cm; reference 2,3,4 cm under matched conditions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Treatment mean: 6 cm
  • b: Reference mean: 3 cm
  • c: Treatment mean: 18 cm
  • d: Reference mean: 9 cm
Answer: Treatment mean: 6 cm; Reference mean: 3 cm

Group means compare the prepared changes.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain the missing reference

Fixed case information

A model classroom tries a new lamp setting and observes taller seedlings than last month, when water and seed variety were also different.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the lamp-alone claim is weak and propose a comparison that improves it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Water/seed differences provide alternative explanations. Uses a concurrent matched reference with the same water and seed variety while varying lamp setting.

  1. Water/seed differences provide alternative explanations.
  2. Uses a concurrent matched reference with the same water and seed variety while varying lamp setting.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional controlled virtual experiment randomly assigns comparable pots. Seed type, light, water and duration are kept comparable. Treatment height changes are 4,5,6 cm and reference changes are 1,2,3 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies mean treatment advantage in this case?

  • a: 3 cm
  • b: 9 cm
  • c: 15 cm
  • d: 6 cm
Answer: 3 cm

The difference of group means is 5 − 2 = 3 cm.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the mean difference and state the design features that make a treatment explanation more credible.

Example of a full-credit answer: The treatment group’s mean growth is 3 cm greater. Cites random assignment/comparable pots and matched other conditions, while keeping the conclusion within the virtual experiment.

  1. The treatment group’s mean growth is 3 cm greater.
  2. Cites random assignment/comparable pots and matched other conditions, while keeping the conclusion within the virtual experiment.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A uses six separately treated virtual pots in each group. B uses one pot per group and photographs each six times.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Stronger unit replication; Independent units in B; What repeated photos add

  • a: Plan A
  • b: One per group
  • c: Repeated observations of the same pot
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Stronger unit replication → Plan A; Independent units in B → One per group; What repeated photos add → Repeated observations of the same pot

More views of one pot do not replace independent experimental units.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger plan and explain the unit-versus-reading distinction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Separate treated pots sample unit variation; multiple photos of one pot remain observations of the same unit.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Separate treated pots sample unit variation; multiple photos of one pot remain observations of the same unit.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Ten comparable model panels are available. Five will receive coating X, five no coating. The outcome is absorbed energy under equal incoming light.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Reference: Uncoated panels.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The same experimental logic applies to materials.

3B · Short answer

Describe the two groups and an assignment/control rule that strengthens the comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compares coating X with uncoated reference panels. Randomly assigns comparable panels and/or keeps incoming light and other key properties matched.

  1. Compares coating X with uncoated reference panels.
  2. Randomly assigns comparable panels and/or keeps incoming light and other key properties matched.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A report says “We tested twenty plants,” but actually measured one plant twenty times after one treatment.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Count error; Actual independent plant count; Actual reading count

  • a: Readings mistaken for independent plants
  • b: One
  • c: Twenty
  • d: No error
Answer: Count error → Readings mistaken for independent plants; Actual independent plant count → One; Actual reading count → Twenty

The treatment was applied to only one independent plant.

4B · Open ended

Correct the counts and explain why the distinction matters for the conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: There is one independently treated plant and twenty readings. Repeated readings do not show how the treatment varies across twenty different plants.

  1. There is one independently treated plant and twenty readings.
  2. Repeated readings do not show how the treatment varies across twenty different plants.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

You have twelve comparable virtual pots. Use all twelve, with several independently treated pots in each condition, to test whether a new soil cover changes seedling height growth compared with no cover over seven days. Keep seed type, light and water comparable.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Suggested group size; Reference condition; Measured outcome

  • a: Six per group
  • b: No cover
  • c: Height change over seven days
  • d: All twelve get cover
Answer: Suggested group size → Six per group; Reference condition → No cover; Measured outcome → Height change over seven days

Both treatment and reference need independent units and a common outcome.

5B · Open ended

Propose group assignment and the measurements/controls needed for a useful test.

Example of a full-credit answer: Randomly assigns six comparable pots to cover and six to no cover, or an explicitly justified balanced allocation. Measures initial/final height over seven days while keeping seed type, light and water comparable.

  1. Assigns the twelve comparable pots to cover and no-cover groups with multiple independent pots in each, using random assignment or a justified comparable allocation.
  2. Measures initial/final height over seven days while keeping seed type, light and water comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.8 · Selecting appropriate measurements

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Choose by question

Worked-example information

A virtual cart travels a fixed 3 m and you want its average speed.

Question: What must you measure in addition to distance?

Answer: Travel time.

Why: Average speed is distance divided by elapsed time.

Example 2 · Choose enough range
Tool range
ToolMaximum cm
A20
B100

Worked-example information

A sample length is about 45 cm. Tools have ranges 0–20 cm and 0–100 cm.

Question: Which can directly span it in one placement?

Answer: The 0–100 cm tool.

Why: The first tool’s range is too short for a direct single placement.

Example 3 · Respect resolution

Worked-example information

A virtual display shows only whole degrees and reads 24°C.

Question: May the report claim a measured value of 24.003°C?

Answer: No.

Why: The extra digits were not supplied by the instrument.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Match quantity to instrument

Fixed case information

A prepared task asks for the time taken by a model object to fall. Available tools are timer, ruler and balance.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Suitable instrument; Quantity; Suitable unit

  • a: Timer
  • b: Duration
  • c: Seconds
  • d: Balance
Answer: Suitable instrument → Timer; Quantity → Duration; Suitable unit → Seconds

Choose the tool for the stated quantity.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Find a temperature change

Fixed case information

A virtual thermometer reads 18°C initially and 25°C finally.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Temperature rise: 7°C
  • b: Initial value: 18°C
  • c: Temperature rise: 43°C
  • d: Initial value: 450°C
Answer: Temperature rise: 7°C; Initial value: 18°C

A change uses final minus initial.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Check range

Fixed case information

A model sample is about 75 g. Balance A ranges to 50 g; B to 200 g.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Suitable range: Balance B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The chosen range must include the anticipated value.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Read displayed detail

Fixed case information

An instrument displays steps of 0.5 cm. A record adds three decimal places without another method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies displayed resolution in this case?

  • a: 0.5 cm
  • b: 0.001 cm
  • c: A longer number proves accuracy
  • d: Hide the instrument type
Answer: 0.5 cm

Reporting cannot create detail that was not measured.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a starting offset

Fixed case information

An object starts at the virtual ruler’s 1-cm mark and ends at its 9-cm mark. A learner reports the end reading as the full length.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Find the correct length and explain the reference-point mistake.

Example of a full-credit answer: The correct length is 8 cm. The start was at the 1-cm position relative to the reading rule, so subtract the start reading or align with zero.

  1. The correct length is 8 cm.
  2. The start was at the 1-cm position relative to the reading rule, so subtract the start reading or align with zero.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual cup starts at 35°C and ends at 27°C after six minutes. The question asks how much it cooled.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Temperature drop; Needed records; Comparable interval

  • a: 8°C
  • b: Start and end temperature
  • c: Six minutes
  • d: 62°C
Answer: Temperature drop → 8°C; Needed records → Start and end temperature; Comparable interval → Six minutes

The outcome is a temperature difference over a stated interval.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the drop and identify the measurement information needed for comparing another cup.

Example of a full-credit answer: The drop is 8°C. Requires comparable initial/final temperature measurements over the same six-minute interval.

  1. The drop is 8°C.
  2. Requires comparable initial/final temperature measurements over the same six-minute interval.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A model leaf is about 6 cm long. Ruler A spans 0–10 cm in 1-mm steps; B spans 0–100 cm in 10-cm steps.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: More useful tool: Ruler A
  • b: Adequate range: 0–10 cm
  • c: More useful tool: Ruler B
  • d: Adequate range: Only maximum length matters
Answer: More useful tool: Ruler A; Adequate range: 0–10 cm

A has both sufficient range and finer useful detail.

2B · Short answer

Choose the ruler and justify using both range and resolution.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A because 6 cm lies within its 10-cm range. Its 1-mm steps provide more useful detail than B’s 10-cm steps.

  1. Chooses A because 6 cm lies within its 10-cm range.
  2. Its 1-mm steps provide more useful detail than B’s 10-cm steps.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual experiment needs to compare 12 and 16 mL. Tool A displays 1-mL steps up to 50 mL; B displays 10-mL steps up to 1,000 mL.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies more informative tool in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: 28 mL difference
  • d: A cannot hold 16 mL
Answer: A

The useful resolution depends on the difference being investigated.

3B · Open ended

Choose the tool and explain why a larger maximum capacity is not the key advantage here.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A for its 1-mL detail and adequate range. B’s larger capacity does not resolve the 4-mL comparison well with 10-mL steps.

  1. Chooses A for its 1-mL detail and adequate range.
  2. B’s larger capacity does not resolve the 4-mL comparison well with 10-mL steps.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A thermometer measures one model panel’s front surface at 30°C. A report claims every point inside all panels is exactly 30°C.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which part of the report extends the one surface measurement to untested places?

  • a: Every point in all panels
  • b: A surface reading exists
  • c: All interiors measured
  • d: No further data needed
Answer: Every point in all panels

One local reading cannot establish all internal temperatures.

4B · Short answer

Explain the overclaim and describe additional measurements that would address it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The reading only establishes the measured surface location under the stated conditions. Needs appropriate measurements at other panels/locations or inside the models before making a broader claim.

  1. The reading only establishes the measured surface location under the stated conditions.
  2. Needs appropriate measurements at other panels/locations or inside the models before making a broader claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual ramp study asks for average speed over a marked 2-m path. Use a timer resolving 0.1 s and at least three trials.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Required timed interval; Speed calculation; Record detail

  • a: Start line to finish line
  • b: 2 m divided by elapsed seconds
  • c: Trial time with units
  • d: Time after stopping only
Answer: Required timed interval → Start line to finish line; Speed calculation → 2 m divided by elapsed seconds; Record detail → Trial time with units

Define the interval, repeat it and report supported detail.

5B · Open ended

Describe the measurement procedure and how each speed will be calculated and reported.

Example of a full-credit answer: Times the same start-to-finish 2-m path on at least three trials using a common rule and 0.1-s-supported records. Calculates each speed as 2 divided by time and reports metres per second without invented precision.

  1. Times the same start-to-finish 2-m path on at least three trials using a common rule and 0.1-s-supported records.
  2. Calculates each speed as 2 divided by time and reports metres per second without invented precision.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.9 · Distinguishing quantitative and qualitative data

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two kinds in one sentence

Worked-example information

A record says “The model has 8 leaves with purple edges.”

Question: Which information is quantitative and which is qualitative?

Answer: Eight leaves is quantitative; purple edges is qualitative.

Why: Count and appearance describe different features.

Example 2 · Count categories
Surface categories
TypeCount
Smooth4
Rough6

Worked-example information

A fictional sample set contains four smooth and six rough surfaces.

Question: How many samples are there?

Answer: Ten.

Why: The category frequencies are numerical counts.

Example 3 · A code mistake

Worked-example information

A key says 1=clear, 2=cloudy, 3=opaque.

Question: Does an average code of 2 prove a physical cloudiness of 2 grams?

Answer: No.

Why: The values are category labels, with no mass unit or calibrated equal intervals.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Classify the record

Fixed case information

A virtual leaf record lists length 7 cm, colour green and edge type smooth.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Quantitative measure; Colour category; Edge category

  • a: Length 7 cm
  • b: Green
  • c: Smooth
  • d: Sample identifier
Answer: Quantitative measure → Length 7 cm; Colour category → Green; Edge category → Smooth

A measured length and descriptive categories differ.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Count observations

Fixed case information

Prepared categories are rough, smooth, rough, rough, smooth.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies rough count in this case?

  • a: Three
  • b: Two rough
  • c: Five smooth
  • d: Ten observations
Answer: Three

Counting category occurrences creates quantitative frequencies.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Read the code key

Fixed case information

A sample database uses soil type codes 1=sand model, 2=clay model and 3=mixed model.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Meaning of code 2: Two grams of soil.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A code’s interpretation depends on the supplied key.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Distinguish observation from cause

Fixed case information

A record says “brown patch present” and “plant is definitely diseased.” Only appearance was observed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies direct description in this case?

  • a: Brown patch present
  • b: Definitely diseased is directly measured
  • c: No appearance recorded
  • d: Every cause proven
Answer: Brown patch present

Descriptions should not be confused with diagnoses.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain a mixed record

Fixed case information

A prepared model report states “12 particles, mostly round, arranged in two clusters.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Identify one quantitative and one qualitative part and explain the distinction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies 12 particles or two clusters as quantitative count data. Identifies mostly round as qualitative shape description rather than a measured amount.

  1. Identifies 12 particles or two clusters as quantitative count data.
  2. Identifies mostly round as qualitative shape description rather than a measured amount.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional material log gives A mass 6 g and smooth surface; B mass 9 g and rough surface.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Heavier sample: B
  • b: Mass difference: 3 g
  • c: Heavier sample: A
  • d: Mass difference: 15 g difference
Answer: Heavier sample: B; Mass difference: 3 g

Mass supports a numerical comparison; surface words describe categories.

1B · Short answer

Compare the masses and identify the qualitative feature without turning it into a number.

Example of a full-credit answer: B is 3 g heavier than A. Smooth versus rough is a surface-category distinction, not a mass difference.

  1. B is 3 g heavier than A.
  2. Smooth versus rough is a surface-category distinction, not a mass difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A defines “toothed edge” with a prepared visual rule. Plan B lets each observer invent meanings and merges the records without checking.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: More consistent plan; Useful feature; Weakness of B

  • a: A
  • b: Shared category rule
  • c: Labels may mean different things
  • d: B
Answer: More consistent plan → A; Useful feature → Shared category rule; Weakness of B → Labels may mean different things

A common operational category helps comparisons.

2B · Open ended

Choose the plan and explain why qualitative observations benefit from definitions.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Shared definitions help observers use the same label for the same feature and reveal uncertain cases.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Shared definitions help observers use the same label for the same feature and reveal uncertain cases.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A prepared survey records bird type, number seen and observation time. Type is categorical; count and duration are quantitative.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Categorical field; Count field; Duration unit

  • a: Bird type
  • b: Number seen
  • c: Minutes
  • d: Bird type as kilograms
Answer: Categorical field → Bird type; Count field → Number seen; Duration unit → Minutes

A data set can combine several kinds of variables.

3B · Short answer

Name the two data kinds in the record and explain why observation time matters for comparing counts.

Example of a full-credit answer: Distinguishes bird type from numerical count/duration. Longer observation can yield more sightings, so counts should be compared with comparable or accounted-for observation time.

  1. Distinguishes bird type from numerical count/duration.
  2. Longer observation can yield more sightings, so counts should be compared with comparable or accounted-for observation time.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner averages sample IDs 10, 20 and 30 and reports “average temperature 20°C.” No temperatures were measured.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Averaging the sample identification numbers establishes the average temperature.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Arithmetic on identification labels cannot invent a measured property.

4B · Open ended

Explain why the calculation does not give temperature and state what data are needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: The numbers identify samples and are not temperature measurements. Needs actual temperature readings in a stated unit before calculating an average temperature.

  1. The numbers identify samples and are not temperature measurements.
  2. Needs actual temperature readings in a stated unit before calculating an average temperature.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual leaf study needs one count/measurement and one appearance category. Observers must follow the same rule and record ambiguous cases.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Suitable numeric field; Suitable category field; Uncertainty practice

  • a: Leaf length in cm
  • b: Edge type from guide
  • c: Mark unclear cases
  • d: Sample ID as mass
Answer: Suitable numeric field → Leaf length in cm; Suitable category field → Edge type from guide; Uncertainty practice → Mark unclear cases

A useful table separates quantities from defined descriptions.

5B · Open ended

Propose one quantitative field and one defined qualitative field, with a rule for unclear cases.

Example of a full-credit answer: Provides a suitable count or measurement with units where needed. Provides a clear category definition/guide and marks uncertain cases for review rather than guessing with certainty.

  1. Provides a suitable count or measurement with units where needed.
  2. Provides a clear category definition/guide and marks uncertain cases for review rather than guessing with certainty.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.10 · Repeating measurements

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find centre and spread
Repeated readings
TrialTime s
15
26
37

Worked-example information

A prepared repeated-time record is 5,6,7 seconds.

Question: What are its mean and range?

Answer: Mean 6 s; range 2 s.

Why: The total 18 divided by 3 gives 6; 7−5 gives 2.

Example 2 · Not the same quantity

Worked-example information

A class records one plant’s height on days 1, 8 and 15.

Question: Are differences necessarily measurement noise?

Answer: No.

Why: The plant may actually grow; these are observations over time.

Example 3 · A repeated offset

Worked-example information

A known 20-g reference reads 22,22,22 g on a model balance.

Question: Will simply averaging fix the offset?

Answer: No.

Why: The readings suggest a systematic problem that needs a reference/zero check.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify repeated readings

Fixed case information

A virtual rod is measured three times with the same ruler and method: 9.8,10.0,10.2 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Repeated target: Same rod length.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The repeated procedure gives a centre and a spread.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Different targets

Fixed case information

A record lists three separate leaf lengths: 4,7,9 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Main variation includes; Target count; Missing repeat evidence

  • a: Differences among leaves
  • b: Three leaves
  • c: Repeated readings of each leaf
  • d: Only instrument noise
Answer: Main variation includes → Differences among leaves; Target count → Three leaves; Missing repeat evidence → Repeated readings of each leaf

Different objects are not repeated measurements of one unchanged object.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Keep a surprising value

Fixed case information

Timer readings are 3.0,3.1,5.2,3.0 s. No recording error has been established.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Appropriate next step: Investigate the unusual reading
  • b: Inappropriate step: Delete it without a reason
  • c: Appropriate next step: Delete 5.2 automatically
  • d: Inappropriate step: Retain all readings and investigate the unusual trial
Answer: Appropriate next step: Investigate the unusual reading; Inappropriate step: Delete it without a reason

An outlier may reveal a real event or measurement issue.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Recognise a shared bias

Fixed case information

A known 8-cm reference gives 9,9,9 cm on the same virtual ruler.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Likely concern; Mean reading; Reference difference

  • a: Systematic positive offset
  • b: 9 cm
  • c: 1 cm
  • d: Perfect accuracy established
Answer: Likely concern → Systematic positive offset; Mean reading → 9 cm; Reference difference → 1 cm

Repeating the same offset does not make it vanish.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · Explain why repeat

Fixed case information

A learner records one fall time of 4.2 s and declares the method never varies. Another makes five planned comparable trials.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what repeats add and what a single reading cannot establish.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repeats reveal variation and support a more informative summary. A single reading cannot establish the spread or prove the method never varies.

  1. Repeats reveal variation and support a more informative summary.
  2. A single reading cannot establish the spread or prove the method never varies.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared readings for one model distance are 14,15,16,15 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Mean; Range; Number of readings

  • a: 15 cm
  • b: 2 cm
  • c: Four
  • d: 60 cm
Answer: Mean → 15 cm; Range → 2 cm; Number of readings → Four

Use all four readings for the mean and the extrema for range.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the mean and range and explain why both are useful.

Example of a full-credit answer: Mean is 15 cm and range is 2 cm. The mean shows a central value while the range shows observed variation.

  1. Mean is 15 cm and range is 2 cm.
  2. The mean shows a central value while the range shows observed variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A measures the same virtual object five times using a fixed method. B measures five different objects once and claims instrument repeatability.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies better repeatability plan in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Only reading noise
  • d: Different target each time
Answer: A

Repeatability needs a comparable repeated target/procedure.

2B · Short answer

Choose the plan and explain what makes the alternative ambiguous for repeatability.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. B mixes differences between objects with possible measurement variation.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. B mixes differences between objects with possible measurement variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Three readings of one unchanged virtual volume are 24,25,26 mL. The instrument uses the same method each time.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Mean volume: 75 mL.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The record supports a mean and spread, not exact certainty.

3B · Open ended

Calculate the mean and range, then explain why the result should not be called exact from these readings alone.

Example of a full-credit answer: Reports a mean of 25 mL and variation/range of 2 mL. The readings vary and may have additional systematic uncertainty, so exactness is not established.

  1. Reports a mean of 25 mL and variation/range of 2 mL.
  2. The readings vary and may have additional systematic uncertainty, so exactness is not established.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A known 10-g reference reads 12,12,12 g. A learner says three identical readings prove the true mass is 12 g.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies error in this case?

  • a: Agreement confused with accuracy
  • b: No issue exists
  • c: 12 g is supplied as true
  • d: Averaging gives 10 automatically
Answer: Agreement confused with accuracy

Consistency can coexist with a biased reading.

4B · Short answer

Explain the mistake and identify a suitable next check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identical readings show consistency but disagree with the 10-g reference. Check zero/calibration or a suitable reference because the instrument appears 2 g high.

  1. Identical readings show consistency but disagree with the 10-g reference.
  2. Check zero/calibration or a suitable reference because the instrument appears 2 g high.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Use a virtual timer on the same falling event at least four times. Keep the start/stop rule fixed and decide how to handle unusual readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Planned repeats: At least four
  • b: Method control: Common start and stop rules
  • c: Planned repeats: One chosen result
  • d: Method control: Different rules each trial
Answer: Planned repeats: At least four; Method control: Common start and stop rules

A repeat plan needs both consistency and transparent records.

5B · Open ended

Describe the repeat procedure and a transparent rule for unusual readings.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses at least four comparable trials with a common timing rule and records all results. Keeps unusual readings with notes, investigates possible errors and reports any justified correction rather than silently deleting them.

  1. Uses at least four comparable trials with a common timing rule and records all results.
  2. Keeps unusual readings with notes, investigates possible errors and reports any justified correction rather than silently deleting them.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.11 · Calculating averages

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Add and divide
Model readings
TrialTime s
13
25
37

Worked-example information

Prepared model times are 3, 5 and 7 s.

Question: What is the mean time?

Answer: 5 s.

Why: The total is 15 s, and 15 ÷ 3 = 5.

Example 2 · A real zero

Worked-example information

Prepared counts are 0, 4 and 8.

Question: What is their mean?

Answer: 4.

Why: All three valid counts belong: 12 ÷ 3 = 4.

Example 3 · Unequal groups

Worked-example information

Group A has one reading of 2. Group B has three readings of 6.

Question: What is the mean of all four readings?

Answer: 5.

Why: The total is 20; divide by four, not by two group labels.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Calculate a mean

Fixed case information

Fictional distances are 6, 9 and 12 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Mean; Total; Reading count

  • a: 9 cm
  • b: 27 cm
  • c: Three
  • d: 3 cm
Answer: Mean → 9 cm; Total → 27 cm; Reading count → Three

Add the three distances then divide by three.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F2 · Include the zero

Fixed case information

Prepared model counts are 0, 2, 4 and 6. All are valid observations.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Mean count; Total count; Number of observations

  • a: 3
  • b: 12
  • c: Four
  • d: Six
Answer: Mean count → 3; Total count → 12; Number of observations → Four

The zero contributes to the observation count.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Missing is not zero

Fixed case information

A table has readings 4, missing, 8. Only the two numerical readings are currently available.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Mean of available readings: 4.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The available mean uses 12 ÷ 2, while the missing result must be disclosed.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Equal means, different spread

Fixed case information

Set A is 4,5,6 and B is 1,5,9. Both means are 5.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies more variable set in this case?

  • a: B
  • b: A
  • c: Every value identical
  • d: Both ranges zero
Answer: B

A shared mean can hide different variation.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain an averaging error

Fixed case information

A learner adds 5,7,9 cm to get 21 cm and reports the mean as 21 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Correct the mean and explain the missed step.

Example of a full-credit answer: The mean is 7 cm. The total 21 cm must be divided by the three readings.

  1. The mean is 7 cm.
  2. The total 21 cm must be divided by the three readings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared water-loss readings are 0,4,5,7 mL, with zero confirmed as a valid observation.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Mean loss; Total loss; Valid trial count

  • a: 4 mL
  • b: 16 mL
  • c: Four recorded trials
  • d: 5.33 mL
Answer: Mean loss → 4 mL; Total loss → 16 mL; Valid trial count → Four recorded trials

All four readings, including zero, belong in the calculation.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the mean and explain why zero remains in the divisor.

Example of a full-credit answer: The mean is 16 ÷ 4 = 4 mL. Zero is a valid measured observation, so there are four trials.

  1. The mean is 16 ÷ 4 = 4 mL.
  2. Zero is a valid measured observation, so there are four trials.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Two timers both average 10 s. A’s readings are 9,10,11; B’s are 5,10,15. The goal is consistent readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: More consistent set: A
  • b: A range: 2 s
  • c: More consistent set: B
  • d: A range: Both have no spread
Answer: More consistent set: A; A range: 2 s

The smaller spread matters for the stated goal.

2B · Open ended

Choose the more consistent record and justify beyond the mean.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Uses its smaller range of 2 s versus 10 s, despite equal means.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Uses its smaller range of 2 s versus 10 s, despite equal means.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Group A has two readings of 4 units; group B has four readings of 10 units. Find the mean of all six readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Overall mean; Overall total; Overall count

  • a: 8 units
  • b: 48 units
  • c: Six
  • d: 7 units
Answer: Overall mean → 8 units; Overall total → 48 units; Overall count → Six

(2×4 + 4×10) ÷ 6 = 8.

3B · Short answer

Calculate the combined mean and explain why simply averaging 4 and 10 gives the wrong overall reading mean.

Example of a full-credit answer: The overall mean is 48 ÷ 6 = 8 units. The groups have unequal reading counts, so their means should not receive equal weight for this question.

  1. The overall mean is 48 ÷ 6 = 8 units.
  2. The groups have unequal reading counts, so their means should not receive equal weight for this question.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Recorded temperatures are 20°C, missing, 24°C. A learner replaces missing with 0°C and reports 14.7°C without disclosure.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Replacing the missing temperature with 0°C without disclosure is a valid summary of these measured readings.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Inventing zero changes the evidence and calculation.

4B · Open ended

Explain the error and give the honest available-data summary.

Example of a full-credit answer: The missing entry is not evidence of 0°C. Reports 22°C as the mean of the two available readings and states one is missing.

  1. The missing entry is not evidence of 0°C.
  2. Reports 22°C as the mean of the two available readings and states one is missing.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual sensor gives readings 7,8,8,9 units. Your report must show the mean and enough detail to judge consistency.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies mean in this case?

  • a: 8 units
  • b: 32 units
  • c: Three readings
  • d: 8-unit range
Answer: 8 units

A checkable report keeps count, units and spread with the mean.

5B · Open ended

Write a brief report with the mean calculation and one useful measure of variation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Shows 32 ÷ 4 = 8 units with four readings. Reports range 2 units or equivalently preserves the raw spread and does not claim every reading equals 8.

  1. Shows 32 ÷ 4 = 8 units with four readings.
  2. Reports range 2 units or equivalently preserves the raw spread and does not claim every reading equals 8.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.12 · Recognising measurement uncertainty

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find interval ends

Worked-example information

A supplied classroom result is 30 ± 2 mL, interpreted here as an interval.

Question: What interval is reported?

Answer: 28 to 32 mL.

Why: Subtract and add two to the central value.

Example 2 · See an overlap
Stated intervals
ObjectLow cmHigh cm
A911
B1012

Worked-example information

A has interval 9–11 cm and B has 10–12 cm.

Question: Is there overlap?

Answer: Yes, from 10 to 11 cm.

Why: The current intervals do not clearly separate the values.

Example 3 · Select a repair

Worked-example information

A virtual ruler reads a known 10-cm reference as 12 cm every time.

Question: What should be checked before simply taking more repeats?

Answer: Zero or calibration against the reference.

Why: The repeated offset suggests systematic error.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read a stated interval

Fixed case information

For this classroom case, 14 ± 2 units means the reported interval from central value minus 2 to plus 2.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies lower end in this case?

  • a: 12 units
  • b: 7 units
  • c: 28 units
  • d: Only 2 units
Answer: 12 units

The supplied convention determines the interval.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Compare interval widths

Fixed case information

Prepared intervals are A=20±1 cm and B=20±4 cm, using the same reporting convention.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies narrower interval in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: 1 cm full width
  • d: 4 cm full width
Answer: A

Full width includes both sides of the centre.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Recognise overlap

Fixed case information

Stated intervals are P=5–7 s and Q=6–8 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Overlap: 6–7 s.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Overlap allows but does not prove equality.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Choose a relevant improvement

Fixed case information

A virtual display rounds to whole centimetres, but the question concerns a 0.2-cm difference. No finer measurement is available.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Main limitation; Useful improvement; Useless change

  • a: Coarse resolution
  • b: Finer suitable instrument
  • c: Write extra decimals without data
  • d: Too many genuine digits
Answer: Main limitation → Coarse resolution; Useful improvement → Finer suitable instrument; Useless change → Write extra decimals without data

The desired difference is smaller than the display step.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain cautious comparison

Fixed case information

A reports 10±1 units and B reports 10.5±1 units. The intervals are interpreted as stated classroom ranges.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the central readings alone do not show a clear difference and why that does not prove equality.

Example of a full-credit answer: The stated intervals overlap, so the method does not clearly distinguish the values. Overlap does not establish exact equality; more informative measurements may be needed.

  1. The stated intervals overlap, so the method does not clearly distinguish the values.
  2. Overlap does not establish exact equality; more informative measurements may be needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

In this toy case, A is reported as 8±1 cm and B as 12±1 cm, interpreted as bounds.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: A interval: 7–9 cm
  • b: B interval: 11–13 cm
  • c: A interval: A 8–9 only
  • d: B interval: B 1–12
Answer: A interval: 7–9 cm; B interval: 11–13 cm

A’s largest bound is below B’s smallest bound.

1B · Open ended

Write both intervals and explain why the order is resolved under the supplied interpretation.

Example of a full-credit answer: A spans 7–9 cm and B spans 11–13 cm. B’s lower bound exceeds A’s upper bound, so B is larger within these stated bounds.

  1. A spans 7–9 cm and B spans 11–13 cm.
  2. B’s lower bound exceeds A’s upper bound, so B is larger within these stated bounds.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A question compares model lengths differing by about 0.3 cm. Tool A rounds to 1 cm; tool B to 0.1 cm with comparable calibration.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies more useful resolution in this case?

  • a: Tool B
  • b: Tool A
  • c: 0.01 cm for A
  • d: Ten cm for B
Answer: Tool B

Finer resolution helps address a difference hidden by whole-centimetre rounding.

2B · Short answer

Choose the tool and explain both its advantage and one remaining limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses B because 0.1-cm steps give useful detail for the 0.3-cm comparison. Notes that calibration, variability or other uncertainty still matters.

  1. Chooses B because 0.1-cm steps give useful detail for the 0.3-cm comparison.
  2. Notes that calibration, variability or other uncertainty still matters.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Prepared intervals are fall A=3.0–3.4 s and B=3.2–3.6 s. The central values differ but overlap is present.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Overlap; Careful conclusion; Unsupported claim of exact equality

  • a: 3.2–3.4 s
  • b: Current intervals do not clearly separate times
  • c: The true times must be identical
  • d: No shared interval
Answer: Overlap → 3.2–3.4 s; Careful conclusion → Current intervals do not clearly separate times; Unsupported claim of exact equality → The true times must be identical

The same interval reasoning applies to time.

3B · Open ended

Identify the overlap and state a conclusion that neither overclaims a difference nor proves equality.

Example of a full-credit answer: The overlap is 3.2–3.4 s. The current intervals do not clearly distinguish the times, but do not prove they are exactly equal.

  1. The overlap is 3.2–3.4 s.
  2. The current intervals do not clearly distinguish the times, but do not prove they are exactly equal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A thermometer displays 21°C in whole-degree steps. A learner types 21.000°C and says uncertainty has vanished.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Error; Actual display step; Needed improvement

  • a: Writing digits treated as new evidence
  • b: 1°C
  • c: A justified better measurement method
  • d: The temperature unit is Celsius
Answer: Error → Writing digits treated as new evidence; Actual display step → 1°C; Needed improvement → A justified better measurement method

Formatting does not create finer observations.

4B · Short answer

Explain the mistake and name a legitimate way to obtain more useful information.

Example of a full-credit answer: Extra written zeros do not reduce uncertainty or improve the instrument’s resolution. Uses a suitably finer calibrated instrument, repeated measurements or a relevant method check.

  1. Extra written zeros do not reduce uncertainty or improve the instrument’s resolution.
  2. Uses a suitably finer calibrated instrument, repeated measurements or a relevant method check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual length tool gives 19,20,21 cm. A prepared method note specifies report centre 20 cm with a classroom interval of 19–21 cm. Explain how to compare a later result.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Reported centre; Stated interval; Required comparison habit

  • a: 20 cm
  • b: 19–21 cm
  • c: Use both interval and centre
  • d: 20.000 exact
Answer: Reported centre → 20 cm; Stated interval → 19–21 cm; Required comparison habit → Use both interval and centre

The method note supplies the reporting convention.

5B · Open ended

Write the report and explain how you would compare it with another measurement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Reports 20 cm with the specified 19–21 cm classroom interval, not as exact. Compares the other result’s interval and method as well as its centre, recognising overlap and limitations.

  1. Reports 20 cm with the specified 19–21 cm classroom interval, not as exact.
  2. Compares the other result’s interval and method as well as its centre, recognising overlap and limitations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.13 · Understanding precision and accuracy

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A tight miss

Worked-example information

For a toy 20-g reference, readings are 22,22,22 g.

Question: What pattern is shown?

Answer: High repeat precision with a positive 2-g bias.

Why: The readings agree with one another but miss the stated reference.

Example 2 · Same mean, different precision
Prepared sets
SetReadings cm
A9.9, 10.0, 10.1
B8, 10, 12

Worked-example information

For a 10-cm reference, A reads 9.9,10.0,10.1 and B reads 8,10,12 cm.

Question: Which set is more precise?

Answer: A.

Why: Both means are 10, but A has much less spread.

Example 3 · Choose the repair

Worked-example information

A ruler is consistently 1 cm high against a reference.

Question: Is more averaging alone the best repair?

Answer: No.

Why: Check the zero or calibration; the shared offset will remain in an average.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Recognise a precise bias

Fixed case information

A known toy target is 6 units; repeated readings are 8,8,8.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Pattern; Offset; Reference

  • a: Precise but biased high
  • b: 2 units
  • c: 6 units
  • d: Accurate because identical
Answer: Pattern → Precise but biased high; Offset → 2 units; Reference → 6 units

Closeness among readings differs from closeness to reference.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Compare spread

Fixed case information

Under the same setup, A reads 14,15,16 and B reads 10,15,20 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: More precise set; A range; B range

  • a: A
  • b: 2 units
  • c: 10 units
  • d: B
Answer: More precise set → A; A range → 2 units; B range → 10 units

The narrower spread indicates greater repeat precision here.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Check agreement with reference

Fixed case information

The supplied reference is 30 g. Method P has mean 30 g; Q has mean 34 g. Both have the same small spread.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Closer mean to reference; Q mean difference; Comparison condition

  • a: P
  • b: 4 g
  • c: Same small spread
  • d: Q
Answer: Closer mean to reference → P; Q mean difference → 4 g; Comparison condition → Same small spread

With equal spread, the reference comparison reveals Q’s offset.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Fine digits can be wrong

Fixed case information

A virtual scale displays 12.000 g for a known 10-g reference every time.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies problem in this case?

  • a: Systematic positive bias
  • b: Perfect accuracy proved
  • c: No displayed digits
  • d: More zeros in the report
Answer: Systematic positive bias

Fine display detail does not establish agreement with reference.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain an accurate mean with spread

Fixed case information

For a supplied 10-cm reference, readings 6,10,14 cm have mean 10 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Describe the mean’s agreement and the repeated readings’ precision separately.

Example of a full-credit answer: The mean equals the supplied 10-cm reference. The readings are widely scattered, with range 8 cm, so repeat precision is poor.

  1. The mean equals the supplied 10-cm reference.
  2. Identifies poor repeat precision because the readings are widely scattered; may support this with the 8-cm range or the 6–14 cm readings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A toy reference is 50 g. Method A reads 52,52,52; B reads 49,50,51 g.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies method with shared offset in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: 2 g low
  • d: 150 g
Answer: A

A is tightly repeatable but offset; B’s mean agrees with the reference with some spread.

1B · Short answer

Compare precision and reference agreement, without treating them as the same property.

Example of a full-credit answer: A has tighter repeat precision but is 2 g high against the reference. B has some spread but its mean is 50 g, matching the supplied reference.

  1. A has tighter repeat precision but is 2 g high against the reference.
  2. B has some spread but its mean is 50 g, matching the supplied reference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A model thermometer gives nearly identical readings but stays 3°C above two supplied reference temperatures.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Most relevant first improvement: Add more uncorrected repeats only.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A repeated reference disagreement points to systematic error.

2B · Open ended

Choose the improvement and explain why it targets the observed problem.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses a calibration/zero or reference-based offset check. A shared 3°C bias is not removed merely by averaging more similarly biased readings.

  1. Chooses a calibration/zero or reference-based offset check.
  2. A shared 3°C bias is not removed merely by averaging more similarly biased readings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual 5.0-s reference event produces 4.9,5.0,5.1 s. Another timer produces 6.0,6.0,6.0 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: More tightly repeated timer: Second
  • b: Mean closer to reference: First
  • c: More tightly repeated timer: First has zero spread
  • d: Mean closer to reference: Second mean is correct
Answer: More tightly repeated timer: Second; Mean closer to reference: First

Timing shows the same precision–accuracy distinction.

3B · Short answer

Explain which timer is more precise and which mean agrees better with the reference.

Example of a full-credit answer: The second is more precise in this record because all readings agree. The first mean is 5.0 s and matches the reference; the second is 1.0 s high.

  1. The second is more precise in this record because all readings agree.
  2. The first mean is 5.0 s and matches the reference; the second is 1.0 s high.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

For a 20-unit reference, readings 10,20,30 average 20. A learner says every reading is both accurate and precise.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Error; Observed range; Correct statement

  • a: Mean used to describe every reading
  • b: 20 units
  • c: Mean agrees but readings scatter
  • d: No error
Answer: Error → Mean used to describe every reading; Observed range → 20 units; Correct statement → Mean agrees but readings scatter

A correct mean can hide large individual differences.

4B · Open ended

Correct the claim using both the mean and individual spread.

Example of a full-credit answer: The mean equals 20, but individual readings differ from it and from the reference. The 20-unit range shows poor repeat precision compared with a tight set.

  1. The mean equals 20, but individual readings differ from it and from the reference.
  2. The 20-unit range shows poor repeat precision compared with a tight set.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual length sensor may have both bias and random variation. You have a 10-cm reference and can take five readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies needed reference check in this case?

  • a: Compare centre with 10 cm
  • b: Only one favourite reading
  • c: Count display digits only
  • d: Hide the reference
Answer: Compare centre with 10 cm

One repeated reference series can reveal both centre offset and spread.

5B · Open ended

Propose a procedure that checks bias and precision separately.

Example of a full-credit answer: Measures the 10-cm reference five times and compares the mean/centre with 10 to assess possible bias. Inspects and reports the spread of all five readings to assess repeat precision.

  1. Measures the 10-cm reference five times and compares the mean/centre with 10 to assess possible bias.
  2. Inspects and reports the spread of all five readings to assess repeat precision.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.14 · Organising data

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Repair the headings

Worked-example information

A table has columns “A, B, C” holding trial number, ramp height and distance.

Question: What headings would be clearer?

Answer: Trial, ramp height (cm), travel distance (cm).

Why: Each heading names the variable and measurement unit.

Example 2 · Preserve the row
Raw record
SampleLength cm
A2
B7
C4

Worked-example information

Prepared rows are A:2 cm, B:7 cm and C:4 cm.

Question: When sorting by length, what travels with each value?

Answer: Its sample identifier and all associated fields.

Why: Otherwise length could be assigned to the wrong sample.

Example 3 · A missing reading

Worked-example information

A thermometer disconnects during trial 4.

Question: What belongs in its cell?

Answer: A clear missing marker with the reason.

Why: It is not evidence of 0°C.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Choose clear headings

Fixed case information

A virtual cart record needs trial ID, ramp height and travel distance. Both lengths use centimetres.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Useful outcome heading: Travel distance (cm)
  • b: Identifier field: Trial ID
  • c: Useful outcome heading: Number only
  • d: Identifier field: Distance used as identity
Answer: Useful outcome heading: Travel distance (cm); Identifier field: Trial ID

Labels keep the roles and units explicit.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Preserve a valid zero

Fixed case information

A prepared count table has trial 1=0, trial 2=3 and trial 3=missing.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Valid count; Unavailable value; Incorrect replacement

  • a: 0 in trial 1
  • b: Trial 3
  • c: Missing automatically becomes zero
  • d: A measured zero remains zero
Answer: Valid count → 0 in trial 1; Unavailable value → Trial 3; Incorrect replacement → Missing automatically becomes zero

Zero and missing encode different evidence.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Keep unit conversions visible

Fixed case information

A record contains lengths 100 cm and 2 m. One metre equals 100 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies second length in cm in this case?

  • a: 200 cm
  • b: 2 cm
  • c: One cm per m
  • d: 100 cm
Answer: 200 cm

Consistent units are needed before numerical comparison.

Scientific explorer: unit lab

F4 · Protect linked fields

Fixed case information

Sample P has mass 4 g and colour red; Q has mass 9 g and colour blue. A sort changes only masses, leaving IDs and colours fixed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false? Sorting the mass column alone always preserves each sample’s correct mass and colour.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A table’s row links are part of the scientific record.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a transparent correction

Fixed case information

The raw notebook shows 18 cm for trial B, but the typed table says 81 cm. The author checks the notebook before changing the table.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the correction is justified and what should be preserved in the record.

Example of a full-credit answer: The original source confirms 18 cm, so 81 was a copying error. Keeps a correction note/original value and source rather than silently changing the record.

  1. The original source confirms 18 cm, so 81 was a copying error.
  2. Keeps a correction note/original value and source rather than silently changing the record.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A prepared list says “trial A, shade 20%, 27°C; trial B, shade 60%, 23°C.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Outcome column; Setting column; Identifier column

  • a: Temperature (°C)
  • b: Shade (%)
  • c: Trial
  • d: Shade as °C
Answer: Outcome column → Temperature (°C); Setting column → Shade (%); Identifier column → Trial

The three fields have distinct meanings and units.

1B · Open ended

Propose appropriate columns and explain how they preserve the comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses trial ID, shade (%) and temperature (°C) as separate columns. Keeps each temperature linked to its own shade setting and trial.

  1. Uses trial ID, shade (%) and temperature (°C) as separate columns.
  2. Keeps each temperature linked to its own shade setting and trial.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Report A includes a mean, count and link to raw readings. B shows only a mean with no count or source.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? More checkable report: A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The calculation and evidence can be checked when the raw record remains available.

2B · Short answer

Choose the report and explain two things a reader can check from it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Readers can recalculate the mean/count and inspect variation or unusual readings in the raw data.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Readers can recalculate the mean/count and inspect variation or unusual readings in the raw data.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A fictional shell-shape survey records round=4, spiral=6, pointed=2. Categories use a shared guide.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies total observed in this case?

  • a: 12
  • b: 10
  • c: Round
  • d: Kilograms as category count
Answer: 12

A frequency table needs category definitions and counts.

3B · Open ended

Describe a useful table and include a check on the total.

Example of a full-credit answer: Lists each shape category with its count using the shared definitions. Checks that 4 + 6 + 2 = 12 observations.

  1. Lists each shape category with its count using the shared definitions.
  2. Checks that 4 + 6 + 2 = 12 observations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A table puts 3 m and 40 cm in a column labelled cm but enters 3 and 40. It then says 40 is longer.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies error in this case?

  • a: Metre value not converted
  • b: No error
  • c: 0.03 cm
  • d: 40 cm
Answer: Metre value not converted

The comparison reverses when the unit mistake is corrected.

4B · Short answer

Correct the entries and explain why the original conclusion failed.

Example of a full-credit answer: Converts 3 m to 300 cm; the other value remains 40 cm. The original compared unequal units as plain numbers, so it wrongly ranked the lengths.

  1. Converts 3 m to 300 cm; the other value remains 40 cm.
  2. The original compared unequal units as plain numbers, so it wrongly ranked the lengths.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual cooling study has three cover types and three trials each. It records start and end temperature after five minutes, including possible missing readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Useful row unit; Needed columns; Missing-data rule

  • a: One cover trial
  • b: Cover, trial, start, end and units
  • c: Mark missing with reason
  • d: One merged number
Answer: Useful row unit → One cover trial; Needed columns → Cover, trial, start, end and units; Missing-data rule → Mark missing with reason

A planned structure supports later calculation of cooling.

5B · Open ended

Propose the table structure and a rule that preserves missing or corrected observations.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses one row per trial with cover ID, trial ID and start/end temperatures in °C at the stated interval. Marks missing readings honestly and records corrections with a source/reason rather than inventing zeros.

  1. Uses one row per trial with cover ID, trial ID and start/end temperatures in °C at the stated interval.
  2. Marks missing readings honestly and records corrections with a source/reason rather than inventing zeros.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.15 · Interpreting tables, graphs and charts

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Read a change
Cooling record
Time minTemperature °C
030
525
1020

Worked-example information

A prepared temperature table lists 0 min:30°C, 5 min:25°C and 10 min:20°C.

Question: How much did temperature fall over ten minutes?

Answer: 10°C.

Why: Subtract the final value from the initial value.

Example 2 · Read category bars

Worked-example information

A fictional survey has oak model leaves=3 and grass model leaves=9.

Question: How many more grass-model leaves are counted?

Answer: Six.

Why: The difference is 9−3; the chart does not explain why the counts differ.

Example 3 · Do not extend forever

Worked-example information

A line rises at three measured settings.

Question: Does that prove it rises forever beyond them?

Answer: No.

Why: No unmeasured settings or justified continuing model have been supplied.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read the graph quantity

Fixed case information

A prepared graph has horizontal time in minutes and vertical temperature in °C.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Vertical quantity: Travel distance.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Axis labels identify the variables.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Find a table difference

Fixed case information

Fictional lengths at day 1 and day 6 are 4 cm and 13 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Increase; Final value; Initial value

  • a: 9 cm
  • b: 13 cm
  • c: 4 cm
  • d: 17 cm
Answer: Increase → 9 cm; Final value → 13 cm; Initial value → 4 cm

The change is final minus initial.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Read unequal intervals

Fixed case information

A record rises 2 units from minute 0 to 1 and another 2 units from minute 1 to 5.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Faster average rise: First interval
  • b: First duration: 1 minute
  • c: Faster average rise: Second interval
  • d: First duration: Five minutes for first
Answer: Faster average rise: First interval; First duration: 1 minute

The same change over less time is a greater average rate.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · See an axis warning

Fixed case information

Bars labelled 90 and 100 start from an axis baseline of 89. A viewer says the second value is ten times the first.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Actual difference; Actual ratio; Visual issue

  • a: 10 units
  • b: 100 divided by 90
  • c: Truncated baseline exaggerates bar-height ratio
  • d: Tenfold increase
Answer: Actual difference → 10 units; Actual ratio → 100 divided by 90; Visual issue → Truncated baseline exaggerates bar-height ratio

Read numerical values before interpreting apparent bar lengths.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a limited trend

Fixed case information

Measured outputs at settings 1,2,3 are 2,4,6 units. No measurements exist at settings above 3.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Describe the observed pattern using the values and state a limit on extending it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Output rises from 2 to 4 to 6 over settings 1–3. The record alone does not establish the pattern at untested settings or forever.

  1. Output rises from 2 to 4 to 6 over settings 1–3.
  2. The record alone does not establish the pattern at untested settings or forever.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared temperatures are 40°C at 0 min, 34°C at 3 min and 28°C at 6 min.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Total drop; First interval drop; Average drop per minute

  • a: 12°C
  • b: 6°C
  • c: 2°C per minute
  • d: 68°C
Answer: Total drop → 12°C; First interval drop → 6°C; Average drop per minute → 2°C per minute

The six-minute drop is 40−28=12; divide by six for average rate.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the total drop and describe the pattern across the two equal intervals.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total drop is 12°C. Both three-minute intervals drop 6°C, an equal average drop rate in this record.

  1. The total drop is 12°C.
  2. Both three-minute intervals drop 6°C, an equal average drop rate in this record.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A fictional survey counts three rock-shape categories: round 5, angular 8 and flat 3. The categories are not successive times.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies suitable display in this case?

  • a: Bar chart of category counts
  • b: A time-history claim
  • c: Temperature
  • d: Every category is a time point
Answer: Bar chart of category counts

The graph should reflect categorical data.

2B · Open ended

Choose a display and explain why the category order does not show change over time.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses a labelled bar chart or equivalent category-frequency display. The shape categories are groups, not successive times, so their order is not a time trend.

  1. Uses a labelled bar chart or equivalent category-frequency display.
  2. The shape categories are groups, not successive times, so their order is not a time trend.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Prepared paired records are light settings 1,2,3 with model growth 3,5,7 cm. Other possible factors were not controlled in the supplied observational record.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies descriptive association in this case?

  • a: Higher light settings accompany greater growth
  • b: Higher light accompanies less growth
  • c: 21 cm change
  • d: All causes controlled
Answer: Higher light settings accompany greater growth

The association is clear but the design does not isolate cause.

3B · Short answer

Describe the association with numbers and explain why the graph alone does not prove causation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Growth rises from 3 to 7 cm as light setting rises in the record. Uncontrolled factors could explain some of the association; the plot alone cannot isolate a light effect.

  1. Growth rises from 3 to 7 cm as light setting rises in the record.
  2. Uncontrolled factors could explain some of the association; the plot alone cannot isolate a light effect.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Values A=48 and B=52 are plotted with a vertical baseline at 47. A learner says B is five times A because visible bar heights are 1 and 5.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? The actual value 52 is five times the actual value 48.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A truncated axis changes visual height ratios.

4B · Open ended

Explain the graph-reading error and provide the correct numerical comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: The baseline is truncated, so visible bar-height ratios are not ratios of the data values. B is 4 units greater than A, with ratio 52/48 rather than five.

  1. The baseline is truncated, so visible bar-height ratios are not ratios of the data values.
  2. B is 4 units greater than A, with ratio 52/48 rather than five.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

You have model temperatures at 0,2,4,6 minutes: 20,23,26,29°C. Make a graph and indicate which points are actually measured.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Suitable horizontal axis; Suitable vertical axis; Measured-point rule

  • a: Time (min)
  • b: Temperature (°C)
  • c: Mark the four supplied times
  • d: Favourite colours
Answer: Suitable horizontal axis → Time (min); Suitable vertical axis → Temperature (°C); Measured-point rule → Mark the four supplied times

A graph needs accurate labels, scale and measured-point status.

5B · Open ended

Propose the axes/display and one note that prevents overinterpreting the connecting line.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses time in minutes horizontally and temperature in °C vertically with the four correct points. States that the points are supplied measurements and any line between them is a guide/interpolation, not proof every intermediate moment was measured.

  1. Uses time in minutes horizontally and temperature in °C vertically with the four correct points.
  2. States that the points are supplied measurements and any line between them is a guide/interpolation, not proof every intermediate moment was measured.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.16 · Identifying patterns

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Find a plateau
Model sequence
SettingOutput
12
25
37
47
57

Worked-example information

Prepared output values for increasing settings are 2,5,7,7,7.

Question: Where is the plateau?

Answer: Across the last three observations.

Why: Output stays at 7 despite higher settings.

Example 2 · Find a repeated sequence

Worked-example information

A prepared colour sequence is light, dark, light, dark.

Question: What pattern is described?

Answer: A repeating two-stage cycle.

Why: It repeats categories instead of continually increasing.

Example 3 · A conditional prediction

Worked-example information

A toy numerical rule is 3,6,9, adding 3 each step.

Question: What follows if the same rule continues?

Answer: 12.

Why: The prediction explicitly depends on the stated rule continuing.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Describe a rising pattern

Fixed case information

Prepared model values at successive settings are 2,4,6,8 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Direction; Step difference; Tested setting count

  • a: Increasing
  • b: 2 units
  • c: Four
  • d: Decreasing
Answer: Direction → Increasing; Step difference → 2 units; Tested setting count → Four

The full supplied sequence increases by a constant amount.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Find a cycle

Fixed case information

A virtual light record repeats bright, dim, bright, dim, bright, dim.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Pattern type; Stages per cycle; Sequence after bright

  • a: Repeating cycle
  • b: Two
  • c: Dim
  • d: Permanent increase
Answer: Pattern type → Repeating cycle; Stages per cycle → Two; Sequence after bright → Dim

The pair repeats rather than rising forever.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Notice a plateau

Fixed case information

Model output across settings 1–5 is 1,3,5,5,5.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Plateau value: 5.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The output stops rising over the last three supplied settings.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F4 · Keep an exception

Fixed case information

Measurements mostly cluster at 10,11,10, but one trial reads 19 with no known cause.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies appropriate action in this case?

  • a: Investigate the 19 reading
  • b: Erase 19 immediately
  • c: Only keep 19
  • d: No checking possible
Answer: Investigate the 19 reading

Exceptions can reveal real variation or error.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain endpoints

Fixed case information

A sequence over five times is 2,6,10,6,2. A learner says nothing changed because first and last are equal.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Describe the actual pattern and explain why endpoints alone are insufficient.

Example of a full-credit answer: The record rises from 2 to a peak of 10 and then falls back to 2. Equal first and last values hide the substantial changes between them.

  1. The record rises from 2 to a peak of 10 and then falls back to 2.
  2. Equal first and last values hide the substantial changes between them.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared growth-index values at settings 1–6 are 2,4,6,8,8,8.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies early pattern in this case?

  • a: Increase
  • b: Always increases without limit
  • c: Fall to zero
  • d: Setting 1
Answer: Increase

The record has an increasing region and a flat region.

1B · Open ended

Describe both regions using values and explain why one straight increasing rule is incomplete.

Example of a full-credit answer: Values rise from 2 to 8 over settings 1–4. They remain 8 at settings 4–6, so an always-increasing rule misses the plateau.

  1. Values rise from 2 to 8 over settings 1–4.
  2. They remain 8 at settings 4–6, so an always-increasing rule misses the plateau.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Record values are 10,13,12,16,18 across time. A says “generally increases with a small dip”; B says “increases at every step.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? More accurate statement: A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

A preserves the local exception and overall direction.

2B · Short answer

Choose the statement and justify it using the exception and overall trend.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A because the overall change is from 10 to 18. Notes the 13-to-12 decrease, which contradicts increasing at every step.

  1. Chooses A because the overall change is from 10 to 18.
  2. Notes the 13-to-12 decrease, which contradicts increasing at every step.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A prepared toy signal follows 1,3,5,1,3,5. The model explicitly repeats the three-value cycle.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Next value under rule; Cycle length; Last value before the cycle restarts

  • a: 1
  • b: Three values
  • c: 5
  • d: 7
Answer: Next value under rule → 1; Cycle length → Three values; Last value before the cycle restarts → 5

The stated repeating rule restarts after 5.

3B · Open ended

Predict the next two values and state the assumption behind the prediction.

Example of a full-credit answer: Predicts 1 then 3. Uses the explicitly stated three-value repeating cycle, rather than assuming indefinite growth.

  1. Predicts 1 then 3.
  2. Uses the explicitly stated three-value repeating cycle, rather than assuming indefinite growth.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A prepared observation record shows warmer days and more ice-cream sales. A learner claims buying ice cream causes the weather to warm. No experiment was performed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies error in this case?

  • a: Association treated as cause
  • b: Causation proved
  • c: No possible alternatives
  • d: Only a prettier plot
Answer: Association treated as cause

The relationship has possible directions and shared influences.

4B · Short answer

Explain the causal error and offer one plausible alternative explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The observed association alone does not establish that sales cause warmer weather. Warm weather may increase ice-cream buying, or another common factor may influence both.

  1. The observed association alone does not establish that sales cause warmer weather.
  2. Warm weather may increase ice-cream buying, or another common factor may influence both.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A toy model gives outputs 3,6,9 at settings 1,2,3. You suspect an add-three rule but can test settings 4 and 5.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Predicted next outputs: 12 and 15
  • b: Useful test: Measure settings 4 and 5
  • c: Predicted next outputs: Guaranteed forever
  • d: Useful test: Repeat the title only
Answer: Predicted next outputs: 12 and 15; Useful test: Measure settings 4 and 5

New settings can challenge the proposed rule.

5B · Open ended

State predictions and a test that could reveal whether the pattern stops continuing.

Example of a full-credit answer: Predicts 12 and 15 if the add-three rule continues. Measures outputs at settings 4 and 5 and compares them with the prediction, retaining deviations instead of forcing the rule.

  1. Predicts 12 and 15 if the add-three rule continues.
  2. Measures outputs at settings 4 and 5 and compares them with the prediction, retaining deviations instead of forcing the rule.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.17 · Drawing evidence-based conclusions

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Claim with evidence
Prepared cooling data
CoverDrop °C
A4
B9

Worked-example information

Prepared matched cooling drops are cover A=4°C and B=9°C over five minutes.

Question: What conclusion answers which reduced cooling more?

Answer: A reduced cooling more in these trials: its drop was 5°C smaller.

Why: The same interval and conditions make the temperature-drop comparison relevant.

Example 2 · A prediction loses

Worked-example information

A model predicted treatment growth greater than reference growth. Means are treatment=3 cm and reference=5 cm.

Question: Does the record support the prediction?

Answer: No.

Why: The measured direction is opposite in this record; methods and alternative explanations can be checked.

Example 3 · A cautious observation

Worked-example information

Two existing gardens differ in water, soil and growth.

Question: Can the growth difference be attributed only to water?

Answer: No.

Why: Several factors differ, so the observational comparison does not isolate water.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Link claim to measurement

Fixed case information

Fictional matched filters leave A=2 particles and B=7 particles from equal starting counts.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Lower remaining count; Difference; Supported scope

  • a: A
  • b: 5 particles
  • c: These model trials
  • d: B
Answer: Lower remaining count → A; Difference → 5 particles; Supported scope → These model trials

The measured particle count answers the stated removal comparison only.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Use relevant evidence

Fixed case information

The question asks which virtual cup cooled less. Data list temperature drops A=3°C, B=8°C, with colours red and blue.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Relevant evidence: Temperature drops
  • b: Less cooling: Cup A
  • c: Relevant evidence: Cup colour alone
  • d: Less cooling: Cup B
Answer: Relevant evidence: Temperature drops; Less cooling: Cup A

The outcome must match the conclusion.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Distinguish cause from association

Fixed case information

An existing-site record links wetter soil with taller plants, but seed varieties and light differ.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies supported description in this case?

  • a: Association between soil wetness and height
  • b: All causes controlled
  • c: No other factors vary
  • d: Every site has identical seeds
Answer: Association between soil wetness and height

An observational relationship alone does not isolate the cause.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Read a contrary result

Fixed case information

Prediction: longer blades give longer model fall times. Prepared means are long=2 s and short=4 s under matched settings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Prediction status; Observed direction; Useful next step

  • a: Not supported by this record
  • b: Long blades fell faster here
  • c: Check method and explanation
  • d: Proved correct
Answer: Prediction status → Not supported by this record; Observed direction → Long blades fell faster here; Useful next step → Check method and explanation

The observed direction opposes the stated prediction.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F5 · Explain a limited conclusion

Fixed case information

Three virtual ramp trials at one surface show a mean 6-cm advantage for a setting. A report claims the setting wins on every surface forever.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Rewrite the conclusion to match the evidence and identify one untested extension.

Example of a full-credit answer: States that the setting had a 6-cm mean advantage in these three trials on the tested surface. Notes that other surfaces or conditions were not tested and would need further evidence.

  1. States that the setting had a 6-cm mean advantage in these three trials on the tested surface.
  2. Notes that other surfaces or conditions were not tested and would need further evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared matched drop times are model A:4,5,6 s and B:7,8,9 s. The question asks which takes longer on average.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Longer mean time: B
  • b: A mean: 5 s
  • c: Longer mean time: A
  • d: A mean: 15 s
Answer: Longer mean time: B; A mean: 5 s

Group B’s mean is three seconds longer in this record.

1B · Short answer

State the conclusion with numerical evidence and keep it within the tested models.

Example of a full-credit answer: B takes longer on average: 8 s versus 5 s, a 3-s difference. Limits the claim to the supplied models/trials instead of all falling objects.

  1. B takes longer on average: 8 s versus 5 s, a 3-s difference.
  2. Limits the claim to the supplied models/trials instead of all falling objects.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A says “The shade model reduced temperature rise from 9 to 4°C under the equal input.” B says “The model proves every real school will cool exactly 5°C.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Better supported conclusion; Measured reduction; Overreach in B

  • a: A
  • b: 5°C
  • c: Guaranteed real-world effect
  • d: B
Answer: Better supported conclusion → A; Measured reduction → 5°C; Overreach in B → Guaranteed real-world effect

A matches the model record and scope.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger conclusion and explain how evidence and scope support your choice.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A using the 9-to-4°C reduction. The record is a virtual equal-input case, so it does not establish the same exact change at every real school.

  1. Chooses A using the 9-to-4°C reduction.
  2. The record is a virtual equal-input case, so it does not establish the same exact change at every real school.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Prepared pond records show more shade and fewer model algae counts, but nutrient input also differs. No controlled experiment was performed.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies supported relationship in this case?

  • a: Shade and counts are associated
  • b: Shade cause proved
  • c: Nutrients identical
  • d: Every pond was controlled
Answer: Shade and counts are associated

A new context still requires the same distinction between association and cause.

3B · Short answer

Write a conclusion that describes the pattern and identifies the causal limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The more-shaded pond record has fewer algae counts in the supplied comparison. Different nutrient inputs remain an alternative explanation, so shade alone is not established as the cause.

  1. The more-shaded pond record has fewer algae counts in the supplied comparison.
  2. Different nutrient inputs remain an alternative explanation, so shade alone is not established as the cause.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner predicted more light means more growth. Recorded model changes are low light=6 cm and high light=4 cm. The conclusion copies the prediction without mentioning the results.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? The prediction itself is evidence that high light produced more growth in these trials.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Conclusions should follow data rather than preference.

4B · Open ended

Correct the conclusion and explain why the prediction cannot replace the evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: The low-light model grew 2 cm more, so these results do not support the predicted direction. A prediction is an expectation to test, not a substitute for the actual observations.

  1. The low-light model grew 2 cm more, so these results do not support the predicted direction.
  2. A prediction is an expectation to test, not a substitute for the actual observations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual water-saving test records daily use before repair 18 units and after repair 12, with equal model demand. It uses one model configuration.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies supported saving in this case?

  • a: 6 units per day
  • b: 30 units saved
  • c: All conditions unknown
  • d: Every real site guaranteed
Answer: 6 units per day

The numerical difference supports a limited model conclusion.

5B · Open ended

Write a conclusion including its numerical support and one limitation or follow-up.

Example of a full-credit answer: States a 6-unit daily reduction under equal model demand, using 18−12. Notes that one configuration does not establish every real site’s saving, or proposes checking more relevant conditions.

  1. States a 6-unit daily reduction under equal model demand, using 18−12.
  2. Notes that one configuration does not establish every real site’s saving, or proposes checking more relevant conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.18 · Evaluating experimental designs

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Name the confound

Worked-example information

A virtual test compares lids, but each lid is placed on a different cup volume and starting temperature.

Question: What flaw should be named?

Answer: Lid type is bundled with volume and starting temperature.

Why: The measured cooling difference cannot easily be assigned to the lid alone.

Example 2 · Count the real units
Study structure
PanelsPhotos eachTotal photos
21020

Worked-example information

A treatment is applied to two model panels, each photographed ten times.

Question: How many independently treated panels are there?

Answer: Two.

Why: Twenty photographs do not become twenty independent treatment units.

Example 3 · A genuine strength

Worked-example information

A virtual comparison randomly assigns matched starting samples and uses the same outcome rule.

Question: What strength can be credited?

Answer: It reduces systematic selection and measurement differences.

Why: That strengthens the comparison without proving unlimited generality.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Evaluate the intended contrast

Fixed case information

A model tests ramp height but uses heavy carts for high ramps and light carts for low ramps.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies design concern in this case?

  • a: Mass changes with height
  • b: Only height changes
  • c: Cart colour measured
  • d: Keep masses linked to height
Answer: Mass changes with height

The two factors are bundled.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · Check the measured property

Fixed case information

A design claims to compare material strength but records colour and surface temperature only.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies main mismatch in this case?

  • a: Strength is not measured
  • b: Strength was fully tested
  • c: Only mass measured
  • d: A better poster
Answer: Strength is not measured

The outcome does not answer the strength question.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Count independent units

Fixed case information

A study treats three virtual pots per group and measures each four times.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Independent pots per group; Readings per group; Repeated readings per pot

  • a: Three
  • b: Twelve
  • c: Four
  • d: Twelve independent pots
Answer: Independent pots per group → Three; Readings per group → Twelve; Repeated readings per pot → Four

Evaluate the treatment-unit count separately from readings.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F4 · Identify a measurement strength

Fixed case information

All virtual fall trials use the same release line, timer definition and first-contact endpoint.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Design strength; Start rule; Stop rule

  • a: Consistent outcome measurement
  • b: Release line
  • c: First contact
  • d: No common method
Answer: Design strength → Consistent outcome measurement; Start rule → Release line; Stop rule → First contact

Shared rules make recorded times more comparable.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain a narrow strength

Fixed case information

A well-controlled toy erosion model varies cover while rain and slope stay fixed. Its author claims it predicts exact real landslide times.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Identify one design strength and explain why the author’s real-world claim exceeds it.

Example of a full-credit answer: The design keeps rain and slope comparable while varying cover in the toy model. An illustrative erosion index does not establish exact real landslide timing or include all real factors.

  1. The design keeps rain and slope comparable while varying cover in the toy model.
  2. An illustrative erosion index does not establish exact real landslide timing or include all real factors.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual study assigns the six tallest seedlings to treatment and six shortest to reference, then compares final height only.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Selection flaw: Initial height differs by group
  • b: Outcome concern: Final height ignores starting difference
  • c: Selection flaw: No starting difference
  • d: Outcome concern: Every plant starts equal
Answer: Selection flaw: Initial height differs by group; Outcome concern: Final height ignores starting difference

Two connected flaws make treatment interpretation weak.

1B · Open ended

Identify the assignment and outcome problems and propose a connected improvement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Groups differ systematically at the start and final height alone does not account for that. Uses comparable/random assignment and initial-to-final growth measures under matched conditions.

  1. Groups differ systematically at the start and final height alone does not account for that.
  2. Uses comparable/random assignment and initial-to-final growth measures under matched conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A uses four independent virtual panels per condition, random assignment and equal light. B uses one panel per condition with twelve repeated photos and unequal light.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies stronger design in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Twelve independent panels in B
  • d: Unequal light is essential
Answer: A

A better separates the treatment from unit and input differences.

2B · Short answer

Choose the stronger design and justify with independent units and input control.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A with four independently treated panels per condition. Equal light reduces an alternative explanation that remains in B.

  1. Chooses A with four independently treated panels per condition.
  2. Equal light reduces an alternative explanation that remains in B.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A question concerns all school garden beds. A survey observes only the sunniest corner and claims all beds have the same insect count.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Scope problem; Target population; Useful improvement

  • a: Only one habitat subset sampled
  • b: All garden beds
  • c: Sample varied beds appropriately
  • d: Every bed observed
Answer: Scope problem → Only one habitat subset sampled; Target population → All garden beds; Useful improvement → Sample varied beds appropriately

The study’s sample does not cover the target conditions.

3B · Open ended

Explain the coverage problem and propose a sampling change relevant to the target population.

Example of a full-credit answer: The sunniest corner may not represent all garden-bed conditions. Samples multiple appropriately selected sunny and shaded/varied beds using a common counting effort.

  1. The sunniest corner may not represent all garden-bed conditions.
  2. Samples multiple appropriately selected sunny and shaded/varied beds using a common counting effort.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A model boat study times one design from release to crossing a line, but another from halfway along the route to the line. The report compares the times directly.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? Flaw: Different timing intervals.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Changing the measurement definition changes what the values mean.

4B · Short answer

Explain why the times cannot support the stated comparison and specify the repair.

Example of a full-credit answer: The designs were timed over different travel intervals. Uses the same defined release/start and finish line for both, then repeats measurements.

  1. The designs were timed over different travel intervals.
  2. Specifies the same defined start/release point and finish line for both designs before comparing newly recorded times.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

You must review a virtual insulation experiment with two cover types. The claim is lower temperature loss over five minutes. Select three checks and explain what one detects.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Setup and timing checks; Unit check; Evidence check

  • a: Starts, controls and outcome timing
  • b: Independent cups per condition
  • c: All valid readings retained
  • d: Only font and colour
Answer: Setup and timing checks → Starts, controls and outcome timing; Unit check → Independent cups per condition; Evidence check → All valid readings retained

Checks should connect to causes of misleading evidence.

5B · Open ended

Propose three relevant design checks and explain the risk one of them detects.

Example of a full-credit answer: Names three relevant checks such as matched starts, independent units, assignment, controls, measurement rule or complete data. Connects at least one check to a specific bias, confound, measurement mismatch or unsupported generalisation.

  1. Names three relevant checks such as matched starts, independent units, assignment, controls, measurement rule or complete data.
  2. Connects at least one check to a specific bias, confound, measurement mismatch or unsupported generalisation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.19 · Identifying limitations

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · One season only

Worked-example information

A fictional habitat survey covers one week in a rainy season.

Question: Which broader question remains open?

Answer: How the habitat differs in other seasons.

Why: The study can describe the sampled week without establishing year-round conditions.

Example 2 · A coarse tool
Proposed comparison
ObjectApproximate cm
A5.1
B5.3

Worked-example information

Two model lengths are estimated as 5.1 and 5.3 cm, but the measuring tool rounds to whole centimetres.

Question: What is the relevant limit?

Answer: Resolution is too coarse to distinguish the small difference well.

Why: More decimal places in typing would not add evidence.

Example 3 · A model omission

Worked-example information

A toy water model includes rain and pumping but omits leakage.

Question: Does this prove real tanks never leak?

Answer: No.

Why: The omission is a model assumption, not evidence of no leakage.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name the coverage limit

Fixed case information

A virtual seed study uses one variety under one light setting. It claims all varieties behave identically in every light condition.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Coverage limit: One variety and one light setting
  • b: Valid narrow scope: The tested model condition
  • c: Coverage limit: All conditions were tested
  • d: Valid narrow scope: No result can be used
Answer: Coverage limit: One variety and one light setting; Valid narrow scope: The tested model condition

The claim reaches beyond the design.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Recognise short duration

Fixed case information

A prepared record covers model plant growth for days 1–3 only.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Known interval; Unmeasured interval; Unsupported claim

  • a: Three days
  • b: Later weeks
  • c: The same rate lasts forever
  • d: Three centimetres
Answer: Known interval → Three days; Unmeasured interval → Later weeks; Unsupported claim → The same rate lasts forever

Short records cannot establish indefinite continuation.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Identify instrument limitation

Fixed case information

A virtual ruler rounds to 1 cm and the desired difference is 0.2 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Limitation: Too much exact detail.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The measurement method cannot resolve every desired detail.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F4 · Separate omitted from absent

Fixed case information

A model omits evaporation and calculates storage from inflow minus pumping.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Omitted process; Meaning of omission; Unsupported real claim

  • a: Evaporation
  • b: Not represented in this model
  • c: Evaporation never occurs
  • d: Pumping omitted
Answer: Omitted process → Evaporation; Meaning of omission → Not represented in this model; Unsupported real claim → Evaporation never occurs

An omitted factor remains outside the model’s evidence.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain a useful limited result

Fixed case information

A controlled virtual surface test finds A gives 2 cm more travel than B in three trials with one cart. It has not tested other carts.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State the supported result and explain the specific limit without dismissing the evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: A showed a 2-cm travel advantage in the supplied trials with this cart. Other carts are untested, so generalisation to them remains uncertain while the narrow result remains informative.

  1. A showed a 2-cm travel advantage in the supplied trials with this cart.
  2. Other carts are untested, so generalisation to them remains uncertain while the narrow result remains informative.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: data lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional school has 12 sunny beds and 8 shaded beds. The survey samples only 3 sunny beds, then claims a school-wide average insect count.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Missing coverage; Sampled subset; Weakened claim

  • a: Shaded beds
  • b: Three sunny beds
  • c: School-wide average
  • d: Every bed sampled
Answer: Missing coverage → Shaded beds; Sampled subset → Three sunny beds; Weakened claim → School-wide average

Coverage of one subset may not represent the whole school.

1B · Short answer

Explain why the school-wide claim is limited and what the current data can still describe.

Example of a full-credit answer: The sample omits shaded beds and may not represent all garden conditions. It can describe the three sampled sunny beds under the recorded method.

  1. The sample omits shaded beds and may not represent all garden conditions.
  2. It can describe the three sampled sunny beds under the recorded method.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A timer records only tenths of seconds. A report nevertheless claims that two means, each based on only two recorded trials, differ by 0.01 s. Caveat A concerns unsupported timing detail and few trials; B says the graph border is green.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Relevant limitation; Measurement concern; Data concern

  • a: A
  • b: Difference smaller than display step
  • c: Only two trials each
  • d: B
Answer: Relevant limitation → A; Measurement concern → Difference smaller than display step; Data concern → Only two trials each

The caveat should affect what the comparison can establish.

2B · Open ended

Choose the caveat and explain how both its features affect confidence in the tiny difference.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A because the display resolution is coarse relative to the claimed difference. Few trials provide limited information about variability, so the tiny difference is not firmly established.

  1. Chooses A because the display resolution is coarse relative to the claimed difference.
  2. Few trials provide limited information about variability, so the tiny difference is not firmly established.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A toy greenhouse diagram tracks light-energy paths but does not calculate temperature, clouds or regional weather. A learner asks for tomorrow’s exact temperature from it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Physical relationships represented; Unavailable output requested by the learner; Appropriate type of model

  • a: Energy-path relationships
  • b: Weather temperature forecast
  • c: Explanatory energy diagram
  • d: Exact regional wind-speed calculation
Answer: Physical relationships represented → Energy-path relationships; Unavailable output requested by the learner → Weather temperature forecast; Appropriate type of model → Explanatory energy diagram

A model’s purpose and omitted processes limit its use.

3B · Short answer

Explain what the model is useful for and why it cannot answer the forecast question.

Example of a full-credit answer: It can illustrate the stated energy-transfer pathways. It lacks the weather/temperature processes and measurements needed for an exact forecast.

  1. It can illustrate the stated energy-transfer pathways.
  2. It lacks the weather/temperature processes and measurements needed for an exact forecast.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A filter test measures visible particles only. A report says “We found no data about dissolved chemicals, so there are no dissolved chemicals.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies error in this case?

  • a: Unmeasured treated as absent
  • b: Complete chemistry test exists
  • c: All chemicals measured
  • d: Only graph labels unknown
Answer: Unmeasured treated as absent

No measurement is not a zero result.

4B · Open ended

Explain the error and write a scientifically accurate statement about dissolved chemicals.

Example of a full-credit answer: Lack of a chemical test does not establish absence of dissolved chemicals. Their presence or amount is unknown from this particle-only study and requires suitable evidence.

  1. Lack of a chemical test does not establish absence of dissolved chemicals.
  2. Their presence or amount is unknown from this particle-only study and requires suitable evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual cooling study tests only thin and thick covers for three minutes. You want to know whether the same ranking holds at longer intervals.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies relevant next factor in this case?

  • a: Observation duration
  • b: Only change poster font
  • c: Change every input at once
  • d: Invent later values
Answer: Observation duration

The follow-up should address the time-scope limit.

5B · Open ended

Propose a follow-up that addresses the time limitation and state what should remain comparable.

Example of a full-credit answer: Measures both cover types at specified longer intervals, such as six and nine minutes. Keeps starting temperature/volume and the measurement method comparable, and records actual follow-up results rather than assuming the original ranking.

  1. Measures both cover types at specified longer intervals, such as six and nine minutes.
  2. Keeps starting temperature/volume and the measurement method comparable, and records actual follow-up results rather than assuming the original ranking.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.20 · Recommending improvements

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Target the bias

Worked-example information

A model balance reads a 10-g reference as 12 g repeatedly.

Question: What improvement fits the problem?

Answer: Check zero/calibration and remeasure the reference.

Why: More uncorrected repeats would not remove the systematic offset.

Example 2 · Target the coverage
Current coverage
HabitatSampled plots
Sunny5
Shaded0

Worked-example information

A fictional habitat sample includes five sunny plots and no shaded plots.

Question: What improves a whole-site comparison?

Answer: Add appropriately selected shaded plots using the same observation effort.

Why: It addresses missing habitat coverage.

Example 3 · Target the timing

Worked-example information

Different observers start a virtual timer at different events.

Question: What should be standardised?

Answer: A shared start/stop definition and practice/check of that rule.

Why: This targets inconsistent measurement rather than changing the treatment.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Choose a targeted repair

Fixed case information

A virtual ruler is consistently 2 cm high against a known reference.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Targeted repair; Named problem; Success check

  • a: Check zero/calibration
  • b: Systematic offset
  • c: Remeasure reference
  • d: Only add more uncorrected readings
Answer: Targeted repair → Check zero/calibration; Named problem → Systematic offset; Success check → Remeasure reference

The improvement should address bias directly.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Improve repeated timing

Fixed case information

A virtual fall test has one trial at each setting and visibly inconsistent start rules.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Relevant improvement; Method problem; Information problem

  • a: Common timing rule plus repeats
  • b: Inconsistent start
  • c: Only one trial
  • d: Only change colour
Answer: Relevant improvement → Common timing rule plus repeats; Method problem → Inconsistent start; Information problem → Only one trial

The two changes address distinct specific weaknesses.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Improve a sample

Fixed case information

A question concerns all garden zones, but only edge plots are sampled.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies needed extension in this case?

  • a: Include interior plots appropriately
  • b: Only more edge plots forever
  • c: Just the edge
  • d: Different count time everywhere
Answer: Include interior plots appropriately

Coverage must match the intended scope.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F4 · Repair units

Fixed case information

A table mixes metres and centimetres without labels.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Needed repair; Retain; Purpose

  • a: Label and convert units transparently
  • b: Original values and units
  • c: Make numerical comparisons valid
  • d: Delete all unit notes
Answer: Needed repair → Label and convert units transparently; Retain → Original values and units; Purpose → Make numerical comparisons valid

A documented conversion prevents false numerical comparisons.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a success check

Fixed case information

A model timer protocol is revised to use a common start event. Before readings are 3,5,7 s; after they are 4.8,5.0,5.2 s for the same reference event.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what improved and one thing this comparison alone does not prove.

Example of a full-credit answer: Repeated readings scatter less after the common timing rule, with range falling from 4 to 0.4 s. This alone does not prove perfect accuracy; reference agreement or other checks are still needed.

  1. Identifies improved repeat precision because the after readings are much less scattered; may support this with ranges of 4 s before and 0.4 s after.
  2. This alone does not prove perfect accuracy; reference agreement or other checks are still needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A virtual shade test uses 10-minute exposure for shade A and 20 minutes for shade B. It aims to compare the temperature rise under the two shade types.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Priority repair; Named confound; Outcome rule

  • a: Use equal exposure duration
  • b: Time differs with shade
  • c: Same temperature-change method
  • d: Double every duration differently
Answer: Priority repair → Use equal exposure duration; Named confound → Time differs with shade; Outcome rule → Same temperature-change method

Equal time directly addresses the unwanted difference.

1B · Open ended

Propose the repair and explain why it makes the shade comparison more informative.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses the same defined exposure duration for both shade types. Time affects temperature rise, so matching it reduces an alternative explanation for differences.

  1. Uses the same defined exposure duration for both shade types.
  2. Time affects temperature rise, so matching it reduces an alternative explanation for differences.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A model conclusion targets three soil types, but all trials use type A. Plan 1 adds more A trials only; Plan 2 samples A, B and C with a common method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Better coverage repair: Plan 2.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The repair should address the generalisation gap.

2B · Short answer

Choose the plan and explain what the other plan would fail to fix.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan 2. More A readings do not provide evidence about untested B and C, even if they improve the A summary.

  1. Chooses Plan 2.
  2. More A readings do not provide evidence about untested B and C, even if they improve the A summary.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual sensor rounds to 5-unit steps, while expected differences are about 1 unit. A second suitable sensor has 0.5-unit steps with a reference check.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Relevant replacement: Second sensor
  • b: Problem addressed: Insufficient resolution
  • c: Relevant replacement: Same sensor with more typed digits
  • d: Problem addressed: Only colour mismatch
Answer: Relevant replacement: Second sensor; Problem addressed: Insufficient resolution

Finer supported detail targets the small difference.

3B · Open ended

Recommend a measurement improvement and explain why typed decimals alone would not achieve it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses the suitable finer-resolution sensor with a reference check. Typing extra decimals adds no new measured information to the coarse readings.

  1. Uses the suitable finer-resolution sensor with a reference check.
  2. Typing extra decimals adds no new measured information to the coarse readings.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner proposes deleting every result opposite to the hypothesis, calling this “improving accuracy.” No recording errors are established.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies problem in this case?

  • a: Selective deletion biases evidence
  • b: Accuracy automatically improves
  • c: Only agreeing results count
  • d: Guarantee the prediction wins
Answer: Selective deletion biases evidence

An improvement cannot be defined as forcing agreement.

4B · Short answer

Explain why the proposal is invalid and give a legitimate response to disagreeing results.

Example of a full-credit answer: Deleting results solely because they disagree selects evidence to favour the hypothesis. Retains records, checks possible errors/conditions and repeats or revises the explanation transparently.

  1. Deleting results solely because they disagree selects evidence to favour the hypothesis.
  2. Retains records, checks possible errors/conditions and repeats or revises the explanation transparently.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual balance has a suspected +1-g offset and large trial scatter. You have reference masses and can repeat readings before and after adjustments.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies bias check in this case?

  • a: Compare means to references
  • b: Only redraw the graph
  • c: Choose one best value
  • d: Hide failed checks
Answer: Compare means to references

Two observed problems require distinguishable checks.

5B · Open ended

Propose an improvement plan for bias and scatter, including how you will check success.

Example of a full-credit answer: Checks/adjusts zero or calibration using references and compares mean offsets before and after. Standardises the measurement procedure, repeats readings and compares spread while preserving the records.

  1. Checks/adjusts zero or calibration using references and compares mean offsets before and after.
  2. Standardises the measurement procedure, repeats readings and compares spread while preserving the records.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.21 · Replicating findings

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · New data or a copy?

Worked-example information

Class B uses fresh virtual panels and the same coating test as class A, keeping its own readings.

Question: Is this a replication attempt?

Answer: Yes.

Why: It independently collects relevant new data using the original comparison.

Example 2 · Compare directions
Prepared studies
StudyReduction units
A4
B3

Worked-example information

Class A finds a 4-unit reduction; class B finds a 3-unit reduction under comparable conditions.

Question: Must the numbers be identical to count as broadly agreeing?

Answer: No.

Why: Both show reduction; uncertainty and method details determine how closely they agree.

Example 3 · A different question

Worked-example information

An original test uses dry surfaces; a follow-up uses wet surfaces and changes the outcome.

Question: Is disagreement automatically a direct contradiction?

Answer: No.

Why: Important conditions and the measured question changed and must be examined.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify replication

Fixed case information

A new team follows a reported virtual filter method with fresh model units and independently records particle counts.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: New evidence activity; Important feature; Action that reuses old data without collecting new observations

  • a: Replication attempt
  • b: Fresh independently collected data
  • c: Copying the old table
  • d: Changing to a different scientific question
Answer: New evidence activity → Replication attempt; Important feature → Fresh independently collected data; Action that reuses old data without collecting new observations → Copying the old table

Replication adds a new relevant data collection.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Separate repeated readings

Fixed case information

One team photographs the same treated plant ten times without another treatment unit or new study.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies what this provides in this case?

  • a: Repeated observations of one plant
  • b: Ten new independent studies
  • c: Ten newly treated plants
  • d: Ten plants
Answer: Repeated observations of one plant

Repeated views of one unit are not independent studies.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Compare study results

Fixed case information

Prepared matched studies report a treatment advantage A=5 units, B=4 units, C=6 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Shared direction: Positive advantage
  • b: Observed spread of estimates: 2 units
  • c: Shared direction: All negative effects
  • d: Observed spread of estimates: 15-unit range
Answer: Shared direction: Positive advantage; Observed spread of estimates: 2 units

Similar direction with modest numerical variation can support the finding.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Track method differences

Fixed case information

A replication uses a different seed variety and a longer duration than the original.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Differences to report; Reason to report; Recommended action about the changed conditions

  • a: Variety and duration
  • b: They may influence results
  • c: Record and compare the changed conditions
  • d: Nothing changed
Answer: Differences to report → Variety and duration; Reason to report → They may influence results; Recommended action about the changed conditions → Record and compare the changed conditions

Method differences help interpret whether the same finding was tested.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a disagreeing replication

Fixed case information

An independent virtual test finds little treatment difference where an earlier small test found a large one. Both provide their data.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain how to respond scientifically and why disagreement alone does not establish dishonesty.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compares methods, data, uncertainty and conditions, and considers further tests. Differences can arise from variation, changed conditions or mistakes, so disagreement alone is not proof of dishonesty.

  1. Compares methods, data, uncertainty and conditions, and considers further tests.
  2. Differences can arise from variation, changed conditions or mistakes, so disagreement alone is not proof of dishonesty.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

An original prepared study reports treatment mean 12 and reference 8 units. A new comparable study reports 15 and 12 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Original advantage; New advantage; Shared direction

  • a: 4 units
  • b: 3 units
  • c: Treatment higher
  • d: 20 units
Answer: Original advantage → 4 units; New advantage → 3 units; Shared direction → Treatment higher

Compare within-study differences rather than raw treatment means alone.

1B · Short answer

Compare the treatment effects and explain what the new study contributes.

Example of a full-credit answer: The original advantage is 4 and the new one 3 units, both in the same direction. The new study adds independent evidence under comparable conditions rather than merely recalculating the old data.

  1. The original advantage is 4 and the new one 3 units, both in the same direction.
  2. The new study adds independent evidence under comparable conditions rather than merely recalculating the old data.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A new team documents treatment settings, fresh sample IDs, raw readings and differences from the original. Another republishes the original graph with a new title.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Actual replication record; Useful trace; Weak alternative

  • a: Fresh-data team
  • b: New sample IDs and raw readings
  • c: Reused graph without new data
  • d: All future results guaranteed
Answer: Actual replication record → Fresh-data team; Useful trace → New sample IDs and raw readings; Weak alternative → Reused graph without new data

Independent evidence requires new data and transparent method.

2B · Open ended

Choose the record and justify why the other does not independently test the finding.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the fresh-data team. A reused graph supplies no new observations and cannot show that the result occurs again independently.

  1. Chooses the fresh-data team.
  2. A reused graph supplies no new observations and cannot show that the result occurs again independently.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual habitat model finding is tested with a second prepared location using the same count effort and category definitions. Some habitat conditions differ.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Replication strength: Common measurement method
  • b: Changed context: Second location
  • c: Replication strength: All conditions identical
  • d: Changed context: Same old data reused
Answer: Replication strength: Common measurement method; Changed context: Second location

A new location can test generality while introducing relevant differences.

3B · Short answer

Explain what the second location can add and what must be recorded to interpret it.

Example of a full-credit answer: It adds new evidence about whether the pattern occurs in another location/context. Records habitat differences while keeping count effort and category rules comparable.

  1. It adds new evidence about whether the pattern occurs in another location/context.
  2. Records habitat differences while keeping count effort and category rules comparable.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says a replication with effect 4.8 units fails because the original effect was 5.0 units. Both have stated uncertainty intervals that overlap.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false? A 4.8-unit replication result must fail to support a 5.0-unit original simply because the numbers are not identical.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Replication is not a demand for identical random samples or readings.

4B · Open ended

Explain why the claim is too strict and name what should be compared instead.

Example of a full-credit answer: Small numerical differences can arise from sampling/measurement variation, especially with overlapping intervals. Compares direction, effect size, uncertainty and method/conditions rather than exact digits alone.

  1. Small numerical differences can arise from sampling/measurement variation, especially with overlapping intervals.
  2. Compares direction, effect size, uncertainty and method/conditions rather than exact digits alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

An earlier virtual study compared covered and uncovered pots for seven days using height change. Plan a new class study with fresh pots and report method differences.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies keep core outcome in this case?

  • a: Seven-day height change
  • b: Reuse old observations only
  • c: Change every question
  • d: Publish agreement only
Answer: Seven-day height change

The plan should preserve the core comparison and produce a new record.

5B · Open ended

Propose the new data collection and explain how you will compare and report its results.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses fresh comparable pots, a cover/reference comparison and the same seven-day height-change outcome with appropriate controls. Reports all new readings and protocol differences, comparing effects and uncertainty even if the result disagrees.

  1. Uses fresh comparable pots, a cover/reference comparison and the same seven-day height-change outcome with appropriate controls.
  2. Reports all new readings and protocol differences, comparing effects and uncertainty even if the result disagrees.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S11.22 · Verifying findings

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Recompute a mean

Worked-example information

Raw readings are 2,4,6 units. A report gives mean 12.

Question: What does recalculation show?

Answer: The mean is 4 units; 12 is the total.

Why: Adding is only the first step; divide by three.

Example 2 · Check a conversion
Conversion check
OriginalReported cmCorrect cm
1.5 m15150

Worked-example information

A table copies 1.5 m as 15 cm. One metre equals 100 cm.

Question: What is the correct converted value?

Answer: 150 cm.

Why: Multiply 1.5 by 100.

Example 3 · Arithmetic is not the whole claim

Worked-example information

A virtual test correctly shows a 3-unit particle reduction. Its headline says all water is safe.

Question: Has the headline been verified?

Answer: No.

Why: The correct particle calculation does not test every chemical or biological property.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Trace a copied value

Fixed case information

A raw prepared record gives sample K=36 cm, but the typed table says 63 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Verified source value: 36 cm.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The original record identifies a transcription problem.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Recalculate the average

Fixed case information

Raw times are 6,8,10 s. Reported mean is 24 s.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Correct mean: 8 s
  • b: Total: 24 s
  • c: Correct mean: 24 s
  • d: Total: 72 s
Answer: Correct mean: 8 s; Total: 24 s

The reported number is a total, not a mean.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Check a unit claim

Fixed case information

A source records 2.4 m. The table labels the value 2.4 cm. One metre equals 100 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies correct centimetre value in this case?

  • a: 240 cm
  • b: 0.024 cm
  • c: 24 cm
  • d: 2.4 cm is unchanged correctly
Answer: 240 cm

A label change alone does not convert a quantity.

Scientific explorer: unit lab

F4 · Check scope as well as numbers

Fixed case information

A study measured one model panel’s temperature. A headline says all panels everywhere have that exact temperature.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies verified narrow property in this case?

  • a: One panel’s measured temperature
  • b: All panels were measured
  • c: No number exists
  • d: A repeated headline only
Answer: One panel’s measured temperature

Correct local data do not establish universal coverage.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain what was verified

Fixed case information

A reviewer recalculates a mean correctly from a supplied data file but has not checked how the observations were collected.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

State what the reviewer can confirm and what remains unverified.

Example of a full-credit answer: Can confirm the arithmetic/summary computed from the supplied values. Cannot thereby confirm the original measurement procedure or authenticity/accuracy of data collection.

  1. Can confirm the arithmetic/summary computed from the supplied values.
  2. Cannot thereby confirm the original measurement procedure or authenticity/accuracy of data collection.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Prepared before/after model use is 22 and 15 units per day under equal demand. A report claims 37 units saved.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Correct saving; Wrong operation; Necessary comparison

  • a: 7 units/day
  • b: Adding instead of subtracting
  • c: Before minus after
  • d: 37 units/day
Answer: Correct saving → 7 units/day; Wrong operation → Adding instead of subtracting; Necessary comparison → Before minus after

Savings are the decrease, 22−15, not the sum.

1B · Open ended

Correct the calculation and explain what the verified number does and does not establish.

Example of a full-credit answer: The reduction is 7 units/day because 22−15=7. It describes the supplied equal-demand model comparison; it does not guarantee that saving at every real site.

  1. The reduction is 7 units/day because 22−15=7.
  2. It describes the supplied equal-demand model comparison; it does not guarantee that saving at every real site.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A report supplies raw readings, units, calculation steps and method notes. Another supplies only an image saying “scientifically verified.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: More checkable trail; Useful arithmetic evidence; Useful context evidence

  • a: Raw-data report
  • b: Calculation steps
  • c: Method notes
  • d: Badge-only image
Answer: More checkable trail → Raw-data report; Useful arithmetic evidence → Calculation steps; Useful context evidence → Method notes

A verification claim requires a checkable chain of evidence.

2B · Short answer

Choose the stronger source and explain two checks its records make possible.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the detailed report. Its data/steps allow recalculation and its method notes allow checking whether the claimed property and scope match the study.

  1. Chooses the detailed report.
  2. Its data/steps allow recalculation and its method notes allow checking whether the claimed property and scope match the study.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A prepared survey lists round 7, pointed 5 and flat 4 samples. A summary states total 18.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies verified total in this case?

  • a: 16
  • b: 18
  • c: 34
  • d: Only count category names
Answer: 16

7+5+4=16; the category total should match the raw counts.

3B · Open ended

Correct the total and describe how you would preserve a checkable correction.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total is 16 rather than 18, a difference of 2. Keeps the original category counts and records the corrected sum with a note/source rather than changing category values to fit 18.

  1. Corrects the total to 16 using 7 + 5 + 4; an additional statement that the report is 2 too high is acceptable but not required.
  2. Keeps the original category counts and records the corrected sum with a note/source rather than changing category values to fit 18.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Three websites repeat the same table copied from one unverified post. A learner says three independent studies confirmed it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Counting the repeated copies as independent studies is an error.
  • b: The repeated table originates in one unverified post.
  • c: The websites independently performed three new experiments.
  • d: The three copies have no shared source.
Answer: Counting the repeated copies as independent studies is an error.; The repeated table originates in one unverified post.

Repeating one source does not create independent evidence.

4B · Short answer

Explain the independence error and propose a meaningful verification step.

Example of a full-credit answer: The sites copy one source, so they are not three independent studies. Traces the original data/method or seeks genuinely independent relevant measurements before treating the claim as confirmed.

  1. The sites copy one source, so they are not three independent studies.
  2. Traces the original data/method or seeks genuinely independent relevant measurements before treating the claim as confirmed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual report claims cover A cools 4°C less than B. Raw drops are A:3,4,5 and B:7,8,9°C. Both use five minutes, but start temperatures are not supplied.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Arithmetic result; Known matching condition; Missing design information

  • a: Mean difference 4°C
  • b: Five-minute interval
  • c: Starting temperatures
  • d: Difference 12°C
Answer: Arithmetic result → Mean difference 4°C; Known matching condition → Five-minute interval; Missing design information → Starting temperatures

The arithmetic can be checked while a design question remains open.

5B · Open ended

Verify the mean difference and identify one necessary design check before accepting a cover-only causal claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Means are A=4°C and B=8°C, so B’s drop is 4°C larger. Checks whether starting temperatures and other key conditions were comparable; missing starts prevent fully verifying a cover-only causal interpretation.

  1. Means are A=4°C and B=8°C, so B’s drop is 4°C larger.
  2. Identifies a necessary check of comparable starting temperatures and links this missing information to the unresolved cover-only causal claim.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.1 · Distinguishing observations from interpretations

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A quieter speaker

Worked-example information

A classroom sensor reads 60 sound units before a cover and 48 after it. A learner says the cover absorbed sound.

Question: Which part is an observation?

Answer: The readings of 60 and 48 units.

Why: Absorption is a proposed explanation; the readings alone do not show every sound pathway.

Example 2 · Two seed trays
Seedling count
TraySeedlings
A7
B4

Worked-example information

Tray A has 7 seedlings and tray B has 4 after one week. Someone claims the colour of the trays caused the difference.

Question: What was observed, and what was inferred?

Answer: The counts were observed; the colour explanation was inferred.

Why: Other conditions such as watering could differ.

Example 3 · A moving shadow

Worked-example information

A chalk outline no longer matches a shadow after one hour.

Question: Does the observation mean the pole walked?

Answer: No. The shadow position changed; a moving pole is only one proposed explanation.

Why: Compare the pole’s position and the direction of sunlight before deciding.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Water-level record

Fixed case information

At 9 a.m. a virtual cup contains 50 mL. At noon it contains 44 mL. No cause was recorded.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Recorded change; Interpretation not yet tested; Missing evidence

  • a: A drop of 6 mL
  • b: Water leaked
  • c: Where the lost water went
  • d: A rise of 6 mL
Answer: Recorded change → A drop of 6 mL; Interpretation not yet tested → Water leaked; Missing evidence → Where the lost water went

The subtraction describes a measurement; it does not identify a cause.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Describe a leaf

Fixed case information

A photograph taken at noon shows two yellow leaves. A comment says the plant is angry.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Direct observation; Unsupported interpretation; Useful record detail

  • a: Two leaves are yellow
  • b: The plant is angry
  • c: Photograph time
  • d: Two roots are blue
Answer: Direct observation → Two leaves are yellow; Unsupported interpretation → The plant is angry; Useful record detail → Photograph time

Visible colour and count can be described; anger was not observed.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · Identify a recorded quantity

Fixed case information

A toy cart travels 2 m in 4 s on a classroom track. A learner proposes that wheel friction slowed it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Recorded distance; Recorded time; Proposed explanation

  • a: 2 m
  • b: 4 s
  • c: Wheel friction slowed the cart
  • d: 4 m
Answer: Recorded distance → 2 m; Recorded time → 4 s; Proposed explanation → Wheel friction slowed the cart

Distance and time were supplied as measurements; the friction explanation needs a comparison.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F4 · Keep the columns separate

Fixed case information

A log has observation “the sensor reads 18 °C” and interpretation “the shade caused cooling.” Only one reading is available.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies observation column in this case?

  • a: 18 °C reading
  • b: Shade caused cooling
  • c: The Sun is cold
  • d: No sensor was used
Answer: 18 °C reading

A single reading does not establish why it has that value.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · An honest description

Fixed case information

A virtual jar shows bubbles after stirring. Their source was not tested. One child says a new gas was certainly made by a reaction.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State the observation and explain why the cause is still uncertain.

Example of a full-credit answer: Bubbles appeared after stirring. The observation alone cannot distinguish a reaction from release of trapped air.

  1. Bubbles appeared after stirring.
  2. The observation alone cannot distinguish a reaction from release of trapped air.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional covered box reads 24 °C initially and 28 °C later. A learner says the cover created energy.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Recorded temperature change: Increase of 4 °C
  • b: Claim needing correction: The cover created energy
  • c: Recorded temperature change: Decrease of 4 °C
  • d: Claim needing correction: The reading rose from 24 °C to 28 °C
Answer: Recorded temperature change: Increase of 4 °C; Claim needing correction: The cover created energy

The temperature change is recorded; creation of energy is not established and conflicts with conservation.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the recorded change and distinguish it from the learner’s explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: The increase is 4 °C. That observation does not show energy was created; energy transfers must be considered.

  1. The increase is 4 °C.
  2. That observation does not show energy was created; energy transfers must be considered.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Notebook A says “three drops formed on the cold surface; condensation may explain them.” B says “the surface definitely manufactured water.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? More careful notebook: Notebook B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A distinguishes the observation from a tentative explanation.

2B · Open ended

Choose a notebook and explain how its wording separates observation and interpretation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses notebook A. Identifies the drop count as observation and condensation as a proposed explanation.

  1. Chooses notebook A.
  2. Identifies the drop count as observation and condensation as a proposed explanation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A virtual sound sensor reads 40 units behind screen X and 25 behind screen Y. Screen material and thickness both differ.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies lower recorded value in this case?

  • a: Behind screen Y
  • b: Behind screen X
  • c: The two are equal
  • d: No reading is recorded
Answer: Behind screen Y

The readings differ, but two changing features make the cause ambiguous.

3B · Short answer

Describe the measured difference and explain why its cause is not isolated.

Example of a full-credit answer: Y reads 15 units lower than X. Both material and thickness differ, so the comparison does not isolate either cause.

  1. Y reads 15 units lower than X.
  2. Both material and thickness differ, so the comparison does not isolate either cause.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A report labels “the puddle was 2 cm deep” as a theory and “water soaked into the soil” as a direct measurement. Only depth was measured.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies direct measurement in this case?

  • a: Puddle depth was 2 cm
  • b: Water soaked into soil
  • c: The depth was never read
  • d: Both were direct measurements
Answer: Puddle depth was 2 cm

The measured depth and the proposed water pathway have different evidence roles.

4B · Open ended

Correct the labels and say what would help check the proposed explanation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Labels depth as the observation and infiltration as an interpretation. Suggests measuring soil moisture, water flow or another relevant observation.

  1. Labels depth as the observation and infiltration as an interpretation.
  2. Suggests measuring soil moisture, water flow or another relevant observation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A virtual investigation records plant height on two dates and explores why it changed. The record must separate data from explanation and include a follow-up check.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Data column; Explanation column; Follow-up

  • a: Heights with dates and units
  • b: A possible cause of growth
  • c: Compare a relevant factor fairly
  • d: A guaranteed cause only
Answer: Data column → Heights with dates and units; Explanation column → A possible cause of growth; Follow-up → Compare a relevant factor fairly

A useful record marks which statements were measured and which need testing.

5B · Open ended

Propose one observation entry and one interpretation with a way to check it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Record “Monday: 8 cm; Friday: 10 cm.” Propose that water availability affected growth, then compare equal plants with controlled watering.

  1. Gives a measurable height entry with date/unit or equivalent explicit observation.
  2. Gives a plausible tentative explanation plus a relevant comparison or measurement to check it.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.2 · Distinguishing hypotheses, models, theories and laws

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A testable proposal

Worked-example information

A learner proposes that equal wet cloths dry faster in moving air than still air, all else equal.

Question: Which role does this statement have?

Answer: A testable hypothesis.

Why: It predicts a difference that comparable measurements can check.

Example 2 · A small solar system

Worked-example information

A classroom display uses balls on stands. Ball sizes and spaces are deliberately exaggerated.

Question: Is it a model or an exact copy?

Answer: A model.

Why: It represents selected relationships and leaves out accurate scale.

Example 3 · No promotion ladder

Worked-example information

A poster says “hypothesis → theory → law” means increasingly proven guesses.

Question: What needs correction?

Answer: Theory and law are different scientific roles, not stages in that ladder.

Why: Evidence can strengthen or revise each kind of scientific work without changing its role.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · A testable idea

Fixed case information

A team proposes that equal ice blocks lose remaining solid-ice mass faster through melting in warmer rooms, with equal time and containers. The measurement concerns solid ice remaining, not the total mass of the container and melted water.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Proposed role; Predicted measurement; Useful control

  • a: Hypothesis
  • b: Different loss of solid-ice mass
  • c: Equal starting ice blocks
  • d: A proven universal law
Answer: Proposed role → Hypothesis; Predicted measurement → Different loss of solid-ice mass; Useful control → Equal starting ice blocks

The proposal leads to a measurement that could test it.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F2 · A particle drawing

Fixed case information

Large coloured dots show gas particles in a box. The drawing omits actual particle size and full three-dimensional motion.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Scientific role: A scale photograph.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The drawing is a deliberately simplified representation.

Scientific explorer: particle lab

F3 · A stated relationship

Fixed case information

A classroom card states I = V/R for an ideal resistor at fixed resistance. It describes how the three quantities relate under the model assumptions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Role of the formula; Predicted current at 6 V and 3 Ω; Assumption

  • a: A stated quantitative relationship
  • b: 2 A
  • c: Ideal fixed resistance
  • d: An opinion about batteries
Answer: Role of the formula → A stated quantitative relationship; Predicted current at 6 V and 3 Ω → 2 A; Assumption → Ideal fixed resistance

A formula has defined quantities and conditions; it is not an unsupported preference.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F4 · A broad explanation

Fixed case information

A reference describes cell theory as a broad evidence-based account of cells and living things. A learner calls theory a mere unsupported guess.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Scientific meaning here; The misleading meaning specifically used by the learner; Relevant check

  • a: Well-tested explanatory framework
  • b: Unsupported guess
  • c: The evidence behind the explanation
  • d: A random prediction
Answer: Scientific meaning here → Well-tested explanatory framework; The misleading meaning specifically used by the learner → Unsupported guess; Relevant check → The evidence behind the explanation

Scientific theory has a stronger and different meaning from casual guessing.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Model limitation

Fixed case information

A virtual water tank has only input and output valves. Real tanks may also leak, but the model omits leakage.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what makes this a model and state one limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: It represents a tank with selected input/output rules. It omits leakage, so a leaking real tank needs an additional flow.

  1. It represents a tank with selected input/output rules.
  2. It omits leakage, so a leaking real tank needs an additional flow.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

An ideal tank model starts at 30 L, receives 8 L and loses 3 L. It assumes no leak or overflow.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Predicted final volume: 35 L
  • b: Required condition: No uncounted flow
  • c: Predicted final volume: 41 L
  • d: Required condition: 19 L
Answer: Predicted final volume: 35 L; Required condition: No uncounted flow

30 + 8 − 3 =35, under the stated boundary assumptions.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the prediction and name an assumption needed for it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Predicts 35 L. Names no leakage, no overflow or no other uncounted input/output.

  1. Predicts 35 L.
  2. Names no leakage, no overflow or no other uncounted input/output.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Proposal A says increasing light from level 2 to 4 will change growth in equal virtual plants. B says the plants contain an undetectable force that explains every outcome.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies testable proposal in this case?

  • a: A
  • b: B
  • c: Both equally testable
  • d: Neither mentions plants
Answer: A

A links a controllable comparison to a measurement.

2B · Short answer

Choose a proposal and explain why it can be scientifically tested.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Explains that comparing measured growth at the stated light levels could agree or disagree with the proposal.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Explains that comparing measured growth at the stated light levels could agree or disagree with the proposal.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A program represents a wave by amplitude and frequency. It omits room echoes. A school wants to predict sound in an echoing hall.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Missing feature: Frequency.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A representation useful for one question may need extension for another.

3B · Open ended

Name the missing feature and propose how to improve use in the hall.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies omitted echoes/reflections. Proposes adding reflection effects or comparing with hall measurements before relying on predictions.

  1. Identifies omitted echoes/reflections.
  2. Proposes adding reflection effects or comparing with hall measurements before relying on predictions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A child says a hypothesis becomes a theory and then a law once enough people agree.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which description identifies the mistaken relationship asserted among hypothesis, theory and law?

  • a: Treating terms as a promotion ladder
  • b: Correct scientific rule
  • c: More votes always make truth
  • d: A model must be a photograph
Answer: Treating terms as a promotion ladder

Scientific roles and evidence matter; popularity does not promote an explanation.

4B · Short answer

Correct the ladder claim and explain the different roles of theory and law.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rejects a theory-to-law promotion ladder or a vote-based progression. Explains that theories give broad explanations while laws describe relationships under conditions.

  1. Rejects a theory-to-law promotion ladder or a vote-based progression.
  2. Explains that theories give broad explanations while laws describe relationships under conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Make a model of a school water store for one day. Include at least one input and one output, and identify a real feature left out.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Needed input; Needed output; Needed caution

  • a: Water entering the store
  • b: Water used or lost
  • c: Name an omitted feature
  • d: Only a colourful title
Answer: Needed input → Water entering the store; Needed output → Water used or lost; Needed caution → Name an omitted feature

A useful model has quantities, rules and an honest boundary.

5B · Open ended

Propose the model’s input/output rule and state one limitation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Gives a rule that adds a named input and subtracts a named output from a starting store. Names an omitted real feature such as leakage, changing demand, contamination or variable rainfall.

  1. Gives a rule that adds a named input and subtracts a named output from a starting store.
  2. Names an omitted real feature such as leakage, changing demand, contamination or variable rainfall.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.3 · Evaluating scientific evidence

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Relevant measurement

Worked-example information

Two paper types are compared for absorbency. The record includes water absorbed and wrapper colour.

Question: Which measure directly addresses the claim?

Answer: Water absorbed.

Why: Wrapper colour is not an absorbency measurement.

Example 2 · Read all three trials
Absorbed water
TrialA mLB mL
185
296
3107

Worked-example information

Paper A absorbs 8, 9, 10 mL; paper B absorbs 5, 6, 7 mL using equal pieces and times.

Question: Which absorbed more in these trials?

Answer: Paper A.

Why: Each supplied A value is greater than eachB value; the conclusion remains about the tested setup.

Example 3 · A missing comparison

Worked-example information

A plant grows after a new watering plan, but no similar plant follows the old plan.

Question: What is missing?

Answer: A suitable comparison under comparable conditions.

Why: Growth might have occurred without the new plan.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Choose relevant evidence

Fixed case information

A claim says surface A makes a toy cart roll farther than surface B. Equal carts start from the same ramp height.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Relevant outcome: Recorder’s shirt colour.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Distance addresses the motion claim; the other details do not measure it.

Scientific explorer: motion lab

F2 · Check a repeated comparison

Fixed case information

Fictional equal-size filters remove 6, 7, 8 visible particles in three A trials and 3, 4, 5 in three B trials.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Larger removal in these trials; Number of trials per filter; Limit

  • a: Filter A
  • b: Three
  • c: Only visible particles measured
  • d: Filter B
Answer: Larger removal in these trials → Filter A; Number of trials per filter → Three; Limit → Only visible particles measured

The dataset favoursA for visible particles only; it does not establish drinking-water safety.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Inspect the sampling

Fixed case information

A school asks only its gardening club whether every student wants a garden.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Sample actually asked: Gardening-club members
  • b: Population in the claim: Every student
  • c: Sample actually asked: Every student
  • d: Population in the claim: All families nationwide
Answer: Sample actually asked: Gardening-club members; Population in the claim: Every student

A relevant interest group may not represent the full school.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F4 · Check the measuring tool

Fixed case information

A reference mass is 10 g. A classroom scale reads 12 g on every repeat.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies error relative to reference in this case?

  • a: 2 g high
  • b: 2 g low
  • c: No difference
  • d: 22 g high
Answer: 2 g high

Repeating a biased measurement does not remove the offset.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · Qualify a conclusion

Fixed case information

Four equal virtual trays show less soil loss with cover than without it. All tests used one rain intensity.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State a conclusion the evidence supports and one limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: States that cover reduced soil loss in the tested setup. Notes only one rain intensity or limited trials/landscape conditions were tested.

  1. States that cover reduced soil loss in the tested setup.
  2. Notes only one rain intensity or limited trials/landscape conditions were tested.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Matched virtual lamps each use 100 energy units. Lamp A gives 40 useful units and B gives 65. Both serve the same lighting task.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: More efficient lamp; Efficiency difference; Common input

  • a: B
  • b: 25 percentage points
  • c: 100 energy units
  • d: A
Answer: More efficient lamp → B; Efficiency difference → 25 percentage points; Common input → 100 energy units

Useful/input gives 40% and 65% under the stated model.

1B · Short answer

Choose the more efficient lamp and justify it with the numbers.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses B. Uses 65% versus 40% or 25 percentage-point difference to justify the choice.

  1. Chooses B.
  2. Uses 65% versus 40% or 25 percentage-point difference to justify the choice.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Source A gives repeated equal-condition measurements of cooling. Source B gives one unmeasured enthusiastic comment.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Stronger evidence for cooling; Useful feature; Limit of B

  • a: Source A
  • b: Repeated comparable measurements
  • c: No measured comparison
  • d: Source B
Answer: Stronger evidence for cooling → Source A; Useful feature → Repeated comparable measurements; Limit of B → No measured comparison

Relevant controlled measurements carry more information than a testimonial.

2B · Open ended

Choose the stronger evidence and explain one reason.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Source A. Cites repeated comparable measurements and/or the lack of measured comparison in B.

  1. Chooses Source A.
  2. Cites repeated comparable measurements and/or the lack of measured comparison in B.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A cloth test used clean water. Someone claims the cloth also removes dissolved salt. No salt measurement was made.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Which substance’s removal is claimed without a relevant measurement in the supplied case?

  • a: Dissolved salt
  • b: Visible mud clumps
  • c: Floating leaves
  • d: Large stones
Answer: Dissolved salt

Evidence for one property does not establish another.

3B · Short answer

Explain the gap and propose the measurement needed.

Example of a full-credit answer: States that the original test did not measure dissolved salt removal. Proposes a valid before/after salt-concentration measurement or equivalent dissolved-salt test.

  1. States that the original test did not measure dissolved salt removal.
  2. Proposes a valid before/after salt-concentration measurement or equivalent dissolved-salt test.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A report lists only the best result 9 from trials 4, 5, 9 and says the usual result is 9.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Omitted evidence; Mean of all three; Problem

  • a: Readings 4 and 5
  • b: 6
  • c: Selecting only the best trial
  • d: No readings were omitted
Answer: Omitted evidence → Readings 4 and 5; Mean of all three → 6; Problem → Selecting only the best trial

All valid observations must be considered;4+5+9=18 and 18/3=6.

4B · Open ended

Identify the reporting error and calculate the full-data mean.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies omission of 4 and 5 or cherry-picking. Calculates a mean of 6 using all three results.

  1. Identifies omission of 4 and 5 or cherry-picking.
  2. Calculates a mean of 6 using all three results.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class wants to compare two virtual cup covers for keeping water warm. It can use equal cups and checked sensors.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Needed outcome: Temperature change over equal time
  • b: Condition to keep: Starting temperature and water amount
  • c: Needed outcome: Only the label colour
  • d: Condition to keep: Change every condition
Answer: Needed outcome: Temperature change over equal time; Condition to keep: Starting temperature and water amount

A fair repeated comparison can address the specific cooling claim.

5B · Open ended

Propose a fair comparison and say how you will make its evidence more dependable.

Example of a full-credit answer: Compares covers using equal cups, starting water conditions and time while measuring temperature change. Adds repeated trials, checked sensors, complete records or another concrete reliability improvement.

  1. Compares covers using equal cups, starting water conditions and time while measuring temperature change.
  2. Adds repeated trials, checked sensors, complete records or another concrete reliability improvement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.4 · Evaluating source credibility

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Popularity or method?

Worked-example information

A video has many likes but no measurements. A named engineer reports repeated equal-condition tests of a bridge model.

Question: Which gives stronger evidence about that model’s load capacity?

Answer: The documented tests.

Why: Relevant expertise and a checkable method matter more than popularity.

Example 2 · Repeated copies

Worked-example information

Four posts display the same table from one laboratory report.

Question: How many independent datasets are shown?

Answer: One.

Why: Copying a table does not make a new investigation.

Example 3 · Date and relevance

Worked-example information

A recent article measures a different product; an older report tests the exact material named in a classroom question.

Question: Which is directly relevant to that material?

Answer: The report testing the named material, subject to checking whether conditions still match.

Why: Recency and relevance are separate questions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Relevant expertise

Fixed case information

A class asks about local rock layers. Source A is a geologist’s field report with mapped layers. Source B is an actor’s unreferenced opinion.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? More relevant source: Source A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The field report combines relevant expertise with evidence the reader can inspect.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Trace the original

Fixed case information

Post X cites Post Y, which links to Report Z containing the actual measurements and methods.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies original measurement source in this case?

  • a: Report Z
  • b: Post X
  • c: A follower count
  • d: An unrelated advertisement
Answer: Report Z

Following the chain reaches the evidence rather than stopping at repeated summaries.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Independent sources

Fixed case information

Five fictional posts reproduce one test dataset. A separate class runs a new comparable test.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies independent datasets now in this case?

  • a: Two
  • b: Six
  • c: Five
  • d: Zero
Answer: Two

The five copies share one dataset; the new test adds another.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F4 · Check a source’s purpose

Fixed case information

A manufacturer advertises a filter and gives no test method. The claim concerns removal of visible particles.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Purpose to consider; Missing evidence; Reasonable response

  • a: Selling the filter
  • b: A documented relevant test
  • c: Seek independent comparable measurements
  • d: A guaranteed false result
Answer: Purpose to consider → Selling the filter; Missing evidence → A documented relevant test; Reasonable response → Seek independent comparable measurements

Commercial purpose creates a reason to inspect the evidence, not an automatic verdict.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain source relevance

Fixed case information

A report tests a roof material at 25 °C. A post claims the same result applies at every temperature, without further tests.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what is credible about the report and what is unsupported in the post.

Example of a full-credit answer: The report names a specific tested condition or provides traceable measurements. The claim about every temperature goes beyond the supplied evidence.

  1. The report names a specific tested condition or provides traceable measurements.
  2. The claim about every temperature goes beyond the supplied evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Report A measures equal soil samples: 18 and 9 mL drain in five minutes. Report B says “my garden feels best” without a method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies stronger evidence for drainage in this case?

  • a: Report A
  • b: Report B
  • c: Both have the same method
  • d: Neither contains measurements
Answer: Report A

A supplies relevant quantities and a common observation time.

1B · Open ended

Choose the source and explain why its evidence fits the claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Report A. Uses the measured drainage and equal time/sample comparison to justify relevance.

  1. Chooses Report A.
  2. Uses the measured drainage and equal time/sample comparison to justify relevance.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A scientific article names authors, describes its test, links data and states a limit. A glossy poster has no author or source.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: More checkable source; Traceability feature; Important caution

  • a: The article
  • b: Linked data and method
  • c: Its stated limit still applies
  • d: The poster
Answer: More checkable source → The article; Traceability feature → Linked data and method; Important caution → Its stated limit still applies

A reader can examine the article’s evidence and boundaries.

2B · Short answer

Choose the more checkable source and name one feature that justifies your choice.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses the article. Identifies named relevant authors, linked data, a described method or stated limitations.

  1. Chooses the article.
  2. Identifies named relevant authors, linked data, a described method or stated limitations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A trusted astronomy website accurately describes planets. A copied page there makes a claim about a medicine without medical sources.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: What needs fresh checking; Relevant expertise needed; Invalid shortcut

  • a: The medicine claim
  • b: Medical research expertise
  • c: Trust every claim because one topic is accurate
  • d: The planet names only
Answer: What needs fresh checking → The medicine claim; Relevant expertise needed → Medical research expertise; Invalid shortcut → Trust every claim because one topic is accurate

Credibility is relevant to a particular claim and evidence, not a blanket guarantee.

3B · Open ended

Explain why the website’s astronomy record is insufficient and name a suitable check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Expertise in astronomy does not establish the medicine claim. Proposes checking relevant medical research or a qualified authoritative health source.

  1. Expertise in astronomy does not establish the medicine claim.
  2. Proposes checking relevant medical research or a qualified authoritative health source.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says ten copied posts prove a claim because many websites agree. All ten cite the same untested statement.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Error: Counting copies as independent evidence
  • b: Independent tests supplied: None
  • c: Error: Seeking relevant independent tests
  • d: Independent tests supplied: A complete proof
Answer: Error: Counting copies as independent evidence; Independent tests supplied: None

Repeated wording is not repeated investigation.

4B · Short answer

Identify the reasoning error and propose a better verification step.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that copies of one claim are not independent evidence. Proposes examining original methods/data or finding a genuinely independent relevant investigation.

  1. Explains that copies of one claim are not independent evidence.
  2. Proposes examining original methods/data or finding a genuinely independent relevant investigation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Create a short checklist for a science poster. It must check both who made the claim and the evidence behind it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies authorship check in this case?

  • a: Relevant author expertise
  • b: Only font size
  • c: Only popularity
  • d: Only agreement with your opinion
Answer: Relevant author expertise

A source checklist should connect identity, evidence and scope.

5B · Open ended

Write two useful checklist questions, one about authorship and one about evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Asks who produced/reviewed the claim and whether expertise is relevant. Asks for original data, method, independent verification or another concrete evidence check.

  1. Asks who produced/reviewed the claim and whether expertise is relevant.
  2. Asks for original data, method, independent verification or another concrete evidence check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.5 · Recognising scientific uncertainty

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A range of readings
Readings
Trialmm
118
220
322

Worked-example information

A class records 18, 20 and 22 mm for a flexible sample under the same method.

Question: What is the observed range?

Answer: 18 to 22 mm; the spread is 4 mm.

Why: The full set communicates variation without claiming a statistical confidence interval.

Example 2 · Consistent but shifted

Worked-example information

A 10 g reference reads 12 g three times.

Question: Has repetition removed the uncertainty about accuracy?

Answer: No. A consistent offset remains.

Why: Check calibration against the reference.

Example 3 · Possible is not equal

Worked-example information

A fictional model estimates 8 successes in 10 similar trials.

Question: Does uncertainty mean success and failure are equally likely?

Answer: No. The estimate favours success, while a single outcome is not guaranteed.

Why: An estimated probability has meaning even though it is not certainty.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Read the variation

Fixed case information

Fictional lengths measured by one method are 9, 10 and 11 cm.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Smallest reading; Largest reading; Mean

  • a: 9 cm
  • b: 11 cm
  • c: 10 cm
  • d: 8 cm
Answer: Smallest reading → 9 cm; Largest reading → 11 cm; Mean → 10 cm

The observations vary; their mean is 10 cm.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F2 · Spot an offset

Fixed case information

A checked 20 °C reference reads 23 °C on the classroom sensor every time.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · True or false

True or false? Systematic difference: 3 °C high.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Agreement among repeats does not remove a common offset.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F3 · Model limits

Fixed case information

A water model includes rain and pumping but omits leaks and seasonal changes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Known model input; Omitted flow; Omitted time variation

  • a: Rain
  • b: Leaks
  • c: Seasonal changes
  • d: A complete real aquifer
Answer: Known model input → Rain; Omitted flow → Leaks; Omitted time variation → Seasonal changes

The model can help with stated questions while leaving out real influences.

Scientific explorer: aquifer lab

F4 · Interpret an estimated chance

Fixed case information

A fictional chance model gives 3 favourable outcomes among 4 equally likely outcomes.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Estimated chance; Single-trial certainty; Unfavourable outcomes

  • a: 3 out of 4
  • b: Not guaranteed
  • c: 1 out of 4
  • d: 4 out of 4
Answer: Estimated chance → 3 out of 4; Single-trial certainty → Not guaranteed; Unfavourable outcomes → 1 out of 4

A probability greater than half still allows the other outcome.

Scientific explorer: probability lab

F5 · Explain a limited result

Fixed case information

Two trial means are 10.0 and 10.2 units. The sensor reads only to the nearest whole unit, and few trials were done.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why caution is needed and give one useful next step.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies coarse resolution or too few trials as limiting the tiny-difference claim. Suggests finer checked measurement, more appropriate repeats or another relevant improvement.

  1. Identifies coarse resolution or too few trials as limiting the tiny-difference claim.
  2. Suggests finer checked measurement, more appropriate repeats or another relevant improvement.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Tool A gives 19, 20, 21 units. Tool B gives 20, 20, 20. The reference value is 20. All are fictional readings.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies smaller observed spread in this case?

  • a: Tool B
  • b: Tool A
  • c: Both have a spread of 3
  • d: Neither mean can be found
Answer: Tool B

Both means equal 20; B’s repeats have less spread in this small set.

1B · Short answer

Compare the spread and explain what the reference lets you say about the means.

Example of a full-credit answer: B has smaller spread than A. Both means equal 20 and match the stated reference in this set.

  1. B has smaller spread than A.
  2. Both means equal 20 and match the stated reference in this set.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A model predicts storage between 45 and 55 units under its chosen assumptions. Plan A states “about 50, with a modelled range 45–55.” B states “exactly 50 in every real tank.”

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Better statement: Plan A
  • b: Useful information: A modelled range
  • c: Better statement: Plan B
  • d: Useful information: Both equally careful
Answer: Better statement: Plan A; Useful information: A modelled range

A retains the model’s range and conditional meaning.

2B · Open ended

Choose a statement and justify it with the reported uncertainty.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses A. Explains that it retains the range and model assumptions rather than claiming exact universal 50.

  1. Chooses A.
  2. Explains that it retains the range and model assumptions rather than claiming exact universal 50.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A sample of 10 leaves has 6 spotted leaves. A different random sample has 4. The whole tree was not counted.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false? Why samples can differ: Sampling variation.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Different samples can differ by chance without making either record invalid.

3B · Short answer

Explain one reason for the different results and propose a useful improvement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Names sampling variation or different leaves selected. Suggests larger/repeated representative samples or counting the defined population.

  1. Names sampling variation or different leaves selected.
  2. Suggests larger/repeated representative samples or counting the defined population.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says scientists cannot know anything about climate because exact weather next month is uncertain.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies error in this case?

  • a: Confusing different questions and timescales
  • b: Every climate conclusion is false
  • c: Weather and climate are identical
  • d: No measurements exist
Answer: Confusing different questions and timescales

Uncertainty in a specific forecast does not erase evidence about long-term patterns.

4B · Open ended

Identify the reasoning error and distinguish the two kinds of evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that uncertain exact weather does not mean nothing is known about climate. Contrasts short-term forecasts with long-term climate measurements/patterns.

  1. Explains that uncertain exact weather does not mean nothing is known about climate.
  2. Contrasts short-term forecasts with long-term climate measurements/patterns.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A team measures 6, 7, 8 units in three trials. Its report must communicate the centre and the observed variation without inventing certainty.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Mean; Observed interval; Needed caution

  • a: 7 units
  • b: 6 to 8 units
  • c: Only three trials
  • d: 21 units
Answer: Mean → 7 units; Observed interval → 6 to 8 units; Needed caution → Only three trials

A mean plus the observed interval describes these data honestly.

5B · Open ended

Write a short result statement with the mean and a suitable uncertainty or scope statement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Reports the mean as 7 units. Reports observed readings 6–8 and/or explains that only three trials do not guarantee future values.

  1. Reports the mean as 7 units.
  2. Reports observed readings 6–8 and/or explains that only three trials do not guarantee future values.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.6 · Recognising conflicts of interest

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A seller’s test

Worked-example information

A fictional cup company pays for a heat-retention test of its own cups.

Question: What should readers know?

Answer: The company funded the test and benefits from favourable findings.

Why: That is a relevant interest to disclose, not proof that the readings are false.

Example 2 · A reviewer’s connection

Worked-example information

A science-fair judge’s sibling enters a project.

Question: What is a suitable response?

Answer: Disclose the relationship and let an unconnected judge evaluate that entry.

Why: The safeguard addresses the specific potential influence.

Example 3 · A blinded comparison

Worked-example information

Two products are labelled X andY before the tester measures them.

Question: What risk can coding reduce?

Answer: The tester’s expectations about the brand affecting measurement or treatment.

Why: Coding does not fix every possible problem, but it can reduce this influence.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify who benefits

Fixed case information

A fictional lamp seller commissions a test and advertises the highest result. It gains sales if buyers believe the lamp is efficient.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies relevant interest in this case?

  • a: More sales for the seller
  • b: The test date alone
  • c: The table colour
  • d: The tester’s shoe size
Answer: More sales for the seller

The financial interest is relevant to how results may be selected or presented.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Separate concern from proof

Fixed case information

A report declares company funding and publishes its full method. A reader says funding alone proves every number fake.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Reader’s error; Useful action; Known fact

  • a: Treating a conflict as proof of falsity
  • b: Examine methods and independent checks
  • c: Funding was declared
  • d: A temperature reading of 20 °C
Answer: Reader’s error → Treating a conflict as proof of falsity; Useful action → Examine methods and independent checks; Known fact → Funding was declared

Potential influence and demonstrated false data are different claims.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F3 · A judging role

Fixed case information

A judge is asked to score a project made by a close family member. Other qualified judges are available.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies relevant connection in this case?

  • a: Close family relationship
  • b: The project colour
  • c: Keep the connection secret
  • d: Award automatic first place
Answer: Close family relationship

Disclosure and reassignment can manage the specific conflict.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F4 · Complete reporting

Fixed case information

A sponsor permits publication of successful trials but asks to hide unsuccessful trials.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Concern; Data needed; Safeguard

  • a: Selective reporting
  • b: All valid trials
  • c: Pre-agreed complete reporting
  • d: Perfect transparency
Answer: Concern → Selective reporting; Data needed → All valid trials; Safeguard → Pre-agreed complete reporting

Suppression can distort the apparent result even when shown numbers are correct.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F5 · Explain an independent check

Fixed case information

A product developer reports a result. A second team with no sales interest repeats the stated method with new samples.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain what makes the second test useful and what still must be checked.

Example of a full-credit answer: It gathers independent new data rather than merely copying the first report. Its method, sample conditions and full results still need comparison and evaluation.

  1. It gathers independent new data rather than merely copying the first report.
  2. Its method, sample conditions and full results still need comparison and evaluation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A seller shows a score 9 as its typical result. Its three valid trials were 3, 6, 9, and the seller benefits from high scores.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Mean of complete data: 6
  • b: Relevant interest: Sales benefit
  • c: Mean of complete data: 9
  • d: Relevant interest: 18
Answer: Mean of complete data: 6; Relevant interest: Sales benefit

The mean is 6; the interest makes the selection worth checking but the numerical issue is visible in the records.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the mean and explain the concern about the displayed result.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates 6. Explains that showing only 9 overstates typical performance and may serve the seller’s interest.

  1. Calculates 6.
  2. Explains that showing only 9 overstates typical performance and may serve the seller’s interest.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Two brands are tested. Plan A uses coded samples and the same method, with all results recorded. Plan B lets the sponsor choose which results to show.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Stronger safeguard: Plan A.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Coding and complete reporting address different sources of influence.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and justify it using one safeguard.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Explains how coding or complete reporting reduces a relevant influence.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Explains how coding or complete reporting reduces a relevant influence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A scientist reviews a paper written by a close collaborator. No money is involved.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies potential interest in this case?

  • a: A close professional relationship
  • b: No possible conflict ever
  • c: A guaranteed false paper
  • d: A need to change the data
Answer: A close professional relationship

Relationships can influence judgement even without payment.

3B · Open ended

Explain the possible conflict and propose a way to manage it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies the close collaboration as a potential influence on review. Proposes disclosure and independent reassignment/review as appropriate.

  1. Identifies the close collaboration as a potential influence on review.
  2. Proposes disclosure and independent reassignment/review as appropriate.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A poster says every company-funded study is fraudulent and every unfunded study is correct.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Main error; Proper evaluation; Role of disclosure

  • a: Funding is treated as a truth test
  • b: Inspect evidence and safeguards
  • c: Reveal a potential interest
  • d: The poster proves fraud
Answer: Main error → Funding is treated as a truth test; Proper evaluation → Inspect evidence and safeguards; Role of disclosure → Reveal a potential interest

Neither funding nor its absence replaces evaluating scientific evidence.

4B · Short answer

Correct both parts of the poster’s claim.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains company funding does not by itself prove fraud. Explains lack of funding does not guarantee correctness; evidence still needs evaluation.

  1. Explains company funding does not by itself prove fraud.
  2. Explains lack of funding does not guarantee correctness; evidence still needs evaluation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A class tests a donated material. The donor hopes the class will recommend it. The report must reveal this interest and make results checkable.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Disclosure to include; Evidence to include; Useful next check

  • a: Donation and donor interest
  • b: Method and all valid results
  • c: Independent comparable testing
  • d: Only donor praise
Answer: Disclosure to include → Donation and donor interest; Evidence to include → Method and all valid results; Useful next check → Independent comparable testing

Transparency lets others inspect both the connection and the evidence.

5B · Open ended

Propose one disclosure statement and one evidence safeguard.

Example of a full-credit answer: Discloses that the donor supplied the material and may benefit from a recommendation. Proposes complete reporting, coded comparisons, independent testing or a similarly specific safeguard.

  1. Discloses that the donor supplied the material and may benefit from a recommendation.
  2. Proposes complete reporting, coded comparisons, independent testing or a similarly specific safeguard.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.7 · Recognising bias

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A convenient corner

Worked-example information

A class counts litter only near the busiest gate and describes the entire school.

Question: What bias is possible?

Answer: The selected location may systematically contain more litter than other areas.

Why: Use a defined sampling plan across the school.

Example 2 · A shifted scale

Worked-example information

A 5 g reference reads 6 g every time.

Question: What error is shown?

Answer: A consistent 1 g-high offset.

Why: More repetitions of that same tool do not remove the shift.

Example 3 · Only good trials
Full record
TrialUnits
18
29
33

Worked-example information

A report includes 8 and 9 but omits a valid 3 from the same test.

Question: Why is the summary misleading?

Answer: It selectively hides a lower result.

Why: All valid trials matter when describing typical performance.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Who was sampled?

Fixed case information

A class asks only basketball players whether the playground needs more courts, then claims all students agree.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies sample in this case?

  • a: Basketball players
  • b: All students
  • c: Every family in the town
  • d: No one was asked
Answer: Basketball players

The chosen group may have different preferences from the whole school.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

F2 · Check the scale

Fixed case information

A 10 g reference gives 12 g on a scale in four repeats.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies offset in this case?

  • a: 2 g high
  • b: 2 g low
  • c: Zero error
  • d: 22 g high
Answer: 2 g high

Consistent repeats can still be consistently wrong.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F3 · Expectations in testing

Fixed case information

A tester knows which coded plant is expected to grow best and gives it more water. The test claims to compare light alone.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Uncontrolled difference; Claimed changed factor; Risk

  • a: Water amount
  • b: Light
  • c: Expected winner receives different treatment
  • d: Only the plant labels
Answer: Uncontrolled difference → Water amount; Claimed changed factor → Light; Risk → Expected winner receives different treatment

Changing water as well as light can favour one group.

Scientific explorer: investigation lab

F4 · Choose all valid trials

Fixed case information

Recorded values are 4, 5, 12. A report shows only 12 because it is the highest.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Omitted values; Selection rule used; More honest record

  • a: 4 and 5
  • b: Choose the highest
  • c: All three valid values
  • d: No values omitted
Answer: Omitted values → 4 and 5; Selection rule used → Choose the highest; More honest record → All three valid values

Selecting only the maximum distorts the result.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F5 · Explain a sampling improvement

Fixed case information

A yard has sunny and shaded areas. A team counts insects only in shade. It wants a yard-wide estimate.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Describe the likely sampling problem and propose a targeted improvement.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that sampling only shade can miss differences in sunny areas. Proposes a yard-wide random or appropriately divided sampling plan using comparable methods.

  1. Explains that sampling only shade can miss differences in sunny areas.
  2. Proposes a yard-wide random or appropriately divided sampling plan using comparable methods.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: sample lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A tester reports the mean of the two highest trials 8 and 10 as 9. The full valid set is 2, 4, 8, 10.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Full-data mean; Selected mean; Direction of distortion

  • a: 6
  • b: 9
  • c: Upward
  • d: 12
Answer: Full-data mean → 6; Selected mean → 9; Direction of distortion → Upward

The full sum 24 divided by 4 is 6; selecting high trials raises the summary.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the full mean and explain how selection changed the report.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates 6. Explains that choosing only 8 and 10 raises the reported mean to 9 and omits lower valid results.

  1. Calculates 6.
  2. Explains that choosing only 8 and 10 raises the reported mean to 9 and omits lower valid results.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A tester compares two fabrics. Plan A hides brand names behind codes and uses equal test rules. Plan B displays the expected winner prominently.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Better expectation safeguard; Key feature; Additional requirement

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Coded identities
  • c: Same procedure for both
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Better expectation safeguard → Plan A; Key feature → Coded identities; Additional requirement → Same procedure for both

Coding can reduce expectation effects, while equal procedures preserve comparability.

2B · Open ended

Choose the plan and explain the bias it addresses.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Explains that hiding brand/expected identity can reduce preferential treatment or reading influenced by expectations.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Explains that hiding brand/expected identity can reduce preferential treatment or reading influenced by expectations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A temperature sensor is always 2 °C high. A new study averages 100 readings from that sensor without a reference check.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Remaining problem: The systematic offset
  • b: What averaging can reduce: Some random variation
  • c: Remaining problem: All error disappears
  • d: What averaging can reduce: The temperature becomes exact
Answer: Remaining problem: The systematic offset; What averaging can reduce: Some random variation

Averaging does not cancel a shared offset.

3B · Short answer

Explain why 100 readings do not solve the problem and name the relevant check.

Example of a full-credit answer: The same 2 °C systematic offset remains in the average. A suitable reference/calibration check is needed to identify or correct it.

  1. The same 2 °C systematic offset remains in the average.
  2. A suitable reference/calibration check is needed to identify or correct it.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says surveying 500 garden-club members must represent every student better than a random school-wide sample of 50. Only selection method and sizes are given.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: The learner’s size-only reasoning shortcut; Key difference; Needed judgement

  • a: Larger always means less biased
  • b: Who could be selected
  • c: Evaluate the sampling method
  • d: Checking a reference mass to calibrate a scale
Answer: The learner’s size-only reasoning shortcut → Larger always means less biased; Key difference → Who could be selected; Needed judgement → Evaluate the sampling method

Size and selection bias are different; the whole-school frame matters.

4B · Open ended

Correct the shortcut and explain what the selection method changes.

Example of a full-credit answer: Rejects the claim that larger automatically means less biased. Explains that sampling only one interest group can systematically miss other students.

  1. Rejects the claim that larger automatically means less biased.
  2. Explains that sampling only one interest group can systematically miss other students.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Estimate litter across a school with paths, classrooms and garden areas. Include a sampling rule and a consistent counting rule.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · True or false

True or false? Sampling goal: Cover the defined school area.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

A defensible count matches selection and method to the population.

5B · Open ended

Propose a sampling plan and a consistent counting procedure.

Example of a full-credit answer: Uses random or appropriately distributed locations across the defined school areas. Uses a consistent item definition, area/time and recording procedure rather than selectively keeping counts.

  1. Uses random or appropriately distributed locations across the defined school areas.
  2. Uses a consistent item definition, area/time and recording procedure rather than selectively keeping counts.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.8 · Understanding peer review

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Two things changed

Worked-example information

A seedling report changes both light and water but claims to test only light.

Question: What should a reviewer question?

Answer: The water difference, because it offers another explanation.

Why: A fair light comparison should keep relevant water conditions comparable.

Example 2 · Review or replication?

Worked-example information

A scientist checks the arithmetic in a published table. A second team grows new plants using the reported method.

Question: Which action is replication?

Answer: The second team’s new plant investigation.

Why: Checking a table is review; gathering new comparable data is replication.

Example 3 · Revise a conclusion

Worked-example information

A report tests one material at 20 °C but claims every material behaves the same at every temperature.

Question: What revision is justified?

Answer: Limit the conclusion to the tested material and conditions.

Why: A reviewer can improve the match between evidence and scope.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify a useful comment

Fixed case information

A report lists water volumes as 12, 15 and 14 without giving a unit. A reviewer asks the authors to identify the unit and tool.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Scientific concern; Useful response; A response that changes page appearance instead of measurement information

  • a: Missing measurement information
  • b: Add the unit and tool
  • c: Change only the page colour
  • d: The author’s favourite food
Answer: Scientific concern → Missing measurement information; Useful response → Add the unit and tool; A response that changes page appearance instead of measurement information → Change only the page colour

Units and methods make measurements interpretable and checkable.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F2 · Follow a review cycle

Fixed case information

A journal receives a report, obtains expert comments, receives a revision, and then makes an editorial decision.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies step after expert comments in this case?

  • a: Author revision
  • b: Automatic truth certification
  • c: A class popularity vote
  • d: Destroy all earlier records
Answer: Author revision

A review cycle allows specific concerns to be addressed before an editorial decision.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F3 · Review a numerical summary

Fixed case information

Three valid results are 4, 6 and 8 units. The report calls 8 the mean.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Correct mean; Reported mean; Reviewer’s concern

  • a: 6
  • b: 8
  • c: The calculation does not match all trials
  • d: 4
Answer: Correct mean → 6; Reported mean → 8; Reviewer’s concern → The calculation does not match all trials

The sum is 18 and the mean is 6; a reviewer can identify this arithmetic error.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F4 · Distinguish checks

Fixed case information

Reviewer A reads the methods and checks the graph. Team B collects new data with the same stated method.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · True or false

True or false: Reviewer A is the one collecting the new experimental data in this case.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Review and replication provide different kinds of checking.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain a limit of review

Fixed case information

A peer-reviewed classroom study tests five pots for one week. A post says publication proves the result applies to every plant forever.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the post is too broad and state a better conclusion.

Example of a full-credit answer: Peer review does not prove all plants or future conditions were tested. Limits the finding to the observed pots, week and method, with further tests needed.

  1. Peer review does not prove all plants or future conditions were tested.
  2. Limits the finding to the observed pots, week and method, with further tests needed.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional report records 10, 12 and 14 mL but reports a mean of 14 mL.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · True or false

True or false? Correct mean: 14 mL.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

The mean uses all three trials: 36 divided by 3 is 12 mL.

1B · Open ended

Calculate the correct mean and explain the change the report needs.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates 12 mL. Explains that the mean must include all three results rather than the maximum.

  1. Calculates 12 mL.
  2. Explains that the mean must include all three results rather than the maximum.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Report A describes a filter test but omits the starting particle counts. Comment X asks for those counts to check comparability. Comment Y attacks the author’s handwriting.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: More useful comment; Reason; Needed evidence

  • a: Comment X
  • b: Starting conditions affect the comparison
  • c: The initial counts
  • d: Comment Y
Answer: More useful comment → Comment X; Reason → Starting conditions affect the comparison; Needed evidence → The initial counts

X identifies a specific methodological concern and a checkable improvement.

2B · Short answer

Choose the comment and justify it with the scientific concern.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Comment X. Explains why initial particle counts matter for a fair comparison.

  1. Chooses Comment X.
  2. Explains why initial particle counts matter for a fair comparison.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A class uses a toy erosion model. Its report calls the model output an exact prediction of next month’s real soil loss.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies reviewer’s concern in this case?

  • a: Model output is overstated as an exact forecast
  • b: The simulation measures every real hillside
  • c: No model assumptions exist
  • d: A brighter graph makes it exact
Answer: Model output is overstated as an exact forecast

A reviewer should check the connection between assumptions and the conclusion.

3B · Open ended

Explain the overstatement and propose a useful revision.

Example of a full-credit answer: The toy erosion index is not an exact real-world forecast. States the assumptions/limits and presents the output as a simplified exploration or proposes real validation.

  1. The toy erosion index is not an exact real-world forecast.
  2. States the assumptions/limits and presents the output as a simplified exploration or proposes real validation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says a peer-reviewed paper can never contain an error because experts have approved it.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: The learner’s claim about error-free papers; More accurate role; Further check

  • a: Review guarantees no errors
  • b: Expert scrutiny can find problems
  • c: Replication and continuing evaluation
  • d: The paper’s length in pages
Answer: The learner’s claim about error-free papers → Review guarantees no errors; More accurate role → Expert scrutiny can find problems; Further check → Replication and continuing evaluation

Review improves scrutiny but cannot guarantee correctness.

4B · Short answer

Correct the learner’s claim and name a further scientific check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that peer review can miss errors and does not guarantee truth. Names replication, reanalysis or another relevant independent evidence check.

  1. Explains that peer review can miss errors and does not guarantee truth.
  2. Names replication, reanalysis or another relevant independent evidence check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A report compares two paper bridges. It gives their maximum loads but omits bridge width and the number of trials.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Design detail to request: Bridge width
  • b: Evidence detail to request: Number and results of trials
  • c: Design detail to request: Only author popularity
  • d: Evidence detail to request: Only the cover picture
Answer: Design detail to request: Bridge width; Evidence detail to request: Number and results of trials

Useful review questions target a missing comparison condition and repeated evidence.

5B · Open ended

Write two review questions: one about a fair comparison and one about repeated evidence.

Example of a full-credit answer: Asks whether bridge dimensions or other relevant design conditions were comparable. Asks for the number of trials and/or all repeated results to judge variation.

  1. Asks whether bridge dimensions or other relevant design conditions were comparable.
  2. Asks for the number of trials and/or all repeated results to judge variation.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.9 · Understanding scientific consensus

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Many copies, one test

Worked-example information

Twelve posts repeat one classroom measurement. Three other classes perform new comparable tests.

Question: Which adds independent evidence?

Answer: The three new tests.

Why: Copies may spread information but do not create new observations.

Example 2 · Agreement with a range
Expansion tests
TeamIncrease in mm
A2
B3
C2

Worked-example information

Three fictional teams measure expansion as 2, 3 and 2 mm under comparable warming conditions.

Question: What do all three results support?

Answer: The sample expanded in these tests, while the exact amount varies.

Why: A shared direction can coexist with uncertainty about size.

Example 3 · A surprising new result

Worked-example information

One new measurement conflicts with several well-documented results.

Question: What should happen next?

Answer: Check methods and seek independent tests of the disagreement.

Why: Neither dismissing the new result automatically nor accepting it uncritically is justified.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Identify the basis of agreement

Fixed case information

Several independent teams use relevant methods, publish their records and reach a similar explanation. A poll of fans supports a different idea without measurements.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Stronger scientific basis; Weak substitute; Important check

  • a: Independent relevant investigations
  • b: A popularity poll
  • c: Methods and limitations
  • d: No teams collected any records
Answer: Stronger scientific basis → Independent relevant investigations; Weak substitute → A popularity poll; Important check → Methods and limitations

Evidence and critical scrutiny support scientific consensus.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F2 · Count independent datasets

Fixed case information

Four articles repeat Dataset A. Two separate teams gather Datasets B and C.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies independent datasets in this case?

  • a: Three
  • b: Six
  • c: Four
  • d: One
Answer: Three

A, B and C are three datasets; copying A does not multiply it.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Find the shared result

Fixed case information

Three fictional expansion changes are +1, +2 and +3 mm after the same warming procedure.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Shared direction: Expansion
  • b: Uncertain detail: Exact amount
  • c: Shared direction: Contraction
  • d: Uncertain detail: No change in any trial
Answer: Shared direction: Expansion; Uncertain detail: Exact amount

Every change is positive, although the sizes differ.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F4 · Respond to new evidence

Fixed case information

A carefully documented new result conflicts with an accepted explanation. Its method can be repeated.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Useful next action; Unsupported reason for rejecting the new result; Reason to revise

  • a: Independent investigation of the result
  • b: Reject it solely because it is new
  • c: Strong relevant evidence
  • d: Accept it because it is surprising
Answer: Useful next action → Independent investigation of the result; Unsupported reason for rejecting the new result → Reject it solely because it is new; Reason to revise → Strong relevant evidence

A surprising result merits scrutiny and comparison with the wider evidence.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain agreement and uncertainty

Fixed case information

Teams agree that a sample grows when heated. Their measurements differ slightly because of tool resolution and conditions.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

State what the teams agree on and what remains uncertain.

Example of a full-credit answer: They agree the tested sample increases in size under the stated heating conditions. The precise amount is uncertain because measurements/conditions differ.

  1. They agree the tested sample increases in size under the stated heating conditions.
  2. The precise amount is uncertain because measurements/conditions differ.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

Three independent fictional tests compare a covered and uncovered soil tray. Recorded erosion indices are lower with cover in all three tests.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · True or false

True or false? Common finding: Cover lowered the measured index.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Converging comparisons support a limited conclusion about the tested conditions.

1B · Short answer

State the shared finding and one limit of applying it widely.

Example of a full-credit answer: All three tests show a lower index for the covered tray. Limits the conclusion to the test conditions and avoids an exact universal real-world erosion prediction.

  1. All three tests show a lower index for the covered tray.
  2. Limits the conclusion to the test conditions and avoids an exact universal real-world erosion prediction.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Source A summarises relevant independent studies, methods and uncertainties. Source B shows a count of social-media likes for a claim.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies better basis in this case?

  • a: Source A
  • b: Source B
  • c: Likes are independent experiments
  • d: No methods need examination
Answer: Source A

A review of relevant evidence is more informative than a popularity count.

2B · Open ended

Choose the more useful source and explain why.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Source A. Explains that it evaluates relevant independent scientific evidence rather than popularity.

  1. Chooses Source A.
  2. Explains that it evaluates relevant independent scientific evidence rather than popularity.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Researchers agree a material expands when warmed, but disagree whether one sample expanded 2.0 or 2.2 mm. A post says the whole expansion idea is disproved.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Disagreement concerns; Shared observation; Post’s error

  • a: The exact amount
  • b: Positive expansion
  • c: Treating a narrow uncertainty as total disproof
  • d: Whether any observation exists
Answer: Disagreement concerns → The exact amount; Shared observation → Positive expansion; Post’s error → Treating a narrow uncertainty as total disproof

A small size disagreement does not erase agreement on the direction in the evidence.

3B · Short answer

Explain the distinction between the shared conclusion and the disputed detail.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both measurements support positive expansion under the tested conditions. The disagreement concerns the precise amount, so it does not by itself disprove expansion.

  1. Both measurements support positive expansion under the tested conditions.
  2. The disagreement concerns the precise amount, so it does not by itself disprove expansion.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A learner says twenty copied blog posts must outweigh two careful independent experiments because twenty is larger than two.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Hotspot

Which response would improve the learner’s reasoning about the copied posts?

  • a: Compare independent methods and data instead of counting copied posts
  • b: More copies always mean better evidence
  • c: Every post is a new experiment
  • d: Only the number of words matters
Answer: Compare independent methods and data instead of counting copied posts

Scientific judgement considers the quality and independence of evidence.

4B · Open ended

Identify the error and explain what should be compared instead.

Example of a full-credit answer: Copies of one claim are not twenty independent tests. Compare relevant methods, data quality, independence and limitations.

  1. Copies of one claim are not twenty independent tests.
  2. Compare relevant methods, data quality, independence and limitations.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Prepare a poster about a classroom scientific conclusion. It must explain the supporting evidence and one remaining question.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Support section; Uncertainty section; Good reporting habit

  • a: Independent relevant findings
  • b: A specific unanswered question
  • c: Keep the conclusion within the evidence
  • d: Only an opinion poll
Answer: Support section → Independent relevant findings; Uncertainty section → A specific unanswered question; Good reporting habit → Keep the conclusion within the evidence

A useful summary shows why the conclusion is supported and where more work is needed.

5B · Open ended

Propose two poster sections and describe what each should contain.

Example of a full-credit answer: One section presents relevant supporting findings and how they were obtained or checked. Another names a specific uncertainty/limit and a possible further check.

  1. One section presents relevant supporting findings and how they were obtained or checked.
  2. Another names a specific uncertainty/limit and a possible further check.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.10 · Comparing competing explanations

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Where did the water come from?

Worked-example information

One patch beside a tap is wet; nearby uncovered ground is dry.

Question: Which explanation fits better: widespread recent rain or a local leak?

Answer: A local leak fits this pattern better, but should be checked.

Why: The spatial pattern distinguishes the explanations without proving the exact cause.

Example 2 · Light or water?

Worked-example information

Plant A receives more light and more water than Plant B and grows taller.

Question: Can the difference be assigned to light alone?

Answer: No. Water also differs.

Why: A controlled comparison is needed to separate the explanations.

Example 3 · A shared prediction
Predictions
ConditionExplanation AExplanation B
X55
Y38

Worked-example information

Two explanations both predict a reading of 5 under Condition X, but predict 3 and 8 under Condition Y.

Question: Which condition better distinguishes them?

Answer: Condition Y.

Why: Its predictions differ.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Name alternatives

Fixed case information

A classroom light does not turn on in a model circuit. The switch may be open or the battery voltage may be zero.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies possible explanation a in this case?

  • a: Open switch
  • b: The lamp proves gravity stopped
  • c: Only one explanation is possible
  • d: No circuit condition matters
Answer: Open switch

Both suggested conditions can prevent current in the simplified circuit.

Scientific explorer: circuit lab

F2 · Choose a separating condition

Fixed case information

Hypothesis A predicts 4 units in Test X and 8 in Test Y. Hypothesis B predicts 4 in X and 2 in Y.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies more discriminating test in this case?

  • a: Test Y
  • b: Test X
  • c: Neither test has predictions
  • d: Both tests predict identical outcomes
Answer: Test Y

The predictions differ in Y but coincide in X.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Find an alternative cause

Fixed case information

Two soil trays receive different water amounts and have different vegetation cover. The covered tray loses less soil.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Second changed factor: Water amount.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

Water differences prevent isolating cover as the only explanation.

Scientific explorer: erosion lab

F4 · Evaluate a conflicting reading

Fixed case information

A sensor gives one unexpected value. A reference check then shows the sensor is shifted by 3 units.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: New explanation for the reading; Useful next step; Unsupported certainty claim about the theory

  • a: Sensor offset
  • b: Check or correct the instrument and repeat
  • c: The theory is certainly false from this reading alone
  • d: No check is needed
Answer: New explanation for the reading → Sensor offset; Useful next step → Check or correct the instrument and repeat; Unsupported certainty claim about the theory → The theory is certainly false from this reading alone

A measurement problem must be evaluated before interpreting the result.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · Explain an unresolved test

Fixed case information

Explanation A and Explanation B both predict the observed 6 units under the tested condition. They predict different values under a second condition that has not been tested.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

Explain why the result is inconclusive and propose the better next test.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both explanations predict 6 under the completed condition, so that observation does not distinguish them. Proposes the second condition because the predictions differ.

  1. Both explanations predict 6 under the completed condition, so that observation does not distinguish them.
  2. Proposes the second condition because the predictions differ.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A water patch appears beside a pipe. Three checks show nearby uncovered ground dry and the patch returning after wiping. Compare a local leak with widespread rainfall.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Better-fitting explanation: A local leak
  • b: Supporting pattern: A returning local patch with dry surroundings
  • c: Better-fitting explanation: Widespread rain is proved
  • d: Supporting pattern: Both explanations are equally measured facts
Answer: Better-fitting explanation: A local leak; Supporting pattern: A returning local patch with dry surroundings

The location and recurrence fit a local source better, while a check is still needed.

1B · Open ended

Choose the better-supported explanation and use the observations to justify it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses a local leak as better supported. Uses the local returning wet patch and dry surroundings, without claiming certainty beyond the evidence.

  1. Chooses a local leak as better supported.
  2. Uses the local returning wet patch and dry surroundings, without claiming certainty beyond the evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Plan A compares similar plants with equal water and soil but different light. Plan B changes light, water and soil together.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Better plan; Changed factor; Controlled examples

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Light
  • c: Water and soil
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Better plan → Plan A; Changed factor → Light; Controlled examples → Water and soil

Plan A reduces specified alternative explanations for growth differences.

2B · Short answer

Choose a plan and explain how it separates explanations.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Explains that keeping water and soil comparable helps isolate the light difference.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Explains that keeping water and soil comparable helps isolate the light difference.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

Two containers cool at different rates. One is wider and made of a different material. A learner blames only the material.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Alternative influence; Better comparison; Claim requiring caution

  • a: Container shape or exposed area
  • b: Equal shape and volume with different materials
  • c: Material alone caused the whole difference
  • d: The report describes differing cooling rates
Answer: Alternative influence → Container shape or exposed area; Better comparison → Equal shape and volume with different materials; Claim requiring caution → Material alone caused the whole difference

A fair material comparison controls relevant geometry and starting conditions.

3B · Open ended

Name an alternative influence and design a comparison to reduce it.

Example of a full-credit answer: Names shape/exposed area, starting temperature, volume or another relevant uncontrolled factor. Proposes a comparison holding those relevant conditions similar while varying material.

  1. Names shape/exposed area, starting temperature, volume or another relevant uncontrolled factor.
  2. Proposes a comparison holding those relevant conditions similar while varying material.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

Explanations A and B both predict 10 units in a selected test. The observed result is 10. A pupil says A alone has been proved.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies reasoning error in this case?

  • a: The result also fits B
  • b: B predicted zero
  • c: No prediction was made
  • d: A alone predicted ten
Answer: The result also fits B

A shared prediction cannot uniquely identify one explanation.

4B · Short answer

Explain the pupil’s error and propose a discriminating next step.

Example of a full-credit answer: Both explanations predicted the observed 10, so the result does not prove A alone. Proposes a condition or measurement where their predictions differ.

  1. Both explanations predicted the observed 10, so the result does not prove A alone.
  2. Proposes a condition or measurement where their predictions differ.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A seedling leans toward a window. Explanation A links leaning to light direction. Explanation B links it to a fixed room direction regardless of light. Use a teacher-managed virtual setup with similar plants.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Factor to vary; Factor to keep similar; Useful measurement

  • a: Light direction
  • b: Other growing conditions
  • c: Direction of leaning
  • d: Change all conditions at once
Answer: Factor to vary → Light direction; Factor to keep similar → Other growing conditions; Useful measurement → Direction of leaning

Changing light direction separates the predictions while controls limit other influences.

5B · Open ended

Propose a controlled comparison and state how its outcome would distinguish the explanations.

Example of a full-credit answer: Changes the light direction while keeping relevant plant, water and other growing conditions comparable. Explains that leaning following the changed light supports A, while staying in the fixed room direction supports B under the test assumptions.

  1. Changes the light direction while keeping relevant plant, water and other growing conditions comparable.
  2. Explains that leaning following the changed light supports A, while staying in the fixed room direction supports B under the test assumptions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.11 · Using scientific information in decision-making

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Choose within a budget
Shade plans
PlanCost tokensArea units
A812
B1218

Worked-example information

Fictional shade Plan A costs 8 tokens and covers 12 area units. Plan B costs 12 tokens and covers 18. The budget is 10 tokens.

Question: Which plan meets the budget?

Answer: Plan A.

Why: B covers more but exceeds the stated limit; cost is part of the decision.

Example 2 · Compare like with like

Worked-example information

Device A saves 6 L each day. Device B saves 30 L over five comparable days.

Question: Which saves more per day?

Answer: They save the same: 6 L per day.

Why: Convert the periods before comparing.

Example 3 · Add a monitoring plan

Worked-example information

A class chooses vegetation cover to reduce a fictional erosion index.

Question: What should it record to check the change?

Answer: Comparable before-and-after erosion observations and rainfall conditions.

Why: The evidence must distinguish a cover effect from changed test conditions.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Find the feasible option

Fixed case information

Fictional Plan A costs 6 tokens and saves 4 L per day. Plan B costs 11 tokens and saves 7 L per day. The budget is 8 tokens.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies option within budget in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Both exceed the budget
  • d: Neither saves water
Answer: Plan A

A meets the constraint even though B has a larger stated saving.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Compare equal periods

Fixed case information

A fictional device saves 3 L daily. Another saves 15 L over five comparable days.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: First daily saving: 3 L per day
  • b: Second recorded total: 15 L over five days
  • c: First daily saving: 15 L per day
  • d: Second recorded total: 5 L per day
Answer: First daily saving: 3 L per day; Second recorded total: 15 L over five days

Dividing 15 L by five days gives 3 L per day.

Scientific explorer: unit lab

F3 · Identify an uncertainty

Fixed case information

A toy energy plan meets demand using a chosen mix that includes a renewable supply. Real output may vary with conditions, but no local weather data are provided.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · True or false

True or false? Known model condition: Exact future output is guaranteed.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

A model plan should be checked against real variability before a real decision.

Scientific explorer: energy mix lab

F4 · Separate a value from a measurement

Fixed case information

A plan costs 9 tokens and serves 30 pupils. The class says access for all pupils should be a priority.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Recorded number of pupils served; Stated priority; Recorded cost in tokens

  • a: 30 pupils served
  • b: Access for all pupils
  • c: 9 tokens cost
  • d: Fairness has a measured mass
Answer: Recorded number of pupils served → 30 pupils served; Stated priority → Access for all pupils; Recorded cost in tokens → 9 tokens cost

A value judgement about fairness can guide the use of measured costs and benefits.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F5 · Explain monitoring

Fixed case information

A virtual school repairs a leaking tank. Use was 50 L per comparable day before repair and 35 L after, with the same listed activities.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Calculate the reduction and propose one check before claiming a lasting saving.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates 15 L per comparable day. Proposes repeated comparable-day readings or checking other changed conditions.

  1. Calculates 15 L per comparable day.
  2. Proposes repeated comparable-day readings or checking other changed conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A school needs at least 12 shade-area units and has 10 tokens. Plan A gives 14 units for 9 tokens; Plan B gives 18 for 12; Plan C gives 8 for 7.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies plan meeting both constraints in this case?

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Plan B
  • c: Plan C
  • d: None of the plans
Answer: Plan A

A meets both requirements; B exceeds cost and C provides too little area.

1B · Short answer

Choose a plan and check both constraints with numbers.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A and notes 14 area units meet the minimum of 12. Notes its cost of 9 tokens fits the maximum of 10.

  1. Chooses Plan A and notes 14 area units meet the minimum of 12.
  2. Notes its cost of 9 tokens fits the maximum of 10.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A fictional aquifer model starts at 40 units with recharge 6 per step. Plan A pumps 4; Plan B pumps 9. Ignore other flows for this comparison.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · True or false

True or false? Plan avoiding model depletion: Plan B.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Recharge minus pumping is +2 for A and -3 for B under the stated toy assumptions.

2B · Open ended

Choose the plan that avoids depletion in this model and justify it using both flows.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A. Explains that recharge 6 exceeds pumping 4, giving a net gain of 2 per step under the model assumptions.

  1. Chooses Plan A.
  2. Explains that recharge 6 exceeds pumping 4, giving a net gain of 2 per step under the model assumptions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A successful shade design was tested in a wide playground. A new site is narrow and has an emergency path that must remain clear.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: New constraint; Evidence to gather; Unsupported action

  • a: Keep the emergency path clear
  • b: Site dimensions and shade layout
  • c: Copy the plan without checking fit
  • d: The colour of the plan’s folder
Answer: New constraint → Keep the emergency path clear; Evidence to gather → Site dimensions and shade layout; Unsupported action → Copy the plan without checking fit

Evidence from one site must be checked against the new setting’s constraints.

3B · Short answer

Explain why copying is insufficient and propose a useful adaptation or check.

Example of a full-credit answer: The new narrow site and required clear path differ from the tested setting. Proposes measuring the layout and adapting/checking the shade plan to preserve access.

  1. The new narrow site and required clear path differ from the tested setting.
  2. Proposes measuring the layout and adapting/checking the shade plan to preserve access.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A pupil selects the cheapest water device without checking whether it meets the required saving or whether maintenance costs were included.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Missing performance check; Missing cost check; Reasoning error

  • a: Required water saving
  • b: Maintenance cost
  • c: Treating purchase price as the only criterion
  • d: The device’s printed serial number
Answer: Missing performance check → Required water saving; Missing cost check → Maintenance cost; Reasoning error → Treating purchase price as the only criterion

A low price alone does not establish that a plan meets its purpose and constraints.

4B · Open ended

Identify two missing checks that could change the decision.

Example of a full-credit answer: Checks whether the device achieves the required saving under relevant conditions. Checks maintenance or other relevant total costs instead of purchase price alone.

  1. Checks whether the device achieves the required saving under relevant conditions.
  2. Checks maintenance or other relevant total costs instead of purchase price alone.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A fictional garden loses soil after model rain. The class can add plant cover or reduce the slope in the virtual tray. Choose one change and a fair way to measure its effect.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Possible change; Outcome measure; Fair comparison

  • a: Increase cover
  • b: Erosion index under equal model rain
  • c: Keep other chosen settings comparable
  • d: Change every setting and keep no record
Answer: Possible change → Increase cover; Outcome measure → Erosion index under equal model rain; Fair comparison → Keep other chosen settings comparable

A design decision becomes testable when its change and outcome measure are explicit.

5B · Open ended

Propose one allowed change and describe a fair before-and-after check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses increased cover or reduced slope as a plausible model intervention. Compares erosion output with other relevant settings such as rain held comparable and records the result.

  1. Chooses increased cover or reduced slope as a plausible model intervention.
  2. Compares erosion output with other relevant settings such as rain held comparable and records the result.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.12 · Recognising the limits of scientific claims

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · Sample and population

Worked-example information

A class examines 6 leaves from one tree and finds spots on 4.

Question: Can it conclude every tree in town has the same spot rate?

Answer: No. It has evidence about the sampled leaves, not all trees.

Why: A broader appropriate sample would be needed.

Example 2 · A shared seasonal pattern

Worked-example information

Fictional weekly sunshine and ice-cream sales both increase.

Question: Does the graph prove ice cream causes sunshine?

Answer: No. A shared trend is not a causal test.

Why: The direction, confounders and method must be examined.

Example 3 · Precision in reporting

Worked-example information

A ruler has whole-centimetre markings, and no finer method is used.

Question: Is a reported length of 12.0007 cm supported?

Answer: No. The extra digits suggest precision the method did not provide.

Why: Report measurements at a resolution justified by the tool.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Locate the tested scope

Fixed case information

A report tests two fabric samples for 10 minutes using room-temperature water.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · True or false

True or false? Tested materials: Two fabric samples.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: True

The stated method supports a limited claim about the actual samples and conditions.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F2 · Recognise a correlation limit

Fixed case information

Fictional data show more umbrella sales on wetter days. The study only records daily totals.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Observed pattern; Unproved claim; Caution about possible alternative causes

  • a: Sales and rainfall rise together
  • b: Sales cause rain
  • c: Other explanations remain
  • d: Only daily totals were collected
Answer: Observed pattern → Sales and rainfall rise together; Unproved claim → Sales cause rain; Caution about possible alternative causes → Other explanations remain

An observational pattern does not establish the claimed causal direction.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F3 · Identify a model number

Fixed case information

A water explorer uses 100 rain units and chosen infiltration and evaporation percentages. It outputs a runoff amount.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Output type; Input type; Unsupported use

  • a: Simplified model result
  • b: Chosen assumptions
  • c: Exact real flood forecast
  • d: Colour of the on-screen buttons
Answer: Output type → Simplified model result; Input type → Chosen assumptions; Unsupported use → Exact real flood forecast

The toy water budget conserves its chosen units but is not a flood model.

Scientific explorer: water lab

F4 · Match resolution to a claim

Fixed case information

A sensor rounds to the nearest 1 unit. A report says one result is certainly 0.001 unit larger based only on that sensor.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies important limit in this case?

  • a: One-unit resolution
  • b: Perfect exactness
  • c: No rounding occurs
  • d: More decimal places create new evidence
Answer: One-unit resolution

Writing extra digits cannot add measurement information.

Scientific explorer: measurement lab

F5 · Write a bounded conclusion

Fixed case information

A fictional class tests three pairs of equal-size paper strips. Under one loading method, the folded strip holds more than the flat strip in each of the three comparisons.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Open ended

State a supported conclusion and one limit.

Example of a full-credit answer: Says the folded strips held more under the stated tested conditions. Limits the claim to these materials, sizes, trials or method rather than every structure.

  1. Says the folded strips held more under the stated tested conditions.
  2. Limits the claim to these materials, sizes, trials or method rather than every structure.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A fictional seed study tests 12 seeds of one plant type for 7 days at one temperature. Nine sprout.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies observed fraction in this case?

  • a: 9 out of 12
  • b: 12 out of 12
  • c: 3 out of 12
  • d: 9 out of 7
Answer: 9 out of 12

Nine of twelve sprouted in the stated sample; the result does not test every seed type or condition.

1B · Open ended

Report the observed result and explain why it is not a universal germination rate.

Example of a full-credit answer: Reports 9 of 12 sprouted by day 7 under the stated conditions. Notes the limited plant type, sample, time or temperature and need for broader evidence.

  1. Reports 9 of 12 sprouted by day 7 under the stated conditions.
  2. Notes the limited plant type, sample, time or temperature and need for broader evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

Two virtual materials are tested three times with equal starting conditions. Material A transfers heat faster in those runs. Claim X stays within those runs. Claim Y says A is best for every possible use.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Better-supported claim: Claim X
  • b: Evidence feature: Comparable repeated runs
  • c: Better-supported claim: Claim Y
  • d: Evidence feature: Neither claim mentions evidence
Answer: Better-supported claim: Claim X; Evidence feature: Comparable repeated runs

A heat-transfer result does not decide every application or criterion.

2B · Short answer

Choose the justified claim and explain the limit of the alternative.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Claim X. Explains that tested heat-transfer speed does not establish suitability for every use or condition.

  1. Chooses Claim X.
  2. Explains that tested heat-transfer speed does not establish suitability for every use or condition.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

A model surface reflects 30 of 100 visible-light units. A poster assumes it reflects the same amount of every radiation band without testing.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · True or false

True or false: the visible-light result establishes the same reflected share for every radiation band.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Material interactions can depend on wavelength, so a visible-light setting alone is insufficient.

3B · Open ended

Explain why the extension is unsupported and propose a relevant check.

Example of a full-credit answer: The given result concerns visible light and does not establish behaviour for every band. Proposes relevant measurements or evidence for the other radiation bands/material conditions.

  1. The given result concerns visible light and does not establish behaviour for every band.
  2. Proposes relevant measurements or evidence for the other radiation bands/material conditions.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A survey finds that pupils who visit the library more often also report reading more books. A headline says the survey proves visits alone cause every improvement in reading.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Headline error; Observed relationship; Possible alternative

  • a: Causation and universality exceed the survey
  • b: More visits associated with more books
  • c: Reading interest affects both
  • d: Every factor was controlled
Answer: Headline error → Causation and universality exceed the survey; Observed relationship → More visits associated with more books; Possible alternative → Reading interest affects both

A survey association leaves alternatives and does not support an every-pupil guarantee.

4B · Short answer

Identify the overstatement and give a more accurate version.

Example of a full-credit answer: Explains that an observational association does not prove visits alone cause all improvement. States that the surveyed pupils showed an association, while other influences and wider applicability remain uncertain.

  1. Explains that an observational association does not prove visits alone cause all improvement.
  2. States that the surveyed pupils showed an association, while other influences and wider applicability remain uncertain.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

A classroom investigation compares water absorption in two sponge pieces of equal size using three trials. Design a report box containing the finding and an appropriate limit or next test.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Finding section; Limit section; Next test

  • a: Summarise the actual comparison
  • b: State tested samples and conditions
  • c: Broader comparable samples or conditions
  • d: Claim every sponge is identical
Answer: Finding section → Summarise the actual comparison; Limit section → State tested samples and conditions; Next test → Broader comparable samples or conditions

A report can be useful while clearly showing where its evidence ends.

5B · Open ended

Write a template for the finding and one specific limit or next test.

Example of a full-credit answer: Describes comparing the two tested equal-size pieces using all three trials, without inventing unavailable result values. Names a sample/condition limit or proposes more comparable samples/conditions to extend the finding.

  1. Describes comparing the two tested equal-size pieces using all three trials, without inventing unavailable result values.
  2. Names a sample/condition limit or proposes more comparable samples/conditions to extend the finding.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

S12.13 · Recognising false or misleading scientific information

Open this standalone activity

Three worked examples

Example 1 · A dramatic percentage

Worked-example information

A fictional test reports improvement from 1 successful trial to 2. A poster says “100% more successes” but omits the counts.

Question: What context should be restored?

Answer: The change was from 1 to 2 successes, and the trial totals are needed.

Why: The relative change alone does not show the size or success rate.

Example 2 · A cropped quotation

Worked-example information

A report says “The coating reduced absorption in these three tests.” A post quotes only “The coating reduced absorption” and claims all conditions are proved.

Question: What is missing?

Answer: The limit to those three tests.

Why: The original wording does not support a universal claim.

Example 3 · A confident generated answer

Worked-example information

An AI-written paragraph cites a paper that cannot be found from its supplied title and author.

Question: What should a reader do?

Answer: Check the reference and seek traceable evidence before relying on the claim.

Why: Fluency does not establish that a citation exists or supports the statement.

Formative quiz · 10 points

F1 · Restore the denominator

Fixed case information

A poster says 8 pupils preferred a new water bottle. The survey asked 10 pupils, and 2 preferred the old bottle.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F1 · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Preference fraction; Total respondents; Other preference count

  • a: 8 out of 10
  • b: 10
  • c: 2
  • d: 8 out of 8
Answer: Preference fraction → 8 out of 10; Total respondents → 10; Other preference count → 2

The denominator reveals the survey size behind the count.

Scientific explorer: graph lab

F2 · Inspect a graph claim

Fixed case information

Two fictional measurements are 98 and 100 units. A poster draws them with a vertical axis beginning at 97 and claims the second value is twice the first.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F2 · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies actual difference in this case?

  • a: 2 units
  • b: 98 units
  • c: 100 units
  • d: 198 units
Answer: 2 units

A shortened axis can exaggerate visual difference; 100 is not twice 98.

Scientific explorer: data lab

F3 · Keep quotation context

Fixed case information

The original report says a material worked in one dry-room test. A shared post says the report proves it works in every wet and dry setting.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F3 · Multiple answers

Select all statements that agree with the case.

  • a: Original scope: One dry-room test
  • b: Shared post’s claimed scope: Every wet and dry setting
  • c: Original scope: All wet settings were tested
  • d: Shared post’s claimed scope: Only the original dry-room test
Answer: Original scope: One dry-room test; Shared post’s claimed scope: Every wet and dry setting

The shared claim removes a condition and adds settings that were not tested.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

F4 · Check an image’s evidence

Fixed case information

A picture is labelled as today’s river pollution. Its original record shows it was taken years earlier in another place.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F4 · Dropdown selection

Complete each row by selecting its best response.

Complete or match: Mismatch; Useful verification; Claim about today’s local river that the old photograph cannot establish

  • a: Date and location
  • b: Original image record and corroboration
  • c: It proves today’s local condition
  • d: The colour proves the date
Answer: Mismatch → Date and location; Useful verification → Original image record and corroboration; Claim about today’s local river that the old photograph cannot establish → It proves today’s local condition

An image can be real while its new caption is misleading.

Scientific explorer: timeline lab

F5 · Explain a source check

Fixed case information

A fluent AI answer names a study but supplies no working reference. Its claim matters to a science project.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

F5 · Short answer

Explain why the answer is not yet verified and give a concrete next step.

Example of a full-credit answer: Fluent text and an unverified citation do not establish that the study exists or supports the claim. Proposes finding/checking the original source and relevant independent evidence.

  1. Fluent text and an unverified citation do not establish that the study exists or supports the claim.
  2. Proposes finding/checking the original source and relevant independent evidence.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific explorer: evidence lab

Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points

Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning

Fixed case information

A post advertises a typical performance of 12 units by showing only the best trial. The complete valid results are 3, 6 and 12.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

1A · Hotspot

Select the answer area. Which choice correctly identifies mean of all trials in this case?

  • a: 7 units
  • b: 12 units
  • c: 21 units
  • d: 3 units
Answer: 7 units

The full mean is 21 divided by 3, or 7; showing only 12 hides variation.

1B · Short answer

Calculate the full mean and explain the misleading presentation.

Example of a full-credit answer: Calculates 7 units. Explains that choosing only the best trial overstates typical performance and hides the other valid results.

  1. Calculates 7 units.
  2. Explains that choosing only the best trial overstates typical performance and hides the other valid results.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 2 · Justify Choice

Fixed case information

A surprising science post links a shortened quotation. Plan A reads the original report and compares relevant independent evidence. Plan B checks only the number of shares.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

2A · Drag and drop

Place each response beside its matching clue. You can drag or use the alternative controls.

Complete or match: Better route; Context check; Independent check

  • a: Plan A
  • b: Read the original report
  • c: Compare separate relevant evidence
  • d: Plan B
Answer: Better route → Plan A; Context check → Read the original report; Independent check → Compare separate relevant evidence

Traceable sources and independent evidence can test the claim; popularity cannot.

2B · Open ended

Choose a route and justify its two evidence checks.

Example of a full-credit answer: Chooses Plan A and explains that the original report restores wording/method/context. Explains that relevant independent evidence helps check the claim beyond repeated copies.

  1. Chooses Plan A and explains that the original report restores wording/method/context.
  2. Explains that relevant independent evidence helps check the claim beyond repeated copies.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 3 · Transfer Application

Fixed case information

An infographic says a seed treatment is “five times better” because 5 seeds sprouted with it and 1 without it. It omits how many seeds were planted in each group.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

3A · Multiple choice

Which choice correctly identifies missing information in this case?

  • a: Group sizes
  • b: The colours alone
  • c: No denominator is relevant
  • d: Counts always equal rates
Answer: Group sizes

Success counts cannot be compared as rates without their denominators and conditions.

3B · Short answer

Explain the missing information and how it affects the claimed comparison.

Example of a full-credit answer: The total planted in each group is missing, along with relevant comparison conditions. Explains that counts alone do not establish a fivefold success rate; compare fractions using the group totals.

  1. The total planted in each group is missing, along with relevant comparison conditions.
  2. Explains that counts alone do not establish a fivefold success rate; compare fractions using the group totals.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 4 · Error Analysis

Fixed case information

A graph uses an incorrect unit. A reader immediately says the author deliberately lied, but there is no evidence about how the error occurred.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

4A · True or false

True or false: an incorrect unit by itself proves that the author deliberately lied.

  • true: True
  • false: False
Answer: False

Evidence of an error does not by itself establish deliberate intent.

4B · Open ended

State the supported criticism and explain why the intent claim goes too far.

Example of a full-credit answer: Identifies the incorrect unit as a real issue requiring verification/correction. Explains that an error alone does not show whether it was deliberate or accidental.

  1. Identifies the incorrect unit as a real issue requiring verification/correction.
  2. Explains that an error alone does not show whether it was deliberate or accidental.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Pair 5 · Design / Propose

Fixed case information

Create a short check before sharing a science infographic. Include one check on its numbers and one check on its source or context.

Using the explorer

The explorer is a simplified learning model. You may change it to investigate, but answer from the fixed case information above. Its results are not measurements of the real world.

5A · Matching

Match each clue to its best response. Use each response at most once.

Complete or match: Number check; Source check; Scope check

  • a: Inspect units, axes or denominators
  • b: Trace the original report
  • c: Compare the headline with tested conditions
  • d: Only count likes
Answer: Number check → Inspect units, axes or denominators; Source check → Trace the original report; Scope check → Compare the headline with tested conditions

A useful checklist tests both the data presentation and the evidence trail.

5B · Open ended

Write one concrete numerical check and one concrete source/context check.

Example of a full-credit answer: Checks a specific numerical feature such as axis scale, units, denominator, time period or complete trials. Traces the original source or compares the headline/quotation with the actual method and limits.

  1. Checks a specific numerical feature such as axis scale, units, denominator, time period or complete trials.
  2. Traces the original source or compares the headline/quotation with the actual method and limits.

0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.

Scientific source notes

These primary institutional references support concept checking. All invented classroom data and toy-model settings are teaching examples, not results from the cited studies.

S12.1–S12.13 scientific evidence, enquiry and information evaluation
Science S1–S4 (51 original topic modules)
sources_S3_energy_rewrite
sources_S3_rewrites_4_6
sources_S3_rewrites_7_8_12
Primary institutional sources consulted for scientific concept checking. Lessons, contexts, questions, worked examples, counts, budgets and source cards are original classroom material. Numerical teaching data and models are fictional unless a source explicitly says otherwise; none are presented as clinical results, real field studies, legal limits, resource quotas or forecasts.
Original authoring concept-check bibliography for S9–S11 (53 modules). Sources informed scientific concepts; all numerical classroom cases, question wording and rubrics were authored for these modules.