Reading: worked examples, formative practice and mastery
Original practice for the Reading topics supplied by the teacher.
Learning sequence in every activity
- Four concept lesson pages introduce the topic for approximately 10-year-old learners.
- Three worked question-and-answer examples show a source, a question, its answer and why the answer works.
- Five formative questions use four distinct objective formats and one short-answer or open-ended response. Each has a source explorer, scoring and twelve feedback-language choices.
- Formative review shows the five item scores and a score out of 10. Learners can review or continue to mastery. An unavailable written AI score stays pending and can retry while they continue.
- Five mastery and critical-thinking pairs retain the original ten questions and a separate score out of 20.
- Final summary shows formative /10, mastery /20, combined /30, and the current attempt’s saving and upload status. All fifteen responses are included in reporting.
| Mastery pair | Thinking focus | Maximum |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Applied Reasoning | 2 interactive + 2 written points |
| 2 | Justify Choice | 4 points |
| 3 | Transfer Application | 4 points |
| 4 | Error Analysis | 4 points |
| 5 | Design / Propose | 4 points |
These five thinking stages are the requested teaching sequence, not the OECD PISA proficiency scale. All sources, names and data are original classroom examples, not official released PISA items. Formative scores and mastery scores describe different stages of practice; the combined total is for complete module reporting.
Opening and completing a module
- Use Extract All on the ZIP. Open START_HERE.html or any individual activity HTML.
- Complete consent. Choose Region, Division and School, check the school code, and enter the learner initials, section and grade.
- Read the concepts and worked examples, then complete the formative quiz. The formative review leads to mastery.
- Use the question’s source tools and evidence notebook. Drag-and-drop items also support selecting a token then its target.
- At the last question, open Results. Saving and uploading are automatic; no separate Submit button is required.
- Try Again reloads this standalone file and starts with fresh consent. Prior saved reports remain available to the reporting service.
Every activity is one complete HTML. It works without companion assets, a local web server, an installer or an executable. Use a current browser with JavaScript, IndexedDB and gzip DecompressionStream support. Lessons, sources and objective questions work offline. Live AI feedback, nonblank written scoring and uploads need internet access.
Scoring and multilingual feedback
Single-choice, true/false and hotspot items receive 2 for a correct answer and 0 otherwise. Matching, dropdown and drag-and-drop items receive 2 for all correct mappings, 1 for some correct mappings, and 0 for none. Multiple-answer items receive 2 for the exact correct set, 1 for a nonempty correct subset with no incorrect choice, and 0 if any incorrect option is selected.
Each written item has two explicit content requirements. A response meeting both receives an AI estimate of 2; one receives 1; neither, an irrelevant response, or a blank receives 0. The model is given the full source, question, reference answer, learner response and rubric. Equivalent reasoning and valid alternative proposals are accepted. Spelling and grammar are not scored unless meaning is unclear.
Blank written responses receive 0 locally. Nonblank responses use the existing AI scoring service. Missing, invalid or failed AI results stay pending; they are never converted into a zero or N/A. Final performance reports wait for all required estimates. Changing a written answer invalidates its previous AI score.
The feedback choices are English, Filipino, Ilocano, Pangasinan, Kapampangan, Bikol, Waray, Cebuano, Hiligaynon, Maranao, Maguindanao and Tausug. Each selected-language request carries complete question context and the learner’s answer. The display rejects clearly English output for another selected language and some obvious mismatches; it does not certify fluency. Regional-language accuracy and AI grading quality depend on the deployed model and require teacher or proficient-speaker review. This update does not install or upgrade a server model.
Saving, recovery and dashboard data
The supplied consent, school directory and reporting services are retained. Draft responses and AI request evidence save before transmission. Completed results are frozen before their three report bodies are queued. Each activity and each attempt has its own identifier. This edition uses a new content/edition identifier so an older ten-question draft cannot be mistaken for a fifteen-question attempt.
The staging endpoint remains https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/moodle-staging-upload.php. The supplied CSV schemas remain unchanged: 29 utilization/completion columns, 28 base and identity quiz-performance columns (29 when endpoint-request evidence is attached), and 73 item-response columns. The item-response report contains fifteen item rows. Each item’s response JSON identifies its formative or mastery phase and carries that phase’s score and maximum, with the full item context, response, rubric, source-explorer evidence and seven-page lesson progress. The performance report total is out of 30.
Live feedback uses https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/pisa-multilingual-feedback.php; written scoring uses https://teachaid.ph/teachaid-api/moodle-ai-feedback.php. The same existing server configuration is used. No production server changes are included in these files.
Final-summary saving and upload indicator
| Indicator | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Answers saved on this device | Responses are retained while AI scores or final report preparation are pending. |
| Saved on this device | The completed attempt and all three report bodies are saved locally. |
| Queued for upload · 0/3 confirmed | The saved reports are waiting for server receipts. Upload retries automatically. |
| Partly uploaded · 1/3 or 2/3 confirmed | The named reports have receipts. The remaining reports stay queued. |
| Upload confirmed by teachaid.ph · 3/3 | All three current-attempt receipts match the saved filenames and SHA-256 hashes. |
| Waiting for AI scores / Saving needs attention | The final reports are not yet ready. Keep the activity open for automatic retry. |
Completion, Performance and Item responses have separate status labels. Confirmation means the staging server received the reports; subsequent dashboard processing is a separate server step. Receipts from older attempts cannot mark this attempt as uploaded.
Allow browser storage and use the same browser profile when reopening pending work. Do not clear its activity data while reports or AI scores are pending. Copying an HTML file does not copy learner records. Retry runs while the activity is open and connected, or when it is reopened.
Access and presentation
The original Frontlearners logo, school directory, consent controls, watermark and supplied expiry remain embedded. The expiry remains 31 May 2027 at 23:59:59 device-local. The runtime is encoded to make casual reading harder; this is not tamper-proof access control. Progress blocks track actual lessons, examples and questions within the same topic. All navigation stays in one tab.
Topic answer keys and written rubrics
Use these references to review student reasoning. Worked-example answers are teaching material; they are not scored. Quiz sources differ from the worked examples.
R1.1 · Recognising words accurately
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Stable or table?
Reading card
A pony stood in the stable. A wooden table stood outside its door. Amira first read both words as table. She looked again at the beginning of the longer word.
Question: Which word names the pony’s shelter?
Answer: Stable names the shelter; table names the piece of furniture.
Why: Stable has an s before table. Read that beginning and then the whole sentence. The pony and the door help you check the meaning, but the printed letters decide which word is present.
Example 2 · Letters in the middle
Weather sentence
A grey cloud covered the sun. Noel read could instead of cloud, then noticed that his sentence did not make sense. The same five letters appear in both words, but their order differs.
Question: How should Noel check his reading?
Answer: He should read c-l-o-u-d in order and say cloud.
Why: In cloud, l comes before o. In could, l comes after u. Looking only at the first and last letters would miss the difference. Read every letter in order, then reread the complete sentence.
Example 3 · An ending changes the number
Trip note
One bus waits beside the office. Two buses wait beside the hall. The organiser asks Jessa to count all the vehicles mentioned in the note.
Question: Why must Jessa notice the ending of buses?
Answer: Buses is plural, so that sentence refers to two vehicles. The note mentions three vehicles in all.
Why: The ending -es is part of the word, not decoration. Reading bus both times could hide the change in number. Jessa checks the whole word together with one and two before counting.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A fruit preparation card
Instruction
Please slice the melon into pieces. Put the pieces in the blue bowl.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the action word printed in the instruction.
- a: slide
- b: slice
- c: spice
The instruction prints slice. The fourth letter is c, and the action means cutting the melon.
Source explorer: word lab
F2 · Two knot directions
Loose knot
Untie the knot so that the rope opens.
Loose end
Retie the knot so that it becomes secure again.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete each direction using its exact action word.
Complete or match: ___ the knot to open the rope.; ___ the knot to secure it again.
- a: retie
- b: untie
- c: untidy
Un- changes tie to undoing a knot; re- means tying it again. Untidy is a different word.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Labels for three tasks
Card 1
Paint the fence blue.
Card 2
Point to the gate.
Card 3
Plant the young tree.
F3 · Drag and drop
Place the exact printed action word beside each card.
Complete or match: Card 1: ___ the fence.; Card 2: ___ to the gate.; Card 3: ___ the tree.
- a: plant
- b: paint
- c: point
Paint, point and plant differ in their middle letters. Each word also fits a different action.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · The sound-free hallway
Reminder
Walk silently past the recording room. The pupils inside are making an audio story.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which reading keeps every letter of the printed word?
- a: Walk silent past the room.
- b: Walk silently past the room.
- c: Walk silence past the room.
- d: Walk silencing past the room.
Silently is the printed word. Its -ly ending must be read, and it describes how to walk.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · A library word and an animal word
Library line
You may borrow one atlas and return it on Friday.
Animal line
The rabbit rests in a burrow under the ground.
F5 · Short answer
Explain how you can tell borrow from burrow in these lines.
Example of a full-credit answer: Borrow has o after b and means taking the atlas for a time. Burrow has u after b and names the rabbit’s hole.
- Identifies the o/u difference after b in borrow and burrow.
- Connects borrow to temporarily taking the atlas and burrow to the rabbit’s underground hole.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Packet
Classroom example: Place one seed in each small hole. Cover it with soil. Keep the spare seeds in the dry tray.
Tool labels
The tray holds seeds. A bead is a small craft object with a hole. The class keeps beads in a separate art box.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the directions using the exact printed words.
Complete or match: Place one ___ in each hole.; Keep spare seeds in the dry ___.
- a: tray
- b: seed
- c: bead
The packet prints seed and tray. Bead is a different word and object.
1B · Short answer
Explain how checking seed rather than bead would change what you put in the hole.
Example of a full-credit answer: The packet says seed, which can grow into a plant. A bead belongs to the art materials, so choosing it would not follow the planting direction.
- Identifies the printed word as seed, not bead.
- Explains the different object/action caused by the mistaken reading.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Notice heading
Classroom example: SCHOOL VISIT. Bring a packed lunch and a light raincoat. Meet beside the school gate at eight.
Reading note
Rafi thinks the notice says “Bring a packed launch”. He is unsure because that phrase does not fit a bag of food.
2A · Hotspot
Select the notice line that Rafi should reread to check his mistaken word.
- a: SCHOOL VISIT
- b: Bring a packed lunch and a light raincoat.
- c: Meet beside the school gate at eight.
The lunch line contains the word Rafi misread. Its letters and food context help him check it.
2B · Open ended
Why is checking both the letters and the sentence better than guessing from the first sound?
Example of a full-credit answer: Lunch and launch start similarly, so the first sound is not enough. The printed letters say lunch, and a packed lunch is food to bring on the visit.
- Notes that the words share a beginning or sound, so guessing can fail.
- Uses the exact letters or food context to support lunch.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Notice
Classroom example: Recipes are the instructions for preparing food. Receipts show what was bought and paid for. The club stores them in different folders.
Folder task
Put the sheet “mix the flour and water” with the cooking instructions. Put the shop bill with the record of spending. Read the whole label before sorting.
3A · Drag and drop
Drag each sheet to its correct folder label.
Complete or match: Mix flour and water; Shop bill showing payment
- a: Receipts
- b: Recipes
- c: Reports
Recipes give preparation instructions; receipts record purchases. Their similar beginnings do not make them interchangeable.
3B · Short answer
Give one reading step that prevents confusing recipes and receipts, and explain how it helps.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare the letters after rec, then read the folder descriptions. That checks the different word endings and whether the sheet gives instructions or records a purchase.
- Proposes checking distinguishing letters or reading the full word.
- Connects the check to the different folder meanings.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Park sign
Classroom example: Stay on the marked trail. The trail follows the stream and ends at the picnic shelter.
Misreading
Lena reads “Stay on the marked trial” and thinks the sign describes a test. She looked at the first and last letters but did not check the middle order.
4A · Multiple choice
Which correction best explains Lena’s error?
- a: Trail and trial mean the same thing.
- b: The middle letters are in a different order; trail names the path.
- c: The sign must be about a classroom test.
- d: Only the last letter needs checking.
Trail has a before i and names a path. Trial has i before a and is a different word.
4B · Open ended
Explain the error and how the rest of the sign helps confirm the correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: Lena swapped the order of a and i. The sign describes following a stream to a shelter, which fits a trail or path rather than a test.
- Identifies the changed order of middle letters.
- Uses a relevant path detail from the sign to confirm trail.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Goal
Classroom example: A class wants a game that rewards accurate reading rather than the fastest guess. Players compare words such as quiet and quite in complete sentences.
Materials
There are word cards, sentence cards and a pencil for underlining letters. The game must let a player explain a correction without being mocked for a mistake.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all game rules that directly support careful word reading.
- a: Underline the letters that differ before choosing.
- b: Choose using only the first letter.
- c: Read the chosen word in the sentence and explain its fit.
- d: Award points only to the fastest shout.
Comparing letters and checking the sentence encourage accuracy. First-letter guesses and speed-only rewards do not.
5B · Short answer
Propose two steps for one fair round of this game.
Example of a full-credit answer: First, each player quietly underlines the different letters on a pair of cards. Next, the player chooses a sentence, reads the fitting word and explains the choice; the group checks it kindly.
- Includes a step that checks the complete spelling or distinguishing letters.
- Includes a meaning/context check or kind explanatory correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.2 · Understanding sentences
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Who gives and who receives?
Art-room sentence
Santi handed Lila the paintbrush before he carried the paper to the shelf. Lila began painting while Santi put the paper away.
Question: Who receives the paintbrush, and what does Santi do next?
Answer: Lila receives the brush. Santi then carries the paper to the shelf.
Why: The first action is handed, with Santi doing it and Lila receiving the brush. Before places that action earlier than carrying the paper. Keeping the people and the time word prevents a backwards retelling.
Example 2 · Only limits a group
Reading-room rule
Only pupils with a blue pass may use the recording booth today. Pupils with green passes may borrow headphones at the desk.
Question: Does a green pass allow a pupil into the recording booth today?
Answer: No. Today’s booth permission is limited to pupils with a blue pass.
Why: Only makes the blue-pass condition necessary for this permission. The second sentence gives green-pass pupils a different option; it does not remove the first rule. Read the two actions separately before deciding what is allowed.
Example 3 · A surprise is still true
Team report
Although their banner was small, the team’s message was easy to read. They used thick dark letters on a plain pale background.
Question: Was the message hard to read because the banner was small?
Answer: No. The sentence says the message was easy to read despite its small size.
Why: Although links two facts that may seem surprising together. It does not turn easy into hard. Read both parts and keep the contrast: small banner, clear message. The next sentence helps explain that contrast.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Returning a ball
Sentence
After Nena gave the ball to Ivo, he placed it in the cupboard.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the interpretation that keeps the sentence’s meaning.
- a: Ivo received the ball and then stored it.
- b: Nena received the ball and then stored it.
- c: Ivo stored the ball before receiving it.
Nena gives the ball to Ivo. After shows that Ivo stores it later.
Source explorer: word lab
F2 · Read each linking word
Line A
Before the show began, the helpers closed the curtain.
Line B
After the show ended, the helpers stacked the chairs.
Line C
Because the floor was wet, the helpers used another doorway.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each sentence with the meaning of its link.
Complete or match: Line A; Line B; Line C
- a: Stacking happened later than the show.
- b: The wet floor explains the doorway choice.
- c: Closing happened earlier than the show.
Before and after give time order. Because connects the wet floor to the choice of doorway.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Pronouns in a clear account
Account
Berto carried the crate while May held the door. He put it on a mat. Then May closed the door.
F3 · Matching
Match each word in “He put it on a mat” to its meaning.
Complete or match: He; it; a mat
- a: the crate
- b: Berto
- c: the surface receiving the crate
Berto is the person carrying and placing the crate. It refers to that crate; the mat is where it is put.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Not all is not none
Inspection note
Not all of the plates are round. Three are round and two are square.
F4 · True or false
The note means that none of the plates are round.
- true: True
- false: False
Three plates are round. Not all means the whole set is not round; it does not mean none are round.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · A condition and an order
Class direction
If the green lamp is on, collect your folder before joining the line. If the lamp is off, remain seated.
Current situation
The green lamp is on.
F5 · Open ended
Explain what a pupil should do now, including the order of the two actions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Because the lamp is on, the pupil should collect the folder first and then join the line. The instruction to remain seated applies only when the lamp is off.
- Uses the lamp-on condition to choose collecting the folder and joining the line rather than remaining seated.
- Places collecting the folder before joining the line.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Sentence
Classroom example: After reading the first chapter, Niko lends the book to Sela.
Situation
There is one book. Niko starts with it, and Sela is waiting for a turn. No sentence says that either child has finished the whole book.
1A · Multiple choice
Which event happens first?
- a: Sela lends the book to Niko.
- b: Niko reads the first chapter.
- c: Sela finishes the whole book.
- d: Niko finishes every chapter.
After places Niko’s chapter reading before the lending. The sentence does not say he reads the whole book.
1B · Open ended
Explain what after tells you and what the sentence does not tell you about finishing the book.
Example of a full-credit answer: After shows that Niko reads chapter one before lending the book. It does not say either child finishes the whole book.
- Gives the correct order using after.
- Identifies that whole-book completion is unstated.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Rule A
Classroom example: Only members may borrow the club camera.
Rule B
Members may borrow only the club camera.
Rule C
Members may not borrow the club camera.
2A · Matching
Match each rule to what it means.
Complete or match: Rule A; Rule B; Rule C
- a: Members are forbidden to borrow the camera.
- b: Borrowers must be members.
- c: The camera is the only thing members may borrow.
The position of only changes what it limits. Not removes permission.
2B · Short answer
Choose two rules and explain how one small word changes their meaning.
Example of a full-credit answer: Rule A limits who can borrow to members. Rule C uses not, so it forbids members from borrowing the camera.
- Accurately explains one selected rule.
- Accurately contrasts a second selected rule using only or not.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New notice
Classroom example: If the playground is wet, the chess club meets in Room 2; otherwise it meets outside.
Today
The playground is dry today. Both Room 2 and the outdoor tables are available.
3A · True or false
The notice tells the chess club to meet in Room 2 today.
- true: True
- false: False
Room 2 is the wet-playground option. Otherwise gives the outside option when the playground is dry.
3B · Open ended
Explain which part of the instruction applies today and why.
Example of a full-credit answer: Otherwise applies because the playground is dry, so the club should meet outside. The Room 2 instruction applies only if it is wet.
- Connects dry conditions to otherwise.
- Identifies outside as today’s location and distinguishes the wet condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original sentence
Classroom example: The helper gives the empty box to the driver before carrying the full bag inside.
Wrong retelling
“The driver gives a full box to the helper after the helper carries the bag inside.” The retelling changes several details.
4A · Dropdown selection
Repair the retelling using the original sentence.
Complete or match: Who gives the box?; What kind of box is it?; When is the box given?
- a: The helper
- b: An empty box
- c: Before the bag is carried inside
- d: The driver
The original names the helper as giver, empty as the box description, and before as the order.
4B · Short answer
Describe two changes that made the retelling inaccurate.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes the giver from helper to driver, and changes before into after. It also incorrectly describes the box as full.
- Identifies one specific contradiction with the original.
- Identifies a different specific contradiction with the original.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Need
Classroom example: The art group must cap the pens before putting them into the shared box. Dry pens cannot be used tomorrow.
Audience
Younger pupils will read the direction. It should name the pens and box clearly, and should not rely on an unclear “it” or “they”.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all details that a clear direction needs.
- a: Cap the pens before putting them away.
- b: Name the shared box as the storage place.
- c: Say to put uncapped pens away first.
- d: Use “do it there” without naming anything.
The direction needs the correct order and a clear storage place. The other options reverse the action or hide the meaning.
5B · Open ended
Write one clear sentence for the younger pupils and explain one wording choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: Before you put the pens in the shared box, put their caps on. I used before to make the order clear.
- Writes a sentence with capping before storage in the shared box.
- Explains a word or phrase that makes the direction clear.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.3 · Understanding short passages
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A box with a different purpose
Short passage
Rina carried an empty box to the courtyard. Her friends expected a delivery, but she put the box beside the mural. Small paint pots went inside it so they would not roll away.
Question: Why did Rina bring the box?
Answer: She brought it to hold the paint pots and stop them rolling away.
Why: The first sentence names the box but not its purpose. The final sentence supplies the reason. Her friends’ expectation is not what actually happens. Read to the end before deciding which explanation the passage supports.
Example 2 · A change of meeting place
Short passage
The story group planned to sit under the mango tree. Workers were repairing the bench there. The group moved to the covered walkway and began at the planned time.
Question: What changed, and what stayed the same?
Answer: The meeting place changed, but the starting time stayed the same.
Why: The passage separates location from time. The repair explains the move, while the final words preserve the original start. A complete retelling needs both details; it should not add a delay that the passage never mentions.
Example 3 · Know what is missing
Short passage
Eli found a silver key beside the classroom door. He gave it to the office staff. They placed it in the lost-property tray. Nobody in the passage identifies its owner.
Question: Can we say that the key belongs to Eli’s teacher?
Answer: No. The passage tells us where it was found and stored, but not who owns it.
Why: A key beside a classroom could belong to different people. That possibility is not evidence of ownership. Keep the stated facts and leave the owner unknown until the text or a later check supplies that information.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A hat for a puppet
Passage
Omar carried a tiny hat to school. He did not plan to wear it. His group needed the hat for a puppet in their play.
F1 · True or false
Omar brought the hat for a puppet rather than for himself to wear.
- true: True
- false: False
The last two sentences state both what he did not intend and the puppet’s need.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Keeping the tickets dry
Passage
Rain began as Hana reached the gate. She put the paper tickets inside a sealed pouch. At the desk, she took the dry tickets out and handed them over.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the action that helped keep the tickets dry.
- a: Hana reached the gate.
- b: Hana used a sealed pouch.
- c: Hana handed tickets to the desk.
Putting the paper tickets inside the sealed pouch protected them during the rain.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · A shared folding job
Passage
The class needed twenty paper fans. Noel folded eight, and the other pupils folded twelve. They counted twenty before decorating them. The passage does not give the finishing time.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select every statement supported by the passage.
- a: Noel folded eight fans.
- b: The class counted twenty fans.
- c: Noel folded all twenty fans.
- d: The job finished at three o’clock.
The counts support the first two statements. Other pupils folded twelve, and no clock time is supplied.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · A moved lunch
Passage
A loose roof sheet was being repaired beside the usual lunch tables. The teacher moved lunch to the hall so pupils would stay away from the repair area. Lunch began at noon as usual.
F4 · Multiple choice
Why was lunch moved to the hall?
- a: To avoid the nearby repair area.
- b: To begin the meal an hour earlier.
- c: To make room for a singing lesson.
- d: To let pupils paint the lunch tables.
The teacher’s stated reason was to keep pupils away from the repair area. The time remained noon.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · A careful delivery
Passage
Jo’s class made paper flowers for the office. Wind blew several petals loose outside, so Jo put the flowers in a lidded basket. She opened it only after reaching the office.
F5 · Short answer
Why did Jo use the lidded basket, and when did she open it?
Example of a full-credit answer: Jo used the basket because wind was loosening the petals. She opened it after she reached the office.
- Connects the lidded basket to protecting the flowers from wind that loosened petals.
- States that Jo opened the basket after reaching the office.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Short passage
Classroom example: Jo wanted to read during lunch. The canteen was noisy, so she asked the librarian where she could sit. The librarian showed her a shaded bench outside the library. Jo read there until the bell.
Reading task
Use the passage to connect Jo’s purpose, action and result. Do not add a rule saying everyone must sit on the bench.
1A · Matching
Match each part of the passage.
Complete or match: Jo’s purpose; Her helpful action; Where she read
- a: Asked the librarian
- b: At a shaded bench
- c: Read during lunch
The passage states why Jo acted, whom she asked and where she read.
1B · Short answer
Explain how the librarian’s suggestion helped Jo.
Example of a full-credit answer: Jo wanted a place to read away from the noisy canteen. The shaded bench outside the library gave her a place to read until the bell.
- Identifies the reading/noise problem.
- Connects the suggested bench with the reading result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Short passage
Classroom example: Tess could not find the ribbon for her model boat. Her brother remembered seeing it beside the blue paper. Tess checked there and found it under the paper. She thanked him and finished the sail.
Question focus
Look for details showing that the brother’s memory was useful. The passage does not say he moved or hid the ribbon.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all details that support the idea that his memory helped.
- a: He remembered the ribbon near the blue paper.
- b: He secretly hid the ribbon.
- c: Tess found it under the paper after checking there.
- d: The ribbon was red.
His remembered location led Tess to the place where she found the ribbon. Hiding and colour are not stated.
2B · Open ended
Explain why accusing the brother of hiding the ribbon goes beyond the passage.
Example of a full-credit answer: The passage says he remembered a location and helped Tess find it. It does not describe him moving or hiding the ribbon.
- Uses his stated helpful action.
- States that hiding or moving the ribbon is not supported.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Short passage
Classroom example: The games shelf is open during break. Pupils write their names before borrowing a game. A borrowed game must be returned before the final bell, even if the players have not finished.
New situation
A group begins a game near the end of the day. The final bell is about to ring, and the game is unfinished.
3A · True or false
The group may keep the game after the final bell because it is unfinished.
- true: True
- false: False
The notice says return before the final bell even if play is unfinished.
3B · Short answer
What should the group do, and which words make the rule clear?
Example of a full-credit answer: They should stop and return the game before the final bell. The words “even if the players have not finished” show that an unfinished game is not an exception.
- Gives the required return action/time.
- Uses the unfinished-game condition to justify it.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Short passage
Classroom example: A small branch blocked the footpath. Amira could not lift it alone. She asked a nearby adult to help, and together they moved it to the edge. Other walkers could then pass.
Retelling to check
“Amira moved a whole tree by herself and then closed the footpath.”
4A · Dropdown selection
Choose accurate replacements for the retelling.
Complete or match: What blocked the path?; Who moved it?; What happened afterwards?
- a: A small branch
- b: Amira and an adult
- c: Walkers could pass
- d: A whole tree
The retelling exaggerates the object, removes the helper and reverses the result.
4B · Open ended
Explain two ways the retelling changes the meaning.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes a small branch into a whole tree, making the task much larger. It also says Amira acted alone, although the adult helped her.
- Identifies one inaccurate detail and its correction.
- Identifies a second different inaccurate detail and its correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Short passage
Classroom example: The class compost pot accepts fruit peels and dry leaves. It does not accept plastic wrappers. Ruel made a reminder card after finding a wrapper in the pot.
Draft card: title
COMPOST POT
Draft card: accepted materials
Fruit peels and dry leaves go here.
Draft card: missing line
This space is available for one more instruction.
5A · Hotspot
Select the part of the draft where Ruel should add the missing restriction.
- a: COMPOST POT
- b: Fruit peels and dry leaves go here.
- c: This space is available for one more instruction.
The empty instruction line can add the rule about wrappers without removing the accepted materials.
5B · Short answer
Write the missing line and explain why readers need it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep plastic wrappers out of this pot. Readers need this restriction because the passage says wrappers are not accepted and one was put there.
- Writes an accurate no-plastic-wrapper restriction.
- Explains its value using the rule or the found wrapper.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.4 · Understanding long passages
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Track the whole route story
Paragraph 1 — A visitor problem
The school was preparing an open morning. Visitors would see the garden, the craft room and the story hall. In the previous event, several visitors had asked where the craft room was. Its entrance faced a narrow side path, so it could not be seen from the main gate. The class wanted to make the route easier to follow.
Paragraph 2 — The first plan
The pupils first made six arrow cards. Each card carried the words Craft room in dark print. They placed cards at the gate, beside the garden and at the turns in the path. A large welcome banner remained over the main gate. The team checked that every arrow pointed toward the next part of the route rather than straight at a wall.
Paragraph 3 — A small trial
Six volunteers tried the route on Tuesday. Four reached the craft room without asking. Two passed the final turn because a branch partly covered the last arrow. One volunteer also said that the words were difficult to read from far away. The class wrote down these observations instead of simply calling the first plan a success or a failure.
Paragraph 4 — A revision
With an adult’s help, the pupils moved the last card into a clear space. They made the letters larger on every card. They kept the six-arrow route because nobody reported trouble with the earlier turns. A pupil suggested adding more decoration, but the class chose to spend its remaining time checking that the words and directions were easy to see.
Paragraph 5 — The second trial
On Thursday, six different volunteers used the revised route. All six reached the craft room without asking. Two stopped close to a card to read it, but neither took a wrong turn. These trials happened in daylight on dry mornings. Nobody had yet tested the route in rain or with a visitor who needed larger print than the new cards provided.
Paragraph 6 — What comes next
The pupils kept the improved cards for the open morning. They also planned to place a helper at the gate and invite comments from visitors. Their report said that the changes helped the volunteers in the second trial. It did not say that every future visitor would find the room alone. The team would use new comments to decide whether further changes were needed.
Question: How does the first paragraph help explain the project described later?
Answer: It identifies the hidden craft-room entrance, which explains why the class tests and improves a route of signs.
Why: The beginning supplies the problem. The middle gives the first trial and revision, and the end reports a limited improvement. Connecting these parts is stronger than describing only the welcome banner, which is a small detail.
Example 2 · Connect a problem to its revision
Paragraph 1 — A visitor problem
The school was preparing an open morning. Visitors would see the garden, the craft room and the story hall. In the previous event, several visitors had asked where the craft room was. Its entrance faced a narrow side path, so it could not be seen from the main gate. The class wanted to make the route easier to follow.
Paragraph 2 — The first plan
The pupils first made six arrow cards. Each card carried the words Craft room in dark print. They placed cards at the gate, beside the garden and at the turns in the path. A large welcome banner remained over the main gate. The team checked that every arrow pointed toward the next part of the route rather than straight at a wall.
Paragraph 3 — A small trial
Six volunteers tried the route on Tuesday. Four reached the craft room without asking. Two passed the final turn because a branch partly covered the last arrow. One volunteer also said that the words were difficult to read from far away. The class wrote down these observations instead of simply calling the first plan a success or a failure.
Paragraph 4 — A revision
With an adult’s help, the pupils moved the last card into a clear space. They made the letters larger on every card. They kept the six-arrow route because nobody reported trouble with the earlier turns. A pupil suggested adding more decoration, but the class chose to spend its remaining time checking that the words and directions were easy to see.
Paragraph 5 — The second trial
On Thursday, six different volunteers used the revised route. All six reached the craft room without asking. Two stopped close to a card to read it, but neither took a wrong turn. These trials happened in daylight on dry mornings. Nobody had yet tested the route in rain or with a visitor who needed larger print than the new cards provided.
Paragraph 6 — What comes next
The pupils kept the improved cards for the open morning. They also planned to place a helper at the gate and invite comments from visitors. Their report said that the changes helped the volunteers in the second trial. It did not say that every future visitor would find the room alone. The team would use new comments to decide whether further changes were needed.
Question: Why did the pupils move the last card and enlarge the lettering?
Answer: Two volunteers missed a partly hidden arrow, and one found the words hard to read at a distance.
Why: The reasons occur in paragraph 3, while the actions occur in paragraph 4. Pair each action with the difficulty it addresses. The text gives no reason to claim that the earlier turns were wrong or that extra decoration was needed.
Example 3 · Keep the ending’s limit
Paragraph 1 — A visitor problem
The school was preparing an open morning. Visitors would see the garden, the craft room and the story hall. In the previous event, several visitors had asked where the craft room was. Its entrance faced a narrow side path, so it could not be seen from the main gate. The class wanted to make the route easier to follow.
Paragraph 2 — The first plan
The pupils first made six arrow cards. Each card carried the words Craft room in dark print. They placed cards at the gate, beside the garden and at the turns in the path. A large welcome banner remained over the main gate. The team checked that every arrow pointed toward the next part of the route rather than straight at a wall.
Paragraph 3 — A small trial
Six volunteers tried the route on Tuesday. Four reached the craft room without asking. Two passed the final turn because a branch partly covered the last arrow. One volunteer also said that the words were difficult to read from far away. The class wrote down these observations instead of simply calling the first plan a success or a failure.
Paragraph 4 — A revision
With an adult’s help, the pupils moved the last card into a clear space. They made the letters larger on every card. They kept the six-arrow route because nobody reported trouble with the earlier turns. A pupil suggested adding more decoration, but the class chose to spend its remaining time checking that the words and directions were easy to see.
Paragraph 5 — The second trial
On Thursday, six different volunteers used the revised route. All six reached the craft room without asking. Two stopped close to a card to read it, but neither took a wrong turn. These trials happened in daylight on dry mornings. Nobody had yet tested the route in rain or with a visitor who needed larger print than the new cards provided.
Paragraph 6 — What comes next
The pupils kept the improved cards for the open morning. They also planned to place a helper at the gate and invite comments from visitors. Their report said that the changes helped the volunteers in the second trial. It did not say that every future visitor would find the room alone. The team would use new comments to decide whether further changes were needed.
Question: Does the second trial prove that every visitor will find the room without help?
Answer: No. All six new volunteers succeeded, but the trials covered only dry daylight conditions and a small set of readers.
Why: Paragraph 5 gives both the positive result and the untested conditions. Paragraph 6 keeps that limit in the report. A reader must carry both pieces forward; selecting only the success sentence would make the conclusion too broad.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Map the listening account
Paragraph 1 — The listening trail
A class planned a listening trail for a school exhibition. Visitors would hear a short bird recording, a story opening and a rhythm pattern at three stations. The aim was to let people enjoy each recording without sounds from another station mixing into it. The first plan placed all three stations close together along one wall of the hall.
Paragraph 2 — The first test
Four small groups tried the trail on Monday. The bird recording was quiet, while the rhythm recording was louder. Three groups reported that the rhythm covered some of the bird sounds. All four groups could follow the numbered station labels. The pupils realised that clear directions alone did not solve the listening problem. They listed both useful parts and difficulties in their notebook.
Paragraph 3 — A changed layout
The class moved the rhythm station to the far end of the hall and lowered its volume. The bird station stayed near the entrance, with the story station between them. The numbered labels were kept. An adult checked the cables so visitors would have a clear walkway. The team changed the sound arrangement, not the order of the three activities.
Paragraph 4 — Trying again
On Wednesday morning, four different groups tried the new layout. All four reported that they could hear the bird sounds clearly. Three also finished every station; the fourth group left early for another activity. The teacher recorded that departure separately. Leaving early did not show that the group had failed to understand the trail or disliked the recordings.
Paragraph 5 — A remaining question
Both tests took place before the other exhibition stalls opened. The hall was quieter than it would be during the full event. The class had not yet checked whether a large crowd would make the bird station difficult to hear. A new poster therefore said Clearer listening in our second small trial, instead of promising perfect sound for everyone at all times.
Paragraph 6 — Next steps
The pupils planned another check during a busy rehearsal. They would ask visitors whether they could hear each recording and note where people had difficulty. If crowd noise covered the bird sounds, they could discuss another location with the teacher. They would keep the useful numbered labels while collecting evidence about the sound problem that remained uncertain.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Match each paragraph to its main job in the account.
Complete or match: Paragraph 1; Paragraph 3; Paragraph 5
- a: Names a remaining uncertainty
- b: Explains the original goal
- c: Describes the revised layout
The opening gives the goal, paragraph 3 explains changes, and paragraph 5 identifies the untested busy hall.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Keep the supported findings
Paragraph 1 — The listening trail
A class planned a listening trail for a school exhibition. Visitors would hear a short bird recording, a story opening and a rhythm pattern at three stations. The aim was to let people enjoy each recording without sounds from another station mixing into it. The first plan placed all three stations close together along one wall of the hall.
Paragraph 2 — The first test
Four small groups tried the trail on Monday. The bird recording was quiet, while the rhythm recording was louder. Three groups reported that the rhythm covered some of the bird sounds. All four groups could follow the numbered station labels. The pupils realised that clear directions alone did not solve the listening problem. They listed both useful parts and difficulties in their notebook.
Paragraph 3 — A changed layout
The class moved the rhythm station to the far end of the hall and lowered its volume. The bird station stayed near the entrance, with the story station between them. The numbered labels were kept. An adult checked the cables so visitors would have a clear walkway. The team changed the sound arrangement, not the order of the three activities.
Paragraph 4 — Trying again
On Wednesday morning, four different groups tried the new layout. All four reported that they could hear the bird sounds clearly. Three also finished every station; the fourth group left early for another activity. The teacher recorded that departure separately. Leaving early did not show that the group had failed to understand the trail or disliked the recordings.
Paragraph 5 — A remaining question
Both tests took place before the other exhibition stalls opened. The hall was quieter than it would be during the full event. The class had not yet checked whether a large crowd would make the bird station difficult to hear. A new poster therefore said Clearer listening in our second small trial, instead of promising perfect sound for everyone at all times.
Paragraph 6 — Next steps
The pupils planned another check during a busy rehearsal. They would ask visitors whether they could hear each recording and note where people had difficulty. If crowd noise covered the bird sounds, they could discuss another location with the teacher. They would keep the useful numbered labels while collecting evidence about the sound problem that remained uncertain.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select every finding supported by the complete account.
- a: All four second-trial groups heard the birds clearly.
- b: The crowded exhibition hall had not yet been tested.
- c: Every second-trial group finished every station.
- d: The first labels sent all groups to the wrong stations.
Paragraphs 4 and 5 support the first two statements. One group left early, and the original labels were followed successfully.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Connect the opening and revision
Paragraph 1 — The listening trail
A class planned a listening trail for a school exhibition. Visitors would hear a short bird recording, a story opening and a rhythm pattern at three stations. The aim was to let people enjoy each recording without sounds from another station mixing into it. The first plan placed all three stations close together along one wall of the hall.
Paragraph 2 — The first test
Four small groups tried the trail on Monday. The bird recording was quiet, while the rhythm recording was louder. Three groups reported that the rhythm covered some of the bird sounds. All four groups could follow the numbered station labels. The pupils realised that clear directions alone did not solve the listening problem. They listed both useful parts and difficulties in their notebook.
Paragraph 3 — A changed layout
The class moved the rhythm station to the far end of the hall and lowered its volume. The bird station stayed near the entrance, with the story station between them. The numbered labels were kept. An adult checked the cables so visitors would have a clear walkway. The team changed the sound arrangement, not the order of the three activities.
Paragraph 4 — Trying again
On Wednesday morning, four different groups tried the new layout. All four reported that they could hear the bird sounds clearly. Three also finished every station; the fourth group left early for another activity. The teacher recorded that departure separately. Leaving early did not show that the group had failed to understand the trail or disliked the recordings.
Paragraph 5 — A remaining question
Both tests took place before the other exhibition stalls opened. The hall was quieter than it would be during the full event. The class had not yet checked whether a large crowd would make the bird station difficult to hear. A new poster therefore said Clearer listening in our second small trial, instead of promising perfect sound for everyone at all times.
Paragraph 6 — Next steps
The pupils planned another check during a busy rehearsal. They would ask visitors whether they could hear each recording and note where people had difficulty. If crowd noise covered the bird sounds, they could discuss another location with the teacher. They would keep the useful numbered labels while collecting evidence about the sound problem that remained uncertain.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which change directly addresses the opening listening problem?
- a: Adding decoration to the numbered station cards.
- b: Moving the rhythm away and lowering it.
- c: Removing every label from the original trail.
- d: Making the exhibition end earlier than planned.
Moving and quietening the rhythm station addresses sound mixing. The numbered labels already worked.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Find the limit on the result
Paragraph 1 — The listening trail
A class planned a listening trail for a school exhibition. Visitors would hear a short bird recording, a story opening and a rhythm pattern at three stations. The aim was to let people enjoy each recording without sounds from another station mixing into it. The first plan placed all three stations close together along one wall of the hall.
Paragraph 2 — The first test
Four small groups tried the trail on Monday. The bird recording was quiet, while the rhythm recording was louder. Three groups reported that the rhythm covered some of the bird sounds. All four groups could follow the numbered station labels. The pupils realised that clear directions alone did not solve the listening problem. They listed both useful parts and difficulties in their notebook.
Paragraph 3 — A changed layout
The class moved the rhythm station to the far end of the hall and lowered its volume. The bird station stayed near the entrance, with the story station between them. The numbered labels were kept. An adult checked the cables so visitors would have a clear walkway. The team changed the sound arrangement, not the order of the three activities.
Paragraph 4 — Trying again
On Wednesday morning, four different groups tried the new layout. All four reported that they could hear the bird sounds clearly. Three also finished every station; the fourth group left early for another activity. The teacher recorded that departure separately. Leaving early did not show that the group had failed to understand the trail or disliked the recordings.
Paragraph 5 — A remaining question
Both tests took place before the other exhibition stalls opened. The hall was quieter than it would be during the full event. The class had not yet checked whether a large crowd would make the bird station difficult to hear. A new poster therefore said Clearer listening in our second small trial, instead of promising perfect sound for everyone at all times.
Paragraph 6 — Next steps
The pupils planned another check during a busy rehearsal. They would ask visitors whether they could hear each recording and note where people had difficulty. If crowd noise covered the bird sounds, they could discuss another location with the teacher. They would keep the useful numbered labels while collecting evidence about the sound problem that remained uncertain.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the passage detail that limits a claim of success during the full exhibition.
- a: The trail has three numbered stations.
- b: Both trials happened before other stalls opened.
- c: An adult checked that the walkway was clear.
The tests occurred in a quieter hall. They do not establish how well the trail works with the full crowd.
Source explorer: search lab
F5 · Explain the report’s careful wording
Paragraph 1 — The listening trail
A class planned a listening trail for a school exhibition. Visitors would hear a short bird recording, a story opening and a rhythm pattern at three stations. The aim was to let people enjoy each recording without sounds from another station mixing into it. The first plan placed all three stations close together along one wall of the hall.
Paragraph 2 — The first test
Four small groups tried the trail on Monday. The bird recording was quiet, while the rhythm recording was louder. Three groups reported that the rhythm covered some of the bird sounds. All four groups could follow the numbered station labels. The pupils realised that clear directions alone did not solve the listening problem. They listed both useful parts and difficulties in their notebook.
Paragraph 3 — A changed layout
The class moved the rhythm station to the far end of the hall and lowered its volume. The bird station stayed near the entrance, with the story station between them. The numbered labels were kept. An adult checked the cables so visitors would have a clear walkway. The team changed the sound arrangement, not the order of the three activities.
Paragraph 4 — Trying again
On Wednesday morning, four different groups tried the new layout. All four reported that they could hear the bird sounds clearly. Three also finished every station; the fourth group left early for another activity. The teacher recorded that departure separately. Leaving early did not show that the group had failed to understand the trail or disliked the recordings.
Paragraph 5 — A remaining question
Both tests took place before the other exhibition stalls opened. The hall was quieter than it would be during the full event. The class had not yet checked whether a large crowd would make the bird station difficult to hear. A new poster therefore said Clearer listening in our second small trial, instead of promising perfect sound for everyone at all times.
Paragraph 6 — Next steps
The pupils planned another check during a busy rehearsal. They would ask visitors whether they could hear each recording and note where people had difficulty. If crowd noise covered the bird sounds, they could discuss another location with the teacher. They would keep the useful numbered labels while collecting evidence about the sound problem that remained uncertain.
F5 · Open ended
Why is “Clearer listening in our second small trial” more accurate than “Perfect sound for everyone”?
Example of a full-credit answer: All four second-trial groups heard the birds clearly, so the report can describe that improvement. The full busy hall was not tested, so perfect sound for every visitor is not established.
- Uses the positive second-trial finding that all four groups heard the bird sounds clearly.
- Explains that the untested crowded hall or limited trial prevents a claim about perfect sound for everyone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: document lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
1. A shelf with a problem
Classroom example — The travelling book box. Every Friday, the pupils at Banaba School exchanged storybooks on a shelf near the gate. Some pupils could not use it. The school bus left soon after lessons, and those pupils had no time to stop. During rainy weeks, the lowest shelf also became damp. Class 5 did not want to end the exchange. They wanted more pupils to borrow books while keeping the books dry.
2. Listening before choosing
At a class meeting, Pia suggested moving all the books into her classroom. Omar pointed out that younger pupils might not know where to find them. The teacher asked the class to collect information before choosing. For one week, pairs of pupils counted visits to the shelf. They also asked ten bus passengers about borrowing. Eight passengers wanted an earlier borrowing time. The pupils wrote down the answers without adding names.
3. A small trial
The class planned a two-week trial. A covered box would visit three classrooms during the final fifteen minutes before lunch on Wednesdays. A pupil helper would carry a list of book titles. Borrowers would write a book title and return date on a card. The ordinary Friday shelf would stay open. This meant the trial added a choice rather than removing the old one. The teacher arranged for an adult to help move the box.
4. What the records showed
In the first week, twelve books were borrowed from the travelling box. Four borrowers said they had never used the Friday shelf. In the second week, fifteen books were borrowed, including five by pupils who travelled by bus. These counts did not show how much anyone read at home. On the second Wednesday, the box arrived late at one classroom because a helper had copied the wrong room number. Two pupils there missed their chance.
5. Changes and questions
The helpers wanted to write “The box works perfectly” on a poster. Pia disagreed. She liked the extra borrowing, but the missed classroom mattered too. The class changed the route card so each room number appeared beside the teacher’s name. They also added a place to note the arrival time. Omar suggested checking whether books were returned in usable condition. The group agreed that counting loans alone would not answer that question.
6. The next plan
At the next meeting, the class proposed continuing the travelling box for a month while keeping the Friday shelf. Helpers would check the route together before leaving and record late arrivals, loans and book condition. At the end of the month, they would ask both borrowers and pupils who still could not borrow what needed changing. Their final poster read, “Another way to borrow: help us improve it.” The box was a useful beginning, not a finished solution.
1A · Matching
Match each story stage to the detail that belongs there.
Complete or match: Original access problem; Trial arrangement; New information from week two
- a: A box visits classrooms before lunch.
- b: Bus passengers lack time at the Friday shelf.
- c: A copied room number causes a late arrival.
The opening problem, trial design and recorded difficulty occur at different stages of the passage.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the trial addresses a problem from the beginning of the passage.
Example of a full-credit answer: Bus passengers lacked time after lessons to use the Friday shelf. Visiting classrooms before lunch gives them an earlier chance to borrow without waiting after school.
- Identifies the bus passengers’ original timing problem.
- Connects the before-lunch visit with improved access.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
1. A shelf with a problem
Classroom example — The travelling book box. Every Friday, the pupils at Banaba School exchanged storybooks on a shelf near the gate. Some pupils could not use it. The school bus left soon after lessons, and those pupils had no time to stop. During rainy weeks, the lowest shelf also became damp. Class 5 did not want to end the exchange. They wanted more pupils to borrow books while keeping the books dry.
2. Listening before choosing
At a class meeting, Pia suggested moving all the books into her classroom. Omar pointed out that younger pupils might not know where to find them. The teacher asked the class to collect information before choosing. For one week, pairs of pupils counted visits to the shelf. They also asked ten bus passengers about borrowing. Eight passengers wanted an earlier borrowing time. The pupils wrote down the answers without adding names.
3. A small trial
The class planned a two-week trial. A covered box would visit three classrooms during the final fifteen minutes before lunch on Wednesdays. A pupil helper would carry a list of book titles. Borrowers would write a book title and return date on a card. The ordinary Friday shelf would stay open. This meant the trial added a choice rather than removing the old one. The teacher arranged for an adult to help move the box.
4. What the records showed
In the first week, twelve books were borrowed from the travelling box. Four borrowers said they had never used the Friday shelf. In the second week, fifteen books were borrowed, including five by pupils who travelled by bus. These counts did not show how much anyone read at home. On the second Wednesday, the box arrived late at one classroom because a helper had copied the wrong room number. Two pupils there missed their chance.
5. Changes and questions
The helpers wanted to write “The box works perfectly” on a poster. Pia disagreed. She liked the extra borrowing, but the missed classroom mattered too. The class changed the route card so each room number appeared beside the teacher’s name. They also added a place to note the arrival time. Omar suggested checking whether books were returned in usable condition. The group agreed that counting loans alone would not answer that question.
6. The next plan
At the next meeting, the class proposed continuing the travelling box for a month while keeping the Friday shelf. Helpers would check the route together before leaving and record late arrivals, loans and book condition. At the end of the month, they would ask both borrowers and pupils who still could not borrow what needed changing. Their final poster read, “Another way to borrow: help us improve it.” The box was a useful beginning, not a finished solution.
2A · Multiple choice
Why is Pia right to question “The box works perfectly”?
- a: No books were borrowed.
- b: The Friday shelf was removed.
- c: The records show extra borrowing but also a missed opportunity caused by a late visit.
- d: The text says all pupils dislike books.
Loan counts show use, while the late visit shows a real difficulty. Both must inform the conclusion.
2B · Short answer
Use two parts of the passage to justify a more careful judgement of the trial.
Example of a full-credit answer: The first week brought twelve loans, including four people new to the shelf. However, the wrong room number caused a late visit and two pupils missed out, so the trial helped but needs improvement.
- Uses a correct positive borrowing result.
- Uses the late/missed visit to limit an overly strong success claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
1. A shelf with a problem
Classroom example — The travelling book box. Every Friday, the pupils at Banaba School exchanged storybooks on a shelf near the gate. Some pupils could not use it. The school bus left soon after lessons, and those pupils had no time to stop. During rainy weeks, the lowest shelf also became damp. Class 5 did not want to end the exchange. They wanted more pupils to borrow books while keeping the books dry.
2. Listening before choosing
At a class meeting, Pia suggested moving all the books into her classroom. Omar pointed out that younger pupils might not know where to find them. The teacher asked the class to collect information before choosing. For one week, pairs of pupils counted visits to the shelf. They also asked ten bus passengers about borrowing. Eight passengers wanted an earlier borrowing time. The pupils wrote down the answers without adding names.
3. A small trial
The class planned a two-week trial. A covered box would visit three classrooms during the final fifteen minutes before lunch on Wednesdays. A pupil helper would carry a list of book titles. Borrowers would write a book title and return date on a card. The ordinary Friday shelf would stay open. This meant the trial added a choice rather than removing the old one. The teacher arranged for an adult to help move the box.
4. What the records showed
In the first week, twelve books were borrowed from the travelling box. Four borrowers said they had never used the Friday shelf. In the second week, fifteen books were borrowed, including five by pupils who travelled by bus. These counts did not show how much anyone read at home. On the second Wednesday, the box arrived late at one classroom because a helper had copied the wrong room number. Two pupils there missed their chance.
5. Changes and questions
The helpers wanted to write “The box works perfectly” on a poster. Pia disagreed. She liked the extra borrowing, but the missed classroom mattered too. The class changed the route card so each room number appeared beside the teacher’s name. They also added a place to note the arrival time. Omar suggested checking whether books were returned in usable condition. The group agreed that counting loans alone would not answer that question.
6. The next plan
At the next meeting, the class proposed continuing the travelling box for a month while keeping the Friday shelf. Helpers would check the route together before leaving and record late arrivals, loans and book condition. At the end of the month, they would ask both borrowers and pupils who still could not borrow what needed changing. Their final poster read, “Another way to borrow: help us improve it.” The box was a useful beginning, not a finished solution.
New setting
A sports club wants a travelling box of skipping ropes. Some pupils leave early. The box must arrive at the correct groups, and returned ropes must be usable.
3A · Dropdown selection
Apply the book-box lessons to the sports-kit plan.
Complete or match: Early departures; Risk of visiting the wrong group; Need to know whether ropes stay usable
- a: Offer a borrowing time before pupils leave.
- b: Check group names beside route locations.
- c: Record the condition of returned ropes.
- d: Count only the colour of the box.
These actions address timing, route accuracy and condition, the same kinds of issues discussed in the passage.
3B · Open ended
Explain one idea that transfers well and one detail that must change for ropes.
Example of a full-credit answer: A checked route and early borrowing time can help both projects. The condition record must check ropes for damage or tangles rather than checking book pages.
- Identifies a relevant transferable access, route or record-keeping idea.
- Adapts a concrete detail to sports equipment rather than books.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
1. A shelf with a problem
Classroom example — The travelling book box. Every Friday, the pupils at Banaba School exchanged storybooks on a shelf near the gate. Some pupils could not use it. The school bus left soon after lessons, and those pupils had no time to stop. During rainy weeks, the lowest shelf also became damp. Class 5 did not want to end the exchange. They wanted more pupils to borrow books while keeping the books dry.
2. Listening before choosing
At a class meeting, Pia suggested moving all the books into her classroom. Omar pointed out that younger pupils might not know where to find them. The teacher asked the class to collect information before choosing. For one week, pairs of pupils counted visits to the shelf. They also asked ten bus passengers about borrowing. Eight passengers wanted an earlier borrowing time. The pupils wrote down the answers without adding names.
3. A small trial
The class planned a two-week trial. A covered box would visit three classrooms during the final fifteen minutes before lunch on Wednesdays. A pupil helper would carry a list of book titles. Borrowers would write a book title and return date on a card. The ordinary Friday shelf would stay open. This meant the trial added a choice rather than removing the old one. The teacher arranged for an adult to help move the box.
4. What the records showed
In the first week, twelve books were borrowed from the travelling box. Four borrowers said they had never used the Friday shelf. In the second week, fifteen books were borrowed, including five by pupils who travelled by bus. These counts did not show how much anyone read at home. On the second Wednesday, the box arrived late at one classroom because a helper had copied the wrong room number. Two pupils there missed their chance.
5. Changes and questions
The helpers wanted to write “The box works perfectly” on a poster. Pia disagreed. She liked the extra borrowing, but the missed classroom mattered too. The class changed the route card so each room number appeared beside the teacher’s name. They also added a place to note the arrival time. Omar suggested checking whether books were returned in usable condition. The group agreed that counting loans alone would not answer that question.
6. The next plan
At the next meeting, the class proposed continuing the travelling box for a month while keeping the Friday shelf. Helpers would check the route together before leaving and record late arrivals, loans and book condition. At the end of the month, they would ask both borrowers and pupils who still could not borrow what needed changing. Their final poster read, “Another way to borrow: help us improve it.” The box was a useful beginning, not a finished solution.
Student summary
“The class removed Friday borrowing. The trial proved that pupils read more at home. The helpers then changed the route card.”
4A · Multiple answers
Select all claims in the student summary that the passage does not support.
- a: The class removed Friday borrowing.
- b: The trial proved pupils read more at home.
- c: The helpers changed the route card.
- d: The box had a two-week trial.
The Friday shelf stayed open. The passage explicitly says loan counts do not show home reading. The route-card change and two-week trial are supported.
4B · Short answer
Correct the two unsupported claims.
Example of a full-credit answer: The travelling box added a choice while the Friday shelf stayed open. Loan counts showed borrowing, but they did not show how much pupils read at home.
- Corrects the claim about removing Friday borrowing.
- Corrects the claim about proven home reading.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
1. A shelf with a problem
Classroom example — The travelling book box. Every Friday, the pupils at Banaba School exchanged storybooks on a shelf near the gate. Some pupils could not use it. The school bus left soon after lessons, and those pupils had no time to stop. During rainy weeks, the lowest shelf also became damp. Class 5 did not want to end the exchange. They wanted more pupils to borrow books while keeping the books dry.
2. Listening before choosing
At a class meeting, Pia suggested moving all the books into her classroom. Omar pointed out that younger pupils might not know where to find them. The teacher asked the class to collect information before choosing. For one week, pairs of pupils counted visits to the shelf. They also asked ten bus passengers about borrowing. Eight passengers wanted an earlier borrowing time. The pupils wrote down the answers without adding names.
3. A small trial
The class planned a two-week trial. A covered box would visit three classrooms during the final fifteen minutes before lunch on Wednesdays. A pupil helper would carry a list of book titles. Borrowers would write a book title and return date on a card. The ordinary Friday shelf would stay open. This meant the trial added a choice rather than removing the old one. The teacher arranged for an adult to help move the box.
4. What the records showed
In the first week, twelve books were borrowed from the travelling box. Four borrowers said they had never used the Friday shelf. In the second week, fifteen books were borrowed, including five by pupils who travelled by bus. These counts did not show how much anyone read at home. On the second Wednesday, the box arrived late at one classroom because a helper had copied the wrong room number. Two pupils there missed their chance.
5. Changes and questions
The helpers wanted to write “The box works perfectly” on a poster. Pia disagreed. She liked the extra borrowing, but the missed classroom mattered too. The class changed the route card so each room number appeared beside the teacher’s name. They also added a place to note the arrival time. Omar suggested checking whether books were returned in usable condition. The group agreed that counting loans alone would not answer that question.
6. The next plan
At the next meeting, the class proposed continuing the travelling box for a month while keeping the Friday shelf. Helpers would check the route together before leaving and record late arrivals, loans and book condition. At the end of the month, they would ask both borrowers and pupils who still could not borrow what needed changing. Their final poster read, “Another way to borrow: help us improve it.” The box was a useful beginning, not a finished solution.
5A · Drag and drop
Place each record field beside the question it would help answer.
Complete or match: Did every classroom get its visit on time?; Did borrowed books come back usable?; Who still has difficulty borrowing?
- a: Arrival time by classroom
- b: Returned-book condition
- c: Comments from pupils who cannot borrow
- d: Box decoration colour
Different questions need different evidence. Loan counts alone cannot replace arrival, condition or access information.
5B · Open ended
Propose a small improvement check for the next month. State what you would record and how it would guide a decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record each classroom’s planned and actual arrival time. If the same room is repeatedly late, change the route or departure time while keeping the early borrowing opportunity.
- Proposes a relevant measurable record or feedback question tied to the passage.
- Explains how its results would guide a specific improvement without claiming certainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.5 · Identifying the main idea
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Topic and message
Passage
At the craft club, scissors have a marked basket. Glue bottles stand in a separate tray. Paper scraps go into a reuse box. These places help members return materials when the session ends.
Question: What is the main idea, beyond the topic “craft materials”?
Answer: The club gives materials clear storage places so members can put them away.
Why: The topic names the subject, but the main idea says something about it. Each important detail names a storage arrangement. The answer covers their shared purpose without claiming that all clubs use the same system.
Example 2 · Avoid an idea that is too small
Passage
The class practised speaking slowly, facing the listeners and pausing between points. These habits helped the audience follow the presentations. Each speaker used a different picture.
Question: Is “Speakers used different pictures” the best main idea?
Answer: No. The passage mainly explains speaking habits that help an audience understand.
Why: The picture detail is true but does not cover most of the passage. Slow speech, facing listeners and useful pauses fit a broader idea about clear delivery. A main idea should gather the important details together.
Example 3 · Avoid an idea that is too large
Passage
During one afternoon, six pupils tried a shaded reading spot. Five said it felt cooler than the sunny steps. One preferred sitting indoors because insects distracted him.
Question: Would “Outdoor reading is best for every pupil” fit the passage?
Answer: No. The small trial found that shade felt cooler than the sunny steps to five pupils, while one preferred reading indoors.
Why: Every pupil is broader than the evidence. The passage describes six pupils on one afternoon and includes a different preference. Keep the size of the main idea matched to the size and limits of the account.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match short passages to their message
Passage A
Numbered hooks and matching bag tags help pupils find their own bags.
Passage B
A reading club offers a morning session and an afternoon session so more pupils can attend.
F1 · Matching
Match each passage to its main idea.
Complete or match: Passage A; Passage B
- a: Extra session times widen the chance to attend.
- b: A labelling system helps pupils locate belongings.
A concerns finding bags through labels. B concerns access through two meeting times.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Topic or main idea?
Paragraph
Pupils prepare for the play by checking props, practising lines and testing the music. Their preparation helps the rehearsal run smoothly.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the two labels for this paragraph.
Complete or match: The topic is ___.; The main idea is ___.
- a: preparing for a play
- b: Preparation helps the rehearsal run smoothly.
- c: Music is always the most important subject.
A topic names the subject. The main idea connects the preparations to their shared purpose.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Three proposed headings
Passage
A class checks its shared pencils each week. Short ones go into a small pot, sharpened ones into a ready tray, and broken ones to an adult. This routine keeps useful pencils easy to find.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each proposed main idea to its description.
Complete or match: The class has a small pot.; A weekly routine keeps shared pencils usable.; Every school has perfect pencil supplies.
- a: Fits the whole passage
- b: Too broad for the evidence
- c: Only one small detail
The routine joins all the details. The pot is only one detail, while every school goes beyond this class.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Check the central message
Passage
The school garden team counts the tools before and after a session. Missing tools are reported to the teacher. This helps the team notice losses promptly. The tally sheet is green.
F4 · True or false
The main idea is that the tally sheet has an attractive colour.
- true: True
- false: False
Most of the passage describes checking and reporting tools. The sheet’s colour is a small detail, not the central message.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Name the shared purpose
Passage
At the class book exchange, books are grouped by broad subject. Each group has a large label. A pupil helper explains the labels to first-time visitors. These arrangements help readers find a suitable section.
F5 · Short answer
State the main idea and give one detail that fits it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The exchange helps readers find suitable book sections. For example, the broad subject groups have large labels that guide readers.
- States that the arrangements help readers find suitable book sections or navigate the exchange.
- Gives a relevant detail such as subject grouping, large labels or the helper’s explanation and connects it to that idea.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Garden paragraph
Classroom example: Pupils put labels beside seedlings, drew a watering chart and checked the soil together. These jobs helped them share responsibility for the garden.
Music paragraph
The band practised in small groups, listened to one another and slowed difficult sections. By Friday they could play the song together more smoothly.
1A · Matching
Match each paragraph with its main idea.
Complete or match: Garden paragraph; Music paragraph
- a: Practice and listening helped the band improve together.
- b: Shared jobs helped pupils care for the garden.
- c: Every pupil prefers music to gardening.
Each main idea covers several related actions. A claim about every pupil’s preference is not supported.
1B · Short answer
Choose one paragraph and explain how two details support its main idea.
Example of a full-credit answer: In the garden paragraph, labels and a watering chart help pupils know what needs care. Checking the soil together also shares the work, supporting the idea of joint responsibility.
- States or clearly identifies the chosen paragraph’s central idea.
- Connects at least two accurate details to that idea.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Passage
Classroom example: The club tested three water carriers. A wide bowl spilled when carried quickly. A bottle with a lid kept water inside. A small jug was easy to pour but had no cover. The club discussed which carrier suited each job.
Candidate main idea
“The wide bowl spilled.”
2A · True or false
The candidate sentence covers the main idea of the whole passage.
- true: True
- false: False
It covers only one test. The passage compares different carriers for different jobs.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the candidate is too narrow and give a better main-idea sentence.
Example of a full-credit answer: It mentions only the bowl, leaving out the bottle, jug and choice of jobs. A better main idea is that different water carriers suit different uses.
- Explains that the candidate omits other important comparisons.
- Gives a main idea covering the carriers and their suitability.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New passage
Classroom example: A community reading corner offers picture books for younger readers, large-print pages for people who need them and audio recordings for visitors who prefer listening. Volunteers help visitors find a useful format.
Editor’s task
The notice board needs a main heading and two supporting notes. The heading should cover the whole passage.
3A · Drag and drop
Place the notes in the right roles.
Complete or match: Main heading; Supporting detail about print formats; Supporting detail about volunteer help
- a: A reading corner offers different ways to access stories.
- b: Large-print pages are available.
- c: Volunteers help visitors choose a format.
The heading covers the range of access choices. The other statements are examples supporting that broader idea.
3B · Short answer
Explain why “Only picture books” would be a poor heading here.
Example of a full-credit answer: The corner also offers large print and audio, so “Only picture books” excludes important information. The passage is about several ways to access stories.
- Identifies at least one other format or service.
- Connects the omission to the broader main idea.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Passage
Classroom example: To reduce lunch waste, one class counted unopened food, asked pupils about portion size and tried a smaller first serving with seconds available. Their plan changed after listening to pupils.
Reader’s claims
One reader says the passage is mainly about counting. Another says it proves every school has solved food waste.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all statements that explain a problem with those claims.
- a: Counting is only one part of the class’s process.
- b: The passage describes one class, not every school.
- c: The passage is entirely about lunchbox colours.
- d: The class never asked pupils anything.
One claim is too narrow and the other too broad. The passage describes a class using information to revise its plan.
4B · Open ended
Write a main idea that avoids both errors and explain one detail it includes.
Example of a full-credit answer: The class used counts and pupils’ views to improve its lunch-waste plan. Asking about portions supports the idea that listening helped shape the change.
- Gives a central idea encompassing information gathering and plan improvement.
- Links a correct detail to that idea without overgeneralising.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing goal
Classroom example: Write a paragraph with the main idea “A buddy system helps new pupils find their way at school.”
Available notes
A buddy can show the library, explain where to queue and answer questions. One pupil owns purple shoes. The new pupil may need help during the first week.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose useful content for each paragraph part.
Complete or match: Opening sentence; Supporting action about queueing; Supporting action about finding a place
- a: A buddy helps a new pupil learn school routines.
- b: Show where to queue.
- c: Explain where the library is.
- d: Describe purple shoes.
The opening and two actions support the buddy-system idea. Shoe colour does not help explain it.
5B · Short answer
Propose one more supporting detail and explain its connection to the main idea.
Example of a full-credit answer: A buddy could walk with the new pupil to the correct classroom on the first day. That helps the pupil learn where to go and reduces getting lost.
- Proposes a plausible detail about orientation or school routines.
- Explains how it supports the stated main idea.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.6 · Identifying supporting details
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Match evidence to a claim
Notice
Claim: The new timetable is easier to read. The headings use larger print. Morning and afternoon sessions are separated. The notice board has a wooden frame.
Question: Which two details directly explain the claim?
Answer: Larger headings and separated morning and afternoon sessions directly explain easier reading.
Why: Both details change how information can be found or read. The wooden frame may be real, but it does not show that the timetable’s information is clearer. Judge relevance against the exact claim, not against the general topic of notice boards.
Example 2 · A detail can point against an idea
Report
Claim: Everyone could hear the announcement. The first two rows heard clearly. Three pupils at the back said that several words were too quiet to understand.
Question: Does the report support the word everyone?
Answer: No. The back-row report is evidence against everyone hearing the whole announcement.
Why: Supporting evidence must fit the size of the claim. Clear hearing in two rows is useful information, but it cannot cancel the stated difficulty elsewhere. Keep the conflicting detail instead of selecting only the convenient part.
Example 3 · Explain the connection
Class record
The shared glue supply lasted longer this month. Pupils closed the lids after use, and fewer bottles dried out. The cupboard door was painted red.
Question: How does the closed-lid detail help explain the longer-lasting supply?
Answer: Closed lids are linked in the account with fewer bottles drying out, so more glue remained usable.
Why: A useful answer connects the action to the claim through the stated result. Simply repeating “closed lids” is less clear. The red cupboard is unrelated to keeping glue usable; the passage does not say that its colour changed the supply.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A relevant design detail
Claim
The new instruction card is easier for beginners to follow.
Details
Each action is on its own numbered line. A small star decorates the corner.
F1 · True or false
Putting each action on its own numbered line is relevant support for the claim.
- true: True
- false: False
Numbered lines help readers identify separate actions and their order. The star does not explain how to follow the task.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Evidence of less waiting
Claim
A new return routine reduced waiting in this class.
Record
Before the change, pupils waited about five minutes. In two later sessions, they waited about two minutes. The return tray is yellow. The class mascot is a turtle.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select the two details needed to compare waiting before and after the change.
- a: The earlier wait was about five minutes.
- b: The later waits were about two minutes.
- c: The tray used for returns is yellow.
- d: The class mascot is a turtle.
The earlier and later times allow a comparison. The colours and mascot do not measure waiting.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Support for a weather change
Claim
The class moved its display because the wind was disturbing it.
Observations
Cards repeatedly blew off the outdoor table. A pupil wore a blue cap. The display contained eight drawings.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the strongest supporting detail.
- a: Cards repeatedly blew off the table.
- b: A pupil’s cap was blue.
- c: Eight drawings were displayed.
Cards blowing away directly show the wind disturbing the display.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Sort the reasons
Claim
The borrowing list became more accurate.
Checking action
The helper checked each book number against the shelf.
Repeated claim
The list was accurate because it was accurate.
Pencil detail
The pencil used for writing was striped.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each note to its role.
Complete or match: Checking numbers against the shelf; It was accurate because it was accurate; Using a striped pencil
- a: Repeats the claim
- b: Unrelated appearance detail
- c: Relevant checking action
Checking book numbers can improve the list. Repeating accurate supplies no new reason, and pencil stripes are unrelated.
Source explorer: claim board
F5 · Choose and explain a useful detail
Claim
The reading display offers more than one way to use a story.
Details
A printed story sits beside an audio recording of the same story. The display has a green cloth and three paper flowers.
F5 · Open ended
Choose a detail that supports the claim, and explain how it does so.
Example of a full-credit answer: The same story is available in print and as an audio recording. Readers can read the words or listen, which gives two ways to use it.
- Selects the printed story and audio recording of the same story.
- Explains that reading and listening are two distinct ways to access or use the story.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Observation record
Classroom example: The tool shelf now has picture labels. Frequently used scissors are on a low shelf. A blue poster hangs nearby. Pupils can return tools without asking an adult to reach high shelves.
Idea to support
The changes make the shelf easier for pupils to use independently.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all details that directly support the idea.
- a: Picture labels identify where tools belong.
- b: Frequently used scissors are on a low shelf.
- c: The nearby poster is blue.
- d: The record is written on white paper.
Labels help identify places and low storage helps pupils reach tools. The colours do not establish independent use.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the two selected details help in different ways.
Example of a full-credit answer: Labels help pupils know where tools belong. Low shelves help them reach the scissors without adult assistance.
- Explains how labels support identification or returning tools.
- Explains how low storage supports independent reach.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Before
Classroom example: A class walking route had a narrow muddy section. Pupils often stopped there to avoid deep puddles.
After
The group used a nearby raised path. In three walks they no longer stopped at the old muddy section. The new path still took them to the same gate.
2A · Multiple choice
Which detail best supports “The change avoided the old muddy blockage”?
- a: The class has twenty pupils.
- b: The new route reaches the same gate.
- c: They no longer stopped at the muddy section on three walks.
- d: Some pupils wore green bags.
The observed lack of stops at that section directly relates to avoiding the blockage.
2B · Short answer
Explain why reaching the same gate is useful but less direct evidence for avoiding the muddy blockage.
Example of a full-credit answer: Reaching the same gate shows the route still reaches its destination. The observation about no stops at the muddy section directly shows what happened to the blockage problem.
- Identifies what the same-gate detail establishes.
- Distinguishes it from the direct no-stops evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Draft poster
Classroom example: “Our reading corner welcomes different readers.”
Panel A
Large-print booklets are available beside the ordinary print copies.
Panel B
The table was painted yellow last year.
Panel C
The volunteer’s bag has a star on it.
3A · Hotspot
Select the panel that best supports the poster’s claim.
- a: Large-print booklets beside ordinary print copies.
- b: The table was painted yellow last year.
- c: The volunteer’s bag has a star.
Different print sizes are a relevant access choice. Decoration and bag design do not support the access claim.
3B · Open ended
Suggest another detail that would support the claim, and explain why it would help.
Example of a full-credit answer: An audio version of a story could support the claim because it offers another way for visitors to access the same text.
- Proposes a relevant concrete access or inclusion detail.
- Explains how it serves different readers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Claim
Classroom example: The new class clean-up routine shares the work more evenly.
Notes
A rota gives each group a different job each week. Every group gets a turn at tidying materials. The chart has a red border. “It is fair because it is fair,” says one pupil.
4A · Matching
Match each note with its role.
Complete or match: Each group gets a different weekly job.; The chart has a red border.; It is fair because it is fair.
- a: Relevant support about shared work
- b: An unrelated appearance detail
- c: A repeated claim without new support
The rota explains how work is shared. Border colour and a repeated claim do not show even sharing.
4B · Short answer
Repair the repeated-claim sentence using a real supporting detail.
Example of a full-credit answer: The routine shares work more evenly because every group gets a turn at different jobs on the rota.
- Replaces circular repetition with an actual rota detail.
- Explains how the detail relates to sharing work.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing plan
Classroom example: Miko wants to claim that a new story display helps pupils choose books. He has recorded the display colour but has not asked readers or watched how they use it.
Possible next step
He could ask readers whether the short book descriptions helped them choose, and record their reasons.
5A · True or false
Recording only the display colour is enough evidence that it helps pupils choose books.
- true: True
- false: False
Colour alone does not show whether readers can choose books more easily.
5B · Open ended
Propose a way to collect a relevant detail and explain what it could show.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask pupils whether the short descriptions helped them choose and ask for an example. Their answers could show which descriptions were useful, although not every pupil may agree.
- Proposes an observation or question about actual book choosing.
- Explains what the resulting detail could support without claiming certainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.7 · Summarising information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Keep the change and the result
Report
At first, the class kept all drawing paper in one tall pile. Pupils often disturbed the pile while looking for a size. The class separated large and small sheets into two trays. During the next lesson, pupils found their sizes more quickly. The trays were blue.
Question: What is a short, accurate summary?
Answer: Separating paper by size helped pupils find sheets more quickly in the next lesson.
Why: The summary keeps the problem’s important action and observed result. The tray colour is not needed to understand the change. The wording also keeps the time limit; it does not promise that the arrangement will always work perfectly.
Example 2 · Group repeated examples
Notice
Bring a ruler, a pencil and an eraser for the drawing activity. Bring a filled water bottle as well. The activity begins after morning break. Do not bring paint because the room has no place to wash brushes.
Question: How can we shorten the notice without losing a rule?
Answer: After morning break, bring basic drawing tools and water; do not bring paint.
Why: Ruler, pencil and eraser can be grouped as basic drawing tools when summarising. The separate water requirement and no-paint rule still matter. A shorter version should preserve instructions people need, rather than remove a condition just to save words.
Example 3 · Keep both views
Discussion
Mina favours a longer reading session because she wants time to finish chapters. Joren favours a shorter session because he also wants time for drawing. They agree that the class should keep a daily reading period.
Question: What summary keeps the agreement and the disagreement?
Answer: Both want daily reading, but they disagree about how long the session should last.
Why: The shared idea does not erase the difference. A summary saying both want longer reading would change Joren’s view. Naming the agreement and one clear contrast is shorter than retelling every reason while keeping the discussion’s meaning.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the summary for each account
Account A
The weaving group lacked enough ribbon. Members shared the remaining strips and completed one small wall hanging together.
Account B
The classroom clock stopped. The teacher used a watch to keep the afternoon activities on time.
F1 · Matching
Match each account with its accurate summary.
Complete or match: Account A; Account B
- a: A watch replaced a stopped clock for timing activities.
- b: Sharing limited ribbon allowed one joint wall hanging.
The summaries retain each account’s main difficulty and practical response without adding a result.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · An overclaim in a short summary
Original
Eight pupils tried a picture checklist once. Six remembered every task, while two missed one task.
Proposed summary
The checklist made every pupil remember every task every day.
F2 · True or false
The proposed summary accurately preserves the original result.
- true: True
- false: False
Six of eight succeeded in one trial. Every pupil and every day add claims the source does not support.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Choose what a summary needs
Report
A class made a sign for the drinking-water station. Some letters were too small, so the pupils rewrote them in larger print. The sign became easier to read from the doorway. It had a tiny flower in one corner.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the summary without adding a claim.
Complete or match: The pupils changed ___ to improve readability.; They could then read the sign from ___.
- a: the doorway
- b: the size of the letters
- c: every part of the town
Larger letters and reading from the doorway are the central change and observed result.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Keep the essential information
Reminder
The model-making session has moved from Tuesday to Thursday. It will still begin at 2 p.m. in Room 4. Bring a cardboard base. The reminder was written in purple ink.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select all facts a useful short reminder should keep.
- a: The session is now on Thursday.
- b: It begins at 2 p.m. in Room 4.
- c: A cardboard base should be brought.
- d: The reminder uses purple ink.
The day, time/place and required material help pupils act. The ink colour is unnecessary.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Summarise a limited success
Passage
The class tested a new line-up routine for three days. Pupils collected their bags before joining the line. The line formed more quickly on two days, but a missing bag delayed the third day. The class plans to try the routine again next week.
F5 · Short answer
Write a one- or two-sentence summary that keeps the change and the mixed result.
Example of a full-credit answer: The class tested collecting bags before lining up. It was quicker on two of three days, but a missing bag caused a delay on the third day.
- States the change or trial of collecting bags before joining the line.
- Preserves the mixed result: quicker on two days with a missing-bag delay on the third, rather than success every day.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Passage
Classroom example: The puppet-show screen tore before the performance. The group patched it with spare cloth, tested the light behind it and moved one lamp so the patch made less shadow. The audience could see the puppets, and the show continued.
Summary frame
The summary needs the problem, the main response and the outcome. The colour of the spare cloth is not given.
1A · Drag and drop
Place the summary parts in the correct roles.
Complete or match: Problem; Main response; Outcome
- a: The group patched the screen and adjusted a lamp.
- b: The screen tore before the show.
- c: The audience could see the puppets and the show continued.
These parts preserve the central problem, response and result without inventing details.
1B · Short answer
Write a one-sentence summary using the important connection between the repair and result.
Example of a full-credit answer: After the screen tore, the group patched it and adjusted the light so the puppet show could continue clearly.
- Includes the torn-screen problem and relevant repair.
- Includes the continued/visible show as the result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Original
Classroom example: Six pupils tried reading with a page marker. Four said it helped them keep their place; two preferred reading without it. The teacher planned to offer markers as an option.
Proposed summary
“Every pupil must use a page marker because all readers prefer one.”
2A · True or false
The proposed summary keeps the meaning of the original.
- true: True
- false: False
The original reports mixed preferences in a small group and an optional choice, not a rule for every reader.
2B · Open ended
Explain two important changes made by the inaccurate summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes four of six liking the marker into all readers liking it. It also changes offering an option into requiring everyone to use one.
- Identifies the exaggerated preference claim.
- Identifies the changed optional-versus-required policy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Announcement
Classroom example: The community seed swap will be held on Saturday morning in the covered court. Bring labelled spare seeds if you have them. Visitors without seeds may still come to learn and take a small starter packet while supplies last.
Task
A short class message should keep who may attend and the main conditions.
3A · Multiple choice
Which summary best keeps the announcement’s key meaning?
- a: Only visitors with seeds may attend.
- b: A Saturday seed swap welcomes learners with or without seeds, with starter packets available while supplies last.
- c: Every visitor is guaranteed unlimited seeds.
- d: The event happens every morning.
The accurate summary preserves the time, inclusive attendance and limited packet supply.
3B · Short answer
Which condition should not be removed from a message about starter packets, and why?
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep “while supplies last” because packets are limited. Without it, the message could wrongly promise a packet to every visitor.
- Identifies the supply-limit condition.
- Explains the false guarantee created by leaving it out.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original
Classroom example: The class placed a mat at the doorway to catch mud. At the end of three rainy days, less mud reached the reading area. The pupils still had to clean the mat each day.
Weak summary
“The mat was rectangular. The doorway was near a wall. The reading area was in the classroom. Cleaning is never needed now.”
4A · Dropdown selection
Choose the information a repaired summary needs.
Complete or match: Main action; Observed result; Continuing requirement
- a: Put a mat at the doorway.
- b: Less mud reached the reading area on three rainy days.
- c: Clean the mat each day.
- d: No cleaning is ever needed.
The useful summary keeps the action, limited observation and daily cleaning, rather than unrelated shapes or an invented permanent result.
4B · Open ended
Write a corrected summary in no more than two sentences.
Example of a full-credit answer: A doorway mat reduced mud reaching the reading area during three rainy days. The class still needed to clean the mat daily.
- Preserves the mat action and observed reduction.
- Preserves the continuing cleaning requirement and avoids a universal claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Passage
Classroom example: The science club tested paper bridges with the same span. Folded paper held more counters in this trial than flat paper. The club used one paper type and wants to try another before making a broader claim.
Draft card: heading
Paper-bridge trial
Draft card: result
Folded paper held more counters in this trial.
Draft card: empty box
Add a sentence that keeps the trial’s limitation.
5A · Hotspot
Select the part of the card where the limitation should be added.
- a: Paper-bridge trial
- b: Folded paper held more counters in this trial.
- c: Add a sentence that keeps the trial’s limitation.
The empty box should state the limited paper type or need for another test.
5B · Short answer
Write the missing limitation sentence and explain why it belongs in the summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: Only one paper type was tested, so the club wants to try another. This stops the card from claiming that the result applies to all paper bridges.
- States the one-paper-type limit or planned further test accurately.
- Explains that the limit prevents overgeneralising the result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.8 · Sequencing events and ideas
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Printed order is not event order
Account
At noon, Tala displayed the finished kite. Earlier that morning she had attached its tail. Before attaching the tail, she had joined the frame and paper.
Question: What is the event order?
Answer: Join the frame and paper, attach the tail, then display the finished kite.
Why: The first printed sentence describes the final event. Earlier and before take us back in time. Place each action on an imaginary card and use these clues to arrange them, instead of copying the sentence order.
Example 2 · A step depends on another step
Instructions
Write the plant’s name on a label. Tie the label to the pot. Take a photograph with the label facing the camera. The photograph should show which plant belongs to which name.
Question: Why should the photograph come last?
Answer: The named label needs to be attached and visible before the photograph can identify the plant.
Why: This order follows the task’s purpose as well as the printed steps. Taking the photograph first would leave out the required label. Explain the dependency: the final step needs work completed in the earlier steps.
Example 3 · Do not invent an order
Event note
Before the guests arrived, Asha arranged the chairs and Ben filled the water jug. The note does not say which helper began or finished first. Guests arrived at ten.
Question: Can we put Asha’s work before Ben’s with certainty?
Answer: No. Both jobs happened before the guests arrived, but their order relative to each other is unknown.
Why: A sequence can contain an uncertain part. The text gives a shared deadline, not an exact order between the two jobs. Keep that uncertainty instead of treating the order of names in a sentence as a time signal.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Three stages of a paper model
Note
Before assembling the model, Luz cut out its pieces. After assembling it, she photographed it.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which order agrees with the note?
- a: Photograph, assemble, then cut out.
- b: Cut out, assemble, then photograph.
- c: Assemble, photograph, then cut out.
- d: Cut out, photograph, then assemble.
Cutting comes before assembly, and the photograph comes after assembly.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · A timed delivery log
09:05
The office received the empty display stand.
09:20
The class attached its drawings.
09:35
The helper moved the completed display to the hall.
F2 · Matching
Match each event to its place in the sequence.
Complete or match: Receive the empty stand; Attach the drawings; Move the completed display
- a: Third
- b: First
- c: Second
The times establish 09:05, then 09:20, then 09:35.
Source explorer: timeline
F3 · Which order claims are justified?
Account
Miko checked the speaker before playing the recording. After the recording ended, he disconnected the speaker. The account does not say when he wrote the title card.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select every order statement supported by the account.
- a: Checking came before playing.
- b: Disconnecting came after playing ended.
- c: Writing the card came before checking.
- d: Disconnecting came before the recording.
The first two orders are stated. The title-card timing is unknown, and disconnecting happened afterwards.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Prepare a clear sequence card
Step A
First, put the blank card flat on the desk.
Step B
Next, write the name in the middle.
Step C
Finally, place the completed name card on the display.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the sequence using the time words in the instructions.
Complete or match: ___ put the blank card down.; ___ write the name.; ___ display the completed card.
- a: Finally
- b: First
- c: Next
First introduces preparation, next continues the job, and finally marks the last stated step.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F5 · Repair a reversed instruction
Goal
Make a card showing a leaf outline.
Required actions
Place the leaf flat on paper. Trace around it while it stays in place. Lift the leaf away when the outline is finished.
Mixed-up instruction
Lift the leaf, trace around it, then place it on paper.
F5 · Open ended
Give the correct order and explain why tracing must happen before lifting the leaf.
Example of a full-credit answer: Place the leaf on the paper, trace around it, then lift it away. The leaf must remain in place to guide the pencil while tracing.
- Gives the order place the leaf, trace it, then lift it.
- Explains that the leaf needs to stay in place as the guide for the outline during tracing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Message
Classroom example: Before the singers arrived, the teacher opened the hall. The singers placed their bags by the wall, then warmed up. They began the song only after the pianist was ready.
Task
Use the time words to find the earliest event. The passage does not say what time the pianist arrived.
1A · Multiple choice
Which event definitely happens first?
- a: The singers begin the song.
- b: The teacher opens the hall.
- c: The singers warm up.
- d: The singers place bags by the wall.
Before the singers arrived places opening the hall before their later actions.
1B · Open ended
Explain the order of the singers’ bag placement and warm-up using a clue from the text.
Example of a full-credit answer: They place their bags first and then warm up. The word then connects the warm-up to the earlier bag placement.
- Gives the correct order of the two actions.
- Identifies then or equivalent textual timing evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
09:05
Classroom example: The caretaker notices a loose sign.
09:12
The caretaker places the sign safely on a table.
09:20
The caretaker tightens the bracket before hanging the sign again.
2A · Hotspot
Select the last recorded event before the bracket was tightened.
- a: 09:05 — notices a loose sign
- b: 09:12 — places the sign on a table
- c: 09:20 — tightens the bracket
The 09:12 entry is the preceding recorded event. The times establish the sequence.
2B · Short answer
Why do the clock times provide stronger ordering evidence than the length of each note?
Example of a full-credit answer: The times show when each event occurred, so 09:12 precedes 09:20. Note length only shows how much was written and does not establish event time.
- Uses the relevant times to justify order.
- Explains why note length is not timing evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New instructions
Classroom example: Read the seed names before making labels. Attach labels before placing the pots on the public display. Water according to the seed-care notes after setting up the pots.
Constraint
Visitors need correct labels from the moment the display opens.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all ordering statements supported by the instructions.
- a: Read seed names before writing labels.
- b: Place unlabeled pots on display before making labels.
- c: Attach labels before the pots go on display.
- d: Watering must happen before any seed name is read.
The instructions explicitly place reading before label-making and labels before public display.
3B · Open ended
Propose an order for the first three actions and explain why that order helps visitors.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the names, make the labels, then attach them before displaying the pots. This prevents visitors seeing unlabeled or wrongly labeled pots when the display opens.
- Gives the reading → label-making → attaching order.
- Connects preparation to accurate information for visitors.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original
Classroom example: The team first measured the shelf. After choosing a box that fitted, they carried the box to the room. Finally they filled it with reading cards.
Wrong report
“They filled the box, then measured the shelf to decide whether the empty box would fit.”
4A · Matching
Match each sequence position with the original action.
Complete or match: First; After measuring, before carrying; Finally
- a: Measure the shelf
- b: Choose a box that fits
- c: Fill the box with cards
The original prepares the correct box before carrying and filling it. The report reverses the preparation.
4B · Short answer
Explain why measuring before choosing is useful, not just earlier.
Example of a full-credit answer: The shelf measurement tells the team how large the box can be. Choosing before measuring could leave them with a box that does not fit.
- Explains what the measurement tells the team.
- Identifies a plausible problem avoided by measuring first.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Goal
Classroom example: Make a card that tells a reader how to send a class library request. The reader needs to choose a book, check the title, then give the request to the librarian.
Available steps
Write the chosen title. Check the spelling against the catalogue. Hand the request to the librarian. A correction is easier before handing it over.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose the step for each place on the card.
Complete or match: Start; Before handing over; Last
- a: Write the chosen title
- b: Check its spelling against the catalogue
- c: Give the request to the librarian
- d: Wait for a book without requesting it
The request must be written and checked before the librarian receives it.
5B · Open ended
Write a three-step card using time words and explain where a useful check belongs.
Example of a full-credit answer: First write the chosen title. Next check it against the catalogue. Finally give the request to the librarian. The check belongs before handing it over so errors can be corrected.
- Gives the three required steps in a sensible order.
- Explains why checking occurs before delivery.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.9 · Understanding vocabulary from context
Three worked examples
Example 1 · An explanation beside the word
Passage
The clay figure was fragile: one thin arm broke when the box was dropped. Its maker wrapped the figure carefully before carrying it to the display.
Question: What does fragile mean here?
Answer: Fragile means easily broken or damaged.
Why: The broken thin arm provides a direct clue, and the careful wrapping fits that meaning. Replace fragile with easily broken and reread the passage. The interpretation explains both the accident and the later care without needing to guess from the word’s sound.
Example 2 · Opposites can supply a clue
Passage
The first shelf was crowded with books. The second shelf was sparse, with only two small booklets and plenty of empty space.
Question: What does sparse suggest about the second shelf?
Answer: It has only a small amount spread out, with much empty space.
Why: The contrast with crowded and the example of two booklets work together. Sparse does not mean broken or untidy here. Test a meaning against all the nearby details, including the contrast between the two shelves.
Example 3 · Choose the meaning that fits
Passage
The pupils watched a leaf drift along the stream. The current carried it past a smooth stone. The teacher reminded them to watch safely from the path.
Question: Does current mean “happening now” in this passage?
Answer: No. Here current means the movement or flow of water.
Why: A leaf is being carried along a stream, so the water meaning fits the action. Happening now is a real meaning in another context, but it cannot explain what carries the leaf. A familiar definition must still match this sentence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Two context meanings
Line 1
The container was transparent, so everyone could see the shells inside.
Line 2
The cloth was opaque; it hid everything beneath it.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Choose the meanings that fit these lines.
Complete or match: Transparent means ___.; Opaque means ___.
- a: not see-through
- b: see-through
- c: very noisy
Seeing the shells explains transparent; hiding what is beneath explains opaque.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Locate the clue for weary
Passage
After the long walk, Sami was weary. His legs felt heavy, and he sat down to rest before continuing. His bag was blue, and the path led to the hall.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the strongest clue that weary means tired.
- a: His legs felt heavy, and he sat down to rest.
- b: His bag was blue.
- c: The path led to the hall.
Heavy legs and resting support the meaning tired. Bag colour and the path’s destination do not explain weary.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Meaning and evidence together
Passage
The hall grew dim when thick clouds covered the sun. Pupils moved nearer a lamp to see their drawings clearly.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select all statements that fit dim in this passage.
- a: Dim means having little light.
- b: Moving near a lamp is a useful clue.
- c: Dim means filled with loud voices.
- d: The text says the drawings vanished.
Clouds covering the sun and a lamp point to reduced light, not sound or disappearing drawings.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · Match each word to its local meaning
Line A
The queue was brief; it lasted only a minute.
Line B
The path was narrow, with room for just one person at a time.
Line C
The box was vacant: there was nothing inside it.
F4 · Matching
Match each word to its meaning in the given line.
Complete or match: brief; narrow; vacant
- a: empty
- b: short in time
- c: not wide
The minute explains brief, the single-person width explains narrow, and nothing inside explains vacant.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · Use the clue, not a wild guess
Passage
The group replenished the paper tray after it became empty. They added a fresh stack so the next class would have enough sheets.
F5 · Short answer
What does replenished mean here, and which detail helps you work it out?
Example of a full-credit answer: It means filled again or supplied again. The tray was empty and the group added a fresh stack of paper.
- Defines replenished as filled or supplied again in this context.
- Uses the empty tray followed by adding a fresh stack as the supporting context clue.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: word lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Passage
Classroom example: At first, Sami was reluctant to read aloud. He stayed seated and whispered that he was unsure. After a friend offered to read beside him, he agreed to try.
Focus word
Use the actions around reluctant to choose its meaning in this situation.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all clues that suggest reluctant means unwilling or hesitant at first.
- a: He stayed seated.
- b: He whispered that he was unsure.
- c: He had already shouted the whole story confidently.
- d: He was the tallest child.
Staying seated and expressing uncertainty support hesitation. The other statements are not in the passage.
1B · Short answer
Give the likely meaning of reluctant and one clue supporting it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Reluctant means hesitant or not ready to agree. Sami stays seated and says he is unsure before accepting help.
- Gives a suitable hesitant/unwilling meaning.
- Connects it to a stated action or expression of uncertainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Sentence A
Classroom example: The empty basket was light, so one child carried it easily.
Sentence B
A patch of light fell through the window and brightened the table.
2A · Dropdown selection
Choose the meaning of light in each sentence.
Complete or match: Sentence A; Sentence B
- a: Not heavy
- b: Brightness that helps us see
- c: A kind of basket
Carrying easily relates to weight; brightening the table relates to visible light.
2B · Open ended
Explain why one meaning cannot simply be used for both sentences.
Example of a full-credit answer: The basket sentence gives a carrying and weight clue. The window sentence describes brightness, so the same word has a different meaning there.
- Explains the weight clue in Sentence A.
- Explains the brightness clue in Sentence B.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New passage
Classroom example: The teacher asked for a concise report. “Keep the important findings, but use only a few clear sentences,” she explained.
Student guess
A pupil guesses that concise means long and full of repeated examples.
3A · True or false
The pupil’s guess fits the teacher’s explanation.
- true: True
- false: False
A few clear sentences and important findings point to brief and focused, not long and repetitive.
3B · Short answer
What does concise most likely mean, and which words help you decide?
Example of a full-credit answer: Concise means brief but including the important points. “Only a few clear sentences” and “keep the important findings” provide the explanation.
- Gives a brief/focused meaning.
- Uses the teacher’s explanation as evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Passage
Classroom example: Dali had a bright idea for storing the art cards: use labeled envelopes so each set stays together.
Wrong interpretation
“Bright means shining with strong light, so Dali’s idea must glow.”
4A · Multiple choice
Which explanation repairs the interpretation?
- a: Bright here means a clever or useful idea.
- b: Every idea gives off visible light.
- c: The sentence describes a lamp.
- d: Envelopes must be yellow.
Idea and the practical storage solution support the clever/useful sense of bright, not literal light.
4B · Open ended
Explain the error and give one context clue for the better meaning.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reader used the light meaning of bright literally. The sentence describes a useful labeled-envelope plan, so bright means clever in this context.
- Identifies the inappropriate literal/light meaning.
- Uses the idea or useful plan as evidence for clever.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Goal
Classroom example: Help younger readers understand three words from context: sturdy, damp and transparent.
Meaning notes
Sturdy means strong and not easily damaged. Damp means slightly wet. Transparent means see-through. Each card needs a sentence with a useful clue.
5A · Drag and drop
Match the word with a sentence that supplies a clear clue.
Complete or match: Sturdy; Damp; Transparent
- a: We could see the seeds through the clear bag.
- b: The strong stool did not wobble when used.
- c: The towel felt a little wet after the splash.
Each sentence gives an observation connected to the word’s meaning.
5B · Short answer
Write a new sentence teaching one of the words, then name the clue you included.
Example of a full-credit answer: The sturdy shelf stayed firm under the books without bending. “Stayed firm” and “without bending” show that sturdy means strong.
- Writes a sentence using one target word accurately.
- Identifies a meaningful context clue that helps readers infer its meaning.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R1.10 · Understanding technical and academic words
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read a subject definition
Mini-glossary
Habitat: the place where a living thing normally lives. Observation: something noticed using the senses or a measuring tool. The class recorded a snail on a damp leaf beside the garden wall.
Question: Which term names the kind of place where the snail lives?
Answer: Habitat names the place where it normally lives.
Why: The glossary gives a subject meaning, so we use that definition instead of guessing. The recorded sighting is an observation. One sighting can suggest where to investigate, but by itself it does not prove every place the snail normally lives.
Example 2 · Notice the instruction word
Task card
Classify the shapes into triangles and circles. Classify means put objects into groups using a shared feature. The card shows two triangles and three circles.
Question: What should the learner do when asked to classify?
Answer: Put the triangles in one group and the circles in another.
Why: The action word asks for grouping. Drawing the shapes beautifully or counting their colours would not complete this instruction. Understanding an academic word helps you choose the right action, even when the objects themselves are familiar.
Example 3 · Estimate is not an exact count
Task card
Estimate how many buttons are in the jar, then count them. An estimate is a sensible approximate amount. An exact count checks every button.
Question: Is a reasonable estimate meant to be an exact counted answer?
Answer: No. It is a sensible approximate amount that can later be checked by counting.
Why: The card distinguishes two jobs. Estimate uses available clues to make a reasonable approximation; count checks each item. A learner should not claim to have counted simply because the estimate happens to equal the later total.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · An instruction to explain
Task card
Explain why the drawing was moved indoors. Explain asks you to give a reason or show how something happens. Wind kept lifting the corners of the paper outside.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which response does the task word explain require?
- a: Name the colour of the drawing paper.
- b: Give the reason for moving the drawing.
- c: Copy the title with large bright letters.
- d: List the people standing beside the paper.
The task asks for the reason: wind lifted the paper’s corners. Naming an unrelated feature does not explain the move.
Source explorer: word lab
F2 · Use the glossary accurately
Glossary
Data: information collected for a question. A measurement is a recorded amount with a unit. A prediction says what may happen next.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select every correct use of these glossary words.
- a: A list of recorded plant heights is data.
- b: A height of 12 centimetres is a measurement.
- c: A prediction is a result already measured.
- d: Every measurement can leave out its unit.
Recorded heights are collected information; 12 centimetres gives an amount and unit. A prediction concerns a possible later outcome.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Three academic actions
Directions
Compare means identify similarities or differences. Describe means tell what something is like. Justify means give reasons or evidence for a choice.
F3 · Matching
Match the academic word to its action.
Complete or match: compare; describe; justify
- a: Tell the shape and texture of a leaf.
- b: Give evidence for choosing one route.
- c: Find ways two containers are alike or different.
Each action matches the definition given in the directions.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Find a technical word’s example
Glossary
A scale on a chart shows what its numbered positions mean. In this chart, each numbered step represents two books.
Note
The chart title is Books returned. Its bars are green.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the detail that explains the chart’s scale.
- a: The title says Books returned.
- b: Each numbered step represents two books.
- c: The bars are coloured green.
The books per step tell the reader how the numbers represent quantities.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Follow the command to justify
Task
Choose a container for carrying loose counters and justify your choice. Justify means give a reason or evidence for a choice.
Container facts
Box A has a lid that closes. Tray B has no lid. The counters must remain inside while being carried.
F5 · Open ended
What does the task word justify ask you to do? Then choose a container and give a reason using the container facts.
Example of a full-credit answer: Justify asks me to give a reason or evidence for my choice. I choose Box A because its closing lid helps keep the counters inside while it is carried.
- Explicitly explains that justify means to give a relevant reason or evidence for a choice.
- Applies the instruction by choosing Box A and linking its closing lid to keeping the counters inside during carrying.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Glossary
Classroom example: Habitat means the place where a living thing lives. Adaptation means a feature that helps it survive in its environment. Observation means something noticed or measured.
Field notes
A pupil records that a snail is under a damp log. The pupil describes its shell and measures how far it moves in one minute.
1A · Dropdown selection
Use the glossary to label the notes.
Complete or match: The place under the damp log; The measured distance moved
- a: Habitat
- b: Observation
- c: Advertisement
The location is a habitat description. The measured distance is an observation.
1B · Open ended
Explain why measuring the snail’s movement is an observation rather than a guess.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil measures and records an actual distance during one minute. A guess would give an unmeasured idea about the movement.
- Connects observation to a real measurement or noticed event.
- Distinguishes it from an unsupported guess.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Task card
Classroom example: Compare the two classroom bags. Bag A has one large pocket and a zip. Bag B has three small pockets and a zip.
Word guide
Compare: identify relevant similarities and differences. Describe: give features of something. Predict: say what may happen next using reasons.
2A · Multiple choice
Which answer best follows compare?
- a: Bag A has a pocket.
- b: Both bags have zips, but their pocket arrangements differ.
- c: Tomorrow every bag will break.
- d: Compare means count only the letters in a word.
It gives a similarity and a difference, as the word guide requires.
2B · Short answer
Explain why describing only Bag A would not fully meet this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: The task asks about two bags together. Describing only Bag A misses the similarity of zips and the difference in pocket arrangement.
- States that comparison needs a relationship between both bags.
- Identifies a relevant similarity or difference omitted by a one-bag description.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Word guide
Classroom example: Chronology means time order. Evidence means information used to support an idea. Source means where information comes from.
Display materials
The class has dated photographs, an interview record and a row of year labels. They want visitors to see changes in the old school building.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each display job with the most useful word.
Complete or match: Arrange photographs from earliest to latest.; Name the interview record where a statement came from.; Use a photograph to support a claim about a roof change.
- a: Source
- b: Evidence
- c: Chronology
Time order is chronology, origin is source, and supporting information functions as evidence.
3B · Open ended
Explain how the same photograph can be both a source and evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The photograph is a source because it is where information about the building comes from. It becomes evidence when a detail in it supports a specific claim, such as a changed roof.
- Explains source as the origin of information.
- Explains evidence as information supporting a particular claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Experiment note
Classroom example: Variable means something that can change. In this paper-airplane trial, the pupils change wing width, keep the paper type the same and measure flight distance.
Pupil’s claim
“Paper type is the changed variable because paper is a science word.”
4A · Hotspot
Select the experiment-note region naming the factor the pupils actually changed.
- a: The pupils change wing width.
- b: They keep the paper type the same.
- c: They measure flight distance.
The note explicitly identifies wing width as what is changed. Paper type is kept constant.
4B · Short answer
Correct the claim using both the changed factor and the factor kept the same.
Example of a full-credit answer: Wing width is the changed variable. Paper type is kept the same, so it is not the factor being changed in this trial.
- Correctly identifies wing width as changed.
- Correctly contrasts the unchanged paper type.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Goal
Classroom example: Make a glossary entry for conclusion in a class report. The class defines a conclusion as a judgement that follows from the information collected.
Available evidence
In a classroom borrowing trial, pupils borrowed more picture books than puzzle books. The record shows borrowing only; it does not measure which books were read at home.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all useful parts of an accurate glossary entry for conclusion.
- a: A short meaning: a judgement based on information.
- b: An example: picture books were borrowed more often in this trial.
- c: A claim that every pupil dislikes puzzles.
- d: A decorative border with no explanation.
The definition and limited evidence-based example teach the word. The universal dislike claim is unsupported.
5B · Open ended
Write a glossary entry with a meaning and a new, sensible example based on the trial.
Example of a full-credit answer: Conclusion: a judgement drawn from evidence. Example: borrowing of the two book types was unequal in this trial, with more picture-book loans.
- Gives an accurate evidence-based meaning of conclusion.
- Gives a relevant limited example supported by the borrowing data.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.1 · Finding explicitly stated information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Arrival and starting time differ
Workshop notice
Paper-making workshop: arrive at the gate by 8:45 a.m. The lesson starts at 9 a.m. and finishes at 10:30 a.m. Meet the helper beside the blue notice board.
Question: At what time does the lesson start?
Answer: The lesson starts at 9 a.m.
Why: The notice gives three times with different labels. Start matches the question, while arrive and finishes answer other questions. Read the words attached to each time before copying a number. A correct detail includes a.m. so its meaning stays clear.
Example 2 · Keep an exception
Borrowing rule
Class magnifiers may be borrowed on Monday, Tuesday and Thursday. They are not available on Wednesday because the science club uses them. Return each magnifier to the teacher before going home.
Question: Can a pupil borrow a class magnifier on Wednesday under this rule?
Answer: No. Wednesday is explicitly excluded because the science club uses the magnifiers.
Why: The answer is written directly in the rule. Reading only the phrase may be borrowed would miss the day restriction. Keep exceptions such as not available when locating a fact; do not replace the stated rule with a usual routine.
Example 3 · Copy the requested kind of detail
Trip card
Destination: Riverside Puppet Museum. Meeting place: school foyer. Group guide: Ms Lim. Museum activity leader: Mr Cruz. Pupils meet their guide at the school foyer at 8 a.m.
Question: Who is the group guide?
Answer: Ms Lim is the group guide.
Why: The card lists two people with different roles. Ms Lim matches the group-guide label; Mr Cruz leads the museum activity. Matching the exact role matters more than choosing the nearest name or the first familiar name on the card.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the weaving-session notice
Notice
Weaving session: Thursday. Register at the office. Bring a small piece of clean cloth. The activity takes place in the art room.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the notice facts.
Complete or match: Session day: ___; Registration place: ___; Required material: ___
- a: the office
- b: a small piece of clean cloth
- c: Thursday
The notice directly states the day, registration location and material.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · A closing time with a condition
Notice
The reading room closes at 4 p.m. on school days. On Saturday it closes at noon. It does not open on Sunday.
F2 · Multiple choice
When does the reading room close on Saturday?
- a: At noon on Saturday.
- b: At four on Saturday.
- c: At noon every Sunday.
- d: At four every Sunday.
The Saturday sentence gives noon. The school-day time does not apply to Saturday.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Facts actually on the card
Activity card
The sculpture display is in Room 6. It opens on Friday at 10 a.m. Admission is free. No closing time is printed on this card.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select every fact explicitly stated on the activity card.
- a: The display is in Room 6.
- b: Admission to the display is free.
- c: The display closes at 3 p.m.
- d: Every visitor receives a sculpture.
Room 6 and free admission are stated. Closing time and gifts are not supplied.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Keep people and roles straight
Team list
Ms Ong is the organiser. Mr Tan is the first-aid contact. Ms Diaz is the transport contact.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each person with the stated role.
Complete or match: Ms Ong; Mr Tan; Ms Diaz
- a: Transport contact
- b: Organiser
- c: First-aid contact
The roles are listed directly, so there is no need to infer them from the names.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Give two exact notice details
Notice
For the Tuesday bead workshop, bring a shallow container to keep beads from rolling. Collect your materials from the desk beside Room 3 before entering the workshop.
F5 · Short answer
What should a pupil bring, and where should materials be collected?
Example of a full-credit answer: Bring a shallow container. Collect materials from the desk beside Room 3.
- Identifies a shallow container as the item to bring.
- Identifies the materials desk beside Room 3 as the collection place.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: search lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Notice
Classroom example: Paper-craft workshop. Saturday, 9:30–11:00, Room 4. Bring one clean cardboard box. Register with Ms Cruz by Thursday. No paint is needed.
Question task
Find the stated place, starting time and item to bring. These details are separate from the finish time and registration deadline.
1A · Drag and drop
Place each notice detail beside its label.
Complete or match: Place; Starting time; What to bring
- a: 9:30
- b: Room 4
- c: One clean cardboard box
- d: Thursday
The labels in the notice distinguish place, start time and required material.
1B · Short answer
Explain why Thursday is not the workshop day, and give the actual workshop day.
Example of a full-credit answer: Thursday is the deadline for registration. The workshop itself is on Saturday.
- Identifies Thursday as registration deadline.
- Identifies Saturday as the event day.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Opening notice
Classroom example: The school lending desk opens at lunch from Monday to Friday. On Wednesday, borrowing begins ten minutes later because helpers attend a meeting.
Reader’s question
A pupil asks whether Wednesday borrowing begins at exactly the same time as other weekdays.
2A · Hotspot
Select the sentence that directly answers the pupil’s question.
- a: The lending desk opens at lunch from Monday to Friday.
- b: On Wednesday, borrowing begins ten minutes later because helpers attend a meeting.
- c: The notice is about a lending desk.
The Wednesday sentence supplies the exception to the usual lunchtime opening.
2B · Open ended
State the Wednesday difference and the reason explicitly given.
Example of a full-credit answer: Borrowing begins ten minutes later on Wednesday because the helpers attend a meeting.
- States the ten-minute delay.
- States the helpers’ meeting as the given reason.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Sports shelf
Classroom example: Borrow up to two balls per group. Return them to the basket before 3:00. A damaged ball must be handed to the teacher instead of placed in the basket.
New situation
A group has borrowed one ball. They notice that its outer cover has torn.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all actions required by the stated rule for this damaged ball.
- a: Return it before 3:00.
- b: Hand it to the teacher.
- c: Hide it under the basket.
- d: Keep it until next week.
The general return time still applies, and the damaged-ball exception changes who receives it.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the exception changes the return place without removing the deadline.
Example of a full-credit answer: The damaged ball goes to the teacher rather than the basket. Nothing in the rule removes the before-3:00 return requirement.
- Gives the teacher rather than basket requirement.
- Retains the stated return deadline.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Trip note
Classroom example: Meet at Gate B at 7:40. The bus leaves at 8:00. Bring water in a refillable bottle. Lunch will be provided at the centre.
Pupil’s copied list
“Meet at Gate A at 8:00. Bring a packed lunch.”
4A · Matching
Match each mistaken part with its correction from the note.
Complete or match: Meeting gate; Meeting time; Lunch arrangement
- a: Gate B
- b: 7:40
- c: Lunch provided at the centre
- d: Gate A
The copied list confuses the meeting time with departure and changes the gate and lunch arrangement.
4B · Open ended
Explain one confusion involving time and one involving food.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil used the 8:00 bus departure as the meeting time, which is actually 7:40. The note says lunch is provided, rather than requiring a packed lunch.
- Corrects meeting versus departure time.
- Corrects the lunch arrangement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Notice
Classroom example: The art display is in the covered hall on Friday afternoon. Families may visit from 2:00 to 4:00. The notice does not name the number of pictures.
Question draft
“How many pictures will be displayed?”
5A · True or false
The notice explicitly gives the answer to the draft question.
- true: True
- false: False
No picture count appears in the notice. A location or visiting-time question could be answered directly.
5B · Short answer
Write one question the notice directly answers, then give its precise answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Question: When may families visit? Answer: Friday from 2:00 to 4:00 in the afternoon.
- Writes a question about an explicitly stated detail.
- Provides the matching accurate answer with needed labels or conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.2 · Scanning headings and sections
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A heading with a related word
Visitor guide — Fees
Children enter free with an adult. Adult tickets cost 40 pesos.
Visitor guide — Facilities
Water stations and toilets are beside the entrance.
Visitor guide — Activities
A guide tells stories at 11 a.m.
Question: Which section should you read to find the cost of an adult ticket?
Answer: Read Fees, then find the adult-ticket price of 40 pesos.
Why: The question uses cost while the heading uses fees. They refer to the same kind of information. The heading is a useful starting clue, but the price comes from reading the section, not from the heading alone.
Example 2 · Go from broad to narrow
Cooking-club handbook
Equipment Borrowing a bowl: Ask the helper at the shelf. Cleaning tools: Rinse the tools and place them on the drying rack. Meetings Weekly sessions: Tuesday afternoons.
Question: Where would you look for what to do after washing a tool?
Answer: Look under Equipment, then Cleaning tools; the section says to use the drying rack.
Why: Equipment narrows the area, and Cleaning tools narrows it again. Borrowing a bowl is nearby but answers a different question. Scanning levels of headings helps you choose a section before reading its details closely.
Example 3 · A matching word can mislead
Photo guide — Taking a clear picture
Hold the camera steady and keep the subject in the frame.
Photo guide — Finding a saved picture
Open the album named Class project. Use the date labels to find the session.
Photo guide — Sharing a picture
Ask the teacher which images may be shared.
Question: Which heading helps you locate a picture already saved?
Answer: Finding a saved picture is the relevant section.
Why: Every heading includes picture, so that repeated word alone does not choose the answer. The task is finding an existing image, not taking or sharing one. Match the action in the question to the section’s purpose.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Scan the festival handbook
Getting there
Use the north entrance beside the footpath.
What to bring
Bring a filled water bottle and a hat.
Changing your booking
Ask the office before Wednesday noon.
F1 · Matching
Match each question to its most useful section.
Complete or match: Which entrance should I use?; What items should I pack?; How can I change my booking?
- a: What to bring
- b: Changing your booking
- c: Getting there
The headings concern access, preparation and booking changes respectively.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Follow a heading and subheading
Toy-library guide
Borrowing Choosing a toy: Ask for one available item. Return dates: Bring it back within seven days. Care Cleaning: Wipe the toy with a dry cloth.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the heading path for finding when a toy is due back.
Complete or match: First choose ___.; Then read ___.
- a: Return dates
- b: Borrowing
- c: Cleaning
Return dates is the narrow section inside Borrowing. Cleaning concerns care, not deadlines.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Two sections for two needs
Opening hours
The centre opens at 9 a.m. and closes at 4 p.m.
Borrowing rules
Borrowers show a school pass and return games after one week.
Garden history
The front garden was planted by a volunteer group.
Wall colours
The hall is painted pale yellow.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which sections help a pupil find the opening time and what to show when borrowing?
- a: Opening hours
- b: Borrowing rules
- c: Garden history
- d: Wall colours
The first section supplies the time. The second supplies the school-pass requirement.
Source explorer: search lab
F4 · Organise a clear guide
Entrance
Visitors must use the east gate.
Lunch
Lunch is served at noon.
Lost property
Lost jackets can be collected from the office.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each fact under the clearest heading.
Complete or match: Use the east gate.; Lunch is served at noon.; Collect lost jackets from the office.
- a: Lost property
- b: Meal times
- c: Entrances
Each heading names the kind of fact a reader would expect beneath it.
Source explorer: builder
F5 · Explain your scanning path
Music-room handbook — Using instruments
Collect an instrument from the helper. Return it at the end of the session.
Music-room handbook — Faults and damage
If an instrument has a loose part, stop using it and tell the teacher.
Music-room handbook — Club times
The club meets on Monday and Thursday.
F5 · Open ended
Which section should you use if an instrument has a loose part, and what does that section tell you to do?
Example of a full-credit answer: Use Faults and damage. It tells the reader to stop using the instrument and tell the teacher.
- Selects the Faults and damage section because a loose part is a possible fault.
- States the section’s actions: stop using the instrument and tell the teacher.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: source tabs
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Joining
Classroom example: New members bring a signed form to the class teacher by Friday.
Meeting times
The nature club meets on Tuesday at lunch in Room 3.
Equipment
Members may borrow magnifiers during club sessions and return them before leaving.
1A · True or false
The best section to check first for the weekly meeting day is Equipment.
- true: True
- false: False
Meeting times directly signals day and time information.
1B · Open ended
Name the better heading and explain why its meaning fits the question.
Example of a full-credit answer: Meeting times is better because the question asks when the club meets. The Equipment section concerns borrowing tools.
- Chooses Meeting times.
- Connects its meaning to the day/time question or contrasts the unrelated equipment role.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Visitor guide — Travel
Classroom example: The community gallery is beside the market. The walking entrance faces River Street.
Visitor guide — Opening hours
The gallery opens from 10:00 to 5:00 on Saturdays and Sundays.
Visitor guide — Looking after exhibits
Leave food outside the exhibit room and do not touch paper displays.
2A · Hotspot
Select the section that answers “When does the gallery close on Sunday?”
- a: Travel: entrance faces River Street.
- b: Opening hours: 10:00 to 5:00 on Saturdays and Sundays.
- c: Looking after exhibits: leave food outside.
The opening-hours section supplies the Sunday closing time of 5:00.
2B · Short answer
Explain why spotting Sunday is not enough unless you read the times beside it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Sunday tells us the relevant day, but the question asks for closing time. Reading the full line identifies 5:00 as the end of the opening period.
- Distinguishes the day keyword from the requested time.
- Correctly identifies 5:00 as closing time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Menu: Your account
Classroom example: Change your display name or update the class code.
Menu: Finding books
Search by title, author or topic. Use filters to narrow the list.
Menu: Borrowing limits
Borrow up to three digital books for seven days.
3A · Multiple choice
Which menu section should a pupil open to find how long a digital book can be kept?
- a: Your account
- b: Finding books
- c: Borrowing limits
- d: Any section containing the word book gives the same answer.
Borrowing limits covers duration. Finding books concerns searching, not how long a loan lasts.
3B · Open ended
Explain why Finding books is a tempting but weaker choice for this question.
Example of a full-credit answer: It contains the subject word books, but its text explains searching. The question asks for loan duration, which is under Borrowing limits.
- Identifies the keyword temptation.
- Distinguishes search instructions from borrowing duration.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Guide facts
Classroom example: Arrive ten minutes before a performance. Keep tickets until entry. Ask the desk about lost property. Refreshments are sold in the courtyard.
Wrong layout
The guide placed the lost-property instruction under Snacks and the refreshment information under Arrival. Readers could not find what they needed.
4A · Drag and drop
Move each fact to a clear heading.
Complete or match: Arrive ten minutes early.; Ask about lost property.; Refreshments are in the courtyard.
- a: Arrival
- b: Help desk
- c: Snacks
Each heading names the kind of information in its section.
4B · Short answer
Explain why the original layout caused a problem for someone who lost a hat.
Example of a full-credit answer: A person would reasonably look under Help desk or Lost property. Putting that instruction under Snacks hides it in a section with a different purpose.
- Identifies a sensible heading for lost property.
- Explains the mismatch between reader’s need and Snacks.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Facts to organise
Classroom example: A class craft room has safety rules, borrowing rules and clean-up steps. Safety includes keeping scissors closed while carrying them. Borrowing includes signing out a glue bottle. Clean-up includes wiping tables.
Design goal
A new pupil should be able to find a rule from its purpose without reading the whole handbook.
5A · Matching
Match each proposed heading to its most suitable fact.
Complete or match: Carry tools safely; Borrow shared materials; Leave the room ready
- a: Sign out a glue bottle.
- b: Carry closed scissors carefully.
- c: Wipe the tables.
The headings describe safe carrying, borrowing and clean-up, so each fact has a predictable place.
5B · Open ended
Propose a heading for rules about returning borrowed materials, and explain where you would place it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use “Returning materials” as a subheading under “Borrow shared materials”. It belongs with borrowing because pupils need both parts of the loan routine.
- Proposes a clear return-related heading.
- Explains a sensible relationship to the handbook structure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.3 · Searching tables
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Use a row and a column
| Club | Start | Room |
|---|---|---|
| Origami | 1 p.m. | 2 |
| Sketching | 2 p.m. | 5 |
| Storytelling | 3 p.m. | 1 |
Club schedule
Club | Start | Room Origami | 1 p.m. | 2 Sketching | 2 p.m. | 5 Storytelling | 3 p.m. | 1
Question: Which room is used by Sketching?
Answer: Sketching uses Room 5.
Why: Find the Sketching row first, then follow it to the Room column. The 2 p.m. entry is in the same row but answers a time question. Keeping both labels in view prevents copying a nearby value of the wrong kind.
Example 2 · Read the unit in the heading
| Pupil | Time spent reading (minutes) | Pages read |
|---|---|---|
| Ari | 12 | 5 |
| Bea | 15 | 7 |
| Cal | 10 | 4 |
Reading records
Pupil | Time spent reading (minutes) | Pages read Ari | 12 | 5 Bea | 15 | 7 Cal | 10 | 4
Question: How long did Bea spend reading?
Answer: Bea spent 15 minutes reading.
Why: The row identifies Bea, while the column heading identifies time in minutes. Seven is her page count, not her reading time. Include the unit with 15 so a reader knows whether the answer means minutes, pages or something else.
Example 3 · A dash does not mean zero
| Plant | Height on Monday (cm) | Height on Friday (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| Fern | 9 | 10 |
| Bean | 12 | — |
| Mint | 7 | 8 |
Plant record
Plant | Height on Monday (cm) | Height on Friday (cm) Fern | 9 | 10 Bean | 12 | — Mint | 7 | 8 A dash means the measurement was not recorded.
Question: What can we say about the bean’s Friday height?
Answer: The Friday height is not recorded; we cannot treat it as zero centimetres.
Why: The table note defines the dash. Monday’s 12 centimetres does not fill the missing Friday cell, because the question asks about a different day. Read symbols and notes before calculating or comparing values in a table.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Locate one session
Session table
Session | Start | Room Drawing | 9 a.m. | 4 Puppets | 10 a.m. | 7 Singing | 11 a.m. | 2
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the facts for the Puppets session.
Complete or match: Start: ___; Room: ___
- a: Room 4
- b: 10 a.m.
- c: Room 7
The Puppets row gives 10 a.m. under Start and 7 under Room.
Source explorer: table lab
F2 · Select the correct cell fact
Book counts
Day | Returned | Borrowed Monday | 8 | 11 Tuesday | 6 | 9 Wednesday | 10 | 7
F2 · Hotspot
Select the fact at Tuesday × Borrowed.
- a: Tuesday: 6 returned
- b: Tuesday: 9 borrowed
- c: Monday: 11 borrowed
The Tuesday row and Borrowed column meet at 9. The other entries match only part of the question.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Match questions to table values
Art packs
Pack | Sheets | Price (pesos) A | 10 | 20 B | 15 | 28 C | 20 | 35
F3 · Matching
Match each question to the correct labelled value.
Complete or match: How many sheets are in Pack B?; What is the price of Pack A?; How many sheets are in Pack C?
- a: 20 sheets
- b: 15 sheets
- c: 20 pesos
Pack B has 15 sheets; Pack A costs 20 pesos; Pack C has 20 sheets. Units distinguish equal-looking numbers.
Source explorer: table lab
F4 · Check missing measurements
Ribbon lengths
Ribbon | Length (cm) Red | 25 Blue | — Green | 18 A dash means not measured.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select every statement supported by the table.
- a: The red ribbon measures 25 cm.
- b: The green ribbon measures 18 cm.
- c: The blue ribbon measures zero cm.
- d: The blue ribbon is shorter than every other ribbon.
The two numerical lengths are recorded. The dash leaves the blue length unknown, so it cannot be ranked.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Show how you found the cell
Watering record
Tray | Water added on Monday (mL) | Water added on Tuesday (mL) A | 40 | 50 B | 60 | 45 C | 30 | 35
F5 · Short answer
How much water was added to Tray B on Tuesday, and how did you locate that value?
Example of a full-credit answer: 45 mL. I followed the Tray B row to the Water added on Tuesday column.
- States 45 mL, including the correct unit.
- Identifies the intersection of the Tray B row and Tuesday water-added column.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: table lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Book-club timetable
Classroom example: Tuesday — Story circle — Room 1 — 12:15. Wednesday — Comic workshop — Room 3 — 12:30. Thursday — Poetry corner — Room 2 — 12:15.
How to read the record
Each row describes one activity. The columns are Day, Activity, Room and Start. Read across the same row to keep the details together.
1A · Multiple choice
Where is the Wednesday comic workshop?
- a: Room 1
- b: Room 2
- c: Room 3
- d: The table does not name a room.
The Wednesday/Comic workshop row has Room 3 in the Room column.
1B · Short answer
Describe the row and column you used to find your answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: I found the Wednesday Comic workshop row and followed it to the Room column, which says Room 3.
- Identifies the correct Wednesday/Comic workshop row.
- Identifies the Room column and matching value.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Book-club timetable
Classroom example: Tuesday — Story circle — Room 1 — 12:15. Wednesday — Comic workshop — Room 3 — 12:30. Thursday — Poetry corner — Room 2 — 12:15.
How to read the record
Each row describes one activity. The columns are Day, Activity, Room and Start. Read across the same row to keep the details together.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported by the timetable.
- a: Story circle and Poetry corner both start at 12:15.
- b: Comic workshop is in Room 3.
- c: Every activity starts at 12:30.
- d: Poetry corner is on Wednesday.
The two 12:15 entries and the comic-workshop room are explicitly listed. The other claims mix rows or ignore differences.
2B · Open ended
Explain why scanning only the Start column would not be enough to find the poetry room.
Example of a full-credit answer: The Start column contains times, not room names. I need the Poetry corner row and the Room column to get Room 2.
- Explains the wrong information type in Start.
- Identifies the correct row-column route for Room 2.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Plant table
Classroom example: Pot A — Monday height 8 cm — Friday height 10 cm. Pot B — Monday height 7 cm — Friday height not recorded. Pot C — Monday height 9 cm — Friday height 11 cm.
Table note
Not recorded means no measurement was written. It does not tell us the plant’s actual height.
3A · True or false
The table records Pot B’s Friday height as zero centimetres.
- true: True
- false: False
The Friday value is not recorded. Missing information is not a measured zero.
3B · Short answer
What can and cannot be stated about Pot B from this table?
Example of a full-credit answer: Pot B measured 7 cm on Monday. Its Friday height is unknown from the table, so I cannot state that it was zero or compare its Friday height with the others.
- States a valid recorded fact about Pot B.
- Explains the limit created by the missing Friday measurement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original table
Classroom example: Group A — Arrival 9:00 — Start 9:10 — Finish 9:40. Group B — Arrival 9:20 — Start 9:30 — Finish 10:00.
Wrong note
“Group B starts at 9:20 and Group A finishes at 10:00.” The writer has confused a column and a row.
4A · Dropdown selection
Choose the correct values from the original table.
Complete or match: Group B start; Group A finish; Group B arrival
- a: 9:30
- b: 9:40
- c: 9:20
- d: 10:00
Group B’s 9:20 is arrival, not start. Group A’s finish is in its own row, at 9:40.
4B · Open ended
Explain one row error and one column error in the wrong note.
Example of a full-credit answer: It takes 10:00 from Group B’s row as Group A’s finish. It also uses Group B’s Arrival column, 9:20, as its Start time instead of 9:30.
- Identifies the cross-row finish-time error.
- Identifies the arrival-versus-start column error.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Table draft
Classroom example: A class records how long three short reading games take. The draft headings are Game, Number and Notes. Number contains 4, 6 and 5, measured in minutes.
Design need
A younger pupil should know exactly what those numbers measure without asking the writer.
5A · Hotspot
Select the heading that needs a more precise label.
- a: Game
- b: Number
- c: Notes
Number does not say that the values are duration in minutes. The heading should identify both meaning and unit.
5B · Short answer
Propose a better heading and explain how it improves the table.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use “Time taken (minutes)”. It tells readers that 4, 6 and 5 measure duration, not scores or numbers of players.
- Proposes an accurate duration heading with minutes.
- Explains how the label prevents a plausible misunderstanding.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.4 · Searching charts and diagrams
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read a bar with its label and unit
Chart description
A classroom chart is titled Lanterns completed. Its bars are labelled Red team: 6, Blue team: 9 and Green team: 4. The vertical scale counts lanterns and begins at zero.
Question: How many lanterns did the Blue team complete?
Answer: The Blue team completed 9 lanterns.
Why: Find the Blue team label, follow its bar and read 9 on the lantern-count scale. Nine is not a time or a number of pupils. A chart answer needs the category and unit, not just whichever bar looks most noticeable.
Example 2 · Follow arrows in a process
Diagram description
A three-part diagram shows: Fold a card → Write a greeting → Put the card in an envelope. The arrows mean “do this next”.
Question: Which action comes immediately after folding the card?
Answer: Write a greeting on the folded card.
Why: Follow the arrow leaving the first labelled stage. It points to writing the greeting, while putting the card in the envelope comes later. Reading the arrow key matters: these arrows show order, not distance or the amount of time each action takes.
Example 3 · Keep the chart’s coverage
Chart description
The chart is titled Books chosen by one group on Monday. Its data are Stories: 7, Comics: 5 and Poems: 3. No Tuesday data and no other groups are shown.
Question: Can the chart tell us which kind every class prefers?
Answer: No. It only reports the choices of one group on Monday.
Why: The title limits who and when the data describe. A taller bar shows more choices within that display, but it does not expand the group or the dates. Check the title and notes before turning a chart reading into a larger claim.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Search the lantern chart
Chart values
Lanterns completed in one session: Team A, 6; Team B, 10; Team C, 8. The unit is lanterns.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the bar for Team B’s completed lanterns.
- a: Team A: 6 lanterns
- b: Team B: 10 lanterns
- c: Team C: 8 lanterns
The Team B label matches the bar with value 10 lanterns.
Source explorer: chart lab
F2 · Search a labelled process
Stage 1 — Label
Write the owner’s name on a label.
Stage 2 — Attach
Attach the label to the folder.
Stage 3 — Store
Place the folder in the return tray.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each labelled stage with its action.
Complete or match: Label; Attach; Store
- a: Place the folder in the tray
- b: Write the owner’s name
- c: Fasten the label to the folder
Each action matches its named stage. The arrows preserve Label, Attach, Store order.
Source explorer: map lab
F3 · Read a chart note
Title and values
Favourite fruit of twelve pupils: Mango, 5; Banana, 4; Guava, 3.
Chart note
Each pupil selected one fruit. These results describe only the twelve pupils asked.
F3 · True or false
This chart proves that mango is the favourite fruit of every pupil in the school.
- true: True
- false: False
The chart covers twelve pupils, and only five of those chose mango. It cannot establish every pupil’s preference.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Use a diagram’s key
Diagram
Entrance → Information desk → Display room.
Key
An arrow means the next stop on the suggested visiting route. It does not show distance.
F4 · Multiple choice
What does the arrow from the desk to the display room mean?
- a: The display room is the next stop.
- b: The display room is exactly one metre away.
- c: The display room is always the busiest place.
- d: The display room is smaller than the desk.
The key says that arrows show the next stop. It gives no distance, size or popularity information.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Give a chart value with its evidence
Chart record
Paper models completed: Monday, 8; Tuesday, 12; Wednesday, 7. The chart unit is completed models.
F5 · Open ended
Which day has the largest number of completed models, and what labelled value supports your answer?
Example of a full-credit answer: Tuesday has the largest number. Its bar is labelled 12 completed models, compared with 8 on Monday and 7 on Wednesday.
- Identifies Tuesday as the largest count.
- Uses the Tuesday value of 12 completed models as evidence, with the correct unit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: chart lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Chart data
Classroom example: Books returned by day: Monday 6, Tuesday 9, Wednesday 4. The unit is books. Each bar represents one listed day.
Chart limits
This small chart shows returns, not books borrowed or minutes spent reading.
1A · Multiple choice
Which day has the greatest number of returned books in this chart?
- a: Monday
- b: Tuesday
- c: Wednesday
- d: The chart measures reading minutes.
Tuesday’s bar represents 9 books, larger than 6 and 4.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the title and unit prevent a mistaken answer about reading time.
Example of a full-credit answer: The title says books returned and the unit is books. Therefore the values count returns, not the number of minutes pupils read.
- Uses the return title or category correctly.
- Uses the books unit to distinguish count from time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Water-filter diagram
Classroom example: A demonstration diagram shows muddy water entering at the top, passing through a filter layer, then collecting in a lower cup. Arrows point downward. The diagram does not claim the collected water is safe to drink.
Labels
Top container: muddy water. Middle layer: filter. Lower container: collection cup.
2A · Hotspot
Select the labeled part where water collects after passing through the filter.
- a: Top container — muddy water
- b: Middle layer — filter
- c: Lower container — collection cup
The downward arrows and labels place the collection cup after the filter layer.
2B · Short answer
Which two visual clues establish the collection point’s place in the process?
Example of a full-credit answer: The part is labelled collection cup and is below the filter. Downward arrows show water moving from the top through the filter into that cup.
- Uses the collection-cup label or position.
- Uses the downward process arrows/order.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Map guide
Classroom example: The playground map places the gate on the west side, the reading shelter in the centre and the water point on the east side. A circle marked W means water point.
Visitor’s need
A visitor needs the water point and a sheltered reading place. This map gives locations, not opening times.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all information the map explicitly provides for the visitor.
- a: The water point is on the east side.
- b: The reading shelter is in the centre.
- c: The water point opens at seven.
- d: Every path takes exactly two minutes.
Locations and the W symbol are given. Opening and walking times are absent.
3B · Open ended
Explain how the key and location labels work together to help the visitor.
Example of a full-credit answer: The key tells the visitor that W marks a water point. Its position on the east side then tells the visitor where to look.
- Explains the symbol’s meaning through the key.
- Connects the symbol/location to finding the place.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Chart data
Classroom example: In one class survey, 8 pupils chose drawing, 6 chose singing and 5 chose acting as their preferred club activity. Each pupil selected one activity.
Wrong caption
“This proves drawing is the favourite activity of all children everywhere.”
4A · True or false
The wrong caption is justified by the chart’s scope.
- true: True
- false: False
The chart describes one class survey. It cannot establish the preference of all children everywhere.
4B · Short answer
Rewrite the caption so it matches the data and state what makes it more accurate.
Example of a full-credit answer: In this class survey, drawing received the most choices. This keeps the conclusion limited to the surveyed class rather than all children.
- Gives an accurate most-chosen drawing result.
- Limits the claim to this class/survey.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Process to show
Classroom example: The school paper-reuse system has three stages: collect one-sided paper, check that private information is not visible, then place suitable sheets in the drawing tray.
Design goal
The diagram should show order and make the checking step visible. It should not imply every collected sheet is suitable.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose a label for each diagram position.
Complete or match: First box; Middle check; Final destination for suitable sheets
- a: Collect one-sided paper
- b: Check for private information
- c: Drawing tray
- d: All sheets are always suitable
The process includes a decision before paper reaches the drawing tray.
5B · Open ended
Propose one arrow or label that makes the checking requirement clear.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add an arrow labelled “Only suitable sheets” from the checking box to the drawing tray, with a separate route for sheets that fail the check.
- Proposes a clear visual indication that checking comes before reuse.
- Shows that unsuitable sheets do not automatically enter the drawing tray.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.5 · Using indexes, menus and hyperlinks
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Use an index entry
Book index
Baskets, 4–5 Beads, 8–9 Paper folding, 12–15 Weaving, 18–20
Question: Where should you begin looking for paper-folding instructions?
Answer: Begin on page 12 in the Paper folding section.
Why: The index connects a topic with its page range. Page 12 is the start of the relevant range; pages 18–20 concern another craft. After turning to the page, check the heading and instructions to confirm that they answer your particular question.
Example 2 · Follow a “see” direction
Index
Night sky: see Astronomy Astronomy, 22–27 Weather, 30–34
Question: Does “Night sky: see Astronomy” give a page number by itself?
Answer: No. It directs the reader to Astronomy, which gives pages 22–27.
Why: See is a navigation instruction. Follow it to the named entry, then use the page range there. Treating Astronomy as a page or jumping to Weather would skip the direction. Related vocabulary can lead you to the right part of a book.
Example 3 · Check a link’s destination
Menu label
Current club timetable
Destination heading
Club timetable — last school year
Destination note
This page is archived. Use the new timetable link for this school year.
Question: Should the reader rely on this page as the current timetable?
Answer: No. The destination identifies itself as last year’s archived timetable and points to a newer page.
Why: A link label is a clue, not proof that its destination is current. Read the page heading and notes after following it. Here the destination supplies a clear warning, so the reader should continue to the new timetable.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Use the craft-book index
Index
Clay figures, 6–8 Kites, 14–17 Masks, 21–23
F1 · Drag and drop
Match the question topic to the relevant index range.
Complete or match: How are clay figures shaped?; How is a kite frame made?; How is a mask decorated?
- a: Pages 21–23
- b: Pages 6–8
- c: Pages 14–17
The index maps each topic to its printed range.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Choose a menu route
Visitors menu
Opening hours; Entrances; Contact office
Borrowing menu
Borrowing limits; Return dates; Lost items
Activities menu
Story sessions; Drawing club; Weekend events
F2 · Matching
Match each information need with its best menu.
Complete or match: When must a borrowed game be returned?; Which entrance should a visitor use?; When does the drawing club meet?
- a: Activities
- b: Borrowing
- c: Visitors
Each menu groups related destinations. Return dates, entrances and drawing club appear in different groups.
Source explorer: network
F3 · Use a descriptive link
Information need
A pupil needs the current rules for borrowing a school tablet. The menu offers four link labels.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which link is the best starting point?
- a: Our colourful classroom photo gallery
- b: Current school tablet borrowing rules
- c: How our school started many years ago
- d: Stories from last year’s sports festival
The second label names both the object and the needed borrowing rules. Check the destination after opening it.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · A label is not the whole answer
Link label
Saturday science workshop details
Destination note
This page describes a workshop held last term. No new Saturday date has been announced here.
F4 · True or false
The link label alone proves that a workshop will run this Saturday.
- true: True
- false: False
The destination describes a past event. The label alone cannot establish a current booking.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Explain an index route
Index
Stars: see Sky watching Sky watching, 16–19 Storms, 24–26
Page 16 heading
Sky watching: identifying patterns of stars
F5 · Short answer
How would you use this index to find information about patterns of stars?
Example of a full-credit answer: Follow Stars to Sky watching, then go to pages 16–19, starting at page 16. Its heading confirms that the section concerns patterns of stars.
- Follows the Stars cross-reference to Sky watching and its pages 16–19.
- Checks the destination heading or page content to confirm it covers patterns of stars.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: network
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Book index
Classroom example: Bees 12–13; Butterflies 18–20; Compost 26; Insects 10–21; Worms 28. Entries name topics and page numbers.
Question
A pupil wants the pages specifically about butterflies, not the whole insect chapter.
1A · Multiple choice
Which index entry is the most direct route?
- a: Compost 26
- b: Insects 10–21
- c: Butterflies 18–20
- d: Worms 28
The specific butterfly entry narrows the search to the relevant pages rather than the whole insect chapter.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the insect entry could help but is less direct.
Example of a full-credit answer: Butterflies are included in the wider insect chapter, so it may contain the answer. The butterfly entry points directly to pages 18–20 and avoids unrelated insect pages.
- Recognises the broader insect entry as potentially relevant.
- Explains the advantage of the more specific page range.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Index A
Classroom example: Rain barrels: see Water collection.
Index B
Water collection, pages 31–33. Water safety, pages 40–42.
Page heading
Page 31: Collecting rain from roofs.
2A · True or false
The cross-reference tells the reader to find a page numbered “see”.
- true: True
- false: False
See directs the reader to the Water collection entry, which supplies pages 31–33.
2B · Open ended
Describe the two steps from Rain barrels to the relevant pages.
Example of a full-credit answer: First follow the cross-reference to Water collection. Then use its page range, 31–33, to find the relevant section.
- Follows the cross-reference to Water collection.
- Uses the correct page range as the second step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Portal menu
Classroom example: Learning → Reading, Maths, Science. Activities → Clubs, Visits. Help → Passwords, Contact.
Club page
Activities → Clubs lists meeting days and places for each club.
Need
A new pupil wants the day and room for the reading club, not a reading lesson.
3A · Dropdown selection
Choose the navigation steps for this need.
Complete or match: First main menu; Next section; Detail to read
- a: Activities
- b: Clubs
- c: Reading club meeting details
- d: Help → Passwords
The club meeting information is organised under Activities and Clubs, even though the word reading also appears under Learning.
3B · Short answer
Explain why selecting Learning → Reading might miss the answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: That route leads to reading lessons. The question is about a club meeting, so the Activities → Clubs route matches its purpose.
- Distinguishes lesson content from club administration.
- Chooses or explains the purpose-matched Activities/Clubs route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Available links
Classroom example: “This week’s lunch menu” opens food choices. “Library opening hours” opens a weekly schedule. “Favourite book covers” opens a gallery.
Reader error
A pupil needs the library closing time but chooses Favourite book covers because it contains book.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all reasons why this route is weak.
- a: Book covers describes a gallery, not opening hours.
- b: The opening-hours link directly names the needed kind of information.
- c: Every page containing book gives the same facts.
- d: Food choices are always library times.
Matching a subject word is less useful than matching the information need. The opening-hours label is more direct.
4B · Open ended
Give a better route and one check to make at its destination.
Example of a full-credit answer: Open Library opening hours, then check the correct weekday and closing time in the schedule.
- Chooses the opening-hours link.
- Checks a relevant destination detail such as day or closing time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Guide pages
Classroom example: One page explains returning books, one lists workshop dates, and one gives a contact address for questions.
Design requirement
Readers should predict a page’s purpose from its link label without opening every page.
5A · Matching
Match each destination with a clear link label.
Complete or match: Book-return instructions; Workshop calendar; Contact address
- a: When workshops happen
- b: How to return a book
- c: Ask the organiser
Each label describes the information or action available at the destination.
5B · Short answer
Propose a clear label and return route for a new page about lost library cards.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use “What to do if you lose your library card” and add a “Back to Library help” link. The label describes the problem and the return link lets readers recover their route.
- Proposes a descriptive lost-card link label.
- Provides a sensible route back or related help navigation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.6 · Searching within digital documents
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A match is only a starting point
Search matches for seal
Match 1: A seal is a sea animal in the story. Match 2: Seal the envelope before placing it in the outgoing tray. Match 3: The club badge has a seal design.
Question: Which match helps answer how to prepare an outgoing envelope?
Answer: Match 2 is relevant: seal the envelope before putting it in the tray.
Why: All three matches contain seal, but the word serves different purposes. The question concerns an envelope, so the surrounding sentence decides which match answers it. A search count tells you where a word occurs, not which occurrence is useful.
Example 2 · Try a related term
Search attempt
Mila searches the digital guide for “raincoat” and finds no match.
Guide section
Wet weather: Bring a waterproof jacket if rain is expected.
Question: Does the empty raincoat search prove the guide has no clothing advice for rain?
Answer: No. A search for waterproof or a scan of Wet weather finds relevant advice.
Why: A document may use different words for a similar idea. Revise the search and inspect a likely heading before declaring the information absent. The actual sentence still needs reading so the final answer keeps its condition about expected rain.
Example 3 · Read a condition around the result
Search result
The word visitors is highlighted in this sentence: “Visitors may enter through Gate 2 after 9 a.m.; before then, they must report to the main office.”
Question: Can the highlighted word alone tell a visitor to use Gate 2 at 8:30 a.m.?
Answer: No. Before 9 a.m., the sentence directs visitors to the main office.
Why: The word match locates a useful sentence, but the time condition changes the action. Read before and after the highlighted word. Copying only the Gate 2 phrase would lose the exception that matters to this visitor.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose the useful match
Match A
The story’s battery-powered robot speaks politely.
Match B
To charge the class recorder, connect its cable at the teacher’s charging desk.
Match C
The club will charge 10 pesos for each printed booklet.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the match that explains where to charge the class recorder.
- a: The story robot uses a battery.
- b: The recorder uses the teacher’s charging desk.
- c: The club booklet costs 10 pesos.
Match B concerns the requested recorder and charging location. Match C uses charge to mean a fee.
Source explorer: search lab
F2 · An empty exact search
Search attempt
Searching for bike returns no match.
Guide text
Bicycle parking is beside the caretaker’s office.
F2 · True or false
The empty bike search proves the guide gives no parking location.
- true: True
- false: False
The guide uses bicycle. A related search word can locate the stated parking place.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Choose a useful search term
Task
Find the rule for a cracked plastic ruler in the equipment guide.
Guide headings
Borrowing materials; Damaged materials; Weekly timetable; Shelf labels
F3 · Multiple choice
Which search term is the strongest first choice?
- a: materials
- b: damaged
- c: weekly
- d: labels
Damaged points to the condition of a cracked ruler. Materials is broader, while weekly and labels concern other topics.
Source explorer: query lab
F4 · Use the correct surrounding sentence
Match 1
Borrowed costumes are returned to the drama cupboard.
Match 2
Borrowed puzzles are returned to the games desk.
Match 3
Borrowed magnifiers are returned to the science teacher.
F4 · Matching
Match each borrowed object to its stated return destination.
Complete or match: Costume; Puzzle; Magnifier
- a: Science teacher
- b: Drama cupboard
- c: Games desk
All three sentences contain returned, but their objects and destinations differ.
Source explorer: search lab
F5 · Repair an unsuccessful search
Question
Where should a pupil put a damaged book?
First search
The exact phrase damaged book returns no match.
Guide excerpt
Repairs: Place torn pages or loose covers in the repair tray and tell the library helper.
F5 · Open ended
Suggest a better search word and state the action you find in the guide.
Example of a full-credit answer: Search for repairs, torn or covers. The guide says to put the damaged item in the repair tray and tell the library helper.
- Suggests a relevant alternative search term from the guide, such as repairs, torn or covers.
- States the repair-tray action and telling the library helper from the matched passage.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: search lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Borrowing
Classroom example: Borrow a magnifier by writing your name on the card. Return it to its tray after the activity.
Damage
If a magnifier is cracked, stop using it and tell the teacher. Do not place cracked equipment back in the tray.
Display
The wall display shows drawings made with magnifiers.
1A · Multiple choice
Which search word most directly locates the rule for a cracked magnifier?
- a: the
- b: display
- c: cracked
- d: name
Cracked is the distinctive condition in the question and appears in the damage rule.
1B · Open ended
State the action found in the matching section and explain why reading the whole sentence matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: Stop using the cracked magnifier and tell the teacher. Reading the whole sentence prevents me from treating a match as just a word without its required action.
- Gives the relevant stop-and-tell action.
- Explains the need to read context rather than rely on the keyword.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Match 1
Classroom example: Return borrowed games before the final bell.
Match 2
Select Return to menu to leave the digital game page.
Match 3
The school story describes a sailor’s return home.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each search result for return to its meaning.
Complete or match: Match 1; Match 2; Match 3
- a: Give borrowed items back
- b: Navigate to a menu
- c: Come home after a journey
The same word has different functions; surrounding text identifies the relevant borrowing rule.
2B · Short answer
Why does Match 1 answer a game-loan question but Match 2 not answer it?
Example of a full-credit answer: Match 1 gives a deadline for giving borrowed games back. Match 2 is a navigation command on a digital page, not a loan rule.
- Explains Match 1’s borrowing meaning.
- Distinguishes Match 2’s menu-navigation meaning.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Travel guide
Classroom example: Bicycles may be left in the marked rack beside the east gate. Walking visitors use the main gate. Keep emergency exits clear.
Search attempt
A pupil uses a short informal name for a bicycle and finds no exact match in the travel guide.
3A · True or false
The empty search proves that the guide gives no bicycle-parking information.
- true: True
- false: False
The guide uses bicycles rather than bike. A different term can locate the relevant sentence.
3B · Open ended
Propose a better search and give the parking information it should locate.
Example of a full-credit answer: Search bicycles or rack. The guide says bicycles may be left in the marked rack beside the east gate.
- Proposes a relevant term actually present in the guide.
- Retrieves the correct rack/east-gate information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
General rule
Classroom example: Visitors usually enter through the main door.
Event exception
For the evening concert, visitors enter through the side door beside the hall.
Search error
A reader searches enter, reads only the first match and tells concert visitors to use the main door.
4A · Hotspot
Select the passage the reader missed that corrects the concert advice.
- a: Visitors usually enter through the main door.
- b: For the evening concert, visitors enter through the side door beside the hall.
- c: A reader searched for enter.
The event-specific exception overrides the usual route for this concert.
4B · Short answer
Explain why the first search match was not enough.
Example of a full-credit answer: The first match gives the usual rule, but the question concerns the evening concert. The later match gives the specific side-door exception for that event.
- Distinguishes the general rule from the event-specific case.
- Uses the correct side-door exception.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Document task
Classroom example: A pupil must find whether a wet library book should go on the normal returns shelf. The document uses damp, water damage and help desk in different sections.
Routine goal
The search should handle a failed first term and should check the full rule before the pupil acts.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose a sensible search step for each situation.
Complete or match: First attempt; If wet has no match; Before acting on a match
- a: Search a distinctive relevant word.
- b: Try damp or water damage.
- c: Read the surrounding rule and its conditions.
- d: Assume the rule does not exist.
A useful search routine starts relevantly, revises wording and checks context.
5B · Open ended
Propose a short search plan that includes both an alternative term and a context check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Search wet, then try damp or water damage if needed. Read the matching section to learn the required action and check whether the normal returns rule has an exception.
- Includes a useful alternative search term.
- Includes reading the surrounding instruction/exception before acting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.7 · Constructing effective search queries
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Choose topic and need
Information need
Rafi wants instructions for repairing a loose wheel on a small toy cart. He does not need pictures of real delivery vehicles or advertisements for new toys.
Question: What focused search query could he try?
Answer: Toy cart loose wheel repair instructions.
Why: The query names the object, the problem and the kind of help required. A single word such as cart is much broader. Search results still need checking; clear query words improve the starting point without guaranteeing that every result will be useful or correct.
Example 2 · Resolve two meanings
First search
Searching for bat care shows results about both sports equipment and flying animals.
Actual need
Lina needs instructions for cleaning a wooden sports bat.
Question: How can Lina make the query clearer?
Answer: She can try cleaning wooden sports bat.
Why: Wooden and sports identify the intended object, while cleaning names the action. Adding unrelated favourite colours would not fix the two-meaning problem. Inspect the new results and adjust again if they still concern animal care or a different material.
Example 3 · Search without assuming the answer
Question
The class wants to compare paper bags and cloth bags for carrying its library books. Pupils have not yet tested which works better for their needs.
Question: Which is a fairer query: “why paper bags are always best” or “paper cloth bags carrying books comparison”?
Answer: The comparison query is fairer because it asks about both materials and the actual task.
Why: The first query builds a conclusion into the search before evidence is examined. A useful query can name the options and relevant purpose without declaring a winner. After searching, the class should still read the evidence and its conditions.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Search for the actual repair
Need
A pupil wants instructions for fixing a torn paper kite, not for buying a new one.
Guide preview
Kite repair guide: patching tears in paper coverings.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which query most closely matches the pupil’s need?
- a: paper kite tear repair instructions
- b: colourful kite festival photo collection
- c: new kite prices delivery tomorrow
- d: famous kite shapes around cities
The first query names paper kites, tears and repair instructions. The others target photographs, shopping or shapes.
Source explorer: query lab
F2 · Choose keywords for three needs
Need A
Find when the school garden opens on Saturday.
Need B
Find how to fold a paper envelope.
Need C
Find the rules for borrowing a class camera.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each need to its focused keyword group.
Complete or match: Need A; Need B; Need C
- a: class camera borrowing rules
- b: paper envelope folding steps
- c: school garden Saturday opening hours
Each query combines the main topic with the requested action, rule or time.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · A longer query is not always better
Need
Find the school chess club’s meeting day.
Proposed addition
A pupil adds favourite red shoes to the query, although shoes have no connection to the question.
F3 · True or false
Adding favourite red shoes makes this query more focused on the meeting day.
- true: True
- false: False
The extra words are unrelated. Useful detail, not length alone, makes a query focused.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Clarify a word with two meanings
Need A
Find how to clean a computer mouse.
Need B
Find what a pet mouse can eat.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each query with the useful clarifying word.
Complete or match: ___ mouse cleaning guide; pet mouse ___ guide
- a: food
- b: computer
- c: cloud
Computer identifies the device; food identifies the feeding question about an animal.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · Build a query and explain a word
Need
A pupil wants the opening time of the school library on Saturday. The ordinary Monday timetable may be different.
F5 · Short answer
Write a focused query and explain why one of its words is important.
Example of a full-credit answer: School library Saturday opening hours. Saturday matters because the pupil needs that day’s hours, which may differ from Monday’s.
- Proposes a query containing the school library, Saturday and opening time/hours or equivalent focused terms.
- Explains how a relevant term narrows the search, such as Saturday selecting the needed day rather than weekday hours.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: word lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Question A
Classroom example: What does a caterpillar eat?
Question B
When does the community library open on Saturday?
Question C
How can we fold a paper envelope?
1A · Matching
Match each question to the most useful query.
Complete or match: Question A; Question B; Question C
- a: community library Saturday opening hours
- b: paper envelope folding steps
- c: caterpillar food
Each query combines the topic with the information needed, avoiding unrelated broad terms.
1B · Short answer
Choose one query and explain the jobs of two of its key words.
Example of a full-credit answer: In caterpillar food, caterpillar names the animal and food names the information needed. That is more focused than animals.
- Identifies the topic function of a chosen query term.
- Identifies the information-need function of another term.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Need
Classroom example: The class wants instructions for making a paper windmill that does not need a pin. They are not searching for large electricity-generating windmills.
Word tiles
paper; windmill; no pin; electricity prices; instructions. Choose words that preserve the material, object and constraint.
2A · Drag and drop
Drag the best word group to each query role.
Complete or match: Material and object; Safety/design constraint; Type of information
- a: paper windmill
- b: no pin
- c: instructions
- d: electricity prices
These groups specify the craft, constraint and need for a procedure; electricity prices concern another meaning.
2B · Open ended
Write a useful query and explain why no pin belongs in it.
Example of a full-credit answer: paper windmill no pin instructions. No pin is a required design constraint, so it helps avoid instructions that depend on a pin.
- Writes a query containing paper windmill and instructions or equivalent.
- Explains how no pin represents the actual constraint.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New need
Classroom example: Find the time and place of the fictional Green Street seed swap this Saturday. A general page about seeds does not answer this event question.
Local source cards
Green Street seed swap — Saturday, covered court, 9:00. Seed growth guide — sunlight and water. Green Street history — old photographs.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all query elements that help target the event information.
- a: Green Street seed swap
- b: Saturday time place
- c: all plants in the world
- d: old photographs only
The event name and schedule/location terms target the needed information. The others shift the topic.
3B · Short answer
Explain why seed alone is less useful than the event name, and identify one detail to check in a result.
Example of a full-credit answer: Seed alone could find growing guides. Green Street seed swap targets the event; I would check that the result gives the correct Saturday time or place.
- Explains why the broad seed term can retrieve unrelated information.
- Names a relevant result check such as event identity, day, time or place.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Search attempt
Classroom example: A pupil wants the animal’s sleeping place but searches mouse house. Results include computer accessories and a toy house.
Relevant classroom source
Wood mouse shelter: wood mice make nests in sheltered places such as ground burrows. This is a source about the animal.
4A · Multiple choice
Which revised query most clearly keeps the intended meaning?
- a: mouse computer repair
- b: wood mouse animal shelter
- c: house colour
- d: prove every mouse lives in a computer
Animal and wood mouse clarify the living creature; shelter names the needed information.
4B · Open ended
Describe the ambiguity and how the revised words reduce it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mouse can mean an animal or a computer device. Adding animal or wood mouse removes that confusion, and shelter keeps the search focused on its living place.
- Identifies the animal/computer ambiguity.
- Explains the clarifying and information-focus roles of the revised query.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Project question
Classroom example: The class wants to compare paper and cloth gift bags for repeated use. They need evidence about durability and number of uses.
Draft query
“Why paper bags are always the best and cloth bags are bad.”
5A · True or false
The draft query is a fair way to investigate both bag types.
- true: True
- false: False
It assumes a conclusion and asks for one-sided agreement rather than a comparison using relevant evidence.
5B · Short answer
Propose a more balanced query and name one useful comparison criterion.
Example of a full-credit answer: paper cloth gift bags repeated use durability comparison. A useful criterion is how many uses each bag survives under similar conditions.
- Proposes a query that includes both bag types without a predetermined winner.
- Names a relevant comparable criterion such as durability or repeated uses.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.8 · Selecting relevant search results
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Match the purpose, not just a keyword
Need
Find simple steps for repairing a loose button on a school shirt.
Result A
Shirt button repair: a beginner’s step-by-step guide.
Result B
School shirt sale: new colours and prices.
Result C
A story about a magical button.
Question: Which result is the best first place to read?
Answer: Result A, because its preview offers beginner repair steps for a shirt button.
Why: All the results include a related word, but only A matches the needed action and level. The choice is a starting point. The full guide must still be read to check its instructions and any adult-help requirements.
Example 2 · A place and a date can matter
Need
Find this term’s programme for the neighbourhood reading centre.
Result A
Neighbourhood reading centre: this term’s session programme.
Result B
A different town’s reading centre programme.
Result C
Neighbourhood reading centre: an archived programme from last year.
Question: Why is Result A the most relevant starting point?
Answer: It matches both the correct centre and the current term.
Why: Result B has the wrong place, while C has the wrong period. Similar titles can describe different events. Check these conditions before reading for details, and confirm them again on the full page rather than assuming a preview is complete.
Example 3 · A preview can leave out a limit
Search preview
Weekend art session — free entry.
Full-page note
Free entry applies to the drawing demonstration. The materials workshop requires advance registration.
Question: Does the preview establish free access to every part of the event?
Answer: No. The full page limits free entry to the demonstration and gives a separate workshop condition.
Why: A short preview helps select a page but may omit important distinctions. Read the full source before acting. The best result selection is followed by checking the exact event, activity and conditions that match the question.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose a result for each need
Result A
Paper boat folding: clear steps for beginners.
Result B
Paper boat race results: winners from last year.
Result C
Community boat museum: visiting hours this month.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Choose the result that best matches each need.
Complete or match: Learn to fold a paper boat: ___; Find the museum’s visiting hours: ___
- a: Result B
- b: Result C
- c: Result A
Folding instructions and museum visiting hours are different information needs.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Match this week’s event
Need
Find the time of this week’s Saturday puppet show at the town library.
Results
One listing is current and names the town library. Other results concern a school play, an archived library show or making puppets.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which result should be read first?
- a: School play timetable for next month
- b: Town library puppet show this Saturday
- c: Archived town library puppet show last year
- d: Making sock puppets with scrap material
The second title matches the event, location and requested Saturday.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Position is not relevance
Need
Find instructions for caring for a borrowed class tablet.
Results
The first result advertises a new tablet. A later result is the class tablet care guide.
F3 · True or false
The first result must be the most relevant because it appears first.
- true: True
- false: False
The care guide matches the task. A shopping advertisement can appear first without answering the care question.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Notice the reason for rejection
Need
Find beginner instructions for making a paper lantern.
Result A
Advanced metal-lantern welding.
Result B
Beginner paper-lantern instructions.
Result C
Photos of lanterns at a festival.
F4 · Matching
Match each result to the best description.
Complete or match: Result A; Result B; Result C
- a: Matches the practical beginner need
- b: Shows images but not instructions
- c: Uses the wrong material and skill level
B matches paper and beginner instructions. A concerns advanced metal work, while C offers photographs.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Choose and check a result
Need
Find the borrowing deadline for a costume from the school drama cupboard.
Result A
Drama cupboard borrowing rules — return dates and care.
Result B
History of famous theatre costumes.
Result C
New costume shop opening sale.
F5 · Open ended
Which result would you open first, and what would you check on the full page?
Example of a full-credit answer: I would open Result A because it offers the school cupboard’s return rules. I would read the actual deadline and any condition that applies to the borrowed costume.
- Selects Result A because it matches the school cupboard’s borrowing/return rules.
- Says to check the actual return deadline and applicable conditions on the full page rather than treating the title as the answer.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: source tabs
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Need
Classroom example: A pupil needs steps for repairing a loose book-cover corner with teacher-approved materials.
Result A
Library care guide: how to mend a loose cover corner; includes materials and illustrated steps.
Result B
Classroom book-care video transcript: repairing small cover damage with an adult helper.
Results C and D
C: The history of famous book covers. D: Discount posters showing colourful books.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all results most directly relevant to the repair task.
- a: Result A: repair guide with steps
- b: Result B: repair transcript with adult help
- c: Result C: history of cover designs
- d: Result D: book posters for sale
A and B provide practical repair information. C and D mention books but serve different purposes.
1B · Open ended
Explain why a result can contain book cover and still be irrelevant to this repair.
Example of a full-credit answer: The history result discusses designs over time rather than repair steps. Matching words alone does not guarantee the instructions the pupil needs.
- Identifies the topic-word overlap.
- Explains the mismatch between design history and repair instructions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Result 1
Classroom example: Community library opening hours, including weekend times.
Result 2
How to renew a borrowed library book, with step-by-step instructions.
Result 3
A map showing the library entrance and nearby bus stop.
2A · Matching
Match each need to its best result.
Complete or match: Find a Sunday visiting time; Extend a book loan; Locate the entrance
- a: Result 1
- b: Result 2
- c: Result 3
Each result addresses a different practical question about the same library.
2B · Short answer
Why is there no single best result for every library question?
Example of a full-credit answer: The useful result depends on the need. Opening hours answer when, renewal instructions answer how to extend a loan, and the map answers where.
- States that relevance depends on the question.
- Illustrates with at least two correct need-result relationships.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Question
Classroom example: Where will the fictional Riverside story walk meet this Sunday?
Result A
Riverside story walk — this Sunday: meeting point at the east footbridge.
Result B
Riverside story walk — last year: photographs from the old playground meeting point.
Result C
Riverside café: weekend menu and prices.
3A · Hotspot
Select the result that directly matches the event and day in the question.
- a: This Sunday: story-walk meeting point at east footbridge.
- b: Last year: photos at old playground meeting point.
- c: Café weekend menu and prices.
The current Sunday event result matches both event identity and timing. Last year’s photos may describe a different arrangement.
3B · Open ended
Explain why last year’s result should not determine this Sunday’s meeting place.
Example of a full-credit answer: It describes an earlier event and an old meeting point. The current Sunday result specifically names the east footbridge, so the dated context matters.
- Identifies the old result’s date/context mismatch.
- Uses the current result’s relevant meeting detail.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Three research needs
Classroom example: Need 1: learn what an index does. Need 2: find a bus timetable. Need 3: understand how a seed opens.
Results chosen carelessly
A pupil chose an index-card shop, a bus-colouring page and a seed advertisement because each title repeated a keyword.
Useful alternatives
A reading guide explains indexes; a transport page lists departure times; a science page explains germination with diagrams.
4A · Drag and drop
Replace each weak choice with a purpose-matched result.
Complete or match: What an index does; Bus departure times; How a seed opens
- a: Reading guide explaining indexes
- b: Transport timetable
- c: Science explanation of germination
These choices match the required explanation or schedule, not just a repeated word.
4B · Short answer
Explain the common error behind the three original choices.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil chose matching keywords without checking the result’s purpose. A shop, colouring page and advertisement do not necessarily explain the requested ideas or give a timetable.
- Identifies keyword-only selection.
- Explains a concrete mismatch between an original result and its need.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Project
Classroom example: A class wants a child-friendly explanation of why the Moon seems to change shape. Results include an illustrated explanation, a poster shop and a poem about moonlight.
Selection goal
The chosen result should explain the phenomenon with understandable text and diagrams, not merely mention the Moon.
5A · Multiple choice
Which rule best guides the first selection?
- a: Always choose the brightest picture.
- b: Choose the first result without reading its preview.
- c: Look for an explanation of Moon phases with suitable text and diagrams.
- d: Choose only pages selling something.
The rule matches the information need and intended reader. Appearance or position alone cannot do that.
5B · Open ended
Propose two checks to make after opening the selected explanation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check that it actually explains the changing appearance rather than only showing pictures. Then check whether the labels and language are understandable and whether it names a useful source for its explanation.
- Checks that the full content answers the phenomenon question.
- Adds a relevant usability or source-quality check rather than relying on ranking.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.9 · Distinguishing relevant from irrelevant information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Use the question as a filter
Question
What does a pupil need to bring to the clay session?
Notice
The clay session is in Room 5. Bring an apron and a shallow tray. The room has yellow walls. The teacher’s sample is a small bird.
Question: Which details belong in the answer?
Answer: Bring an apron and a shallow tray.
Why: The question asks for required materials, so the material list is directly relevant. The room, walls and sample may be true, but they answer different questions. Selecting relevant information means fitting the task, not deciding that other details are false.
Example 2 · One fact can serve a different task
Notice
The singing group meets at 3 p.m. in the hall. The hall has two entrances. The group’s poster shows a smiling sun.
Question: Is 3 p.m. relevant to “When does the group meet?” and “What picture is on the poster?”
Answer: It is relevant to the meeting-time question, but not to the poster-picture question.
Why: Relevance changes with the question. Keep the same fact and test whether it answers the current need. A useful reading habit is to restate the task before collecting details, especially when a notice contains several kinds of information.
Example 3 · A condition can be essential
Question
Can a pupil borrow the display camera today?
Rule
Pupils may borrow the camera only with the teacher’s permission. The camera case is blue, and a strap is attached.
Question: Which detail is essential for answering the question?
Answer: The teacher’s permission is required.
Why: Only introduces a condition for borrowing, so it directly affects the answer. The blue case and strap do not establish permission. An eye-catching description may be less useful than a small word that changes what someone is allowed to do.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Pick the needed material
Question
What must a participant bring to the bookmark workshop?
Notice
Bring a ruler. The session is in Room 8. The organiser wears a red badge. The display has six sample bookmarks.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which detail directly answers the question?
- a: The session is in Room 8.
- b: A ruler must be brought along.
- c: The organiser has a red badge.
- d: Six sample bookmarks are displayed.
The question asks what to bring. A ruler answers that need; the other details concern location, appearance or display.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Match facts to useful questions
Notice
The collage session begins at 1 p.m. in Room 3. Participants bring old magazines.
F2 · Matching
Match each fact with the question it answers.
Complete or match: 1 p.m.; Room 3; Old magazines
- a: What should participants bring?
- b: Where is the session?
- c: When does the session begin?
Time, location and materials answer different question words.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Find the relevant condition
Task
Decide whether Kai may borrow a board game today.
Notes
Kai has a school pass. Borrowers must show a school pass. The cupboard handle is silver.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the rule needed for this decision.
- a: Borrowers must show a school pass.
- b: The cupboard handle is silver.
- c: Board games are stored in a cupboard.
The pass requirement is relevant because Kai has a pass. The handle’s appearance does not decide permission.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Select notes for a route question
Question
How can a visitor reach the new art display from the gate?
Notes
Follow the signs along the left path. Turn right at the hall. The display contains twelve pictures. Some frames are green.
F4 · Multiple answers
Select all notes relevant to explaining the route.
- a: Follow signs along the left path.
- b: Turn right at the hall.
- c: The display contains twelve pictures.
- d: Some picture frames are green.
The path and turn provide directions. Picture counts and frame colours do not explain the route.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Keep a deadline reminder focused
Task
Write a reminder about when and where borrowed costumes must be returned.
Deadline
Return costumes by Thursday noon.
Destination
Put them in the drama cupboard.
Decoration
The cupboard door has a star sticker.
Play history
The last play had five scenes.
F5 · Short answer
Write the two useful return details, name one detail you would leave out, and explain why you would leave it out.
Example of a full-credit answer: Return costumes by Thursday noon to the drama cupboard. I would leave out the star sticker because it does not change the deadline or destination.
- Includes both Thursday noon and the drama cupboard as the required return details.
- Identifies an irrelevant detail, such as the star sticker or five-scene play, and explains that it does not answer when/where to return.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Question
Classroom example: Can our group visit the library on Saturday morning, and where should we meet?
Facts
The library opens Saturday at 9:00. Groups meet at the side entrance. The front wall is orange. The librarian enjoys painting in her free time.
1A · Matching
Sort the facts by their job in this question.
Complete or match: Saturday opening at 9:00; Groups meet at side entrance; The front wall is orange
- a: Helps answer when we can visit
- b: Helps answer where to meet
- c: Does not answer this visit-planning question
Time and meeting place address the question. Wall colour does not determine either.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the wall colour can be true but unnecessary here.
Example of a full-credit answer: It may accurately describe the library, but the group needs opening time and meeting place. Wall colour does not answer those parts of the question.
- Distinguishes truth from relevance.
- Connects the exclusion to the specific timing/location task.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Question
Classroom example: Which room is suitable for a quiet read-aloud recording?
Room notes
Room A has closed windows and little background noise. Room B has a busy fan and traffic noise. Room A has a purple notice board. Room B contains six blue chairs.
2A · Multiple choice
Which detail is most relevant to the question?
- a: The notice board is purple.
- b: The chairs are blue.
- c: Room A has little background noise.
- d: Both rooms have names.
Background noise directly affects a quiet recording. Colour and labels do not establish quietness.
2B · Open ended
Explain one detail you would keep and one you would leave out.
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep the little-background-noise detail because the task is recording sound. Leave out the purple board because its colour does not affect the noise described.
- Selects and justifies a relevant acoustic detail.
- Selects and explains an irrelevant appearance detail.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Task
Classroom example: Write a reminder telling pupils when to return borrowed costumes.
Notice line A
Return costumes by Friday afternoon.
Notice line B
The costume rack has wooden hangers.
Notice line C
The stage curtain is green.
3A · Hotspot
Select the line that belongs in the deadline reminder.
- a: Return costumes by Friday afternoon.
- b: The rack has wooden hangers.
- c: The stage curtain is green.
Only the first line supplies the requested return deadline.
3B · Short answer
What other kind of detail could make this reminder more useful, and why?
Example of a full-credit answer: The return location or person to give the costumes to would help pupils act on the deadline. They would know both when and where to return them.
- Proposes a relevant action detail such as return place/person.
- Explains how it helps pupils complete the return.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Task
Classroom example: Make a reading note about where the class emergency torch is stored and how to report that it is missing. This is a fictional organisation task.
Source details
The torch is in the labelled cupboard by the door. Tell the teacher if it is missing. The cupboard was painted last year. The class pet is named Dot.
Weak note
“Dot is our pet, and the cupboard was painted last year.”
4A · Drag and drop
Place the details into useful and unrelated roles.
Complete or match: Storage location; Action if missing; Unrelated detail
- a: Labelled cupboard by the door
- b: Tell the teacher
- c: The class pet is named Dot
The task asks where and what to do if missing. The pet detail does not address either.
4B · Open ended
Rewrite the weak note with the two requested pieces of information.
Example of a full-credit answer: The emergency torch is in the labelled cupboard by the door. If it is missing, tell the teacher.
- Gives the precise stated storage location.
- Gives the stated reporting action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Research goal
Classroom example: Find out which part of the lunch queue causes delays. Pupils can ask about time waiting, where the queue stops and what happens at the serving table.
Draft question
“What colour is your favourite school bag?”
5A · True or false
The draft question is relevant to finding where lunch-queue delays occur.
- true: True
- false: False
A favourite bag colour does not locate or explain queue delays.
5B · Short answer
Propose two relevant questions that examine different parts of the delay problem.
Example of a full-credit answer: Where does the queue stop most often? How long do you usually wait at the serving table? One locates the blockage, and the other measures waiting at a particular stage.
- Proposes a relevant question about where or when delay occurs.
- Proposes a different relevant question about duration, process or cause.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R2.10 · Locating information across several sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Collect different pieces
Programme
The puppet-making activity starts at 10 a.m. in the craft room.
Location guide
The craft room is beside the main hall.
Materials note
Participants bring one clean sock.
Question: What does a visitor need to know to attend prepared?
Answer: Go to the craft room beside the main hall for the 10 a.m. activity, bringing one clean sock.
Why: The programme supplies time and room, the location guide explains where that room is, and the materials note supplies what to bring. Keep each fact attached to its source while combining them so that one missing piece is not filled by a guess.
Example 2 · Check that documents belong together
Programme A
Current term: story performance on Thursday in the hall.
Programme B
Last term: story performance on Tuesday in the garden.
Question
Where is this term’s story performance?
Question: Should the two programmes be combined into one event description?
Answer: No. This term’s performance is in the hall; the other programme describes last term.
Why: The event name is similar, but the time labels differ. Combining Thursday from one document with the garden from another would create an event that neither source describes. Check dates, versions and labels before joining facts.
Example 3 · Notice a missing part
Notice
The art centre offers a guided tour on Saturday.
Map
The art centre is beside the community hall.
Booking note
Reserve a place through the school office.
Question: Do these sources tell us the tour’s starting time?
Answer: No. They give a day, a location and a booking route, but no starting time.
Why: Several sources do not automatically make an answer complete. Break the question into needed facts and check whether each has a source. The next step is to ask for the missing time, rather than copy an unrelated number or assume a usual schedule.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find a fact in the right source
Programme
The model workshop starts at 9:30 a.m.
Room map
The model workshop uses Room 2, beside the stairs.
Materials card
Bring a small cardboard base.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Choose the source that answers each question.
Complete or match: When does it start? ___; Where is the room? ___; What should I bring? ___
- a: Materials card
- b: Programme
- c: Room map
The programme supplies time, the map supplies location, and the card supplies materials.
Source explorer: network
F2 · Combine only current-event facts
Current notice
This term’s drawing walk meets at Gate 1 on Friday.
Current kit list
For this term’s drawing walk, bring a pencil and a clipboard.
Archived notice
Last term’s drawing walk met at Gate 3 on Monday.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select all facts for this term’s drawing walk.
- a: Meet at Gate 1 on Friday.
- b: Bring a pencil and clipboard.
- c: Meet at Gate 3 on Monday.
- d: Use last term’s meeting place.
The first two sources explicitly describe this term. The archived place and day belong to a different event.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Know what two sources do not supply
Notice
The mosaic session is on Wednesday.
Room list
Mosaic sessions use the craft room.
Question
What time does the Wednesday mosaic session begin?
F3 · True or false
The two sources establish the Wednesday mosaic session’s starting time.
- true: True
- false: False
They give the day and room, but neither gives a starting time.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Locate the condition source
Schedule
The visit begins at 8 a.m.
Map
The entrance is beside the covered court.
Permission note
A signed permission slip must be shown before joining the visit.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the source that identifies the required permission document.
- a: Schedule: begins at 8 a.m.
- b: Map: entrance beside covered court
- c: Permission note: signed slip required
The permission note names the signed document. Time and location do not establish that requirement.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · Build a complete plan from two notices
Session programme
The weaving demonstration starts at 11 a.m. in Room 9.
Entrance note
Room 9 is reached through the courtyard doorway, not the main hall.
Materials note
Visitors need no materials because this session is a demonstration.
F5 · Open ended
When should a visitor attend, and which doorway should the visitor use? Name the source for each fact.
Example of a full-credit answer: Attend the 11 a.m. demonstration, as stated in the programme. Use the courtyard doorway, as stated in the entrance note.
- States 11 a.m. and attributes it to the session programme.
- States the courtyard doorway and attributes it to the entrance note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Event notice
Classroom example: The paper-art workshop takes place in the craft room and begins at 10:00 on Saturday. Registered pupils should arrive ten minutes early.
Building map
The craft room is Room 6 beside the east stairs. The office is Room 1 near the main entrance.
Materials list
Bring a clean cardboard tube and a pencil. Scissors will be supplied.
1A · Hotspot
Select the source region that answers where the craft room is.
- a: Workshop begins at 10:00 on Saturday.
- b: Craft room: Room 6 beside the east stairs.
- c: Bring a cardboard tube and a pencil.
The map gives room and position. The other sources supply time and materials.
1B · Open ended
Combine the relevant sources to state where to go and when to arrive.
Example of a full-credit answer: Go to Room 6 beside the east stairs and arrive at 9:50 on Saturday, ten minutes before the 10:00 workshop.
- Gives the map’s correct room and location.
- Gives the correct arrival time/day based on the notice.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Library schedule
Classroom example: The story session starts at 2:00 and ends at 2:40 on Friday.
Library map
The story room is upstairs beside the picture-book shelf.
Booking note
Families should reserve seats by Thursday. Entry to this session is free.
2A · Matching
Match each information need to its source.
Complete or match: Session finish time; Room location; Reservation deadline
- a: Library schedule
- b: Library map
- c: Booking note
The documents have different purposes; matching each need avoids confusing time, place and booking rules.
2B · Short answer
Explain why the schedule alone cannot fully plan a family’s visit.
Example of a full-credit answer: It gives session times but not the room location or Thursday reservation deadline. The family needs the map and booking note too.
- Identifies at least one needed fact absent from the schedule.
- Names the source that supplies that missing fact.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Volunteer notice
Classroom example: The fictional Garden Helpers event is on Saturday from 8:30 to 10:00. Meet at the south gate.
Equipment note
For Garden Helpers, bring a hat and a refillable water bottle. Shared hand tools will be provided.
Access note
The south gate path is open this Saturday. The north path is closed for repairs.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each fact in the volunteer reminder.
Complete or match: Meeting place; Personal item to bring; Path to avoid
- a: South gate
- b: Refillable water bottle
- c: North path
- d: Own power tools
The notice, equipment note and access note each contribute a different required detail.
3B · Open ended
Write a short reminder using one fact from each source.
Example of a full-credit answer: Meet at the south gate at 8:30 on Saturday. Bring a hat and refillable water bottle; use the south path because the north path is closed.
- Includes an accurate event time/place and an equipment detail.
- Includes the correct access restriction from the access note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
This year’s notice
Classroom example: The 2026 class story fair meets in the covered court on 14 November.
Old programme
The 2025 story fair used the garden stage and included a puppet show.
Current transport note
For the 2026 story fair, the school walking group meets at the main gate at 8:15.
4A · Dropdown selection
Choose facts that belong in the 2026 plan.
Complete or match: Event location; Event date; Walking-group meeting
- a: Covered court
- b: 14 November
- c: Main gate at 8:15
- d: Garden stage
The current notice and transport note refer to 2026. The garden-stage fact belongs to the old programme.
4B · Short answer
Explain the error in using the old programme’s location with the current transport note.
Example of a full-credit answer: The programme describes 2025, while the transport note is for 2026. Mixing them creates a plan with last year’s location even though this year’s notice names the covered court.
- Identifies the differing years/versions.
- Explains the wrong-location result and gives the current location.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Event schedule
Classroom example: The nature drawing session starts at 9:30 in the park shelter.
Bus timetable
The bus reaches Park Stop at 9:10. The timetable does not show how long it takes to walk from the stop to the shelter.
Planning goal
The class needs a realistic arrival plan that includes the walk.
5A · True or false
These two sources prove the class will reach the shelter before the session begins.
- true: True
- false: False
The bus arrives before the session, but the walking time is missing. The sources do not prove timely arrival at the shelter.
5B · Open ended
Propose one further source or question and explain how it would complete the plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check a park map with walking distances or ask the organiser for the walking time from Park Stop to the shelter. That would show whether the twenty-minute gap is enough.
- Seeks relevant information about the stop-to-shelter walk.
- Explains how it tests whether the arrival gap is sufficient.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.1 · Inferring meaning that is not directly stated
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read the action as a clue
At the doorway
A few drops fell through a gap above the doorway. Lila tucked her library book inside her coat before stepping underneath. She took the book out again when she reached the dry corridor.
Question: Why did Lila probably put the book inside her coat?
Answer: She probably wanted to keep the book dry.
Why: The passage does not say her reason directly. The falling drops, the covered book and the dry corridor work together as clues. Keeping a book away from water explains her action. This is a supported inference, although Lila’s exact thoughts are not quoted.
Example 2 · Support a feeling without claiming certainty
Before the announcement
Rafi practised his first sentence three times behind the curtain. When his name was called, he took a deep breath and held his notes tightly. He then walked onto the platform.
Question: What feeling is reasonable to infer, and how certain should we be?
Answer: Rafi may feel nervous about speaking, but the passage does not prove exactly how he feels.
Why: Repeated practice, a deep breath and tightly held notes can support that inference. They do not prove that Rafi dislikes speaking or will make a mistake. Use words such as may or probably when the text supplies clues rather than a direct statement.
Example 3 · Separate a clue from an extra story
The missing marker
Mara reached into the marker box, looked at the empty space marked blue, and asked Ben, “Have you finished your sky yet?” Ben was drawing at the next desk.
Question: What can we reasonably infer about Mara’s question?
Answer: Mara probably thinks Ben may be using the blue marker and wants to find it.
Why: The empty blue space and Ben’s sky drawing connect to her question. The text does not prove that Ben took the marker without permission or plans to hide it. A helpful inference explains the clues while avoiding an invented story about someone’s motives.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A quick change of plan
Workshop scene
A puddle appeared below the jar on the art table. Tomas picked up a cloth and moved the paper sheets to a higher shelf. He had not started drawing.
F1 · Multiple choice
Why is Tomas probably moving the paper?
- a: He wants to keep the sheets dry.
- b: He plans to hide every sheet from friends.
- c: He thinks the shelf will draw for him.
- d: He has finished all the drawings already.
The puddle and the move to a higher shelf support protecting the paper from water. The other motives are not supported.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · Use more than one clue
Aya’s bag
Threads dangled from one end of Aya’s bag strap. When she lifted the strap, that end pulled away from the bag. Aya carried the bag underneath with both hands. A yellow badge was pinned to its side.
F2 · Multiple answers
Which two details support the inference that Aya is trying to stop the bag from falling?
- a: Threads dangle from the strap’s end.
- b: The strap pulls away when lifted.
- c: The bag has a yellow badge.
- d: Aya’s name contains three letters.
Loose threads and the separating strap suggest it cannot safely support the bag. A badge or a name does not explain the carrying choice.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Find the strongest social clue
At the bench
Lina had placed her bag on the only free part of a bench. A new pupil approached. Lina put her bag on the ground and patted the empty place beside her.
F3 · Hotspot
Which detail best supports the inference that Lina is inviting the pupil to sit?
- a: Lina owns a bag.
- b: A bench stands nearby.
- c: Lina pats the empty place beside her.
Patting the newly cleared space is a strong invitation clue. Owning a bag or being near a bench does not by itself show an invitation.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · Three kinds of statement
Original scene
Omar shook his empty water bottle. He looked towards the drinking-water station and joined its queue.
Reading reminder
A stated fact is printed directly. An inference uses clues. An unsupported guess adds something the text does not establish.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Classify each statement.
Complete or match: Omar’s bottle is empty. ___; Omar probably wants to refill his bottle. ___; Omar always forgets to drink at breakfast. ___
- a: Supported inference
- b: Unsupported guess
- c: Directly stated fact
The empty bottle is stated; looking at and joining the water-station queue supports refilling; breakfast habits are never given.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · An empty labelled seat
Before the play
Jori left the chair marked “Mika” empty beside him. Each time the classroom door opened, he looked up. He kept the programme for Mika on the empty chair.
F5 · Short answer
What is Jori probably expecting? Give two details from the scene that support your inference.
Example of a full-credit answer: Jori probably expects Mika to arrive and sit beside him. He keeps Mika’s labelled chair empty and looks towards the door each time it opens. Saving Mika’s programme is another useful clue.
- Infers that Jori is expecting or waiting for Mika to arrive or join him, without claiming certainty about an unsupported motive.
- Supports that inference with any two relevant details: Mika’s empty labelled chair, watching the opening door, or saving Mika’s programme.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: source tabs
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Story
Classroom example: At the door, Inez wiped her wet shoes on the mat. Drops fell from her closed umbrella. “That shower caught me halfway here,” she said.
Inference task
The story never directly says “Inez walked through rain”, but several details may support that idea.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all details that support the inference that Inez has just been out in rain.
- a: Her shoes are wet.
- b: Drops fall from her umbrella.
- c: Her coat is purple.
- d: She has lived there for ten years.
The wet shoes and dripping umbrella fit recent rain. Coat colour and years of residence are not stated.
1B · Short answer
State the inference and explain how the two clues work together.
Example of a full-credit answer: Inez has probably just been in rain. Wet shoes alone could come from a puddle, but the dripping umbrella and mention of a shower support the rain explanation.
- Gives the supported recent-rain inference.
- Connects at least two relevant clues rather than inventing details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Before the reading
Classroom example: Paolo reads the same short speech quietly three times. He pauses at two long words and tries them again.
When called
When his name is called, he takes a deep breath and carries his paper to the front. The text does not tell us his exact feeling.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the inference with suitable evidence and wording.
Complete or match: Paolo is probably trying to...; The strongest practice clue is...; How certain are we about his feelings?
- a: prepare to read the speech accurately
- b: he repeats the speech and difficult words
- c: his exact feeling is not directly stated
- d: he definitely hates every speech
His repeated reading supports preparation, but it does not establish a certain private feeling.
2B · Open ended
Why is “He is preparing” better supported than “He hates speeches”?
Example of a full-credit answer: Repeating the speech and difficult words shows preparation. Nothing says he hates speeches, and taking a breath can have several explanations.
- Uses the practice details to support preparation.
- Explains the lack of evidence for certain hatred.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New story
Classroom example: Lila moves a chair beside the tall cupboard, then stops. She looks at the teacher and asks for help reaching a box on the top shelf.
Possible inference
Lila recognises that she needs help to reach the box safely.
3A · True or false
The possible inference fits Lila’s actions better than “She has already taken the box down alone”.
- true: True
- false: False
She stops and asks for help. The passage does not describe her removing the box by herself.
3B · Short answer
Which actions support the inference, and what event should you avoid adding?
Example of a full-credit answer: Stopping and asking the teacher support needing help. I should not add that she has already climbed or removed the box alone, because the text does not say that.
- Uses stopping/asking as relevant evidence.
- Identifies an unsupported completed action to avoid adding.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Story
Classroom example: The class rabbit thumps once when a chair scrapes nearby. Arun lowers his voice and moves the chair more gently. The rabbit then sits quietly.
Overstatement
A reader says, “Arun knows every animal is always frightened by every chair.”
4A · Drag and drop
Match the statements to their status.
Complete or match: The chair scraped near the rabbit.; Arun may be trying to avoid disturbing this rabbit.; Every animal is always frightened by every chair.
- a: Directly stated event
- b: Reasonable limited inference
- c: Unsupported overstatement
The text supports a local inference about Arun’s response, not a universal animal rule.
4B · Open ended
Rewrite the overstatement as a careful inference and give its clue.
Example of a full-credit answer: Arun may be trying not to disturb the rabbit, because he lowers his voice and moves the chair more gently after the thump.
- Gives a limited plausible inference about this situation.
- Uses Arun’s changed behaviour as support.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Story opening
Classroom example: Mei checks the weather notice, puts a spare plastic cover in her bag and looks at her paper model.
Draft ending A
She hopes to protect the model during the trip.
Draft ending B
The model is definitely worth a million pesos.
Writing task
The writer wants to suggest protection from wet weather without stating Mei’s thought directly.
5A · Hotspot
Select the existing story region that would best connect with an added clue about protecting the model from rain.
- a: Mei checks the weather notice and packs a plastic cover.
- b: The model is definitely worth a million pesos.
- c: The bag might be any colour.
Weather information and a cover are relevant to protecting paper from rain. Value and colour are unsupported distractions.
5B · Short answer
Propose one new action that strengthens the protection inference, and explain the connection.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mei could wrap the paper model in the cover before stepping into the rain. Wrapping a paper object when rain begins supports the idea that she wants to keep it dry.
- Adds a plausible action linked to weather protection.
- Explains how that action supports the intended inference without claiming unrelated facts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.2 · Identifying cause and effect
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Explain how one event produces another
The display
The cardboard display leaned against a stand. Its lower clip came loose. Without that clip holding the bottom in place, the board slid down and covered part of the title.
Question: What caused the board to slide down?
Answer: The loose lower clip stopped holding the board in position.
Why: A cause helps explain why an effect happened. Here the passage supplies the link: the clip had held the bottom, and that support was lost. The hidden title is a later effect of the slide. Keep these steps connected instead of simply listing events in any order.
Example 2 · Follow a short cause chain
The shadow activity
A lamp shone on a screen. Pia placed an opaque cardboard star between the lamp and the screen. The card blocked some light, and a star-shaped shadow appeared on the screen.
Question: How did placing the card lead to the shadow?
Answer: The card blocked light from reaching part of the screen, so that part became a star-shaped shadow.
Why: The explanation needs a link between action and result. Saying “Pia moved the card, then a shadow appeared” gives only the order. The source explains why: the opaque card blocks light. Use that supplied mechanism to join the cause and effect.
Example 3 · Do not turn “after” into “because”
Two happenings
The classroom clock chimed at ten. A moment later, rain began outside. No one recorded any connection between the clock’s sound and the weather.
Question: Can we conclude that the clock caused the rain?
Answer: No. The passage gives a time order, but no evidence that the clock made the rain begin.
Why: An earlier event is not automatically a cause. The word later tells us when something happened, not why. A cause claim needs a connection supported by the source. Here it is fair to report both events while leaving the reason for the rain unexplained.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match causes to their effects
Pencil case
A piece of lining caught between the zip’s teeth, so the zip could not move.
Window shade
The lowered shade blocked the bright light that had been shining into Niko’s eyes.
Speaker cable
The cable was pulled from the music player, breaking the connection and stopping the speaker’s sound.
F1 · Drag and drop
Drag the effect to the cause that explains it.
Complete or match: Lining catches in the zip.; A shade blocks the bright light.; The speaker cable disconnects.
- a: The speaker stops producing the music.
- b: The zip cannot move along its track.
- c: Bright light stops shining in Niko’s eyes.
Each account supplies a direct connection: caught lining prevents movement, the shade blocks light, and the disconnected cable breaks the sound connection.
Source explorer: cause lab
F2 · A sequence with no tested cause
Observation 1
The lunch bell rang.
Observation 2
A drawing fell from the wall a few seconds later.
What was checked
No one checked the tape or tested whether the sound affected the drawing.
F2 · True or false
These observations prove that the lunch bell made the drawing fall.
- true: True
- false: False
The fall happened after the bell, but no connection was established. The tape or another cause could matter.
Source explorer: timeline
F3 · Choose the connected explanation
Outdoor sign
A gust pushed the light sign over. The helper attached two heavy weights to its base. The added weights held the base steady when the next similar gust arrived, and the sign stayed upright.
F3 · Multiple choice
Why did the sign stay upright in the second gust, according to the account?
- a: The sign was heavier at its top.
- b: The weights helped hold its base steady.
- c: The helper covered the whole sign in cloth.
- d: The next gust stopped before it reached the sign.
The account connects the extra weight at the base with greater stability. It does not say the wind disappeared or the sign changed material.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Find the link between action and result
Filling a cup
The cup was already full. Jun kept pouring. The extra water had no space inside the cup, so it flowed over the rim onto the tray.
F4 · Hotspot
Which detail explains why water flowed over the rim?
- a: Jun was holding the bottle.
- b: The extra water had no space inside the full cup.
- c: A tray was below the cup.
The cup was full, so additional water could not remain inside it. The tray catches the result but does not cause the overflow.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Explain a blocked outlet
Usual condition
Water enters a shallow tray slowly and leaves through a small outlet hole. When the hole is open, the water level stays low.
Changed condition
A leaf covers the outlet hole. Water continues to enter, but the leaf prevents water from leaving. The water level rises.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the cause-and-effect chain from the leaf covering the hole to the rising water level. Use two connected steps.
Example of a full-credit answer: The leaf blocks the outlet, so water cannot leave through the hole. Water keeps entering while it cannot leave, so it collects in the tray and the level rises.
- Explains that the leaf covering the outlet prevents or reduces water leaving the tray.
- Connects continued incoming water with accumulating water and a rising level while the outlet is blocked.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Observation
Classroom example: The group painted one side of a thin paper sheet with watery paint. That side became wet and the sheet curled as it dried. An unpainted comparison sheet stayed flat.
Explanation supplied
The classroom guide explains that uneven wetting and drying can make thin paper bend. This trial does not compare all paper types.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all details relevant to the supplied explanation of curling.
- a: Only one side was wetted with paint.
- b: The unpainted comparison sheet stayed flat.
- c: The painter wore a red shirt.
- d: Every paper type was tested.
Uneven wetting and the comparison sheet are relevant to the proposed cause. Shirt colour and an unperformed universal test are not.
1B · Open ended
Explain the proposed cause and keep the conclusion limited to the trial.
Example of a full-credit answer: Uneven wetting and drying of the painted sheet may explain its curling. The comparison stayed flat, but this trial alone does not show what every paper type would do.
- Connects uneven wetting/drying to curling.
- States an appropriate limitation of the single trial.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Classroom story
Classroom example: A box was left in front of the supply cupboard, so the door could not open fully. Because the door was blocked, the helpers could not reach the paper until the box was moved.
Task
Keep the blocking event, the door effect and the access effect distinct.
2A · Matching
Match each cause with its stated effect.
Complete or match: Box left in front of cupboard; Door cannot open fully; Box moved away
- a: Helpers can reach the paper again
- b: Door is blocked
- c: Helpers cannot reach the paper
The text gives a chain from obstruction to blocked opening to lost access, then describes removal.
2B · Short answer
Explain why moving the box is a better response than asking helpers to pull harder.
Example of a full-credit answer: The box is the stated obstruction. Removing it lets the door open, while pulling harder does not remove the cause and may damage something.
- Identifies the box as the cause of restricted opening.
- Explains why removing it addresses the access problem more directly.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New situation
Classroom example: A bottle’s cap is loose. When the bottle tips, water escapes around the cap and wets the table. The table is wiped, but the cap is still loose.
Goal
Choose actions that deal with both the cause and the visible effect.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each action beside what it addresses.
Complete or match: Stop the stated leak cause; Remove the water already on the table; Check whether the fix worked
- a: Tighten the cap correctly
- b: Wipe the table
- c: Tip the closed bottle carefully over a sink and observe
- d: Change the table colour
Tightening addresses the loose cap; wiping addresses existing water; observing a controlled check tests the repair.
3B · Open ended
Explain why wiping alone may not solve the problem.
Example of a full-credit answer: Wiping removes the spilled water, but the loose cap remains. If the bottle tips again, water can escape again.
- Distinguishes the wet table as an effect.
- Explains that the unchanged loose cap can produce the effect again.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Event record
Classroom example: At 10:00, a new poster was put up. At 10:05, the classroom clock stopped. The record contains no information connecting the poster to the clock.
Pupil’s claim
“The poster caused the clock to stop because it happened first.”
4A · Hotspot
Select the record statement that shows why the cause claim is not established.
- a: The poster was put up at 10:00.
- b: The clock stopped at 10:05.
- c: No information connects the poster to the clock.
The order is known, but the record supplies no causal connection.
4B · Short answer
Explain the error and name one kind of check that could investigate the clock’s cause.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats earlier as caused. Checking the clock’s battery or mechanism could investigate a relevant cause instead of assuming the poster did it.
- Explains that sequence alone does not establish cause.
- Proposes a relevant cause investigation rather than an unrelated guess.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Situation
Classroom example: A classroom seedling tray dries faster on a sunny windowsill than in a shaded corner. The class wants to investigate whether location is involved.
Planning note
Other conditions, such as tray size and starting water amount, could also affect drying. A useful comparison keeps those conditions alike.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose a planning component for each purpose.
Complete or match: Factor to compare; Condition to keep alike; Effect to record
- a: Sunny versus shaded location
- b: Starting water amount
- c: How quickly the trays dry
- d: Colour of the pupils’ shoes
A focused comparison changes location while controlling another relevant condition and records the drying effect.
5B · Open ended
Propose a fair comparison and explain how it would strengthen the cause claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use similar trays with equal starting water in sunny and shaded places, then record drying over the same period. Keeping other conditions alike helps test whether location contributes to the difference.
- Proposes a comparison with relevant conditions kept alike.
- Explains how recording the effect helps assess location rather than merely assuming causation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.3 · Identifying comparison and contrast
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Compare the same feature
Basket A
Basket A holds six small balls and has one handle.
Basket B
Basket B holds six small balls and has two handles.
Question: What is one similarity and one difference?
Answer: Both baskets hold six small balls. Basket A has one handle, while Basket B has two.
Why: Compare capacity with capacity and handles with handles. Comparing Basket A’s number of balls with Basket B’s number of handles would mix different features. A clear comparison names the shared feature before stating whether its values match or differ.
Example 2 · Keep “not stated” separate from “different”
Poster A
Saturday puppet show: 2 p.m., Hall 1. Admission is free.
Poster B
Saturday puppet show: 3 p.m., Hall 2. The poster gives no admission price.
Question: Can we say that the two shows have different admission prices?
Answer: No. Poster A says free, but Poster B does not state a price.
Why: We can compare the stated starting times and halls and see differences. We cannot compare two prices because only one is known. Missing information is not the same as a different value. We would need to check the second show’s price before making a price comparison.
Example 3 · Choose by a stated purpose
Folder A
Folder A is waterproof, holds ten sheets and fits inside a school bag.
Folder B
Folder B is not waterproof, holds thirty sheets and fits inside a school bag.
Task
Mina must carry eight sheets outside during light rain.
Question: Which folder better fits Mina’s stated task?
Answer: Folder A: it holds all eight sheets and is waterproof.
Why: Both folders fit inside the bag and have enough space for eight sheets. Waterproofing is the useful difference for this rainy trip. Folder B’s larger capacity might help with another task, but it does not make it the better choice for every purpose.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Spot a true contrast
Clay session
The clay session lasts forty minutes and takes place in Room 4.
Paper session
The paper session lasts forty minutes and takes place in Room 7.
F1 · Hotspot
Which statement correctly contrasts the two sessions?
- a: Both sessions last forty minutes.
- b: Clay uses Room 4, while paper uses Room 7.
- c: The clay session lasts longer than the paper session.
The rooms differ. Forty minutes is a shared duration, so it is a similarity, not a contrast.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Same, different or unknown?
Boat A
Boat A is made of folded paper. It is 12 centimetres long and was tested in a tray.
Boat B
Boat B is made of folded paper. It is 15 centimetres long. Its testing place is not stated.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Classify each comparison.
Complete or match: The boats’ material is ___.; Their stated lengths are ___.; Information about whether testing places match: ___
- a: Different
- b: Not enough information
- c: The same
Both are paper; 12 and 15 centimetres differ; only Boat A’s testing place is supplied.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Match the comparison to its feature
Notebook A
Notebook A has 40 pages, a green cover and dotted pages.
Notebook B
Notebook B has 60 pages, a green cover and lined pages.
F3 · Matching
Match each statement with the feature it compares.
Complete or match: Both covers are green.; A has 40; B has 60.; A is dotted; B is lined.
- a: Page pattern
- b: Number of pages
- c: Cover colour
The words cover, page totals, and dotted/lined identify three distinct features.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Choose for the actual need
Container A
This container holds eight markers and closes with a lid.
Container B
This container holds twelve markers and has no lid.
Need
Carry six markers in a bag without their falling out of the container.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which comparison best supports a choice for this task?
- a: A holds all six markers and has a closing lid.
- b: B is better because every task needs twelve markers.
- c: A is better because it holds more markers than B.
- d: B closes securely while A has no closing lid.
Both have enough capacity, but only A has a lid. The choice follows the stated need, not a claim that A is best for every task.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Two invitations
Invitation A
The mural workshop starts at 9 a.m. in Room 5. Bring a pencil. Helpers provide paper.
Invitation B
The collage workshop starts at 10 a.m. in Room 5. Bring a pencil. Helpers provide magazines.
F5 · Short answer
State one similarity and one difference between the two workshops. Compare the same feature in both sources.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both workshops are in Room 5 and ask visitors to bring a pencil. The mural workshop starts at 9 a.m., while the collage workshop starts at 10 a.m. Their supplied materials also differ: paper versus magazines.
- Gives an accurate similarity supported by both invitations: Room 5 or bringing a pencil.
- Gives a paired, accurate difference in starting time, workshop activity, or supplied materials, with the corresponding value for each workshop.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Space A
Classroom example: The garden bench has daylight and room for four readers. It has no roof, so it is not used during rain.
Space B
The covered veranda has daylight and room for four readers. A roof keeps the seats dry in ordinary rain.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all similarities explicitly stated for both spaces.
- a: They have daylight.
- b: They have room for four readers.
- c: Neither has a roof.
- d: Both are beside a pond.
Both descriptions state daylight and capacity for four. Their roof conditions differ, and a pond is not mentioned.
1B · Short answer
Explain which difference matters on a rainy day and why.
Example of a full-credit answer: The veranda has a roof while the garden bench does not. The roof keeps its seats dry, making it the stated usable option during ordinary rain.
- Identifies the roof/cover difference.
- Connects the difference to dry, usable seating during rain.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Guide A
Classroom example: The craft club lends tools only during its meetings. Tools must stay in the room.
Guide B
The drawing club lends sketchbooks for one week. Borrowers may take them home.
Shared point
Both clubs lend materials to members, but the lending arrangements differ.
2A · Hotspot
Select the paired detail that most directly shows the difference in where borrowed materials may be used.
- a: Craft tools stay in the room; drawing sketchbooks may go home.
- b: Both clubs lend materials.
- c: Both descriptions contain the word club.
The stay-in-room versus take-home contrast directly answers the location-of-use question.
2B · Open ended
Why is “both lend materials” accurate but insufficient for this question?
Example of a full-credit answer: It gives a similarity, not the requested difference in location. The relevant contrast is staying in the room versus taking materials home.
- Recognises the statement as a supported similarity.
- Supplies the specific contrast needed by the question.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Plan A
Classroom example: A museum group visits on Tuesday, starts at 9:00 and spends one hour in the display hall.
Plan B
A second group visits on Thursday, starts at 9:00 and spends ninety minutes in the display hall.
3A · Matching
Match each feature with the comparison it supports.
Complete or match: Start time; Visit day; Time in display hall
- a: Same: 9:00
- b: Different: Tuesday and Thursday
- c: Different: one hour and ninety minutes
Each comparison uses the same feature in both plans.
3B · Short answer
Explain why comparing Plan A’s Tuesday with Plan B’s ninety minutes would be unhelpful.
Example of a full-credit answer: Tuesday is a day and ninety minutes is a duration. They are different features, so they cannot show whether the plans share a day or have the same visit length.
- Identifies the different kinds of information.
- Explains that a useful comparison needs the same feature.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Text A
Classroom example: This backpack has two pockets and an adjustable strap.
Text B
This backpack has two pockets. The description does not mention its strap.
Wrong conclusion
“Only Backpack A has an adjustable strap, and the backpacks have different pocket counts.”
4A · Drag and drop
Classify each corrected statement.
Complete or match: Both have two pockets.; Backpack B’s strap feature is not stated.; Backpack A’s strap is adjustable.
- a: Supported similarity
- b: Missing information about B
- c: Stated feature of A
The pocket counts match. Silence about B’s strap does not establish that it is not adjustable.
4B · Open ended
Explain the two errors in the wrong conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: It treats B’s missing strap information as proof of no adjustable strap. It also claims different pocket counts even though both have two.
- Identifies missing-information versus absence error.
- Corrects the falsely claimed pocket-count difference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Task
Classroom example: A class wants a storage box that fits a low shelf and holds large paper sheets. Two boxes are available.
Plan
The pupils propose comparing only the colours, without checking height or paper space.
5A · True or false
Comparing only colour is enough to choose a box for the stated needs.
- true: True
- false: False
Colour does not show shelf fit or capacity for large sheets. Those dimensions must be compared for both boxes.
5B · Short answer
Propose two features to compare and explain how each connects to the goal.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare each box’s height with the shelf opening, and compare its inside length and width with the paper sheets. These checks address shelf fit and usable paper space.
- Chooses a relevant shelf-fit feature for both boxes.
- Chooses a relevant paper-capacity feature and connects it to the goal.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.4 · Recognising assumptions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Find the hidden “if”
The plan
There are twenty-seven pupils and a bus with thirty passenger seats. “Every pupil will have a seat,” says Dan. The note does not say whether any passenger seats are already reserved for other people.
Question: What is Dan assuming?
Answer: Dan assumes that at least twenty-seven of the seats are available for the pupils.
Why: Thirty seats sounds sufficient, but the conclusion needs a hidden condition: enough seats must actually be free for this group. An assumption is an unstated idea a plan relies on. Checking the available seats would test this assumption without deciding that Dan must be wrong.
Example 2 · A working file is not the whole plan
At home and at school
Miri saves her slides on a website. “I can show them at school without downloading a copy,” she says. The slides work on her home computer, but she has not checked the classroom connection.
Question: Which unstated condition does Miri’s plan depend on?
Answer: The classroom must be able to reach the website when she needs the slides.
Why: Success at home does not establish that the school connection will work. Miri may be right, but her plan depends on access that has not been checked. She can test the classroom connection or prepare a saved copy to reduce the effect of that uncertainty.
Example 3 · Do not guess what silence means
A drawing discussion
During a discussion, Sela listens without speaking. Jon says, “She must be bored.” The account does not describe Sela’s thoughts or ask her why she is quiet.
Question: What assumption has Jon made?
Answer: He assumes that a quiet listener is bored.
Why: Silence can have several explanations: Sela might be thinking, listening carefully or waiting for a turn. None is proved here. Recognising an assumption means noticing the extra idea between the observation and the conclusion. Jon could ask Sela a friendly question instead of treating his guess as a fact.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Uncover the condition behind a plan
Print plan
“We have enough paper to print the posters, so printing can begin.” No one has checked the ink.
Route plan
“The side gate is a shorter route, so we can enter there.” No one has checked whether it is open.
Drawing plan
“There are six blue pencils for six pupils, so all can start.” No one has checked whether the pencils can be used.
F1 · Matching
Match each plan with its unchecked assumption.
Complete or match: Start printing the posters.; Enter through the side gate.; Give every pupil a usable blue pencil.
- a: All six pencils are usable.
- b: The side gate is open.
- c: The printer has enough ink.
Paper alone does not guarantee ink, a short route does not guarantee an open gate, and a count does not guarantee usable pencils.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Fact, conclusion and hidden bridge
Observed fact
A donation box contains twenty pencils.
Conclusion
The organiser says the box provides a usable pencil for each of twenty pupils.
Missing check
No one has tested or sharpened the donated pencils.
F2 · Drag and drop
Drag each label to the matching statement.
Complete or match: The box contains twenty pencils.; The twenty pupils can each receive a usable pencil.; All twenty donated pencils are usable.
- a: Unstated assumption
- b: Observed fact
- c: Conclusion
The count is observed. The conclusion adds usability, which depends on the unchecked assumption that all the pencils work.
Source explorer: claim board
F3 · A prediction has an assumption
Yesterday
The paint on a card dried in twenty minutes in a warm, airy room.
Tomorrow’s plan
“Tomorrow’s cards will also be dry in twenty minutes,” says Kian.
Unknown conditions
Tomorrow’s paint thickness and room conditions have not been checked.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete each description.
Complete or match: Yesterday’s twenty-minute result is ___.; Tomorrow’s twenty-minute drying time is ___.; Similar paint thickness and room conditions are ___.
- a: An unchecked assumption behind the prediction
- b: An observed result
- c: A prediction rather than a measured result
A measured past result is different from a future prediction. Similar conditions would make the prediction more reasonable but have not been established.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · A printable page and access to a printer
Homework notice
The teacher posts a printable practice sheet on the class website. A pupil says, “Every family can now print a copy at home.” The notice contains no information about families’ printers.
F4 · True or false
The pupil’s conclusion assumes that every family has access to a working printer at home.
- true: True
- false: False
A printable file does not by itself establish access to a home printer. The conclusion relies on that unstated condition.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Check the entry-route assumption
Sign plan
Put every welcome sign along the path from the north gate. The organiser says every visitor will then see a sign.
Site information
The school has a north gate and a south gate. The organiser has not checked which gates visitors will use.
F5 · Open ended
What assumption makes this sign plan uncertain? Propose one practical check or improvement that addresses it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The plan assumes that every visitor will enter through the north gate or walk along its path. Check the planned entrances with the organiser, or place clear signs along both entrance routes.
- Identifies the assumption that all visitors will use or pass the north-gate route where the signs are placed.
- Proposes a relevant check of visitor entrance routes, or an improvement such as signs covering both gates or directing all visitors through a verified route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: network
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Plan statement
Classroom example: “We posted the rehearsal change on the class portal, so every member now knows about it.”
Known fact
The message was posted at 6:00 in the evening. The text gives no record of who opened it or whether everyone could access the portal.
Other note
The rehearsal is now in Room 5.
1A · Hotspot
Select the part of the plan statement that goes beyond the known posting fact.
- a: We posted the rehearsal change.
- b: Every member now knows about it.
- c: The rehearsal is now in Room 5.
Posting a message does not establish that every member accessed and understood it.
1B · Open ended
State one hidden assumption and suggest one way to check it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The plan assumes every member can access the portal and has read the message. Ask members to acknowledge it or provide another notice for those without access.
- Identifies an access or read/understood assumption.
- Proposes a relevant check or alternative communication route.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Known facts
Classroom example: The picnic table seats six people. Eight pupils plan to attend. Two adults may also join, but their attendance is not confirmed.
Plan claim
“The one table will seat everyone because some people probably will not come.”
2A · Dropdown selection
Classify each statement.
Complete or match: The table seats six.; Eight pupils plan to attend.; Enough people will stay away for the table to fit everyone.
- a: Stated capacity
- b: Stated planned attendance
- c: Unverified assumption
The plan relies on absences that have not been established by the supplied facts.
2B · Short answer
Explain why the table decision needs another check even if absences are possible.
Example of a full-credit answer: Possible absence is not confirmed absence. The planned pupil group already exceeds six, so the organiser should confirm attendance or arrange more seats.
- Distinguishes possibility from verified attendance.
- Connects capacity/planned numbers to a useful further check or action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New plan
Classroom example: A teacher’s helper sends a digital worksheet and says, “Everyone can print it at home before tomorrow.”
Information available
The class has not been asked about printers or printing materials. The school has spare paper copies available.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all assumptions the plan makes.
- a: Every pupil has access to a working printer.
- b: Every pupil has the materials or help needed to print.
- c: The school has spare paper copies.
- d: The worksheet was sent digitally.
Printer access and ability to print are unstated requirements. The spare copies and digital sending are given facts.
3B · Open ended
Propose a fairer plan that checks access and provides an alternative.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask who can print the worksheet and give school paper copies to pupils who cannot. That keeps printing access from deciding who can take part.
- Includes checking printing access rather than assuming it.
- Provides a suitable paper or equivalent access alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Discussion record
Classroom example: Three pupils spoke in favour of a later club meeting. The other nine pupils did not speak before the bell interrupted the discussion.
Claim
“Everyone agreed because nobody said no.”
4A · Multiple choice
Which explanation best identifies the reasoning error?
- a: Silence always means agreement.
- b: Only spoken comments ever count as evidence.
- c: The silent pupils’ views were not established; the discussion ended before they answered.
- d: The bell proves everyone dislikes the club.
The record contains three positive views and nine unknown views. Lack of spoken objection does not establish unanimous agreement.
4B · Short answer
Propose a way to check the silent pupils’ views and explain why it is needed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask each pupil privately or use a short vote with a chance to explain. It is needed because the bell cut off the discussion and silence does not show agreement.
- Proposes an inclusive method of gathering the missing views.
- Explains why the existing silence is insufficient evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Project
Classroom example: The class wants to share a book box with nearby families. It has ten books but does not know which ages or languages the families need.
Draft plan
“These ten books will suit every family because our class likes them.”
5A · True or false
The class’s own preferences establish that the books suit every nearby family.
- true: True
- false: False
The families may have different ages, languages or interests. The class’s preference alone does not establish suitability for all.
5B · Open ended
Propose two useful questions for families before choosing the final box.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask which ages will use the box and which reading languages or formats would be useful. Their answers can guide book choices instead of assuming every family is like our class.
- Asks about one relevant need such as age, language, format or reading level.
- Asks about a different relevant need and relates it to selecting suitable books.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.5 · Predicting likely outcomes
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Use a pattern, with a condition
Practice record
On Monday, Wednesday and Friday, the craft club put unfinished models on a drying shelf before leaving. The plan for next Monday lists the same activity and the same closing routine.
Question: What is a reasonable prediction for next Monday?
Answer: The club will probably put unfinished models on the drying shelf if the planned routine continues.
Why: The repeated pattern and the unchanged plan support the prediction. They do not make the future certain: a changed activity or a different instruction could change the result. A useful prediction points to its evidence and makes any important condition clear.
Example 2 · Notice a warning sign
A model bridge
When two small blocks were placed on the model bridge, its middle bent slightly. With three blocks, it bent much farther. The class is considering adding another similar block without changing the bridge.
Question: What might happen if another similar block is added?
Answer: The bridge may bend more or fail to support the blocks.
Why: The increasing bend is a clue about what extra load could do. It does not tell us the exact number of blocks the bridge can hold or guarantee that it will break next. Keep the prediction linked to the observed pattern and the unchanged bridge.
Example 3 · New information can change a forecast
Usual programme
The music room usually opens after lunch on Thursdays.
New notice
This Thursday only, the music room is closed for repairs all day.
Question: Should we predict that pupils can enter after lunch this Thursday?
Answer: No. The specific new notice says the usual routine will not happen this Thursday.
Why: Past patterns help with predictions, but current information matters too. A forecast based only on usual Thursdays would ignore a known change. Check whether the conditions behind a pattern still apply before using it to predict the next event.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Connect each clue to a likely outcome
Paper stack
Loose paper lies beside an open window. A strong breeze is blowing the top sheets upwards.
Display stand
The stand is wobbling because one support is missing. The display is being left in the same position.
Paint routine
During each of three practice sessions, the same thin paint dried within ten minutes in the same room. The next session uses the same materials and conditions.
F1 · Matching
Match each account with its best-supported prediction.
Complete or match: Loose sheets beside the breezy window.; Wobbling stand without one support.; Repeated drying result with unchanged conditions.
- a: The paint will probably dry within about ten minutes.
- b: Some loose sheets may blow away.
- c: The display may fall if the support is not fixed.
Each prediction follows a stated clue and continuing condition. None claims an exact future result with certainty.
Source explorer: cause lab
F2 · A forecast is not a promise
Walk record
During the last three walks, the class reached the garden in twelve minutes. Tomorrow they will use the same route, but the leader has not checked for delays.
F2 · True or false
The record guarantees that tomorrow’s walk will take exactly twelve minutes.
- true: True
- false: False
Twelve minutes is a reasonable estimate from the record, but an unmeasured future delay could change the time.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Choose the clue that matters
Costume box
A light box holds paper hats. Its lid is loose, and gusts keep lifting one edge. The box has a star sticker and was packed on Tuesday.
F3 · Hotspot
Which detail best supports predicting that the hats may blow out?
- a: The box was packed on Tuesday.
- b: The box has a star sticker.
- c: Gusts keep lifting the loose lid.
The lifting lid gives moving air a way to reach the paper hats. Packing day and decoration do not explain that risk.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Use the latest condition
Normal plan
The outdoor puppet performance normally takes place at noon on Fridays.
Friday update
This Friday the performance will move indoors if rain continues. Rain is continuing at 11:45 a.m.
Next week
No information is provided about next Friday’s weather or programme.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each prediction.
Complete or match: This Friday’s show will probably be ___ if rain continues.; An outdoor show would fit the usual plan only if the stated rain condition ___.; Next Friday’s location is ___ from these sources.
- a: No longer applies
- b: Not established
- c: Indoors
The current rain activates the stated indoor plan. The sources do not establish next week’s conditions.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Predict from a changed track
Trial A
A toy car rolled down a ramp onto a clear track and reached the finish line.
Trial B
The same car and ramp were used, but a sponge barrier was placed across the track. The car hit the barrier and stopped before the line.
Next trial
The car, ramp and sponge barrier will stay in the same positions.
F5 · Short answer
What will probably happen in the next trial? Support the prediction with the most relevant previous result, and make clear that it is a prediction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The car will probably stop at the sponge before the finish line, because it did so in Trial B with the same arrangement. This is a likely outcome, not a guaranteed measurement of the next run.
- Predicts that the car is likely to stop at the sponge or before the line, using cautious wording rather than claiming an observed or guaranteed result.
- Supports the prediction with Trial B’s stop and the unchanged car, ramp and barrier arrangement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: sequence lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Routine A
Classroom example: The class reading trolley visits Room 1 every Monday unless the room is closed. Room 1 is open next Monday.
Routine B
The outdoor drawing group moves indoors whenever rain starts. Rain has just begun.
Routine C
A paper-tray notice says helpers refill it when fewer than five sheets remain. Only three sheets remain.
1A · Matching
Match each situation with the most supported next action.
Complete or match: Routine A; Routine B; Routine C
- a: The drawing group is likely to move indoors.
- b: Helpers are likely to refill the tray.
- c: The trolley is likely to visit Room 1.
Each prediction follows a stated routine under the given condition, while still describing a future action.
1B · Short answer
Choose one prediction and identify both its rule and present condition.
Example of a full-credit answer: For the paper tray, the rule is to refill below five sheets. The present count is three, so a refill is the supported next action.
- Identifies a correct stated rule.
- Connects it to the current condition and predicted action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Story
Classroom example: The model cart’s wheel wobbles more each time it turns. Nari notices the axle peg is slipping out. She stops the cart and reaches for the repair box.
Prediction task
Use the sequence of clues to predict Nari’s likely next step, not a guaranteed distant outcome.
2A · Drag and drop
Place the reasoning parts in a useful prediction chain.
Complete or match: Observed problem; Immediate response already stated; Likely next action
- a: Wheel wobbles and peg slips
- b: Nari stops the cart
- c: Nari tries to secure or repair the wheel
- d: The cart wins every future race
The repair box and stopped cart support an immediate repair attempt. They do not guarantee future race results.
2B · Open ended
Why is a repair attempt better supported than a prediction of winning a race?
Example of a full-credit answer: The text directly connects the slipping wheel, stopping and reaching for repair tools. It gives no race evidence or guarantee that the repair will succeed.
- Uses the immediate repair-related clues.
- Explains the missing evidence for a guaranteed race outcome.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Usual pattern
Classroom example: The garden club normally meets outside at lunch on Fridays.
New notice
This Friday the garden path is closed for repairs. The notice says the club will use Room 4 when the path is closed.
Prediction need
Predict this Friday’s location using both the normal pattern and the exception.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the conditional prediction.
Complete or match: Condition that changes the routine; Likely meeting place; Reason the usual pattern is not enough
- a: The garden path is closed
- b: Room 4
- c: The notice gives a closed-path exception
- d: The garden must always be used
The explicit exception applies to the current closure, so it changes the normal outdoor prediction.
3B · Short answer
Explain what new information made you revise the usual prediction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The path closure activates the notice’s Room 4 rule. Although the club usually meets outside, this Friday’s condition is different.
- Identifies the closure as relevant new information.
- Connects it to the Room 4 exception rather than the usual location.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Record
Classroom example: In three practice rounds, the same team completed the puzzle first. In the next round the puzzle will have different pieces and a new rule.
Prediction
“That team is certain to win every future round.”
4A · Multiple choice
Which forecast best respects the record and the changed conditions?
- a: The team may do well, but the new pieces and rule could change the result.
- b: The team is guaranteed to win forever.
- c: Past practice tells us nothing at all.
- d: The new rule guarantees the team will lose.
The record supports experience or recent success, but changed conditions prevent a certain universal prediction.
4B · Open ended
Identify the useful evidence and the reason for uncertainty.
Example of a full-credit answer: The team finished first in three rounds, which suggests useful experience. Different pieces and a new rule may change the next result, so winning is not certain.
- Uses the three successful practice rounds as relevant evidence.
- Identifies changed conditions as a limitation on certainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Plan
Classroom example: The library will place a clear return sign beside the desk. Helpers predict that fewer visitors will ask where to return books.
Suggested check
Count those questions during similar opening periods before and after adding the sign. Also note any change in visitor numbers.
5A · True or false
The suggested check could provide relevant evidence about the prediction, though it would not guarantee the sign is the only cause.
- true: True
- false: False
Before/after question counts relate to the prediction, while visitor numbers and other changes may also matter.
5B · Short answer
Propose one observation to record and one condition that should be considered when comparing the results.
Example of a full-credit answer: Record how many visitors ask where to return books. Compare periods with similar visitor numbers, or note visitor counts, so a quieter day is not mistaken for a sign effect.
- Names an observable measure tied to the predicted change.
- Names a relevant comparison condition or alternative explanation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.6 · Inferring the author’s intention
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Instructions guide an action
Bookmark card
Fold the paper in half. Press the crease flat. Open it, then draw a line along the crease. Cut on the line with suitable classroom scissors.
Question: What is the main purpose of this card?
Answer: To instruct the reader how to prepare the paper.
Why: The steps use action words and a clear order. Those features support an instructional purpose. The card is not mainly trying to sell paper or tell a funny story. Identify what the writing helps the reader do, rather than guessing the author’s private feelings about the activity.
Example 2 · Notice language that asks for a choice
Class invitation
Join our lunchtime drawing circle! Try a new idea, meet other young artists and help fill our display with colour. Sign up on the classroom sheet today.
Question: What does the writer mainly want readers to do?
Answer: The writer wants readers to join the drawing circle.
Why: The invitation highlights appealing benefits and ends with a direct request to sign up. It gives some information, but that information supports persuasion. A text can serve more than one purpose; the main purpose is the one most strongly shown by its wording and arrangement.
Example 3 · The text does not reveal every private motive
A short story opening
The toy robot bowed so deeply that its cardboard hat fell into the soup bowl. “Excellent landing!” it announced, while everyone at the table tried not to laugh.
Question: What purpose is supported by the passage?
Answer: The writer is likely trying to entertain readers with a funny event.
Why: The surprising accident and the robot’s cheerful comment create humour. These details support an entertaining purpose. They do not tell us whether the writer wants fame or wrote the story in a happy mood. Infer the purpose of the writing from the text, not an unseen personal motive.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the request to act
Poster
Bring a clean spare jar to our craft collection. Your jar can become a pencil holder for the reading room. Please place donations in the labelled box by Thursday.
F1 · Hotspot
Which wording most clearly reveals the poster’s purpose of encouraging donations?
- a: A jar can become a pencil holder.
- b: Bring a clean spare jar to our craft collection.
- c: The box has a label.
Bring directly invites a donation. The other details explain the use or collection method.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · Three texts, three main purposes
Assembly steps
Fit the two cardboard slots together. Stand the model on a flat surface. Check that both feet touch the table.
Event report
The class exhibition opened at 9 a.m. Thirty models were displayed in the hall. Families visited until noon.
Funny tale
The painted dragon sneezed, and every paper moustache in the kingdom flew into the air.
F2 · Drag and drop
Drag the main purpose to each text.
Complete or match: Assembly steps; Event report; Funny tale
- a: Entertain with an amusing story
- b: Instruct the reader how to do something
- c: Inform the reader about an event
Ordered commands guide an action; the report supplies event facts; the dragon’s unlikely sneeze creates a humorous story.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Select clues to persuasion
Book-swap invitation
Give a finished book a new reader! Join Friday’s book swap and discover a story chosen by another pupil. Bring one suitable book and sign your name before Thursday.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two features support the purpose of persuading pupils to join?
- a: It directly invites readers to join Friday’s swap.
- b: It presents discovering another story as a benefit.
- c: It explains how printers manufacture books.
- d: It reports completed results from Friday’s swap.
The invitation and appealing benefit aim to encourage a choice. Manufacturing and completed results do not appear in the text.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Purpose can differ for the same object
Text A
This class telescope has a focus wheel and a protective lens cover. Its storage box is in the science cupboard.
Text B
Before putting the telescope away, replace the lens cover and close the storage box carefully.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each purpose statement.
Complete or match: Text A mainly helps the reader ___.; Text B mainly helps the reader ___.
- a: Follow a storage procedure
- b: Learn facts about the telescope
Text A describes parts and storage location. Text B gives an action sequence for putting the telescope away.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Explain a writer’s main purpose
Notice
Help our class make a quiet reading corner. Donate a clean cushion if your family has one to spare. A softer seat could make the corner more comfortable. Please ask an adult before bringing anything.
F5 · Open ended
What is the notice’s main purpose? Explain your answer using one request and one supporting detail from the wording.
Example of a full-credit answer: The notice aims to encourage suitable cushion donations for a reading corner. It asks readers to donate a clean spare cushion and explains that softer seats could make the corner more comfortable.
- Identifies encouraging or requesting cushion donations for the reading corner as the main purpose.
- Supports the purpose with both a request to help or donate and a relevant detail such as the comfort benefit, spare clean cushions, or asking an adult first.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: word lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Poster heading
Classroom example: Try the lunchtime story circle!
Poster invitation
Bring a favourite short story and share one interesting moment. New listeners are welcome; you do not have to read aloud.
Practical details
Thursday at lunch, under the covered veranda.
1A · Hotspot
Select the part that most directly shows the writer wants readers to take part.
- a: Try the lunchtime story circle!
- b: Thursday at lunch.
- c: Under the covered veranda.
Try is a direct invitation. The time and place support it but do not by themselves state the desired action.
1B · Open ended
Explain how one other detail makes the invitation easier for a hesitant pupil to accept.
Example of a full-credit answer: The poster says new listeners are welcome and reading aloud is not required. That lowers a possible barrier for someone unsure about performing.
- Identifies a relevant welcoming/optional-speaking detail.
- Explains how it supports participation for a hesitant reader.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Text A
Classroom example: Place the returned cards in the labelled tray before leaving.
Text B
The old tray creaked like a tiny boat as the cards tumbled in, and Lio wondered where it might sail.
Text C
Last week the class returned 42 cards. Four damaged cards were set aside for repair.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each text with its main purpose.
Complete or match: Text A; Text B; Text C
- a: Entertain through an imaginative scene
- b: Instruct readers what to do
- c: Report recorded information
The command, imaginative narration and recorded counts offer distinct evidence of purpose.
2B · Short answer
Choose two texts and identify a language clue for each purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: Text A uses the command place, so it instructs. Text B imagines a tray as a boat, which creates an entertaining scene rather than a return rule.
- Identifies an accurate purpose and clue for one text.
- Identifies an accurate purpose and clue for a second text.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New text
Classroom example: A shadow forms when an object blocks light. In this classroom demonstration, a torch shines toward a wall and a card blocks part of the light. Moving the card changes the shadow’s position.
Context
This paragraph appears beside a labelled science diagram. It gives no product price or invitation to buy anything.
3A · Multiple choice
What is the paragraph mainly trying to do?
- a: Sell a particular torch.
- b: Explain how a shadow forms using a demonstration.
- c: Tell a fictional adventure about a wall.
- d: Prove that every shadow is identical.
The definition and demonstration explain a process. Sales and universal sameness are not supported.
3B · Open ended
Give two details that support your inference about its purpose.
Example of a full-credit answer: It states that an object blocks light and describes a torch-card-wall demonstration. Both help readers understand the process shown in the diagram.
- Uses the process definition as a purpose clue.
- Uses the demonstration or diagram context as another explanatory clue.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Notice
Classroom example: Please close the reading-room door gently. Loud bangs disturb people who are reading or recording audio.
Reader’s claims
One reader says the writer hates all visitors. Another says the writer wants to reduce disturbing noise. A third says the writer wants to lock everyone out.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all interpretations that go beyond the evidence.
- a: The writer hates all visitors.
- b: The writer wants to reduce disturbing noise.
- c: The writer wants to lock everyone out.
- d: The writer asks for gentle door closing.
The notice gives a noise reason and a gentle-closing request. It does not establish hatred or an exclusion plan.
4B · Short answer
State a supported intention and explain why the stronger personal accusation is unjustified.
Example of a full-credit answer: The writer wants people to close the door gently to reduce noise. Nothing in the notice shows hatred of visitors; it gives a practical reason about readers and recordings.
- Gives the supported noise-reduction/gentle-closing intention.
- Explains the absence of support for the personal accusation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing brief
Classroom example: Create three short texts about a class seed tray: a care instruction, a report and an invitation to help.
Available content
The tray needs a soil-moisture check each morning. Seven seedlings appeared this week. Volunteers can join the next observation session.
5A · Matching
Match each sentence with the purpose it serves best.
Complete or match: Care instruction; Report; Invitation
- a: Seven seedlings appeared this week.
- b: Check the soil moisture each morning.
- c: Join our next seedling observation session.
Commands guide care, counts report observations and invitations ask readers to join.
5B · Open ended
Write a new sentence for one purpose and explain the wording that makes it fit.
Example of a full-credit answer: “Come and help record tomorrow’s seedling heights” is an invitation. Come and help directly asks readers to take part in a specific action.
- Writes an appropriate sentence for one stated purpose.
- Explains a concrete wording/content choice that serves that purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.7 · Connecting information from different paragraphs
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Find what “this change” refers to
Paragraph 1
At the exhibition, visitors could not read labels hidden behind the models. The class moved each label to the front of its model.
Paragraph 2
This change helped visitors read the titles without reaching over the displays.
Question: What does this change mean in Paragraph 2?
Answer: It means moving each label from behind its model to the front.
Why: Paragraph 2 depends on an action described in Paragraph 1. Reading it alone would leave the change unclear. Look backwards for the action that fits the reported result: front labels can be read without reaching over models. Linking the paragraphs gives both the solution and its purpose.
Example 2 · Follow a contrasting link
Paragraph 1
Some pupils wanted a noisy rhythm game for the class celebration. They liked clapping and calling out patterns.
Paragraph 2
Other pupils, however, wanted a quieter drawing game. The class planned separate activity corners so both groups could choose.
Question: How does Paragraph 2 connect to Paragraph 1?
Answer: It introduces a different preference and then describes a plan that includes both groups.
Why: However signals a contrast with the first group’s choice. The second paragraph does not say that the first group changed its mind or that one game was cancelled. Read the contrast and the final plan together to understand how the class responded to different preferences.
Example 3 · A later paragraph can limit a rule
Paragraph 1
Pupils may borrow the class puzzle boxes to use during break.
Paragraph 2
Boxes with a red repair label are an exception. They must stay on the shelf until all pieces have been checked.
Question: May a pupil borrow a box with a red repair label?
Answer: No. The second paragraph limits the general borrowing permission.
Why: Paragraph 1 gives the usual rule, while Paragraph 2 adds an exception. The two paragraphs belong to one explanation and must be read together. Stopping after the first paragraph could lead to an incorrect action. Words such as exception, unless and however often signal an important limit or change.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Connect a problem and its solution
Paragraph 1
Visitors kept mistaking the costume cupboard for the stage entrance because both doors had small, similar labels.
Paragraph 2
The class put a large arrow beside the stage door and changed the cupboard label to a different colour. These changes made the two routes easier to distinguish.
F1 · Multiple answers
Which two statements correctly join information from both paragraphs?
- a: The changes respond to confusion between two doors.
- b: The large arrow helps identify the stage entrance.
- c: The class removed both doors from the building.
- d: The second paragraph says all labels were discarded.
The first paragraph gives the confusion; the second gives two label changes intended to distinguish the routes. Removing doors or discarding all labels is not stated.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · See each paragraph’s job
Paragraph 1
At the activity table, pupils could not tell which box held unused paper.
Paragraph 2
The class tested a clear label reading “Unused paper” on one box during Monday’s session.
Paragraph 3
The record covers only Monday. It does not tell us whether new visitors will understand the label next week.
F2 · Matching
Match each paragraph to its role in the whole account.
Complete or match: Paragraph 1; Paragraph 2; Paragraph 3
- a: States a limit on what the record shows
- b: Describes the problem
- c: Describes a trial response
The account moves from confusion, to a label trial, to a limit on the evidence. Each paragraph adds a different part.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F3 · Trace referring words backwards
Paragraph 1
Yani made three paper masks. She placed the masks inside a wide box. The box stood beside the stage.
Paragraph 2
These were for the final scene. It kept their ribbons from becoming tangled.
Reading clue
In Paragraph 2, these refers to several objects and it refers to one container.
F3 · Drag and drop
Connect each word with what it refers to.
Complete or match: She in Paragraph 1; These in Paragraph 2; It in Paragraph 2
- a: The wide box
- b: Yani
- c: The three paper masks
She names Yani, these refers to the plural masks for the scene, and it refers to the singular box protecting the ribbons.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · Do not ignore the qualification
Paragraph 1
The new picture labels helped several pupils find the art materials quickly.
Paragraph 2
Two pupils still needed spoken directions because the pictures were unfamiliar to them.
F4 · True or false
Together, the paragraphs show that every pupil found the materials without spoken help.
- true: True
- false: False
The second paragraph states that two pupils still needed spoken directions. Several does not mean every pupil.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Join the problem to the response
Paragraph 1
On delivery day, pupils carried loose worksheets from the office. Their hands were full, and some sheets slipped to the floor.
Paragraph 2
The helper provided shallow trays for carrying the sheets. This solution kept the pages together while pupils walked.
F5 · Short answer
What does this solution refer to, and how does it address the problem described earlier?
Example of a full-credit answer: It refers to providing shallow trays for carrying the worksheets. The trays keep the loose pages together so they are less likely to slip from pupils’ full hands onto the floor.
- Identifies the provision or use of shallow carrying trays as this solution.
- Connects the trays keeping pages together with the earlier problem of loose sheets slipping or falling while pupils carried them.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Paragraph 1
Classroom example: The class’s picture cards were stored in one deep box. Pupils spent several minutes searching, and some cards bent while they pulled through the pile.
Paragraph 2
The helpers separated the cards into labelled shallow trays. They placed a sample picture on each tray so younger pupils could identify the set.
Paragraph 3
This arrangement made it easier to find a set without lifting every card. The helpers still needed to check that cards were returned to the correct tray.
1A · Drag and drop
Match the ideas across the paragraphs.
Complete or match: Problem in paragraph 1; Response in paragraph 2; Remaining task in paragraph 3
- a: Store cards in labelled shallow trays
- b: Searching a deep mixed box
- c: Check that cards return to the correct tray
The tray arrangement responds to the earlier search problem; the final paragraph adds a continuing check.
1B · Short answer
Explain how the plan addresses two difficulties in the first paragraph.
Example of a full-credit answer: Separate labelled trays reduce searching through one deep pile. Shallower storage also means pupils need not pull through and bend every card to reach a set.
- Connects labels/separation to easier searching.
- Connects shallow storage/reduced handling to avoiding bent cards.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Paragraph 1
Classroom example: The class wants to display paper models outside so families can walk around them easily.
Paragraph 2
However, paper models can be damaged by rain. The organiser reserves the covered hall as a backup and will check the weather before opening.
Paragraph 3
If rain is expected, the display will use the hall. Clear signs will direct visitors from the usual outdoor entrance.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the explanation linking the paragraphs.
Complete or match: Purpose of outdoor plan; Reason for backup; Condition for using the hall
- a: Easy access around the models
- b: Risk of rain damage
- c: Rain is expected
- d: The models must always stay outdoors
The access goal, weather risk and condition work together; the later paragraphs qualify the first plan.
2B · Open ended
Explain why reading only paragraph 1 would give an incomplete visiting plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: It would suggest the display is always outside. The later paragraphs add a rain backup in the hall and signs directing visitors there.
- Identifies the incomplete always-outside understanding.
- Uses the later condition and backup location to complete it.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Paragraph 1
Classroom example: The first notice told families to bring a box for the class swap.
Paragraph 2
Several families replied that they had no spare box. The organiser arranged reusable bags for anyone who needed one.
Paragraph 3
This alternative means a missing box will not prevent a family from joining.
3A · Hotspot
Select the earlier detail that explains “This alternative” in paragraph 3.
- a: The first notice asked for a box.
- b: The organiser arranged reusable bags for anyone who needed one.
- c: Several families replied to a notice.
The alternative is the reusable-bag arrangement, which solves the missing-box problem.
3B · Short answer
Explain the link between the families’ replies and the organiser’s new arrangement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The replies revealed that some families lacked a spare box. Reusable bags give those families another way to carry items and still join the swap.
- Identifies the need revealed in the replies.
- Connects the bag arrangement to access/participation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Paragraph 1
Classroom example: A small reading group tried meeting near the playground. They enjoyed the shade but often stopped because of loud games nearby.
Paragraph 2
The group moved to a quieter veranda. They kept the same meeting time and books so they could focus on the location change.
Wrong summary
“They changed the meeting time because they disliked all the books.”
4A · Matching
Match each summary issue with the relevant correction.
Complete or match: Meeting time changed; All books disliked; Reason for the move
- a: The time stayed the same.
- b: The text gives no dislike claim; books stayed the same.
- c: Nearby game noise interrupted reading.
The wrong summary invents a time change and book dislike, while missing the stated noise problem.
4B · Open ended
Write a corrected sentence linking the problem and change.
Example of a full-credit answer: The group moved from the playground to a quieter veranda because nearby games interrupted reading, while keeping the same time and books.
- Connects the noise problem to the location change.
- Preserves at least one controlled unchanged detail, time or books.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Paragraph 1
Classroom example: The school found that younger pupils sometimes missed the notice board because the notices were above their eye level.
Paragraph 3
After the change, helpers will ask younger pupils whether they can see and understand the notices. They will revise the display if needed.
Writing gap
The middle paragraph needs to explain a practical change that responds to the problem and can be checked afterwards.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all ideas that would help the missing middle paragraph connect the other two.
- a: Place copies of key notices lower down.
- b: Use clear, readable text on those copies.
- c: Remove every notice and give no replacement.
- d: Describe the caretaker’s favourite sport instead.
Lower placement responds to visibility, and readable text relates to understanding. The other ideas break the problem-to-check connection.
5B · Short answer
Write a suitable middle paragraph with one change and a reason for it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The helpers will place clear copies of key notices at a height younger pupils can see. This gives them a better chance to read the information before the helpers ask whether the change worked.
- Proposes a relevant practical response to height/visibility.
- Explains its connection to the problem and later checking step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.8 · Connecting information from different documents
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Combine a schedule with a travel time
Session notice
The paper-theatre session starts at 10 a.m. in the activity room.
Route guide
Walking from the north gate to the activity room takes about ten minutes.
Arrival plan
Jo plans to reach the north gate at 9:45 a.m.
Question: Does Jo’s plan allow time to reach the session before it starts, if the walk takes about ten minutes?
Answer: Yes. Jo would arrive at about 9:55 a.m., five minutes before the 10 a.m. start.
Why: No document states the whole answer. The notice supplies the start, the guide supplies the walk and the plan supplies arrival at the gate. Connect those facts to work out room arrival. The result still depends on the walk taking about ten minutes.
Example 2 · Two records can have different roles
Class rule
Completed models must be put on the blue shelf before the room closes.
Today’s record
Tali finished her model. It is still on her desk, and the room closes in five minutes.
Question: What should Tali do to follow the rule?
Answer: Put the finished model on the blue shelf before the room closes.
Why: The rule gives a general requirement, while the record gives the current situation. Neither source alone tells us both. Together they show that Tali’s model meets the condition completed and has not yet reached the required shelf. Linking a rule with a specific case helps us choose an appropriate action.
Example 3 · A conflict needs checking
Notice A
Today’s weaving demonstration: 1 p.m. in Room 2.
Notice B
Today’s weaving demonstration: 1 p.m. in Room 8. Neither notice has a revision time.
Question: What can we conclude about the room?
Answer: The notices conflict about the room, so the correct room needs confirmation.
Why: The event and time match, but the room numbers do not. We should not combine the notices into an invented Room 28 or assume one writer is lying. A current confirmation from the organiser would resolve the practical question. Recognising a conflict is different from knowing which source is correct.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Do two notices settle the location?
Notice A
This Friday’s clay display is in the hall.
Notice B
This Friday’s clay display is in the library. No update date appears on either notice.
F1 · True or false
Together, these notices establish one confirmed location for this Friday’s clay display.
- true: True
- false: False
They refer to the same event and day but give different locations. Neither source is identified as the correction, so confirmation is needed.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Join a rule and a current case
Equipment rule
Only completed and labelled models may be placed in the exhibition cabinet.
Current model
Nera’s model is complete, but its label has not yet been attached.
F2 · Multiple choice
What must Nera do before placing the model in the cabinet?
- a: Attach the missing label to Nera’s model.
- b: Remove every label from the exhibition cabinet.
- c: Start a second model before finishing this one.
- d: Place the unlabelled model inside immediately.
The model already meets the completed condition. It still needs a label to meet both requirements in the rule.
Source explorer: network
F3 · Name the relationship between documents
Pair A
The printed programme and the teacher’s notice both give a 2 p.m. start for the same current event.
Pair B
The current programme gives the room number; the current map shows how to reach that room.
Pair C
Two undated notices give different prices for the same session and ticket type.
F3 · Matching
Match each pair with its relationship.
Complete or match: Pair A; Pair B; Pair C
- a: Conflict about the same fact
- b: Agreement about the same fact
- c: Complementary information
A agrees on time, B supplies different useful parts, and C gives incompatible prices without a way to choose between them.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Use each rule with its matching record
Rule and record A
Rule: wet brushes go in the drying tray. Record: Pia’s brush is wet.
Rule and record B
Rule: finished name badges go in the envelope. Record: Ren’s badge is finished.
Rule and record C
Rule: damaged scissors are handed to the teacher. Record: Sol’s scissors have a loose handle. The class labels a loose handle as damage.
F4 · Drag and drop
Drag the supported action to each case.
Complete or match: Pia’s wet brush; Ren’s finished badge; Sol’s damaged scissors
- a: Hand the item to the teacher.
- b: Put the item in the drying tray.
- c: Put the item in the envelope.
Each current record meets a condition in its paired rule, so the stated action follows.
Source explorer: builder
F5 · Choose a room using two documents
Group list
The illustration group has ten pupils and two adult helpers. Everyone needs a seat.
Room information
Room A has ten available seats. Room B has fifteen available seats. Both rooms are available at the group’s planned time.
F5 · Open ended
Which room can seat the whole group? Explain using information from both documents.
Example of a full-credit answer: Room B can seat the whole group. The group has twelve people: ten pupils plus two helpers. Room B has fifteen seats, while Room A’s ten seats are too few.
- Uses the group list to establish that twelve people, including both adult helpers, need seats.
- Chooses Room B and supports the choice by comparing its fifteen available seats with the group’s need; accepts an additional explanation that Room A has too few.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Club request
Classroom example: The book club needs a room for twelve pupils from 12:15 to 12:45 on Thursday.
Hall schedule
The small hall is free from 12:00 to 1:00 on Thursday. It has sixteen seats.
Other room
Room 2 has eight seats and is free at the same time.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all conclusions supported by the two relevant records.
- a: The small hall has enough seats for the club.
- b: The club’s requested time fits within the hall’s free period.
- c: Room 2 seats all twelve pupils.
- d: The hall is free every Thursday forever.
The club has twelve pupils and the hall sixteen seats; its time lies inside the stated free period. The records do not prove a permanent schedule.
1B · Open ended
Explain how two different kinds of information support the hall choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: The capacity comparison is twelve pupils versus sixteen seats. The time comparison is 12:15–12:45 within the Thursday 12:00–1:00 free period.
- Correctly combines pupil and seat counts.
- Correctly combines the requested and available time periods.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Class note
Classroom example: Our project needs six picture books about animals by Wednesday morning.
Library message
Four animal picture books are ready now. Two more will be returned on Thursday, if borrowers return them on time.
Planning question
Can the class rely on this library message alone for all six books by Wednesday morning?
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the combined reading.
Complete or match: Needed by Wednesday; Ready now; Reason the remaining two cannot be assumed available by Wednesday
- a: Six animal picture books
- b: Four animal picture books
- c: Their expected return is Thursday, after the deadline
- d: All six are already guaranteed
The need and availability do not fully match. The expected returns are later and conditional.
2B · Short answer
What should the class do next, and why?
Example of a full-credit answer: Look for two more suitable books elsewhere or revise the plan with the teacher. The message guarantees only four ready now, and the other two are expected after Wednesday.
- Identifies the shortfall/timing mismatch.
- Proposes a reasonable next information search or plan revision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Workshop card
Classroom example: The drawing workshop is for registered children aged nine to eleven. It begins at 10:00 in the drawing room inside the community hall.
Registration reply
Tala, aged ten, is registered for the drawing workshop. The reply says to bring a pencil.
Hall map
The drawing room is the first room on the left after the main entrance.
3A · Matching
Match each combined conclusion with the facts needed.
Complete or match: Tala meets the stated age condition.; Tala has a confirmed place.; Tala can locate the drawing room.
- a: Age ten plus the nine-to-eleven range
- b: Her registration reply
- c: The hall map and named workshop room
The workshop card, reply and map contribute different evidence for eligibility, booking and location.
3B · Open ended
Write a short plan for Tala using one detail from each document.
Example of a full-credit answer: Tala can attend the registered nine-to-eleven workshop at 10:00. She should bring a pencil and enter the main door, then use the first room on the left.
- Combines workshop/registration details accurately.
- Adds the correct room-location information from the map.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Event notice
Classroom example: The art walk is on Sunday and starts at 9:00.
Bus page
Weekday timetable: the village bus reaches the park at 8:40. A separate weekend timetable is available, but its times are not shown here.
Wrong claim
“The bus will certainly get us to Sunday’s art walk at 8:40.”
4A · Multiple choice
What is the main problem with the claim?
- a: The bus time is a weekday time, while the event is on Sunday.
- b: Every bus timetable is useless.
- c: A park can never host an art walk.
- d: 8:40 is later than 9:00.
The documents refer to different day categories. Sunday’s arrival time must be checked in the weekend timetable.
4B · Short answer
Name the missing source and explain how it could change the plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: The weekend timetable is needed. Its Sunday arrival may differ from 8:40, so it could show that another bus or travel plan is necessary.
- Identifies the weekend/Sunday timetable as needed.
- Explains that a different time could change whether the plan works.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Visit notice
Classroom example: The storytelling session starts at 11:00 in the garden shelter.
Transport note
The bus reaches Garden Stop at 10:45.
Map caption
Garden Stop and the shelter are marked, but the map gives no walking distance or travel time.
Planning need
A family wants to know whether taking this bus gives enough time to reach the shelter.
5A · Hotspot
Select the source region that reveals the missing connection in the family’s plan.
- a: Session starts at 11:00.
- b: Bus reaches Garden Stop at 10:45.
- c: The map gives no walking distance or travel time.
The fifteen-minute gap cannot be judged without knowing the stop-to-shelter journey.
5B · Open ended
Propose one additional fact to obtain and explain how to use it with the existing times.
Example of a full-credit answer: Find the walking time from Garden Stop to the shelter, allowing for the family’s pace. Compare that with the fifteen minutes between arrival and the session to see whether the route is practical.
- Seeks relevant stop-to-shelter travel information.
- Explains how it completes the comparison with the available time gap.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R3.9 · Drawing conclusions from text and evidence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Keep the conclusion within the group
Sticker choice
Eight pupils in a drawing group chose a sticker. Five chose a star and three chose a circle. No other pupils were asked.
Question: What conclusion does the record support?
Answer: More pupils in this drawing group chose a star than a circle.
Why: Five is greater than three, so that comparison is supported. The record does not show what every pupil in the school would choose or why anyone chose a shape. A conclusion should match the people, time and choices actually recorded. Keep the group’s name in the conclusion to avoid making it too broad.
Example 2 · A difference is not a complete explanation
Two sessions
On Monday, six pupils joined the craft session. On Tuesday, ten joined. A new poster appeared on Tuesday, and the timetable also changed. No pupil was asked why they attended.
Question: Does the record prove that the new poster caused the increase?
Answer: No. Attendance increased, but the record does not establish which change caused it.
Why: The new poster and the new timetable both differ between sessions. Other factors may also matter. We can report the attendance numbers without assigning an unsupported cause. Asking pupils how they heard about the session or comparing more carefully planned trials could help investigate the reason.
Example 3 · A successful trial has limits
Container trial
One closed sample box was carried across the classroom three times. Its counters stayed inside on all three trips. No open boxes or other box designs were tested.
Question: What is a fair conclusion from this trial?
Answer: This closed sample box kept its counters inside during the three recorded classroom trips.
Why: The record supports success in those trials. It does not prove the box will never spill, work in every situation or outperform every other design. A careful conclusion states what was tested and what happened. New situations or comparisons need additional evidence.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Distinguish supported and unsupported claims
Ribbon record
Among eight pupils in one group, five chose a green ribbon and three chose a yellow ribbon. Each pupil chose exactly one ribbon. No other pupils were asked.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Classify each conclusion.
Complete or match: More of these eight pupils chose green than yellow. ___; All eight of these pupils chose green. ___; Most pupils in the whole school prefer green. ___
- a: Contradicted by the record
- b: Not established by this record
- c: Supported by the record
Five exceeds three; three yellow choices contradict all eight choosing green; the unasked school population is outside the evidence.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · Match evidence to a careful conclusion
Reading trial
Four tested labels were read correctly by all six pupils in the trial.
Attendance record
Nine pupils attended the first meeting, and twelve attended the second.
Material check
Three of ten donated folders had torn corners.
F2 · Matching
Match each record with its supported conclusion.
Complete or match: Reading trial; Attendance record; Material check
- a: Some donated folders had torn corners.
- b: All six pupils read the four tested labels correctly.
- c: The second meeting had three more pupils than the first.
Each conclusion follows its recorded counts without adding a cause, a new group or a guaranteed future result.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · One result does not describe every attempt
Paper-glider record
A pupil measured one paper glider’s flight as two metres. Other gliders flew too, but their distances were not recorded.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is supported?
- a: Every glider flew farther than two metres.
- b: The measured glider travelled two metres.
- c: The measured glider was the best of all designs.
- d: All the other gliders failed to leave the ground.
Only one distance is recorded. The source does not establish how the other flights compare.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Avoid a cause claim from two changing sessions
First rehearsal
The rehearsal began without music. Eight pupils were present.
Second rehearsal
Music played at the start. Twelve pupils were present. The meeting time and invitation method also changed.
F4 · True or false
These records prove that playing music caused four more pupils to attend.
- true: True
- false: False
Attendance increased, but several things changed. The records do not isolate music as the cause.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Report a result without overclaiming
Trial record
Eight pupils tried two labels from the classroom doorway. Six read the large-print label correctly; three read the small-print label correctly. These were the only labels and pupils tested.
Proposed headline
Large print is always readable for everyone!
F5 · Short answer
Replace the headline with a careful conclusion. Include the recorded comparison and one limit on what the trial shows.
Example of a full-credit answer: In this trial, more of the eight pupils read the large-print label correctly: six compared with three for the small-print label. This does not show that every person can read every large-print label, because only these pupils and two labels were tested.
- States the accurate observed comparison: six of eight read the large-print label correctly versus three of eight for the small-print label, or an equivalent accurate numerical comparison.
- Limits the conclusion to this trial, these eight pupils or these two labels, or explains why the evidence does not prove that large print is always readable for everyone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Survey
Classroom example: Ten pupils chose one story format. Six chose printed pages, three chose audio and one chose a large-print booklet. All ten responses are recorded.
Scope
This is one classroom group. The survey asks preference, not how well pupils understand each format.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all conclusions supported by the record.
- a: Printed pages were chosen by most pupils in this group.
- b: More than one format was preferred within the group.
- c: Every child everywhere prefers printed pages.
- d: Printed pages always produce the best understanding.
Six of ten is most of this group, and choices include three formats. The survey does not establish universal preference or learning outcomes.
1B · Short answer
Explain one supported conclusion and one limit of the survey.
Example of a full-credit answer: Most surveyed pupils chose printed pages because six of ten selected them. The survey does not measure understanding, so it cannot prove that format teaches best.
- States a supported conclusion with relevant numbers or categories.
- Identifies a genuine scope or measurement limitation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
First attempt
Classroom example: Before picture labels were added, five visitors asked where to return the craft kits during a one-hour session.
Second attempt
After labels were added, two visitors asked during a second one-hour session. Both sessions had twenty visitors.
Limit note
The class recorded only two sessions. Other differences between the sessions were not checked.
2A · Hotspot
Select the evidence comparison most relevant to whether the labels may have helped.
- a: Five questions before and two after, with twenty visitors in each session.
- b: The labels were printed on a Tuesday.
- c: A helper wore a striped shirt.
The comparable visitor counts and fewer questions are relevant, while the small number of sessions limits certainty.
2B · Open ended
Give a cautious conclusion and one reason not to claim the labels are guaranteed to work every time.
Example of a full-credit answer: The labels may have helped because fewer visitors asked in the second comparable session. Only two sessions were recorded and other differences were not checked, so the result is not a guarantee.
- Connects the lower question count to a cautious possible benefit.
- States a specific limitation preventing a universal guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New trial
Classroom example: Three groups tried a card-sorting routine. Two finished with every card in the correct tray. The third mixed two trays because its labels were missing.
Question
What should the class reasonably conclude before using the routine again?
3A · Multiple choice
Which conclusion best fits all the evidence?
- a: The routine worked perfectly for every group.
- b: The routine can work, but clear labels appear important and the missing-label problem should be fixed.
- c: No group could use the routine.
- d: Missing labels can never affect sorting.
Two groups succeeded, while the third had a specific labeling problem. A balanced conclusion includes both.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the successful and unsuccessful groups contribute different information.
Example of a full-credit answer: The two successful groups show the routine can work in these conditions. The group with missing labels reveals a problem to address before wider use.
- Uses the successful groups as limited positive evidence.
- Uses the failed case to identify the labeling condition or improvement need.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Evidence
Classroom example: A class tested a new reading reminder with twelve pupils. Seven remembered the return day, three forgot it and two were absent when checked. The record does not include any other class.
Claims
Claim A: Every tested pupil remembered. Claim B: The absent pupils definitely forgot. Claim C: All classes will show the same result.
4A · Matching
Match each claim with its main problem.
Complete or match: Claim A; Claim B; Claim C
- a: Ignores three recorded forgotten responses
- b: Turns missing observations into definite failures
- c: Generalises beyond the class studied
The three claims respectively contradict recorded results, invent absent pupils’ outcomes and extend beyond the sample.
4B · Open ended
Write a conclusion that reports the result without making those errors.
Example of a full-credit answer: Seven pupils remembered and three forgot among those checked; two were absent, so their results are unknown. The record describes this class only.
- Accurately reports the checked results and unknown absences.
- Keeps the conclusion limited to the studied class.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Current finding
Classroom example: A school tried a reading corner for one week. Borrowing increased from twelve books in the previous week to eighteen. The class does not know whether more pupils visited or the same pupils borrowed more.
Goal
Plan future records so the class can distinguish these explanations for a future change. The old records cannot reveal how many different pupils borrowed in the past.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each new record with the question it helps answer.
Complete or match: Count different pupils who borrow; Count loans per pupil using anonymous codes; Ask pupils who still do not borrow
- a: Did the number of borrowers change?
- b: Did existing borrowers take more books?
- c: What barriers may remain?
Loan totals alone cannot separate more borrowers from more loans per borrower or reveal remaining access barriers.
5B · Short answer
Propose a future evidence plan that distinguishes the two explanations while respecting pupils’ privacy. State one limit of the old records.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use anonymous pupil codes to record different borrowers and loans per borrower during two comparable future weeks, then compare both counts without publishing names. These new data cannot reconstruct the unknown past borrower counts.
- Proposes recording distinct borrowers and loans per borrower across two comparable future periods.
- Explains that the old loan totals cannot establish past borrower counts, while avoiding unnecessary names/public identification.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.1 · Identifying a claim
Three worked examples
Example 1 · What does the cook recommend?
Canteen note
Several pupils ask what is in the soup. The cook writes: Put an ingredient card beside each soup pot. Then pupils can read it before choosing.
Question: Which sentence states the cook’s main claim?
Answer: Put an ingredient card beside each soup pot.
Why: This sentence recommends an action. The questions from pupils describe the problem, and reading before choosing explains a benefit. Look for the idea the writer wants accepted, not just the first sentence. The claim can be sensible even though the note does not show that every pupil will read the card.
Example 2 · A claim without should
Garden group
Six watering cans are mixed together. Groups spend time finding their own cans. Colour tags would make our cans easier to identify.
Question: What claim does the group make, although it does not use the word should?
Answer: Colour tags would make the group’s watering cans easier to identify.
Why: A claim does not need a special signal word. Here the last sentence gives the idea the earlier details are meant to support. The number of cans is background information; it is not the main message. We can identify the proposed benefit without yet deciding how well colour tags will work.
Example 3 · Choose a precise message
Writing task
A class has loose recipe cards for its pretend restaurant. Three cards were misplaced yesterday. Mila wants a message asking classmates to return cards to one labelled folder.
Question: What clear claim could Mila put at the start of her message?
Answer: Return our recipe cards to the labelled folder after each use.
Why: The claim names both the action and the objects. Mila can follow it with the record of misplaced cards as a reason. “Be better” would leave readers guessing what to do. A precise claim makes a proposal easier to discuss, but it still needs sensible reasons if Mila wants to persuade classmates.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Cardboard offcuts
Art note — sentence 1
We should keep usable cardboard offcuts in one tray.
Art note — sentence 2
Yesterday, four pupils needed small pieces and could not find any.
Art note — sentence 3
Could the tray fit beside the paper shelf?
F1 · Drag and drop
Place each sentence in its role.
Complete or match: We should keep usable offcuts in one tray.; Four pupils could not find small pieces yesterday.; Could the tray fit beside the paper shelf?
- a: An observation offered as a reason
- b: The action claim
- c: A question about the plan
The first sentence recommends the action. The second reports a need; the third asks about space.
Source explorer: claim board
F2 · Two short proposals
Puzzle club
A few pieces were left on the floor. Count the pieces before closing each puzzle box.
Watering team
Plants near the door were missed. Use a plant checklist during each watering round.
F2 · Matching
Match each message to its main claim.
Complete or match: Puzzle club message; Watering team message
- a: Use a checklist during watering.
- b: Count pieces before closing boxes.
The missing pieces and missed plants are reasons. The count and checklist sentences give the proposed actions.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · What the notices ask us to accept
Snack table
Crumbs remain after snack time. Wipe the table after eating.
Costume cupboard
Capes look alike. Add a name label inside each cape.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Choose the action claim from each notice.
Complete or match: The snack-table notice asks us to ___.; The costume notice asks us to ___.
- a: count all the crumbs
- b: label each cape
- c: wipe after eating
Wiping and labelling are the requested actions. Counting crumbs is not proposed by either writer.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Trays for bean pots
Group report
Our bean pots are mixed together. Twice this week we checked the wrong group’s pots. Give each group its own tray so its pots stay together.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which statement is the main claim?
- a: Each group should have a tray.
- b: Two checks involved the wrong pots.
- c: Bean pots are mixed on the table.
- d: This week included two mistaken checks.
The separate-tray proposal is the main claim. The other options describe observations offered to explain the need.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · The coat-peg message
Class message
Yesterday, three coats fell because two coats shared one peg. Give each pupil a named peg. This may make it easier to keep coats apart.
F5 · Open ended
State the main claim and name the observation used to support it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The claim is to give each pupil a named peg. The supporting observation is that three coats fell yesterday when two coats shared one peg.
- Identifies the proposal to give each pupil a named peg.
- Identifies the observed fallen coats/shared peg as the reason, rather than treating the possible benefit as an observed result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: document lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Mila’s note
Fictional classroom example. Our class should wait under the covered walkway. Yesterday, rain soaked three notebooks at the open gate.
Questions
The teacher asks, “How many pupils can stand safely under the walkway?” No space count has been made yet.
1A · Matching
Match each statement to its role.
Complete or match: Wait under the covered walkway.; Rain soaked three notebooks.; How many pupils can fit?
- a: A question to investigate
- b: The proposed action
- c: An observation supporting it
The action is the claim; the wet notebooks are evidence; the capacity question asks for missing information.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the walkway sentence is the claim and the notebook sentence supports it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The walkway sentence recommends where to wait. The wet notebooks show a problem the covered place might prevent.
- Identifies the walkway recommendation as the message to accept.
- Connects the soaked notebooks to a reason for cover.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Club message
Fictional classroom example. Two board-game boxes have torn corners. Pieces fell out during packing. A repair box with tape would help our club look after its games.
Inventory
The shelf holds six games and a blue basket. The message does not ask the club to buy new games.
2A · Multiple choice
Which statement best captures the writer’s claim?
- a: All games should be replaced.
- b: The blue basket is the best colour.
- c: A repair box would help protect club games.
- d: The club has exactly two games.
The writer proposes repair supplies to address damaged boxes, not replacement or colour changes.
2B · Short answer
Give one source detail that makes your chosen claim reasonable.
Example of a full-credit answer: The torn boxes let pieces fall out, so tape in a repair box could help keep the pieces together.
- Uses torn boxes or falling pieces as evidence.
- Explains how repair supplies address that problem.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Notice
Fictional classroom example. Please mark a separate walking lane beside the playing area. Younger pupils cross there on their way to the library. Clear arrows could guide walkers around the game.
Draft messages
The team is choosing statements for a proposal, rather than listing every fact about the ground.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all statements that make an action claim matching the notice.
- a: Mark a separate lane for walkers.
- b: The library has a door.
- c: Use arrows to guide walkers around games.
- d: Every child enjoys sports.
Both selected statements propose ways to separate walking from play.
3B · Open ended
Apply the same idea to a busy art table: propose a clear claim and name the problem it would address.
Example of a full-credit answer: Our class should mark a place for drying paintings so wet sheets are not placed under other work.
- States a specific action claim for the art table.
- Connects the action to a relevant table problem.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Paragraph
Fictional classroom example. The garden team planted eight seedlings. Several were stepped on beside the path. The team argues that a low border should separate the bed from the path.
Reader’s answer
Ben says the main claim is “Eight seedlings were planted” because it includes an exact number.
4A · True or false
Ben has correctly identified the paragraph’s main claim.
- true: True
- false: False
The number is a detail; the proposal for a border is the main claim.
4B · Short answer
Correct Ben’s answer and explain his mistake.
Example of a full-credit answer: The main claim is that a low border should separate the bed from the path. Ben chose a detail about planting instead of the proposed solution.
- States the border recommendation.
- Explains the confusion between a numerical detail and the claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Problem
Fictional classroom example. Unlabelled water bottles are left after lunch. A teacher wants a short proposal that includes one clear action and one supporting observation.
Available ideas
Yesterday five bottles were unlabelled. Labels can show owners’ names. The school fence is green.
5A · Drag and drop
Place the useful proposal parts in their roles.
Complete or match: Action claim; Supporting observation
- a: Five bottles were unlabelled yesterday.
- b: Ask pupils to label their bottles.
- c: The fence is green.
The labelling action responds to the observed unlabelled bottles; fence colour is unrelated.
5B · Open ended
Write a two-sentence proposal with one clear action claim and one relevant reason.
Example of a full-credit answer: Pupils should label their water bottles. Five unlabelled bottles were left yesterday, so labels could help return them.
- Proposes a specific relevant action to identify bottles.
- Gives a reason linked to returning or recognising the lost bottles.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.2 · Identifying supporting evidence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A claim about staying shut
Lunch-bag test
A group tested two empty bags with the same ten marbles. After each bag was gently turned upside down three times, the zip bag kept all ten marbles inside. The tie bag lost two.
Question: Which observation supports the limited claim that the zip bag held these marbles better in this test?
Answer: The zip bag kept all ten marbles, while the tie bag lost two.
Why: This is a result about holding the contents, so it connects directly to the claim. The bag’s colour would not test that claim. The result is limited to these bags, these marbles and this trial; it does not prove that every zip bag will hold every object better.
Example 2 · Evidence about finding a page
| Practice dictionary | Total search time |
|---|---|
| Without letter tabs | 54 seconds |
| With letter tabs | 36 seconds |
Dictionary trial
The same six pupils found the same three words in a practice dictionary. Without letter tabs, their total search time was 54 seconds. With tabs, it was 36 seconds. The cover stayed unchanged.
Question: What evidence supports faster searches with tabs in this small trial?
Answer: The total search time fell from 54 to 36 seconds for the same six pupils and three words.
Why: The times measure the action named in the claim. Mentioning the group and task keeps the conclusion within the evidence. Practice might also have helped on the second attempt, so this result supports the observation without proving that tabs alone caused the whole difference. Another carefully arranged trial would help.
Example 3 · Choose a record before testing
Pencil-holder plan
A pupil claims that a wide holder tips over less easily than a narrow holder. The class can put the same twelve pencils in each and gently tilt the same board under them.
Question: What should the class record to test the claim?
Answer: Record the board angle at which each holder tips, using the same pencils and board.
Why: A tipping record measures stability, which is the feature named in the claim. Identical pencils and the same board help make the comparison fair. A list of favourite colours would answer a different question. The test should be repeated carefully before the class makes a broad statement about all holders.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A booklet that stays open
Claim
The flat clip kept this booklet open during our fan test.
Trial record
The same booklet was tested for one minute with the fan at the same setting. Without the clip its cover closed; with the clip it stayed open.
F1 · True or false
The trial record provides relevant evidence for the stated fan-test claim.
- true: True
- false: False
The record tests whether the booklet stayed open under the named conditions. It supports this trial, not every possible wind condition.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Match a claim to a record
Claims
The class wants evidence about a clock’s audibility, a map’s clarity and a bottle lid’s seal.
Records
A: how many pupils heard the clock from the back row. B: how many readers found the correct route on the map. C: how many drops escaped a filled, closed bottle during a careful tip test.
F2 · Matching
Match each claim to the most relevant record.
Complete or match: The clock can be heard at the back.; The map helps readers find the route.; The closed lid keeps water inside.
- a: Readers finding the correct route
- b: Drops escaping during a tip test
- c: Pupils hearing the clock
Hearing counts concern audibility, route choices concern map clarity, and escaped drops concern the seal.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · What supports a storage claim?
Craft-box note — statement
The divided box keeps beads sorted.
Craft-box note — counted result
After the same short carrying walk, 18 of 20 beads remained in their labelled compartments.
Craft-box note — pupil comment
One pupil called the box beautiful.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the evidence check.
Complete or match: The count of sorted beads is ___.; Calling the box beautiful is ___.
- a: relevant measured support
- b: a personal judgement about appearance
- c: proof of perfect sorting
The count directly concerns sorting, but two beads moved. A beauty judgement does not measure sorting.
Source explorer: claim board
F4 · Page-finding pockets
Reading file
A teacher says transparent pockets made task cards quicker to find in one trial. The record gives 42 seconds with opaque sleeves and 28 seconds with transparent pockets for the same set of cards. Both sets used the same binder.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which detail best supports the trial claim?
- a: The binder contained exactly the same set of task cards.
- b: Both kinds of sleeves fitted inside the same class binder.
- c: Recorded search time fell from 42 to 28 seconds.
- d: The teacher kept the timing results on a separate sheet.
The time comparison is direct evidence about finding speed. The other details describe useful conditions or record keeping.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · The return-slot trial
Class claim
The new return slot was used by more of the twenty book borrowers on Tuesday than the old basket was on Monday.
Borrower log
The class had twenty borrowers on each day. On Monday, 11 returned books to the basket; on Tuesday, 17 used the slot. No other days were measured.
F5 · Short answer
Give the evidence supporting the class claim and explain why it fits the claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The log shows 17 of 20 borrowers using the slot on Tuesday compared with 11 of 20 using the basket on Monday. Those counts measure the return-place use described in the claim, for those two days only.
- Gives the relevant comparison of 17 of 20 on Tuesday with 11 of 20 on Monday.
- Connects those counts to use of the return places without claiming the result applies to every day.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: table lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Claim
Fictional classroom example. The library team says the trolley lets pupils return books in less time.
Trial log
The same class returned the same number of books in six minutes without the trolley and four minutes with it. Only one trial of each method was recorded.
1A · True or false
The trial log supports the limited claim that returns were faster with the trolley in this test.
- true: True
- false: False
Four minutes is less than six; the wording correctly limits the conclusion to this test.
1B · Short answer
Name the supporting result and one reason to repeat the test.
Example of a full-credit answer: The return took four rather than six minutes. Repeating it would show whether the result occurs again instead of relying on one trial.
- Identifies the four-versus-six-minute result.
- Explains the need to check repeatability or a one-trial limitation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Proposal
Fictional classroom example. A class claims a felt mat reduces the sound of chairs scraping the floor.
Records
With the same chairs moved in the same way, a sound meter gave lower readings on the mat in four trials. The mat is yellow and cost 200 classroom tokens.
2A · Multiple choice
Which detail provides the most relevant support?
- a: The mat is yellow.
- b: The price is 200 tokens.
- c: The same movement gave lower sound readings on the mat.
- d: The chairs belong to the class.
Matched movement and measured sound address the claim; colour and ownership do not.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the sound readings are better support than the price.
Example of a full-credit answer: The readings measure the sound the claim is about. Price says what the mat costs but does not tell whether scraping becomes quieter.
- Connects sound readings to the claimed effect.
- Explains why price does not measure noise reduction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New setting
Fictional classroom example. The school club wants to test whether larger labels make lunch boxes easier to identify. It also wants to know whether the labels stay attached after washing.
Possible records
A timed matching task records identification. A wash log records which labels remain attached. A colour vote records favourite designs.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each claim to a suitable evidence record.
Complete or match: Labels help identify boxes faster.; Labels remain attached after washing.
- a: Log of labels still attached after washing
- b: Favourite-colour vote
- c: Time taken to match boxes to owners
Identification time and washing durability require different evidence.
3B · Short answer
Propose a fair identification test using old and new labels.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask the same readers to match comparable boxes using each label size, and record the times under the same viewing conditions.
- Compares identification with old and new labels.
- Includes a fair condition and a relevant timing or accuracy measure.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Evidence
Fictional classroom example. Eighteen of twenty club members say they like the new song. No one has measured whether the song helps pupils remember spelling words.
Claim under review
A poster says, “The vote proves this song improves spelling.”
4A · Matching
Match each statement to the kind of information it gives.
Complete or match: Eighteen members like the song.; The song improves spelling.
- a: A learning claim not tested by this vote
- b: A preference result
- c: A count of correct spellings
Liking a song is different from learning spellings with it.
4B · Open ended
Explain the poster’s error and name evidence that could test its claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: It treats liking the song as proof of better spelling. A comparison of spelling results with and without the song could test the learning claim.
- Explains the preference-versus-learning mismatch.
- Suggests measuring relevant spelling performance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Proposal sheet
Fictional classroom example. The class wants to claim that a cover keeps a seed tray drier during a short water-spray test.
Test choices
Plan A: photograph the bright cover. Plan B: spray equal water on matched covered and uncovered trays, then measure collected water. Plan C: ask which cover looks nicest.
5A · Hotspot
Select the test-plan region that could provide relevant comparative evidence.
- a: Plan A: photograph the bright cover
- b: Plan B: matched covered and uncovered trays; equal spray; measure water
- c: Plan C: vote for the nicest cover
Plan B compares the relevant outcome under matched conditions.
5B · Short answer
Design one useful record for the test and explain what result would support the cover claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a table of water collected in each tray after equal spraying. Less collected water in the covered tray would support the limited test claim.
- Proposes a record of water in covered and uncovered trays.
- States the relevant supporting direction: less water with the cover.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.3 · Distinguishing claims from evidence
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A recommendation and its record
Assembly note
Place a low step beside the display table. During a supervised trial, five pupils could not see the objects at the back of the table.
Question: Which sentence is the claim, and which supplies evidence?
Answer: The low-step recommendation is the claim. The record of five pupils being unable to see is evidence offered for it.
Why: The first sentence says what the writer wants done. The second reports a difficulty that helps explain the proposal. Finding the evidence does not prove that a step is the safest or only solution. Other solutions and safe arrangements would still need to be considered.
Example 2 · Repeating praise is not a test
Two notes
Note A: This pen is dependable because it is the most dependable pen. Note B: This pen wrote the full practice page without stopping; the test page is attached.
Question: Which note provides an observation instead of repeating praise?
Answer: Note B provides an observation: the pen completed one practice page without stopping.
Why: Note A uses the same judgement twice, so it supplies no separate reason. Note B offers something the reader can inspect. It supports a limited conclusion about one writing task. Neither note establishes that the pen will always work, and the attached page should still be checked before accepting the report.
Example 3 · A number can still be a claim
Robot-club poster
Our robot solves every maze in ten seconds! The poster names no maze, timing record or test. A separate class notebook lists three trial times: 18, 21 and 19 seconds.
Question: Why is the poster’s number not evidence for its own promise?
Answer: The ten-second statement is an unsupported claim; no test is given to establish it.
Why: A number may look precise while still needing a source. The notebook contains actual reported trial results that can be checked, and those three results do not match the poster’s promise. Keep the statement being promoted separate from the observations offered to judge it. Do not assume that adding a number turns a promise into proof.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choosing a floor mat
Class note
The cork mat should stay in the quiet corner. In a recorded comparison, 12 of 16 pupils chose it over the rubber mat after sitting on both.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which sentence gives the claim?
- a: Twelve pupils selected the cork mat.
- b: Sixteen pupils sat on both materials.
- c: The cork mat should stay in the corner.
- d: Four pupils did not select the cork mat.
Keeping the mat is the proposed action. The preference count is evidence offered for that proposal.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · The stepping-stone argument
Message — sentence 1
Use marked stepping stones in the pretend obstacle course.
Message — sentence 2
In yesterday’s round, seven players asked where to go next.
Message — sentence 3
Marks could show the intended route.
F2 · Drag and drop
Place each part in its role.
Complete or match: Use marked stepping stones.; Seven players asked where to go next.; Marks could show the intended route.
- a: Recorded observation
- b: Explanation of a possible benefit
- c: Action claim
The request is the claim; the seven questions are the observation; the final sentence explains how marks might help.
Source explorer: claim board
F3 · Which panel is evidence?
Paint-brush argument
Claim: The new rinse cup keeps this tray drier in the ten-minute art trial. The teacher is comparing evidence with repeated claims.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the panel that offers evidence about keeping the tray dry.
- a: The cup is excellent because it is a great cup.
- b: In equal ten-minute trials, the old cup left six wet patches and the new cup left two.
- c: The new cup is certainly the finest rinse cup.
A counted wet-patch comparison is evidence about dryness. Repeated praise is not a separate observation.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · A neatly labelled argument
Bean-growing log
The class measured the same pot each morning. The log records a height of 4 cm on Monday and 6 cm on Friday.
Pupil explanation
This bean plant grew taller during the school week. The change from 4 cm to 6 cm supports that conclusion.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the two descriptions.
Complete or match: “The plant grew taller during the week” is the ___.; “4 cm on Monday and 6 cm on Friday” is the ___.
- a: recorded evidence
- b: conclusion drawn from the record
- c: unrelated decoration
The measured heights are the evidence. The growth statement expresses what the pupil concludes from them.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Quiet wheels
Equipment request
We should use the soft-wheeled trolley for moving craft boxes. In a recorded test on the same corridor, its sound reading was lower than the hard-wheeled trolley’s at the same distance.
F5 · Open ended
Identify the claim and the evidence offered for it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The claim is to use the soft-wheeled trolley for craft boxes. The evidence is the lower sound reading compared with the hard-wheeled trolley on the same corridor at the same distance.
- Identifies the recommendation to use the soft-wheeled trolley.
- Identifies the comparative sound-test result as the evidence, rather than repeating the recommendation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: document lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Meeting note
Fictional classroom example. The back table was noticeably dim. Three pupils there could not read the smallest print on a worksheet. The class representative says, “We should improve the light at that table.”
Limit
The class has not tested a lamp yet. The note describes a problem and a suggested response.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete each description.
Complete or match: We should improve the light is a…; Three pupils could not read the print is…
- a: supporting observation
- b: proposed claim
- c: completed lamp test
The recommendation is a claim; the reported reading difficulty is evidence of a problem.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the observation supports the proposal without proving that a particular lamp will solve it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Difficulty reading at that table suggests the lighting needs attention. No lamp was tested, so the note does not establish which lamp would work.
- Links the reading difficulty to the lighting proposal.
- Recognises that the effectiveness of a particular lamp remains untested.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Test record
Fictional classroom example. In the same bending test, a thin bookmark tore after two bends and a thick bookmark after eight. The maker concludes that the thick bookmark lasted longer in this test.
Extra sentence
The maker also writes, “Our design is wonderful.” No test measured wonderfulness.
2A · Drag and drop
Place each sentence in its role.
Complete or match: Test evidence; Limited test conclusion; Personal praise
- a: The design is wonderful.
- b: The thick bookmark lasted longer in this test.
- c: Two bends versus eight before tearing.
The count is evidence, the limited comparison is a conclusion, and wonderful is praise.
2B · Short answer
Why is the limited conclusion better supported than the personal praise?
Example of a full-credit answer: The bend counts directly compare how long the bookmarks lasted. They do not measure whether a design is wonderful, which is a judgement.
- Explains the count-to-durability link.
- Distinguishes personal praise from the measured result.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Transport example
Fictional classroom example. A notice recommends leaving five minutes earlier for a club trip. Its reason is that three recent trips reached the venue after the starting time.
Reader’s task
Decide which part is the recommended change and which part reports past events.
3A · True or false
“Three recent trips arrived late” is supporting information, while “leave earlier” is the proposed claim.
- true: True
- false: False
The past arrivals support a proposed change in departure time.
3B · Open ended
Give a different claim the same arrival evidence might support, and explain the connection.
Example of a full-credit answer: The club should check its route time before the next trip, because repeated late arrivals suggest its travel estimate may be too short.
- Proposes a relevant alternative action or conclusion.
- Links that action to the repeated late arrivals.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Argument card
Fictional classroom example. “Our reading bench is useful because it is helpful. It has green paint. Four pupils borrowed books while seated there on Tuesday.”
Review question
Which part adds a separate observation about pupils actually using the bench, instead of simply praising it again?
4A · Hotspot
Select the sentence that provides a separate observation about pupils actually using the bench.
- a: The bench is useful because it is helpful.
- b: It has green paint.
- c: Four pupils borrowed books while seated there on Tuesday.
The borrowing observation adds relevant information; helpful just repeats useful.
4B · Short answer
Explain why “useful because it is helpful” is weak support and state what the observation actually shows.
Example of a full-credit answer: Useful and helpful repeat the same judgement. The observation shows that four pupils used the bench during book borrowing on one day.
- Identifies repeated meaning rather than independent support.
- Limits the observation to the stated users or occasion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Planning brief
Fictional classroom example. A garden team wants a message recommending plant labels. Visitors confused mint with another herb on four recorded visits. The team must state an action, support it and acknowledge what has not been tested.
Untested point
Nobody has yet compared different label designs.
5A · Matching
Match each message part to its job.
Complete or match: Add clear labels to the herb pots.; Confusion was recorded on four visits.; We still need to test label designs.
- a: A limitation
- b: A claim
- c: Supporting evidence
The proposal, recorded problem and untested detail serve different roles.
5B · Open ended
Write a short proposal containing a claim and its relevant evidence, without claiming a label design is proven.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add labels to the herb pots because visitors confused herbs on four recorded visits. We should try and compare designs before choosing one.
- Includes a label proposal supported by the recorded confusion.
- Acknowledges that effectiveness or design remains to be tested.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.4 · Distinguishing facts from opinions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A timetable can be checked
Gallery leaflet
The leaflet says, “Our model gallery opens at ten.” Sam says, “It is the most exciting room in school.” A current opening notice lists ten o’clock.
Question: Which statement is factual, and which is an opinion?
Answer: The opening-time statement is factual and agrees with the notice. “Most exciting” is Sam’s opinion.
Why: A factual statement concerns something we can check. Here a relevant notice supplies that check. Excitement is a personal response, so another visitor could feel differently. Calling the opening-time statement factual describes its kind; checking it against the current notice is the additional step that establishes its accuracy in this example.
Example 2 · Split a mixed description
Mural review
The mural has nine painted birds, and its colours are the loveliest in the whole building. A close photograph lets readers count all nine birds.
Question: Which part can be checked by counting, and which expresses a judgement?
Answer: Nine painted birds can be checked. “Loveliest colours” expresses a judgement.
Why: One sentence can do both jobs. The photograph can establish the number, but it cannot prove that every viewer will find the colours loveliest. Separate the two parts before labelling them. A true count does not turn a nearby opinion into a fact, and an opinion does not make the count false.
Example 3 · Words that look like opinions
Two comments
Lena says, “I think this rope is two metres long.” Arun says, “This rope feels nicer than the rough one.” A tape measure is available.
Question: Does “I think” make Lena’s length statement an opinion about preference?
Answer: No. The length is a checkable factual statement, even though Lena sounds uncertain.
Why: Read the meaning, not just a signal phrase. A tape measure can test the two-metre claim. Arun’s “nicer” describes his own preference and might differ from another person’s view. Neither speaker’s confidence decides whether the length claim is accurate. Checking and personal preference are different kinds of reading work.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A shell display
Labels
A: The display contains twelve shells. B: The spiral shell is the prettiest. C: The largest shell is 8 cm wide and wonderfully beautiful.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each label with the kind of statement it contains.
Complete or match: Label A; Label B; Label C
- a: Opinion only
- b: Both a checkable detail and an opinion
- c: Checkable factual statement only
A gives a count, B gives a preference, and C mixes a measurement with praise.
Source explorer: word lab
F2 · Uncertain words, checkable details
Mara’s comment
Mara says, “I think the rehearsal begins at 2 p.m.”
Joel’s comment
Joel says, “For me, afternoon rehearsals are more enjoyable.”
F2 · Dropdown selection
Choose the best description of each statement.
Complete or match: Mara’s statement about the starting time is ___.; Joel’s statement about enjoyment is ___.
- a: a checkable time claim
- b: a personal preference
- c: a verified timetable entry
A timetable could check Mara’s claim, but none is supplied. Joel describes his own enjoyment.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · The round badge
Badge card
The maker writes, “The badge is 22 mm across.” No ruler or measuring record is shown.
F3 · True or false
The sentence about 22 mm is a factual claim that can be checked, although this card does not verify it.
- true: True
- false: False
Diameter can be measured. Its checkability makes it a factual claim; a measurement is still needed to verify the number.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Which question fits?
Review tasks
The class will write three parts of a model-boat review: an exact size, a personal preference and a checked event result.
F4 · Matching
Match each task to the question that fits it.
Complete or match: Report an exact size.; Report a personal preference.; Report a checked event result.
- a: Which design do you like best?
- b: Which boat reached the line first in the recorded race?
- c: How many centimetres long is the boat?
Size and race results are checkable. Liking one design is a personal judgement.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · The handmade badge review
Review sentence
This badge is 5 cm wide, and it is the loveliest badge in our class.
F5 · Short answer
Identify the factual claim and the opinion in the review sentence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The factual claim is that the badge is 5 cm wide; a ruler could check it. The opinion is that it is the loveliest badge in the class.
- Identifies the 5 cm width as a checkable factual claim.
- Identifies loveliest badge as a personal judgement/opinion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Display label
Fictional classroom example. The red kite has four ribbons. It flew for twelve minutes in the club demonstration. Its maker calls it “the most exciting kite on the field”.
Reading task
Separate recorded or countable details from the maker’s judgement.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each statement to the most specific description.
Complete or match: The kite has four ribbons.; The kite flew for twelve minutes.; It is the most exciting kite.
- a: A personal judgement
- b: A countable feature
- c: A timed result
Ribbons and flight time can be checked; most exciting expresses a judgement.
1B · Short answer
Choose one checkable statement and describe how to check it. Then name the opinion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Count the ribbons to check whether there are four. “Most exciting” is the maker’s opinion.
- Gives a valid check for a ribbon or time statement.
- Identifies most exciting as the opinion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Book-review card
Fictional classroom example. “This book has six chapters. Its final chapter starts on page 41. The ending is wonderfully surprising.”
Reader’s purpose
The librarian wants to quote the reviewer’s personal judgement, not a page-location fact.
2A · Hotspot
Select the region that gives the reviewer’s opinion.
- a: This book has six chapters.
- b: Its final chapter starts on page 41.
- c: The ending is wonderfully surprising.
Wonderfully surprising evaluates the ending; chapter and page details can be checked.
2B · Open ended
Explain why different readers could reasonably disagree with the selected statement while agreeing on the chapter count.
Example of a full-credit answer: Readers can react differently to the ending. They can count the same six chapters even if they do not share the reviewer’s reaction.
- Explains that the ending judgement depends on a reader’s reaction.
- Explains that the chapter count can be checked independently.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional classroom example. “I think the practice starts at 3:30,” writes Leo. The attached current timetable also says 3:30. Another pupil writes, “Afternoon practices are the best.”
New context
The class is learning that signal words do not decide everything.
3A · True or false
The words “I think” make the practice time impossible to check.
- true: True
- false: False
The time remains a checkable claim and can be compared with the timetable.
3B · Short answer
Explain how you would check the start time and how the other pupil’s statement differs.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the current timetable for 3:30. “Afternoon practices are the best” is a preference, not a scheduled time.
- Uses the timetable to check the time claim.
- Identifies the best-practice statement as a judgement or preference.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Visitor card
Fictional classroom example. “The model bridge is two metres long and is the most amazing object here.”
Mistaken answer
Nico marks every word as fact because the sentence contains a measurement.
4A · Matching
Match each part to its role.
Complete or match: The bridge is two metres long.; It is the most amazing object here.
- a: An opinion about the display
- b: A length claim that can be measured
- c: A direction to an exit
The measurement does not turn the separate praise into a fact.
4B · Open ended
Correct Nico’s classification and explain why the sentence needs two labels.
Example of a full-credit answer: Two metres long is checkable by measuring. Most amazing is a personal judgement, so one sentence contains both kinds of statement.
- Correctly classifies the length claim.
- Correctly classifies the praise and recognises the mixed sentence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing brief
Fictional classroom example. Write a review of a board game. The box states that it is for two to four players. Your test game lasted fifteen minutes. You enjoyed its animal pictures.
Purpose
Help another child distinguish game information from your own reaction.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the review plan.
Complete or match: The two-to-four-player statement belongs under…; I enjoyed the animal pictures belongs under…
- a: Personal reaction
- b: Checkable game information
- c: A safety guarantee
Player range is box information; enjoyment is a personal reaction.
5B · Short answer
Write a brief review containing one accurate checkable detail and one clearly personal opinion.
Example of a full-credit answer: The box says the game is for two to four players. I enjoyed the animal pictures.
- Includes a checkable detail supported by the supplied information.
- Expresses a personal opinion as a judgement rather than a universal fact.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.5 · Identifying reasons supporting a conclusion
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Why move the sign?
Visitor plan
New visitors often turn into the wrong corridor. A direction sign stands after the turning point. Move the sign before the turn so visitors can see it in time.
Question: What reason supports moving the sign?
Answer: Visitors need the direction before they choose a corridor, and the present sign appears too late.
Why: The reason connects the proposed action to the problem. The building’s paint colour would be about the same place but would not explain this change. Try joining the parts with because: move the sign earlier because visitors must see directions before deciding where to turn. The explanation makes the proposed action understandable.
Example 2 · Two reasons, one conclusion
Garden visit
The group should carry one shared route card. The route has three unfamiliar turns, and the group must return to the same gate. Each pupil already has a water bottle.
Question: Which two details help explain the route-card proposal?
Answer: The unfamiliar turns and the need to return to the same gate support carrying a route card.
Why: Both details concern finding the way. Having water bottles may matter for the visit, but it does not explain why a route card is needed. A relevant reason does more than mention the same event. It helps the reader see how the proposed action could meet a particular need.
Example 3 · A reason can count against a plan
Display proposal
Move the class model beside the open door so it is easier to see. The model is light enough to be knocked over by a strong draught. The door is used often.
Question: Does the draught detail support or challenge that location?
Answer: It challenges that location because the moving air could knock over the light model.
Why: A nearby detail is not automatically a supporting reason. First identify the decision: where to display the model. Then decide how each fact affects it. The draught detail raises a problem for the doorway location. The class may need a more stable position or another way to make the model visible.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Planning a reading visit
Plan
Take a printed room list on the visit. There are four similar doors, and the phone signal inside the building is unreliable.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the links between reasons and the proposed room list.
Complete or match: Four similar doors make a room list useful for ___.; Unreliable phone signal makes a printed copy useful because ___.
- a: it changes the doors’ colours
- b: finding the intended room
- c: it can be read without a connection
The list helps identify rooms, and paper remains readable when a phone cannot connect.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · The green folder
Proposal
We should replace the torn folder because its cover is green. The class wants to stop papers falling out.
F2 · True or false
The folder’s green colour explains why replacing it would stop papers falling out.
- true: True
- false: False
Colour does not establish whether the folder holds papers. The tear, not the colour, is relevant to that problem.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Keep the instruction card nearby
Craft task
The group is assembling a paper bridge. The steps must be followed in order. Pupils forget which fold comes next. The instruction card has a decorative star. The card is printed on cream paper.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select the two reasons supporting keeping the instruction card beside the work.
- a: The steps must be followed in order.
- b: Pupils forget which fold comes next.
- c: The card has a decorative star.
- d: The card is printed on cream paper.
Step order and forgotten folds explain why the instructions should be handy. The star and paper colour do not explain the need.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Sort reasons for a portable board
Decision
The class proposes a wheeled board to carry a diagram between rooms.
Notes
The diagram is needed in two rooms. A wheeled board cannot pass through the narrow connecting doorway. The school’s badge is blue.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place each note in its role for this proposal.
Complete or match: The diagram is needed in two rooms.; The board cannot pass through the doorway.; The school badge is blue.
- a: Challenges the proposed plan
- b: Supports the need for a movable diagram
- c: Does not address this decision
Sharing between rooms supports mobility. The doorway blocks this particular plan. Badge colour does not address moving the board.
Source explorer: claim board
F5 · A numbered-tool return plan
Workshop problem
At clean-up time, pupils cannot tell which small tools are missing. The class proposes drawing each tool’s outline on a numbered board. A spare wall space is available.
F5 · Open ended
Give one reason supporting the numbered-outline board and explain its link to finding missing tools.
Example of a full-credit answer: An empty outline would show that its tool has not been returned. The matching number could help pupils identify which tool to look for, so the board makes the missing item clearer.
- Gives a relevant reason based on an empty outline or identifiable numbered position.
- Explains how that feature helps notice or identify a missing tool, rather than offering unrelated praise.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Guide plan
Fictional classroom example. The art club proposes a one-way route through its narrow exhibition room.
Reason cards
Card 1: Groups met head-on twice in yesterday’s trial. Card 2: The posters use purple paper. Card 3: The school owns brushes.
1A · Hotspot
Select the region that best supports a one-way route.
- a: Groups met head-on twice in the narrow room.
- b: The posters use purple paper.
- c: The school owns brushes.
Head-on meetings relate directly to the movement problem a one-way route could reduce.
1B · Open ended
Explain the link between the selected reason and the route proposal.
Example of a full-credit answer: A one-way route makes groups move in the same direction, which could reduce the head-on meetings seen in the trial.
- Uses the observed head-on meetings.
- Explains how same-direction travel addresses that problem.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Club cupboard
Fictional classroom example. Paint bottles leak when laid sideways. Paper bends when pushed under heavy boxes. The club proposes upright bottle holders and a separate flat paper shelf.
Constraint
The reason for each change should match the specific problem.
2A · Matching
Match each proposal with its supporting reason.
Complete or match: Keep paint bottles upright.; Give paper a separate flat shelf.
- a: Paper bends beneath heavy boxes.
- b: Sideways bottles leak.
- c: The door handle is shiny.
Each proposal addresses the corresponding storage problem.
2B · Short answer
Choose one match and explain why the other problem would be weaker support for that proposal.
Example of a full-credit answer: Upright holders address leaking sideways bottles. Bent paper does not explain how bottles should stand.
- Explains the relevant proposal-to-problem link.
- Distinguishes the unrelated reason for that same proposal.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
New situation
Fictional classroom example. At a school festival, ticket buyers and ticket holders stand in one line. People who already have tickets wait while others pay. A volunteer proposes two labelled lines.
Plan parts
The proposal must connect each label with the people it will help.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each group with the reason for its line.
Complete or match: Buy tickets here; Enter with a ticket here
- a: These visitors have already paid.
- b: These visitors still need to pay.
- c: These visitors like bright signs.
Separate lines distinguish people who need payment from those ready to enter.
3B · Open ended
Explain how the proposal could address the delay, and name a condition needed for it to work.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ticket holders would not wait behind each payment. The labels must be clear, and someone must direct people to the right line.
- Explains separation of payment from entry.
- Names a relevant condition such as clear signs, space or guidance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Class proposal
Fictional classroom example. A class wants to keep reading books dry and easy to reach. One pupil proposes an uncovered box under a dripping tap.
Details
The box is close to the reading table. The tap drips into it. The box is large enough for the books. Its painted stars are attractive.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all details that support at least one stated goal, even though the full plan remains flawed.
- a: The box is close to the reading table.
- b: The tap drips into the box.
- c: The box has enough room for the books.
- d: The stars look attractive.
Nearness and capacity help access or storage; dripping water defeats dryness, and decoration is unrelated.
4B · Short answer
Explain why some supporting reasons still do not make this a good overall plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: Nearness and space are helpful, but water dripping into the box threatens the goal of keeping books dry. The box should be moved or covered appropriately.
- Acknowledges a relevant supporting feature.
- Explains the conflicting wetness problem and its importance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Design brief
Fictional classroom example. The club lends cloth bags. Pupils often forget where to return them. A return basket must be easy to find and must not block the doorway.
Idea
Put a labelled basket beside the borrowing desk, outside the walking path.
5A · True or false
The proposed basket location has reasons connected to both finding the return point and keeping the path clear.
- true: True
- false: False
The borrowing desk is a recognisable location, while the outside-path condition addresses access.
5B · Open ended
Propose your own suitable return arrangement and give two reasons linked to the brief.
Example of a full-credit answer: Place a clearly labelled return basket beside the borrowing desk but away from the doorway. Borrowers can find it easily, and it will not block people walking through.
- Proposes an identifiable return point linked to easy finding.
- Explains a layout choice that keeps the doorway or path clear.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.6 · Recognising counterarguments
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A concern about the cost
Visit discussion
Ari proposes buying matching notebooks for the history visit. Bea replies, “Some families may not be able to pay for a new notebook. Could we use the notebooks we already have?”
Question: What counterargument does Bea raise?
Answer: Buying new notebooks may create an extra cost that some families cannot manage.
Why: Bea challenges one part of the plan and suggests another way to meet the need. She does not say the history visit is worthless. State the concern fairly before answering it. Ari could check whether existing notebooks would work or whether spare notebooks are available, rather than accusing Bea of opposing every class activity.
Example 2 · Answer the actual objection
Practice cards
Proposal: Put every practice card on a website. Objection: Some pupils cannot connect to the internet at home. Reply A: The website looks exciting. Reply B: Keep printed copies available as well.
Question: Which reply addresses the objection?
Answer: Reply B: keep printed copies available as well.
Why: The objection concerns access, so a useful reply must explain how pupils without a connection can get the cards. Exciting appearance does not solve that problem. This does not show that websites are always unsuitable. It shows how a counterargument can lead to a more complete plan that uses both online and printed materials.
Example 3 · An objection can improve a plan
Bell proposal
Pupils suggest a bell for the outdoor game area. The reading group worries that a loud bell beside its window will interrupt quiet work. Both groups want pupils to know when games end.
Question: How could the proposal respond to the reading group’s concern?
Answer: Trial a quieter signal farther from the reading window, then check that game players can still notice it.
Why: The reply keeps the shared goal while addressing the stated noise concern. It does not pretend the readers dislike games or that the players dislike reading. Testing both audibility and noise would show whether the revision works. A fair response can improve a proposal instead of simply declaring one side the winner.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A wheeled art cart
Proposal
Use a cart to move art supplies between classrooms.
Concern
The corridor has one step, so wheels alone may not solve the whole trip.
Reply
Check the step and plan safe help before choosing a cart.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the argument map.
Complete or match: The concern challenges the plan because ___.; The reply answers it by proposing ___.
- a: the route includes a step
- b: the supplies look colourful
- c: a check and safe plan for the step
The step is a relevant obstacle. Checking and planning for it responds to the concern rather than ignoring it.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Choosing a meeting time
Lia
Meet at seven in the morning.
Niko
Some members arrive later by bus.
Cora
Choose a time after those buses arrive.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match the statement to its role.
Complete or match: Meet at seven in the morning.; Some members arrive later by bus.; Meet after those buses arrive.
- a: Counterargument about access
- b: Response that adjusts the plan
- c: Original proposal
Niko raises a timing obstacle. Cora changes the time to address that obstacle.
Source explorer: perspective
F3 · Replies that fit concerns
Concerns
A: The poster uses letters too small for the back row. B: The timetable leaves no time to put equipment away. C: The game needs pieces the class does not own.
Possible replies
Try a larger-letter poster at the same distance. Add five minutes for packing away. Choose a version using the class’s existing pieces.
F3 · Matching
Match each concern to its most direct reply.
Complete or match: Concern A: letters too small; Concern B: no packing-away time; Concern C: missing game pieces
- a: Use existing pieces.
- b: Try larger letters.
- c: Add packing-away time.
Each reply addresses the particular difficulty, rather than merely praising the original plan.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · A fair reading of an objection
Trip note
A pupil says, “Please check whether the path is accessible before we choose it.” Another pupil replies, “You never want us to go anywhere.”
F4 · True or false
The reply fairly restates the request to check path access.
- true: True
- false: False
A request to check one path does not say the pupil opposes every trip. The reply exaggerates the objection.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · A shared craft machine
Proposal
Keep the class label maker on one table so everyone can use it.
Objection
If several groups need labels at once, a queue may stop them working.
F5 · Short answer
State the objection fairly and suggest one practical response to it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The objection is that groups may have to wait when they need the shared label maker at the same time. Groups could book short turns or prepare labels at different times so the queue is smaller.
- Identifies the concern about simultaneous use causing a queue or delay.
- Proposes a relevant response such as a turn schedule, staggered label-making or another workable way to reduce waiting.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Proposal
Fictional classroom example. A group wants recorded music in the courtyard at lunchtime.
Replies
Alma worries that nearby readers will struggle to hear their partners. Tomas says the proposal poster has nice colours. Mina asks what songs people like.
1A · Multiple choice
Which reply is a counterargument about a possible problem with the plan?
- a: The poster has nice colours.
- b: Music might make nearby reading difficult.
- c: Which songs do people like?
- d: The courtyard is at school.
The reading concern gives a reason the proposed music may need changing.
1B · Short answer
Explain why that concern is relevant and propose one adjustment.
Example of a full-credit answer: Music could interfere with readers hearing each other. The group could use a quieter area or limit volume away from reading tables.
- Connects music to the stated reading difficulty.
- Suggests an adjustment that addresses noise or location.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Committee note
Fictional classroom example. A pupil proposes placing a mobile bookshelf in the hallway.
Responses
Response A: Books should be easy to reach. Response B: The proposed spot may leave too little room for wheelchairs to pass. Response C: The shelf is brown.
2A · Hotspot
Select the response region that challenges the proposed placement.
- a: A: Books should be easy to reach.
- b: B: The spot may leave too little wheelchair space.
- c: C: The shelf is brown.
The passage-space concern directly challenges the location, while supporting the goal of access.
2B · Open ended
Explain why moving the shelf may answer the objection better than removing all books from the hallway.
Example of a full-credit answer: Moving it to a wide, accessible spot could preserve access to books while keeping wheelchair space clear. Removing every book is more than the objection asks for.
- Addresses the need for clear passage.
- Preserves the book-access goal or accurately limits the objection.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Discussion
Fictional classroom example. A class proposes a fish tank. Jo asks who will feed the fish during holidays. Pat worries that the chosen shelf may not safely hold the filled tank.
Task
The class should match each concern with a relevant response before deciding.
3A · Dropdown selection
Choose a response that addresses each concern.
Complete or match: Feeding during holidays; Shelf strength
- a: Arrange a responsible care plan for holidays.
- b: Check the filled tank’s weight and a suitable support.
- c: Choose a brighter tank decoration.
Care arrangements and support checks answer different practical objections.
3B · Short answer
Choose one concern and explain why the decoration response fails to answer it.
Example of a full-credit answer: A holiday care concern needs a plan for someone to feed and check the fish. Brighter decorations do not provide care when school is closed.
- Accurately explains either the care or support concern.
- Explains why decoration does not address that concern.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original comment
Fictional classroom example. “I support a class garden, but we need a watering plan for weekends,” says Lito.
Mistaken reply
“Lito hates plants and wants every garden closed,” says another pupil.
4A · True or false
The reply fairly represents Lito’s counterargument.
- true: True
- false: False
Lito supports the garden and asks about weekend care; the reply exaggerates and changes his position.
4B · Open ended
State Lito’s actual concern and suggest a relevant answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: He wants to know how the garden will be watered on weekends. The class could arrange an approved rota or another suitable care system.
- Identifies weekend watering rather than opposition to gardens.
- Offers a response that addresses weekend care.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Proposal
Fictional classroom example. Run a painting club in the shared study room after lunch.
Objections
Readers need quiet. Wet paint could damage books. The room is shared, so both activities should remain possible.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each adjustment with the concern it addresses.
Complete or match: Protect nearby books; Keep a quiet study area
- a: Use a separate covered painting table away from book shelves.
- b: Set a low-noise area and separate the activities.
- c: Use a bigger club badge.
Table protection addresses paint; separating low-noise study addresses the reading concern.
5B · Short answer
Propose a workable club plan that answers both objections.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use a covered table away from books, and keep the painting group in a separate quiet section or time. Readers still have a calm place and books are protected from paint.
- Addresses paint protection for books.
- Addresses quiet access for readers while allowing an activity plan.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.7 · Evaluating whether evidence supports a claim
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Keep the conclusion inside the test
Clay test
The class wrapped one lump of clay in cloth and put another equal lump in a closed tub. After one afternoon in the same room, the tub’s clay was softer. No other materials or days were tested.
Question: Does this establish that every tub keeps all clay soft forever?
Answer: No. It supports only a limited comparison of these two lumps over that afternoon.
Why: The very wide claim adds every tub, all clay and forever, none of which the small test examines. The result is still useful: the tub’s clay was softer under the described conditions. A good reader preserves those limits rather than treating limited evidence as either complete proof or completely useless.
Example 2 · Same result, several possible causes
Practice report
One reading group used new word cards and had an extra ten minutes of practice. Its score rose. The report says the cards alone caused the improvement.
Question: Why does the report not establish that the cards alone caused the higher score?
Answer: Both the cards and practice time changed, so the report does not separate their possible effects.
Why: The score increase is an observation, but the explanation goes further. Extra practice could matter too. A useful next comparison would keep practice time the same while changing the cards. Recognising this limit does not prove that the cards had no effect; it means the stated evidence cannot isolate their effect.
Example 3 · Evidence about the right feature
Container comparison
A seller says Box A is stronger than Box B. The only listed test compares their colours: eight pupils prefer A’s blue lid to B’s orange lid. No load or damage test is given.
Question: Does the colour-preference result support the strength claim?
Answer: No. It reports a colour preference, not a test of strength.
Why: The evidence and the claim concern different features. A box could have a popular colour while being weak, or an unpopular colour while being strong. To evaluate the strength claim, readers need a relevant test, such as a described load test under matching conditions. The number eight does not repair the mismatch.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Six readers, one paragraph
Trial
Six pupils read one practice paragraph aloud. Four made fewer pauses with the larger print.
Conclusion choices
One claim describes those six pupils and that paragraph. Another claims that larger print helps every reader with every text.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the careful conclusion.
Complete or match: The reported improvement happened for ___ pupils.; The tested text was ___.
- a: every
- b: four of six
- c: one practice paragraph
The source reports four of six pupils and one paragraph. It does not establish a result for all readers or texts.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · What did each test measure?
Test records
A: Ten identical blocks were placed on each model shelf; the teacher recorded whether it bent. B: Pupils read two labels from two metres away; correct readings were counted. C: Equal amounts of water were poured into two containers; escaped drops were counted.
F2 · Matching
Match each record to the feature it can help evaluate.
Complete or match: Record A; Record B; Record C
- a: Reading clarity at that distance
- b: Holding the tested load
- c: Keeping water inside in that trial
The records concern bending under a load, reading labels and escaping water. They should not be used to claim unrelated benefits.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Two changes in the music room
Room change
During one week, the group moved to a quieter room.
Group-size change
During that same week, the group size was reduced from sixteen pupils to eight.
Recorded outcome
Fewer interruptions were recorded after both changes. The record supplies no separate trial of either change alone.
F3 · True or false
This record proves that the quieter room alone caused the reduction in interruptions.
- true: True
- false: False
Room conditions and group size both changed. The record cannot separate their effects.
Source explorer: cause lab
F4 · Sort conclusions by evidence
Test
Five identical toy cars were rolled once on a smooth board. All five reached the finish line. No carpet trial was carried out.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each conclusion to its evidence status.
Complete or match: All five tested cars reached the line on the board.; Every toy car will always reach any finish line.; These cars would reach the line on carpet.
- a: Directly reported by this test
- b: Much broader than this test
- c: Not tested on that surface
The first statement reports the trial. The second generalises far beyond it. The third needs a carpet test.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Does the timer help every group?
Trial log
One group used a sand timer to take turns in one board game. During that game, all four members had a turn.
Poster claim
A sand timer guarantees fair turns in every game and every group.
F5 · Open ended
Write a conclusion the log supports and explain one limit of the poster’s claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: In the recorded game, all four members of one group had a turn while using a sand timer. The log does not test every group or game, so it cannot justify the poster’s guarantee.
- States a limited conclusion about the four members, one group or recorded game.
- Explains that every game/every group or a guarantee goes beyond the single trial.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Trial
Fictional classroom example. Four pupils folded one paper box each using Method A, then Method B. Their second boxes were faster to complete. They had not tried either method before.
Claim
The instructor says the result proves Method B is always faster for everyone.
1A · True or false
The trial proves the instructor’s claim that Method B is always faster for everyone.
- true: True
- false: False
A small fixed-order trial cannot establish always or everyone; practice may affect the second attempt.
1B · Open ended
Name one limit of the evidence and suggest a better comparison.
Example of a full-credit answer: Only four pupils tried the methods in one order. Let some pupils begin with B and others with A, and compare more trials.
- Identifies small sample, fixed order or practice as a limitation.
- Suggests a relevant improvement to the comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Trial sheet
Fictional classroom example. The same eight readers located named shelves using small and large labels. With large labels, seven found the correct shelf; with small labels, four did. Viewing distance stayed the same.
Other details
The large labels were printed on Tuesday. The printer has a grey cover.
2A · Hotspot
Select the region most directly supporting improved accuracy in this trial.
- a: Seven correct with large labels; four with small labels.
- b: The labels were printed on Tuesday.
- c: The printer cover is grey.
Correct-location counts measure the claimed outcome.
2B · Short answer
Explain why the count supports a limited claim, and give an appropriate limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: More of these eight readers found the correct shelf with large labels. The trial does not show that every person or every distance will give the same result.
- Connects the seven-versus-four count to accuracy.
- Limits the conclusion to tested readers or conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Packaging test
Fictional classroom example. Ten identical biscuits were carried in a hard box and ten in a paper bag on the same short route. One in the box and five in the bag broke. No one tested whether either package was waterproof.
Claims
The team must distinguish what this test supports from what it never measured.
3A · Dropdown selection
Classify each claim using this test.
Complete or match: The box protected biscuits better on this route.; The box keeps out all rain.
- a: Supported within the stated test
- b: Not measured in this test
- c: A favourite-colour judgement
Breakage was compared; rain protection was not tested.
3B · Open ended
Propose a suitable follow-up for the untested claim without treating it as already true.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare matched packages under the same controlled water exposure and check whether contents become wet. Until then, waterproofing remains untested.
- Proposes a relevant controlled water or wetness comparison.
- Acknowledges that the current evidence does not establish waterproofing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Class records
Fictional classroom example. In Week 1, a class had ten minutes of reading practice daily. In Week 2, it had twenty minutes and also received new bookmarks. Its reading quiz average rose.
Faulty conclusion
A note says the new bookmarks caused the improvement, with no other possible explanation.
4A · Drag and drop
Match the record to the appropriate interpretation.
Complete or match: Practice time increased.; Bookmarks were introduced.; Quiz average rose.
- a: Another change that could affect learning
- b: The proposed cause, not isolated by the comparison
- c: The observed outcome
The records contain two changes, so the bookmark effect is not separated.
4B · Short answer
Explain the error and write a more careful conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Practice time and bookmarks both changed, so the comparison cannot isolate bookmarks as the cause. The class average rose in Week 2, but the cause needs further checking.
- Identifies the simultaneous practice change.
- Gives a cautious conclusion without a definite bookmark-cause claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Two proposed claims
Fictional classroom example. A club says a sign helps visitors find the art room and that its lettering lasts in rain.
Design goal
Each claim needs its own relevant evidence. The club can compare way-finding and weather exposure separately.
5A · Matching
Match each test with the property it examines.
Complete or match: Record correct room finding with and without the sign.; Compare lettering before and after equal water exposure.
- a: Legibility after water exposure
- b: Help with finding the room
- c: Popularity of the sign colour
Navigation accuracy and wet-weather lettering are different outcomes.
5B · Open ended
Design a fair check of one claim, naming the comparison and the result you would record.
Example of a full-credit answer: For way-finding, compare similar visitors using and not using the sign, with the same starting place, and record correct room finding.
- Specifies a relevant comparison for either claim.
- Names a controlled condition and a relevant recorded outcome.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.8 · Identifying unsupported conclusions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · One morning is not every morning
Gate observation
At 7:40 on Tuesday, Amira counted three bicycles at the school rack. She wrote, “Only three pupils ever ride bicycles to school.” No other times or days were checked.
Question: Which words make Amira’s conclusion too broad?
Answer: “Only” and “ever” turn one count at one time into a claim about all pupils and all days.
Why: The count establishes what Amira saw at 7:40 on Tuesday. Other cyclists might arrive later or on different days. A careful replacement would say that three bicycles were at the rack at that time. Do not replace her broad claim with another guess about how many cyclists there must be.
Example 2 · A blank space is not a zero
Measuring sheet
The Monday column says 6 seedlings. The Tuesday column is blank. A note explains that Tuesday’s count was not taken.
Question: Can we conclude that there were no seedlings on Tuesday?
Answer: No. Tuesday’s value is unknown because nobody recorded a count.
Why: A blank cell and a recorded zero have different meanings. Zero would tell us that a count was made and none were found. The note says the measurement is missing, so readers should not invent it. A good report can leave a result unknown and explain what information would be needed to fill the gap.
Example 3 · A search has limits
Lost-puppet search
Joel looked inside the top drawer and found no puppet. He announced, “The puppet is not anywhere in the room.” The shelves and other drawers were not checked.
Question: What conclusion does Joel’s search actually support?
Answer: He did not find the puppet in the top drawer he checked.
Why: His search covered one place, so it does not establish absence from the whole room. A narrow conclusion can be accurate and still leave the main question open. The next step is to check other likely places systematically. Do not guess that another pupil took the puppet merely because this first search did not find it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Match observations to careful conclusions
Three records
A: On Monday, five of twelve pupils chose drawing. B: One of four lamps did not switch on during a test. C: At noon, both measured pots had moist soil.
F1 · Matching
Match each record to a conclusion it supports.
Complete or match: Record A; Record B; Record C
- a: Both measured pots were moist at noon.
- b: Five of the twelve chose drawing on Monday.
- c: One of the four tested lamps did not switch on.
Each conclusion stays within the actual observation instead of describing all pupils, lamps or pots.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · The unmeasured afternoon
Visitor log
Morning visitors: 18. Afternoon visitors: not counted. An empty total box has not yet been completed.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the report accurately.
Complete or match: The morning count is ___.; The afternoon count is ___.; The whole-day total is ___.
- a: 18
- b: not known from this log
The log gives eighteen for the morning. Without an afternoon count, neither that count nor the whole-day total is known.
Source explorer: table lab
F3 · Small samples and wide claims
Colour trial
Three pupils tried two marker colours on one poster. Two preferred purple and one preferred brown. No other pupils were asked.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match each statement to the best description.
Complete or match: Two of the three tested pupils preferred purple.; Every pupil in the school prefers purple.; The other pupils’ preferences are unknown.
- a: An unsupported whole-school conclusion
- b: A reported trial result
- c: A limit of the available information
The trial establishes its own three preferences. It does not establish the preferences of pupils who were not asked.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · A single practice attempt
Practice log
On her first try, Ren did not finish the paper maze. She has not tried again, and no other tasks were observed.
F4 · True or false
The log proves that Ren will never be able to solve a paper maze.
- true: True
- false: False
One unfinished attempt cannot establish what Ren can learn or do on later attempts.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · The unopened cupboard
Search note
The class searched two open shelves for the missing compass. It was not on either shelf. The cupboard was locked and was not searched.
Conclusion
There is no compass anywhere in the classroom.
F5 · Short answer
Explain why the conclusion is unsupported and give a narrower statement that the note supports.
Example of a full-credit answer: The cupboard was not searched, so checking two shelves does not establish that the compass is nowhere in the classroom. The note supports saying that it was not found on the two shelves searched.
- Identifies the unsearched cupboard or the limited search as the gap.
- Replaces the broad conclusion with the supported statement that the compass was not found on the two checked shelves.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: document lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Count
Fictional classroom example. On Tuesday, twenty comic books and five poetry books were borrowed. No borrowing counts were collected on other days.
Possible conclusions
The librarian wants a statement supported by this one-day count.
1A · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is supported?
- a: No pupil ever likes poetry.
- b: Comics will always be borrowed more.
- c: More comics than poetry books were borrowed on Tuesday.
- d: Every pupil in school borrowed a comic.
The count supports a comparison on Tuesday, not universal preferences or future behaviour.
1B · Short answer
Identify one unsupported conclusion from the options and explain the missing evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Always borrowing more comics is unsupported because only Tuesday was counted. Records from other days would be needed to investigate a continuing pattern.
- Identifies an overbroad option.
- Explains the relevant missing group, time or preference information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Observation
Fictional classroom example. During the first five minutes of break, six pupils used the skipping ropes. The observer then went indoors and did not count later use.
Claims
One claim describes the observation; another claims no one used ropes after the observer left.
2A · Matching
Match each conclusion to its support status.
Complete or match: Six pupils used ropes in the observed five minutes.; Nobody used ropes later in break.
- a: Not supported: later break was not observed
- b: Supported by the stated count
- c: A statement about rope price
The first matches the observation; the second treats an unobserved period as empty.
2B · Open ended
Explain why leaving the playground prevents the observer from ruling out later rope use.
Example of a full-credit answer: The observer could no longer see the ropes. Pupils might have used them later, so an additional observation period is needed.
- Recognises that later activity was not observed.
- Explains that absence of a record does not prove absence of use.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Sales record
Fictional classroom example. The school shop sold all ten orange pencils on Monday. Blue pencils were not stocked that day. The shopkeeper wants to compare colour preferences.
Decision
Distinguish claims the sales record can support from guesses about unavailable choices.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all conclusions supported by the record.
- a: Ten orange pencils were sold on Monday.
- b: Orange is preferred to blue by all pupils.
- c: The record cannot establish pupils’ preference between orange and blue pencils.
- d: No pupil wants a blue pencil.
Only orange was available; its sales cannot establish preference over blue.
3B · Short answer
Design one fairer way to investigate colour preference.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer comparable orange and blue pencils at the same price and record choices, or ask a varied group with both options shown.
- Provides both colours as comparable options.
- Uses a relevant choice or preference record rather than one unavailable option.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Science-notebook page
Fictional classroom example. Tray A had four seedlings on Friday. The space for Tray B’s seedling count is blank because the class forgot to count it.
Mistaken summary
A pupil writes, “Tray B had zero seedlings, so A grew better.”
4A · Drag and drop
Put each field under the right interpretation.
Complete or match: Tray A: 4; Tray B: blank
- a: A measured count
- b: A missing observation
- c: A measured count of zero
Blank means no count was recorded, not that no seedlings existed.
4B · Open ended
Correct the summary and name the next step.
Example of a full-credit answer: Tray A had four recorded seedlings, but Tray B’s count is unknown. Count Tray B before comparing growth.
- Distinguishes missing data from zero.
- Calls for the missing count or avoids the unsupported comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Report material
Fictional classroom example. Twelve members attended a new drawing workshop. Nine wrote that they enjoyed it. Three returned no form. No other pupils were asked.
Writing goal
The report should state the result accurately and leave room for unanswered questions.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the careful report.
Complete or match: The number who reported enjoyment was…; The opinions of the three non-respondents are…
- a: nine workshop members
- b: unknown from these forms
- c: all pupils in the school
The result concerns nine respondents; missing forms do not reveal the other opinions.
5B · Short answer
Write a supported conclusion and one useful follow-up question.
Example of a full-credit answer: Nine of twelve attendees reported enjoying the workshop. We could ask the three non-respondents for their views without assuming they disliked it.
- States an accurate limited result.
- Asks a relevant follow-up without inventing the missing opinions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.9 · Recognising emotional and persuasive language
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Pressure to belong
Bookmark advert
“Everyone with good taste owns a Sparkle Bookmark. Join the clever crowd today!” The advert gives no information about price, size or durability.
Question: How does the advert try to persuade readers?
Answer: It links buying the bookmark with being clever and having good taste, creating pressure to belong.
Why: Those labels may make a reader want to join the praised group. They do not establish the bookmark’s usefulness or quality. A reader can enjoy a design while still asking practical questions about price and durability. Spotting this emotional appeal does not prove every possible product claim is false; it shows what the wording is doing.
Example 2 · A fact inside an emotional message
Club invitation
“Do not miss our amazing treasure hunt! It starts at 3 p.m. beside Room 2. You will regret staying away!” The organiser’s schedule also lists 3 p.m. and Room 2.
Question: Which part is supported information, and which words add emotional pressure?
Answer: The time and place match the schedule. “Amazing” is praise, and “You will regret staying away” adds pressure.
Why: A message can mix checkable details with emotional wording. Keep both observations in your reading: the schedule verifies the practical details, but it cannot prove how every pupil will feel. You do not need to discard the useful information just because the invitation also uses an excited tone.
Example 3 · Calm wording still needs evidence
Product notice
“This ruler improves every pupil’s test score.” The sentence is printed plainly, without exclamation marks. No study, comparison or score record is supplied.
Question: Does the calm tone establish the score claim?
Answer: No. The claim still needs relevant evidence about scores.
Why: Neutral wording can make a message feel serious, but tone is not a test result. This claim concerns every pupil and needs much more than a plain font. A fair rewrite could describe measured features such as length and markings if they were checked. Readers should assess evidence separately from whether the writing sounds excited or calm.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A dramatic fair invitation
Invitation
“Our fair is unbelievably brilliant! Come at 10 a.m. to see twelve class stalls.” The organiser’s plan lists 10 a.m. and twelve stalls.
F1 · True or false
The word “brilliant” proves that every visitor will enjoy the fair.
- true: True
- false: False
Brilliant expresses enthusiastic praise. A schedule and stall count do not establish every visitor’s feelings.
Source explorer: word lab
F2 · Spot the pressure phrases
Snack-box advert
The seller wants pupils to choose its new snack box. The ad mixes persuasive phrases with plain product details.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select the two phrases that apply emotional pressure.
- a: Only a fool would leave home without one.
- b: Everyone who matters already carries this box.
- c: The box has three separate compartments.
- d: The lid measures fifteen centimetres across.
The first two phrases insult or exclude non-buyers. The other two make checkable product claims.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · What feeling is being encouraged?
Message A
“Be a proud member of our team!”
Message B
“Act now or you may miss the only chance!”
Message C
“Only careless pupils would disagree.”
F3 · Matching
Match each message to its clearest persuasive technique.
Complete or match: Message A; Message B; Message C
- a: Urgency and fear of missing out
- b: An insult aimed at disagreement
- c: Pride and belonging
A appeals to belonging, B pressures readers to act quickly, and C shames disagreement.
Source explorer: perspective
F4 · Rewrite the pet-show notice fairly
Original notice
“The greatest show ever! Only boring people will stay home. The class pet show opens at 1 p.m.”
Checked detail
The organiser confirms that the show opens at 1 p.m. No evidence compares it with every earlier show.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each part to the editing action that fits.
Complete or match: The class pet show opens at 1 p.m.; The greatest show ever!; Only boring people will stay home.
- a: Remove the insult about non-attenders.
- b: Keep the checked practical detail.
- c: Replace the unsupported exaggeration.
The opening time is verified. The greatest-ever claim lacks comparison evidence, and the insult adds pressure without information.
Source explorer: claim board
F5 · A fair invitation to try chess
Draft invitation
“Only clever pupils join chess club! Come on Wednesday at 12:30 in Room 6.”
Confirmed details
The organiser confirms Wednesday, 12:30 and Room 6. Beginners are welcome.
F5 · Open ended
Rewrite the invitation to remove the pressure while keeping useful details, and explain what pressure you removed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Try chess club on Wednesday at 12:30 in Room 6. Beginners are welcome. I removed the claim that only clever pupils join because it pressures readers by linking membership to intelligence.
- Gives a fair invitation retaining the confirmed meeting time/place or equivalent useful meeting details without the intelligence judgement.
- Explains that the original phrase uses praise/exclusion or pressure about being clever rather than evidence about who should join.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Poster
Fictional classroom example. “Be a superstar! Everyone is joining the paper-model club. Build a model boat on Thursday at 3:00.”
Reading task
Notice the different jobs performed by excitement, group pressure and practical information.
1A · Matching
Match each phrase to its main job.
Complete or match: Be a superstar!; Everyone is joining.; Thursday at 3:00
- a: A practical time detail
- b: An exciting personal promise
- c: A popularity-pressure claim
The phrases promise status, appeal to popularity and provide a time respectively.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the popularity phrase should not decide whether you join, and name a useful detail to check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Even if many people join, the club may or may not suit my interests. I should check its activities or whether the time works for me.
- Separates popularity pressure from suitability.
- Names a relevant practical detail or personal fit to investigate.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Advertisement
Fictional classroom example. “The miracle pencil that never makes mistakes! Buy today and become the best writer.” The seller gives no test results.
Product facts
The listing states a length of 17 centimetres and a blue barrel. It does not describe a spelling-checking device.
2A · Multiple choice
Which phrase most clearly makes an unsupported exaggerated promise?
- a: Blue barrel
- b: Length: 17 centimetres
- c: Never makes mistakes
- d: Pencil for sale
Never makes mistakes promises an unlimited result that the listed features do not support.
2B · Short answer
Rewrite the advert as a fair description using one supplied fact, without keeping the impossible promise.
Example of a full-credit answer: A 17-centimetre pencil with a blue barrel is available. It is a writing tool, not a guarantee of mistake-free work.
- Includes a supplied checkable product fact.
- Removes or explicitly rejects the impossible mistake-free guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Campaign card
Fictional classroom example. A class wants pupils to bring reusable containers. One draft says, “Only careless children use anything else.” Another says, “Bring a reusable container if you have one; ask us if you need help.”
Goal
Encourage participation without insulting pupils or assuming everyone has the same supplies.
3A · Dropdown selection
Choose the effect of each draft.
Complete or match: Only careless children…; Ask us if you need help.
- a: Offers support and includes different situations
- b: Uses blame or shame
- c: Provides a measured waste total
The first labels people negatively; the second offers practical help.
3B · Open ended
Write an encouraging version and explain one wording choice.
Example of a full-credit answer: Bring a reusable container when possible, and ask the class team for help if needed. “When possible” avoids blaming pupils who lack one.
- Writes a relevant encouraging message without shaming.
- Explains how a wording choice avoids pressure or recognises different circumstances.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Newsboard statement
Fictional classroom example. “We are delighted that the repair team fixed 18 chairs this month. What an amazing team!” The team’s dated repair log lists 18 completed chairs.
Reader’s reaction
One reader says the whole statement must be false because it sounds excited.
4A · Hotspot
Select the region that can be checked against the repair log.
- a: We are delighted
- b: The team fixed 18 chairs this month
- c: What an amazing team!
The number and period can be checked; excitement neither proves nor disproves that record.
4B · Short answer
Explain the reader’s error and how to assess the factual part.
Example of a full-credit answer: An excited tone does not make the chair count false. Compare the 18-chair claim with the dated repair log.
- Explains that tone alone does not determine factual truth.
- Uses the repair log to check the count and period.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Brief
Fictional classroom example. The school puzzle fair is on Friday at 2:00. Pupils can try three puzzle stations. Entry is free. There is no competition or prize for best pupil.
Design rule
Make the notice appealing without inventing rewards or pressuring readers.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all phrases that are supported and suitable for the notice.
- a: Try three puzzle stations on Friday.
- b: Everyone who misses it is foolish.
- c: Free entry at 2:00.
- d: Win the best-pupil trophy.
The first and third use supplied details; insult and trophy claims do not fit the brief.
5B · Open ended
Write a two-sentence invitation that is lively and accurate.
Example of a full-credit answer: Come and explore three puzzle stations this Friday at 2:00. Entry is free, so you can try a new puzzle with friends.
- Includes accurate event information from the brief.
- Uses inviting wording without invented rewards, guarantees or insults.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R4.10 · Identifying missing information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A detailed notice with a gap
Origami session
“Try paper folding in Room 3 with Ms Ana. Bring a pencil. The session will include boats and flowers.” The notice does not say when the session starts.
Question: What missing detail is most important for arriving on time?
Answer: The starting date and time are needed.
Why: The notice has useful details about the place, teacher and materials, but those do not tell a pupil when to arrive. Start with the decision you need to make. A question about the teacher’s favourite colour would not fill the scheduling gap. Missing information may be an oversight; the notice alone does not tell us why it was omitted.
Example 2 · Compare the same amount
Ribbon offers
Shop A advertises a roll for 20 pesos. Shop B advertises a roll for 30 pesos. The length of each roll is not stated. The ribbons are the same width and material.
Question: Why can we not yet decide which ribbon costs less per metre?
Answer: We need the length of each roll before comparing the price for the same amount.
Why: A lower total price does not always mean a lower price per metre. The cheaper roll might contain much less ribbon. Ask for both lengths, then compare equal quantities. The matching width and material remove two possible differences, but they do not fill the missing length information.
Example 3 · A number needs a group size
Club report
“Eight pupils chose a puppet workshop.” One reader calls it nearly everybody’s choice. The report does not say how many pupils were asked.
Question: Which missing detail would let us judge “nearly everybody”?
Answer: The total number of pupils asked.
Why: Eight out of nine would mean something very different from eight out of eighty. The count is useful, but the conclusion about nearly everybody needs the group size. Do not invent a total to make the conclusion work. Ask a specific follow-up question about how many pupils were offered the choice and recorded in the count.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choosing a swim-club session
Session notice
Beginner practice is in the shallow training pool. Bring a towel. The notice gives the day and starting time but no finishing time.
Family need
A parent must arrange the pick-up time.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which missing detail matters most for this decision?
- a: What time will the session end?
- b: What colour are the poolside chairs?
- c: Which towel pattern does the coach like?
- d: How many windows overlook the water?
The parent needs the finishing time to arrange pick-up. The other details do not answer that scheduling question.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Is the percentage enough?
Survey claim
“Seventy-five percent chose the new board game.” The report gives no number of participants and no description of who was asked.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the follow-up that helps interpret this percentage.
- a: How many pupils were asked, and which pupils were included?
- b: What colour was the survey sheet?
- c: Was the percentage written in large print?
The participant count and group tell readers what the percentage describes. Paper colour and print size do not provide that context.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Missing details for different decisions
Craft kit
The kit lists its price but not how many pupils can share it.
Bus notice
The notice lists its route but not whether it stops at the school gate.
Contest notice
The notice lists the theme but not the closing date.
F3 · Drag and drop
Match the decision to the missing information.
Complete or match: Buy enough kits for twenty pupils.; Check whether a pupil can get off at school.; Know when to hand in the entry.
- a: Closing date
- b: Pupils served by one kit
- c: Whether the bus stops at the school gate
Each missing detail answers the specific planning question rather than adding unrelated information.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Read the comparison carefully
Test summary
Two teams completed a puzzle. Team A took seven minutes and Team B took nine. The report omits the number of pieces and the number of pupils in each team.
F4 · Matching
Match each question to the information needed.
Complete or match: Did both teams face puzzles of the same size?; Did both teams have the same number of helpers?
- a: Number of pupils per team
- b: Number of puzzle pieces
Puzzle size concerns piece counts. Available helpers concerns team size. Both matter before making a fair performance comparison.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Enough materials for a mural
Supply offer
A poster offers one paint set for 120 pesos. It lists the colours but not the amount of paint in each pot.
Class need
The class must paint a large cardboard mural and wants to know whether one set will be enough.
F5 · Short answer
Name one missing detail the class should ask for and explain why it matters.
Example of a full-credit answer: The class should ask how much area one set can cover under the suggested use, or how much paint each pot contains together with an estimate of coverage. That helps compare the set’s capacity with the mural’s size.
- Asks for useful quantity/coverage information such as paint volume or area covered by the set.
- Explains how the information helps judge whether the amount is enough for the large mural.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Invitation
Fictional classroom example. “Join our model-making workshop on Monday in Room 4. Materials are provided. Starts at 3:30.”
Family question
A pupil’s aunt needs to arrange collection after the workshop. No finish time appears in the invitation.
1A · True or false
The invitation provides enough information to know when to collect the pupil after the workshop.
- true: True
- false: False
It gives a starting time but no finishing time.
1B · Short answer
State the missing detail and explain why the starting time cannot replace it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The finish or collection time is missing. Knowing when the workshop starts does not tell how long it lasts.
- Identifies finish time or duration as missing.
- Explains the start-versus-finish distinction for collection.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Shop cards
Fictional classroom example. Offer A costs 30 classroom tokens for a pack of six pencils. Offer B costs 24 tokens, but its card does not state the number of pencils.
Decision
A class wants to compare cost per pencil, not just pack prices.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the comparison notes.
Complete or match: Known for Offer A; Missing for Offer B
- a: Six pencils for 30 tokens
- b: Number of pencils in the pack
- c: Colour of the shop wall
A unit-price comparison requires the quantity in both packs.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the cheaper pack price does not yet prove that Offer B is cheaper per pencil.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer B may contain fewer pencils. We need its pencil count to compare the cost of the same quantity or one pencil.
- Identifies the missing quantity.
- Explains its effect on per-pencil rather than pack-price comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Survey summary
Fictional classroom example. Class A reports that 80% of its respondents enjoy mystery stories. Class B reports 70%. Neither summary states how many pupils replied or how pupils were selected.
Teacher’s task
The teacher wants to judge how well the summaries represent the classes.
3A · Matching
Match each missing detail to why it matters.
Complete or match: Number of respondents; How respondents were selected
- a: Helps judge whether only a particular group answered
- b: Shows how many answers the percentage represents
- c: Tells the colour of the questionnaire
Size and selection answer different questions about the survey.
3B · Short answer
Write one useful follow-up question and explain how its answer would help.
Example of a full-credit answer: How many pupils in each class answered? This shows whether the percentages describe many pupils or only a few.
- Asks about response count or selection method.
- Explains the corresponding representativeness or scale issue.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Plan sheet
Fictional classroom example. A club trip has 28 pupils and two supervising adults. The bus is blue and leaves at 8:00. Its passenger capacity is not listed.
Mistaken approval
A pupil says the colour and departure time prove the bus is suitable for the whole group.
4A · Hotspot
Select the missing-information field that must be checked for group size.
- a: Bus colour: blue
- b: Departure: 8:00
- c: Passenger capacity: not provided
Capacity determines whether the 30-person group can be accommodated; colour and time do not.
4B · Open ended
Explain the approval error and ask the necessary question.
Example of a full-credit answer: Colour and departure time do not show how many people fit. Ask whether the bus has suitable passenger places for all 30 people.
- Explains the irrelevance of colour/time to capacity.
- Requests capacity for pupils plus adults, or all 30 travellers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Brief
Fictional classroom example. A chess introduction welcomes beginners on Wednesday in the library. Organisers know it starts at 3:15 and finishes at 4:00. Pupils must sign up with Ms Reyes by Tuesday.
Existing draft
“Chess introduction, Wednesday, library. Beginners welcome.” The notice should support attendance and collection.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each addition to the need it addresses.
Complete or match: When to arrive and be collected; How and when to register
- a: 3:15 to 4:00
- b: Sign up with Ms Reyes by Tuesday
- c: The chess pieces are black and white
Time range and registration details fill the practical gaps.
5B · Short answer
Write an improved notice including both missing practical details.
Example of a full-credit answer: Beginners can join chess in the library on Wednesday from 3:15 to 4:00. Sign up with Ms Reyes by Tuesday.
- Includes both start and finish times.
- Includes registration person and deadline.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.1 · Evaluating source credibility
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Who knows the booking rule?
Two notices
A colourful fan page says any class can use the hall whenever it likes. The hall manager’s dated booking notice lists reserved periods and a contact number. The manager maintains the actual booking calendar.
Question: Which source is stronger for checking whether the hall is free tomorrow?
Answer: The manager’s current booking notice and calendar are stronger for that question.
Why: The manager is responsible for the record that answers the question, and the notice can be checked against it. Colourful design does not establish accuracy. Even a responsible source can contain an error, so a last-minute booking may still need confirmation. The judgement is about suitability and inspectable evidence, not about declaring a source perfect.
Example 2 · Trace the impressive number
Two reports
Report A says, “Our model town has 500 trees,” but gives no count. Report B names the class counters, explains that each model tree was counted once, and links to a numbered list of 86 trees.
Question: Which report gives a reader more to inspect?
Answer: Report B gives named counters, a method and a numbered list supporting its total.
Why: A precise number alone does not show how it was obtained. The method and list make Report B easier to check, although the reader should still inspect whether the list is complete and free of duplicates. The larger number in Report A is not automatically more credible because it sounds impressive.
Example 3 · Credible for which question?
A first-person diary
Nina writes that she felt nervous before her first puppet performance and relaxed after her friends smiled. She does not describe the feelings of every other performer.
Question: For which question is Nina’s diary a useful source?
Answer: It is useful for learning how Nina describes her own experience of that performance.
Why: A personal diary can be strong evidence about the writer’s reported feelings. It is much weaker evidence about everyone else’s feelings. Credibility depends partly on the question being asked. Readers should not dismiss the diary for being personal, but they should not use it to claim that all performers felt the same way.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Clues behind a page
A classroom webpage
The page names the pupil who counted the toy animals, links a numbered count sheet, and uses sparkling green headings. A date says when the count took place.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each feature to what it helps you judge.
Complete or match: A named counter and linked count sheet; The date of the count; Sparkling green headings
- a: When the information applies
- b: How the number can be checked
- c: Appearance rather than verification
The named record makes checking possible, the date gives timing, and decorative headings do not verify the count.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · A familiar website can make an error
First notice
The school news page first listed the game at 2 p.m.
Correction
The page later posted a clear correction: the game starts at 2:30 p.m.
Schedule check
The organiser’s schedule confirms the corrected time of 2:30 p.m.
F2 · True or false
Because the first time appeared on a familiar school page, it could not have been wrong.
- true: True
- false: False
The correction and organiser’s schedule show that the first time was wrong. Familiar sources can still make errors.
Source explorer: timeline
F3 · Choose a source suited to the question
Available sources
A caretaker keeps the daily key-loan log. A performer writes a diary about her own stage experience. A teacher keeps the signed room-allocation sheet.
F3 · Matching
Match each question to the most suitable listed source.
Complete or match: Who borrowed the craft-room key yesterday?; How did the performer describe her feelings?; Which class was assigned Room 4?
- a: Performer’s own diary
- b: Signed room-allocation sheet
- c: Daily key-loan log
Each source fits a different question. One source’s usefulness in its own area does not make it best for every question.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · When does the model fair close?
Page A
A current organiser notice lists the closing time and event contact.
Page B
A brightly coloured fan post has no date.
Page C
A copied invitation describes last year’s event.
Page D
A page shows how many people liked the event.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which source is strongest for checking this year’s closing time?
- a: The current organiser notice and contact.
- b: The colourful fan post without a date.
- c: The copied invitation from last year’s event.
- d: The page listing this event’s many likes.
The current organiser notice directly concerns this year’s schedule and provides a way to check it.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · The more checkable toy-ramp report
Report A
“Our ramp is the best! Everybody knows it.” No author or trial is named.
Report B
Pupil counters Lani and Omar describe rolling the same toy car three times from the same start. They give each travel distance in an attached table and date the trial.
F5 · Open ended
Which report is more credible for checking this toy-car trial? Explain one strength of its trial method and one other feature that makes it easier to check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Report B is more credible for this trial because it describes a repeatable method using the same car and start, and it provides dated measurements or named counters that a reader can check.
- Chooses Report B and gives a relevant reason about the described trial method/controlled conditions.
- Gives another relevant reason such as inspectable distances, a trial date or identifiable counters; does not claim these guarantee perfect accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Source A
Fictional classroom example. Reading-room staff notice, updated 12 March: Open Saturdays from 9:00 to 12:00. Staff maintain the room timetable.
Source B
Visitor comment from two years earlier: I usually found it open in the afternoon.
Source C
Undated poster: Our reading room is wonderful!
1A · Matching
Match each source to the information it can most directly provide.
Complete or match: Current staff notice; Old visitor comment; Undated praise poster
- a: A past personal experience
- b: Current scheduled hours
- c: A positive opinion
The current staff timetable directly addresses opening hours; the other sources serve different purposes.
1B · Open ended
Which source would you use first for this Saturday, and what extra check could help before travelling?
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the current staff notice because staff maintain the timetable. Check for a newer closure notice or contact the room if the trip depends on it.
- Selects the current staff timetable for relevant authority and date.
- Suggests a suitable check for exceptions or updates.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Article A
Fictional classroom example. A pupil reporter names the survey date and links the class count sheet: 24 trees in the school grounds.
Article B
An unsigned page says “Hundreds of trees!” without a date, location boundary or record.
Task
The class needs a count for its own school grounds.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each feature to the credibility check it supports.
Complete or match: Named survey date; Linked count sheet; School-ground boundary
- a: Can readers inspect the evidence?
- b: Is the information for the right place?
- c: When was the count made?
Date, evidence and scope are separate checks that make the count assessable.
2B · Short answer
Explain two reasons Article A is a stronger starting point without claiming it cannot contain mistakes.
Example of a full-credit answer: It identifies when and where the count was made and lets readers inspect the count sheet. The totals can still be checked for errors.
- Uses a relevant date or location-scope feature.
- Uses inspectable evidence or acknowledges checking the count rather than automatic trust.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Sources
Fictional classroom example. The match scorer’s signed sheet records 12–10. A fan’s message sent halfway through says 6–5. A colourful poster announces “An amazing game!”
Question
A pupil needs the final recorded score, not a description of the excitement.
3A · Dropdown selection
Choose the strongest source for each question.
Complete or match: What was the final recorded score?; What score did the fan report halfway through?
- a: The signed final scorer’s sheet
- b: The halfway fan message
- c: The colourful praise poster
The best source depends on whether the question asks about the final record or a historical message.
3B · Open ended
Why is the fan’s message not necessarily dishonest even though it differs from the final sheet?
Example of a full-credit answer: It was sent halfway through, so it may accurately describe an earlier score. Timing explains why it need not match the final result.
- Recognises that the messages concern different times.
- Avoids treating the difference alone as evidence of dishonesty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Page review
Fictional classroom example. A smooth-looking website claims the school fair starts on Sunday. It gives no author or date. The current organiser’s notice says Saturday.
Reader’s rule
A reader says a polished website and many followers always make a source reliable.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all sensible actions before accepting the website’s date.
- a: Check the current organiser’s notice.
- b: Accept Sunday because the page looks professional.
- c: Look for the website’s source and update date.
- d: Count bright colours as proof.
Relevant current authority and traceable sourcing are useful; appearance is not verification.
4B · Short answer
Explain the reader’s faulty rule and give your tentative decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: Design and followers do not verify a date. I would rely first on the current organiser’s notice and check whether the website has a newer sourced update.
- Rejects appearance or popularity as sufficient proof.
- Makes an evidence-based provisional choice or update check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Project brief
Fictional classroom example. A class will post advice about caring for its garden. Its checking card should direct pupils to an identifiable, relevant source with inspectable evidence.
Draft card areas
Area A: Choose the brightest page. Area B: Check author, relevant knowledge, date and supporting record. Area C: Trust any result that appears first.
5A · Hotspot
Select the area with a useful source-checking routine.
- a: A: Pick the brightest page
- b: B: Check author, knowledge, date and supporting record
- c: C: Trust the first result
Area B asks for relevant evidence and provenance rather than visual or ranking shortcuts.
5B · Open ended
Propose two checks for a garden claim and explain what each check tells you.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check whether the author has relevant gardening knowledge, then inspect the record or reliable reference supporting the particular claim. These checks address expertise and evidence.
- Proposes a relevant author, date or scope check with purpose.
- Proposes a separate evidence or corroboration check with purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.2 · Evaluating author expertise
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Match knowledge to the problem
People to ask
A weaving teacher has years of experience choosing thread for woven mats. A successful football coach trains passing and teamwork. The class wants to know which thread is less likely to break while weaving.
Question: Who has the more relevant expertise for this question?
Answer: The weaving teacher has the more relevant experience with thread in woven mats.
Why: The coach may be highly skilled, but that skill is in a different area. Match expertise to the exact task rather than deciding that one person is cleverer overall. The weaving teacher should still explain the reason for the recommendation and any test or experience behind it. Relevant experience is a useful clue, not a guarantee.
Example 2 · Witnessing is a kind of knowledge
A rehearsal question
Pia operated the lights at yesterday’s rehearsal and kept a timing sheet. A lighting engineer was not present. The question is: at what time did the rehearsal’s lights go out?
Question: Who is better placed to report that particular event time?
Answer: Pia and her timing sheet are better placed to report what happened during that rehearsal.
Why: A technical expert may explain lighting systems, but an absent expert does not automatically know the details of one event. A witness with a relevant record can answer this narrower question. The record should still be checked, especially if the exact time matters. Different questions need different kinds of knowledge.
Example 3 · A title does not settle every claim
Author profile
Mr Santos studies how paper absorbs water. He writes that a particular folded-paper design flies farther than all other designs, but gives no flight tests or aeroplane-design experience.
Question: Does his paper-research role by itself establish the flight claim?
Answer: No. His work concerns water absorption, and the broad flight claim still needs relevant testing.
Why: A field can be related without answering the same question. Understanding one property of paper does not automatically show which folded design flies farthest. A reader should ask about comparable flight trials and the designs included. Respect for someone’s expertise is compatible with checking whether a particular claim falls within it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Who can explain the school model?
Profiles
Ana measured the model’s scale and built its ruler markings. Ben maintains the drawing showing which model parts represent real rooms. Cora performs songs at assemblies. Dan collects colourful stickers.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two people with relevant knowledge for checking the model’s scale and room layout.
- a: Ana, who measured its scale and markings.
- b: Ben, who maintains its labelled room drawing.
- c: Cora, who performs songs at school assemblies.
- d: Dan, who collects many colourful sticker designs.
Ana and Ben have direct relevant work on the model. The other interests do not establish expertise about its scale or layout.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · A question about a stage curtain
Question
The class wants to know which fabric is easier to stitch into a curtain.
Profiles
Nora has sewn stage curtains and can show sample seams. Leo paints scenery. Tess writes scripts. Ali plays the drum.
F2 · Multiple choice
Whose experience best matches the stitching question?
- a: Nora, who sews curtains and shows seams.
- b: Leo, who paints detailed stage scenery carefully.
- c: Tess, who writes scripts for many performances.
- d: Ali, who practises drums for the performances.
Nora’s sewing experience directly concerns stitching fabric. Other theatre roles involve different skills.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Expert or witness?
Roles
A sound technician can explain how a microphone works. A pupil who recorded the class announcement has the original audio and a dated log.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Choose the source most suited to each question.
Complete or match: How does the microphone change sound into a signal?; What words were spoken in yesterday’s announcement?
- a: The sound technician’s relevant explanation
- b: The original recording and its dated log
Technical knowledge fits the equipment question. The original recording fits the question about exact words at a particular event.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Three kinds of useful knowledge
People
A librarian maintains the loan register. A carpenter builds and tests wooden shelves. A pupil wrote a diary about her first library visit.
F4 · Matching
Match each question to the relevant source.
Complete or match: Who has the overdue book according to the register?; How can the proposed wooden shelf be joined securely?; How did this pupil feel during her first visit?
- a: Pupil’s account of her own experience
- b: Librarian’s current loan register
- c: Carpenter’s shelf-building knowledge
The register, building knowledge and diary serve different purposes. Being knowledgeable in one area does not answer every question.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Advice about a puppet joint
Design question
A puppet’s cardboard elbow keeps tearing when it bends.
Profiles
Mina builds moving cardboard puppets and keeps examples of joints she tested. Carlo is a champion runner with no stated craft experience.
F5 · Short answer
Whom should the class ask first, and what relevant evidence should they request?
Example of a full-credit answer: They should ask Mina because she builds moving cardboard puppets. They could ask to see her tested joint examples or records of how often a joint bends before tearing.
- Chooses Mina because her puppet/joint-building experience fits the question.
- Requests relevant examples or test evidence about bending joints or preventing tears, rather than accepting the title alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
People
Fictional classroom example. Ms Ada manages the library timetable. Mr Nilo repairs bicycles. Pia records the school garden’s daily observations.
Questions
The class needs the current library hours and help checking a bicycle brake.
1A · Dropdown selection
Choose the most relevant person for each question.
Complete or match: Current library opening hours; Checking a bicycle brake
- a: Ms Ada, timetable manager
- b: Mr Nilo, bicycle repairer
- c: Pia, garden recorder
Responsibility for the timetable and bicycle repair experience fit the questions.
1B · Short answer
Explain one match and name a question that person’s listed role does not qualify them to answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mr Nilo repairs bicycles, so brake checking fits his experience. That role alone does not make him the source for current library hours.
- Connects a role to its relevant question.
- Identifies a different question outside the listed expertise.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Authors
Fictional classroom example. Author A is a pupil who measured this pond’s depth weekly and provides dated records. Author B is a famous singer who has not visited the pond. Author C sells pond posters.
Task
The class needs evidence of changes in this pond’s measured depth.
2A · Multiple choice
Which author is the strongest starting point for the depth record?
- a: The famous singer
- b: The pupil with dated measurements
- c: The poster seller because the pictures are large
- d: Whichever author writes most confidently
The pupil has relevant direct measurements that can be inspected.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the pupil’s age does not make the dated measurements useless, and give one check to perform.
Example of a full-credit answer: Useful measurements depend on the method and record, not only age. Check that the same measuring point and method were used each week.
- Recognises relevant observations can be useful regardless of fame or age.
- Suggests a concrete method or consistency check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Team roles
Fictional classroom example. The costume maker fits and repairs clothing. The lighting technician sets up stage lights. The attendance clerk maintains pupil attendance records.
New task
A class must organise questions for different members of the team.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each question with the relevant role.
Complete or match: How can this costume hem be repaired?; How should this stage light be adjusted?; Which pupils were absent on rehearsal day?
- a: Lighting technician
- b: Attendance clerk
- c: Costume maker
Each role has knowledge or responsibility matching a different question.
3B · Short answer
Explain why it would be unwise to treat any one team member as the expert on all three questions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Their responsibilities are different. The costume maker knows clothing repairs but may not maintain attendance records or be trained in lighting equipment.
- Recognises domain-specific expertise.
- Uses a correct example of a role-to-question boundary.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Article
Fictional classroom example. A retired sea-navigation teacher writes about a new school reading method. The article gives no reading research or teaching experience relevant to literacy.
Reader’s claim
“The author was a teacher, so the reading method must work,” says a pupil.
4A · Matching
Match each detail with its relevance.
Complete or match: Sea-navigation teaching experience; Claim about a reading method; Missing reading research
- a: The new claim needing appropriate evidence
- b: Experience in a different subject area
- c: A gap to investigate before accepting effectiveness
A broad title does not establish expertise or evidence for every educational claim.
4B · Open ended
Explain the mistake and describe a more suitable source to consult.
Example of a full-credit answer: Teaching navigation does not by itself establish reading-method expertise. Consult relevant literacy research or an experienced reading specialist who explains evidence.
- Identifies the mismatch between expertise and claim.
- Names a relevant expert or research source with evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Planning brief
Fictional classroom example. A class is planning an accessible book corner. It needs knowledge about book organisation and about how pupils with different access needs use the space.
Proposal
Invite the librarian and pupils who use the corner, including those with access needs, then inspect the layout together.
5A · True or false
The proposed panel brings relevant but different kinds of knowledge to the layout decision.
- true: True
- false: False
The librarian knows organisation, while users can describe practical access experiences.
5B · Short answer
Propose two people or groups to consult and explain the distinct contribution of each.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask the librarian about organising books and pupils with different access needs about reaching shelves and moving through the space.
- Chooses a relevant source for book organisation.
- Chooses users or relevant access expertise and explains a distinct contribution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.3 · Checking publication date and relevance
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A newly posted old photograph
Archive page
A page posted on 10 September 2026 displays a photograph labelled “Our first school garden, June 2019.” The class wants to know what the garden looked like when it first opened.
Question: Is the 2019 photograph relevant even though it is old?
Answer: Yes. Its event date fits the historical question about the garden’s opening.
Why: The posting date tells when the page appeared; the photograph label tells when the pictured event took place. For a question about the past, an older record may be exactly what is needed. It would not, by itself, show how the garden looks today. Relevance depends on the period the question asks about.
Example 2 · An update may change only one detail
Club webpage
The page says “Updated 8 October 2026: contact spelling corrected.” Its timetable is still labelled “July 2025 holiday sessions.” The class is planning a visit in October 2026.
Question: Does the update label establish that the old timetable is current?
Answer: No. The stated update corrected a name, while the timetable still describes July 2025.
Why: Read what was updated, not just the newest date. A current-looking page can contain old material. The class needs a timetable covering its intended visit or confirmation from the organiser. This is a reason to check the schedule, not a reason to assume every detail on the page is false.
Example 3 · Choose the date for the task
Two records
A bus chart is labelled “Monday–Friday, term 1.” A separate dated notice says the special Saturday visit uses a different departure time. The class is travelling on that named Saturday visit.
Question: Which record is more relevant to this journey?
Answer: The notice for the special Saturday visit is more relevant.
Why: The weekday chart may still be correct for its own period and service. It simply does not answer the Saturday question as directly. Check the event, day and applicable period together with the source. Choosing the relevant notice does not require declaring the other record wrong; the records can describe different arrangements.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Three dates on an exhibition page
Page information
Published: 12 August 2026. Exhibition photographed: 18 March 2024. Last updated: 14 August 2026, to correct a spelling error.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Choose the date that answers each question.
Complete or match: When did the photographed exhibition happen?; When did this page first appear?; When was the spelling correction made?
- a: 14 August 2026
- b: 18 March 2024
- c: 12 August 2026
Event, publication and update dates describe different actions.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Find a record for the right period
Record shelf
A: The original 2018 prize list. B: The organiser’s schedule for the current Friday fair. C: Last month’s attendance register.
F2 · Matching
Match each question to the most relevant record.
Complete or match: Who won the 2018 model prize?; When does the current Friday fair begin?; Who attended the sessions last month?
- a: Record B
- b: Record C
- c: Record A
The old prize list is appropriate for history, while a current event needs its current schedule.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Check a changed opening time
Visit plan
The class wants to visit a craft display tomorrow. A page was republished today, but its hours are copied from a two-year-old leaflet. No statement says the hours were checked.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select the two useful checks.
- a: Ask the responsible organiser for tomorrow’s hours.
- b: Find a current notice covering the planned visit.
- c: Treat today’s republishing date as proof of the hours.
- d: Use the leaflet’s decorative border to judge accuracy.
The organiser and a current applicable notice can check tomorrow’s hours. Republishing alone does not show that old hours were rechecked.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · History is not out of date for every purpose
History project
A class is investigating what appeared in its first newsletter in 2008. It has a readable copy of that issue with its original date and page numbers.
F4 · True or false
The 2008 issue should be rejected just because it is old, even though the question asks what that issue contained.
- true: True
- false: False
The dated original issue directly addresses the historical question. An old date is not automatically a problem.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · A fresh page with old bus times
Webpage
Published today. Bus table: valid for the 2024 summer trip. A note says today’s change fixed the page colour.
Learner’s decision
The class needs departure times for its October 2026 trip.
F5 · Open ended
Explain why this page does not yet establish the needed departure time and name a useful next check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The table applies to the 2024 summer trip; today’s colour change does not make it valid for October 2026. The class should check the organiser’s or operator’s timetable for its actual October 2026 trip.
- Identifies the mismatch between the old table’s applicable period and the current trip, despite the new page date.
- Names a current, responsible and trip-specific timetable or confirmation as the needed next check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Notices
Fictional classroom example. The museum’s current June notice says Saturday hours are 10:00–14:00. An April notice says 9:00–12:00. A history article describes its opening ceremony twenty years ago.
Task
The visit is this Saturday in June. No special closure is listed.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all useful checks for planning the June visit.
- a: Use the current June hours.
- b: Use the opening-ceremony time from twenty years ago.
- c: Check for a newer notice about this Saturday.
- d: Assume the oldest timetable never changes.
The current relevant schedule and possible exception notices address the visit date.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the history article may be reliable yet unsuitable for this particular decision.
Example of a full-credit answer: It may accurately describe the opening ceremony, but that event time does not tell us the museum’s hours this Saturday.
- Distinguishes historical accuracy from current relevance.
- Connects the needed information to this Saturday’s hours.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Article heading
Fictional classroom example. Published 18 August 2026. “Looking back at the school garden opening on 3 June 2016.”
Reader’s purpose
A pupil wants to record when the garden first opened, not when the article appeared.
2A · Dropdown selection
Assign the correct date to each meaning.
Complete or match: Garden opening event; Article publication
- a: 3 June 2016
- b: 18 August 2026
- c: No date is supplied
The event and publication are explicitly dated differently.
2B · Short answer
Explain why using 2026 as the garden’s opening year would be an error.
Example of a full-credit answer: 2026 is when the article was published. The article says the opening itself happened in 2016.
- Identifies the publication date’s role.
- Correctly identifies 2016 as the event year.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Timetables
Fictional classroom example. A coach keeps three sheets: last term’s timetable, the current term’s regular timetable, and a dated notice changing only next Tuesday’s practice.
Questions
One pupil is researching last term, while another is arranging next Tuesday’s collection.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each question with the most relevant record.
Complete or match: When was practice last term?; When is practice next Tuesday?; What is the normal current-term pattern?
- a: Current regular timetable
- b: Dated next-Tuesday change notice
- c: Last term’s timetable
The best record depends on the exact period and any stated exception.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the special notice should not be copied as the schedule for every future week.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes only next Tuesday. Other weeks follow the regular timetable unless a further notice changes them.
- Recognises the notice’s one-day scope.
- Preserves the regular timetable for dates outside that scope.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Webpage
Fictional classroom example. A club page says “Updated today: corrected a spelling error.” Its embedded timetable is labelled “Term 1”. The school is now in Term 3.
Mistake
A pupil says today’s update proves every timetable entry is current.
4A · Multiple choice
What is the main problem with the pupil’s conclusion?
- a: A spelling correction does not establish that the Term 1 timetable applies in Term 3.
- b: All web pages are false.
- c: Old tables can never be used for any purpose.
- d: Every update changes all information.
The update’s purpose and the table’s term must be checked separately.
4B · Short answer
State the specific information you would seek before using the timetable.
Example of a full-credit answer: Find the Term 3 timetable or ask the club organiser whether the listed times still apply this term.
- Seeks the schedule for the actual current term.
- Uses the responsible organiser or an explicitly applicable record.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Archive task
Fictional classroom example. The class is storing a current event notice, an old event report and a one-day cancellation. Each needs a clear label so readers do not mix up times.
Goal
Labels should make it easy to see when information applies.
5A · Matching
Match each document with the most useful label.
Complete or match: Current event notice; Old event report; One-day cancellation
- a: Event happened on…
- b: Applies to the event on…
- c: Exception for this date only…
The labels distinguish future applicability, past occurrence and a limited change.
5B · Open ended
Propose two date fields for a class notice and explain why both help.
Example of a full-credit answer: Include the event date and the date the notice was issued or updated. Readers can see when to attend and whether a newer instruction may exist.
- Includes an applicability or event date.
- Includes publication/update date and explains its different purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.4 · Identifying bias
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Who was asked?
Games report
A pupil interviews six members of the basketball club and writes, “Our school prefers basketball to all other games.” No pupils from other clubs or pupils outside clubs were asked.
Question: What selection problem should readers notice?
Answer: The report uses basketball-club members to speak for the whole school.
Why: The six pupils’ preferences may be accurately reported, but the selected group is already closely connected to basketball. A fuller school-wide picture would need a more suitable range of pupils. Identify the sampling limit without inventing a motive: the report does not tell us whether the writer deliberately tried to mislead anyone.
Example 2 · Unequal labels for similar actions
Two descriptions
A newsletter calls one group’s request for a longer break “a thoughtful proposal.” It calls another group’s similar request “a selfish demand.” It gives no evidence explaining the different labels.
Question: How might the wording steer the reader?
Answer: The first label praises one group, while the second pushes readers to disapprove of the other.
Why: The labels frame similar actions differently before evidence is offered. Readers should compare the actual requests and reasons rather than accept the labels as proof. The wording gives a reason to ask about uneven presentation; it does not establish that every factual detail in the newsletter is wrong or that we know the writer’s intention.
Example 3 · Accurate examples can leave a gap
Craft-display review
A reviewer lists three compliments about a display. The organiser’s response sheet also contains concerns about small labels, but the reviewer never mentions them. The review claims to describe all recorded feedback.
Question: Why is the review incomplete for its stated purpose?
Answer: It includes compliments but leaves out the recorded concerns while claiming to cover all feedback.
Why: Selective reporting can create a one-sided picture even if the quoted compliments are genuine. The issue is the mismatch between the review’s broad promise and the information it selects. A fuller account should include the relevant concerns too. The existence of a concern does not prove the whole display was poor.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A survey from one team
Survey
A report asks only members of the school choir whether the music budget should rise. It presents their answers as the views of every pupil.
F1 · Multiple choice
What is the clearest limitation of the report?
- a: It asks one group but speaks for all pupils.
- b: It uses written answers rather than coloured charts.
- c: It discusses a budget instead of a sports fixture.
- d: It gives pupils a question about school activities.
Choir members alone may not represent everyone. The limitation concerns the selected group, not the mere use of writing or a budget question.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Look for uneven framing
Reporting task
Two groups both ask to use a room after lunch. The report supplies no extra evidence about either group’s behaviour.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the wording that treats the two groups unevenly.
- a: Both groups requested the room after lunch.
- b: The sensible first group proposed a plan; the greedy second group made a demand.
- c: The organiser has not yet chosen between the two requests.
The second wording praises one group and condemns the other without supplying evidence for those different judgements.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Bias and factual details
Poster
A club poster strongly favours its own team and lists three match dates.
Fixture check
The three dates on the poster agree with the official fixture sheet for those matches.
F3 · True or false
Because the poster favours one team, all three checked dates must be false.
- true: True
- false: False
A source can favour a view while containing accurate facts. Judge the dates using the fixture sheet, not viewpoint alone.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · What is missing from the account?
Play-area review
A review claims to cover everyone’s recorded experience. It includes praise from running-game players but leaves out the written comments of pupils who use the quiet seating area.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each detail to its role in evaluating the review.
Complete or match: Praise from running-game players; Quiet-area pupils’ written comments; Read both sets of comments before summarising
- a: A relevant perspective omitted
- b: A way to make the account fuller
- c: The perspective included
A fuller account must consider the relevant recorded experiences it promises to describe. It need not pretend all experiences were identical.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · A one-sided robot-club review
Review
“Every comment about our robot club was positive.” The review quotes two compliments.
Complete feedback sheet
Two pupils praised the building tasks. Two other pupils said they needed clearer instructions. All four comments concern the same club session.
F5 · Short answer
Identify the selective presentation and suggest one fair improvement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The review leaves out the two comments requesting clearer instructions and wrongly says every comment was positive. It should include both the praise for building and the concern about instructions when summarising the four comments.
- Identifies the omitted instruction concerns or the unsupported all-positive claim.
- Suggests including both relevant positive and critical feedback in a fuller summary without inventing the writer’s motive.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Survey report
Fictional classroom example. A reporter asks ten football-club members which new playground feature they want. All choose a goal. The headline says, “The whole school wants another goal.”
Missing voices
Pupils who use quiet seating, skipping ropes or accessible play areas were not asked.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete the bias check.
Complete or match: The surveyed group was…; The missing information includes…
- a: football-club members
- b: views of pupils using other activities
- c: every pupil in school
A single-interest group cannot represent the whole school without further evidence.
1B · Short answer
Explain the selective sampling and suggest one improvement.
Example of a full-credit answer: Only football-club members were asked, so other playground needs may be missing. Include pupils from different activities and access needs.
- Identifies selection of only one interest group.
- Proposes broader relevant participation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Report wording
Fictional classroom example. Team A asks for a practice timetable and is called “organised”. Team B asks for the same timetable and is called “demanding”.
Known facts
Both teams submitted the same request politely. No further difference is supplied.
2A · Matching
Match each part with its role.
Complete or match: Both teams request a timetable.; Organised and demanding; No different behaviour is supplied.
- a: Unequal evaluative wording
- b: Shared factual action
- c: A limit on justifying the unequal labels
The report treats the same stated action differently without a supplied factual basis.
2B · Open ended
Explain how the wording could influence readers and offer a neutral rewrite.
Example of a full-credit answer: The labels make Team A sound positive and Team B troublesome. A neutral version is: Both teams politely requested a practice timetable.
- Explains the contrasting favourable and unfavourable framing.
- Provides a neutral account preserving the shared action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Review
Fictional classroom example. A visitor posts three photographs of dry beds after one unusually hot afternoon. The caption says the school garden is always neglected.
Other available records
The class has watering logs and photographs taken over the term, including healthy and dry sections.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all useful ways to check whether the review gives a full picture.
- a: Inspect dated watering logs.
- b: Assume every photograph is fake.
- c: Compare photographs across different days and sections.
- d: Accept always because three photos were posted.
Records across time and places address the narrow selection without dismissing the photos automatically.
3B · Short answer
Describe the review’s limitation and what the wider records could clarify.
Example of a full-credit answer: It selects one hot afternoon and a few dry beds. Records across the term could show whether dryness was occasional or part of a continuing care problem.
- Identifies the limited time or place selection.
- Explains how broader records test the generalisation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Debate
Fictional classroom example. One poster praises every feature of a new lunch queue. Another criticises every feature. Neither gives waiting-time records or asks pupils with different needs.
Mistaken response
A pupil says the critical poster must be true because the praise poster seems biased.
4A · Multiple choice
Which response is most reasonable?
- a: Automatically trust the opposite poster.
- b: Seek relevant queue records and different users’ experiences.
- c: Trust whichever poster uses stronger words.
- d: Ignore all information about the queue forever.
Bias in one source does not prove the opposing claims; both need relevant evidence.
4B · Open ended
Explain why an opposite viewpoint is useful but not enough by itself.
Example of a full-credit answer: It can reveal different concerns, but its claims also need evidence. Waiting-time records and user experiences can test the competing descriptions.
- Recognises the value of additional perspectives.
- Explains that opposite claims still need evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing brief
Fictional classroom example. A new drama club had enjoyable rehearsals but some pupils could not attend the late time. A report should describe success and relevant access concerns.
Draft plan
Interview only the most enthusiastic members and describe absent pupils as lazy.
5A · True or false
The draft plan gives a fair account of why some pupils did not attend.
- true: True
- false: False
It excludes their experiences and labels motives without evidence.
5B · Short answer
Propose two reporting steps that would make the account fairer.
Example of a full-credit answer: Interview pupils who could and could not attend, and include the rehearsal time plus their stated reasons. Avoid calling anyone lazy without evidence.
- Includes relevant missing participants or perspectives.
- Uses actual reasons or neutral wording rather than unsupported motive labels.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.5 · Identifying commercial interests
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A helpful disclosure
Pencil review
A pupil’s craft blog says, “The shop gave me this pencil set free so I could review it.” The review praises the colours and gives photographs of the pupil’s tests.
Question: What commercial connection should readers notice?
Answer: The reviewer received the product free from the shop that may benefit from sales.
Why: The disclosure helps readers understand a possible influence on the review. It does not prove that the colours are poor or that the tests are false. Readers can inspect the tests and compare other relevant information. Recognising a commercial interest means checking claims thoughtfully, rather than accepting or rejecting everything at once.
Example 2 · A link that earns money
Game-page note
A website recommends a counting game and says, “We receive a small payment if you buy through this link.” It also states the number of players and the price.
Question: Why does the payment note matter?
Answer: The website can benefit financially when readers buy the game through its link.
Why: That benefit is a commercial interest. The number of players and price are still checkable details; the payment does not automatically make them wrong. A reader should distinguish those details from praise such as “the best game for everyone.” Asking how the game was tested would help evaluate a recommendation beyond the sales link.
Example 3 · A discount is not a quality test
Paper offer
A stall advertises “Half-price sketch pads today!” The class needs paper that can hold wet paint. The offer does not state paper thickness or show a painting test.
Question: Does the discount establish that the paper suits wet paint?
Answer: No. It concerns the selling price, not how the paper behaves with wet paint.
Why: The seller wants purchases, while the class needs evidence about suitability. A lower price may matter to the budget, but it cannot answer every product question. The class should seek paper specifications or a relevant test before buying. A fair decision checks both cost and the feature needed for the task.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Who gains from a purchase?
Review notes
A seller owns the shop offering a ruler. A blogger receives a payment when readers use her buying link. A class report describes a ruler it already owned and states that nobody paid for the report.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the commercial-interest check.
Complete or match: The shop owner can gain money through ___.; The blogger can gain money through ___.; The stated class report describes ___.
- a: a paid referral link
- b: sales in the shop
- c: no declared payment or sales link
The first two sources have stated sales-related benefits. The class report declares none, although its factual claims still need checking.
Source explorer: source tabs
F2 · Read the disclosure
Disclosure cards
A: “The maker gave me the puzzle free.” B: “I own the shop selling this kit.” C: “I earn a fee when a reader buys using my code.”
F2 · Matching
Match each disclosure to its commercial connection.
Complete or match: Disclosure A; Disclosure B; Disclosure C
- a: Payment linked to purchases
- b: Ownership of the selling business
- c: A free product from the maker
Free products, ownership and purchase-linked fees are different connections a reader should recognise.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · What does the offer actually establish?
Sticker advertisement
“Three sheets for 15 pesos! Best labels for every outdoor job!” The advert states no weather test or material description.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which claim needs evidence beyond the price offer?
- a: Three sticker sheets cost fifteen pesos.
- b: The seller offers a pack of three sheets.
- c: The labels suit every kind of outdoor job.
- d: The displayed offer gives a total pack price.
Outdoor suitability needs relevant performance evidence. A stated price and quantity do not establish it.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · A useful shopping checklist
Brush requirement
The class needs a reusable art tray that can hold wet brushes.
Shelf requirement
The chosen tray must fit the class’s 30 cm-wide shelf.
Spending requirement
The tray must stay within the class budget.
Seller’s message
The seller promises its tray is “the only smart choice.”
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each buying question to the need it checks.
Complete or match: Will the material hold wet brushes without leaking?; Is its width no more than 30 cm?; What is the total price?
- a: Shelf fit
- b: Budget
- c: Task performance
The three questions check practical needs. The seller’s praise does not replace those checks.
Source explorer: builder
F5 · A sponsored notebook post
Post
“The notebook company paid for this post. Its cover is excellent, so every pupil should buy it.” No durability test or comparison is included.
Class question
The class wants to know whether the cover will survive daily bag use.
F5 · Open ended
Explain the commercial interest and name one useful check of the cover claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The company paid for the post and may benefit if readers buy the notebook. The class should inspect a relevant wear test or independent comparison of the cover under similar daily bag use.
- Identifies the paid promotion or financial interest connected to sales.
- Proposes relevant durability evidence or an independent comparable test, without assuming payment proves every claim false.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Review
Fictional classroom example. “This is the best bottle!” writes an activity blogger. A note says the maker supplied the bottle free and pays the blogger when readers buy through the post.
Evidence supplied
The review lists the 600-millilitre capacity but gives no leak-test method.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all details showing a commercial connection.
- a: The maker supplied the bottle free.
- b: The bottle holds 600 millilitres.
- c: The blogger earns money from purchases through the post.
- d: The review uses black text.
The gift and purchase payment connect the writer to sales; capacity is a product feature.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the connection should affect your reading without assuming the review is entirely false.
Example of a full-credit answer: The writer may benefit from sales, so I should check claims such as leak resistance using other evidence. The capacity may still be accurate.
- Identifies a possible sales incentive.
- Calls for checking claims without automatically declaring every detail false.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Advertisement
Fictional classroom example. “Our pencil case has three pockets, costs 45 tokens, and guarantees top marks.” The seller provides a photograph of the pockets and a price label, but no learning study.
Task
Separate checkable product features from an unsupported learning promise.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each claim with its evidence status.
Complete or match: Three pockets; Costs 45 tokens; Guarantees top marks
- a: Shown by the price label
- b: Shown by the pocket photograph
- c: Not supported by the supplied product evidence
The photograph and label address features and price, not guaranteed learning outcomes.
2B · Short answer
Explain why the two supported product facts do not prove the marks promise.
Example of a full-credit answer: Pockets and price describe the case, not how pupils learn or perform. A useful case cannot guarantee everyone’s marks.
- Distinguishes product features from learning outcomes.
- Rejects the unsupported universal guarantee.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Two posts
Fictional classroom example. Post A is written by the game’s shop and encourages purchases. Post B is a pupil’s classroom review describing two trial games and one confusing rule; no sales connection is stated.
Need
The class wants to know how the game worked for first-time players.
3A · Dropdown selection
Choose the description that best fits each post.
Complete or match: Post A; Post B
- a: A seller’s promotional message
- b: A described user experience with a stated limitation
- c: A guarantee that all players will enjoy it
The seller has a sales purpose; the classroom review describes a limited experience.
3B · Open ended
What useful information would you seek from both posts before deciding?
Example of a full-credit answer: Check player number and rules, then look for clear accounts of how beginners managed them. I would also check any undisclosed connection and avoid assuming two trials describe everyone.
- Identifies relevant beginner-use or product information.
- Recognises scope or commercial-connection checks.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Offer
Fictional classroom example. A shop advertises a large discount on a drawing kit. It does not list which tools are included. The class needs rulers and compasses for a specific lesson.
Mistake
A pupil says the discount alone proves the kit is the right purchase.
4A · True or false
The discount alone establishes that the kit meets the class’s needs.
- true: True
- false: False
A lower price does not reveal whether the required tools are included.
4B · Short answer
Explain the mistake and ask one precise question before buying.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil treats price as proof of suitability. Ask whether the kit includes the rulers and compasses required for the lesson.
- Separates discount from suitability.
- Requests the relevant contents or required tools.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing brief
Fictional classroom example. A maker gave your club a free sketchpad. You used ten pages and noticed that thick marker ink showed through them. The maker asks for a review.
Responsibilities
Readers should know the connection and the actual test experience, including its limits.
5A · Multiple choice
Which opening best supports an honest review?
- a: This pad is perfect for everyone.
- b: We received this pad free from the maker; here is what happened in our ten-page trial.
- c: We will hide the gift so readers trust us.
- d: The maker likes us, so every claim is proven.
It discloses the connection and limits the review to described experience.
5B · Open ended
Draft a short review that discloses the gift and reports the relevant limitation.
Example of a full-credit answer: The maker gave our club this sketchpad free. In our ten-page trial, thick marker ink showed through, so we would test other pens before recommending it for all uses.
- Clearly discloses the free product connection.
- Accurately reports bleed-through and limits the recommendation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.6 · Identifying political interests
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A campaign has a purpose
Student-council flyer
A council candidate proposes spending part of the activity fund on a shaded game area. Her flyer asks pupils to vote for her and lists reasons for the plan.
Question: What political interest is stated in the flyer?
Answer: The candidate wants votes and acceptance of her plan for shared school funds.
Why: The interest concerns leadership and a public decision. That does not make the proposal automatically wrong. Readers can examine the cost, who would use the area and whether the promised steps are practical. Understanding the writer’s role helps readers ask useful questions without guessing that every campaign statement is dishonest.
Example 2 · A promise is not a completed result
Campaign message
“If elected, I will propose a weekly equipment-sharing hour.” A pupil reports this as, “The sharing hour has already been introduced.” No council decision has been made.
Question: What distinction has the pupil missed?
Answer: The message is a future proposal, not a report that the hour already exists.
Why: Campaigns often describe intended actions. A reader should preserve words such as if and will when summarising. The proposal could later be accepted, changed or rejected. Check a decision record before reporting it as completed. Recognising the campaign purpose helps keep promises separate from outcomes without deciding which candidate anyone should choose.
Example 3 · Apply the same questions to both plans
Two council plans
Plan A proposes more art materials. Plan B proposes more sports equipment. Both would use the same activity fund, but neither flyer gives a total cost or explains how pupils would share the purchases.
Question: What fair comparison could readers make first?
Answer: Ask both plans for total cost and how access would be shared.
Why: The same criteria help readers compare public choices fairly. Asking about costs only for the plan you dislike would be uneven. Pupils may still prefer different activities after reading the answers. A fair comparison makes those preferences informed by relevant information instead of turning disagreement into an accusation about someone’s character.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Identify the stated interest
Message
“Vote for our team. We will propose using the council fund to repaint the shared game lines.” The message is signed by the council candidates.
F1 · Multiple choice
What interest is directly stated?
- a: Winning votes for a shared-fund proposal.
- b: Selling individual tickets for a private cinema.
- c: Reporting a completed repainting inspection yesterday.
- d: Recording everyone’s private favourite paint colour.
The candidates ask for votes and promote a proposal about shared funds. The message does not establish the other purposes.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Promise, evidence or slogan?
Campaign card A
“If elected, we will request new chess sets.”
Campaign card B
“The signed council record shows that two sets were bought last term.”
Campaign card C
“Our team is the only team that cares!”
F2 · Drag and drop
Place each campaign statement in its category.
Complete or match: Card A; Card B; Card C
- a: A checkable record of a past purchase
- b: A future proposal
- c: A slogan that does not establish other teams’ motives
A proposes action, B refers to a purchase record, and C makes a broad judgement without evidence about other teams.
Source explorer: claim board
F3 · Fair questions for a shared plan
Proposal A
Buy umbrellas for a shared stand.
Proposal B
Build a class notice board.
Comparison task
Readers want to compare both proposals using the same fair criteria: cost, access and practical steps.
F3 · Matching
Match each criterion to the question that checks it.
Complete or match: Cost; Access; Practical steps
- a: Who can use it and when?
- b: Who will carry out the work and by what date?
- c: What total amount will it require?
These questions can be applied to either proposal and make the plans easier to compare.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Which detail reveals a campaign connection?
Newsletter page
The page argues for changing the student-council voting rule. Several details appear in its footer and header.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the detail that identifies a stated political interest.
- a: The page uses a blue heading.
- b: The writer coordinates the campaign for the proposed voting-rule change.
- c: The page contains five short paragraphs.
The campaign role links the writer to one side of the rule decision. Colour and paragraph count do not establish that role.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · The equipment-fund statement
Statement
A student-council candidate says, “Choose my team; we want the activity fund to buy music equipment.” The flyer says nothing about cost or how non-members could use it.
F5 · Short answer
Name the stated political interest and one useful question for evaluating the proposal.
Example of a full-credit answer: The candidate seeks votes and favours using shared funds for music equipment. A useful question is how much it will cost or how pupils beyond the music group will get access.
- Identifies seeking votes or influencing the shared-fund decision for music equipment.
- Asks a relevant policy question about cost, access, evidence or a practical plan without inventing a dishonest motive.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Campaign poster
Fictional classroom example. A student-council candidate promises a shaded waiting area if elected and asks pupils for their votes.
Maintenance record
The school caretaker’s log says two existing roof panels were repaired last month. The log does not endorse a candidate.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each statement with its role.
Complete or match: Vote for me and I will propose a shaded waiting area.; Two roof panels were repaired last month.
- a: A campaign promise seeking support
- b: A record of completed maintenance
- c: A guarantee that every future plan will happen
The campaign seeks votes for a future proposal; the log records an earlier action.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the maintenance record does not prove the candidate’s promise will be completed.
Example of a full-credit answer: The record concerns repairs already done, not approval or funding for the candidate’s new plan. A future proposal needs its own practical steps.
- Distinguishes the past record from the new promise.
- Identifies a relevant missing implementation condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Newsletter regions
Fictional classroom example. Header: “Prepared by the Keep the Courtyard Quiet campaign.” Body: “We propose a quiet courtyard during lunch.” Evidence box: “Eight nearby readers reported difficulty concentrating.”
Reading task
Identify the stated group connection before evaluating the evidence.
2A · Hotspot
Select the region that reveals the writer’s campaign interest.
- a: Prepared by the Keep the Courtyard Quiet campaign
- b: We propose a quiet courtyard during lunch
- c: Eight readers reported difficulty concentrating
The author label explicitly identifies the campaigning group.
2B · Open ended
How should this connection affect your evaluation of the eight-reader report?
Example of a full-credit answer: I should inspect how the readers were selected and what they were asked, and seek relevant views from other courtyard users. The connection alone does not make the report false.
- Proposes checking the report’s method or selection.
- Avoids automatic rejection and considers relevant missing perspectives.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Budget discussion
Fictional classroom example. The art club proposes buying paint; the sports club proposes replacing worn balls. Both seek the same student-council funds.
Known information
Each group describes benefits to its members. Neither has supplied a full cost list or the number of pupils served.
3A · Multiple choice
Which next step best supports a fair comparison?
- a: Choose the louder group.
- b: Ask both groups for costs, users served and the condition of existing equipment.
- c: Assume both groups are lying.
- d: Judge the colour of their posters.
Shared evidence and criteria allow the proposals to be compared fairly.
3B · Short answer
Name two shared criteria and explain why they matter.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare costs to see what the budget can cover, and users served or equipment condition to understand the need and reach of each purchase.
- Names a relevant resource or cost criterion with purpose.
- Names a distinct relevant need, access or benefit criterion with purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Statement
Fictional classroom example. Bea asks a candidate how an extra club day would be supervised. Another pupil says, “Bea hates all clubs and wants them closed.”
Evidence
Only Bea’s supervision question is available; she has made no statement against clubs.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all conclusions justified by the information.
- a: Bea asked about supervision.
- b: Bea hates all clubs.
- c: The accusation goes beyond Bea’s stated question.
- d: Every candidate is dishonest.
The question is documented; the broad claims about motives are not.
4B · Open ended
Correct the accusation and give a useful response to Bea.
Example of a full-credit answer: Bea asked how supervision would work, not for clubs to close. The candidate should explain who would supervise or how that will be arranged.
- Accurately limits Bea’s position to the stated question.
- Proposes a response addressing supervision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Two fictional proposals
Fictional classroom example. Plan A keeps the courtyard quiet all lunch. Plan B creates a quiet zone and a play zone. The class wants to compare the plans without campaigning for a named person.
Criteria
Consider readers’ needs, play opportunities, available space and who will help manage the plan.
5A · Matching
Match each question with the criterion it checks.
Complete or match: Can readers hear one another?; Is there enough space for both zones?; Who will explain and manage the rules?
- a: Practical management
- b: Reading access
- c: Space feasibility
These questions examine different practical effects using shared criteria.
5B · Short answer
Propose a fair way to gather evidence before choosing between the plans.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask readers and players about their needs, then trial the layout and record noise, space and movement using the same criteria for both plans.
- Includes relevant different users or viewpoints.
- Uses comparable practical observations or criteria rather than popularity alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.7 · Comparing different sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Agreement and extra detail
Pupil report
The class planted eight herb pots on Thursday.
Teacher log
On Thursday, the class planted eight herb pots and labelled each pot.
Question: What do the sources agree on, and what extra detail appears in one?
Answer: Both report eight herb pots planted on Thursday. Only the teacher log mentions labels.
Why: The pupil’s silence about labels is not a claim that no labels existed. Good comparison separates agreement from additional information. Neither source by itself tells us how well the plants will grow. Keeping the exact shared details prevents us from inventing disagreement or adding conclusions that neither source supports.
Example 2 · Different counts, different groups
Report A
Twelve pupils joined the morning paper-folding session.
Report B
Nine pupils joined the afternoon paper-folding session.
Question: Do the numbers contradict each other?
Answer: No. They describe different sessions at different times.
Why: Before comparing numbers, check what each number counts. Morning attendance and afternoon attendance can both be reported accurately even when they differ. A useful summary preserves the two session labels. We would need more information to say whether some pupils attended both or to calculate the number of different pupils across the whole day.
Example 3 · Several pages, one origin
Source trail
The class blog quotes a count from the museum leaflet. A neighbourhood page copies the same class-blog paragraph. A third post copies the neighbourhood page. None reports a new count.
Question: Do these three pages provide three independent checks of the leaflet’s count?
Answer: No. Their information traces back to the same original leaflet.
Why: Agreement can result from copying. Trace where each claim came from before counting sources as separate evidence. A separately checked visitor log or a new count could add independent information if it addresses the same question. Copies may help readers find a claim, but they do not multiply the observations behind it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · What two records share
Team note
The class displayed six model houses on Tuesday. Four had paper roofs.
Teacher note
Six model houses were displayed on Tuesday. The display stood near the east window.
F1 · Matching
Match each detail to where it appears.
Complete or match: Six model houses on Tuesday; Four paper roofs; Display near the east window
- a: Team note only
- b: Both notes
- c: Teacher note only
The count and day agree. Roof material and location are extra details in different notes, not contradictions.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · A comparison that preserves scope
Library events
Source A counts fourteen visitors to Monday’s storytelling session. Source B counts eleven visitors to Wednesday’s puppet session.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the accurate comparison.
- a: The sources must disagree because fourteen is not eleven.
- b: The sources describe different events and days, so both counts could be correct.
- c: The sources prove that the same three visitors stopped coming.
The events and dates differ. The texts do not identify individual visitors or establish a contradiction.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Missing mention is not denial
Garden diary
“We watered the seedlings before lunch.”
Class log
“Before lunch we watered the seedlings and checked their labels.”
F3 · True or false
The diary contradicts the class log about checking labels because it does not mention labels.
- true: True
- false: False
The diary leaves out the label check; it does not say that no check happened.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · How many independent counts?
Organiser tally
The organiser counts thirty entries.
First blog
The first blog copies thirty from the organiser’s tally; it makes no new count.
Second blog
The second blog copies the first blog’s thirty; it makes no new count.
Gate volunteer
The gate volunteer separately counts the same entries and also records thirty.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which pair supplies two separately made counts?
- a: The organiser tally and the volunteer’s count.
- b: The first blog and its copy on the second blog.
- c: The first blog and the organiser tally it copied.
- d: The second blog and the first blog it copied.
The organiser and gate volunteer made separate counts. The blogs repeat the organiser’s tally.
Source explorer: network
F5 · Two accounts of a craft sale
Class diary
Our craft sale opened at nine. We sold ten paper boats in the first hour.
Teacher log
The sale opened at nine. By noon, twenty-two paper boats had been sold.
F5 · Open ended
State one agreement and explain why the two boat totals need not conflict.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both sources say the sale opened at nine. Ten boats in the first hour and twenty-two by noon concern different periods, so later sales could increase the total without either figure being wrong.
- Identifies the shared opening time of nine.
- Explains that the counts cover different periods and can both be true, without inventing an exact later sales breakdown.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Account A
Fictional classroom example. The school newsletter says the book fair opened at 9:00 in the hall and offered story books.
Account B
The librarian’s log says the hall book fair opened at 9:00 and included science books as well as stories.
1A · True or false
The accounts disagree because only Account B mentions science books.
- true: True
- false: False
Account A does not say science books were absent; B adds a detail.
1B · Open ended
State one agreement and explain why the extra detail is not a contradiction.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both place the fair in the hall at 9:00. Mentioning story books does not rule out science books, so B can add information.
- Identifies a genuine shared detail.
- Explains omission versus denial.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Report A
Fictional classroom example. The class report counts twelve pupils who helped in the morning.
Report B
The organiser’s report counts eighteen pupils who helped at any time during the whole day.
Question
The reports use different time scopes, and some pupils joined after lunch.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the scope notes.
Complete or match: Report A counts…; Report B counts…
- a: morning helpers
- b: all-day participation
- c: only adults
The counts can both be accurate because the time periods differ.
2B · Short answer
Explain why subtracting the counts does not by itself show that either report is wrong.
Example of a full-credit answer: The whole-day count can include later helpers in addition to morning pupils. Different counting periods explain why the totals need not match.
- Identifies different time scopes.
- Explains inclusion of later helpers without assuming error.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Documents
Fictional classroom example. The trip letter gives the destination and departure time. The current transport notice gives the return time. The venue guide describes the exhibits.
Task
A pupil needs a complete plan and wants to know which document supplies each part.
3A · Matching
Match each need with the most relevant document.
Complete or match: When do we leave?; When will we return?; What can we see at the venue?
- a: Venue guide
- b: Trip letter
- c: Transport notice
Different sources contribute different parts of the plan.
3B · Open ended
Explain how using more than one document improves the plan, and name one consistency check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Together they provide departure, return and exhibit information. Check that the letter and transport notice concern the same trip date.
- Explains complementary information across documents.
- Names a relevant date, destination or version consistency check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Search results
Fictional classroom example. Three blogs all say the school concert is on Thursday. Each credits the same undated flyer. The current organiser’s notice says Friday.
Mistake
A pupil trusts Thursday because three websites outnumber one.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each item to its evidence role.
Complete or match: Three blogs quoting one flyer; Current organiser’s notice
- a: One shared source repeated
- b: A separate current responsible source
- c: Three independent observations
The three blogs do not provide three independent confirmations.
4B · Short answer
Explain the counting error and what you would check next.
Example of a full-credit answer: The blogs repeat one flyer, so their number exaggerates the independent support. Check the organiser’s dated Friday notice and any later correction.
- Recognises common source dependence.
- Prioritises a relevant current record or update check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Project
Fictional classroom example. A class compares two accounts of a garden visit. Both report planting beans. One reports 20 visitors; the other reports 16 pupils and four adults.
Goal
The notebook should preserve the groups counted and help readers see whether the totals conflict.
5A · Multiple choice
Which notebook entry is most accurate?
- a: The sources contradict because 20 and 16 differ.
- b: Both describe 20 visitors when pupils and adults are included.
- c: The second source proves there were no adults.
- d: Numbers should be removed from every comparison.
Sixteen pupils plus four adults describes the same total as 20 visitors.
5B · Open ended
Design two useful column headings for comparing these sources, and explain how they prevent confusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use “Who is counted?” and “Number in that group.” This separates pupils from all visitors and makes the matching total clear.
- Includes a heading that preserves group or scope.
- Includes a heading for count/detail and explains how comparison becomes fairer.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.8 · Verifying information through other sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Check the exact claim
Forwarded message
“The class art walk has moved to the gym.”
Organiser’s notice
The dated notice says, “The art walk remains in the covered court. Only the preparation meeting has moved to the gym.”
Question: What does the original notice establish about the forwarded message?
Answer: The message has confused the preparation meeting with the art walk. The art walk remains in the covered court.
Why: Verification requires matching the exact activity, not just spotting the same word gym. Read enough context to see what changed. A helpful correction names the event and location clearly. It need not accuse the person who forwarded the message, because the evidence establishes the mistake but not the person’s intention.
Example 2 · A relevant link or an unrelated one?
Claim with a link
A post says a model-building contest closes on Friday and links to the school’s lunch menu. The menu lists meals but says nothing about the contest.
Question: Does the link verify the closing date?
Answer: No. The linked menu does not address the contest’s deadline.
Why: A link is not proof merely because it opens a real page. The source must support the particular claim. A useful next step is to find the contest organiser’s instructions or a dated notice for the same event. The claim remains unverified until relevant evidence is found; the unrelated link alone does not tell us the correct deadline.
Example 3 · Keep a short checking trail
Count investigation
A poster says the class collected forty batteries for safe collection by adults. The original collection sheet totals thirty-four. The supervising teacher confirms that the poster copied a digit incorrectly.
Question: What should a correction record?
Answer: It should state the claim checked, the collection sheet’s total of thirty-four, and the supervising teacher’s confirmation of the copying error.
Why: A checking trail lets another reader follow the correction rather than rely only on the new writer’s confidence. It should identify the same collection event and relevant records. Do not add claims about other classes or collections. Accurate corrections stay as focused as the evidence used to make them.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Verify the room change
Claim
A repost says today’s handwriting workshop has moved to Room 5.
Available sources
The organiser has a dated workshop notice. A teacher supervising today’s workshop has the assigned-room sheet. Two other posts copy the same repost.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two useful verification sources.
- a: The organiser’s dated notice for today’s workshop.
- b: The supervising teacher’s assigned-room sheet for today.
- c: A second post copying the first repost’s wording.
- d: A third post copying that same repost again.
The notice and room-assignment record directly address the actual event. Copies do not add independent verification.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · Many copies are still one claim
Original post
One unverified post says a prize has been won. It names no judge or result list.
Reposts 1–3
Three accounts copy that original claim. None supplies a separate observation.
Reposts 4–5
Two more accounts copy the same original claim. They give no new result record.
F2 · True or false
The five reposts establish five independent confirmations that the prize was won.
- true: True
- false: False
They repeat one source. A relevant result list or confirmation from the responsible organiser is still needed.
Source explorer: network
F3 · Match a claim to the right check
Claims
A: The assembly begins at 8:30. B: A display has twenty model birds. C: The author said a particular sentence in a recorded talk.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Select the most direct checking source.
Complete or match: Check the assembly starting time.; Check the displayed bird count.; Check the author’s exact spoken words.
- a: The relevant full recording or transcript
- b: The organiser’s current assembly schedule
- c: A careful count of that same display
A schedule checks time, an appropriate count checks quantity, and a full recording or transcript checks the words in context.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · What does the source actually say?
Forwarded claim
“All afternoon clubs are cancelled.”
Original notice
Only the chess-club session is cancelled this afternoon. The drama and drawing sessions continue as scheduled.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the correction supported by the notice.
- a: Every afternoon activity has been permanently stopped.
- b: Only chess is cancelled this afternoon; drama and drawing continue.
- c: The notice proves the person forwarding the claim intended to trick everyone.
The notice identifies a single cancelled session and names two that continue. It does not establish intent or a permanent closure.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Checking a seed-packet count
Poster
The class poster says its display contains fifty labelled seed packets.
Inventory
The numbered inventory for that same display contains forty-six entries. A second teacher separately recounts the packets and also finds forty-six.
F5 · Short answer
What count is better supported, and what evidence supports it?
Example of a full-credit answer: Forty-six is better supported because the numbered inventory and a separate teacher’s recount of the same display both give forty-six.
- Identifies forty-six as the better-supported count.
- Cites the inventory and separate recount as relevant confirming evidence for that same display.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: table lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Messages
Fictional classroom example. Two friends forward the same message saying the art workshop is cancelled. Neither message names a source.
Current notice
The organiser’s dated page says the workshop will run as planned and gives a contact for changes.
1A · True or false
Two forwards of the same unsourced message provide two independent confirmations.
- true: True
- false: False
They repeat one unverified message rather than separate evidence.
1B · Short answer
Explain the difference between repetition and verification, and name the useful next check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Forwarding repeats a claim. Checking the organiser’s current notice or contacting the organiser can test whether cancellation is actually recorded.
- Distinguishes copied messages from independent evidence.
- Identifies a relevant responsible-source check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Poster
Fictional classroom example. A poster says the principal called the library “closed for the whole month”.
Original circular
The dated circular says, “The library is closed for cleaning on Monday. It opens normally from Tuesday.”
Reading task
Locate the source wording that directly checks the poster’s claim.
2A · Hotspot
Select the original-source region that contradicts the month-long claim.
- a: Closed for cleaning on Monday
- b: It opens normally from Tuesday
- c: The circular has a school heading
Opening normally from Tuesday is incompatible with being closed for the whole month.
2B · Open ended
Explain how consulting the original changes the conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: The original limits the closure to Monday and says normal opening resumes Tuesday. The poster’s month-long wording misrepresents it.
- Uses the original one-day closure or Tuesday reopening.
- Explains the mismatch with the month-long claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Online summary
Fictional classroom example. A summary says the class read 60 books in April. Its link leads to a class record table showing March: 60 and April: 42.
Task
A pupil wants to verify the month and value rather than trust the copied sentence.
3A · Multiple choice
What is the best conclusion from the supplied original record?
- a: April is recorded as 42; the summary seems to have used March’s value.
- b: All class records must be false.
- c: April is 60 because the summary says so.
- d: The months do not matter.
The original table distinguishes the two months and their counts.
3B · Short answer
Describe the specific checking step that revealed the error.
Example of a full-credit answer: I matched the claim’s April date to the April row in the original table instead of taking the 60 from March.
- Identifies checking the original table.
- Matches the correct month and explains the misplaced value.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Article
Fictional classroom example. A page claims the new playground is open today. Its “proof” link goes to an old article about the architect’s childhood, which says nothing about opening dates.
Available check
The park office maintains a current opening notice and construction update.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all sensible conclusions or actions.
- a: The link does not support the opening-date claim.
- b: Any link makes a claim verified.
- c: Check the current park-office opening notice.
- d: The architect’s childhood proves the park is open.
Relevance matters: the linked article does not answer the opening question.
4B · Open ended
Explain why having a link is insufficient and what a useful link would contain.
Example of a full-credit answer: The source must actually state or support the claim. A useful link would lead to a current opening notice for this playground and date.
- Distinguishes presence of a link from relevant support.
- Specifies current opening information for the same place/date.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Claim to check
Fictional classroom example. A group chat says the school science display has moved from Room 3 to the hall tomorrow.
Available sources
An older timetable lists Room 3. A dated organiser update addresses tomorrow’s display. Another chat message copies the first message.
5A · Matching
Match each source with its checking value.
Complete or match: Older timetable; Tomorrow’s organiser update; Copied chat message
- a: A relevant current source for the proposed change
- b: A previous plan that may have changed
- c: Repetition rather than independent confirmation
Timing, responsibility and independence determine each source’s value.
5B · Short answer
Propose a two-step verification plan and say what you would do if the update is unclear.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the organiser’s dated update for tomorrow, then confirm the room with the organiser if unclear. I would keep the location uncertain until that check rather than forward it as settled.
- Uses the relevant current original source.
- Includes a sensible follow-up or communicates uncertainty if unresolved.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.9 · Detecting contradictory information
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Same object, same moment
Two notes
Note A: At noon on Tuesday, the glass jar on the science table was empty. Note B: At noon on Tuesday, that same jar contained five buttons. Both refer to the same moment, before anyone touched it.
Question: Can both notes be accurate as written?
Answer: No. The same jar cannot be empty and contain five buttons at that same moment.
Why: The shared object and time matter. If one note described a different moment, the jar might have changed. Here the notes explicitly rule that out. Identifying the contradiction does not tell us which note is correct. A relevant photograph or careful observation record could help resolve it.
Example 2 · Same number word, different meaning
Fair totals
One report counts twenty visits through a gate, including people who returned. Another counts sixteen different visitors and explains that four entered twice.
Question: Must these totals contradict each other?
Answer: No. They count different things: gate visits and different people.
Why: Read the definition of a count before comparing it. A person who returns can add another visit without becoming another person. Here the explanation allows the totals to fit together. Do not erase either label when summarising. A useful comparison states exactly what each total measures, rather than declaring a conflict from unequal numbers alone.
Example 3 · Some and none
Class records
The attendance note says that no members of Group B were absent on Thursday. A checked register for Group B on that Thursday marks one member absent.
Question: Which two details conflict?
Answer: No Group B members absent conflicts with one Group B member absent for the same day.
Why: A claim of none rules out even one example. Both records refer to the same group and day, so this is a real contradiction to investigate. It differs from “some came by bus” and “some walked,” which can both describe different members of one group. Small limiting words change the meaning of a statement.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Compare identical event times
Poster A
The same Wednesday puppet show begins at 2 p.m.
Poster B
That Wednesday puppet show begins at 3 p.m. Both posters claim to give the single start time; no change has been announced.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the contradiction check.
Complete or match: The posters refer to ___.; Their claimed single start times are ___.
- a: the same event
- b: different and incompatible
- c: different events
Both claim a different single start time for the same event. The conflict needs checking; the text does not identify the correct time.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · An extra detail
Diary
The pupils made paper stars on Friday.
Teacher note
The pupils made paper stars on Friday and hung them by the window.
F2 · True or false
These sources contradict each other because only the teacher note mentions hanging the stars.
- true: True
- false: False
The diary does not say that the stars were not hung. It simply leaves out that detail.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Which pairs really conflict?
Comparison rule
For each option below, the statements describe the same moment and the same objects or event unless different days or different pupils are named.
F3 · Multiple answers
Select the two pairs that cannot both be true as described.
- a: The same closed box is empty; it contains three counters.
- b: All ten pupils attended; one of those ten was absent.
- c: The tap was closed on Monday; it was open on Tuesday.
- d: Some pupils walked; some other pupils travelled by bus.
An empty box cannot contain three counters at the same moment, and all present conflicts with one absent. Different days or different pupils can explain the other pairs.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · Find the conflicting detail
Original record
The same class display contained exactly eight model animals at 11 a.m.
Task
Choose a statement that conflicts with the record about that same display and time.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the contradictory statement.
- a: The display stood on the long table.
- b: Exactly ten model animals were in that display at 11 a.m.
- c: Some displayed animals were made of paper.
Exactly eight and exactly ten cannot both be its total at the same time. Location and material can fit with either total.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Two labels for one rehearsal
Label A
The recording is labelled “Friday’s rehearsal lasted exactly twenty minutes.”
Label B
The log for the same Friday rehearsal says its total length was exactly thirty minutes. The meaning of rehearsal length is the same in both records.
F5 · Open ended
Identify the contradiction and explain why both statements cannot be correct as written.
Example of a full-credit answer: The same rehearsal is said to last exactly twenty minutes and exactly thirty minutes. Because both statements describe the same total duration of the same event, they cannot both be correct; a timing record is needed to decide which is accurate.
- Identifies the conflicting twenty-minute and thirty-minute totals.
- Explains that they concern the same event and same total duration, without claiming that the contradiction alone proves which record is correct.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: document lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Records
Fictional classroom example. Record A says Room 2 was empty at 10:00. Record B says five pupils were in Room 2 at 10:00. Record C says the same room was empty at 8:00.
Task
Compare time and meaning before marking a conflict.
1A · Matching
Match each comparison with its status.
Complete or match: A versus B; B versus C
- a: Could both be true because the times differ
- b: Contradiction about the same room and time
- c: Agreement about the number of pupils
Empty and five pupils at 10:00 conflict; a room can change between 8:00 and 10:00.
1B · Open ended
State the exact contradiction and explain what it does not yet tell you.
Example of a full-credit answer: A says no pupils were in Room 2 at 10:00, while B says five were. This shows a conflict but not which record is correct.
- Accurately states the incompatible same-time claims.
- Recognises that detecting the conflict alone does not identify the correct source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Survey
Fictional classroom example. A class travel table records six pupils walking to school that morning. A summary says no pupils in that class walked that morning.
Alternative sentence
Another sentence says some classmates travelled by bus; the table also records bus travellers.
2A · Multiple choice
Which statement contradicts the recorded walking count?
- a: Some classmates travelled by bus.
- b: Six pupils walked that morning.
- c: No pupils in that class walked that morning.
- d: The table records travel methods.
No walkers cannot match a record of six walkers in the same class and morning.
2B · Short answer
Rewrite the contradictory summary so it matches the walking evidence, and explain the important word change.
Example of a full-credit answer: Some pupils in the class walked; the table records six. Replacing no with some removes the denial of the recorded walkers.
- Writes an accurate walking summary.
- Explains the no-versus-some or zero-versus-six distinction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Documents
Fictional classroom example. A Monday notice says chess meets Tuesday. A later correction says this week’s chess meeting moves to Wednesday. A separate art notice also lists Wednesday.
Question
Compare each statement within its date and subject.
3A · Dropdown selection
Classify each comparison.
Complete or match: Old chess plan versus later chess correction; Chess on Wednesday versus art on Wednesday
- a: A changed plan explained by a later correction
- b: Different events that can share a day
- c: A contradiction that proves both clubs are cancelled
A correction can replace a plan, and different clubs may meet on the same day.
3B · Open ended
Why should you not report “The school contradicts itself, so no club meets”?
Example of a full-credit answer: The correction explains the chess change, and the art notice concerns a separate event. Neither says all clubs are cancelled.
- Uses version or event distinctions to explain the apparent differences.
- Rejects the unsupported cancellation conclusion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Inventory
Fictional classroom example. A signed count says all eight supply boxes were empty at the noon inspection. A photograph record from the same inspection clearly lists Box 4 as containing rulers.
Extra detail
Box 4 was painted green. A later note says the boxes were emptied after lunch.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all details forming the actual contradiction.
- a: All eight boxes were empty at noon.
- b: Box 4 contained rulers at the same noon inspection.
- c: Box 4 was green.
- d: The boxes were emptied after lunch.
The first two make incompatible claims at noon; colour and a later event do not form that conflict.
4B · Short answer
Explain why the after-lunch note does not erase the need to check the noon records.
Example of a full-credit answer: It describes a later change. The two noon records still disagree about whether Box 4 contained rulers at that time.
- Distinguishes noon from after lunch.
- Preserves the exact unresolved noon conflict.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Brief
Fictional classroom example. Two accounts describe a school concert. One counts 40 pupils; another counts 45 people including five adults. A third claims only 35 people were present in total at the same performance.
Goal
Separate differences in categories from a real total-count conflict.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each pair with the appropriate interpretation.
Complete or match: 40 pupils versus 45 people including five adults; 45 people total versus 35 people total at the same performance
- a: Different categories that can fit together
- b: Incompatible total counts
- c: A difference in poster colour
Category differences can reconcile 40 and 45; the same total cannot be both 45 and 35.
5B · Open ended
Propose two columns that would help readers find real contradictions and explain their use.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use “Who or what is counted?” and “Time/event and number.” These keep category differences separate and let readers compare totals for the same event.
- Includes category, scope or definition information.
- Includes time/event and claimed value, explaining like-for-like comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.10 · Resolving conflicts between sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A dated correction explains the change
Original invitation
The class paper-plane display was scheduled for Room 7.
Organiser’s correction
A later notice from the same organiser says, “Room 7 is being repaired. This notice replaces the earlier invitation: use Room 9 for the display.”
Question: Which room should visitors use, and why?
Answer: Visitors should use Room 9 because the responsible organiser explicitly replaced the earlier room instruction.
Why: The reason is more than the later date. The correction identifies the same event, explains the change and states what it replaces. The earlier invitation can remain a useful historical record of the original plan. Readers should preserve the correction when sharing the current instruction.
Example 2 · Different definitions can resolve a conflict
Club totals
The door counter recorded twenty-two entries, including repeat entries. The named attendance list contained eighteen different pupils. Four of those pupils left and entered once more.
Question: How can the totals be consistent?
Answer: Eighteen pupils made twenty-two entries because four entered a second time.
Why: The reports count different units. One counts door crossings and the other counts people. Defining those units resolves the apparent disagreement without deciding that someone counted badly. A clear summary would retain both labels. If the repeat-entry explanation were missing, readers should ask for it instead of guessing it to force agreement.
Example 3 · Sometimes the answer stays uncertain
Two unsigned notes
One note says the practice walk starts at eight. Another says nine. Neither is dated or names an organiser. No other schedule is available in the folder.
Question: Should a reader simply choose the later time?
Answer: No. The supplied evidence does not establish which time is correct.
Why: A useful response is to say the start time is unconfirmed and ask the responsible organiser for a current schedule. Guessing the later time may still make someone miss the walk. Resolving a conflict can mean finding a better source, but when that source is not yet available, uncertainty is the accurate conclusion.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Which instruction applies now?
Earlier notice
The model launch is planned for the yard.
Organiser update
Rain is expected. The organiser’s dated update says this launch is moved to the covered court and replaces the yard instruction.
Unrelated note
A next-month event will use the hall.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each notice to its role for today’s model launch.
Complete or match: Earlier yard notice; Organiser’s covered-court update; Next-month hall note
- a: Unrelated event information
- b: Current replacement instruction
- c: Earlier plan now replaced
The organiser’s explicit replacement resolves this location conflict. The later event note is about something else.
Source explorer: timeline
F2 · A copied total differs
Original count sheet
The numbered sheet lists twelve red flags and eight blue flags: twenty flags in all.
Typed summary
The typed summary says there were twenty-eight flags.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the best next check for this disagreement.
- a: Inspect the original numbered count sheet and add its categories.
- b: Choose the total printed in the larger font.
- c: Ask which writer has the more attractive signature.
The original count sheet gives the categories needed to check the total. Appearance does not settle arithmetic.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · The newest page is not always strongest
Responsible notice
The organiser’s current signed schedule places the reading relay at 10 a.m.
Later anonymous post
An anonymous post made afterward says 11 a.m., gives no evidence and does not identify an organiser-approved change.
F3 · Multiple choice
What is the best-supported next action?
- a: Check with the organiser about a possible change.
- b: Accept eleven because the anonymous post is newer.
- c: Pick whichever starting time your friends prefer.
- d: Assume the organiser must have invented the schedule.
The later post does not establish an approved change. The responsible organiser can confirm whether the current schedule has been replaced.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · What remains unresolved?
Two labels
Two undated labels give different opening times for the same workshop. Neither identifies its source.
Available evidence
No current notice or responsible-source confirmation is supplied.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the careful response.
Complete or match: The opening time is currently ___.; A useful next source is ___.
- a: confirmed by the bigger label
- b: unconfirmed from these labels
- c: the organiser’s current notice
The two labels do not settle the time. A current responsible notice could resolve it.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Resolving a copied visitor total
Original record
The organiser’s signed tally for the puppet display lists twenty-four visitors and includes twenty-four tick marks.
Newsletter
The newsletter gives forty-two visitors. The organiser checks the tally and confirms that the newsletter reversed the digits.
F5 · Short answer
Which total should the corrected newsletter use, and why?
Example of a full-credit answer: It should use twenty-four. The original signed tally has twenty-four tick marks, and the organiser confirms that forty-two was a copying error with the digits reversed.
- Gives the corrected total of twenty-four.
- Explains the resolution using the original tally and/or the organiser’s verified digit-reversal correction.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: source tabs
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Report A
Fictional classroom example. The class newsletter reports 24 pupil visitors to the gallery.
Report B
The gallery log records 27 visitors: 24 pupils and three teachers, for the same visit.
Question
Readers want to resolve the apparent disagreement about attendance.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each figure with its scope.
Complete or match: 24; 27
- a: Pupils only
- b: Pupils plus three teachers
- c: Teachers only
The totals are compatible once their groups are specified.
1B · Short answer
Explain how both reports can be accurate and suggest clearer wording for the newsletter.
Example of a full-credit answer: One counts pupils and the other counts everyone. The newsletter could say “24 pupils and three teachers visited, 27 people in total.”
- Explains the difference in counting scope.
- Provides a clear reconciled account without inventing participants.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Notice board
Fictional classroom example. Monday notice: Assembly in Room A on Friday. Wednesday organiser correction: Friday’s assembly is moved to the hall; this replaces Monday’s room instruction.
Unrelated note
A pupil’s old diary also says Room A.
2A · Hotspot
Select the region that resolves the current room question.
- a: Monday: Friday assembly in Room A
- b: Wednesday organiser correction: Friday assembly moved to the hall
- c: Old diary: Room A
The responsible organiser explicitly updates the same event’s location.
2B · Open ended
Explain why the old diary and Monday notice should not outweigh the correction just because they are two sources.
Example of a full-credit answer: The diary repeats the earlier plan, while the correction explicitly changes that plan. Two old references do not override the relevant update.
- Recognises the correction’s applicability and authority.
- Explains why repeated older information is not stronger current evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Conflicting records
Fictional classroom example. Two pupils count the same shelf at 2:00. One records 11 hats and the other 13. Neither explains whether a pair of gloves was counted as a hat.
Available action
The class can recount the shelf now, preserving a photograph of the 2:00 contents.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all useful steps for resolving the difference.
- a: Agree what counts as a hat.
- b: Choose the pupil with the louder voice.
- c: Inspect the same-time photograph and count using the agreed rule.
- d: Add the two totals and call that the answer.
A common definition and relevant evidence address the discrepancy.
3B · Short answer
Describe a fair checking method and one limit if the shelf contents have since changed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the 2:00 photograph and a shared hat definition to recount. A count of the changed shelf would describe now, not necessarily 2:00.
- Uses a shared definition and same-time evidence.
- Recognises the limit of later changed contents.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Sources
Fictional classroom example. A new anonymous page says the fair is cancelled but gives no source. Yesterday’s dated organiser notice says it will proceed. The organiser has not yet replied to a question about the new claim.
Reader’s rule
A pupil says the newest page must always be right.
4A · True or false
The newer anonymous page automatically resolves the conflict.
- true: True
- false: False
Recency alone does not establish authority or evidence; the cancellation claim still needs checking.
4B · Open ended
State a cautious current conclusion and the next useful action.
Example of a full-credit answer: The organiser’s notice is the better-supported record so far, but the new cancellation claim is unresolved. Seek a current confirmation from the organiser before treating it as settled.
- Does not automatically trust the anonymous page or claim certainty without support.
- Requests relevant current organiser confirmation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Class problem
Fictional classroom example. An equipment list says there are 15 usable skipping ropes. A repair log says three of those 15 need repair. The activity leader needs the number ready for use now.
Goal
Write a note that distinguishes total ropes from currently usable ropes and identifies anything needing confirmation.
5A · Multiple choice
Which note best handles the apparent conflict?
- a: All 15 are certainly usable because one list says so.
- b: The total is 15, but if three still need repair, only 12 are ready; confirm repair status.
- c: The ropes have disappeared.
- d: The two numbers should simply be averaged.
The repair status affects the usable count and needs current confirmation.
5B · Short answer
Write your own resolution note with the condition that must be checked.
Example of a full-credit answer: There are 15 ropes in total. If the three listed repairs are unfinished, 12 are usable; check whether those repairs have now been completed.
- Distinguishes total from usable and gives the conditional count.
- Identifies current repair completion as the needed check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.11 · Recognising misleading headlines
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Some readers are not all readers
Article
In one practice session, five of eight pupils found the coloured word cards easier to read. Three did not. No other class was tested.
Headline
Coloured Cards Help Every Pupil Read Better
Question: What does the headline exaggerate?
Answer: It changes a limited report of easier reading into a claim about every pupil and improved reading.
Why: The article reports who found cards easier to read in one session. It does not measure every pupil or establish a general reading improvement. A fair headline could say “Five of Eight Pupils Report Easier Reading with Coloured Cards.” Preserve what was actually measured as well as the group size.
Example 2 · A short closure becomes a permanent one
Notice
The model railway room will close for one Tuesday afternoon while its floor is cleaned. It will open again on Wednesday morning.
Headline
Model Railway Room Closes Forever
Question: Why does the headline mislead?
Answer: It turns a one-afternoon closure into a permanent closure.
Why: The missing time limit changes the practical meaning. A reader who sees only the headline may believe the room will never reopen. Short headlines cannot include every detail, but they should keep limits that prevent a substantially wrong impression. “Railway Room Closed Tuesday Afternoon for Cleaning” would preserve the notice’s main meaning.
Example 3 · A question is not a finding
Class article
Could a new folder help pupils find music sheets faster? The class plans to compare folders next week. No results have been collected yet.
Headline
New Folder Proven to Speed Every Search
Question: What has the headline added that the article does not establish?
Answer: It adds a proven result and a promise about every search before the test has happened.
Why: The article presents a question and a plan. The headline reports a settled success. Words such as proven need evidence of an actual investigation, and every search is wider still. A faithful headline would announce the planned comparison rather than invent its outcome. Interesting wording can still remain accurate.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose faithful headings
Article
In one class, twelve of twenty pupils chose a longer lunch reading period in a survey. Eight chose the current length. The survey did not include other classes.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two headings that fit the article.
- a: Twelve of Twenty Pupils Prefer Longer Reading Period
- b: One Class Reports Its Reading-Period Preferences
- c: Every Class Demands a Longer Reading Period
- d: Longer Reading Period Proven Best for Everyone
The first two headings preserve the limited survey. The others invent school-wide views or proof of what is best.
Source explorer: headline lab
F2 · Keep an uncertain finding uncertain
Report
A small trial suggests that the new desk marker may reduce mix-ups. The class needs more trials before making a firm conclusion.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the headline that keeps the report’s uncertainty.
- a: New Desk Marker May Reduce Mix-ups in Small Trial
- b: New Desk Marker Ends All Mix-ups Forever
- c: Class Proves Every Desk Marker Is Useless
May and small trial preserve the result’s uncertainty and scope. The other headings claim conclusions the report does not give.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · A question in a headline
Headline
Could a New Route Shorten Our Walk?
Article
The class will measure two possible routes tomorrow. Neither route has been timed yet.
F3 · True or false
This headline and article already establish that the new route is shorter.
- true: True
- false: False
They ask a question and describe a future measurement. No timing result has yet been reported.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Match the exaggeration
Full reports
A room closes for one day. A test involves one small group. A possible explanation still needs checking.
Headlines
A: “Room Shuts for Good.” B: “Every Pupil Gets the Same Result.” C: “Possible Explanation Proved Beyond Doubt.”
F4 · Matching
Match each headline to the limit it removes.
Complete or match: Headline A; Headline B; Headline C
- a: The finding remains uncertain.
- b: The closure lasts one day.
- c: Only one small group was tested.
A changes duration, B expands the group, and C removes uncertainty.
Source explorer: claim board
F5 · Write a faithful practice headline
Short report
Five pupils tried a new way to organise word cards. Three found their cards faster on the second round; two took the same time. The class has not tested other pupils or repeated the comparison.
F5 · Open ended
Write a fair headline and explain one limit your headline preserves.
Example of a full-credit answer: Three of Five Pupils Find Word Cards Faster in Small Trial. This keeps the result limited to three pupils in the tested group rather than promising faster searches for everyone.
- Writes a headline consistent with a small trial and the reported improvement for three of five pupils, without inventing universal success or proven cause.
- Explains a preserved limit such as the small group, mixed results, one trial or lack of wider testing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Headline
Fictional classroom example. “School library shuts down!”
Full notice
The library will close from 10:00 to 11:00 on Tuesday for a shelf repair. It will open normally before and after that hour.
1A · Multiple choice
What important context does the headline leave unclear?
- a: The library closes for only one hour on Tuesday.
- b: The repair uses books from every school.
- c: The library has no shelves.
- d: The school has permanently closed.
The full notice describes a short temporary closure, not permanent shutdown.
1B · Open ended
Write a more accurate headline and explain the limit you kept.
Example of a full-credit answer: Library closes for one-hour shelf repair on Tuesday. This keeps the limited duration so readers do not think it is permanently closed.
- Produces a headline preserving the short Tuesday closure.
- Explains how the retained limit prevents a misleading impression.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Study summary
Fictional classroom example. Eight pupils tried a reading game for one week. Six said it made practice enjoyable. The trial did not test whether reading scores improved.
Draft headline
“Game raises every pupil’s reading score.”
2A · Drag and drop
Match each phrase to its status in the summary.
Complete or match: Eight pupils for one week; Six enjoyed practice; Every pupil’s scores improved
- a: Stated trial scope
- b: Reported enjoyment
- c: Not established by this trial
The trial measures reported enjoyment in a small group, not everyone’s reading gains.
2B · Short answer
Explain two ways the headline goes beyond the summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: It changes enjoyment into improved scores, which were not tested. It also changes a small group into every pupil.
- Identifies the untested score outcome.
- Identifies the overgeneralisation from eight pupils to everyone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Match report
Fictional classroom example. The school team won its first match of a three-match friendly event, 8–6. Two matches remain, and no overall winner has been decided.
Headline choices
The class must choose a heading that matches the result without inventing a tournament outcome.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all accurate headline ideas.
- a: School team wins opening friendly match 8–6.
- b: School team has won every match in the event.
- c: Opening win leaves two matches to play.
- d: Final tournament champion already decided.
The opening result is known; later results and an overall winner are not.
3B · Open ended
Propose a lively but accurate headline of your own.
Example of a full-credit answer: Strong start: school team wins first friendly match 8–6. This reports the known opening result without claiming the whole event is won.
- Includes the opening-match win or score accurately.
- Avoids claiming later wins or an overall championship.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Article heading
Fictional classroom example. “Could a second lunch queue reduce waiting?”
Article body
The school is considering a trial. No waiting-time comparison has been run yet.
Shared caption
A repost says, “Second queue proves waiting is solved.”
4A · True or false
The repost accurately reports a proven result from the article.
- true: True
- false: False
The article poses a question and proposes a trial; it reports no completed result.
4B · Short answer
Explain the change in certainty and write a cautious correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The repost turns a question into a proven success. A correction is: The school is considering a second-queue trial to see whether waiting falls.
- Identifies question/proposal being changed into proof.
- Gives a correction preserving uncertainty and trial status.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Report
Fictional classroom example. A class collected 32 used notebooks for recycling during a one-week campaign. The report does not measure total school waste or claim that waste has ended.
Possible headline regions
A: Class collects 32 notebooks in one-week recycling drive. B: School ends all waste forever. C: Recycling makes every pupil perfect.
5A · Hotspot
Select the headline region that preserves the report’s main result and scope.
- a: A: Class collects 32 notebooks in one-week recycling drive
- b: B: School ends all waste forever
- c: C: Recycling makes every pupil perfect
The first keeps the class, count and time period without inventing universal outcomes.
5B · Open ended
Design a headline and one short subtitle that keep the result accurate.
Example of a full-credit answer: Headline: Thirty-two notebooks collected! Subtitle: Our class’s one-week recycling drive gathered used notebooks; it did not measure all school waste.
- Headline accurately reports the collection result.
- Subtitle preserves scope or avoids unsupported wider claims.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.12 · Recognising misinformation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A mistaken copied digit
Class messages
The original costume list says to bring two safety pins for an adult to use. A copied reminder says twenty. The copier checks the original and posts a correction, explaining that an extra zero slipped in.
Question: What inaccurate information should be corrected?
Answer: The reminder should say two pins, not twenty.
Why: The original list and the checked copying explanation establish the error. This classroom case gives evidence of a mistake, not an attempt to trick readers. A helpful correction focuses on the number and the source. It should reach people who saw the earlier reminder so they do not keep following the wrong instruction.
Example 2 · A genuine photo with the wrong date
Shared image
A real photograph of a crowded book stall is captioned “Our stall today.” The school archive identifies the same photograph as last year’s fair. The sharer’s reason is not known.
Question: What can readers say with confidence?
Answer: The photograph does not show today’s stall; its verified archive date is last year.
Why: A picture can be genuine while its caption is inaccurate. Correct the date using the relevant archive. Do not infer how crowded today’s stall is, because the old photograph cannot answer that question. The evidence also does not reveal why the person shared the wrong caption, so a careful correction avoids an unsupported accusation.
Example 3 · Correct without repeating the rumour as fact
Group message
A message claims that all craft sessions are cancelled. The organiser’s dated notice says only today’s clay session is cancelled; paper craft continues.
Question: What would a helpful correction say?
Answer: Only today’s clay session is cancelled. Paper craft continues, according to the organiser’s dated notice.
Why: The correction names the exact error and gives the relevant source. It does not need an insult or a dramatic accusation. Readers who are unsure should check the organiser’s notice rather than forward the broad claim again. Stating the accurate information clearly helps prevent a correction from accidentally spreading the original false message.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Respond to a wrong hand-in date
Shared reminder
A repost says entries are due on Thursday.
Checked notice
The organiser’s notice for the same contest gives Friday. The organiser confirms that Friday remains correct.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two helpful actions.
- a: Share a clear correction giving Friday and the notice.
- b: Ask the repost’s sender to update the wrong deadline.
- c: Accuse the sender of deliberate lying without more evidence.
- d: Keep forwarding Thursday because many people saw it first.
A sourced correction and an update reduce the error’s spread. Popularity and guessed intent do not improve accuracy.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Keep error and intent separate
Checked case
A flyer claims that the puppet show is in Room 4. The confirmed organiser notice places it in Room 6. No information explains how the flyer got the room wrong.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each statement to its evidence status.
Complete or match: The flyer’s Room 4 claim is wrong.; The flyer maker deliberately tried to trick visitors.; Ask for a correction citing the organiser’s Room 6 notice.
- a: A reasonable corrective action
- b: Not established by the supplied evidence
- c: Established by the checked location
The room error is established. Intent is unknown. A factual correction can be made without guessing intent.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Which message needs correction?
Original timetable
The first model-building session begins at 9:15 in Room 8.
Forwarded messages
Four messages describe the same first session. Only one changes the checked time.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which message contains the incorrect detail?
- a: Meet at nine-fifteen in Room Eight.
- b: The first session starts at 9:15 in Room 8.
- c: The first session begins at 9:50 in Room 8.
- d: Room Eight hosts the first session at nine-fifteen.
The 9:50 message conflicts with the checked 9:15 start. The other messages restate the same time and room.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · An error is not proof of a motive
Source comparison
A post gives twelve model ships. A checked inventory gives ten. The source does not show who changed the number or why.
F4 · True or false
The inventory difference alone proves that the poster intended to deceive readers.
- true: True
- false: False
It establishes a numerical error, not the poster’s intention. More relevant evidence would be needed to establish deliberate deception.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Repair the wrong finishing time
Wrong reminder
The craft session finishes at 4 p.m.
Confirmed organiser notice
The same session finishes at 3 p.m. The organiser confirms the notice is current; the reason for the wrong reminder is unknown.
F5 · Short answer
Write a short correction that gives the right finishing time and its evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The craft session finishes at 3 p.m., according to the current organiser notice, which the organiser has confirmed. Please use this time in place of 4 p.m.
- Corrects the finishing time to 3 p.m. for the same session.
- Cites the current organiser notice or organiser confirmation as evidence, without inventing the reminder writer’s intent.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: source tabs
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Shared message
Fictional classroom example. Dan forwards a timetable saying the chess club meets on Monday. The attached sheet is labelled last term.
Current timetable
The current term’s organiser notice lists chess on Thursday. Dan says he did not notice the old label.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each detail to its role.
Complete or match: Monday on last term’s sheet; Thursday on current notice; Dan did not notice the label
- a: Old information wrongly used for the present
- b: Supported current meeting day
- c: Stated explanation consistent with a mistake
The current-day claim is inaccurate; the stated oversight is not evidence of a deliberate lie.
1B · Short answer
Write a correction and explain why you should not call Dan a deliberate deceiver on this evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Chess meets Thursday this term, according to the current notice. Dan says he missed the old label, and the evidence does not show he intended to mislead.
- Corrects the meeting day with the current source.
- Separates the established error from unproven deceptive intent.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Original record
Fictional classroom example. The class charity stall sold 46 bookmarks. The treasurer’s signed total and item list agree.
Newsletter draft
A pupil types 64 bookmarks in the newsletter, reversing the digits. The pupil notices and asks for a correction.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the correction record.
Complete or match: Supported count; Detail to correct
- a: 46 bookmarks
- b: 64 in the newsletter draft
- c: The stall’s location
The original records support 46; the draft reverses the digits.
2B · Open ended
Explain what makes this a precise correction instead of an attack on the whole newsletter.
Example of a full-credit answer: It identifies the wrong number and replaces it with 46 from the records. It does not claim that every other newsletter detail is false.
- Correctly identifies the supported replacement and source.
- Limits the correction to the actual error.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Photo record
Fictional classroom example. A photograph shows the school garden during last year’s renovation. The dated archive labels it clearly.
New post
A pupil reposts it with “The garden looks like this today,” without checking the archive date.
Current record
A photo taken today shows the completed garden.
3A · Matching
Match each item to its information role.
Complete or match: Archived renovation photo; Today caption on that old photo; Dated current photo
- a: A historical image
- b: An inaccurate current-time claim
- c: Evidence of the garden’s present appearance
A real old image can mislead when given an incorrect current caption.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the photo can be genuine while the post is misleading.
Example of a full-credit answer: The image may accurately show last year’s renovation. Calling it today’s view assigns the wrong time and misrepresents the current garden.
- Distinguishes image authenticity from caption accuracy.
- Identifies the old-versus-current time mismatch.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Group message
Fictional classroom example. “Urgent! The school fair is cancelled. Forward to everyone!” No source or date is supplied.
Available notice
The organiser’s current dated notice says the fair is proceeding. No cancellation update is supplied.
4A · True or false
The urgent wording is enough evidence to forward the cancellation as confirmed.
- true: True
- false: False
Urgency is a request for action, not verification of the claim.
4B · Open ended
State a responsible next action and explain why it is better than immediate forwarding.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the current organiser notice or ask the organiser for confirmation. This tests the claim instead of spreading an unsupported cancellation.
- Chooses a relevant verification step before sharing as fact.
- Explains the difference between urgency and evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Situation
Fictional classroom example. Your class chat says the museum trip leaves at 8:30. The current signed letter clearly says 8:00, and the organiser confirms that no change has been made.
Goal
Correct the departure time clearly, respectfully and with a source.
5A · Multiple choice
Which correction is most useful?
- a: Everyone in the chat is dishonest.
- b: The confirmed departure is 8:00, not 8:30; check the current signed trip letter.
- c: Maybe any time will do.
- d: Forward both times without explanation.
It gives the exact correction and source without inventing motives.
5B · Short answer
Write your own correction and include what readers should check.
Example of a full-credit answer: Please use 8:00 for departure. The current signed trip letter and organiser confirm it; the earlier 8:30 message was incorrect.
- Clearly states 8:00 instead of 8:30.
- Names the relevant confirming source in respectful wording.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.13 · Recognising disinformation
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A plan to create a false belief
Fictional craft fair case
A group posts that the bead stall has no beads left. The checked stock list shows many beads. A teacher verifies a message from the poster: “I know they still have beads. I will say they have none so people come to our stall instead.”
Question: What makes this a case of deliberate false information?
Answer: The verified message shows that the poster knew the claim was false and wanted visitors to believe it.
Why: The stock list checks the factual error. The separate verified message establishes the intention to mislead. Both matter: a wrong stock count by itself would not show what the poster knew or intended. Readers should correct the claim using the checked stock information.
Example 2 · The same error can have different causes
Two copied labels
One label wrongly says a model bridge holds ten blocks. Its maker shows a copying slip and corrects it to six. Another maker’s verified note says, “It holds six, but I will write ten so our model seems stronger.”
Question: Why do these wrong labels support different conclusions about intent?
Answer: The first has evidence of a copying mistake; the second has evidence of a knowing false claim meant to impress readers.
Why: The incorrect number alone is not the whole story. Read the evidence about how and why each label was made. Do not assume that all errors are tricks, or that a polite-looking label cannot mislead.
Example 3 · Check the evidence about the supposed plan
Review folder
A post wrongly says the puppet workshop has no places left. The organiser confirms that places remain. An unsigned screenshot claims the poster planned to keep others away, but nobody has verified the screenshot’s origin or context.
Question: Can the folder establish that the poster deliberately deceived readers?
Answer: It establishes the false claim about places, but it does not establish deliberate intent.
Why: The organiser can check availability. The anonymous screenshot needs its own verification before it can support an accusation. A useful response corrects the availability information and asks the organiser for details. It leaves the poster’s motive unconfirmed instead of turning a doubtful accusation into another misleading message.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A knowingly false stall rumour
Checked classroom case
A post claims all seed packets at a class swap are spoiled. The organiser’s inspected stock record says the packets are usable.
Verified message
In this fictional case, a teacher verifies the poster’s message: “I know the packets are fine. I will invent a spoilage story so pupils visit our decoration stall instead.”
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two details that together establish deliberate deception.
- a: The inspected stock record contradicts the spoilage claim.
- b: The verified message admits inventing the story to redirect pupils.
- c: The post uses a bright border around its heading.
- d: Several pupils read the post before visiting the fair.
The stock record checks the falsehood. The verified message shows knowledge and an intention to mislead. Design and audience size do not establish that intention.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Which evidence establishes knowing deception?
Model-car display
A poster wrongly claims that another group broke the display track. A teacher checks that the track was already damaged before that group arrived.
Verified admission
The teacher verifies the poster’s statement: “I knew they did not damage it, but I blamed them so others would avoid their display.”
F2 · Hotspot
Select the detail that directly establishes the intention to mislead.
- a: The track was already damaged before the group arrived.
- b: The teacher-verified admission of knowingly inventing blame.
- c: The accusation was printed at the top of the page.
The admission directly describes knowing invention and its purpose. The earlier damage establishes the error but does not, alone, establish the poster’s intent.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · A motive guess is not enough
Class sale post
A pupil shares an incorrect price for a competing stall. The pupil also sells similar crafts. No message, admission or other evidence shows whether the pupil knew the price was wrong.
F3 · True or false
Selling similar crafts proves that the pupil knowingly invented the incorrect price.
- true: True
- false: False
A competing interest can prompt careful checking, but it does not prove knowledge or intent. The price should be verified and corrected without guessing the reason.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Different evidence, different labels
Case A
A pupil accidentally swaps the colours in a team list, shows the mistaken draft and corrects it.
Case B
A verified planning note says a pupil will knowingly invent a team’s withdrawal so classmates choose another team. The team has not withdrawn.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which description fits the supplied evidence?
- a: A is a copying mistake; B plans deliberate deception.
- b: Both cases prove plans to deceive their classmates.
- c: A proves deception; B records an accidental copying slip.
- d: Neither case supplies any information about the writers’ intentions.
A has evidence of an accidental swap. B includes a verified plan to spread a known falsehood for a misleading purpose.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · The invented missing-materials story
Checked event record
The weaving workshop has all its required materials and will go ahead.
False post and verified plan
A post says the workshop cannot run because all materials are missing. In this fictional case, a teacher verifies its maker’s message: “The materials are there, but I will say they are missing so nobody joins that workshop.”
F5 · Open ended
Explain why this is deliberate false information rather than simply an unexplained error.
Example of a full-credit answer: The claim that the materials are missing is false because the checked record says all are present. The verified message shows the maker knew this and wanted people to believe the false claim so they would stay away.
- Identifies the false missing-materials claim using the checked event record.
- Uses the verified statement to explain knowing invention and the intended misleading effect, rather than inferring intent from the error alone.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: quote lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Case A
Fictional classroom example. Kai posts the wrong rehearsal time, then shows the mistyped draft and immediately corrects it. No evidence of an intention to mislead is supplied.
Case B
In this fictional case, a teacher verifies Ren’s admission: Ren knew the correct time and posted a false one specifically so another group would miss rehearsal.
1A · Dropdown selection
Classify the cases using only the supplied evidence.
Complete or match: Case A; Case B
- a: Incorrect information; deliberate deception not established
- b: Deliberate false information with verified intent to mislead
- c: Proof that every future message will be false
The cases share an error but differ in evidence of deliberate misleading.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the same wrong result does not justify the same judgement about intent in both cases.
Example of a full-credit answer: Case A supplies a mistake and correction, not proof of deception. Case B explicitly includes a verified admission of knowingly misleading another group.
- Distinguishes false content from intent evidence.
- Uses the verified admission as the decisive difference without overgeneralising.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Records
Fictional classroom example. A signed timetable proves the concert starts at 2:00. A post falsely says 4:00. An unverified anonymous screenshot claims the poster wanted others to miss it.
Checking rule
The screenshot’s source and full context have not been established.
2A · Matching
Match each record with what it establishes on the supplied facts.
Complete or match: Signed current timetable; The 4:00 post; Anonymous intent screenshot
- a: The inaccurate statement being checked
- b: The supported start time
- c: An unverified allegation about motive
The timetable settles the time, while the screenshot does not yet settle intention.
2B · Short answer
Explain why you can correct the time while withholding a conclusion about deliberate deception.
Example of a full-credit answer: The timetable supports 2:00 and contradicts 4:00. The only motive claim is unverified, so intent remains unknown.
- Correctly uses the timetable to establish the time error.
- Keeps intent uncertain because its evidence is unverified.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Classroom case
Fictional classroom example. A pupil posts that a rival team’s award was cancelled. The organiser confirms the award stands. A teacher verifies that the pupil invented the cancellation to damage the team’s reputation.
Response choices
The class needs a response that corrects the falsehood without creating new harmful claims.
3A · Multiple choice
Which response best fits the evidence and the class’s responsibility?
- a: Invent a false story about the poster.
- b: Correct the award status using the organiser’s record and seek adult support about the deliberate deception.
- c: Assume every post by every pupil is false.
- d: Keep forwarding the false cancellation.
The response corrects the record and addresses verified deception without retaliation.
3B · Open ended
Write a factual correction that does not repeat unsupported accusations.
Example of a full-credit answer: The organiser confirms that the team’s award has not been cancelled. Please check the organiser’s record and stop sharing the cancellation claim.
- Accurately corrects the award status using the organiser.
- Avoids retaliation or invented accusations while discouraging further false sharing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Disagreement
Fictional classroom example. Two club members argue about a game. Later, one shares an incorrect equipment count. The only known facts are the argument and the wrong count.
Accusation
A reader says being angry proves the pupil deliberately invented the number.
4A · True or false
The argument alone proves that the wrong count was deliberately invented.
- true: True
- false: False
Anger can be a possible motive but is not proof that this particular error was intentional.
4B · Short answer
Explain the reasoning error and state what can be concluded safely.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reader turns a possible motive into proof. We can say the count is wrong if checked, but the available facts do not establish why it was shared.
- Distinguishes possible motive from evidence of the actual deliberate act.
- Keeps the conclusion limited to the established error and uncertain intent.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Situation
Fictional classroom example. A false evacuation-practice time appears in a class message. The current teacher notice gives the correct time. The sender’s reason is unknown, and an anonymous accusation is spreading.
Goal
Help pupils use the correct instruction without turning an unknown motive into a new rumour.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all appropriate steps.
- a: Share the current teacher notice’s correct practice time.
- b: Label the sender a deliberate deceiver without evidence.
- c: Ask a responsible adult to investigate if needed, while stating intent is unknown.
- d: Invent a punishment story to frighten the sender.
The steps correct the information and preserve uncertainty about intent.
5B · Open ended
Propose a short response plan that handles both the wrong time and the uncertain accusation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the teacher’s current notice to correct the time. Do not repeat the anonymous accusation as fact; ask a teacher to check the situation if needed.
- Corrects the practical information from the relevant source.
- Avoids an unsupported intent accusation and uses appropriate follow-up.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.14 · Recognising fabricated quotations
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Quotation marks promise the speaker’s words
Recorded art interview
The teacher-approved transcript records Isha saying, “I like the curved pattern because it reminds me of waves.”
Draft quote card
The card attributes this sentence to Isha: “Straight lines are boring and should never be used.”
Question: Is the card an accurate quotation from this interview?
Answer: No. The supplied interview contains a preference for a curved pattern, not the card’s criticism of straight lines.
Why: Quotation marks should preserve the speaker’s actual words. A writer cannot invent a stronger sentence just because it might seem to fit a preference. A fair alternative would quote Isha’s recorded sentence or clearly summarise her preference without quotation marks.
Example 2 · A summary can be accurate without being a quotation
Pupil’s statement
“The first knot was difficult, but practising slowly helped me finish it.”
Report sentence
The pupil found the knot difficult at first and completed it with slow practice.
Question: Should the report sentence be placed inside quotation marks as the pupil’s exact words?
Answer: No. It is a fair paraphrase, but its wording differs from the original.
Why: A paraphrase restates meaning in the writer’s own words. It can be useful and accurate while remaining outside quotation marks. If exact wording matters, copy the original carefully and name its source. Do not treat every changed word as a false idea; distinguish a clearly labelled summary from an invented quotation.
Example 3 · Keep a limit that changes meaning
Maker’s interview
“This paper holds its shape indoors. I have not tested it in rain.”
Shared card
The card reports: The maker said, “This paper holds its shape in rain.”
Question: What change makes the card inaccurate?
Answer: It replaces indoors with in rain, claiming a result the maker specifically said had not been tested.
Why: The problem is not merely a shorter sentence. The substituted words change where the result applies. Checking the full interview reveals the invented claim. A careful quote should retain the recorded words, and a summary should preserve the indoor limit and the lack of a rain test. The maker’s actual statement does not establish outdoor performance.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose exact, supported quotations
Checked interview
The craft tutor said, “Fold the corners first. A careful crease helps the box hold its shape.”
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two quotations that reproduce complete sentences from the interview.
- a: “Fold the corners first.”
- b: “A careful crease helps the box hold its shape.”
- c: “Fold every edge as quickly as possible.”
- d: “A colourful box never needs careful creases.”
The first two choices use the interview’s actual sentences. The other sentences introduce words and claims not present in the interview.
Source explorer: quote lab
F2 · Quote, paraphrase or invention?
Original statement
The class recorder’s checked transcript says, “I enjoyed drawing the map, but I still need help with the key.”
Three reports
A: “I enjoyed drawing the map, but I still need help with the key.” B: The pupil liked drawing the map and wanted more help with its key. C: “I can draw perfect maps without any help.”
F2 · Matching
Match each report to its description.
Complete or match: Report A; Report B; Report C
- a: A fair paraphrase outside quotation marks
- b: An invented quotation not supported by the transcript
- c: An exact quotation from the transcript
A preserves the words. B restates the meaning without claiming exact words. C invents a statement that conflicts with the need for help.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Check the original, not its copies
Quote image
An image attributes “Only expensive brushes make good pictures” to a visiting artist.
Available records
The school holds a complete, authenticated recording of that artist’s interview. Three blogs simply repeat the same image without linking any recording.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Choose the evidence-aware checks.
Complete or match: The strongest supplied source for checking the words is ___.; The three repeated images are ___.
- a: the authenticated interview recording
- b: three independent recordings of the interview
- c: copies of one unverified quotation
The recording can be checked directly. Repeated copies do not establish that the artist said the sentence.
Source explorer: network
F4 · Find the changed qualification
Approved transcript
The teacher said, “We may add a second session if enough helpers volunteer.”
Published card
The card quotes the teacher as saying, “We will add a second session.”
F4 · Hotspot
Select the description of what the card changes.
- a: It turns a conditional possibility into a definite promise.
- b: It accurately preserves the condition about enough helpers.
- c: It merely changes the size of the printed letters.
May and if enough helpers volunteer limit the original statement. Removing both changes its meaning and does not give an accurate quotation.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · Repair a false quote card
Authenticated interview
A model maker says, “I tested the small wheel on a smooth board.”
Draft card
The card attributes this to the maker: “I tested every wheel on every surface.”
F5 · Short answer
Give a corrected quotation or clear paraphrase, then explain what the draft wrongly expands.
Example of a full-credit answer: The maker said, “I tested the small wheel on a smooth board.” The draft wrongly expands one small wheel and one smooth board to every wheel and every surface.
- Provides an accurate quotation or clearly unquoted paraphrase preserving the small wheel and smooth board.
- Identifies the draft’s unsupported expansion from one tested wheel/surface to every wheel/surface.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: document lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Original class record
Fictional classroom example. The teacher-approved transcript says: “We should not remove the garden. We should repair its fence.”
Quote card
A shared card says the teacher stated, “We should remove the garden.”
1A · Drag and drop
Match each text with its role.
Complete or match: We should not remove the garden.; We should remove the garden.; We should repair its fence.
- a: Original opposition to removal
- b: Altered wording that reverses meaning
- c: Original proposed action
Removing not reverses the first sentence; fence repair is the actual proposal.
1B · Short answer
Explain the alteration and write an accurate brief summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: The card deletes not and reverses the meaning. The teacher opposed removing the garden and proposed repairing its fence.
- Identifies the missing negation and reversed meaning.
- Accurately summarises the original position and proposed repair.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Speaker’s message
Fictional classroom example. Ana writes: “I enjoyed the first workshop, but I need more practice with folding.”
Two reports
Report A says Ana enjoyed the workshop and wanted more folding practice. Report B places “I mastered every skill instantly” inside quotation marks and attributes it to Ana.
2A · Matching
Match each report with its description.
Complete or match: Report A; Report B
- a: A paraphrase consistent with the message
- b: An invented quotation contradicting the message
- c: A complete word-for-word transcript
A preserves meaning without claiming exact wording; B invents a claim of instant mastery.
2B · Open ended
Explain why Report A should not be presented as Ana’s exact quotation, even though it is a fair summary.
Example of a full-credit answer: It uses the reporter’s different wording. It can be a paraphrase attributed to Ana, but quotation marks should be reserved for her actual words.
- Recognises that wording differs despite preserved meaning.
- Distinguishes fair paraphrase from exact quotation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Original statement
Fictional classroom example. The organiser says, “If rain enters the hall, we will move the display to Room 6. Otherwise it stays in the hall.”
Shared quote
A message quotes only: “We will move the display to Room 6.”
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the context check.
Complete or match: Condition omitted by the shared quote; Default location if the condition does not occur
- a: Rain enters the hall
- b: The hall
- c: Room 6 in every situation
The original describes a conditional move, not a definite move in all circumstances.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the shortened quote could mislead and give a fairer announcement.
Example of a full-credit answer: It makes a possible move sound certain. The display stays in the hall unless rain enters it; then it moves to Room 6.
- Identifies the lost condition and resulting false certainty.
- Restores the correct conditional location instructions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Search results
Fictional classroom example. Four pages display the same image claiming a coach said, “Only winners deserve training.” All credit an unnamed social-media post. No recording or authenticated statement is supplied.
Task
Decide what the available evidence does and does not establish.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all careful conclusions or actions.
- a: The quotation is not verified by the supplied copies.
- b: Four copies prove the coach said it.
- c: Look for a relevant original recording or authenticated statement.
- d: Failure to find a recording here proves the coach never said anything similar.
Repeated unverified attribution does not prove authenticity, and limited searching does not prove universal absence.
4B · Open ended
Explain why neither “certainly genuine” nor “certainly invented” follows from these results alone.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pages repeat one unverified image, so they do not establish the words. But this limited set also does not show that no original exists elsewhere.
- Recognises lack of independent or original support.
- Avoids treating failure to find evidence in this set as proof of fabrication.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Verified source
Fictional classroom example. In the teacher-approved transcript, a librarian says, “Return books by Friday so the next group can borrow them.”
Card brief
Make a short card that preserves the deadline and reason. You may quote accurately or paraphrase clearly.
5A · Multiple choice
Which card is faithful to the supplied source?
- a: “Return books whenever you like,” says the librarian.
- b: “Return books by Friday so the next group can borrow them,” says the librarian, from the approved transcript.
- c: “Late books prove pupils are selfish,” says the librarian.
- d: “Friday returns guarantee perfect reading,” says the librarian.
It preserves the exact words and identifies the source without adding claims.
5B · Short answer
Draft a faithful quote or labelled paraphrase and explain one accuracy check you used.
Example of a full-credit answer: The librarian asks pupils to return books by Friday so the next group can borrow them. This is a paraphrase; I checked both the deadline and the reason against the transcript.
- Preserves the Friday deadline and borrowing reason.
- Uses exact quotation or clearly presented paraphrase and names an appropriate source check.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.15 · Recognising manipulated images and videos
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A brightness change is not automatically a false story
Photo record
A teacher-approved edit log says a dim photograph of the class paper sculpture was brightened so its folds were easier to see. No objects were added or removed. The caption still identifies the sculpture and the same classroom event.
Question: Does this record alone establish an attempt to deceive?
Answer: No. It documents a brightness adjustment, but supplies no false event claim or evidence of deceptive intent.
Why: Editing can serve different purposes. Ask exactly what changed and whether the resulting picture and caption misrepresent the subject. Do not jump from “edited” to “deliberately dishonest.” Further evidence could matter, but it should not be invented.
Example 2 · Playback speed and real time differ
Verified video record
A model boat takes twelve seconds to cross a tray in the original recording. An editing log shows a version played at twice the original speed, lasting six seconds. Its caption says, “The boat crossed in six seconds.”
Question: Why does the caption misrepresent the crossing time?
Answer: Six seconds is the edited playback time; the boat’s recorded crossing took twelve seconds.
Why: The speed change makes the action appear faster. Comparing the original timing with the edit log establishes the alteration, instead of guessing from how fast the boat looks. A fair caption would state the actual twelve-second crossing and disclose that the clip plays at double speed.
Example 3 · A real picture can be placed in the wrong setting
Archive record
A verified photograph shows paper kites hung inside the town craft centre. A new post uses that photograph with the caption “Kites hanging in our school library today.” The school librarian confirms no such display is there.
Question: What is established, and what remains unknown?
Answer: The picture is being given the wrong location and current-event caption. The supplied information does not establish who changed the caption or why.
Why: Misleading media do not always require changing the picture itself. Check the date, place and event attached to it. Correct the caption with the relevant records, while keeping unknown intent separate from the demonstrated error.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A crop hides part of a colour board
Cropped description
The posted crop shows only the left side of a class colour board: three blue squares. Its caption claims, “Every square on our board is blue.”
Verified full-board description
The same board has three blue squares on the left and three yellow squares on the right. The supplied edit record confirms that the right side was cropped out.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each detail to its role.
Complete or match: Three blue squares in the crop; Three yellow squares outside the crop; Every square on the board is blue
- a: A claim contradicted by the full board
- b: A genuine but limited part of the board
- c: Omitted context that changes the conclusion
The blue squares are real. The removed yellow squares show why the caption about every square is false.
Source explorer: crop lab
F2 · A faster replay
Original recording
A marble rolls along a model track in eight seconds.
Verified edit log
The shared version plays the same run at twice its original speed and lasts four seconds. No second run was filmed.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the accurate timing description.
Complete or match: The recorded run actually took ___.; The shared clip lasts four seconds because ___.
- a: eight seconds
- b: the replay speed was doubled
- c: the marble repeated the run faster
The original run still took eight seconds. Changing playback speed changes how long viewing takes, not how long the original event took.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · A blurry edge is a question, not proof
Photo review
A pupil sees a blurry edge around a cardboard castle in a photograph. No original file, other photograph or editing record has been provided.
F3 · True or false
The blurry edge alone proves someone added the castle to deceive viewers.
- true: True
- false: False
The edge may justify checking the original, but it does not establish an addition or deceptive intent. The necessary creation evidence is missing.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Check the claim a caption makes
Three media questions
A: A caption says a parade photo was taken today. B: A caption claims a tray contains only two objects, but only one corner is shown. C: A clip claims to show how long a model windmill turned.
Available checks
The trusted archive’s date record; the verified uncropped tray photo; the original recording and its playback-speed history.
F4 · Matching
Choose the most relevant check for each question.
Complete or match: A: Was the photo taken today?; B: Does the tray contain only two objects?; C: How long did the windmill actually turn?
- a: Original timing and playback-speed history
- b: Trusted archive date record
- c: Verified full image of the tray
Date records check time context, the full frame checks omitted objects, and original timing checks whether playback changes the apparent duration.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · A reversed clean-up sequence
Original frame at 1:00
The art table has paper scraps on it. In a shared clip, this frame appears last.
Original frame at 1:02
A pupil brushes the scraps into a bin. In the shared clip, this frame appears in the middle.
Original frame at 1:04
The table is clear. The shared clip puts this frame first and says, “This pupil made the table messy.” A verified editing record confirms that the clip reversed the original frame order.
F5 · Open ended
Explain how the shared clip misleads, and describe what the original sequence shows.
Example of a full-credit answer: The edit reverses the event order, making the clear table appear before the scraps. The original timestamps show the pupil clearing the scraps into a bin and leaving the table clean, so the caption misrepresents the action.
- Identifies the reversed event order as the documented misleading change.
- Describes the original clean-up sequence or gives a fair account of the pupil clearing the scraps, rather than creating the mess.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: sequence lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Verified full-frame description
Fictional classroom example. The class’s archived photo shows three empty chairs at the left and twenty occupied chairs at the right. It was taken during the same exhibition talk.
Posted crop and caption
The crop includes only the three empty chairs. Its caption says, “Nobody attended the talk.” The supplied edit record confirms the crop boundary.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each detail with what it establishes.
Complete or match: Three empty chairs in the crop; Twenty occupied chairs in the full frame; Nobody attended
- a: A true detail from a limited area
- b: Context contradicting the sweeping caption
- c: A claim not supported by the full image
The crop can show real empty seats while its caption misrepresents the wider scene.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the media can use a genuine image yet create a misleading impression.
Example of a full-credit answer: The crop keeps real empty chairs but removes the occupied part. The caption wrongly treats that limited view as proof that nobody attended.
- Identifies relevant context removed by cropping.
- Explains the unsupported leap from a partial frame to the whole event.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Original record
Fictional classroom example. A verified photograph of the classroom game scoreboard reads 12–9. The game’s signed score sheet also reads 12–9.
Edited version
A supplied, verified editing log shows the first score label was changed from 12 to 21. The edited image reads 21–9.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the evidence assessment.
Complete or match: Best evidence of the label alteration; Score supported by the original and sheet
- a: The verified edit log and comparison of versions
- b: 12–9
- c: 21–9 because edited images are newer
The documented change establishes alteration, while the original and sheet support 12–9.
2B · Short answer
Explain why the conclusion is based on stronger evidence than simply saying the digit looks strange.
Example of a full-credit answer: The verified log identifies the exact edit, and the original photograph and score sheet show 12–9. An odd-looking digit alone would not establish alteration.
- Uses the verified comparison/log to establish the change.
- Distinguishes documented evidence from appearance-based guessing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Short clip
Fictional classroom example. A ten-second clip shows Mara leaving the classroom during an activity. A caption says she refused to help.
Full recording record
The teacher-approved full transcript shows the teacher first asking Mara to fetch spare glue. Mara leaves and returns with it two minutes later.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all conclusions supported by the fuller record.
- a: Mara was asked to fetch glue.
- b: Leaving by itself proves refusal to help.
- c: The caption omits context that changes the meaning.
- d: Every short video is deliberately deceptive.
The fuller context explains a helpful task; the brief action does not establish the caption’s motive.
3B · Open ended
Write a fair caption and explain what context it preserves.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mara leaves to fetch spare glue after the teacher asks her, then returns with it. This preserves the instruction and outcome missing from the short clip.
- Provides a caption consistent with the glue task.
- Explains the importance of the omitted instruction or return.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Image review
Fictional classroom example. A photo of a kite has a shadow that a pupil finds unusual. No original file, lighting details or edit history is available.
Accusation
The pupil says the shadow alone proves the photo was manipulated to deceive viewers.
4A · Multiple choice
What is the most careful conclusion?
- a: The photo is certainly deceptive.
- b: The unusual shadow raises a question, but manipulation and intent are not established by this evidence alone.
- c: All shadows prove images are genuine.
- d: The pupil can identify every editing method from the shadow.
Appearance can prompt checking but does not alone establish editing or intent.
4B · Short answer
Name two relevant next checks and explain why they would help.
Example of a full-credit answer: Seek the original image and compare any available edit history or other photos of the same scene. These may explain the shadow or document a change.
- Proposes checking the original/provenance or context.
- Proposes a distinct relevant comparison or edit-history check without claiming certainty.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Class display
Fictional classroom example. A poster will show a historical flood photograph supplied by a verified archive. The photo is dated 2018 and shows a different town from the school’s town. It must not be presented as today’s local event.
Label areas
Area A: Historic photo, 2018, River Town archive. Area B: Flood outside our school today! Area C: This picture proves every town is flooding.
5A · Hotspot
Select the label region that preserves the verified image context.
- a: A: Historic photo, 2018, River Town archive
- b: B: Flood outside our school today
- c: C: Every town is flooding
The first label preserves time, place and provenance without inventing a current local event.
5B · Open ended
Design a short label and one check for using the photo responsibly.
Example of a full-credit answer: Historic flood photograph from River Town, 2018, supplied by the verified archive. Check that any crop keeps the relevant scene context and does not imply the event is current or local.
- Preserves the historical date/place or source in the label.
- Adds a relevant provenance/context check or explicitly avoids current-local misrepresentation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R5.16 · Recognising artificial intelligence-generated content
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A record of what the tool actually made
Checked production log
A teacher verifies the class audio-project log. An AI tool generated the spoken narration from a script that pupils wrote themselves. The pupils recorded the background sounds by tapping and shaking classroom objects.
Question: What contribution does the record establish as AI-generated?
Answer: The spoken narration was generated by the tool; the pupils wrote the script and recorded the background sounds.
Why: Identify each contribution rather than labelling the whole project as entirely machine-made or entirely human-made. The verified log gives evidence about the process. It does not, by itself, establish whether every factual statement in the script is accurate; those claims need their own checks.
Example 2 · Check an answer even when its origin is known
Tool output
A disclosed AI draft says a display has six red models and seven blue models, making fifteen models in all.
Checked inventory
The class inventory confirms six red models and seven blue models, with no other models in the display.
Question: Which part of the draft needs correction?
Answer: The total should be thirteen, because six plus seven equals thirteen.
Why: The AI disclosure tells readers how the draft was produced. The inventory and addition identify the particular error. It would be wrong to say the colour counts must also be false just because the total is wrong. Verify specific claims separately and keep the correct information when making a correction.
Example 3 · A source name is a starting point, not a completed check
Generated reading note
A classroom AI tool suggests that the art-club handbook permits painting on any wall. It names page four as its source.
Actual page four
The checked page says that pupils may paint only the movable practice boards with the teacher’s permission.
Question: Does giving a page number make the generated claim reliable?
Answer: No. The actual page does not support painting on any wall; it limits permission to movable practice boards.
Why: A source reference is useful only if the source can be found and says what is claimed. Read it directly. Here the page provides a concrete correction. Knowing that a tool generated the answer is different from checking whether its cited evidence supports it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Handwriting does not establish the whole process
Paragraph review
A pupil hands in a neatly handwritten paragraph. No draft history, creation record or disclosure is supplied. The paragraph might have been written from scratch or copied from another draft.
F1 · True or false
Handwriting alone proves that no AI tool helped create the paragraph’s wording.
- true: True
- false: False
Handwriting shows how this copy was put on the page. It does not establish the source of its wording or the earlier drafting process.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Find evidence of generated wording
Class poem project
A teacher checks the project’s saved creation history. It records an AI tool producing the poem’s opening two lines at 12:04; the pupil then writes the remaining lines. The poem uses a rhyme and has tidy punctuation.
F2 · Hotspot
Which detail establishes that the opening two lines were generated with AI?
- a: The teacher-verified saved tool output containing those lines.
- b: The fact that the finished poem includes rhyming words.
- c: The tidy punctuation used throughout the finished poem.
The verified creation record shows the tool’s actual contribution. Rhyme and punctuation can occur in human writing too.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Separate origin from a particular error
Disclosed AI draft
An AI-generated display guide says there are eight model towers.
Checked current record
The teacher’s checked inventory and full display photograph show six towers. The rest of the draft has not been checked yet.
F3 · Multiple choice
What correction is justified now?
- a: Change eight towers to the checked count of six.
- b: Delete every sentence because generated writing is always false.
- c: Keep eight because the generated guide sounds very certain.
- d: Accept every other sentence because one error was located.
The inventory and photograph justify correcting this count to six. Neither AI origin nor one detected error settles the accuracy of all the other sentences.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · What does each record tell us?
Poster production record
A verified project log says an AI tool suggested the poster’s title. A pupil’s checked saved drafts show the pupil drawing its plant illustrations. A separate checked seed register confirms the names of the plants shown.
F4 · Matching
Match each piece of evidence to what it supports.
Complete or match: Tool output in the verified log; Pupil’s saved illustration drafts; Checked seed register
- a: The plant names used in the display
- b: AI assistance with the title
- c: The pupil’s drawing contribution
The log and drafts trace who or what made parts of the poster. The register checks the factual plant names.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · A careful label for mixed work
Verified record — tool contribution
An AI tool suggested label wording for the class shell collection.
Verified record — pupil contribution
Pupils chose the final wording for the labels.
Verified record — factual check
Pupils checked each shell name against the teacher’s labelled collection record.
F5 · Short answer
Write a short note explaining how AI helped and how the shell names were checked.
Example of a full-credit answer: An AI tool suggested label wording. We selected the wording and checked the shell names against the teacher’s labelled collection record.
- Accurately discloses that AI suggested the label wording, without claiming it created the entire collection or all final work.
- Names the separate check of shell names against the teacher’s labelled collection record, rather than assuming generated labels are automatically correct.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Project A
Fictional classroom example. A teacher-confirmed log shows a pupil asked an AI tool for a first draft, then revised it. The project discloses this help.
Project B
Another paragraph has long words and neat punctuation. No creation record or disclosure is supplied.
1A · Dropdown selection
Classify the evidence about AI use.
Complete or match: Project A; Project B
- a: AI assistance documented in a verified creation record
- b: Origin cannot be established from these style clues alone
- c: Proof that every sentence is inaccurate
A verified process record supports provenance; writing style does not reliably establish it.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the projects support different conclusions about origin, without judging factual accuracy yet.
Example of a full-credit answer: A has a confirmed record of AI assistance. B only has a style description, which does not establish how it was written. Either project’s facts still need checking.
- Contrasts process evidence with unreliable style inference.
- Separates authorship/provenance from factual accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Generated answer
Fictional classroom example. A classroom tool’s answer is labelled “AI-generated draft” and says the museum opens on Mondays.
Current museum record
The museum’s official classroom timetable says it is closed on Mondays and open Tuesday to Sunday.
Question
Find the evidence that checks the opening-day claim, not merely the content’s origin.
2A · Hotspot
Select the region that directly checks whether the museum opens on Monday.
- a: Label: AI-generated draft
- b: Current museum timetable: closed Mondays
- c: The draft uses complete sentences
The current timetable addresses the factual claim; the AI label identifies the stated origin.
2B · Open ended
Explain what is wrong in the draft and why the label alone would not have established that error.
Example of a full-credit answer: The Monday-opening claim conflicts with the current timetable. Being labelled AI-generated does not itself make a particular claim false; the timetable supplies the relevant check.
- Correctly identifies the Monday error using the timetable.
- Separates an AI-origin label from evidence of factual truth.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Records
Fictional classroom example. A teacher-verified art log records an AI image tool generating a background. The pupil’s own drawing supplies the main character. The final poster contains both.
Task
Describe contributions accurately rather than calling the entire poster wholly human-made or wholly generated.
3A · Matching
Match each part to its documented origin.
Complete or match: Background; Main character; Final poster
- a: Pupil’s drawing
- b: AI tool output
- c: A combination of documented contributions
The record identifies distinct sources for the two parts.
3B · Short answer
Write an accurate disclosure and explain why “AI made everything” would be misleading.
Example of a full-credit answer: An AI tool generated the background, and I drew the main character. Saying AI made everything would erase the pupil’s documented drawing contribution.
- Discloses the AI-generated background and human-drawn character.
- Explains the mixed contribution instead of an inaccurate all-or-nothing label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Classroom case
Fictional classroom example. An automated checker labels a pupil’s paragraph “likely AI”. No verified creation record is supplied, and the paragraph’s claims have not yet been checked.
Claim
A classmate says this alone proves cheating and proves every fact in the paragraph is wrong.
4A · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is justified from the supplied information?
- a: Cheating and factual errors are both proven.
- b: The checker label is a clue to investigate, not conclusive proof of authorship, wrongdoing or factual accuracy.
- c: Every detector label is always correct.
- d: A paragraph’s origin decides every fact it contains.
A label alone does not establish creation history or intent, and factual claims require separate verification.
4B · Open ended
Propose a fair next step for authorship and a separate step for accuracy.
Example of a full-credit answer: Discuss the pupil’s drafts or creation process with the teacher rather than making an accusation. Check the paragraph’s specific facts against relevant sources.
- Uses a fair process/provenance inquiry without treating the label as proof.
- Separately verifies factual claims using appropriate evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Project brief
Fictional classroom example. A pupil used a tool to suggest a first paragraph about the school’s history. The pupil then checked dates in the school archive and corrected one invented quotation. The final text uses a paraphrase supported by the archive.
Reader needs
The note should explain assistance and checking without claiming that AI use guarantees truth.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each note element to its purpose.
Complete or match: A tool suggested the first paragraph.; I checked dates in the school archive.; I removed an unsupported quotation.
- a: Discloses assistance
- b: Describes a factual verification step
- c: Describes a correction based on evidence
The three elements make assistance and human checking traceable.
5B · Short answer
Write a short responsible-use note with one disclosure and one specific checking action.
Example of a full-credit answer: I used an AI tool to suggest a first draft. I checked the dates in the school archive and removed a quotation that the archive did not support.
- Clearly discloses the tool’s role as drafting assistance.
- Names a concrete date or quotation check/correction without claiming automatic accuracy.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.1 · Stories
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A problem starts a story
The missing apron
Santi arrived for the school cooking display with a bowl and spoon. He reached into his bag for his apron, but found only a towel. He remembered leaving the apron on a chair at home. His group was about to begin.
Question: What problem does Santi face?
Answer: Santi needs his apron for the display, but he has left it at home.
Why: A story problem is the difficulty a character must deal with. The bowl and spoon are background details; the missing apron and the approaching start create the difficulty. We should not say that Santi lost the apron, because he remembers where it is.
Example 2 · Actions suggest a feeling
The rehearsal
Before her first song, Bea gripped her music sheet and whispered, “What if I forget?” After practising once with her friend, she lifted her head and sang the opening line clearly.
Question: How may Bea’s feeling have changed?
Answer: She may have changed from worried to more confident after practising with her friend.
Why: Her question and tight grip suggest worry; her clearer singing suggests growing confidence. These are clues to a feeling, rather than a direct statement naming it. A good reading explains both the earlier behaviour and the later change without claiming to know every thought in her mind.
Example 3 · An ending that grows from the story
The wet drawing
Omar’s drawing became damp on the walk to school. He wanted to show its bright colours at the exhibition. His teacher offered a dry shelf and spare paper, but the exhibition would not begin until the afternoon.
Question: Suggest an ending that fits the problem and the available time.
Answer: Omar laid the drawing on the shelf to dry and used spare paper to make a title card. In the afternoon he displayed the dry drawing beside the card.
Why: This ending uses the offered materials and the time before the exhibition. It solves the damp-drawing problem through a believable action. Other endings can fit, but they should explain how Omar deals with the damp paper rather than introduce an unrelated surprise.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · The play banner
Opening
The class was decorating its stage. A corner of Jia’s paper banner tore loose.
Action
Ren held the banner steady while Jia fastened the corner with a paper clip.
Result
The banner stayed in place for the opening scene.
F1 · Drag and drop
Place each detail beside its story role.
Complete or match: Setting; Problem; Helpful action
- a: A corner of the banner tore loose.
- b: Ren held the banner while Jia repaired it.
- c: The class was decorating its stage.
The stage is where the story happens; the tear is the difficulty; holding the banner helps solve it.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F2 · Patient practice
Rico’s model
Rico’s paper tower fell twice. He looked at the folded base, widened it and tried again. When a classmate offered advice, Rico listened before making another fold.
F2 · Multiple answers
Which two details most clearly suggest that Rico keeps trying thoughtfully?
- a: He changes the base and tries again.
- b: He listens before making another fold.
- c: The tower is made from paper.
- d: A classmate is present in the room.
Changing the base and considering advice show thoughtful persistence. Paper and another person’s presence do not by themselves show that trait.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Who is telling the story?
A first-person passage
I waited beside the bus stop with my cousin. When the bus arrived, I checked the number before we stepped forward. My name is Mila, and this was my first trip to the library.
F3 · True or false
The passage is narrated by the character Mila.
- true: True
- false: False
Mila names herself and uses I to tell her own experience. That does not establish the name of the real author.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · A turning point
Beginning
Dan could not reach the fallen shuttlecock behind the bench.
Change
He noticed a long cardboard tube and gently rolled the shuttlecock toward the open side.
Ending
He picked it up and returned to the game.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the moment when Dan finds a way to solve the problem.
- a: He cannot reach behind the bench.
- b: He uses the tube to roll the shuttlecock.
- c: He returns to the game.
Using the tube changes the situation and makes retrieval possible.
Source explorer: timeline
F5 · A useful next event
Story so far
Tala promises to return a borrowed basket today. She notices that one handle is loose. The owner is still at home, and Tala has time to visit before evening.
Your ending
Continue the story without hiding the loose handle. Show Tala taking responsibility for the basket.
F5 · Open ended
Write a fitting next event. Explain how it shows Tala taking responsibility.
Example of a full-credit answer: Tala visits the owner, explains that the handle is loose and asks how to help put it right. She takes responsibility by telling the truth about the problem instead of returning the basket without mentioning it.
- Proposes an event that includes telling the owner about the loose handle while arranging the return.
- Explains how the action shows responsibility for the borrowed basket.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Before dusk · classroom example
Lina had promised to guide her younger cousin to the reading tent. At the path, a lantern had gone out. She knew the wider route would take longer. She paused, tested her torch, and chose the wider lit path.
At the tent
They arrived after the first song but before the story began. “We missed a song,” her cousin said. “We can still enjoy the story,” Lina replied, placing the torch beside her.
1A · True or false
Lina accepts missing one song so that she and her cousin can use a better-lit route.
- true: True
- false: False
Her choice of the lit path causes a later arrival, and her reply accepts missing the song.
1B · Open ended
What does Lina’s decision suggest about what matters to her? Use two details.
Example of a full-credit answer: She values her cousin’s safety more than arriving for every activity. She tests her torch and chooses the lit path even though they miss a song.
- Infers care or safety as a priority.
- Uses the route choice plus the accepted delay or torch check as support.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Rafi’s problem · classroom example
Rafi borrowed a paper boat and tore its sail. He first placed it behind a box. Later he carried it to Amira and said, “I tore this. Can we mend it together?”
Amira’s reply
Amira gave him tape. “Thank you for telling me,” she said. They worked until the boat could stand again, although a strip of tape remained visible.
2A · Matching
Match each story detail to the conclusion it best supports.
Complete or match: Hides the boat; Tells Amira he tore it; Repairs it with Amira
- a: Takes responsibility
- b: Avoids facing the problem
- c: Works to put things right
Hiding avoids the problem; admitting the damage accepts responsibility; mending addresses it.
2B · Short answer
Why is “Rafi becomes more responsible” a stronger reading than “nothing changes”?
Example of a full-credit answer: He moves from hiding the damage to admitting it, and then helps repair the boat.
- Contrasts the hiding with the admission.
- Connects the repair to changed behaviour.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Old story pattern · classroom example
In a story, a child protects one fragile seedling by asking friends to mark a safe walking path. The seedling grows, and the friends keep using the path.
New setting
Write a new story in a school library. A small book display keeps being knocked over when people hurry through a narrow gap. The characters must solve the problem together.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each new event in the story stage it fits.
Complete or match: Problem; Cooperative action; Result
- a: Friends move stools to mark a clear route
- b: The display stays upright as visitors use the route
- c: Visitors keep bumping the book display
The events preserve a shared solution to a repeated movement problem in a different setting.
3B · Open ended
Add one new event that develops this library story without copying its old setting. Explain how it fits.
Example of a full-credit answer: A visitor tries the new route while the friends watch. They move a stool when the gap is too narrow, which helps make their solution work.
- Proposes a plausible event in the library setting.
- Explains its connection to the display problem or cooperative solution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Story extract · classroom example
Jo could not reach a high shelf. Sam fetched a safe step stool. Jo used it while the teacher stood nearby. Together they returned the box to the table.
Reader’s summary
“Sam climbed onto Jo’s shoulders and took the box down without help.”
4A · Dropdown selection
Correct the summary using the story.
Complete or match: Who used the stool?; Who stood nearby?; What equipment helped?
- a: Jo
- b: The teacher
- c: A step stool
- d: Sam’s shoulders
The story names Jo as the stool user, the teacher as nearby, and a step stool as the equipment.
4B · Short answer
Explain one important way the inaccurate summary changes the story.
Example of a full-credit answer: It invents climbing on shoulders and removes the teacher, making the action seem unsupported rather than using a stool with an adult nearby.
- Identifies an invented or altered action/person.
- Explains how that changes the reader’s understanding of the event.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Opening · classroom example
Eli is looking for the class drum before the show. Bea remembers moving it into the dry storeroom when a roof began to leak. Eli has not yet asked her.
Ending rules
The ending must explain where the drum is and show Eli learning to ask classmates for information. It should follow from clues already in the story.
5A · Hotspot
Select the story clue that an ending should use to explain the drum’s location.
- a: Eli is looking before the show
- b: Bea moved the drum into the dry storeroom
- c: The show is for the class
Bea’s action directly explains where the drum went.
5B · Open ended
Propose a two- or three-sentence ending that meets both ending rules.
Example of a full-credit answer: Eli asks Bea whether she has seen the drum. She takes him to the dry storeroom, and he thanks her for explaining instead of searching alone.
- Uses the storeroom/Bea clue to resolve the missing drum.
- Shows Eli asking or learning to seek classmates’ information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.2 · Essays
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Find the idea joining the paragraphs
A short essay
I used to rush when copying patterns. First, I learned to look carefully at the first shape. Next, I checked whether each new shape followed the rule. My work became clearer when I slowed down and checked.
Question: What is the essay mainly explaining?
Answer: It explains how looking carefully and checking helped the writer copy patterns more accurately.
Why: The main idea connects the opening problem, the two actions and the result. “Shapes” names the topic but does not explain the message. A detail such as the first shape matters because it helps develop the wider idea about careful working.
Example 2 · Give an example a job
Essay point
Practising a small skill can make a difficult task easier.
Possible example
Lira practised tying a simple knot each day. Later, she used that knot to hang a card neatly on her project.
Question: How does Lira’s experience develop the essay point?
Answer: It shows a small skill, knot tying, being practised and then used in a larger project.
Why: An example should make the idea more concrete. The important connection is between the repeated practice and its later use. The example does not prove that every task becomes easy after the same amount of practice; its claim should stay close to the experience described.
Example 3 · Choose a careful conclusion
Essay evidence
During a week of paired reading, I asked my partner about three unfamiliar words. We discussed the sentences and checked a class word list. I then understood those sentences better.
Question: What conclusion fits this evidence?
Answer: Working with a partner and checking the word list helped the writer understand those three sentences.
Why: A conclusion draws together the evidence already given. It should not suddenly claim that paired reading solves every reading problem for everyone. Naming the actions and the limited result keeps the ending useful, clear and supported by the essay.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · More than a title
Essay
Learning a new dance took more than watching once. I practised the first four steps slowly. Then I joined them to the next four. Breaking the dance into small sections helped me learn it.
F1 · True or false
The essay’s central idea is that breaking a task into smaller sections can help learning.
- true: True
- false: False
Both sets of steps develop the idea of learning in small sections.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Parts of an essay
Opening
Our class learned that listening changes group work.
Middle
When we let each speaker finish, we heard ideas we had missed.
Ending
Giving everyone a turn helped us make a shared plan.
F2 · Matching
Match each section to its main job.
Complete or match: Opening; Middle; Ending
- a: Gives a specific example.
- b: Introduces the central idea.
- c: Draws the idea together.
The opening states the focus, the middle develops it and the ending connects the result to that focus.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F3 · Connect the ideas
Essay draft
I could not remember the order of the moves. I drew a small picture for each move. The pictures helped me practise the order.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the account so its connections match the draft.
Complete or match: I drew pictures ___ I needed help remembering the order.; The pictures showed the sequence; ___, I could practise it.
- a: because
- b: therefore
- c: although
Because introduces the reason for drawing; therefore introduces the resulting help.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · Choose a relevant detail
Essay focus
The essay explains how labelling storage boxes makes art materials easier to find.
Notes
The writer is choosing one detail for the next paragraph.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the detail that belongs in the paragraph.
- a: A picture of scissors marks the box containing scissors.
- b: The writer likes a song about the sea.
- c: The bus arrived five minutes early.
A label identifying the contents directly explains finding materials.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Explain the essay’s message
Paragraph 1
When I learned to draw a bicycle, I began with the two wheels.
Paragraph 2
I added the frame next and checked how its lines joined the wheels.
Paragraph 3
Working on one part at a time helped me complete the picture without losing my place.
F5 · Short answer
State the main idea and explain how one earlier paragraph develops it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The essay shows that working on one part at a time can make a drawing manageable. Beginning with the wheels is an example of dividing the larger picture into a small first task.
- Identifies the main idea as completing a larger drawing through smaller parts or steps.
- Connects the wheels or frame paragraph to that main idea with an explanation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Opening · classroom example
Our garden became easier to care for when we shared small tasks. At first, one group tried to water, weed and label everything. Several beds were forgotten.
Middle
We made a simple rota. Each team checked one bed and left a note for the next team. Missing labels were replaced quickly because someone knew where to look.
Ending
The garden still needs attention. Shared tasks do not remove work, but they help us notice and solve problems together.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete each statement about the essay.
Complete or match: The main idea concerns…; The rota is mainly…; The ending says shared work…
- a: an example of organising tasks
- b: helps without removing all work
- c: sharing manageable responsibilities
- d: growing the tallest plants
All sections connect organisation and shared responsibility; plant height is not discussed.
1B · Short answer
How does the middle section develop the opening idea?
Example of a full-credit answer: It gives a rota and team notes as specific ways to share small tasks, then shows labels being replaced more quickly.
- Names a concrete method from the middle.
- Connects that method or its result to shared responsibility.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Essay focus · classroom example
A pupil is writing that making mistakes can improve a craft when the maker looks carefully and changes something.
Notebook
In one weaving trial, loose strips slipped out. The maker tightened the next row, which stayed in place. A separate note says the blue strips looked bright beside the window.
2A · Multiple choice
Which example most clearly supports the essay’s focus?
- a: The blue strips looked bright
- b: Loose strips led the maker to tighten the next row
- c: The notebook had a green cover
- d: The window was open
The example includes a mistake, a response and an improved result.
2B · Open ended
Explain why your chosen example supports improvement better than the colour note.
Example of a full-credit answer: The loose strips show what went wrong and tightening shows a purposeful change. The colour note describes appearance without showing learning.
- Links the mistake to the corrective change.
- Explains why appearance alone does not demonstrate improvement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Pattern to transfer · classroom example
An essay about a garden explains a problem, a shared plan, and evidence of what changed. Its conclusion also admits a remaining difficulty.
New notes
The reading club lost track of borrowed books. Members tried a borrowing card, and fewer books were missing at the next meeting. Two cards were still incomplete.
3A · True or false
The new essay can use the same structure while explaining that the borrowing card helped but did not solve every problem.
- true: True
- false: False
The notes supply a problem, a trial, an improvement and a limitation.
3B · Short answer
Write a careful conclusion for the reading-club essay using the evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: The borrowing card helped us keep track of more books, but two cards were incomplete. We should make the card easier to finish and check it next time.
- States improvement supported by fewer missing books.
- Includes the incomplete cards or a sensible next step addressing them.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Draft plan · classroom example
The writer’s main idea is that observing a place slowly reveals useful details. Three planned paragraphs are: a rushed first visit, a slower visit with a notebook, and a comparison of what was noticed.
Misplaced ending
The draft ends: “Therefore, every person must buy the most expensive notebook to observe well.” No notebook prices or comparisons appear earlier.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each draft feature to the revision it needs.
Complete or match: Rushed visit paragraph; Slower notebook visit paragraph; Claim about expensive notebooks
- a: Use it to show the later method
- b: Remove or support this new claim
- c: Use it to establish the first comparison
The visits create a comparison; price is a new unsupported conclusion.
4B · Open ended
Rewrite the ending so that it follows from the essay rather than its notebook-price claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: Slowing down and recording details helped the writer notice more. A useful next visit would allow time to pause and compare notes.
- Removes the unsupported price requirement.
- Connects the conclusion to slower observation and recording details.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing purpose · classroom example
New pupils want to know how to make their first week easier. Write a short essay with one main idea and two different useful examples. Do not promise that everyone will feel the same.
Available notes
A map helped one pupil find rooms. A classmate explained the lunch queue. Another pupil’s bag was yellow. A final note says some pupils still needed time to feel comfortable.
5A · Matching
Match each useful note to its role in the plan.
Complete or match: Map helped find rooms; Classmate explained lunch queue; Some pupils still needed time
- a: Shows asking a person for help
- b: Adds a careful limit to the conclusion
- c: Shows using information to find places
The first two are different practical examples; the final note avoids an overconfident promise.
5B · Short answer
Propose a main idea and a conclusion for this essay using the notes.
Example of a full-credit answer: Main idea: using clear information and asking for help can make a first week easier. Conclusion: a map and a helpful classmate may ease problems, although settling in can still take time.
- Proposes a main idea covering both useful examples.
- Ends with a realistic conclusion that allows different experiences.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.3 · News articles
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Find the event in the opening
Classroom news report
On Wednesday morning, pupils at Bayani School opened a small seed-sharing shelf beside the library. The gardening club collected labelled packets from families. Visitors may take one packet after reading the growing instructions.
Question: What happened, where and when?
Answer: Pupils opened a seed-sharing shelf beside the school library on Wednesday morning.
Why: The opening supplies the central event, place and time. The club’s collection explains background, while the one-packet rule explains use. Keeping these jobs distinct helps a reader give a short accurate news summary without leaving out the event itself.
Example 2 · A quotation is someone’s statement
News extract
The school reporter counted sixteen visitors at the drawing workshop. “We hope to offer another workshop next month, ” said organiser Ms Robles. No date for another session has been announced.
Question: Has a second workshop already been scheduled?
Answer: No. The organiser hopes to offer one, but the report says that no date has been announced.
Why: The quotation reports a hope, not a completed arrangement. The observed visitor count and the future hope are different kinds of information. Checking the words hope and no date prevents an uncertain plan from becoming a definite news claim.
Example 3 · Check the headline against the body
Headline
School hall opens again
Report body
The hall’s reading area reopened on Monday. The stage remains closed while lights are checked. The office will announce a separate stage reopening date.
Question: What should a careful one-sentence summary say?
Answer: The hall’s reading area reopened on Monday, but its stage remains closed.
Why: The headline is short and leaves out an important limit. Reading the body shows that only one area reopened. A careful summary keeps both the change and the remaining closure; it does not invent a date for a part whose reopening has not yet been announced.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · The report’s opening
Report
On Friday, the Grade 5 art club displayed twenty paper masks in the school corridor. Visitors viewed the masks during the morning break.
F1 · Drag and drop
Place each detail beside the question it answers.
Complete or match: Who organised the display?; What was displayed?; On which day were the masks displayed?
- a: Twenty paper masks
- b: The Grade 5 art club
- c: Friday
The group answers who, the masks answer what and Friday answers when.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · What has actually happened?
Reported event
A class tested a new borrowing card on Tuesday. Twelve pupils used it.
Next step
The librarian plans to ask for comments on Friday. The article does not report those comments yet.
F2 · Multiple answers
Select the two completed events stated in the report.
- a: Every pupil approved the new card.
- b: The class tested the card on Tuesday.
- c: Twelve pupils used the borrowing card.
- d: The librarian collected Friday’s comments.
Testing and the twelve users are reported events. The comments are future work and universal approval is not reported.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Words that keep a plan uncertain
Quote
“If the equipment arrives, we may begin on Monday, ” the club leader said. The delivery date is not yet confirmed.
F3 · True or false
The quotation guarantees that the club will begin on Monday.
- true: True
- false: False
If and may make the start conditional, and the delivery is not confirmed.
Source explorer: quote lab
F4 · News features do different jobs
Article parts
Headline: New reading cart visits classrooms. Byline: Written by pupil reporter Eli Santos. Source: The librarian supplied the visit timetable.
F4 · Matching
Match each news feature to its role.
Complete or match: Headline; Byline; Named source
- a: Identifies who wrote the article.
- b: Identifies where information came from.
- c: Briefly signals the article’s event.
A headline introduces the news, a byline credits the writer and a source supplies information.
Source explorer: search lab
F5 · Repair a news summary
Article
The school has ordered two new noticeboards. Delivery is expected next week. Until they arrive, announcements will remain on the existing board.
Draft summary
The school installed two new noticeboards today.
F5 · Open ended
Rewrite the draft accurately and explain its main error.
Example of a full-credit answer: The school has ordered two noticeboards and expects delivery next week; announcements still use the existing board. The draft turns an order and expected delivery into a completed installation today.
- Writes a corrected summary that keeps the order/delivery as pending rather than installed today.
- Explains the difference between a planned or expected event and a completed event.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Headline and date · classroom example
Footpath crossing opens beside San Roque School. School News Desk, 8 July. The report concerns a fictional school crossing opened that morning.
Opening paragraph
The school opened a marked walking crossing beside its east gate on 8 July. Staff guide walkers from 7:00 to 7:30 a.m. Bicycles must be walked across during that period.
Background
The north gate remains open. A parent volunteer said the new markings are easier to see. The report does not give a count of pupils using either gate.
1A · Hotspot
Select the report region that tells a cyclist what to do during the staffed period.
- a: School News Desk, 8 July
- b: Bicycles must be walked across from 7:00 to 7:30 a.m.
- c: A volunteer says markings are easier to see
- d: The north gate remains open
That region states the action and the time condition.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the bicycle instruction is more useful for this decision than the volunteer’s opinion.
Example of a full-credit answer: It gives a clear action, walking the bicycle, and the staffed time. The opinion about visibility does not tell a cyclist what is required.
- Uses the required action and time condition.
- Distinguishes the instruction from the visibility opinion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Library report · classroom example
The town library tested a Saturday story hour on 6 August. Twenty children attended, according to its sign-in sheet. The librarian said, “We hope to repeat it next month if a storyteller is available.”
Reporter’s visit
The reporter saw chairs being put away after the session and spoke to the librarian. The next session has not been placed on the calendar.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported as completed events.
- a: A story-hour trial took place on 6 August
- b: A session next month is guaranteed
- c: Twenty children attended according to the sign-in sheet
- d: A storyteller has been booked for every Saturday
The trial and attendance are reported as completed; future arrangements remain uncertain.
2B · Short answer
Why should a report avoid saying that the next story hour is confirmed?
Example of a full-credit answer: The librarian says “hope” and makes it depend on a storyteller; the calendar has no confirmed session.
- Identifies the conditional or hopeful wording.
- Uses the unconfirmed storyteller/calendar evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier article · classroom example
On Monday, the school bulletin said Friday’s craft show would be in the courtyard. It listed the start time as 3 p.m.
Update from organisers
On Thursday, organisers confirmed that the show would move to the hall because rain was forecast. They said the Friday date and 3 p.m. start time were unchanged.
3A · True or false
An updated news report should change the venue to the hall while keeping the confirmed date and time.
- true: True
- false: False
The update changes only the venue and explicitly retains Friday at 3 p.m.
3B · Open ended
Write a short update that helps a reader who saw only Monday’s article.
Example of a full-credit answer: Friday’s craft show will now be in the hall, not the courtyard, organisers confirmed Thursday. It still starts at 3 p.m.
- Clearly identifies the new venue and earlier venue being replaced.
- Keeps the confirmed Friday date and 3 p.m. time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Full report · classroom example
One class tried a ten-minute reading break for three days. Its teacher said several pupils seemed calmer afterwards. No other classes were studied, and calmness was not formally measured.
Headline draft
“Reading breaks calm every pupil in every school.”
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete the corrections needed in the headline.
Complete or match: The study covered…; The teacher described…; The headline should avoid…
- a: one class over three days
- b: a guaranteed effect in all schools
- c: an informal observation
- d: a countrywide experiment
A small informal observation cannot support a universal claim.
4B · Short answer
Suggest a more accurate headline and explain one limit it keeps.
Example of a full-credit answer: “One class tries short reading breaks.” It keeps the small trial scale and does not claim a proven effect on everyone.
- Proposes a headline consistent with the reported trial.
- Names the sample, duration or informal-measurement limitation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Assignment · classroom example
Report a proposed weekend repair workshop. Organisers have chosen a room but are still checking which adults can supervise. No opening date is confirmed.
Reader needs
Families want to know whether the event is ready, who may attend and where to find a confirmed update. The story should not invent arrangements.
5A · Multiple choice
Which reporting plan best fits the evidence?
- a: Announce that the workshop opens this weekend
- b: Report it as proposed and ask organisers about supervision and the confirmed date
- c: Describe every repair as guaranteed free
- d: Replace the missing date with a guess
The plan preserves the proposal’s uncertain status and seeks missing practical details.
5B · Open ended
Propose two questions to ask before publishing, and explain why families need the answers.
Example of a full-credit answer: Ask when the date will be confirmed so families know when to plan, and ask who may attend and who will supervise so they know whether it suits them.
- Asks about a genuinely missing arrangement such as date or eligibility.
- Asks a second distinct practical question and connects the answers to readers’ decisions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.4 · Scientific reports
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Name a report section
Investigation extract
Question: Which paper boat carries more counters? Method: Make each boat from one equal-sized sheet. Add counters one at a time. Record how many it carries before sinking.
Question: Which part tells another group what to do?
Answer: The method tells the group to use equal-sized sheets, add counters one at a time and record the result.
Why: A scientific report separates its question from its procedure. The question states what is being investigated; the method explains the comparison. Reading the method also lets us notice conditions, such as sheet size, that help make the comparison fair.
Example 2 · Read a measured result
| Towel | Water absorbed (mL) |
|---|---|
| A | 14 |
| B | 19 |
Class results
Two equal-sized paper towels were tested with the same method. Towel A absorbed 14 millilitres of water. Towel B absorbed 19 millilitres. These are results from one trial.
Question: What comparison is supported?
Answer: Towel B absorbed 5 millilitres more water than towel A in this trial.
Why: The numbers measure absorbed water, so the unit millilitres belongs in the answer. Subtracting 14 from 19 gives the difference. The words in this trial keep the conclusion within the evidence; one trial does not establish what will happen with every towel or test.
Example 3 · Spot a missing measurement
Draft report
We compared two paper helicopters. Helicopter A stayed in the air for 3 seconds. We forgot to time helicopter B. Our draft says B remained in the air longer than A.
Question: Can the draft’s comparison be supported?
Answer: No. The report lacks a flight-time measurement for B, so it cannot show which remained in the air longer.
Why: A conclusion needs results that answer its question. An unmeasured value is not zero and should not be invented. The group could repeat a fair comparison, time both flights and then report what the measurements show.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the conclusion’s scope
Report
In one classroom test, a folded card bridge held eight counters. A flat card bridge of the same material and length held five. Only these two bridges were tested.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion fits the report?
- a: The folded bridge held more in this test.
- b: All folded bridges hold every heavy load.
- c: The flat bridge used a different material.
- d: Every bridge will hold exactly eight counters.
The folded bridge held more counters in the stated test. The report does not support a universal strength claim.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Find the fair comparison
Plan
A class will compare how quickly two equal-sized cloth pieces dry. Both begin with the same amount of water and hang in the same room. The material differs.
F2 · Multiple answers
Which two conditions are explicitly kept the same?
- a: The material of both cloth pieces
- b: The final drying time of each cloth
- c: The starting amount of water
- d: The room where the cloths hang
Water amount and room are held alike. Material differs; drying time is what the class will observe.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Sections of a short report
Question
Does adding a fold change how far this paper glider travels?
Method
Release folded and unfolded versions from the same marked point.
Result
The folded version travelled 2 metres; the unfolded version travelled 1 metre in this trial.
F3 · Matching
Match each report statement to its section.
Complete or match: Does a fold change distance?; Use the same marked release point.; The folded version travelled 2 metres.
- a: Result
- b: Question
- c: Method
The question asks, the method describes the procedure and the result records a measurement.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Evidence for a temperature statement
Cooling record
The class recorded a cup’s water temperature after ten minutes. Cup A: 28 degrees Celsius. Cup B: 31 degrees Celsius. The report says A was cooler at that point.
Other notes
A had a blue label. Both cups stood on a white tray.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the evidence that supports the cooler-at-ten-minutes statement.
- a: A: 28°C; B: 31°C after ten minutes.
- b: Cup A had a blue label.
- c: Both cups stood on a white tray.
Twenty-eight degrees is lower than thirty-one at the same recorded time.
Source explorer: table lab
F5 · A limited scientific conclusion
Report
A class compared two paper-strip designs. In three trials, design P held 6, 7 and 6 counters; design Q held 3, 4 and 3. Strip length and paper type were kept the same. Only these designs were tested.
F5 · Short answer
State a conclusion supported by the results and one limit on that conclusion.
Example of a full-credit answer: Design P held more counters than Q in all three trials. This finding concerns these two tested designs and does not prove that P is stronger than every other design.
- Uses the results to state that P held more counters than Q in the trials.
- States a relevant limit, such as only these designs or these testing conditions being studied.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: table lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Question and method · classroom example
Which cloth dries faster in our classroom? The class soaked equal-sized cotton and synthetic cloths, squeezed each in the same way, and hung both beside the same window. They checked once each hour.
Results and limit
The cotton felt dry after three hours; the synthetic cloth felt dry after two. The class used one piece of each fabric. They judged dryness by touch rather than weighing water.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete a careful reading of the report.
Complete or match: The quicker cloth in this test was…; One condition kept similar was…; One measurement limit was…
- a: synthetic
- b: the place where both hung
- c: dryness judged by touch
- d: cotton in every possible setting
The report supports a comparison in one setting and describes a rough measure of dryness.
1B · Short answer
Give the result and one reason not to make a claim about all cloths.
Example of a full-credit answer: The synthetic piece was judged dry an hour earlier. Only one piece of each was used, and touch may not measure dryness precisely.
- Accurately states the observed comparison.
- Identifies one stated sample or measurement limit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Paper ramps · classroom example
Investigators rolled the same toy car down two ramps. Both started at the same height. Ramp A’s surface was smooth; ramp B had a rough covering. They released the car without pushing.
Repeated distances
The car travelled 82, 80 and 81 cm after ramp A, and 51, 53 and 52 cm after ramp B. These were measurements for this car and these coverings.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all details that support a fair comparison of the coverings.
- a: The same car was used
- b: Ramp A was secretly pushed harder
- c: Both ramps began at the same height
- d: The investigators changed car size between ramps
Using one car and the same starting height reduces other explanations for the comparison.
2B · Open ended
Explain how the repeated results support the report’s conclusion without making it universal.
Example of a full-credit answer: All three smooth-ramp distances are longer than all three rough-ramp distances. That supports a difference for this setup, but not every car or covering.
- Uses the repeated pattern in the measured distances.
- Limits the conclusion to the tested setup or explains a remaining generalisation limit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier investigation · classroom example
A class compared two types of paper using the same sheet size, fold pattern and launch point. They measured flight distance rather than judging by appearance.
New question
A second class wants to compare how two paper types absorb water. They plan equal-sized strips, equal starting water amounts, and the same soaking time.
3A · True or false
The new class can transfer the idea of keeping comparison conditions equal, even though it measures water absorption instead of flight.
- true: True
- false: False
The fair-comparison principle applies while the measured outcome changes.
3B · Short answer
Name a useful water-absorption measurement and explain one condition that should stay equal.
Example of a full-credit answer: Measure the amount of water taken up by each equal-sized strip after the same soaking time. Equal time prevents one strip from having longer to absorb.
- Proposes a relevant observable absorption measurement.
- Names an equal condition and explains its role in the comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Leaf trial · classroom example
One plant was placed near a window and another in a cupboard. The window plant was watered daily; the cupboard plant was not watered. After a week, the window plant had more new leaves.
Draft conclusion
“Light alone caused the difference.”
4A · Multiple choice
What is the main problem with the draft conclusion?
- a: Both light and watering changed
- b: Leaves cannot be counted
- c: The report names two places
- d: The week had seven days
The report cannot separate the effects of light and water because both changed.
4B · Open ended
Repair the conclusion and suggest a fairer follow-up.
Example of a full-credit answer: The plants grew differently, but this test changed both light and water. A follow-up should vary light while giving similar plants equal water.
- Explains that the result does not isolate light because watering also changed.
- Proposes holding water and other relevant conditions similar while changing light.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Investigation brief · classroom example
Compare whether two reusable bag materials hold the same load without stretching. Use equal-sized bags and identical test weights. Stop before a bag tears. Report observations honestly.
Report parts
The reader needs to know the question, how the loads were added, and what stretching was observed at each load. A result has not yet been collected.
5A · Drag and drop
Place each planned statement in its report section.
Complete or match: Question; Method; Results to record
- a: Add identical weights in equal steps
- b: Stretch observed at each tested load
- c: Which material stretches less at the same load?
The question identifies the comparison; the method gives steps; results require actual observations.
5B · Short answer
Propose one fair-testing rule and one clear way to present the eventual results.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use equal-sized bags and add the same loads to both. Record load and observed stretch in a labeled table, leaving entries blank until measured.
- States a relevant fair-testing condition.
- Proposes a labeled record that uses actual observations rather than invented results.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.5 · Opinion articles
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Find the writer’s position
Opinion extract
Our class should keep a box for reusable paper. Many sheets have writing on only one side. Using the blank sides for rough work would give those sheets another use.
Question: What does the writer want the class to do?
Answer: The writer wants the class to keep a box for paper that can be used again.
Why: The words should keep state the proposed action. The unused sides provide a reason, and rough work gives a practical use. Identifying the position does not require agreeing with it; it means explaining fairly what the writer proposes and why.
Example 2 · Evidence that fits a reason
Opinion
We should label the classroom trays so materials are easier to return.
Observation
On three afternoons, pupils asked which tray held the glue sticks. The trays had no labels.
Question: How does the observation connect to the proposal?
Answer: The repeated questions show uncertainty about where glue belongs, so labels could address that specific problem.
Why: Relevant evidence connects to the reason behind a proposal. This observation concerns finding the correct tray, rather than an unrelated feature such as tray colour. It makes a labelled-tray trial sensible, but it does not guarantee that every pupil will always return every item correctly.
Example 3 · Answer an objection fairly
Proposal
A pupil suggests moving quiet reading outdoors because the room gets crowded.
Objection
Another pupil says rain could interrupt the reading time.
Question: What response deals with the objection?
Answer: Try outdoor reading on dry days and keep an indoor place available when it rains.
Why: The reply takes the concern seriously and changes the plan to deal with it. Calling the other pupil lazy would not answer the rain problem. A balanced opinion can keep its main aim while adding a practical condition that makes participation more reliable.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Reasons for a water station
Opinion article
The class should put the shared drinking-water jug on a low table. Some younger pupils cannot reach the current high shelf. The low table is beside the cup tray.
F1 · Multiple answers
Which two reasons directly relate to using the low table?
- a: The cup tray is beside that table.
- b: The class has a colourful wall calendar.
- c: The writer likes the jug’s painted flowers.
- d: Younger pupils can reach it more easily.
Reach and access to cups concern the arrangement. Calendar and decoration do not explain its usefulness.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · Parts of an opinion
Position
Our club should lend board games for home use.
Reason
Borrowing lets families try a game before buying one.
Objection
Some pieces might not be returned.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each statement with its role.
Complete or match: Lend games for home use.; Families can try a game first.; Pieces might go missing.
- a: A practical objection
- b: The proposed action
- c: A reason for the action
The proposal is the action, the reason explains a benefit and the objection identifies a problem to address.
Source explorer: claim board
F3 · Address concerns rather than people
Concern A
The craft club needs enough tables.
Concern B
The chess group needs a quiet corner.
Concern C
Both groups use the room after class.
F3 · Matching
Match each concern to a relevant planning response.
Complete or match: Enough tables for craft work; Quiet for chess players; Both groups need time in the room
- a: Agree on a shared timetable.
- b: Count the available work tables.
- c: Choose a separate quiet corner.
The responses address space, noise and scheduling rather than attacking either group.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · A reasoned reply
Opinion
The noticeboard should use larger print so readers farther away can read it.
Objection
Larger print may leave less room for long messages.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the reply that answers the actual objection.
- a: Use shorter messages and put full details beside the board.
- b: People who disagree do not care about reading.
- c: The noticeboard’s frame was painted last year.
Shorter messages and a place for details address the space concern while keeping larger print.
Source explorer: perspective
F5 · A proposal with a useful condition
Need
Pupils want to borrow classroom puzzles during lunch.
Concern
The teacher notes that pieces must be counted so the next group receives a complete puzzle.
Available arrangement
A check-out sheet and labelled puzzle bags are available.
F5 · Open ended
Write a brief opinion proposing a borrowing rule. Give one reason showing how your rule handles the concern.
Example of a full-credit answer: Allow lunchtime borrowing if pupils record the puzzle and count its pieces when returning it. This helps the next group receive a complete puzzle and makes missing pieces easier to notice.
- Proposes a borrowing rule with a return/counting or equivalent completeness check.
- Explains how that condition addresses missing pieces or readiness for the next group.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Opinion column · classroom example
Our classroom should have a quiet reading corner. During group work, pupils who finish early sometimes struggle to read beside lively discussions. A small screened corner could give them another choice.
Evidence and caution
In a class survey, 18 of 28 pupils wanted a quieter option. The writer says the corner should remain optional and should not block a doorway.
1A · Matching
Match each article part to its role.
Complete or match: We should have a quiet corner; 18 of 28 pupils wanted a quieter option; Do not block a doorway
- a: Survey evidence
- b: Practical condition
- c: Writer’s position
The proposal is the position, the survey supports demand, and the doorway rule constrains the design.
1B · Open ended
Explain how the writer supports the proposal while keeping it practical.
Example of a full-credit answer: The survey shows interest from 18 pupils. Making the corner optional and keeping the doorway clear addresses how it could fit the room.
- Uses the survey as relevant support.
- Explains one practical condition and its role.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Proposal · classroom example
The garden club should put clear labels beside its seedlings so new members can water and care for them correctly.
Notes
Members confused two seedlings with different watering instructions. Labels could include the plant name and care note. A separate note says the club’s shirts are green.
2A · Multiple choice
Which reason best supports the proposal?
- a: Green shirts look attractive
- b: Labels could prevent confusion between plants with different care needs
- c: Labels always make plants grow faster
- d: Every member likes the same colour
The reported confusion gives a practical reason for names and care notes.
2B · Short answer
Why is the care-confusion evidence more useful than the shirt colour?
Example of a full-credit answer: It describes a problem the labels can address: identifying plants and their different instructions. Shirt colour does not show a need for plant labels.
- Connects the specific confusion to the label proposal.
- Explains the irrelevance of the colour note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Original opinion · classroom example
A writer supports a classroom music break but accepts that some pupils need quiet. The proposal offers an optional music space and a separate quiet activity.
New issue
A class is deciding whether to use bright flashing animations in a display. Some pupils enjoy movement; others find it distracting. The display must remain easy to read.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each need to a suitable part of a balanced display plan.
Complete or match: Viewers who prefer still text; Viewers who enjoy movement; Everyone needs readable information
- a: Offer an optional animation control
- b: Keep a clear, complete static version
- c: Use readable labels in either view
The plan transfers the principle of choice while preserving access to information.
3B · Open ended
Propose a display rule that responds to both groups and explain its benefit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Start with still text and let viewers choose a non-flashing animation. Keep all important information in the still version so either choice works.
- Proposes a realistic choice or alternative that addresses both preferences.
- Preserves readable access to the important information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Different views · classroom example
Neri supports longer library opening hours because some pupils arrive late. Lito worries that the same volunteers would have to stay longer and suggests adding a second team.
Opinion draft
“Anyone who questions longer hours does not care about reading.” The draft gives no evidence about Lito’s feelings.
4A · Hotspot
Select the source region that shows the draft has ignored a practical objection.
- a: Neri supports longer opening hours
- b: Lito worries about volunteer hours and suggests a second team
- c: The draft claims critics do not care about reading
Lito’s concern is staffing, not rejection of reading.
4B · Short answer
How could the writer answer Lito fairly instead of guessing his feelings?
Example of a full-credit answer: The writer could discuss whether a second volunteer team is available and explain how longer hours would be staffed.
- Identifies the real staffing concern.
- Suggests an evidence-based reply or practical response without attacking motives.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Opinion task · classroom example
The canteen queue blocks the reading-room door. Pupils want a plan that keeps the door clear and treats people fairly. The canteen has one service counter.
Possible evidence
A marked waiting line fits along the opposite wall. Two helpers can guide the line at busy times. No evidence shows that pupils in one section deserve to be served first.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all plan components supported by the information.
- a: Mark a queue along the opposite wall
- b: Always serve one favoured section first
- c: Use helpers to keep the doorway clear
- d: Claim that the queue can vanish with no changes
The marked line and helpers address the stated obstruction without unfair priority.
5B · Open ended
Write a brief proposal with one reason and one way to check whether it works.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mark the line on the opposite wall and use helpers so the reading-room door stays open. Watch the doorway during busy times for a week and ask whether the queue feels fair.
- Proposes a feasible, fair arrangement that clears the doorway.
- Gives a relevant check of how well the plan works.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.6 · Instructions and manuals
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read a condition before acting
Bookmark instructions
Paint a pattern on the paper bookmark. Leave it flat until the paint is dry. Only then place it inside a book.
Question: May a learner put the bookmark in a book while the paint is wet?
Answer: No. The instructions say to wait until the paint is dry before placing it inside a book.
Why: The action is controlled by a condition. Reading only place it inside a book would miss the words until and only then. Following the condition keeps wet paint away from the book; it is part of the procedure, not an optional decoration.
Example 2 · Steps that depend on earlier steps
Paper pocket guide
First fold the lower flap upward. Next glue the two side edges. Wait for the glue to dry. Finally insert the note through the open top.
Question: Why should the note go in last?
Answer: The pocket needs to be folded, joined and dry before the note is inserted.
Why: The earlier steps create the container that holds the note. The open top is intentional, so gluing every edge would change the design. A careful reader follows the order and also checks what each step is meant to achieve rather than treating the numbered actions as separate commands.
Example 3 · Check a manual’s limit
Classroom display guide
This small cardboard holder is for one sheet of paper. Place it on a flat desk. If it leans, remove the sheet and ask the teacher to check the base.
Question: What should a pupil do if the holder leans?
Answer: Remove the sheet and ask the teacher to check the base.
Why: The guide states a response to a particular problem. Adding more sheets or continuing to use the leaning holder would ignore both the one-sheet limit and the conditional instruction. Asking the responsible adult follows the guide without guessing how to repair unfamiliar equipment.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Make a folded card
Step 1
Fold the card along the marked line.
Step 2
Press the fold flat.
Step 3
Write the name on the outside panel.
F1 · Drag and drop
Place each action in its stated step.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Write the name outside.
- b: Press the fold flat.
- c: Fold along the marked line.
The guide gives folding, pressing and writing in that order.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F2 · Find the instruction’s condition
Guide
Use the display clip only after the paint on the card has dried. If the card still feels damp, leave it on the drying tray.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the words that tell you when the clip may be used.
- a: Only after the paint has dried.
- b: The card is for a display.
- c: A drying tray is available.
The dryness condition determines when the clip may be used.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Follow the stated limit
Classroom holder manual
Use this holder for a single photo card. Do not place books in it. Ask the teacher if the card does not fit.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which action follows the manual?
- a: Add a notebook behind several cards.
- b: Place one suitable photo card inside.
- c: Fill it with two heavy reading books.
- d: Force an oversized card into its slot.
The holder is for one photo card; the manual rules out books and says to ask about fit.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Match steps to their purposes
Packing guide
Write the group name on the envelope so it can be returned. Count the cards before packing so the set is complete. Close the flap so the cards stay inside.
F4 · Matching
Match each action to its purpose.
Complete or match: Write the group name.; Count the cards.; Close the flap.
- a: Keep cards inside.
- b: Identify the receiving group.
- c: Check the complete set.
Each reason explains why its instruction matters.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · Read before using the tray
Guide
Put only dry paper shapes in the sorting tray. If a shape has wet glue, place it on the drying sheet first. Move it into the tray once the glue is dry.
Learner’s plan
Neri will put a newly glued shape directly into the sorting tray.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what Neri should change and which instruction gives the reason.
Example of a full-credit answer: Neri should put the shape on the drying sheet and wait before moving it to the tray. The guide allows only dry shapes in the tray and says wet glue must dry first.
- Replaces immediate tray placement with drying first and moving it after it is dry.
- Connects the change to the guide’s dry-paper or wet-glue condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Materials and steps · classroom example
Use a dry paper square and a label. First fold the sides inward. Next fold the bottom up and secure it with tape. Add dry seeds only after the bottom is closed. Finally label the envelope.
Check
Hold the envelope upright over a tray. If a gap lets seeds fall through, close the gap before storing it. Do not put damp seeds into the paper envelope.
1A · Matching
Match each instruction to its purpose.
Complete or match: Close the bottom before adding seeds; Use dry seeds; Check over a tray
- a: Prevents wet contents soaking the paper
- b: Catches seeds if a gap remains
- c: Keeps seeds from falling out while filling
Each instruction addresses a particular problem with storing seeds.
1B · Short answer
Explain why adding seeds before closing the bottom would not follow the guide.
Example of a full-credit answer: The bottom must be closed first so the seeds stay inside while the envelope is filled.
- Identifies the required order.
- Explains the risk of seeds falling through an open bottom.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Manual · classroom example
Step 1: Insert the wide base into the lower slot. Step 2: Slide the backing card into the upright groove. Step 3: Place a light paper sign in the clip. Check that the stand rests flat before using it.
Parts
The wide base supports the stand. The backing card supports the sign. The clip holds paper; it is not designed to hold a heavy object.
2A · Drag and drop
Place each action at the correct stage.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Insert the backing card
- b: Place the light paper sign
- c: Insert the wide base
The base supports the stand before the backing and sign are added.
2B · Open ended
Why is the final flatness check useful even after the three steps are followed?
Example of a full-credit answer: A part may not be fully seated. Checking that the base rests flat helps reveal an unstable assembly before the sign is displayed.
- Links the check to stability or proper assembly.
- Explains that completing steps does not guarantee every part is seated correctly.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Card-making guide · classroom example
Press two glued paper pieces together. Keep them flat until the glue dries. Decorate only after the join is dry.
New task
A learner makes a paper label using the same glue. The label is still damp at its joined edge, although the surface away from the join feels dry.
3A · Dropdown selection
Apply the guide to the new label.
Complete or match: The part to check is…; Decoration should begin…; Until then the label should remain…
- a: the joined edge
- b: after the join dries
- c: flat
- d: as soon as any surface feels dry
The guide refers to the joined area drying, not merely a different part of the paper.
3B · Short answer
Explain why the learner should not use the dry area away from the join as the only check.
Example of a full-credit answer: The condition concerns the glued join. A dry nearby surface does not show that the damp joined edge is ready.
- Identifies the join as the relevant part.
- Explains why dryness elsewhere does not meet the condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Manual excerpt · classroom example
Before moving the classroom display, remove loose cards from its pockets. Carry the empty display with two people, keeping it upright. Replace the cards after setting it down.
Learner’s plan
“I will leave the cards inside and tilt the display to make it easier to carry.”
4A · True or false
The learner’s plan follows the manual because the display will still be moved.
- true: True
- false: False
The result alone does not satisfy the procedure; loose cards must be removed and the display kept upright.
4B · Open ended
Identify two changes needed to bring the plan into line with the manual.
Example of a full-credit answer: Remove the loose cards before carrying, and use two people to keep the empty display upright.
- Corrects leaving the loose cards inside.
- Corrects the carrying method by keeping it upright with two people.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Draft instructions · classroom example
“Fold the paper. Put things in it.” The intended tray has corners folded upward and taped together. It should hold only light, dry classroom items.
Testing brief
A beginner needs to know where to fold and what the tray can hold. No cutting or unfamiliar equipment is needed.
5A · Hotspot
Select the source detail that supplies a missing use limit.
- a: Corners fold upward
- b: Corners are taped together
- c: Hold only light, dry classroom items
That detail explains what contents the paper tray is designed to carry.
5B · Short answer
Propose two improvements to the draft: one about making the tray and one about using it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show the upward corner folds with a labeled sketch, then explain where to tape. State that the tray is for light, dry items only.
- Adds a clear making detail such as fold location or taping.
- Adds the relevant light-and-dry use limit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.7 · Public announcements
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Turn a notice into a plan
Club announcement
Story Club members: meet at the covered court at 3:30 p.m. on Thursday. Bring your reading notebook. This week’s session will finish at 4:00 p.m.
Question: What should a member plan to do?
Answer: Go to the covered court at 3:30 p.m. on Thursday with a reading notebook.
Why: The audience is Story Club members, and the notice gives a place, time and requirement. Reading those details together creates a useful plan. The finishing time is also relevant for arranging collection, but it should not be confused with the time members are asked to arrive.
Example 2 · An update changes one detail
Original notice
The spelling game will be held in Room 6 at 10:00 a.m. on Friday.
Update
Friday’s spelling game moves to Room 8. The time is unchanged.
Question: Where and when should participants go?
Answer: They should go to Room 8 at 10:00 a.m. on Friday.
Why: The update replaces the room while preserving the date and time. Readers must join the new instruction with the information it leaves unchanged. An updated notice does not automatically cancel every detail of the original; its wording tells us exactly what has changed.
Example 3 · A deadline comes before an event
Workshop announcement
The paper-weaving workshop is on Saturday, 12 June, from 9 to 10 a.m. Reserve a place with the teacher by Thursday, 10 June. Materials are provided for registered pupils.
Question: Why would waiting until Saturday to reserve a place miss the instruction?
Answer: The reservation deadline is Thursday, two days before the Saturday workshop.
Why: The notice gives two different dates for two different actions. Saturday tells when the activity happens; Thursday tells when a place must be reserved. Matching each date to its action prevents a reader from arriving with an incorrect assumption about registration.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Details a participant needs
Notice
The drawing club meets on Tuesday at 2:45 p.m. in Room 3. Bring a pencil and a blank sheet. New members may ask Ms Cruz before attending.
F1 · Multiple answers
Select the two statements that follow the notice.
- a: A current member goes to Room 3 on Tuesday.
- b: A current member brings a pencil and blank sheet.
- c: The club meets in Room 2 every morning.
- d: Every visitor must bring a painted poster.
The stated room, day and materials guide a current member. The other statements add or change requirements.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · A limited closure
Office notice
The small reading room is closed on Monday morning for cleaning. The main library remains open. The small room reopens at noon.
F2 · True or false
The notice says the whole library is closed all day Monday.
- true: True
- false: False
Only the small reading room is closed, and only until noon.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Current place and time
Earlier notice
The puppet show starts at 1:00 p.m. beside the garden.
Update
Because the stage floor is wet, today’s puppet show moves to the covered walkway. The 1:00 p.m. start stays the same.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which plan uses the update correctly?
- a: Go to the covered walkway at three.
- b: Go to the school gate before noon.
- c: Go to the covered walkway at one.
- d: Go to the garden two hours later.
Only the venue changed; the start remains 1:00 p.m.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · Find the earlier action
Announcement
The music sharing is on Friday. Tell your adviser by Wednesday if you need to borrow a music stand. Collect the stand before Friday’s session.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the detail that tells you when to request a stand.
- a: Tell your adviser by Wednesday.
- b: The music sharing is on Friday.
- c: Collect the stand before the session.
Wednesday is the deadline for the request; collecting and performing are later actions.
Source explorer: search lab
F5 · Write the missing essentials
Organiser’s details
A classroom story swap is for Grade 5 pupils. It will be held in Room 9 on Wednesday from 3:00 to 3:30 p.m. Pupils should bring one short story to share.
Unclear draft
Join our story swap soon!
F5 · Open ended
Replace the unclear draft with a useful short announcement. Include who it is for, the arrangement and what to bring.
Example of a full-credit answer: Grade 5 pupils can join the story swap in Room 9 on Wednesday from 3:00 to 3:30 p.m. Bring one short story to share.
- Identifies Grade 5 pupils and accurately includes the Room 9/Wednesday/3:00–3:30 arrangement.
- States the requirement to bring one short story to share.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Notice header · classroom example
READING CLUB — VENUE UPDATE. Posted by the school office on 14 September. This notice is for pupils attending Thursday’s reading club.
New arrangement
Meet in Room 6 at 3:15 p.m. on Thursday, 16 September. The library is being cleaned. The meeting time has not changed. Bring your reading notebook.
Contact
Ask the reading-club adviser if you need help finding Room 6. Other library activities will receive separate notices.
1A · Hotspot
Select the announcement region that tells a member where to go.
- a: Reading Club — Venue Update
- b: Meet in Room 6 at 3:15 p.m. on Thursday, 16 September
- c: Other activities receive separate notices
The arrangement line gives the new location with its time and date.
1B · Open ended
What should a club member change in their plan, and what should they keep?
Example of a full-credit answer: Go to Room 6 instead of the library, while keeping the Thursday 3:15 meeting time.
- Identifies the changed venue.
- Identifies the unchanged meeting time/date.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Notice A — pupils · classroom example
Book exchange: pupils may bring one clean book on Wednesday. Exchange tables open in the hall at lunchtime.
Notice B — volunteers
Adult volunteers should report to the office at 10:30 a.m. on Wednesday to help arrange the hall.
Notice C — visitors
Visitors attending the afternoon exhibition should use the south entrance after 1 p.m.
2A · Matching
Match each reader to the notice that directly guides that reader.
Complete or match: Pupil bringing a book; Adult helping arrange tables; Visitor arriving for the exhibition
- a: Notice C
- b: Notice A
- c: Notice B
The notices address different groups and different actions.
2B · Short answer
Why should a pupil not use the adult volunteer arrival time as the book-exchange time?
Example of a full-credit answer: That time is for adults arranging the hall; pupils are told the exchange opens at lunchtime.
- Distinguishes the two audiences or purposes.
- Uses the pupil notice’s actual timing.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier pattern · classroom example
A pool notice explains a closed section, an alternative area and the period of the closure.
New announcement facts
The school’s east stairway is closed for painting on Monday morning. The west stairway remains open. The classrooms upstairs are still in use.
3A · Multiple choice
Which announcement keeps the important distinctions?
- a: All upstairs classrooms are closed all week
- b: Use the west stairway on Monday morning while the east stairway is painted
- c: The school has no open stairs
- d: The east stairway is closed forever
It gives the affected route, alternative and limited time without inventing a building closure.
3B · Open ended
Write a short announcement for someone who needs an upstairs classroom.
Example of a full-credit answer: On Monday morning, use the west stairway to reach upstairs classrooms. The east stairway is closed for painting during that period.
- Identifies the usable alternative and purpose.
- Includes the correct limited closure time and affected stairway.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Craft display notice · classroom example
The display opens on Friday, 22 October, at 2 p.m. in the hall. Pupils who want a table must request one from the office by Tuesday, 19 October.
Mistaken plan
A pupil plans to request a table on Friday because that is the date printed largest on the notice.
4A · Drag and drop
Match the notice details to the correct actions.
Complete or match: By Tuesday, 19 October; Friday, 22 October, 2 p.m.; In the hall
- a: Attend the display opening
- b: Where the display takes place
- c: Request a table
The booking deadline comes before the opening day.
4B · Short answer
Explain why the pupil’s plan misses a detail and how to correct it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The large date is the opening, not the request deadline. The pupil should ask the office for a table by Tuesday, 19 October.
- Distinguishes event date from deadline.
- States the correct request action and deadline.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Planning facts · classroom example
A class cleanup is for Grade 5 volunteers in the school garden on Saturday from 8 to 9 a.m. An adult coordinator will provide gloves. Volunteers must register with the class adviser by Thursday.
Draft poster
“HELP OUR GARDEN! COME SOON!” The draft has a large picture but none of the practical arrangements.
5A · True or false
A revised poster should include registration information as well as the activity’s time and place.
- true: True
- false: False
Volunteers need to know how to join before they can follow the event arrangements.
5B · Open ended
Propose a clear two- or three-sentence notice that tells the intended volunteers what to do.
Example of a full-credit answer: Grade 5 volunteers: join the school-garden cleanup on Saturday, 8–9 a.m. Register with the class adviser by Thursday; the adult coordinator will provide gloves.
- Includes the intended audience and correct event place/time.
- Includes the registration action and Thursday deadline.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.8 · Advertisements
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Separate a feature from a promise
Classroom advertisement
Try the Star Sketch Pad: 40 blank pages with a firm cover. Become an amazing artist overnight! Available at the class craft sale.
Question: Which part describes a checkable product feature?
Answer: The pad has 40 blank pages and a firm cover.
Why: A buyer could count the pages and inspect the cover. Becoming an amazing artist overnight is a promise about a person’s future ability, and the advertisement gives no evidence for it. Attractive language can make an offer noticeable, but the reader still needs to distinguish what the product includes from what the seller claims it will achieve.
Example 2 · Read the whole offer
Sale poster
FREE ruler with every purchase of three exercise books. Offer applies to this Friday’s school stall only. One ruler per qualifying purchase, while stocks last.
Question: Does a pupil receive a free ruler just for visiting the stall?
Answer: No. The pupil must buy three exercise books, and rulers must still be available.
Why: The large word free has conditions attached. The quantity, date and stock limit all belong to the offer. Reading the whole poster prevents the promise from being widened into a gift for every visitor or for any purchase on any day.
Example 3 · Choose evidence that matches the claim
Advertised claim
This pencil case keeps a closed zip secure during travel.
Available information
A smiling cartoon appears on the poster. A test note says the zipped case was shaken gently twenty times and remained closed.
Question: Which information is more relevant to the zip claim?
Answer: The test note is more relevant because it describes what happened to the closed zip during shaking.
Why: The cartoon attracts attention but does not test the zip. The test is relevant while still limited to its stated conditions; it does not prove the case will stay closed in every possible journey. A careful reader asks whether the evidence measures the advertised feature.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the purchase conditions
Offer
Buy two folders and receive one label sheet. The offer is available at the school stall on Friday. Label sheets cannot be collected without the folder purchase.
F1 · Multiple answers
Which two statements correctly describe the offer?
- a: The offer promises free folders throughout the year.
- b: Two folders must be bought to receive the sheet.
- c: The stated offer is available at Friday’s stall.
- d: Every visitor may collect a sheet without buying.
The purchase quantity and Friday availability are explicit conditions.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Advertisement parts
Product detail
A reusable pouch with a zip and two pockets.
Persuasive phrase
The most exciting pouch in the universe!
Condition
Offer ends when the ten available pouches are sold.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each advertisement detail to its role.
Complete or match: A zip and two pockets; Most exciting in the universe; Only ten pouches available
- a: A stock condition
- b: A checkable feature
- c: Persuasive praise
Features can be inspected, praise expresses an attractive judgement and the stock note limits availability.
Source explorer: claim board
F3 · Praise is not a measurement
Poster
Nine pupils say the lunch bag looks cheerful. The poster therefore claims that its zip never sticks. No zip test is described.
F3 · True or false
Praise for the bag’s appearance establishes that its zip never sticks.
- true: True
- false: False
The comments concern appearance, not zip performance, so they do not establish the claim.
Source explorer: quote lab
F4 · Read what a price covers
Offer A
Notebook: ₱18 each, 40 pages.
Offer B
Notebook pack: ₱45 for three, 40 pages each.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete each statement using the offers.
Complete or match: The ₱18 price buys ___.; The ₱45 price buys ___.
- a: one notebook
- b: three notebooks
- c: forty notebooks
Each in A refers to one notebook; B explicitly describes a pack of three.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Improve a truthful advertisement
Sale facts
The class stall offers used storybooks for ₱15 each. Buyers may inspect them. There are twelve books, and some have marked covers.
Draft
Perfect new books for everyone!
F5 · Short answer
Write an accurate replacement advertisement that includes the price and two useful conditions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Used storybooks are ₱15 each at the class stall. Twelve are available; some covers are marked, so inspect a book before buying.
- States that the books are used and cost ₱15 each.
- Includes at least one stock/condition/inspection fact in addition to their used status, without calling them perfect or new.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Poster · classroom example
BRIGHTDAY DRAWING KIT — “Bring your ideas to life!” The kit contains six coloured pencils and one small sketch pad. Price: ₱75.
Offer strip
A free eraser is included for purchases made on Saturday only, while the listed stock lasts. The poster does not say the kit improves school marks.
1A · Matching
Match each poster detail to its role.
Complete or match: Bring your ideas to life!; Six pencils and one small pad; Free eraser on Saturday only
- a: Product contents
- b: Promotional slogan
- c: Limited offer condition
The slogan attracts attention; the contents describe the kit; the eraser has a time limit.
1B · Short answer
What should a buyer check before expecting a free eraser? Explain using the poster.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check that the purchase is on Saturday and that the listed eraser stock remains, because both conditions limit the offer.
- Identifies the Saturday condition.
- Identifies the stock condition and connects it to receiving the eraser.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Offer A · classroom example
A pack of four plain cards costs ₱20. The buyer collects it from the school fair. No extra collection fee is charged.
Offer B
A pack of four glitter cards costs ₱18, plus a ₱10 delivery fee. Delivery is the only collection option. A pupil needs plain cards and can visit the fair.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each detail to the decision it helps make.
Complete or match: Offer A’s plain cards; Offer B’s ₱10 delivery fee; Pupil can visit the fair
- a: Raises B’s full cost above its headline price
- b: Shows A matches the needed card type
- c: Makes A’s collection method possible
Suitability includes card type, total cost and access to the collection method.
2B · Open ended
Justify which offer better meets this pupil’s stated need.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer A provides the plain cards needed for ₱20, and the pupil can collect them. Offer B adds delivery cost and offers a different card type.
- Connects A’s contents and collection method to the need.
- Accounts for B’s extra delivery cost or unsuitable card type.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Club advert · classroom example
“FREE WORKSHOP!” The next line says: “Materials fee ₱30. Places must be booked before Wednesday. For pupils aged 9–12.”
Reader situation
Lara is 10 and wants to attend. Her family wants to know whether the word “free” means they will pay nothing.
3A · Hotspot
Select the part that answers the family’s question about unavoidable cost.
- a: FREE WORKSHOP!
- b: Materials fee ₱30
- c: For pupils aged 9–12
- d: Book before Wednesday
The materials fee shows a stated charge even though the workshop heading says free.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the same careful-reading strategy used for prices helps with this workshop.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read all conditions, not just the heading. The workshop still requires a ₱30 materials fee, so “free” does not mean no payment at all.
- States the strategy of reading the full terms.
- Uses the materials fee to interpret the offer correctly.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Advertisement · classroom example
“Our backpack makes every child run faster!” The evidence below says ten pupils liked its blue colour. No running times or backpack-weight comparisons are given.
Product facts
The backpack has two pockets and a zip. The advertisement does not give its weight or capacity.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete the evaluation of this advertisement.
Complete or match: The tested preference concerned…; The speed claim would need…; The present evidence…
- a: colour
- b: relevant running comparisons under stated conditions
- c: does not establish the speed claim
- d: proves every child becomes faster
Liking a colour does not measure running performance.
4B · Open ended
Identify the mismatch between the claim and evidence, then state what could be reported honestly.
Example of a full-credit answer: The claim concerns speed, but the evidence concerns colour preference. The advert could honestly say ten pupils liked the blue colour, without claiming faster running.
- Identifies the different claim and evidence topics.
- Offers an accurate limited statement supported by the survey.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Sale facts · classroom example
The class has 30 used storybooks. Each costs ₱15. Some have names written inside, but all pages are present. The sale is Friday lunchtime in Room 3.
Advertising goal
Attract interested readers while making the books’ condition and purchase arrangements clear. Do not promise better grades or unlimited stock.
5A · True or false
An honest advertisement may mention the low price while also stating that the books are used and stock is limited.
- true: True
- false: False
Appeal and accurate conditions can appear together.
5B · Short answer
Write a short advertisement that is appealing and tells buyers two important conditions.
Example of a full-credit answer: Find your next story for ₱15! Our 30 used books are on sale Friday lunchtime in Room 3; some have names written inside, but all pages are present.
- Gives an appealing accurate offer with price or relevant content.
- Includes condition and limited stock or clear purchase arrangements without false guarantees.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.9 · Social-media posts
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A screenshot has an original date
Screenshot
Posted Monday: “Our craft group meets tomorrow at 3 p.m.”
Forwarded message
A friend forwards the screenshot on Thursday without changing its words.
Question: Which day did the original post mean by tomorrow?
Answer: It meant Tuesday, the day after the Monday post.
Why: A relative date is read from the original message’s context. Forwarding on Thursday does not turn tomorrow into Friday. The screenshot may be old, so the reader should check for a current arrangement before attending rather than silently changing its intended date.
Example 2 · Follow a post to its source
Short post
“Sports court open again!” The post links to a facilities notice.
Linked notice
The walking area around the court is open. The playing surface remains closed until the repairs are checked.
Question: What important limit is missing from the short post?
Answer: Only the surrounding walking area is open; the playing surface is still closed.
Why: A post may shorten the information in its source. Reading the linked notice reveals the exact area covered by the reopening. The post’s excitement and brevity are not substitutes for the practical conditions a reader needs before using the court.
Example 3 · A copied message is not a second witness
Sharing trail
One club member posts that a meeting has moved. Four other accounts copy the same message without contacting the organiser. The organiser’s page has not yet been checked.
Question: Do the five posts provide five independent confirmations?
Answer: No. The four copies all depend on the first message.
Why: Counting copies can make a claim seem better checked than it is. Independent confirmation would require separate relevant evidence, such as the organiser’s current notice. The number of shares tells us about spread, not whether the venue change is correct or why anyone shared it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · A forwarded date
Original post
Posted Tuesday: “Bring your drawing tomorrow.”
Forward
The same post is forwarded on Friday. No new instruction is added.
F1 · True or false
The original post asked pupils to bring the drawing on Wednesday.
- true: True
- false: False
Tomorrow refers to the day after the Tuesday posting, not the later forwarding date.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Post details have different jobs
Post
From: Book Club organiser. Posted: 8 September. Message: Saturday’s exchange starts at 9 a.m. Source link: the current organiser’s notice.
F2 · Matching
Match each detail to what it helps you check.
Complete or match: Book Club organiser; 8 September; Link to the current notice
- a: When the post was made
- b: Where to inspect the original arrangement
- c: Who is presenting the message
Identity, posting date and source link answer different checking questions.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Before sharing a lost-item post
Post
A post says a blue sports cap was found at yesterday’s club meeting. It gives the school office as the contact and shows a close-up of the cap.
Possible sharing choices
A classmate wants to pass on useful information without adding private details.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two actions improve a careful share?
- a: Add a guessed owner’s home address.
- b: Claim the cap belongs to a specific pupil without checking.
- c: Keep the office contact named in the post.
- d: Check which date yesterday refers to.
The contact and original date help verification. Guessing an owner or sharing unnecessary private details does not.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · The label changes the meaning
Original post
A class humour page labels a drawing “An imaginary classroom on the moon — a joke.”
Cropped copy
A cropped copy shows only “classroom on the moon” and the drawing.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the words that identify the original post’s purpose.
- a: An imaginary classroom — a joke.
- b: Classroom on the moon.
- c: A drawing appears with the words.
Imaginary and a joke identify the original humorous context.
Source explorer: crop lab
F5 · A careful update
Old post
The club’s old post gives Room 4 for Friday’s meeting.
Organiser’s new notice
A notice posted today by the organiser changes the room to Room 7 and keeps Friday’s 2 p.m. time.
Your task
Write a helpful reply under the old post.
F5 · Open ended
Write a short correction that gives the current arrangement and identifies where it was confirmed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Friday’s meeting is now in Room 7 at 2 p.m. The organiser’s notice posted today confirms the room change; the time stays the same.
- States Room 7 and Friday at 2 p.m. accurately.
- Attributes the correction to today’s organiser notice rather than a guess or share count.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: network
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Shared screenshot · classroom example
“Book swap tomorrow, 1 p.m., by the hall!” The screenshot shows no posting date. It was forwarded to Mina on Friday.
Original club post
The club’s original page shows the message was posted on Monday, 5 July. An update dated Tuesday, 6 July, says the swap took place that afternoon.
1A · Multiple choice
What should Mina conclude about the word “tomorrow”?
- a: It automatically means Saturday because she received it Friday
- b: It referred to Tuesday, 6 July, in the original Monday post
- c: It proves a new swap happens every day
- d: The date cannot matter
Relative time words depend on the original posting date, and the update confirms the event.
1B · Open ended
Explain why the date of forwarding does not reset the original announcement.
Example of a full-credit answer: The message was written Monday about the next day. Forwarding it Friday does not create a new event, and Tuesday’s update says it already happened.
- Uses the original date to interpret tomorrow.
- Uses the update or explains that forwarding does not change event arrangements.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Post A · classroom example
“Our school bus route is changing!” The post gives no date, school name or source, and readers have copied it many times.
Post B
“North School route update, 12 June: see the transport office’s dated notice. Route 2 uses the west stop from Monday.” The post names its source and exact route.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all details that make Post B easier to check.
- a: It identifies a dated transport-office notice
- b: It gives the exact route affected
- c: Its lettering could be made brighter
- d: Readers can copy it many times
The date/source and precise route help readers verify the arrangement and its relevance.
2B · Short answer
Why is the number of copies not a substitute for checking the transport notice?
Example of a full-credit answer: Copies may all repeat the same unchecked message. The original dated notice is where the route and timing can be verified.
- Explains that copies are not independent confirmation.
- Identifies the original notice as the relevant verification source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Useful model · classroom example
A reading-club post gives an event date, place, intended audience and organiser contact. It labels a later change as an update.
New facts
The art club’s Saturday sketch walk moves from the garden to the covered court. It still starts at 9 a.m. Members should bring a pencil. The adviser confirmed the move Friday.
3A · Drag and drop
Place the new facts into the post sections.
Complete or match: Update; Unchanged arrangement; What to bring
- a: Saturday, 9 a.m.
- b: Move from garden to covered court
- c: A pencil
The post should distinguish the changed place from the retained time and materials.
3B · Open ended
Write a short update using the model, including how the change was confirmed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Art club update: the adviser confirmed Friday that Saturday’s sketch walk will be at the covered court instead of the garden. Start time remains 9 a.m.; bring a pencil.
- States the changed place and unchanged time correctly.
- Attributes the update to the adviser’s Friday confirmation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original post · classroom example
The drama club’s page says: “FICTIONAL POSTER FOR OUR PLAY: Giant cat becomes mayor!” A small image shows a costume cat at a desk.
Cropped repost
A shared image removes the drama-club label and shows only “Giant cat becomes mayor!” A reader says the picture proves a real election result.
4A · Hotspot
Select the original region that corrects the reader’s interpretation.
- a: FICTIONAL POSTER FOR OUR PLAY
- b: Giant cat becomes mayor!
- c: Costume cat at a desk
The explicit play label identifies the image as fictional promotional material.
4B · Short answer
What went wrong in the reader’s interpretation, and what should be restored when sharing it?
Example of a full-credit answer: The reader lost the explicit play context and treated a fictional poster as news. Sharing should restore the drama-club and fictional-play label.
- Identifies the missing fictional/play context.
- Proposes restoring the relevant label rather than claiming the image proves a real event.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Discussion post · classroom example
A pupil shares an old photo and asks whether tomorrow’s school exhibition is cancelled. The current office notice says the exhibition is going ahead in the hall at 2 p.m.
Reply goal
Help classmates find the confirmed arrangement. Do not mock the questioner or publish private contact details. The notice is dated today.
5A · Matching
Match each reply part to its useful purpose.
Complete or match: Today’s office notice confirms the event; Hall, 2 p.m. tomorrow; Please check the current notice
- a: Gives practical arrangements
- b: Points to verification
- c: Identifies the current evidence
A helpful reply gives evidence, usable details and a way to verify them.
5B · Open ended
Propose a respectful reply that answers the concern and identifies the evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Thanks for checking. Today’s school-office notice says the exhibition is going ahead in the hall tomorrow at 2 p.m.; the current notice has the confirmed details.
- Answers with the correct current time/place/status.
- Names the dated official notice in a respectful reply without unnecessary private information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.10 · Emails
Three worked examples
Example 1 · The subject is a clue, the body is the instruction
Email header
From: Ms Ramos. Subject: Art folders.
Email body
Please tell me by Tuesday whether you need a folder for Friday’s display. Do not bring completed artwork until Friday.
Question: What must the pupil do by Tuesday?
Answer: Tell Ms Ramos whether a folder is needed.
Why: The subject names the topic, while the body states the requested action and deadline. Friday belongs to the display and artwork delivery, not the reply deadline. Matching each date with its action helps prevent a pupil from answering one part of the email while missing another.
Example 2 · Use an attachment with the message
Our group will prepare the blue display table. Please read the attached list and bring one item beside your name.
Attached list
Dara — glue stick. Noel — ruler. Pia — coloured paper.
Question: What should Noel bring?
Answer: Noel should bring a ruler.
Why: The email explains how to use the attached list, and the list supplies Noel’s specific item. Either source alone would be incomplete: the email does not name the item, and the list by itself does not explain the group’s task. The name must be matched to its own row.
Example 3 · Write a reply that answers the request
Email request
Can you help arrange the reading corner on Thursday from 3:00 to 3:20 p.m.? Please reply with yes or no so I can plan the team.
Learner’s situation
Iris is available for the whole time.
Question: What is a clear reply Iris could send?
Answer: Yes, I can help on Thursday from 3:00 to 3:20 p.m.
Why: The reply answers the requested yes-or-no decision and confirms the relevant arrangement. “Sounds fun” would express interest without clearly saying whether Iris can attend. A useful email reply supplies what the sender needs to plan, without adding unrelated or unnecessary private information.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the requested actions
Subject: Class reading display. Please reply by Monday with the title you chose. Bring the finished title card on Thursday. The display opens on Friday.
F1 · Multiple answers
Which two actions does the email ask the reader to do?
- a: Bring the finished title card on Thursday.
- b: Bring every storybook on Monday morning.
- c: Wait until Friday to decide on a title.
- d: Reply by Monday with the chosen title.
The email has a Monday reply and Thursday delivery; Friday is the display opening.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Email parts
Header
From: School art adviser. To: Art Club pupils. Subject: Friday materials.
Body
Bring one clean cardboard tube on Friday. Reply if you need help finding one.
F2 · Matching
Match each email part to its information.
Complete or match: From; To; Subject
- a: The message topic
- b: The sender
- c: The intended recipients
From identifies sender, To identifies recipients and Subject signals the topic.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Message plus attachment
Use the attached rehearsal list. Attend the time beside your group name.
Attachment
Blue Group: 1:30 p.m. Green Group: 2:00 p.m. Gold Group: 2:30 p.m.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the two group arrangements.
Complete or match: Green Group attends at ___.; Gold Group attends at ___.
- a: 1:30 p.m.
- b: 2:00 p.m.
- c: 2:30 p.m.
The attachment supplies each group’s particular time.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · An unexpected request
An unexpected email with the club’s colours asks pupils to send their account passwords to see a public event timetable.
Known information
The club usually posts its timetable on the public school board.
F4 · True or false
The familiar colours alone prove that the password request is genuine and necessary.
- true: True
- false: False
Colours can be copied and do not establish the sender or a need for a password. A pupil should check through a trusted adult or known club contact.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Reply to a specific question
Which of the two rehearsal times can you attend: Tuesday at 3 p.m. or Wednesday at 3 p.m.? Please reply by Monday.
Learner’s information
Ben can attend Wednesday but has another school activity on Tuesday.
F5 · Short answer
Write Ben’s clear reply and state when it should be sent.
Example of a full-credit answer: I can attend the Wednesday rehearsal at 3 p.m., but I am unavailable on Tuesday. Ben should send this reply by Monday.
- Clearly selects Wednesday at 3 p.m. for Ben’s attendance.
- Identifies Monday as the reply deadline.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: word lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Email header · classroom example
From: Ms Vera, class adviser. To: Grade 5 craft group. Subject: Card display — reply needed. Sent Monday, 4 October.
Message
Please tell me by Wednesday whether you can help arrange cards on Friday from 2 to 3 p.m. Reply with yes or no. You do not need to send a card design yet.
Closing
Thank you. Ms Vera. The room number will be sent after helpers are confirmed.
1A · Hotspot
Select the message region that states what the reader must do first.
- a: Subject: Card display
- b: Tell me by Wednesday whether you can help Friday, 2–3 p.m.
- c: The room number will be sent later
The email asks for an availability reply by Wednesday.
1B · Short answer
What should the reply contain, and what should the reader avoid assuming?
Example of a full-credit answer: It should say yes or no about Friday from 2 to 3 p.m. The reader should not invent a room number because that will be confirmed later.
- States the requested availability response.
- Recognises the room remains unconfirmed or avoids sending an unrequested design.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Organiser’s email · classroom example
“Please reply with the day you can bring your model: Tuesday or Thursday. We will plan table space using your answers.”
Pupil’s situation
Hana can bring the model on Thursday, but not Tuesday. The organiser does not need Hana’s home address or account password.
2A · Multiple choice
Which reply best answers the organiser’s request?
- a: I like making models
- b: I can bring my model on Thursday
- c: Here is my password
- d: I will bring it sometime
It provides the exact day needed for table planning without unrelated private details.
2B · Open ended
Why is this reply more useful than “sometime”?
Example of a full-credit answer: Thursday is one of the offered days and lets the organiser reserve table space. “Sometime” leaves the scheduling decision unresolved.
- Identifies the specific requested day.
- Explains how specificity helps the organiser’s planning.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Message · classroom example
From: School librarian. Subject: Return-window change. Please return borrowed display books to the library desk by 1 p.m. on Thursday. Do not leave them outside the closed reading room.
Attachment note
Attached: list of display-book titles. Use the list to check whether your book is part of the display collection.
3A · Matching
Match each part to the information it provides.
Complete or match: Subject line; Body; Attachment list
- a: Which book titles are included
- b: The message’s general topic
- c: Where and by when to return books
The subject introduces the change; the body gives action details; the attachment identifies the books.
3B · Short answer
How would a pupil use both the message and list to decide what to do?
Example of a full-credit answer: First check whether the title is on the display list. If it is, return it to the library desk by 1 p.m. Thursday rather than leaving it outside the room.
- Uses the title list to establish whether the request applies.
- Uses the body’s correct location and deadline to plan the action.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Earlier email — Monday · classroom example
The planning meeting is Friday at 2 p.m. in Room 2.
Latest email — Wednesday
The meeting will now start at 2:30 p.m. on Friday. Room 2 remains the venue. Please use this updated start time.
Mistaken note
A pupil writes “Wednesday, 2:30, Room 2” in a calendar.
4A · Dropdown selection
Correct the calendar entry.
Complete or match: Meeting day; Meeting time; Meeting room
- a: Friday
- b: 2:30 p.m.
- c: Room 2
- d: Wednesday
Wednesday is the sending date of the update; Friday remains the event day.
4B · Open ended
Explain the error and how the latest email should be used.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil confused the update’s sending day with the meeting day. The latest message changes the start time to 2:30 but keeps Friday and Room 2.
- Identifies the sending-date/event-date confusion.
- States the updated time while retaining the unchanged day/place.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Writing task · classroom example
Ask the librarian whether your class may use the reading room on Tuesday from 10 to 11 a.m. You do not yet have permission. The class has 24 pupils and one teacher.
Useful email parts
The librarian needs to recognise the request, understand the proposed arrangement and know that you are awaiting confirmation.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each email part to its function.
Complete or match: Subject; Main request; Closing
- a: Could our 24 pupils and teacher use the room Tuesday, 10–11 a.m.?
- b: Thank you; we will wait for your confirmation.
- c: Reading-room booking request
The parts identify the topic, provide the arrangement and avoid pretending permission has been granted.
5B · Short answer
Write a short request that gives the necessary arrangement and respects the need for permission.
Example of a full-credit answer: Could our class of 24 pupils and one teacher use the reading room Tuesday from 10 to 11 a.m.? Please let us know whether it is available; we will wait for confirmation.
- Includes the proposed group and date/time arrangement.
- Clearly asks permission or availability rather than claiming the booking is confirmed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.11 · Online discussions
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Follow what a reply answers
Question from Mina
Does the club have enough chairs for twelve visitors?
Reply from Jo
I counted ten chairs in the room this morning.
Reply from Eli
I like the new wall poster.
Question: Which reply directly helps answer Mina’s question?
Answer: Jo’s reply helps because it gives the number of chairs available.
Why: A useful reply connects to the question being discussed. Ten chairs is relevant to whether twelve visitors can sit, while liking the poster concerns a different feature of the room. Jo’s count still has a time attached, so the group may need to check whether any chairs have since been added.
Example 2 · Disagreement can identify a practical need
Suggestion
Kai proposes holding the club talk beside the playground.
Response
Lena says younger pupils use the playground at that time and the talk may be hard to hear.
Question: Is Lena’s response a relevant counterargument?
Answer: Yes. It identifies noise at the proposed place and time, which could affect the talk.
Why: Lena addresses the arrangement rather than attacking Kai. A helpful discussion could investigate a quieter time or location. Disagreement does not mean a contributor dislikes the group; the words provide evidence about a practical concern, not about a hidden personal motive.
Example 3 · Summarise agreement and uncertainty
Thread
Ari: “We should hold a story exchange.” Sol: “Agreed; each person can recommend a short story.” Nita: “I agree about the exchange, but we have not chosen its day.”
Question: What is a fair summary of the thread?
Answer: All three agree to a story exchange; the day for it remains undecided.
Why: The summary separates a shared decision from an open question. It would be inaccurate to say that the whole plan is settled or that the contributors disagree about holding an exchange. Reading several replies together helps identify exactly where the discussion has reached.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose the relevant reply
Question
Rina asks, “Is the art room available at 2 p.m. on Thursday?”
Room record
The booking list shows another class there until 2:30 p.m.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which reply best answers Rina’s question?
- a: The art room has colourful curtains.
- b: The school owns several new brushes.
- c: I enjoyed last Thursday’s activity.
- d: It is booked until half past two.
The booking directly answers availability at 2 p.m.; the other comments do not.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Messages do different jobs
Message A
We should move the display nearer the entrance.
Message B
Visitors yesterday said they could not find it.
Message C
Would the entrance still leave enough walking space?
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each message to its main role.
Complete or match: Move the display nearer the entrance.; Visitors said they could not find it.; Would walking space remain clear?
- a: A practical question
- b: A proposed action
- c: Reported evidence
The first proposes a change, the second supplies a reason from visitors and the third checks a condition.
Source explorer: claim board
F3 · A respectful response
Pao’s proposal
Pao wants a longer lunch reading session.
Mei’s concern
Mei worries that pupils will miss time to return books before class.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the reply that moves the discussion forward.
- a: Could we reserve the final five minutes for returning books?
- b: Mei must dislike everyone who enjoys reading.
- c: Pao’s favourite colour is blue, so the plan is wrong.
Reserving return time addresses the concern without making a personal attack.
Source explorer: perspective
F4 · What is decided?
Luz
Let us use picture labels.
Han
I agree. We still need to choose the label size.
Maya
I agree about pictures. I can bring a ruler to help compare sizes.
F4 · Matching
Match each point to the thread’s status.
Complete or match: Using picture labels; Choosing the label size; Bringing a ruler
- a: An unresolved decision
- b: A shared agreement
- c: Maya’s offered action
The group agrees on pictures, has not chosen a size and has one offered action.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · Close a thread accurately
Toni’s message
We need a reading mat.
Alma’s reply
Yes, but the cupboard may have one.
Vic’s next step
I can ask the teacher tomorrow before we buy anything.
F5 · Open ended
Write a short closing message that states the shared need and the next step without claiming a purchase is already agreed.
Example of a full-credit answer: We agree that we need a reading mat. Vic will ask the teacher tomorrow whether one is in the cupboard before the group decides about buying one.
- States the need for a reading mat without claiming a purchase has been agreed.
- Identifies Vic’s teacher/cupboard check as the next step before a buying decision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: network
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Mara — question · classroom example
Where should our story club meet if the library is being cleaned on Thursday?
Ben — reply to Mara
The adviser’s notice says Room 7 is available Thursday from 3 to 4 p.m. I copied those details from the notice.
Ira — reply to Ben
Thanks. Does the notice say whether the room has enough chairs for 20 pupils? I could not find that detail.
1A · Hotspot
Select the message region that identifies the thread’s remaining practical question.
- a: Where should the club meet?
- b: Room 7 is available Thursday, 3–4 p.m.
- c: Does Room 7 have enough chairs for 20 pupils?
Ben addresses the venue and time; Ira identifies the unanswered capacity question.
1B · Open ended
Summarise what is known and what still needs checking.
Example of a full-credit answer: Room 7 is listed as available Thursday from 3 to 4 p.m. The group still needs to check whether it has chairs for 20 pupils.
- States the supported venue/time information.
- States the unresolved chair-capacity issue.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Topic · classroom example
A discussion asks how to stop labels falling off outdoor seed pots. The labels get wet when the pots are watered.
Replies
Tess: “Try tying labels to the pots; mine stayed on during two watering sessions.” Noe: “You are all bad gardeners.” Pia: “What material were the labels made from?” Ren: “I like purple.”
2A · Multiple answers
Select all replies that help investigate the label problem.
- a: Tess’s description of a tested fastening
- b: Noe’s insult
- c: Pia’s question about label material
- d: Ren’s colour preference
Tess adds relevant limited experience, and Pia asks about a factor that may affect wet labels.
2B · Short answer
Why do these contributions help more than the insult or colour preference?
Example of a full-credit answer: They address how labels are attached and how their material handles water. The insult and colour preference do not explain why the labels fall off.
- Identifies relevant problem-solving information in the useful replies.
- Explains why the other comments do not address the cause or solution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier lesson · classroom example
A useful thread separates what is agreed from what still needs evidence, then asks a focused next question.
New thread
Members agree to hold a puzzle session on Friday after class. One says the hall is free; another says a choir uses it then. Neither gives a current booking source.
3A · Multiple choice
Which reply best moves the discussion forward?
- a: The louder person must be right
- b: Can the office confirm Friday’s hall booking? We agree on Friday but need a room
- c: Let us pretend the choir does not exist
- d: Friday must now mean Saturday
It preserves agreement while seeking a relevant source to resolve the disputed venue.
3B · Open ended
Write a focused reply for this new thread and explain what it would resolve.
Example of a full-credit answer: We agree on Friday after class. Could someone check the office booking list for the hall? That would resolve the conflicting room claims.
- Preserves the agreed day/time while identifying the dispute.
- Proposes checking a relevant booking source to resolve the room question.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Thread · classroom example
Ari supports a longer art-club meeting. Bea likes the idea if pupils can still catch their bus. Cal asks whether a bus-time check has been made. No decision has been announced.
Summary posted
“Everyone agreed to stay late, and the new schedule is final.”
4A · True or false
The summary accurately represents the discussion as a final agreement.
- true: True
- false: False
Bea adds a condition, Cal asks for missing information, and no decision is announced.
4B · Short answer
Correct the summary in one or two sentences.
Example of a full-credit answer: There is interest in a longer meeting, but bus times still need checking. No final schedule has been announced.
- Recognises the conditional/unresolved bus issue.
- Avoids claiming a final or unanimous decision.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Thread facts · classroom example
The garden team agrees to use reusable watering cans. Members disagree about where to store them. The shed is dry but locked after class; the porch is open but exposed to rain.
Closing goal
Write a closing post that records the agreement and proposes a fair next step for the storage question. Do not announce a storage decision the group has not made.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the planning notes for the closing post.
Complete or match: Agreement to record; Issue still open; Useful next step
- a: use reusable watering cans
- b: where to store them
- c: compare access and protection before choosing
- d: announce that everyone chose the porch
The closing should preserve agreement and make the unresolved trade-off visible.
5B · Open ended
Propose a closing post with a specific way to investigate the remaining issue.
Example of a full-credit answer: We agree to use reusable cans. Before choosing storage, ask when the shed can be opened and whether a covered porch box is possible; then compare access and protection together.
- Accurately records agreement without inventing a storage decision.
- Proposes a relevant check addressing both access and weather protection.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.12 · Government documents
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read a fictional public guide’s audience
Practice public-office guide
Greenfield Park Office: School groups may request the small picnic space on weekdays. Requests must name an adult group leader. This classroom document describes only the small picnic space.
Question: Does the guide promise the same arrangement for every park area?
Answer: No. It describes school-group requests for the small picnic space on weekdays.
Why: Public documents have a scope: who, where and when. The office name does not make every sentence a rule for every service the office runs. Keeping the named group, space and days in the answer helps explain the guide accurately without inventing a wider rule.
Example 2 · A request is not an approval
Fictional application guide
Send the activity request form to the centre office. Staff will check room availability. Wait for a confirmation message before telling participants that the room is booked.
Question: Is sending the form enough to claim the room is booked?
Answer: No. The applicant must wait for the office’s confirmation after availability is checked.
Why: The document describes several stages. Submission begins a request; confirmation establishes the booking in this example. Skipping that distinction could lead a group to announce an arrangement that has not been accepted. Read what happens after the form is sent, not only the first action.
Example 3 · Keep a temporary rule within its dates
Practice office notice
The children’s information desk opens at 10 a.m., instead of 9 a.m., from 12 to 14 March while shelves are moved. Other desks keep their usual hours.
Question: What change should a reader report?
Answer: Only the children’s information desk opens an hour later during 12–14 March.
Why: The notice gives a specific desk and a short period. It does not announce a permanent opening time or a change to every service. Dates and exceptions are part of the meaning; leaving them out would make a small temporary change sound much larger.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the issuing office
Practice document
Riverbend Community Office — Room-use guide. Issued: 1 July. Registered school clubs may request a weekday meeting room. The office confirms requests after checking availability.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the part that identifies who issued the guide.
- a: Riverbend Community Office
- b: Issued: 1 July
- c: Weekday meeting room requests
The office name identifies the issuer; the other details identify date and purpose.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Read the application stages
Stage 1
Complete the request form.
Stage 2
Staff check whether the requested space is available.
Stage 3
The office sends approval or asks for another date.
F2 · Drag and drop
Place each stage in the correct order.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Staff check the space.
- b: The office replies about approval.
- c: Complete the request form.
Submitting starts the process; the check comes before the reply.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F3 · Who and when does the rule cover?
Practice guide
This free map-printing session is for registered school groups visiting on Tuesdays. Each group may collect one map. Other visits should ask the office for their own arrangements.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two statements are supported by the guide?
- a: The described session is for registered school groups.
- b: A participating group may collect one map.
- c: Every visitor may collect unlimited maps every day.
- d: The guide forbids every other kind of visit.
The guide names the group and map limit. It asks other visitors to check, rather than banning them.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Read a temporary notice
Craft-room notice
From 6 to 8 May, the craft room opens at 11 a.m. rather than 9 a.m.
Games-room notice
The games room keeps its usual 9 a.m. opening.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the arrangements for 7 May.
Complete or match: The craft room opens at ___.; The games room opens at ___.
- a: 9 a.m.
- b: 11 a.m.
- c: 1 p.m.
The temporary change applies only to the craft room; the games room remains unchanged.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Explain a guide simply
Fictional centre guide
A school club can request a display table by submitting a form. Staff review table availability and send a confirmation. A submitted form alone is not a confirmed reservation.
F5 · Short answer
Explain the two stages a club should understand before announcing that a table is reserved.
Example of a full-credit answer: The club first submits a request form. It should announce a reserved table only after staff check availability and send confirmation.
- Identifies submitting a request form as the initial action.
- Explains that staff confirmation after checking availability is required before claiming a reservation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: source tabs
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Document header · classroom example
San Isla Parks Office — Classroom Example Guide. Updated 3 March. Purpose: requests to use the covered picnic area for organised group activities.
Rules
Registered school groups may request a two-hour slot. Send the group name, requested date and adult contact to the office. A request is not a booking until the office sends confirmation.
Scope
Ordinary walking paths remain open to visitors without a group booking. The guide applies to the covered picnic area, not every park facility.
1A · Matching
Match each guide detail to the question it answers.
Complete or match: Registered school groups; Office confirmation; Covered picnic area
- a: Which facility does this guide cover?
- b: Who may request a slot?
- c: What makes the booking confirmed?
Eligibility, confirmation and scope answer different practical questions.
1B · Short answer
Explain why a class should not announce a confirmed booking immediately after sending a request.
Example of a full-credit answer: The guide says a request becomes a booking only when the office confirms it; sending the details starts the process but does not finish it.
- Identifies the separate confirmation requirement.
- Distinguishes requesting from receiving approval.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Document A · classroom example
Public Health Office: weekly water-testing results for three public fountains. Includes sample dates and whether each test met the stated standard.
Document B
Parks Office: map of flower beds and names of plants.
Document C
Library Office: holiday opening hours. A reader wants the latest stated test result for Fountain 2.
2A · Multiple choice
Which document directly fits the reader’s question?
- a: Document A
- b: Document B
- c: Document C
- d: Whichever has the brightest cover
The testing report contains fountain-specific results and sample dates.
2B · Open ended
Why is this choice relevant, and what date should the reader inspect?
Example of a full-credit answer: The water-testing report directly concerns Fountain 2. The reader should inspect the sample or reporting date to identify the latest result rather than assuming an old test is current.
- Connects the document content to Fountain 2’s test result.
- Explains why the sample/report date matters.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional library programme guide · classroom example
The storytelling room may be requested by groups with an adult organiser. A group may request one morning or afternoon slot. The office confirms the room after checking availability.
Two requests
Group A has an adult organiser and requests Tuesday morning. Group B has no adult organiser and asks to reserve every morning automatically.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported by the guide.
- a: Group A meets the stated adult-organiser and single-slot conditions
- b: Group A is already guaranteed a room
- c: Group B needs an adult organiser to meet the stated requirement
- d: Group B may automatically reserve all mornings
Meeting application conditions does not guarantee availability; Group B does not meet the adult-organiser condition.
3B · Short answer
What can Group A reasonably do next, and what must it still wait for?
Example of a full-credit answer: It can submit its Tuesday-morning request with the adult organiser’s details, then wait for the office’s availability confirmation.
- States a next step consistent with meeting the request conditions.
- Recognises that availability/approval remains unconfirmed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Office notice · classroom example
Community reading room: during the three-day repair period, 10–12 May, opening hours are 1–5 p.m. The usual 9 a.m. opening resumes on 13 May.
Reader’s claim
“The reading room will never open in the morning again.”
4A · True or false
The reader’s permanent conclusion follows from the notice.
- true: True
- false: False
The notice explicitly limits the changed hours to three days and gives a return date.
4B · Open ended
Correct the claim with both the temporary arrangement and its limit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The room opens at 1 p.m. during 10–12 May only. Its usual 9 a.m. opening returns on 13 May.
- States the temporary hours and dates.
- Includes the stated return to usual morning opening.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Fictional sports-office rules · classroom example
A school group requests a court by naming a date, time and adult organiser. The office checks availability. Use is confirmed only in the office’s reply. No payment is requested in this example.
Reader need
A pupil wants to help the teacher understand the three stages without mistakenly promising the court to classmates.
5A · Drag and drop
Place the stages in the order the rules require.
Complete or match: First; Second; Third
- a: Wait while the office checks availability
- b: Read the office reply to learn whether use is confirmed
- c: Send date, time and adult organiser
The guide describes a request, a check and a separate reply.
5B · Short answer
Propose a short checklist for the teacher that includes one useful caution.
Example of a full-credit answer: List the requested date, time and adult organiser; send the request; read the reply. Do not announce a confirmed court booking until the office confirms it.
- Includes the required request details or stages.
- Includes a caution distinguishing request from confirmation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.13 · Tables
Three worked examples
Example 1 · A cell needs two labels
| Item | Borrowed Monday (books) | Borrowed Tuesday (books) |
|---|---|---|
| Atlas | 3 | 5 |
| Dictionary | 4 | 2 |
| Story collection | 6 | 7 |
Class borrowing table
Columns: Item | Borrowed on Monday | Borrowed on Tuesday. Rows: Atlas |3|5; Dictionary |4|2; Story collection |6|7. All values count books.
Question: How many dictionaries were borrowed on Tuesday?
Answer: Two dictionaries were borrowed on Tuesday.
Why: Read across the Dictionary row to the Tuesday column. The nearby four belongs to Monday, while five belongs to atlases. A cell does not carry its meaning alone: the row, column and unit together tell us what the number describes.
Example 2 · Meet both conditions
| Session | Start | Places left |
|---|---|---|
| Drawing | 9 a.m. | 0 |
| Paper folding | 10 a.m. | 4 |
| Storytelling | 11 a.m. | 3 |
Workshop table
Columns: Session |Start |Places left. Rows: Drawing |9 a.m.|0; Paper folding |10 a.m.|4; Storytelling |11 a.m.|3. A pupil can arrive no earlier than 10 a.m. and needs an available place.
Question: Which sessions satisfy both conditions?
Answer: Paper folding and storytelling both start at or after 10 a.m. and have places left.
Why: Checking only time or only places can give an incomplete answer. Drawing fails both conditions here. A table question may have several suitable rows, so we should not invent a single best choice when the stated requirements allow two.
Example 3 · A dash needs its note
| Pot | Plant height (cm) |
|---|---|
| A | 12 |
| B | — |
| C | 9 |
Practice record
The table lists plant heights: Pot A—12 cm; Pot B—dash; Pot C—9 cm. Note: A dash means the plant was not measured that day.
Question: Does the dash show that Pot B’s plant was 0 cm tall?
Answer: No. Its height is unknown from this record because it was not measured.
Why: A missing measurement must not be turned into a zero. Zero is a particular measured value; the note explains that no measurement was recorded. The reader can compare A and C but should leave B out of a numerical ranking until its height is known.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the correct row and column
Equipment table
Columns: Item |Available |Borrowed. Rows: Brushes |8|4; Rulers |5|2; Scissors |6|3. Values count items.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the table fact that answers: How many rulers are borrowed?
- a: Brushes: 4 borrowed
- b: Rulers: 2 borrowed
- c: Scissors: 3 borrowed
The Rulers row and Borrowed column meet at 2.
Source explorer: table lab
F2 · Use the table headings
Reading timetable
Columns: Group |Day |Room. Rows: Amber |Monday|2; Coral |Tuesday|5; Jade |Wednesday|3.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the group arrangements.
Complete or match: Coral Group meets in Room ___.; Jade Group meets on ___.
- a: 5
- b: Wednesday
- c: Monday
Coral’s row gives Room 5; Jade’s row gives Wednesday.
Source explorer: search lab
F3 · Select rows meeting two rules
Workshop options
A pupil needs a session starting at 10 a.m. or later with at least two places left. Rows: Weaving—10 a.m., 3 places; Painting—9 a.m., 5 places; Story craft—11 a.m., 2 places; Mask making—noon, 1 place.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two workshops meet both rules?
- a: Mask making
- b: Weaving
- c: Painting
- d: Story craft
Weaving and story craft meet both time and capacity rules. Painting is too early and mask making has only one place.
Source explorer: table lab
F4 · Read special table symbols
Table key
0 means measured and none found. A dash means not measured. N/A means the field does not apply.
F4 · Matching
Match each table entry to its meaning.
Complete or match: 0; Dash; N/A
- a: The field does not apply.
- b: Measured and none found.
- c: Not measured.
The table key distinguishes zero, missing measurement and a field that does not apply.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · Explain a table choice
Task
A group needs at least six seats and can use a room only after 1 p.m.
Room table
Room A: 8 seats, available noon–1 p.m. Room B: 6 seats, available 2–3 p.m. Room C: 4 seats, available 2–3 p.m.
F5 · Open ended
Choose a suitable room and explain how both requirements are met.
Example of a full-credit answer: Room B fits. It has six seats, meeting the group’s minimum, and its 2–3 p.m. time is after 1 p.m.
- Selects Room B using its capacity of at least six seats.
- Explains that Room B’s 2–3 p.m. availability meets the after 1 p.m. requirement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Workshop table · classroom example
Slot A: Tuesday, 10 a.m., 12 seats, paper craft. Slot B: Tuesday, 1 p.m., 18 seats, drawing. Slot C: Wednesday, 10 a.m., 16 seats, paper craft.
Reader needs
A class of 15 wants paper craft and can attend Wednesday morning. Seats are maximum group sizes; the listed slots are available.
1A · Drag and drop
Match the table entries to their correct interpretation.
Complete or match: Slot A; Slot B; Slot C
- a: Enough seats but a different activity and day
- b: Meets the stated day, activity and seat needs
- c: Paper craft but too few seats and the wrong day
Only C meets all three requirements; each other row fails at least one.
1B · Open ended
Explain how you used more than one column to find a suitable slot.
Example of a full-credit answer: I checked Wednesday morning, paper craft and at least 15 seats. Slot C has all three, with 16 seats.
- Uses the day/time and activity conditions.
- Uses the capacity condition to justify C.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Library returns table · classroom example
Monday: 14 books. Tuesday: —. Wednesday: 11 books. Note: — means the count was not recorded. These are returned books, not books borrowed.
Proposed conclusion
A pupil says Tuesday had the fewest returns because the dash means zero.
2A · True or false
The table justifies saying that Tuesday had zero returned books.
- true: True
- false: False
The note explicitly defines the dash as missing information.
2B · Short answer
Why can Tuesday not be ranked as the lowest day from this table?
Example of a full-credit answer: Its count is missing rather than zero, so we cannot compare its number of returns with 14 or 11.
- Correctly interprets the dash as not recorded.
- Explains that missing data prevents the proposed ranking.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Garden delivery table · classroom example
Tray X: 8 seedlings, arrives Monday, needs shade. Tray Y: 12 seedlings, arrives Tuesday, needs sun. Tray Z: 10 seedlings, arrives Monday, needs sun.
New need
A volunteer can collect on Monday and has space for 10 sun-loving seedlings. Tray quantities cannot be split.
3A · Multiple choice
Which tray meets the stated conditions?
- a: Tray X
- b: Tray Y
- c: Tray Z
- d: All three
Tray Z arrives Monday and contains exactly 10 seedlings needing sun.
3B · Open ended
Explain why looking only at the quantity would be insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: The volunteer must also check arrival day and light needs. Tray Z fits 10 seedlings, Monday collection and sun; quantity alone would not show the other conditions.
- Identifies timing and/or light as necessary additional columns.
- Connects all relevant conditions to Tray Z.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Club timetable · classroom example
Chess: Room 2, starts 3:00. Art: Room 5, starts 3:30. Drama: Hall, starts 4:00. All are on Thursday.
Copied note
A pupil writes “Art — Room 2 — 3:00” by copying values from the row above the Art label.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all corrections needed for the Art entry.
- a: Use Room 5
- b: Use 3:30
- c: Change Thursday to Monday
- d: Change Art to Drama
Art’s row gives Room 5 and 3:30; the day and club remain unchanged.
4B · Short answer
Explain the copying error and a method that would prevent it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The pupil took the Chess row’s values. Trace across from Art and check each heading, or highlight the whole Art row before copying.
- Identifies values coming from the wrong row.
- Proposes a row-and-heading checking method.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Information to organise · classroom example
The class lends sports equipment. Each record needs the item name, number available and place to return it. One item count has not been checked yet.
Sample records
Balls: 6, sports cupboard. Hoops: 4, hall rack. Cones: count not checked, sports cupboard. A reader must not mistake “not checked” for zero.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose headings or notes that make the table clear.
Complete or match: Column for 6 and 4; Column for cupboard or rack; Note for the unchecked count
- a: Number available
- b: Return place
- c: — means not checked
- d: — always means none
Clear labels and the missing-value note preserve what is known.
5B · Open ended
Propose the table’s headings and explain how you would show the cones’ unknown count.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use Item, Number available and Return place. Put a dash for cones and add “— means not checked,” so it is not read as zero.
- Proposes headings covering item, count and return place.
- Distinguishes the missing count from zero with an explicit label or note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.14 · Graphs
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read labels before bar height
Classroom bar-graph data
Title: Bookmarks made by each group. Horizontal labels: Sun, Moon, Star. Vertical unit: Number of bookmarks. Values: Sun 6, Moon 9, Star 4. The bar scale starts at zero.
Question: Which group made the most bookmarks?
Answer: Moon Group made the most, with nine bookmarks.
Why: The tallest bar represents the largest value only after we read what its height counts. Here it counts bookmarks, not pupils or hours. The answer should include the category and value. A graph’s title and unit prevent a correct-looking comparison from being attached to the wrong quantity.
Example 2 · A difference is not the larger value
Graph record
The class graph shows 7 books returned on Monday and 11 on Tuesday. The scale counts books and starts at zero.
Question: How many more books were returned on Tuesday?
Answer: Four more books were returned on Tuesday.
Why: The question asks for a difference, so subtract Monday’s 7 from Tuesday’s 11. Eleven is Tuesday’s total, not the increase. Reading the comparison word more is as important as reading the bars. The graph does not explain why the count changed; it only provides the recorded counts.
Example 3 · Keep a graph’s scope
Graph note
A bar graph shows favourite fruits chosen by 24 pupils in one class on 6 August: Mango 10, Banana 8, Papaya 6. Each pupil chose one fruit. Mango has the highest count. No other class was surveyed.
Question: Can the graph show that mango is every child’s favourite fruit?
Answer: No. It shows only that mango received the most choices among those 24 pupils in that survey.
Why: The source note identifies the people and occasion represented. A graph can accurately describe a small group without describing everyone. Keeping the group in a summary helps avoid turning a classroom result into an unsupported statement about all children.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the unit
Graph data
Title: Library visits this week. Labels: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday. Values: 8, 12, 10. Unit: visits. A pupil can make more than one visit.
F1 · True or false
The graph alone proves that 12 different pupils visited on Tuesday.
- true: True
- false: False
The graph counts visits, and a pupil may visit more than once. It does not identify 12 different people.
Source explorer: chart lab
F2 · Read a difference
Graph data
Bookmarks completed: Red Group 5; Blue Group 9; Gold Group 7. The graph counts bookmarks, not learners.
F2 · Multiple choice
How many more bookmarks did Blue make than Red?
- a: Four more bookmarks
- b: Five more bookmarks
- c: Seven more bookmarks
- d: Nine more bookmarks
Blue made 9 and Red made 5, so the difference is 4.
Source explorer: table lab
F3 · Use the plotted categories
Graph data
Cards collected on three days: Monday 4, Tuesday 6, Wednesday 3. Each bar represents the total for its labelled day.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the two readings.
Complete or match: The highest bar belongs to ___.; Wednesday’s bar represents ___ cards.
- a: Tuesday
- b: 3
- c: Monday
Tuesday’s 6 is the highest; Wednesday’s value is 3.
Source explorer: chart lab
F4 · Graph features have purposes
Graph description
A graph has the title “Weekly borrowed books”, day labels along the bottom and a vertical scale labelled “Number of books”.
F4 · Matching
Match each feature to the question it answers.
Complete or match: Title; Day labels; Number-of-books scale
- a: Which day does a bar describe?
- b: What is the overall graph about?
- c: What quantity does height measure?
The title gives the topic, labels identify categories and the scale defines the measured quantity.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Summarise a graph carefully
Class graph
One class counted reusable bottles brought on three days: Monday 10, Tuesday 12, Wednesday 8. These counts cover only this class and these days.
F5 · Short answer
State the highest recorded count and explain one limit on what the graph tells us.
Example of a full-credit answer: Tuesday had the highest count, with 12 bottles. The graph covers one class on three days, so it does not establish bottle use in every class or on every day.
- Identifies Tuesday’s 12 bottles as the highest recorded count.
- States a relevant limit concerning the one class, three days or lack of evidence about other days/groups.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Graph data · classroom example
In one class survey, pupils chose one fruit: banana 9 votes, mango 12 votes, papaya 6 votes, pineapple 3 votes. The graph’s unit is votes.
Survey scope
Thirty pupils answered once each. These data describe their choices for a classroom snack, not the number of fruits in the school garden.
1A · Multiple choice
Which statement correctly reads the graph?
- a: Mango received the most votes in this class survey
- b: There are twelve mango trees at school
- c: Every pupil in the country prefers mango
- d: Papaya received twelve votes
Mango has 12 votes, the highest count, within the stated class sample.
1B · Short answer
State the strongest supported conclusion and one limit on it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Mango was the most selected fruit among these 30 pupils for this snack. The graph does not show what all children prefer.
- States the correct highest category and measured meaning.
- Keeps the conclusion within the stated class/survey scope.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Walk-count record · classroom example
A class counted walkers entering the east gate on three mornings: Monday 20, Tuesday 28, Wednesday 24. Each count covered the same 7:00–7:15 period.
Reading goal
Explain the highest day and what “24” means without treating a short count as an all-day total.
2A · Drag and drop
Match the graph-reading statement to its correct explanation.
Complete or match: Tuesday is highest; Wednesday shows 24; Counts are comparable in time
- a: Twenty-four walkers were counted in the stated period
- b: All observations covered the same fifteen minutes
- c: Twenty-eight is larger than twenty and twenty-four
The numerical comparison and the time limit both matter.
2B · Open ended
Why is “Wednesday had 24 walkers all day” not justified?
Example of a full-credit answer: The record covers only 7:00–7:15. Twenty-four is the count in that interval, so later arrivals are not represented.
- Identifies the limited observation interval.
- Explains why the count cannot be treated as a full-day total.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Plant-height chart · classroom example
Seedling height at the end of each week: Week 1, 4 cm; Week 2, 7 cm; Week 3, 9 cm. These are measurements of one seedling’s height, not weekly amounts of growth.
Question
A reader wants the total measured height at the end of Week 2.
3A · Hotspot
Select the plotted observation that answers the reader’s question.
- a: Week 1 — 4 cm total height
- b: Week 2 — 7 cm total height
- c: Week 3 — 9 cm total height
The Week 2 observation is the seedling’s total height at that time.
3B · Short answer
Explain why 7 cm should not be described as the growth during Week 2.
Example of a full-credit answer: Seven centimetres is the total height then. Growth during Week 2 compares 7 cm with the earlier 4 cm, rather than treating the total as a change.
- Distinguishes total height from change.
- Uses the earlier observation as necessary comparison evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Borrowing graph values · classroom example
Books borrowed: Monday 40, Tuesday 42, Wednesday 41. A drawing uses a vertical scale beginning at 39, making Tuesday’s bar look much taller than Monday’s.
Summary draft
“Tuesday’s borrowing was several times Monday’s.” The exact values are printed beside the bars.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all statements that help correct the summary.
- a: Tuesday is 42 books compared with Monday’s 40
- b: The scale begins at 39, so apparent bar lengths need care
- c: Tuesday has more than three times Monday’s books
- d: Printed values can be ignored when bars look different
The values show a small difference; the truncated scale explains the dramatic visual impression.
4B · Open ended
Write a corrected comparison and explain the misleading impression.
Example of a full-credit answer: Tuesday had two more borrowed books than Monday, 42 versus 40. Starting the scale at 39 makes that small difference appear much larger.
- States an accurate comparison using the values.
- Explains the effect of the nonzero scale start.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Survey data · classroom example
One class chose a club activity: drawing 8 votes, music 5, gardening 7. Each pupil chose once. The class wants a graph for its noticeboard.
Design needs
Readers should identify categories, exact vote counts and the surveyed group. The graph should not pretend to describe other classes.
5A · True or false
A bar graph with activity labels, vote counts and a title naming the class survey would fit these data.
- true: True
- false: False
The data compare categories, and the labels keep the meaning and scope clear.
5B · Short answer
Propose a title and two labeling choices for the graph, explaining one benefit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Title: “Our Class’s Club-Activity Votes.” Label the categories Drawing, Music and Gardening, and the value scale “Votes,” with 8, 5 and 7 shown. This prevents counts being confused with attendance.
- Proposes a title that identifies the survey scope.
- Proposes appropriate category/unit/value labels and a relevant clarity benefit.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.15 · Maps
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Use the direction arrow
Practice map description
North is at the top. The school garden is above the hall. The office is to the right of the hall. The main gate is below the hall.
Question: Which place is north of the hall?
Answer: The garden is north of the hall.
Why: The north arrow establishes how directions relate to the page. Above the hall therefore means north in this map. The office is east and the gate is south. Without checking the direction arrow, a reader might assume that the page is oriented in a way the map never intended.
Example 2 · Follow a connected route
Practice route map
The marked path goes from Gate to Courtyard and from Courtyard to Art Room. A hedge separates Gate from Art Room, so there is no direct path between them.
Question: What marked route leads from Gate to Art Room?
Answer: Go from Gate to Courtyard, then from Courtyard to Art Room.
Why: A route must follow the map’s stated connections. A straight line drawn between the start and destination would cross the hedge, so visual closeness alone is not enough. Naming the intermediate courtyard shows that the reader has followed the actual path rather than guessed a shortcut.
Example 3 · Know what an unscaled map can tell you
Map note
This simple map shows the canteen beside the court and the library beyond the court. It has a north arrow and labelled paths, but no distance scale.
Question: Can the map establish that the canteen is exactly 20 metres from the library?
Answer: No. It can show their positions and routes, but not an exact distance without a scale or a stated measurement.
Why: A map can be useful even when it is not a measured plan. The important limit is to avoid turning picture spacing into a real-world measurement. To answer an exact-distance question, a reader needs an appropriate scale or another reliable distance record.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Directions on a school map
Map key
North is up. The garden is north of the hall; the gate is south; the office is east. The diagram has no distance scale.
F1 · Multiple answers
Which two statements follow the map key?
- a: The gate is north of the garden.
- b: The office is exactly 100 metres away.
- c: The garden is north of the hall.
- d: The office is east of the hall.
The stated directions support the garden being north and the office being east; no exact distance is given.
Source explorer: map lab
F2 · An unmarked shortcut
Route note
The map marks a path from Entrance to Shelter and from Shelter to Garden. A planted bed lies between Entrance and Garden. No direct path is marked there.
F2 · True or false
The note shows a direct marked path from Entrance to Garden.
- true: True
- false: False
Only the route through the Shelter is marked; a straight line would cross the planted bed.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Find the destination
Map note
The entrance is on the west side. The pond is in the middle. The reading hut is east of the pond. Follow Entrance → Pond → Reading hut.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the reading hut, the destination east of the pond.
- a: Entrance
- b: Pond
- c: Reading hut
The reading hut is the final labelled place and lies east of the pond.
Source explorer: map lab
F4 · Read a map legend
Legend
A star marks the information point. A dotted line marks a walking path. A shaded rectangle marks a building.
F4 · Matching
Match each described symbol to the legend.
Complete or match: Star; Dotted line; Shaded rectangle
- a: Building
- b: Information point
- c: Walking path
The legend defines each symbol; the reader should not substitute a guessed meaning.
Source explorer: word lab
F5 · Explain a usable route
Open paths
The path from Gate to Fountain is open. The path from Fountain to Library is open.
Closure note
The direct Gate-to-Library path is closed today. No distances are supplied.
F5 · Open ended
Describe an allowed route from Gate to Library and explain why you would not use the direct path.
Example of a full-credit answer: Go from Gate to Fountain, then from Fountain to Library. The direct Gate-to-Library path is closed today, so it is not an allowed route.
- Describes the connected Gate → Fountain → Library route.
- Explains that the direct path is closed rather than assuming it can be used because it looks shorter.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Map description · classroom example
North is at the top. The library is northwest, the hall northeast, the garden southwest and the main gate southeast. Paths connect the gate to the hall, hall to library, and library to garden.
Legend
The labels identify the library, hall, garden and gate. North is at the top. This is a simple diagram with no distance scale.
1A · Dropdown selection
Complete these map readings.
Complete or match: The place northwest of the gate is…; The first connected stop from gate toward library is…; Exact route distance is…
- a: the library
- b: the hall
- c: not given by this diagram
- d: always 100 metres
Location, connectivity and the absence of scale answer different map questions.
1B · Open ended
Describe the route from the main gate to the library and explain why you cannot give its exact distance.
Example of a full-credit answer: Follow the gate-to-hall path, then the hall-to-library path. The diagram has no distance scale, so the exact distance is unknown.
- Describes the connected route through the hall.
- Uses the missing scale to limit distance claims.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Park routes · classroom example
The entrance connects to the fountain and the covered court. The fountain connects to the reading tent. A second open path connects the covered court to the reading tent.
Update
The fountain-to-tent path is closed today for repairs. The entrance-to-court and court-to-tent paths are open. The tent remains open.
2A · True or false
A visitor can still reach the reading tent using the covered-court route.
- true: True
- false: False
The update explicitly leaves both links in the entrance–court–tent route open.
2B · Short answer
Justify the route using the two open path segments.
Example of a full-credit answer: Walk from the entrance to the covered court, then from the court to the reading tent. Both segments are stated as open, unlike the fountain-to-tent link.
- Identifies both connected open segments.
- Uses the closure information to explain the alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Museum floor diagram · classroom example
Legend: star = help desk; open book = reading area; cup = café. The help desk is near the entrance, the reading area is upstairs, and the café is beside the courtyard.
Visitor needs
One visitor needs directions, another wants a quiet place to read, and a third wants a drink. This fictional diagram shows purposes, not walking distances.
3A · Matching
Match each visitor to the map symbol that fits the need.
Complete or match: Needs directions; Wants a reading place; Wants a drink
- a: Cup
- b: Star
- c: Open book
The legend assigns each symbol a meaning tied to the visitor’s goal.
3B · Open ended
Explain how you would use a new building’s unfamiliar symbols without assuming they mean the same as another map.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read that building’s legend first, then connect the named place to the visitor’s need. Symbols can have different meanings on another map.
- Uses the current map’s legend to identify meaning.
- Explains why meanings should not be assumed from another map.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Map note · classroom example
The main gate is south of the hall. A fenced flower bed lies between them. The marked path goes east around the bed and then north to the hall. No path crosses the bed.
Visitor plan
“I will walk straight north through the bed because the hall looks close.” The map has no scale.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all corrections supported by the map note.
- a: Use the marked route around the bed
- b: Avoid claiming an exact distance from an unscaled map
- c: Walk through the fence because north is correct
- d: Assume every drawing centimetre means ten metres
A direction alone does not remove barriers, and no scale means no exact distance conversion.
4B · Short answer
Explain why knowing that the hall is north is not enough to choose the route.
Example of a full-credit answer: The fenced bed blocks a straight route. The usable path goes east around it and then north, so route connectivity matters as well as direction.
- Identifies the barrier as limiting the straight route.
- Describes the stated connected alternative.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Event layout · classroom example
Visitors enter at the south gate. The exhibit hall is north of the garden. A paved path goes from the gate along the garden’s east edge to the hall. The garden itself is not a walking route.
Design brief
Make a simple visitor map that clearly shows a start, destination and allowed route. Exact distances have not been measured.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each planned label to its role.
Complete or match: South gate; Exhibit hall; Paved path along the garden’s east edge
- a: Destination
- b: Allowed route
- c: Starting point
These three labels form the essential journey information.
5B · Open ended
Propose two map features that would prevent a visitor from walking through the garden.
Example of a full-credit answer: Show the paved route with connected arrows from gate to hall, and mark the garden as a non-walking area with a clear legend. Label it a diagram because distances are not measured.
- Makes the allowed gate-to-hall route visible.
- Clearly identifies the garden as a barrier/non-route or supplies an equivalent usable warning.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.16 · Diagrams
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read what an arrow means
Diagram key
Diagram: Question card → Teacher’s check → Answer posted. Key: An arrow means the next stage in handling a classroom question.
Question: What follows the teacher’s check?
Answer: The answer is posted after the teacher’s check.
Why: The arrow key says the diagram shows an order of stages. Following the arrow from the teacher’s check leads to the posted answer. It does not tell us how far apart the places are or exactly how long checking takes. Reading the key keeps the explanation tied to the diagram’s intended meaning.
Example 2 · A branch depends on a condition
Sorting diagram
Start with a returned puzzle. Check whether all pieces are present. If yes, put it in the ready box. If no, put it in the check box for the teacher.
Question: Where should a puzzle with a missing piece go?
Answer: It should go in the check box for the teacher.
Why: The diagram has two possible routes, and the completeness check selects the route. A missing piece makes the answer to “all present?” no. Following the first visible branch without testing the condition could send an incomplete puzzle to the ready box and mislead the next user.
Example 3 · A simple drawing is not a measurement
Diagram note
A diagram uses three equal-sized boxes for collecting, sorting and storing paper. The boxes show stages, not the sizes of the rooms or the time needed for each task.
Question: Do the equal boxes show that all three stages take the same time?
Answer: No. The note says the boxes represent stages and do not measure time.
Why: Design choices can make a process easier to read without representing physical quantities. Equal shapes do not become evidence of equal duration simply because they look alike. A timing claim would need measured times or a label explicitly giving those values.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Follow the arrows
Process diagram
A classroom request follows Collect card → Read request → Give reply. Arrows mean the next stage; they do not measure distance or time.
F1 · Multiple choice
What happens immediately after reading the request?
- a: Measure the room width
- b: Give the reply
- c: Collect a new card
- d: Repeat the first stage
The arrow leaving Read request leads to Give reply.
Source explorer: map lab
F2 · Use a branch condition
Diagram rule
Check whether a returned marker has a cap. If it has a cap, place it in the ready tray. If its cap is missing, place it in the teacher’s check tray.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the two routes.
Complete or match: A marker with its cap goes to the ___.; A marker without its cap goes to the ___.
- a: ready tray
- b: teacher’s check tray
- c: recycling poster
The presence of the cap determines the route in this diagram.
Source explorer: word lab
F3 · Labels explain diagram parts
Diagram key
A rectangle names an action. A diamond asks a yes-or-no question. An arrow links one stage to the next.
F3 · Matching
Match the diagram feature to its role.
Complete or match: Rectangle; Diamond; Arrow
- a: Shows the next-stage connection
- b: Names an action
- c: Asks a yes-or-no question
The key defines the symbols; their meaning should be read rather than assumed.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Keep the model’s limits
Diagram note
The seed-packet diagram shows Label envelope → Add seeds → Close flap. All boxes are the same size for neatness. The note says stage times and material amounts are not shown.
F4 · Multiple answers
Which two statements are supported?
- a: The flap is closed after seeds are added.
- b: All three stages last exactly one minute.
- c: Each box represents the same material amount.
- d: Labelling comes before seeds are added.
The arrows establish order. The note explicitly says timing and quantities are not shown.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Explain a branch to a reader
Diagram
Check a returned book. If a page is torn, give the book to the teacher. If no page is torn, put it on the return shelf.
Book condition
The reader finds a torn page in the returned book.
F5 · Short answer
State the correct next action and explain which branch makes it correct.
Example of a full-credit answer: Give the book to the teacher. The observed torn page meets the diagram’s if-a-page-is-torn condition, so the return-shelf branch does not apply.
- States that the book should go to the teacher.
- Connects that action to the torn-page condition in the diagram.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Process diagram · classroom example
A classroom recycling model has three boxes: Collection box → Sorting table → Material centre. Arrows mean the next stage for collected bottles. Bottles are checked at the sorting table before transport.
Model note
The boxes are equal in size for readability. They do not show building sizes, travel distances or time spent at each stage.
1A · Hotspot
Select the diagram part where bottles are checked before transport.
- a: Collection box
- b: Sorting table
- c: Material centre
The source places the checking action at the sorting table.
1B · Short answer
Explain the role of the sorting table in the diagram’s sequence.
Example of a full-credit answer: It comes after collection and before the material centre. Bottles are checked there before being transported onward.
- Places sorting correctly between the other stages.
- States its checking function before transport.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Soil is dry · classroom example
Check the soil. If it is dry, follow the next-step arrow to add the stated small amount of water. The diagram’s arrows show decisions and actions, not water physically flowing between boxes.
Soil is not dry
Check the soil. If it is not dry, follow the next-step arrow to wait and check later. This branch does not call for immediate watering. Both branches begin with checking the soil condition.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported by the diagram.
- a: Dry soil leads to the watering step
- b: Soil that is not dry leads to waiting
- c: Every arrow represents flowing water
- d: Checking always requires immediate watering
The branch changes the action according to the soil condition.
2B · Open ended
Why does the decision box matter for following this guide?
Example of a full-credit answer: It makes watering depend on whether the soil is dry. Without reading it, someone could water even when the guide says to wait.
- Explains the condition controlling the branch.
- Identifies the incorrect unconditional watering that the branch prevents.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier diagram skill · classroom example
A process diagram can show actions in order. Read the arrow key and do not skip a required stage just because the final goal is clear.
New borrowing diagram
Choose a game → Check all pieces with the librarian → Record the loan → Take the game. Arrows mean “complete this stage before the next.”
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the interpretation of the borrowing diagram.
Complete or match: Before recording the loan, the learner must…; The arrow key means…; The final action is…
- a: check all pieces with the librarian
- b: finish each stage before the next
- c: take the game
- d: take the game before checking it
The arrows express a required order ending in taking the checked and recorded game.
3B · Short answer
Explain why “choose a game, then take it” is an incomplete reading.
Example of a full-credit answer: It skips checking the pieces and recording the loan, both required stages between choosing and taking the game.
- Identifies the skipped checking stage.
- Identifies the skipped recording stage or explains that arrows require both before taking.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Garden process diagram · classroom example
Prepare soil → Plant seeds → Wait for growth. The three boxes are drawn with equal widths. A note says: “Diagram shows order only; times vary.”
Reader’s claim
“Preparing, planting and growing must each take exactly one day because the boxes match.”
4A · True or false
Equal box widths establish equal time spent on the three stages.
- true: True
- false: False
The note says the diagram shows order only and gives no measured durations.
4B · Open ended
What does the diagram establish, and what information would be needed to compare durations?
Example of a full-credit answer: It establishes the stage order. To compare duration, we would need measured or stated time for each stage, not the boxes’ widths.
- Identifies order as the represented relationship.
- Identifies actual duration data as missing and needed.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Procedure · classroom example
A pupil notices damaged classroom equipment, stops using it and tells the teacher. The teacher arranges a check. The pupil uses the equipment again only after the teacher confirms it is ready.
Diagram purpose
Help pupils follow this reporting procedure. Do not include repair instructions for children or imply that reporting automatically makes equipment ready.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each diagram label to its place in the procedure.
Complete or match: First response; Next responsible action; Condition for using again
- a: Teacher confirms it is ready
- b: Stop using and tell the teacher
- c: Teacher arranges a check
The sequence keeps use paused until a separate confirmation.
5B · Short answer
Propose a short diagram plan that clearly prevents use before confirmation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Stop using → Tell teacher → Teacher arranges check → Teacher confirms ready → Use again. Label arrows as required order and show waiting before the confirmation.
- Includes stopping/reporting and teacher checking in a sensible order.
- Makes return to use conditional on the teacher’s confirmation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.17 · Infographics
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Use the picture key
Practice infographic
Title: Cups returned after the club meeting. The panel shows three cup symbols. Key: Each cup symbol represents four real cups. The count covers today’s meeting.
Question: How many real cups do the three symbols represent?
Answer: They represent twelve cups.
Why: The symbols do not necessarily stand for one object each. The key gives four cups per symbol, so three groups of four make twelve. The title and note also keep the number attached to returned cups at today’s meeting, rather than cups owned by the whole school.
Example 2 · Keep the total with the count
Survey infographic
A panel says “8 chose blue”. Its note says “Favourite bookmark colour, one class, 20 pupils, one choice each.” Other colours were also offered.
Question: What can a reader say about the eight choices?
Answer: Eight of the twenty pupils in that class chose blue as their favourite bookmark colour.
Why: The short panel leaves out information supplied by the note. Joining them tells us what was chosen, by whom and out of how many responses. The number eight alone cannot show a whole-school preference or even establish that blue received more choices than every other colour.
Example 3 · An honest visual comparison
Infographic plan
The class collected six empty boxes on Monday and twelve on Tuesday. The designer plans to use one equal-sized box symbol for every two real boxes.
Question: How many symbols should represent each day?
Answer: Monday needs three symbols, and Tuesday needs six symbols of the same size.
Why: The key keeps the comparison consistent: six divided by two is three, and twelve divided by two is six. Enlarging Tuesday’s symbols as well as doubling their number would exaggerate the visual change. Clear labels and a consistent key let the reader recover the original counts.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the pictograph key
Infographic
Four book symbols are shown. The key says each symbol represents three books donated in the classroom drive.
F1 · True or false
The four symbols represent twelve donated books.
- true: True
- false: False
Each of four symbols represents three books, giving 4×3=12.
Source explorer: word lab
F2 · Infographic parts
Title
How our class travels to school
Number panel
Walking: 7 pupils
Source note
Class survey, 20 pupils, one answer each, Monday
F2 · Matching
Match each infographic part to its main job.
Complete or match: Title; Number panel; Source note
- a: Gives a category’s count
- b: Explains the topic
- c: Identifies the surveyed group and occasion
The parts work together: topic, result and source context.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · What can the infographic establish?
Infographic panels
A class survey of twenty pupils records favourite reading places. Library: 8; Classroom: 7; Home: 5. Each pupil chose one place.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two statements follow the infographic?
- a: Eight pupils in this class chose the library.
- b: The three recorded counts add to twenty.
- c: Every pupil in the school prefers the library.
- d: The survey explains why each place was chosen.
The counts establish the class totals but give neither a whole-school result nor reasons for individual choices.
Source explorer: chart lab
F4 · Find the missing context
Panel
“15 items reused” appears above a picture of a craft table.
Note
Source: A count by one craft group during Tuesday’s activity.
Decoration
A large green border surrounds the panel.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the part that tells whose activity and which occasion the count describes.
- a: 15 items reused
- b: One craft group during Tuesday’s activity
- c: The large green border
The note supplies both the group and occasion.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · A headline that fits the data
Infographic data
At one class’s swap day, 12 pupils exchanged a total of 18 books. The record covers that event only.
Overstated headline
Every child now shares all their books!
F5 · Open ended
Write a more accurate headline and explain one limit that your wording preserves.
Example of a full-credit answer: Twelve pupils exchange 18 books at class swap day. This keeps the claim about the recorded event instead of claiming that every child shares every book.
- Provides a headline accurately describing the class swap event using the 12 pupils and/or 18 books without a universal claim.
- Explains that the record concerns one event/group and cannot establish behaviour of every child or every book.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: headline lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Infographic title · classroom example
OUR CLASS REFILL WEEK. Monday: 2 bottle icons. Tuesday: 3 bottle icons. Wednesday: 1 bottle icon. Key: each icon represents 5 water-bottle refills.
Source note
Counts were recorded at the classroom refill station over these three days. The icons represent refill events, not different pupils or bottles purchased.
1A · Hotspot
Select the infographic region needed to interpret what one bottle icon means.
- a: Our Class Refill Week
- b: Key: each icon represents 5 refills
- c: Counts recorded at classroom station
The key gives the unit represented by the picture.
1B · Open ended
Explain why Tuesday’s three icons do not mean only three refills or necessarily three pupils.
Example of a full-credit answer: Each icon stands for five refill events, so Tuesday represents fifteen refills. The measure counts events and does not identify how many different pupils refilled.
- Uses the key correctly to interpret Tuesday’s represented count.
- Distinguishes refill events from unique pupils.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Infographic panels · classroom example
Class B’s one-week travel survey: walk 12 pupils, bicycle 4, vehicle 8. Total: 24 pupils, one usual travel choice each.
Proposed headline
“Half of Class B usually walks to school.” The source note names the class and survey week.
2A · True or false
The proposed headline fits the infographic’s numbers and stated group.
- true: True
- false: False
Twelve of the 24 surveyed pupils is half, and the headline names the correct class.
2B · Short answer
Why is “Half the whole town walks” not equally supported?
Example of a full-credit answer: The data cover 24 pupils in Class B, not all town residents. The matching headline keeps the correct group rather than expanding the claim.
- Identifies the actual class sample.
- Explains that the townwide claim goes beyond the data.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Garden infographic · classroom example
Seed packets used in the school garden this month: beans 6, pechay 4, tomatoes 2. A packet symbol represents one packet. Packet sizes and seed numbers differ.
New reading task
A pupil wants to decide which statements can be read directly from the infographic without assuming equal seeds per packet.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported by the infographic.
- a: More bean packets than tomato packets were used
- b: The garden used exactly three times as many bean seeds as tomato seeds
- c: The unit counted is packets
- d: Every packet contains the same number of seeds
The display counts packets and explicitly warns that their contents differ.
3B · Open ended
Explain how the unit note changes what the reader can conclude.
Example of a full-credit answer: It allows comparison of packet counts, but not exact seed counts. Different packet sizes mean six bean packets need not contain three times the seeds of two tomato packets.
- Distinguishes packets from seeds as the measured unit.
- Explains why unequal packet contents prevent the proposed seed comparison.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Infographic · classroom example
“Library visitors: 40 on Monday, 30 on Tuesday, 50 on Wednesday.” A small note says: “Classroom example: counts from one week in April.”
Reader’s claim
“Wednesday will always be the busiest library day.” The poster gives no other weeks and makes no prediction.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete a careful reading.
Complete or match: Busiest observed day; Time covered; Status of “always busiest”
- a: Wednesday
- b: one week in April
- c: not established by these data
- d: every week of the year
The data support a past comparison within one week, not an unlimited prediction.
4B · Short answer
Rewrite the claim accurately and name useful further evidence.
Example of a full-credit answer: Wednesday was busiest during the reported April week. Counts across more weeks would help assess whether that pattern often repeats.
- Limits the comparison to the observed week.
- Suggests repeated observations relevant to the wider pattern.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Data and goal · classroom example
A class repaired 6 folders, reused 9 envelopes and donated 5 books during one project week. These are different item categories counted once each. The infographic should celebrate the work without claiming a measured reduction in waste weight.
Design checklist
Readers need category labels, item counts, the class/project-week scope and a note explaining what was counted.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each design element to the information it preserves.
Complete or match: Title naming the class project week; Numbers 6, 9 and 5 beside categories; Note “items counted, not kilograms”
- a: The measure’s unit and limit
- b: The scope in group and time
- c: The exact category results
The three elements keep the message, counts and measure from being confused.
5B · Open ended
Propose an infographic layout and one wording choice that avoids exaggeration.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use three labeled panels for 6 repaired folders, 9 reused envelopes and 5 donated books, titled with our class and project week. Say “items given another use,” not “kilograms of waste saved.”
- Proposes a layout retaining categories, counts and scope.
- Uses wording consistent with item counts rather than an unmeasured environmental quantity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.18 · Forms
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read choose one carefully
Fictional workshop form
Choose ONE session: Morning or Afternoon. Write your classroom group code. The practice learner can attend only the afternoon session.
Question: How should the learner complete the session field?
Answer: Select Afternoon only.
Why: The label sets the number of allowed choices, and the learner’s availability selects the appropriate option. Ticking both would not follow the form even if both sessions sound interesting. The group-code field serves a separate purpose, so it should not be used to explain the session choice instead of marking the requested option.
Example 2 · A conditional field may not apply
Practice form
Do you need a borrowed ruler? Choose Yes or No. If Yes, write the quantity needed. If No, leave the quantity field blank.
Learner’s situation
Aila already has a ruler and does not need to borrow one.
Question: What should Aila enter?
Answer: Choose No and leave the quantity field blank.
Why: The form explains when the extra field applies. Here a blank quantity is correct because the No choice makes that field unnecessary. It would be different from forgetting a required field. The reader must use the form’s own rule rather than assume that every empty box is an error.
Example 3 · Submission and approval differ
Practice room-request form
Enter the club name, preferred date and responsible teacher. After submission, the office checks room availability and sends a confirmation. Do not announce a booking before confirmation.
Question: Can a club announce that its room is booked immediately after submitting?
Answer: No. The club must wait for the office’s confirmation.
Why: A form may collect a request without granting it. The instructions explain what happens after submission, so reading the final note matters as much as filling the fields. A completed form and an approved booking are different stages in this classroom example.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Put answers in the correct fields
Practice form
Fields: Group code; Chosen activity; Preferred session. Fictional answers: G4; Paper weaving; Afternoon.
F1 · Matching
Match each answer to its field.
Complete or match: G4; Paper weaving; Afternoon
- a: Chosen activity
- b: Preferred session
- c: Group code
A group code identifies the group, paper weaving names the activity and afternoon gives the session.
Source explorer: table lab
F2 · One choice is required
Form instruction
Choose ONE way to receive the club notice: Paper copy or Email. This practice learner wants a paper copy.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which entry follows both instructions?
- a: Select Email and add Paper too.
- b: Leave every choice unmarked.
- c: Select Paper copy only.
- d: Select both available choices.
Paper copy alone matches the preference and the choose-one rule.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Find the required field
Form labels
Activity choice: Required. Favourite colour: Optional. Extra comment: Optional.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the field that must be completed.
- a: Activity choice
- b: Favourite colour
- c: Extra comment
The form explicitly labels activity choice as required.
Source explorer: word lab
F4 · Apply a conditional form rule
Form rule
Need a borrowed folder? Choose Yes or No. If Yes, enter the quantity. If No, leave quantity blank.
Practice learner
Learner P7 needs two borrowed folders.
F4 · Drag and drop
Place the entries beside the correct fields.
Complete or match: Borrowing choice; Quantity; Learner code
- a: P7
- b: Yes
- c: 2
The need for two folders requires Yes and 2; P7 belongs in the identity-code field.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Explain a correct blank field
Form
Will you borrow a paintbrush? Choose Yes or No. Complete “Number of brushes” only if you choose Yes.
Practice entry
Sam has a brush, selects No and leaves the number field blank.
F5 · Short answer
Explain whether Sam’s blank number field follows the instruction and why.
Example of a full-credit answer: Yes. Sam chose No because no brush is needed, and the form says to complete the number field only after choosing Yes.
- States that leaving the number blank follows the form in this case.
- Explains the connection between choosing No and the field applying only to Yes.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: evidence lens
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Form heading · classroom example
FICTIONAL ART-CLUB PRACTICE FORM. Required: learner initials, section and one preferred session. Optional: favourite art material. Do not enter real personal information in this classroom exercise.
Session field
Choose ONE: Tuesday lunchtime; Thursday after class. The form records a preference; the adviser confirms a place later.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all statements that correctly follow the form instructions.
- a: Choose one preferred session
- b: Leave the optional material field blank if desired
- c: A completed form guarantees a place immediately
- d: Both session choices must be selected
The form requires one session and marks the material question optional; approval comes later.
1B · Short answer
Explain why choosing a session is different from receiving a confirmed place.
Example of a full-credit answer: The form records what the learner prefers. The adviser still has to confirm whether a place is available.
- Identifies the form’s preference-recording purpose.
- Recognises the separate adviser confirmation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Practice field · classroom example
Preferred session — choose one of the listed times: Monday, 3–4 p.m.; Wednesday, 3–4 p.m. Use fictional learner details.
Learner situation
The fictional learner is free Wednesday from 3 to 4 p.m. and unavailable Monday. A nearby field separately asks for favourite activity.
2A · Multiple choice
Which response belongs in Preferred session?
- a: Painting
- b: Wednesday, 3–4 p.m.
- c: Both days despite being unavailable Monday
- d: A home address
It answers the requested schedule choice and matches availability.
2B · Open ended
Why should “Painting” go elsewhere on this form?
Example of a full-credit answer: Painting describes an activity, not a session time. It would fit the separate favourite-activity field, while this field needs Wednesday’s time.
- Distinguishes activity from schedule information.
- Identifies the appropriate field or correct schedule response.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Equipment-loan form · classroom example
Fields: Item requested; Date needed; Number required. The form says to use a number for quantity and to request one item type per line.
Fictional request
A team needs three magnifying glasses for 12 November. They do not need other equipment. Availability will be checked after the request.
3A · Drag and drop
Place each response in the matching form field.
Complete or match: Item requested; Date needed; Number required
- a: 12 November
- b: 3
- c: Magnifying glasses
Each value answers a different labeled field.
3B · Short answer
Explain how you would check this request before sending it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check that the item field names magnifying glasses, the date is 12 November and the quantity is 3. Remember it requests availability rather than proving the equipment is reserved.
- Checks the labels against the correct item/date/quantity.
- Recognises that availability still needs confirmation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Practice form instructions · classroom example
Transport required? Choose Yes or No. If Yes, choose one listed bus stop. If No, leave the bus-stop field blank. This is a fictional form exercise.
Incorrect response
A learner selects No but invents a bus stop because they think every blank must be filled.
4A · Matching
Match each situation to the correct response rule.
Complete or match: Transport: Yes; Transport: No; Unclear listed stop
- a: Ask for clarification rather than inventing a stop
- b: Choose one listed bus stop
- c: Leave bus-stop field blank
The form’s conditional rule determines whether the bus-stop field applies.
4B · Open ended
Identify the learner’s mistake and explain the proper correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: They ignored the No condition and invented unnecessary information. They should keep No and leave the bus-stop field blank as instructed.
- Identifies the conditional-field misunderstanding or invented information.
- States the correct No/blank response.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Purpose · classroom example
A class wants to choose one story for a read-aloud. Each pupil should choose one of three titles and may add a short reason. No names, passwords or home details are needed.
Draft fields
Field A: “Choose one story: River Journey / The Paper Kite / Moon Garden.” Field B: “Reason, optional.” Field C: “Your account password.”
5A · Hotspot
Select the draft field that should be removed because it is unrelated to the preference task.
- a: Choose one story from the three titles
- b: Reason, optional
- c: Your account password
An account password has no role in choosing a class story.
5B · Short answer
Propose two clear instructions for the improved form.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose exactly one of the three story titles. You may add a short reason, but do not enter private account details because the task needs only your preference.
- Clearly states the one-choice rule.
- Makes the reason optional and/or limits the form to necessary non-private information.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.19 · Mixed-text documents
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Join a paragraph with a table
| Workshop | Day and time | Room | Places left |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drawing | Saturday, 9 a.m. | 2 | 3 |
| Weaving | Saturday, 10 a.m. | 4 | 0 |
Leaflet paragraph
Choose a workshop with an available place. Materials are supplied, but registration closes on Thursday.
Session table
Drawing: Saturday 9 a.m., Room 2, three places. Weaving: Saturday 10 a.m., Room 4, no places.
Question: Can a pupil register for the weaving session using this leaflet?
Answer: No. The table shows no available places for weaving.
Why: The paragraph gives the general registration rule, and the table supplies each session’s availability. Neither should be read alone. Knowing that registration remains open until Thursday does not create space in a full session; the reader must combine the rule with the relevant row.
Example 2 · A map supplies the location
Event note
The class display is in the Cedar Room after lunch.
Leaflet map key
The Cedar Room is next to the main staircase. The Pine Room is beside the garden exit.
Question: Which landmark helps a visitor find the display?
Answer: The main staircase helps, because the Cedar Room is next to it.
Why: The prose names the event’s room, while the map key locates that room. Matching the shared label Cedar joins the two formats. Choosing the garden exit because it is a familiar landmark would attach the Pine Room’s location to the wrong event.
Example 3 · Keep an update with the table
Printed schedule
Storytelling: Friday 2 p.m., Room 1.
Update box on the same leaflet
For this Friday only, storytelling moves to Room 6. The time stays 2 p.m.
Question: Which arrangement applies this Friday?
Answer: Storytelling is in Room 6 at 2 p.m.
Why: The update box changes one field in the printed schedule. A careful reader uses the room from the update and the unchanged time from both sources. The larger schedule table is not automatically more current than a smaller note that explicitly corrects it.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Use text and timetable together
Leaflet text
All workshops require a reservation before Friday. Bring a pencil.
Timetable
Collage: Saturday 9 a.m., Room 3. Story maps: Saturday 10 a.m., Room 5.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Complete the plan for Story maps.
Complete or match: The session is in Room ___.; The learner should bring a ___.
- a: 5
- b: pencil
- c: 3
The timetable gives Room 5 and the paragraph gives the pencil requirement.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Find where the number comes from
Introductory text
The leaflet invites pupils to a paper-craft display.
Table
Friday visitors: 24. Saturday visitors: 31.
Map caption
The display room is beside the central staircase.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the part that tells how many visitors came on Saturday.
- a: Invitation paragraph
- b: Visitor-count table
- c: Map caption
The table contains the day-by-day counts; the paragraph and map answer other questions.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Read a restriction alongside a schedule
Schedule
The reading room opens from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. on Tuesday.
Note
From noon to 1 p.m., the room is reserved for a teacher meeting. Pupils may use it at other opening times.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two times are available to pupils on Tuesday?
- a: 4 p.m.
- b: 10 a.m.
- c: 11 a.m.
- d: 12:30 p.m.
Ten and eleven are inside the opening period and outside the noon meeting. 12:30 is reserved and 4 is after closing.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Which update changes the plan?
Original table
Stamp display: Thursday 1 p.m., Room 2.
Update note
This Thursday’s stamp display moves to Room 7. The 1 p.m. time is unchanged.
F4 · Multiple choice
Which plan follows the whole document?
- a: Room 2 on Thursday at 1 p.m.
- b: Room 7 on Friday at 2 p.m.
- c: Room 2 on Friday at 2 p.m.
- d: Room 7 on Thursday at 1 p.m.
The update replaces Room 2 with Room 7 and keeps the day and time.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Explain which source supplies each fact
Notice paragraph
Visitors to the classroom exhibition must bring a reusable name badge.
Session table
Blue Group: 10 a.m. in Room 8. Gold Group: 11 a.m. in Room 9.
F5 · Open ended
State Blue Group’s arrangement and explain what the paragraph adds to the table.
Example of a full-credit answer: Blue Group visits Room 8 at 10 a.m. The paragraph adds the requirement to bring a reusable name badge, which is not stated in the table.
- Accurately gives Blue Group’s Room 8 and 10 a.m. arrangement.
- Identifies the reusable-name-badge requirement as information added by the paragraph.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Leaflet paragraph · classroom example
The class garden day includes planting and label-making. Planting is outdoors; label-making is in the covered court. Pupils may attend one session and should check the timetable.
Timetable
Planting: 9:00–9:30, garden, bring a hat. Label-making: 9:30–10:00, covered court, pencils provided.
Map note
The covered court is beside the west gate. The garden is north of the court. This diagram does not provide distances.
1A · True or false
A pupil attending label-making should go to the covered court beside the west gate at 9:30.
- true: True
- false: False
The timetable supplies the activity, place and time, while the map note locates the court.
1B · Open ended
Identify which two parts you combined to plan this visit.
Example of a full-credit answer: The timetable says label-making is at the covered court from 9:30. The map note says that court is beside the west gate.
- Uses the correct schedule information.
- Uses the correct location note and explains their shared label.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Exhibit introduction · classroom example
The class exhibit shows how pupils reused paper. Visitors can discuss the models with their makers.
Session table
Model talks: 2 p.m., Room A. Poster viewing: 2–4 p.m., corridor. Question circle: 3 p.m., Room B.
Venue map note
Room A is opposite the main entrance. Room B is at the corridor’s far end.
2A · Dropdown selection
Choose the most direct part for each reading purpose.
Complete or match: Understand the exhibit’s purpose; Find the question-circle time; Locate Room B
- a: Introduction
- b: Session table
- c: Venue map note
- d: Any picture regardless of label
The formats complement one another by explaining purpose, timing and location.
2B · Short answer
Why does a visitor attending the question circle need both the table and map note?
Example of a full-credit answer: The table gives 3 p.m. and Room B. The map note shows where Room B is, so the two parts together guide the visit.
- Uses the table’s time/place.
- Explains the location contribution of the map note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Display text · classroom example
A class compared two paper-towel brands using equal-sized sheets and the same starting water amount.
Results table
Towel A absorbed 18 mL. Towel B absorbed 24 mL. These values come from one trial of each towel.
Diagram caption
The drawing shows the pouring method, not the towels’ real relative sizes.
3A · Drag and drop
Match each part to the interpretation it supports.
Complete or match: Equal-sized sheets in the text; 18 and 24 mL in the table; Diagram caption
- a: Numerical comparison for this trial
- b: A comparison condition
- c: A warning not to infer size from the drawing
Each format contributes a distinct piece needed for a careful report reading.
3B · Open ended
Write a conclusion that uses the results and respects one note from another part.
Example of a full-credit answer: With equal-sized sheets, Towel B absorbed 24 mL compared with 18 mL for Towel A in this trial. The caption says the drawing shows the method, so its shapes cannot establish the towels’ real relative sizes.
- Accurately compares the two measured results.
- Uses a relevant method condition or diagram note from another source part, rather than only a note from the results table.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original leaflet table · classroom example
Story session: Friday, 1 p.m., library. Craft session: Friday, 2 p.m., Room 4.
Later update box
Confirmed Thursday by the adviser: the story session moves to the hall. Its day and time remain Friday, 1 p.m. The craft session is unchanged.
Mistaken reading
A pupil assumes the bigger old table must be more reliable than the smaller update box.
4A · Matching
Match each detail to its current status.
Complete or match: Story-session venue; Story-session day/time; Craft session
- a: Unchanged: Friday, 1 p.m.
- b: Changed to the hall
- c: Unchanged: Friday, 2 p.m., Room 4
The dated confirmation changes only the story-session venue.
4B · Short answer
Explain why print size should not decide which venue to use.
Example of a full-credit answer: The smaller box is a later confirmed update that explicitly replaces the library with the hall. Text size does not make the older venue current.
- Uses the later confirmation and explicit change.
- Explains that visual prominence is not evidence of currency.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Visitor needs · classroom example
An open classroom has three displays. Visitors need to know the purpose, opening times and where the rooms are. Some visitors have never entered the building.
Available information
Purpose: share pupils’ projects. Times: all displays open 10–11 a.m. Rooms: Reading in Room 1, Maths in Room 2, Science in Room 3. The entrance is nearest Room 1.
5A · Multiple choice
Which layout best meets the different needs?
- a: A decorative title with no room labels
- b: A short purpose paragraph, a labeled schedule table and a room diagram using the same room names
- c: Three unrelated pictures with no caption
- d: A long paragraph that omits opening times
The three connected formats address purpose, timing and navigation.
5B · Open ended
Propose the information for two linked parts and explain the label that connects them.
Example of a full-credit answer: A table lists each display with Room 1, 2 or 3 and 10–11 a.m. A diagram labels those same rooms and the entrance, letting visitors connect the display to its location.
- Plans two complementary parts with relevant content.
- Explains consistent room/display labels linking the parts.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.20 · Multiple linked digital sources
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Follow the link that fits the question
School event page
Links: Programme; Room map; Lunch menu. The page says activities use several rooms.
Reading goal
A visitor wants to know where the puppet demonstration takes place.
Question: Which link is the best first step?
Answer: Open the Programme to find the demonstration’s room, then use the Room map if its location is needed.
Why: The goal determines the reading route. A programme usually connects activities with their arrangements; the map can then locate the named room. The lunch menu may be interesting, but it does not directly answer this question. Linked reading involves purposeful choices rather than opening every available page.
Example 2 · Record the source of each fact
Booking page
Paper collage session: Saturday 10 a.m.; registration required.
Materials page linked from it
Registered participants should bring a glue stick. Paper will be supplied.
Question: What two-source plan should a participant make?
Answer: Register for the Saturday 10 a.m. session and bring a glue stick; the materials page says paper is supplied.
Why: The booking page gives the session and registration rule, while the linked page gives materials. Keeping each fact connected to its source helps the reader check changes later. The plan must also concern the same session rather than combine unrelated pages merely because they appear nearby.
Example 3 · Check the destination itself
Summary page
“Click here for this year’s art-fair schedule.”
Linked destination
The opened file is titled Last Year’s Art Fair and gives a date from the previous year.
Question: Does the link establish this year’s schedule?
Answer: No. Its destination is last year’s file, so this year’s arrangement still needs checking.
Why: A link label can promise something its destination does not provide. The reader must inspect the opened document’s title and date. An old file may be genuine historical information while still being unsuitable evidence for the current event; calling it current would misrepresent its scope.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Choose the useful source
Programme
This linked page lists the activity times.
Map
This linked page shows the room locations.
Materials list
This linked page gives what to bring for each activity.
F1 · Matching
Match each reading need to the most relevant link.
Complete or match: When does weaving begin?; Where is Room 6?; What should I bring?
- a: Map
- b: Materials list
- c: Programme
The links have different jobs: time, location and materials.
Source explorer: network
F2 · A link needs a relevant destination
Claim
The summary says next week’s session is free.
Destination A
A current registration page states “No session fee; bring your own notebook.”
Destination B
An old photograph shows a busy hall.
F2 · Hotspot
Select the source that directly checks the fee claim.
- a: The summary’s excited title
- b: The current registration page
- c: The old hall photograph
The registration page states the fee condition directly.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Join two linked pages
Event page
The map-making activity begins at 2 p.m. in the Willow Room.
Room map
Willow Room is beside the east staircase. Birch Room is beside the west staircase.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which plan uses both sources correctly?
- a: Go to Willow by the east stairs at 2 p.m.
- b: Go to Birch by the west stairs at 2 p.m.
- c: Go to Willow by the west stairs at 3 p.m.
- d: Go to Birch by the east stairs at 3 p.m.
The event supplies Willow and 2 p.m.; the map locates Willow beside the east staircase.
Source explorer: source tabs
F4 · Read the current linked update
Overview page
The club meeting is listed in Room 1.
Linked update dated today
Today’s meeting moves to Room 4. Its 3 p.m. start is unchanged.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the current meeting plan.
Complete or match: Go to Room ___.; Arrive for the ___ start.
- a: 4
- b: 3 p.m.
- c: 1
The linked update changes the room to 4 and preserves 3 p.m.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Build a short source trail
Programme page
The story workshop begins at 9 a.m. and lists Room 10.
Directions page
Room 10 is upstairs beside the library staircase.
Registration page
Places must be reserved by Thursday; walk-in places are not promised.
F5 · Short answer
Explain how a learner would use at least two of these pages to plan attendance, including the reservation condition.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the registration page to reserve by Thursday. Use the programme to plan for 9 a.m. in Room 10, and the directions page to find it beside the library staircase.
- Includes the requirement to reserve by Thursday from the registration page.
- Uses at least one other page accurately for the 9 a.m./Room 10 arrangement or its location, naming or clearly distinguishing that source.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: network
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Event page · classroom example
The fictional town museum offers a Saturday story tour. Links point to the current timetable and visitor map. The event page says visitors should check both before travelling.
Current timetable
Story tour: Saturday, 10:00–10:45. Meet at the learning desk. Booking closes Friday at noon.
Visitor map
The learning desk is inside the west entrance. The east entrance is closed this week.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all actions supported by the linked sources.
- a: Book before Friday noon
- b: Use the west entrance to reach the learning desk
- c: Arrive at the closed east entrance
- d: Assume booking is unnecessary
The timetable supplies the booking deadline; the map supplies the open entrance.
1B · Short answer
Explain why the event page alone is not enough to complete the visit plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: It introduces the tour but directs readers elsewhere for the deadline and entrance. The timetable and map supply those practical details.
- Names a needed detail from the timetable.
- Names a needed location/access detail from the map.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
School fair hub · classroom example
Links: Programme, Stall map and Accessibility note. The hub gives a general welcome but no individual session times.
Programme
Puppet show: 11 a.m., Stage C. Reading circle: noon, Tent A.
Stall map and access note
Map: Stage C is beside the south gate. Accessibility note: the south-gate route is step-free; the east-gate route includes stairs.
2A · Drag and drop
Match each planning question to the source that directly answers it.
Complete or match: When is the puppet show?; Where is Stage C?; Which entrance route is step-free?
- a: Accessibility note
- b: Programme
- c: Stall map
Each source has a distinct function that contributes to the complete plan.
2B · Open ended
Justify a reading route for a visitor who wants the puppet show and a step-free route.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the programme for 11 a.m. at Stage C, the map for Stage C’s position, and the accessibility note for the south-gate step-free route.
- Combines show time and location from the appropriate sources.
- Uses the access note for the visitor’s stated route need.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Three posts · classroom example
Post A, Post B and Post C each repeat the same sentence: “The garden opens Monday.” All three link to a single undated club note.
Current office page
The office page, updated today, says the garden opening date has not yet been confirmed. It asks readers to wait for a dated announcement.
3A · True or false
The three repeated posts provide three independent confirmations that the garden opens Monday.
- true: True
- false: False
They share one undated source, while the current office page says the date is not confirmed.
3B · Short answer
What should a careful reader report after tracing these sources?
Example of a full-credit answer: Several posts repeat one undated note, but the current office page says the opening date is unconfirmed. Monday should not be presented as a confirmed opening.
- Recognises the shared origin rather than independent evidence.
- Uses the current uncertainty to avoid confirming Monday.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Homework page · classroom example
A link labeled “Current exhibit times” is supposed to help visitors plan this year’s exhibit.
Link destination
The link opens a page titled “Exhibit archive — last year.” It lists last year’s dates and a note that arrangements may change.
Reader’s note
A reader copies the old times without noticing the archive label.
4A · Dropdown selection
Complete the diagnosis.
Complete or match: The destination actually concerns…; The link label by itself…; A useful next step is…
- a: last year’s exhibit
- b: does not establish current times
- c: find this year’s confirmed programme
- d: guarantees the destination is current
The destination’s content and date override assumptions based on the link label.
4B · Open ended
Explain the error and how the reader can repair the plan.
Example of a full-credit answer: The reader treated an archived destination as current because of the link label. Find the current year’s confirmed programme before using any times.
- Identifies the archive/current mismatch.
- Proposes checking the current programme rather than reusing old times.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Reading goal · classroom example
Help a new pupil join a school workshop. The welcome page links to a session calendar, a joining guide and a building map.
Source details
The calendar gives dates and times. The joining guide explains who can attend and how to request a place. The map labels room locations. Requests require confirmation before attendance.
5A · Multiple choice
Which reading plan covers the pupil’s full need?
- a: Read only the welcome slogan
- b: Use the joining guide, session calendar and map, then check the required confirmation
- c: Use the map to guess eligibility
- d: Treat every available date as a guaranteed place
Joining conditions, schedule, location and confirmation all matter to a usable plan.
5B · Short answer
Propose a short source trail with a note to save from each of two different sources.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the joining guide and note eligibility plus the confirmation requirement. Read the calendar and note the chosen session date/time; then use the map to find its room.
- Plans a trail using complementary relevant sources.
- Names concrete facts to save and preserves the confirmation condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R6.21 · Artificial intelligence-generated answers
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Check one claim at a time
Source note
The class collected 14 storybooks and 6 dictionaries for a shelf.
AI-generated answer in this exercise
The class collected 14 books altogether, and all were dictionaries.
Question: Which claims need correction?
Answer: The total should be 20 books, and the collection included 14 storybooks as well as 6 dictionaries.
Why: The answer makes separate claims about the total and the kinds of books. Both can be checked against the original note. Fluent wording does not replace that check. Identifying each error precisely is more useful than deciding that every answer from an AI system must be entirely right or entirely wrong.
Example 2 · Keep an unknown detail unknown
Source notice
A poetry activity is on Friday afternoon in Room 3. The notice does not give a starting time.
AI-generated reply
It begins at 2:15 p.m.
Question: Is 2:15 p.m. supported by this notice?
Answer: No. The notice gives Friday afternoon but does not supply an exact time.
Why: A plausible time is still a guess when the source does not contain it. A careful reply would say the exact start is not stated and suggest checking with the organiser. The issue is missing evidence; the text alone does not tell us whether the mistake was deliberate.
Example 3 · Inspect a citation rather than its appearance
AI-generated statement
“The art workshop is free, ” with a link labelled Workshop details.
Opened source
The linked page describes the school’s gardening club and says nothing about the art workshop’s fee.
Question: Does the link verify the fee statement?
Answer: No. The destination concerns a different activity and does not state the art workshop’s fee.
Why: A citation can look formal while failing to provide relevant evidence. The reader must check what the linked source actually says and whether it addresses the same claim. The fee might be free or paid; this unrelated link does not settle the question either way.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Correct a generated summary
Original record
The class made 8 red badges and 5 blue badges.
AI-generated summary
There were 8 badges in total and all were red.
F1 · Dropdown selection
Correct the generated summary using the record.
Complete or match: The total number of badges was ___.; The number of blue badges was ___.
- a: 13
- b: 5
- c: 8
Eight red plus five blue gives thirteen badges; five were blue.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Fluency does not verify a claim
AI-generated answer
A confidently worded answer gives a workshop start of 10:30 a.m.
Only source supplied
The notice says “Tuesday morning” and gives no exact start.
F2 · True or false
The exact 10:30 a.m. start is verified because the generated answer sounds confident.
- true: True
- false: False
Confidence is not source evidence. The supplied notice does not establish an exact start.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Check an important detail
Original list
Puppet practice: Wednesday, Room 6. Music practice: Thursday, Room 2.
AI-generated answer
Puppet practice is on Thursday in Room 2.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which correction follows the original list?
- a: Puppet practice is Friday in Room 2.
- b: Puppet practice is Wednesday in Room 6.
- c: Puppet practice is Thursday in Room 6.
- d: Puppet practice is Wednesday in Room 2.
The answer has used the music row. The puppet row gives Wednesday and Room 6.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · A useful checking routine
AI-generated paragraph
The paragraph says the workshop is on Friday in Room 8 and gives a link. You need to check the date and room before making a plan.
Original notice
The teacher’s current workshop notice lists Friday and Room 8.
Linked destination
The linked page is titled Workshop details and lists this same workshop on Friday in Room 8.
Appearance
The paragraph uses long words and has a neat border.
F4 · Multiple answers
Which two actions help verify the important details?
- a: Accept the paragraph because it uses long words.
- b: Assume that a neat layout guarantees accurate details.
- c: Compare the date and room with the original notice.
- d: Open the link and check that it covers this event.
Direct comparison and inspecting the source help verify claims. Style and layout alone do not.
Source explorer: builder
F5 · Replace an unsupported exact answer
Source
The class will visit the exhibit next week. The teacher will announce the day later.
AI-generated answer
The visit is definitely on Monday.
F5 · Open ended
Write a corrected answer and explain why the original AI answer is not supported.
Example of a full-credit answer: The visit is planned for next week, but the day has not been announced. Monday is unsupported because the source says the teacher will provide the day later.
- Replaces definite Monday with next week and an unannounced/unknown day.
- Explains that the original source supplies no Monday date and explicitly leaves the day for a later announcement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: quote lab
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Original notice · classroom example
The school exhibit opens on Friday at 2 p.m. in the hall. Entry is for pupils and their invited family members. The notice does not mention refreshments.
AI-generated answer
“The exhibit opens Friday at 2 p.m. in the hall. Everyone in town may attend, and free juice will be served.”
1A · Matching
Match each AI statement to its evidence status.
Complete or match: Friday at 2 p.m. in the hall; Everyone in town may attend; Free juice will be served
- a: Not stated in the notice
- b: Supported by the notice
- c: Conflicts with the stated invited audience
Time and venue match; the audience is expanded beyond the notice; juice is invented relative to the source.
1B · Open ended
Write a corrected answer that preserves the supported facts and handles the missing detail.
Example of a full-credit answer: The exhibit opens Friday at 2 p.m. in the hall for pupils and invited family members. The notice does not say whether refreshments are available.
- Keeps the correct time/place and restricted audience.
- Marks refreshments as unspecified rather than inventing a claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
AI response · classroom example
“I am completely certain the reading workshop starts at 9 a.m.” The response gives no current source.
Current organiser note
The organiser’s dated note says the workshop begins at 10 a.m. and asks visitors to use that revised time.
2A · True or false
The AI’s confident wording is a stronger reason to use 9 a.m. than the organiser’s current revised note.
- true: True
- false: False
Confidence is not a source; the relevant current note gives 10 a.m.
2B · Short answer
Explain which time a reader should use and why.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use 10 a.m. because the current organiser note explicitly gives the revised start. The AI’s certainty does not supply evidence for 9 a.m.
- Uses the correct current start time and source.
- Distinguishes confident wording from supporting evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Original class table · classroom example
Books donated: Section A, 12; Section B, 9; Section C, 15. The table covers one collection day.
AI summary
“Section C donated the most on the collection day. These figures prove Section C always cares more about reading than the other sections.”
3A · Multiple answers
Select all careful judgments about the AI summary.
- a: The highest-count statement matches the table
- b: The table does not establish how much anyone cares or what always happens
- c: The figures prove lasting differences in caring
- d: One true sentence makes every later sentence reliable
A single-day count supports the ranking but not a claim about motives or permanent patterns.
3B · Open ended
Give a revised summary and explain what you removed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Section C donated the most books on that collection day, with 15. I removed the claim about always caring more because the table measures donations for one day, not feelings or all future events.
- Retains the accurate count/ranking within the day’s scope.
- Explains why motives and permanent patterns are unsupported.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Source paragraph · classroom example
The garden adviser said the seedlings need regular checks. She explained that some dry soil may need water, while already damp soil may not.
Generated answer
The AI claims the adviser said, “Water every seedling every hour.” Those exact words do not appear in the paragraph.
4A · Drag and drop
Match each answer feature to the appropriate correction.
Complete or match: Invented quotation marks; Every seedling every hour; Original conditional advice
- a: Keep the condition about soil moisture
- b: Remove the false claim of exact words
- c: Do not replace the source with an unsupported fixed schedule
A quote must preserve actual words; the source also gives conditional rather than hourly advice.
4B · Short answer
Explain two problems with the generated answer.
Example of a full-credit answer: It presents words as a quotation even though they are absent from the source. It also changes moisture-dependent advice into an unsupported hourly rule for every seedling.
- Identifies the fabricated exact quotation.
- Identifies the altered meaning or unsupported universal schedule.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Task · classroom example
Use an AI-generated summary of a school notice as a draft. The final summary must preserve the event time, audience and any conditions. The original notice remains available.
Useful checking actions
Compare each important claim with the notice. Mark missing details as unknown. Check any claimed quotation word for word. Do not assume a fluent paragraph is verified.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the routine.
Complete or match: First identify…; For each claim, compare it with…; For a detail absent from the notice…
- a: important factual claims
- b: the original notice
- c: state that it is not provided
- d: invent a likely answer
The routine checks evidence and keeps gaps visible.
5B · Open ended
Propose a two-step checking routine and an example of a claim you would verify.
Example of a full-credit answer: First list the summary’s time, audience and conditions. Then compare each with the notice, correcting mismatches and marking absent details unknown; for example, check whether the listed start time matches.
- Proposes a concrete comparison of important claims with the original source.
- Includes a way to correct or flag unsupported details, with a relevant example.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.1 · Personal
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Choose reading for your own goal
Hana’s plan
Hana has twenty minutes before lunch and wants to make something with paper. She has paper and a pencil.
Hobby guide
Folded name card: paper and pencil; about ten minutes. Painted model house: cardboard, paint and glue; about an hour.
Question: Which activity fits Hana’s situation?
Answer: The folded name card fits her available materials and twenty-minute period.
Why: Personal reading helps us make decisions for our own needs. The more colourful model house is not automatically the best choice. Hana must match both the time and the materials, rather than choose using the title alone. She can save the longer activity for another occasion.
Example 2 · Read a condition before making a promise
Borrowed game note
You may borrow the animal-card game this weekend. Keep all thirty cards together. Return it to Aunt May before Sunday dinner because she needs it on Monday.
Miko’s idea
Miko wants to lend half the cards to a friend until Monday.
Question: Does Miko’s idea fit the note?
Answer: No. It separates the cards and would prevent the complete game being returned before Sunday dinner.
Why: The note contains conditions, not just permission to borrow. Miko should read them before promising the cards to someone else. This is a personal decision because it affects his plan and responsibility for a borrowed item. A suitable alternative is to invite the friend to play while keeping the complete set together.
Example 3 · Change a plan when relevant details change
Earlier family message
After breakfast we will draw outside beside the garden.
Later family message
The ground is wet. We will still draw after breakfast, but use the covered balcony. Please bring the same drawing materials.
Question: What should a reader change in the plan?
Answer: Change the location to the covered balcony; keep the after-breakfast time and the same drawing materials.
Why: An update may replace one detail while leaving the others intact. Comparing the two messages prevents either ignoring the change or unnecessarily changing everything. Here the wet ground explains the new location, while the later message explicitly preserves the timing and materials.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Pick a suitable home activity
Your goal
You want a quiet activity before a family call in fifteen minutes. You have a book and pencil, but no glue.
Activity list
Reading challenge: read a short page and note a favourite sentence; ten minutes. Paper mobile: cut and glue shapes; forty minutes.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which plan fits all the stated conditions?
- a: Start both activities and finish them together.
- b: Choose the mobile and wait for glue to arrive.
- c: Read a page and note a favourite sentence.
- d: Begin the forty-minute glued paper mobile.
The reading challenge is quiet, uses available materials and fits the fifteen-minute period.
Source explorer: compare
F2 · Use a personal checklist
Nina’s sketch-walk note
Meet your cousin at the corner after lunch. Bring a small notebook and a pencil. Your cousin will bring drinking water for both of you. Leave the large paint set at home.
F2 · Multiple answers
Which two things should Nina pack according to the note?
- a: A pencil
- b: The large paint set
- c: Water for the whole group
- d: A small notebook
The note assigns the notebook and pencil to Nina; the cousin supplies water and the paint set stays home.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Read your own reminder
Wednesday
Finish the last chapter before returning the book.
Thursday
Return the book to Uncle Jo.
Friday
Tell my cousin whether I enjoyed the ending.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the plan from the reminder.
Complete or match: Finish the last chapter by ___.; Return the book on ___.
- a: Wednesday
- b: Thursday
- c: Friday
Reading comes before the Thursday return. The Friday conversation is a separate task.
Source explorer: timeline
F4 · Find the detail that affects your choice
Game guide
This paper-and-pencil game needs two players. Each player takes a turn drawing one line. The game ends when the grid is full.
Your situation
You are choosing a game to play alone while waiting for a friend.
F4 · Hotspot
Which detail shows that this game does not fit the current plan?
- a: It needs two players.
- b: It uses pencil lines.
- c: It ends when the grid is full.
The required second player is absent. The equipment and ending do not resolve that mismatch.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Explain a personal reading choice
Lia’s goal
Lia wants to practise drawing an animal before bedtime. She has ten minutes and only paper and a pencil.
Guide A
Draw a cat using five simple shapes. Materials: paper and pencil. Estimated time: eight minutes.
Guide B
Make a painted animal mask. Materials: card, string, paint and glue. Estimated time: fifty minutes.
F5 · Short answer
Which guide should Lia use now? Give a reason that connects its requirements to her situation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Lia should use Guide A. It takes about eight minutes and needs only the paper and pencil she has, so it fits her ten minutes before bedtime.
- Chooses Guide A, the five-shape cat drawing.
- Connects at least one specific requirement accurately to Lia’s situation: the eight-minute time fits ten minutes, or the paper-and-pencil materials are available.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Invitation · classroom example
Nico invites classmates to a paper-craft afternoon on Saturday, 2–3 p.m., at the covered community room. Bring a pencil. Paper and scissors will be provided by the adult organiser.
Personal plan
Aya is free from 1:30 to 3:30 and owns a pencil. Her old note from another event says to bring coloured paper, but this invitation does not require it.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each invitation detail to the plan it supports.
Complete or match: Saturday, 2–3 p.m.; Covered community room; Bring a pencil
- a: Where Aya should go
- b: What Aya should take
- c: When Aya should attend
Each detail answers a different personal-planning question.
1B · Short answer
Explain why Aya can plan to attend without buying coloured paper for this event.
Example of a full-credit answer: The event fits her free time, and the invitation says paper will be provided. She needs to bring her pencil, not follow an unrelated older note.
- Uses the event time and personal availability to establish fit.
- Uses the current supplied-materials instruction rather than the old note.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Activity cards · classroom example
Paper bird: 15 minutes; one sheet of paper and a pencil. Painted box: 45 minutes plus drying time; a box, paint and brush. Bead chain: 25 minutes; beads and string.
Reader situation
Mira has 20 minutes before leaving and has paper and a pencil. She has no beads, paint or brush.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete the reasons for a suitable choice.
Complete or match: Activity that fits both needs; Time fact supporting it; Materials fact supporting it
- a: Paper bird
- b: 15 minutes is within 20
- c: Paper and pencil are already available
- d: Paint will dry immediately
The bird fits both the available time and materials without invented conditions.
2B · Open ended
Justify the choice using both kinds of information, not only what looks enjoyable.
Example of a full-credit answer: The paper bird takes 15 minutes, less than the 20 available, and it uses materials Mira already has. The other tasks take longer and need missing supplies.
- Uses the time constraint correctly.
- Uses the available-materials constraint correctly.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
School outing note · classroom example
For an indoor museum visit, bring a water bottle and a notebook. Large sports equipment should stay at school. The group will not use the outdoor field.
New personal situation
Jules remembers taking a ball on a previous park trip. This time Jules wants to pack for the museum visit described in the current note.
3A · Matching
Match each item to its status for this visit.
Complete or match: Water bottle; Notebook; Ball
- a: Requested for recording observations
- b: Not requested; sports equipment stays at school
- c: Requested for drinking water
The current indoor-visit note specifies two items and excludes sports equipment.
3B · Short answer
Explain the reading strategy Jules should transfer from packing for one trip to another.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the new trip’s instructions and purpose each time. Bring the bottle and notebook for this museum visit rather than copying the old park packing list.
- States the strategy of checking current purpose/instructions.
- Applies it to the required and excluded items.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
First message · classroom example
“Meet me by the garden gate at 4 p.m.,” writes a cousin on Monday.
Latest message
On Tuesday the cousin writes, “The garden gate is closed. Let us meet by the library entrance instead. Four o’clock is still fine.”
Reader’s mistake
A pupil changes the time to Tuesday at noon because the latest message arrived during lunch.
4A · Multiple choice
What meeting plan is supported?
- a: Library entrance at 4 p.m.
- b: Garden gate at noon
- c: Library entrance whenever the message arrived
- d: Garden gate at 4 p.m. despite the closure
The update changes the place and explicitly keeps four o’clock.
4B · Open ended
Explain the mistake and the two details the pupil should record.
Example of a full-credit answer: Arrival time of a message is not the meeting time. Record the library entrance as the new place and 4 p.m. as the unchanged time.
- Identifies the message-arrival/event-time confusion.
- States the correct changed place and unchanged time.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
New invitation · classroom example
A story-making session is Sunday, 10–11 a.m., at the youth room. Bring a notebook. The invitation says an adult will lead the session but does not explain how to request a place.
Planning goal
Create a checklist that uses the confirmed details and identifies what still needs asking. Do not invent a booking method.
5A · Multiple answers
Select all sensible checklist entries.
- a: Note Sunday, 10–11 a.m., youth room
- b: Ask the organiser how to request a place
- c: Assume every reader already has a confirmed place
- d: Invent a password that the invitation never requests
A good plan uses the stated arrangements and asks about the missing joining process.
5B · Short answer
Propose a brief personal plan and one question you would ask before attending.
Example of a full-credit answer: Set aside Sunday 10–11 and prepare a notebook for the youth room. Ask the organiser whether a place must be booked and how to do so.
- Uses relevant confirmed time/place/material details.
- Asks a necessary unanswered question without inventing an arrangement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.2 · Educational
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Notice what the school task asks you to do
Class task
Compare the two story characters. Give one way they are alike and one way they differ. Use a detail from the story for each comparison.
Lea’s first idea
Lea plans to copy the whole first paragraph and colour a border.
Question: What should Lea do to meet the reading task?
Answer: Find a supported similarity and a supported difference between the characters.
Why: The word compare directs the work. Copying a paragraph may preserve the story’s words, but it does not necessarily show a comparison. A coloured border can decorate the page, yet it cannot replace the requested thinking. Lea can check her draft against the two requirements before spending time decorating it.
Example 2 · Use a success guide to improve an answer
Success guide
A useful learning-journal entry names one difficulty and explains a strategy that helped.
First draft
Today’s puzzle was hard. I liked the blue pieces.
Added sentence
Sorting the edge pieces first helped me find the outline.
Question: How does the added sentence improve the entry?
Answer: It names a strategy, sorting edge pieces, and explains how it helped with the difficulty.
Why: School reading includes using instructions and success guides to check our own work. The first draft mentions difficulty but does not show what helped. The new sentence supplies that missing part. A strong revision responds to a stated requirement rather than simply making the answer longer.
Example 3 · Turn feedback into a specific next step
Pupil’s answer
The second character is helpful.
Teacher feedback
Add an action from the story that shows the character helping someone.
Story detail
The character carries a neighbour’s dropped books back to the gate.
Question: What revision answers the feedback?
Answer: The character is helpful because they carry the neighbour’s dropped books back to the gate.
Why: The teacher asks for evidence, so the revision connects the judgement to a particular action. Changing the lettering or adding more praise would not supply that evidence. This makes feedback useful: read what is missing, locate the relevant source detail, then add the connection the reader needs.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Meet the task requirements
Reading response task
Write a short response to the story. State the main problem and describe one action that helps solve it. You do not need to retell every event.
F1 · Multiple answers
Which two things must the response include?
- a: The story’s main problem
- b: An action that helps solve the problem
- c: Every sentence copied from the story
- d: A drawing of every minor character
The instruction names the problem and a helpful action. It explicitly says a complete retelling is unnecessary.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F2 · Read action words carefully
Identify
Name or point out the requested feature.
Compare
Explain a similarity or difference between two things.
Infer
Use clues to work out an idea that is not directly stated.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each task to its action word.
Complete or match: Name the narrator.; Explain how the two endings differ.; Use actions to work out how the narrator feels.
- a: Infer
- b: Identify
- c: Compare
Naming identifies, examining a difference compares, and using clues about an unstated feeling infers.
Source explorer: source tabs
F3 · Follow the stages of a school task
Monday
Read a partner’s draft and write one useful comment.
Tuesday
Revise your own draft using feedback.
Wednesday
Hand in the revised response with the earlier draft.
F3 · Dropdown selection
Complete the classroom work plan.
Complete or match: Revise your own response on ___.; Hand in both versions on ___.
- a: Tuesday
- b: Wednesday
- c: Monday
Tuesday is the revision stage. Both the revised response and earlier draft are handed in on Wednesday.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F4 · Choose feedback that helps the learning goal
Goal
Explain why the story’s ending fits its earlier events.
Draft answer
I like the ending because it is nice.
F4 · Hotspot
Select the feedback that best helps this answer meet the goal.
- a: Name an earlier event and connect it to the ending.
- b: Use your favourite colour for the heading.
- c: Make every letter twice as large.
The first comment adds a reason based on the story; the others change presentation rather than the requested explanation.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Use the checklist to revise
Task checklist
Explain one way the setting affects a character’s action. Use one detail from the passage.
Passage
Rain began during the outdoor puppet practice. Niko carried the paper puppets under the shelter to keep them dry.
Draft
The setting is outdoors.
F5 · Open ended
Write a revised answer that explains the setting’s effect and uses a passage detail.
Example of a full-credit answer: The rainy outdoor setting makes Niko move the puppets under the shelter. He carries them there to keep the paper dry.
- Explains that rain/the outdoor conditions lead Niko to move or protect the puppets.
- Uses the concrete detail of carrying the paper puppets under the shelter to keep them dry.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Task card · classroom example
Compare two classroom plants. Describe one similarity and one difference you can observe. Include a labeled sketch of each. Do not claim one grows faster unless you have measurements over time.
Available observations
Plant A has broad leaves and is 18 cm tall. Plant B has narrow leaves and is 18 cm tall. Both are in labeled pots.
1A · Drag and drop
Match each observation to the assignment role it can fill.
Complete or match: Both are 18 cm tall; Broad versus narrow leaves; No repeated growth measurements
- a: Observable difference
- b: Limit on a growth-rate claim
- c: Observable similarity
Equal height is a similarity; leaf shape differs; a single observation cannot establish growth rate.
1B · Open ended
Write a comparison that meets the evidence requirement without inventing growth information.
Example of a full-credit answer: Both plants are 18 cm tall. Plant A has broad leaves while B has narrow leaves. These observations do not show which grows faster.
- States a supported similarity and difference.
- Avoids or explicitly limits an unsupported growth-rate conclusion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Project rubric · classroom example
A good explanation names an answer, uses two observations and explains how those observations support it. Pictures may help, but decoration is not a substitute for evidence.
Draft response
“The covered spot is better for reading.” The draft includes a bright border but no observations about the spots compared.
2A · Hotspot
Select the rubric region that identifies the draft’s main missing element.
- a: Names an answer
- b: Uses two observations and explains how they support it
- c: Pictures may help
The draft states a position but supplies no observed support or connection.
2B · Short answer
Explain what the pupil should add and why a brighter border would not solve the problem.
Example of a full-credit answer: Add two relevant observations, such as noise or shade, and explain how they support the choice. A border changes appearance but gives no evidence.
- Identifies relevant observations and a reasoning connection as needed.
- Explains why decoration does not meet the evidence criterion.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier task · classroom example
In science, “explain your choice” means connect the answer to evidence, rather than repeat the chosen word.
New reading task
Choose which passage heading fits and explain why. Passage: pupils repaired books, sorted shelves and made clear borrowing labels so classmates could find materials more easily.
Heading choices
A: Making the reading area easier to use. B: A story about winning a race. C: Learning to cook outside.
3A · Multiple choice
Which response best transfers the explanation skill?
- a: A, because it is A
- b: A, because repairs, sorting and labels all improve access to reading materials
- c: B, because racing is exciting
- d: C, without referring to the passage
The response selects the fitting heading and connects several details to its meaning.
3B · Open ended
Give your own explanation of the heading using two passage details.
Example of a full-credit answer: The heading about easier use fits because sorted shelves help people find books and clear borrowing labels help them know how to take materials.
- Selects or states the fitting central heading idea.
- Connects at least two relevant passage details to that idea.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Teacher feedback · classroom example
“Your poster identifies the water-use problem clearly. Add where your figures came from and explain how the proposed action addresses the problem.”
Pupil’s interpretation
“I must erase the whole poster and choose a different topic.” The teacher did not request a new topic.
4A · Multiple answers
Select all changes the feedback actually asks for.
- a: Add the source of the figures
- b: Explain the connection between action and problem
- c: Replace the topic with an unrelated one
- d: Remove the clearly identified problem
The feedback preserves the clear problem and asks for two specific improvements.
4B · Short answer
How can the pupil revise efficiently while responding to both requests?
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep the current problem, add a source label for the figures, and write how the proposed action would reduce the stated water-use problem.
- Keeps the valid existing focus rather than inventing a new task.
- Addresses both source attribution and the action-to-problem explanation.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Assignment · classroom example
Create a short report comparing two playground areas. Use the provided observations, include one advantage and one limitation for each, and finish with a recommendation for quiet reading.
Work conditions
A draft is due Tuesday; the final report is due Friday. No new outdoor measurement is required. The evidence sheet is already supplied.
5A · Matching
Match each checklist item to the requirement it checks.
Complete or match: Evidence from the sheet; Advantages and limitations for both areas; Tuesday draft and Friday final
- a: Both work stages
- b: A fair comparison
- c: Use of the given observations
The checklist should cover evidence, balanced comparison and deadlines.
5B · Open ended
Propose a three-step work plan that preserves the comparison and recommendation.
Example of a full-credit answer: Read the observations and note an advantage and limitation for each area. Draft the comparison and evidence-based quiet-reading recommendation by Tuesday. Revise and check the criteria before Friday.
- Plans a comparison using both areas and supplied evidence.
- Includes a reasoned recommendation and the staged deadlines.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.3 · Occupational
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read an order as a set of requirements
Museum gift-counter order
Order for a class visit: six blue postcards and four green postcards. Put them in two separately labelled bundles.
Worker’s plan
Prepare ten postcards in one mixed bundle.
Question: What does the worker need to correct?
Answer: Prepare six blue and four green postcards, then separate and label the two bundles.
Why: A workplace order specifies more than a total. Ten postcards satisfies the count, but a mixed bundle ignores the colour grouping and labels. Reading all the requirements helps the worker prepare what the customer actually requested. Checking the finished work against the original order is more reliable than remembering only the largest number.
Example 2 · Ask about information that is missing
Plant-shop work note
Place the seed packets in the display trays. The note gives no instruction about whether to group them by plant name or planting month.
Situation
Both arrangements are possible, and the worker wants to follow the manager’s plan.
Question: What should the worker do before choosing the arrangement?
Answer: Ask the manager which grouping is required.
Why: A workplace instruction can leave a decision unstated. Making up a requirement and presenting it as certain could cause unnecessary rework. The useful reading skill is to identify the exact missing information and ask a focused question. Here the worker can ask whether the trays should be arranged by plant name or planting month.
Example 3 · Make a handover distinguish done from pending
Theatre preparation record
Costume labels have been printed. Three labels have been attached. Seven labels are still waiting on the table. The next worker starts after lunch.
Question: What should the handover tell the next worker?
Answer: All labels are printed, three are attached, and seven still need attaching.
Why: A clear handover separates different stages of a job. “The labels are finished” would hide the remaining work because printing is not the same as attaching. Stating both the completed part and the next action helps another worker continue accurately without repeating tasks or overlooking the seven waiting labels.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Follow the café’s written order
Order ticket
Customer order: three apple snack pots and one banana snack pot. Pack the apple pots in one bag and the banana pot in another.
F1 · Multiple choice
Which preparation follows the whole ticket?
- a: Two apple pots together; two banana pots separate.
- b: Three banana pots together; one apple pot separate.
- c: Three apple pots and one banana pot in one bag.
- d: Three apple pots together; one banana pot separate.
Separating three apple pots from one banana pot matches both the quantities and the packing instruction.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Check when an item is ready for collection
Toy-repair desk instructions
Mark an item ready for collection only when its safety check is complete and its owner label is attached. A booked collection time alone does not make an item ready.
F2 · Multiple answers
Which two conditions are needed before staff mark an item ready?
- a: The item has a bright colour.
- b: Its safety check is complete.
- c: Its owner label is attached.
- d: A collection time has been booked.
Both the completed safety check and the attached owner label are required. The other details do not satisfy those conditions.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F3 · Read a stock record
Stock record
Item: folded paper bags. Available: twenty-four. Next action: order more when only six remain.
F3 · Matching
Match each field to its information.
Complete or match: Item; Current quantity; Reorder point
- a: Six remaining
- b: Folded paper bags
- c: Twenty-four available
The record distinguishes what is stored, how many are available now and when another order is needed.
Source explorer: table lab
F4 · A draft is not an approval
Earlier message
The exhibition label has been drafted.
Later work note
The supervisor still needs to check and approve the wording before printing.
F4 · True or false
Staff may treat the label as approved for printing because a draft exists.
- true: True
- false: False
The work note states that checking and approval are still required. A draft completes only an earlier stage.
Source explorer: compare
F5 · Write an accurate handover
Book-cover repair record
Four covers need protective sleeves. Two have sleeves fitted. Two sleeves are cut and waiting beside the remaining books.
Handover purpose
The next worker needs to know what is finished and what to do next.
F5 · Short answer
Write a short handover that gives the completed work and the remaining task.
Example of a full-credit answer: Two covers already have protective sleeves fitted. Fit the two cut sleeves to the remaining two books.
- States that sleeves are fitted on two covers/books.
- States that two remaining books still need their already-cut sleeves fitted.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Order record · classroom example
Order 24: Hill Class; 30 black-and-white A5 programmes; collect Thursday. Order 25: River Club; 20 colour A4 posters; collect Friday.
Work request
The printer’s assistant is asked to prepare Hill Class’s programmes. A5 is the requested paper size; no change has been authorised.
1A · Multiple choice
Which preparation note matches the request?
- a: 30 black-and-white A5 programmes for Thursday
- b: 20 colour A4 posters for Friday
- c: 30 colour posters with any size
- d: Hill Class’s order is already collected
It matches the customer, product, quantity, size and collection date.
1B · Short answer
Name two fields you would verify before confirming the order note.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check that Hill Class needs 30 programmes and that they are black-and-white on A5 paper; also check Thursday collection.
- Verifies the correct item/quantity or customer identity.
- Verifies another distinct relevant field such as format, size or collection day.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Librarian’s message · classroom example
Prepare the three requested books for Class D. Two are on the shelf. The third is due back tomorrow. Tell the teacher the set is ready only after all three are checked and packed.
Current status
The two available books have been packed. The third has not returned. No substitute title has been authorised.
2A · Hotspot
Select the message region that determines whether the teacher can be told the set is ready.
- a: Prepare three requested books
- b: Tell the teacher only after all three are checked and packed
- c: The third is due back tomorrow
The stated readiness condition requires all three, not merely the available two.
2B · Open ended
What should the librarian report now, and why?
Example of a full-credit answer: Two books are packed and the third is still awaited. The set is not yet ready because all three must be checked and packed before confirmation.
- Accurately reports partial completion and the missing book.
- Applies the all-three readiness condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier work skill · classroom example
When reading an order, match the correct identifier and then check every needed field. Do not borrow a detail from a neighbouring row.
Community delivery records
Parcel P: Reading Room, 4 paper boxes, west entrance. Parcel Q: Art Room, 2 paint boxes, east entrance. The adult courier is asked about Parcel P.
3A · Drag and drop
Match Parcel P’s fields to the correct values.
Complete or match: Destination; Contents and quantity; Entrance
- a: West entrance
- b: Reading Room
- c: 4 paper boxes
Every selected detail belongs to Parcel P, not Q.
3B · Short answer
Explain how checking the identifier first reduces a possible mix-up.
Example of a full-credit answer: It keeps the Reading Room’s four paper boxes and west entrance together. Without it, someone might take the Art Room’s east entrance from the other record.
- Explains using P to keep its fields together.
- Identifies a plausible cross-row mix-up prevented by the method.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Repair-desk log · classroom example
Display stand: received Monday. Inspection completed Tuesday. Replacement base requested Wednesday; not yet received. Final stability check: not yet done.
Draft handover
“The stand is fully ready because inspection is complete.” The work instruction requires the replacement base and final check before return.
4A · True or false
The handover correctly marks the stand ready for return.
- true: True
- false: False
Inspection is only one stage; the replacement and final check are still required.
4B · Open ended
Rewrite the handover so the next adult knows the true status.
Example of a full-credit answer: Inspection is complete, but the replacement base and final stability check are still pending. Do not return the stand as ready yet.
- Preserves the completed inspection accurately.
- Names remaining requirements and avoids premature readiness.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Office task · classroom example
An adult prepares activity packs for two groups. Group A needs 12 packs Thursday; Group B needs 8 Friday. All packs are assembled, but the office must check each group’s label before release.
Note purpose
The next adult needs quantities, collection days and the remaining label check. Do not mark release authorised before the check.
5A · Dropdown selection
Choose the correct content for the handover.
Complete or match: Group A; Group B; Before release
- a: 12 packs, Thursday
- b: 8 packs, Friday
- c: check each group label
- d: assume any label is acceptable
The note must preserve both orders and the outstanding condition.
5B · Short answer
Propose a concise handover note with a clear distinction between done and still required.
Example of a full-credit answer: Packing is complete: Group A has 12 for Thursday and Group B 8 for Friday. Before releasing either set, check its group label.
- Accurately states both groups’ quantities/days or completed packing.
- Clearly keeps label verification as a required next step.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.4 · Community
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Include the people a community decision affects
Neighbourhood suggestion
Move the shared noticeboard inside the hall so rain cannot reach it.
Residents’ comments
The hall is locked most evenings. Several residents can visit only after work. The noticeboard is currently readable from the outside path.
Question: What important problem should the group consider?
Answer: An indoor board could be unavailable to residents who can visit only when the hall is locked.
Why: A community plan affects people with different routines. Protecting notices from rain is useful, but that benefit does not remove the need for access. Reading the comments together helps the group identify a condition a revised plan must meet, such as keeping important information visible from outside when the hall is closed.
Example 2 · Check whose views a survey represents
Shared courtyard survey
A volunteer asked twelve visitors on Saturday morning which games they preferred. Nine chose board games.
Community use
Other residents use the courtyard on weekday evenings and were not asked.
Question: Can the survey establish what all courtyard users prefer?
Answer: No. It reports the choices of the twelve Saturday-morning visitors, not every user.
Why: The result can still be useful if its scope is stated accurately. People who visit at other times may have different needs. A stronger community consultation could invite views at more times and in more ways. We should not replace missing opinions with guesses or assume a small group speaks for everyone.
Example 3 · Read the exact limit of a service change
Community-centre notice
On Thursday, the craft room closes for shelf repairs. The centre’s foyer and information desk remain open during normal hours.
Neighbour’s message
The whole centre will be closed on Thursday.
Question: How should the message be corrected?
Answer: Only the craft room closes; the foyer and information desk remain open during normal hours.
Why: A community notice can affect several services differently. The neighbour’s message turns a limited closure into a complete one. Checking the named spaces helps residents make accurate plans. The correction should preserve the real disruption while also telling people which services they can still use.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Understand different community needs
Arman
I visit after work, when the hall is locked. I need to read notices outside.
Bea
Small print is difficult for me to read. Larger lettering helps.
Cora
I want to find notices quickly without walking around parked bicycles.
F1 · Matching
Match each resident to the change that directly answers their comment.
Complete or match: Arman; Bea; Cora
- a: Larger, clear lettering
- b: An unobstructed path to the board
- c: A noticeboard readable outside opening hours
Each proposal addresses the specific access issue the resident names.
Source explorer: perspective
F2 · Use the local borrowing rules
Community puzzle shelf
Borrowing is open on Tuesday and Saturday. A household may borrow one puzzle at a time. Return it at the next opening before choosing another puzzle.
Family plan
A family borrows a puzzle on Tuesday.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the family’s plan.
Complete or match: The next opening is ___.; The household may have ___ puzzle borrowed at a time.
- a: Saturday
- b: one
- c: three
Saturday is the next listed opening after Tuesday, and the rule limits each household to one puzzle.
Source explorer: document lens
F3 · Improve a community consultation
Current consultation
Only people attending an afternoon meeting were asked about the community reading corner.
People not reached
Some residents work that afternoon. Others cannot attend in person but can send a short note.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two actions would broaden participation?
- a: Count the same meeting votes twice.
- b: Treat silence as agreement with the plan.
- c: Offer a way to send a written comment.
- d: Ask again at a different time of day.
Written comments and another time let additional residents contribute. Recounting or assuming agreement does not add their views.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F4 · Make a community trial measurable
Action
For one week, place a clearly labelled return tray beside the community game shelf.
Reason
Last week, several returned games were left on chairs where others could not find them.
Check
Count how many returned games are left on chairs during the trial week.
F4 · Drag and drop
Match each part of the trial to its job.
Complete or match: What the group will try; Why the trial is proposed; How the group will check it
- a: Count returned games left on chairs.
- b: Add a labelled return tray for a week.
- c: Games were left where others could not find them.
A useful trial states an action, its reason and an observable result to examine.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F5 · Choose a plan that respects shared use
Shared-room schedule
A quiet reading group uses the room from two until three. After three, the room is available for a music rehearsal.
Plan A
Start the music rehearsal at half past two in the same room.
Plan B
Start the music rehearsal at three after the reading group finishes.
F5 · Open ended
Recommend a rehearsal plan and explain how it respects the other community group.
Example of a full-credit answer: Choose Plan B and begin at three. The reading group can use its full quiet period until three, and the rehearsal uses the room after that period.
- Recommends Plan B or explicitly starts rehearsal at three or later within the stated availability.
- Explains that this preserves the reading group’s quiet use from two until three.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: compare
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Room notice · classroom example
The community centre offers Room A for quiet reading, 2–4 p.m., and the covered court for group games at the same time. The hallway must remain clear for people entering both spaces.
Reader needs
One group wants to read quietly. Another wants an active game. Both groups should use the assigned spaces without blocking shared access.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all plans that follow the notice.
- a: Readers use Room A
- b: Game players use the covered court
- c: Store equipment across the hallway
- d: Hold a loud game in the quiet reading room
The two activities have assigned spaces, and the hallway must stay clear.
1B · Open ended
Explain how following the room assignments helps both groups.
Example of a full-credit answer: Readers get the quiet space and game players get the active space. Keeping the hallway clear lets both groups reach their areas.
- Recognises the different space needs of readers and players.
- Explains the shared-access benefit of a clear hallway.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Survey summary · classroom example
A proposal to close the park at 4 p.m. cites a survey of 20 morning visitors. Fifteen said they usually left before 4 p.m.
Other viewpoint
An after-school group says it arrives at 4:30 p.m. Its members were not present during the morning survey. The park’s current closing time is 6 p.m.
2A · Dropdown selection
Complete a careful interpretation.
Complete or match: The survey directly describes…; A group not represented was…; Before claiming broad agreement, organisers should…
- a: the morning visitors surveyed
- b: the after-school users
- c: seek views from later users too
- d: assume everyone leaves before four
A morning-only sample does not establish all users’ preferences.
2B · Short answer
Why does the after-school viewpoint matter even though most surveyed visitors leave early?
Example of a full-credit answer: Those surveyed visit at a different time. Closing at four would affect the after-school group that was not represented, so its needs should be considered.
- Identifies the survey’s time-based coverage limitation.
- Explains the closure’s different effect on the missing group.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Neighbourhood notice · classroom example
For a community book exchange, leave the entrance clear, label donated books by age range and put damaged books on the separate repair table.
New setting
A school toy exchange wants to use the same organising principles. It has an entrance, age-range labels and a table for toys needing an adult’s check.
3A · Matching
Match the organising principle to a suitable toy-exchange action.
Complete or match: Keep access open; Help people find suitable items; Separate items needing attention
- a: Use age-range labels
- b: Keep the entrance free of boxes
- c: Place toys needing checking on the adult-check table
The practical principles transfer even though the objects change.
3B · Open ended
Explain one transferred rule and how it would help the new event.
Example of a full-credit answer: Keep boxes away from the entrance so visitors can enter and leave easily. This uses the same shared-access principle as the book exchange.
- Proposes a correct action in the new toy-exchange setting.
- Explains the shared organising purpose that transfers.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Original notice · classroom example
The community centre’s kitchen is closed Tuesday for a pipe repair. The reading room and front desk remain open. Wednesday opening will be confirmed after the repair check.
Forwarded message
“The entire centre is shut forever.”
4A · Hotspot
Select the region that directly disproves the claim that every part is closed.
- a: Kitchen closed Tuesday
- b: Reading room and front desk remain open
- c: Wednesday opening will be confirmed
The notice explicitly identifies spaces that remain open.
4B · Short answer
Write a corrected community update that keeps both known facts and uncertainty clear.
Example of a full-credit answer: Only the kitchen is closed Tuesday for repair; the reading room and front desk remain open. The kitchen’s Wednesday opening awaits confirmation.
- Correctly limits Tuesday’s closure and names open areas.
- Preserves the uncertainty about Wednesday rather than inventing a reopening.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Shared problem · classroom example
Children want space for a reading circle; gardeners need access to water taps. The proposed reading mats would block the only path to the taps.
Available option
A shaded corner beside the path has space for a small circle without covering the path. No one has yet tested whether it stays quiet during gardening.
5A · Multiple choice
Which proposal best addresses both needs?
- a: Keep the mats across the tap path
- b: Try the shaded corner, keep the path open and check noise during a short trial
- c: Ban all gardening without discussion
- d: Claim the corner is always quiet without testing
It uses available space, preserves access and investigates the unresolved noise issue.
5B · Open ended
Propose a short trial and one observation that would help decide whether to continue.
Example of a full-credit answer: Hold a reading circle in the shaded corner for one gardening session while keeping the tap path clear. Note whether readers can hear and gardeners can reach water without interruption.
- Proposes a feasible arrangement respecting both reading and tap access.
- Gives an observation that tests the arrangement’s effect on the users.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.5 · National
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read a countrywide notice with local details
Fictional national programme notice
A story-poster programme is open to participating schools across the country. Each school chooses its own display day.
Local school note
Our school will display its posters on Friday.
Question: Does Friday become the display day for every school?
Answer: No. Friday is this school’s day; the national notice lets each participating school choose.
Why: National reading often connects a wide programme with local arrangements. The two sources do not conflict: one sets the general rule and one applies it locally. Keeping their scopes separate prevents a detail about one school from being presented as a rule for the whole country.
Example 2 · Keep a national report’s unit clear
Fictional distribution update
A learning-kit project delivered two hundred boxes to twenty centres. Each box contains several booklets. The update does not state the number of children who received a booklet.
Question: Can the report tell us that two hundred children received booklets?
Answer: No. Two hundred counts boxes, not children.
Why: Large projects may report deliveries, centres, materials or people, and these units mean different things. The number of children would require additional information about booklet counts and distribution. A careful reader can repeat the known delivery figure without turning it into an unsupported statement about how many children were reached.
Example 3 · Distinguish a national proposal from a decision
Fictional consultation notice
A committee proposes a yearly countrywide storytelling week. It invites comments before making a final recommendation. No start date has been approved.
Headline draft
Storytelling Week Starts Next Monday!
Question: Why does the headline need revision?
Answer: The programme is still a proposal, and no starting date has been approved.
Why: A proposal describes something people are considering. The headline turns that possibility into an announced event and adds a date absent from the notice. A more accurate headline could say that a committee is seeking views on a storytelling-week proposal. This preserves the distinction between discussion and an approved decision.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Locate the scope of a national report
Fictional project update
A reading-material pilot invited centres across several regions. The results below describe only the twenty-seven volunteer centres that sent records.
Result
Those centres reported receiving their first parcels.
F1 · Hotspot
Which phrase limits the result’s coverage?
- a: Across several regions
- b: Only the twenty-seven volunteer centres that sent records
- c: Their first parcels
The second phrase names the reporting group. An invitation across regions does not mean every centre supplied results.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Read the stage of a countrywide plan
Fictional announcement
A plan to create audio versions of learning booklets is being considered. A committee will examine costs next month. No recordings have yet been released.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which summary accurately describes the plan?
- a: Audio booklets are proposed; none are released yet.
- b: Audio booklets are finished and available everywhere.
- c: Every school already received all audio recordings.
- d: The committee rejected audio booklets last month.
The announcement describes a proposal under consideration and explicitly states that recordings have not been released.
Source explorer: headline lab
F3 · Make a national resource accessible locally
Fictional resource notice
The programme offers downloadable stories and printed copies through participating centres.
Local situation
Some families have no reliable internet connection. The local centre receives printed copies every week.
F3 · Multiple answers
Which two responses are supported by these sources?
- a: Keep the download option for families who can use it.
- b: Say that all families must have internet to participate.
- c: Claim that the programme offers only online stories.
- d: Tell families that printed copies are available at the centre.
The notice supports both formats. Printed copies address the stated access problem while downloads remain an available option.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · One place does not represent every place
Fictional local report
At one island school, twenty pupils preferred the audio story to the printed story.
Limits
The report gives no results from other schools or regions.
F4 · True or false
This report proves that pupils in every region prefer audio stories.
- true: True
- false: False
The evidence concerns one school. It cannot establish the preferences of all pupils across all regions.
Source explorer: evidence lens
F5 · Join a national option with a local need
Fictional programme guide
Participating schools may use online story packs or request printed packs from their district office.
Local class note
The class wants to join, but its internet connection is unreliable. Its teacher can collect a pack from the district office on Thursday.
F5 · Short answer
Give a suitable participation plan and explain which local need it addresses.
Example of a full-credit answer: The teacher can request a printed story pack and collect it from the district office on Thursday. Printed materials let the class participate despite its unreliable internet connection.
- Uses the printed-pack option through the district office, consistent with the teacher’s collection opportunity.
- Explains that this addresses unreliable internet while allowing the class to participate.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: network
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Fictional national circular · classroom example
The Republic Reading Week programme invites all schools to hold one reading event during 1–7 November. Each school chooses its own day. Printed activity sheets are available for schools that cannot use the online pack.
Local school plan
Hill School chooses 3 November. Bay School has not yet announced its date. This is an invented classroom policy example, not an actual government rule.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported by the circular.
- a: Schools may choose a day within 1–7 November
- b: A printed option is available
- c: Every school must use Hill School’s 3 November date
- d: Only schools with internet may participate
The circular permits local dates within the week and supplies a non-online option.
1B · Short answer
Explain why Hill School’s date should not be reported as every school’s date.
Example of a full-credit answer: The circular lets each school choose within the week. Hill School chose 3 November, while Bay School’s date is still unannounced.
- Identifies the local-choice rule.
- Uses the different announcement status to limit the national claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Fictional national report · classroom example
A reading survey sampled 40 schools across four regions. It reports that 30 sampled schools offered a weekly reading club. It does not claim to include every school in the country.
What is counted
The unit is schools, not pupils. The report gives no separate counts of pupils attending each club.
2A · Matching
Match each reported detail to its meaning.
Complete or match: 40 schools; 30 schools; No pupil counts
- a: Limits what can be said about individual attendance
- b: Size of the school sample
- c: Sampled schools offering a weekly club
School counts describe the sample and services, not individual participation.
2B · Open ended
Why is “30 pupils attended clubs nationwide” an inaccurate summary?
Example of a full-credit answer: Thirty counts schools offering clubs in the sample, not pupils. The report gives neither pupil attendance nor a count of all schools nationally.
- Correctly identifies the school unit and sampled scope.
- Explains that pupil attendance is not provided.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional museum network notice · classroom example
Participating museums will offer one free school-group visit each month. Groups must request a date from their chosen museum and wait for confirmation. Local capacity differs.
Local planning question
A teacher wants to take a class to the coastal museum. The national notice does not list that museum’s available dates.
3A · Hotspot
Select the notice region that tells the teacher the next planning step.
- a: One free school-group visit each month
- b: Request a date from the chosen museum and wait for confirmation
- c: Local capacity differs
The notice requires a local request and separate confirmation.
3B · Short answer
How should the teacher combine the national information with local checking?
Example of a full-credit answer: Use the national offer as the starting point, then ask the coastal museum for available dates and wait for confirmation before treating a visit as booked.
- Uses the national offer without inventing local availability.
- Includes the local request and confirmation requirement.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Feature story · classroom example
A reporter describes a mobile library trial in one mountain town. Twenty households used it during the first month. The article notes that neighbouring towns have not yet tried the service.
Headline draft
“Every household in the country now has a mobile library.”
4A · True or false
The feature story supports the headline’s countrywide claim.
- true: True
- false: False
The story concerns twenty households in one town’s trial and explicitly limits coverage.
4B · Open ended
Write a fair headline and explain the scope correction.
Example of a full-credit answer: “One mountain town trials a mobile library.” This names the local trial instead of claiming service for every household nationally.
- Proposes a headline consistent with the local trial.
- Explains the difference between observed local coverage and universal national coverage.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Planning goal · classroom example
A fictional national reading campaign should reach schools with different access to internet. Some can download material quickly; others receive printed deliveries once a month.
Constraints
Use the same core reading activity for fair participation. Allow schools enough preparation time and state where they can request the appropriate format.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete a practical campaign plan.
Complete or match: Core activity; Delivery formats; Preparation timing
- a: the same reading task for all participating schools
- b: online and printed versions
- c: allow for slower printed delivery
- d: online access only
The plan keeps a common task while responding to different access conditions.
5B · Short answer
Propose two plan features that support participation without changing the core task.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer the same activity as a download and a printed pack, with a clear request contact. Announce it early enough for monthly deliveries so schools can prepare.
- Provides equivalent accessible formats or a clear way to request them.
- Addresses preparation time or delivery differences while preserving the common activity.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.6 · Scientific
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Separate an observation from an explanation
Class observation note
There are small wet footprints on the floor beside an open doorway.
Suggested explanation
Someone may have walked in from the wet courtyard.
Question: Which statement is directly observed, and which is an explanation?
Answer: The wet footprints are the observation. Someone coming from the courtyard is a possible explanation.
Why: Scientific reading distinguishes what was recorded from what might account for it. The footprints provide evidence, but the note does not show who made them or where that person came from. A cautious explanation uses words such as may until more evidence is available, instead of presenting one possible cause as certain.
Example 2 · Read both a number and its unit
| Sponge | Water held (mL) |
|---|---|
| A | 12 |
| B | 18 |
Class test record
In the same test, sponge A held twelve millilitres of water and sponge B held eighteen millilitres. Both pieces were the same size.
Draft conclusion
Sponge B held six grams more water.
Question: What needs correcting in the conclusion?
Answer: The difference is six millilitres, because the recorded measurement is water volume in millilitres.
Why: Subtracting twelve from eighteen gives six, but the unit must still match what was measured. The report gives no mass measurements in grams. Scientific reading requires checking labels as well as arithmetic so that a correct numerical difference does not become a different, unsupported claim.
Example 3 · Look for a fair comparison
Draft investigation
A class wants to compare how two paper shapes float. Shape A uses a small sheet in a shallow tray. Shape B uses a large sheet in a deep bucket.
Possible revision
Use equal-sized sheets of the same paper and test both shapes in the same tray with the same water depth.
Question: Why is the revision more useful for comparing shape?
Answer: It keeps paper size, paper type and test conditions alike while the folded shape changes.
Why: When several conditions differ, a result cannot clearly show which difference mattered. The revision makes the comparison easier to interpret. It does not guarantee a particular outcome; the class must still observe, measure and report what actually happens.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the parts of an investigation
Question
Which of two card ramps lets the same toy car travel farther?
Method
Release the same car without pushing from the top of each ramp; measure its travel distance.
Result
From ramp A it travelled sixty centimetres; from ramp B it travelled seventy-five centimetres.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each report section to its job.
Complete or match: Question; Method; Result
- a: Reports the measured travel distances.
- b: Explains how the comparison was carried out.
- c: States what the class wants to find out.
The question sets the purpose, the method describes the test and the result records what happened.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F2 · Keep a conclusion within the evidence
Classroom test
Three trials counted how many counters each paper platform held. Platform P held eight, ten and nine. Platform Q held five, seven and six. Only these two platforms were tested.
F2 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is supported by all three trials?
- a: Both platforms held equal numbers in every trial.
- b: P held more counters than Q in each trial.
- c: Q held more counters than P in each trial.
- d: Every paper platform holds exactly seven counters.
For each trial, P’s count exceeds Q’s. These results concern the two tested platforms.
Source explorer: table lab
F3 · Find a measured result
Prediction
The darker card will feel warmer.
Recorded measurement
After the test, card A is twenty-six degrees Celsius and card B is twenty-nine degrees Celsius.
Proposed explanation
The cards may absorb light differently. This explanation still needs investigating.
F3 · Hotspot
Select the recorded measurement.
- a: The darker card will feel warmer.
- b: Card A is 26 °C and card B is 29 °C.
- c: The cards may absorb light differently.
The temperature statement reports measured values. The other statements predict or suggest an explanation.
Source explorer: claim board
F4 · Do not invent a missing result
Trial record
Paper rotor A took four seconds to fall. The timer was not started for rotor B, so B has no recorded time.
Purpose
The class wants to compare the falling times.
F4 · Dropdown selection
Complete the evidence check.
Complete or match: The recorded time for rotor A is ___.; The falling time for rotor B is ___.
- a: four seconds
- b: not recorded
- c: zero seconds
A has a measured four-second result. A missing measurement for B is not the same as a zero-second fall.
Source explorer: document lens
F5 · Suggest a test that answers the question
Question
Does folding this paper strip help it support more counters?
Available materials
Several identical paper strips, the same two supports and a set of identical counters.
Proposed comparison
One strip can be left flat and another folded. The supports can be kept the same distance apart.
F5 · Open ended
Describe a fair comparison and state the result you would record.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare a flat and a folded strip made from identical paper, using the same supports and gap. Add the same kind of counters and record how many each strip holds before it bends or falls.
- Compares flat and folded strips while keeping the paper and support arrangement/gap alike.
- Records a comparable outcome for both strips, such as the number of identical counters held before the same failure condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Classroom investigation · classroom example
A class placed equal amounts of water in two identical uncovered dishes. Dish A sat by a sunny window; dish B sat on a shaded shelf. After one afternoon, A had less water remaining.
Report note
The class measured the water levels but did not measure temperature or air movement. This is one classroom trial.
1A · True or false
The report directly observes less water remaining in dish A, but it does not measure every possible reason for that difference.
- true: True
- false: False
Water level was measured, while temperature and air movement were not.
1B · Open ended
State the observation and one reason to keep the explanation cautious.
Example of a full-credit answer: Dish A had less water left after the afternoon. The class did not measure temperature or air movement and ran only one trial, so it should not claim a fully isolated cause.
- States the correct observed comparison.
- Uses an unmeasured factor or single-trial limit to justify caution.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Paper strength test · classroom example
The class compared two paper types using strips of equal width and length. They added identical clips one at a time until each strip tore. Each type was tested three times.
Results
Type A held 4, 5 and 4 clips. Type B held 7, 6 and 7 clips. The report concerns these paper types under this classroom method.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all features that help make the comparison interpretable.
- a: Equal strip dimensions
- b: Identical clips added one at a time
- c: Different strip widths for every trial
- d: Ignoring all trials in which a strip tears early
Dimensions and loads are kept comparable; selectively ignoring results would distort the record.
2B · Short answer
Explain how the results support a limited conclusion about the tested papers.
Example of a full-credit answer: Type B held more clips in each of its trials than Type A did in any trial. This supports greater strength for these strips under this method, not every possible paper use.
- Uses the repeated result pattern accurately.
- Limits the claim to tested materials/conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Warm afternoon 1 · classroom example
During the first visit to the garden pond, pupils saw dragonflies on a warm afternoon. The log records sightings for this visit only; it does not establish what happens on every warm day.
Warm afternoon 2
During a second warm-afternoon visit, pupils again saw dragonflies at the pond. This is another recorded observation, not a count of all dragonflies in the area.
Warm afternoon 3
On the third warm-afternoon visit, dragonflies were seen again. The three afternoon observations took place in warm weather.
Rainy morning
On one rainy-morning visit, no dragonflies were seen. Both the time of day and weather differed from the afternoon visits. The log contains these four visits and no other observations.
3A · Dropdown selection
Complete the careful interpretation.
Complete or match: What the log records; What it does not establish; Useful additional evidence
- a: no sighting on one rainy morning
- b: dragonflies never visit on rainy days
- c: more observations at comparable times in different weather
- d: a permanent rule from one absence
One absence in one differently timed visit cannot establish a universal pattern.
3B · Open ended
Explain how you would transfer the paper-test habit of fair comparison to further pond observations.
Example of a full-credit answer: Observe for the same length of time at comparable times of day in different weather, recording sightings each time. That reduces the timing difference while checking whether the pattern repeats.
- Proposes repeated relevant observations with comparable timing/duration.
- Explains how the plan addresses a limitation of the original log.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Two reports · classroom example
Report A says a seedling was 8 centimetres tall. Report B says another was 70 millimetres tall. The conversion note says 10 millimetres equals 1 centimetre.
Reader’s claim
“Seventy is bigger than eight, so the second seedling is taller.”
4A · Matching
Match each measurement to its equivalent or correct interpretation.
Complete or match: 8 centimetres; 70 millimetres; Comparing 70 and 8 without units
- a: 70 mm is 7 cm
- b: Ignores different measurement units
- c: 8 cm is 80 mm
Converting to a common unit shows the first seedling is taller.
4B · Short answer
Correct the comparison and explain why the original reasoning failed.
Example of a full-credit answer: Eight centimetres is 80 millimetres, which is greater than 70 millimetres. The reader compared numbers expressed in different units.
- Gives an accurate common-unit comparison.
- Explains that the mistake was ignoring units.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Reading observation · classroom example
Two same-sized cloths were left in different places and dried at different speeds. The report did not record air movement, and each place was tested only once.
Planning goal
Propose a classroom follow-up that explores air movement while keeping cloth type, starting wetness and observation time similar. An adult will arrange the equipment.
5A · Drag and drop
Match each plan element to its role.
Complete or match: Air movement condition; Cloth type and starting wetness; Water remaining after equal time
- a: What should stay similar
- b: What will be compared
- c: What will be recorded
The plan separates the changed factor, comparison conditions and measured outcome.
5B · Open ended
Propose a follow-up in two or three sentences and say what result would be recorded.
Example of a full-credit answer: Use similar cloths with the same starting wetness in two adult-arranged air-movement conditions. After equal time, measure water remaining and repeat the comparison.
- Changes air movement while keeping relevant cloth/wetness/time conditions similar.
- Records a relevant outcome and/or repeats the comparison without inventing results.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.7 · Environmental
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Keep an environmental result tied to its measure
Classroom reuse record
On Monday the class put twelve clean, one-sided sheets into a reuse tray. On Tuesday it put in eight. The sheets were counted, not weighed.
Draft summary
The class saved twenty kilograms of paper.
Question: How should the summary be corrected?
Answer: The class collected twenty sheets for reuse across the two days; their mass was not measured.
Why: An environmental claim still needs the right unit and a clear description of what happened. Counting sheets does not establish their mass, or prove every sheet was later reused. The record is useful evidence when reported accurately, without adding measurements or outcomes that were never observed.
Example 2 · Separate an environmental goal from a result
School project plan
The class wants fewer snack wrappers left on its courtyard path. It will place a labelled wrapper bin near the exit and count litter each afternoon.
Current stage
The bin has not yet been placed, and no new counts have been made.
Question: Can the class already say the project reduced litter?
Answer: No. Reducing litter is the goal; the class still needs results after the plan begins.
Why: A sensible action can be worth trying without having a proven effect in advance. Reading the project stage prevents a hopeful statement from becoming a claim of success. The proposed counts will help the class check its result, while other changes, such as different visitor numbers, may also matter.
Example 3 · Consider practical trade-offs
Garden proposal
Plant a seedling in each of six pots to add greenery beside the reading corner.
Conditions
The corner is used every afternoon. Pots must not block the walkway. A volunteer can water them each morning but is away on weekends.
Question: What must the plan address before it begins?
Answer: It needs a place for the pots that keeps the walkway clear and someone to cover weekend watering.
Why: An environmental idea has practical conditions as well as hoped-for benefits. The sources identify two needs without showing that either has already been solved. A useful response keeps the goal while arranging access and care. Simply adding more pots would not answer the problems the reading reveals.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the measured environmental result
School garden record
During one supervised cleanup, a group counted eighteen plastic wrappers along the east fence. It did not measure their mass or survey the rest of the neighbourhood.
F1 · Hotspot
Select the result the record actually supports.
- a: Eighteen plastic wrappers counted along the east fence
- b: Eighteen kilograms removed from the whole neighbourhood
- c: All plastic litter permanently removed from the school
The record gives a wrapper count for one fence during one cleanup. It supplies no mass or whole-area result.
Source explorer: document lens
F2 · Read a project’s different stages
Goal
Reduce unused handout copies at the club desk.
Action
Ask the leader how many pupils are attending before making copies.
Evidence to collect
Count unused copies after each meeting for four weeks.
F2 · Drag and drop
Match each detail to its role in the project.
Complete or match: What the project hopes to improve; What the group will do; What the group will record
- a: Ask for the expected attendance before copying.
- b: Count unused copies after each meeting.
- c: Reduce unused handout copies.
A goal, an action and a measurement are related but are not the same part of a project.
Source explorer: sequence lab
F3 · Read a cautious environmental conclusion
First week
The same classroom bin contained twenty disposable cups after the Friday club.
Second week
It contained twelve disposable cups after the Friday club. The number of visitors was not recorded.
F3 · Multiple choice
Which conclusion is best supported?
- a: The club has permanently stopped all disposable waste.
- b: Exactly eight visitors stopped using disposable cups.
- c: The recorded cup count fell from twenty to twelve.
- d: Every visitor used fewer cups during the second week.
The counts show eight fewer cups in that bin. Without visitor records, the sources do not show individual behaviour or a permanent outcome.
Source explorer: compare
F4 · A goal is not a completed measurement
Campaign poster
Our goal is zero litter beside the community bench.
Monitoring note
The volunteers will begin counting litter beside the bench next Monday. No before-and-after results are available yet.
F4 · True or false
The poster proves that there is already zero litter beside the bench.
- true: True
- false: False
The poster states a goal. The monitoring note says the evidence needed to assess progress has not yet been collected.
Source explorer: headline lab
F5 · Propose a small evidence-based check
Observed problem
Snack wrappers are often left beside the club exit after meetings.
Possible action
The club can place a clearly labelled wrapper bin beside the exit for the next three meetings.
Checking conditions
Compare wrapper counts from the same area after meetings. Record attendance too, because meeting sizes can differ.
F5 · Short answer
Describe a small trial and explain what evidence would help judge whether the area becomes less littered.
Example of a full-credit answer: Place the labelled wrapper bin by the exit for three meetings. Count wrappers in the same area after meetings before and during the trial, and note attendance when comparing the counts.
- Proposes the labelled bin beside the club exit for the stated trial, or a similarly specific feasible action addressing wrappers there.
- Uses comparable wrapper counts from the same area before/during the trial, with attendance considered or another justified way to keep comparisons fair.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Classroom beach report · classroom example
Volunteers collected 8 bags of litter from a marked 200-metre beach section on Saturday. The report does not record bag weights or litter beyond the marked section.
Proposed summary
“Eight bags were collected from the marked section.” Another reader suggests changing it to “All ocean pollution has been removed.”
1A · True or false
The report supports the limited eight-bag summary but not the claim that all ocean pollution was removed.
- true: True
- false: False
The observation concerns a defined section and bag count only.
1B · Short answer
Identify two limits that prevent the larger claim.
Example of a full-credit answer: The volunteers covered only a marked 200-metre section, and the record counted eight bags without measuring pollution elsewhere or all forms of pollution.
- Identifies the limited area sampled/cleaned.
- Identifies the limited measure or missing wider pollution evidence.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
School resource notes · classroom example
Paper team: counted unused sheets left after printing. Water team: measured litres used at a refill station. Garden team: recorded the number of surviving seedlings after one month.
Reading goal
Each team should describe the quantity it actually measured rather than borrow another team’s unit.
2A · Matching
Match each claim topic to the relevant measurement.
Complete or match: Printing leftovers; Water volume; Seedling survival
- a: Number of seedlings still alive
- b: Number of unused sheets
- c: Litres recorded
The correct unit depends on what the team observed.
2B · Open ended
Why would “The paper team saved ten litres” not follow from its record alone?
Example of a full-credit answer: The paper team counted sheets, not water volume. A claim in litres needs additional relevant evidence rather than changing units without support.
- Identifies the actual sheet-count measure.
- Explains the missing evidence needed for a different water-volume claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Earlier plan · classroom example
A class reduced discarded paper cups by offering reusable cups and arranging collection and washing. The report treated cleaning arrangements as part of the plan.
New proposal
A school wants reusable lunch containers for a shared event. It has a collection point but has not assigned washing or checked whether enough containers are available.
3A · Multiple answers
Select all useful checks before the new plan is used.
- a: Who will clean the returned containers?
- b: Are enough suitable containers available?
- c: Can the word reusable replace all planning?
- d: Should missing containers be ignored?
Collection alone does not establish cleaning capacity or enough containers.
3B · Short answer
Explain how the earlier cup plan helps improve the container proposal.
Example of a full-credit answer: It shows that reuse needs a complete system. The new plan should assign cleaning and confirm enough containers as well as providing a collection point.
- Transfers the idea of planning the full reuse cycle.
- Applies it to the missing cleaning and availability arrangements.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Before — busy sports day · classroom example
Before adding the new sign, the class counted 12 pieces of litter on a busy sports day. It used the same marked garden area and counting method later used for the after-sign observation.
After — quiet rainy day
After adding the sign, the class counted 4 pieces of litter on a quiet rainy day. The area and counting method were unchanged. A draft conclusion says, “The sign alone caused the litter count to fall.”
4A · Hotspot
Select the evidence region that identifies another possible explanation for the count change.
- a: Same areas and counting method
- b: Busy sports day compared with quiet rainy day
- c: The class used a new sign
Different visitor activity and weather could affect the litter count independently of the sign.
4B · Open ended
Revise the conclusion and suggest a better comparison.
Example of a full-credit answer: Litter was lower on the second day, but the days differed in activity and weather. Compare several similar days before and after the sign to investigate its effect more fairly.
- Preserves the observed reduction while rejecting an isolated-cause claim.
- Proposes more comparable or repeated observations addressing the confounding conditions.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Class problem · classroom example
Many worksheets are printed but never used. The class wants to test whether asking pupils which sheets they need reduces unused copies.
Trial constraints
Keep the lesson type and class size similar across the comparison. Count unused sheets at the end of each lesson. Do not claim measured water or energy savings from sheet counts alone.
5A · Dropdown selection
Complete the trial plan.
Complete or match: Change to test; Outcome to count; Condition to keep similar
- a: asking which sheets are needed before printing
- b: unused printed sheets
- c: lesson type and class size
- d: all global resource use
The plan aligns a specific change with a directly measured local outcome.
5B · Short answer
Propose a short trial and an honest way to report its result.
Example of a full-credit answer: Compare similar lessons before and after asking which sheets are needed, counting unused copies each time. Report the sheet-count difference and any limits, without claiming unmeasured water or energy savings.
- Defines a relevant before/after trial with comparable conditions and sheet counts.
- Proposes reporting within the actual measure’s scope.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.8 · Financial
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Read what a price applies to
Shop label
Erasers: three in a pack. Price: thirty pesos per pack.
Purchase plan
Dina wants two packs.
Question: What will Dina receive and pay?
Answer: She will receive six erasers and pay sixty pesos.
Why: The label has two different numbers: three describes the contents of one pack and thirty describes the price of one pack. Buying two packs doubles both the contents and the pack price. Reading the unit beside each number prevents mistaking the pack price for the price of a single eraser or treating the contents as money.
Example 2 · Distinguish a spending plan from a receipt
Before shopping
Rafi plans to spend fifty pesos on a sketchbook and twenty pesos on a pencil.
Receipt
Sketchbook: forty-five pesos. Pencil: fifteen pesos. Total paid: sixty pesos.
Question: Which source tells how much Rafi actually spent?
Answer: The receipt records sixty pesos actually paid; the earlier plan was seventy pesos.
Why: A budget helps us plan, while a receipt records the completed purchase. The two figures can differ without either document being meaningless. Reading their purposes helps Rafi compare his expectation with the result. He should use the receipt when recording actual spending and keep the plan if he wants to see how accurate his estimate was.
Example 3 · Notice the full cost of an offer
Offer A
One craft kit costs fifty pesos at the school stall. Collection has no extra charge.
Offer B
The same kit costs forty pesos from a seller, with a fifteen-peso delivery charge for this order.
Question: Which offer has the lower stated total for one kit?
Answer: Offer A totals fifty pesos; Offer B totals fifty-five pesos, so A costs five pesos less.
Why: The lower item price does not necessarily give the lower full cost. The delivery condition matters because it applies to this order. This comparison uses only the stated charges and the same item quantity; it does not invent discounts or assume that a delivery fee disappears.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Read the lines of a receipt
Craft-shop receipt
Coloured paper packs: three packs at twelve pesos per pack. Line total: thirty-six pesos. No other item is listed.
F1 · Drag and drop
Match each number to its receipt meaning.
Complete or match: Three; Twelve pesos; Thirty-six pesos
- a: Price per pack
- b: Number of packs
- c: Total cost for the packs
Three counts packs; twelve pesos prices each pack; thirty-six pesos is the total for all three.
Source explorer: table lab
F2 · Compare money planned with money spent
Money available
Luca has sixty pesos for a school craft purchase.
Receipt
Luca spends forty-eight pesos on the required materials. No other purchase is made.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete Luca’s spending record.
Complete or match: Money actually spent: ___ pesos.; Money remaining: ___ pesos.
- a: 48
- b: 12
- c: 60
The receipt records forty-eight pesos spent; sixty minus forty-eight leaves twelve.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · Read the condition behind a price headline
Workshop advertisement
Entry to the paper-craft display is free. Joining the optional craft-making activity costs twenty pesos for its materials.
Your plan
You want to make a craft item, not only view the display.
F3 · Hotspot
Which detail must be included when planning the cost of making a craft item?
- a: Entry to the display is free.
- b: The optional craft-making materials cost twenty pesos.
- c: The advertisement uses a colourful heading.
The free entry covers viewing. The source states a separate material cost for making an item.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Use a complete purchase total
Price list
Drawing pad: thirty-five pesos. Pencil set: twenty pesos. Carry bag: five pesos if requested.
Order
Mara buys the pad and pencil set and uses her own bag.
F4 · Multiple choice
What total follows Mara’s order?
- a: Sixty pesos, including a requested carry bag.
- b: Thirty-five pesos, charging only for the pad.
- c: Twenty-five pesos, omitting the drawing pad.
- d: Fifty-five pesos, with no carry-bag charge.
The pad and pencil set cost thirty-five plus twenty, or fifty-five pesos. Mara has not requested the five-peso bag.
Source explorer: source tabs
F5 · Make a plan within the stated budget
Budget
A pupil has seventy pesos and needs paper and a pencil for a project.
Shop offer
A basic kit containing both paper and a pencil costs fifty-five pesos. Decorative ribbon is optional and costs twenty pesos extra.
F5 · Open ended
Recommend a purchase within the budget. Explain why adding the ribbon would or would not fit.
Example of a full-credit answer: Buy the basic kit for fifty-five pesos, which supplies both required items and leaves fifteen pesos. Adding the ribbon would cost seventy-five pesos altogether, exceeding the seventy-peso budget.
- Chooses the basic kit without the optional ribbon and shows that it meets the required materials within seventy pesos.
- Explains that fifty-five plus twenty is seventy-five pesos, so adding the ribbon would exceed the budget.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Offer label · classroom example
Set of coloured paper: ₱40. Delivery fee: ₱15 per order. Collection is not available. The price covers one set of 20 sheets.
Reader need
A pupil has a fictional ₱50 budget and needs one set. No other offers or discounts are stated.
1A · Hotspot
Select the label region that must be added to the item price to check the budget.
- a: Set of coloured paper: ₱40
- b: Delivery fee: ₱15 per order; no collection
- c: One set contains 20 sheets
Delivery is required, so the payable total includes the ₱15 fee.
1B · Open ended
Explain whether the stated budget covers the offer and which detail decides it.
Example of a full-credit answer: The total is ₱55, so ₱50 is not enough. The required delivery fee must be added to the ₱40 price.
- Accounts correctly for the full ₱55 total and budget.
- Explains that delivery is unavoidable under the stated terms.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Offer A · classroom example
Three plain notebooks for ₱60, collected at the school fair. No extra fee. Each notebook has the required lined pages.
Offer B
Three decorative notebooks for ₱50, plus a required ₱20 delivery fee. They also have lined pages. The buyer needs three lined notebooks and can collect at the fair.
2A · Multiple answers
Select all statements supported by the offers.
- a: Offer A totals ₱60
- b: Offer B totals ₱70 with delivery
- c: Offer B costs only ₱50 in total
- d: Decoration is a stated requirement
A has no fee; B includes a required fee; the need concerns quantity and lined pages.
2B · Short answer
Justify a cost-conscious choice without claiming that decoration is always worthless.
Example of a full-credit answer: Offer A meets the need for three lined notebooks and costs ₱60 compared with B’s ₱70. Decoration may matter to some buyers, but it is not required in this task.
- Compares the correct full costs and suitable contents.
- Distinguishes the stated need from optional preference without a universal claim.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Fictional event notice · classroom example
A class-show ticket costs ₱10 per visitor. A group pack covers four visitors for ₱32. The pack cannot be split into separate discounted tickets.
Planning situations
One family brings four visitors. Another person is attending alone. Everyone needs one admission; no other charges are listed.
3A · Matching
Match each statement to the correct interpretation.
Complete or match: ₱10 per visitor; ₱32 group pack; A person attending alone
- a: One ticket costs ₱10
- b: A single ticket fits the one-person need
- c: One pack covers four people together
The unit and grouping condition determine the suitable option.
3B · Open ended
Explain why the four-person family and the single visitor need not choose the same option.
Example of a full-credit answer: The family can use all four places in the ₱32 pack, which costs less than four ₱10 tickets. A single visitor needs only one ₱10 ticket and cannot buy one split pack place at a discount.
- Uses the family’s group size to interpret the pack.
- Uses the single visitor’s need and no-splitting condition.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Advertisement · classroom example
A bag originally priced at ₱100 is offered for ₱80 this week. It is optional for the class project; the learner already has a usable bag.
Budget note
The learner has ₱90 and needs ₱50 of required project materials. A mistaken note says, “Buying the bag adds the ₱20 discount to my money.”
4A · Drag and drop
Match each amount to its meaning.
Complete or match: ₱80; ₱20; ₱50
- a: Reduction from the old bag price
- b: Required project-material cost
- c: Money paid to buy the bag
A discount reduces the price compared with before; it is not income added to the budget.
4B · Short answer
Explain the budget error and a sensible decision for this task.
Example of a full-credit answer: The ₱20 is a price reduction, not money received. Buying the optional ₱80 bag would leave too little for the required ₱50 materials, so keeping the usable bag fits the stated needs.
- Explains discount versus actual money received/spent.
- Connects the decision to required materials and available funds.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Budget facts · classroom example
A class has a fictional ₱120 for a display. Required paper costs ₱50 and tape ₱30. Optional ribbon costs ₱25. A delivery charge is not yet known because the shop has not replied.
Planning rule
Do not promise purchases beyond the available amount or treat the unknown delivery fee as zero. Collection may be possible, but it has not been confirmed.
5A · Multiple choice
Which plan best handles the information responsibly?
- a: Assume delivery is free and spend everything
- b: Reserve for paper and tape, ask the delivery or collection cost, then decide whether ribbon fits
- c: Call the unknown fee zero in the budget
- d: Buy ribbon first and ignore required materials
It prioritises required items and resolves the missing cost before optional spending.
5B · Open ended
Propose a brief budget plan and the question that must be answered before finalising it.
Example of a full-credit answer: Set aside ₱80 for required paper and tape, leaving ₱40 before any fee. Ask the shop about delivery or confirmed collection, then buy ribbon only if the full total remains within ₱120.
- Accounts for required costs and remaining budget accurately.
- Preserves the unknown charge and conditions optional spending on the full total.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
R7.9 · Digital and online
Three worked examples
Example 1 · Choose a purposeful route through a page
Class webpage menu
Story library: complete stories. Activity guide: what to read and what to submit. Photo gallery: pictures of earlier projects.
Reading goal
You need to find the instructions for this week’s reading task.
Question: Which menu choice should you open first?
Answer: Open Activity guide, because its description matches the need for task instructions.
Why: Digital pages can offer many interesting links at once. A useful reading route begins with the question you need to answer and the label most likely to help. The gallery may show attractive work, but it is not described as the source of current instructions. Reading with a goal reduces unnecessary searching.
Example 2 · Read the label on a digital result
Result 1
School art-club guide: explains the club’s free paper-folding activities.
Result 2
Sponsored result: buy deluxe paper-folding sets. This is a shop advertisement.
Question
A pupil wants the club’s activity instructions.
Question: Which result better matches the question?
Answer: Result 1 matches the club and its activity guide more directly.
Why: The sponsored result is labelled as an advertisement for a product. That does not prove its statements are false, but its purpose differs from the pupil’s need. Selecting a relevant result requires reading the description and purpose, rather than assuming the first, brightest or paid-for result is the best answer.
Example 3 · Check a saved screen against a current source
Saved screenshot from Monday
The online class gallery opens on Friday.
Current organiser notice dated Wednesday
The gallery will open on Saturday instead of Friday. This replaces the earlier announcement.
Question: Which opening day should a reader use now?
Answer: Use Saturday, the day in the current replacement notice.
Why: A screenshot preserves what a page said at an earlier time. It may be an accurate record of an old announcement while no longer giving the current arrangement. Here the later source is from the organiser and explicitly replaces the earlier date. Both the timing and that stated connection justify using the update.
Formative quiz · 10 points
F1 · Find the right part of a digital learning page
Read
This section opens the full passage.
Instructions
This section explains what work to submit.
Help
This section explains how to use the page controls.
F1 · Matching
Match the question to the most useful page section.
Complete or match: Where can I read the complete story?; What work must I submit?; How do I enlarge the passage text?
- a: Help
- b: Read
- c: Instructions
The labels separate learning content, task requirements and help with the page controls.
Source explorer: network
F2 · Read an online update accurately
Earlier post
The class photo-gallery link will open on Tuesday, and comments will close on Thursday.
Replacement post dated today
The link now opens on Wednesday. Comments still close on Thursday.
F2 · Dropdown selection
Complete the current online schedule.
Complete or match: The gallery link opens on ___.; Comments close on ___.
- a: Wednesday
- b: Thursday
- c: Tuesday
The replacement changes the opening to Wednesday but explicitly keeps the Thursday comment deadline.
Source explorer: compare
F3 · A polished page still needs evidence
Webpage extract
A page with colourful graphics claims that the school has cancelled every club. It gives no date, named source or link to a school notice.
F3 · True or false
The colourful design is enough to verify that all school clubs are cancelled.
- true: True
- false: False
Appearance does not establish a claim’s evidence. A current, relevant school source is needed to check the announcement.
Source explorer: document lens
F4 · Check the destination, not just the result title
Search result title
Current instructions for the class book review.
Opened destination
The file is labelled Previous Term and describes last term’s assignment.
Other available link
The teacher’s page has a This Week section with a newly dated book-review instruction file.
F4 · Multiple choice
What is the most useful next reading step?
- a: Open the teacher’s current instruction file.
- b: Follow the old file because its title is short.
- c: Assume both assignments have identical rules.
- d: Use the search title without opening any file.
The opened destination is old. The teacher’s current file is the relevant next source for this week’s requirements.
Source explorer: search lab
F5 · Keep an online reading choice connected to its purpose
Class task
Read the teacher’s linked leaf-shape guide and identify the shape shown in the worksheet.
Unexpected pop-up
A separate game asks for your home address before offering a prize. It does not contain the leaf-shape guide.
Class rule
Do not enter personal details in unrelated pages; ask a trusted adult when unsure.
F5 · Short answer
Explain what you should read next and what you should do about the unrelated request.
Example of a full-credit answer: Continue with the teacher’s linked leaf-shape guide. Do not enter a home address in the unrelated game; close or leave it and ask a trusted adult if unsure.
- Chooses the teacher’s leaf-shape guide as the relevant source for the assigned reading.
- Avoids supplying the home address to the unrelated game and follows the stated class rule, such as leaving it or asking a trusted adult.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Source explorer: builder
Mastery and critical thinking · 20 points
Pair 1 · Applied Reasoning
Class page · classroom example
Heading: “Friday reading task.” Instructions: read the supplied story, note two clues about the character and write a short explanation. Due Friday. A link labeled “Story text” opens the passage.
Side panel
A bright box says “Win a new bicycle!” and asks visitors to open a separate promotion. It is labeled Advertisement and is not part of the class task.
1A · Multiple answers
Select all actions that directly help complete the class task.
- a: Open the supplied story text
- b: Find two character clues and explain them
- c: Enter the bicycle promotion instead of reading
- d: Treat every side-panel instruction as homework
The task specifies the story and evidence response; the advertisement has another purpose.
1B · Short answer
Explain how labels and the task goal help you ignore the distraction.
Example of a full-credit answer: The page labels the bicycle panel as an advertisement, while the task asks for story clues and an explanation. The story link and instructions directly serve that goal.
- Uses the advertisement/task distinction in the page labels.
- Connects chosen actions to the stated homework purpose.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 2 · Justify Choice
Event website · classroom example
The home page welcomes visitors and links to three documents. Programme: event times. Access guide: step-free entrances and facilities. Booking guide: how to request and confirm a place.
Visitor needs
A family wants the puppet-show time, a step-free route and confirmation of whether places must be requested.
2A · Matching
Match each need to the best source.
Complete or match: Puppet-show time; Step-free route; Place-request process
- a: Booking guide
- b: Programme
- c: Access guide
Each source is designed for a different part of the visitor’s plan.
2B · Open ended
Why would reading only the home-page welcome leave this family’s plan incomplete?
Example of a full-credit answer: The welcome introduces the event but the linked programme, access guide and booking guide contain the needed time, route and joining conditions.
- Identifies at least two missing practical details.
- Explains that relevant linked sources, not the welcome alone, supply them.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 3 · Transfer Application
Saved screenshot · classroom example
An old class-page screenshot lists the assembly in the courtyard at 8 a.m. It was saved last week.
Current update
Today’s school notice says the assembly moves to the covered court because of rain. The 8 a.m. time is unchanged. The notice names the school office as issuer.
3A · Hotspot
Select the current notice region that changes what a pupil should do.
- a: School office issued today’s notice
- b: Assembly moves to the covered court
- c: The 8 a.m. time is unchanged
The new location is the action-changing detail; the start time remains the same.
3B · Short answer
Explain the plan a pupil should make and why the screenshot is insufficient.
Example of a full-credit answer: Go to the covered court at 8 a.m. The screenshot preserves last week’s courtyard location, while today’s office notice explicitly updates it.
- Gives the current place and unchanged time.
- Explains the older screenshot versus newer confirmed update.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 4 · Error Analysis
Unexpected message · classroom example
A message using the club’s familiar colours says, “Enter your school-account password here to see the public chess timetable.” It arrived from an address the learner does not recognise.
Known information
The club normally publishes its timetable on the school noticeboard. No password is needed to read that public schedule. A teacher can confirm the correct page.
4A · True or false
The familiar colours are enough to prove that entering the password is necessary and appropriate.
- true: True
- false: False
Appearance is not verification, and a public timetable does not require the private password described.
4B · Open ended
What should the learner do, and which details support that decision?
Example of a full-credit answer: Do not enter the password. Ask the teacher through the known school route, because the address is unfamiliar and the public schedule normally needs no password.
- Avoids supplying the password and proposes a trusted verification route.
- Uses the unrelated private request or unfamiliar sender as evidence rather than relying on appearance.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.
Pair 5 · Design / Propose
Planning task · classroom example
Find the confirmed date, room and joining condition for a school coding session. Search results include an old flyer, a current school-calendar entry and a club page linking to the joining guide.
Source details
The current calendar gives the date and room. The joining guide says places must be confirmed by the adviser. The old flyer advertises last term’s session.
5A · Multiple choice
Which reading route best answers the task?
- a: Use only the old flyer because it is colourful
- b: Check the current calendar, follow the joining guide and confirm a place with the adviser
- c: Guess the room from the club logo
- d: Assume a search result is a confirmed booking
The route uses current schedule evidence and preserves the joining requirement.
5B · Short answer
Propose a short checklist for someone planning to attend.
Example of a full-credit answer: Check the current calendar’s date and room, read the joining guide, and ask the adviser for confirmation before treating a place as booked. Ignore last term’s flyer for current arrangements.
- Uses current sources for date/room and distinguishes the old flyer.
- Includes the separate adviser confirmation required to join.
0: Wrong, irrelevant or blank; neither requirement met. 1: One requirement met. 2: Both requirements met. Accept equivalent ideas and valid alternatives; exact wording is not required.