TEACHAID · 83 standalone modules
Climate Literacy · Teacher guide and answer keys
Age-adapted lessons, evidence exploration and reasoned climate decisions.
Start a lesson
- Extract the ZIP completely to a folder on the device. Open START_HERE.html in a current Chrome, Edge, Firefox or Safari browser. A file preview inside a ZIP is not the complete extracted package.
- Choose a topic. Each topic is a complete HTML file, so it can also be copied and opened on its own. There is no installation, local web server or account required to open the learning content.
- Read the consent screen with an appropriate adult. Select Region, Division and School; the school code fills automatically. Select the learner’s grade and enter the required learner and section identifiers. Continue only when the consent statement is understood and agreed.
- Work through the lesson and examples, try the formative quiz, and then complete the five mastery pairs. The final page shows scores and the separate saving and upload indicators.
The opening catalogue uses the same browser tab. Each learner module has all its code, images, school list and learning content embedded. An internet connection is needed for live AI feedback, written-response scoring and report delivery. Objective questions and simulations work without a connection.
What every module contains
| Part | Content and purpose |
|---|---|
| Concept lesson | Four pages with short explanations, familiar examples and a “try it” prompt. The language is designed for a learner around age 10. |
| Worked examples | Three separate question-and-answer examples explain both the result and the reasoning. The next section is the formative quiz. |
| Formative quiz | Five questions use five different formats: four different objective formats and one written response. The formative result is shown before mastery begins. |
| Mastery assessment | Five pairs, with one objective and one short-answer or open-ended question per pair. The five objective formats differ within the module. |
| Results | Formative score /10, mastery score /20, total /30, results by thinking level, and explicit local saving and server receipt states. |
The five thinking levels
| Level | What to listen for |
|---|---|
| Applied Reasoning | Uses the supplied facts to explain a situation or work out a result. |
| Justify Choice | Chooses among plausible options and explains the evidence or constraint behind the choice. |
| Transfer Application | Adapts an idea when a condition, place, resource or group changes. |
| Error Analysis | Identifies the specific problem in a claim or method and repairs it. |
| Design / Propose | Proposes a feasible action or investigation that satisfies the stated requirements. |
These are TEACHAID instructional dimensions requested for this collection. They are not official OECD proficiency levels. The CL identifiers organize the requested topics; the items are original classroom practice, not released PISA assessment items. PISA normally assesses 15-year-olds; this collection adapts the ideas for younger learners. The OECD page identifies the referenced framework as preliminary October 2025 material.
Use the workbenches as experiments
Ask learners to change one input, predict a result, run the model and compare their prediction with the result. The climate workbenches include energy balance, storage and flows, rainfall and runoff, electricity mixes, emissions, local heat, coastal water levels and data trends. Other interactions include maps, tables, budgets, evidence comparisons, claim sorting, sequences and community perspectives. Notebooks and saved comparisons help learners explain their thinking.
Assessment questions use the fixed data stated in their source cards. Moving a slider does not silently change an answer key. The models deliberately simplify the real world: their numbers are classroom assumptions, not local measurements, safety thresholds or forecasts. Show learners how a model helps answer a limited question and what it leaves out. For a mastery pair, explore the shared scene before answering part A and return to it when explaining part B.
Scoring and teaching decisions
Each item has a maximum of two points. A single-choice, true/false or hotspot response earns two points when correct and zero otherwise. A multiple-answer response earns two when every correct option and no incorrect option is selected; it earns one for a nonempty correct subset with no incorrect selection. A mapping earns two when all rows are correct, one when at least one row is correct, and zero when none is correct. For written work, each of the two topic-specific rubric criteria is worth one point; equivalent correct reasoning is allowed.
Use the formative responses to identify the next teaching step. For example, a learner who can name a lower-emission option but cannot explain the comparison needs work on evidence and justification. The five mastery pairs show differences among thinking skills that a total score can hide. Learner progression is not gated by a minimum score. For compatibility with the original dashboard reports, the combined percentage is classified as passing at 75% or above and below that threshold otherwise. That reporting classification does not establish durable mastery from one short activity. A teacher can review the attempt, revisit the lesson and use a new attempt after discussion.
Choice-list and mapping options are shuffled for a fresh attempt and kept stable within an attempt. True/false labels and hotspot diagrams retain their layout. Question-format plans vary among topics using a balanced seeded selection. Repeated attempts do not draw a new bank of questions; they practise the same authored concepts and tasks with newly ordered options.
AI feedback and written scoring
The feedback selector includes English, Filipino, Cebuano, Hiligaynon, Ilocano, Bikol, Waray, Kapampangan, Pangasinan, Maranao, Maguindanaon and Tausug. Lesson and question text is in English. Each selected language is sent explicitly to the feedback service. Feedback uses the current item, fixed evidence, answer key or rubric, and the learner’s actual response. It is available in the formative and mastery sections. Written responses are scored through the existing TEACHAID AI endpoint and labelled AI estimated score.
Live service limitation: the current service returned replies for all twelve language selections during transport checks, but some regional-language replies mixed languages or substituted another language. Basic mismatch checks reject certain detectable cases; they cannot certify translation quality. A partial-credit trial was also over-scored by the current AI service. Teachers should review written grades with the two-criterion rubrics below and check unfamiliar language with a fluent speaker. The modules retain this limitation in the learner feedback note and score labels. A successful HTTP response alone does not prove that an explanation or score is correct.
Written responses can be entered and saved offline. A nonblank response awaiting AI is left pending, never converted into an invented zero. Its completed performance reports wait for an actual score. Keep or reopen the activity with the same browser, location and learner details when a connection returns, before access expires on 31 May 2027. Pending written scoring cannot resume after the access cutoff. Empty submitted responses receive zero as omissions. Network failure shows a pending/retry state. Exact requests and response evidence are preserved with the attempt for review.
Consent, saving and reporting
The original TEACHAID consent workflow, embedded Region → Division → School directory and school-code mapping are preserved from the supplied reference modules. The school list is a bundled snapshot, not a live directory service. Access expires at the end of 31 May 2027 according to the device’s local clock. Frontlearners branding and the page watermark appear throughout. The encoded payload includes an integrity check, which helps detect accidental changes but is not a security boundary against a person editing the file or device clock.
Draft progress, answers, explored model settings and active item time are saved in persistent browser storage when the browser permits it. Time counts while the question is visible and active; time on lessons or in a hidden tab is excluded. Browser storage belongs to that browser and file location. Clearing it, using a different device, or moving the file can make the old local attempt unavailable. Keep the extracted folder in place until the reports are confirmed.
On submission the attempt is locked. The client saves the attempt and freezes three original CSV reports before sending them: completion, performance and item responses. The reports preserve the original learner, school, attempt identifier and content hash. Queued reports retry with their original data. A new learner or new attempt does not take ownership of a prior queued report.
| Last-page indicator | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Saved on this device | A durable local save has been verified. |
| Queued for upload · 0/3 confirmed | All reports are saved; no matching server receipts have been confirmed. |
| Partly uploaded · 1/3 or 2/3 confirmed | The stated number of reports has a matching receipt. Remaining reports stay queued. |
| Upload confirmed by teachaid.ph · 3/3 | The staging server has returned matching filename and SHA-256 receipts for all three reports. |
| Upload waiting for AI scores | Saved written responses still need AI scores before completed performance reports can be frozen. |
| Saving needs attention | Persistent local saving has not been verified. The module keeps retrying and does not send unsaved reports. |
An “OK” HTTP response with a wrong filename or hash does not count as uploaded. “3/3 confirmed” means receipt by the staging endpoint; it does not independently certify later dashboard ingestion or rendering. The live staging health route was reachable during verification. Upload-state tests used intercepted synthetic requests, so the test suite did not add fictional pupils to the server.
Climate-science guardrails
Weather and climate use different timescales. Natural greenhouse warming makes Earth habitable; additional greenhouse gases change the energy balance. Ocean warming and ocean acidification are distinct, and acidification means declining pH even while the ocean remains alkaline. Land ice adds water to the sea; floating sea ice has little direct effect on sea level. Extreme-event changes depend on the type and location; the lessons do not claim that every storm becomes more frequent. Migration and livelihoods have several causes. Mitigation, adaptation, fairness and costs are considered together, and political agreement is not a scoring criterion.
Primary-source links are included with each module and repeated in the answer guide. They support the scientific concepts; fictional classroom numbers are identified as illustrative. Real disaster and health actions should follow the responsible adults and local authorities identified in the lessons.
Topic answer keys and rubrics
Open a topic below. Source cards, question keys, worked examples and written-response criteria are included so a teacher can review the reasoning without inspecting code.
CL1.1 — Difference between weather and climate
Tell a short weather observation from a long climate pattern, and choose evidence that fits the question.
Worked examples
1. A sudden shower
Worked classroom example
Fictional observations: Tuesday is sunny at 9 a.m. and rainy at 2 p.m.
Question: Has the climate changed between those two times?
Answer: The observation shows changing weather.
Two measurements within a day describe an event. A claim about climate needs patterns over much longer periods.
2. A useful summary
Worked classroom example
In a made-up three-day exercise, temperatures are 27, 30 and 30°C.
Question: What is their average, and is it a climate normal?
Answer: The average is 29°C; it is not a climate normal.
Add 27 + 30 + 30 = 87 and divide by 3. Three days remain a short weather sample even after averaging.
3. Two rainy-season records
Worked classroom example
A fictional archive contains June rainfall for 30 years. A second card contains yesterday’s rain.
Question: Which source helps describe usual June rainfall?
Answer: The 30-year June archive.
It compares the same part of the year many times. Yesterday’s record can describe yesterday accurately but cannot represent all Junes.
Formative quiz
Sort the school records
Fixed evidence 1
Card A: wind measured at 10 a.m. today.
Fixed evidence 2
Card B: usual July rainfall calculated from 30 years.
1. Choose the category for each record.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Card A
- Card B
Available labels: Future guarantee | Weather observation | Climate summary
A is a single-time observation; B summarizes many years.
Choose a timescale
Fixed evidence 1
Tomorrow’s excursion needs a near-term rain forecast.
Fixed evidence 2
Long-term roof drainage planning uses many years of rain measurements and future risk information.
2. Match each decision to its most relevant evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Tomorrow’s excursion
- Long-term drainage
Available labels: Long records and future risk | One photograph of a cloud | Near-term rain forecast
Evidence must match the decision’s time scale.
A cool point
Fixed evidence 1
Classroom annual means for Years 1–5 are 26, 27, 28, 27 and 29°C.
Fixed evidence 2
These five points are practice data, not a real climate record.
3. True or false: the cooler Year 4 alone proves there is no upward pattern in this series.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Year 4 is lower than Year 3, but the full series ends 3°C above its start.
Useful climate questions
Fixed evidence 1
An imaginary school has 30 years of monthly rainfall and temperature records, plus today’s forecast.
4. Select all questions that the long record helps answer.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- How has the annual mean changed?
- Will it rain at 2 p.m. tomorrow?
- Will one cloud cross our gate?
- Which months are usually wettest?
Climate records help identify long-term patterns, not the exact timing of tomorrow’s weather.
Explain the headline
Headline
A chilly Monday proves warming has stopped.
Evidence
One local day can be cool while long-term global averages rise.
5. Explain why the headline is weak and name better evidence.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the mismatch between one day/local weather and long-term climate.
- Names suitable multi-year temperature evidence, preferably across locations.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Rain decisions
Fixed evidence 1
The class has a forecast for tomorrow and a 30-year monthly rain table.
Fixed evidence 2
A picnic is tomorrow; a new school garden must fit usual seasonal rainfall.
6. Match the decision with the more suitable starting record.
Matching · 2 points
- Picnic tomorrow
- Seasonal garden plan
Available labels: One undated photo | Tomorrow’s forecast | 30-year monthly archive
Short events need near-term weather information; seasonal planning needs climate context.
7. Explain why the garden needs the long record and one reason to still check current conditions.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects the long record with typical seasonal rainfall.
- Explains that present conditions can differ and also need checking.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Two reporting methods
Fixed evidence 1
For an imaginary town, Team A compares the same months across 30 years.
Fixed evidence 2
Team B compares one hot noon with one cool dawn.
8. Select all reasons to prefer Team A for a climate claim.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- It compares matching parts of the year.
- It removes all measurement error.
- It covers many years.
- It guarantees next Tuesday’s rain.
A longer, season-matched comparison fits climate; it does not guarantee weather or eliminate error.
9. Justify which team is more useful and identify a weakness of the other method.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Selects Team A for long, season-matched evidence.
- Identifies the time-of-day or very short sample problem in Team B.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a mountain school
Fixed evidence 1
A coastal school has 30 years of records.
Fixed evidence 2
A mountain school has only one week.
Fixed evidence 3
Their elevation and location differ.
10. True or false: the mountain school can adopt the coastal climate average as if it were its own measured climate.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Location and elevation matter; the coastal record is not a direct measurement at the mountain school.
11. What additional evidence should the mountain school seek, and why?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names longer local or comparable-site records.
- Explains why coastal and highland conditions need not match.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a graph claim
Fixed evidence 1
Practice annual means: Year 1 = 25, Year 2 = 26, Year 3 = 27, Year 4 = 26, Year 5 = 28°C.
Fixed evidence 2
Pia says: “Year 4 fell, so every year became colder.”
12. Select the statement that fits all five points.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Values varied; the endpoint rose
- Every year became hotter
- Every year became colder
- The values never changed
There is one fall and several rises; the last value is above the first.
13. Identify Pia’s error and replace her claim with an accurate description.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies cherry-picking one interval or the false “every year” claim.
- Correctly describes variability plus a higher final value.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Plan a class record
Observation task
Record weather for one month using the same place and time.
Climate task
Use a reliable longer archive to discuss usual patterns; do not call one month a 30-year climate normal.
14. Place each action under its purpose.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Consistent month-long measurements
- Reliable many-year archive
Available labels: Describe our month’s weather | Guarantee every future day | Investigate long-term climate
Both tasks are useful, but their claims have different time spans.
15. Propose a two-part investigation: one fair observation step and one honest climate-comparison step.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes consistent daily weather measurement.
- Uses longer climate evidence and does not label one month as an established climate.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.2 — Components of the climate system
Trace connections among air, oceans, land, ice and living things instead of treating climate as one separate part.
Worked examples
1. Name the connection
Worked classroom example
A fictional diagram shows sea water evaporating and later falling as rain on a school garden.
Question: Which system parts are linked?
Answer: Ocean, atmosphere and land.
Evaporation transfers water to the air. Rain transfers water to the land; it does not create a new supply from nothing.
2. Follow the store
Worked classroom example
A model ocean starts with 40 heat units, gains 9 and loses 4 in one step.
Question: How much is stored after the step?
Answer: 45 heat units.
40 + 9 − 4 = 45. This is energy bookkeeping, not a prediction of sea temperature.
3. Correct an arrow
Worked classroom example
An arrow is labeled “plants absorb carbon dioxide” but points from plants to air.
Question: How should the diagram change?
Answer: Reverse the arrow so it points from air to plants.
During photosynthesis, carbon from atmospheric carbon dioxide enters plant material. Respiration would use a different process label.
Formative quiz
Find the water store
Fixed evidence 1
In this system diagram, sea water is the ocean part, surrounding air is atmosphere, soil is land and a tree represents living things.
1. Select the ocean component.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Ocean
- Atmosphere
- Living things
- Land
The ocean is the large saltwater component.
Label the arrows
Fixed evidence 1
Evaporation moves water from sea to air.
Fixed evidence 2
Rainfall moves water from air to land.
2. Place the process beside the matching arrow.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Sea → air
- Air → land
Available labels: Evaporation | Rainfall | Photosynthesis
Each label identifies the process, not just the location.
A connected store
Fixed evidence 1
Model ocean heat: initially 30 units, gain 8, loss 3 per step.
Fixed evidence 2
The model does not include every real ocean process.
3. True or false: in one step, the store increases by 5 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Eight enters and three leaves, so the net gain is five.
Two different transfers
Fixed evidence 1
Photosynthesis transfers carbon from air into growing plants.
Fixed evidence 2
River flow transfers water from land toward the ocean.
4. Choose the substance moved in each description.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Photosynthesis into plant material
- River flow toward the sea
Available labels: Water | Sunlight as a substance | Carbon
Carbon and water transfers should not be confused with energy flows.
Explain a connected change
Fixed evidence 1
In a classroom landscape, 60 water units fall as rain.
Fixed evidence 2
Half soaks into soil and half runs off.
Fixed evidence 3
Paving reduces the soaking fraction to one quarter; other losses are ignored.
5. How does the paving change runoff in this model, and which two system parts are directly linked?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly identifies increased runoff or calculates 30 to 45.
- Explains the connection between land surface and movement/storage of water.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Trace a rainy morning
Evaporation
Sea water becomes vapour in the atmosphere.
Condensation
Cloud droplets form from water vapour.
Rainfall
Rain moves water from air to land.
Return flow
A stream returns some land water to the sea.
6. Select all transfers described in the source.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Rain moves water to land
- Trees create all rainfall from nothing
- Streams remove water from Earth
- Ocean water enters the atmosphere
The source describes water moving among system parts, not appearing or disappearing.
7. Explain two connected transfers that carry water from sea to land.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies evaporation from ocean to atmosphere.
- Identifies condensation/rainfall leading from atmosphere to land.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Why the ocean matters
Fixed evidence 1
A toy system stores 70 heat units in water and 10 in air.
Fixed evidence 2
Those are classroom amounts, not actual global proportions.
8. Select the component with the larger stated heat store.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Neither has a store
- Both: 10 units
- Water: 70 units
- Air: 10 units
The water store is larger in the stated model.
9. Why should a team include water measurements as well as air measurements? Use the model and give one limit.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the larger modeled water store to justify measuring water.
- States a limitation of the simplified model or its made-up amounts.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a land change
Fixed evidence 1
Two model plots each receive 80 water units.
Fixed evidence 2
A planted plot lets 60% soak in; a paved plot lets 20% soak in.
Fixed evidence 3
Ignore other losses.
10. Choose the correct runoff for each plot.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Planted plot
- Paved plot
Available labels: 48 water units | 64 water units | 32 water units
Runoff is rainfall minus the amount that soaks in.
11. A new school has the paved plot. Explain how changing its surface could affect water, and state one limit.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects more infiltration with less runoff under the source rule.
- Names an omitted local factor or limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the system explanation
Incorrect explanation
The ocean gains heat, so the air, land and ice can never be affected.
System evidence
Air and ocean exchange energy. Warming can affect land conditions and ice melt.
12. Which revision is best?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Every part changes by the same amount.
- The ocean has no energy store.
- Climate parts can exchange energy.
- Only the ocean receives sunlight.
Connected parts can affect one another without changing equally or immediately.
13. Identify the error and describe one valid connection.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the false assumption that ocean and other parts are isolated.
- Describes a valid energy or matter connection involving the ocean.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a connected investigation
Available measurements
Air temperature, soil moisture, rain amount and classroom snack preference.
Task
Study how rainfall changes water in the school soil. Keep the place and measurement method consistent.
14. Match each useful measurement with its role.
Matching · 2 points
- Rain amount
- Soil moisture
Available labels: Water arriving from air | Favourite snack | Water held in land
These measurements address the rain-to-soil connection.
15. Propose two linked measurements and explain how you would compare them fairly.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Selects rain and soil moisture, or equivalent valid linked measurements.
- Gives a consistent comparison such as same plot/method and before–after timing.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Climate change and Earth observations
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.3 — Atmosphere
Explain how the atmosphere moves water and energy, and distinguish greenhouse gases from most of the air.
Worked examples
1. Name the instrument
Worked classroom example
A fictional school wants to record the air temperature at noon. It has a thermometer and a rain gauge.
Question: Which should it use?
Answer: The thermometer.
The target property is temperature. The rain gauge would answer a different question about precipitation.
2. Follow water
Worked classroom example
A damp towel becomes dry. No water was poured away.
Question: Where can some of its water have gone?
Answer: Into the surrounding air as water vapour.
Evaporation changes liquid water to gas. The water has changed form and location, rather than disappeared.
3. Small does not mean unimportant
Worked classroom example
A model air sample is mostly gases that interact weakly with outgoing infrared, plus a small amount that absorbs it.
Question: Can the smaller part affect the energy flow?
Answer: Yes. Its properties matter as well as its amount.
Counting molecules alone does not tell us how strongly each gas interacts with infrared energy.
Formative quiz
An invisible mixture
Fixed evidence 1
The atmosphere is a mixture of gases.
Fixed evidence 2
Air can push a kite even when the gases are invisible.
1. True or false: invisible air can exert a force.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Moving air can push objects while remaining invisible.
Pick the instrument
Fixed evidence 1
To record rainfall, use a rain gauge.
Fixed evidence 2
A thermometer measures temperature; a wind vane shows wind direction; a gas sensor measures a chosen gas.
2. Select the instrument for rainfall.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Rain gauge
- Gas sensor
- Thermometer
- Wind vane
A rain gauge collects precipitation for measurement.
Water forms
Fixed evidence 1
A cloud contains visible droplets or ice crystals.
Fixed evidence 2
Water vapour is invisible gas.
3. Choose the correct description.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Water vapour
- Liquid cloud droplets
Available labels: No matter present | Liquid form of water | Gas form of water
Vapour and liquid droplets are different forms of water.
Read the energy account
Fixed evidence 1
A model receives 100 energy units, reflects 30 and sends 65 to space as infrared during one step.
4. What is the net energy gain?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 5 units
- 95 units
- 65 units
- 35 units
100 − 30 − 65 = 5 energy units gained.
A warmer classroom
Fixed evidence 1
Toy indicator: base 28°C + extra heat 4°C − shade reduction 4°C × shade fraction.
Fixed evidence 2
At 50% shade, the indicator is 30°C.
Fixed evidence 3
These are model assumptions.
5. Explain why this local indicator cannot describe the whole atmosphere, and name a better comparison.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the limited local/model scope.
- Proposes broader, consistent measurements across locations or time.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Water in the air
Fixed evidence 1
A classroom drawing shows ocean, air, soil and rock.
Fixed evidence 2
Evaporated water travels first into the air.
6. Select the receiving component for evaporated water.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Atmosphere
- Ocean
- Rock
- Soil
Evaporation places water vapour in the atmosphere.
7. Explain what evaporation changes and what it does not destroy.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States that liquid becomes gas/vapour and enters air.
- Explains that the water is conserved rather than destroyed.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Why use a gas sensor?
Fixed evidence 1
The school wants to compare carbon-dioxide concentration in two air samples.
Fixed evidence 2
Temperature and rainfall are separate properties.
8. Which tool directly matches the question?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- A calibrated CO₂ sensor
- A classroom rain gauge
- A simple wind-direction vane
- A shaded air thermometer
A sensor for the specified gas measures its concentration.
9. Justify the tool choice and name one step that makes the comparison fair.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that the sensor measures CO₂ concentration.
- Names consistent/calibrated measurement conditions or method.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — A changed energy flow
Fixed evidence 1
In a toy atmosphere, incoming energy is 100, reflected energy 30 and outgoing infrared 70.
Fixed evidence 2
A changed condition reduces outgoing infrared to 66; incoming and reflection stay fixed.
10. True or false: the changed condition produces a net gain of 4 energy units in that step.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
100 − 30 − 66 = 4; the comparison holds other arrows fixed.
11. Explain the new imbalance and one reason it is not an exact temperature forecast.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains the four-unit gain caused by reduced outgoing energy.
- Names an omitted process or distinguishes energy accounting from temperature prediction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the cloud claim
Student claim
Clouds are invisible water vapour, so a cloud photo measures all atmospheric water.
Science card
Clouds contain visible droplets or ice; vapour is invisible gas. A photograph does not measure all water.
12. Select all corrections supported by the cards.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Vapour can exist outside clouds.
- Clouds contain droplets or ice.
- All atmospheric water is solid.
- Cloud photos count all vapour.
Visible clouds are not a complete measure of invisible vapour.
13. Correct both mistakes in the student claim.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly distinguishes cloud particles from water vapour.
- Explains why a photograph is not a full water measurement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a weather station
Task
Measure air temperature and rainfall at school.
Quality rule
Use suitable instruments and record place, date, time and units. Keep the method consistent.
14. Place each tool beside its task.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Air temperature
- Rainfall
Available labels: Rain gauge | Thermometer | Compass
Each instrument must match the property being recorded.
15. Propose the two instruments and a consistent recording routine.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Selects instruments appropriate to temperature and rainfall.
- Provides a consistent documented observation routine.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Climate change and Earth observations
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
- NASA: Causes of climate change
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.4 — Oceans
Explain how oceans store and move heat and carbon, and distinguish these roles from an unlimited climate solution.
Worked examples
1. Heat bookkeeping
Worked classroom example
A toy ocean contains 50 heat units. During one step it receives 9 and releases 4.
Question: What is its new store?
Answer: 55 heat units.
The net gain is 5, so 50 + 9 − 4 = 55. No temperature unit should be attached to an energy store.
2. Move, not create
Worked classroom example
Two model water boxes hold 30 and 20 heat units. Five move from the first to the second.
Question: What are the new amounts and combined total?
Answer: 25 and 25; the total stays 50.
The first box loses what the second gains. A transfer changes distribution while conserving the combined amount in this closed model.
3. Two ocean changes
Worked classroom example
A hypothetical sample becomes warmer and its measured pH becomes lower.
Question: Are these the same observation?
Answer: No: one concerns temperature and the other chemistry.
A temperature instrument and a pH measurement record different properties. More information is needed to explain both changes.
Formative quiz
Stores and flows
Fixed evidence 1
A model ocean contains 80 heat units.
Fixed evidence 2
It gains 10 heat units each step.
1. Choose the role of each quantity.
Dropdown · 2 points
- 80 units present
- 10 units entering per step
Available labels: Flow | Store | Temperature in °C
The store is an amount; the flow includes a time interval.
A current connects boxes
Fixed evidence 1
Moving water transfers 6 heat units from a warm model box to a cooler box.
Fixed evidence 2
The model is closed to other energy changes.
2. Match each box with its change.
Matching · 2 points
- Giving box
- Receiving box
Available labels: Loses 6 heat units | Gains 6 heat units | Creates 6 heat units
In this closed transfer, the loss and gain are equal.
Inspect the water store
Fixed evidence 1
Toy ocean heat begins at 40 units, with 12 entering and 7 leaving in one step.
3. Select the store after one step.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 52 heat units
- 35 heat units
- 45 heat units
- 59 heat units
40 + 12 − 7 = 45 heat units.
Two measurements
Fixed evidence 1
Temperature tells how warm a sample is. pH describes its acidity/alkalinity.
Fixed evidence 2
Lowering ocean pH is called acidification even when seawater remains alkaline.
4. Place the property beside its measurement.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Temperature reading
- pH reading
Available labels: Acidity/alkalinity | Current direction | Warmth of the sample
Temperature and pH are different measurements.
Read a short record
Fixed evidence 1
Fictional surface temperatures for five visits are 27, 28, 27, 29 and 30°C.
Fixed evidence 2
All visits use the same site and depth.
5. Describe this record and one reason it does not describe the entire ocean.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Accurately describes variability and a higher endpoint.
- Identifies limited site, depth or time coverage.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — One ocean step
Fixed evidence 1
A toy store begins at 70 heat units, receives 14 and releases 9 during one step.
6. Choose each quantity.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Net change
- Final store
Available labels: 84 heat units | Gain of 5 units | 75 heat units
The net gain is 14 − 9 = 5; add it to 70.
7. Explain the final store and why calling it “75°C” would be wrong.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly calculates or explains 75 heat units.
- Distinguishes energy units from degrees of temperature.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Which observation set?
Fixed evidence 1
Team A samples one surface point once.
Fixed evidence 2
Team B repeats measurements at several locations and depths using checked instruments.
8. Match each method with its coverage.
Matching · 2 points
- Team A
- Team B
Available labels: Several places, depths and times | Every ocean location | One point at one time
Team B covers more of the ocean but still does not measure every point.
9. Justify the more informative method and state a remaining limit.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Chooses Team B using its broader coverage.
- Acknowledges sampling or measurement limits.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to two connected bays
Fixed evidence 1
In a closed classroom model, Bay A holds 40 heat units and Bay B holds 20.
Fixed evidence 2
A current carries 8 from A to B.
10. Place the final amount in each bay.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Bay A after transfer
- Bay B after transfer
Available labels: 28 heat units | 48 heat units | 32 heat units
A loses eight, B gains eight, and the combined 60 units remain.
11. Explain the new amounts and whether the current created extra heat.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives both correct final amounts or their valid calculation.
- Explains conservation of the total during transfer.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a claim about emissions
Claim
The ocean absorbs some carbon dioxide, so any amount of fossil-fuel emissions is harmless.
Evidence
Ocean uptake is limited and added CO₂ changes seawater chemistry; atmospheric buildup also continues.
12. Choose the best correction.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Uptake has limits and consequences
- The ocean exchanges no carbon
- Uptake makes all emissions harmless
- Carbon dioxide is only a heat unit
Taking up some CO₂ is not unlimited removal and can change ocean chemistry.
13. Identify the faulty jump and give one consequence it ignores.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the unjustified jump from partial uptake to harmless unlimited emissions.
- Names acidification or continuing atmospheric warming/buildup.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Plan an ocean record
Fixed evidence 1
A class has permission to compare prepared water samples only.
Fixed evidence 2
The study asks whether temperature differs between labeled surface and deeper samples.
Fixed evidence 3
No children enter the water.
14. Which plan best fits the question and 6-token budget?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Read labels without measuring temperature
- Measure both samples and record their labels
- Measure one sample and buy a poster
- Mix both samples before measuring them
Two measurements cost four tokens and two label records cost two; keeping samples distinct preserves depth information.
15. Propose a plan that compares both samples fairly and preserves the depth information.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes comparable temperature measurements of both samples.
- Preserves depth labels and a consistent/repeated measurement method.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA JPL: Earth’s energy balance
- NASA: The carbon cycle
- NASA: Climate change and Earth observations
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.5 — Land
Investigate how land surfaces exchange water, carbon and energy, and explain why local conditions matter.
Worked examples
1. Split a rain shower
Worked classroom example
Toy plot: 80 water units fall; 25% soak in. Ignore other losses.
Question: How much runs off?
Answer: 60 water units.
One quarter of 80 is 20. Subtract that infiltration from rainfall: 80 − 20 = 60.
2. Read a shade indicator
Worked classroom example
Hypothetical rule: 28 + 4 − 4 × shade fraction. Shade is 75%.
Question: What does the indicator show?
Answer: 29°C in the toy model.
The shade term is 3, giving 28 + 4 − 3 = 29. The rule is supplied for learning, not as a real prediction.
3. A fair surface comparison
Worked classroom example
A class measures paving at noon but garden soil at dawn.
Question: Can it isolate the surface effect?
Answer: No; time of day also changed.
Measure both under comparable conditions. Otherwise the observed difference may involve sunlight timing as well as the surfaces.
Formative quiz
Land and water
Fixed evidence 1
Soil can hold water.
Fixed evidence 2
Water may infiltrate, run off, collect or evaporate.
1. True or false: rain reaching land can infiltrate as well as run off.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Rain can take several pathways, including infiltration and storage.
Name the pathway
Fixed evidence 1
Infiltration means water soaking into soil.
Fixed evidence 2
Runoff means water flowing over the surface.
2. Match each description.
Matching · 2 points
- Soaks into soil
- Flows over the surface
Available labels: Runoff | Infiltration | Carbon storage
The terms describe different water pathways.
A model rain budget
Fixed evidence 1
Rainfall is 60 units; infiltration is 50%.
Fixed evidence 2
Ignore storage and evaporation.
3. Place the correct amount beside each pathway.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Infiltration
- Runoff
Available labels: 60 units evaporating | 30 units running off | 30 units soaking in
Half of 60 follows each modeled pathway.
Fair measurement
Goal
Compare the temperatures of garden soil and paving.
Fair comparison
Measure at matching times and document location and surface.
Poor comparison
Changing both surface and time of day makes interpretation harder.
4. Select all useful steps.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Measure at matching times
- Measure one at dawn, one at noon
- Delete every cooler reading
- Record the surface and location
Matching times and documented surfaces improve the comparison.
Explain a surface change
Fixed evidence 1
Toy plots receive 100 rain units.
Fixed evidence 2
The garden infiltrates 60%; paving infiltrates 20%.
Fixed evidence 3
Other losses are ignored.
5. Compare the runoff and explain one limit of applying these numbers to a real school.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 40 and 80 runoff units.
- Names a real omitted factor or identifies the percentages as illustrative assumptions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — After a shower
Fixed evidence 1
A classroom model receives 80 rain units.
Fixed evidence 2
Forty percent soaks into the soil; no other losses occur.
6. Place each amount correctly.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Water soaking in
- Water running off
Available labels: 40 units | 48 units | 32 units
40% of 80 is 32; the remaining 48 runs off.
7. Explain the two amounts and how they account for all the rain in this model.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives 32 infiltrated and 48 runoff units.
- Explains conservation of all 80 units under the two-pathway assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — A shade comparison
Fixed evidence 1
Toy indicator: base 28, extra heat 4, full-shade reduction 4.
Fixed evidence 2
At 0% shade it is 32; at 50% it is 30.
8. True or false: this model proves exactly the same cooling at every real school.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The model is based on supplied assumptions and omits local influences.
9. Why can the model help compare ideas, and why should a school still measure its own site?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains comparison under stated model assumptions.
- Explains the need for local evidence using an omitted factor.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — A different soil
Fixed evidence 1
School A assumes 60% infiltration.
Fixed evidence 2
School B has compacted soil and a different slope.
Fixed evidence 3
Both wish to reduce runoff.
10. Select all useful next steps for School B.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Check slope and drainage
- Ignore soil because both are schools
- Measure local infiltration
- Copy 60% as a guaranteed value
The idea can transfer, but the numerical assumption needs local checking.
11. Transfer the runoff-reduction idea to School B with one action and one measurement.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a plausible action that can increase infiltration or manage runoff.
- Includes a relevant fair local measurement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the carbon claim
Claim
Trees contain carbon, so soil cannot contain any.
Evidence
Carbon can be stored in both plant material and soil; the amounts and forms differ.
12. Which correction is supported?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Only leaves store carbon
- Soil carbon is always zero
- All soil carbon is identical to sunlight
- Plants and soil can both store carbon
One carbon store does not exclude another.
13. Identify the error and give a more accurate statement.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the false either-or assumption.
- Correctly identifies plant and soil carbon stores.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a schoolyard trial
Fixed evidence 1
The class can change one small supervised plot and measure runoff.
Fixed evidence 2
It must keep a comparison plot unchanged and avoid blocking drains.
14. Choose the plan meeting the investigation requirements.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Change both plots and keep no records
- Change one plot; compare and measure
- Measure only the nicest photograph
- Block the drain to store all runoff
A changed plot plus an unchanged comparison and measurements makes the trial interpretable.
15. Propose a trial with a comparison and a result you would measure.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a changed plot and an unchanged comparable plot.
- Includes relevant runoff/infiltration measurement while respecting drainage safety.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.6 — Ice
Distinguish land ice from floating sea ice and investigate how ice affects sea level and reflected sunlight.
Worked examples
1. Ice on a mountain
Worked classroom example
A fictional diagram shows a glacier resting on land and draining toward the ocean.
Question: Why can its melt raise ocean water amount?
Answer: The meltwater arrives from a store that was on land.
Land ice is not already floating in and displacing ocean water. Its starting location explains the difference.
2. A bright surface
Worked classroom example
Toy sunlight input is 90 units. A bright surface reflects 60; a dark one reflects 20.
Question: How much does each absorb?
Answer: The bright surface absorbs 30 and the dark one 70 units.
Subtract reflection from the common input: 90 − 60 = 30 and 90 − 20 = 70. These are illustrative values.
3. A temporary recovery
Worked classroom example
Practice ice areas are 8, 7, 6, 7 and 5 square units.
Question: Does the fourth point remove the overall decline?
Answer: No. The series ends at 5, below the starting 8.
A temporary rise belongs in the description, but it does not erase the other measurements.
Formative quiz
Two kinds of ice
Fixed evidence 1
Glaciers can lie on land.
Fixed evidence 2
Sea ice floats.
Fixed evidence 3
Land-ice melt adds water to the ocean; floating ice already displaces water.
1. Select all accurate statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Some ice is stored on land
- Land ice and sea ice have identical direct effects
- All ice forms beneath the ocean
- Sea ice floats on ocean water
Starting on land or floating makes a physical difference.
Name the locations
Fixed evidence 1
A mountain glacier rests on land.
Fixed evidence 2
A sea-ice floe floats in seawater.
2. Place the location label.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Mountain glacier
- Sea-ice floe
Available labels: Water vapour | Land ice | Floating sea ice
The distinction concerns where the ice is stored.
Reflection comparison
Fixed evidence 1
Classroom energy inputs are 100 units.
Fixed evidence 2
Bright surface reflects 70; dark surface reflects 25.
Fixed evidence 3
The rest is absorbed.
3. Match the surface with absorbed energy.
Matching · 2 points
- Bright surface
- Dark surface
Available labels: 30 energy units | 100 reflected units | 75 energy units
Subtract reflected energy from the same incoming amount.
Inspect a toy coast
Fixed evidence 1
Water is initially 15 cm above the model datum.
Fixed evidence 2
A supplied scenario adds 8 cm.
Fixed evidence 3
Ground is 30 cm above the same datum.
4. Select the final water surface level.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 23 cm
- 15 cm
- 38 cm
- 7 cm
15 + 8 = 23 cm above the common datum.
Explain the feedback
First change
Some bright ice is lost.
Next effect
Darker water is exposed and absorbs more sunlight under the stated conditions.
5. Explain how these two changes can reinforce warming, and say why the chain is not a complete forecast.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links ice loss to greater absorption and additional warming.
- Acknowledges omitted processes or limited predictive scope.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare melting locations
Fixed evidence 1
Land ice adds water when it melts into the sea.
Fixed evidence 2
Floating sea ice already displaces water and has a much smaller direct melting effect on sea level.
6. True or false: melting land ice can add water that was not already in the ocean.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Floating ice already displaces seawater; land ice can add new ocean water.
7. Explain why the direct effects differ and name one reason sea-ice loss still matters.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains the land-versus-floating distinction.
- Names a valid energy-balance or ecosystem consequence of sea-ice loss.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a useful energy comparison
Fixed evidence 1
Two model surfaces each receive 100 sunlight units.
Fixed evidence 2
One reflects 65 and the other reflects 20.
8. Which statement follows from the data?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Both absorb all 100 units
- The 20-reflection surface absorbs more
- The 65-reflection surface absorbs more
- Reflection creates incoming sunlight
They absorb 80 and 35 units respectively.
9. Justify the conclusion with both absorbed amounts.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates absorbed amounts 80 and 35.
- Uses them to justify which surface absorbs more.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a changed surface
Fixed evidence 1
A model starts with 120 incoming units and 80 reflected.
Fixed evidence 2
After ice loss, reflection is 50; incoming stays 120.
10. Match each state with absorption.
Matching · 2 points
- Before the change
- After the change
Available labels: 70 units | 40 units | 30 units
120 − 80 = 40; 120 − 50 = 70.
11. Explain how absorption changes and one condition held fixed in this comparison.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly states the 30-unit increase or both amounts.
- Identifies fixed incoming energy as the comparison condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an ice graph claim
Fixed evidence 1
Fictional ice-area values for Years 1–5 are 10, 9, 8, 9 and 7 square units.
Fixed evidence 2
A learner says Year 4 proves ice increased over the whole period.
12. Which description fits the full series?
Hotspot · 2 points
- An overall decrease with one increase
- A final value above the first
- An increase in every interval
- No change in any interval
The area falls from 10 to 7 overall, despite the rise from 8 to 9.
13. Identify the mistake and write an accurate replacement claim.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies cherry-picking one interval.
- Accurately describes overall decrease with variability.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a reflection test
Fixed evidence 1
A supervised classroom test compares light and dark surfaces under the same lamp.
Fixed evidence 2
The aim is to investigate energy absorption, not forecast glacier melt.
14. Select all useful controls.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Change both lamp power and colour
- Use the same lamp distance
- Measure one now and one next season
- Use equal exposure times
Distance and exposure should match to isolate the surface comparison.
15. Propose a fair comparison and state one limit of what it can show.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes matching exposure conditions and a relevant comparison.
- States an appropriate limitation relative to real ice/climate.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.7 — Ecosystems
Explain connections between living things and their environment, including carbon, water and habitat needs.
Worked examples
1. More than animals
Worked classroom example
A fictional pond contains frogs, plants, water, mud and sunlight.
Question: Which of these belong to the ecosystem?
Answer: All of them belong.
The ecosystem includes living organisms and their non-living surroundings, connected by resources and processes.
2. Count carbon carefully
Worked classroom example
A toy plant store starts at 25 carbon units, gains 7 and loses 3.
Question: What is the ending store?
Answer: 29 carbon units.
25 + 7 − 3 = 29. This accounts for both uptake and loss instead of assuming all incoming carbon stays.
3. Planting is a beginning
Worked classroom example
A class plants 20 suitable seedlings and checks them after several months. Fifteen survive.
Question: Why is the later check useful?
Answer: It measures survival, not just planting effort.
A planting-day count cannot reveal later growth, habitat use or survival. Repeated evidence helps judge whether the action is working.
Formative quiz
Parts of an ecosystem
Fixed evidence 1
A pond contains fish, water, plants and sunlight.
Fixed evidence 2
Living and non-living parts interact.
1. Classify the two parts.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Fish
- Pond water
Available labels: Outside every ecosystem | Living component | Non-living component
Both categories belong to the ecosystem.
Follow the carbon
Fixed evidence 1
Photosynthesis transfers carbon into growing plants.
Fixed evidence 2
Decomposition can return carbon from dead material to the environment.
2. Match each process with its transfer.
Matching · 2 points
- Photosynthesis
- Decomposition
Available labels: Creation of carbon from nothing | Carbon into growing plants | Carbon from dead material
Carbon changes form and location rather than being created by these processes.
Count carefully
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional insect survey counts 12, 14, 11, 10 and 9 insects on equal visits.
Fixed evidence 2
Several causes could affect the count.
3. True or false: this count alone proves climate change is the only cause.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The count describes a pattern but does not isolate a cause.
Balance a plant store
Fixed evidence 1
A toy vegetation store starts at 30 carbon units, gains 8 and loses 3 during one step.
4. Place the two results.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Net gain
- Final store
Available labels: 35 carbon units | 41 carbon units | 5 carbon units
The gain is 8 − 3 = 5, added to the starting 30.
A planting report
Report
A class planted 50 seedlings yesterday and calls the habitat fully restored.
Missing evidence
Survival, suitable species, water conditions and other living things have not yet been checked.
5. Why is the restoration claim too early, and what should the class measure later?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains why planting alone does not establish restoration.
- Names suitable repeated survival or ecosystem measurements.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A carbon step
Fixed evidence 1
Toy vegetation begins with 40 carbon units, takes in 10 and loses 4 during one step.
6. Choose the correct amounts.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Net change
- Final store
Available labels: 54 carbon units | Gain of 6 units | 46 carbon units
Ten enters and four leaves; the store rises by six.
7. Explain the final amount and why stored carbon may later leave.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains the 46-unit store.
- Names a valid process that can release stored carbon.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose suitable restoration
Site evidence
A fictional wetland has waterlogged soil and native wetland plants.
Plans
Plan A protects existing habitat and uses suitable native plants. Plan B dries the wetland to plant an unsuitable dry-land species.
8. Match each plan with the supported judgment.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Plan A
- Plan B
Available labels: Guaranteed success everywhere | Fits the stated wetland conditions | Conflicts with the stated habitat
A plan should fit the ecosystem, not merely maximize tree counts.
9. Justify the better plan and name one outcome to monitor.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies Plan A using habitat suitability/protection.
- Names a relevant monitored outcome beyond planting counts.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a food-web change
Fixed evidence 1
In a fictional food web, insects feed on a certain plant and small birds feed on those insects.
Fixed evidence 2
A change reduces that plant’s abundance.
10. True or false: the change could affect the birds through the insects.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Food relationships can carry an effect through the web, though outcomes depend on other food and conditions.
11. Explain a possible indirect effect and one reason it is not certain.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Traces the plant–insect–bird connection.
- States a plausible condition or alternative that limits certainty.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a survey conclusion
Fixed evidence 1
Fictional frog counts are 8, 9, 7, 6 and 7 on five visits.
Fixed evidence 2
A learner reports: “The last count is higher, so every habitat condition improved.”
12. Which correction follows?
Hotspot · 2 points
- All conditions improved for certain
- One rise does not measure every condition
- Frog counts cannot ever be useful
- The final count exceeds every earlier count
A count is one indicator; its final rise does not establish improvement in everything.
13. Identify the overclaim and suggest another relevant measurement.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies overgeneralization from one indicator/interval.
- Suggests a relevant additional ecosystem measurement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a habitat check
Goal
Test whether a small native-plant patch improves habitat use by insects.
Conditions
Keep a comparison area and use equal observation times. Do not disturb animals.
14. Match each action to its purpose.
Matching · 2 points
- Unchanged comparison area
- Equal observation times
Available labels: Check change beyond background variation | Guarantee the desired result | Make counts more comparable
These steps improve evidence without guaranteeing success.
15. Propose a safe habitat investigation with a comparison and a repeatable measure.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a changed area and a suitable comparison.
- Includes repeated comparable insect/habitat measurements without disturbance.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
- NASA: The carbon cycle
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.8 — Earth’s energy balance
Use an energy account to explain balanced, gaining and losing conditions while keeping energy units separate from temperature.
Worked examples
1. A balanced account
Worked classroom example
One model step: 100 incoming units, 20 reflected, 80 outgoing infrared.
Question: What is the net gain?
Answer: 0 energy units.
100 − 20 − 80 = 0. Both ways energy leaves must be counted.
2. A small imbalance
Worked classroom example
One model step: 90 incoming, 25 reflected, 60 outgoing infrared.
Question: Does the system gain or lose energy?
Answer: It gains 5 units.
90 − 25 gives 65 absorbed; 65 − 60 gives a gain of 5.
3. Repair a unit
Worked classroom example
A learner calculates a net energy gain of 4 units and calls it a 4°C temperature rise.
Question: What is wrong?
Answer: Energy units cannot be relabeled as degrees.
The temperature response also depends on mass, heat capacity and other processes. The exercise supplied no conversion to temperature.
Formative quiz
Compute a balance
Fixed evidence 1
One classroom step has incoming 100, reflected 30 and outgoing infrared 70 energy units.
1. What is the net energy gain?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 30 units
- 0 units
- 70 units
- 100 units
100 − 30 − 70 = 0.
Find the gain
Fixed evidence 1
A model receives 100 units, reflects 25 and releases 70 as infrared.
2. Select the net result.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Loss 70
- Gain 5
- Gain 25
- Loss 5
100 − 25 − 70 = 5 units gained.
Keep units straight
Fixed evidence 1
A model gain is 6 energy units.
Fixed evidence 2
No heat capacity or temperature conversion is given.
3. True or false: the calculation proves an exact 6°C temperature rise.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Energy and temperature have different units; the conversion is not supplied.
Two ways of leaving
Fixed evidence 1
Reflected sunlight returns incoming light to space.
Fixed evidence 2
Outgoing infrared is energy emitted by the Earth system.
4. Choose the correct label.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Sunlight returned to space
- Infrared emitted toward space
Available labels: Outgoing infrared | New incoming sunlight | Reflected energy
Reflection and emission are different outgoing pathways.
Follow stored energy
Fixed evidence 1
A toy heat store starts at 40 units.
Fixed evidence 2
Each step adds 9 and removes 5.
5. What is the store after one step, and why must the excess be counted?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives 44 units or a net gain of four added to 40.
- Explains that the excess is stored/conserved.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — An energy surplus
Fixed evidence 1
During one model step, incoming is 120, reflected is 40 and outgoing infrared is 72 energy units.
6. Select the net result for the 120-unit input.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Gain 8 units
- Loss 8 units
- Gain 48 units
- Loss 72 units
120 − 40 − 72 = 8 units gained.
7. Show how to find the net gain and distinguish it from a temperature forecast.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains the eight-unit net gain.
- Distinguishes energy gain from an exact temperature prediction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a balanced setting
Fixed evidence 1
Incoming sunlight is fixed at 100 units and reflection at 35.
Fixed evidence 2
Balance requires outgoing infrared to equal absorbed sunlight.
8. Choose the amounts needed for balance.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Absorbed sunlight
- Outgoing infrared for balance
Available labels: 35 outgoing units | 65 absorbed units | 65 outgoing units
Absorption is 100 − 35 = 65; outgoing must match it.
9. Justify the required outgoing amount and explain what happens if it is only 60.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies 65 using the absorbed amount.
- Correctly explains the five-unit surplus at outgoing 60.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer after darker surfaces
Fixed evidence 1
Before change: incoming 100, reflected 40, outgoing 60.
Fixed evidence 2
After change: reflected 25; the other two arrows stay fixed for this step.
10. Place the net results.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Before change
- After change
Available labels: Loss: 15 units | Gain: 15 units | Balance: 0 units
Less reflection raises absorbed energy in the specified one-step comparison.
11. Explain the changed balance and why later steps may differ.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly links reduced reflection to a 15-unit gain.
- Acknowledges that other flows/responding temperatures can change later.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair double subtraction
Fixed evidence 1
A model has incoming 100, reflected 30 and outgoing infrared 65.
Fixed evidence 2
Ali first finds 70 absorbed, then subtracts reflection again and reports −25.
12. Which correction is valid?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 70 − 65 = 5 gained
- 70 − 30 − 65 = 25 gained
- 100 + 30 − 65 = 65 gained
- 65 − 100 = 35 gained
Reflection was already removed in the 70 absorbed units.
13. Identify Ali’s error and give the corrected calculation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies double subtraction of reflected energy.
- Gives a correct five-unit net gain calculation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a two-case demonstration
Fixed conditions
Keep incoming at 100 and reflection at 30.
Goal
Show one balanced case and one gaining case by changing outgoing infrared only.
14. Match the setting with the result.
Matching · 2 points
- Outgoing 70
- Outgoing 60
Available labels: Gain of 10 units | Loss of 10 units | Balanced case
With 70 absorbed, outgoing 70 balances and outgoing 60 leaves a surplus.
15. Propose both settings and explain which two energy quantities you keep the same to make the comparison fair.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides valid balanced and gaining outgoing settings.
- Explicitly holds incoming and reflection fixed to isolate the change.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
- NASA JPL: Earth’s energy balance
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.9 — Greenhouse effect
Explain the natural greenhouse effect and how adding greenhouse gases changes outgoing energy.
Worked examples
1. Natural effect
Worked classroom example
A student says greenhouse gases only appeared when factories were built.
Question: Is that correct?
Answer: No. Greenhouse gases existed naturally before industry.
Human activities have added to some concentrations, strengthening a process that already existed.
2. A changed outgoing arrow
Worked classroom example
Toy case A: incoming 100, reflected 30, outgoing 70. Case B changes outgoing to 64.
Question: How does the balance change?
Answer: From 0 to a gain of 6 energy units.
The other arrows remain fixed. This identifies the immediate imbalance, not a temperature forecast.
3. Choose the correct explanation
Worked classroom example
Two explanations say warming occurs because of added greenhouse gases or because all energy can no longer escape.
Question: Which is more accurate?
Answer: Added greenhouse gases change the flow of infrared; energy still escapes.
A total blockage would misrepresent the atmosphere. The energy budget includes continuing outgoing radiation.
Formative quiz
A natural process
Fixed evidence 1
Naturally occurring greenhouse gases absorb and emit some infrared energy.
Fixed evidence 2
Human additions can strengthen this effect.
1. True or false: the greenhouse effect existed before human industry.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The natural greenhouse effect predates human industry.
Name the energy
Fixed evidence 1
Sunlight arrives from the Sun.
Fixed evidence 2
Earth emits infrared energy; greenhouse gases interact with some of it.
2. Match each arrow.
Matching · 2 points
- Sun → Earth
- Earth system → space
Available labels: Ocean water flow | Outgoing infrared | Incoming sunlight
Energy enters and leaves through different pathways.
What the effect does
Fixed evidence 1
Greenhouse gases absorb and emit infrared energy.
Fixed evidence 2
The atmosphere still sends energy to space.
3. Select all accurate statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The atmosphere is a solid glass roof
- Some infrared is absorbed by gases
- All outgoing energy is blocked forever
- Energy still reaches space
The effect changes radiative flow without making a solid sealed cover.
Compare model cases
Fixed evidence 1
Both cases receive 100 units and reflect 30.
Fixed evidence 2
A sends 70 infrared units out; B sends 66.
4. Choose the net result.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Case A
- Case B
Available labels: Gain: 4 units | Balance: 0 units | Loss: 4 units
A balances at 70 absorbed and 70 outgoing; B gains four.
Explain natural versus added
Natural effect
Existing greenhouse gases help keep Earth warm.
Added gases
Human additions alter outgoing energy at a given temperature.
5. Explain why the natural effect can be useful while adding more gases still causes a problem.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the role of the natural greenhouse effect.
- Explains that added concentrations can cause extra energy gain/warming.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — An immediate imbalance
Fixed evidence 1
A classroom atmosphere receives 100 energy units, reflects 30 and releases 62 as infrared during one step.
6. Which net result is correct?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Loss of 62 units
- Gain of 8 units
- Loss of 8 units
- Gain of 32 units
100 − 30 − 62 = 8 units gained.
7. Explain the eight-unit gain and why energy still leaves the model.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the net gain using the given amounts.
- States that 62 units still leave; the flow is not fully blocked.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose the mechanism
Fixed evidence 1
Explanation A: greenhouse gases absorb and emit infrared.
Fixed evidence 2
Explanation B: the ozone hole lets all heat in and is the main greenhouse mechanism.
8. Classify the explanations.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Explanation A
- Explanation B
Available labels: Confuses greenhouse effect and ozone | Matches the greenhouse mechanism | Shows a complete temperature forecast
The greenhouse mechanism concerns infrared exchange, not treating the ozone hole as its main cause.
9. Justify the better explanation and correct the other one.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies A through infrared absorption/emission.
- Distinguishes ozone/ultraviolet protection from the greenhouse mechanism.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a different planet model
Fixed evidence 1
Planet model X and Y receive the same 80 units and reflect 20.
Fixed evidence 2
X emits 60; Y emits 55 for the chosen step.
10. Select all supported statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- X receives no sunlight
- Y gains exactly 5°C
- Y gains 5 energy units
- X has no net energy gain
The energy accounts are 0 for X and +5 for Y; degrees cannot be inferred.
11. Compare the two balances and state what extra information a temperature prediction would need.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 0 and +5 energy units.
- Names relevant storage/response information or heat capacity.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a blanket analogy
Claim
A greenhouse gas is a blanket, so it blocks every kind of energy permanently.
Correction evidence
Gases absorb and emit selected infrared wavelengths; energy continues escaping.
12. Choose the more accurate statement.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Gases change infrared exchange
- Gases make a solid roof
- No energy can escape Earth
- Every energy wavelength is blocked
An analogy does not replace the physical absorption and emission process.
13. Identify the analogy’s limit and replace the incorrect mechanism.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the blanket/solid complete-blocking analogy as limited.
- States a correct infrared absorption/emission mechanism with continuing escape.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a fair demonstration
Fixed evidence 1
Keep incoming at 100 and reflection at 30.
Fixed evidence 2
Compare an outgoing setting of 70 with one below 70.
Fixed evidence 3
Do not relabel energy units as degrees.
14. Match the labels to example settings.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Balanced reference
- Energy-gaining comparison
Available labels: Outgoing 70 | Incoming 0 | Outgoing 60
These settings illustrate the effect of reduced outgoing energy while other arrows are fixed.
15. Design the two cases and explain what the demonstration can show.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives a balanced and gaining pair with fixed incoming/reflection.
- Correctly limits the result to energy balance rather than temperature prediction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Causes of climate change
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.10 — Greenhouse gases
Identify major greenhouse gases, connect sources to gases, and compare amounts without confusing gas mass with warming effect.
Worked examples
1. Read a gas formula
Worked classroom example
A source labels two gases CO₂ and CH₄.
Question: Which names do the labels represent?
Answer: Carbon dioxide and methane.
Both are greenhouse gases, but they have different properties. The formula helps preserve the gas identity in a record.
2. Keep the unit
Worked classroom example
An invented inventory lists 3 kg of methane and supplies no conversion metric.
Question: Can this be renamed 3 kg CO₂-equivalent?
Answer: No. It states methane mass only.
A comparison of warming effects needs a defined metric and time horizon; equal gas masses do not establish equal effects.
3. Use the classroom factor
Worked classroom example
A toy activity has 8 units, each assigned 2 emission units, and a 25% reduction.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 12 emission units.
The baseline is 16; one quarter is 4. Subtracting the avoided 4 leaves 12. These units are stated assumptions, not measured gas masses.
Formative quiz
Identify greenhouse gases
Fixed evidence 1
Carbon dioxide and methane absorb and emit infrared.
Fixed evidence 2
Most nitrogen and oxygen in air do not do so in the same way.
1. Select all greenhouse gases in this list.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Carbon dioxide
- Nitrogen
- Methane
- Oxygen
CO₂ and methane are greenhouse gases; the most abundant air gases have different infrared properties.
Source and gas
Fixed evidence 1
Burning coal releases CO₂.
Fixed evidence 2
Leaking unburned natural gas can release methane.
2. Place the main named gas.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Coal combustion
- Unburned natural-gas leakage
Available labels: Carbon dioxide | Methane | Oxygen
The specified pathways name different gases.
Read the unit
Fixed evidence 1
A classroom record says “4 kg methane released.” It does not give a CO₂-equivalent factor or time horizon.
3. Select what the record directly states.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 4°C of warming
- 4 kg of methane
- 4 kg of CO₂-equivalent
- 4 kg of oxygen
The mass is methane; a different metric cannot be inferred without its definition.
Feedback reasoning
Driver
Human-added long-lived greenhouse gases drive much of current warming.
Response
Warming can increase atmospheric water vapour.
Feedback
Extra water vapour can amplify the initial warming.
4. True or false: water-vapour feedback can amplify warming driven by added CO₂.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A feedback can amplify a change driven by another influence.
A toy emissions account
Fixed evidence 1
A made-up activity uses a factor of 3 emission units per activity unit.
Fixed evidence 2
Ten activity units occur, and a measure cuts emissions by 20%.
5. Calculate the remaining emission units and explain why they are not automatically kilograms of methane.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly calculates 24 remaining emission units.
- Preserves the supplied unit and rejects an unsupported methane-mass interpretation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A matched source question
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional fuel pipe leaks methane before the fuel is burned.
Fixed evidence 2
A separate burner emits carbon dioxide during combustion.
6. Which measure directly targets the named methane leak?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Rename the burner exhaust
- Repair the leaking pipe
- Count nearby rain clouds
- Measure only ocean salinity
Repairing the leak targets escaping unburned methane.
7. Explain why the measure fits the leak and why it does not automatically remove combustion CO₂.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects repair to the unburned methane pathway.
- Distinguishes remaining combustion CO₂ from leakage.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose honest labels
Fixed evidence 1
Record A says 5 kg CH₄.
Fixed evidence 2
Record B says 5 kg CO₂.
Fixed evidence 3
No climate-effect metric is supplied.
8. Place the supported judgment.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Comparison of mass
- Comparison of warming effect
Available labels: Needs a defined comparison metric | Equal stated masses | Guaranteed equal warming
Equal kilograms of different gases do not establish equal warming.
9. Justify why the masses match but the warming effects cannot be equated from these records alone.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Recognizes equal mass in the records.
- Explains why gas properties and metric/time horizon matter for warming.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer an emission rule
Fixed evidence 1
Toy activity A uses 12 units at factor 2; activity B uses 8 units at the same factor.
Fixed evidence 2
There is no reduction measure.
10. Choose the results under this rule.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Activity A
- Activity B
Available labels: 16 emission units | 20 emission units | 24 emission units
Multiply each activity amount by the same stated factor.
11. Explain the difference and one reason the factor should not be assumed for every real activity.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 24 and 16, or their difference of eight.
- Names a reason a real emission factor could differ.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a gas misconception
Claim
Nitrogen is most of the air, so it must be the main greenhouse gas; smaller amounts cannot matter.
Evidence
Gas properties determine infrared interactions. Smaller amounts of greenhouse gases can matter.
12. Select all valid corrections.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Small concentrations can affect energy flow
- Infrared properties differ among gases
- Only the largest gas component can matter
- Every gas absorbs infrared identically
Abundance alone does not determine greenhouse behavior.
13. Identify the faulty assumption and state the property that matters.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies abundance-alone reasoning as faulty.
- Names infrared absorption/emission as the relevant property.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a gas record
Fixed evidence 1
A school project records emission estimates.
Fixed evidence 2
Each entry must identify the gas and the unit; any CO₂-equivalent comparison must state its metric and time horizon.
14. True or false: an entry labeled only “20 emissions” is sufficient for comparing gases.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Gas, unit, basis and any comparison metric must be clear.
15. Propose two essential parts of an emission record and explain their purpose.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes gas identity and a clear unit.
- Includes the basis or comparison metric/time horizon and explains interpretability.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Causes of climate change
- United Nations: Methane
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.11 — Carbon cycle
Follow carbon between stores, balance transfers, and distinguish the carbon cycle from creating or destroying carbon.
Worked examples
1. Move five counters
Worked classroom example
Air has 40 carbon counters and plants have 10. Photosynthesis moves five from air to plants in a closed exercise.
Question: What are the new stores?
Answer: Air 35; plants 15.
The combined 50 remains. The transfer changes where carbon is stored.
2. An atmospheric surplus
Worked classroom example
A toy atmospheric store starts at 60, receives 15 and loses 9 in one step.
Question: What is the final amount?
Answer: 66 carbon units.
The net addition is 6. Natural removals occur, but they do not cancel the larger addition.
3. Stock and yearly uptake
Worked classroom example
A woodland record says 200 carbon units stored and 8 taken up during a year.
Question: Can we call the yearly uptake 200?
Answer: No. The numbers describe different quantities.
The existing store includes past accumulation; eight describes a particular year’s additional flow.
Formative quiz
Stores and transfers
Fixed evidence 1
The atmosphere contains a carbon amount.
Fixed evidence 2
Photosynthesis transfers carbon from air into plants.
1. Match each phrase.
Matching · 2 points
- Carbon currently in air
- Photosynthesis into plants
Available labels: Transfer | Store | Creation of carbon
Carbon cycles between stores through processes.
Follow two arrows
Fixed evidence 1
Photosynthesis moves carbon from air to plants.
Fixed evidence 2
Burning fossil fuel moves carbon from fuel into air as CO₂.
2. Choose the direction.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Photosynthesis
- Fossil-fuel burning
Available labels: Air → sunlight | Fuel store → air | Air → plants
The direction must match the process.
Calculate a carbon store
Fixed evidence 1
A toy atmospheric store begins at 50, gains 11 and loses 7 carbon units during one step.
3. What is the final store?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 54 units
- 46 units
- 61 units
- 68 units
50 + 11 − 7 = 54.
Check a cycle diagram
Fixed evidence 1
A good diagram labels carbon stores, arrow directions and processes.
Fixed evidence 2
It distinguishes stocks from yearly flows.
4. Select all useful diagram features.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The same transfer counted twice
- Arrow directions and time units
- Named stores and processes
- Unlabeled arrows with no meaning
The movement and accounting must be explicit.
Explain continued buildup
Fixed evidence 1
A model air store receives 20 carbon units in a step.
Fixed evidence 2
Plants and ocean together remove 14.
5. Does the store rise or fall, and why do the removals not settle the question alone?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives a six-unit increase.
- Explains that net balance depends on additions as well as removals.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read the whole account
Fixed evidence 1
Toy atmosphere starts at 90 carbon units, receives 18 and loses 12 in one period.
6. Choose each amount.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Net change
- Final store
Available labels: Gain of 6 units | 108 carbon units | 96 carbon units
Eighteen minus twelve is six; add six to ninety.
7. Explain the final store and why a removal of 12 does not mean the store falls.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly calculates or explains 96.
- Compares inflow and outflow rather than treating removal alone as net change.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose the right arrow
Fixed evidence 1
In the source diagram, photosynthesis moves carbon from air to plants.
Fixed evidence 2
Respiration moves carbon from organisms to the environment.
8. Select the photosynthesis direction.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Air → plants
- Water → no carbon
- Plants → air
- Rock → sunlight
The process takes carbon from atmospheric CO₂ into growing plant material.
9. Justify the direction and explain what would be wrong with calling it new carbon creation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the air-to-plant transfer.
- Distinguishes transfer from creation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a smaller removal
Fixed evidence 1
A model starts at 60 carbon units with inflow 15.
Fixed evidence 2
Initially outflow is 12; after a change it is 8.
Fixed evidence 3
Compare one step from the same start.
10. Place the final stores.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Outflow 12
- Outflow 8
Available labels: 67 carbon units | 63 carbon units | 52 carbon units
The lower outflow leaves four more units after the same input.
11. Explain the change in final store and one assumption that makes the comparison fair.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares the final amounts or four-unit difference.
- Identifies a held-fixed starting amount, inflow or period.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a sink claim
Fixed evidence 1
A woodland holds 300 carbon units and takes up 9 during this year.
Fixed evidence 2
A report counts all 300 as new removal this year.
12. True or false: counting all 300 as this year’s new removal is justified by the record.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The existing stock and the yearly uptake are different quantities.
13. Identify the accounting error and replace the reported new removal.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies stock–flow confusion.
- Correctly gives nine units as the reported yearly uptake.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a carbon model
Fixed evidence 1
Use 40 counters across an air box and plant box.
Fixed evidence 2
Show photosynthesis by moving counters; do not add or discard any.
14. Which demonstration follows the rule?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Start 30/10; transfer 5 → 25/15
- Start 30/10; remove 5 → 25/10
- Start 30/10; add 5 → 30/15
- Start 30/10; rename sunlight as carbon
The valid transfer preserves the combined 40 counters.
15. Propose a valid starting split and transfer, explaining the conservation check.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides a valid transfer from air to plants without adding/removing counters.
- Checks that the combined total stays 40.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: The carbon cycle
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.12 — Natural climate variation
Recognize natural climate influences and variability while distinguishing them from the explanation for current human-driven warming.
Worked examples
1. A variable series
Worked classroom example
Practice values are 10, 12, 11 and 13.
Question: Can a decline occur within a series that ends higher?
Answer: Yes. The third point falls, but the final point exceeds the first.
The statements refer to different intervals. Reading every point avoids turning one interval into the whole story.
2. Keep the geographic scope
Worked classroom example
A fictional notice says dry conditions are more likely in one region.
Question: Does it guarantee drought in every region?
Answer: No. It states a chance for the named region.
Probability is not certainty, and a regional statement cannot silently become a worldwide forecast.
3. A natural energy influence
Worked classroom example
A toy account has incoming 100, reflection 30 and outgoing 70. Reflection rises to 35 for one comparison step.
Question: What is the new net balance?
Answer: A loss of 5 energy units.
100 − 35 − 70 = −5. This illustrates an influence on reflection while holding other arrows fixed; it is not a forecast.
Formative quiz
Different influences
Fixed evidence 1
El Niño involves ocean–atmosphere variability.
Fixed evidence 2
Orbital changes act over very long timescales.
1. Choose the description.
Dropdown · 2 points
- El Niño
- Orbital change
Available labels: Ocean–atmosphere pattern | Very-long-term sunlight pattern | Daily school thermometer error
These are distinct natural influences, not one uniform process.
Evidence and claim
Fixed evidence 1
One cool day is weather evidence.
Fixed evidence 2
A consistent multi-decade temperature series is relevant to long-term patterns.
2. Match the evidence to its scope.
Matching · 2 points
- One cool day
- Multi-decade series
Available labels: Long-term temperature pattern | Local weather event | Guaranteed future storm
Evidence must match the scale of a claim.
Read variation
Fixed evidence 1
Fictional values over five years are 20, 22, 21, 23 and 22 units.
3. Which description is accurate?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Every year is lower than the last
- Values vary and end higher
- The first and last values match
- Every year rises by the same amount
The series has rises and falls and ends two units above the first.
Avoid a false choice
Fixed evidence 1
Natural variation and human influences can occur together.
Fixed evidence 2
Past natural changes do not establish the cause of every current change.
4. True or false: past natural climate change does not rule out human influence now.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Past natural causes do not rule out present human influence.
A temporary energy influence
Fixed evidence 1
A toy account receives 100 energy units.
Fixed evidence 2
Reflection rises from 30 to 40 while outgoing remains 70 for one comparison step.
5. How does the net balance change, and why is this only an illustration of a possible influence?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives a ten-unit loss after the reflection change.
- Acknowledges the fixed-arrow model’s limits.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare periods
Fixed evidence 1
Fictional annual values are 10, 12, 11, 13 and 12.
Fixed evidence 2
The source measures a classroom indicator, not actual global temperature.
6. Choose each comparison.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Year 2 to Year 3
- Year 1 to Year 5
Available labels: Decrease of 1 unit | Increase of 2 units | No change
A short decline can coexist with a higher endpoint.
7. Explain how both comparisons can be correct without contradicting each other.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly describes both changes.
- Explains that the time spans differ.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose useful causal evidence
Fixed evidence 1
A class compares measured energy changes, gas records and known natural influences.
Fixed evidence 2
Another class uses one local cold day to deny all human influence.
8. Which approach is stronger for discussing causes?
Hotspot · 2 points
- A preferred answer without records
- Several relevant records and mechanisms
- An unlabelled picture alone
- One selected cold day alone
Attribution uses multiple relevant measurements and physical explanations.
9. Justify the stronger approach and identify the other approach’s scale problem.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies multiple relevant evidence/mechanisms.
- Identifies the local-day versus global-long-term mismatch.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to another region
Fixed evidence 1
A regional notice says an ocean–atmosphere pattern raises the chance of dry conditions in Region A.
Fixed evidence 2
It does not state Region B’s outlook.
10. True or false: the notice guarantees drought in every town of Region B.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
It concerns chances in Region A, not guaranteed outcomes everywhere.
11. How should Region B use the notice, and what extra information does it need?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps the notice’s geographic/probabilistic scope.
- Requests relevant Region B/local evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a cherry-picked graph
Fixed evidence 1
Practice temperatures are 25, 26, 27, 26 and 28°C.
Fixed evidence 2
A post shows only Years 3–4 and claims the entire series cooled.
12. Select all valid criticisms.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- One decline proves every cause
- The full series ends above its start
- The post omits other years
- The omitted years must be fake
The selected interval is real but is not the full pattern.
13. Identify the misleading selection and write a description using all five values.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the selective short interval.
- Correctly describes full-period variability and higher endpoint.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a balanced explanation
Requirement
Explain a long-term change and a shorter fluctuation without declaring them mutually exclusive.
Evidence rule
Use a full labeled record and compare plausible mechanisms; do not infer a cause from a single point.
14. Match the evidence task.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Long consistent record
- Mechanism comparison
Available labels: Guarantee identical regional effects | Describe overall change and variability | Test possible causes
Describing a pattern and explaining a cause are related but different tasks.
15. Propose a two-step investigation that separates pattern description from cause testing.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the full record to describe trend and variability.
- Tests causes with mechanisms and additional evidence rather than one point.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NOAA: Weather and climate
- NASA: Causes of climate change
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL1.13 — Human-caused climate change
Explain the evidence-based link between human activities, greenhouse gases and current warming without confusing every event with climate attribution.
Worked examples
1. Source and response
Worked classroom example
A diagram connects fuel burning, added greenhouse gases and changed infrared flow.
Question: Which is the human activity?
Answer: Fuel burning.
The gases and energy response are later links in the explanation. Naming each link helps distinguish activity from its effects.
2. An emission cut
Worked classroom example
An invented activity emits 60 units before a 20% reduction.
Question: How many are avoided and how many remain?
Answer: 12 avoided; 48 remain.
One fifth of 60 is 12. The reduction helps, but the remaining 48 must still appear in the account.
3. Several contributors
Worked classroom example
A fictional flooded school has heavy rain, blocked drainage and low-lying classrooms.
Question: Must one explanation exclude all the others?
Answer: No. Several contributors can act together.
Rainfall is a hazard, drainage affects water movement and low buildings increase exposure. A useful response can address more than one.
Formative quiz
Name the links
Fixed evidence 1
Burning fossil fuel releases greenhouse gases.
Fixed evidence 2
Increased greenhouse-gas concentrations change infrared energy flow.
1. Place each description.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Fossil-fuel burning
- Changed infrared energy flow
Available labels: Measurement of spelling | Human activity/source | Climate-system mechanism
The source and mechanism are connected but different parts of the explanation.
Use several records
Fixed evidence 1
Climate attribution uses gas measurements, temperatures, energy knowledge and other evidence.
Fixed evidence 2
One local day has limited scope.
2. Select all relevant evidence types.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- An unrelated sports score
- Long-term temperature records
- One preferred headline alone
- Greenhouse-gas records
Relevant independent measurements are stronger than unrelated or selected information.
Flow versus store
Fixed evidence 1
Emissions are gas released during a period.
Fixed evidence 2
Concentration describes gas present in air.
3. Choose the description.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Emission rate
- Atmospheric concentration
Available labels: Amount relative to air | Exact temperature change | Release per time period
A flow is not the same measurement as concentration.
Two kinds of response
Fixed evidence 1
Reducing fossil-fuel emissions is mitigation.
Fixed evidence 2
Preparing a shaded safe area for heat is adaptation.
4. Match each action.
Matching · 2 points
- Reduce fossil-fuel emissions
- Prepare for dangerous heat
Available labels: Proof that climate never varies | Adaptation | Mitigation
One limits the cause; the other addresses harm.
Explain accumulation
Fixed evidence 1
A toy atmosphere receives 16 carbon units each step and removes 10.
Fixed evidence 2
Its starting store is 70.
5. What happens after one step, and why does the existence of natural removal not eliminate buildup?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly states 76 or a six-unit increase.
- Explains that net accumulation depends on both inflow and outflow.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare an emission measure
Fixed evidence 1
A made-up activity has baseline emissions of 40 units.
Fixed evidence 2
A verified classroom scenario reduces them by 25%.
6. Place the result labels.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Amount avoided
- Amount remaining
Available labels: 30 emission units | 10 emission units | 25 emission units
One quarter of 40 is ten, leaving thirty.
7. Explain the reduction and why remaining emissions should still be reported.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives ten avoided and thirty remaining.
- Explains the need to include remaining emissions in the account.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose an explanation
Explanation A
Several measurements and known gas properties explain a long-term warming response.
Explanation B
One hot lunchtime proves every later storm has only one cause.
8. Which explanation has the stronger basis?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- B: one local lunchtime for all storms
- A: multiple records and a mechanism
- Both prove every future event
- Neither can use any measurement
A uses relevant evidence at an appropriate scale; B makes unsupported leaps.
9. Justify A and identify a scope problem in B.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies the mechanism-plus-evidence approach.
- Identifies overgeneralization across time/events or unsupported single-cause attribution.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to school flooding
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional school’s flood risk involves intense rainfall, blocked drains and classrooms beside a low channel.
Fixed evidence 2
Climate influences can affect rainfall risk; exposure and drainage also matter.
10. Select all defensible responses.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Clear drains through responsible adults
- Assess rainfall and local exposure
- Assume rainfall is the only factor
- Ignore climate because drains also matter
Several contributors can be addressed together.
11. Propose one local response and explain how multiple contributors can coexist.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes an appropriate drainage/exposure/preparedness response.
- Explains coexistence of climate/hazard and local contributors.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a natural-cycle claim
Claim
The carbon cycle is natural, so adding fossil carbon cannot change atmospheric carbon.
Toy evidence
Air receives 14 carbon units and loses 9 during a step.
12. Choose each correction.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Net change in the toy air store
- Effect of calling a process natural
Available labels: Does not rule out added human influence | Gain of 5 carbon units | Automatic cancellation of emissions
A natural cycle can be disturbed by additional inputs.
13. Identify the logical error and use the model to correct it.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains why “natural” does not imply automatic cancellation.
- Uses the correct five-unit accumulation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a combined school plan
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional school wants to reduce electricity-related emissions and reduce heat exposure.
Fixed evidence 2
It can monitor electricity use and shade access.
Fixed evidence 3
Health actions follow responsible adults and official guidance.
14. Choose the plan that addresses both stated goals.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Electricity check only, no heat planning
- A banner without any measurements
- Shade check only, no emission action
- Efficiency with electricity and shade checks
The plan needs both an emission pathway and a heat-exposure response.
15. Propose one mitigation action and one adaptation action, each with a relevant indicator.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides a plausible mitigation action with an emission/energy indicator.
- Provides a plausible adaptation action with a relevant exposure/preparedness indicator.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
- NASA: Causes of climate change
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.1 — Fossil-fuel use
Connect fossil-fuel use to carbon transfers and compare emission reductions using clearly stated boundaries.
Worked examples
1. A carbon journey
Worked classroom example
A diagram starts with carbon in coal and ends with CO₂ in air after burning.
Question: What kind of change is shown?
Answer: A transfer from fossil carbon storage to the atmosphere.
The carbon changes form and location. Its absence from the visible coal does not mean it has vanished.
2. Use a stated factor
Worked classroom example
Toy fuel use is 9 units and the factor is 4 emission units per fuel unit.
Question: What is the total?
Answer: 36 emission units.
9 × 4 = 36. The result uses the supplied classroom factor and is not a measured real fuel inventory.
3. Report the remainder
Worked classroom example
A made-up 50-unit baseline is cut by 20%.
Question: What is avoided and what remains?
Answer: 10 units avoided and 40 remain.
One fifth of 50 is 10. A reduction claim should still report the remaining 40.
Formative quiz
Fuel and service
Fixed evidence 1
Coal is an energy source.
Fixed evidence 2
Lighting is a service that different energy systems can provide.
1. Place each label.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Coal
- Useful lighting
Available labels: Energy service | Fuel source | Measured temperature
A source and the service it provides are distinct.
Follow fossil carbon
Fixed evidence 1
Fossil-fuel burning transfers carbon to air as CO₂.
Fixed evidence 2
Some natural sinks remove CO₂, but their uptake is not unlimited.
2. Select all accurate statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Natural uptake need not cancel additions
- All carbon vanishes during burning
- Any natural sink removes unlimited CO₂
- Burning fossil fuel adds atmospheric CO₂
Both additions and removals must be counted.
A useful reduction
Fixed evidence 1
A toy activity emits 40 units before a 25% reduction.
3. True or false: the reduction leaves 30 emission units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A quarter is removed, leaving 30 of the original 40 units.
Calculate two cases
Fixed evidence 1
At a classroom factor of 3 emission units per fuel unit, Case A uses 6 fuel units and Case B uses 8.
4. Match each case with emissions.
Matching · 2 points
- Case A
- Case B
Available labels: 24 emission units | 14 emission units | 18 emission units
Multiply activity by the stated factor.
An atmospheric store
Fixed evidence 1
A model air store starts at 100 carbon units, receives 15 and loses 9 per step.
5. Find the final store and explain why “a sink exists” is not enough to conclude no buildup.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives 106 or a six-unit net addition.
- Explains why inflow and outflow must both be compared.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Keep equal useful light
Fixed evidence 1
Two fictional lamps provide the same useful light.
Fixed evidence 2
A uses 10 electricity units; B uses 6.
Fixed evidence 3
The toy supply factor is 2 emission units per electricity unit.
6. Select all correct conclusions.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- B produces exactly zero units
- B produces 12 model units
- A and B provide different stated light
- A produces 20 model units
Equal light is specified; the model totals are 20 and 12.
7. Explain the emission difference and why equal light matters.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares the totals or eight-unit difference.
- Explains why keeping service equal makes the comparison fair.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a useful account
Fixed evidence 1
A school wants to compare a fuel-saving change.
Fixed evidence 2
Option A counts fuel for the same operating hours; option B compares a full week with a single day.
8. Which comparison is more informative?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Only the smallest recorded number
- Only the cleaner-looking exhaust
- A full week against one day
- Same service and operating period
A matched service and period helps isolate the change.
9. Justify the comparison and name one other record needed.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies matched service/time.
- Names fuel quantity, factor or accounting boundary as needed evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to more activity
Fixed evidence 1
A toy vehicle uses 2 emission units per trip.
Fixed evidence 2
It makes 15 trips instead of 10, with the factor unchanged.
10. Select the new total.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 45 units
- 25 units
- 20 units
- 30 units
15 × 2 = 30 emission units.
11. Explain how the total changed even though the factor stayed the same.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives the 20-to-30 increase.
- Explains activity amount versus per-unit factor.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a renewable-timescale claim
Fixed evidence 1
Fossil fuels form over geological timescales.
Fixed evidence 2
A learner says tomorrow’s fuel use is replaced by new fossil fuel tomorrow.
12. True or false: the learner’s replacement claim follows from the source.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Formation is far too slow to replace current use from day to day.
13. Identify the mistaken timescale and give the correct meaning of non-renewable here.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the daily-versus-geological timescale mistake.
- Explains non-renewability relative to the rate of human use.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an energy-saving comparison
Fixed evidence 1
The class can review meter records with adults.
Fixed evidence 2
It must keep necessary lighting and compare similar school days.
14. Match each check with its purpose.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Meter records
- Useful-light check
Available labels: Compare energy use | Measure methane directly | Keep the needed service
An energy reduction must be assessed alongside its service.
15. Propose a supervised reduction trial with an energy measure and a service check.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a safe supervised action and comparable energy measurement.
- Includes a check that necessary service is retained.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: Causes of climate change
- IPCC AR6: Energy systems
- NASA: The carbon cycle
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.2 — Electricity production
Compare electricity sources and demand using an explicit emission account, including generation and lifecycle limits.
Worked examples
1. Two source shares
Worked classroom example
Toy demand is 100 units: 50 at factor 2 and 50 at factor 0.2.
Question: What is the total?
Answer: 110 emission units.
50 × 2 = 100 and 50 × 0.2 = 10. Add the contributions, not just the factors.
2. Less demand
Worked classroom example
A made-up supply factor is 1.5 units per electricity unit. Use falls from 20 to 16.
Question: What emissions are avoided?
Answer: 6 emission units.
Four electricity units are avoided; 4 × 1.5 = 6. The service must still meet the stated need.
3. A boundary check
Worked classroom example
One label says “no exhaust while operating”; another says “zero impacts at every stage.”
Question: Do the labels mean the same thing?
Answer: No. The second makes a much wider claim.
Manufacture, materials and disposal belong to a lifecycle account even when operating exhaust is absent.
Formative quiz
A source boundary
Fixed evidence 1
An equipment record has no fuel-burning exhaust during operation.
Fixed evidence 2
Manufacturing and construction are outside that operating record.
1. True or false: an operating-exhaust record leaves manufacturing emissions untested.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A wider account includes stages absent from the operating boundary.
Two electricity sources
Fixed evidence 1
In this toy mix, fossil generation has factor 2 and renewable generation factor 0.2 emission units per electricity unit.
2. Match each source with its supplied factor.
Matching · 2 points
- Fossil group
- Renewable group
Available labels: 2 per electricity unit | 0.2 per electricity unit | 20 per electricity unit
These are classroom assumptions, not universal source values.
Compute a mixed supply
Fixed evidence 1
Demand is 100 electricity units; 50% is renewable.
Fixed evidence 2
Factors are fossil 2 and renewable 0.2.
3. What is the total under these assumptions?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 100 emission units
- 110 emission units
- 20 emission units
- 220 emission units
50 × 2 + 50 × 0.2 = 110.
Read a proposal fairly
Fixed evidence 1
A school compares two electricity plans that must provide the same service.
Fixed evidence 2
Emissions, cost and reliable delivery all matter.
4. Select all relevant checks.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Electricity delivered when needed
- Only the shortest advertisement
- Only the colour of the equipment
- Emissions under a stated boundary
Service reliability and a defined emission account are relevant.
Demand and emissions
Fixed evidence 1
Toy factor is 2 emission units per electricity unit.
Fixed evidence 2
Use falls from 30 to 24 while useful lighting stays equal.
5. Calculate the remaining emissions and explain why the equal-light condition matters.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly calculates 48 remaining or 12 avoided from 60.
- Explains service-matched efficiency.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A new mix
Fixed evidence 1
Toy demand is 80 electricity units with 25% renewable supply.
Fixed evidence 2
Factors: renewable 0.2 and fossil 2.
6. Place the emission contributions.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Renewable contribution
- Fossil contribution
Available labels: 120 emission units | 40 emission units | 4 emission units
20 renewable units × 0.2 = 4; 60 fossil units × 2 = 120.
7. Find the total and explain why each factor applies to only part of the demand.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly totals 124 emission units.
- Explains weighting by the 20/60 source amounts.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose the lower total
Fixed evidence 1
Two plans meet the same service: A uses 100 units at average factor 1.2; B uses 120 at factor 0.8.
Fixed evidence 2
Factors include the same stated stages.
8. Select the lower-emission result.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Plan A: 120 units
- Both: 96 units
- Plan B: 96 units
- Both: 120 units
A gives 120; B gives 96 despite higher electricity use.
9. Justify the choice with both totals and name one non-emission requirement still worth checking.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 96 and 120.
- Names a relevant additional decision requirement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to increased demand
Fixed evidence 1
A toy mix stays at 50% renewable, with factors 0.2 and 2.
Fixed evidence 2
Demand increases from 100 to 120 units.
10. Choose the totals.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Demand 100
- Demand 120
Available labels: 132 emission units | 120 emission units | 110 emission units
The average factor is 1.1; changing demand changes the total.
11. Explain why a fixed source mix does not mean fixed total emissions.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares the two totals.
- Distinguishes a fixed mix/factor from changing demand.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a factor average
Fixed evidence 1
A learner uses 90% fossil at factor 2 and 10% renewable at 0.2, but takes the simple average 1.1 as if shares were equal.
12. What is the correct weighted factor?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 0.90 per unit
- 1.10 per unit
- 2.20 per unit
- 1.82 per unit
0.9 × 2 + 0.1 × 0.2 = 1.82.
13. Identify the mistake and show the corrected weighting.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies failure to weight unequal shares.
- Gives correct weighted calculation/result.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an electricity trial
Goal
Reduce electricity-related emissions while maintaining useful light.
Evidence
Adults can provide meter records and a consistent light/service check. The source mix may change over time.
14. Select all records needed for a defensible comparison.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Only a photograph of a switch
- Electricity use and matching period
- Stated supply factor or mix
- Only the number of pupils smiling
Demand and the emission factor both affect the result.
15. Propose a comparison that measures energy, retains service and states the supply assumption.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes comparable energy records and a retained-service check.
- States or documents the supply factor/mix assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Energy systems
- IPCC AR6: Demand, services and social aspects of mitigation
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.3 — Transportation
Compare transport emissions per trip and per passenger while considering safety, access and the required journey.
Worked examples
1. Share a trip
Worked classroom example
A toy shuttle emits 48 units and carries 12 passengers over the specified route.
Question: What is the average per passenger?
Answer: 4 emission units.
48 ÷ 12 = 4. This uses the given trip total, actual passengers and common route.
2. Capacity is not occupancy
Worked classroom example
A bus has 30 seats but only 10 passengers. Its model trip emissions are 60.
Question: What divisor gives the actual per-passenger estimate?
Answer: 10 passengers, giving 6 units each.
Empty seats do not count as people transported. Dividing by 30 would understate the estimate for this trip.
3. A practical choice
Worked classroom example
A fictional low-emission route has no safe crossing for children. Another option has a supervised accessible crossing.
Question: Can emissions alone settle the choice?
Answer: No. Safety and access must also be satisfied.
A plan must provide the journey safely. Learners compare options with adults rather than taking an unsafe route.
Formative quiz
Journey quantities
Fixed evidence 1
A vehicle-trip total refers to the whole vehicle journey.
Fixed evidence 2
A per-passenger estimate divides that total by actual passengers.
1. Choose the measure.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Whole trip’s 40 units
- 40 units shared by 10 people
Available labels: 4 units per passenger | Vehicle-trip emissions | 40 units per passenger
The total and the shared average are different quantities.
Count the passengers
Fixed evidence 1
A toy bus emits 60 units per trip.
Fixed evidence 2
Trip A carries 20; Trip B carries 10.
Fixed evidence 3
The route and toy trip total are fixed.
2. Match each per-passenger amount.
Matching · 2 points
- Trip A
- Trip B
Available labels: 3 units per passenger | 30 units per passenger | 6 units per passenger
Divide 60 by actual passengers.
Read a new trip
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional shuttle emits 36 units over a fixed route with 9 passengers.
3. Select the emissions per passenger.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 4 units
- 3 units
- 36 units
- 9 units
36 ÷ 9 = 4 units per passenger.
A boundary claim
Fixed evidence 1
A vehicle has no tailpipe exhaust.
Fixed evidence 2
Its electricity generation and manufacture are outside that tailpipe measure.
4. True or false: electricity generation and manufacture can matter beyond tailpipe exhaust.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A lifecycle account includes stages beyond the tailpipe.
Choose a feasible route
Route A
A short walking route lacks a safe crossing.
Route B
An accessible shared ride has a supervised stop and a stated emission estimate.
5. Explain why the route choice needs more than an emission number and name one required check.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that safety/access constraints matter alongside emissions.
- Names a specific relevant route/access check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare the same journey
Fixed evidence 1
Toy journey A emits 20 units for 4 passengers.
Fixed evidence 2
Journey B emits 60 units for 20 passengers.
Fixed evidence 3
Both cover the same distance and boundary.
6. Which has lower emissions per passenger?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- B: 3 per passenger
- A: 5 per passenger
- B: 20 per passenger
- A: 4 per passenger
A is 20 ÷ 4 = 5; B is 60 ÷ 20 = 3.
7. Justify the lower choice and explain why total vehicle emissions alone would mislead.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 3 and 5 per passenger.
- Explains the role of passenger occupancy in interpreting totals.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — A route decision
Route evidence
A safe supervised path is available for some pupils; others need accessible shared transport.
Goal
Reduce emissions while preserving a safe feasible journey for everyone.
8. Match the planning response.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Pupils with a safe usable path
- Pupils needing accessible transport
Available labels: Provide a feasible accessible ride | Require one unsafe option for all | Consider supervised active travel
Different needs can justify different options.
9. Propose a fair choice process and explain why one identical route may not suit all.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses a needs-based safe choice process.
- Explains a specific difference in feasibility/access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to fewer passengers
Fixed evidence 1
A toy bus emits 72 units per trip.
Fixed evidence 2
Occupancy falls from 24 passengers to 12; the trip total remains fixed in this model.
10. Choose the two averages.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Before
- After
Available labels: 12 units per passenger | 6 units per passenger | 3 units per passenger
Halving passengers doubles this fixed-total average.
11. Explain the change and name the assumption that allowed this calculation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 3 and 6.
- States the fixed trip-total/actual-passenger assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the empty-seat error
Fixed evidence 1
A 40-seat vehicle carries 8 passengers and emits 48 units.
Fixed evidence 2
A learner divides by 40 and reports 1.2 per passenger.
12. Select the corrected average.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 6 per passenger
- 8 per passenger
- 1.2 per passenger
- 40 per passenger
Use eight actual passengers: 48 ÷ 8 = 6.
13. Identify the wrong divisor and give the corrected calculation.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies capacity versus actual occupancy error.
- Correctly calculates six per passenger.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a school travel study
Fixed evidence 1
The class may use anonymised adult-provided counts.
Fixed evidence 2
It must compare the same route and include safety/access requirements.
14. True or false: counting only vehicle totals is enough to compare emissions per pupil.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Actual passengers and matched journey conditions are also needed.
15. Propose the two main quantities needed for a per-pupil estimate and one fair-comparison condition.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names trip emissions and actual passenger count.
- States a matched journey boundary/distance or a necessary feasibility condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Transport
- IPCC AR6: Demand, services and social aspects of mitigation
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.4 — Industry
Distinguish energy emissions, process emissions and material demand when comparing industrial changes.
Worked examples
1. Add the sources
Worked classroom example
Toy factory emissions: energy 24 units and process 16.
Question: What is the defined total?
Answer: 40 emission units.
Add both included categories. The total would be incomplete if either were ignored.
2. One part changes
Worked classroom example
Energy emissions fall from 30 to 20; process emissions remain 15.
Question: What is the new total and reduction?
Answer: 35 total, a reduction of 10.
The starting total was 45. Only the ten-unit energy decrease changes this two-part account.
3. Factor and output
Worked classroom example
A toy factory changes from 10 products at 4 units each to 20 at 3 each.
Question: Does total emissions fall?
Answer: No. It rises from 40 to 60.
The per-product factor improved, but production doubled. Both factor and output determine the total.
Formative quiz
Two factory sources
Fixed evidence 1
Fuel used for heat causes energy-related emissions.
Fixed evidence 2
A chemical manufacturing reaction can cause process emissions.
1. Choose the source category.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Fuel for heat
- Gas from the manufacturing reaction
Available labels: Energy emissions | No emission source | Process emissions
Different sources may need different measures.
A complete toy account
Fixed evidence 1
Energy emissions are 18; process emissions are 12.
Fixed evidence 2
Both are included in the account.
2. Place each total.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Combined emissions
- Process part
Available labels: 6 emission units | 30 emission units | 12 emission units
The combined total is 18 + 12 = 30.
A per-item factor
Fixed evidence 1
A toy workshop makes 15 equal-quality items at 2 emission units each.
3. What is the total?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 7.5 emission units
- 30 emission units
- 17 emission units
- 13 emission units
15 × 2 = 30 under the stated factor.
Service and material
Fixed evidence 1
A safe repair extends an item’s useful life.
Fixed evidence 2
A replacement requires new production under the supplied comparison.
4. Match each action with its intended effect.
Matching · 2 points
- Safe repair
- Careful material cutting
Available labels: Guarantee zero impacts | Extend useful service | Reduce production waste
Both can reduce new material demand without claiming zero emissions.
Explain a partial change
Fixed evidence 1
A factory’s toy emissions are energy 40 and process 20.
Fixed evidence 2
An upgrade reduces the energy part by 25%; process stays 20.
5. Find the new combined total and explain why it is not zero.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly calculates the 50-unit combined total.
- Explains remaining energy and unchanged process contributions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read an improved account
Fixed evidence 1
Before: energy 30, process 20.
Fixed evidence 2
After: energy 18, process 20.
Fixed evidence 3
These are fictional comparable production records.
6. Select the new total.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 32 units
- 38 units
- 20 units
- 50 units
18 + 20 = 38 emission units.
7. Explain the reduction and identify the source that did not change.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly describes the 12-unit total decrease.
- Identifies unchanged process emissions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Compare product service
Fixed evidence 1
Two fictional chairs meet the same safety standard.
Fixed evidence 2
Chair A lasts 2 years at 20 production units; B lasts 4 years at 30.
Fixed evidence 3
Assume no repair or disposal differences.
8. Choose the production emissions per service year.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Chair A
- Chair B
Available labels: 10 units per year | 7.5 units per year | 30 units per year
Divide production emissions by the supplied useful lifetime.
9. Justify the lower service-year value and state the comparison’s limit.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 7.5 and 10.
- Names a stated lifetime or omitted-stage limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to greater output
Fixed evidence 1
A toy plant initially makes 20 items at 3 emission units each.
Fixed evidence 2
Later it makes 30 at 2.5 each.
10. Place the totals.
Matching · 2 points
- Initial period
- Later period
Available labels: 50 emission units | 60 emission units | 75 emission units
Output growth outweighs the lower per-item factor.
11. Explain why improved per-item efficiency did not reduce this total.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives the correct totals or 15-unit increase.
- Explains output versus intensity.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a zero-emission claim
Fixed evidence 1
A factory switches purchased electricity to a lower-emission source.
Fixed evidence 2
It still burns fuel for heat and has process emissions.
12. True or false: the electricity change alone proves the whole factory has zero emissions.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Other included sources remain and must be measured.
13. Identify the incomplete boundary and name two sources that must still be counted.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the omitted-source/boundary error.
- Names both remaining fuel and process sources.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a useful factory comparison
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional workshop will compare a waste-reducing production method.
Fixed evidence 2
Both methods must make equal-quality items.
Fixed evidence 3
Learners use supplied records only.
14. Match each record with its role.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Material waste per period
- Equal-quality items produced
Available labels: Guarantee every environmental benefit | Measure useful output | Measure discarded material
The records let the class compare waste relative to service.
15. Propose a comparison that records waste and output without confusing lower production with better efficiency.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Measures both waste and useful output under comparable conditions.
- Uses per-item and/or total comparison to distinguish efficiency from less production.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Industry
- IPCC AR6: Demand, services and social aspects of mitigation
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.5 — Agriculture
Explain several agricultural emission pathways while considering food production, livelihoods and site-specific solutions.
Worked examples
1. Three source labels
Worked classroom example
A toy farm record lists tractor CO₂, livestock methane and soil nitrous oxide.
Question: Why keep separate gas labels?
Answer: They describe different pathways and gases.
An emission estimate needs a defined gas and metric. Equal masses cannot silently be added as equal climate effects.
2. A supplied reduction
Worked classroom example
A fictional methane pathway emits 30 units. A tested scenario cuts that pathway by 20%.
Question: How much remains in that pathway?
Answer: 24 units.
The reduction is 6. Other farm sources are not automatically reduced by this pathway-specific result.
3. Read the yield constraint
Worked classroom example
A model plan must produce at least 10 crop baskets. A emits 20 units with 11 baskets; B emits 15 with 8.
Question: Does B satisfy the full requirement?
Answer: No. It misses the stated food requirement.
Its emission number is smaller, but a feasible comparison must also meet the required output.
Formative quiz
Agricultural pathways
Fixed evidence 1
Livestock digestion can release methane.
Fixed evidence 2
Soil and fertiliser processes can release nitrous oxide.
Fixed evidence 3
Farm fuel use can release CO₂.
1. Select all accurate links.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Soil processes → nitrous oxide
- Livestock digestion → methane
- All farm emissions are oxygen
- Every farm has identical emissions
Different activities and conditions produce different gases and amounts.
Keep source labels
Fixed evidence 1
A tractor burns fuel.
Fixed evidence 2
A livestock digestion pathway releases methane.
2. Match the named gas.
Matching · 2 points
- Fuel-burning tractor
- Livestock digestion
Available labels: Methane | Carbon dioxide | Nitrogen as the stated emission
The sources require different explanations.
Read the farm table
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional trial records 12 crop baskets and 40 water units.
Fixed evidence 2
Yield and water use measure different outcomes.
3. Place each indicator.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- 12 baskets
- 40 water units
Available labels: Water use | Exact methane mass | Food output
The source does not supply a methane measurement.
One pathway changes
Fixed evidence 1
A methane pathway starts at 50 toy units and is cut by 20%.
Fixed evidence 2
Other sources are unchanged.
4. Choose the two amounts.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Avoided in this pathway
- Remaining in this pathway
Available labels: 40 emission units | 20 emission units | 10 emission units
One fifth of 50 is ten, leaving forty.
A local trial
Plan
A practice from one wet rice site is proposed for a different soil and crop.
Needed evidence
Local water conditions, yield, emissions and farmers’ knowledge can change the decision.
5. Why should the practice be checked locally, and name two useful outcomes to compare.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains site-specific differences or the need for local expertise.
- Names two relevant outcomes, such as yield plus water/emissions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A methane scenario
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional pathway emits 40 units before a 25% reduction.
Fixed evidence 2
The numbers apply only to this pathway.
6. Select the remaining emissions.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 30 units
- 10 units
- 25 units
- 40 units
The reduction is ten, leaving thirty.
7. Explain the result and why the entire farm cannot be called zero-emission from it.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives thirty remaining or ten avoided.
- Explains the pathway boundary and remaining/other sources.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a feasible crop plan
Fixed evidence 1
The toy requirement is at least 10 crop baskets and no more than 50 water units.
Fixed evidence 2
Plan A: 11 baskets, 45 water, 30 emissions.
Fixed evidence 3
Plan B: 8 baskets, 35 water, 20 emissions.
8. Select all supported statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- B has lower emissions but misses yield
- B satisfies every requirement
- A meets the stated crop minimum
- Lower emissions alone settle the plan
Feasibility includes the food requirement as well as emissions.
9. Justify which plan meets the constraints and state B’s specific problem.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly justifies A with yield and water limits.
- Identifies B’s yield shortfall.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a water account
Fixed evidence 1
A toy farm water store starts at 60 units.
Fixed evidence 2
Inflow is 15.
Fixed evidence 3
Method A uses 20 per step; Method B uses 12, with other conditions fixed.
10. Choose the final stores.
Matching · 2 points
- Method A
- Method B
Available labels: 63 water units | 87 water units | 55 water units
Compute start plus inflow minus use for each method.
11. Explain the difference and why yield should also be checked before choosing B.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares the stores or eight-unit difference.
- Explains the need to check crop output or another essential trade-off.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an all-farms claim
Claim
One trial lowered methane, so the same method works identically on every farm and lowers every gas.
Evidence
Soil, crop, water and management differ. A methane result does not automatically measure CO₂ or nitrous oxide.
12. Choose the appropriate judgments.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Use at a different farm
- Claim about every gas
Available labels: Needs additional gas evidence | Needs local checking | Guaranteed by one methane trial
Both generalizations exceed the trial evidence.
13. Identify the two overgeneralizations and explain what should be checked.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies unsupported transfer to all farms.
- Identifies unsupported transfer from methane to every gas and requests evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a farmer-led comparison
Fixed evidence 1
A supervised trial compares two practices on comparable plots.
Fixed evidence 2
It must record food output and at least one environmental indicator, with local agricultural advice.
14. Match the measurement role.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Crop yield
- Water use or relevant emissions
Available labels: Food-service outcome | Guaranteed profit | Environmental outcome
Both types of outcome matter to the stated trial.
15. Propose a fair trial with one food indicator and one environmental indicator.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes comparable plots/periods and crop yield.
- Includes a relevant environmental indicator measured consistently.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
- United Nations: Methane
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.6 — Deforestation
Explain how forest clearing changes stored carbon, future uptake and habitat, and evaluate protection using evidence.
Worked examples
1. A changed store
Worked classroom example
A fictional forest holds 100 carbon units. A stated clearing event releases 25 and leaves 75 stored elsewhere or on site.
Question: How much entered the air in that account?
Answer: 25 carbon units.
The original store is not identical to the release. The source explicitly states that some carbon remains stored.
2. Seedling and mature forest
Worked classroom example
A mature plot stores 180 units. A new planting stores 6 at the starting date.
Question: Does planting the same number of trees instantly replace the store?
Answer: No. The starting amounts are very different.
Growth and survival take time. Tree count alone does not establish equal carbon storage.
3. Two connected indicators
Worked classroom example
A forest protection project measures cover and water quality over several visits.
Question: Why use both?
Answer: They describe different ecosystem outcomes.
Forest area can remain while its condition changes. Additional indicators help assess water and habitat effects.
Formative quiz
Timing of a release
Fixed evidence 1
Cleared wood may burn, decay or enter products.
Fixed evidence 2
Some stored carbon may remain for a time.
1. True or false: some carbon can remain stored after clearing, depending on its fate.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Carbon fate and release timing depend on what happens to wood and soil.
Stock and flow
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional forest has 150 carbon units stored and takes up 5 new units this year.
2. Choose each quantity.
Dropdown · 2 points
- 150 carbon units
- 5 units this year
Available labels: Existing store | Immediate total emission | Annual uptake
A standing stock is not an annual flow.
Track one loss
Fixed evidence 1
A toy forest store starts at 90 carbon units, gains 6 and loses 20 in a period.
3. Place the final amount and net change.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Final store
- Net change
Available labels: Loss of 20 units | 76 carbon units | Loss of 14 units
Both growth and loss belong in the net account.
Protection outcomes
Carbon and habitat goal
Protect the existing forest and check its physical condition.
Community goal
Respect affected communities and listen to their observations.
Evidence goal
Monitor outcomes over time rather than relying on a sign alone.
4. Select all useful monitoring evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Community and habitat condition records
- Only the day’s opening ceremony
- Repeated forest-cover observations
- Only the size of a project sign
Monitoring should measure the outcomes the project claims to protect.
Explain replacement time
Fixed evidence 1
A mature plot stores 200 toy carbon units.
Fixed evidence 2
A new plot begins at 10 and gains 5 per period under a simple rule.
Fixed evidence 3
Real growth can vary.
5. Why is the new plot not an immediate replacement, and what must be monitored as it grows?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the large initial storage gap and time required.
- Names survival/growth monitoring or uncertainty in the growth assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A carbon inventory
Fixed evidence 1
Before a stated clearing period a plot has 120 units.
Fixed evidence 2
It gains 4 through growth and loses 30 through included processes.
6. Choose the two results.
Matching · 2 points
- Final store
- Net loss
Available labels: 94 carbon units | 90 carbon units | 26 carbon units
120 + 4 − 30 = 94, a net loss of 26.
7. Explain the final amount and why the gross loss of 30 differs from the net loss.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly computes 94 or the 26-unit net loss.
- Distinguishes gross loss from a net account including growth.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose protection evidence
Fixed evidence 1
Team A uses repeated mapped observations and local checks.
Fixed evidence 2
Team B says a protection sign proves no further forest loss can occur.
8. True or false: a protection sign alone proves permanent prevention of forest loss.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
An intention or rule needs implementation and continuing outcome evidence.
9. Justify the stronger method and name a useful outcome to monitor.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Prefers repeated observations over the sign alone.
- Names a relevant monitored outcome.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a protection plan
Fixed evidence 1
Site A’s main pressure is clearing for roads; Site B’s main pressure is repeated fire.
Fixed evidence 2
The communities and access needs differ.
10. Match each starting investigation.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Site A
- Site B
Available labels: Fire risk and management evidence | Assume identical pressures | Road planning and clearing evidence
A transferred plan needs evidence about the new site’s actual pressure.
11. How should Site B adapt the idea of protection without copying every action from A?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Adapts action to the fire pressure rather than copying road measures.
- Includes local evidence and/or affected-community participation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a tree-count claim
Fixed evidence 1
A report says 100 new seedlings instantly replace the carbon and habitat of 100 mature trees.
Fixed evidence 2
It gives no size, survival or habitat data.
12. What is the main error?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Mature trees never change with time
- Seedlings never contain any carbon
- Every planting necessarily harms habitat
- Equal counts imply equal function
Equal counts do not establish equal storage, survival or ecosystem function.
13. Identify the missing comparison and propose two relevant measurements.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains why count alone does not establish equal carbon/habitat.
- Names two relevant measurements, such as storage and survival.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a protection check
Goal
Check whether a local protection action reduces forest loss.
Requirements
Use repeated comparable observations and hear affected residents; do not double-count the same area.
14. Select all useful steps.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Count one area as two separate forests
- Assume no loss without checking
- Record residents’ relevant observations
- Map the same area at repeated times
Repeated observations and community evidence help check the outcome.
15. Propose a monitoring plan with one physical indicator and one participation/accounting safeguard.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a repeated physical forest indicator.
- Includes participation or protection against double-counting.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
- NASA: The carbon cycle
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.7 — Land-use change
Compare changes in land use through carbon, water, heat and community effects rather than one label alone.
Worked examples
1. Use versus cover
Worked classroom example
A place is used as a playground and has both paving and grass.
Question: Which term is the use and which describes cover?
Answer: Playground is the use; paving and grass are covers.
One use can contain different physical surfaces, so both descriptions are useful.
2. Runoff from a changed surface
Worked classroom example
Toy rainfall is 100 units. Before, 20% infiltrates; after, 50%. No other losses are included.
Question: How does runoff change?
Answer: It falls from 80 to 50 units.
Infiltration rises from 20 to 50, leaving 30 fewer runoff units under the two-pathway rule.
3. A wider decision
Worked classroom example
A plan improves shade but blocks the only accessible route to classrooms.
Question: Does it meet a requirement to preserve access?
Answer: No. The access requirement is unmet.
A favorable climate-related indicator does not cancel a necessary social or safety condition.
Formative quiz
Identify land cover
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional school map labels grass, paving, trees and water.
Fixed evidence 2
The question asks for an impermeable paved surface.
1. Select the paved area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Grass
- Paving
- Water
- Trees
Paving is the hard surface named in the source.
Separate terms
Purpose
School garden names how the area is used.
Physical surface
Soil and plants describes the area’s land cover.
2. Choose each category.
Dropdown · 2 points
- School garden
- Soil and plants
Available labels: Land use | Future temperature | Land cover
Purpose and cover are related but different descriptions.
Follow changed runoff
Fixed evidence 1
Two equal toy plots receive 80 rain units.
Fixed evidence 2
Plot A infiltrates 50%; Plot B infiltrates 25%.
3. Match the runoff amount.
Matching · 2 points
- Plot A
- Plot B
Available labels: 40 water units | 20 water units | 60 water units
Subtract infiltration from rain for each plot.
Read the local shade model
Fixed evidence 1
Toy indicator is 28 + 4 − 4 × shade fraction.
Fixed evidence 2
At 25% shade it is 31°C.
4. What does the model show at 75% shade?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 29°C
- 28°C
- 31°C
- 35°C
28 + 4 − 3 = 29°C under this assumed rule.
Explain a limited conclusion
Fixed evidence 1
A plot change reduces modeled runoff.
Fixed evidence 2
No measurements of habitat, cost or access are included.
5. What conclusion is supported, and what additional check is needed before calling the whole plan successful?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the conclusion to runoff under the stated model/evidence.
- Names a relevant additional requirement or outcome to check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare identical rain
Fixed evidence 1
Rainfall is 100 model units.
Fixed evidence 2
The old surface infiltrates 30%; the new surface infiltrates 60%.
Fixed evidence 3
Other pathways are omitted.
6. Select the runoff reduction.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 60 water units
- 20 water units
- 30 water units
- 90 water units
Runoff decreases from 70 to 40, a reduction of 30.
7. Explain the two runoff amounts and identify the common condition.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives 70 and 40 or their 30-unit difference.
- Identifies common rainfall or the controlled two-pathway comparison.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Compare complete plans
Fixed evidence 1
Equal-area school plans must retain an accessible path.
Fixed evidence 2
Plan A adds shade and keeps the path; Plan B adds more shade but blocks it.
8. Match each plan to the constraint.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Plan A
- Plan B
Available labels: Fails stated access condition | Guaranteed best in every place | Meets stated access condition
More shade does not compensate for failing a required access route.
9. Justify the feasible choice and describe how the other plan could be improved.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Justifies A through the stated constraint.
- Proposes a plausible redesign preserving access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the idea elsewhere
Fixed evidence 1
A successful permeable plot trial used sandy soil.
Fixed evidence 2
A second site has different soil, slope and drainage.
10. True or false: the second site is guaranteed the identical runoff percentage.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Local conditions can change the measured effect.
11. How would you adapt the trial to the second site and check its result?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Adapts to local site conditions rather than assuming the same percentage.
- Includes a relevant comparable measurement/control.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a hidden-area comparison
Fixed evidence 1
Plan A stores 100 carbon units across 10 area units.
Fixed evidence 2
Plan B stores 90 across 5.
Fixed evidence 3
A report says A has more carbon per area because 100 is larger.
12. Choose the carbon per area.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Plan A
- Plan B
Available labels: 10 units per area | 20 units per area | 18 units per area
The relevant comparison divides each total by its own area.
13. Identify the error and correct the per-area ranking.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies totals versus per-area confusion.
- Correctly calculates/ranks 10 and 18.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a land-use investigation
Fixed evidence 1
A school will test one small surface change.
Fixed evidence 2
The goal is less runoff while keeping safe access.
Fixed evidence 3
Learners only observe supervised areas.
14. Match the measurement to the goal.
Matching · 2 points
- Runoff after comparable rain
- Check of the accessible route
Available labels: Water-management outcome | Proof of every ecosystem effect | Access requirement
Each goal needs evidence suited to it.
15. Propose a trial that measures runoff and checks access, with a fair comparison.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a fair changed-versus-comparison runoff measurement.
- Includes an explicit safe-access check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
- NASA: Climate and Earth’s energy budget
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.8 — Consumption and waste
Trace consumption and waste through a product’s life and compare reduction, reuse and disposal using stated assumptions.
Worked examples
1. Count lifecycle stages
Worked classroom example
Toy product emissions are manufacture 12, transport 3 and use 5 units.
Question: What is the included total?
Answer: 20 emission units.
12 + 3 + 5 = 20. This total includes only the stated stages; disposal would need another entry if relevant.
2. Spread the starting impact
Worked classroom example
A toy reusable item has 20 manufacture units and no other included impact in this simplified example. It is used ten times.
Question: What is the manufacture impact per use?
Answer: 2 units per use.
20 ÷ 10 = 2. Real comparisons must also consider relevant cleaning and disposal impacts.
3. Prevent leftovers
Worked classroom example
A fictional canteen cuts avoidable food waste from 12 to 9 kg for the same number of adequate meals.
Question: What fraction was avoided?
Answer: 3 kg, or 25% of the original waste.
The reduction is 12 − 9 = 3. Divide by the original 12 to obtain one quarter.
Formative quiz
A lifecycle boundary
Raw materials
Obtain the materials used to make the bottle.
Manufacture
Make the bottle from those materials.
Transport
Move the bottle to its users.
Use
Use and clean the bottle as required.
Disposal
Manage the bottle when its useful life ends.
1. True or false: manufacture and disposal can both belong to a product’s lifecycle.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Earlier and later stages can also contribute.
Different actions
Fixed evidence 1
Repair restores useful service.
Fixed evidence 2
Recycling processes discarded material for another use.
2. Place the action label.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Fix a safe usable chair
- Process suitable scrap material
Available labels: Repair | Recycle | Prevent all future emissions
The actions keep value in different ways.
A product account
Fixed evidence 1
Toy stages: manufacture 16, transport 4, use 6 emission units.
3. Match each amount.
Matching · 2 points
- Total included emissions
- Manufacture contribution
Available labels: 16 units | 20 units | 26 units
Include all three stated stages in the total.
A waste reduction
Fixed evidence 1
Avoidable waste starts at 40 toy units and falls by 25% for an equal service.
4. Select the remaining amount.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 40 units
- 25 units
- 30 units
- 10 units
A quarter of forty is ten, leaving thirty.
Question a green label
Label
This cup is reusable, so it has no environmental impact.
Missing information
Manufacture, actual number of uses, cleaning and disposal are not described.
5. Why is the claim too strong, and what two kinds of information would improve the comparison?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects zero-impact inference from reusability alone.
- Names two relevant lifecycle/use details.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare equal uses
Fixed evidence 1
Toy option A costs 3 emission units per use.
Fixed evidence 2
B starts at 12 manufacture units and costs 1 per use.
Fixed evidence 3
Compare 10 uses; other stages are equal or excluded.
6. Which has lower included emissions after ten uses?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- B: 22 units
- A: 30 units
- A: 13 units
- B: 120 units
A = 10 × 3 = 30; B = 12 + 10 × 1 = 22.
7. Justify the result and state the assumption about service.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 22 and 30.
- States equal useful service/use count or the explicit boundary assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a food-waste trial
Fixed evidence 1
The canteen serves the same number of adequate meals.
Fixed evidence 2
It compares avoidable leftovers before and after a portion-choice change.
8. Match each measure with its purpose.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Avoidable leftovers
- Adequate meals served
Available labels: Check the food service remains | Measure prevented waste | Prove every gas is zero
Waste reduction should retain the needed food service.
9. Explain why both measures are needed and name one fair-comparison condition.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the need for waste and adequate-service measures.
- Names a fair matching condition/method.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to fewer uses
Fixed evidence 1
Use the same toy rules: A has 3 units per use; B has 12 starting units plus 1 per use.
Fixed evidence 2
Compare only 3 uses.
10. Place the totals for three uses.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Option A
- Option B
Available labels: 15 emission units | 9 emission units | 3 emission units
At three uses, B has not spread its starting impact across enough uses to beat A under these assumptions.
11. Explain why the ranking differs from a ten-use comparison without claiming one product is always better.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 9 and 15.
- Explains dependence on use count/assumptions rather than universal superiority.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an incomplete disposal claim
Fixed evidence 1
A school’s waste bin becomes lighter because some waste is burned elsewhere.
Fixed evidence 2
A report claims the smaller bin alone proves lower total emissions.
12. What is the main error?
Hotspot · 2 points
- A complete lifecycle comparison
- An omitted disposal stage
- A direct measurement of every gas
- A proof that all prevention failed
Moving material out of the bin does not remove its disposal impacts from the wider account.
13. Identify the missing boundary and describe evidence needed to check the claim.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies off-site treatment/burning as omitted.
- Requests complete destination/treatment evidence within a consistent boundary.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a reduction project
Goal
Reduce avoidable school materials waste without removing needed learning materials.
Evidence plan
Record useful materials supplied, waste amount and where remaining waste goes.
14. Select all useful steps.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Cut needed materials without checking
- Hide discarded items from the account
- Record the destination of remaining waste
- Measure waste before and after
The comparison must measure prevention and track the remainder.
15. Propose one prevention or reuse action and two records that would test it.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a plausible action preserving useful service.
- Names at least two relevant records, including waste and service or disposal.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- IPCC AR6: Demand, services and social aspects of mitigation
- United Nations: Methane
- IPCC AR6: Industry
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.9 — Carbon emissions
Distinguish carbon dioxide emissions, atmospheric concentration and net changes, and build transparent emission accounts.
Worked examples
1. A lower flow, a growing store
Worked classroom example
Toy carbon inflow falls from 12 to 8 per step; removal remains 5.
Question: Does the store still grow after the change?
Answer: Yes, by 3 units per step.
The new inflow is smaller than before but still exceeds removal. Rate reduction is not yet a falling store.
2. Avoided versus removed
Worked classroom example
A baseline activity would emit 40 units; the changed activity emits 28. No capture occurs.
Question: What is avoided and what is physically removed?
Answer: 12 avoided; no removal is stated.
The difference compares two emission scenarios. It does not describe taking twelve units out of the air.
3. No double counting
Worked classroom example
A defined inventory has transport 12 and electricity 18. The electricity subtotal already includes lighting.
Question: May we add the lighting part again?
Answer: No. The correct stated total is 30.
Adding a subtotal twice would inflate the inventory. Source labels and boundaries prevent this.
Formative quiz
Flow and concentration
Fixed evidence 1
A release per day is an emission rate.
Fixed evidence 2
Gas present relative to air is concentration.
1. Place the quantity labels.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Release per day
- Gas relative to air
Available labels: Exact global temperature | Concentration | Emission rate
The quantities are connected but measured differently.
A reduced input
Fixed evidence 1
Toy inflow is 8 carbon units and outflow is 5 during one step.
2. True or false: the store must fall merely because inflow was reduced from a larger amount.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The present net flow is still +3, so the store grows.
Compare a baseline
Fixed evidence 1
Baseline emissions are 50 toy units.
Fixed evidence 2
Changed emissions are 35.
Fixed evidence 3
No capture or removal is included.
3. Choose the correct descriptions.
Dropdown · 2 points
- 15-unit difference
- 35-unit changed total
Available labels: Remaining emissions | Avoided emissions | Physical removal from air
Avoided emissions are a baseline comparison, not automatically removal.
Add once
Fixed evidence 1
A defined inventory has 14 transport units and 26 electricity units; these are separate non-overlapping sources.
4. What is the total?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 52 emission units
- 26 emission units
- 40 emission units
- 12 emission units
14 + 26 = 40, with each source counted once.
Explain the labels
Fixed evidence 1
A graph says “carbon fell by 20” but gives no gas, unit, period, baseline or boundary.
5. Name two essential missing details and explain why they matter.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names gas/unit information that is missing.
- Names period/baseline/boundary information and links it to interpretation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A net atmospheric account
Fixed evidence 1
A toy store receives 9 units and loses 6 in a period.
Fixed evidence 2
It starts at 80 carbon units.
6. True or false: the final store is 83 carbon units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
80 + 9 − 6 = 83.
7. Explain the result and distinguish the nine-unit emission from the three-unit net addition.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains 83 and net +3.
- Distinguishes gross input from net change after removals.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — An inventory comparison
Fixed evidence 1
Two reports cover the same gas, period and sources.
Fixed evidence 2
A is 60 units; B is 45.
Fixed evidence 3
Neither includes physical carbon removal.
8. Select all supported statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The changed case is zero-emission
- B still reports 45 units
- B physically removed 15 units
- B is 15 units below A
The difference is a reduction relative to A, not capture.
9. Justify the reduction and explain why it should not be described as removing carbon from air.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives the fifteen-unit reduction under matched scope.
- Distinguishes avoided release from physical removal.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to changing output
Fixed evidence 1
A toy process improves from 4 to 3 emission units per item, while output rises from 10 to 16 items.
10. Choose the totals.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Before
- After
Available labels: 48 emission units | 40 emission units | 12 emission units
The lower factor is outweighed by increased production.
11. Explain the changed total and the two quantities a report should show.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares 40 and 48.
- Identifies factor/intensity and activity/output as needed quantities.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair double counting
Fixed evidence 1
An electricity subtotal is 30 units and already contains 8 lighting units.
Fixed evidence 2
Transport is a separate 12.
Fixed evidence 3
A report adds 30 + 8 + 12 = 50.
12. What is the corrected total?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 42 emission units
- 38 emission units
- 50 emission units
- 54 emission units
Use 30 + 12 = 42; lighting is inside the electricity subtotal.
13. Identify what was counted twice and show the corrected total.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies double-counted lighting.
- Correctly computes 42 with the non-overlapping categories.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a clear emission report
Fixed evidence 1
A class estimates a school activity’s emissions.
Fixed evidence 2
It must label the gas/unit, period, included sources and estimate basis.
14. Match each detail with its purpose.
Matching · 2 points
- Period and included sources
- Activity amount and factor
Available labels: Show the calculation basis | Define the accounting scope | Guarantee an exact future climate
Scope and method are both needed for checking an estimate.
15. Propose a short reporting format with a clear scope and a reproducible calculation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes gas/unit and period/boundary.
- Includes activity/factor calculation basis or enough detail for reproduction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- NASA: The carbon cycle
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6: Industry
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL2.10 — Methane emissions
Identify methane sources, separate leakage from combustion, and compare methane reductions without confusing them with all greenhouse gases.
Worked examples
1. Name the pathway
Worked classroom example
A fictional gas-system record describes unburned methane escaping from a pipe.
Question: Is this leakage or combustion?
Answer: Leakage.
The gas escapes before burning. Combustion is a different process and needs a different entry in the account.
2. A checked reduction
Worked classroom example
A toy methane pathway starts at 60 units. A measure reduces it by 30%.
Question: How much is avoided and remains?
Answer: 18 avoided and 42 remain.
30% of 60 is 18, so 60 − 18 = 42. Other gas pathways are not described by this calculation.
3. Mass and climate effect
Worked classroom example
Two records report 2 kg methane and 2 kg CO₂, with no conversion metric.
Question: What equality is established?
Answer: Equal mass, not equal warming effect.
Their properties differ. A climate-effect comparison requires a defined metric and time horizon.
Formative quiz
Two gas pathways
Fixed evidence 1
Unburned methane escaping is leakage.
Fixed evidence 2
Burning a carbon-containing fuel can produce CO₂.
1. Choose the process label.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Methane escapes before burning
- Fuel reacts during burning
Available labels: Leakage | Combustion | Photosynthesis
The two stages should not be conflated.
Match the sources
Fixed evidence 1
Fossil-fuel systems can leak methane.
Fixed evidence 2
Low-oxygen decomposition of organic waste can also produce methane.
2. Match each description.
Matching · 2 points
- Unburned gas escaping from a pipe
- Organic waste breaking down with little oxygen
Available labels: Low-oxygen decomposition | Fuel-system leakage | Rain turning into methane
Different sources can produce the same greenhouse gas.
Keep claims within scope
Fixed evidence 1
A trial reduces methane from one pathway.
Fixed evidence 2
It gives no measurements of CO₂ or other gases.
3. Select all accurate statements.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Other gas results need their own evidence
- Every greenhouse gas becomes zero
- The methane pathway may improve
- A methane result proves all farms identical
A pathway-specific result does not measure the whole system.
Calculate a reduction
Fixed evidence 1
A toy methane baseline is 80 emission units.
Fixed evidence 2
The stated measure cuts it by 25%.
4. Place the amounts.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Avoided methane units
- Remaining methane units
Available labels: 60 units | 20 units | 25 units
One quarter of eighty is twenty, leaving sixty.
Explain a source-specific action
Record
A qualified team repairs a methane leak and checks that pathway afterward.
Boundary
The facility also burns fuel and uses electricity; those sources are not part of the leak check.
5. What can the repair evidence support, and what wider claim would need more evidence?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the supported conclusion to the checked methane pathway.
- Identifies wider unmeasured sources needed for a whole-facility claim.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read a methane account
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional pathway starts at 50 methane units and is reduced by 40%.
6. Choose each result.
Matching · 2 points
- Methane units avoided
- Methane units remaining
Available labels: 20 units | 30 units | 40 units
Forty percent of fifty is twenty; thirty remain.
7. Explain both amounts and why this does not quantify a CO₂ reduction.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives avoided and remaining amounts.
- Preserves gas/metric boundaries rather than equating the result to CO₂.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a targeted response
Fixed evidence 1
A fictional record identifies a fuel-system methane leak.
Fixed evidence 2
Qualified staff must handle it; children do not approach it.
8. Select the response that directly fits the record.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Wastewater checks without inspecting fuel equipment
- Qualified leak repair with follow-up checks
- Combustion measurements without checking the leak
- Electricity records without testing the gas
Trained personnel target the leak and verify the result; learners do not handle gas hazards.
9. Justify the response and name the evidence needed afterward.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects qualified action to the specific leak and safe responsibility.
- Names follow-up methane measurement/inspection.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to waste prevention
Fixed evidence 1
Under a toy rule, each unit of a particular waste stream produces 2 methane units.
Fixed evidence 2
Waste falls from 20 to 14 units; the factor stays fixed.
10. Place the methane estimates.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Before prevention
- After prevention
Available labels: 40 methane units | 28 methane units | 12 methane units
Multiply the waste amount by the given pathway factor.
11. Explain the reduction and one reason a real waste system may need a different factor.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares totals or twelve-unit reduction.
- Names a condition affecting real methane generation or release.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a one-gas claim
Claim
A facility cuts methane, so it no longer needs to count carbon dioxide.
Evidence
Methane and CO₂ have separate sources and properties; a cut in one does not erase the other.
12. Select all valid corrections.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Keep methane and CO₂ labels clear
- Rename every CO₂ release as methane
- Continue accounting for CO₂ sources
- Assume both gases fell by identical amounts
A gas-specific action should keep other sources visible.
13. Identify the error and state how the report should handle the two gases.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the unsupported substitution of one gas reduction for another.
- Proposes separate gas reporting or a properly defined common metric.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a monitoring plan
Fixed evidence 1
A qualified waste-management team will test a methane-reduction change.
Fixed evidence 2
It needs a before/after method, a stated boundary and records of other important outcomes.
14. True or false: a single unlabeled low reading proves permanent zero methane for the whole site.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Time, method, boundary and repeated evidence matter; one reading cannot establish permanence.
15. Propose a monitoring plan with comparable methane checks and one additional safeguard or outcome.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes comparable repeated methane measurements with a clear method/scope.
- Includes safety or another relevant outcome/safeguard.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: PISA 2029 Climate Literacy preliminary framework
- United Nations: Methane
- IPCC AR6: Agriculture, forestry and other land uses
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report: Summary for policymakers
All named communities and numeric datasets are fictional classroom examples. Model outputs illustrate stated assumptions and are not forecasts.
CL3.1 — Rising temperatures
Explain a warming trend without confusing it with every day becoming hotter, and use evidence to plan a cooler school day.
Worked examples
1. Read the direction
Worked classroom example
Fictional annual means: 25, 26, 25, 27 °C.
Question: What is the first-to-last change?
Answer: An increase of 2 °C.
27 − 25 = 2. The third value is cooler than the second, but the full series still ends higher.
2. Use the model rule
Worked classroom example
Toy rule: indicator = 28 + 4 − 3 × shade fraction. Shade is 100%.
Question: What indicator does the model give?
Answer: 29 °C in this toy model.
28 + 4 − 3 = 29. This number demonstrates a stated rule; it is not a forecast or a medical threshold.
3. Improve a comparison
Worked classroom example
Trial A used shade at 9 a.m.; trial B used sun at noon.
Question: Why is this not a fair test of shade alone?
Answer: Both shade and time changed.
Time can change temperature. Compare at the same time, with comparable instruments, then repeat the test.
Formative quiz
Find the long pattern
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual school-area means are 26, 27, 26, 28, 29 °C. These five practice points illustrate a pattern, not a measured local climate record.
1. For “Find the long pattern”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- First-to-last change: Rise of 3 °C
- Change from year 2 to 3: Fall of 1 °C
- Change from year 2 to 3: Every year rises equally
- First-to-last change: Fall of 1 °C
29−26=3; 26−27=−1. A temporary dip and an overall rise can occur together.
Read the shade rule
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy model: base 28 °C, added warmth 4 °C, shade reduction at full shade 4 °C. Indicator = 28+4−4×shade fraction. Use shade levels 0%, 50%, 100%.
2. Build the answer board for “Read the shade rule”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- No shade
- Half shade
- Full shade
Available labels: 32 °C | 26 °C | 28 °C | 30 °C
Subtract 0, 2 and 4 from 32 for the three model settings.
Separate a day and a climate
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
An imaginary radio reports today is cooler than yesterday.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A research record reports a warming average over many years. The statements refer to different time scales.
3. Connect each detail in “Separate a day and a climate” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Today compared with yesterday
- Average across many years
- Using one cool day to reject warming
Available labels: Insufficient evidence | Longer-term climate pattern | Short-term weather change | Proof of no climate change
A daily change does not test the direction of a long-term average.
Keep measurements comparable
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
The class wants to test a shade roof.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Team A compares two similar shaded thermometers at the same hour, one below the roof and one at an uncovered site.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
Team B compares a morning reading to a noon reading.
Fixed classroom case · 4 — fictional practice data
Adults arrange safe access.
4. Which conclusion about useful next step follows from “Keep measurements comparable”?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Repeat the matched readings
- Same-hour matched readings
- Time changed as well as shade
- Use only the hottest reading
The matched method keeps more conditions similar; repetition checks changing weather.
Why the dip does not decide
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Practice series: 27, 28, 27, 29, 30 °C over five fictional years. A pupil points only to year 3 and says the whole record is cooling.
5. Explain why the pupil’s conclusion is incomplete. Use both the year-3 dip and the full first-to-last change.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the year-2-to-year-3 decrease of 1 °C.
- Uses the overall 3 °C increase to explain why the full record is not cooling.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A hotter background
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual counts of days above one fixed classroom threshold: 2, 4, 3, 5, 6. The threshold and observation method stayed the same. This is not a real health threshold.
6. Build the answer board for “A hotter background”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Change in count from first to last
- Year 3 compared with year 2
- Best overall description
Available labels: Increase of 4 days | One fewer day | No variability in the record | Generally more threshold days
The counts vary but rise from 2 to 6.
7. How can the count fall in year 3 while the whole record still suggests more hot-threshold days? Use the values for the temporary fall and the first-to-last comparison.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses 4→3 to identify the temporary decrease.
- Uses 2→6 to explain the overall increase.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a school response
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional choices: Plan A adds shade at the school waiting area and repeats comparable temperature checks.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B changes only the poster colour and takes no readings. The aim is to reduce sun exposure and check whether the change helps.
8. Complete the explanation of “Choose a school response” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Plan meeting both aims
- What the shade addresses
- How to check the change
Available labels: Repeated matched measurements | Plan B | Local sun exposure | Plan A
Plan A connects an action to the stated exposure problem and includes a check.
9. Justify choosing Plan A using one reason about exposure and one reason about evidence.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links shade to reducing direct sun exposure.
- Explains why repeated comparable measurements help evaluate the result.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the rule
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A second school uses toy indicator = 27+5−4×shade fraction. It can shade either 25% or 75% of the modeled area. These are hypothetical conditions, not a forecast.
10. For “Transfer the rule”, which numerical answer gives difference between the settings? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 31 °C
- 29 °C
- 4 °C
- 2 °C
The two reductions are 1 and 3 °C, giving indicators 31 and 29 °C.
11. Use the second school’s rule to explain which shade setting gives the lower indicator and by how much.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes or identifies 29 °C at 75% and 31 °C at 25%.
- States that 75% shade gives a 2 °C lower model indicator.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a strong claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional test gives 31 °C at an unshaded station and 29 °C below shade during one afternoon.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Nilo writes: “Shade always lowers every place by exactly 2 °C.”
12. True or false? This one-afternoon test proves shade always lowers every place by exactly 2 °C.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The measured difference is real within the fictional test, but one test cannot establish an identical effect everywhere.
13. Identify Nilo’s overstatement and rewrite the conclusion so it matches the evidence.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the unsupported universal claim.
- Rewrites a limited conclusion using the observed 2 °C difference.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a fair cooling trial
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
The class has two comparable thermometers, one shaded waiting area and one similar unshaded area.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A teacher can record both at the same hour on five days.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The plan must compare shade fairly and include repeated observations.
14. Connect each detail in “Design a fair cooling trial” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Keep the comparison fair
- Check day-to-day changes
- Record useful context
Available labels: Measure both at the same hour | Change instrument each day | Note clouds and wind | Repeat on all five days
Same-time comparable instruments and repeated observations help distinguish shade from changing weather.
15. Propose a brief teacher-led trial that meets both requirements: a fair shade comparison and repeated observations.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps time and instrument method comparable between shade and no shade.
- Repeats paired observations on multiple days rather than relying on one reading.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 11: Extremes
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
- NOAA: Climate and weather
Temperature models and all numerical records are hypothetical. Shade indicators are not health thresholds; use adult and official guidance for real heat conditions.
CL3.2 — Changing rainfall
Explain how rainfall can change in amount, timing and intensity, and reason about water storage and runoff.
Worked examples
1. Equal totals
Worked classroom example
Practice month A has four showers of 20 units. Month B has one shower of 80 units.
Question: Which month has more total rain?
Answer: Neither; both total 80 units.
4×20=80. The totals match, but the one large event may create different runoff and storage challenges.
2. Runoff arithmetic
Worked classroom example
In a classroom model, rain is 90 units and one third soaks in.
Question: How much runs off?
Answer: 60 units.
30 units soak in. The remaining 90−30=60 units run off under this two-part model.
3. A changing tank
Worked classroom example
A fictional tank starts with 50 units, receives 15 and supplies 25. Its capacity is 100.
Question: What is stored after one step?
Answer: 40 units.
50+15−25=40. The tank is not full, so no overflow adjustment is needed.
Formative quiz
Count total and events
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Practice pattern A: four events of 20 rain units. Pattern B: one event of 80 units. Assume no other rain.
1. True or false? Pattern A receives more total rain than pattern B.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Both totals are 80, but timing differs.
Water on two surfaces
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy rain is 80 water units. Surface A lets 50% soak in; surface B lets 25% soak in. Model runoff equals rain minus water soaking in.
2. For “Water on two surfaces”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Runoff from surface B: 60 water units
- Runoff from surface A: 40 water units
- Runoff from surface B: 80 water units soaking in
- Runoff from surface A: 60 water units
A absorbs 40 and B absorbs 20, leaving 40 and 60 runoff.
A dry gap in a wet month
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional weekly rainfall is 60, 0, 0, 20 units. Water is needed every week. The monthly total is 80 units.
3. For “A dry gap in a wet month”, which numerical answer gives total for the month? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 80 rain units
- Weeks 2 and 3
- Can water last through the gap?
- Rain falls every week
The total alone hides the two-week gap.
Check a broad statement
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
One fictional coastal town records a wet month; an inland town records a dry month.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A headline says: “Every place now gets more rain every month.”
4. In “Check a broad statement”, select the answer area for “Evidence against the headline’s scope”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- One place and one period
- The inland dry-month record
- Many comparable local records
- All future months everywhere
The headline extends far beyond the two limited observations.
Explain a falling store
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy tank starts at 60 units, receives 10 and supplies 20 each step. Capacity is 100. No other flow occurs.
5. Why does the tank shrink even though some rainwater enters? State the net change per step and connect it to supply and use.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the net loss of 10 units per step.
- Explains that the outgoing amount exceeds the incoming amount.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Same rain, different runoff
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A classroom model has 100 rain units. A garden model allows 60% to soak in, while a paved-area model allows 20%. All remaining water runs off; the percentages are assumptions.
6. True or false? The garden model produces 40 water units of runoff from the stated 100 rain units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
100−60=40 and 100−20=80.
7. Explain why the modeled paved area produces more runoff, and calculate the difference.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Relates lower infiltration in the paved-area model to more runoff.
- Calculates the 40-unit runoff difference.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose information for planting
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional farm must decide when to sow a crop needing steady water early in growth.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Record A shows only an annual total. Record B shows rain for each week across several comparable seasons, including dry gaps.
8. Complete the explanation of “Choose information for planting” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- More useful timing evidence
- Detail hidden by annual total
- Other relevant crop detail
Available labels: Length of dry gaps | Record B | Record A alone | When young plants need water
Weekly patterns address timing, while a yearly total cannot reveal dry gaps.
9. Why is Record B more useful for the planting decision, and what crop information should accompany it?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that weekly data reveal timing or dry gaps.
- Adds the crop’s growth-stage water needs as relevant information.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — A new catchment setting
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A different school model receives 120 rain units. Its surface lets 25% soak in. A proposed surface would let 50% soak in. All other water runs off.
10. For “A new catchment setting”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Runoff before change: 90 water units
- Runoff after change: 60 water units
- Runoff before change: 60 water units
- Runoff after change: 60-unit reduction
Infiltration rises from 30 to 60, reducing runoff from 90 to 60.
11. Apply the rule to the new setting. Give the runoff before and after the change and explain the reduction.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes the runoff values 90 and 60 units.
- Explains that extra infiltration accounts for the 30-unit reduction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the average claim
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional weekly rain is 0, 0, 40, 40 units. Mira calculates an average of 20 per week and writes: “There were 20 units of rain in every week.”
12. In “Repair the average claim”, what best describes average per week?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 40 rain units each week
- Average is not each observation
- 0 rain units
- 20 rain units
The mean is 80÷4=20, but individual weeks differ.
13. Explain Mira’s mistake and rewrite her sentence using the real weekly pattern.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes the mean from each individual observation.
- Uses the 0,0,40,40 pattern or its two-dry/two-wet description correctly.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Plan for a dry interval
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional school garden: no incoming water for two steps, 15 units needed each step, and 40 units initially stored.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Option A reserves 30 units for those two steps. Option B uses all 40 before the dry interval. The plan must supply both steps and avoid exceeding the stored amount.
14. For “Plan for a dry interval”, select the numerical answer that gives water needed for the interval. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 30 units
- Option B
- Option A
- 10 units
Two steps need 2×15=30 units, leaving 10 from the original 40.
15. Propose a plan that supplies both dry steps without using more water than is stored. Include the total reserved amount and a way to check the plan.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Reserves or allocates 30 units total, 15 for each of two steps.
- Includes checking remaining storage or a comparable tracking method.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 11: Extremes
- NOAA: El Niño and La Niña questions
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
Rainfall directions vary by place and season. All rainfall series and infiltration fractions are fictional practice data.
CL3.3 — Stronger or more frequent extreme events
Distinguish the frequency and strength of extreme events, interpret comparisons carefully, and plan proportionate preparedness.
Worked examples
1. Count versus share
Worked classroom example
Fictional period A: 10 storms, 2 intense. Period B: 8 storms, 4 intense.
Question: What changed?
Answer: Total storms fell from 10 to 8; intense share rose from 20% to 50%.
2/10=20% and 4/8=50%. More intense share does not mean more total storms.
2. Compare equal time
Worked classroom example
Place A records 6 events in 3 years; place B records 8 in 4 years.
Question: Which has the higher average annual count?
Answer: Neither: both average 2 per year.
6÷3=2 and 8÷4=2. Comparing raw totals would hide the different record lengths.
3. Rain and runoff
Worked classroom example
A toy storm brings 100 rain units and 40% soak in.
Question: What runs off?
Answer: 60 units.
100−40=60. This simplified model illustrates one pathway; it does not forecast a real flood or its damage.
Formative quiz
Different storm measures
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Two equal fictional periods: A has 10 storms, including 2 intense; B has 8, including 4 intense.
1. Complete the explanation of “Different storm measures” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Total storm-count change
- Intense-storm count change
- Intense share in period B
Available labels: 50% of storms | All measures decreased | Decrease of 2 storms | Increase of 2 storms
Total count and intensity-related measures need separate comparisons.
Look beyond the headline
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A classroom report says heavier rainfall per intense storm is possible under a warmer scenario.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A headline rewrites this as “Every town will have more storms next year.”
2. For “Look beyond the headline”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Unsupported addition: A guarantee of more storms
- Unsupported addition: Every town next year
- Measure in the report: Rainfall per intense storm
- Measure in the report: Every town next year
The headline changes the measure, place coverage and certainty.
Compare rainfall response
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy storm model: 120 rain units; 25% soak in; all remaining water runs off. No evaporation or storage is modeled.
3. True or false? In the stated storm model, 90 of the 120 water units soak into the ground.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
One quarter of 120 is 30, leaving 90.
Whose risk is greater?
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Two fictional communities receive the same heavy rain. A has accessible warnings and a prepared safe shelter. B has no clear warning route and some residents cannot reach the shelter.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The case gives no evidence that rain itself differed.
4. Connect each detail in “Whose risk is greater?” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Hazard comparison
- Important risk difference
- A relevant improvement
Available labels: B had stronger rainfall | Access to warning and shelter | Make warnings and shelter accessible | Same heavy rain
Different protection and access can change harm without a different hazard.
Use a precise sentence
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional equal-period storm counts: 12 total and 3 intense, then 10 total and 4 intense. No regional forecast is provided.
5. Write two linked observations: what happened to total storm count and what happened to intense-storm count?
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the decrease in total storms from 12 to 10.
- States the increase in intense storms from 3 to 4.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A changed heavy-rain pattern
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual counts above one fixed heavy-rain threshold are 1, 3, 2, 4, 5. Definitions and measurement method are unchanged.
6. Complete the explanation of “A changed heavy-rain pattern” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- First-to-last difference
- Temporary decrease
- Overall pattern
Available labels: 4 more threshold events | Rising with year-to-year variation | Increasing by one every year | Year 2 to year 3
The count goes from 1 to 5, with a dip from 3 to 2.
7. Explain the general pattern using the first and last values, and identify one reason it is not a smooth increase.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the first and last values to identify an overall increase.
- Identifies the 3-to-2 dip as variation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a relevant preparation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
The imaginary barangay expects possible heavy rainfall, with uncertain exact timing. Plan A checks official alerts, practises a teacher-led route and helps residents needing assistance.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B waits until floodwater is visible before deciding who needs help.
8. Build the answer board for “Choose a relevant preparation”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Better preparation under uncertainty
- Why timing uncertainty matters
- Who needs inclusion
Available labels: Plans should be ready beforehand | People needing assistance | Plan A | Plan B
A warning and accessible plan can be prepared before the exact event time is known.
9. Justify Plan A with one reason about uncertainty and one about inclusion.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains why preparation can be useful before exact timing is known.
- Explains the value of assisting people who face access barriers.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a harder downpour
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new toy catchment has 160 rain units and 25% infiltration. An earlier case had 120 rain units with the same percentage. Other pathways are omitted.
10. For “Transfer to a harder downpour”, select the numerical answer that gives new runoff. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 30 water units
- 40-unit runoff increase
- 90 water units
- 120 water units
Runoff is 75% of rainfall: 120 versus 90.
11. Apply the same rule to both storms. Explain why the runoff differs and state the increase.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes the two runoff values, 120 and 90.
- Links their 30-unit difference to heavier rain with the same infiltration share.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the storm claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional chart shows a rise in the share of intense storms.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Ben writes: “This proves the total number of storms increases everywhere.” The chart contains no total counts and no local breakdown.
12. In “Repair the storm claim”, what best describes what is actually shown?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Intense-storm share
- Total counts and local breakdown
- It changes measure and scope
- Proof of all local storm totals
A share alone does not determine the total count, and global statements do not guarantee every local outcome.
13. Identify two problems in Ben’s claim and replace it with a conclusion the chart can support.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes intense share from total storm count.
- Rejects the unsupported everywhere claim or rewrites a properly scoped conclusion.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Build a careful public message
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school’s evidence says heavy-rain risk is higher in a scenario, but the date of the next storm is unknown. The message must state that uncertainty and give one safe preparation action.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
School instructions require learners to follow adults and official alerts, never enter floodwater.
14. Connect each detail in “Build a careful public message” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Accurate risk wording
- Safe preparation action
- Unsafe overstatement
Available labels: Follow adult-led official-alert plans | Explore floodwater to check it | Risk can rise without a known date | A storm is certain tomorrow
A useful message can communicate increased risk while avoiding false certainty and hazardous actions.
15. Write a two-sentence school message meeting both requirements: uncertainty and safe preparation.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States that increased risk does not specify a certain event date.
- Gives a safe adult-led action linked to official warnings or preparedness.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 11: Extremes
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
- UNDRR: Early warning systems
The title includes frequency and intensity, but these are separate measures. Do not infer more total typhoons everywhere from evidence of stronger rainfall or a greater intense-storm share.
CL3.4 — Drought
Understand drought as an extended water shortage relative to needs, track a water store, and compare practical responses.
Worked examples
1. A net shortage
Worked classroom example
Toy store starts at 80 units. Each step brings 10 in and 25 out.
Question: How much remains after one step?
Answer: 65 units.
80+10−25=65. The store loses 15 per step under the stated assumptions.
2. Saving changes the balance
Worked classroom example
A second plan reduces outflow from 25 to 15, with inflow still 10.
Question: What is the new loss per step?
Answer: 5 units.
15−10=5. The store still shrinks, but more slowly; saving does not create new water.
3. Check an interval
Worked classroom example
A tank stores 45 units, no water arrives, and essential use is 15 per step.
Question: Can it supply three steps?
Answer: Yes, exactly three steps under these assumptions.
3×15=45. Nothing remains afterward, so the plan has no spare water for extra needs.
Formative quiz
Read the dry sequence
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional weekly rain is 20, 10, 5, 0, 0 units. A reference expectation for each week in this classroom case is 20. This is a teaching example, not a drought declaration.
1. For “Read the dry sequence”, select the numerical answer that gives observed total. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 35 rain units
- 65 more rain units
- 65 fewer rain units
- 100 rain units
The observed total is 35; five reference weeks give 100.
Follow stored water
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy tank has 70 units, receives 5 and supplies 15 in one step. Capacity is 100.
2. Build the answer board for “Follow stored water”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- End-of-step store
- Incoming water
- Net loss
Available labels: 5 units | 80 units | 10 units | 60 units
70+5−15=60, a loss of 10.
Choose what drought means
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A classroom description compares three situations: one rainless afternoon
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
a prolonged below-usual rainfall period with water shortages
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
and a tank shrinking because use exceeds refill.
3. Complete the explanation of “Choose what drought means” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Situation describing drought
- Too little evidence on its own
- Tank-balance explanation
Available labels: Use exceeds replacement | One rainless afternoon | Prolonged unusual dryness and shortage | Any warm afternoon
Duration, unusual dryness and shortages matter; a daily weather observation is insufficient.
Compare two water plans
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Toy inflow is 10 units per step. Plan A uses 20; Plan B uses 15. Both start with 60 units.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
There are no other modeled flows.
4. True or false? Plan A loses 10 stored water units per step under the stated flows.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Both plans lose water, but Plan B loses it more slowly.
Explain continued shortage
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional water store receives 8 units and supplies 18 each step. It begins with 50 units. Some rain arrives, but stored water keeps falling.
5. Explain why the store falls despite rain, and calculate the amount left after one step.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that outflow of 18 exceeds inflow of 8.
- Calculates the final store of 40 units.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Count two dry steps
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy store starts at 80 units. Each step adds 10 and removes 25. Capacity is 100. Apply the same rule twice.
6. For “Count two dry steps”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- After second step: 50 units
- After second step: 20 units total loss
- After first step: 65 units
- After first step: 50 units
Each step loses 15, so two steps lose 30.
7. Use the balance rule to explain the amount remaining after two steps. Show the repeated change.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the 15-unit loss per step.
- Applies it twice to obtain 50 units remaining.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a useful response
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
In the fictional school, a leaking tap wastes 5 units per step. Essential uses need 15, and the available inflow is 15.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan A repairs the leak while keeping essential uses. Plan B adds a poster but leaves the leak unchanged.
8. For “Justify a useful response”, choose the supported result for plan that balances these flows.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 5 leak units per step
- Plan A
- Plan B ends the loss
- 15 units per step
Repair removes the avoidable loss while preserving the stated essential uses.
9. Why does Plan A fit this case? Explain both its water-balance benefit and its treatment of essential needs.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links leak repair to eliminating the extra 5-unit loss or balancing inflow and outflow.
- Explains that the required 15 units of essential use remain available.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a longer interval
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new tank begins with 60 units and receives none during four steps. Plan A uses 20 per step; Plan B uses 15 per step. All amounts are hypothetical.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer to a longer interval” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Four-step need under A
- Four-step need under B
- Plan within stored supply
Available labels: Both plans fit | Plan B | 60 units | 80 units
4×20=80 exceeds 60, while 4×15=60 fits exactly.
11. Which plan can supply all four steps? Give the total need and one limitation of that plan.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Selects Plan B and calculates or states its 60-unit total need.
- Identifies the lack of reserve or another valid stated-assumption limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Fix a negative-water result
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy tank contains 12 units, receives 0 and is asked to supply 20. Sol writes: “The tank contains −8 units afterward.” The model cannot store negative water.
12. For “Fix a negative-water result”, select the numerical answer that gives water actually available. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 8 units
- 20 units available
- 12 units
- 0 units
A shortage means unmet demand, not negative physical water.
13. Explain Sol’s mistake and describe both the final store and the unmet demand.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States that the final physical store is 0 rather than negative.
- Calculates or explains the 8 units of unmet demand.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a two-step allocation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional garden store has 50 units and no refill for two steps. Required plant care needs 20 per step. Optional cleaning uses 15 total. The plan must meet plant care and stay within 50 units.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Adults handle water-use decisions; these amounts are not real household rules.
14. Build the answer board for “Design a two-step allocation”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Required two-step total
- Water remaining after required use
- Optional use that fits
Available labels: 40 units | 10 units | At most 10 units | All 15 optional units
Required use leaves 10, so the optional 15-unit task must be reduced or postponed.
15. Propose an allocation meeting both requirements. State what happens to optional cleaning.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Allocates 40 units to the two required 20-unit care steps.
- Keeps total use at or below 50 by limiting or postponing optional cleaning.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 11: Extremes
- NOAA: El Niño and La Niña questions
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
Drought is assessed relative to local conditions and needs. Toy tanks omit many real hydrological processes and do not define real water-allocation rules.
CL3.5 — Flooding
Trace how heavy rain and local conditions can lead to flooding, then compare safer community choices.
Worked examples
1. Runoff from a schoolyard
Worked classroom example
Toy rainfall is 80 units and 25% soaks in.
Question: How much is runoff?
Answer: 60 units.
20 units soak in, so 80−20=60 remain as runoff. The rule omits evaporation and storage.
2. Water relative to a floor
Worked classroom example
Model water surface is 50 cm above a chosen datum. A floor is 40 cm above the same datum.
Question: How deep is water above the floor?
Answer: 10 cm in the model.
50−40=10. Both measurements must use the same reference level.
3. Check who can act
Worked classroom example
A fictional warning is only sent by phone; some households have no working phone.
Question: What weakness should planners address?
Answer: The message may not reach everyone.
Add an accessible warning route and check receipt. Having a message is different from everyone receiving and understanding it.
Formative quiz
Runoff after paving
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy rain is 100 units. Garden infiltration is 60%; paved-area infiltration is 20%. All other water runs off.
1. For “Runoff after paving”, select the numerical answer that gives garden runoff. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 20 extra units
- 40 extra units
- 80 units
- 40 units
Runoff is rain minus infiltration: 40 versus 80.
A drain’s capacity
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional drain can remove 30 water units during one step. Inflow is 50 units. No other pathway is included.
2. For “A drain’s capacity”, which numerical answer gives water arriving? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 50 units
- 30 units
- 80 units collect
- 20 units
50−30=20 remains in this one-step model.
Spot the access problem
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
The imaginary barangay issues a clear phone warning, but six households have no working phone.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A volunteer plan includes adult-led visits along approved safe routes before flooding.
3. True or false? Every household can receive the phone-only warning in this case.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The communication gap concerns access, not rainfall control.
Separate hazard and exposure
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
In a classroom coastal model, water reaches 50 cm above the same datum. Floor A is at 40 cm; floor B is at 70 cm. The model ignores waves and building damage.
4. Connect each detail in “Separate hazard and exposure” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Water over floor A
- Water over floor B
- Reason results differ
Available labels: 10 cm | 30 cm over floor B | Different floor heights | 0 cm
Water is above A but below B in this simple height comparison.
Explain the split
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy rainfall is 120 units; 25% enters the ground, and the rest is runoff. A learner says all 120 units must become runoff.
5. Correct the claim by calculating both parts and explaining why they add to the rainfall.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates infiltration of 30 and runoff of 90 units.
- Explains that the two parts account for the fixed total of 120.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Two sites, one water surface
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional water level is 45 cm above a model datum. Ground A is 30 cm and ground B is 60 cm above that datum. Ignore waves and flow.
6. Connect each detail in “Two sites, one water surface” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Depth at site A
- Depth at site B
- Site above the water surface
Available labels: 15 cm | Both sites have 45 cm depth | 0 cm | Site B
Depth is water level minus land height when positive.
7. Explain why site A is wet and site B is dry in the model, using their heights.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates or identifies 15 cm depth at A.
- Uses B’s 60 cm height above the 45 cm water surface to explain zero depth.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a combined response
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school has high runoff and a warning message that some families cannot access. Plan A adds a suitable rain garden and an accessible adult-led warning system.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B adds only a sign saying “Be careful.” Assume the garden’s suitability has been assessed by adults.
8. True or false? Plan B addresses both the high runoff and the inaccessible-warning problem.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Runoff control and communication act on different parts of risk.
9. Justify the combined plan by explaining the separate roles of the garden and warnings.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links the garden to infiltration or reduced runoff.
- Links accessible warnings to timely protective action rather than stopping rain.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — A larger rain event
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
New toy rain is 150 units. Current infiltration is 20%; a proposed surface allows 40%. All remaining water is runoff.
10. For “A larger rain event”, select the numerical answer that gives current runoff. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 30 units
- 90 units
- 60-unit reduction
- 120 units
Infiltration increases from 30 to 60, leaving 120 versus 90 runoff.
11. Use the rule to calculate the proposed reduction, and state one reason it is not a real flood forecast.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes the reduction of 30 units using the two runoff values.
- Identifies a valid omitted process or explains that illustrative runoff is not a forecast of flood depth.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the zero-risk promise
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional runoff trial reduces modeled runoff from 80 to 50 units.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A poster says: “Flooding is now impossible.” The trial did not test larger storms or blocked drains.
12. In “Repair the zero-risk promise”, what best describes unsupported promise?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Larger storms or blocked drains
- 30 fewer runoff units
- Flooding is impossible
- No improvement occurred
Reduced runoff is useful evidence but does not eliminate all flood pathways.
13. Explain what the trial supports and what the poster wrongly promises.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the valid 30-unit reduction or its limited tested scope.
- Rejects zero risk using an untested condition from the case.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an inclusive preparation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
An imaginary school needs a plan for official heavy-rain warnings. Some families use phones; others need another accessible channel. The task requires reaching both groups and checking that the message is understood.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
No child may enter floodwater or carry out dangerous inspection.
14. Build the answer board for “Design an inclusive preparation”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Reach phone users
- Reach other families
- Check communication
Available labels: Ask for receipt and understanding | Provide an accessible second channel | Wait until children see flooding | Use the approved phone channel
Coverage and understanding both matter; a sent message is not necessarily received.
15. Propose a safe adult-led warning plan meeting both requirements: reach both groups and check understanding.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes both a phone route and another accessible adult-led route.
- Includes checking receipt or understanding of the required safe action.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 11: Extremes
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- UNDRR: Early warning systems
Flood models are illustrative. Children should never enter floodwater or undertake real drainage, electrical or evacuation experiments.
CL3.6 — Sea-level rise
Explain why sea level rises, distinguish sea level from water depth, and compare simple coastal scenarios.
Worked examples
1. Add a rise
Worked classroom example
Toy sea surface starts at 20 cm and rises by 15 cm, using one datum.
Question: What is the new level?
Answer: 35 cm above the datum.
20+15=35. A rise is a change in level, not automatically the depth over every piece of land.
2. Compare with land
Worked classroom example
Toy water surface is 55 cm; land is 40 cm above the same datum.
Question: What is the water depth over that land?
Answer: 15 cm.
55−40=15. A second site at 70 cm would have zero depth in this model.
3. Choose the ice pathway
Worked classroom example
Card A shows floating ice melting. Card B shows a land glacier melting into the sea.
Question: Which card directly adds water formerly stored on land?
Answer: Card B.
The glacier transfers land-stored water into the ocean. Floating ice already displaces seawater.
Formative quiz
Read the shared ruler
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy base sea level is 20 cm, added rise is 15 cm and ground is 30 cm, all relative to the same datum.
1. For “Read the shared ruler”, select the numerical answer that gives new water surface. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 15 cm depth
- 35 cm above datum
- 5 cm
- 30 cm above datum
The surface is 20+15=35, then depth is 35−30=5.
Find the two pathways
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A classroom diagram describes warming seawater expanding, land ice melting into the ocean, and floating sea ice already displacing water.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These mechanisms have different direct effects on sea level.
2. Complete the explanation of “Find the two pathways” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Warming seawater
- Melting land ice
- Floating sea-ice melt
Available labels: Adds all displaced water again | Adds water from land storage | Expansion of existing water | Much smaller direct level effect
Expansion and land-ice addition are distinct; floating ice already displaces water.
A short record with variation
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual coastal levels relative to one datum are 10, 12, 11, 14, 15 cm. These values are classroom data.
3. Build the answer board for “A short record with variation”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Overall first-to-last change
- Temporary dip
- Last recorded level
Available labels: Rise of 5 cm | 15 cm | Rise of 15 cm | Year 2 to year 3
The change is 15−10, not the final level itself.
Local versus global
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Town A’s land is sinking while Town B’s land is stable. Both are beside the same simplified rising ocean surface.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
No amounts are supplied.
4. For “Local versus global”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Meaning of relative level: Identical local change is certain
- Extra influence at Town A: Sinking land
- Extra influence at Town A: Water height compared with land
- Meaning of relative level: Water height compared with land
Land motion can change local relative level; without amounts we cannot calculate it.
Explain level and depth
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A model has water at 50 cm and ground at 35 cm above one datum. A pupil calls the flood depth 50 cm.
5. Correct the pupil’s depth and explain why water level and depth are different here.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates 15 cm depth.
- Distinguishes datum-based water level from depth above land.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare two coastal sites
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
In a toy case the water surface is 65 cm above a datum. Site A ground is 50 cm, and Site B ground is 80 cm. Ignore waves and erosion.
6. Complete the explanation of “Compare two coastal sites” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Depth at Site A
- Depth at Site B
- Site higher than the water
Available labels: 0 cm | 15 cm | Site B | Both sites have 65 cm depth
Subtract ground height only where water exceeds it.
7. Explain the different modeled outcomes at A and B using their heights.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies 15 cm water depth at A.
- Explains zero depth at B because 80 cm exceeds 65 cm.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose the stronger evidence
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Record A has one photograph at an unknown tide.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Record B has many years of comparable tide-gauge averages, checked for instrument changes and local land movement. The question concerns long-term local relative sea level.
8. Connect each detail in “Choose the stronger evidence” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Stronger long-term evidence
- Main limit of Record A
- Useful local check
Available labels: Record A alone | Unknown tide and single time | Land movement | Record B
Comparable long records address a trend and local reference, unlike one untimed image.
9. Justify Record B using its time coverage and one measurement check.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses long comparable time coverage as a reason.
- Names instrument consistency or land movement as a relevant check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a new datum case
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A different toy island uses water level 30 cm, added rise 20 cm and ground level 55 cm above a single datum. Then an additional scenario adds another 10 cm of water.
10. For “Transfer to a new datum case”, select the numerical answer that gives water before additional scenario. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 50 cm
- 5 cm
- 25 cm depth
- 0 cm
Water first remains below 55; at 60 it is 5 above ground.
11. Apply the height rule to both scenarios. Why does depth begin only after the extra rise?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives zero initial depth and 5 cm later depth.
- Explains that water must exceed the ground height before the model has positive depth.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the ice explanation
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A poster says: “Sea level rises only because floating sea ice melts.” The lesson evidence includes warming-water expansion and melting glaciers on land.
12. Build the answer board for “Repair the ice explanation”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Missing warming mechanism
- Missing ice contribution
- Problem with “only”
Available labels: Melting land glaciers | Expansion of seawater | It excludes major mechanisms | Floating ice is the sole source
The poster leaves out two major mechanisms and overstates floating-ice melt.
13. Rewrite the poster with two correct mechanisms instead of its “only” claim.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names seawater expansion as a mechanism.
- Names melting land ice adding water as a mechanism.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a comparison for a coast
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class has annual water-level summaries and a survey of three ground heights using the same datum. The task is to identify places that might be exposed in a stated high-water scenario and clearly report a model limit.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Real safety decisions belong to adults and qualified services.
14. For “Design a comparison for a coast”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Useful comparison: The same datum
- Required common reference: The same datum
- Useful comparison: Water surface versus each ground height
- Required common reference: Use the water level as every depth
Height comparisons can screen a stated scenario, while omitted processes limit their meaning.
15. Propose a two-step classroom investigation that compares exposure and includes a model limitation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses a shared-datum comparison of water level with land height.
- States a valid model limit or rejects using the result as a real safety map.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NOAA: Tracking sea level rise and fall
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
Coastal heights use a common hypothetical datum. The simple model omits tides, waves, erosion, drainage and local land motion unless supplied in the case.
CL3.7 — Ocean warming
Describe ocean warming as a gain of heat, interpret ocean records, and distinguish its effects from changing ocean chemistry.
Worked examples
1. Energy remains
Worked classroom example
Toy ocean budget: 100 incoming, 25 reflected, 65 outgoing energy units.
Question: What is the net gain?
Answer: 10 energy units.
100−25−65=10. This is a gain of energy, not a temperature increase of 10 degrees.
2. Read a depth table
Worked classroom example
Fictional readings at the same time: surface 29 °C, deeper layer 24 °C.
Question: What is the temperature difference?
Answer: 5 °C.
29−24=5. The readings describe two depths, not a change through time.
3. Separate processes
Worked classroom example
A card reports warmer water; another reports lower seawater pH.
Question: Do both cards measure the same thing?
Answer: No. One measures temperature; the other measures chemistry.
They can be related to climate change while remaining different observations and mechanisms.
Formative quiz
Energy into a water model
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Incoming energy is 100 units; 20 are reflected and 70 leave. No other terms occur in this single-step model.
1. Connect each detail in “Energy into a water model” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Absorbed incoming energy
- Net energy gain
- What cannot be read directly
Available labels: 80 units | A temperature change in degrees | 10 units | 100 incoming energy units
100−20=80 and 80−70=10; the model has no degree conversion.
Surface and depth
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional comparable measurements: at the surface 29 °C; at 50 m depth 25 °C; at 100 m depth 22 °C. The numbers are for practice.
2. In “Surface and depth”, select the answer area for “Warmest sampled layer”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 7 °C
- All depths are identical
- Depth of each measurement
- The surface
These readings vary with depth; 29−22=7.
A changing ocean record
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual layer temperatures are 26, 27, 26, 28, 29 °C, with the same layer and method throughout.
3. For “A changing ocean record”, which numerical answer gives overall change? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Year 2 to year 3
- Same layer and method
- Rise every single year
- Rise of 3 °C
The full record rises but includes a dip.
Temperature is not pH
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Lab note A reports water temperature rising.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Lab note B reports seawater pH declining. The notes use different instruments and quantities.
4. Complete the explanation of “Temperature is not pH” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Note A measures
- Note B measures
- Correct combined reading
Available labels: Warmth of the water | Both are temperature readings | Different changes can occur together | A seawater chemistry property
Temperature and pH must not be substituted for one another.
Explain an energy gain
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy water budget receives 120 units, reflects 30 and sends 80 away. It has no formula for converting energy to degrees.
5. Explain whether this model gains energy and why you cannot report a temperature rise in degrees from it alone.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates or identifies the positive 10-unit energy gain.
- Explains the missing conversion or water-system information needed for degrees.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare heat budgets
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy case A: incoming 100, reflected 20, outgoing 80. Case B: incoming 100, reflected 20, outgoing 70. Units are energy units per step.
6. Connect each detail in “Compare heat budgets” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Net balance in A
- Net balance in B
- Difference causing the gain
Available labels: Gain of 10 energy units | More incoming energy in B | 0 energy units | Less outgoing energy in B
Incoming and reflected energy match; the outgoing change creates the difference.
7. Use the two budgets to explain why B gains energy while A does not.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes or states the net balances 0 and +10.
- Identifies lower outgoing energy as the changed term.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a suitable observing plan
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A samples one beach surface once.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B repeats measurements at labelled sites and depths with comparable instruments. The question concerns change across a coastal water area over time.
8. Complete the explanation of “Choose a suitable observing plan” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Better plan for that question
- Main weakness of A
- Useful labels to preserve
Available labels: Place, depth and date | One place and one moment | Plan B | Plan A proves the whole ocean
The broader repeated method matches the spatial and time scope more closely.
9. Justify Plan B with one reason about repeated observations and one about coverage.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of repeated time observations.
- Explains the value of multiple labelled places or depths.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the budget
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new toy bay receives 90 energy units, reflects 15 and sends out 80 in one step. The rules are the same as before.
10. Build the answer board for “Transfer the budget”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Absorbed input
- Net balance
- Direction of stored-energy change
Available labels: Gain of 5 energy units | Decreases in this step | 75 energy units | Loss of 5 energy units
90−15−80=−5, a loss in this step.
11. Apply the rule and explain what the negative result means, without claiming a long-term trend.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the −5-unit balance.
- Interprets it as a single-step loss rather than proof of long-term cooling.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a coral statement
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional survey finds bleached corals after warm-water stress.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Kai writes: “All bleached corals are already dead, and temperature explains every reef problem.” No survival follow-up or other-stressor study was made.
12. In “Repair a coral statement”, select the answer area for “Observed condition”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Every reef problem
- Later survival or recovery
- Coral bleaching
- Guaranteed death of all corals
Bleaching indicates stress; survival and other causes need separate evidence.
13. Identify two overstatements and replace them with a cautious description of what was observed.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects equating all bleaching with established death.
- Rejects temperature as the proven sole cause of every reef problem.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a repeatable ocean comparison
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A teacher supplies safe archived temperatures from two labelled depths for five dates. The classroom study must compare like with like and report a limitation.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
No field swimming or unsupervised water sampling is part of this task.
14. True or false? Comparing the same labelled depth across dates is more suitable for studying time change than mixing different depths.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Keeping dates and depths clear prevents confusing a depth difference with a time change.
15. Propose a study of the archived data that keeps depth comparisons fair and states one coverage limit.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps depth consistent when comparing changes over dates.
- States a valid limitation in depth, location or time coverage.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
- NOAA: Tracking sea level rise and fall
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
Energy units are not degrees. Coral bleaching is stress and does not imply automatic death; ocean warming and acidification are distinct processes.
CL3.8 — Ocean acidification
Explain how absorbed carbon dioxide changes seawater chemistry, read pH evidence carefully, and avoid confusing acidification with warming.
Worked examples
1. Read the pH direction
Worked classroom example
Fictional pH values are 8.2 then 8.0.
Question: Did pH rise or fall, and is the later value above 7?
Answer: It fell by 0.2 pH units and remains above 7.
Lower pH indicates an acidifying direction, even while the value is still alkaline.
2. Choose the instrument record
Worked classroom example
Record A gives temperature in °C. Record B gives pH with a documented method.
Question: Which directly addresses the pH question?
Answer: Record B.
Temperature may also matter, but it is not a replacement for a chemistry measurement.
3. Avoid a simple percentage
Worked classroom example
A pH record changes from 8.1 to 8.0. A pupil calls this a 0.1% acidity rise.
Question: What is wrong?
Answer: pH units are not percentage units.
Report a decrease of 0.1 pH unit. The scale is logarithmic; percentage changes require additional chemistry, not this subtraction.
Formative quiz
Follow a practice pH record
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional values over five sampling dates are 8.2, 8.2, 8.1, 8.1, 8.0. The method and site are held comparable.
1. True or false? The first and last pH readings in this record are equal.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Read the difference and the final position separately.
Carbon enters a toy store
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A bookkeeping model begins with 40 CO2 units in a water store. During a step, 12 enter and 2 leave. No pH-conversion formula is supplied.
2. For “Carbon enters a toy store”, select the numerical answer that gives final co2 store. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- pH becomes 10
- 10 model units
- 50 model units
- The resulting seawater pH
40+12−2=50, but carbon accounting is not a seawater chemistry solver.
Two records, different quantities
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Card A reports temperature 28 then 29 °C.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Card B reports pH 8.2 then 8.1. These are fictional observations.
3. For “Two records, different quantities”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Card A change: pH declines by 0.1
- Card A change: Warming by 1 °C
- Card B change: pH declines by 0.1
- Card B change: Both show a 1 °C change
The units tell us that temperature and pH are different.
A fair shell comparison
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional study keeps organism type, food and temperature the same while comparing two pH conditions. Shell growth is measured in both groups.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A second study changes food, species and pH together.
4. Complete the explanation of “A fair shell comparison” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Stronger test of pH conditions
- Problem with second study
- Measured response
Available labels: Several factors changed together | Shell growth | First study | Second study isolates pH
Keeping other factors comparable makes interpretation more focused.
Explain still-alkaline change
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional seawater record moves from pH 8.3 to 8.1. A learner says acidification is impossible because both readings exceed 7.
5. Explain why the learner is mistaken using both the change in pH and the values’ position relative to 7.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the downward pH change as acidification.
- Explains that remaining above 7 is compatible with an acidifying direction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Use two kinds of evidence
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional pH values are 8.2, 8.1, 8.1, 8.0 across four dates. Temperature is measured separately. The task asks about the chemistry record, not heat.
6. True or false? The recorded pH decreases by 0.2 pH unit from the first date to the last.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The data provide a pH change; they do not supply a temperature change.
7. Describe the chemistry change and explain why it cannot be reported as a temperature change.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the 0.2 pH-unit decline.
- Distinguishes pH from temperature and avoids interpreting it as degrees.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose evidence for a claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Claim: a bay’s pH declined during a monitored period. Record A gives calibrated pH observations with dates and methods.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Record B gives a photograph of one damaged shell with no location, date or chemistry measurements.
8. Build the answer board for “Choose evidence for a claim”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- More direct evidence for the claim
- Limit of the photograph
- Useful detail in Record A
Available labels: Record B proves all causes | Record A | It does not measure pH change | Dates and measurement method
A chemistry time record addresses the claim more directly than an unexplained image.
9. Justify using Record A and explain one reason the photograph is insufficient.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links dated pH measurements to the claimed decline.
- States that a shell image alone lacks pH evidence or cannot exclude other causes.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Apply the distinction elsewhere
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
At another fictional site, pH changes from 8.0 to 7.9 while temperature stays 28 °C in both samples. Measurement methods are comparable.
10. Connect each detail in “Apply the distinction elsewhere” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- pH direction
- Temperature change
- Possible combined description
Available labels: Decreasing | No measured change | Warming must equal pH decline | Acidification without measured warming
The supplied observations show a chemistry change without a temperature change in these samples.
11. Explain what changed and what stayed the same, and why the two processes should remain separate in the report.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly identifies the pH decline and unchanged temperature.
- Avoids adding an unsupported warming claim and distinguishes chemistry from temperature.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Fix the percentage error
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional report gives pH 8.2 then 8.1.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Ana writes: “Acidity increased by 0.1%, and the sea is now below pH 7.”
12. Complete the explanation of “Fix the percentage error” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Correct arithmetic difference
- Position of final value
- Wrong unit in the claim
Available labels: Percent acidity | 0.1% is the pH unit | Above pH 7 | 0.1 pH-unit decline
pH is not a simple percentage scale, and 8.1 is greater than 7.
13. Correct both errors without attempting an unsupported percentage calculation.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Replaces the unsupported percentage with a 0.1 pH-unit decline.
- Correctly states that 8.1 remains above 7.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a careful chemistry study
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A teacher supplies safe archived pH records from the same bay site for six dates, plus temperature and method notes. The plan must compare pH consistently and keep alternative influences visible.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Learners do not handle chemicals or collect hazardous samples.
14. In “Design a careful chemistry study”, select the answer area for “Main comparison”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- One site cannot represent all seas
- Use a shell photo as a pH meter
- pH across comparable dates
- Temperature and method notes
Consistency and companion records make conclusions more careful.
15. Propose a short archive-based study meeting both requirements: consistent pH comparison and attention to other influences.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Compares dated pH readings using consistent site and measurement methods.
- Uses temperature or other method/context information to avoid a one-cause conclusion.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
pH is logarithmic, not a simple percentage scale. Declining pH can leave seawater alkaline. CO2-store models do not calculate real seawater pH.
CL3.9 — Biodiversity loss
Distinguish kinds of living things from their numbers, explain climate-related pressures, and assess habitat evidence carefully.
Worked examples
1. Kinds and numbers
Worked classroom example
Fictional plot A has 20 individuals of one species. Plot B has 12 individuals across four species.
Question: Which plot has greater sampled species richness?
Answer: Plot B.
Species richness counts kinds: four versus one. Total individuals are a separate measure.
2. Track habitat patches
Worked classroom example
Toy habitat begins with 15 patches, gains 3 suitable restored patches and loses 5.
Question: How many patches remain?
Answer: 13 patches.
15+3−5=13. This patch count does not specify how many species are present.
3. Limit a conclusion
Worked classroom example
One short visit sees no butterflies after rain; earlier visits found several.
Question: Does this prove local extinction?
Answer: No.
Visibility, timing and weather can affect what is seen. Repeat comparable surveys before making a strong conclusion.
Formative quiz
Count living kinds
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional garden survey records mango trees, hibiscus shrubs, grass and butterflies. Counts are 3, 8, 20 and 6 individuals. Treat the four labels as four distinct species for this exercise.
1. Build the answer board for “Count living kinds”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Sampled species count
- Total individual count
- Most numerous sampled group
Available labels: 4 species | 37 species | Grass | 37 individuals
Four kinds and 37 individuals are different measures.
Follow a habitat store
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy suitable habitat patches: initial 20, restored 3, lost 5, capacity 30. A step changes patch count only.
2. For “Follow a habitat store”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Net change: 28 patches
- Net change: Loss of 2 patches
- Patches after one step: Loss of 2 patches
- Patches after one step: 18 patches
20+3−5=18; patch amount is not a species inventory.
Read a survey pattern
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional repeated surveys use the same method and record 8, 7, 7, 6, 5 species. These are classroom samples, not a complete biodiversity measure.
3. Connect each detail in “Read a survey pattern” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- First-to-last change
- Last survey count
- Limit of the indicator
Available labels: 3 fewer individuals | 5 sampled species | 3 fewer sampled species | It counts observed kinds only
The series concerns species count, not total individuals or all biodiversity.
Consider two pressures
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional wetland becomes hotter and also loses half its vegetation to clearing. A frog count falls.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
No experiment separates temperature from habitat loss.
4. In “Consider two pressures”, select the answer area for “Climate-related pressure”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Vegetation clearing
- Only one factor changed
- Heat alone caused all losses
- Hotter conditions
Several changes occurred, so a single-cause claim is not established.
Explain a limited observation
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional survey finds 30 birds of two species in Plot A and 20 birds of five species in Plot B.
5. Explain why Plot B can have greater sampled species richness even though Plot A has more birds. Use both kinds of counts.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes individual count from species count.
- Uses the two-versus-five species comparison correctly.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Interpret a restoration balance
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy reserve begins with 24 suitable habitat patches. A project restores 4 while 6 are lost in the same step. The model counts patches, not habitat quality.
6. For “Interpret a restoration balance”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Net direction: 28 patches after ignoring losses
- Remaining patches: Decrease
- Net direction: Decrease
- Remaining patches: 22 patches
24+4−6=22, so adding patches does not ensure a net gain.
7. Why does the modeled habitat count fall even though restoration occurs? Calculate the remaining count.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that losses of 6 exceed gains of 4.
- Calculates 22 remaining patches.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a stronger survey
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A searches one patch for five minutes in rain and compares it with last year’s one-hour sunny survey.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B repeats the same route and duration in comparable seasons, recording weather and observer effort.
8. For “Choose a stronger survey”, choose the supported result for stronger comparison.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Survey method and effort
- Plan A proves disappearance
- Search conditions and effort differ
- Plan B
Comparable effort and conditions reduce detection-related confusion.
9. Justify Plan B using one point about survey effort and one about conditions.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of consistent route or duration.
- Explains the value of comparable season/weather or documenting conditions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to another habitat
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A second fictional area starts with 12 patches, gains 5 and loses 2 per step. Maximum capacity is 30. Use one step only.
10. For “Transfer to another habitat”, select the numerical answer that gives new patch count. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Which species use the patches
- 3 patches
- 19 patches
- 15 patches
12+5−2=15; habitat quantity still does not identify species use.
11. Apply the patch rule and identify one additional observation needed to judge biodiversity benefits.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates 15 patches or a net gain of 3.
- Requests species-use, diversity or habitat-quality evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a counting claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school replaces a mixed garden of five plant species with 100 plants of one species.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A poster says: “More plants means more plant species.”
12. Build the answer board for “Repair a counting claim”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- New individual count
- New species count
- Error in the poster
Available labels: 100 species | 100 plants | 1 species | Confuses individuals with kinds
Many individuals of a single species still count as one species.
13. Explain the error and compare the old and new sampled plant richness.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies confusion between abundance and richness.
- Correctly compares five old species with one new species.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a habitat check
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school plans suitable native vegetation with adult ecological advice. It must check both habitat condition and organisms using the area.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It can repeat safe photo-point observations and a teacher-led species checklist once per comparable season.
14. Connect each detail in “Design a habitat check” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Habitat indicator
- Organism indicator
- Fair comparison feature
Available labels: Comparable seasons and effort | Count planting bags only | Repeated species-use checklist | Vegetation condition at fixed points
Tracking the action alone is weaker than checking the habitat and its users.
15. Propose two linked checks: one for habitat condition and one for living things, keeping observations comparable.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a repeatable habitat-condition measure.
- Includes a repeatable organism/species measure with comparable effort or season.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- NOAA: Ocean acidification education resources
Species richness, abundance, habitat area and biodiversity are related but different. A missing observation is not proof of extinction; climate is not the sole pressure on ecosystems.
CL3.10 — Ecosystem disruption
Trace connections in an ecosystem and explain how a change can spread without assuming every outcome is certain.
Worked examples
1. Follow an arrow
Worked classroom example
In this fictional diagram, arrows mean food → eater: grass → insect → bird.
Question: What does the insect supply to the bird?
Answer: Food.
The arrow’s direction represents a feeding link, not a command that every bird eats only that insect.
2. Read timing
Worked classroom example
Fictional insect peak: week 3. Chick food need: weeks 5–6.
Question: What possible problem should be investigated?
Answer: Food timing may not match chick needs.
The two schedules differ. Actual harm needs evidence about insect availability and alternative food.
3. Track wetland water
Worked classroom example
Toy wetland starts with 40 units, receives 15 and loses 20.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 35 units.
40+15−20=35. The model tracks water quantity, not the complete health of the ecosystem.
Formative quiz
A small food web
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
In a fictional diagram, arrows mean food → eater. Plants feed insects; insects feed birds. Some birds also eat fruit, so the insect link is not their only food source.
1. For “A small food web”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Plants to insects arrow: Plants provide food to insects
- Insects to birds arrow: Insects provide food to birds
- Plants to insects arrow: Insects provide food to birds
- Insects to birds arrow: Every bird eats plants only
Read the key and preserve the stated alternative food.
A water-dependent habitat
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy wetland store starts at 60 units, receives 10 and loses 20 in a step. Water quantity is the only modeled variable.
2. For “A water-dependent habitat”, select the numerical answer that gives final water store. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Exact number of surviving birds
- 10 units
- 70 units
- 50 units
Water balance does not specify a biological survival rule.
Look for a timing gap
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional records: flower bloom peaks in week 2; pollinator visits peak in week 4. Previously both peaked in week 3. Peak timing does not describe all flowers or visits.
3. Complete the explanation of “Look for a timing gap” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Current flower peak
- Current pollinator peak
- Gap between current peaks
Available labels: No possible timing difference | Week 2 | 2 weeks | Week 4
The peaks differ by two weeks, suggesting a relationship to investigate.
Do not infer every outcome
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional plant-food count falls from 10 to 7 units. An insect group can also use another food that was not measured.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A headline says every insect must disappear.
4. Connect each detail in “Do not infer every outcome” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Measured change
- Missing information
- Unsupported claim in the headline
Available labels: Every insect must disappear | Availability of the other food | Less of one food source | All food was measured
Alternative food and other conditions limit the claim.
Explain a changing flow
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy wetland receives 8 water units per step and loses 13, beginning with 45. Some plants depend on wet conditions, but no species-response formula is supplied.
5. Explain the water change and name one extra observation needed before predicting effects on the plants.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the loss of 5 or final store of 40 units.
- Names relevant plant, soil or habitat evidence rather than equating water units with organism losses.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A shared resource declines
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional weekly insect-food counts are 12, 10, 9, 7, 6 units. Two bird groups use these insects, and one group also eats fruit. No bird counts are given.
6. In “A shared resource declines”, select the answer area for “Food-record direction”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The fruit-eating group
- Actual bird population change
- Overall decline
- Both bird populations are known
The resource declines, but population outcomes have not been measured.
7. Describe a possible effect on birds and one reason the exact effect is uncertain.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects declining insect food to a possible feeding pressure on birds.
- Uses alternative food or missing response data to explain uncertainty.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose broader monitoring
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A wetland restoration aims to improve connected habitat. Plan A counts only planted stems.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B records water conditions, plant survival and birds using the area in comparable seasons.
8. Build the answer board for “Choose broader monitoring”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- More informative monitoring
- Limit of stem count alone
- Example connected indicator
Available labels: It misses survival and connections | Plan B | Water and bird use | Plan A proves full recovery
Monitoring several connected parts tests more of the intended ecosystem pathway.
9. Justify Plan B using one plant-related measure and one wider ecosystem measure.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains why plant survival is more informative than planting count alone.
- Connects a water or bird indicator to wider ecosystem functioning.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a timing comparison
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
At a second fictional site, insects peak in week 5 and chick food demand peaks in weeks 5–6. At the first site insects peaked in week 2 with the same chick demand. Other conditions are unknown.
10. True or false? The second site has a closer overlap between the insect peak and chick food demand than the first site.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The second peak overlaps demand more closely, but quantity and other foods are still unknown.
11. Explain which site has the closer timing match and what else must be checked before judging chick success.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the second site’s closer overlap using the weeks.
- Names relevant missing food or outcome evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Fix a one-cause explanation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional stream warms and receives new polluted runoff in the same month.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Insect counts then fall.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
Ria writes: “Warming alone is proven to have caused every loss.”
12. Connect each detail in “Fix a one-cause explanation” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Climate-related change
- Other changed condition
- Problem with “alone is proven”
Available labels: Only water temperature changed | Polluted runoff | Causes were not separated | Warmer water
Two pressures changed together, so the record cannot isolate warming as the sole cause.
13. Identify the reasoning error and suggest one comparison that would improve the investigation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the simultaneous pollution pressure or confounding.
- Proposes a reasonable comparison or additional measurements to separate possible causes.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a connected check
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school wetland project must track both water conditions and a living response.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It has teacher-supplied water-level records and safe photo observations of plant survival.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The goal is to assess connections without claiming every cause is known.
14. Complete the explanation of “Design a connected check” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Physical indicator
- Living response indicator
- Careful conclusion
Available labels: Plant survival observations | Compare patterns and acknowledge limits | One photo proves all causes | Water-level record
Both kinds of evidence are needed to examine a proposed connection.
15. Design a brief monitoring plan with a physical and a living indicator, then state how you will limit the conclusion.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses both a water/physical indicator and a living response over comparable dates.
- Acknowledges alternative influences or avoids claiming the pattern alone proves causation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Food-web arrows require a key. Simple resource models do not determine exact species outcomes; timing, alternative food, habitat quality and other pressures matter.
CL3.11 — Food security
Explain how climate can affect food availability, access and stability, and compare practical food-security plans.
Worked examples
1. Count a food store
Worked classroom example
Fictional store: 50 meal units, 15 delivered, 25 used.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 40 meal units.
50+15−25=40. Quantity is only one part of food security; suitability and access still need checks.
2. Find the access barrier
Worked classroom example
A fictional farm has enough food, but the only delivery bridge is closed.
Question: Which problem does this show?
Answer: A transport and access barrier.
The food exists, so increasing the crop alone would not reopen the delivery route.
3. Plan a short interruption
Worked classroom example
Two days need 20 meal units each. A safe store contains 45.
Question: Can the stated quantity cover two days?
Answer: Yes, with 5 units remaining.
2×20=40 and 45−40=5. This does not answer questions about nutrition, safety or a longer interruption.
Formative quiz
Different links in the chain
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional cases: a drought reduces a crop; a closed bridge delays deliveries; a household cannot afford available food.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These cases concern different food-security pathways.
1. Complete the explanation of “Different links in the chain” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Drought reduces crop
- Closed bridge
- Food unaffordable
Available labels: Economic access | Only the food’s colour | Production and availability | Transport access
Availability and access can fail for different reasons.
Count available meal units
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy store begins with 70 meal units, receives 10 and supplies 25 in a step. Capacity is 100. Safety and nutrition are outside the arithmetic model.
2. For “Count available meal units”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Net stock loss: 85 meal units
- End-of-step stock: 15 meal units
- End-of-step stock: 55 meal units
- Net stock loss: 15 meal units
70+10−25=55; inventory is not a nutrition assessment.
Read harvest variability
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional harvest records with the same area and units are 40, 45, 30, 42, 35 sacks. The case does not identify causes.
3. Build the answer board for “Read harvest variability”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Largest harvest
- Smallest harvest
- Range of harvests
Available labels: 15 sacks | 45 sacks | 30 sacks | 45-sack range
45−30=15; variation alone does not reveal the cause.
Compare route plans
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional Plan A relies on one low bridge for every delivery.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B has a suitable adult-approved alternative route and checks whether distant households receive food. Assume both meet food-safety requirements.
4. Connect each detail in “Compare route plans” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Plan with route redundancy
- Single point of disruption in A
- Fairness check in B
Available labels: Plan A has two routes | Delivery to distant households | Plan B | The low bridge
An alternative route and distribution checks address two stated weaknesses.
Explain food access
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional market has enough safe food, but a damaged route prevents supplies reaching one village.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
No shortage at the market is reported.
5. Explain why the village can face food insecurity despite the market supply, and name a response matching the barrier.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies transport or delivery access as the barrier despite available food.
- Proposes a relevant safe access/supply response rather than merely more production.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Use a three-day inventory
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional safe food store has 80 meal units. No deliveries arrive for three days. Required use is 25 units each day.
6. For “Use a three-day inventory”, which numerical answer gives stock after three days? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 25 units remain
- 75 meal units
- 5 meal units
- Little reserve for a longer gap
3×25=75, leaving 5.
7. Explain whether the quantity covers three days and what limit remains.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the 75-unit need and sufficient 80-unit stock.
- Identifies the small reserve or inability to cover a further full day.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a plan that reaches people
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A increases food at a central store but has no delivery arrangement for an isolated group.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B checks safe stock and arranges an approved delivery route to that group. The aim is adequate supply and access.
8. Complete the explanation of “Choose a plan that reaches people” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Plan addressing both stated needs
- Gap in Plan A
- Useful success measure
Available labels: Stored totals alone prove access | Food actually reaches the group | Plan B | Last part of delivery access
The outcome is accessible food, not merely a central stockpile.
9. Justify Plan B using one point about supply and one about access.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the role of checking available safe stock.
- Explains the role of actual delivery/access for the isolated group.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a larger group
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A second fictional group needs 30 meal units per day for two days. It has 50 units and can receive one delivery of 20 units before the gap.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer to a larger group” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Total available after delivery
- Two-day requirement
- Remaining quantity
Available labels: 20 units remain | 70 meal units | 60 meal units | 10 meal units
50+20−2×30=10.
11. Does the extra delivery make the two-day quantity plan feasible? Show the total supply and remaining amount.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates 70 available versus 60 required.
- States the 10-unit remainder after meeting the two-day requirement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a harvest claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
An imaginary harvest falls from 50 to 35 sacks after a dry season.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A pest outbreak also occurred.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
Jules writes: “All 15 lost sacks were proven to be caused only by climate change.”
12. For “Repair a harvest claim”, select the numerical answer that gives observed harvest difference. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Pest outbreak
- Only climate change is proven
- 15 fewer sacks
- No harvest difference
A difference is observed, but causes were not separated.
13. State the valid observation and explain why the causal claim is too strong.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly states the 15-sack decrease.
- Identifies the pest/causal-evidence limitation and rejects the sole-cause claim.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a short food plan
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional two-day school activity needs 20 meal units per day. It has a budget of 50 tokens; safe meal units cost 1 token each and route-check coordination costs 5. The plan must supply both days and check delivery access. All prices are classroom assumptions.
14. Build the answer board for “Design a short food plan”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Meal cost for both days
- Cost including route check
- Budget remaining
Available labels: 55-token total | 45 tokens | 40 tokens | 5 tokens
Forty meal units plus the 5-token access check cost 45.
15. Propose a plan within 50 tokens that meets both the meal quantity and delivery-access requirements.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides 40 meal units for the two 20-unit days.
- Includes the delivery-access check while keeping total cost at or below 50.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Fictional meal units measure inventory only, not nutrition or food safety. Climate pressures interact with pests, practices, markets, transport and unequal access.
CL3.12 — Water security
Reason about reliable access to sufficient safe water, using both water balances and evidence about quality and access.
Worked examples
1. A tank balance
Worked classroom example
Toy tank: 60 units initially, 20 in, 30 out, capacity 100.
Question: What remains after one step?
Answer: 50 units.
60+20−30=50. This calculation says nothing about whether the water is drinkable.
2. Capacity matters
Worked classroom example
A toy tank has 90 units, capacity 100, and receives 25 with no outflow.
Question: What can it store and what overflows?
Answer: It stores 100 and 15 overflow.
Only 10 of the incoming 25 fit. A larger computed total cannot remain inside the stated capacity.
3. Ask the missing question
Worked classroom example
A fictional report says a village has a full tank but gives no test results or access information.
Question: What two checks are still needed?
Answer: Water suitability and people’s access.
Full storage does not establish safety or fair distribution.
Formative quiz
Three water-security questions
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional checklist asks: How much water is available? Is it suitable for the intended use? Can all users reach the supply?
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These are separate questions.
1. Build the answer board for “Three water-security questions”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Amount available
- Suitability for use
- Ability to obtain it
Available labels: Quantity | Quality | Access | Colour alone proves safety
Quantity, quality and access each matter.
A shrinking tank
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy tank: initial 80, inflow 10, outflow 25, capacity 100.
2. For “A shrinking tank”, select the numerical answer that gives final store. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 15 units
- 65 units
- Outflow exceeds inflow
- 95 units
80+10−25=65.
A water-supply record
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional weekly usable supply is 60, 50, 55, 40, 35 units. Demand is 45 each week. The figures are classroom assumptions.
3. For “A water-supply record”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Supply in week 5: Week 1 has a shortfall
- Weeks below demand: Weeks 4 and 5
- Supply in week 5: 35 units
- Weeks below demand: 35 units
The 40 and 35 values are below 45; the last shortfall is 10.
More water, new problem
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional flood raises stored water from 30 to 70 units, but the supply is flagged as contaminated by the responsible service.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A pupil says the larger amount automatically solves drinking-water security.
4. True or false? The amount of stored water rises by 40 units, even though its drinking-water suitability remains a problem.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
More volume does not cancel the contamination warning.
Explain incomplete evidence
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school has 100 stored units.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The report does not say whether the water is suitable or whether all learners can reach the supply.
5. Why is the report insufficient to show secure drinking-water access? Name the two missing checks.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies missing water-quality/suitability evidence.
- Identifies missing access or distribution information.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Balance a dry interval
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy store has 90 units. Over each of two steps, 5 enter and 30 are needed. Capacity is 120.
6. For “Balance a dry interval”, select the numerical answer that gives net loss each step. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 25 units
- 60 units
- 30 units remain
- 40 units
90−25−25=40 while 30+30=60 is supplied.
7. Explain how the store can supply 60 units yet lose only 50 from its starting amount.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes 60 units supplied from the 50-unit net loss.
- Accounts for the 10 units of incoming water over two steps.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a complete check
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A reports only how full the tank is.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B records quantity, follows qualified quality results and checks whether users with mobility difficulties can reach the supply.
8. For “Choose a complete check”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- More complete water-security check: Qualified quality results
- More complete water-security check: Plan B
- Additional safety evidence: Plan A proves all needs are met
- Additional safety evidence: Qualified quality results
Plan B checks three distinct requirements.
9. Justify Plan B using both a quality reason and an access reason.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the purpose of quality/suitability checks.
- Explains the importance of addressing access barriers.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a smaller store
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new toy tank holds 30 units, receives 5 and is asked to supply 40 in one step. Capacity is 50. Incoming water is available before use.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer to a smaller store” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Water available that step
- Unmet demand
- Final stored amount
Available labels: 5 units | Negative 5 physical units | 35 units | 0 units
30+5=35 is available; 5 of the requested 40 cannot be supplied.
11. Apply the rule to explain both the final store and the unmet need.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the final store is zero, not negative.
- Calculates unmet demand of 5 units.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a safety shortcut
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional learner says: “The water is clear and the tank is full, so tests and access checks are unnecessary.” No reliable quality result or access survey is given.
12. Build the answer board for “Repair a safety shortcut”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What fullness establishes
- Condition requiring reliable drinking-water tests
- Condition requiring an access survey
Available labels: Clear water proves all conditions | Stored amount | Access for all intended users | Safe drinking quality
Appearance and volume do not replace quality and access evidence.
13. Identify the two missing lines of evidence and rewrite the claim responsibly.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects clarity as sufficient proof of safe quality.
- Names access evidence as another requirement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a monitored allocation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school needs 20 water units per step for three steps and starts with 70 suitable units. There is no refill. The plan must reserve required supply and check remaining amount after each step.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These are practice allocations, not real drinking guidelines.
14. Complete the explanation of “Design a monitored allocation” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Required total
- Reserve after three steps
- Useful monitoring schedule
Available labels: 60 units | 10 units | Check after every step | 80 units needed
Three uses of 20 total 60, leaving 10.
15. Propose a plan meeting the required supply and monitoring conditions, and state the final reserve.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Allocates 60 units total across the three required steps.
- Includes repeated store checks and correctly identifies a 10-unit final reserve.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
- UNDRR: Early warning systems
Quantity, quality and access are distinct. No task provides drinking-water treatment instructions; learners use safe records and follow qualified adult guidance.
CL3.13 — Human health
Identify climate-related health pathways and compare safe, inclusive prevention plans without treating a classroom model as medical advice.
Worked examples
1. Read a toy indicator
Worked classroom example
Toy rule: 29+4−4×shade fraction. Shade is 50%.
Question: What is the model indicator?
Answer: 31 °C in this toy rule.
Half of 4 is 2, so 29+4−2=31. This value does not establish real health safety.
2. Match action to pathway
Worked classroom example
A fictional school provides an accessible cooler waiting space and checks safe water access.
Question: Do these address exactly the same need?
Answer: No. They address heat exposure and suitable water access.
A combined plan can address several pathways without treating one action as a cure for all risks.
3. Count who receives a warning
Worked classroom example
In a fictional class of 30 households, 24 receive a phone alert.
Question: How many still need an effective communication route?
Answer: 6 households.
30−24=6. Sending one alert does not prove everyone received it.
Formative quiz
Separate health pathways
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional situations: unusually hot classrooms; a flood interrupts suitable water supply; a storm blocks a route to a health facility.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These describe exposures and services, not individual diagnoses.
1. Connect each detail in “Separate health pathways” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Hot classrooms
- Interrupted suitable water
- Blocked health-facility route
Available labels: Heat-exposure pathway | Water-security pathway | Every case is the same illness | Access-to-care pathway
The pathways differ and require relevant protective planning.
Compare shade settings
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy rule: 28+6−4×shade fraction. Compare 0%, 50% and 100% shade. The result is not a medical safety threshold.
2. For “Compare shade settings”, which numerical answer gives full-shade indicator? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 30 °C
- 32 °C
- 34 °C
- 28 °C at full shade
The model subtracts 0, 2 or 4 from 34.
Check communication reach
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional school has 40 households. A message reaches 30 by phone and a separate accessible channel reaches the remaining 10. No household is counted twice.
3. For “Check communication reach”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Additional channel reach: 10 households remain unreached
- Total reached: 40 households
- Total reached: 10 households
- Additional channel reach: 10 households
The two non-overlapping groups add to all 40.
Observe a record carefully
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional school reports of heat discomfort across five comparable observation periods are 8, 6, 7, 4, 3. The record does not identify every cause and is not medical diagnosis.
4. For “Observe a record carefully”, select the numerical answer that gives first-to-last difference. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Period 2 to 3
- 5 fewer reports
- One action caused every change
- No variation in the reports
Counts decline overall with variation; causation needs more evidence.
Explain a safe model limit
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
The toy shade model gives a lower indicator with more shade. A pupil says the number guarantees every outdoor activity is safe. The model has no humidity, health or activity inputs.
5. Explain why the guarantee is unsupported, and state the appropriate basis for real school decisions.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names a relevant omitted factor or explains the toy-model limit.
- Directs real decisions to responsible adults and official/local guidance.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A message must reach people
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional school: 50 households, 35 confirmed phone-alert receipts, 15 with no receipt. The task is communication planning, not predicting illness.
6. Build the answer board for “A message must reach people”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Confirmed reach
- Still needing contact
- Next evidence to seek
Available labels: Receipt and understanding | 15 households | 35 households | All 50 are confirmed
A sent message and a confirmed, understood message are different.
7. Explain the communication gap and one way adults can check that the gap is closed.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies 15 households still lacking confirmation.
- Proposes accessible follow-up with receipt or understanding verification.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose an inclusive heat plan
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A opens a cooler space but does not check who can reach it.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B opens an accessible cooler space, follows official guidance, checks safe water access and identifies people needing assistance.
8. For “Choose an inclusive heat plan”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Plan addressing access barriers: Usable access is not checked
- Gap in Plan A: A sign alone proves access
- Plan addressing access barriers: Plan B
- Gap in Plan A: Usable access is not checked
Plan B connects protection to actual access and relevant needs.
9. Justify Plan B using one physical protection and one inclusion feature.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names a relevant protection such as a cooler space or safe water access.
- Explains how accessibility or assistance makes protection usable.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the toy comparison
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A different school model uses 27+5−4×shade fraction. Compare 25% and 75% shade. No health-safety threshold is defined.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer the toy comparison” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Indicator at 25% shade
- Indicator at 75% shade
- Difference
Available labels: 29 °C | 2 °C | 4 °C difference | 31 °C
The indicators are 32−1 and 32−3.
11. Calculate the difference between settings and give one reason it does not prove a real activity is safe.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the 2 °C difference correctly.
- States an appropriate missing factor or non-safety-threshold limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a before-and-after claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional discomfort reports fall from 10 to 5 after a shade project.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
That week was also cooler and attendance was lower.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
A report says the project alone definitely caused the entire reduction.
12. Complete the explanation of “Repair a before-and-after claim” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Observed report change
- Other changing conditions
- Too-strong causal wording
Available labels: Weather and attendance | 5 fewer reports | No other conditions changed | Alone definitely caused it
Weather and the number present can affect counts; the project’s separate effect is not isolated.
13. State the observed improvement and explain why its full cause remains uncertain.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly describes the reduction from 10 to 5.
- Identifies weather or attendance as alternative influences.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a check adults can use
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school heat plan must ensure an accessible cooler space and clear warnings for all families.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It can check room access and confirmed message understanding.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
No student health experiment is allowed.
14. Use the evidence in “Design a check adults can use”. Which result answers the question about communication check?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Poster count proves everything
- Confirm receipt and understanding
- Testing learners in heat
- Verify people can use the space
Checking actual access and communication evaluates two practical parts of the plan.
15. Propose two safe checks: one for the cooler space and one for warning communication.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes an actual accessibility/availability check for the cooler space.
- Includes accessible communication with receipt or understanding verification.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- WHO: Heat and health
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
Educational health pathways only. Toy heat outputs are not safety thresholds or diagnosis; follow qualified adult and official guidance for real conditions.
CL3.14 — Livelihoods
Trace how climate affects ways people earn a living and compare livelihood plans using costs, reliability and fairness.
Worked examples
1. Sales and income
Worked classroom example
A fictional stall has sales of 120 tokens and stated costs of 80.
Question: What remains after those costs?
Answer: 40 tokens.
120−80=40. The result is a simplified net amount, not the total sales.
2. A route interruption
Worked classroom example
A fictional fish seller has stock but cannot reach the market after a bridge closes.
Question: What is the immediate livelihood pathway?
Answer: Transport access prevents sales.
More stock alone would not solve the missing route. Any alternative must be safe and approved.
3. Look beyond an average
Worked classroom example
Worker group A gains 10 tokens; group B loses 4.
Question: Why report both changes?
Answer: The groups experience different effects.
A single combined figure can hide the loss faced by B and weaken a fairness assessment.
Formative quiz
Identify livelihood pathways
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional cases: a dry spell reduces crop output; a bridge closure stops delivery; a heat plan changes outdoor work schedules.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These affect different parts of earning a living.
1. Build the answer board for “Identify livelihood pathways”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Lower crop output
- Stopped delivery
- Changed work schedule
Available labels: All are the same price change | Exposure and working-time pathway | Production pathway | Transport pathway
Following the pathway helps match a response to the actual problem.
A simple operating budget
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional stall sales are 100 tokens. Stated costs are 40 for goods and 25 for delivery. No other costs are modeled.
2. Connect each detail in “A simple operating budget” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Total stated costs
- Amount remaining
- Gross sales
Available labels: 65 tokens remaining | 65 tokens | 35 tokens | 100 tokens
100−40−25=35.
Read working-day variation
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional safe operating days over five equal periods are 20, 18, 19, 15, 16. No causes are assigned by the record.
3. For “Read working-day variation”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Lowest recorded value: 15 days
- First-to-last difference: 15 days
- Lowest recorded value: Every period is lower
- First-to-last difference: 4 fewer days
The sequence varies, with an overall reduction from 20 to 16.
Compare supply choices
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional cooperative’s only road sometimes closes. Plan A keeps the same sole route.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B assesses an approved alternative route, its cost and access for small suppliers.
4. Which conclusion about necessary practical check follows from “Compare supply choices”?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Any road is safe automatically
- Plan B
- Cost and safe access
- Small suppliers
An alternative helps only if safe, usable and affordable.
Explain a lost sale
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional vendor’s stock is undamaged, but a closed bridge prevents delivery to customers.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A learner says the only solution is to buy more stock.
5. Explain why more stock alone does not solve this case, and propose a response matching the barrier.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies transport access rather than stock quantity as the bottleneck.
- Proposes a relevant safe route or delivery response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Calculate a disruption’s effect
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Before a fictional disruption, sales are 120 tokens and costs 70. During it, sales are 90 and costs remain 70. Ignore other factors.
6. Connect each detail in “Calculate a disruption’s effect” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Before-cost-adjusted remainder
- During-cost-adjusted remainder
- Decrease in remainder
Available labels: 50 tokens | Only 20 tokens lost | 20 tokens | 30 tokens
120−70=50 and 90−70=20, a difference of 30.
7. Explain how the unchanged costs affect the money remaining, and calculate the decrease.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the two remainders, 50 and 20.
- States the 30-token decline and links it to lower sales with unchanged costs.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a feasible adaptation
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional workers’ cooperative can spend 30 tokens. Option A costs 20 and provides a suitable approved shaded rest area plus worker consultation. Option B costs 40 and includes no consultation. The aim is feasible exposure reduction with worker input.
8. True or false? Option B meets both the 30-token budget limit and the worker-consultation requirement.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A costs 20≤30 and meets the consultation condition.
9. Justify Option A using both the budget and worker-involvement requirements.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Shows A fits within the 30-token budget.
- Uses worker consultation as the second required reason.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a changed delivery cost
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A different fictional stall has sales of 150 tokens and goods costs of 80. Usual delivery costs 20; an approved alternative costs 35. Both can deliver the same quantity safely.
10. Build the answer board for “Transfer to a changed delivery cost”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Remainder with usual route
- Remainder with alternative
- Additional delivery cost
Available labels: 50 tokens | 35 tokens | 15 tokens | Alternative leaves 65
150−80−20=50 and 150−80−35=35.
11. Calculate the alternative’s effect on the remainder, and explain why the route may still be useful when the usual one is closed.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the 15-token reduction or both valid remainders.
- Explains the alternative’s access/reliability value during closure.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a recovery claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional town’s average sales rise after a project.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Prices also rose, and one small-supplier group lost access to the market.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
A poster says every worker is better off because of the project alone.
12. In “Repair a recovery claim”, what best describes alternative influence?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Average sales rose
- Some suppliers lost access
- Every worker is measured better off
- Prices also rose
The average and timing do not prove a sole cause or universal benefit.
13. Identify one causal problem and one fairness problem in the poster.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies price changes or another stated causal confounder.
- Identifies the excluded group or explains that averages can hide losses.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a livelihood evaluation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional market-route project aims to improve reliable deliveries without excluding small vendors.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It can record deliveries completed and survey which vendor groups can use the route.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The plan must check reliability and inclusion.
14. Complete the explanation of “Design a livelihood evaluation” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Reliability indicator
- Inclusion indicator
- Useful context record
Available labels: Completed deliveries over comparable periods | Weather and prices during the trial | Total poster count | Access by different vendor groups
The two outcome checks address the project’s stated aims.
15. Propose one reliability check and one inclusion check, with a fair comparison.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses completed/reliable deliveries over comparable periods.
- Checks access or outcomes separately for relevant vendor groups.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGII Technical Summary: migration, livelihoods and vulnerability
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
Token budgets and livelihood records are fictional. Adaptation choices depend on safety, resources, rights, markets and affected workers’ input; no job switch is assumed easy or universally available.
CL3.15 — Migration
Explain how climate hazards can influence movement alongside other factors, and evaluate respectful plans for people who move or stay.
Worked examples
1. Read the definition
Worked classroom example
Fictional records list 12 households temporarily evacuated and 4 moving permanently.
Question: Should these be described as 16 permanent moves?
Answer: No.
The total includes different forms of movement. Preserve the temporary/permanent distinction.
2. Identify multiple reasons
Worked classroom example
A fictional family describes repeated flood damage, a new job and nearby relatives as reasons to move.
Question: Is flood damage the only recorded reason?
Answer: No.
Climate-related hazard, work and family all appear in the account; a single-cause label would lose information.
3. A model limit
Worked classroom example
Toy water level exceeds land height at one site. No household information is supplied.
Question: Can the model predict a migration count?
Answer: No.
It estimates only a height relationship. Decisions, resources, policies and alternative protection are missing.
Formative quiz
Different forms of movement
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional records: 8 households leave for two nights during an emergency; 5 move for a seasonal job; 3 relocate permanently.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The categories do not overlap.
1. Complete the explanation of “Different forms of movement” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Two-night emergency move
- Seasonal job move
- Long-term change of home
Available labels: Temporary displacement | All are permanent relocation | Seasonal migration | Permanent relocation
Definitions preserve the different durations and reasons.
Read a household account
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Family A names repeated flooding and a job offer as reasons for moving.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Family B names relatives and school access. These are fictional accounts, not representative statistics.
2. Connect each detail in “Read a household account” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Climate-related reason in A
- Other reason in A
- Reason named by B
Available labels: Job offer | Family and school access | Repeated flooding | All families gave one cause
Accounts can include several reasons, and families differ.
Exposure is one piece
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy coastal water level is 45 cm above a datum and ground is 30 cm. No information about residents’ choices, resources or protection is supplied.
3. For “Exposure is one piece”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- What the model describes: Physical height exposure
- Modeled water depth: 15 cm
- What the model describes: 15 people must migrate
- Modeled water depth: Physical height exposure
Centimetres of depth do not convert directly to people moving.
A count with clear categories
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual counts of temporary evacuations are 12, 18, 10, 20, 15 households. Each value counts households in that year, not permanent moves.
4. Build the answer board for “A count with clear categories”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Highest yearly count
- Last-year count
- What cannot be assumed
Available labels: All moves were permanent | 12 temporary evacuations in year 1 | 20 households | 15 households
Definitions and repeated households matter; these are annual temporary-evacuation counts.
Explain a movement barrier
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional household says it wants a safer housing option but cannot afford transport and cannot access the proposed building.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A neighbour says staying proves the household has no concern.
5. Explain why the neighbour’s inference is unfair, then name one barrier and a practical change the plan should consider.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes constrained staying from lack of concern or preference.
- Names a stated cost/accessibility barrier and a relevant response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read movement evidence carefully
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional survey asks 20 moving households about reasons; multiple reasons are allowed. Twelve mention flood damage and 14 mention employment. Counts overlap, so they cannot be added as separate households.
6. True or false? The 12 flood mentions and 14 employment mentions can come from 20 households because some households may mention both.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Overlapping reason counts measure mentions, not disjoint people.
7. Why can 12 and 14 mentions occur in a survey of 20 households? Explain what this says about reasons for moving.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains overlap or multiple responses.
- Connects the overlap to multiple influences and avoids adding mentions as separate households.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a participatory option
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A assigns a new site without asking residents about access to school or work.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B consults affected and host communities, checks safe housing and plans school and livelihood access. Neither plan guarantees everyone will want to move.
8. In “Choose a participatory option”, select the answer area for “Plan considering people’s needs”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Relocation count alone proves success
- Plan B
- Meaningful consultation
- Housing, school and work access
Participation and access help assess whether an option is workable.
9. Justify Plan B using one reason about voice and one about practical access.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the role of consultation or meaningful choice.
- Explains the importance of practical housing, school or livelihood access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the exposure comparison
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
At another toy coast, water level is 60 cm and ground is 55 cm above the same datum. A planner also has records of household preferences, mobility barriers and available protection.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer the exposure comparison” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Modeled depth
- Human-decision evidence
- Why physical data are incomplete
Available labels: 5 cm | 5 households must move | Preferences and mobility barriers | Options and protection also matter
Physical exposure is one input, not a migration formula.
11. Use the model’s result and name two kinds of human information needed for a movement decision.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates or states 5 cm modeled depth.
- Names at least two relevant human/context factors, such as preferences, mobility, resources or protection.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a single-cause headline
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional survey says movers mention flood damage, job changes and family ties.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A headline says: “Every move was caused only by climate.” The survey does not attribute the flood events to climate change.
12. Build the answer board for “Repair a single-cause headline”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Reasons actually recorded
- Unsupported word
- Additional evidence gap
Available labels: Only | The survey records no other factors | Flood, work and family factors | Event attribution was not supplied
The headline discards other reasons and adds an attribution claim not established by the survey.
13. Identify the overstatement and rewrite the headline in a way that preserves the survey’s evidence.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the multiple recorded reasons or missing attribution.
- Provides a revised statement that preserves multiple factors without universal sole-cause language.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an outcome check
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional voluntary relocation proposal must preserve school access and include residents’ preferences. A report can record travel access and confidential adult-led feedback about options.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The evaluation must not treat the number moved as its only success measure.
14. Use the evidence in “Design an outcome check”. Which result answers the question about incomplete success measure?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Residents can express preferences
- All residents must agree identically
- Number moved alone
- Usable school access
A useful evaluation checks everyday access and meaningful voice.
15. Propose an evaluation with one school-access check and one way to include residents’ views.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a usable, safe school-access outcome.
- Includes accessible resident feedback or a meaningful-choice check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGII Technical Summary: migration, livelihoods and vulnerability
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
Migration and displacement have multiple interacting causes. Physical exposure is not a migration-count model; respect choices, constraints, host communities and people who remain.
CL3.16 — Effects on vulnerable communities
Distinguish hazard, exposure and vulnerability, and evaluate climate plans that address unequal barriers fairly.
Worked examples
1. Separate the three ideas
Worked classroom example
In a fictional case, heavy rain falls; houses stand in its flood path; some residents cannot access warnings.
Question: Which are hazard, exposure and vulnerability?
Answer: Rain is the hazard, location in the path is exposure, and warning barriers contribute to vulnerability.
The terms describe different parts of risk, helping planners match actions to needs.
2. Find the missing group
Worked classroom example
A fictional warning reaches 42 of 50 households.
Question: How many still need an effective route?
Answer: 8 households.
50−42=8. A high overall reach is not complete reach.
3. Check a fair budget
Worked classroom example
An imaginary access plan costs 15 tokens for a shared message and 10 for an accessible alternative. Budget is 30.
Question: Does it fit?
Answer: Yes, total 25 with 5 remaining.
15+10=25. The second channel addresses an identified barrier, rather than simply duplicating the same message.
Formative quiz
Name parts of risk
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional case: heavy rainfall threatens a low-lying street.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Houses stand in the water’s path, and some residents cannot receive the phone-only warning.
1. Build the answer board for “Name parts of risk”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Heavy rainfall
- Houses in the water’s path
- Phone-only warning barrier
Available labels: Exposure | Vulnerability-related condition | All are only rainfall intensity | Hazard
The components differ and suggest different actions.
Count warning access
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional community has 60 households. Forty-five confirm the main warning. Fifteen need another accessible channel.
2. True or false? The main warning has confirmed receipt from 45 households, leaving 15 needing another effective channel.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A sent warning is not universal access.
Same water, different ground
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy coastal water is 50 cm above a datum. Site A ground is 30 cm; site B ground is 70 cm. This only models physical exposure, not people’s full vulnerability.
3. For “Same water, different ground”, select the numerical answer that gives depth at a. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 20 cm
- Access and recovery resources
- Physical height measures every risk
- 0 cm
Site A is below the water and B above it; social conditions still need evidence.
Budget an access improvement
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional budget is 40 tokens. A general warning service costs 20; an accessible alternative for a previously missed group costs 15. Both are required.
4. Complete the explanation of “Budget an access improvement” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Combined cost
- Budget remaining
- Reason for the alternative
Available labels: 35 tokens | 5 tokens | 45 tokens total | Remove a documented access barrier
20+15=35, within 40.
Explain unequal access
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional cooling room is open to everyone, but the only entrance has stairs and no suitable alternative.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Some intended users cannot use it.
5. Explain why “open to everyone” is insufficient here, and name the type of change needed.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the stair/accessibility barrier despite formal permission.
- Proposes a suitable accessible route or equivalent service.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read group outcomes
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional access before and after a project: Group A 20 of 20 then 20 of 20; Group B 5 of 10 then 9 of 10. People are counted once within each group.
6. In “Read group outcomes”, select the answer area for “Group B’s access gain”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 29 of 30 people
- 4 people
- 1 person in Group B
- All 30 have access
20+9=29, and B improves by 9−5=4.
7. Explain both the improvement and the remaining problem using the group data.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly identifies the four-person improvement or 29-of-30 total.
- Identifies the remaining one-person gap in Group B.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a needs-based response
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional main alert already reaches Group A but misses Group B because of format barriers. Plan A buys more of the same format.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B develops an accessible format with Group B and checks understanding. Both cost the same.
8. True or false? Buying more warnings in the same inaccessible format removes Group B’s stated format barrier.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Changing the inaccessible format targets the documented problem.
9. Justify Plan B using one reason about the barrier and one about participation.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links the accessible format to the stated barrier.
- Explains the usefulness of participation by the affected group.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a plan to another group
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new fictional site has a safe room reached by stairs. Ten of 40 intended users need an accessible route. An approved access improvement costs 25 tokens within a 30-token budget.
10. Build the answer board for “Transfer a plan to another group”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- People facing the route barrier
- Cost remaining after improvement
- Purpose of the improvement
Available labels: 10 people | Make the safe room usable | Only permission needs changing | 5 tokens
The barrier is practical access and the stated option fits the budget.
11. Explain why the improvement can be justified even though only a quarter of users need it, and show that it fits the budget.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that the smaller group still needs usable access or equitable protection.
- Correctly shows the 25-token cost fits with 5 remaining.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an average-only claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional flood project reduces average water exposure overall but increases exposure in one neighbouring street.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A poster says: “Everyone is safer because the average improved.”
12. Connect each detail in “Repair an average-only claim” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Known overall result
- Unequal local result
- Error in the poster
Available labels: An average is treated as everyone | One street’s exposure increased | Average exposure decreased | No local differences exist
A lower average can coexist with a worse result for a subgroup.
13. Identify the error and propose a more honest statement about the project.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains that an improved average does not imply universal improvement.
- Includes the increased neighbouring-street exposure in a corrected statement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an inclusive evaluation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional warning plan must reach all groups and let affected people report barriers.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Available checks are confirmed receipt by group and accessible feedback meetings or messages.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The task is to propose an evaluation, not decide whose needs matter less.
14. Complete the explanation of “Design an inclusive evaluation” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Reach measure
- Participation measure
- Follow-up responsibility
Available labels: Overall average alone is enough | Address remaining gaps | Accessible feedback on barriers | Receipt and understanding by group
Group-level access and feedback identify barriers an average can hide.
15. Propose an evaluation with a group-level reach check and an accessible way to learn about remaining barriers.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes group-level reach or understanding measurement.
- Includes an accessible feedback mechanism and attention to remaining barriers.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 WGII Technical Summary: migration, livelihoods and vulnerability
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
Vulnerability is shaped by conditions and barriers, not an inherent weakness of a group. Avoid stereotypes; include affected people and examine unequal outcomes.
CL4.1 — Temperature records
Read temperature records with correct units and baselines, compare like with like, and distinguish a long-term pattern from short variation.
Worked examples
1. Find an average
Worked classroom example
Fictional temperatures: 24, 26, 28 °C.
Question: What is the mean?
Answer: 26 °C.
The total is 78 and 78÷3=26. Individual readings still range from 24 to 28.
2. Calculate an anomaly
Worked classroom example
Practice baseline is 25 °C; observed mean is 27 °C.
Question: What is the anomaly?
Answer: +2 °C.
27−25=+2. This is a difference from a reference, not a separate thermometer reading.
3. Keep a missing reading visible
Worked classroom example
A fictional series is 26, missing, 28 °C.
Question: Should the missing value be entered as 0 °C?
Answer: No.
Zero is an actual value with a different meaning. Mark the observation as missing and explain how calculations handle it.
Formative quiz
Read the complete series
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual means are 25, 26, 25, 27, 28 °C with comparable methods. The series illustrates a pattern only.
1. Complete the explanation of “Read the complete series” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- First-to-last change
- Temporary dip
- Final mean
Available labels: Year 2 to year 3 | Increase of 3 °C | Increase in every year | 28 °C
The full change is 28−25=3, while the middle dip remains visible.
Use a stated baseline
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional baseline is 26 °C. Three observed means are 25, 26 and 28 °C.
2. Connect each detail in “Use a stated baseline” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Anomaly for 25 °C
- Anomaly for 26 °C
- Anomaly for 28 °C
Available labels: +28 °C | +2 °C | 0 °C | −1 °C
Subtract the baseline from each observation.
Compare methods
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Record A contains daily means from one screened instrument.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Record B contains only selected noon readings in direct sunlight. The task is a fair comparison of daily mean air temperature.
3. Build the answer board for “Compare methods”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Record matching the task
- Limit in B’s time sampling
- Limit in B’s exposure
Available labels: Both are daily means | Noon only | Record A | Direct sunlight affects comparison
Averaging period and instrument exposure must match the question.
Explore a smoother
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional values are 24, 27, 25, 28, 26 °C. The mean of the first three is (24+27+25)÷3, or about 25.3 °C rounded to one decimal.
4. For “Explore a smoother”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- What smoothing changes: A new thermometer reading
- What smoothing changes: How neighbouring values are summarised
- First three-point mean: 25.3 °C
- First three-point mean: How neighbouring values are summarised
A moving mean summarises existing values without adding observations.
Explain zero anomaly
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Practice baseline is 27 °C. A reported anomaly is 0 °C, and a learner says the air is at freezing temperature.
5. Explain the learner’s mistake and give the actual temperature for this case.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains anomaly as a difference from the baseline.
- Identifies the actual temperature as 27 °C.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — A trend with a dip
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual means: 26, 27, 26, 28, 29, 30 °C. Use all six points, which were measured comparably.
6. Build the answer board for “A trend with a dip”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- First-to-last increase
- Year-to-year decrease
- Full-record description
Available labels: Steady increase with no dip | Overall warming with variation | 27 to 26 °C | 4 °C
The full rise is 30−26=4, with a real short decrease inside it.
7. Describe the whole pattern and use the temporary dip to explain why “every year is hotter” is inaccurate.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the 4 °C overall rise or correct endpoints.
- Identifies the dip and rejects a monotonic-every-year claim.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a fair comparison
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A compares two stations’ same-year annual means after checking instrument and location changes.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B compares one station’s hottest noon with another’s monthly mean.
8. For “Choose a fair comparison”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- More comparable plan: Plan A
- Mismatch in B: Different time summaries
- Mismatch in B: Plan B isolates climate
- More comparable plan: Different time summaries
Comparable summaries and documented methods make the comparison interpretable.
9. Justify Plan A using one point about time summaries and one about measurements.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains matched averaging periods or years.
- Explains the usefulness of instrument/location consistency checks.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a new baseline
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional observation is 29 °C. Baseline A is 26 °C; baseline B is 28 °C. The observation itself is unchanged.
10. Complete the explanation of “Transfer to a new baseline” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Anomaly against baseline A
- Anomaly against baseline B
- Actual observed temperature
Available labels: +2 °C against both | +1 °C | +3 °C | 29 °C
29−26=3 and 29−28=1; the reference changes the difference, not the observation.
11. Explain why two anomaly values can describe the same observation. Calculate both.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates +3 °C and +1 °C correctly.
- Explains the baseline dependence while preserving the same observed temperature.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a selected-window claim
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Full fictional record: 24, 25, 27, 26, 28, 29 °C. A caption shows only years 3–4, 27 to 26, and claims the whole six-year period cooled.
12. For “Repair a selected-window claim”, select the numerical answer that gives selected-window direction. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Full record falls by 1 °C
- Increase of 5 °C
- Extending the short window to all years
- Decrease of 1 °C
The two-point window is real but does not represent the full six-year pattern.
13. Explain how the selected window misleads, and write a full-record conclusion.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Recognises the selected 27-to-26 decrease without denying it.
- Uses the full 24-to-29 rise to correct the overall conclusion.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a clear temperature report
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class must report six annual means with one missing observation.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It must preserve the data honestly and make the comparison understandable.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It can show labelled points, a stated baseline and method notes.
14. True or false? The missing observation should be marked as missing rather than entered as an invented zero.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Transparent labels and missing-data handling prevent false information.
15. Propose a report that handles the missing point honestly and makes temperature or anomaly values interpretable.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps the missing observation explicit rather than substituting zero or an invented value.
- Provides clear units/time and the baseline if reporting anomalies.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Temperature records and baselines are fictional. An anomaly is a difference from a reference; smoothing and selected windows do not create observations or establish causes.
CL4.2 — Carbon-dioxide records
Interpret atmospheric carbon-dioxide records, distinguish concentration from emissions, and reason about seasonal variation and long-term change.
Worked examples
1. Read ppm change
Worked classroom example
Fictional values: 400 ppm then 406 ppm.
Question: What is the concentration change?
Answer: An increase of 6 ppm.
406−400=6. The unit is concentration, not tonnes of emissions or degrees of warming.
2. A slower flow still adds
Worked classroom example
Toy store starts at 100 CO2 units. Inflow is cut from 12 to 9 while removal remains 6.
Question: Does the store still grow at the new setting?
Answer: Yes, by 3 units per step.
9−6=3. A lower inflow is not necessarily lower stored quantity.
3. Do not lose the cycle
Worked classroom example
Fictional similar-season values are 400, 403 and 406 ppm over three years, though each year contains a short dip.
Question: What do the comparable seasonal values show?
Answer: A longer-term rise.
A within-year dip does not erase the increase between comparable parts of successive years.
Formative quiz
Read the concentration unit
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional CO2 chart gives 400, 402, 401, 404, 406 ppm. The values describe atmospheric concentration.
1. For “Read the concentration unit”, which numerical answer gives quantity on the axis? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 402 to 401 ppm
- Increase of 6 ppm
- CO2 concentration
- 6 tonnes emitted
The difference retains the ppm unit and the short dip remains part of the record.
Track a toy carbon store
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A CO2 bookkeeping model starts with 80 units, receives 12 and removes 7 in one step. Capacity is 150. Units are invented, not ppm.
2. True or false? The toy CO2 store gains 5 model units during the stated step.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
80+12−7=85; inventory units cannot be relabelled as ppm or degrees.
Match quantity and unit
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional table lists concentration in ppm, emissions in tonnes per year, and air temperature in °C.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Each measure answers a different question.
3. Build the answer board for “Match quantity and unit”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Amount mixed into air
- Amount released over time
- Warmth of the air
Available labels: All are ppm | Concentration in ppm | Emissions in tonnes per year | Temperature in °C
Units distinguish concentration, flow and temperature.
Inspect the season
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional same-month CO2 values over four years are 400, 403, 405 and 408 ppm. Within each year, other months can be higher or lower.
4. For “Inspect the season”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Same-month overall change: They reduce seasonal mismatch
- Same-month overall change: Increase of 8 ppm
- Why same months help: They reduce seasonal mismatch
- Why same months help: No seasonal variation can exist
Comparing the same season helps reveal the longer direction without removing real seasonal variation.
Explain slower growth
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy inflow falls from 15 to 10 CO2 units per step. Removal stays at 6. Starting store for the new step is 90.
5. Explain why the store still grows after the inflow reduction, using the new flow values.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the new net gain of 4 units.
- Explains that inflow remains greater than removal despite its reduction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Use a record with a dip
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional CO2 sequence: 398, 401, 400, 403, 405, 404 ppm. All values have comparable methods; the final pair is a short dip.
6. Connect each detail in “Use a record with a dip” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- First-to-last difference
- Final short change
- Full description
Available labels: Overall fall of 1 ppm | Overall rise with short variation | Increase of 6 ppm | Decrease of 1 ppm
404−398=6 despite the final 405-to-404 decline.
7. Explain how the final dip and overall rise can both be true. Use the relevant values.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses 405→404 to describe the short dip.
- Uses 398→404 to identify the overall 6 ppm increase.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a trend comparison
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A compares the same month over many years using a maintained instrument.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B compares one seasonal high with one seasonal low and calls the difference a long-term trend.
8. For “Choose a trend comparison”, choose the supported result for stronger longer-term comparison.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Maintenance and calibration record
- Any two points establish a trend
- Seasonal timing is mismatched
- Plan A
Same-season multi-year data and instrument checks better match the question.
9. Justify Plan A with one reason about seasons and one about measurement reliability.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of matching seasons across years.
- Explains the role of calibration or consistent instrument methods.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Apply a new balance
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new toy store starts at 100 CO2 units. Plan A adds 8 and removes 8 each step. Plan B adds 8 and removes 10. Capacity is 160.
10. For “Apply a new balance”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Net change under A: 0 units
- Net change under B: Both stores must increase
- Net change under A: Loss of 2 units
- Net change under B: Loss of 2 units
Equal flows balance; greater removal lowers the store under this toy rule.
11. Explain why A holds the store steady while B lowers it, without claiming these fixed flows describe the real atmosphere.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains net zero for A and −2 for B.
- States the toy/fixed-assumption limit rather than treating it as a real atmospheric prediction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a unit claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional concentration rises from 410 to 415 ppm.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A caption states: “Five tonnes were emitted and the air warmed five degrees.” No emission mass or temperature is given.
12. For “Repair a unit claim”, select the numerical answer that gives valid observed difference. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 5 ppm concentration rise
- The chart measures both mass and heat
- Temperature measurements
- Mass released over time
A ppm difference cannot be relabelled as mass or temperature.
13. Correct the caption and identify the two unsupported quantities.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Reports the valid 5 ppm change.
- Rejects both unsupported emissions-mass and temperature claims.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an honest CO2 graphic
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class has monthly CO2 readings for three years, with a few missing values.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The graphic must show the longer pattern and preserve seasonal variation.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It can show monthly points plus labelled yearly summaries.
14. Build the answer board for “Design an honest CO2 graphic”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Preserve variation
- Clarify the longer pattern
- Handle missing values
Available labels: Show gaps explicitly | Replace gaps with the lowest point | Keep monthly points visible | Add labelled comparable summaries
Transparent monthly and summary views serve different purposes.
15. Propose a graphic that communicates both seasonal variation and the longer pattern without inventing missing observations.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps monthly variation visible alongside a clearly described longer-term summary.
- Marks missing data instead of inventing replacement observations.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
CO2 concentration in ppm differs from emissions in mass per time. The reservoir analogy uses invented inventory units, not a real carbon-cycle or ppm forecast.
CL4.3 — Satellite data
Explain what satellites can observe, interpret images with dates and legends, and check limitations before making climate claims.
Worked examples
1. Read the key
Worked classroom example
A fictional satellite-style grid has 12 cells: 5 green vegetation, 4 blue water and 3 grey cloud-obscured cells.
Question: How many cells show observed vegetation?
Answer: 5 cells.
The grey cells are unknown surface information, not automatically vegetation loss or bare land.
2. Compare equal areas
Worked classroom example
Two fictional same-season maps cover the same 20-cell area. Vegetation is classified in 12 cells then 9.
Question: What is the mapped change?
Answer: 3 fewer vegetation-classified cells.
12−9=3. Classification accuracy and any obscured cells still need checking.
3. Choose a fair pair
Worked classroom example
One image is from the wet season; another from the dry season.
Question: What extra comparison would help study a long-term change?
Answer: Use comparable seasons across years.
Seasonal vegetation differences can otherwise be mistaken for a longer-term change.
Formative quiz
Read a classified grid
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional map has 16 cells: 6 vegetation, 5 water, 3 built surface and 2 cloud-obscured. The categories are exclusive.
1. For “Read a classified grid”, which numerical answer gives observed vegetation cells? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 6 cells
- 16 cells
- 2 cloud-obscured cells
- 2 cells of proven bare land
Cloud obscuration is missing surface information, not a land-cover class.
Compare mapped cover
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional comparable same-season maps classify 12, 11, 10, 12, 9 vegetation cells over five years in one fixed 20-cell area. No cells are cloud-obscured in this case.
2. Build the answer board for “Compare mapped cover”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- First-to-last mapped difference
- Temporary increase
- Unit being counted
Available labels: 3 species disappeared | Classified map cells | 3 fewer vegetation cells | Year 3 to year 4
Mapped cover is not a species count.
Energy detected from above
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy energy budget: incoming 100, reflected 30 and outgoing 65 energy units. A remote-observation lesson compares these signals. No temperature conversion is supplied.
3. For “Energy detected from above”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Reflected portion: 30 energy units
- Reflected portion: 5 °C warming
- Net energy gain in model: 5 energy units
- Net energy gain in model: 30 energy units
100−30−65=5; energy signals and temperature require distinct interpretation.
Which pair supports a change claim?
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Pair A shows the same area in the same season with comparable sensors and little cloud.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Pair B shows different areas in different seasons, one mostly cloud-obscured.
4. True or false? Pair A provides the more comparable view because area, season and sensor conditions are better matched.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The measurement scope and visibility must match the intended comparison.
Explain grey cells
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional canopy map has 4 grey cells labelled “surface obscured by cloud.” A caption counts them as four new cleared fields.
5. Explain the caption’s error and name one observation that could resolve the missing information.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the legend to distinguish missing surface information from clearing.
- Proposes suitable new imagery or ground evidence to resolve it.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Count mapped land-cover change
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Two fictional maps cover the same 25 cells in comparable seasons. First map: 15 vegetation, 10 other. Later map: 11 vegetation, 14 other. All cells are observed.
6. Use the evidence in “Count mapped land-cover change”. Which result answers the question about what the result measures?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Four animal species extinct
- Mapped land-cover classification
- 11 of 25 cells
- Decrease of 4 cells
The count describes a mapped class, not every ecological or social outcome.
7. Describe the mapped change and one thing it cannot establish by itself.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly states the 4-cell vegetation decrease.
- Names a valid quantity or cause not established by classification alone.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose independent checking
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional vegetation map is uncertain in mixed pixels. Plan A republishes the same image on five websites.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B compares it with independent safe ground-survey records and documents disagreements.
8. In “Choose independent checking”, select the answer area for “Stronger accuracy check”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Plan B
- They repeat one original source
- More copies mean more measurements
- Investigate method and context
Independent observations add evidence; copies do not multiply the measurements.
9. Justify Plan B and explain why reposting the image does not provide five independent checks.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of independent ground evidence.
- Distinguishes reposted copies from independent observations.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a legend to another map
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new fictional sensor map uses red for vegetation, blue for water and black for unobserved pixels. It has 8 red, 6 blue and 2 black cells. The previous map used green for vegetation.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer a legend to another map” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Vegetation in the new map
- Unobserved surface
- Rule for colour meaning
Available labels: Use the current map’s legend | Red must mean hotter land | 8 red cells | 2 black cells
Colours are assigned by the map key, not a universal rule.
11. Explain how to read the new map without importing the old colour meanings. Give the vegetation count.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly identifies 8 vegetation cells.
- Explains that each map’s own legend determines its colour meanings.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a seasonal claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional wet-season image has 14 green vegetation cells; a dry-season image has 9.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A post calls the difference proof of a five-cell permanent loss over years.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
Only those two seasonal images are supplied.
12. For “Repair a seasonal claim”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Important timing mismatch: No map difference exists
- Observed mapped difference: Wet versus dry season
- Observed mapped difference: 5 fewer green cells
- Important timing mismatch: Wet versus dry season
The difference is observed, but a seasonal comparison cannot alone establish permanent loss.
13. Acknowledge the map difference and explain what comparison is needed before claiming permanent long-term loss.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Acknowledges the five-cell difference without denying it.
- Requests comparable seasonal multi-year evidence or equivalent controls.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a satellite-evidence caption
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class uses five same-season maps of a fixed area, with some cloud-obscured pixels.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The caption must communicate change and limits.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It can state dates, area, legend, method and missing observations.
14. True or false? The caption should state the fixed area and comparable seasons used for the five-map comparison.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
An honest caption lets readers distinguish observation from inference.
15. Write a caption plan that identifies the comparison and handles cloud-obscured information honestly.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes area/time/season and the mapped quantity or legend.
- Keeps obscured cells unknown and acknowledges an appropriate measurement limit.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- NOAA: Tracking sea level rise and fall
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
Satellite-style maps and pixel counts are fictional. Sensor type, calibration, pixel size, seasons, clouds and classification uncertainty affect interpretation; display colours require a legend.
CL4.4 — Ocean measurements
Choose ocean measurements that match a question, preserve depth and time labels, and combine complementary evidence.
Worked examples
1. Match the property
Worked classroom example
A fictional study asks whether seawater pH is declining. Available records are temperature, pH and wave height.
Question: Which directly addresses the question?
Answer: The pH record.
Other properties may provide context, but they do not replace a chemistry measurement.
2. Compare a depth pair
Worked classroom example
Fictional same-time readings: 28 °C at the surface, 23 °C at depth.
Question: What is the difference?
Answer: 5 °C.
28−23=5. It is a depth difference at one time, not automatically a warming trend.
3. Read an energy balance
Worked classroom example
Toy ocean step: 100 incoming, 20 reflected, 75 outgoing energy units.
Question: What is the net?
Answer: A gain of 5 energy units.
100−20−75=5. Further physical information would be needed to convert this into temperature change.
Formative quiz
Choose the right measurement
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional research questions ask about ocean warmth, acidity direction and water-surface height.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Available measurements are temperature, pH and sea level.
1. In “Choose the right measurement”, select the answer area for “Ocean warmth question”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Sea-level record
- One instrument value answers all
- pH record
- Temperature record
Match the measured property to the question.
Keep depth labels
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional same-time temperatures: surface 30 °C, 50 m depth 26 °C, 100 m depth 23 °C.
2. For “Keep depth labels”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Surface minus 100 m: 7 °C
- Surface minus 100 m: 26 °C
- Reading at 50 m: 26 °C
- Reading at 50 m: Seven years of warming
Depth differences are not changes over years.
Follow a comparable record
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional same-depth annual ocean temperatures: 25, 26, 26, 27, 28 °C. The measurement method stays comparable.
3. Complete the explanation of “Follow a comparable record” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Overall temperature change
- Years with equal readings
- Necessary preserved label
Available labels: Measurement depth | Rise of 3 °C | Years 2 and 3 | Each reading is from a new depth
The same-depth condition makes a time comparison meaningful.
Energy into and out of water
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy step: 120 incoming, 30 reflected and 80 outgoing energy units. No equation for degrees is supplied.
4. For “Energy into and out of water”, which numerical answer gives net modeled gain? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The model measures pH
- 10 energy units
- 10 °C warming
- 90 energy units
Energy bookkeeping and temperature/chemistry are different.
Explain two valid readings
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
At the same fictional time, a surface sensor reads 29 °C and a deeper sensor reads 24 °C.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Both are checked and correctly labelled.
5. Explain why the readings need not conflict, and state what must be kept the same to compare warming through time.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies depth as a valid reason for the difference.
- Requires comparable depth and measurement context for a time-trend comparison.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare two ocean properties
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional observations: temperature 28 then 29 °C; pH 8.2 then 8.1. Both samples use comparable methods and location.
6. Build the answer board for “Compare two ocean properties”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Temperature change
- pH change
- Interpretation
Available labels: Decrease of 0.1 pH unit | Warming and acidification signals differ | Temperature decreased by 0.1 | Increase of 1 °C
Two properties change in different numerical directions and units.
7. Explain what each record shows without treating pH and temperature as the same quantity.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly describes the 1 °C temperature increase.
- Correctly describes the 0.1 pH decline and distinguishes the quantities.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose complementary evidence
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A claim concerns rising local relative sea level. Evidence A is a maintained tide-gauge record with local land-motion checks.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Evidence B is a single surface-temperature reading. Satellite-height records are also available for wider context.
8. True or false? A single surface-temperature reading directly measures the long-term change in local relative sea level.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The height claim needs height records; temperature alone cannot determine local relative sea level.
9. Justify using the gauge record and explain how satellite data can complement it.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links the gauge and land checks to local relative sea level.
- Explains the broader spatial contribution of satellite-height evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the depth rule
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new record compares surface temperature in year 1 with a 100 m-depth temperature in year 2. Values are 29 and 24 °C. The purpose is to measure year-to-year warming.
10. Complete the explanation of “Transfer the depth rule” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Numerical difference
- Main comparison problem
- Needed fair evidence
Available labels: 5 °C lower reading | A proven 5 °C climate cooling | Depth changed between readings | Same-depth comparable time records
A depth change can explain the difference, so it cannot isolate time change.
11. Explain why the difference is not a valid estimate of year-to-year warming, and propose the needed comparison.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies depth as a confounding difference.
- Proposes a matched-depth/site/method time comparison.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an energy-unit error
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A toy ocean budget gains 8 energy units.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A caption states this means ocean temperature rose 8 °C and sea level rose 8 cm.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
No conversion rules or water-volume information are supplied.
12. Connect each detail in “Repair an energy-unit error” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Valid model result
- Missing temperature link
- Missing level link
Available labels: A model of volume and level change | Every unit equals a degree and centimetre | A physical conversion using water properties | Gain of 8 energy units
Different physical quantities cannot be equated without a defined relationship.
13. Identify the two unsupported conversions and rewrite the result using the valid unit.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects direct conversion of energy units into degrees.
- Rejects direct conversion into sea-level centimetres and preserves the energy-unit result.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an ocean-data comparison
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class has temperature and pH records at two labelled depths on six dates.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It must study change through time and keep different quantities clear.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
All records are supplied; no field sampling is required.
14. In “Design an ocean-data comparison”, select the answer area for “Fair time comparison”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Separate units and labelled series
- Average pH and °C into one value
- Only sampled sites and depths are covered
- Same property and depth across dates
Different properties need separate scales and matched sampling context.
15. Propose a report that compares time changes fairly and avoids mixing temperature with pH.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps depth/property consistent in time comparisons.
- Presents temperature and pH separately with their correct units or clearly distinct labelled scales.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- NOAA: Tracking sea level rise and fall
- NOAA: Ocean acidification education resources
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
Ocean properties have different units and sampling contexts. A depth difference is not a time trend; simple energy budgets do not directly produce real temperature or sea-level changes.
CL4.5 — Ice-core evidence
Explain what ice cores can reveal about past air and climate, and distinguish direct samples from interpreted clues.
Worked examples
1. Read a layer order
Worked classroom example
A fictional undisturbed core has an upper layer labelled younger and a lower layer labelled older.
Question: Which layer represents the earlier period?
Answer: The lower, older-labelled layer.
Use the supplied dating labels. Real cores require dating checks rather than a universal depth-to-year rule.
2. Identify the evidence
Worked classroom example
One sample measures CO2 in trapped bubbles; another uses ice properties to estimate temperature.
Question: Which directly samples past air?
Answer: The bubble sample.
The temperature value is reconstructed from a calibrated clue; it is not an ancient thermometer reading.
3. Find a gas difference
Worked classroom example
Fictional older and younger samples show 270 and 290 ppm CO2.
Question: What is the change from older to younger?
Answer: An increase of 20 ppm.
290−270=20. The unit is gas concentration, not a temperature difference.
Formative quiz
Parts of an ice archive
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A classroom core description includes trapped air bubbles, isotope measurements in the ice, and layer-dating methods.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These provide different information.
1. Complete the explanation of “Parts of an ice archive” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Trapped bubble analysis
- Ice isotope interpretation
- Layer dating
Available labels: Past atmospheric gas sample | A clue for temperature reconstruction | A direct ancient thermometer | Estimated timing of the archive
Different archive features answer different questions.
Follow an older-to-younger record
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional CO2 values in dated samples from older to younger are 270, 275, 280, 278, 290 ppm. These are invented practice data.
2. Build the answer board for “Follow an older-to-younger record”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Overall older-to-younger change
- Temporary decrease
- Measured quantity
Available labels: CO2 concentration in samples | Increase of 20 ppm | 280 to 278 ppm | 20 °C temperature rise
The gas record rises overall with a small intermediate dip.
An archive and a toy store
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
To distinguish stock from flow, a toy atmospheric CO2 store begins at 60 units, gains 9 and loses 4. This is an analogy, not an ice-core dating or ppm model.
3. Connect each detail in “An archive and a toy store” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Final toy store
- Net addition
- Not obtained from the analogy
Available labels: 60 units at the start | 65 units | 5 units | The actual age of an ice layer
Store arithmetic cannot date a core or replace measured concentrations.
Compare evidence labels
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Card A says “CO2 measured from bubbles.”
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Card B says “temperature estimated from ice properties using a calibrated relationship.”
4. For “Compare evidence labels”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Card with past-air sample: Card A
- Card with past-air sample: Card B
- Card with a reconstructed estimate: Both are direct ancient thermometers
- Card with a reconstructed estimate: Card B
Measured gas and reconstructed temperature are related evidence with different methods.
Explain the thermometer mistake
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional worksheet shows an ice-based temperature reconstruction.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A learner says scientists found a working thermometer inside the ancient ice.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The worksheet says the estimate uses calibrated ice properties.
5. Correct the learner’s explanation and state why a reconstruction should include method or uncertainty information.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies inference from calibrated ice properties rather than a thermometer.
- Explains the value of method or uncertainty information.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read a labelled gas change
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional older sample contains 280 ppm CO2 and a younger sample 305 ppm. Estimated temperature is reported separately and is not supplied in this case.
6. Build the answer board for “Read a labelled gas change”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Gas-concentration increase
- Direction through time
- Missing quantity
Available labels: 280 ppm in the older sample | Temperature change | 25 ppm | Older to younger
305−280=25 ppm; no temperature difference is given.
7. Describe the gas change and explain why you cannot turn it directly into degrees of warming.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the 25 ppm increase.
- Distinguishes gas concentration from temperature and rejects an unsupported conversion.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a stronger archive claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Record A includes a core’s location, dating method, measured gases and reconstruction uncertainty.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Record B is a cropped graph with no units, dates or method. Both claim to describe past climate.
8. Complete the explanation of “Choose a stronger archive claim” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- More assessable evidence
- Problem with B
- Helpful uncertainty role
Available labels: A neat line needs no method | Missing units, dates and method | Defines precision of the estimate | Record A
Transparent methods let readers assess what the archive supports.
9. Justify Record A using one measurement detail and one timing or uncertainty detail.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names the importance of measured-property or unit/method information.
- Explains the importance of dating or uncertainty for interpretation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a reversed time axis
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new fictional graph reads left to right from younger to older. Left CO2 is 300 ppm and right CO2 is 280 ppm. The question asks for change from older to younger.
10. In “Transfer to a reversed time axis”, select the answer area for “Older sample on this graph”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Right-hand value
- Increase of 20 ppm
- The time axis is reversed
- Decrease of 20 ppm through time
To move older to younger here, read from right to left.
11. Explain how to read the graph for the requested time direction and give the change.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the supplied reversed age labels correctly.
- Calculates a 20 ppm increase in the requested older-to-younger direction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an exact-age claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional worksheet dates a sample to roughly 1,000 years before the reference year, with an uncertainty range from 900 to 1,100 years.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A caption calls its age exactly 1,000 with no uncertainty.
12. True or false? The stated dating evidence proves the sample is exactly 1,000 years old with no uncertainty.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
An estimate and its range should be reported together.
13. Rewrite the caption to preserve the estimate and its uncertainty, and explain why “exactly” is unsuitable.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes the central estimate and the 900–1,100 range.
- Explains that the estimate does not justify exact-age wording.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an archive evidence card
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class must present an ice-core gas result and a temperature reconstruction.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The card must distinguish the two methods and make timing understandable.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It can include units, age direction and uncertainty.
14. For “Design an archive evidence card”, which numerical answer gives gas-result label? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Measured bubble CO2 with ppm
- Unlabelled curves prove everything
- Reconstructed temperature with method
- Age direction and dating uncertainty
The reader needs the measured quantities and their interpretation limits.
15. Propose a clear evidence card with distinct gas and temperature labels plus useful timing information.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Clearly distinguishes measured bubble gas from reconstructed temperature.
- Includes useful age direction, dating method or uncertainty information.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NASA: Introduction to ice cores
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
Ice cores preserve gas samples and physical clues; temperature reconstructions and dating involve interpretation. Toy carbon stores neither date ice nor calculate real ppm.
CL4.6 — Climate models
Understand climate models as rule-based tools, compare scenarios, and judge model results using tests and stated limitations.
Worked examples
1. Run the rule
Worked classroom example
Toy tank starts with 50 units, receives 20 and supplies 15. Capacity is 100.
Question: What is the next store?
Answer: 55 units.
50+20−15=55. This is the result under the stated one-step rule.
2. Compare scenarios
Worked classroom example
Toy energy A: 100 in, 30 reflected, 70 out. B: 100 in, 30 reflected, 60 out.
Question: Which gains energy?
Answer: B gains 10 units; A is balanced.
Only outgoing energy changes. The result illustrates a conditional comparison, not a temperature forecast.
3. State the limit
Worked classroom example
A toy reservoir predicts water volume but includes no water-quality variable.
Question: Can it establish that the water is safe to drink?
Answer: No.
The model does not represent the needed quality information. Its useful quantity result has a clear limit.
Formative quiz
Balance a model step
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy energy model: incoming 100, reflected 25, outgoing 65 units. Rule is incoming minus reflected minus outgoing.
1. For “Balance a model step”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Absorbed incoming energy: 10 units
- Net energy gain: 10 units
- Absorbed incoming energy: 75 units
- Net energy gain: 10 °C by definition
100−25−65=10 energy units; no temperature conversion is defined.
Apply storage limits
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy tank begins at 90 units, capacity 100, receives 25 and has no outflow in one step. Excess becomes overflow.
2. For “Apply storage limits”, select the numerical answer that gives amount before capacity limit. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 100 units
- 115 units fit inside
- 15 units
- 115 units
Only 10 more units fit; the remaining 15 overflow.
Compare an assumption
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Scenario A uses inflow 10 and outflow 15.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Scenario B uses inflow 20 and outflow 15. Both begin at 50 with capacity 100 and run for one step.
3. Complete the explanation of “Compare an assumption” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Store under A
- Store under B
- Changed input
Available labels: 45 units | 55 units | Both outflows differ | Inflow
The only changed flow is the incoming amount.
Read observations beside a model
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional observed values are 10, 12, 11, 14. Model estimates for the same points are 10, 11, 12, 14. Units and timing match.
4. Connect each detail in “Read observations beside a model” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Exact matches
- Mismatch at point 2
- Mismatch at point 3
Available labels: Model is 1 unit lower | Every point matches | Model is 1 unit higher | Points 1 and 4
Check each paired value rather than one perfect point.
Explain a projection
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A toy model says a store will shrink if outflow stays above inflow.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Its report labels the flows as assumptions, but a headline says the future is fixed regardless of choices.
5. Explain why the model result is conditional and name a change that could alter it.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the assumed flow condition.
- Names a relevant changed input and explains that it can change the result.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Compare energy scenarios
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy A has 120 incoming, 30 reflected and 90 outgoing units. B has the same incoming and reflection but 80 outgoing.
6. Complete the explanation of “Compare energy scenarios” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- A net balance
- B net balance
- Input responsible for difference
Available labels: Outgoing energy | 0 units | Gain of 10 units | Incoming energy increased in B
The budgets differ by 10 in outgoing energy only.
7. Explain how the changed term creates the difference between A and B.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes net balances of 0 and +10.
- Identifies the reduction in outgoing energy as the changed cause within the model.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a useful model test
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Plan A checks one point that matches exactly.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B compares several relevant observations, examines mismatches and checks physical limits. The goal is to evaluate a model for a stated question.
8. True or false? Matching one selected observation exactly is enough to show a model is reliable across all relevant conditions.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Broad relevant testing and physical checks reveal more than a selected success.
9. Justify Plan B with one observation-based reason and one rule-based reason.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of multiple relevant observations.
- Explains checking physical limits, units or internal rules.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer the store rule
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new toy store starts at 40 units, receives 5 and supplies 12 each step. Capacity is 80. Use the rule for two steps.
10. Build the answer board for “Transfer the store rule”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- After one step
- After two steps
- Net loss per step
Available labels: 33 units | 26 units | 7 units | 19 units after two steps
Each step loses 12−5=7, so 40 becomes 33 then 26.
11. Apply the same rule twice and explain why the result depends on the flows remaining unchanged.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes the two-step result of 26 through repeated 7-unit losses.
- States that the repeated calculation assumes the same flows each step.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an unsupported conversion
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A toy energy model gains 6 energy units.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Its author labels the output “6 °C warming next year,” although no water amount, heat capacity or time conversion is defined.
12. Connect each detail in “Repair an unsupported conversion” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Valid result
- Missing relationship
- Missing timing support
Available labels: A rule linking steps to next year | Every model unit equals 1 °C | Energy-to-temperature conversion | Gain of 6 energy units
The stated model supports an energy balance, not the added temperature and date claims.
13. Identify the missing information and rewrite the output label responsibly.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies a missing physical conversion to degrees.
- Removes the unsupported future-year claim and retains the model’s actual step/unit scope.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a transparent model report
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class compares two reservoir scenarios with the same starting store and different use rates.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The report must make the comparison reproducible and state a limitation.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It has input settings, the balance rule and output tables.
14. In “Design a transparent model report”, select the answer area for “Reproducible details”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Output alone explains the model
- Inputs, rule and number of steps
- Quality and other flows may be omitted
- Same starting store
Inputs and rules let another learner reproduce the result.
15. Propose a report that another learner can reproduce and that clearly limits its claim.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes enough inputs/rules/steps to reproduce the scenario comparison.
- States a relevant omission or conditional limitation rather than presenting a complete forecast.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
All models are explicitly simplified and use fictional inputs. Scenario outputs are conditional and must not be relabelled as forecasts or unrelated physical/social quantities.
CL4.7 — Trends and variability
Separate a longer-term trend from short fluctuations and investigate how averaging and selected windows change a graph’s appearance.
Worked examples
1. Find both features
Worked classroom example
Practice values: 20, 22, 21, 23, 24.
Question: What are the overall change and one fluctuation?
Answer: Overall +4; one drop from 22 to 21.
The full direction and the temporary decrease are both true descriptions.
2. Compare variability
Worked classroom example
Series A: 10, 11, 12. Series B: 10, 5, 12.
Question: Which has a larger range?
Answer: B: range 7, compared with A’s 2.
B’s maximum 12 minus minimum 5 is 7. Equal endpoints do not mean equal variation.
3. Read a moving mean
Worked classroom example
Practice values: 6, 9, 12.
Question: What is their three-point mean?
Answer: 9.
The total 27 divided by 3 is 9. This summary does not turn all original observations into 9.
Formative quiz
Find a full-record trend
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Practice values over six years are 10, 12, 11, 13, 12, 15 units.
1. For “Find a full-record trend”, which numerical answer gives first-to-last change? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Overall rise with fluctuations
- Increase of 5 units
- 12 to 11 units
- Every year increases
The sequence includes falls but ends five units higher.
Two records, same endpoints
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional A: 10, 11, 12, 13. B: 10, 5, 16, 13. Both use the same unit and equal time spacing.
2. Connect each detail in “Two records, same endpoints” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Endpoint increase for both
- Range in A
- Range in B
Available labels: 3-unit endpoint increase | 11 units | Both ranges are 3 | 3-unit range
B varies from 5 to 16 even though its endpoints match A’s.
A moving-window summary
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Practice sequence: 8, 10, 12, 14, 16. The mean of the first three values is 10; the mean of the last three is 14.
3. True or false? The mean of the first three values, 8, 10 and 12, is 14 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A moving mean is recalculated for each chosen window.
A selected short decline
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Full fictional record is 10, 12, 15, 14, 16, 18.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A social post displays only 15 then 14 and calls the full record a decline.
4. Complete the explanation of “A selected short decline” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Short selected change
- Full-record change
- Missing context
Available labels: Increase of 8 units | The rest of the time series | Decrease of 1 unit | Both changes are declines
The selected pair and whole series describe different periods.
Explain two true descriptions
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Practice record: 30, 32, 31, 34, 35. One learner says it rises overall; another notices a fall between the second and third points.
5. Explain how both learners can be correct, using the full endpoints and the short decrease.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the 30-to-35 overall rise.
- Uses the 32-to-31 dip to explain variability within the trend.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read a fluctuating rise
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional comparable annual temperature anomalies are 0, 1, 0.5, 1.5, 1, 2 °C relative to one stated practice baseline.
6. Connect each detail in “Read a fluctuating rise” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- First-to-last anomaly change
- One downward step
- Baseline consistency
Available labels: 1 to 0.5 °C | Every value is an actual air temperature | Same reference throughout | Increase of 2 °C
These are differences from one baseline, with a rising overall pattern and dips.
7. Describe the trend and one fluctuation, and explain why keeping the same baseline matters.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Describes the overall rise and a valid dip.
- Explains comparability from using the same reference baseline.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose an honest display
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Chart A shows all points with a labelled time axis and an optional labelled smoother.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Chart B hides inconvenient points and removes its time labels. The task is to communicate trend and variability.
8. In “Choose an honest display”, select the answer area for “More honest display”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Which period and units are shown
- Chart B shows the full evidence
- Short fluctuations and exceptions
- Chart A
The viewer needs both the data and the context of the summary.
9. Justify Chart A with one reason about raw data and one about labels or smoothing.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains how raw observations preserve variability.
- Explains the role of time labels or a labelled smoothing window.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a flat endpoint case
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new practice sequence is 10, 15, 5, 14, 10 units. The first and last values match, but intermediate points differ.
10. For “Transfer to a flat endpoint case”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Endpoint change: 0 units
- Highest minus lowest: 10 units
- Highest minus lowest: No change occurred at any time
- Endpoint change: 10 units
The range is 15−5=10 even though final equals initial.
11. Explain why zero endpoint change does not mean the record was constant. Use the range.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies equal endpoints or zero endpoint difference.
- Uses the 5-to-15 range of 10 to demonstrate nonconstant values.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the smoother claim
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional chart shows raw values and a five-point moving mean.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A caption says: “The smooth curve is five new measurements, so it proves the cause of the trend.”
12. True or false? A five-point moving mean supplies new independent measurements that prove the cause of the trend.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Smoothing changes presentation, not the number of independent observations or causal evidence.
13. Correct both parts of the caption: the claim about new measurements and the claim about cause.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes a moving summary from new independent observations.
- Rejects smoothing as sufficient causal proof.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a two-view explanation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class must explain a 12-point record with several dips.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The report must show the general pattern and preserve short variation.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It can display all points and a clearly labelled moving average.
14. Use the evidence in “Design a two-view explanation”. Which result answers the question about view clarifying broad pattern?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- All original points
- State the window and full period
- A labelled moving average
- Hide every dip
Two transparent views help readers inspect the tradeoff of smoothing.
15. Propose two complementary graph views and state one label needed to keep the summary honest.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes raw/full data and a summary view.
- States the averaging window or another essential label preserving the summary’s meaning.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NOAA: Climate and weather
- NOAA: Understanding climate normals
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
Synthetic short series teach pattern reading, not real climate attribution. Trend, variability, endpoint change, smoothing and causal explanation are distinct.
CL4.8 — Scientific uncertainty
Understand scientific uncertainty as information about limits, compare ranges and scenarios, and make careful decisions without demanding impossible certainty.
Worked examples
1. Report a range
Worked classroom example
A fictional estimate is 30 units, with a stated model range 25–35.
Question: Is exactly 30 guaranteed?
Answer: No.
30 is the central estimate, while the range expresses spread under the stated model method.
2. Compare scenario assumptions
Worked classroom example
Toy A uses 10 water units per step; B uses 20. Both start with 50 and receive 5.
Question: Why do their stores differ after a step?
Answer: Their outflow assumptions differ.
A ends at 45 and B at 35. The rule can be consistent while inputs change.
3. Use a review point
Worked classroom example
A fictional plan is checked after each week’s storage reading.
Question: What benefit does this provide?
Answer: It can be adjusted when evidence changes.
A review point makes uncertainty manageable without pretending that the first plan is exact forever.
Formative quiz
Read the estimate honestly
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional water-level estimate: central value 40 cm, stated scenario range 30–50 cm. The range compares supplied model scenarios, not a guaranteed probability interval.
1. For “Read the estimate honestly”, which numerical answer gives central estimate? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 30–50 cm
- No information is available
- 40 cm
- Exactly 40 cm is guaranteed
The central value and scenario spread both provide information.
See why scenarios differ
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy store begins at 60, receives 10 and has capacity 100. Scenario A uses 15; scenario B uses 25 in one step.
2. True or false? Scenario A ends with 55 water units after the stated single step.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
60+10−15=55 and 60+10−25=45.
A range of model balances
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy energy cases share 100 incoming and 20 reflected units. Outgoing energy is 70, 75 or 80 in the three scenarios.
3. For “A range of model balances”, select the numerical answer that gives gain when outgoing is 70. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Every case gains 20
- 5 units
- 0 units
- 10 units
The output spread follows directly from the changed outgoing assumption.
Match uncertainty sources
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A classroom example lists a thermometer with limited precision, changing year-to-year weather, and unknown future emissions choices.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
These are distinct sources of uncertainty.
4. For “Match uncertainty sources”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Year-to-year weather changes: Natural variability
- Instrument precision: Measurement uncertainty
- Year-to-year weather changes: All mean scientists know nothing
- Instrument precision: Natural variability
Different uncertainties require different kinds of interpretation or follow-up.
Explain useful uncertainty
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional report says coastal water in its scenarios reaches 40–60 cm above a model datum. It does not identify an exact event date. A pupil says the report contains no useful information.
5. Explain one useful decision question the range can inform and one claim it cannot justify.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names a relevant comparison or planning use of the range.
- Identifies the missing exact timing or rejects a guaranteed exact result.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply both ends of a range
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy water surface ranges from 40 to 60 cm above one datum. Ground is 50 cm. The model depth is max(0, water minus ground).
6. For “Apply both ends of a range”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Depth at upper scenario: 10 cm
- Depth at lower scenario: 0 cm
- Depth at lower scenario: 10 cm
- Depth at upper scenario: 20 cm at every level
At 40 the land is higher; at 60 the difference is 10.
7. Explain the two modeled depth outcomes and why one exact depth would lose useful information.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly gives 0 and 10 cm at the two bounds.
- Explains why the result depends on the water-level scenario.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose an adaptable plan
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional water supply may be 40–60 units per step. Essential use is 35. Plan A commits to 60 units of use whatever arrives.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Plan B reserves 35 for essential use and reviews optional use after the supply reading.
8. Build the answer board for “Choose an adaptable plan”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Plan robust across the stated supply
- Reason A may fail
- Useful adaptation feature
Available labels: Plan A fits every case | Adjust optional use after monitoring | It assumes the highest supply | Plan B
The lower supply cannot meet 60, while reserving essentials and adjusting options is more flexible.
9. Justify Plan B using the lower supply case and its review process.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the 40-unit low case to show the benefit of protecting 35 essential units.
- Explains adjustment of optional use through monitoring.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a new range
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new toy estimate gives 70–90 usable water units for a two-step interval. Essential use totals 60; an optional task uses 20. There is no other inflow.
10. Complete the explanation of “Transfer to a new range” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Low-supply amount after essentials
- High-supply amount after essentials
- Optional task guaranteed to fit all cases
Available labels: No; it needs 20 units | It fits at the lower bound | 10 units | 30 units
At 70 only 10 remain; at 90, 30 remain.
11. Explain whether the full optional task fits every scenario, and propose a flexible rule.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the lower-bound 10-unit remainder to reject an always-fit claim.
- Proposes a conditional optional-use rule that protects essential supply.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair two opposite errors
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional report gives a central estimate of 20 with a range 15–25.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Comment A says “exactly 20 is certain”; comment B says “the range means nothing is known.”
12. In “Repair two opposite errors”, what best describes problem in comment b?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Both comments are fully accurate
- It dismisses useful bounded information
- Estimate and range together
- It erases the stated spread
A useful estimate can have uncertainty without being exact or meaningless.
13. Correct both comments in one balanced explanation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects exact certainty while preserving the range.
- Explains that uncertainty does not erase the information in a bounded estimate.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a recommendation with a review point
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional community plan is based on two water-supply scenarios and can change optional use monthly.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The recommendation must state a relevant uncertainty and a practical review trigger.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
Qualified adults handle real allocations.
14. In “Design a recommendation with a review point”, select the answer area for “Uncertainty to report”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- New measured supply or storage
- Which supply scenario occurs
- Adjust optional use when evidence changes
- Promise one exact supply forever
A conditional recommendation can remain useful as evidence improves.
15. Write a brief recommendation that acknowledges uncertainty and includes a review trigger.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States a relevant scenario or supply uncertainty.
- Provides a concrete monitoring/review trigger linked to an adjustable action.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
- IPCC AR6 WGII: Summary for policymakers
The classroom ranges are stated scenario spreads, not automatically confidence or probability intervals. Uncertainty can coexist with strong evidence; real safety decisions need qualified local guidance.
CL4.9 — Evaluating climate claims
Evaluate a climate claim by matching its scope to evidence, checking methods and distinguishing a supported conclusion from an overstatement.
Worked examples
1. Check scope
Worked classroom example
Fictional evidence: one school records a cooler Friday. Claim: the whole planet is cooling for decades.
Question: Does the evidence match the claim?
Answer: No.
One school and one day cannot establish a worldwide long-term trend.
2. Check a model statement
Worked classroom example
Toy energy budget: 100 in, 20 reflected, 70 out. Claim: the system gains 10 energy units this step.
Question: Is the claim supported by the rule?
Answer: Yes.
100−20−70=10. The claim keeps the model’s unit and one-step scope.
3. Separate fact and priority
Worked classroom example
Two fictional routes have the same delivery time. A family prefers the cheaper one; another prefers the route with accessible stops.
Question: Must one be wrong about the travel time?
Answer: No.
They can agree on the measurement and weigh cost or accessibility differently.
Formative quiz
Locate the claim’s scope
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Evidence: one fictional town records 40 rain units in one week.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Claim: every town will get exactly 40 units every future week.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
No other data are supplied.
1. Which part of the claim adds BOTH unobserved places and unobserved future times to the one-town, one-week record?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The one reading covers all places
- One town in one week
- Every town and every future week
- Relevant broader records and methods
The claim expands location, time and certainty beyond the observation.
Check a measured trend
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional comparable temperature means are 24, 25, 24, 26, 27 °C. A claim says the series rises overall with a temporary dip.
2. Build the answer board for “Check a measured trend”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Overall numerical change
- Dip in the record
- Claim’s fit to these data
Available labels: It describes both features | Increase of 3 °C | It increases every year | 25 to 24 °C
The evidence supports an overall rise and a dip, not an unbroken rise.
Test the energy claim
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Toy budget has 120 incoming, 20 reflected and 90 outgoing energy units. A claim says there is a 10-unit energy gain in this step.
3. For “Test the energy claim”, select the numerical answer that gives net modeled gain. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 10 energy units
- 10 °C next year
- 110 energy units
- A gain in this step
The arithmetic supports the stated energy balance but not a new temperature forecast.
Choose relevant evidence
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Question: did a bay’s pH decline? Source A provides dated calibrated pH values.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Source B gives a bright photograph of a sunset without water measurements.
4. Connect each detail in “Choose relevant evidence” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Direct evidence for the question
- Why B is insufficient
- Useful detail to check in A
Available labels: Popularity of the sunset image | It does not measure pH | Dates and measurement method | Source A
Evidence must address the measured quantity, not just look persuasive.
Explain a causal limit
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school’s electricity use drops after an efficiency campaign.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The same month has fewer school days.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The report says the campaign alone caused the full decrease.
5. State what the evidence supports and identify one comparison that would help test the campaign’s effect.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes the observed decrease from sole-cause proof.
- Proposes a comparable operating-period or other reasonable controlled comparison.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Judge a narrowly stated claim
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional annual counts of a fixed threshold event are 2, 3, 2, 4, 5. Claim: “Across these five practice years, the count ends higher than it starts, with variation.”
6. True or false? Across the five supplied practice years, the event count ends 3 events higher than it starts.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The claim preserves both the measured period and the fluctuation.
7. Explain why the claim fits the record using a number for the overall change and a number pair showing variation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the endpoint increase of 3 or correct 2→5 comparison.
- Uses the 3→2 dip to support the variation statement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a stronger source
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Source A gives original methods, dates, units and a relevant record, including uncertainty.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Source B says “everyone knows” and provides no source or method. The task is to assess a measurement claim.
8. For “Choose a stronger source”, choose the supported result for reason methods matter.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Source B is stronger by confidence
- They show how evidence was obtained
- Agreement claims are not measurements
- Source A
Transparent evidence can be examined; confident wording alone cannot.
9. Justify choosing A using one detail about dates, units or scope and one detail about methods, original data or uncertainty. Explain why each helps evaluation.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names a relevant date/unit/scope feature.
- Names a method, original-data or uncertainty feature and explains its value.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a claim to a new case
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy tank begins with 50 units, receives 15 and supplies 20. Claim: “It loses 5 units this step if these flows apply.” Capacity is 100 and no other flows are modeled.
10. For “Transfer a claim to a new case”, select the numerical answer that gives final store. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Loss of 5 units
- 45 units
- The stated flows apply
- The tank always loses 20
The claim correctly ties its result to the supplied flows.
11. Evaluate the claim using the rule, then explain why it does not describe every future step automatically.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Checks the 45-unit store or 5-unit loss correctly.
- Explains the conditional nature of extending the result to later steps.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a global-weather claim
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional post shows one cool morning in a Philippine town and states: “This proves global warming has ended.” It includes no global or long-term record.
12. Complete the explanation of “Repair a global-weather claim” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Observation actually supplied
- Mismatch with the conclusion
- Needed evidence for the broad question
Available labels: Local short weather versus global climate | Long relevant records from many places | The photograph measures all years | One local cool morning
The time and geographic scopes do not match.
13. Explain the scope mismatch and rewrite a conclusion limited to the observation.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the local/short-term versus global/long-term mismatch.
- Provides a limited accurate conclusion rather than the global claim.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an evidence-based recommendation
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional school’s measured runoff is higher on paving than a suitable garden area in comparable trials.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It can propose a small adult-approved surface project and monitor later runoff.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The recommendation must link action to evidence and state a check or limit.
14. For “Design an evidence-based recommendation”, select ALL supported statements. Choose two.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Evidence link: An approved limited project
- Evidence link: More infiltration can reduce modeled runoff
- Feasible next step: An approved limited project
- Feasible next step: Promise all flooding ends
A justified recommendation connects a measured pathway to a feasible tested action.
15. Write a brief recommendation with one evidence link and one way to check or limit the claim.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Links the proposed action to the infiltration/runoff evidence.
- Includes a relevant evaluation method or explicit limitation on the flood-risk claim.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- IPCC AR6 Synthesis: Summary for policymakers
Claim evaluation checks scope, methods, units, independence and causal reasoning. A recommendation may combine factual evidence with explicitly stated values and tradeoffs.
CL4.10 — Identifying misleading climate information
Identify misleading climate presentations by checking missing context, graphs and source origins, while distinguishing an error from proven deceptive intent.
Worked examples
1. Restore the time context
Worked classroom example
Full practice series: 10, 12, 11, 14, 15. A post shows only 12→11 and calls all five points a decline.
Question: What is the correction?
Answer: The short section falls by 1, but the full series rises by 5.
Both observations are retained; the misleading step is extending the selected window to the whole record.
2. Read the real difference
Worked classroom example
A zoomed graph shows values 100 then 101, with an axis from 99 to 102.
Question: What is the numerical increase?
Answer: 1 unit.
The zoom changes appearance, not the values. A clear axis can make the zoom legitimate; the caption must remain accurate.
3. Count original sources
Worked classroom example
Four fictional posts all copy the same photograph from one account.
Question: Are these four independent observations?
Answer: No.
They share one origin. Check that origin and seek genuinely separate evidence when the claim needs it.
Formative quiz
Check a selected window
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Full fictional record: 20, 22, 21, 23, 25 units. A post displays 22 then 21 and says the entire record fell.
1. For “Check a selected window”, which numerical answer gives full-record change? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Decrease of 1 unit
- No short dip exists
- Increase of 5 units
- Short window treated as whole record
The short dip is real, but the caption gives it the wrong time scope.
Read a zoomed scale
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A fictional graph shows 100 then 102 units on a vertical axis from 99 to 103. The axis is clearly labelled. The caption claims a 20-unit increase.
2. True or false? The values 100 and 102 differ by 2 units, regardless of the graph’s zoomed vertical scale.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A zoom does not alter the subtraction 102−100.
An image’s missing context
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional flood photo is from Place A in Year 1. A post labels it Place B this week.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The original source preserves Place A and Year 1 in its metadata and caption.
3. Build the answer board for “An image’s missing context”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Original location
- Original time
- Problem in the repost
Available labels: Location and date were changed | Place A | Year 1 | The image proves this week in B
The source context does not match the repost’s claim.
A model becomes a false certainty
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy coastal case gives water level 50 cm and ground 40 cm, with no date. A post calls it a guaranteed 10 cm flood tomorrow in every coastal town.
4. Connect each detail in “A model becomes a false certainty” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Modeled depth in this case
- Missing timing information
- Unsupported geographic scope
Available labels: No event date is supplied | Every coastal town | 10 cm | Tomorrow is part of the model
The arithmetic does not provide the added date or universal location claim.
Explain copied evidence
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Five fictional websites show the same graph and link back to one original dataset.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A pupil counts them as five independent datasets.
5. Explain the counting error and name what would provide an independent check.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes five copies from one underlying dataset.
- Names a separate observation or method as an independent check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Inspect the entire pattern
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Full practice sequence is 8, 10, 9, 12, 11, 14. A cropped view uses only 12→11 and labels the whole period “falling.”
6. True or false? The selected 12-to-11 segment falls by 1 unit, even though the full record rises overall.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The problem is the caption’s scope, not the existence of the selected dip.
7. Explain the misleading step and give a corrected full-period statement using numbers.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the selected-window scope error.
- Uses the full 6-unit rise while acknowledging the short dip.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a useful correction
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Correction A says “The author is evil” without showing data.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Correction B shows the full dated record, explains the cropped interval and limits its conclusion to what the source supports.
8. Connect each detail in “Choose a useful correction” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Evidence-based correction
- Missing element in A
- What B avoids assuming
Available labels: Correction B | Insults establish the data | The author’s motive | A checkable explanation
A correction should address the evidence and specific error, not unsupported claims about intent.
9. Justify Correction B with one evidence reason and one reason about motive.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of showing source context and the specific misleading step.
- Distinguishes an error from proof of the author’s intent.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a new graph
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A new fictional chart shows 48 then 50 units on a labelled 47–51 axis. A caption says the quantity doubled. No other values are shown.
10. For “Transfer to a new graph”, select the numerical answer that gives actual difference. Use the stated units.
Hotspot · 2 points
- 50 units
- 2 units
- 96 units
- 50 is twice 48
Doubling 48 gives 96, not 50; the zoomed scale does not change that.
11. Use arithmetic to correct the doubling claim and explain the role of the zoomed axis.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Corrects the claim using +2 or the required doubled value of 96.
- Explains that axis scaling changes appearance rather than the underlying numbers.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a false-source conclusion
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional image has grey pixels labelled “cloud-obscured.” A repost says each grey pixel is proven deforestation and accuses the original scientist of hiding it.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
No clear surface view is available.
12. In “Repair a false-source conclusion”, what best describes unsupported personal claim?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Cloud pixels directly measure clearing
- Every grey pixel is deforestation
- Surface hidden by cloud
- The scientist’s deceptive intent
Neither the surface classification nor the alleged motive follows from obscured pixels.
13. Correct both the image interpretation and the unsupported claim about intent.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the legend to reject definite deforestation from obscured pixels.
- Rejects the motive accusation as unsupported or calls for relevant evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a responsible correction card
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class corrects a post that confused one cool day with a long-term global trend.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The card must state the true observation and explain the time-and-place mismatch.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
It should direct readers to suitable evidence rather than attack a person.
14. Build the answer board for “Design a responsible correction card”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Preserve the real observation
- Explain the mismatch
- Useful next evidence
Available labels: Daily local weather is not global climate | One place had a cool day | Relevant long records across places | Call every reader dishonest
A clear correction keeps the accurate observation and limits its meaning.
15. Draft a two-part correction that states the valid observation and explains what broader evidence is needed.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Preserves a properly scoped local daily observation.
- Explains the mismatch and requests relevant broad long-term evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- NOAA: Climate and weather
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
A nonzero graph axis or short period is not automatically misleading when clearly labelled and relevant. Identify the specific mismatch; do not infer deceptive intent without evidence.
CL4.11 — Comparing evidence from several sources
Compare evidence from different methods and sources, check independence, and build a conclusion that respects both agreement and limits.
Worked examples
1. One origin, many copies
Worked classroom example
Three fictional pages all reproduce the same station graph.
Question: How many original datasets have been identified?
Answer: One.
The number of pages is not the number of independent measurements. Trace each citation to its origin.
2. Keep different quantities apart
Worked classroom example
A fictional record shows temperature rising by 1 °C while another shows pH falling by 0.1.
Question: Should their changes be averaged into 0.45?
Answer: No.
The units and quantities are different. Describe the temperature and chemistry findings separately before discussing their connection.
3. Compare matching summaries
Worked classroom example
A local daily maximum is 32 °C and a regional monthly mean is 27 °C.
Question: Does the difference prove an instrument error?
Answer: No.
They describe different time summaries and areas. Match the statistic, period and scope before testing disagreement.
Formative quiz
Label each source’s contribution
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Fictional Source A measures air temperature, Source B measures ocean temperature, and Source C records local relative sea level.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
The records are different quantities with their own locations and dates.
1. In “Label each source’s contribution”, select the answer area for “Source A contributes”.
Hotspot · 2 points
- All three measure pH
- Air-temperature evidence
- Ocean-temperature evidence
- Relative sea-level evidence
A synthesis preserves each measured quantity rather than merging labels.
Trace repeated copies
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
Four fictional websites link to the same original station dataset.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
A fifth source provides a separately measured ocean record.
2. True or false? The four websites repeating the station graph identify only one original station dataset.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Trace the evidence origin instead of counting pages.
Compare matched temperature records
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Two fictional independent methods measure comparable annual temperature anomalies for four years. A: 0, 1, 1, 2. B: 0.2, 0.8, 1.2, 1.8 °C. Both use the same baseline.
3. Complete the explanation of “Compare matched temperature records” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Overall direction in both
- Exact values at every point
- Useful interpretation
Available labels: Opposite overall trends | They are not identical | Broad agreement with measurement differences | Upward
Both end higher than they start, though individual estimates differ.
Inventory and measurement
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
A toy water model predicts 50 units after a step from 60+10−20. An independent fictional gauge reports 49 units with stated measurement uncertainty. No tolerance threshold is defined.
4. For “Inventory and measurement”, which numerical answer gives model result? Use the stated units.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 1 unit
- Exact identity of the values
- 50 units
- 49 units
A small difference should be interpreted with methods and uncertainty, not ignored or exaggerated.
Explain apparent disagreement
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional surface sensor reads 29 °C while a deep sensor reads 24 °C at the same time.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Both are checked.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
A student says their difference proves both are unreliable.
5. Explain why the readings can both be valid and what labels should be preserved when combining them.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies depth differences as a valid explanation.
- Requires relevant sampling labels when comparing or combining records.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Find agreement without exact equality
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Fictional independent records over five comparable years: A is 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 units; B is 10.5, 11, 11.5, 13, 13.5. Same units and scope are used.
6. Complete the explanation of “Find agreement without exact equality” by choosing a result for each row.
Dropdown · 2 points
- First-to-last change in A
- First-to-last change in B
- Shared broad pattern
Available labels: An overall increase | Increase of 4 units | Every point must match exactly | Increase of 3 units
Different estimates can agree on direction without being identical.
7. Explain what the two records agree on and one difference that should remain visible.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the common upward direction.
- Preserves the different magnitudes or specific measurement differences.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose sources for a local plan
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional flood plan needs evidence about runoff and access barriers. Source A supplies comparable runoff measurements. Source B records residents’ reported warning-access barriers.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
Source C is an unrelated temperature photograph from another country.
8. For “Choose sources for a local plan”, choose the supported result for source lacking the needed relevance.
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Only photographs count as evidence
- Source B
- Source C
- Source A
Different relevant methods can address complementary planning questions.
9. Justify using both A and B rather than adding C simply to increase the source count.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the complementary physical and access contributions of A and B.
- Explains C’s lack of relevant scope rather than judging only by source quantity.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to incompatible summaries
Fixed classroom case — fictional practice data
Record A gives one town’s hottest day at 34 °C. Record B gives a region’s monthly mean at 28 °C. Both are credible within their labels. A report subtracts them and calls it a six-degree error.
10. Connect each detail in “Transfer to incompatible summaries” with the result supported by its evidence.
Matching · 2 points
- Numerical difference
- Main comparability problem
- How to make the comparison fair
Available labels: Use the same area, period and statistic | Different area and time summaries | 6 °C | The regional mean must be wrong
Different summaries can legitimately differ.
11. Explain why the six-degree difference is not automatically an error and propose a fairer comparison.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the differing time/statistic/geographic scopes.
- Proposes a matched statistic, period and area comparison.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the independence count
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional report lists six articles as six independent confirmations.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
All six quote one original graph, and none adds a new measurement or analysis.
12. True or false? The six articles provide six independent original measurements, even though they all repeat the same graph.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Repetition of a source is not independent confirmation.
13. Correct the evidence count and describe what kind of additional source would strengthen the check.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Recognises one underlying evidence origin despite six articles.
- Proposes a genuinely separate relevant dataset or method.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a transparent synthesis
Fixed classroom case · 1 — fictional practice data
A fictional class has a local temperature record, a comparable ocean record, and a source-quality note for each.
Fixed classroom case · 2 — fictional practice data
It must state shared findings and limits.
Fixed classroom case · 3 — fictional practice data
The records cover different parts of the climate system and are independently collected.
14. Build the answer board for “Design a transparent synthesis”: drag or tap each result into its matching row.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Synthesis first step
- Agreement statement
- Limit statement
Available labels: Preserve scope and uncertainty | State what each record measures | Average every quantity into one value | Describe a supported shared direction
A synthesis connects findings without erasing what each source can measure.
15. Propose a short synthesis structure that explains agreement and preserves the records’ limits.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes identifying each measured quantity and checking for a supported shared finding, without mixing units.
- Preserves scope, method or uncertainty limitations of each record.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- NASA: Evidence for climate change
- IPCC AR6 WGI Chapter 1: Methods and uncertainty
- NOAA: Tracking sea level rise and fall
- NASA: Introduction to ice cores
Multiple pages can share one original source. Independence, relevance and comparable units/sampling matter; different valid records may measure different conditions.
CL5.1 — Renewable energy
Compare renewable energy choices using emissions, available energy and community needs.
Worked examples
1. An evening classroom
Worked classroom example
Classroom assumptions: evening demand is 8 units; stored solar energy is 5 units.
Question: How much extra supply or saving is needed?
Answer: 3 energy units.
Subtract the available 5 from the needed 8. Storage moves energy across time but cannot supply more than the energy available.
2. Two equal supplies
Worked classroom example
Illustrative factors: source P releases 3 units per electricity unit; source Q releases 1. Both supply 4 electricity units.
Question: Which has lower model emissions?
Answer: Q: 4 units, compared with P: 12.
Multiply each factor by the same output. This is a fair model comparison because the amount supplied and the counted stages are equal.
3. A cloudy-day decision
Worked classroom example
A fictional reading room needs 7 units. Solar provides 3, storage provides 2, and efficient lights save 2.
Question: Can the plan meet the remaining demand?
Answer: Yes: demand falls to 5 and supply totals 5.
Demand reduction and cleaner supply work together. The result follows from these assumptions, not from a claim that every reading room works the same way.
Formative quiz
Sun and demand
Sun and demand · evidence 1
Fictional model: demand is 100 electricity units. The renewable share is 40%. Fossil electricity has factor 2; renewable electricity has factor 0.1. Factors include simplified life-cycle emissions.
1. True or false: Doubling demand from 100 to 200 units while keeping the same renewable share and factors leaves model emissions unchanged.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
More electricity at unchanged factors means more total emissions. The positive renewable factor counts assumed life-cycle effects.
Choose a reliable evening plan
Choose a reliable evening plan · evidence 1
Fictional school: evening demand is 8 units. Plan A supplies 6 solar-stored units; B supplies 8 stored units; C supplies 5; D supplies 7. All are available at evening.
2. Which plan meets the fixed evening demand?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Plan C supplies the needed 8 units.
- Plan A supplies the needed 8 units under the stated conditions.
- Plan B supplies the needed 8 units.
- Plan D supplies the needed 8 units.
Only B reaches eight; A has six, leaving two still needed.
Follow stored energy
Follow stored energy · evidence 1
Classroom battery: 20 stored energy units; 10 enter; 6 leave in one step. Capacity is 50. Ignore losses only for this toy calculation.
3. Follow stored energy: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is stored after one step?
- Where do the incoming units come from?
Available labels: They must be supplied by an energy source. | The battery holds 16 units. | The battery holds 24 units.
20+10−6=24. Storage shifts supplied energy in time; it is not a fuel or generator.
Read the whole day
Read the whole day · evidence 1
Fictional solar outputs at four equal periods: 0, 3, 5, 0 electricity units. The room needs energy after sunset too.
4. Read the whole day: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Output is five units in every period.
- The noon value proves evening supply.
- Output changes across the day.
- Another supply or stored energy is needed.
The record includes two zero periods. A daily maximum cannot stand in for evening availability.
Explain a fair comparison
Explain a fair comparison · evidence 1
A poster compares a panel supplying 5 units with a diesel set supplying 20 units.
Explain a fair comparison · evidence 2
It counts panel manufacture
Explain a fair comparison · evidence 3
only diesel operation.
Explain a fair comparison · evidence 4
These are fictional classroom examples.
5. Name two changes that would make the emissions comparison fair.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Requires equal electricity delivered.
- Requires comparable life-cycle boundaries.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Use the energy mix
Use the energy mix · evidence 1
Fictional school supplies 100 units: 60 fossil at factor 2 and 40 renewable at factor 0.1. All factors count the same simplified life-cycle boundary.
6. Use the energy mix: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- How many emission units come from fossil supply?
- How many come from renewable supply?
Available labels: Fossil supply produces 60 units. | Renewable supply produces 4 units. | Fossil supply produces 120 units.
60×2=120 and 40×0.1=4; total is 124.
7. Explain why moving some supply from fossil to renewable lowers this model total. Mention the factors and equal demand.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Compares factor 2 with factor 0.1.
- Keeps delivered demand constant in the explanation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose for the cloudy week
Choose for the cloudy week · evidence 1
Fictional clinic reading room needs 10 units daily.
Choose for the cloudy week · evidence 2
Option A provides 10 on sun and 4 on cloud
Choose for the cloudy week · evidence 3
option B provides 8 solar plus 2 backup on sun and 4 solar plus 6 backup on cloud.
Choose for the cloudy week · evidence 4
Backup emissions must be counted.
8. Choose for the cloudy week: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A reaches 10 units on both days.
- B reaches 10 units on both days.
- Its backup emissions must be counted.
- B’s backup has no environmental effect.
B meets the stated service requirement; the backup is useful but is still included in the emissions comparison.
9. Justify B for this room, then state one climate trade-off to examine.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the all-weather ten-unit requirement.
- Identifies a relevant backup-emissions trade-off.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a larger room
Transfer to a larger room · evidence 1
A new fictional room needs 12 units after sunset. Stored solar supplies 8 and efficient equipment saves 3 of the original demand. No other supply is available.
10. Transfer to a larger room: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is demand after the saving?
- What shortage remains?
Available labels: Supply is short by 1 unit. | The remaining demand is 15 units. | The remaining demand is 9 units.
12−3=9, and 9−8=1. The original plan must be adjusted for the larger room.
11. Propose one adjustment and show why it fixes the changed demand.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Finds the one-unit gap.
- Gives an adjustment that closes it without inventing energy.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Find the missing condition
Find the missing condition · evidence 1
Mika claims: “Our panel supplies 9 units at noon, so it always supplies our 9-unit evening demand.” The fictional record is 1, 5, 9, 0 at dawn, morning, noon and evening.
12. Find the missing condition: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the error in Mika’s claim?
- What does the evening record actually show?
Available labels: Noon output is used as evening output. | The panel supplies 0 evening units. | The noon output must be added twice.
The output time matters. A noon value does not establish stored energy or evening supply.
13. Repair Mika’s claim using the record and name the missing part of the plan.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Corrects the time mismatch with the given values.
- Identifies storage or another verified evening source.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a small energy plan
Design a small energy plan · evidence 1
Fictional choices: one panel costs 3 tokens and supplies 4 sunny-day units; one storage pack costs 2 and can deliver 2 evening units if charged. Budget 8. Need at least 4 evening units. Panels must supply the charging energy; ignore losses.
14. Which plan can meet the stated evening target within budget?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Three packs without panels create 6 under the stated conditions.
- One panel and one pack deliver 4.
- One panel and two packs cost 7.
- Two panels and two packs cost 8.
A panel supplies four charging units and two packs store four; total cost is 3+2+2=7.
15. Design a plan meeting both budget and evening demand. Explain where the stored energy comes from.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets budget and four-unit evening target.
- Accounts for the source of charging energy.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.2 — Energy efficiency
Explain how efficient equipment provides the same useful service with less energy.
Worked examples
1. Equal reading light
Worked classroom example
Two fictional lamps provide the same desk light. A uses 10 energy units per lesson; B uses 6.
Question: How much does B save each lesson?
Answer: 4 units.
10−6=4. Equal useful light makes this an efficiency comparison; a dimmer lamp would require a different judgment.
2. Longer use
Worked classroom example
A fan changes from 3 units/hour for 2 hours to 2 units/hour for 4 hours.
Question: Did total use fall?
Answer: No: it rose from 6 to 8 units.
The new fan uses less each hour, but longer operation more than cancels that saving. Equipment efficiency and total consumption are related but different.
3. A controlled check
Worked classroom example
A class compares ten occupied lessons before and after an upgrade, with similar weather and activities.
Question: Why record occupancy and weather?
Answer: They can change energy demand independently of the upgrade.
A fair check reduces alternative explanations. The result is stronger when the lighting or cooling service is also comparable.
Formative quiz
Equal useful light
Equal useful light · evidence 1
Fictional tests: lamp A gives 500 light units using 10 energy units; B gives 500 using 6; C gives 200 using 4. Compare A and B for equal service.
1. Equal useful light: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- C provides less light than A and B.
- B uses 4 fewer units than A.
- A uses 4 fewer units than B.
- C provides the same light as A.
A and B give equal light; 10−6=4. C changes the useful service.
Use per hour
Use per hour · evidence 1
Classroom assumption: a device uses 3 energy units per hour for 4 hours. At a fixed rate, total use is rate times hours.
2. Use per hour: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is total use?
- What would 2 hours use at that rate?
Available labels: The device uses 7 units. | Two hours would use 6 units. | The device uses 12 units.
Multiply three by four, or three by two. The workbench’s units represent energy in this bookkeeping task.
An efficient room
An efficient room · evidence 1
Fictional room: demand is 100 energy units before an efficiency improvement and 80 after, with the same services. Electricity factors and shares stay fixed.
3. What changes when demand falls at fixed factors? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Total model emissions fall.
- The room must become darker.
- Total model emissions must rise.
- The electricity mix becomes fully renewable.
Less energy for equal service lowers modeled emissions when the factors and source shares remain fixed.
Check the baseline
Check the baseline · evidence 1
A fictional classroom records 22, 21, 23 and 22 units on four occupied days. After a change it records 16, 17, 16 and 17 on comparable occupied days.
4. What does this record show?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Every later day uses more units.
- Later comparable days use fewer units.
- The record proves all schools save equally.
- No further measurement can be useful.
The observed comparison favours a saving under the stated conditions, while service quality and other changes still matter.
Explain the overnight lights
Explain the overnight lights · evidence 1
A teacher replaces lamps with efficient models,
Explain the overnight lights · evidence 2
leaves them on overnight.
Explain the overnight lights · evidence 3
The classroom is empty after 5 p.m.
5. Explain one efficiency benefit and one additional action that prevents waste.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains equal light with lower energy.
- Proposes turning off unnecessary use without reducing needed service.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Calculate the useful saving
Calculate the useful saving · evidence 1
Fictional lamps supply equal light. Old: 5 units/hour for 4 hours. New: 3 units/hour for 4 hours.
6. Calculate the useful saving: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- How much energy did the old lamps use?
- How much do the new lamps use?
Available labels: Old lamps used 9 units. | New lamps use 12 units. | Old lamps used 20 units.
5×4=20 and 3×4=12. The saving is eight units for the same light and time.
7. Find the saving and explain why this is an efficiency comparison.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates eight units saved.
- Uses equal light and time as the fair comparison.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a good check
Choose a good check · evidence 1
After new fans, the school wants to test savings.
Choose a good check · evidence 2
Plan A compares occupied school days with holidays.
Choose a good check · evidence 3
Plan B compares occupied days with similar heat and fan hours, recording comfort too.
8. Choose a good check: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which check better isolates the change?
- What service outcome does it record?
Available labels: Plan A compares similar conditions. | It also checks classroom comfort. | Plan B compares similar conditions.
Comparable occupancy, weather and use reduce alternative explanations; comfort checks whether the service is maintained.
9. Justify Plan B with one feature that keeps demand conditions comparable and one check that useful service or comfort is maintained.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies comparable demand conditions.
- Identifies adequate comfort or equivalent service.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — A longer afternoon
A longer afternoon · evidence 1
A fictional device originally uses 4 units/hour for 3 hours. A replacement uses 2 units/hour, but now runs for 7 hours.
10. What happens to total energy?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- It falls from 12 to 7 units.
- It falls to 2 units in total.
- It rises from 12 to 14 units.
- It stays at 12 units exactly under the stated conditions.
4×3=12, while 2×7=14. A lower hourly rate does not guarantee a lower total.
11. How could the new device use less than the old 12-unit total? Give a running time, show the calculation and state the condition about needed service.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Chooses a duration below six hours.
- Shows a correct total and preserves needed service.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the percentage claim
Repair the percentage claim · evidence 1
Fictional audit: old use 40 units; new use 30 for equal service. Ben says, “Ten units were saved, so the reduction is 10%.”
12. Repair the percentage claim: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The denominator is the original 40 units.
- The reduction is 25% of old use.
- The reduction is 10% of old use.
- The reduction is 75% of old use.
Ten divided by forty is one-quarter, or 25%; units saved and percent saved are different.
13. Correct Ben’s percentage and explain the denominator.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives 25% using 10/40.
- Explains why old use is the baseline.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an energy walk
Design an energy walk · evidence 1
A fictional classroom may spend 6 tokens. A timer costs 2 and avoids 3 waste units/day; a lamp upgrade costs 4 and saves 5 units/day at equal light. The teacher must approve changes. Target: save at least 7 units/day.
14. Design an energy walk: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which available plan reaches the target?
- What approval is required?
Available labels: Both actions cost 6 and save 8. | The teacher must approve the changes. | Timer alone saves 7 units daily.
The two actions total six tokens and eight saved units; pupils observe and propose, while an adult approves implementation.
15. Propose a plan within budget and a way to check that useful lighting is preserved.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets the budget and at least seven-unit saving.
- Checks equal useful light during comparable use.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.3 — Sustainable transportation
Compare transport fairly per passenger and plan accessible lower-emission journeys.
Worked examples
1. One vehicle, more riders
Worked classroom example
Fictional equal-distance trip: a vehicle emits 24 units. It carries either 4 or 8 passengers.
Question: How do per-person emissions change?
Answer: They fall from 6 to 3 units.
Divide twenty-four by each occupancy. The vehicle total remains the same under this assumption, while it is shared among more riders.
2. Compare equal journeys
Worked classroom example
A toy car trip emits 12 units for 2 passengers; a bus trip emits 30 for 10 passengers over the same distance.
Question: Which has lower emissions per passenger?
Answer: The bus: 3 units versus the car’s 6.
A larger vehicle total can still mean a lower per-passenger total. Comparing only twelve with thirty misses occupancy.
3. Keep access
Worked classroom example
A fictional route redesign lowers emissions but removes the only accessible stop.
Question: What must the proposal improve?
Answer: Restore an accessible way for affected passengers to travel.
Climate benefit and access are both decision criteria. A plan that prevents some children reaching school does not meet the service goal.
Formative quiz
A shared trip
A shared trip · evidence 1
Fictional equal-distance journey: jeepney total 30 emission units with 10 passengers; car total 12 with 2 passengers.
1. A shared trip: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the jeepney total per passenger?
- What is the car total per passenger?
Available labels: Jeepney emissions are 30 per passenger. | Car emissions are 6 per passenger. | Jeepney emissions are 3 per passenger.
30÷10=3 and 12÷2=6. Both journeys cover the same distance.
Count avoided trips
Count avoided trips · evidence 1
Toy model: 10 identical trips produce 4 units each. Sharing removes 25% of those trip-equivalent units without reducing passenger access.
2. Count avoided trips: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the starting emission total?
- What is the modeled total after sharing?
Available labels: The reduced total is 30 units. | Starting emissions are 40 units. | Starting emissions are 14 units.
10×4=40; reducing forty by one-quarter leaves thirty. Fractional trip equivalents are only a simplified aggregate.
Choose a school route
Choose a school route · evidence 1
Fictional map: Route A is 400 m with an unprotected fast-road crossing; Route B is 500 m with supervised crossings and a usable ramp. A child needs the ramp.
3. Which route meets the stated access and safety conditions?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Route A meets both stated conditions.
- Both routes have identical access under the stated conditions.
- Route B meets both stated conditions.
- The shortest route needs no checks.
B is longer but provides the required ramp and supervised crossings.
Electricity still matters
Electricity still matters · evidence 1
Fictional electric vehicle consumes 20 electricity units for a route. Compare the same vehicle and route under different electricity mixes, using toy factors 2 fossil and 0.1 renewable.
4. What follows when renewable share increases at fixed demand? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Renewable share changes route distance.
- Charging emissions are always zero.
- A battery has no life-cycle impacts.
- Modeled charging emissions decrease.
Electricity sources affect charging emissions; a full life-cycle analysis also counts production and other stages.
An inclusive travel plan
An inclusive travel plan · evidence 1
A fictional school has pupils who can walk safely.
An inclusive travel plan · evidence 2
Other pupils live beyond walking distance.
An inclusive travel plan · evidence 3
Some pupils require accessible transport.
5. Suggest one lower-emission travel action and explain how the plan keeps access for a pupil who cannot walk.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a plausible lower-emission transport action.
- Preserves access for the stated pupil.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read both totals
Read both totals · evidence 1
Equal-distance classroom data: minibus emits 36 units for 12 passengers; two-person car emits 14. Assume equal life-cycle boundaries.
6. Read both totals: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The car has 14 units per passenger.
- The minibus has 12 units per passenger.
- The car has 7 units per passenger.
- The minibus has 3 units per passenger.
Divide total by occupancy for each equal-distance journey.
7. Explain why the larger vehicle total does not by itself mean a worse per-passenger result.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses occupancy to calculate or explain the minibus rate.
- Compares with the car’s seven-unit rate.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a route recommendation
Justify a route recommendation · evidence 1
Fictional choices: Route P uses 6 units per passenger and has an accessible stop
Justify a route recommendation · evidence 2
Q uses 4 and also has an accessible stop.
Justify a route recommendation · evidence 3
Both have supervised crossings and equal travel time.
8. True or false: P has the lower per-passenger emissions.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Q meets the same stated service and access conditions at four rather than six units.
9. Recommend P or Q using both the emissions figures and the access evidence.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the correct emissions comparison.
- Cites the retained access or safety conditions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — An almost empty return trip
An almost empty return trip · evidence 1
A fictional minibus emits 30 units per trip. Outbound it carries 10 pupils; returning it carries only 3. Distance and vehicle emissions are the same.
10. An almost empty return trip: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the return rate per passenger?
- What was the outbound rate?
Available labels: The outbound rate was 3 units per passenger. | The return rate is 10 units per passenger. | The return rate is 3 units per passenger.
30÷3=10, while 30÷10=3. Occupancy changes the comparison.
11. Explain how the lower return occupancy changes the result and propose a way to improve it without denying needed travel.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the occupancy effect correctly.
- Suggests feasible sharing or scheduling that preserves needed travel.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the zero claim
Repair the zero claim · evidence 1
Rafi says, “An electric ride has no exhaust, so making and powering it cause zero emissions.” The source states electricity and vehicle production can cause emissions.
12. Which part of Rafi’s claim needs correction? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Passengers do not affect any comparison.
- Every electricity source has the same emissions.
- No exhaust is confused with no life-cycle emissions.
- Electric rides must burn fuel at the tailpipe.
Tailpipe operation is one stage. The claim wrongly extends it to the whole life cycle.
13. Rewrite Rafi’s claim accurately and name two stages missing from it.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Preserves the limited no-exhaust claim without claiming zero total.
- Names electricity and vehicle or battery production.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an accessible shared service
Design an accessible shared service · evidence 1
Fictional school needs seats for 12 pupils, including one wheelchair user. Vehicle A: 6 seats, accessible, cost 4 tokens; B: 4 seats, not accessible, cost 2. Budget 8. At least one A is needed.
14. Which plan meets seats, access and budget?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Three B vehicles include a wheelchair place under the stated conditions.
- One A alone seats all 12 pupils.
- Two A vehicles give 12 seats for 8.
- Two B vehicles give 12 seats for 8.
Both listed valid combinations include access and enough seats without exceeding eight tokens.
15. Propose a valid combination and explain how it meets the seat and accessibility constraints within budget.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides enough seats within eight tokens.
- Includes at least one accessible A vehicle.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.4 — Forest protection
Explain how protecting existing forests keeps carbon stored while conserving connected habitats.
Worked examples
1. Stock and flow
Worked classroom example
Toy carbon store: start 90 units; growth adds 5; losses remove 2.
Question: What are ending stock and net gain?
Answer: Stock 93; net gain 3.
90+5−2=93. The stock includes carbon already present, so it should not all be reported as carbon newly removed this year.
2. A boundary problem
Worked classroom example
A fictional project prevents clearing 10 plots inside its boundary but clearing rises by 8 similar plots just outside.
Question: Why inspect the surrounding area?
Answer: Some damage may have moved outside the project.
The project boundary is not the whole climate system. Counting only protected plots can overstate the net benefit.
3. Keep a habitat link
Worked classroom example
Two woodland patches contain a species that uses tree cover to move. A wooded strip connects them; an open car park does not.
Question: Which connection meets the stated need?
Answer: The wooded strip.
The choice follows the species condition in the source. A real corridor would also require evidence about width, safety and habitat quality.
Formative quiz
Track a forest store
Track a forest store · evidence 1
Illustrative carbon units: protected forest starts 80, gains 5 and loses 2 in one step; capacity 150.
1. Track a forest store: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the ending carbon store?
- What is the net change this step?
Available labels: The net gain is 3 carbon units. | The store ends at 83 carbon units. | The store ends at 77 carbon units.
80+5−2=83; five minus two gives a net gain of three.
Inspect what protection does
Inspect what protection does · evidence 1
Fictional agreement keeps mature trees and soil intact.
Inspect what protection does · evidence 2
It also maintains a habitat used by local birds.
Inspect what protection does · evidence 3
It does not change emissions from distant vehicles.
2. Inspect what protection does: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Existing forest carbon remains stored.
- All distant vehicle emissions disappear.
- Every tree becomes newly planted.
- The birds retain their stated habitat.
Protection retains existing stores and habitat; the source makes no claim of cancelling all other emissions.
Compare clearing pressure
Compare clearing pressure · evidence 1
Classroom assumptions: 20 clearing units would emit 3 units each. An agreement avoids 50% of that clearing; other effects are not modeled.
3. Compare clearing pressure: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the modeled starting release?
- What release remains after the reduction?
Available labels: The remaining release is 30 units. | The starting release is 23 units. | The starting release is 60 units.
20×3=60 and half remains thirty. This is an illustrative avoided-release calculation.
A corridor on the map
A corridor on the map · evidence 1
Fictional animal needs continuous tree cover. West and east patches connect through strip T. Route R crosses open pavement without cover.
4. True or false: Route R connects continuous tree cover.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The source explicitly requires continuous tree cover, which T provides and R lacks.
Protection and local people
Protection and local people · evidence 1
A fictional forest provides food and materials under community rules.
Protection and local people · evidence 2
A proposal bans all access without speaking to residents.
5. Explain one reason to consult residents and one way to check the forest is still protected.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects consultation to knowledge, rights or livelihoods.
- Names a relevant forest-protection measure to monitor.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Read carbon accounts
Read carbon accounts · evidence 1
Fictional protected plot starts with 100 carbon units, adds 6 and loses 4. An unprotected comparison starts with 100, adds 2 and loses 20.
6. What is the protected ending store? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Protected stock ends at 98 units.
- Protected stock ends at 110 units.
- Protected stock ends at 102 units.
- Protected stock ends at 2 units.
100+6−4=102; 100+2−20=82. The difference is twenty units under the stated assumptions.
7. Explain why the protected plot holds more at the end, using both gains and losses.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Accounts correctly for gains and losses.
- Connects them to the higher protected ending stock.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a protection measure
Choose a protection measure · evidence 1
Fictional forest plan A fences a patch
Choose a protection measure · evidence 2
shifts clearing to a neighbouring patch.
Choose a protection measure · evidence 3
B agrees local use rules and monitors both patches.
Choose a protection measure · evidence 4
Both retain the same inside tree cover.
8. Choose a protection measure: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which plan better checks the wider outcome?
- What issue can A miss?
Available labels: A monitors both affected patches. | B monitors both affected patches. | Clearing may shift to the neighbouring patch.
B observes the relevant wider area; A’s narrow boundary can hide displaced clearing.
9. Justify B using the source and describe one limit of counting only inside trees.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses B’s wider monitoring.
- Explains displaced damage as a limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a fragmented forest
Transfer to a fragmented forest · evidence 1
A fictional species must travel under tree cover between two patches. The current strip is intact. A new road would cut it, but an approved covered crossing is proposed.
10. Transfer to a fragmented forest: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Assume any structure suits every species.
- Count only the road’s painted green areas.
- Maintain a usable connection across the road.
- Observe whether the species uses it safely.
The new barrier changes habitat access; a design needs evidence of safe actual use, not just appearance.
11. Adapt the protection plan to the new road and give one observation that would test it.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Addresses the specific break in tree-covered connectivity.
- Proposes relevant observation of actual safe use.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Find the stock mistake
Find the stock mistake · evidence 1
A report says, “Our protected forest contains 200 carbon units, so it removed 200 units this year.” The stock was 195 at the start; it gained 9 and lost 4.
12. What is the report’s mistake?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The net gain was 195 carbon units.
- It should call all 200 units fossil emissions.
- It should add the loss twice under the stated conditions.
- It confuses total stock with this year’s gain.
The ending stock is 200 but only 9−4=5 was added net during the stated year.
13. Rewrite the claim accurately with the ending stock and net annual change.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the ending stock as 200.
- Separates the five-unit net annual gain.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design protection with a check
Design protection with a check · evidence 1
A fictional agreement has 6 tokens. Habitat patrol costs 2; community consultation costs 2; monitoring both inside and neighbouring patches costs 2. Each can be funded once. The plan must include local voices and detect displaced clearing.
14. True or false: All three actions fit the 6-token budget.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The three activities cost six together, while consultation and two-area monitoring meet the explicit conditions.
15. Propose a plan that includes residents and detects moved clearing within budget. Explain the two required parts.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes meaningful consultation within budget.
- Monitors inside and outside to detect displaced clearing.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.5 — Reforestation
Plan suitable reforestation and distinguish planting from surviving, growing trees.
Worked examples
1. Survival count
Worked classroom example
Classroom planting: 50 seedlings; 40 alive after one season.
Question: What percentage survives?
Answer: 80%.
40÷50=0.8. The report describes survival at that check, not a guarantee of lifelong survival.
2. Care before scale
Worked classroom example
Fictional sites: A has 100 seedlings and no care; B has 60 with suitable soil and planned care. Survival is not yet measured.
Question: Can we claim A restores more forest?
Answer: Not yet.
Initial planting numbers alone do not tell how many survive or whether the habitat is suitable.
3. A carbon difference
Worked classroom example
Toy old forest holds 100 units; new planting holds 5 and gains 3 in a year.
Question: Does one year make the stores equal?
Answer: No: the planting ends at 8.
Starting stores and net additions are different. This arithmetic cannot establish real growth rates.
Formative quiz
Follow surviving seedlings
Follow surviving seedlings · evidence 1
Fictional cohort: 40 planted; counts after checks are 38, 34, 32 and 30.
1. Follow surviving seedlings: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What count belongs in the last survival report?
- What was the starting denominator?
Available labels: 40 seedlings remain alive. | 30 seedlings remain alive. | 40 seedlings were planted.
The final count is thirty; the same original group contained forty.
Choose the suitable site
Choose the suitable site · evidence 1
Classroom survey: A is former local woodland with permission and suitable soil
Choose the suitable site · evidence 2
B is intact natural grassland
Choose the suitable site · evidence 3
C lacks land permission
Choose the suitable site · evidence 4
D has unresolved contamination.
2. Which site meets the stated planting conditions? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Site D has no unresolved issue.
- Site B meets every condition.
- Site C has granted permission.
- Site A meets the conditions.
A fits the stated restoration context; natural grassland has its own value.
Track young carbon
Track young carbon · evidence 1
Toy planting starts with 5 carbon units, gains 4 and loses 1 in a step.
3. Track young carbon: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the ending stock?
- What is the net gain?
Available labels: The planting holds 8 units. | The net addition is 3 units. | The planting holds 10 units.
5+4−1=8; the new net addition is three.
Include care
Include care · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8 tokens. Seedling group costs 3; watering plan 2; survival checks 2. Permission is already secured.
4. What does the complete listed plan cost?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The complete plan costs 9 tokens.
- The complete plan costs 3 tokens.
- The complete plan costs 5 tokens under the stated conditions.
- The complete plan costs 7 tokens.
3+2+2=7, leaving one; the budget includes aftercare.
Explain a good indicator
Explain a good indicator · evidence 1
A fictional report counts only seedlings delivered.
Explain a good indicator · evidence 2
The project goal is a healthy restored woodland after several years.
5. Give one better outcome measure and explain why delivery count is insufficient.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names survival, growth or habitat recovery.
- Explains the gap between delivery and outcome.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply survival evidence
Apply survival evidence · evidence 1
Fictional groups: A planted 60, with 30 alive; B planted 40, with 32 alive.
6. Apply survival evidence: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which group has more surviving seedlings?
- Which has the higher survival fraction?
Available labels: B has 80% survival. | A has 60 survivors. | B has 32 survivors.
A has thirty survivors and 50%; B has thirty-two and 80%.
7. Compare the groups using survivor count and survival percentage.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Compares counts correctly.
- Compares percentages correctly.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify local suitability
Justify local suitability · evidence 1
Fictional experts identify species P as locally suitable and drought-tolerant at this site.
Justify local suitability · evidence 2
Species Q grows quickly elsewhere
Justify local suitability · evidence 3
has not been assessed here.
Justify local suitability · evidence 4
Both cost the same.
8. Which choice has the stronger site evidence? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Species P has local suitability evidence.
- Equal cost proves equal ecological value.
- Fast growth elsewhere proves local success.
- Species Q is proven suitable here.
P has relevant local evidence; speed elsewhere does not establish suitability.
9. Justify a cautious choice and name evidence needed before using Q.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses P’s local suitability evidence.
- Requests relevant local evidence for Q.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a drier season
Transfer to a drier season · evidence 1
Toy watering store: initial 20 water units; inflow falls from 10 to 3; scheduled outflow stays 8 per step. Capacity 40.
10. What is the store after one dry step?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The store gains 3 each step.
- The store falls to 15 units.
- The store rises to 25 units under the stated conditions.
- The store stays at 20 units.
20+3−8=15. Continued demand above inflow depletes the store.
11. Calculate the per-step water deficit, then adapt the care plan to lower inflow without assuming unlimited water.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the five-unit deficit.
- Proposes a feasible water-aware adjustment.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the instant-offset claim
Repair the instant-offset claim · evidence 1
Mara says, “Planting ten seedlings immediately stores as much carbon as ten mature trees.” The toy data give each seedling 1 stored unit and each mature tree 20.
12. Repair the instant-offset claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What do ten seedlings initially store?
- What do ten mature trees store in this example?
Available labels: The mature trees store 200 units. | The seedlings store 10 units. | The seedlings store 200 units.
Ten times one is ten; ten times twenty is two hundred. Future growth is not an immediate equal store.
13. Correct the claim and name one reason later storage is uncertain.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Corrects the unequal starting stocks.
- Names a relevant future uncertainty.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a cared-for planting
Design a cared-for planting · evidence 1
Fictional budget 10. Suitable seedlings cost 4, care costs 3, monitoring costs 2. Goal: establish suitable trees and check survival after one season.
14. Design a cared-for planting: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What does a complete plan cost?
- What outcome should monitoring count?
Available labels: The three actions cost 12 tokens. | The three actions cost 9 tokens. | Count surviving planted trees.
4+3+2=9; the goal needs survival evidence, not just delivery.
15. Design a plan within budget and specify the survival check.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes suitable planting and care within budget.
- Specifies a later survivor count against the original cohort.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.6 — Waste reduction
Compare prevention, reuse and waste treatment, and measure the waste actually avoided.
Worked examples
1. Waste per meal
Worked classroom example
Fictional canteen: 20 meals leave 4 kg; later 20 meals leave 3 kg.
Question: How much less is wasted per meal?
Answer: 0.05 kg less.
4÷20=0.20 and 3÷20=0.15 kg. Equal meal counts allow a clear comparison.
2. A prevention choice
Worked classroom example
One class buys 30 disposable cups daily. A refill plan removes the need for 20.
Question: How many disposable cups remain?
Answer: 10 per day.
Thirty minus twenty is ten. This counts items avoided, not a measured carbon saving.
3. A treatment limit
Worked classroom example
A toy landfill model uses 2 emission units per waste unit. Reducing 10 waste units to 6 changes the total.
Question: What happens?
Answer: Emissions fall from 20 to 12 units.
The eight-unit saving depends on the stated factor; real treatment conditions must be measured separately.
Formative quiz
Choose prevention
Choose prevention · evidence 1
Fictional class options: refill bottles.
Choose prevention · evidence 2
Repair lunchboxes.
Choose prevention · evidence 3
Buy new disposable cups.
Choose prevention · evidence 4
Discard usable containers.
1. Choose prevention: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Repair extends a lunchbox’s use.
- Discarding usable containers prevents waste.
- Buying more cups reduces item demand.
- Refilling avoids another disposable bottle.
Refill and repair reduce the need for replacements before disposal occurs.
Read the waste record
Read the waste record · evidence 1
Fictional canteen serves 20 meals each day. Leftovers are 4, 4, 3, 2 kg across four days.
2. True or false: Leftovers are 4 kg on the last day.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The last value is two, and all meal counts match. The record measures waste, not gas.
Model avoided waste
Model avoided waste · evidence 1
Toy factor: 3 emission units per organic-waste unit. Starting waste 10 units; prevention removes 40%.
3. What is the reduced model total?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The reduced total is 30 units.
- The reduced total is 40 units.
- The reduced total is 18 units.
- The reduced total is 12 units under the stated conditions.
Thirty reduced by forty percent leaves eighteen; twelve is the saving.
Follow materials
Follow materials · evidence 1
Fictional system: reusable tubs return for washing
Follow materials · evidence 2
paper goes to a verified recycler.
Follow materials · evidence 3
Mixed contaminated waste is not accepted by that recycler.
4. Follow materials: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Where do reusable tubs go?
- Where does clean accepted paper go?
Available labels: Tubs return for washing and reuse. | Tubs must always enter landfill. | Paper goes to the verified recycler.
The destination must match the material and actual collection system.
Explain a fair waste check
Explain a fair waste check · evidence 1
A fictional school has 100 meals before a project and 50 after. Total leftovers fall from 10 kg to 6 kg.
5. Did waste per meal improve? Use both rates to explain.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates both per-meal rates.
- Explains that the lower total hides a higher rate.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Use a prevention factor
Use a prevention factor · evidence 1
Toy source: 20 waste units, factor 2 emission units each. A plan prevents 5 waste units.
6. True or false: The new total is 30 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Fifteen remaining waste units times two gives thirty; five avoided times two gives ten.
7. Explain the difference between five waste units avoided and ten emission units avoided.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes waste quantity from modeled emissions.
- Uses the factor two correctly.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a useful project
Choose a useful project · evidence 1
Fictional options: A buys recycling bins without collection
Choose a useful project · evidence 2
B provides refill water and records disposable bottles avoided.
Choose a useful project · evidence 3
The target is fewer disposable bottles.
8. Choose a useful project: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which project has a direct path to the target?
- What weakens A’s claimed recycling result?
Available labels: No collection route is arranged. | B reduces demand for disposable bottles. | A proves all bottles are recycled.
Refill can prevent new bottles; bins alone do not establish completed recycling.
9. Justify B and give one observation needed to check its success.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects refill to avoided bottles.
- Specifies a comparable outcome count.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a bigger event
Transfer to a bigger event · evidence 1
Fictional normal day: 50 meals produce 5 kg leftovers. Event day: 100 meals produce 8 kg.
10. Transfer to a bigger event: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the normal-day rate?
- What is the event-day rate?
Available labels: Normal waste is 10 kg per meal. | Event waste is 0.08 kg per meal. | Normal waste is 0.10 kg per meal.
Divide each total by its meal count; the event total rises while the per-meal rate falls.
11. Explain how total leftovers can increase while waste per meal improves.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the different meal counts.
- Compares the two correct rates.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a methane claim
Repair a methane claim · evidence 1
A pupil says, “Every piece of rubbish produces the same methane.”
Repair a methane claim · evidence 2
Evidence: methane can form when organic waste decomposes without oxygen
Repair a methane claim · evidence 3
glass does not decompose that way.
12. Which correction matches the evidence? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- All rubbish has identical gas emissions.
- Oxygen conditions never affect decay.
- Glass and food decay in the same way.
- Methane depends on material and conditions.
Organic material and oxygen conditions matter; glass is not the same biological material.
13. Correct the claim by naming the relevant material and condition.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies organic waste rather than all rubbish.
- Identifies low/no-oxygen decomposition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a measured reduction
Design a measured reduction · evidence 1
Fictional budget 7. Portion survey costs 2; refill point costs 3; weekly waste weighing costs 2. Goal: reduce avoidable waste and measure it without reducing needed meals.
14. Which plan includes all listed actions within budget?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Bin colour measures avoided emissions.
- Fewer meals always prove less wastefulness.
- All three cost 9 tokens.
- All three cost 7 tokens.
The actions total seven; meal counts distinguish prevention from simply serving less.
15. Propose an action and a fair check while keeping enough food available.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes waste prevention without denying needed food.
- Measures waste relative to comparable meal counts.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.7 — Sustainable agriculture
Compare agricultural practices using emissions, soil, water and food production together.
Worked examples
1. Equal harvest
Worked classroom example
Fictional plots both produce 10 baskets. A uses 40 input units; B uses 30.
Question: How much less input does B use?
Answer: 10 units, or 25% of A.
Equal harvest makes this a useful input comparison. The data do not establish actual fertiliser recommendations.
2. Per-basket emissions
Worked classroom example
Toy farm A emits 60 units for 20 baskets; B emits 40 for 10.
Question: Which has lower emissions per basket?
Answer: A: 3 versus B: 4.
Divide emissions by harvest. A higher farm total can accompany a lower rate per unit of food.
3. Soil bookkeeping
Worked classroom example
A toy soil store has 50 carbon units, gains 4 and loses 6.
Question: What happens?
Answer: It falls to 48.
Management must consider both additions and losses; adding plant matter does not guarantee a positive net change.
Formative quiz
Inputs and crop output
Inputs and crop output · evidence 1
Fictional equal-area trials: A uses 40 input units and yields 20 baskets; B uses 30 and also yields 20.
1. Inputs and crop output: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- How do the inputs compare?
- How do the harvests compare?
Available labels: Both yield 20 baskets. | A uses 10 fewer input units. | B uses 10 fewer input units.
The fixed trial holds stated harvest equal while B uses fewer inputs.
Track soil carbon
Track soil carbon · evidence 1
Toy soil stock starts at 50 carbon units; additions 5; losses 3.
2. Track soil carbon: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the ending soil stock?
- What is the net addition?
Available labels: The soil holds 52 units. | The net gain is 2 units. | The soil holds 58 units.
50+5−3=52; additions minus losses equal two.
Identify the gas pathway
Identify the gas pathway · evidence 1
Source cards: livestock digestion can produce methane
Identify the gas pathway · evidence 2
fertiliser-related soil processes can produce nitrous oxide.
Identify the gas pathway · evidence 3
These pathways vary with management and conditions.
3. Identify the gas pathway: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Every farm releases only carbon dioxide.
- Nitrogen management can affect nitrous oxide.
- Livestock digestion can produce methane.
- All fertiliser becomes methane immediately.
The two pathways involve different processes and gases; neither describes every emission from farming.
Model a management change
Model a management change · evidence 1
Toy farm activity 20 units at factor 3; a management option reduces modeled emissions by 20%, with output held equal.
4. What is the reduced model total?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The total is 48 emission units.
- The total is 12 emission units under the stated conditions.
- The total is 60 emission units.
- The total is 80 emission units.
20×3=60; 80% remains forty-eight, under the stated equal-output assumption.
Explain more than one result
Explain more than one result · evidence 1
A fictional farm trial lowers model emissions
Explain more than one result · evidence 2
uses much more scarce water.
Explain more than one result · evidence 3
Harvest is unchanged.
5. Explain the climate benefit and one additional question needed before scaling the practice.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the equal-harvest emissions benefit.
- Asks about the scarce-water consequence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Use a fair harvest comparison
Use a fair harvest comparison · evidence 1
Fictional A: 60 emission units, 20 baskets. B: 40 units, 10 baskets. Count the same production stages.
6. Use a fair harvest comparison: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is A’s per-basket rate?
- What is B’s per-basket rate?
Available labels: B produces 4 units per basket. | A produces 3 units per basket. | A produces 20 units per basket.
60÷20=3 and 40÷10=4; the lower farm total does not settle the rate comparison.
7. Which has the lower rate and why should total output also be reported?
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly compares per-basket emissions.
- Explains the relevance of food output.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Choose a locally tested practice
Choose a locally tested practice · evidence 1
Fictional A reduces model emissions 20% and preserves harvest in a local trial.
Choose a locally tested practice · evidence 2
B claims 50% reduction elsewhere,
Choose a locally tested practice · evidence 3
local soil and harvest effects are unknown.
8. Choose a locally tested practice: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which has stronger evidence for this farm now?
- What should happen before broad use of B?
Available labels: B is proven best for every soil. | Test B under local farming conditions. | A has relevant local trial evidence.
A’s evidence fits this setting; B may be promising but needs relevant testing.
9. Justify cautious use of A and describe a comparable test of B that records emissions and harvest, with water or soil effects where relevant.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses A’s locally observed benefits.
- Proposes a relevant multi-outcome comparison for B.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to less water
Transfer to less water · evidence 1
Toy irrigation store starts 30 units. Earlier inflow was 12, now 5; withdrawals stay 10 per step.
10. What happens after one changed step?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The store stays at 30 units.
- Inflow exceeds outflow by 5 under the stated conditions.
- The store rises to 35 units.
- The store falls to 25 units.
30+5−10=25, so the existing plan cannot continue indefinitely unchanged.
11. Adapt the plan to the changed water supply and say what food outcome must be checked.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Responds to the lower supply without assuming unlimited water.
- Checks crop output or health as a consequence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Find the one-gas mistake
Find the one-gas mistake · evidence 1
A report says, “Reducing methane proves our farm has zero greenhouse gases.”
Find the one-gas mistake · evidence 2
Source: the farm also uses fuel and nitrogen fertiliser
Find the one-gas mistake · evidence 3
those can involve other gases.
12. Find the one-gas mistake: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What does the report leave out?
- Which fuel-related gas should be counted?
Available labels: Other greenhouse-gas sources remain relevant. | Fuel combustion can release carbon dioxide. | Methane reduction removes every other gas.
One gas is only part of an inventory; fuel and fertiliser pathways still need examination.
13. Correct the claim using two distinct emission pathways.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects the inference from one gas to zero total.
- Names two relevant distinct pathways or gases.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a small farm comparison
Design a small farm comparison · evidence 1
Fictional trial budget 8. Soil advice costs 2; two comparable test plots 3; measuring harvest and water 2. Goal: test a practice without assuming food output is preserved.
14. Design a small farm comparison: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- All three actions cost 10 tokens.
- Record harvest as well as water.
- All three actions cost 7 tokens.
- Water records alone prove equal harvest.
A seven-token plan includes local advice, a comparison and food/water outcomes.
15. Propose a trial within budget that compares the practice and checks food production.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a meaningful comparable trial within budget.
- Measures food output rather than assuming it stays equal.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- US EPA: Global greenhouse-gas overview
- US EPA: Methane emissions
- NOAA: Carbon cycle
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.8 — Sustainable consumption
Use need, durability and life-cycle evidence to make reasoned consumption choices.
Worked examples
1. Useful life
Worked classroom example
Toy bag A has 30 production units and lasts 3 years; B has 24 and lasts 2. Equal service is assumed.
Question: Which has lower production units per year?
Answer: A: 10 versus B: 12.
Divide by useful life. Actual durability must be checked; a promised long life is not enough.
2. Reuse threshold
Worked classroom example
Toy disposable costs 2 emission units per use; reusable costs 10 to make plus 0.5 per wash/use.
Question: At 10 uses, which is lower?
Answer: Reusable: 15 versus disposable: 20.
Count manufacture and repeated washing. The conclusion depends on ten actual uses and the stated factors.
3. A narrow claim
Worked classroom example
A label says packaging emissions fell from 10 to 8 units; other product stages are not given.
Question: What conclusion is justified?
Answer: Packaging emissions fell by 2 units.
A change in one stage does not establish the total product’s climate impact.
Formative quiz
Repair or replace
Repair or replace · evidence 1
Fictional bag still meets the pupil’s needs. Repair uses 3 material units; replacement uses 15 and provides the same remaining service.
1. Repair or replace: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which uses fewer stated material units?
- What condition allows this comparison?
Available labels: Replacement uses 12 fewer units. | The remaining useful service is equal. | Repair uses 12 fewer units.
Fifteen minus three is twelve; equal service is the key stated condition.
Count repeated purchases
Count repeated purchases · evidence 1
Toy item demand: 20 uses; each disposable use has factor 2. A plan avoids 50% of new disposable uses through existing shared items.
2. Count repeated purchases: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the starting model total?
- What is the reduced total?
Available labels: The reduced total is 20 units. | The starting total is 40 units. | The starting total is 22 units.
Twenty times two is forty; half remains twenty under the stated sharing assumption.
Choose the supported claim
Choose the supported claim · evidence 1
A fictional label provides verified evidence only for 20% less packaging material
Choose the supported claim · evidence 2
energy, product lifetime and transport are unmeasured.
3. Which claim matches the evidence? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The package uses 20% less material.
- All transport emissions are removed.
- The whole product has zero emissions.
- Its lifetime is 20% longer.
The scope is packaging material, not total climate impact or product lifetime.
Watch actual reuse
Watch actual reuse · evidence 1
A fictional class tracks a reusable container’s uses: 2, 4, 6, 8 and 10 cumulative uses across five weeks.
4. True or false: The container has been used 10 times.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The data count cumulative uses; adding those cumulative totals would double-count.
Explain an affordable choice
Explain an affordable choice · evidence 1
A fictional pupil can repair a needed bag for 2 tokens or buy a replacement for 8.
Explain an affordable choice · evidence 2
Repair keeps it usable for the required school term.
5. Explain why repair is a reasonable option here using both need and resources.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects repair to the stated service need.
- Identifies the lower resource or cost demand.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a per-use comparison
Apply a per-use comparison · evidence 1
Toy alternatives give equal service: A requires 24 production units for 12 uses; B requires 15 for 5 uses. Cleaning is equal and omitted.
6. Apply a per-use comparison: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A uses 12 units per use.
- B uses 3 units per use.
- A uses 2 units per use.
- B uses 5 units per use.
24÷12=2 and 15÷5=3. Useful lifetime changes the comparison.
7. Explain why A can have a larger production total yet a lower rate.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Accounts for the different useful lifetimes.
- Uses the correct per-use rates.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a credible claim
Justify a credible claim · evidence 1
Fictional supplier P reports all stated life-cycle stages for equal service with methods
Justify a credible claim · evidence 2
Q says “perfectly green” without figures or scope.
8. Which claim is easier to evaluate? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- P’s numbers must cover every future case.
- A green colour is an independent check.
- Q’s broad phrase proves no impact.
- P provides a defined comparison and methods.
Defined methods and scope make a claim checkable; slogans do not.
9. Justify looking more closely at P and name one check you would still make.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies P’s checkable evidence.
- Requests a relevant validity check rather than blind acceptance.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to fewer uses
Transfer to fewer uses · evidence 1
Toy reusable: 10 units to make plus 1 per use. Disposable: 3 per use. The trip now needs only 2 uses instead of 10.
10. Transfer to fewer uses: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is reusable total for two uses?
- What is disposable total for two uses?
Available labels: Reusable total is 2 units. | Disposable total is 6 units. | Reusable total is 12 units.
10+2×1=12, while 2×3=6. The shorter use changes this toy comparison.
11. Explain why the preferred option can change when actual uses fall.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the fixed production cost across fewer uses.
- Uses the correct two-use totals.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a percentage extension
Repair a percentage extension · evidence 1
A poster says, “Packaging emissions fell 50%, so total product emissions fell 50%.” Toy baseline: packaging 4 units, other stages 16; new packaging 2, other stages still 16.
12. Repair a percentage extension: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the true total reduction?
- What are the total before and after?
Available labels: Total emissions fall by 50%. | The totals are 20 and 18 units. | Total emissions fall by 10%.
The saving is two out of twenty, or 10%, although packaging alone halves.
13. Correct the poster with the total calculation and explain the scope mistake.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the ten-percent total reduction.
- Explains the part-versus-whole error.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a shared-material plan
Design a shared-material plan · evidence 1
Fictional class needs 12 ruler-uses in one lesson. Six existing rulers can each serve two pupils in sequence. Storage costs 2 tokens, repair 3; budget 5. New purchases are unnecessary if sharing works.
14. True or false: Six rulers used twice meet only 6 uses.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Six times two equals twelve, while the two care actions fit the budget.
15. Design a plan that meets all ruler-uses without new purchases and explain how sharing will work.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets twelve uses with existing rulers within budget.
- Specifies a feasible sharing/turn system.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.9 — Industrial changes
Compare changes in manufacturing while accounting for output, energy and material use.
Worked examples
1. Rate and total
Worked classroom example
Toy factory: before 10 items at 5 units each; after 20 at 3 each.
Question: Did total emissions fall?
Answer: No: 50 rose to 60.
The rate improved but production doubled. Report both the rate and the total.
2. Material yield
Worked classroom example
Classroom process uses 80 material units and produces 60 useful units.
Question: What is useful yield?
Answer: 75%.
60÷80 is three-quarters. The other twenty units need an identified fate rather than being ignored.
3. An incomplete boundary
Worked classroom example
A toy factory reduces electricity emissions from 20 to 10; process emissions remain 30.
Question: What is the total saving?
Answer: 10 out of 50 units, or 20%.
The electricity part halves, but the whole total falls from fifty to forty.
Formative quiz
Account for production
Account for production · evidence 1
Toy workshop: 20 products at 3 emission units each. A process change reduces the rate 20%, with useful output unchanged.
1. Account for production: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the original total?
- What is the changed total?
Available labels: Original emissions are 23 units. | Changed emissions are 48 units. | Original emissions are 60 units.
Twenty times three is sixty; reducing that by one-fifth leaves forty-eight.
Read all sources
Read all sources · evidence 1
Fictional factory emits from purchased electricity, fuel for heating and a chemical reaction.
Read all sources · evidence 2
A new electricity supply changes only the first source.
2. Read all sources: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Changing electricity removes every source.
- All chemical reactions have zero emissions.
- Heating-fuel emissions still count.
- Chemical-process emissions still count.
The intervention affects one source; the other listed sources remain.
Trace material
Trace material · evidence 1
Toy material store starts with 10 units, receives 50 and sends 40 into usable products. No other outflow occurs in this step.
3. Trace material: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What material remains in the store?
- How much became usable product?
Available labels: The store ends with 20 units. | Products used 40 units. | The store ends with 100 units.
10+50−40=20. Remaining stock is not automatically waste.
Check quality
Check quality · evidence 1
Fictional trial A makes 100 usable tiles with 200 energy units; B makes 100 tiles but only 50 usable with 150 energy units.
4. Which trial uses less energy per usable tile? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- B uses 1 unit per usable tile.
- B’s lower total proves better efficiency.
- Quality does not affect useful output.
- A uses 2 units per usable tile.
200÷100=2; 150÷50=3. Defects change the denominator.
Explain a process trial
Explain a process trial · evidence 1
A proposed fictional process saves electricity
Explain a process trial · evidence 2
needs more raw material for the same number of usable parts.
5. Name the benefit and one further impact that must be measured.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies reduced electricity for equal output.
- Includes the extra material’s environmental effect.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply output accounting
Apply output accounting · evidence 1
Toy factory makes 30 useful parts at factor 4; upgraded process lowers factor to 3 for the same output.
6. How much does total emissions fall? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The total falls by 1 unit.
- The total falls by 30 units.
- The total falls by 120 units.
- The total falls by 90 units.
Old total 120, new ninety, saving thirty.
7. Explain the saving using output and the change per part.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses one unit saved per part.
- Multiplies by thirty equal useful parts.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a repairable design
Justify a repairable design · evidence 1
Fictional tool A can be repaired with a 2-unit replacement part
Justify a repairable design · evidence 2
B requires a 15-unit complete replacement for the same fault.
Justify a repairable design · evidence 3
Both then provide equal service.
8. Justify a repairable design: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which design uses fewer stated replacement materials?
- What service condition is held equal?
Available labels: A uses a 2-unit replacement part. | B uses fewer replacement materials. | Both tools provide the same restored service.
A avoids replacing the entire tool under equal-service assumptions.
9. Justify A and state one practical condition needed for repair to work.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the two-versus-fifteen comparison.
- Names a feasible repair condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to higher demand
Transfer to higher demand · evidence 1
Toy original factory: 20 products at 5 units each. New factory: 40 products at 3 units each.
10. Transfer to higher demand: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the new total?
- What was the original total?
Available labels: The new total is 60 units. | The new total is 120 units. | The original total was 100 units.
40×3=120 exceeds 20×5=100 despite a better rate.
11. Explain why a better per-item rate did not lower the total and name one quantity to reconsider.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the output-versus-rate effect.
- Identifies output/demand or further rate reduction.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the electricity claim
Repair the electricity claim · evidence 1
A report claims a 50% factory-wide saving because electricity emissions fell from 20 to 10. Unchanged heating and process emissions total 80.
12. True or false: The factory total falls by 50%.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The saving is ten out of one hundred, not half of the whole inventory.
13. Correct the report using the full boundary.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the full before/after totals.
- Distinguishes the electricity percentage from the whole percentage.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a useful trial
Design a useful trial · evidence 1
Fictional trial budget 6. Energy meter 2; usable-output count 1; material-waste record 1; worker briefing 2. Goal: test energy improvement without hiding defects.
14. Which complete plan fits the budget?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- All four activities cost 6 tokens.
- All four activities cost 8 tokens.
- An energy meter counts defects automatically.
- A briefing replaces output measurements under the stated conditions.
The listed costs sum to six; usable output makes the efficiency denominator meaningful.
15. Propose a trial within budget and explain how it checks energy for useful output.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes energy and usable-output measurement within budget.
- Uses a comparable per-usable-part evaluation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.10 — Emission reduction
Calculate clear emission reductions and distinguish lower rates from lower totals.
Worked examples
1. Percent saving
Worked classroom example
Toy baseline 120 units; later 90 over the same activity and time.
Question: What is the reduction?
Answer: 30 units, or 25%.
120−90=30; 30÷120 is one-quarter.
2. Two sources
Worked classroom example
Classroom emissions: electricity falls by 12 units; deliveries rise by 4.
Question: What is the combined change?
Answer: An 8-unit reduction.
Count both within the stated boundary rather than reporting only the beneficial change.
3. Sequential actions
Worked classroom example
A toy total of 100 is reduced 20%, then the remaining 80 is reduced 25%.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 60 units.
The second saving is twenty-five percent of eighty, or twenty; the total saving is forty, not forty-five.
Formative quiz
Read a baseline
Read a baseline · evidence 1
Fictional same-period inventory: baseline 80 emission units; new total 60.
1. True or false: The reduction is 20 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
80−60=20, and 20÷80=25%.
Separate an action and outcome
Separate an action and outcome · evidence 1
Fictional plan targets 30% less fuel use.
Separate an action and outcome · evidence 2
No after-data exist.
Separate an action and outcome · evidence 3
Staff have installed scheduling software.
2. Separate an action and outcome: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What has been completed?
- What remains unverified?
Available labels: The targeted fuel saving is unmeasured. | The 30% target has been achieved. | The scheduling software was installed.
An installed action is not yet evidence of its intended effect.
Apply an assumed reduction
Apply an assumed reduction · evidence 1
Toy activity 50 units at emission factor 2; a plan reduces this total 30%.
3. What remains after the change?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 70 emission units remain.
- 100 emission units remain.
- 30 emission units remain under the stated conditions.
- 50 emission units remain.
The baseline is one hundred; seventy percent remains seventy.
Inspect the trend
Inspect the trend · evidence 1
Fictional comparable monthly totals: 100, 95, 98, 90, 85. The target is 80.
4. What is the latest measured total? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The latest total is 80 units.
- The latest total is 85 units.
- A target proves a measured outcome.
- Every month falls without variation.
The last value is eighty-five, still five above target.
Explain a boundary
Explain a boundary · evidence 1
A fictional school reduces electricity emissions by 10 units
Explain a boundary · evidence 2
adds 4 delivery units in the same period.
5. Find the combined saving and explain why both changes belong in this comparison.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates six units net reduction.
- Includes the added delivery source rather than ignoring it.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply the target
Apply the target · evidence 1
Fictional baseline 200 units. A 15% reduction is proposed for the same services and period.
6. True or false: 170 emission units would remain.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
15% of two hundred is thirty, leaving one hundred seventy.
7. Explain the difference between the proposed reduction and the remaining total.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the thirty-unit reduction.
- Separates it from the one-hundred-seventy total.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a credible report
Justify a credible report · evidence 1
Report A gives a 20% saving with baseline, same service, dates and all listed sources.
Justify a credible report · evidence 2
B gives a larger percentage without defining any comparison.
8. Justify a credible report: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A’s dates make measurement unnecessary.
- B is stronger because the number is larger.
- B needs comparable data and scope.
- A defines its baseline and boundary.
Checkability depends on evidence and scope, not just the size of a claim.
9. Justify using A for a decision while naming one validation you would still perform.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses A’s defined evidence as the reason.
- Names a relevant validation step.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to growing demand
Transfer to growing demand · evidence 1
Fictional rate falls from 5 to 4 units per delivery; deliveries rise from 20 to 30.
10. What happens to the total?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- It stays at 100 units under the stated conditions.
- It falls from 120 to 100 units.
- It rises from 100 to 120 units.
- It falls from 100 to 80 units.
Five times twenty is one hundred; four times thirty is one hundred twenty.
11. Explain why the lower rate did not achieve an absolute reduction.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Accounts for the increase in activity.
- Uses the correct totals or twenty-unit rise.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair double counting
Repair double counting · evidence 1
Toy total 100. Action A reduces it 20%, leaving 80. Action B reduces the remaining 80 by 25%. Lina adds 20%+25% and reports 45% total saving.
12. Repair double counting: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the correct total saving?
- What is B’s absolute saving?
Available labels: B saves 20 of the remaining units. | The total saving is 40%. | The total saving is 45%.
B’s quarter of eighty is twenty; final sixty means forty saved from one hundred.
13. Correct Lina’s method and explain why the percentages cannot simply be added.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the forty-percent combined reduction.
- Explains the changing baseline.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an honest target plan
Design an honest target plan · evidence 1
Fictional baseline 100. Action A saves 20 units and costs 3; B saves 15 and costs 2; C saves 10 and costs 2. Savings are independent in this classroom case. Budget 5, target at least 30.
14. Design an honest target plan: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which valid combination saves 35 units?
- Which valid combination saves exactly 30 units?
Available labels: A and C save 30 for 5 tokens. | B and C save 30 for 4 tokens. | A and B save 35 for 5 tokens.
A+B and A+C both fit; B+C saves twenty-five, below target.
15. Propose a valid combination and explain how you will distinguish a target from an achieved reduction.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets budget and at least thirty-unit target.
- Requires comparable after-measurement before claiming achievement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.11 — Carbon capture
Distinguish capturing emissions at a source from removing carbon dioxide from air.
Worked examples
1. Net source release
Worked classroom example
Toy factory would emit 20 units; capture intercepts 12; extra operation emits 3.
Question: What reaches the air?
Answer: 11 units.
20−12+3=11. The reduction is nine, not twelve, after operating emissions.
2. Source or atmosphere
Worked classroom example
Device A captures a factory stream. Device B removes CO2 from ambient air and stores it durably.
Question: Which is atmospheric removal?
Answer: B.
A prevents some new source emissions; B begins with carbon already in the air. Their accounting should not be conflated.
3. Storage loss
Worked classroom example
Toy captured amount 10 units; 2 later leak back to air. Ignore other effects.
Question: How much remains stored?
Answer: 8 units.
Subtract the returned carbon. Captured and durably retained amounts are different measures.
Formative quiz
Name the starting point
Name the starting point · evidence 1
Fictional system A captures factory CO2 before release
Name the starting point · evidence 2
B removes CO2 already in air and stores it.
Name the starting point · evidence 3
Both use energy.
1. True or false: A automatically removes old atmospheric CO2.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The origin of captured carbon distinguishes source capture from atmospheric removal.
Count operating emissions
Count operating emissions · evidence 1
Toy source would emit 20 units. Capture intercepts 12; added operation emits 3.
2. What is the resulting release?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The resulting release is 35 units.
- The resulting release is 11 units.
- The resulting release is 5 units.
- The resulting release is 8 units under the stated conditions.
20−12+3=11; twenty minus eleven is nine.
Track retained carbon
Track retained carbon · evidence 1
Toy store starts 30 units; capture adds 8; leakage removes 2. Capacity 60.
3. Track retained carbon: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the ending store?
- What is the net increase?
Available labels: The ending store is 36 units. | The net increase is 6 units. | The ending store is 40 units.
30+8−2=36. Capturing eight does not mean eight additional units remain.
Read the monitoring plan
Read the monitoring plan · evidence 1
Fictional chain: collection meter measures captured amount
Read the monitoring plan · evidence 2
storage checks test retention
Read the monitoring plan · evidence 3
energy records measure extra operating emissions.
4. Read the monitoring plan: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which record measures captured quantity?
- Which record tests whether carbon stays stored?
Available labels: Storage checks examine retention. | Energy records prove storage is permanent. | The collection meter measures capture.
Different records answer different parts of the carbon-accounting question.
Explain a limited claim
Explain a limited claim · evidence 1
A fictional advert says “100 units captured,”
Explain a limited claim · evidence 2
gives no energy use or storage-retention information.
5. Name one operating or life-cycle emissions measurement and one storage-retention measurement needed to judge the net climate benefit.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies operating or life-cycle emissions.
- Identifies retention or leakage evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply full accounting
Apply full accounting · evidence 1
Toy source baseline 50 units. Capture removes 30 from the stream; operation adds 5; storage leakage returns 2.
6. Apply full accounting: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the final release?
- What is the baseline reduction?
Available labels: The final release is 20 units. | The reduction is 23 units. | The final release is 27 units.
50−30+5+2=27; the avoided amount is twenty-three.
7. Explain why thirty captured units do not equal thirty avoided units.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Counts both added operation and leakage.
- Gives or explains the twenty-three-unit net benefit.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a better-evidenced plan
Justify a better-evidenced plan · evidence 1
Fictional A reports high capture
Justify a better-evidenced plan · evidence 2
no storage check.
Justify a better-evidenced plan · evidence 3
B reports a lower captured amount with verified energy use and retention.
Justify a better-evidenced plan · evidence 4
Exact net totals are not yet supplied.
8. What conclusion is justified now?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Capture alone proves permanent removal.
- B must have the greater net benefit.
- A must have the greater net benefit.
- B has more complete accounting evidence.
Complete evidence is better for evaluation, but without net totals the benefit ranking remains unresolved.
9. Explain why neither capture number alone settles the choice and identify the needed comparison.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Rejects ranking by captured amount alone.
- Requires comparable net accounting and retention.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a dirtier energy supply
Transfer to a dirtier energy supply · evidence 1
Toy capture intercepts 12 of 20 source units. Extra energy emissions rise from 2 to 7 with a changed supply.
10. True or false: The new release is 15 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
20−12+7=15 versus 20−12+2=10. The energy supply changes net performance.
11. Explain the changed net benefit and suggest one relevant improvement to investigate.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Correctly explains the five-unit loss of benefit.
- Proposes a relevant operating-energy improvement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a removal claim
Repair a removal claim · evidence 1
A factory intercepts 8 of 10 new emission units.
Repair a removal claim · evidence 2
Leo says, “It removes 8 units that were already in the atmosphere.”
Repair a removal claim · evidence 3
The source is the factory pipe.
12. What is wrong with the claim? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The capture origin does not matter.
- All ten source units are captured.
- Eight old air units are definitely removed.
- It confuses source capture with air removal.
The carbon is intercepted before entering air; the source statement does not describe removing previously atmospheric carbon.
13. Rewrite the claim accurately and state the remaining source release.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes source capture from atmospheric removal.
- States the two-unit remaining source release.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a credible evaluation
Design a credible evaluation · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8. Capture meter costs 2; energy audit 2; retention monitoring 3. Goal: judge net climate benefit and storage performance.
14. Design a credible evaluation: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which complete evaluation fits?
- Which check addresses later leakage?
Available labels: All three checks cost 7 tokens. | Retention monitoring checks stored carbon. | All three checks cost 9 tokens.
The seven-token plan measures quantity, added emissions and retention separately.
15. Propose an evaluation within budget and explain how it avoids overstating benefit.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes capture, energy and retention checks within budget.
- Uses net accounting rather than capture alone.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC: Carbon dioxide removal and other cross-sector approaches
- IPCC: Energy systems
- IPCC: Synthesis report
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL5.12 — Government climate policies
Evaluate climate policies by their stated goals, evidence, costs and effects on people.
Worked examples
1. Goal or result
Worked classroom example
A fictional policy aims to cut school energy 20%, but comparable records show 10%.
Question: What should the report say?
Answer: The target was 20%; measured reduction was 10%.
A goal and an achieved result are different statements. Both can be reported clearly.
2. A cost trade-off
Worked classroom example
Toy budget 10 tokens: programme A costs 6 and reaches 40 households; B costs 4 and reaches 20 different households.
Question: Can both be funded?
Answer: Yes, for 10 tokens and 60 households.
Add costs and non-overlapping beneficiaries. Real programmes may overlap, so that assumption matters.
3. Mechanism and access
Worked classroom example
A fictional city offers shared rides but no affordable fares.
Question: Why might the policy miss its target?
Answer: People may be unable to use the new option.
Availability on paper is different from practical access. Monitoring should include who actually benefits.
Formative quiz
Identify what happened
Identify what happened · evidence 1
Fictional policy: target 20% less energy
Identify what happened · evidence 2
efficient equipment installed
Identify what happened · evidence 3
after-use has not yet been measured.
1. True or false: The 20% saving is already measured.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Implementation is observed, but the outcome still needs comparable measurements.
Connect instrument and mechanism
Connect instrument and mechanism · evidence 1
Fictional policy A funds safe shared-ride stops.
Connect instrument and mechanism · evidence 2
B sets minimum appliance-efficiency performance.
Connect instrument and mechanism · evidence 3
These are different mechanisms.
2. Connect instrument and mechanism: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What does A directly improve?
- What does B directly set?
Available labels: A changes appliance standards directly. | B sets an appliance performance requirement. | A improves access to shared rides.
Each action should be linked to its actual mechanism, not just called climate-friendly.
Use a stated model
Use a stated model · evidence 1
Fictional policy reaches 100 activity units at factor 2, with an assumed 15% reduction if fully implemented.
3. Use a stated model: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the modeled remaining total?
- What must be checked in practice?
Available labels: The model leaves 170 units. | The model leaves 15 units. | Actual implementation and outcomes need measurement.
Two hundred reduced by fifteen percent leaves one hundred seventy; this is an assumption-based illustration.
Account for access
Account for access · evidence 1
Fictional programme reaches 30 town households and 10 remote households. A new outreach option could reach 10 additional remote households.
4. Account for access: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which group receives the added outreach?
- What is the new total reached?
Available labels: Ten additional remote households are reached. | Ten additional town households are reached. | The total becomes 50 households.
Thirty plus ten plus ten equals fifty; the added group is explicitly remote.
Explain a fair policy question
Explain a fair policy question · evidence 1
A fictional transport rule aims to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions.
Explain a fair policy question · evidence 2
It raises travel costs for families who have no alternative service.
5. Identify one climate aim and one fairness issue to investigate.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the relevant emissions objective.
- Addresses access or cost burdens on the affected families.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a defined target
Apply a defined target · evidence 1
Fictional policy baseline 80 units; measured comparable total 64. Target was 20% reduction.
6. True or false: The measured reduction is 20%.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
80−64=16 and 16÷80=20%; here the measurement, not the target alone, supports success.
7. Explain whether the target was met using both the absolute and percentage change.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates sixteen units saved.
- Calculates twenty percent and compares it with target.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a policy comparison
Justify a policy comparison · evidence 1
Fictional A lowers modeled emissions by 20 units and keeps affordable access.
Justify a policy comparison · evidence 2
B lowers them by 22
Justify a policy comparison · evidence 3
removes the only affordable route for 15 families.
Justify a policy comparison · evidence 4
Both cost the same.
8. Justify a policy comparison: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which statement about A is supported?
- What must be addressed before adopting B unchanged?
Available labels: A has no modeled emissions benefit. | B excludes 15 families from affordable travel. | A preserves the stated affordable access.
The small difference in model benefit does not erase the stated access consequence.
9. Recommend a choice or revision using emissions and access, allowing defensible alternatives.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the emissions evidence accurately.
- Addresses the access burden with a reasoned choice or revision.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to an unserved area
Transfer to an unserved area · evidence 1
Fictional city policy assumes a frequent bus service.
Transfer to an unserved area · evidence 2
A remote barangay has no bus
Transfer to an unserved area · evidence 3
has a school-managed shared van and different distances.
10. Transfer to an unserved area: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which adaptation follows the changed setting?
- What stated constraint makes the adaptation necessary?
Available labels: Evaluate the existing shared van and local access. | Apply the city route map unchanged. | The city bus service is not locally available.
A policy mechanism depends on available services and conditions; the city assumptions do not automatically transfer.
11. Adapt the proposal to the barangay and name one local measurement needed.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Adapts to the actual local transport option.
- Requests relevant local service or emissions data.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a causal claim
Repair a causal claim · evidence 1
A town’s fictional emissions fall after a policy,
Repair a causal claim · evidence 2
a large factory also closes.
Repair a causal claim · evidence 3
A report attributes the entire drop to the policy.
12. What weakens the causal conclusion?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The factory closure is another possible cause.
- Factory activity cannot affect emissions under the stated conditions.
- Any measured drop proves every policy works.
- Timing alone proves the policy caused everything.
A before-after difference can include other changes; attribution needs a fuller comparison.
13. Correct the conclusion and name a way to investigate the policy contribution.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Acknowledges the competing explanation.
- Proposes a relevant comparison or source breakdown.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a policy evaluation
Design a policy evaluation · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8. Emissions records cost 3; household access survey 2; implementation check 2. Goal: assess a transport policy’s climate effect and fairness.
14. Which complete evaluation fits the budget? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- All three checks cost 7 tokens.
- Emissions totals alone reveal every barrier.
- An announcement verifies full implementation.
- All three checks cost 9 tokens.
The checks total seven and examine outcome, access and delivery separately.
15. Propose an evaluation within budget and state one climate and one access indicator.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a relevant comparable climate indicator within budget.
- Includes a meaningful access or fairness indicator.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.1 — Disaster preparedness
Use warnings, safe routes and inclusive practice to prepare for climate-related hazards.
Worked examples
1. Check all pupils
Worked classroom example
Fictional drill: 40 pupils; 38 are accounted for at the meeting place.
Question: Is the drill complete?
Answer: No; two pupils are not yet accounted for.
Report this to the responsible adults using the school procedure. A fast arrival by most pupils does not establish everyone’s safety.
2. Choose a route
Worked classroom example
Practice map: A crosses a low flooded point; B is dry and has an accessible ramp.
Question: Which meets the stated safe-route conditions?
Answer: B.
Use the supplied conditions. Real routes must be verified by responsible authorities, not inferred from a toy map.
3. Backup communication
Worked classroom example
A fictional school’s phone network fails, but its supervised classroom messenger system works.
Question: Why plan both methods?
Answer: A backup can reach people when the first method fails.
The methods still need consistent official instructions and confirmation that people received them.
Formative quiz
Choose the usable route
Choose the usable route · evidence 1
Fictional drill: A has a flooded low point; B is clear and accessible; C is closed for works; D has an unprotected crossing.
1. Which route meets the stated conditions?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Route A is clear and accessible.
- Route C is open for the drill.
- Route B is clear and accessible.
- The shortest label proves safety.
B is the only route meeting the given conditions; a real route requires authorised assessment.
Read a useful warning
Read a useful warning · evidence 1
Fictional official drill message: “At 9 a.m., classes in Block A follow their teachers to Meeting Point B.”
Read a useful warning · evidence 2
A forwarded screenshot has no date or source.
2. Read a useful warning: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- It tells pupils whom to follow.
- It names a time and location.
- An unknown source is always authoritative.
- The screenshot’s missing date proves freshness.
Specific timing, place and adult-led action help pupils respond to the practice message.
Model a low area
Model a low area · evidence 1
Toy map datum: water level 20 cm plus rise 15; low path ground 30. No waves are modeled.
3. Model a low area: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the modeled water surface?
- What depth covers the low path?
Available labels: The path has 5 cm model inundation. | The surface is 20 cm above datum. | The surface is 35 cm above datum.
35−30=5. The model shows exposure; it is not permission to enter floodwater.
Keep track of a group
Keep track of a group · evidence 1
Fictional drill roles: teacher directs the class
Keep track of a group · evidence 2
adult assistant checks assigned pupils
Keep track of a group · evidence 3
pupils stay with their group and report concerns.
4. Keep track of a group: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Who directs the class?
- What should pupils do?
Available labels: Pupils stay with their assigned group. | The teacher directs the class. | Pupils independently inspect floodwater.
The assigned roles maintain supervised movement and reporting.
Explain a runoff concern
Explain a runoff concern · evidence 1
Toy school surface: 60 water units of rain; 25% infiltrates and the rest runs off. The model omits storage and evaporation.
5. Find the modeled runoff and explain one limit when using it for preparedness.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates forty-five runoff units.
- Identifies a model limitation or need for real route assessment.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply the drill record
Apply the drill record · evidence 1
Fictional drill has 50 pupils: 46 arrive, 4 need the planned adult assistance. The goal is all pupils accounted for.
6. Apply the drill record: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What remains to complete the goal?
- What result is required?
Available labels: Four pupils need planned assistance and accounting. | All 50 pupils must be accounted for. | The first 46 prove full completion.
Completion must include those needing assistance, not just the first group.
7. Explain what the plan still needs to do and why the arrival count is insufficient.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the four pupils and planned assistance.
- Explains the all-pupils completion requirement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a backup system
Justify a backup system · evidence 1
Fictional A uses only phone messages.
Justify a backup system · evidence 2
B uses official phone messages plus a maintained speaker and adult relay with the same wording.
Justify a backup system · evidence 3
Phones sometimes fail.
8. Justify a backup system: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which plan handles the stated failure better?
- What should stay consistent across them?
Available labels: B provides working alternative channels. | The official instruction should remain consistent. | A has an independent backup channel.
B avoids dependence on one vulnerable channel while keeping one authoritative action.
9. Justify B and name a check needed during a drill.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the phone-failure scenario to justify backup.
- Checks receipt and understanding across the intended group.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer after route change
Transfer after route change · evidence 1
In a fictional practice map, the usual ramp route is closed. Route C is dry and has a usable ramp; route D has steps. A wheelchair user is in the group.
10. Transfer after route change: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which alternative meets the stated requirement?
- What must be updated?
Available labels: Route D provides a usable ramp. | The supervised plan must use a verified route. | Route C remains dry and accessible.
The change requires an updated accessible route with adult coordination.
11. Adapt the plan and identify who should confirm the change.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Chooses the usable accessible alternative.
- Requires authorised verification and communication.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a certainty claim
Repair a certainty claim · evidence 1
A toy runoff demonstration sends 20 water units down a path. A pupil claims, “Our real path will always get exactly 20 units.” Rainfall and drainage vary in reality.
12. Why is the claim too certain?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Drainage never changes any outcome under the stated conditions.
- The model measures every future storm.
- A toy path fixes all real rainfall.
- The model leaves out changing real conditions.
A simplified demonstration is not a local forecast or a substitute for real warnings.
13. Rewrite the claim and name one missing real-world factor.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Labels the result as conditional and illustrative.
- Names a relevant omitted or variable factor.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an inclusive drill
Design an inclusive drill · evidence 1
Fictional budget 6: accessible-route check 2, backup-message practice 2, attendance/accounting check 2. Goal: all pupils can receive instructions and reach the approved meeting point.
14. Design an inclusive drill: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- All three cost 8 tokens.
- All three cost 6 tokens.
- Only the fastest arrival needs counting.
- Account for every pupil, including assisted pupils.
The full plan addresses route, communication and all-pupil accounting.
15. Design a six-token drill plan and explain how it checks both access and communication.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes usable access and all-pupil accounting.
- Includes a tested communication backup within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.2 — Flood protection
Compare flood measures while considering runoff, exposure and effects on neighbours.
Worked examples
1. Runoff arithmetic
Worked classroom example
Toy rain 100 units; infiltration 40%; other paths omitted.
Question: How much runs off?
Answer: 60 units.
Forty infiltrates and sixty remains as modeled runoff. Real catchments also have storage and evaporation.
2. Storage overflow
Worked classroom example
Toy basin holds 20, receives 50 and releases 10; capacity 40.
Question: How much overflows?
Answer: 20 units.
The unconstrained total is sixty; only forty can remain. Capacity does not make excess water disappear.
3. Wider effects
Worked classroom example
A fictional wall reduces water at school but raises it at nearby houses.
Question: Is the school result enough to approve the plan?
Answer: No.
A wider assessment must consider the transferred risk and other feasible designs.
Formative quiz
Separate hazard and exposure
Separate hazard and exposure · evidence 1
Fictional heavy rainfall affects an empty field and a low school entrance.
Separate hazard and exposure · evidence 2
The entrance is used by children
Separate hazard and exposure · evidence 3
the field is designated water-storage space.
1. Separate hazard and exposure: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The field is designated water-storage space.
- The school entrance is used by pupils.
- An empty field contains the same pupil group.
- Rainfall alone describes all damage.
The same rainfall can affect places differently because use and exposure differ.
Follow runoff
Follow runoff · evidence 1
Toy rain 80 units; 25% infiltrates; the model counts no storage or evaporation.
2. Follow runoff: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- How much infiltrates?
- How much becomes modeled runoff?
Available labels: 25 water units infiltrate. | 60 water units run off. | 20 water units infiltrate.
A quarter of eighty is twenty, leaving sixty.
Check the basin
Check the basin · evidence 1
Toy basin starts 10, receives 40, releases 15 and has capacity 50.
3. Check the basin: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What remains after one step?
- Is there overflow in this step?
Available labels: No overflow occurs below capacity 50. | 65 water units remain. | 35 water units remain.
10+40−15=35, which is below fifty.
Choose an evidence-based claim
Choose an evidence-based claim · evidence 1
Fictional drain maintenance was checked during three light-rain days only.
Choose an evidence-based claim · evidence 2
A report claims it prevents every possible flood.
4. Which statement fits the evidence?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Performance was checked only in light rain.
- Every possible flood has been tested.
- Three light days establish unlimited capacity.
- Maintenance removes all future rainfall under the stated conditions.
The observed conditions limit the claim; heavier events may exceed system capacity.
Explain a neighbour effect
Explain a neighbour effect · evidence 1
A fictional channel reduces school runoff exposure but sends additional water toward downstream homes.
5. Explain one benefit and one risk that must be included in the decision.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the school benefit.
- Identifies transferred downstream risk.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply two surface assumptions
Apply two surface assumptions · evidence 1
Toy rainfall 100 units. Surface A infiltrates 20%; B infiltrates 50%. Other paths omitted.
6. True or false: B has 80 runoff units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Subtract infiltrated amounts from one hundred: fifty and eighty.
7. Explain B’s modeled advantage and one limitation of applying this to a real site.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Compares the thirty-unit modeled difference.
- Names a relevant real-site limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify combined protection
Justify combined protection · evidence 1
Fictional A builds a barrier without maintenance or warning plans.
Justify combined protection · evidence 2
B combines maintained drains, designated storage and accessible official-warning procedures.
8. Justify combined protection: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which plan addresses more failure points?
- What does B still need?
Available labels: Its capacity and performance need checking. | A includes a maintained warning system. | B combines drainage, storage and response.
B considers several mechanisms but still has finite capacity and needs verification.
9. Justify B without claiming perfect protection.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains complementary protection and response.
- Acknowledges limits or ongoing maintenance.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to heavier rain
Transfer to heavier rain · evidence 1
Toy basin starts 20; inflow rises to 70; outflow is 20; capacity 50. Compare one step.
10. How much overflows?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- 70 water units overflow.
- 20 water units remain stored.
- No overflow occurs.
- 20 water units overflow.
Unconstrained storage is seventy; capacity is fifty, leaving twenty overflow.
11. Explain why the old plan needs review and name one complementary response.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies capacity exceedance and twenty-unit overflow.
- Proposes a relevant additional measure or response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a rain-only explanation
Repair a rain-only explanation · evidence 1
A pupil claims all extra street flooding must come from more rain. Fictional records show equal rainfall, but a drain became blocked and more surface was paved.
12. What is missing from the explanation? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The records show doubled rainfall.
- A blocked drain cannot affect runoff.
- Paving proves climate never matters.
- Drainage and surface changes also matter.
These records do not support a rain-only cause; they identify relevant local changes.
13. Correct the explanation using the unchanged rainfall and at least one changed local condition.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the unchanged-rainfall evidence.
- Identifies changed drainage or surface as a possible contributor.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a wider flood check
Design a wider flood check · evidence 1
Fictional budget 7: drain inspection 2, upstream/downstream level checks 3, accessible warning drill 2. Goal: reduce harm without hiding transferred risk.
14. Design a wider flood check: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- School-only readings show every neighbour effect.
- Level checks include both affected areas.
- All three cost 7 tokens.
- All three cost 9 tokens.
The combined plan examines maintenance, wider effects and response within budget.
15. Propose a plan that includes neighbouring areas and people who need assistance.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes upstream/downstream or neighbour effects.
- Includes accessible response within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.3 — Water management
Balance water supply and demand while protecting quality and fair access.
Worked examples
1. One tank step
Worked classroom example
Toy tank starts 30, gains 12 and supplies 8; capacity 60.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 34 units.
30+12−8=34. The net gain is four, while thirty-four is the stock.
2. Unmet demand
Worked classroom example
A toy store has 6 units, receives 2 and is asked to supply 10.
Question: What can it supply?
Answer: 8 units, leaving 2 unmet.
Water cannot be supplied below an empty store. A real plan must protect essential needs.
3. Compare equal users
Worked classroom example
Fictional use falls from 100 to 80 units for the same 40 pupils after a leak repair.
Question: What is the saving?
Answer: 20 units, or 20%.
The same users and service make this more informative than comparing different attendance totals.
Formative quiz
Read the water balance
Read the water balance · evidence 1
Toy tank: initial 30; inflow 12; outflow 8; capacity 60.
1. Read the water balance: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the ending store?
- What is the net change?
Available labels: The tank holds 34 units. | The tank holds 26 units. | The store gains 4 units.
Thirty plus twelve minus eight equals thirty-four.
Separate water uses
Separate water uses · evidence 1
Fictional school: tested treated supply is for drinking
Separate water uses · evidence 2
untreated rainwater is reserved for approved garden use.
Separate water uses · evidence 3
Pupils must follow school rules.
2. Separate water uses: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which source serves drinking under these rules?
- What is the approved rainwater use?
Available labels: Any clear-looking rainwater is safe to drink. | The tested treated supply serves drinking. | Untreated rainwater is for the garden.
The source gives different approved uses; appearance or quantity alone does not establish safety.
Inspect rainfall paths
Inspect rainfall paths · evidence 1
Toy roof area receives 80 water units; the model’s infiltrating share is 25%, with no storage or evaporation included.
3. True or false: 60 units remain as modeled runoff.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The balance yields sixty; collection and water safety require additional information.
Compare demand fairly
Compare demand fairly · evidence 1
Fictional same-size class uses 100, 98, 101, 80 and 79 units across five comparable days; a leak is repaired before day four.
4. Compare demand fairly: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Essential water access should continue.
- Later use is lower in these records.
- Later use is higher in these records.
- The record proves all future supply is secure.
The observed drop is consistent with reduced losses; needed service must remain available.
Explain scarcity fairly
Explain scarcity fairly · evidence 1
Fictional tank supply falls.
Explain scarcity fairly · evidence 2
A proposal removes all handwashing water
Explain scarcity fairly · evidence 3
leaves an avoidable leak unrepaired.
5. Explain a better priority and why it protects essential needs.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Targets avoidable loss or nonessential demand.
- Protects essential drinking or hygiene access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply capacity limits
Apply capacity limits · evidence 1
Toy tank starts 40, receives 30, supplies 10 and has capacity 50.
6. Apply capacity limits: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The tank holds its 50-unit capacity.
- All 30 incoming units overflow.
- 10 water units overflow.
- The tank stores 60 units without limit.
The unconstrained balance is sixty; fifty is stored and ten overflows.
7. Explain the ending store and overflow using the capacity.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes the unconstrained sixty-unit balance.
- Applies capacity to get fifty stored and ten overflow.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a conservation action
Justify a conservation action · evidence 1
Fictional A repairs a 10-unit daily leak while maintaining all uses.
Justify a conservation action · evidence 2
B removes 10 units of essential drinking access.
Justify a conservation action · evidence 3
Costs are equal.
8. Which action meets saving and essential-access goals?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- A increases the daily leak under the stated conditions.
- A saves the leaked water without removing access.
- Equal cost makes the effects identical.
- B preserves all essential drinking access.
The same volume can be saved with very different consequences for people.
9. Justify A using both the water balance and the effect on pupils.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the ten-unit avoidable loss.
- Explains preservation of essential access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to dry conditions
Transfer to dry conditions · evidence 1
Toy store starts 25; inflow falls to 4 while outflow remains 9. Capacity 50.
10. What happens after one step? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The store falls to 20 units.
- The store stays at 25 units.
- The store rises to 30 units.
- Inflow exceeds demand by 5.
25+4−9=20; repeated five-unit losses eventually exhaust the store.
11. Propose an adjustment and explain what it must preserve.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Responds to the five-unit supply deficit.
- Protects essential water needs.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a percentage mistake
Repair a percentage mistake · evidence 1
A pupil says, “Use fell from 80 to 60, so the saving is 20%.” These are comparable water-use totals.
12. Repair a percentage mistake: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the correct percentage?
- Which baseline is used?
Available labels: The original 80 units is the denominator. | The saving is 20% of the baseline. | The saving is 25% of the baseline.
Twenty divided by eighty is one-quarter, or twenty-five percent.
13. Correct the claim and distinguish amount from percentage.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives the twenty-unit absolute saving.
- Calculates twenty-five percent using the original baseline.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a water check
Design a water check · evidence 1
Fictional budget 7: leak inspection 2, store meter 2, access/quality check by responsible adults 3. Goal: lower waste without harming essential service.
14. Design a water check: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What does the full plan cost?
- Which part checks essential service?
Available labels: The full plan costs 7 tokens. | The access and quality check examines service. | The full plan costs 9 tokens.
The plan combines loss detection, quantity measurement and responsible service checks.
15. Design a plan within budget and explain how both quantity and essential service will be checked.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes water-quantity or loss monitoring within budget.
- Includes essential-access and responsible quality checks.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.4 — Climate-resilient agriculture
Design farming responses to climate stress while checking harvest and resource limits.
Worked examples
1. Two trial results
Worked classroom example
Fictional equal plots: A uses 40 water units for 20 baskets; B uses 30 for 20.
Question: What advantage does B show?
Answer: Ten fewer water units for equal harvest.
This is a local trial result. Other seasons and costs still need investigation.
2. A dry-store limit
Worked classroom example
Toy store starts 20, gains 4 and supplies 9.
Question: What remains after one step?
Answer: 15 units.
A repeated five-unit deficit requires an adjustment; storage is finite.
3. Different hazards
Worked classroom example
Field P is dry; Q is waterlogged.
Question: Why should their plans differ?
Answer: They face different water problems.
A locally appropriate measure must respond to the actual stress and avoid creating another problem.
Formative quiz
Match field conditions
Match field conditions · evidence 1
Fictional field P has dry soil and limited supply.
Match field conditions · evidence 2
Field Q has standing excess water and damaged drainage.
1. Match field conditions: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which need belongs to P?
- Which need belongs to Q?
Available labels: Q needs excess-water/drainage assessment. | P needs unlimited extra flooding. | P needs water-conservation planning.
The source identifies opposite water problems requiring locally assessed responses.
Read a trial fairly
Read a trial fairly · evidence 1
Fictional equal-area plots: A uses 40 water units and yields 20 baskets; B uses 30 and yields 20. Labour and soil effects are not measured.
2. Read a trial fairly: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Labour and soil effects need checking.
- B uses less water for equal harvest.
- B yields fewer baskets in the table.
- The trial proves B best in every season.
The table supports a water benefit, while omitted outcomes limit the wider conclusion.
Balance a dry-period store
Balance a dry-period store · evidence 1
Toy irrigation store starts 25, gains 5 and supplies 8; capacity 50.
3. Balance a dry-period store: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the ending store?
- What is the net deficit?
Available labels: 28 water units remain. | Outflow exceeds inflow by 3 units. | 22 water units remain.
25+5−8=22, a three-unit decline.
Compare runoff assumptions
Compare runoff assumptions · evidence 1
Toy rain 100 units. A covered plot has assumed 60% infiltration; an exposed plot has assumed 30%. Other paths omitted.
4. What is covered-plot runoff in this model?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Covered-plot runoff is 70 units.
- Covered-plot runoff is 40 units.
- The factors apply to every real soil.
- Covered-plot runoff is 60 units.
Subtract each assumed infiltrating fraction from one hundred; the factors are illustrative.
Explain a limited result
Explain a limited result · evidence 1
A fictional drought-tolerant variety succeeds in one dry-season trial
Explain a limited result · evidence 2
has not been tested in wet conditions.
5. State what the trial supports and one useful next test.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the conclusion to the tested conditions.
- Proposes a relevant changed-condition trial.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a resource comparison
Apply a resource comparison · evidence 1
Fictional equal harvest is 15 baskets. Practice A needs 45 water units; B needs 30.
6. True or false: B uses 3 units per basket.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Thirty divided by fifteen is two; forty-five divided by fifteen is three.
7. Compare water use per basket to explain B’s demonstrated benefit, then name a limit without claiming it solves every farming problem.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the correct per-basket comparison.
- Acknowledges an untested relevant outcome or condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a small trial
Justify a small trial · evidence 1
Fictional farmer can test a new practice on two comparable small plots or switch every field immediately.
Justify a small trial · evidence 2
Local performance is unknown.
8. Which option creates relevant evidence with limited exposure?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- An immediate full switch proves effectiveness.
- Only the number of planted seeds matters.
- A small comparable trial tests local performance.
- Unknown performance means guaranteed failure under the stated conditions.
A limited trial can compare outcomes before risking the entire harvest.
9. Justify a trial and name one food-output outcome and one resource-use or crop-health outcome that match resilience goals.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the value of a limited relevant comparison.
- Names food output and a relevant resource/health outcome.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to heavier rain
Transfer to heavier rain · evidence 1
Toy field receives 120 rain units and infiltrates 40%; a shallow storage area can hold only 50 runoff units. Ignore other flows.
10. How much runoff does the model produce? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The model produces 50 runoff units.
- The model produces no overflow risk.
- The model produces 48 runoff units.
- The model produces 72 runoff units.
Forty percent infiltrates forty-eight; seventy-two remains, twenty-two above capacity.
11. Explain why the dry-season plan may need revision and name a relevant response to investigate.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the seventy-two versus fifty mismatch.
- Proposes an appropriate excess-water response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a resilience claim
Repair a resilience claim · evidence 1
A pupil says, “The new method saves 40% water, so it is successful.” Trial data: harvest also falls from 20 baskets to 8; families require 20 baskets from these plots.
12. Repair a resilience claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What does the claim leave out?
- What is the new harvest?
Available labels: The large harvest loss still matters. | Water saving proves food needs are met. | The new harvest is 8 baskets.
Adaptation includes maintaining food and livelihoods, not merely reducing one input.
13. Correct the conclusion using water and food outcomes.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Acknowledges the water-saving result.
- Explains the harvest/food-security failure.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a resilient trial
Design a resilient trial · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: local advice 2, comparable plots 3, water and harvest records 2. Goal: test a change under limited water without assuming equal yield.
14. Design a resilient trial: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- All three components cost 10 tokens.
- Water savings alone prove equal harvest.
- All three components cost 7 tokens.
- Harvest must be measured.
The trial includes local relevance, comparison and both resource and food outcomes.
15. Design a trial within budget and explain how it checks resilience rather than only water use.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a comparable local trial within budget.
- Measures food output or health together with water.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.5 — Heat-health planning
Use shade, accessible rest and trusted guidance in a practical school heat plan.
Worked examples
1. Toy shade calculation
Worked classroom example
Illustrative formula: base 28 + extra 4 − 3×shade fraction. Shade is 100%.
Question: What is the indicator?
Answer: 29.
28+4−3=29. This is not a medical safety threshold or a real forecast.
2. Accessible rest
Worked classroom example
Fictional room A has steps only; room B has a usable ramp and the same approved rest facilities.
Question: Which meets the stated access need?
Answer: B.
The facilities are useful only when the people needing them can reach them.
3. Averages can hide exposure
Worked classroom example
Toy location indicators are 28, 28, 29 and 35.
Question: Why inspect all locations?
Answer: The 35 location may need attention despite a lower overall average.
These indicators compare fictional locations; responsible adults assess real risks and actions.
Formative quiz
Use trusted information
Use trusted information · evidence 1
Fictional choices: current official school guidance
Use trusted information · evidence 2
an undated screenshot
Use trusted information · evidence 3
a rumour
Use trusted information · evidence 4
a toy simulation value.
Use trusted information · evidence 5
An outdoor-activity decision is needed.
1. Which is the proper basis among these choices?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Use current official school guidance.
- A toy value proves medical safety.
- Use an undated screenshot as current guidance.
- A rumour replaces responsible adults.
Official guidance and responsible assessment govern real action; a toy model teaches concepts.
Explore shade
Explore shade · evidence 1
Toy indicator = 28+4−3×shade fraction. At 100% shade, the full subtraction applies.
2. Explore shade: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the full-shade indicator?
- What is the no-shade indicator?
Available labels: The full-shade indicator is 29. | The full-shade indicator is 32. | The no-shade indicator is 32.
Full shade subtracts three from thirty-two; the formula is illustrative only.
Match help to barriers
Match help to barriers · evidence 1
Fictional barriers: exposed waiting queue
Match help to barriers · evidence 2
rest room with steps only.
Match help to barriers · evidence 3
Proposed actions: approved shade for the queue
Match help to barriers · evidence 4
an accessible rest route.
3. Match help to barriers: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What addresses the exposed queue?
- What addresses the steps barrier?
Available labels: More steps improve wheelchair access. | Approved queue shade reduces sun exposure. | An accessible rest route improves access.
Each response addresses a specific barrier while other plan needs remain.
Check water availability
Check water availability · evidence 1
Toy water store starts 30 units, receives 5 and supplies 10 during a practice period. Capacity 50; this models quantity only.
4. Check water availability: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What remains in the store?
- What does this model not establish?
Available labels: 25 water units remain. | 45 water units remain. | It does not establish drinking-water quality.
30+5−10=25. Quantity and safe accessible supply are separate checks.
Explain the waiting area
Explain the waiting area · evidence 1
A fictional school has shaded classrooms, but pupils wait 20 minutes in an exposed pickup queue. Adults can revise the pickup arrangement.
5. Propose one response for the queue and explain why shaded classrooms alone do not solve this issue.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a relevant supervised queue improvement.
- Recognises exposure outside the classrooms.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply the shade formula
Apply the shade formula · evidence 1
Toy formula: 28+4−4×shade fraction. Compare 0% and 50% shade; these are not real safety thresholds.
6. Apply the shade formula: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the half-shade indicator?
- What is the no-shade indicator?
Available labels: The half-shade indicator is 30. | The no-shade indicator is 32. | The half-shade indicator is 28.
Half of the four-unit subtraction is two; thirty-two minus two is thirty.
7. Explain the modeled difference and why it cannot by itself approve a real activity.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates or explains the two-unit difference.
- Recognises model limits and responsible real assessment.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify an accessible plan
Justify an accessible plan · evidence 1
Fictional A provides a locked cool room reached only by stairs.
Justify an accessible plan · evidence 2
B provides an approved open rest area with a ramp and drinking-water access.
8. True or false: B provides usable rest and water access.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Actual usability matters, not just the existence of a room.
9. Justify B with two features relevant to pupils’ needs.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the open accessible rest provision.
- Identifies usable water or another distinct stated access feature.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer after a power failure
Transfer after a power failure · evidence 1
Fictional heat plan relies on electric fans. Power fails. An approved shaded area and water supply remain available; teachers have official contingency instructions.
10. Which response follows the stated resources? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Teachers use approved contingency arrangements.
- Power loss makes every shaded option unavailable.
- Continue assuming powered fans are running.
- Pupils should test unsafe heat limits.
The plan must respond to the unavailable equipment using verified alternatives and adult guidance.
11. Adapt the plan using two available resources without making a safety guarantee.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses both the available approved shaded area and water access.
- Keeps decisions under responsible guidance rather than a guarantee.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the average claim
Repair the average claim · evidence 1
Toy indicators: rooms A/B/C are 28, 29, 28; queue D is 35. A pupil says, “Most rooms are cooler, so no place needs checking.”
12. What is the error?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Every location has the same indicator.
- It ignores the more exposed queue.
- Three room readings measure the queue.
- An average removes local differences under the stated conditions.
The high queue value remains relevant even if most other places are lower.
13. Correct the claim and identify a useful next check.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the overlooked queue exposure.
- Proposes a relevant location-specific check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a school heat review
Design a school heat review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 7: approved queue shade 3, accessible rest-route check 2, communication and water-access check 2. Goal: address waiting exposure and include all pupils.
14. Design a school heat review: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which full plan fits the budget?
- What specifically improves inclusion?
Available labels: All three components cost 9 tokens. | All three components cost 7 tokens. | Check that every pupil can reach rest.
The measures address physical exposure, access and the plan’s usability.
15. Propose a plan within budget addressing queue exposure and access, with responsible adult oversight.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Addresses the exposed queue within budget.
- Includes usable access and responsible oversight.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.6 — Resilient infrastructure
Assess infrastructure by the services it maintains, its limits and who can use it.
Worked examples
1. A connected system
Worked classroom example
Fictional shelter is intact, but the only road is closed.
Question: What service problem remains?
Answer: People cannot reach it by that road.
Structure condition and usable access are different. A resilient plan checks both.
2. Raised level
Worked classroom example
Toy water surface is 45 cm above datum; entrance is 50.
Question: What is the model clearance?
Answer: 5 cm.
The calculation shows only a level difference. It does not test waves, structural strength or real access safety.
3. Recovery time
Worked classroom example
Fictional service A returns in 3 days after a comparable outage; B in 1.
Question: Which recovers faster in these records?
Answer: B.
A two-day difference is observed, but costs, reliability and access still need evaluation.
Formative quiz
Inspect dependencies
Inspect dependencies · evidence 1
Fictional clinic has an intact roof and working power, but its single access bridge is closed.
1. What prevents full service access?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The closed bridge blocks the route.
- Working power makes the bridge open.
- An intact roof proves every service works.
- The clinic has no dependence on routes.
The route is a dependency; one sound component does not establish a functioning whole system.
Compare entrance levels
Compare entrance levels · evidence 1
Toy water surface: level 20 plus rise 25. Entrance A is 40; B is 55 cm above the same datum.
2. Which entrance stays above the model surface? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Entrance B is above the 45 cm surface.
- This diagram certifies real structural safety.
- Entrance B has 10 cm of model water.
- Entrance A is above the 45 cm surface.
The surface is forty-five, above A but below B; other safety factors are not modeled.
Check a drain
Check a drain · evidence 1
Toy runoff model receives 100 rain units with 30% infiltration. It omits storage, drain geometry and erosion.
3. True or false: The model produces 30 runoff units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Seventy remains after thirty infiltrates; this balance alone cannot size or certify a structure.
Maintain a backup
Maintain a backup · evidence 1
Fictional plan includes a backup pump, monthly checks and a named adult maintenance team.
Maintain a backup · evidence 2
The backup has limited capacity.
4. Maintain a backup: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A stored pump needs no future checks.
- Regular checks test the backup pump.
- Its capacity is limited.
- A backup has unlimited capacity.
Readiness depends on working equipment and known limits, not ownership alone.
Explain accessible resilience
Explain accessible resilience · evidence 1
A fictional school raises a doorway above a model flood level
Explain accessible resilience · evidence 2
provides only steps.
5. Explain the intended benefit and one access change needed.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the water-exposure aim.
- Addresses the steps barrier with suitable access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply level differences
Apply level differences · evidence 1
Toy surface is 50 cm above datum. Facility floor is 65; access path is 45. No waves or structural forces are modeled.
6. Apply level differences: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What happens to the access path in the model?
- What is the floor clearance?
Available labels: The floor is 15 cm above water. | The path has 5 cm model inundation. | The path is 15 cm above water.
The path lies below the surface even though the floor is above it.
7. Explain why the building’s dry floor is insufficient to show usable access.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the path’s five-unit modeled exposure.
- Distinguishes floor condition from usable access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify redundant access
Justify redundant access · evidence 1
Fictional A has one low route.
Justify redundant access · evidence 2
B has two independently assessed routes, one on higher ground.
Justify redundant access · evidence 3
Both serve the same shelter.
8. What resilience advantage does B offer? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- A has an independent second route.
- Two routes guarantee zero risk forever.
- B can retain an alternative assessed route.
- Higher ground removes every other hazard.
An alternative reduces dependence on one link but must remain suitable and verified.
9. Justify B without claiming that two routes guarantee safety.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains reduced dependence on one route.
- Acknowledges verification and remaining limits.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to more runoff
Transfer to more runoff · evidence 1
Toy basin near a road: initial 10, inflow 80, outflow 20, capacity 50.
10. Transfer to more runoff: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- How much exceeds storage capacity?
- How much remains stored?
Available labels: 20 water units overflow. | 70 water units overflow. | 50 water units remain.
The unconstrained balance is seventy; twenty exceeds the fifty-unit capacity.
11. Explain why a plan for lower inflow needs review and identify a service to protect.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the modeled capacity exceedance.
- Names a relevant essential service and appropriate review.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the maintenance claim
Repair the maintenance claim · evidence 1
A report says, “A backup generator was bought, so power is guaranteed.”
Repair the maintenance claim · evidence 2
Records show it has not been tested and fuel availability is unknown.
12. True or false: Buying proves unlimited reliable operation.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The evidence establishes purchase, not guaranteed operation or certain failure.
13. Rewrite the claim accurately and name two readiness checks.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Separates ownership from verified readiness.
- Names operational testing and energy/fuel availability.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a service-focused review
Design a service-focused review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: structure inspection 3, access review 2, backup test 2. Goal: assess shelter service and access during disruption.
14. Design a service-focused review: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What does the complete review cost?
- What does the access review examine?
Available labels: It checks whether users can reach the shelter. | The complete review costs 10 tokens. | The complete review costs 7 tokens.
Separate checks cover the structure, its connection and its backup service.
15. Propose a review within budget and explain two different failure points it examines.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes at least two distinct service/structure dependencies.
- Fits budget and uses appropriate inspection or testing.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.7 — Coastal protection
Compare coastal adaptation measures using water levels, ecosystems and community needs.
Worked examples
1. Static depth
Worked classroom example
Toy water is 40 cm above datum; ground is 30.
Question: What depth appears?
Answer: 10 cm.
Subtract ground from water. This does not include waves or predict a real event.
2. A higher path
Worked classroom example
Water is 40 cm; path A is 35 and B is 50 above the same datum.
Question: Which is above the model surface?
Answer: B, with 10 cm clearance.
A is five below. Actual access safety still requires authorised assessment.
3. A suitability question
Worked classroom example
Fictional mangrove proposal uses an intact habitat where that species does not naturally establish.
Question: What evidence is needed?
Answer: Local ecological suitability and effects on the existing habitat.
A nature-based label does not guarantee that a particular planting is appropriate.
Formative quiz
Compare coastal heights
Compare coastal heights · evidence 1
Toy water level 20 plus rise 15; village ground 30; all cm above one datum.
1. Compare coastal heights: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the water surface?
- What is the village’s model depth?
Available labels: The water surface is 15 cm. | The modeled depth is 5 cm. | The water surface is 35 cm.
Twenty plus fifteen is thirty-five; subtracting thirty gives five.
Read ecosystem suitability
Read ecosystem suitability · evidence 1
Fictional local assessment: site A is suitable degraded mangrove habitat
Read ecosystem suitability · evidence 2
B is intact seagrass
Read ecosystem suitability · evidence 3
C is an unsuitable rocky cliff
Read ecosystem suitability · evidence 4
D lacks land-use agreement.
2. Which site has the stated restoration suitability? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Site B is empty degraded mangrove habitat.
- Site A is suitable degraded mangrove habitat.
- Every coastal habitat should become mangroves.
- Site C has confirmed suitable mangrove soil.
Restoration should match the ecosystem and avoid damaging valuable existing habitat.
Follow evidence through time
Follow evidence through time · evidence 1
Fictional fixed-datum water indicators are 20, 21, 19, 24, 25 across five comparable periods. They are practice data.
3. Follow evidence through time: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the endpoint change?
- Does every step rise?
Available labels: One step falls before later increases. | The endpoint rises by 5 cm. | The endpoint rises by 25 cm.
Twenty-five minus twenty is five; the third value is lower than the second.
Include a livelihood effect
Include a livelihood effect · evidence 1
Fictional plan: a wall reduces modeled wave exposure
Include a livelihood effect · evidence 2
blocks the only boat-landing access.
Include a livelihood effect · evidence 3
A revised access opening is being assessed.
4. Include a livelihood effect: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What benefit is claimed?
- What burden needs attention?
Available labels: The wall has no effect on access. | It blocks the stated boat-landing access. | The wall reduces modeled wave exposure.
The proposal has both a protection aim and an access consequence requiring assessment.
Explain a model limit
Explain a model limit · evidence 1
A fictional static level diagram shows ground above water.
Explain a model limit · evidence 2
The model omits waves, erosion and drainage.
5. State what the diagram supports and one reason it cannot prove real coastal safety.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the claim to the static level comparison.
- Names a relevant omitted process.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply the shared datum
Apply the shared datum · evidence 1
Toy surface 60 cm; school ground 75; access lane 50, all above the same datum.
6. What is model depth on the lane? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The lane has 10 cm model depth.
- The lane has 15 cm clearance.
- The school ground is 10 cm underwater.
- The school’s height proves the lane dry.
Sixty minus fifty is ten; seventy-five minus sixty is fifteen.
7. Explain why a coastal plan must check the lane as well as school ground.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the lane’s ten-centimetre modeled exposure.
- Explains separate access and site conditions.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a broader assessment
Justify a broader assessment · evidence 1
Fictional A evaluates only water at one building.
Justify a broader assessment · evidence 2
B checks nearby shores, habitat, boat access and maintenance as well as that building.
8. Justify a broader assessment: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which evaluation covers more relevant effects?
- What can A miss?
Available labels: A measures every surrounding shoreline. | B includes neighbouring and community effects. | A can miss shifted erosion or blocked access.
A narrow evaluation can overlook consequences beyond its boundary.
9. Justify B using one physical or ecological effect and one access or livelihood effect that matter to the community.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies a physical or ecological wider effect.
- Identifies an access or livelihood effect.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a higher level
Transfer to a higher level · evidence 1
Toy old water surface 35; new surface 50; ground 45. All units are cm above the same datum.
10. Transfer to a higher level: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The new depth is 50 cm.
- The old clearance was 10 cm.
- It changes from above water to 5 cm depth.
- It stays 10 cm above both surfaces.
Ground forty-five is ten above thirty-five but five below fifty.
11. Explain the changed exposure and name one response that requires local assessment.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the change using the given levels.
- Names a relevant assessed adaptation option.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the universal planting claim
Repair the universal planting claim · evidence 1
A pupil says, “Plant mangroves on every coast and all flooding stops.”
Repair the universal planting claim · evidence 2
Evidence: habitat suitability varies, protection has limits, and waves and surge can exceed measures.
12. Repair the universal planting claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the main error?
- What is required before planting?
Available labels: Assess local habitat and protection limits. | Every coast is identical mangrove habitat. | It assumes universal suitability and complete protection.
A measure can offer benefits without fitting every habitat or preventing every event.
13. Rewrite the claim with a suitability condition and a protection limit.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Requires local ecological suitability.
- Rejects a guarantee of complete flood protection.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a coastal review
Design a coastal review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: level survey 2, habitat assessment 3, community access consultation 2. Goal: compare options without harming existing habitat or access.
14. Which full review fits?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Habitat assessment replaces all local voices.
- A level survey proves ecological suitability.
- All three checks cost 7 tokens.
- All three checks cost 10 tokens under the stated conditions.
The three complementary checks cover physical, ecological and social conditions.
15. Propose a review within budget that addresses both habitat and community access.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes ecological suitability and habitat effects.
- Includes local access needs within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.8 — Ecosystem restoration
Plan ecosystem restoration around the right habitat, its functions and measurable recovery.
Worked examples
1. A cause before a symptom
Worked classroom example
Fictional stream planting fails while polluted discharge continues.
Question: What should the plan address?
Answer: The ongoing pollution source as well as habitat repair.
New plants alone do not remove the pressure that prevents recovery.
2. Water storage
Worked classroom example
Toy wetland store starts 20, gains 30 and releases 15; capacity 50.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 35 water units.
The balance illustrates storage only. It does not measure biodiversity or certify protection from every flood.
3. Measure the goal
Worked classroom example
A fictional project aims to restore native habitat but reports only visitor numbers.
Question: What better evidence is needed?
Answer: Native-species recovery and habitat condition.
A measure must match the intended outcome; popularity alone is not ecosystem recovery.
Formative quiz
Match ecosystem and function
Match ecosystem and function · evidence 1
Fictional damaged wetland needs restored water flow.
Match ecosystem and function · evidence 2
A nearby intact grassland is a different natural habitat.
1. What directly addresses the wetland problem?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Assess and restore suitable water connections.
- A grassland label proves an empty wasteland.
- Decorative planting guarantees wetland recovery.
- Replace both places with identical trees.
Different ecosystems need different processes; existing natural habitat should not be erased without assessment.
Track stored water
Track stored water · evidence 1
Toy wetland: initial 20; inflow 30; outflow 15; capacity 50.
2. Track stored water: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the ending storage?
- What is the net addition?
Available labels: The store gains 15 units. | 65 water units remain. | 35 water units remain.
20+30−15=35; this is simplified water bookkeeping.
Compare runoff assumptions
Compare runoff assumptions · evidence 1
Toy rainfall 80. Restored surface assumes 50% infiltration; damaged surface 25%. No other paths are counted.
3. Compare runoff assumptions: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is restored-surface runoff?
- What is damaged-surface runoff?
Available labels: Damaged runoff is 60 units. | Restored runoff is 40 units. | Restored runoff is 60 units.
Half of eighty runs off in the first case; three-quarters in the second.
Choose the right indicator
Choose the right indicator · evidence 1
Fictional goal: recover native wetland plants.
Choose the right indicator · evidence 2
Candidate records include native cover, souvenir sales, poster colour and launch attendance.
4. Choose the right indicator: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which indicator directly matches the goal?
- What would strengthen it?
Available labels: Souvenir sales directly measure native cover. | Track the same habitat over time. | Native plant cover matches the goal.
Native-cover observations address the ecological outcome rather than publicity.
Explain persistent damage
Explain persistent damage · evidence 1
A fictional riverbank is planted,
Explain persistent damage · evidence 2
an upstream activity continues causing heavy sediment that buries seedlings.
5. Explain why planting alone may fail and what further action to investigate.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the continuing cause of failure.
- Proposes investigating or reducing that cause.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a restoration indicator
Apply a restoration indicator · evidence 1
Fictional same-area native cover: baseline 20%, then 25%, 35%, 40% over three checks. Other conditions are recorded separately.
6. What is the endpoint increase?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The area is fully recovered at 40%.
- Native cover rises by 40 percentage points.
- Cover alone measures every ecosystem function under the stated conditions.
- Native cover rises by 20 percentage points.
Forty minus twenty is twenty percentage points; other functions still require assessment.
7. Describe the change and explain why it is not proof of complete ecosystem recovery.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the correct cover change.
- Names another relevant function or pressure to assess.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify addressing the cause
Justify addressing the cause · evidence 1
Fictional A replants each year while pollution continues.
Justify addressing the cause · evidence 2
B first controls the pollution source, then helps suitable vegetation recover.
8. True or false: A removes the source by planting alone.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Removing the continuing pressure gives recovery a more plausible basis, though outcomes still need monitoring.
9. Justify B and name a measure showing whether the pressure actually falls.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects B to the cause of damage.
- Proposes a relevant pressure measurement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to limited storage
Transfer to limited storage · evidence 1
Toy restored wetland starts 40, gains 50 and releases 20; capacity 60.
10. What does the storage limit imply? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- No water can overflow a wetland.
- 10 water units overflow.
- Only 20 water units remain.
- Restoration gives unlimited capacity.
Unconstrained storage is seventy; capacity sixty leaves ten overflow.
11. Explain why restoration can help without preventing every flood and name a complementary measure.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses finite capacity and modeled overflow.
- Names a relevant complementary measure.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the planting-count claim
Repair the planting-count claim · evidence 1
A fictional report says, “We planted 100 stems, so the ecosystem is restored.”
Repair the planting-count claim · evidence 2
Survival, native suitability and ongoing pollution have not been checked.
12. Repair the planting-count claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the error?
- What evidence is missing?
Available labels: A hundred stems proves every function works. | Planting count is treated as verified recovery. | Survival, suitability and habitat condition need checks.
An action count does not establish living recovery or removal of the damage cause.
13. Rewrite the claim and identify two useful outcome checks.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Separates planting action from achieved recovery.
- Names two relevant outcome checks.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a restoration plan
Design a restoration plan · evidence 1
Fictional budget 9: cause assessment 3, suitable recovery action 3, monitoring 2. Goal: restore habitat without damaging an intact neighbouring area.
14. Design a restoration plan: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which full plan fits?
- What boundary must the plan respect?
Available labels: All three components cost 8 tokens. | All three components cost 11 tokens. | Protect the intact neighbouring habitat.
The eight-token sequence addresses cause, suitable action and outcome while retaining the stated constraint.
15. Propose a plan within budget that addresses damage and checks recovery without harming the neighbour.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Addresses cause and suitable action within budget.
- Includes monitoring and protection of neighbouring habitat.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.9 — Community adaptation
Build community adaptation plans that include different needs and measure who benefits.
Worked examples
1. Who benefits?
Worked classroom example
Fictional plan serves 40 households but none of 10 remote households with the greatest water barrier.
Question: What question should be asked?
Answer: How can the plan reach or appropriately serve the excluded households?
A total beneficiary count can hide important access differences.
2. A measurable goal
Worked classroom example
Fictional project promises “improvement” without a measure or date.
Question: How can it become testable?
Answer: Name a target such as usable water access and a review date.
A clear outcome allows evidence of success or needed adjustment.
3. Delivery and use
Worked classroom example
A community installs 3 shaded benches, but all are behind a locked gate during school pickup.
Question: What has been delivered, and what has not?
Answer: Benches were installed; usable waiting access is unproven.
The project must match when and how people need the service.
Formative quiz
Choose an inclusive meeting
Choose an inclusive meeting · evidence 1
Fictional A meets upstairs with no remote option
Choose an inclusive meeting · evidence 2
B uses an accessible ground-floor room and offers a second time for shift workers.
1. Which plan better addresses the stated barriers?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Attendance alone proves all views are represented.
- One meeting time suits every worker.
- A removes every mobility barrier under the stated conditions.
- B offers accessible space and another time.
B responds to two stated participation needs rather than assuming identical access.
Inspect heat exposure
Inspect heat exposure · evidence 1
Toy shade model: base 28, extra 4, full-shade reduction 4. A public queue has 0% shade; a proposed setting is 50%.
2. Inspect heat exposure: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Responsible local assessment is still needed.
- The model indicator becomes 30.
- The model indicator becomes 28.
- The toy result guarantees medical safety.
The model drops from thirty-two to thirty; real exposure and access require assessment.
Give responsibility a name
Give responsibility a name · evidence 1
Fictional water-point plan: service team maintains the pump
Give responsibility a name · evidence 2
community monitor reports faults
Give responsibility a name · evidence 3
trained adults handle repairs.
3. Give responsibility a name: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Who maintains the pump?
- What is the monitor’s assigned role?
Available labels: The monitor reports faults. | The service team maintains it. | Children should repair electrical wiring.
Clear roles separate reporting from qualified repair and continued maintenance.
Track available water
Track available water · evidence 1
Toy community store starts 50, gains 10 and supplies 15; capacity 100. It models volume only.
4. True or false: The store rises to 55 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The five-unit net loss is a quantity issue; quality and access are separate conditions.
Explain a useful outcome
Explain a useful outcome · evidence 1
A fictional project adds a public shade area, but remote pupils cannot reach it during their waiting period.
5. Explain why installation count is insufficient and suggest an access improvement.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the mismatch between facility and actual need.
- Proposes a relevant access or timing improvement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply beneficiary evidence
Apply beneficiary evidence · evidence 1
Fictional areas: town 30 households, all served; remote 10 households, only 2 served.
6. What is the remote service gap? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Eight remote households remain unserved.
- The total proves equal access by area.
- Two remote households remain unserved.
- All forty households are served.
Ten minus two is eight; thirty plus two is thirty-two, with unequal coverage.
7. Explain why the total coverage hides a local problem using both groups.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the contrasting group coverage.
- Explains the hidden remote access gap.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify shared maintenance
Justify shared maintenance · evidence 1
Fictional A buys a tank without a maintenance plan.
Justify shared maintenance · evidence 2
B buys a suitable tank, names a trained service team and budgets inspections.
Justify shared maintenance · evidence 3
Both store the same volume.
8. True or false: B includes responsible maintenance and inspections.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Equal capacity does not imply equal readiness or long-term service.
9. Justify B and name an outcome showing whether the service stays useful.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the maintenance/responsibility difference.
- Names a relevant service outcome.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a different group
Transfer to a different group · evidence 1
A fictional shade plan suits seated visitors,
Transfer to a different group · evidence 2
market vendors must remain beside their stalls.
Transfer to a different group · evidence 3
A portable approved canopy is possible after local assessment.
10. Transfer to a different group: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Vendors should be ignored in the plan.
- Vendors cannot all leave work for the seated area.
- The original seating fits every work pattern.
- Assess shade that works beside their stalls.
An option must fit how the affected group uses the space.
11. Adapt the plan and explain why consultation with vendors matters.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a relevant work-compatible adjustment.
- Uses consultation to identify actual needs or constraints.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the satisfaction claim
Repair the satisfaction claim · evidence 1
A report says everyone approves a project because all 12 online respondents approve.
Repair the satisfaction claim · evidence 2
The community has 60 households, and 20 lack internet access.
12. Repair the satisfaction claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the sampling problem?
- How many households exist in total?
Available labels: The online responses can exclude offline households. | Twelve responses prove all sixty approve. | There are 60 households.
Neither universal approval nor universal opposition follows; access and nonresponse can bias the sample.
13. Correct the conclusion and suggest a more inclusive way to gather views.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the conclusion to actual respondents.
- Addresses the internet-access exclusion.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a community review
Design a community review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: accessible consultation 3, small service trial 3, outcome records 2. Goal: improve a shared facility while including remote users.
14. Which full plan fits?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- A town total proves every remote need is met.
- All three actions cost 8 tokens.
- All three actions cost 10 tokens.
- Consultation alone guarantees the facility works.
The plan combines participation, trial and records, with access examined across groups.
15. Propose an eight-token plan and specify how remote users’ experience will be checked.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Fits budget and includes meaningful consultation/trial.
- Specifically checks remote users rather than totals alone.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
- UNDRR: Early warning systems
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL6.10 — Early-warning systems
Explain the full warning chain from risk knowledge to accessible action.
Worked examples
1. Four linked tasks
Worked classroom example
Fictional system maps exposed homes, monitors rainfall, issues official messages and practises an accessible response.
Question: Why are all four needed?
Answer: They connect risk, observation, communication and action.
A sensor alone cannot ensure that people know what to do or can do it.
2. A threshold exercise
Worked classroom example
Practice-only gauge readings are 4, 5, 7 and 8. The exercise flags readings at least 7.
Question: Which are flagged?
Answer: 7 and 8.
The inclusive threshold matters. These invented numbers have no real warning meaning.
3. Message reach
Worked classroom example
Fictional message sent to 40 households; 30 confirm receipt.
Question: How many receipts remain unconfirmed?
Answer: 10.
Sent and confirmed are different states. Alternative channels may be needed to reach those households.
Formative quiz
Build the warning chain
Build the warning chain · evidence 1
Fictional tasks: map exposed households
Build the warning chain · evidence 2
monitor river levels
Build the warning chain · evidence 3
communicate official warnings
Build the warning chain · evidence 4
practise accessible response.
1. Build the warning chain: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which task builds risk knowledge?
- Which task checks changing conditions?
Available labels: A siren alone maps every household. | Mapping identifies exposed households. | Monitoring follows river levels.
Risk knowledge and monitoring have distinct roles alongside communication and response.
Inspect message quality
Inspect message quality · evidence 1
Fictional official practice message gives source, date, affected area and action.
Inspect message quality · evidence 2
A forwarded image omits date and source.
2. Inspect message quality: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- It specifies the affected area and action.
- The official message names its source and date.
- A dramatic image replaces action instructions.
- An undated image proves current conditions.
Authority, currency and usable instructions are different parts of message quality.
Read an exercise threshold
Read an exercise threshold · evidence 1
Practice-only readings are 3, 5, 7, 6 and 8. The exercise flags values at least 7; these are not actual alert levels.
3. True or false: Two readings reach the practice threshold.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
At least seven includes seven itself; seven and eight qualify.
Check who received it
Check who received it · evidence 1
Fictional alert exercise: 40 households; 30 confirm phone receipt; 10 are unconfirmed. An official radio and adult relay are available.
4. Check who received it: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- How many still need receipt checking?
- What can help reach them?
Available labels: 10 households are unconfirmed. | All 40 receipts are confirmed. | Use the authorised alternative channels.
Ten lack confirmation; another authorised route can help without assuming why receipt failed.
Explain a response gap
Explain a response gap · evidence 1
In a fictional drill, every household hears a warning,
Explain a response gap · evidence 2
one group cannot use the only route because it has steps.
5. Explain why the system is incomplete and identify the needed improvement.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes receipt from ability to act.
- Addresses the specific accessibility barrier.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a reach calculation
Apply a reach calculation · evidence 1
Fictional drill: 60 households; phone confirms 35; radio confirms 15 different households; no overlap. Ten remain unconfirmed.
6. Apply a reach calculation: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- How many have confirmed receipt?
- How many remain unconfirmed?
Available labels: 50 households have confirmed receipt. | All 60 households confirmed receipt. | 10 households remain unconfirmed.
Here groups do not overlap, so thirty-five plus fifteen equals fifty; ten remain.
7. Explain the confirmed total and why the no-overlap condition matters.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates fifty correctly.
- Explains why duplicate recipients must not be counted twice.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a complete system
Justify a complete system · evidence 1
Fictional A buys sensors only.
Justify a complete system · evidence 2
B combines maintained sensors, official accessible messages and a practised response informed by local risk maps.
8. Justify a complete system: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which plan covers the full chain?
- What does A leave unresolved?
Available labels: A leaves message reach and response unplanned. | A sensors-only purchase completes every link. | B connects risk, monitoring, communication and response.
B includes the linked functions; sensors are useful but insufficient alone.
9. Justify B using two links beyond sensing.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the communication/receipt link.
- Explains prepared feasible response or risk-informed action.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a higher model level
Transfer to a higher model level · evidence 1
Practice map: ground path 35 cm above datum. Toy water surface rises from 30 to 40. Official drill planners must review routes.
10. True or false: The path stays dry under both levels.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Thirty is below the path, forty above it; authorised response planning must adapt.
11. Explain why the warning action may need to change, even if messages still arrive.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the changed route exposure.
- Distinguishes message delivery from feasible response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a sent-equals-safe claim
Repair a sent-equals-safe claim · evidence 1
A report says, “We sent 100 texts, so 100 households are safe.”
Repair a sent-equals-safe claim · evidence 2
It has no receipt, understanding or action records.
12. What does the record establish? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- It establishes that all households acted safely.
- It establishes that 100 texts were sent.
- A sent count measures route accessibility.
- No receipt means every message failed.
Sending alone proves neither success nor universal failure of later links.
13. Correct the claim and name one receipt/understanding check and one check of people’s ability to take the approved action.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the claim to sending.
- Checks communication success and feasible response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a warning drill
Design a warning drill · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: risk-map review 2, sensor check 2, accessible-message test 2, response practice 2. Goal: test the full chain.
14. Design a warning drill: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A sensor check proves every household can move.
- All four checks cost 8 tokens.
- A sensor-only check would miss message access and response.
- All four checks cost 10 tokens.
Each two-token check tests a distinct link in the warning chain.
15. Propose an eight-token drill and explain how it verifies both receipt and ability to act.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes direct receipt/understanding checks.
- Includes feasible inclusive response practice within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- UNDRR: Early warning systems
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.1 — Evaluating proposed climate solutions
Evaluate whether a proposed solution addresses the problem and has checkable evidence.
Worked examples
1. A matching mechanism
Worked classroom example
Fictional problem: lamps run in empty rooms. Proposal: an approved timer.
Question: Why is the proposal relevant?
Answer: It can reduce unnecessary operating time.
The mechanism addresses the stated waste. Check actual use and whether needed lighting remains available.
2. A claim needs a boundary
Worked classroom example
Toy product claims 40% savings but gives no baseline or useful output.
Question: What should be requested?
Answer: Comparable before/after data and the counted service.
A percentage cannot be evaluated well without knowing what it compares.
3. A conditional choice
Worked classroom example
A fictional local trial saves 10 units at equal service; performance during outages is unknown.
Question: What is a reasonable recommendation?
Answer: Consider adoption after checking outage performance.
The recommendation uses available evidence and names a remaining condition rather than promising universal success.
Formative quiz
Match action to problem
Match action to problem · evidence 1
Fictional problem: empty-room lights remain on.
Match action to problem · evidence 2
Options: approved timers, repainting desks, changing book covers or adding a notice without action checks.
1. Which option directly controls unnecessary running time?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Book-cover changes measure electrical use.
- Approved timers can control empty-room operation.
- Repainting desks controls light operating hours.
- A notice proves equipment is switched off.
Timers address the mechanism, but the useful service still needs verification.
Classify the evidence
Classify the evidence · evidence 1
Fictional evidence: a local equal-service energy trial
Classify the evidence · evidence 2
a product photograph
Classify the evidence · evidence 3
an advertised target
Classify the evidence · evidence 4
an after-installation meter record.
2. Classify the evidence: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which record tests the proposed energy benefit?
- Which record mainly shows appearance?
Available labels: The equal-service trial tests the benefit. | The photograph mainly shows appearance. | A photograph measures all future energy use.
The form of evidence determines which claim it can support.
Read a complete result
Read a complete result · evidence 1
Fictional trial: energy falls from 50 to 40 units for equal lighting; maintenance costs 2 tokens per month and is required.
3. Read a complete result: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Monthly maintenance needs 2 tokens.
- The trial saves 40 energy units.
- The trial saves 10 energy units.
- No maintenance resources are needed.
The energy saving and maintenance requirement both belong in the decision.
Inspect the missing condition
Inspect the missing condition · evidence 1
Fictional device needs electricity throughout operation.
Inspect the missing condition · evidence 2
The site has regular outages and no verified backup.
4. What should be checked before relying on the device? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Outages cannot affect powered equipment.
- A device label proves backup exists.
- Assume uninterrupted power at the site.
- Check operation during power outages.
The device’s requirements conflict with a stated local condition.
Explain a cautious recommendation
Explain a cautious recommendation · evidence 1
Fictional solution A saves 8 units in a relevant local trial.
Explain a cautious recommendation · evidence 2
B promises 20 without methods.
Explain a cautious recommendation · evidence 3
Both aim at the same service.
5. Recommend a next step using the evidence and name a needed check for B.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses A’s relevant measured evidence without treating promises as results.
- Requests an appropriate test or evidence for B.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a solution mechanism
Apply a solution mechanism · evidence 1
Fictional school uses 100 energy units, including 20 from empty-room operation. A timer removes 15 of those 20 without affecting occupied lessons.
6. Apply a solution mechanism: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is the new total?
- How much avoidable use remains?
Available labels: The new total is 80 units. | 5 avoidable units remain. | The new total is 85 units.
The timer removes fifteen from one hundred and fifteen from the twenty-unit waste component.
7. Explain the mechanism and one reason to keep monitoring.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects the timer to avoided unneeded operation.
- Identifies remaining waste or the need to verify actual use/service.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify the stronger evidence
Justify the stronger evidence · evidence 1
Fictional A reports equal-service before/after measurements with methods.
Justify the stronger evidence · evidence 2
B shows a celebrity endorsement without measurements.
8. Which provides stronger performance evidence?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Popularity settles the performance question.
- An endorsement measures actual energy savings.
- A gives checkable service-matched measurements.
- A’s method guarantees identical results everywhere.
Measurements matching the goal directly test the claim; endorsement does not.
9. Justify using A’s evidence and state one limit that remains.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the relevant controlled service comparison.
- Acknowledges transfer or measurement limits.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer a promising option
Transfer a promising option · evidence 1
Fictional roof shade works on building P, which has suitable load capacity.
Transfer a promising option · evidence 2
Building Q’s capacity and roof condition are unknown.
10. True or false: Success on P proves Q needs no suitability assessment.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
An action that works at one site still needs the relevant safety and feasibility conditions at another.
11. Explain why the result cannot transfer automatically and identify the needed evidence.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies an unverified setting-specific condition.
- Requests appropriate qualified suitability evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a technology claim
Repair a technology claim · evidence 1
A fictional advert says, “Our device saved 30% in one test, so it will save exactly 30% in every school.”
Repair a technology claim · evidence 2
Conditions and usage differ.
12. Repair a technology claim: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Tests across relevant conditions would help.
- Every school is identical to the test site.
- One test is treated as a universal guarantee.
- Different usage cannot affect savings.
The test can be informative without establishing an exact result everywhere.
13. Rewrite the claim accurately and name one condition to examine in a new school.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the result to tested conditions.
- Names a relevant local condition for transfer.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an evaluation
Design an evaluation · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: baseline measurement 2, small trial 3, service/access check 2. Goal: choose an energy solution without reducing needed learning service.
14. Design an evaluation: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which full evaluation fits?
- What protects the stated service goal?
Available labels: All three actions cost 7 tokens. | Check lighting and access during the trial. | All three actions cost 10 tokens.
The seven-token plan connects baseline, tested change and retained service.
15. Propose an evaluation within budget and name the two results you would compare.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a comparable energy evaluation within budget.
- Checks preservation of useful service or access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.2 — Comparing costs, benefits and risks
Compare costs, benefits and uncertain risks using explicit criteria and limits.
Worked examples
1. Three-year cost
Worked classroom example
Toy project A costs 4 initially and 2 yearly for three years.
Question: What is the total?
Answer: 10 tokens.
Count 4+3×2. State whether yearly payments include the first year; here there are exactly three.
2. Budget and reach
Worked classroom example
Fictional A costs 5 and serves 20; B costs 8 and serves 40. Budget is 6.
Question: Which is affordable unchanged?
Answer: A.
B may have greater reach, but it violates the stated budget unless resources or scope change.
3. A range matters
Worked classroom example
Toy maintenance may cost 2–5 tokens; only 3 are reserved.
Question: What risk remains?
Answer: The reserve may be insufficient.
A range is not a guarantee of the cheapest case. A contingency or revised plan may be needed.
Formative quiz
Separate decision criteria
Separate decision criteria · evidence 1
Fictional tank proposal: purchase costs 6 tokens
Separate decision criteria · evidence 2
it adds 30 water units of storage
Separate decision criteria · evidence 3
poor maintenance could cause service failure.
1. Separate decision criteria: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which is the purchase cost?
- Which is the capacity benefit?
Available labels: The purchase cost is 6 tokens. | The purchase cost is 30 water units. | The added capacity is 30 water units.
Money, capacity and possible failure describe different criteria.
Count the time boundary
Count the time boundary · evidence 1
Toy A: 4 upfront plus 2 yearly for three years. B: 7 upfront plus 1 yearly for three years. Same service.
2. Count the time boundary: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is A’s three-year total?
- What is B’s three-year total?
Available labels: B also costs 10 tokens in total. | A costs 6 tokens in total. | A costs 10 tokens in total.
Both totals are ten when the same three yearly payments are counted.
Keep the constraint visible
Keep the constraint visible · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8. Shade costs 5 and a water-access check costs 3. Both are required for the chosen plan.
3. Keep the constraint visible: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The two parts cost only 5 tokens.
- The two parts cost exactly 8 tokens.
- Three tokens remain after funding both.
- No unallocated tokens remain.
Five plus three equals eight; the budget is fully allocated.
Read the uncertainty
Read the uncertainty · evidence 1
Fictional trial estimates benefit between 10 and 16 units under different conditions.
Read the uncertainty · evidence 2
No single result is guaranteed.
4. Which claim respects the estimate?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Expected benefit ranges from 10 to 16.
- Every case is guaranteed to give 16.
- A range means no evidence exists.
- The estimate proves zero benefit in all cases.
The range conveys uncertainty; it is neither a guaranteed maximum nor proof of no benefit.
Explain a choice under limits
Explain a choice under limits · evidence 1
Fictional plan A costs 6 and gives 12 benefit units
Explain a choice under limits · evidence 2
B costs 9 and gives 20.
Explain a choice under limits · evidence 3
Budget is 7
Explain a choice under limits · evidence 4
service requirements are met by both.
5. Choose a feasible unchanged plan and explain the trade-off.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Selects A under the fixed budget.
- Recognises the lower benefit compared with B.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply full cost accounting
Apply full cost accounting · evidence 1
Toy A costs 3 upfront and 2 per year for four years. B costs 7 upfront and 1 per year for four years. Equal service.
6. Apply full cost accounting: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is A’s total?
- What is B’s total?
Available labels: A costs 5 tokens. | B also costs 11 tokens. | A costs 11 tokens.
3+8 and 7+4 both equal eleven.
7. Explain why the lower purchase price does not establish lower whole-period cost.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Counts initial and repeated costs.
- Compares the correct equal-period totals.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a constrained choice
Justify a constrained choice · evidence 1
Fictional A costs 7, meets the required service and has checked maintenance.
Justify a constrained choice · evidence 2
B costs 6
Justify a constrained choice · evidence 3
requires a replacement part unavailable locally.
8. Justify a constrained choice: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A has a workable maintenance arrangement.
- B depends on an unavailable replacement part.
- B is automatically best because it costs less.
- A’s higher price proves zero risk.
Feasibility and maintenance risk can matter alongside purchase cost.
9. Justify a choice or conditional revision using both cost and maintenance evidence.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the actual cost difference.
- Addresses the unavailable-part risk.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a longer life
Transfer to a longer life · evidence 1
Toy A costs 4 upfront and 3 yearly; B costs 10 upfront and 1 yearly. Both last five years. A was cheaper for one year.
10. Transfer to a longer life: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is A’s five-year total?
- What is B’s five-year total?
Available labels: B costs 15 tokens over five years. | A costs 7 tokens over five years. | A costs 19 tokens over five years.
4+15=19; 10+5=15, so the longer period changes the cost ranking.
11. Explain why the ranking changes when the period becomes five years.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses both five-year totals correctly.
- Explains accumulation of recurring cost.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair the best-case budget
Repair the best-case budget · evidence 1
A fictional project has possible repair cost 2–6 tokens.
Repair the best-case budget · evidence 2
A report reserves 2 and says, “Every repair is fully covered.”
12. Repair the best-case budget: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What is wrong with the report?
- What is the largest stated shortfall?
Available labels: The reserve could be short by 4 tokens. | Two tokens cover every stated cost. | It treats the lowest cost as a guarantee.
The highest stated six exceeds the two-token reserve by four.
13. State the largest possible gap in the repair reserve, correct the coverage claim and propose a contingency.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Recognises the possible four-token gap.
- Proposes a relevant reserve/contingency response.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a feasible portfolio
Design a feasible portfolio · evidence 1
Fictional budget 10. A costs 6, benefit 12; B costs 4, benefit 7; C costs 5, benefit 8. Benefits are independent. Need at least 18 benefit units.
14. Which combination meets budget and target? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- A alone gives at least 18 units.
- B plus C gives 18 benefit units.
- A plus C costs 10 and gives 20.
- A plus B costs 10 and gives 19.
Only A+B reaches eighteen while staying within ten under the stated independence assumption.
15. Propose a valid portfolio and name one assumption to check before using real estimates.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets the budget and eighteen-unit target.
- Identifies a relevant independence or cost-boundary assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
- IPCC: Synthesis report
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.3 — Considering social effects
Identify how climate actions affect access, daily routines and participation across groups.
Worked examples
1. An opening-hours barrier
Worked classroom example
Fictional cooling area opens at 4 p.m.; pupils wait outside at 2 p.m.
Question: Why is location alone insufficient?
Answer: It is unavailable when needed.
The relevant change is suitable supervised access at the waiting time.
2. Unequal reach
Worked classroom example
Toy project serves 30 of 30 town users and 5 of 20 remote users.
Question: What should be reported beyond 35 users?
Answer: Coverage by group and the remote gap.
A total conceals who still cannot benefit.
3. Hidden work
Worked classroom example
A fictional waste project requires two hours of daily unpaid sorting by one already busy group.
Question: What should planning examine?
Answer: Whether work, resources and responsibilities are fairly shared.
A climate benefit does not erase the labour burden.
Formative quiz
Locate the time barrier
Locate the time barrier · evidence 1
Fictional shade area is near school
Locate the time barrier · evidence 2
opens at 4 p.m.
Locate the time barrier · evidence 3
pickup waiting is at 2 p.m.
Locate the time barrier · evidence 4
Adults can assess revised supervised hours.
1. What is the stated barrier? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The area is already open at pickup.
- A new sign changes the opening time by itself.
- The opening time misses the waiting period.
- Distance is the only possible barrier.
The mismatch is timing, not merely distance or awareness.
Match adjustment to need
Match adjustment to need · evidence 1
Fictional needs: wheelchair access to a meeting room
Match adjustment to need · evidence 2
understanding a notice in a familiar language.
Match adjustment to need · evidence 3
Proposed responses are a usable ramp and accurate accessible-language information.
2. Match adjustment to need: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What addresses the mobility barrier?
- What addresses the language barrier?
Available labels: A usable ramp addresses the entrance barrier. | Accurate familiar-language information helps understanding. | A ramp translates the written notice.
The response should match the specific barrier rather than relying on one generic solution.
Inspect group coverage
Inspect group coverage · evidence 1
Fictional facility serves 24 of 30 nearby users and 4 of 20 distant users.
3. Inspect group coverage: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- How many nearby users remain unserved?
- How many distant users remain unserved?
Available labels: Sixteen distant users remain unserved. | Six nearby users remain unserved. | Sixteen nearby users remain unserved.
Subtract served from each group total; the gaps differ markedly.
Recognise additional work
Recognise additional work · evidence 1
Fictional project needs daily collection.
Recognise additional work · evidence 2
Plan A assigns all work to one group without resources
Recognise additional work · evidence 3
B agrees shared roles and funds safe collection.
4. Which plan addresses the stated labour burden?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- An environmental goal removes labour concerns.
- A provides funded shared collection under the stated conditions.
- B agrees roles and resources for collection.
- B makes all maintenance unnecessary.
Work and resources are part of the project’s social effects.
Explain meaningful participation
Explain meaningful participation · evidence 1
A fictional committee asks residents for suggestions before choosing hours.
Explain meaningful participation · evidence 2
The committee changes the schedule after considering residents’ feedback.
5. Explain two features that make this more than collecting signatures after a decision.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies consultation before final choice.
- Identifies actual influence on the decision.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply access rates
Apply access rates · evidence 1
Fictional programme: group A has 20 users, 18 served; group B has 20, 8 served.
6. Which group has the larger access gap?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Both gaps are equal under the stated conditions.
- The total 26 proves equal coverage.
- Group B has 12 unserved users.
- Group A has 12 unserved users.
Equal group sizes make the difference clear: eighteen versus eight served.
7. Explain why reporting only 26 served users is incomplete.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the different group coverage.
- Explains why the aggregate masks unequal access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify an inclusive schedule
Justify an inclusive schedule · evidence 1
Fictional A holds one meeting during shift workers’ work hours.
Justify an inclusive schedule · evidence 2
B offers two times and an accessible written response option.
8. Justify an inclusive schedule: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which option reduces the stated participation barrier?
- What should still be checked?
Available labels: The options must be usable by affected residents. | A already offers two meeting times. | B provides alternative times and response routes.
B improves opportunities, but actual usability and participation still need checking.
9. Justify B without assuming everyone will participate or agree.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects B to the stated barrier.
- Acknowledges actual participation or differing views rather than assuming agreement.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a new barrier
Transfer to a new barrier · evidence 1
A fictional notice was translated accurately,
Transfer to a new barrier · evidence 2
residents with limited vision still cannot read the small print.
Transfer to a new barrier · evidence 3
An accessible audio version is possible.
10. Transfer to a new barrier: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What adjustment addresses the new barrier?
- What did translation already address?
Available labels: Provide an accessible audio or large-print version. | Translation addressed language understanding. | Repeat the same small print in more copies.
Different needs can require complementary formats; solving one does not solve all.
11. Adapt the communication plan and explain why the earlier change was insufficient.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a format addressing visual access.
- Distinguishes that need from language translation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an equal-items claim
Repair an equal-items claim · evidence 1
A report says, “Both villages got one water tank, so benefits are equal.”
Repair an equal-items claim · evidence 2
A has reliable refilling
Repair an equal-items claim · evidence 3
B’s tank is empty most days.
12. Repair an equal-items claim: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Equal equipment does not prove equal usable service.
- One tank guarantees the same service everywhere.
- Refilling cannot affect water availability.
- Compare reliable water access in both villages.
Actual supply and access differ despite equal equipment counts.
13. Correct the claim and name a useful social outcome measure.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Separates delivered equipment from actual benefit.
- Names a service/access outcome measure.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a socially informed check
Design a socially informed check · evidence 1
Fictional budget 7: accessible consultation 3, group-level access records 2, workload review 2. Goal: improve a climate project without hiding exclusion or unpaid burdens.
14. Design a socially informed check: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What does the complete check cost?
- What can the workload review reveal?
Available labels: The complete check costs 7 tokens. | It can reveal concentrated unpaid burdens. | The complete check costs 9 tokens.
The plan examines voice, access and labour as distinct social dimensions.
15. Propose a review within budget that checks both who benefits and who carries extra work.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes group-level access or inclusion evidence.
- Includes workload/burden evidence within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
- IPCC: Synthesis report
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.4 — Considering economic effects
Evaluate costs, savings, livelihoods and timing without treating money as the only outcome.
Worked examples
1. Simple payback
Worked classroom example
Toy equipment costs 15 tokens and saves 3 net tokens each year.
Question: What is simple payback?
Answer: 5 years.
15÷3=5, assuming the annual saving continues and the device lasts that long.
2. Five-year balance
Worked classroom example
Toy cost 10; annual saving 4 for five years; no other costs in this example.
Question: What is savings minus initial cost?
Answer: 10 tokens.
Five times four is twenty; subtract ten. This simplified balance omits unstated real-world costs.
3. A skill transition
Worked classroom example
Fictional workshop adopts new equipment requiring training.
Question: Why count training time and cost?
Answer: Workers need a realistic path to operate and maintain it.
Equipment purchase alone does not create the required skills or preserve livelihoods automatically.
Formative quiz
Separate the cash flows
Separate the cash flows · evidence 1
Toy project costs 12 upfront and saves 3 net tokens yearly. No other costs are assumed.
1. True or false: Simple payback is 9 years.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Twelve divided by three gives four; the calculation depends on continuing savings.
Locate a missing cost
Locate a missing cost · evidence 1
Fictional proposal lists equipment 6 and installation 2.
Locate a missing cost · evidence 2
Maintenance costs 1 each year for three years,
Locate a missing cost · evidence 3
the headline total is 8.
2. What is the three-year total including maintenance? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Maintenance is already counted three times in 8.
- The complete total is 9 tokens.
- The complete total is 8 tokens.
- The total is 11 tokens.
Six plus two plus three equals eleven.
Connect workers to needs
Connect workers to needs · evidence 1
Fictional change creates repair jobs requiring new skills.
Connect workers to needs · evidence 2
Existing workers can attend a funded course,
Connect workers to needs · evidence 3
only if schedules allow.
3. Connect workers to needs: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What action addresses the skill requirement?
- What access condition needs checking?
Available labels: Training times must fit workers’ circumstances. | Provide usable training for existing workers. | New equipment automatically gives everyone skills.
Training must be both available and practically accessible.
Compare useful service
Compare useful service · evidence 1
Fictional before: 10 lessons cost 40 tokens. After: 5 lessons cost 25. The report claims lower cost per lesson.
4. What is the after cost per lesson?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The after cost is 5 tokens per lesson.
- The after cost is 2 tokens per lesson.
- Both periods contain the same lesson count.
- A smaller total proves a smaller rate under the stated conditions.
Twenty-five divided by five is five, higher than forty divided by ten.
Explain a livelihood effect
Explain a livelihood effect · evidence 1
A fictional climate project closes an old service and creates a new one elsewhere.
Explain a livelihood effect · evidence 2
New jobs require different skills and travel.
5. Name one skill or training effect and one job-access or travel effect that should be assessed beyond the total job count.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies skills or transition needs.
- Identifies location, travel, timing or job-access effects.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a full-period balance
Apply a full-period balance · evidence 1
Toy project costs 20 upfront. It saves 6 per year and needs 1 yearly maintenance for five years.
6. Apply a full-period balance: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Annual net saving is 7 tokens.
- The five-year net gain is 5 tokens.
- Five-year net gain is 30 tokens.
- Annual net saving is 5 tokens.
Annual net is six minus one; five years gives twenty-five, less initial twenty leaves five.
7. Show the five-year balance and state one condition behind it.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates the five-token net gain correctly.
- States a relevant lifespan or stable-saving assumption.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a realistic estimate
Justify a realistic estimate · evidence 1
Fictional A includes purchase, maintenance and training over five years.
Justify a realistic estimate · evidence 2
B quotes purchase only for the same service.
8. True or false: A includes the relevant repeated and transition costs.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A defined common boundary is needed before comparing totals.
9. Justify requesting more information from B and name the time boundary to use.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies missing relevant cost categories.
- Uses the common five-year comparison period.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to lower use
Transfer to lower use · evidence 1
Toy device costs 12. At full use it saves 4 net tokens yearly; at lower use it saves only 2. Lifetime is 5 years.
10. Transfer to lower use: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is payback at lower use?
- How does that compare with lifetime?
Available labels: Lower-use payback is 3 years. | Lower-use payback is 6 years. | It exceeds the stated 5-year lifetime.
Twelve divided by two is six; the device lasts only five under the assumption.
11. Explain how lower use changes the financial case without claiming money is the only criterion.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses six-year payback versus five-year life.
- Recognises other criteria without hiding the changed economics.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a job-count claim
Repair a job-count claim · evidence 1
A report says, “Ten old jobs ended and ten new jobs appeared, so nobody is affected.”
Repair a job-count claim · evidence 2
The new jobs require different skills and are far away.
12. What is the error?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Every displaced worker already has a new job.
- Ten new jobs proves no transition is needed.
- Location cannot change job access under the stated conditions.
- Equal counts do not prove the same people benefit.
Who can obtain the work matters as well as the total count.
13. Correct the claim and name one practical transition measure.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes job totals from individual access.
- Proposes a relevant skills/location transition measure.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an economic review
Design an economic review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: full cost record 3, worker consultation 2, service/saving measurement 2. Goal: evaluate a climate upgrade without overlooking livelihoods.
14. Design an economic review: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which full review fits?
- What does worker consultation add?
Available labels: All three checks cost 10 tokens. | It identifies livelihood and transition effects. | All three checks cost 7 tokens.
The plan covers economic quantities, actual service and affected people.
15. Propose a review within budget with one cost measure and one livelihood measure.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes a meaningful full-period cost/saving measure.
- Includes livelihood or transition evidence within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Synthesis report
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.5 — Considering climate justice
Reason about climate fairness using needs, responsibility, participation and the distribution of effects.
Worked examples
1. Same warning, different access
Worked classroom example
Fictional village sends the same app alert to all households, but 15 have no usable smartphones.
Question: What fairness problem remains?
Answer: Those households lack an effective warning route.
Equal sending does not produce equal receipt; appropriate alternative channels can address the barrier.
2. Needs-based allocation
Worked classroom example
Toy rule: first provide one safe-water kit to each of 8 households with no access; budget holds 10 kits.
Question: How many remain after meeting that priority?
Answer: 2 kits.
The allocation follows an explicit need-based rule; the reason and remaining choices should be explained.
3. Voice in planning
Worked classroom example
A fictional coastal project affects fishers, but meetings exclude them.
Question: What should be improved?
Answer: Meaningful accessible participation by affected fishers.
Their access and livelihood knowledge is relevant to evaluating the proposal.
Formative quiz
Check actual opportunity
Check actual opportunity · evidence 1
Fictional app alert is sent to 40 households
Check actual opportunity · evidence 2
10 lack usable smartphones.
Check actual opportunity · evidence 3
An official radio message is available.
1. True or false: The ten households lack the required phone access.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
A shared message still needs usable channels; sending and receiving differ.
Follow an explicit need rule
Follow an explicit need rule · evidence 1
Classroom allocation rule: give one kit first to each household with no safe-water access. There are 6 such households and 4 already served; 8 kits are available.
2. Follow an explicit need rule: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- How many kits meet the stated first priority?
- How many kits then remain?
Available labels: Six kits meet the first priority. | Four kits meet the first priority. | Two kits remain for further allocation.
The answer follows the explicit priority rule, not an unstated political preference.
Connect fairness dimensions
Connect fairness dimensions · evidence 1
Fictional review asks who receives benefits, who can participate and who faces extra costs.
Connect fairness dimensions · evidence 2
These are different questions.
3. Connect fairness dimensions: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which question addresses participation?
- Which question addresses burdens?
Available labels: Ask who can influence the decision. | Ask who carries the extra costs. | Participation means only counting equipment.
Different fairness dimensions need different evidence.
Read responsibility carefully
Read responsibility carefully · evidence 1
Fictional groups A and B each have 20 households. Practice records give A 80 historical emission units and B 20; current exposure is 5 and 15 households respectively. These are invented units.
4. Read responsibility carefully: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which group has greater recorded historical emissions?
- Which group has more currently exposed households?
Available labels: A has greater recorded historical emissions. | B has more currently exposed households. | B has greater recorded historical emissions.
Responsibility and exposure point to different features; the values inform, rather than automatically settle, a proposal.
Explain meaningful voice
Explain meaningful voice · evidence 1
A fictional committee invites residents only after approving a project.
Explain meaningful voice · evidence 2
No changes or appeals are allowed.
5. Explain why this is limited participation and propose one improvement.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the absence of influence on the decision.
- Proposes a meaningful opportunity to influence or revise it.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a stated access goal
Apply a stated access goal · evidence 1
Fictional goal: every household has a usable warning route. Of 50 households, 35 can use the app and 15 cannot; an official radio route could reach those 15.
6. Apply a stated access goal: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What action addresses the stated access gap?
- What should be confirmed afterward?
Available labels: Confirm usable receipt across all 50 households. | Provide a verified alternative for the 15 households. | Send the same app alert again only.
The goal is usable access, so the gap requires an effective alternative and verification.
7. Explain why the alternative is justified by the goal rather than by giving everyone identical tools.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the fifteen-household barrier.
- Explains equal usable opportunity through suitable different means.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a transparent allocation
Justify a transparent allocation · evidence 1
Fictional funds can protect 10 households now.
Justify a transparent allocation · evidence 2
A published rule prioritises 8 with highest verified exposure, then 2 with next-highest exposure.
Justify a transparent allocation · evidence 3
Residents can review the evidence.
8. Justify a transparent allocation: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What makes this allocation checkable?
- What gives residents a voice?
Available labels: Residents can review the evidence and decision. | The priority rule and evidence are published. | The rule guarantees no reasonable disagreement.
Transparency and review make reasons visible without making every judgment beyond question.
9. Justify two features of the process and state that alternatives may still need discussion.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses transparent stated criteria and evidence.
- Recognises meaningful review or reasonable alternative considerations.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a different barrier
Transfer to a different barrier · evidence 1
A fictional programme adds a ramp,
Transfer to a different barrier · evidence 2
some remote residents cannot afford the fare to reach the facility.
Transfer to a different barrier · evidence 3
Budget exists for a transport trial.
10. Transfer to a different barrier: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A ramp automatically pays travel fares.
- Affordable travel remains a barrier.
- The new barrier proves the ramp was useless.
- Test a suitable affordable transport arrangement.
Removing one barrier can help while another still prevents usable access.
11. Adapt the proposal and explain why fairness needs more than the same entrance design.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Addresses the fare/travel barrier.
- Explains practical opportunity beyond identical facility design.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a blame claim
Repair a blame claim · evidence 1
Using fictional records, a pupil says, “Group B emitted fewer units, so none of its members needs to take part in any solution.”
Repair a blame claim · evidence 2
Both groups use shared water and transport systems.
12. True or false: Group B’s lower recorded emissions prove it has no role in shared-system decisions.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Responsibilities can differ while shared systems still need inclusive cooperation.
13. Correct the claim while preserving the relevance of different responsibilities.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Preserves the relevance of differing responsibility.
- Includes fair participation or cooperation without requiring identical burdens.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an inclusive fairness review
Design an inclusive fairness review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: exposure/access mapping 3, accessible consultation 3, public review of criteria 2. Goal: allocate assistance with transparent reasons.
14. Which full review fits?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- All three activities cost 10 tokens.
- All three activities cost 8 tokens.
- A public review must require unanimous agreement.
- Need mapping alone guarantees meaningful voice.
The review combines evidence, participation and transparent reasons.
15. Propose a review within budget that checks needs and allows affected people to influence criteria.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Includes relevant need/exposure evidence.
- Includes meaningful accessible influence and transparent reasons within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
- IPCC: Synthesis report
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.6 — Considering different perspectives
Compare perspectives respectfully while keeping factual claims open to evidence.
Worked examples
1. Fact and value
Worked classroom example
Fictional speaker: “The route is 2 km; I prefer quiet travel.”
Question: Which part can a map check?
Answer: The 2 km distance.
The quiet-travel preference is a value to consider, not a distance measurement.
2. A shared goal
Worked classroom example
Two fictional groups want safe school access; one prefers walking, the other shared rides.
Question: What do they agree on?
Answer: Safe access to school.
Discuss the methods and relevant needs without pretending they disagree about the broad goal.
3. A faithful summary
Worked classroom example
A vendor asks for loading access before market hours, not unlimited traffic all day.
Question: What summary preserves the view?
Answer: The vendor wants timed loading access.
An exaggerated summary would make evaluation less fair and miss a practical compromise.
Formative quiz
Identify a shared aim
Identify a shared aim · evidence 1
Fictional pupils want safe crossings
Identify a shared aim · evidence 2
drivers want reliable pickup without dangerous stops.
Identify a shared aim · evidence 3
Both agree on safe school access.
1. What goal do both groups share?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Pupils oppose every form of transport.
- Drivers ask for dangerous stopping.
- Both want safe school access.
- The groups share no possible goal.
The source gives a common aim and distinct practical concerns.
Sort claims and priorities
Sort claims and priorities · evidence 1
Fictional statement: “The route is 2 km.
Sort claims and priorities · evidence 2
I value a quiet trip.
Sort claims and priorities · evidence 3
We assume the bus arrives every ten minutes,
Sort claims and priorities · evidence 4
have not checked.”
2. Sort claims and priorities: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which statement is a checkable distance claim?
- Which statement is an unverified assumption?
Available labels: The route is 2 km. | Quiet is the measured route distance. | The bus comes every ten minutes.
Distance can be checked; the bus frequency is explicitly unverified.
Read two viewpoints accurately
Read two viewpoints accurately · evidence 1
Fictional vendor requests loading from 6–7 a.m.
Read two viewpoints accurately · evidence 2
Pupils request safer crossings during 7–8 a.m.
Read two viewpoints accurately · evidence 3
Neither requests unlimited vehicle access.
3. Read two viewpoints accurately: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The vendor demands unlimited access all day.
- Loading access is requested from 6–7 a.m.
- Pupils demand a complete permanent road closure.
- Safer crossings are requested from 7–8 a.m.
The requests concern different windows, creating a possible compatible arrangement to assess.
Link perspective to evidence
Link perspective to evidence · evidence 1
Fictional wheelchair user identifies steps on route A. A map confirms the steps; route B has a usable ramp after official assessment.
4. Link perspective to evidence: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What evidence supports the concern about A?
- What alternative meets the stated access condition?
Available labels: Route B provides the verified ramp. | The concern proves every route is unusable. | The map confirms steps on route A.
The specific concern is supported and a relevant alternative is identified.
Explain fair listening
Explain fair listening · evidence 1
A fictional meeting repeats only a critic’s weakest sentence and ignores their request for maintenance evidence.
5. Explain why that summary is unfair and give a better way to respond.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the distorted or incomplete representation.
- Responds to the actual evidence concern.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply fact-value distinctions
Apply fact-value distinctions · evidence 1
Fictional proposal: measured travel time 15 minutes
Apply fact-value distinctions · evidence 2
a parent values reliability
Apply fact-value distinctions · evidence 3
a report assumes everyone owns a smartphone without checking.
6. Apply fact-value distinctions: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which statement needs verification as an assumption?
- Which statement expresses a priority?
Available labels: The parent values reliability. | Universal smartphone ownership needs checking. | A reliability preference measures phone ownership.
The assumption is unverified, not necessarily false; the priority is a value.
7. Explain how to respond differently to the phone assumption and the reliability preference.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Requests evidence for the factual assumption.
- Treats the value as a priority to consider rather than a fact to dismiss.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a faithful comparison
Justify a faithful comparison · evidence 1
Fictional A summarises both views accurately and compares route evidence.
Justify a faithful comparison · evidence 2
B claims opponents “hate children” without evidence about motives.
8. Justify a faithful comparison: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A compares stated concerns and route evidence.
- A requires every person to agree.
- B invents motives instead of addressing the proposal.
- B’s accusation measures route safety.
A engages the actual claims; unsupported motive accusations do not test them.
9. Justify A and name one concrete piece of route evidence worth comparing.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains accurate representation and evidence-based comparison.
- Names relevant concrete route evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to an overlooked group
Transfer to an overlooked group · evidence 1
A fictional pickup plan was designed with drivers and pupils.
Transfer to an overlooked group · evidence 2
Nearby market vendors now report blocked loading access during their agreed hour.
10. Transfer to an overlooked group: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What should planners do next?
- What response could be assessed?
Available labels: Assess a safe compatible loading schedule. | Examine the vendors’ specific access evidence. | Assume vendors oppose all school safety.
The new perspective identifies a testable practical effect, not a reason to abandon safety.
11. Adapt the discussion to include vendors while preserving pupil safety.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Acknowledges and checks the actual vendor concern.
- Preserves pupil safety while proposing a compatible adjustment.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair false balance
Repair false balance · evidence 1
A fictional discussion has repeated measurements showing route A floods in the exercise, and an unsupported statement that it never floods. A pupil says both claims have equal evidence.
12. What is wrong with the equal-evidence claim?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- One unsupported statement erases all observations.
- Respect requires ignoring the repeated records.
- Different evidential support is treated as equal.
- Every opinion has identical measurement support under the stated conditions.
Respectful listening does not require assigning equal evidential strength to unequal support.
13. Explain how to respect the speaker while evaluating the claim accurately.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Separates respect for people from evidential weight.
- Uses records and requests relevant support.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a multi-perspective review
Design a multi-perspective review · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: accessible listening sessions 3, route evidence check 3, revised-plan review 2. Goal: address pupil safety and vendor access.
14. True or false: All three actions cost 10 tokens.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The process combines perspectives with checking and revision.
15. Propose a review within budget and explain how it represents both groups without weakening required safety.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Faithfully includes both stated perspectives.
- Uses evidence and preserves safety within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.7 — Developing local solutions
Develop a local response from observed needs rather than copying a solution unchanged.
Worked examples
1. Define the need
Worked classroom example
Fictional problem: 20 pupils wait in direct sun at the east gate at 2 p.m.
Question: Why is this better than “the school is hot”?
Answer: It identifies users, place and time.
Those details allow a targeted proposal and a relevant evaluation.
2. A local constraint
Worked classroom example
A copied rain garden needs 20 square metres; the available safe site has 8.
Question: Can it be copied unchanged?
Answer: No.
Space is a real constraint. Compare an adapted design or another appropriate measure with expert advice.
3. A useful trial record
Worked classroom example
A fictional plan records queue shade, wait time and user access before and after a small change.
Question: Why use all three?
Answer: They connect the action to exposure and practical usability.
A physical improvement may fail if waiting arrangements or access remain unsuitable.
Formative quiz
Locate the specific need
Locate the specific need · evidence 1
Fictional school: west gate is shaded; east gate has a 2 p.m. exposed queue; rear gate is closed for works.
1. Where is the stated waiting-exposure problem?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The west gate has the stated exposed queue.
- The rear gate is the approved open waiting point.
- The east gate has the exposed queue.
- Every gate has identical conditions.
The local observation identifies a particular place and time.
Inspect a local model
Inspect a local model · evidence 1
Toy queue indicator uses base 28, extra 4, full-shade reduction 4. A 50% shade trial is proposed.
2. Inspect a local model: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is the model indicator at half shade?
- What remains required before real use?
Available labels: The model indicator is 30. | The model indicator is 28. | An approved local safety and access assessment.
The toy calculation subtracts two from thirty-two; real suitability is a separate check.
Compare local constraints
Compare local constraints · evidence 1
Fictional borrowed design requires 20 m² and weekly specialist care.
Compare local constraints · evidence 2
Available site has 8 m² and no confirmed specialist team.
3. Compare local constraints: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Specialist care is confirmed at the site.
- Weekly specialist care is not arranged.
- Twenty square metres is already available.
- Only 8 m² is available for a 20 m² design.
Both space and maintenance assumptions require adaptation or alternatives.
Separate observations and guesses
Separate observations and guesses · evidence 1
Fictional record: the drain is visibly blocked and rainfall was 60 units.
Separate observations and guesses · evidence 2
A pupil guesses that all extra water came from a distant river
Separate observations and guesses · evidence 3
no river data are supplied.
4. Separate observations and guesses: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which fact is directly recorded?
- What needs more evidence?
Available labels: The distant-river explanation needs checking. | The river cause is already verified. | The local drain is visibly blocked.
Use the recorded local condition and investigate unverified explanations.
Explain a local test
Explain a local test · evidence 1
A fictional rainfall model assumes 80 units and 50% infiltration. The proposed local site’s actual infiltration is unknown.
5. State the model runoff and one measurement needed before relying on it locally.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Calculates forty runoff units.
- Requests local evidence for a key assumed condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a targeted proposal
Apply a targeted proposal · evidence 1
Fictional east-gate queue has 20 pupils; approved covered area holds 12. A second supervised area holds 8. Both are accessible.
6. Apply a targeted proposal: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Can the two areas hold the full queue?
- What condition is already stated?
Available labels: Both areas are accessible. | Together they provide only 12 places. | Together they provide 20 places.
Twelve plus eight equals twenty; other real safety details still require responsible assessment.
7. Explain how to use both areas and name one coordination need.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets the twenty-pupil capacity without overfilling.
- Names supervision, assignment or clear communication.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify using local evidence
Justify using local evidence · evidence 1
Fictional A copies a design from a different climate without checking the site.
Justify using local evidence · evidence 2
B uses local observations, user input and qualified suitability review.
8. Which approach better addresses local fit?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- User input replaces all physical assessment.
- A’s different setting proves local success.
- B tests the site’s actual conditions and needs.
- B guarantees every later outcome under the stated conditions.
Local observations, needs and qualified checks complement one another.
9. Justify B using a physical condition and a user need that should be checked.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Names a relevant physical condition.
- Names a relevant local access/use need.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer after a changed rainfall assumption
Transfer after a changed rainfall assumption · evidence 1
Toy original rain 80 at 50% infiltration gives 40 runoff units. Changed rain is 120 at the same assumed infiltration.
10. Transfer after a changed rainfall assumption: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the new model runoff?
- How much more is that than before?
Available labels: The new model runoff is 40 units. | It is 20 runoff units more. | The new model runoff is 60 units.
Half of one hundred twenty is sixty, twenty above forty.
11. Explain why a forty-unit capacity plan needs review and name one relevant adjustment to assess.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies the twenty-unit capacity mismatch.
- Suggests a relevant locally assessed adjustment.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a one-day success claim
Repair a one-day success claim · evidence 1
A fictional shade trial works for one quiet cloudy afternoon.
Repair a one-day success claim · evidence 2
A report claims it is proven for every hot crowded day.
12. True or false: A cloudy trial measures every heat condition.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The trial can inform a next step while leaving important conditions untested.
13. Rewrite the conclusion and identify a specific safe next check.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Limits the claim to the observed trial.
- Names a relevant safe condition or capacity check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a local proposal
Design a local proposal · evidence 1
Fictional budget 9: local assessment 3, small approved trial 4, user review 2. Goal: improve the east-gate queue without blocking accessible passage.
14. Design a local proposal: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which complete proposal fits?
- What constraint must the layout keep?
Available labels: Accessible passage must remain clear. | All three steps cost 11 tokens. | All three steps cost 9 tokens.
The plan funds fit, trial and feedback while keeping the access constraint.
15. Propose a nine-token trial and explain how you will check both waiting benefit and clear access.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Measures a relevant waiting/exposure benefit.
- Preserves and checks accessible passage within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
- UNDRR: Early warning systems
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.8 — Planning individual and collective action
Connect manageable individual actions with coordinated roles and measurable collective results.
Worked examples
1. Individual and system roles
Worked classroom example
A pupil reports an unused light; a teacher approves a routine; maintenance installs suitable controls.
Question: Why separate roles?
Answer: People have different authority and skills.
A safe plan connects observation with responsible implementation rather than asking pupils to handle equipment.
2. Count real actions
Worked classroom example
Of 30 fictional pledged actions, 18 are confirmed complete.
Question: What completion rate is verified?
Answer: 18 of 30, or 60%.
Pledges measure intention. Confirmed action is a separate state.
3. Avoid overlap
Worked classroom example
Two fictional teams both report the same 8-unit reduction from one repaired leak.
Question: What is the combined verified saving?
Answer: 8 units, not 16.
Separate contributions can help one outcome without creating two distinct reductions.
Formative quiz
Choose suitable pupil roles
Choose suitable pupil roles · evidence 1
Fictional school needs leak observations and clear information
Choose suitable pupil roles · evidence 2
electrical and plumbing repairs require qualified adults.
1. Choose suitable pupil roles: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- A report proves the repair is completed.
- Pupils can report observed leaks.
- Pupils should open electrical equipment.
- Qualified responsible adults handle repairs.
Observation and communication can be safe contributions; technical work belongs to appropriate adults.
Connect task and owner
Connect task and owner · evidence 1
Fictional plan: class records disposable cups
Connect task and owner · evidence 2
teacher approves a refill routine
Connect task and owner · evidence 3
service team maintains the approved water point.
2. Connect task and owner: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Who records cup use?
- Who maintains the water point?
Available labels: The class records cup use. | The service team maintains it. | The class independently certifies water safety.
Distinct roles connect observation, approval and ongoing service.
Track action status
Track action status · evidence 1
Fictional campaign: 40 invitations, 30 pledges and 18 confirmed actions. These are different stages.
3. Track action status: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- How many completed actions are confirmed?
- How many people pledged?
Available labels: 30 people pledged. | 18 actions are confirmed. | 40 actions are confirmed.
The record distinguishes outreach, intention and confirmed completion.
Check enabling conditions
Check enabling conditions · evidence 1
Fictional refill campaign has clear posters,
Check enabling conditions · evidence 2
the only approved water point is locked during breaks.
4. What barrier limits the campaign?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- A locked point proves pupils lack motivation.
- The campaign already guarantees actual refilling under the stated conditions.
- The water point is unavailable when needed.
- More posters alone unlock the water point.
The system must make the requested action practically possible.
Explain overlap
Explain overlap · evidence 1
Two fictional teams claim the same 10-unit electricity saving from one agreed switch-off routine.
Explain overlap · evidence 2
No separate second saving is measured.
5. State the verified total and explain how to credit both teams without doubling it.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Keeps the unique saving at ten units.
- Explains shared credit without duplicate outcome counting.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply completion evidence
Apply completion evidence · evidence 1
Fictional campaign: 50 pledges; 35 actions independently confirmed. A report asks for verified completion among pledges.
6. Apply completion evidence: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What completion fraction is confirmed?
- What percentage is that?
Available labels: Confirmed completion is 70%. | All 50 actions are confirmed. | 35 of 50 actions are confirmed.
Thirty-five divided by fifty is seventy percent; unconfirmed actions are not counted as completed.
7. Explain why the report should use thirty-five rather than fifty and give the verified percentage.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes intention from confirmed completion.
- Calculates seventy percent correctly.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify coordinated roles
Justify coordinated roles · evidence 1
Fictional A asks pupils to “save water” with no reporting or repair route.
Justify coordinated roles · evidence 2
B gives pupils a leak-report channel and assigns qualified adults to inspect and repair.
8. Justify coordinated roles: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which plan connects pupil action to a system response?
- What does A leave unclear?
Available labels: A leaves the repair responsibility unclear. | B links reports to responsible adult repair. | A guarantees every leak is repaired.
B provides a practical chain from observation to qualified action.
9. Justify B using safety and the chance that a report leads to change.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Assigns technical work to qualified adults.
- Explains the clear report-to-response link.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer when resources differ
Transfer when resources differ · evidence 1
A fictional online campaign assumes every pupil has a phone.
Transfer when resources differ · evidence 2
Ten pupils lack personal devices
Transfer when resources differ · evidence 3
classroom paper reporting is available.
10. What adjustment keeps participation accessible?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- Offer the classroom paper-reporting route.
- Exclude pupils without devices from the project.
- Require every pupil to purchase a phone.
- No-phone pupils have no useful observations.
Different usable channels can serve the same contribution without imposing a new purchase.
11. Adapt the plan and explain why identical technology is not required for meaningful contribution.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides a usable no-phone route.
- Connects different formats to the same meaningful role.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a double-counted saving
Repair a double-counted saving · evidence 1
Toy school baseline 100; a shared routine lowers use to 80. Team A and team B each report the full 20-unit drop, giving a claimed total of 40.
12. What is the verified reduction? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- Two teams create two separate baselines.
- Shared credit requires doubled measurements.
- The verified reduction is 40 units.
- The verified reduction is 20 units.
The unique before-after difference remains twenty regardless of how many teams contributed.
13. Correct the total and explain how to record shared contributions accurately.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Gives the twenty-unit unique outcome.
- Separates contribution credit from duplicate savings.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design an accessible action plan
Design an accessible action plan · evidence 1
Fictional budget 6: reporting materials 1, adult inspection/repair arrangement 3, follow-up measurement 2. Goal: reduce leaks with roles accessible to pupils without phones.
14. True or false: All three components cost 8 tokens.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The plan links accessible pupil input, responsible service and measured outcomes.
15. Propose the six-token plan with a pupil role, an adult role and a check of results.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Assigns safe accessible pupil and qualified adult roles.
- Includes a meaningful outcome check within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Synthesis report
- IPCC: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.9 — Designing sustainability projects
Design a feasible project with a clear goal, roles, schedule and evidence of outcomes.
Worked examples
1. A measurable target
Worked classroom example
Fictional baseline: 40 cups per 100 lunches. Target: at most 25 cups per 100 lunches after four weeks.
Question: What would meet the target?
Answer: 25 or fewer per 100 comparable lunches.
The denominator and review time make the goal checkable without confusing attendance changes with waste prevention.
2. Budget the full trial
Worked classroom example
Toy setup 4 tokens, cleaning 2, measurement 1; budget 8.
Question: What remains?
Answer: 1 token.
4+2+1=7. Cleaning and evidence collection are part of the project, not invisible extras.
3. Outputs and outcomes
Worked classroom example
A fictional project installs two water points and hopes to reduce disposable bottles.
Question: What are output and outcome?
Answer: Installed points are outputs; fewer disposable bottles for comparable users is an outcome.
Both matter, but installation alone does not establish changed use.
Formative quiz
Connect goal and indicator
Connect goal and indicator · evidence 1
Fictional goal: reduce disposable cups per 100 lunches.
Connect goal and indicator · evidence 2
Possible indicators include cups counted and lunches served
Connect goal and indicator · evidence 3
poster colour does not measure the outcome.
1. Connect goal and indicator: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What numerator measures the unwanted items?
- What denominator makes attendance comparable?
Available labels: Count the disposable cups used. | Poster colour measures cups prevented. | Count the lunches served.
Cup use relative to lunches matches the stated goal.
Put dependencies in place
Put dependencies in place · evidence 1
Fictional steps: adult approval of a safe refill point
Put dependencies in place · evidence 2
prepare cleaning/maintenance
Put dependencies in place · evidence 3
launch the refill routine
Put dependencies in place · evidence 4
measure bottle use.
2. Put dependencies in place: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- What must precede reliance on the refill point?
- What keeps the service usable after launch?
Available labels: Obtain responsible adult approval. | Launch first and never check water safety. | Prepare cleaning and maintenance arrangements.
The action depends on a usable approved service and continued care.
Read a complete budget
Read a complete budget · evidence 1
Fictional budget 8: setup 4, operation 2, measurement 1. All are required for the trial.
3. Read a complete budget: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Four tokens remain after all costs.
- One token remains.
- The full planned cost is 4 tokens.
- The full planned cost is 7 tokens.
Four plus two plus one is seven.
Inspect output and outcome
Inspect output and outcome · evidence 1
Fictional project prints 10 posters. Comparable cup use remains 40 per 100 lunches before and after.
4. True or false: Cup use has not fallen in these records.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The output changed, while the intended measured outcome did not.
Explain a review rule
Explain a review rule · evidence 1
Fictional trial goal is at most 25 cups per 100 lunches after four weeks.
Explain a review rule · evidence 2
The team agrees to revise access or instructions if the result stays above 25.
5. Explain what will trigger revision and name one relevant barrier to investigate.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the specified outcome threshold and review point.
- Names a plausible practical barrier relevant to the project.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a measurable target
Apply a measurable target · evidence 1
Fictional baseline 50 bottles per 100 pupils; target at most 30 after three weeks. Measured result is 28 for comparable attendance.
6. True or false: The measured 28 exceeds the maximum of 30.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Twenty-eight is below thirty; fifty minus twenty-eight equals twenty-two.
7. Explain target achievement and the change using the common denominator.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Compares measured outcome with target correctly.
- Uses the twenty-two change and consistent per-hundred basis.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a realistic sequence
Justify a realistic sequence · evidence 1
Fictional A launches a reusable-cup scheme with no washing plan.
Justify a realistic sequence · evidence 2
B secures approved cleaning and storage before launch, with assigned adults.
8. Justify a realistic sequence: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which plan addresses the stated dependency?
- What does A leave unresolved?
Available labels: Safe continued reuse is not arranged. | A’s purchase proves cleaning will occur. | B prepares approved cleaning and storage first.
Reuse needs practical safe arrangements, not just a purchase or announcement.
9. Justify B and name a post-launch check.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Explains the cleaning/storage dependency.
- Names a relevant continued-use or maintenance check.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a larger class
Transfer to a larger class · evidence 1
Fictional kit serves 20 pupils and costs 3 tokens. Class grows to 40. Cleaning setup costs 2 regardless of class size; budget 8.
10. Transfer to a larger class: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- They serve 40 pupils.
- One kit and cleaning serve 40 pupils.
- Two kits and cleaning cost 5 tokens.
- Two kits and cleaning cost 8 tokens.
Two three-token kits plus two-token setup total eight and cover forty.
11. Adapt the budget for forty pupils and explain which cost repeats and which does not.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Meets forty-pupil capacity within eight tokens.
- Distinguishes scalable kit cost from fixed setup cost.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair an output-only success claim
Repair an output-only success claim · evidence 1
A report says a project succeeded because it held three meetings.
Repair an output-only success claim · evidence 2
Its stated goal was lower energy per occupied lesson
Repair an output-only success claim · evidence 3
no energy records exist.
12. Repair an output-only success claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- What is missing from the success claim?
- What did the meetings count establish?
Available labels: There is no evidence of the energy outcome. | Three project meetings occurred. | Three meetings prove lower energy use.
Meetings are outputs; without outcome records success or failure on the energy goal is unverified.
13. Correct the claim and identify the needed outcome measure.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes delivered meetings from unverified outcome.
- Specifies a comparable energy-per-service measure.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a complete small project
Design a complete small project · evidence 1
Fictional budget 9: baseline 2, approved action 4, maintenance 2, review 1. Goal: reduce avoidable cup use while keeping drinking access.
14. Design a complete small project: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which complete plan fits?
- What service must be preserved?
Available labels: All four steps cost 9 tokens. | Usable drinking access must continue. | All four steps cost 11 tokens.
The budget covers evidence, delivery, continued operation and review while retaining the essential service.
15. Propose a nine-token project with a measurable outcome and a review point, preserving drinking access.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Defines a comparable waste outcome and review time.
- Includes the required full plan within budget and preserves drinking access.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.10 — Evaluating whether interventions work
Evaluate whether an intervention contributed to change using fair comparisons and relevant outcomes.
Worked examples
1. A comparison changes the story
Worked classroom example
Fictional treated room falls from 100 to 80 units; comparison room falls from 100 to 90 during the same period.
Question: What extra decline is associated with the treatment comparison?
Answer: 10 units.
The treated decline is twenty, comparison decline ten. This simple difference helps account for shared changes but does not remove every possible bias.
2. Equal service
Worked classroom example
Room A uses 40 units for 10 lessons; B uses 30 for 5.
Question: Which has lower energy per lesson?
Answer: A: 4 versus B: 6.
The lower total alone would mislead because service amounts differ.
3. Missing is not zero
Worked classroom example
A five-day study has four readings and one missing entry.
Question: How should the missing day appear?
Answer: As missing, with follow-up if possible.
Inventing zero would create a false reduction and distort the average.
Formative quiz
Separate action and outcome
Separate action and outcome · evidence 1
Fictional school installs a timer.
Separate action and outcome · evidence 2
Electricity per comparable occupied lesson is the intended outcome
Separate action and outcome · evidence 3
installation count is an output.
1. Separate action and outcome: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which measure matches the intended outcome?
- What does installation count measure?
Available labels: Measure electricity per occupied lesson. | It measures the delivered equipment output. | Timer count directly measures all energy saved.
The measure should track the service-adjusted change, not merely delivery.
Recognise another cause
Recognise another cause · evidence 1
Fictional energy falls after a campaign,
Recognise another cause · evidence 2
the school also closes for two days.
Recognise another cause · evidence 3
Attendance is lower.
2. Recognise another cause: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Lower attendance can reduce energy use.
- Compare similar occupied service periods.
- Timing alone proves the campaign caused all savings.
- Attendance cannot affect school energy.
The closure is a plausible contributor; it neither proves nor disproves every campaign effect.
Read all trial days
Read all trial days · evidence 1
Fictional comparable savings across five days: 8, 2, 7, 1, 7 units. The average is 5.
3. True or false: Every day saves exactly 8 units.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
The sum twenty-five divided by five is five, and the individual values vary.
Match records to checks
Match records to checks · evidence 1
Fictional evaluation records energy, occupied lessons and adequate lighting.
Match records to checks · evidence 2
A lower energy total is useful only if required learning service remains.
4. Match records to checks: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which record describes the service amount?
- Which record checks service quality?
Available labels: Energy alone counts all occupied lessons. | Occupied lessons describe the service amount. | Adequate lighting checks service quality.
Both quantity and quality of service affect the interpretation of energy changes.
Explain missing data
Explain missing data · evidence 1
Fictional trial has readings 20, 18, missing, 19 and 17.
Explain missing data · evidence 2
A pupil enters zero for the missing day.
5. Explain why zero is wrong and state an honest way to report the record.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes missing from observed zero.
- Proposes transparent reporting or justified follow-up.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply a comparison change
Apply a comparison change · evidence 1
Fictional treated room: 100→80 units. Comparable untreated room: 100→90. Same time and stated service; other differences may still exist.
6. Apply a comparison change: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- The treated decline is 20 units.
- The treated decline is 80 units.
- The extra decline is 10 units.
- The extra decline is 20 units.
Declines are twenty and ten; their difference is ten, subject to the comparison’s limits.
7. Calculate the extra decline and explain why it is still not a universal proof.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Computes ten as the difference of changes.
- Names a relevant causal or generalisation limitation.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a fairer design
Justify a fairer design · evidence 1
Fictional A compares a busy summer month with an empty holiday.
Justify a fairer design · evidence 2
B compares similar occupied rooms in the same period and records weather and service.
8. Justify a fairer design: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- Which design offers the fairer comparison?
- What does its extra recording help examine?
Available labels: Weather and service differences can be checked. | A holds occupancy equal by using a holiday. | B compares similar service in the same period.
B reduces obvious differences while still requiring careful interpretation.
9. Justify B using one feature that makes the groups or periods comparable and one recorded condition that could affect the result.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Identifies comparable period/occupancy/service.
- Identifies relevant recorded conditions that could affect results.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a bigger class
Transfer to a bigger class · evidence 1
Fictional before: 20 pupils use 40 units. After: 40 pupils use 60. Service per pupil is comparable.
10. What is the after rate per pupil? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The after rate is 3 units per pupil.
- The two groups have equal attendance.
- The higher total proves a worse per-pupil rate.
- The after rate is 1.5 units per pupil.
Sixty divided by forty is 1.5; forty divided by twenty is two.
11. Explain why total use can rise while the per-pupil rate falls.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Uses the changed attendance.
- Compares the correct service-adjusted rates.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair selective reporting
Repair selective reporting · evidence 1
A fictional six-day trial has changes of −2, 0, 3, 4, 5 and 8 saved units. The report mentions only the 8-unit day as “the result.” Negative means use increased.
12. What is wrong with the report?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The 8-unit day represents every trial day under the stated conditions.
- A negative value must be erased as impossible.
- Any variation means all measurements are useless.
- It selects one favourable day and hides variation.
The full evidence includes no saving and increased use as well as improvements.
13. Correct the reporting approach and explain why the negative day matters.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Requires complete rather than cherry-picked evidence.
- Interprets the negative saved-unit value correctly.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a stronger small evaluation
Design a stronger small evaluation · evidence 1
Fictional budget 9: baseline and repeated readings 3, comparable-room coordination 3, service-quality check 2. Goal: assess an energy change without reducing necessary lighting.
14. Design a stronger small evaluation: connect each question with its supported answer.
Matching · 2 points
- Which full evaluation fits?
- What prevents a dark-room saving from misleading?
Available labels: All three elements cost 11 tokens. | The lighting-quality check tests useful service. | All three elements cost 8 tokens.
The plan combines repeated outcomes, a comparison and retained service.
15. Propose an evaluation within budget that uses a fair comparison and checks useful lighting.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Defines a meaningful comparable repeated evaluation.
- Preserves and measures lighting service within budget.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Climate evidence and uncertainty
- IPCC: Synthesis report
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.
CL7.11 — Communicating evidence-based recommendations
Communicate a recommendation with accurate evidence, clear reasoning and honest limits.
Worked examples
1. Claim and evidence
Worked classroom example
Fictional equal-service use falls from 40 to 30 units after a trial.
Question: What concise result can be reported?
Answer: Use fell by 10 units in the stated trial.
Include the service and period when available. Do not claim every school will achieve the same change.
2. An honest recommendation
Worked classroom example
A fictional shade trial improves waiting conditions, but crowded-day access is untested.
Question: How can the proposal state both?
Answer: Recommend a larger supervised trial while checking crowded-day access.
The next step uses the observed benefit and targets the remaining uncertainty.
3. Preserve a denominator
Worked classroom example
A fictional result is 5 kg less waste per 100 meals. A summary drops “per 100 meals.”
Question: Why is that a problem?
Answer: The comparison loses its service basis.
The same total could reflect different meal counts, so the denominator is part of the evidence.
Formative quiz
Build a supported message
Build a supported message · evidence 1
Fictional evidence: 40 cups per 100 lunches before
Build a supported message · evidence 2
25 after a refill trial.
Build a supported message · evidence 3
Proposed action: continue a supervised trial with usable water access.
1. Build a supported message: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- Which result matches the evidence?
- Which next step matches the proposal?
Available labels: Cup use fell by 15 per 100 lunches. | Continue the supervised refill trial. | Cup use fell by 25 per 100 lunches.
Forty minus twenty-five is fifteen; the recommendation remains tied to the trial and required service.
Choose the accurate headline
Choose the accurate headline · evidence 1
Fictional trial saves 10 energy units over five comparable lessons.
Choose the accurate headline · evidence 2
No other school is tested.
2. Which headline is supported?
Multiple choice · 2 points
- The trial saved 10 units in every lesson.
- Local trial saves 10 units across five lessons.
- Every school is guaranteed the same saving under the stated conditions.
- No relevant result was measured at all.
The supported statement keeps the total, period and local scope.
Keep the units
Keep the units · evidence 1
Fictional water record: baseline 80 litres/day, later 60 litres/day for the same users.
3. True or false: The reduction is 20 litres per day.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
Eighty minus sixty is twenty, and the daily unit is part of the statement.
Inspect a translated claim
Inspect a translated claim · evidence 1
Original fictional finding: “The measure may reduce exposure under the tested conditions.”
Inspect a translated claim · evidence 2
Translation says: “It always prevents all harm.”
4. What changed incorrectly? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The translation adds an unsupported guarantee.
- An absolute promise is more scientifically accurate.
- Translation permits changing the measured result.
- The two statements have identical certainty.
The translation changes both certainty and scope, which must be preserved.
Explain audience adaptation
Explain audience adaptation · evidence 1
A fictional school committee needs a decision about a trial.
Explain audience adaptation · evidence 2
Pupils need to understand its safe routine.
Explain audience adaptation · evidence 3
The same evidence applies.
5. Name one detail to emphasise for each audience without changing the evidence.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Provides a decision-relevant committee detail.
- Provides a usable pupil-facing detail while preserving facts.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Mastery and critical thinking
Applied Reasoning — Apply accurate reporting
Apply accurate reporting · evidence 1
Fictional same-service trial: 100 energy units before, 80 after. There were four trial weeks at one school.
6. Which result is accurate? Select the matching labelled area.
Hotspot · 2 points
- The trial reduced use by 20 units.
- The reduction was 80 units.
- The trial proves every school saves 80%.
- Four weeks establish all future outcomes.
One hundred minus eighty is twenty; the scope is limited to the reported trial.
7. Write a one-sentence result including the change and scope.
Written response · short answer · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- States the correct change with units.
- Preserves one-school and trial-period scope.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Justify Choice — Justify a qualified recommendation
Justify a qualified recommendation · evidence 1
Fictional proposal A says “Adopt everywhere: guaranteed savings.”
Justify a qualified recommendation · evidence 2
B says “Expand the local trial, check maintenance and compare equal service.”
Justify a qualified recommendation · evidence 3
Only one local trial is available.
8. True or false: A’s certainty is supported by one local trial.
True or false · 2 points
- True
- False
B uses the evidence while addressing uncertainty before wider adoption.
9. Justify B and explain why its qualification is useful to the decision-maker.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Connects the recommendation to the limited trial evidence.
- Explains a practical verification condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Transfer Application — Transfer to a new audience
Transfer to a new audience · evidence 1
A fictional technical note says “25% reduction from baseline 80 units
Transfer to a new audience · evidence 2
equal attendance.”
Transfer to a new audience · evidence 3
A pupil-facing version must preserve the meaning.
10. Transfer to a new audience: connect each question with its supported answer.
Dropdown · 2 points
- What is the equivalent absolute reduction?
- What condition must remain?
Available labels: Attendance was the same in the comparison. | The reduction is 25 units from 80. | The reduction is 20 units from 80.
One quarter of eighty is twenty, leaving sixty; equal attendance matters.
11. Rewrite the result for classmates using the actual before-and-after unit amounts and units saved, while keeping the equal-attendance condition.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Accurately translates the percentage into the stated values.
- Retains the equal-attendance condition.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Error Analysis — Repair a copied-source claim
Repair a copied-source claim · evidence 1
A report calls three websites “three independent studies.”
Repair a copied-source claim · evidence 2
All three repeat the same original trial and supply no new data.
12. Repair a copied-source claim: connect each question with its supported answer.
Drag and drop · 2 points
- How many independent trials are described?
- What should the report do?
Available labels: Identify the shared original source. | Only one independent trial is described. | Three website addresses prove three trials.
Different copies do not create independent observations; the original trial may still be useful.
13. Correct the claim and name one way to strengthen the evidence base.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Distinguishes copied reports from independent studies.
- Requests independent relevant evidence.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Design / Propose — Design a complete recommendation
Design a complete recommendation · evidence 1
Fictional committee budget 8. Local assessment costs 2, approved trial 4, outcome review 2. Evidence suggests potential benefit but crowded-day access is untested.
14. Design a complete recommendation: select the two statements supported by this evidence.
Multiple answers · 2 points
- Assessment, trial and review cost 8 tokens.
- The complete plan costs only 4 tokens.
- Crowded-day access remains untested.
- Potential benefit guarantees every future outcome.
The full eight-token plan turns evidence into a testable next step while retaining the limitation.
15. Write a recommendation naming the action, evidence-based reason, remaining access uncertainty and review.
Written response · open ended · 2 points
Two rubric criteria — one point each:
- Proposes a feasible evidence-linked action within budget.
- Names the access uncertainty and a review that addresses it.
Accept equivalent reasoning and other valid proposals that meet both criteria. The example is not the only acceptable wording. AI scores are estimates; use this rubric for teacher review.
Scientific references
- OECD: Preliminary PISA 2029 Climate Literacy framework
- IPCC: Climate evidence and uncertainty
- IPCC: Synthesis report
Local people, projects, numbers and model factors in these activities are fictional classroom examples. Simplified outputs are not local forecasts or verified emission measurements. More than one reasoned proposal can be valid.